27 ms·
Google employees who work from home could lose money
- timpez 5y agoImagine working from home, and you're doing doubling your productivity. It's crazy how they can invalidate the contributions of working from home and decide to cut the employees' salaries.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoCompanies never lose an opportunity to cut costs. They sense that many employees prefer to work from home, so that they may be willing to essentially pay for the privilege.
- valevk 5y agoBut wouldn't companies also save money by using smaller offices (and maybe by cutting the micro managers who control employees in an office environment)? What you are saying is that companies are capitalizing on the preference rather than any real cost of working from home?
- mytailorisrich 5y agoWhy not both? Cut office costs and salary costs. I don't see this as a signal that these companies necessarily want employees back into offices: If employees do prefer WFH then, as I mentioned, companies may be betting that they will accept a level of cut.
- tsjq 5y agobeancounter MBAs
- falcor84 5y agoYou make it sound derogatory, but counting the figurative beans is part of their job description, and someone has to do it. I've had the misfortune of working in places where no one is willing and able to count the beans, and I promise you that didn't go too well. As with most everything, the difficulty in making an org run well seems to be in finding (and keeping) that fleeting balance between vision and bean counting.
- mnd999 5y agoAnd they no longer need a desk in an expensive office building, or free food. Triple win.
- agilob 5y agoand electricity and water and water cooler breaks
- cabraca 5y agodon't forget the coffee ... lots of coffee.
- memling 5y agoanecdotally my 150-person office consumed about $40k in coffee each year. not a huge amount compared to salary and benefits, but not peanuts either.
- aynyc 5y agoDon’t forget the service contract to maintain the machines, etc.. it’s not cheap. My old job switch from service contract to the pods machines and still came out ahead.
- underseacables 5y agoOr massages, child care, game rooms, or any of the other ridiculous perks. The company could start rolling those back if enough people wfh.
- tester34 5y agoThere'll always be people at office, so I don't think so.
- rjzzleep 5y agoThe reason why they have it all there is specifically to abuse your work hours. Hungry, don't have any food? Go back to the office real quick to grab a snack on a Sunday. And well you might have just figured out something so you might end up back at your desk. There are enough studies on why those campuses are designed that way. The convenience is designed at making sure you spend more time at work.
- sneak 5y agoThere are lots of other companies hiring, and if you're getting a pay cut, you already have big G on your resume. Don't think you have to keep working for a company that has previously conspired to price-fix wages and defraud its workforce out of billions of dollars of wages. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/business/2014/04/apple-google-settle-wage-fixing-hiring-case https://www.vanityfair.com/news/business/2014/04/apple-googl... Eric Schmidt, conspirator in this fraud, had a long and successful career there even after it was discovered.
- kstenerud 5y agoThis will continue until enough high profile people publicly leave their jobs, and specifically mention how their new company doesn't cheat them out of the market rate based on their lifestyle choices.
- robertlagrant 5y agoI don't think market rate means what you think it means. The way for this to balance is for good people to get remote jobs to pay them enough to stay. The difficulty is that more good people are now available via remote, to press down on salaries.
- ascar 5y agoThat is based on the pretty bold assumption that SV salaries are the actual "market rate" while it is much more likely that the true market rate is much lower and SV salaries are inflated. There is enough talent outside of SV that is willing to work for much lower salaries. Actually there is orders of magnitude more talent of similar quality/intelligence available globally.
- lexapro 5y ago>Actually there is orders of magnitude more talent of similar quality/intelligence available globally. Yes and now they don't even have to move to SV anymore.
- jstx1 5y agoThe other side of this is that if you're a high profile person at Google, there are few companies that can give you similar or higher compensation. Even fewer if you only consider remote.
- IshKebab 5y agoYeah I think we've been through this. Your salary isn't purely a function of how much value you bring to the company. It also depends on how much other people are willing to work for. That's how markets work.
- robertlagrant 5y agoRight - a cleaner brings massive value (no one will work in an insanitary environment, so they in a sense underpin all work) but seeing as the labour pool is large, cleaners don't get paid a lot of money.
- WJW 5y agoEverybody was so sure that working from home in a low cost of living region with SF salaries was going to make them rich. The few voices who warned that it also meant a bigger pool of potential employees with lower salary demands were ignored. And so the cycle continues.
- lexapro 5y agoThe value you bring to the company is almost irrelevant. It's all supply and demand. Of course if you bring a lot of value that might increase demand for you, especially if few are able to provide that amount of value. Also, no market is perfect. There are (well-paid) employees that bring zero or even negative value without anyone noticing.
- planet-and-halo 5y agoTheoretically the value you bring should always be higher than what you're paid, since it would be uneconomical to employ you otherwise. That said your second paragraph is absolutely right, there are plenty of failures. In a modern bigcorp I'd be willing to wager that value is created on a bell curve relative to a given salary level (so for example if you take a bunch of people making $60,000 in the same company, some produce no value or negative value, some produce moderate value, some produce extreme value). If I had to guess complexity actually allows the information asymmetries to flourish, so the market is probably extremely distorted and that's why you see the effect.
- moonchrome 5y agoI mean isn't this just removing comp for commuting ? Assuming you got compensated based on commute time, 2 hours commuting a day does not sound worth the 10% to me - do some moonlighting if you're that bent on converting all your time to money.
- brown9-2 5y agoNo, the article makes it pretty clear that it’s a cost of living adjustment
- agilob 5y agobut my cost of living is now higher when Im using more electricity and water at home, and i had to refurbish my room for home office.
- underseacables 5y agoYou could return to the office.
- eloisant 5y agoWe're talking about employees moving to cheaper areas. I'm pretty sure the housing costs (mortgage or rent) largely offsets the additional costs. I still think Google shouldn't do that, it's cheap to do that and they don't have to. However even with a 10% pay cut, employees moving from expensive areas such as Silicon Valley or the Seattle area to a cheaper one like some city in Oregon, the standard of living still goes up.
- bsagdiyev 5y agoIs it really that significantly higher? I can’t imagine you’ve increased usage of those to the tune of thousands of dollars a year.
- ryan93 5y agoYou can buy a home for 7 figures cheaper if you leave silicon valley. Why are you worried about a water bill/
- throwaway_qcjal 5y agoI think this is making a whole lot of out nothing, or at least not much. Google would determine your pay based on your work location, regardless of whether that's your home or the office. As a result people that lived far from the office in a typically less expensive area could see their pay drop.
- Sacho 5y agoGitlab implements this compensation model openly(to the point where there is a calculator for it!) - I don't remember how well it was received when it was first announced, but looks like Google is applying a similar idea.
- zrail 5y agoThe calculator is no longer public.
- smnrchrds 5y agoThat's a shame. When did they make it non-public?
- licebmi__at__ 5y agohttps://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/www-gitlab-com/-/commit/4293020d789359ad8134a054225127f3e0b32a58 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/www-gitlab-com/-/commit/429302...
- chrisseaton 5y agoI don’t think the calculator is public. It used to be and last time I tried it the results were terrible for my area I guess because there just aren’t any other technologists here so nothing to compare to - but that doesn’t say anything about me or how much I’m worth! Also when you looked in the data file you could see little pockets of higher paying areas - I guess if they can’t recruit you they create a little higher paying bubble for you. So I don’t think it works well and it’s also possibly open to distortion.
- brown9-2 5y agoWill they adjust Urs Holzle’s compensation for working from New Zealand?
- PetahNZ 5y agoYea its quite expensive to live here so he will probably get a pay increase.
- underdeserver 5y agoUrs is Google employee #8. He is so rich I doubt he is compensated in any way that's meaningful to him today. He probably only works to have a seat at the table and a say in how the future of technology is built.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> He is so rich I doubt he is compensated in any way that's meaningful to him today. Yet they still pay him a ton (executive comp is public). Weird.
- FiReaNG3L 5y agoTurns out competing with the whole world and not who is ready to relocate to an extremely expensive area of the world brings downsides, who knew. Time to realize that this 'work from home' push will lead to more globalization, and more loss of wealth / quality of life for the people of the West.
- wegs 5y agoI think we'll see more globalization, but I think people overstate the level of the transition: 1) Done well, remote work is at least as effective as office-based. However, my experience is that most companies aren't doing remote work remotely well, even 15 months in. 2) Globalization has to do with more than just being remote. An issue we still haven't solved are time zones. I think the first move we'll see is from San Fran, Mountain View, etc. to cheaper parts of the US, closer to food production, and with more available land.
- Lariscus 5y agoDon't forget, to the CEO and their cronies you are all just peons. If they could pay you nothing at all they would absolutely do so.
- lultimouomo 5y agoIf you could have your company pay you all the money they have (but still magically continue to function), wouldn't you?
- whydid 5y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. How could a company continue to function in this case? A pot of gold or some other form of magic? The point is, compensation is inequitable. Upper management at most tech companies is paid 20-50x what a worker is paid. Do you think that is reasonable?
- pc86 5y agoOf course compensation is inequitable. I don't think anyone outside fringe leftist politicos have ever suggested it should be otherwise? And if your company continues to print money decade after decade while paying upper management 20-50x what a worker makes, maybe that's not the worst thing in the world.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> And if your company continues to print money decade after decade while paying upper management 20-50x what a worker makes, maybe that's not the worst thing in the world. This seems at odds with the normal HN view of Google, which is that they can't do anything right but have such a good thing going with ads that they basically cannot fail. If this is true, then an inanimate object could lead the company to success. I am not convinced it is so extreme, but I am definitely not convinced that paying Sundar billions and billions less would actually change the company.
- 5y ago
- kristopolous 5y agoIt's weird how directly the incentive is to increase your carbon footprint. They'll essentially pay you more for contributing to congestion and pollution.
- nostrebored 5y agoBecause employees in the office are more productive.
- bodge5000 5y agoThats quite the leap of judgement, and I'd say its almost certainly not true (and quite possibly the opposite, I know thats been the case for me).
- Fnoord 5y agoNot universally true, indeed. However if you got little children, it is most certainly true.
- mingusrude 5y agoWhy would it be more productive to work in the office and have the children at day care than working from home and have the children at day care?
- Fnoord 5y agoDaycare? In August? Not here. They got vacation. Daycare's closed. School vacation lasts 6-8 weeks (6 for our's). I do have vacation days left, but not for 6 weeks.
- bodge5000 5y agoI can see why you'd think that, but again having worked with many people who do, I don't see a difference. Of course personal experience is far from hard data, but with a lack of decent data to go off on the subject (partially to do with the fact that productivity is a very vague term, with many disagreeing on how it should be measured, especially with the constant number of external factors affecting it), I can only go by what I experience. I also notice those with children think they're being less productive, whereas the rest of the team doesn't actually notice, so that could be a factor. Thats not saying that WFH is beneficial to all, of course not. I think theres a massive range of factors, children of course being one of them, but I think it comes down to the individual, rather than any broad strokes we can attempt to make.
- vmception 5y agoGiven how many new ways there are to divide the eligible universe of workers (remote/office/mask/vax/woke), all while the sector is still expanding, I'm really excited to see the comp packages skyrocket, for those willing to optimize! The pay is starting to get interesting!
- MartinMcGirk 5y agoI can see why you’d pay a remote staff member differently from an on-prem staff member. As others have said if you’re hiring remote then your talent pool is effectively the whole world, so price competition is fiercer. But if everyone is remote or everyone is on-prem, then location-dependent pricing is complete nonsense. The employees are all still providing the same value to the company. Claiming that you can’t pay someone as much because they live in some rural town somewhere is just the company finding an excuse to keep a larger share of the value created by that employee.
- fakedang 5y agoIsn't Google pushing for a return to on-prem though? So it's the first situation that you mentioned.
- MartinMcGirk 5y agoYeah my comment is kind of tangential to the post and aimed more at the general idea of location-dependent salaries. I don’t argue with the concept of saying “we want you back in the office, if you don’t want to come to the office then take a pay cut” like is going on here.
- namdnay 5y agoIf you remove location-dependent pricing, which location do you align the new single price on? Mountain View? London? Hyderabad?
- wayanon 5y agoEndless loop: you need a higher salary to live where you have space to work from home.
- dagw 5y agoI thought the argument went the other way. If you work from home you might as well live in East Bumblefuck where 10k sq ft. houses are $100k each.
- jensensbutton 5y agoCompanies were never paying based on value provided. They pay market rate which, until recently, was artificially limited to a few expensive markets. With remote, these companies are now able to do what every other large labor driven industry has done and lower their costs by finding labor in cheaper markets.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThis is a good thing, it's not healthy to have all your wealth in one small region of a country.
- ch4s3 5y agoGood thin the US has several huge, wealthy metro areas 8 or 9 states.
- minikites 5y agoFinding cheaper labor elsewhere further concentrates wealth. The only way to spread out the wealth would be to mandate the same salary across regions.
- namdnay 5y agoThat sounds good, but how do you determine this new universal salary? It's either going to be absurdly over market (are you going to pay fresh grads in Hyderabad 150k USD a year?) or absurdly under market (are you going to pay fresh grads in Mountain View 30k USD a year?)
- dsr_ 5y agoClass A office space in Manhattan is about $70/sqft, and the average office employee gets 150 sqft allocated (desk, hallway, conference room, supply closets...) Google is probably 170. That's $11900 annually that they save by not having an employee take up office space. No, it's not fungible on a small scale, but it's certainly fungible on a large scale: reduce your office needs by 100 people and you can rearrange desks and sublet that 17000 sqft. Google has other famous in-office benefits that cost per-person, so $12K per remote is a baseline savings. If Googlers had any collective bargaining power, they wouldn't be getting salary reductions: they would be getting extra expense money for desks, chairs, and ISP upgrades.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> If Googlers had any collective bargaining power, they wouldn't be getting salary reductions: they would be getting extra expense money for desks, chairs, and ISP upgrades. Since Google already pays the most, where do you threaten to leave to while bargaining?
- londons_explore 5y ago"I'll leave to do a startup, and you'll have to hire some new grad and train them for years till they're as good as me" is a common threat.
- jeswin 5y agoAt that point, it's better to let the employee go.
- londons_explore 5y agoExcept that seems to be in the minds of a large chunk of FAANG employees... They can't let them all go. So they give payrises instead
- sjg007 5y ago
- oakfr 5y ago« the company will not change an employee's salary based on them going from office work to being fully remote in the city where the office is located" -> that’s a huge saving for the company right there when you consider the price/sqft of offices in dense areas
- helsinkiandrew 5y ago> One Google employee ..would likely see their pay cut by about 10% by working from home full-time > The employee was considering remote work but decided to keep going to the office - despite the two-hour commute. 10% paycut in place of 10 hours of commute seems a good deal to me.
- paulcole 5y agoUnless you need that 10% of your salary.
- scollet 5y agoIt's not a trade. The worker just loses.
- paulcole 5y agoWhat if they need the money?
- loco5niner 5y agoI imagine they could find some way to make money with an extra 10 hours a week.
- oakfr 5y agoAm surprise by the census data for Lake Tahoe and the 25% drop in salary that goes with it. Isn’t this a super wealthy area? This is going to hurt the Googlers who where going to trade their primary home for their secondary one.
- tomtheelder 5y agoTahoe is definitely not a super wealthy area for permanent residents. It's the same as a lot of tourism driven towns. Lots of middle class and lower middle class folks who work in the tourism industries (skiing, casinos, etc.).
- rexreed 5y agoDoes this mean employee agreements are up for renegotiating? Salary / compensation for work is the key element to an employee agreement. If employers can change compensation at will without employee consent then the employee agreement is truly meaningless and simply a tool for the employer to wield against the employee. I'd imagine a few employee lawsuits on breach of contract that will test that.
- rattlesnakedave 5y agoI'd say the logic is "We entered this agreement with the understanding that you would be in the office x% of the time. We would like you to return to the office at that original capacity. If you would not like to do so, we need to renegotiate our agreement." Not that I agree with any of this, nor am I sure that any of this is even written, but that's probably what it is. All of these gigs being at will employment certainly doesn't help the employee here.
- rexreed 5y ago"With the understanding that" is not a legal framework. Anything that's key to the understanding of a contract needs to be in a contract. Implicit "I always thought that" doesn't hold water. If I entered into an employee contract with the understanding that I would be given responsibility of a team or project, even though such an understanding was not in the contract, and then the management decides to take away that responsibility, can I say that they are in breach because it was "my understanding" that I would be given responsibility? It would be just as much of an "understanding" as saying that there was an implicit agreement about location of work when that's not in the contract either.
- jffry 5y agoAh. "Employment Contracts" are not really a thing in most of the US, at least not like they are in Europe. Yes, employers will have you sign an official looking employment agreement, which basically serves as documentation that they're currently compensating you at X rate, and that you agree to be bound by specific employer rules (like employee handbooks / policies / etc). Those are not legally binding contracts. At-will workers can leave at any time and can be fired at any time for any reason or no reason, aside from for specific things protected by law (like organizing a union drive, or reporting sexual harassment)
- gowan 5y agoi like how the us military makes cost of living adjustments. you have your base pay determined my your rank which is not adjusted by where you live. in addition to that you get a housing stipend (BAH and BAS) that is adjusted by where you live. if i remember correctly the housing stipend is before tax. google is essentially forcing a pay cut to your base salary in addition to the portion of your salary you use for housing.
- vitus 5y agoIf anyone's curious about the underlying details: Each state has an associated salary band. For certain metropolitan statistical areas (defined by the OMB to encompass certain counties), as noted in the article, there is an overriding (typically higher) salary band. This leads to quirks like someone in Milford, PA (~70 miles northwest of NYC) being paid top dollar, as part of the NYC metro area, but someone in Bethlehem (80 miles west of NYC) being paid 15% less. Or, if you live in Santa Cruz, you'd be paid about 10% less than if you continued working out of the Mountain View office (just 30-40 miles to the north). (The 15% paycut for moving to Tahoe is most likely cherrypicked as crossing the state border into Nevada, which is in a lower band than California.)
- jsjohnst 5y ago> The 15% paycut for moving to Tahoe is most likely cherrypicked as crossing the state border into Nevada, which is in a lower band than California The majority of Tahoe is in California.
- vitus 5y agoYes, and California outside of the Bay Area is all the same salary band, whereas if you move across the border to NV, you get bumped down a band.
- rowland66 5y agoIf Google is going to allow US employees to work from anywhere in the US, they should not be adjusting wages based on an employee's residence. Where an employee chooses to live becomes no different from what car they choose to buy. Google should pay a consistent wage scale based on a median cost of living across the US. This would probably be an unpleasant adjustment for many Googlers in high cost locales.
- agnosticmantis 5y agoIs there a public data set of these salary bands? Combining that with housing data would allow one to optimize the salary-to-expense ratio. I think that’d be a valuable service.
- boplicity 5y agoThe cost of commuting on the environment is extremely high. We should be offering incentives to companies to switch to remote work. If 20% of jobs permanently switched to remote, the impact on carbon emissions would be immediate, and extremely positive.
- ctvo 5y agoSources please. Edit: The OP makes an extraordinary claim about remote work and reduction in CO2. I would assume members of HN would be intellectually curious enough to want to dig deeper.
- judge2020 5y agohttps://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-typical-passenger-vehicle#:~:text=typical%20passenger%20vehicle%3F-,A%20typical%20passenger%20vehicle%20emits%20about%204.6%20metric%20tons%20of,around%2011%2C500%20miles%20per%20year https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-t.... > A typical passenger vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of carbon dioxide per year. > This assumes the average gasoline vehicle on the road today has a fuel economy of about 22.0 miles per gallon and drives around 11,500 miles per year.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago22mpg sounds like fleet average. I don't think the average commuter who could work from home is getting 22mpg, probably close to 30 average. I don't think the frequency of trucks and vans relative to cars and crossovers is not high enough within those demographics to drag down the average that far. I'd pad the estimate for carbon saved and say like 3.5ton/yr per work from home employee.
- alistairSH 5y agoMy Honda gets about 20mpg. My BMW about 25mpg. Maybe I'm the exception that proves the rule, but I seriously doubt 30mpg is remotely close to average (for office workers) in the US. Edit - The Ford F-150 is the best selling "car" in the US by a long shot. That isn't all fleet sales - a significant number of normal people own trucks for one reason or another (myself included - Honda Ridgeline).
- inglor_cz 5y agoSo, just a tip for anyone who is really hit by this... Czech railway workers used to strike against Nazis by rigorously and pedantically following all the valid regulations. Even Nazis could not really do anything against that; the Reich was very process-oriented, after all. Do the same to your employer. Follow every idiotic rule to a letter. After all, it is your duty and their rules.
- andrew_ 5y ago(Acknowledgement that there are always life situations which demand abandoning convenience) The solution to this regional pay for remotes nonsense is not to interview with companies which practice it. Same as with the hybrid remote weirdness that's the new hotness.
- pimterry 5y agoInterestingly, in Spain this would be illegal. After a law introduced last year, long-term remote working (>30% of hours outside the office for 3+ months) now requires the worker and company to agree written terms (who'll pay for costs, how much remote is allowed, what worker monitoring will be used, if any, on what schedule does the worker have to be available, etc). As part of that, there's legal protections against discrimination in salary, promotions, working hours etc. You cannot employ a remote worker and an in-office worker in Spain and pay the remote worker less money just because they're remote. More details: https://parakar.eu/sp/remote-working-in-spain-covered-by-law/ https://parakar.eu/sp/remote-working-in-spain-covered-by-law...
- midnightcity 5y agoI wonder at what point it becomes cheaper to simply establish an office in a different jurisdiction for the purpose of hiring remote workers...
- pimterry 5y agoThe same applies to absolutely all employee protections, right? Rather than providing paid holiday, paying overheads like social security, and following other anti-discrimination laws, you could always hire your local workers as non-employee contractors via a foreign jurisdiction. Most companies don't, for lots of good reasons. Remote work makes such tricks a little easier, but not dramatically so.
- biztos 5y agoUntil recently I had a home-office contract in Germany. The contract gave them the right to relocate me, which seemed like a funny clause 15 years ago, nowadays I might worry about them actually doing it as part of some policy alignment.
- mumblemumble 5y ago> One Google employee, who asked not to be identified for fear of retaliation, typically commutes to the Seattle office from a nearby county and would likely see their pay cut by about 10% by working from home full-time, according estimates by the company's Work Location Tool launched in June. > The employee was considering remote work but decided to keep going to the office - despite the two-hour commute. This seems like a nice little meditation on the loss aversion heuristic. I doubt many people would accept a 25% increase in the amount of their time that's committed to work in exchange for a paltry 11% pay increase. But if you frame it as a 10% pay decrease in exchange for a 20% reduction in how much of your life is devoted to work, it suddenly becomes a lot less palatable.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'd absolutely take a 10% pay cut to save 4 hours of my life every workday.
- gowld 5y agoHours and $ are different units with nonlinear impact on happiness, so comparing percentages is fraught. It's not a 25% increase in work time, it's a 50+% reduction in free time.
- ashtonkem 5y agoIt’s also awful timing. After what, 18 months of productive WFH now they want to cut salary?
- chitowneats 5y agoIf Google felt that WFH had no negative effect on productivity, they could go the route of Twitter and others. The C-level clearly disagrees that this arrangement is ideal for the company, and are disincentivizing it with pay cuts.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI think that the c suite makes these decisions on a much more emotional basis than they let on. Honestly, I think they’re sad seeing their big, expensive office spaces not being fully utilized, and want to be able around and physically see workers working.
- docflabby 5y agoGoogle finaly completes its transformation into the new IBM.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI think that lots of people will be willing to reduce pay, to stay home. That will also act as an incentive to corporations, to use remote workers.
- textbookrental 5y agoIt was always a HN mantra that one got paid for the value they create. I guess it is more likely that where you sit is more important than what you do. Also, I see a lot of comments about higher productivity in the office. Google has had record revenue and profits during this time. Clearly that wouldn't be the case if productivity was negatively impacted. This seems to be more about what's good for managers and less about what's good for the company. Managers usually are incentivized to grow their budgets, not shrink them.
- textbookrental 5y agoOr it could be that technology companies will start to use the investment banking model. Where the only way to tell if someone will make a good investment banker is to see if they can spend 100 hours a week in the office doing the most mundane work for a couple of years.
- tzs 5y ago> Screenshots of Google's internal salary calculator seen by Reuters show that an employee living in Stamford, Connecticut - an hour from New York City by train - would be paid 15% less if she worked from home, while a colleague from the same office living in New York City would see no cut from working from home. Screenshots showed 5% and 10% differences in the Seattle, Boston and San Francisco areas. This makes no sense. For employees who are required to work in the office it makes sense to pay more at offices in places with higher costs of living. That's because your pool of potential employees is only people who live there or will move there. The company is requiring that employees live in a specific area so must pay based on the costs of that area. For full time work from home employees the company has no reason to care where the employee lives (other than regulatory--they might not want employees who live in areas where dealing with taxes or regulations are complex or costly). Hence the company should have one uniform rate for full time work at home employees, high enough so that they can get fill all their openings. If that means that the rate is too low for people in NYC why should the company care as long as they can get enough people from Stamford and other places with lower costs of living than NYC?
- sdevonoes 5y ago> If that means that the rate is too low for people in NYC why should the company care as long as they can get enough people from Stamford and other places with lower costs of living than NYC? Exactly. Google doesn't care, and as any other "good" company out there: money comes first, employees are peons. The thing I hope we are discussing here is: what (Google) employees can do about it? Can they do something at all? And if they can't, well, this basically means that in the near future every IT company out there will be doing the same. Sad, but hey, if we let companies do this sort of things, well, we deserve it.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoIt's fair in the sense that they provide each with the means to live at roughy the same standard-of-life: a Stamford $ has more buying power because local prices are lower, so they need fewer of them. Or, one could simply see it as answering a different question. Not "how much are you worth", but rather "how much do you need". If that sounds unfair, consider that it's close to the principle by which most parents care for their children' needs. Or, more prosaically, the New York employee simply has more options besides Google, and they might chose to work in an office if it means a 15% difference.
- ajmurmann 5y agoDespite the headlines, this has little to do with companies taking advantage of remote workers to safe cost and more with companies using pre-pandemic comp mechanisms in a post-pandemic. Comp in the vast majority of companies is based on cost of labor in the market the employee is located at. Software developers are cheaper in Alaska than in SF and even cheaper in Costa Rica, Ukraine or India. And yes, also cheaper in Sacramento than in Palo Alto, even though the difference is much much smaller. Companies are just sticking to that model because it requires little changes on their part and there are so many unknowns about how work will look in a few years. I'd argue that a reasonable model divides roles into ones that benefit from being local and ones that don't. Only ones that need to be local and in person should be subject to local labor costs. Unfortunately, this also might mean that salaries for remote folks will adjust across geographies and could probably roughly align by something like time zones, resulting in lower pay for your average Bay Area developer who's salary is high because they are in the Bay Area and not because they are world class (I expect comp for world class developers to go up regardless of location)
- deanclatworthy 5y agoThere’s no way Google is going to pay a “world class” developer the same salary in SV as in Ukraine. Not unless everyone in SV takes giant pay cuts.
- ajmurmann 5y agoDefinitely not right now. Let's see how things look in 5 years
- abunuwas 5y agoI'm very lucky to be able to work from home in my current contract, and it'll probably continue to be like this for another year if I manage to renew it. However I'm not kidding myself, I know as soon as I land a new contract I'll most likely be required to commute. A lot of people I know are already being required to go to the office some days a week, or will be required to do so from September. The past year has been one of the most productive times of my life, both at work and outside of work, but I reckon productivity is only one of many variables that most employers take into consideration, and perhaps not the most important. I guess they don't even measure productivity by how much you do, but by how much you cost?
- sshagent 5y agoBack in 2009 i took a £10k pay cut as my deal to work from home. That was easy math back then, not only was i reclaiming 4 hours of my life...but the train season ticket was £6k which at that tax bracket made it £10k. I'd wager people in similar positions could do such a thing to sweeten the deal if needed
- c0g 5y agoGiven some tech companies are trying to move some jobs out of the Bay to compete less on salary, can I get hired at a lower pay satellite office then move to the Bay Area and get the salary bump?
- dbg31415 5y agoLocation-based pay is a stupid way to determine pay.
- aeharding 5y agoIn my opinion, there should be pay cuts to continue coming to the office with a 2 hour commute by car. Google's proposal incentivizes the wrong thing.
- lordnacho 5y agoSo it's based on where you live? Isn't it just a matter of some employees getting together to rent a cheap flat in a high-income area? Or you "swap" homes with your single city-dweller friend, who "moves" to a family home in the suburbs...
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoI have not read the counter to this - the cost reduction of office overhead that Google does not have to pay for the employee. No building, no heat/cooling, no building maintenance, no office furniture, no electricity, no networking, no parking, no janitorial service, no security guards, and so on.
- intricatedetail 5y agoSo Google is okay paying landlords for the offices but won't pay workers for use of home as office? Okay. Sounds like the landlord deals could have something to do with tax avoidance?
- shell0x 5y agoI think I'd rather take a pay cut and live in a place I actually like. I have been working remotely for more than 2 years and I can't imagine going back to an office every day. The open-plan layout, the noise, the struggle to find a room to have a call, the slow internet connection(Australian internet is already slow, but at least at home it's just me using it). I also heard that some people absolutely detest WFH, but they have kids or rent a studio apartment. A hybrid model seems to be the best solution going forward.
- rStar 5y agogoogle be losing employees then.
- ridaj 5y agoWhy isn't the "market area" that sets pay levels for a remote worker defined by timezone, not by CBSA? After all, from the work-being-done perspective, a remote worker in rural Oregon is the same as if they were working from home in high-cost Palo Alto. People working remotely from high-cost Zurich do the same work in the same timezone as people working remotely from lower cost Prague or Tunisia. It seems like a not very sound principle to pay people whose work comes in as IP packets based on the geographic origin of those packets, and likely ripe for abuse (why tell Google I moved to Lake Tahoe and get a 25% pay cut? Keep an "address" with a friend in SF where they can mail me stuff, keep the pay...)
- rStar 5y agoworking from home allows me to be productive while getting more sleep instead of commuting. getting enough sleep makes your life much better. who knew?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wly_cdgr 5y agoYou gotta be a special kind of idiot to choose a 2hr commute over a 10% pay cut
- mark_l_watson 5y agoWhile in general I think work from home, or hybrid is a good thing, it is different with Google. I was invited to work there as a contractor on one specific project, and being on campus was so much fun (food, invited lecturers, walking around during breaks). Working remotely wouldn't have been nearly as enjoyable.
- lmilcin 5y agoDoes that mean if I work from home and move to more costly location I get automatic increase? Does this policy account for the fact people working remotely no longer use up office resources? No, I didn't think so... so predictable. These things only ever work one way. Corporations thrive on being able to outsource large part of their work to cheaper locations. Now they are terrified remote work is eroding that ability so they are trying to find excuses to keep differentiate salary based on your location, even if it doesn't make much sense logically. If I work remotely, what difference does it make if I physically sit in bay office or in Romania, if I do my job well as other team members? If I initially sit in LA condo but then move for 2 weeks to Bangalore, am I committing fraud? What is the utility of restricting people's movement when they do all their work remotely? Whatever they do, this problem is bound to create tensions.
- pb7 5y ago>Does that mean if I work from home and move to more costly location I get automatic increase? Yes.
- darkwizard42 5y agoTo your first question. Yes, if you move to a more expensive location based on the bands Google provides, you will automatically see an increase in compensation.
- gen220 5y agoRelevant goomic: https://goomics.net/347/ https://goomics.net/347/ For those who can't / don't want to follow the link: it cleverly contrasts how it's perceived as righteous for corporations to engage in tax-arbitrage to maximize profits, but deceptive for employees to engage in cost-of-living arbitrage to maximize quality of life.
- effingwewt 5y agoOnce I was a 'Roadside Assistance Agent' (call center chair-warmer). When I applied it was for a different LOB (line of business). I was applying for tmobile customer service. I did their tests, we spoke of compensation, hours, days available, all that good stuff. I told them I was tired of being on call 24/7 and wanted regular scheduled hours, so I could know exactly when I get off work, plan accordingly and have a life. They told me I was going to be interviewing with three senior people from my team. They kept asking me weird questions that had nothing to do with the job I had applied for (T-mobile customer service). At the end they told me I was hired, but at the very end they tell me its for a totally different LOB (applied and tested for tmobile, was instead hired for Goodsam Roadside Assistance). They told me everything would remain the same- hours, comp, everything. All lies of course. So I get to training and find out hours are all over the place, no set schedule, and even better? -I never knew when I would get off work. Once we took a call we had to complete it. Imagine someone in BFE Canada, with a 40' RV, with a busted axle, and I have to now manually call all over Canada for 8+ hours to find a mobile mechanic willing to go for our paltry rates,oh and it's three ferrys to get there! They would not let us hand off calls, we could not take breaks even for restroom while on a call. Some calls went well over 8 hours. It was fucking disgusting. When I had enough of this they kept reiterating that we owed the company our time since it was our responsibility. When we accepted the job we took on a responsibility to our customers, our coworkers but most importantly to Qualfon. When they gave us a schedule we had to adhere to it or be fired...but they could change our hours/days on a whim and we had to take it. When they had mandatory overtime we would be fired if we didn't work it as it now counted as 'scheduled time' They didn't seem phased when I mentioned that what they were doing was illegal AF (no breaks, no telling about hours, refusing to let you off calls etc). When I bitched about not having a life because I never knew when I got off work, and how this LOB was a bait and switch, they kept reiterating we needed to keep our promises. I asked what about what we were promised by goodsam and qualfon, how they needed to adhere to our scheduled hours, stop changing days/hours, etc. I was pulled into an office where the site supervisor tried to bully me (a giant dude used to getting his way) we had a screaming match and I offered to take it outside. I mean if you get out of your chair while screaming and stand in my face jamming a finger in my chest, the way I see it you want a fight and I'm happy to oblige. Then starts the screaming for security (which we didn't even have!), which caused laughter since everyone heard what was happening. Anyways I and half the floor walked out that day, and everyone above a phone operator was fired and replaced within a month. This was the same company that when covid started refused to allow social distancing as it meant wasted space, and refused to allow masks as they 'muffled the operator's voice' Moral of the story is every company, every single one, sees what they do as 'good' and anything the employees do/want is 'bad'. They will, with a straight face, fuck you over and expect you to say 'thank you, sir, may I have another' . And they all wonder why no one wants to be in these situations anymore, especially not for bullshit comp.
- drewg123 5y agoAre they going to cut Urs' salary due to him working from NZ? Or are upper level execs exempt?
- whoknew1122 5y agoThis sort of thing is why there needs to be some sort of labor movement. Are unions perfect? No. But something needs to happen. You don't magically provide less value to a company by moving to a place with a lower cost of living. But businesses are using the lower cost of living as an excuse to cut payroll costs. It's disrespectful to the employee, but unfortunately there's nothing an individual employee can do other than quit.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI did a search of the comments for "food" before writing this, and I don't think it was adequately covered. I worked at Google 11 1/2 years, and I've been retired 4 years now. I still bemoan the convenience of being able to have whatever food I want for lunch or dinner, just by walking down to a cafe. Yeah, I buy it now, but I'll never have as much variety as Google did. The food costs for Google per employee are not insignificant, and they go to zero if you work at home. Same for all the other famous benefits Google has. I've also developed a theory about management, by the way: do you like it? Middle managers are the cause of all corporate problems.
- chronolitus 5y agoHave you heard of the Gervais Principle[1]? [1] https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-...
- AlbertCory 5y agoGreat article, thanks. It needs an editor, though. Way too long.
- AlbertCory 5y agoOops, never mind. Most of that is comments.
- drewg123 5y agoI'm an Xoogler, and I have to say: Google does all kinds of stupid and annoying things which are horribly counter-productive. They way they gamified travel was a HUGE waste of time. We had a travel system which required you to come in at the average price of past trips for a trip you're taking (or get VP approval). You could "bank" any $$ you saved if you came in below average. No matter what you did, you had to waste time. You either booked a trip in minutes and likely had to get VP approval for going over the cap, or you set up travel alerts and wound up wasting hours to days booking travel. Did they really intend for engineers making at least $250k in total comp to spend hours booking travel? I doubt it, but that's what happens. And don't even get me started on REWS ("real estate and workplace services") converting cubed workspaces to tables, while bragging about the open concept micro kitches, waterfalls, and eco walls in public building spaces. We got a regular REWS newsletter about new buildings, and the focus was on the nice public spaces, while never mentioning the spaces where we spent 90% of our time doing actual work. And those spaces kept getting worse and worse.
- mleonhard 5y agoIn SFO-SPE (345 Spear St), REWS took away the walls and merged the little offices into one giant open-plan acoustic hellscape. Concrete walkways ensure that every person with wooden-soled shoes will disturb 50 engineers every time they walk to a meeting/cafe/microkitchen/restroom (clop-clop-clop-clop-clop). REWS made themselves a quiet walled office for themselves on the top floor. Google is a dysfunctional organization. The day I joined Google was the best day of my life. A few years later, the day I left Google was the new best day of my life. I have photos from both days, with big smiles. Google's dysfunction is Larry & Sergey's fault. They control the board. They refuse to put in a CEO who will fix the incentive structure to make Googlers focus on users.
- drewg123 5y agoShortly after I left, they moved my team from Plymouth Rd (on the main campus) to a new building in Santa Clara. The old setup had high-walled cubes with 6 people per cube (which is objectively horrific, but good by Google standards). The new setup was a large room with nothing but tables and hard surfaces. Worse, the new location was off the main campus, away from every single other group we collaborated with (and away from all the good food, activities, etc). After the move, most of my group either left or retired.
- justicezyx 5y agoThis has been instated at least before 2016, I was seeking transfer to a Seattle team from Sunnyvale and was told pay will need to be adjusted. I think this is perfectly reasonable.
- xivzgrev 5y agoAt first this policy seemed kind of weird. It doesn’t actually seem tied to remote work per se, but rather distance to office. So what it seems is that google sees a lot of people wanting to work remote. With this, they say you can work remote..but if you choose to live away from office, you will earn less. Now why do they want “remote” employees close to the office? My guess is one of two things: 1) it’s easier to require folks to come into office for random events like team building. Less room to squabble if you live in same city 2) it’s a long term play to “pull” people back into office. When you live in same city as office, it’s a much easier choice to decide “hey maybe I should just go back to office.”
- dougSF70 5y agoI suppose Google's argument could be: if I am going to allow remote work for this role then let's go the whole hog and move the role off-shore. There also a lot of comments in this thread confusing large organizations with individual ineptitide. Don't blame individual managers for spending time in internal meetings unless you only have 10 people working there. It's hard to organize corporations and get people behind the mission especially with a tendency to "insubordination" , also evidenced in the comments here. While many people are more individually effective working alone (at home) corporations are more effective when people work together and have more chance collaborations. IMO, the commute issue is a problem that most US cities have sucky public transport that many people won't use. The only exception is NYC. Solve that and commuting could be less stressful.
- blamestross 5y agoBeing remote puts you in a broader labor market. This move will lower EVERYONE's salaries in the long run. If big tech companies decide it doesn't impact performance too bad, they want this. I also work for a FAANG remotely with a rare skillset and an autoimmune condition, so this had impacted me less than it will others. For my health and my lifestyle, the pay cut is easily worth it.
- omoikane 5y agoFrom the article: > Facebook (FB.O) and Twitter (TWTR.N) also cut pay for remote employees who move to less expensive areas, while smaller companies including Reddit and Zillow (ZG.O) have shifted to location-agnostic pay models, citing advantages when it comes to hiring, retention and diversity. I can't find discussions related to the other companies referenced here. Did those not make it to hacker news?
- dvtrn 5y agoIs anyone familiar enough with the generalities of contract law to speak on that angle of the discussion? I tried searching through the comments but I've been wondering lately: if a Googler (or any worker, really) signs an employment contract that lays out salary, pay frequency and similar, but doesn't specify that said pay, pay frequency and similar are a condition of one's physical location, do they have standing to sue their employer for breach of contract if said employer tries to change their salary when that employee packs up their bags and relocates?
- mamaluigie 5y agoThe office at the location that I currently am based in for my company includes a courtyard with pond for breaks, an onsite massage therapist, food court with good food, workout gym, and other things... If I am not getting to use these extra provided perks I am expecting for my company to make up for that by paying me a portion of what they were spending on all of those in person perks. This is prob going to make some developers quit working at google I could imagine.
- xcambar 5y agoI’m hearing more and more that companies cut compensation based on remote or onsite work. But what I’ve heard only concerns hiring processes, which is already alarming, whereas this article mentions during-contract salary cut, which I can’t comment on since it is just plain illegal where I am (Europe) and I’m just educated to react very strongly to this madness. See? I just did it :)
- Gatsky 5y agoI have noticed that any HN front page thread about compensation has at least 300 comments.
- 01100011 5y agoTranslation: Don't you dare try to accumulate wealth and retire early. Also, I wonder how much more likely upper managers are to own real estate in areas near Google offices.
- runbathtime 5y agoSomehow I think they will be ok. Also, the ones that can show their productivity increased at home might get a raise.
- rebuilder 5y agoSo many different ways to view this. Market realist: Google are just taking their cut of the profit opportunity a lower cost of living provides. Social: it wouldn’t be fair to pay everyone the same if cost of living differs. WTF: Are Google trying to ensure housing costs stay high in urban areas?
- darkwizard42 5y agoOne thing that was included here is that Google is now also reducing your equity compensation as a part of relocation. Changing the salary I understand and there are a lot of valid points and counterpoints on why it should or should not change based on your cost of living in the city/supply vs.demand in the city for the job. I really dislike equity compensation being reduced because equity is supposed to be a direct reward for the value you generate for the company. Why does someone who lives in Zurich/SFO/NYC have any more impact vs. someone who lives in Kansas. Both are contributing the same and their equity should reflect that...
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoWhy do you think the very same points about cost of living not apply here?
- liminal 5y agoDoesn't the company save a lot of money with remote workers? It seems like they could afford to pay _more_ to people who work remotely.
- OnionBlender 5y agoI'm not interested in returning to the office to work in the noisy open floor plan. If they gave me an office I'd consider it but I doubt they would ever do that.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoRemember that work is about compensation per time. If you don’t get that 10% raise you wanted, work smarter and 10% less to give yourself a raise. Use that extra time, because it’s all we have.
- ashtonkem 5y agoPoint from Corey Quinn; there sure are a lot of companies registered in Delaware that want to reduce their workers comp based on location. Apparently what’s good for the Goose is not good for the Gander, according to executives.
- glued 5y agoWorking from home / remote has had significant effects on collaboration and execution especially for more junior employees. Only a handful of more senior engineers have been more productive from my experience. Additionally, company politics are real and if you work remote, you may miss out on opportunities for growth.
- arwhatever 5y agoI was hopeful, perhaps naively, that sending some knowledge workers into the rural regions of our country (U.S.) might help to alleviate both the cultural and economic divides that plague our society. But I guess Google & others don't care.
- heavyset_go 5y agoGoogle is punishing its employees for potentially devaluing its billions of dollars of investments in campus and office real estate.
- kodah 5y agoEvery time I've seen this done it has nothing to do with remote work. It has everything to do with a geo-centric pay model. Companies typically calculate the living expenses of a given geography, and slap that on top of a base pay like it's COLA. The hard part to swallow if you're on the losing end of this equation is that people in high inflation areas have long term assets that inflate as well, like homes. If they receive more long-term appreciating income like RSUs rather than cash then it compounds this problem. A general rule to retirement that I've constructed is that where you retire will be at least less than the cost of living of where you made your money. So, if you choose remote work early on in your career and live in Oklahoma, the choices of places to retire in are slimmed as compared to someone who does exactly what you do in San Francisco. The emotional toll of this is equally burdensome when you figure out that in tech we sell a product in large geographies for an equal price; so effectively someone is making more than you just by their very existence in a geography, whether that be a city, county, state, or nation.
- xtat 5y agoPay is the only leverage bigtech has left
- zR0x 5y agoThe reason they want us in offices is real property is the root of power. If they don’t own all that land they lose influence locally. They can’t put on spectacle in their “stadium”, distracting us from the reality we reconnected to during covid.
- aiava 5y agoGoogle employees could lose money if they stay at google. Great chance for other companies.
- boublepop 5y agoIt only seems fair that employees also make financial sacrifices when working from home, considering that the employer is also sacrificing a lot of expenses related to providing office space for the employee, and since productivity has been shown to grow when working from home, which means the employer suddenly has to do a lot more to keep track of all the increased profits. /S
- jordache 5y agoWhat are people complaining about? A cost of living (COL) variable in your compensation keeps things rational. Plus people are missing the fact that the original compensation of X was established in the context of some geographical region. So people complain if their COL adjustment decreases their pay but all good if COL increases their pay? You gotta have it working in both ways.
- partiallypro 5y agoI don't really get this, shouldn't you get paid more? If more people worked from home that means the company is paying less expenses. Less floor space, less internet costs, less office supplies. To me, cutting pay for remote workers is basically the company double dipping.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoExpect class action suit for Google. See how legal is that to cut salary without having that clause in the contract. And even if for some obscureness they manage to weasel in, expect mass resignation or defectiom with company secrets. On the bright side this is a fair move to give smaller companies the knowledge know-how that accumulated in Google. If I'm the CEO in charged, HR will be the first getting sack for making Google the scapegoat for being the first prominent company to do so. This is what you get when having less than capable HR team.