23 ms·
macOS has checked app signatures online for over 2 years
- daniellarusso 6y agoSo, can you use macOS offline for extended periods of time?
- mikkelam 6y agoYes, it only checks when you're online
- nullc 6y agoA common refrain in arguments that we don't need laws to protect privacy is that the market will take care of it. The market can't act against what it can't see. Privacy loss is often irreversible. A common refrain in arguments that we don't need to reject closed source software to protect privacy is that being closed source doesn't hide the behaviour, and people will still notice backdoors and privacy leaks. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. Parts of the US Governments unlawful massive domestic surveillance apparatus were described in the open in IETF drafs and patent documents for years. But people largely didn't notice and regarded reports as conspiracy theories for a long time. Information being available doesn't necessarily make any difference and making a difference is what matters.
- simias 6y ago> The market can't act against what it can't see. Privacy loss is often irreversible. You're not wrong, but on the other hand has "the market" shown any serious signal that it cares about privacy? From what I can see people seem more than glad to trade privacy and personal information for free services and cheaper hardware. Take Samsung putting ads on their "smart" TV's UI and screenshotting what people are watching for profiling, that's been known for a while now. The market seems fine with it. And I mean, at this point I could just gesture broadly at all of Facebook.
- oarsinsync 6y ago> has "the market" shown any serious signal that it cares about privacy? Depends on what you consider a serious signal of care. If 'voting with you wallet' is the measure, increasing levels of income inequality, stagnant wages, weakening employee rights through the gig-economy, etc. are effectively taking away that choice, as most market participants cannot afford to make the choice. Also, what is the paid alternative to Apple or Google photos that allows me to have the same end user experience, without giving up my privacy? "the market" doesn't even have such an offer that I can see. The closest I can find (and that's through here) is photostructure.com, and even that's lacking all the local-ML-foo that makes Apple/Google photos a compelling option over anything else. > Take Samsung putting ads on their "smart" TV's UI and screenshotting what people are watching for profiling, that's been known for a while now. Known by who? I'd wager a year's salary that >50% of Samsung TV owners (and bump that number up to >75% of Samsung TV users) do not know this is happening.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zepto 6y agoIncome inequality and stagnant wages etc are not the consequences of Apple and Google.
- sudosysgen 6y agoNo one suggested they are. But they still make it much less likely for the average Joe to put money and effort to protect their privacy, and this is known to those that make major pricing decisions.
- kortilla 6y agoWe’re talking about Apple here. People who can afford a Mac over a cheap pc/chrome book already have disposable income and are making trade-offs with it.
- absolutelyrad 6y agoThe market only acts fairly when the product is a commodity. The time for the market to react for a product with the complexity of a mac is decades. As the ecosystem grows, the cost of switching increases. Therefore market starts acting more and more inefficiently. This is why countries have state intervention in such cases. And anti trust exists. If the option was a mac with privacy vs a mac without privacy but $10 cheaper, I'd think the market would pick the mac with privacy. No such choice within the budget exists, and if a company has a monopoly on the ecosystem, then the market cannot react when held hostage. The cost to transition to a different ecosystem is thousands of $'s when you've been using a mac your entire life. It's not like you'd want to relearn many things when you get older, perhaps the sunk cost fallacy as many would define it. It's a bundled deal, it's not like you can pick the parts you like and throw away the ones you don't like it would be in an efficient market. If even someone like me cannot be bothered to move to more privacy friendly platforms, then I don't have hope for other people. It's just not worth it. Until the majority face the consequences of their apathy, any action you take is fruitless. Let them taste the pain, then offer the solution. I know I can be tracked. So what? I can't verify the silicon in my device, can I? Gotta trust someone, maybe blockchain will solve the problem of trust among humans, in a verifiable way.
- _puk 6y agoWhilst I agree with the sentiment, it does occur to me just how many kindles I see with ads. Is there any data released on ads Vs no ads versions? That's the closest comparator I can think of.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI think its worthwhile trying to test the hypothesys, but i dont think anyone takes privacy on a book reader with the same passion as they do on a mobile phone.
- paublyrne 6y ago> Whilst I agree with the sentiment, it does occur to me just how many kindles I see with ads. True, although the price difference for the Kindle is about 20%. If the discount on a Macbook Air was similar, I'm sure it would be well subscribed.
- internet_user 6y agowhich IETF drafts and patents? Can you point me to some links? tia
- nullc 6y agoSure, lemme give you an example: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-cavuto-dtcp-00 https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-cavuto-dtcp-00 This protocol was created so that monitoring infrastructure could reprogram asic-based packet filters on collection routers (optical taps feed routers with half-duplex-mode interfaces), which grab sampled netflow plus specific targets selected by downstream analysis in realtime. It has to be extremely fast so that it can race TCP handshakes. I don't think it's much of an exaggeration to say that the technical components of almost all the mass surveillance infrastructure is described in open sources. Yes, they don't put "THIS IS FOR SPYING ON ALL THE PEOPLE" on it, but they also don't even bother reliably scrubbing sigint terms like "tasking". Sometimes the functionality is described under the color of "lawful intercept", though not always. One of the arguments that people made against the existence of widescale internet surveillance -- back before it was proved to exist-- was that it would require so much technology that it would be impossible to keep secret: the conspiracy would have to be too big. But it wasn't kept secret, not really-- we just weren't paying attention to the evidence around us. For a related patent example: https://patents.google.com/patent/US8031715B1 https://patents.google.com/patent/US8031715B1 which has fairly explicit language on the applications: > The techniques are described herein by way of example to dynamic flow capture (DFC) service cards that can monitor and distribute targeted network communications to content destinations under high traffic rates, even core traffic rates of the Internet, including OC-3, OC-12, OC-48, OC-192, and higher rates. Moreover, the techniques described herein allow control sources (such as Internet service providers, customers, or law enforcement agencies) to tap new or current packet flows within an extremely small period of time after specifying flow capture information, e.g., within 50 milliseconds, even under high-volume networks. > Further, the techniques can readily be applied in large networks that may have one or more million of concurrent packet flows, and where control sources may define hundreds of thousands of filter criteria entries in order to target specific communications.
- polote 6y ago> A common refrain in arguments that we don't need laws to protect privacy is that the market will take care of it Seriously, who has ever been successful at defending that idea ?
- amelius 6y agoSo, we should take away the market's incentive to infringe upon our privacy: by making user-tracking illegal.
- blub 6y agoThe laws are already there. If you care about this and have some free time you may try to make a complain to the Irish data protection commission. I'm not sure if it's infringing though. If Apple says that they do not collect personal data and that the information is thrown away and this is done for a legitimate business purpose or for the customers (i.e. protecting customers), it may well be fine according to the GDPR.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoLying to the customer about what your product does, or having secret functionality, should be a criminal offence in the same way as breaking and entering or stalking are. Then, we would find out very quickly what people value. I firmly believe this ecosystem (as in privacy violating ad and data selling business model) is only dominant because companies are able to mislead with impunity, so it's basically a form of fraud
- ethbr0 6y agoThe act of breaching privacy is technically difficult to prohibit in a way many of us would find palatable. What should be targeted is the product of said breaches. Something like the blood diamond approach. If your company has PII, then you by law must be able to produce a consented attestation chain all the way back to the source. If you do not, then you're charged a fine for every piece of unattested PII on every individual.
- zepto 6y agoBy the time someone is charged with a crime, the damage is already done. And, there will be many scammers who are simply out of reach of meaningful legal remedies.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI thonk we are both arguing that clear consent must be present, and the customer must have clearly agreed to whatever you are doing with the data - that appears similar to GDPR. However, how do you prove John Doe has actually agreed to this? What if John says he did not click accept button? Do we require digital signature with certificates, given that most people don't have them or know how to use them? I think the problem is more tractable for physical products running firmware - there you have real proof of purchase, and, at present, firmware that does whatever it wants.
- chrisweekly 6y agoGreat points. Related tangent: for those interested in this topic of "unlawful massive domestic surveillance", I heartily recommend Cory Doctorow's "Little Brother" novels -- esp the most recent, "Attack Surface". They get the technical details right while remaining accessible and engaging regardless of the reader's geek acumen.
- jaredklewis 6y agoYes, unfortunately there is no safe harbor. Companies can make mistakes or add backdoors and we won't know. See this clusterfuck. Open Source, likewise, can make mistakes and (much more rarely) add backdoors, and we could know, but few have the resources to so. See heartbleed.
- pibechorro 6y agoYa no thanks. Top down regulation will just make startups less likely to enter new disruptive tech. The solution is choice, stop using Apple products and all their shadyness stops being an issue.
- eganist 6y ago> Ya no thanks. Top down regulation will just make startups less likely to enter new disruptive tech. The solution is choice, stop using Apple products and all their shadyness stops being an issue. And since people have demonstrated that they're not appropriately incentivized to stop, that's where the regulations snap in, which brings us back to where we started: there's a need for it. Solution could just be to regulate based on a tightly managed definition of age. Enable younger companies to have a bit more flexibility in determining their business model as controls slowly snap in as the company ages. There are some pretty clear loopholes that immediately come to mind (e.g. re-chartering the company every few years and transferring assets) that'll need to somehow be managed, but it should be enough to give companies runway to figure out how to disrupt and monetize while coming into compliance with consumer protections.
- diffeomorphism 6y ago> The solution is choice Correct. Among apple, MS and google you have no choice. That is why regulation is necessary.
- oblio 6y agoHow do you provide choice? How do you commoditize an entire hardware and software ecosystem, vertically integrated? Just like Standard Oil or AT & T were displaced, right? By customers going to their competitors? I'm being sarcastic, obviously :-)
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoNothing shady about this. It isn’t logged and it protects customers from malware. That was the purpose. Most customers want that.
- AshWolfy 6y ago> Top down regulation will just make startups less likely to enter new disruptive tech Im ok with this
- valuearb 6y agoProbably no one cares because Apple’s OCSP checks don’t reduce your privacy.
- grupthink 6y agoThey should care. The checks are sent unencrypted over HTTP to Apple's OCSP.
- valuearb 6y agoSince they don’t identify specific apps you use, so what’s your point?
- throwaway525142 6y agoAs far as I understand it, most vendors ship a single digit amount of apps. If you start the Tor browser, everyone on your network will know. If you start Firefox, everyone on your network will know you started a Mozilla product, most likely Firefox. If you start the Zoom client, everyone on your network knows you started the Zoom client. I don't think the "it's only the vendor" defense of Apple is any good.
- athms 6y agoOn MacOS, developer certificate requests are NOT done for every application launch. Responses are cached for a period of time before a new check is done. FYI -- Both Firefox and Safari use OCSP to check server certificates. Anybody sniffing your network could figure out which websites you visit. Chrome still uses CRL; it trades precision for performance.
- pseudalopex 6y agoThat period of time was 5 minutes.
- athms 6y ago
- nerbert 6y agoOn argument to make is that the market only cares about the majority of their customers, not all of them. If 0.5% of their customers has their privacy busted by a backdoor, or that 0.01% of google users have their account arbitrarily deleted, this percentage of users is screwed like no one and the company doesn't suffer any damage.
- ardy42 6y ago> A common refrain in arguments that we don't need to reject closed source software to protect privacy is that being closed source doesn't hide the behaviour, and people will still notice backdoors and privacy leaks. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. And there are cases where it's not practical for "people to notice." For instance: a privacy leak that only uses the cell network connection of a phone, which would avoid easily-sniffed connections.
- iso1631 6y agoEven with traffic monitoring, how do you distinguish bad TLS traffic from a machine you don't control to a cloudflare IP to good TLS traffic?
- api 6y ago> The market can't act against what it can't see. Privacy loss is often irreversible. I would add that the market can't act to prevent risks that are outside the market and not taken into account by the market. The big risks from widespread privacy loss are the exploitation of private data by criminals, foreign unconventional warfare by terrorists or hostile states, and the rise of a totalitarian government here in the USA. Criminal action can to some extent be priced into a market, but the other two really can't be.
- Spooky23 6y agoThis isn’t that. I’ve been aware of this for some time, pretty sure it was in the security white paper and talked about as a feature. People forget about CRLs because browsers mostly ignore them. People just go crazy for any Apple story because it attracts attention. People have been paying to send all sorts of app launch analytics to AV companies for example since the 90s.
- kelnos 6y ago> I’ve been aware of this for some time, pretty sure it was in the security white paper and talked about as a feature. That doesn't invalidate what the parent said. The only way awareness helps is if it's general knowledge. I don't believe it was, and you personally having known about it doesn't make it so.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> A common refrain in arguments that we don't need laws to protect privacy is that the market will take care of it. Stronger privacy laws hurt Google, Facebook, and Amazon far more than Apple. Most of Apple's privacy gaffs are just bonehead moves like this one which shouldn't happen, but also don't drive revenue.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI've always thought Apple's focus on privacy (putting aside the current incident) is rather clever as Google have no way to respond. Any improvements to privacy undermine their business model.
- refulgentis 6y agoYou'd think that'd be how it worked out, but funnily enough, it's net negative even when Google actively tries to enhance privacy! Using Apple's privacy-sensitive ad blocker standard made people protest the limitations of a fixed count of sites, and competitors spun it into a way for Google to advantage themselves (details on that somewhat murky, i.e. nonexistent) We have a long way to go as an industry on keeping users _well_ informed on their privacy, and I'm afraid Apple's set us back years by morphing it into an advertising one-liner over actually helping users along.
- kelnos 6y agoI don't look at it that way. I think privacy is secondary to Apple, and that they use privacy as a selling point when it suits them. Their overall goal is tight control over the entire computing experience, and in places where that degrades privacy, so be it.
- ogre_codes 6y agoTheir goal is making money. On the iPhone, that means keeping the system's reputation for security and ease of use trumps more or less everything else. On the Mac? Not so much. For Apple, privacy is a cheap giveaway because unlike Google or Facebook, the way Apple makes money doesn't require they know when my last BM was.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoPerhaps this is why Apple did not ask for permission from the user to add some delay every time the user launches an application. If the user were presented with the choice what would she choose. If we look at the example of OCSP in the website certificate context, the notion of the delay added by OCSP (not to mention privacy concerns) being objectionable has already been acknowledged. As a result we have OCSP stapling. For some reason, in the Apple developer certificate context, OCSP is deemed acceptable by default.
- 8bitsrule 6y ago> arguments that we don't need laws to protect privacy is that the market will take care of it. Since discussion of Apple's behavior in particular has, somehow, been completely de-railed anyway (a frequent happening on HN) ... Can't help but observe that the market takes the best care of those who control it. Freely.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Parts of the US Governments unlawful massive domestic surveillance apparatus were described in the open in IETF drafs and patent documents for years. References?
- raxxorrax 6y agoHow does Windows check executables? I hope they don't do the same. Does it come with a master list of public keys from manufacturers to check the signature against? How does that work for new vendors?
- satysin 6y agoMicrosoft SmartScreen is very similar to Apple's approach. Although I believe you can disable SmartScreen on Windows still which, afaik, you cannot do on macOS without resorting to "hacks" such as editing the hosts file to loopback the Apple OCSP server. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_SmartScreen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_SmartScreen
- minot 6y agoGood thing too because it is easy to screw up signing. For example, even the dotnet team has trouble with it https://github.com/dotnet/core/issues/5202 https://github.com/dotnet/core/issues/5202
- ameyab 6y agoExactly. The policy applies to everyone. Unsigned new binaries (executables) on the internet are not to be trusted by the general public.
- raxxorrax 6y agoUnfortunately Microsoft is that predictable that it is safe to say they already think about removing the option to disable it. Another reason not to use an MS account. I think this is a plain data leak and arguably worse than a trojan can do to your system in context of modern banking security measures. Also I doubt most users are aware that MS gets info on every app you run.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y ago>Does it come with a master list of public keys from manufacturers to check the signature against? That won't handle revocations.
- KingOfCoders 6y ago"Privacy is not a feature".
- intricatedetail 6y agoPrivacy is a currency you pay hidden charges with.
- anticensor 6y agoPrivacy is a thing you only get to choose once per a line of events. Once you commit to the non-private option, you are out of luck. No amount of postcautions will fix that.
- woahAcademia 6y agoDirectly contradicting current Apple Marketing. I lothe Apple(and other unethical companies) for lying in their ads. Any benefits of macOS are instantly gone because you cannot Trust Apple to tell the truth. It's as unreliable as Google keeping a service around.
- m463 6y agoI first started getting an idea that something was amiss with apple years and years ago. "Apple machines don't get viruses" Everyone "knew" that. Everyone knew that apple machines were secure. Turns out there were plenty of things going on with apple just like other companies. The difference was that apple would actively persecute (even prosecute) people who explored or discovered these things. Basically apple marketing was able to prevent a lot of vulnerabilities from publicity. Probably marketing 101, protect your brand.
- Bud 6y agoPlease cite evidence for these extraordinary claims. Who, precisely, did Apple "prosecute" for "exploring" security issues? Please don't post made-up things in public. As an aside, no, everyone did not "know" that Macs don't get viruses. But yes, most informed people were aware that Macs were somewhat less susceptible to malware for a while. Please don't exaggerate wildly.
- lxgr 6y agoIs there any UI indication that OCSP checks have been consistently failing for some period of time? My concern is less local malware (if something malicious has gained the privileges to filter OCSP, it's probably already game over) but rather networks filtering ocsp.apple.com (for whatever reason).
- gruez 6y agoDoes it matter? Would anyone (but the most paranoid) care? My guess is that OCSP is supposed to be part of a defense in depth strategy, so it doesn't have to be 100% airtight to achieve its goals
- raxxorrax 6y agoI care that Apple or Microsoft don't get to know what executables I run. That is information highly relevant to security. And what do mean with paranoid? I think computing is in danger of getting locked down and that would be such a large overall detriment for everybody. It is a matter of having a broad perspective. It is also political because you create information asymmetry. To be honest, to dismiss it as paranoia might not be a really valuable assessment. Subjective, but I think it fairly lacking.
- gruez 6y ago> I care that Apple or Microsoft don't get to know what executables I run. That is information highly relevant to security. I think you missed the context of this comment thread. The "Does it matter" and "Would anyone care?" questions were directed at the question of what happens (presumably from a security point of view), if OSCP requests were being blocked. It's not related to the discussion about whether OSCP queries violate privacy or not.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe only charitable understanding of this program is that Apple has no actual table connecting software to hashes, but that they could use the information to understand outbreaks of botnets/spyware that they could then help inform ISPs/global law enforcement to help stop. Is this even reasonable?
- user-the-name 6y agoThe requests contain only app hashes. They do not contain the unique hardware identifier that Apple computers have. They do not contain your Apple ID, identifying you as a user. Why would you not interpret this charitably as them not actually trying to spy on you? If they wanted to spy on you, why on Earth would they not send the actual valuable information?
- beervirus 6y agoIs it even app hashes, or developer certificate hashes?
- jtbayly 6y agoThe larger the program, the longer it takes to verify the first time you run it. I can only interpret that as meaning they are basing the whole program. Source: me, downloading and running various apps
- jtbayly 6y agoApparently the initial launch delay is Gatekeeper, which is something different.
- whatever1 6y agoWhat does that even mean? Of course they can identify you, you are knocking their door with the same IP with your iCloud account. Maybe the file you are giving them does not have your uid, but as long as you have connected your Mac to your Apple account you are uniquely identified.
- intricatedetail 6y agoAny opt out protection racket should be illegal. Even if it is "anonymous", someone could be identified from their behavioural patterns which are unique to each human. I hope that Apple gets at least hundred billion fine for such brazen violation of privacy so they will learn their lesson and they should be ordered to delete all personal data they don't have legitimate business need for.
- user-the-name 6y agoWhy would they try to identify you from your "behavioural patterns", when they already have the device identifier and your Apple ID, which identify you are your computer uniquely? Which, to be very specific, they _do not send_. They COULD identify you extremely easily, and they specifically chose not to do that.
- lovelyviking 6y agoMay be they have other channels which could or already do send device identifiter and Apple ID. How do you know what _else_ they do ? Who knew they were sending hashes till the recent malfunctioning? What _esle_ we do not know now?
- user-the-name 6y agoIf they wanted that information tied together, they would send it together. Otherwise they have to keep guessing about what goes together with what. That would make no sense. And it was known this data was being sent.
- lovelyviking 6y ago>That would make no sense. Hiding such feature without option to turn it off would also make no sense to me but they did it. >If they wanted that information tied together, they would send it together. sure, unless they wanted to hide the fact they wanted information tied together. In that case they can always provide the line of argument you provide once they caught and say "Oh, if we wanted to spy we would do it openly and brutally. There is no sense for us to make it complicated." But something is telling me that one who wish to spy would do it in some sophisticated manner. The bottom line we do not know and we _can_not_ know since we did not see _all_ sources. You also cannot know what they wanted, so your guess is as good as any other? Or somehow you know something we don't? The bottom line here is the same: who knows. But I think if they wanted to make it open and secure they would simply put option in GUI with clear text explaining what it does and how it does it with ability to turn this thing off. And they didn't do it this way. For me it can mean 'they are hiding something' possibly. What else they hide and why we simply do not know.
- rednum 6y agoAnother fun fact about this system: something changed in how the binaries are evaluated and one VST plugins I've downloaded months ago was marked as malware. The plugin is quite popular in community so I think it's unlikely it contains actual malicious code (in fact I've contacted the developer and he said he has done some fixes for Apple's security policies recently). Imagine my shock when I open an old project in Ableton and suddenly some sounds just don't work. This really sucks, I don't want to worry about whether my music will work five or ten years from now (I can imagine I may I want to remix some old piece). I suppose I can err on side of safety and export all tracks to wav. However, it's not an isolated problem. It feels that every other week something happens that undermines my confidence in Macbook as good device for making music.
- pacifika 6y agoIt's been good practice for a long time to "freeze" or "render" the tracks out after the song is finished so that the song can be loaded without the plugins.
- wintermutestwin 6y agoTrue, but this shouldn't be necessary in response to anti-consumer behavior.
- dkonofalski 6y agoThis is not anti-consumer behavior. Consumers are, overall, protected when they can verify the source of an application or extension on their computers. Their freedom may be limited but it's not a black-and-white "this is anti-consumer".
- cma 6y agoSome signatures are invalidated due to business disputes on entirely different platforms (Epic dispute on iOS, signatures invalidated, or threatened to be before court order prevented it, on OS X, for no security reason).
- jrochkind1 6y agoHonest question I'm not an expert: The initial commments in this thread are painting it as a severe privacy violation. (The actual OP article author does not necessarily share this perspetive). How is what is being done with OCSP different in more concerning way for privacy (if it is) from Firefox or Chrome's use of OCSP?
- pfortuny 6y agoBecause when you browse the Internet you know you are browsing it. When you run software, you do not expected "unexpected" Internet use. You go for a walk, you carry an umbrella, or go dressed. You are at home, you do not expect it to "rain" or for someone to "watch you".
- cdubzzz 6y agoThat seems incredibly naive. I can’t think of a single program off the top of my head that doesn’t use the Internet to some extent while running. Even many CLI tools I use for development do update checks (and sometimes analytics) in the background.
- pfortuny 6y agoYour choice, not mine. Like: Houdini Emacs Latex A file manager Audacity A Terminal ... Off the tip of my head, used almost daily.
- cdubzzz 6y agoI didn’t mean to imply that one could not name programs that don’t communicate. Of course they exist. I’m not arguing for this type of behavior, just pointing out that it is pretty much the norm. On macOS I use Little Snitch to find and shutdown must of this extra traffic.
- gspr 6y ago> I can’t think of a single program off the top of my head that doesn’t use the Internet to some extent while running > I didn’t mean to imply that one could not name programs that don’t communicate. Can you understand how people would read your first comment that way, though?
- stefan_ 6y agoThe irony of arguing that the rapid rate of certificate revocations is proof of the system being necessary and secure. No, it's proof that the system is useless. Code signing is a dead end, and we have known that latest with Stuxnet.
- jezfromfuture 6y agoA nation state virus that stole a cert is not a good argument against this , windows only started checking certs very recently please get your head out of the sand. It’s worked great for many years for us Mac users.
- viktorcode 6y agoWith the system checking for certificate validity Stuxnet would have stopped shortly after its certificate was revoked. Regardless, Stuxnet example is way off the mark. It was designed to work in air-gapped network and defeat particular set of obstacles.
- xalava 6y agoInteresting, but reading the conclusion I'm fascinated in this affaire how technically knowledgeable people loose common sense to defend their favorite brand: - Per launch verification is terrible for privacy, vis-a-vis Apple and the whole network when it happens in plain text - "They should also explain how, having enjoyed their benefits for a couple of years, they’ve suddenly decided they were such a bad idea after all", another key issue: user information, consent and control. - Additionally, the public was made aware because it malfunctioned, which is also a security issue. - Considering the current corporate culture, there are legitimate concerns of what those choices might lead towards
- netsharc 6y agoYeah, the article's last paragraph irks me... to reformulate it in the context of domestic spying, it'd be like saying "NSA's communication monitoring have kept you safe for years, now that you've heard of it, you decide it's a bad idea?". Most people probably never noticed this phone-home feature existed, just like they never knew that NSA was recording everything. (Obviously anyone who bothered to look under the hood could've seen it, but hey, how many people do that).
- Ar-Curunir 6y agoThe Apple thing was not designed for explicit mass-surveillance; NSA’s programs are. That’s kind of a big difference.
- mhh__ 6y agoI think there's an element of people desperately wanting to believe that apple is their tribe, rather than just another company. I can believe Apple do care about privacy, but ultimately they're just another company. For example, I'm sure apple would love the Epic lawsuit to be decided based on a poll of HN users - "I would rather not have the freedom to run whatever I want, because [insert bizarre anecdote]". Don't project your own beliefs onto apple, vote with your wallet if they annoy you - it's just a trackpad.
- 6y ago
- nickpp 6y agoI sometimes wonder if the mods won't end up banning "political" talk on HN. Because these days everything becomes political, even if it really is a technical issue. Case to the point: online signature check was a technical decision, to fight malware. It was implemented similarly by other OS vendors (Microsoft) and it's been this way for years. Now we discover that it has the unfortunate side-effect that it lessens privacy. Apple (and probably other OS vendors) are working to improve that in the future. Also, a technical issue. It was never about privacy. It was never a political issue. Can we please just discuss it from a technological standpoint?
- solinent 6y agoIt's possible that the technical discussion about online signature checking was subsumed by the political discussion--the two are interrelated and if we don't get into these discussions here I don't really see another place for them to happen. It's easy to shrug it off as simply a technical issue, and it's very convenient for the PR department as well.
- shawnz 6y agoThe technical issue is "can we provide these features without weakening privacy?" The political issue is "if we can't provide these features without weakening privacy, should we still provide them?" Aren't they both important points to discuss?
- nickpp 6y agoThey are, but the difference is that we can fix technical issues, or at least improve them. We can (mostly) agree about what's right and wrong and what's better or worse. Political issues on the other hand, just end up antagonizing us ever more. We argue endlessly, go on countless tangents and nobody agrees on anything because we see the very issues under different lights, experiences, values and cultures. I am tired of politics. I just want to get stuff done. Hopefully good stuff, but I’d settle for slightly better.
- shawnz 6y ago
- DavideNL 6y ago> "Those who consider that Apple’s current online certificate checks are unnecessary, invasive or controlling should familiarise themselves with how they have come about, and their importance to macOS security. They should also explain how, having enjoyed their benefits for a couple of years, they’ve suddenly decided they were such a bad idea after all, and what should replace them." A simple opt-out toggle, for privacy reasons, would be a good start... people should stay in control of their own data and be able to choose themselves whether or not they are willing to trade in their privacy (for security in this case).
- dilap 6y agoApple has said they plan to do this, and also encrypt the checking payload. Sounds good to me, though definitely a privacy failure that they didn't do this in the first place. The other thing I'd like to see is the app open immediately, w/ the check happening asynchronously in the background. (This seems like super-basic good engineering to me.) No idea if they're planning to fix that or not.
- ascagnel_ 6y ago> The other thing I'd like to see is the app open immediately, w/ the check happening asynchronously in the background. (This seems like super-basic good engineering to me.) No idea if they're planning to fix that or not. How would this work? The point of the check is to block malware from running, and opening without the check would, by definition, negate the entire system. If malware authors get wise to the async scheme, they can write programs that deliver their payload in the opening milliseconds of an app’s execution, while the network call is running (even the fastest pings would leave 1 or 2 ms worth of window).
- angry_octet 6y agoSurely this check could be done on install/first run, then cached? If you want rapid blacklisting, a frequent call to Apple to say "anything new blacklisted?" would suffice. Same as push notification.
- _qulr 6y agoI give up on Hacker News. Go ahead and wallow in your ignorance, downvoting experts.
- zepto 6y agoIt has been widely known that these checks were happening. Not only that, this isn’t the first server problem that impacted launch performance. It’s just the most severe. The main difference is that this time around there are people who are claiming that Apple is using the OCSP checks for some kind of nefarious tracking purposes. These people have no evidence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Sigmoid 6y ago"The main difference is that this time around there are people who are claiming that Apple is using the OCSP checks for some kind of nefarious tracking purposes." What proof is there that we should trust Apple? They could tracking for nefarious purposes for all you know. Thats the problem.
- zepto 6y agoThat’s true of every single organization and every single individual. You can always justify a conspiracy theory on the basis that you can’t prove a negative like this. Let’s consider another conspiracy theory: “A state actor wants to install spyware, and Apple’s OCSP is a barrier to their goal. They are running an influence campaign to get users to opt out of security protections.” There is no evidence for this theory. But “for all you know” certain people posting here have been paid to spread disinformation as part of this conspiracy. (Just to be clear - there is no evidence for this, and I don’t think it is likely) In the absence of evidence, it is not rational to completely dismiss either or both possibilities (that Apple has a hidden agenda or that there is a conspiracy to weaken Apple’s security). What is irrational is to use the absence of evidence to the contrary to convince yourself that something is obviously true. However on the broader point - I agree that we should not be reliant on trusting Apple for our privacy and security, and cannot afford to be as we move into the future. We need a public domain infrastructure that produces similar or better security and privacy outcomes to the ones Apple is claiming to provide.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- viro 6y agoSo you guys know AV's randomly upload ur files to the cloud right?
- ben509 6y ago> What has been puzzling me ever since is that these OCSP checks have been well-known for a couple of years, and only now have attracted attention. It's not much of a puzzle. Everyone's Mac essentially froze simultaneously, and that's what drew all the initial attention. Then people were digging into why, and the cause of it got a lot of play. Privacy advocates took the opportunity to advocate privacy and had a large and annoyed audience.
- acdha 6y agoDon’t forget to account for selection bias: some people had apps delay launching and they started telling everyone about it as if it was everyone which affected all apps and users. Most of us had no idea there was a problem and thus didn’t feel obligated to start talking about it on social media.
- sneak 6y agoApple also makes apps themselves, and, just like AmazonBasics, has a tendency to clone popular apps (such a tendency that it has a name: to be "sherlocked"). To ignore the fact that Apple receives global platform app popularity data, which provides them a competitive advantage over every other app developer, is somewhat foolish. Gatekeeper has security benefits, yeah. But this data, just like 3P sales stats to Amazon, has commercial value, even anonymized/aggregated, that permits them benefits over everyone else they are competing with in the app market. Let's not conflate things that are good for users with things that are good for Apple, and be careful when assigning decisions exclusively to one bucket or the other. I spoke yesterday on the societal dangers of giving Apple such a pass on privacy violations: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG-7FpHvv-8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG-7FpHvv-8
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jgilias 6y agoIt seems that many tend to overlook the main issue with this. Because of this feature, there are people on this lovely planet of ours who may be in actual physical danger at this very moment.
- valuearb 6y agoCitation needed.
- tasinn 6y agoSanta's 2020 Christmas List 15 Stunning Products That You Probably Haven't Heard About.!! check them!! https://ro.pinterest.com/yourcoolgadgets https://ro.pinterest.com/yourcoolgadgets
- jgilias 6y agoCitation to what? The fact that if you're a journalist in Belarus with a Macbook right now, the kind of apps you open can point you out to authorities controlling the local internet infrastructure in no time? Or do you expect repressive governments to make press releases explaining in detail how they came to rounding up someone?
- valuearb 6y agoOCSP doesn’t send app signatures.
- jgilias 6y agoDeveloper certificates are enough to figure out you're opening, say Tor, or Telegram. See this thread for people discussing this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25095438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25095438 When they implement a toggle for switching this off, along with data encryption, then this particular concern becomes a non-issue.
- lo_fye 6y agoyes. with no personally identifying details included. and it was publicly documented.
- hu3 6y agoIP + timestamp is a personally identifying detail. Otherwise we wouldn't have Tor. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/02/everything-we-know-about-how-the-nsa-tracks-peoples-physical-location/283745/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/02/every...
- matthewmacleod 6y agoIt kind of feels like there's a bit too much noise around this topic. I'm getting the same feeling I did years ago when it was discovered that the iPhone had a historical database of all the locations you'd been to. There were rather a lot of articles about how Apple were "tracking you everywhere you went" and so on. The reason it's similar – they are both dumb, technically bad, and privacy-compromising decisions, and in both cases much of the public discussion about it has been a little hysterical and off-base. Apple should 100% be criticised for this particular failure. It's obviously a bad implementation from a technical and usability point of view; the privacy implications are bad, and this features should not have been able to make it out as-is. But I've legitimately seen people describe this as "Apple's telemetry" which is just obvious nonsense and distracts from the actual problem – how did such a bad implementation of a useful feature end up in a major commercial product, and how are they going to make sure it doesn't happen again?
- dblohm7 6y agoI’m with you on this. If Apple genuinely views privacy as a human right (and FWIW I believe that the right people at Apple do), then they need to learn about privacy by design.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThis is a basic by-the-RFC implementation. The developer who was assigned this just used existing libraries and followed the protocol. This was a rational move on their part. Especially when mucking with x509 has been historically fraught with vulnerabilities. OCSP has since been improved to increase privacy and security, but the extensions to enable that only considered OCSP in the context of TLS.
- dfox 6y agoJust to correct slightly incorrect perception: there is nothing inherently insecure or vulnerable about X.500/ASN.1/BER/DER parsing, in fact it is probably more sane format to parse than JSON. The perception that it is somehow fraught with parser vulnerabilities comes from various implementations that tried to implement BER/DER parser by transforming something more or less equivalent to ASN.1 grammar into actual parser code by means of C preprocessor macros, which is somewhat obviously wrong approach to the problem, at least in the security context.
- JackC 6y ago> Those who consider that Apple’s current online certificate checks are unnecessary, invasive or controlling should familiarise themselves with how they have come about, and their importance to macOS security. They should also explain how, having enjoyed their benefits for a couple of years, they’ve suddenly decided they were such a bad idea after all, and what should replace them. I agree that anyone critiquing Apple's OCSP design should understand it, and the critique should be more nuanced than "just turn that feature off." Computers are now skeleton keys to our lives and we have to go forward rather than back in figuring out how to design them so they can safely do everything we need them to do. But it's not hard to justify the sudden criticism here -- it happened after Apple's bad design of the OCSP feature broke local applications, drawing a lot more attention to how it worked. It's reasonable to then ask whether other parts of the design were also poor, as Apple itself obviously is from the changes it's already announced. To take the author up on what should replace OCSP checks -- how about using something like bloom filters for offline checks, and something like haveibeenpwned's k-anonymity for online checks, to remove the possibility that either Apple or a third party could use OCSP for surveillance?
- nmadden 6y agoThe browser vendors have been looking at this problem for a long time. See https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2020/01/09/crlite-part-1-all-web-pki-revocations-compressed/ https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2020/01/09/crlite-part-1-a... for example (bloom filters included).
- bitL 6y agoWhy can't Apple download all footprints of bad apps locally instead of monitoring every single invocation of apps? Is second execution of an app the same security risk as the first one? That's the design flaw.
- Someone1234 6y agoYou mean bad certificates rather than applications. OCSP can be locally cached, and Apple's implementation does exactly that. But eventually you'll have to refresh the cache and then the implementation needs to be fault tolerant (Apple's wasn't). OCSP leaks what vendors your installed applications are from. The list of leaked certificates changes daily, so any good implementation is going to check again at least several times a week. If you download the entire database, you're just consuming hundreds of megabytes of bandwidth/storage but aren't removing the need to refresh/expire the cache. I'd argue the two biggest flaws Apple's system has is bad fault tolerance and also no user accessible opt out (even if just for emergencies).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dcow 6y agoSecurity and privacy are not parallel concerns, they’re orthogonal. Strong security absolutely does not imply utmost privacy. I find this to be the most dangerous misconception of the late privacy trend. You can’t just turn security and privacy dials to 11. They’re actually two ends of the same dial, or opposing poles of the same sphere. To increase privacy you must move away from perfect security. Why? Because security is all about who you trust (and who you don’t). Privacy is about concealing things from people you trust (and especially from those you don’t). Security is best served with strong identity and periodic integrity checks/monitoring. Privacy is best served via anonymity and opacity. If something is private, by definition there lacks the transparency to audit its integrity. So what I lament is not that a company is trying to achieve both, but rather that as a consumer I’m not educated on the topic and able to make a choice as to where I want to set the dial. You will continue to see “headlines” like this so long as socially we’re obsessed with trying to implement both security and privacy and fall subject to marketing suggesting some service provides the maximum of both. If you trust Apple to verify the integrity of apps on your devices and secure your system from unwanted software, then you trust Apple to maintain the privacy around the data needed to achieve such. That’s the whole value prop of their platform and ecosystem. It’s a walled garden with abundant privacy koolaid fountains. The only reason this is news is because people don’t understand the privacy vs security dichotomy. And because Apple does not provide a way for consumers to choose just how much security they’re comfortable with. If you don’t trust Apple then stop pretending you do by using their hardware/ecosystem.
- WhyNotHugo 6y agoWhile security and privacy are not parallel, they are not orthogonal either. You can have both. Integrity checks can be done anonymously (e.g.: you could have a p2p network of devices sharing a signed database of certificate revocations). Encrypting something gives me privacy. Signing something gives me security. Encrypting a signed package gives me both.
- dcow 6y agoThey _are_ orthogonal, you’re just saying that you can have some of both which is exactly my my point about them existing on a spectrum. And it’s not as simple as encrypting data. You have to trust somebody to determine what good integrity looks like and to then verify the integrity information is fresh. The same privacy concern exists if you run OCSP against cypher-text as it does plaintext. You still have a stream of all the things people do. Bad for privacy. Running a decentralized system means you have to trust all the nodes to not to store data or collude. Same problem in a different way. You simply cannot achieve integrity verification if you don't trust anyone to do it. And this is why they are orthogonal. Trust is not compatible with doubt. The issue here is that Apple took off the shelf OCSP and applied it in a way it was not designed for. So there _are_ actual problems with their late implementation. They should be fixed. And personally I think OCSP is kinda dumb because it mechanically defeats the advantage of certs (you don’t need a cert if you’re going to phone home for every invocation, just check a hash), but meh.
- jchw 6y ago> What has been puzzling me ever since is that these OCSP checks have been well-known for a couple of years, This is where you’re wrong. It was known, but not well-known. Users do not expect an HTTP request to be blocking their application executions. Personally, I don’t see why CRL is not sufficient. Yes I want malicious signatures blacklisted, but can’t I just get a list instead? Some of the reasons CRL is no longer used do not apply to code signatures.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI don't agree with the article's statement that this is necessary. I'm sure it serves a purpose. But it should be more transparent to the user what's going on, and it should be possible to switch it off if the user decides they don't want this. And really, the article also mentions Apple used to do this with a local cache but stopped doing this in Catalina. The question should be asked why. A local cache arguably offers better protection as it will work even without a network connection whereas the OCSP has no alternative other than failing open or stopping the system from working.
- emteycz 6y agoMost things serve a purpose, even if it's a convoluted, dumb, wrong or evil one.
- musicale 6y ago> And really, the article also mentions Apple used to do this with a local cache but stopped doing this in Catalina This exactly. Local cache works fine, certificate revocation is rare, and a marginal to nonexistent improvement in security is not worth the slowdown, denial of service, and privacy invasion. Chrome uses a certificate revocation list for basically the entire internet; certainly macOS can (and indeed should) go back to using such a list for developer certificates, as they did in Mojave.
- 9867680515divya 6y ago8655873941 divu
- 9867680515divya 6y ago8655873941
- keyle 6y agoI know this because if my internet drops out - the router still is up, but packets are going nowhere - opening an app, especially one of mine, takes north of 10 seconds, which is the time for this thing to give up on talking to Apple.
- musicale 6y agoHow long they've done it has no bearing on whether it is an outrageously bad idea. It was bad in Catalina and it's bad in Big Sur. I found it particularly annoying in Catalina to have these slow, unnecessary and intrusive online checks every time you run a Python script and it drove me up a wall until I figured out you could turn off the idiotic behavior in preferences.
- swiley 6y agoThe online component of ocsp is only necessary for revocation lists. There is absolutely no reason to open a network connection every time an app is opened. The state of OSX is unacceptable.
- musicale 6y ago> explain how, having enjoyed their benefits for a couple of years, they’ve suddenly decided they were such a bad idea after all I didn't "enjoy their benefits" - I hated this change when I switched from Mojave to Catalina, and it severely impacted my workflow. Catalina's change to OCSP and online validation adds little if any value, compromises privacy, reduces performance, and introduces unnecessary new failure modes. It's simply a bad idea whose negatives greatly outweigh any minimal positives. > what should replace them Very obviously a Certificate Revocation List, like we had in Mojave. This is the right approach and should not have changed in the first place.
- angry_octet 6y agoA fantastically bad take. "You're more secure because Apple has been careless with your privacy for a long time and you didn't complain before -- be grateful."
- etc-hosts 6y agoI wonder how long until Macosx checks hashes of all media played on devices.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scruffyherder 6y agoCertainly explains why having terribly slow internet makes my mac insanely slow. Shutting off I cloud helped immensely, but this is probably the deeper root. Sucks to have a cellphone only internet.
- _dmd 6y agoWhat I find a lot scarier is that macOS seems to store your local user's password as a hash with Apple. A few months ago I was signing in on my MacBook, and it asked me (assuming because I did not have a mobile number attached) for my Hackintosh local user's password to 2FA. May be buried in the depths of the EULA, but I most definitely never agreed for my LOCAL account password to be uploaded to Apple. At least signature checks can be blocked (for now) on a DNS level. What about my passwords?
- AniseAbyss 6y agoApple doesn't have ads and tracking they said... Anyway that was never worth the premium for me when I can put ad blocking on Lenovo and save a few hundred €.
- saurik 6y ago> They should also explain how, having enjoyed their benefits for a couple of years, they’ve suddenly decided they were such a bad idea after all, and what should replace them. I mean, this is very very presumptuous... the people I know who were "in the know" on this--including myself--never upgraded to Catalina (in addition to doing a SIP disable), in no small part to avoid this intrusive behavior. (Further, there actually was outcry about this a year ago, when a similar issue happened: just, instead of the system not running software at all, it ran all new software super slowly.)
- mlindner 6y agoDid people miss how Apple has already said they've removed all the logs retroactively for this and they're adding a feature to opt-out of this?
- lupinglade 6y agoSurprised this is news to some.