37 ms·
Chuck Feeney Is Now Officially Broke
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoMad respect, not letting that amount of money get to your head and not wasting it on vain stuff surely takes some crazy discipline.
- IncRnd 6y agoMoney may not be important to him. Money is, after all, just a tool.
- khalilravanna 6y agoAbsolutely. Especially being an American. We have such a materialistic, maximalist culture. There’s definitely a psychological element here to be able to tune out all those negative messages (“Why don’t I have a nicer car/house/yacht than Alice/Bob?”). I’d be interested on where he falls on the satisficer/maximizer scale.
- Cerealkiller050 6y ago"Especially being an American" I have always heard the complete opposite. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Giving_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Giving_Index https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2018/12/28/the_generosity_of_americans_139032.html https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2018/12/28/the_ge...
- wahern 6y agoSomewhere between 32% and 75% of American donations are to churches or church-affiliated organizations. https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/oct/30/religious-people-more-likely-give-charity-study/ https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/oct/30/religious-p... Myanmar is an exceptionally devout Buddhist society with many monasteries supported through traditional almsgiving. I suspect that's why Myanmar tops even the U.S. in the World Giving Index, which merely asks whether you've donated money or time (volunteered). Not that faith-based giving is inferior, but different people have different notions about what constitutes philanthropy and charity.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Not that faith-based giving is inferior, but different people have different notions about what constitutes philanthropy and charity. I'm sure there are people who will find a way to invalidate this kind of charity. But it takes a level of dedication, discipline and a moral code to take 10% of earnings for benefit of your community and do it without legal compulsion. And it's the latter part that makes it different then those that pat themselves on the back for merely voting for higher taxes or disparage others for not voting for higher taxes.
- wahern 6y ago> But it takes a level of dedication, discipline and a moral code to take 10% of earnings for benefit of your community and do it without legal compulsion. Absolutely, but I think that's pretty rare among the general population. IIUC, if I drop $10 into the offertory basket at Sunday Mass I'm counted just the same as a Mormon who tithes 10% of their income.
- jedberg 6y agoMost countries don't let you deduct your donations from your taxes. It's hard to compare levels of giving across nations because of this. A lot of people only donate to reduce their tax bill. Also, because we don't have a social safety net in the US, a lot of people donate to make up for that, which is certainly noble, but would be far less necessary if we had a stronger social safety net that more evenly distributed that wealth giveaway.
- Cerealkiller050 6y agoThis is a good point. Unsure if that index referenced, or any other studies/reports on this subject, account for this in terms WHY the donation happened or motive. It does include willingness to help a stranger and volunteerism too, and those are ranked top 3 as well and doesn't reduce tax bills.
- ComputerGuru 6y agoWith very few (and even then, extremely capped) exceptions, the US absolutely does not let you deduct donations from your taxes. You’re allowed to deduct your donations from your pre-tax income, which is equivalent to being able to deduct some percentage (typically less than 30%) of your donations from your actual tax burden. It’s not being pedantic; this changes the calculus altogether. Deducting from your taxes means you can say “oh well, I have to pay $1M in taxes, I might as well just use that money to make a donation to a charity of my choice and gain some PR instead,” whereas deducting your taxable income means “instead of parting with $1M in tax, I would need to part with $5M in charity to zero out my tax burden,” which is a very different decision and still largely a philanthropic one at some level or the other.
- jedberg 6y agoThis is a fair point, most people don't understand how tax deductions work. But yes, I meant your pre-tax income, as all deductions work. Credits apply to taxes directly, deductions always mean pre-tax income.
- triceratops 6y ago> A lot of people only donate to reduce their tax bill. It's still money gone from your pocket. It doesn't save you money overall.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoIs that Giving Index skewed by American tipping culture at all?
- RandallBrown 6y agoI can't imagine it would be. Tips aren't charitable donations.
- khalilravanna 6y agoI have never heard the complete opposite so thanks for the data. It’s interesting because having grown up steeped in the culture for 30 years I have never once heard this or seen much real charitable action. I see small donations and token donations but very rarely anything like donating most of ones wealth or giving up excess to donate to those less well-off. I’d love to better understand this discrepancy. I hear more about how much money people spend more than how much they donate in the media. And even anecdotally I can’t think of anyone talking about a donation they made in conversation. It seems like this should be something we talk about and champion more.
- jariel 6y agoIt's not 'discipline' though. If you were raised a certain way, in a certain era, it wouldn't be rational to spend it on 'frivolity'. There are a lot of people like this. Tons of very rich folks living in normal homes, driving normal cars that they 'never buy news'. I think in some ways more common than not, especially in more rural and suburban areas wherein projecting wealth isn't actually necessary to their professional identity.
- Shared404 6y ago> especially in more rural and suburban areas wherein projecting wealth isn't actually necessary to their professional identity. I don't know about suburban areas in general. I think it largely depends on which neighborhood. While it may not impact peoples professional identity, in many suburbs it impacts their social identity.
- jmt_ 6y agoI agree. I don't think it's a surprise that someone who grew up during the Great Depression could be so frugal, even with massive wealth. Many people who were young during this time seem traumatized by it, often including their children.
- strikelaserclaw 6y agomost people say the would do something like this if they ever became extremely rich, but only a few would actually be able to do it. I'm in awe of the strength of character this guy must have.
- zozbot234 6y agoYou don't need to "become extremely rich" for charitable giving to be quite worthwhile. Even donating trivial amounts of money to high-impact charity can easily come with a factor of 1000× in value created, compared to just spending the same amount of money on your own private consumption. (Of course this assumes that you're choosing the right causes, generally involving very poor countries and the like; not just "donating" to your local art gallery, or for that matter your local college with a billion-dollar endowment.)
- hogFeast 6y agoYou can also donate your time.
- zozbot234 6y agoWell, if you're working in paid employment it will usually be a lot more effective to put in some more time at work, and give away some of the resulting income. "Donating your time" can of course be genuinely worthwhile if you're, e.g. a scientist who might want to do useful research on globally-relevant, critical issues; just not very much otherwise.
- Multiplayer 6y agoI cannot get my head around this. To be that good at making money and that intent at giving it away is such a massive paradox not to mention paradigm shift from how we typically discuss wealth and wealth accumulators. Looking for video interviews....
- quickthrower2 6y agoHe didn’t get caught up in the money trap that almost everyone is, and I wondered how he did that? Is it religion? Is it innate morals? How he was raised? Very interesting. Hope I can learn something from this. What does a non rich person do? I guess it is about trying to influence things rather than injecting money.
- nemo44x 6y ago> What does a non rich person do? Time is money and if you don't have money then give your time. It's the most generous thing a person can do. More so than money in many ways since you can always make more money but you can't make more time. You can't expect to make a major change in the world. But you can make some small changes that means the world to some people.
- mulmen 6y agoI don't see a paradox at all. He made a lot of money by being good at operating organizations. He seems to have given away his money by working with organizations. He just wanted to make an impact on the world and he did. I don't pretend to know the motivations of Bezos or even Musk (even though I think he has been clear) but I see this as consistent with what Feeney did. I can at least conceive of a thought process like "I can help humanity now and in the future by making money to fund new businesses that would not otherwise exist." Maybe the best way to contribute is to give away money to charity, maybe it is to start a rocket company. I don't think either of those are wrong, and I think they can have the same base motivation.
- gimmeThaBeet 6y agoMaybe naively I believe I grasp some of it, but I don't know, to me it takes maybe a little bit of hubris? I certainly see how parts of the mechanics feel very contradictory. The idea that sticks to me is "people are spending money, so it may as well become my money". It feels like a weird and maybe bad example, but it feels like sort of a chaotic good version of The Dark Knight Joker. You have the idea of "if you're good at something never do it for free", combined with a more wholesome version of "some men aren't looking for anything logical, like money." Maybe you just have weird anomalies where you have someone who likes business, like what their work entails, but for whatever reason aren't drawn as much to some of the other trappings. I think the assumption being the baseline is that the interest follows the money.
- sudhirj 6y agoThis is a role model I can actually appreciate. I can't figure out why this is the first time I've heard of him. I've seen lots of news about people buying expensive shit, but the fact that this has never come to my attention is a horrible indicator of what the media chooses to report on.
- mulmen 6y agoI wonder if a person was more involved in charitable giving if they would have heard about this guy before? Mainstream news coverage isn't going to cover him much but stories have been written, he worked closely with Gates and Buffet. My takeaway from this story is to spend my time on things that matter to me. It's a reminder that our news sources are really just another form of entertainment, which is not something that can give your life meaning or a sense of accomplishment.
- jrochkind1 6y agoThe article says "And he gave it away anonymously" but doesn't expand on that.
- wombatmobile 6y agoHe gave anonymously until 9/11 forced his hand. In the wake of the attacks, international money laundering laws were tightened, and large international transactions were scrutinised. Feeney donated some half a billion dollars to medical research in Brisbane, Australia, guided by an old friend from his young days in Hong Kong, the tennis player Ken Fletcher. When Fletcher told former Brisbane Lord Mayor Jim Soorley he had a mate with millions to give away to good causes, nobody in Brisbane would take him seriously. It forced Feeney to come out with his philanthropy, and whilst he never cultivated a public profile, Feeney did at least speak in public on a few occasions when dedicating medical research centres that were built with his donations in Brisbane.
- dougmccune 6y ago> While many wealthy philanthropists enlist an army of publicists to trumpet their donations, Feeney went to great lengths to keep his gifts secret. Seems like that was by design.
- OneGuy123 6y agoThis is "proper" giving away, not that fake celebrity donations of "I donated 200k of my 40M money, see how charitable I am"? And then those celebrities say "You should also donate Joe Doe, we must ALL be charitable". Meanwhile Joe is in debt and cannot even afford to eat non-pesticide laden food while the celebrity retain 99% of his $$$$.
- mrlala 6y agoIt is quite the paradigm indeed. Like you said most people don't really have any extra income. They have a mortgage. Their retirement is heavily underfunded. Kids future school is not paid for. Then there are people that have 100% of everything paid for and already have more than they will ever need... not to mention they can grow their money way quicker than the people who need it.. Yeah, it's pretty easy to be "generous" in that situation because it's literally extra money just sitting around doing nothing but making more money. edit: wow, downvote me and op for this? Must be by the HN 400k engineers without a family who don't understand what the problem is
- olivermarks 6y agoI'd love to know what Chuck Feeney thinks of Bill Gates
- trynewideas 6y ago> In February 2011, Feeney became a signatory to The Giving Pledge. In his letter to Bill Gates and Warren Buffett, the founders of The Giving Pledge, Feeney writes, "I cannot think of a more personally rewarding and appropriate use of wealth than to give while one is living—to personally devote oneself to meaningful efforts to improve the human condition. More importantly, today's needs are so great and varied that intelligent philanthropic support and positive interventions can have greater value and impact today than if they are delayed when the needs are greater."
- olivermarks 6y agoI'd love to know what Feeney thinks of Gates in 2020
- leesec 6y agoWhy?
- olivermarks 6y agohttps://www.ft.com/content/f999c4e4-78a2-4f83-9beb-91c15dccd0b8 https://www.ft.com/content/f999c4e4-78a2-4f83-9beb-91c15dccd... Opinion Coronavirus treatment Bill & Melinda Gates: Vaccine fairness will make us all safer | Free to read Sharing Covid-19 jabs equitably would result in fewer deaths and faster control everywhere'
- bena 6y agoWhat about this article? Context, provide it.
- 6y ago
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/ntXaR https://archive.is/ntXaR
- bagacrap 6y agoExtra props for doing it anonymously.
- throwaway287391 6y agoPreface: yes, absolutely, all the props in the world to this guy for doing something so thoroughly incredible and selfless and rare for the benefit of humanity. Even if I had the means, I know I'd never have the guts to do something so amazingly heroic in as extreme a way as he did. That said (i.e. time to be the irritating pedantic little asshole, but I think it's a genuine enough question about the purpose/execution of philanthropy)... does the anonymity really warrant extra props? We know that the guy gave away essentially all of his money; does the anonymity of the individual donations really make it more selfless? If anything the headlines "Feeney gives $100M to cause X" and going on TV to talk about it etc. would likely bring more attention and donations to X, which I assume is why Bill Gates and others tend to do things that way. Edit: ok, I've just figured out from other posts that it basically wasn't known beyond a small group of people that he was giving away most of his wealth. I didn't realize that (although it's also my first time hearing of him). I agree then, he really did spend the bulk of his life being pretty much truly anonymous and that does deserve extra props.
- bagacrap 6y agoI guess I'm more cynical than you. I see it as subtracting props to insist that your name be inscribed on the side of every structure you fund. Bill Gates and others like him are not "giving away" money, since there's practically nothing material they could buy with it in the traditional sense. Gates is trading useless wealth for social prestige. Compare to Sergey Brin, who also spends money on humanitarian efforts such as disaster relief, but takes pains to avoid headlines.
- dang 6y agoIf curious see also 2018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16513124 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16513124 2013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6081804 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6081804
- dangus 6y agoSome questions lingered in the back of my mind after I read this article: - How much to employees at Duty Free Shoppers (DFS) make? Is their healthcare fully covered? Do they have generous paid time off and access to higher education for themselves and their children? Was any of his fortune used to give back to the employees whose labor built his wealth in the first place? - Does this dude realize how difficult it is to get into Cornell compared to when he went there on the GI bill? Giving to Cornell seems counter-productive to me. Giving a bunch of Ivy League jocks more resources doesn’t seem like an equity promoting endeavor. Not to diminish his other accomplishments. Still, philanthropists get to choose who to include and exclude. Ideally, it wouldn’t have been possible for this guy to amass 8 billion dollars of wealth in the first place - it would have been properly taxed and invested into our communities equitably.
- raiyu 6y agoBecause the government has such a great track record of collecting tax revenue and then investing it where it is appropriate? Questions can be raised about some of his specific donations, but when someone gives away $8B of his wealth, spending nearly none on himself, does it globally, influences other billionaires to do the same, picking at any one of his specific donations seems counter productive. Yes Cornell is an Ivy League school, but it is where he went to school, he probably has very strong ties to that school, perhaps met his wife there, or his business partner, if he chooses to give back to that school that is also good. Plus there was a tremendous amount he gifted to "education" so without knowing all of the details, hard to imagine that he didn't provide some sort investment in to under represented communities. If he helped Vietnam with their healthcare he obviously wasn't just US centric but helped where he though his donation could have an outsized return. By the way he gifted a large amount of money to the Obamacare campaign, so by proxy, he was providing healthcare to his workers, and more likely than not.
- dangus 6y agoMy argument is that a system that allows $8 billion in wealth to accumulate enough to be controlled by one person has already failed. The US government is actually really impressively good in a lot of areas, and I personally get fatigued of the oft-repeated notion that government “can’t possibly work” or that they “can’t possibly spend tax dollars responsibly.”
- renewiltord 6y agoInteresting! I wonder if he tracked outcomes so we can see what the result is of all this. He seems pretty happy with how his charitable "investments" have done. That data could reveal which things are the most effective things to operate charitably in terms of increasing human happiness. That's something I really like about Jack Dorsey's approach. I get to follow along and see what works.
- cantrevealname 6y ago> Where did $8 billion go: health, science, education, and social action Other than science, those are some very bloated and inefficient causes. $1 billion to Cornell? Aren't most of the prestigious universities already swimming in billions of dollars of endowments? He can do what he wants of course, but it would have been nicer if the money was targeted to long shot bets--that only a super rich person could fund--rather than normal things are already well funded through taxes.
- leesec 6y agoSigh, I love hackernews.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoPerfect is the enemy of good.
- colinmhayes 6y agoDisagree. There are more than enough resources on effective NGO's. There is no reason to give cornell a billion dollars when that money could save hundreds of thousands of lives in the developing world.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hamburglar 6y agoIt's possible the guy giving away the money sees something about this organization that you don't.
- colinmhayes 6y agoOr, more likely, he's not maximizing the impact of his donation.
- 6y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> While many wealthy philanthropists enlist an army of publicists to trumpet their donations, Feeney went to great lengths to keep his gifts secret. Crazy respect for this. Many times billionaire charitable foundations are just tax preferred ways of building your image or amassing influence. Bill Gates has done a lot of good, but his charitable work also served to redeem his image from that of the ruthless businessman crushing competitors that he had in the 1990’s. In addition, it has also given him a lot of soft power. I bet there are dozens of heads of state, especially in Africa and Asia, that he could personally get on the phone within 30 minutes if he really wanted to.
- jjeaff 6y agoSure, but what benefit does that power get him except to accomplish the goals of his philanthropy? He doesn't appear to be trying to amass more wealth. He needs to amass connections and power if he wants to accomplish his philanthropic goals. As for fixing his image, sure, maybe that was part of it. But I doubt it. He could have just made a few really big donations and then went off to himself to enjoy his wealth.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoOne of my arguments against the accumulation of vast wealth is that Bill Gates can get an in-person visit with my local representative faster than I, a constituent, can get a return phone call. I think we need 5x the number of representatives at the House level. Separate their duties, strip power from some of them, and keep them in district most of the year so they can actually be held accountable. Would also help to further democratize the House.
- cosmotic 6y agoIt's great he donated his wealth to charity, but it's a little unfair that he took it upon himself to chose where the money went instead of letting the people choose.
- hr2016 6y agoI don't feel so, care to explain why?
- bena 6y agoWhy should the people get to choose?
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoOne of the reasons that private charity is somewhat looked down upon in certain countries with a robust welfare state is that historically, private charities were selective in whom they helped. If the private charity felt that your "lifestyle" (i.e. you were a mother out of wedlock, you were LGBT) or ethnicity was objectionable, you were just left to suffer. Or those private charities would assist you, but you were obliged to convert to their religious denomination or sit through a long sermon before getting to eat. Welfare states run from taxpayer money and overseen by democratically elected officials, while they have their downsides that are often commented on, at least tend to assist groups that would be marginalized otherwise, and there are no religious strings attached.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- guerrilla 6y agoThat and the fact that such charity systems are demonstrably less efficient than welfare. It seems that many of people just want to ignore that evidence though and continue to scaremonger.
- cosmotic 6y agoBecause thats where the money originally came from. Why should the single billionaire get to chose?
- hogFeast 6y agoFor someone who is actually in the middle of doing this: Chris Hohn. He has built one of the largest charities in the UK, and I believe it is top 10 in the world. He has given away his net worth multiple times. His general story is also totally remarkable for the UK, he came from literally nowhere. Somewhat inevitably these days, he is regarded negatively in the media (most recently, he came up because the UK's finance minister used to work at his fund, so Hohn was the "vulture" capitalist with his beak in govt...funnily enough, their view didn't change when they found he is the main funding for Extinction Rebellion...2020 is amazing).
- egypturnash 6y ago"When I first met him in 2012, he estimated he had set aside about $2 million for his and his wife's retirement" Two million is, like, the opposite of broke for the vast majority of Americans. But this is Forbes.
- brewdad 6y agoUsing the 4% rule, $2 million gives you an income stream of $80,000 a year in retirement. Comfortable but hardly lavish.
- epylar 6y ago$2 million in retirement savings puts him above 90th percentile for retirements savings for any age. The maximum 90th percentile I can find is $619,000.00 at ages 60-64. https://dqydj.com/retirement-savings-by-age-united-states/ https://dqydj.com/retirement-savings-by-age-united-states/ If he's broke, then at least 90% of retirees are broke.
- longtimegoogler 6y agoI think cost of living should be factored into this though. San Francisco is one of the most expensive cities in the world. 2 million is meager to try and retire in SF. You are correct that he clearly isn't broke.
- triceratops 6y ago> If he's broke, then at least 90% of retirees are broke. Maybe that should tell you something about the state of retirement savings in this country.
- lucaspm98 6y agoMost people are some combination of financially irresponsible and uneducated. Honestly, with the numbers you have here I have to lean towards irresponsible regardless of whatever difficulties the middle class faces. Even at a median wage just doing the absolute bare minimum of saving 5%-10%, not even factoring in 401ks, would leave you well past this given the last few decades of market returns.
- RandomBacon 6y agoActual title: The Billionaire Who Wanted To Die Broke…Is Now Officially Broke
- tomcat27 6y agoI find those people who determine to earn big and then give away big very interesting minds. Their reasons to earn are most of the times very different from a typical person.
- lefstathiou 6y agoSpeculating here as I am not spectacularly wealthy... I suspect there is more to relate to than first meets the eye. Chuck is human like all of us. Most people have to spend some amount of time solving for generating enough capital to meet their (and their family’s) needs - whatever they may be. The fabulously wealthy / successful did too once upon a time but at some point crossed a threshold the vast vast majority of people - which I will refer to as “typical” - will never, and that is having enough to do and buy literally anything they could possibly desire indefinitely. Thus the motivation to keep on going professionally (ie to earn more and more, something that drives typical people who are solving to meet needs), I suspect, changes to things money can’t buy which are nevertheless “typical”: The desire for impact. Some want it in their life times, others want it for generations (legacy). Some want it in their church or on their job. Others seek and have the means to achieve it on a global scale.
- sandworm101 6y ago>>> When I first met him in 2012, he estimated he had set aside about $2 million for his and his wife's retirement. I don't know about everyone else on HN, but having 2mil in the bank is not my definition of "Broke". I want to see what trusts have been setup. What life estates has he retained? I credit him for giving most all of it away, but "broke" doesn't mean you are worth 0.0001% of some huge number. Broke means you might not cover next month's rent and are parking your car at a friend's to hide it from the repo guy.
- Invictus0 6y agoWhat's your point? That in his 80s he should be struggling for rent money after giving over 8 billion to charity?
- sandworm101 6y agoThe point is that Forbes shouldn't be using terms like broke to describe millionaires when there are millions of people who are actually broke living incredibly difficult lives.
- zuminator 6y agoAre they former billionaires though? The point of him being "broke" isn't that he has nothing, it's that he has shared almost all of what he had, to a much greater extent than most of us could ever dream of.
- sandworm101 6y agoAsk anyone who has shared more of their worth than this man has. Plenty of parents have done more than give up "everything" to support a kids. Talk to any bail bondsman. Plenty of people regularly go past 0 and into negative net assets to help a family members in need. Talk to any veterinarian. They see people give their last dollar, and then leverage out every credit card beyond that last dollar, to save a pet. Broke means broke, not 2mil, not even really 0. Broke means broken. Forbes should not attach that word to this situation because this man is not.
- s_dev 6y agoGreat documentary on him by the Irish National Broadcaster: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMcjxe8slYI&pbjreload=101 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMcjxe8slYI&pbjreload=101
- redis_mlc 6y agoEverybody posting here missed his biggest accomplishments. Chuck Feeney was a major force in stopping the Troubles, and financed the reuilding of Ireland into a tech capital.
- lisper 6y agoNot that I want to in any way detract from this incredible and selfless accomplishment, but he has held on to a $2M retirement fund, so he's not quite "broke" yet.
- elliekelly 6y agoAnd I'm sure there's a trust fund for his benefit somewhere, just in case.
- tilolebo 6y agoI wonder how their daughters feel about that. Especially knowing that for having such a career behind him, he must probably have spent a lot of time working and not being there for his family. Still, mad respect for what he/they did.
- yboris 6y agoI humbly encourage everyone to make giving a larger part of your life. Consider giving at least 10% of your income to cost-effective charities -- because cost-effective charities can do thousands of times more good than merely regular charities. So your $1,000 donation can do as much good as $1 million, if given well. Join others: https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/ https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThat point about cost effectiveness is what always leaves a bitter taste in my mouth when donating. I didn't realize people put lists of recommendations together, that's nice to see. But how would you go about verifying any stated claims?
- brundolf 6y agoThis site ranks charities based on their finances, with breakdowns on different axes: https://www.charitynavigator.org/ https://www.charitynavigator.org/
- yboris 6y agoOverhead is a bad thing to look at: http://overheadmyth.com/ http://overheadmyth.com/ If an organization cures blindness for $20 through cataract surgeries in developing nations, and another spends $40,000 to train a seeing eye dog for a single individual, we are looking at ratios of 1:1000 in terms of effectiveness. The amount spent on 'overhead' is irrelevant!
- FeepingCreature 6y agoGivewell's process is detailed at https://www.givewell.org/how-we-work/process https://www.givewell.org/how-we-work/process It's very plausible to disagree with some of their choices. For instance, you might be interested in efficient charitable giving within your country, and bite the bullet of "this means I value starving africans a lot less." The important part is to prompt charities to document costs and outcomes in general (preferably to a scientific standard), so that people can make more informed choices about their donations no matter their values.
- kaiken1987 6y agoWhat he did was great. But for Forbes to say a man with 2% of 8 billion dollars is broke is a stretch.
- briandear 6y agoRelatively speaking.
- rabidrat 6y agoThe article says he put away $2m for his and his wife's retirement. While I agree it's not quite 'broke' in the classic American sense, it is .025% of his former net worth of $8b.
- r00fus 6y agoYeah, the word "broke" is clickbait. $2m for retirement is more than most. It's simply "not extravagant" which I guess from the eyes of the wealthy class may as well be "broke".
- caturopath 6y agoCertainly not broke, but it seems difficult to find a way without hyperbole to indicate that he's given away billions and now is no longer in the top 10% of people in his age bracket in the US.
- bluedevil2k 6y ago1) It doesn't say how old his wife is, who knows how long her retirement will be. She looks 65+ in the picture, but who knows. 2) A man feels a certain responsibility to take care of his wife even when he's gone. 3) $2M only spins off $80k in income, hardly a rich lifestyle and far less than most Americans on this site could live with. * And check your math, 2% of 8B is $160M not the $2M stated in the article.
- mrastro 6y ago2 million is only 0.025% of 8 billion. It's a bit of editorializing to call it "broke" but donating such a huge percentage of his net worth is commendable and he will be living a relatively much more modest lifestyle.
- gumby 6y agoHe was outed a few years ago due to a IPO of DFS, otherwise he'd still be below the radar. His partner at DFS, Miller, took the opposite route: still a major shareholder, extravagant lifestyle with his kids being classic "rich kids". Nice A/B experiment.
- adaisadais 6y agoHuge fan of Chuck. “Who wants to be the richest person in the graveyard?” Is a question I often ask myself. Chuck has lived that philosophy. I moved to the bay last year and I hoe to one day meet him!
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSo inspiring. It’s sad when all these billionaires and multi-millionaire athletes are afraid to risk a few million dollars by commenting on human rights abuses (concentration camps in China e.g.). You can’t take it with you! Use your wealth for good...
- kevmo 6y agoChuck Feeney sounds like a great guy (I don't know anything about how his empire treated its employees), but I'd really rather the government take and distribute those billions.
- outside1234 6y agoThanks for posting - with all of the horrible selfish things happening (people not wearing masks on purpose, etc. etc.) it is great to have a vision of how we could be better as a people.
- anonAndOn 6y agoMark Benioff donated $100M to the UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital and got his name on the INSTITUTION (not just a building). What many don't know is that donation was to complete a match of $125M offered by Chuck Feeney (who does not have his name on a building anywhere on the campus, AFAIK).[0]. That $125M was only part of the $394M Chuck ended up giving to UCSF.[1] [0]https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/finance/ucsf-childrens-hospital-gets-100m-gift-build-new-hospital https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/finance/ucsf-childrens-ho... [1]https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2015/02/123366/ucsf-receives-100m-gift-advance-health-sciences-mission https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2015/02/123366/ucsf-receives-100m-...
- olivermarks 6y agoFeeney is a wonderful human being!
- benatkin 6y agoI'm OK with his name on it. It seems to be a mutually beneficial branding move. Also it's Marc Benioff. Edit: I'm more than fine with it because it makes Zuckerberg seem less special.
- anonAndOn 6y agoHow is it mutually beneficial for the guy who donated the most money?
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe guy who donated the most money explicitly wanted anonymity.
- jldugger 6y agoThen why are we talking about it?
- renewiltord 6y ago
- fred_is_fred 6y agoYou can obviously give away your wealth or ss an embarrassing counterpoint you can write a book about how hard it is to have money - https://nypost.com/2020/09/14/why-one-very-rich-woman-says-we-need-to-talk-about-money/ https://nypost.com/2020/09/14/why-one-very-rich-woman-says-w...
- hirundo 6y agoCompare two billionaires. One stops and carefully donates his money to have the most impact. He ends up "officially broke." The other doubles down on for profit enterprises, but focuses on those with the most impact, like electrifying a fossil fueled sector of the economy or making us a multi-planetary species. The profits are reinvested to accomplish these goals. He ends up richer than ever. It isn't clear that the second billionaire is less admirable than the first.
- strikelaserclaw 6y agoyea but who knows how your money is going to be used once you are dead.
- switch11 6y agocan we please keep the pro Tesla posts on Tesla threads For God's Sake Let this great guy who gave away $8 billion of his hard earned money get proper credit without dragging a @#$#$ subsidy entrepreneur into it
- batsigner 6y agoHirundo is a Branch Elonian. His religion stipulates that failing to promote Elon whenever posssible is grounds for shunning.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoMusk has signed the giving pledge, so he might end up doing both. He wants to die on Mars, and it seems likely that if it would require the bulk of his fortune to make us a multi-planetary species, he would commit it.
- Paul-ish 6y agoIt is not a competition.
- Vervious 6y agoDepends on your definition of impact. Tesla certainly is not improving education outcomes worldwide, nor funding healthcare research; nor is spaceX saving rainforests from being cut down every day, or helping sustain democracy. I guess EVs have less environmental impact after four years of use, but do Teslas last that long? The intent there (and the impact) is still very much to monetize
- bogorman 6y agoThe Irish education system was also transformed with his generosity. The University of Limerick is a great example. The story is covered in the video. https://youtu.be/OMcjxe8slYI?t=1388 https://youtu.be/OMcjxe8slYI?t=1388
- superasn 6y agoIs a person who invests that money for-profit but makes giant advancements in maths/science while doing it an equally big giver? Take for example, Elon musk. Even though he hasn't given monet away to charities like Chuck, his for-profit enterprises like electric cars, solar farms, spacex and possibly neuralink might just have been things that end up equally great for humanity. So if you have billions I guess timtowtdi.
- zpeti 6y agoAlso - does he actually "have money"? Tesla and SpaceX don't make a profit or pay dividends. My guess is he finances his entire life from taking on debt which is secured against his stock. So how exactly are people like him supposed to just give money away? What happens to the stock he owns then? Would he forgo control of his companies? How would he pay taxes on that income anyway? Lots of questions the billionaires-shouldn't-exist crowd have no concept of.
- pwinnski 6y agoHe started out with a lot of money from his family's South African mining operations. Your mockery is ill-directed, and in the context of a post about someone whose corporate wealth was able to be donated to charity, in really poor taste.
- zpeti 6y agoYeah, because Elon is obviously where he is now because of family money... jesus christ. Ever heard of Zip2 and Paypal? Your resentment and jealousy based communist thinking is pretty ugly.
- pwinnski 6y agoNow you've added personal insults to your class mockery. Please, this sort of casual disregard of other people is not appropriate on HN. Your initial claim was that he had no money apart from company stock, and lives entirely on debt. This is factually incorrect, as I pointed out: his family money predates all of his companies. Attached to your factually-incorrect claim was a casual denigration of a group of people with whose beliefs you disagree. This was both misguided and unnecessary. My factual statement in response was simply: > He started out with a lot of money from his family's South African mining operations. Based solely on that true statement of fact, you derided me, responding to claims I never made and labeling me and my "thinking" in inaccurate and insulting ways. Please, stop.
- haltingproblem 6y agoChuck Feeney embodies what Gandhi said about the rich having wealth in trust and using it for the good of society: "“supposing I have come by a fair amount of wealth — either by way of legacy, or by means of trade and industry — I must know that all that wealth does not belong to me; what belongs to me is the right to an honourable livelihood, no better than that enjoyed by millions of others. The rest of my wealth belongs to the community and must be used for the welfare of the community.” [1] Each time I bike past Cornell Tech, Feeney's generosity awes me. What a mensch. Makes me proud to be human. [1] https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/mahatma-gandhi-wealth-6063201/ https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/mahatma-ga...
- sabujp 6y ago$1 billion to cornell? Cornell doesn't need the money
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- liminal 6y agoAll donations should be anonymous
- caturopath 6y agoNot really my business.
- AdamN 6y agoWhy can't governments receive these donations? Do any benefactors currently give to governments (not via taxes, actually just give)? I know Ted Turner did it with the UN Foundation, although that isn't technically the UN itself. Are there other examples?
- smeyer 6y ago>Why can't governments receive these donations They certainly can. I don't how many people actually do it, but most governments will accept direct cash donations. E.g. here's a page on how to make a gift to the US Government: https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.html https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.h... Edit to add: Here's some data on donations made to reduce the federal debt https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/gift/gift.htm https://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/gift/gift.htm . You can see that this seems to average a few million dollars per year.
- johnwheeler 6y agoThe best part of the article > When I visited a few years ago, inkjet-printed photos of friends and family hung from the walls over a plain, wooden table. On the table sat a small Lucite plaque that read: “Congratulations to Chuck Feeney for $8 billion of philanthropic giving.”
- hownottowrite 6y agoRaise the top tax rate to 90% and all billionaires can feel just as good in their own lifetimes.
- smattiso 6y agoThis guy is my hero. I do hope he was able to enjoy spending some of his money on himself and his family though. I have no problem with billionaires who contribute a lot to society living well as long as they aren't hording resources (huge acreage estates, mega yachts, rental properties). "Contribute to society" is the sticking point for many of them though. I hope I can live like Mr. Feeney, although I personally wouldn't be quite as ascetic as he given the circumstances (I would own a small but nice house in San Diego or Hawaii and a nice 0 emission solar/sail powered boat). Good work Chuck!
- kelnos 6y agoI think out of all possibilities for the attitudes and practices of billionaire philanthropists, Feeney is probably as close to the ideal as possible[0]. But it still makes me sad to see this sort of thing celebrated. A small number of ultra-rich people should not be deciding for society what causes get funded, no matter how pure their intentions are. The fact that individuals are able to amass this much money in the first place is itself a problem. [0] Then again, we can't actually know that he's ideal, since he's worked hard to keep his activities anonymous. On one hand I applaud him for not seeking fame for all this, but on the other, we have little insight into whatever impact -- good or bad -- he's had.
- Hnaomyiph 6y ago>A small number of ultra-rich people should not be deciding for society what causes get funded. Alternatively, we can elect a small number of ultra-rich people into government who would have surly spent his money better on say, funding an ever-growing military.
- ticmasta 6y agoregardless if you're a billionaire or not, at some point money is for keeping score. We all have biases that influence our desires and actions; he was able to indulge his more fully. What's your proposed alternative to the amalgamated actions of rich individuals? I'm not sure what else could work better, and we've certainly seen worse collective approaches throughout history.
- silentsea90 6y agoThere's certainly a paradox in the ideal of being secretive with your donations and thereby not being able to make an example that others could follow, or being vain in beating your drum but setting an example for charity. For myself, I have always wanted to appear to be doing my best in hiding my charitable donations while inadvertently getting discovered for my generosity, killing two birds with one stone. Unfortunately, I don't nearly have the wealth to pull this off.
- ticmasta 6y agoI don't think Chuck Feeney set out to be purposely secretive as much as anonymous and focused on the money doing the work. I think stories like this one in Forbes highlight he understands the necessity of good leadership by talking about the mission after it's accomplished, rather than looking for recognition during the process. Gates & Buffet are role models for the getting started; Feeney for how you finish.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bedhead 6y agoI’ve long argued for massive estate tax rates on large estates in order to incentivize behavior like this. I have no problem at all with Bezos being worth $200 billion (or whatever it is now), but it’s this dynastic wealth that I find borderline sickening. Why in the hell should the Rockefeller’s of today be billionaires??? Also, these giant charitable foundations/family offices are similarly off-putting, as they are setup as semi-perpetual institutions that often only make the minimum 5% distribution annually. (Another fix would be to jack that up to 25% upon death) Big estate taxes seem to solve for a lot of problems with appropriate compromises.
- settrans 6y agoAn Open Letter from Economists on the Estate Tax To whom it may concern: Spend your money on riotous living – no tax; leave your money to your children – the tax collector gets paid first. That is the message sent by the estate tax. It is a bad message and the estate tax is a bad tax. The basic argument against the estate tax is moral. It taxes virtue – living frugally and accumulating wealth. It discourages saving and asset accumulation and encourages wasteful spending. It wastes the talent of able people, both those engaged in enforcing the tax and the probably even greater number engaged in devising arrangements to escape the tax. The income used to accumulate the assets left at death was taxed when it was received; the earnings on the assets were taxed year after year; so, the estate tax is a second or third layer of taxation on the same assets. The tax raises little direct revenue- partly because the estate planners have been so successful in devising ways to escape the tax. Costs of collection and compliance are high, perhaps of the same order as direct tax receipts. The encouragement of spending reduces national wealth and thereby the flow of aggregate taxable income. These indirect effects mean that eliminating the tax is likely to increase rather than decrease the net revenue yield to the federal government. The estate tax is justified as a means of reducing the concentration of wealth. However, the truly wealthy and their estate planners avoid the tax. The low yield of the tax is a testament to the ineffectiveness of the tax as a force for reshaping the distribution of wealth. The primary defense made for the estate tax is that it encourages charity. If so, there are better and less costly ways to encourage charity. Eliminating the estate tax will lead to higher economic growth, which is the most important variable in determining the level of charitable giving. Death should not be a taxable event. The estate tax should be repealed. Signed, Milton Friedman
- bravura 6y ago"Chuck Feeney is what Donald Trump would be, if he lived his entire existence backward." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/05/nyregion/james-bond-of-philanthropy-gives-away-the-last-of-his-fortune.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/05/nyregion/james-bond-of-ph... http://www.nydailynews.com/archives/news/talk-cheap-rich-guy-article-1.776220 http://www.nydailynews.com/archives/news/talk-cheap-rich-guy... It sounds great but I'm still puzzling over this phrase and trying to grok it
- SeanLuke 6y agoI vaguely recall that there are classic levels in Jewish philosophy regarding philanthropy, and among the highest is to give with no expectation of any return whatsoever: that means not only giving where it matters, but to do so anonymously, to organizations that don't benefit you (no opera companies), and to people with no ties to you. In this respect Chuck Feeney has been incredible. This is not to dismiss the likes of Bill Gates: he has been very public with his donations, but in some cases (notably celebrity) notoriety in your donations may create a multiplier effect as it encourages others to do likewise. Even so, I think this is still on a lower-rung, philanthropy-wise, than Feeney's approach. Nonetheless, we're sitting here praising someone who reduced himself from billions to $2M, but we must remind ourselves that this is unimpressive compared to the poor person who donates $25 to others while starving herself. The value of money is nonlinear. I'm sure that Feeney would say this as well: he no doubt sees himself as saddled with the burden of billions of dollars rather than someone doing something amazing. I wonder if I ever will have the strength to do what he has done.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's a good point. And 'broke' isn't 100% broke just yet, he's not going to have to sleep under a bridge. But he's broke enough that the wrong accident can put him on the far side of the line easily enough. Obviously this goes for many people but they tend to end up in that situation by accident, not by design and as an example to other billionaires he's pretty impressive. Try imagining Larry Ellison doing this.
- compsciphd 6y agoI'd presume (perhaps incorrectly, so perhaps hope), that he's pretty insured up to avoid that fate.
- maximente 6y agoit's really hard to imagine someone at age 89, with 2 social security incomes and $2M, who is apparently more frugal than most technology workers, being one "wrong accident" away from "the far side of the line easily enough". an 80% loss of that $2M cash leaves him with a paltry $400K which, assuming a rate of return == inflation, is 10 years of $40K/yr spending, to say nothing of 2x SS income. people's idea of "being broke" is just ridiculous.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's one person I definitely admire. Not afraid to play the game and not afraid to end it on his terms. It's one thing to amass a billion or more, quite another to purposefully, part by part dismantle that empire until there is absolutely nothing left with an unknown chunk of life at the end of it. Chuck Feeney is officially welcome at my table, anytime.
- haltingproblem 6y agoThe amount of negativity in this thread regarding billionaires and charity is stupefying. There are well established reasons why the distribution of wealth is lumpy - the uneven distribution of initial endowments, skills, parenting, luck, education, etc. The work of Pareto and the Ergodicity Economics gives a sound theoretical basis to this realization. There is no middle ground folks - in any incentive driven system you will have a power tailed distribution. Can we just celebrate Chuck Feeney and his awesomeness?
- divbzero 6y ago“What many don't know is that [Mark Benioff] donation was to complete a match of $125M offered by Chuck Feeney (who does not have his name on a building anywhere on the campus, AFAIK).” “I wonder if I ever will have the strength to do what he has done.” “I’ve long argued for massive estate tax rates on large estates in order to incentivize behavior like this.” “This is a role model I can actually appreciate.“ “I humbly encourage everyone to make giving a larger part of your life.” Those are quotes from the current top 5 comments in this thread — plenty of celebration of Chuck Feeney’s awesomeness.
- haltingproblem 6y agoI saw those but there was the usual jaw-boning if Billionaire philanthrophy is good for our society. I understand the hand-wringing but that is akin to wishing that we were all born equal to perfect families in strife free lands with perfect health care and child care and the rest.......utopia. Edit: See below ;)
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIt’s ludicrous to suggest celebrating this. It should make you sick and outraged, not be celebrated. Please read my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24487517 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24487517
- raincom 6y agoWow, he hasn't followed this strategy: "set up a legacy fund that annually tosses pennies at a $10 problem." One of the things almost all foundations do is this: give 100K for $100M problem. There are certain reasons for this: (a) foundations have become mini governments; (b) foundations want to support everyone that comes their way; (c) either foundations can't judge the potential of ventures or they end up supporting their crony or pet projects.
- makomk 6y agoIs it just me or is there something a little off about the phrase "$76 million for grassroots campaigns supporting the passage of Obamacare"? Grassroots and funded secretly by a billionaire seem like fundamental opposites...
- GoodJokes 6y agobut he isn’t broke...
- todsacerdoti 6y agoI highly recommend the book on Chuck - https://www.amazon.com/Billionaire-Who-Wasnt-Secretly-Fortune/dp/1610393341 https://www.amazon.com/Billionaire-Who-Wasnt-Secretly-Fortun...
- monadic2 6y agoWhy is his strategy of giving away money so uncommon? Rich people certainly do not need their wealth.
- balthasar 6y agoPretty gross that he had that money in the first place. Good for him I guess?
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI feel like I won't ever be even 10% of what Chuck Feeney has been.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoFor a long time I dreamed of being wealthy. But a few experiences being a small-time investor have convinced me that being wealthy (and trying to be wealthy) is a lot of work, and it's work I don't particularly enjoy (too much paperwork). I'd much rather work as an individual contributor and earn an upper middle class salary for my entire career, with enough to retire comfortably. Growing up I always heard stories about how happiness is not correlated with income above a certain (commonly achievable) level, and I can now corroborate those stories! You don't have to be rich to give. You can not make the money in the first place, and instead make the world a better place by tending to your own happiness and doing something you enjoy. And if you are lucky like Chuck you can give it away. Or if you are lucky like Jonas Salk you can dedicate your talents to good causes. Congratulations to Chuck for being happy.
- scrozier 6y agoI've had an idea for a while: some body (could be the government) maintains a list of useful/important infrastructure projects--bridges, hospitals, schools, etc. If you die with more than $x million, we take all the excess (like today's estate tax), but you get to pick what gets built, and have your name on it (or not, if you're like Feeney).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eruci 6y agoSeems like his life mission was to become a communist on his own accord, and now that he has achieved that, he is happy. Good that worked out for him.
- cryptica 6y agoWhat a great man. Such a shame that he gave it all away to a bunch of scammers and then a different bunch of billionaire scammers come out and try to claim that they're affiliated with this great man to boost their own reputation when in fact they're nothing alike.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI'm a bit confused. The NYT article from 2017 says they he had finished giving away $8b and was only keeping about$2m for his retirement. This article says the same thing. Is he any more or less broke than in 2017? It sounds like the main development is that he officially dissolved his charity
- heimatau 6y agoImagine...if other Feeney's (mega rich; north $100M) were able to give back to their communities. In some dependable and systematic way. I'd call it Sexat. It's like Taxes but spelled backwards.
- wang_li 6y agoOne could argue that everyone has the same responsibilities to society at large. Thus for every Chuck Feeny and Bill Gates, you, personally you, have an obligation to create many billion dollars of value and give it away. If you don't do that, you're worse than any evil billionaire you care to name. They at least are paying millions of dollars in taxes for any money they pull out of investments. How many millions in taxes have you paid?
- teruakohatu 6y ago> One could argue that everyone has the same responsibilities to society at large. Yes you could argue that. > Thus for every Chuck Feeny and Bill Gates, you, personally you, have an obligation to create many billion dollars of value and give it away Now that is a big jump. It does not follow that we all have the same responsibility that we all have a specific responsibility. Historically some rights were tied to the ability of the upper classes to fulfill some base responsibilities that the lower the classes could never possibly meet. Such as being able to afford a full set of bronze armour and a spear. Thus achieving both moral and social superiority.
- nverno 6y agoThis is a good turnaround of the previous statement. It is incorrect to assume there is only so much wealth, and subsequently, billionaires need to be taxed in order to maintain our standard of living. Most billionaires have created something entirely new, not hoarded some scarce resource from the rest of us.
- comex 6y agoPerhaps, but only to an extent. It is not as if, if only average people were clever enough, we could all become billionaires, and the GDP could be 10,000x higher than it currently is. There are, in fact, scarce resources – including land and minerals and other natural resources, but also labor. Most billionaires become that way by being in charge of a large company, one with a lot of workers. Well, you can't be the ruler without people to rule over. And if not for you, those people would still exist and would be making some other contribution to society.
- paulpauper 6y agoAn even faster way would have been for him to create a website , for example, www.claimmymoney.com and allow people to put in requests for donations, for any reason, that he would either honor or decline. There would probably have to be ID verification and other system in place to try to prevent people from abusing it. Given how so many Americans are living below poverty or in poverty or having expenses, he would have little trouble giving it all away
- pckhoi 6y agoThis method would limit benefactors to only those who have access to the internet and a way to receive money online. Most of the third world country population wouldn't fit into this category. And you can't be solving big systematic problems and bring about societal change by working with individual cases. This is like fighting fire when you should have made the building fireproof in the first place.
- aj7 6y agoAnonymous is how Jewish philanthropy is supposed to work.
- the_arun 6y agoGood for him & communities. Only few people are real monks. I admire for his detachment with Money. Not sure word “broke” is the right adjective here. If consciously someone donated their money to charity they need to be celebrated as a “winner” or overpoweing materialistic “money”? Something amazing. “Broke” means very negative. I don’t know. I could be wrong.
- prutschman 6y agoThis is a criticism of Forbes, not Chuck Feeny: He has $2 million in retirement. That's over 7 times the median net worth of Americans 75+. He's anything but "broke".
- Waterluvian 6y agoIt reassures me that there are examples of people who get hyper rich and retain some perspective on it.
- yholio 6y agoIf you want to have the most impact in your secret donations and change the lives of many people in good, then you should finance democratic and peaceful political underdogs in poor and represive countries. I know it sounds revolting that giving money to politicians is better than fighting malaria or cancer. But at the end of the day, those who are having the most impact in alleviating poverty and disease are not international philanthropists, but the governments of the respective countries. Misery is the result of the lack of institutions or their systemic failure under corrupt, inefficient and incompetent leaders. We have known for decades how to eradicate malaria and provide all people on Earth with basic food, shelter and education, what we lack is world-wide execution of essential state-building and infrastructure that would enable it, and much more. And money is a fundamental part of politics; politicians are just like any other people: if a decent, respectable living an be made in the field of politics, public office will attract decent and respectable people. If the only way you can get into power is by making trades with the devil, since no one will found politics, then what you get is corrupt and ineffective leaders that oppress rather the serve the public. This is why, for all his sins, George Soros remains one of the most effective philanthropists in the world. And this is why he's vilified by a whole wagon of authoritarians, from Putin to Orban to Jinping: they know that the most pressing threat to their power is not some foreign country, or a political or military international alliance; they are most afraid of a well funded and cohesive internal political opposition that can properly articulate the public discontent.
- everyone 6y ago$2 million is not broke
- koolkat666 6y agocan someone here who thinks charity is a morally noble act answer this question: why is it good to extract billions from people who work for you and then give it a way and feel good about it? why not share the profits with your workers in the first place? how is it morally justifiable to steal and exploit in order to give?
- konih 6y agoMay this giant of giving live well. He truly made it through the eye of the needle.
- mlthoughts2018 6y ago> “ Where did $8 billion go? Feeney gave $3.7 billion to education, including nearly $1 billion to his alma mater, Cornell, which he attended on the G.I. Bill. More than $870 million went to human rights and social change, like $62 million in grants to abolish the death penalty in the U.S. and $76 million for grassroots campaigns supporting the passage of Obamacare. He gave more than $700 million in gifts to health ranging from a $270 million grant to improve public healthcare in Vietnam to a $176 million gift to the Global Brain Health Institute at the University of California, San Francisco.” What an absolute gut-punch of deeply sickening waste. I feel extremely outraged reading. It’s a absolutely shocking waste of money. I can’t believe this is celebrated or held up as good. This is a form of basically negligent homicide. $3.7 billion on education? $76 million to lobby for Obamacare. How can you not instead fund known, effective charities like Against Malaria or SCI. $1 billion to a wealthy Ivy League credential mill - that’s astronomical waste. This is the charity equivalent of seeing a lottery winner blow their money on sports cars or Vegas. This is appalling. I mean this so sincerely. People should be sick and outraged over this degree of negligent waste.
- skinnymuch 6y agoWhew. Finally. I was scrolling looking for a comment like this. How is almost no one saying this? The speakers they mentioned are the most establishment politicians you can find. What does that say about his actions that those are the people representing him? How can you give $70M+ to something that is grassroots too?
- s1artibartfast 6y agoWhy? It was his money and he could have bought diamonds and shot them into the sun if he wanted. Instead it seems that the vast majority of the spending was a net positive to society and will do some good. Yes, there was probably a more impactful way of spending it from a humanitarian perspective, but presumably there wasn't a more satisfying way to spend it for Feeney. Nearly everything that everyone does is a negligent homicidal waste if you view it through the lens of opportunity cost. Unless you are living the life of an acetic, working every living hour, and donating it all to charity, you personally are hundreds if not thousands of people a year.
- neycoda 6y agoI think top two reasons to make charitable donations known is to bring attention to those charities and influence others to do the same.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- headmelted 6y agoIt’s true of him regardless, but as someone from Northern Ireland, Chuck Feeney is a freaking hero. I don’t have much to add that hasn’t been said already, but his donations - right up to the last - have made genuine and lasting differences in the hearts and minds of kids growing up here and I doubt even he knows all the good that’s come of what he did in this place. I don’t want to ramble on because it’ll end up sounding like a eulogy but he’s done an incredible thing for our people and we’re incredibly grateful for it.
- mesozoic 6y agoThis article doesn't cover any of the most interesting part. His brokeness. Is he now homeless? Is his plan to now kill himself? Does he get to experience the day to day struggle of broke elderly now? What's the deal?
- nloladze 6y agoThe finest example of a human. Definitely a better person than I could ever be. I would definitely flaunt and spend fabulous sums on dumb shit.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat is Feeney going to do if he lives until he is 105? The next decade and a half might be pretty boring for him.
- archibaldJ 6y agoKnowing people such as Chuck Feeney exist is very motivating. I have had many near-death experiences. When I came back to this world everything saddened me. It’s supposed to be good to be alive. And it is! But ontologically suffering appears to be a fundamental nature about this world. And there are so much unnecessary suffering around us. So many miseries. So many heart-broken things and false dreams and inauthenticity that just result in more sadness. All for nothing at the face of the death. This is why I want to believe. I want to believe in the goodness of people. Just as I’m constantly troubled by the realistic notion of death as I try to appreciate the transient presence of being here, I want to believe things will get better in the sense that there will be less suffering and people will learn and mature and become wiser and nicer to each other. As we approach death and become one with nothing, we become one. As we exist, we are only inducing more pains to ourselves. There are meanings though. I hope there are more meaningful things. We are sentient.
- umvi 6y ago"officially broke" with $2M in the bank for retirement
- signa11 6y agoConor O'Clery’ book ‘The Billionaire Who Wasn't: How Chuck Feeney Secretly Made and Gave Away a Fortune’ is an _excellent_ read. highly recommended!
- hehehehehehe 6y agotest..
- cgtyoder 6y agoNote how all the other mega-wealthy individuals praise him for his actions, but commit to nothing.
- andi999 6y agoNothing left apart from 2 million? Hopefully I can be broke as well for retirement. (Dislike the article, love the person)
- sytelus 6y agoInstead of giving away it all away, why not invest $8B which would generates about $800M per year in returns perpetually and give that as 0% loans for education, health and starting new businesses to people who needs it? This would be then perpetual giving that can outlast the donor.
- cyberdrunk 6y ago> Chuck Feeney Is Now Officially Broke He's not broke, he still has two million dollars (in a very advanced age). I wish I was that broke.
- OJFord 6y agoCan 'officially' be added to the auto-strip list? It's rarely used appropriately.
- dave_aiello 6y agoThis article is definitely worth reading. However, I didn't follow the link for over 21 hours after it was published because, I didn't recognize Chuck Feeney's name, and I couldn't tell from the title what the article was about. I think when an article is shared on HN some consideration needs to be given to ambiguous situations like this.
- blueyes 6y agoChuck's actual works get just a little mention in this piece. He is known for helping to bring peace to Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. That is, to end the Troubles, a conflict that lasted about 30 years, from the late 60s to the late 90s. People who were not yet adults in that time may have difficult imagining the violence of the Troubles. The terrorism, riots, violence and armed actions that characterized a guerrilla war and its suppression, all on the edge of Western Europe. The southern counties that now make up the Republic of Ireland had only achieved independence a few decades before that (the dates are complicated, but let's say it was in 1921) after 800 years of British occupation, and a recent war of independence. That was the backdrop against which Chuck Feeney tried to bring peace. He did so by working with both sides of the conflict, the Catholics and the Protestants, with diplomacy and massive investments, to make sure that they could see a path to peace despite all the anger, animosity and desire for vengeance that decades of violence and killing can instill. He helped resolve that. Not alone, but he was crucial. And we don't even think about it any more because it's all been relatively normal for a while. And that's amazing.
- jaas 6y agoChuck Feeney is not "officially broke." Per this story he has a couple million set aside for retirement and is living a perfectly happy life with all of his needs met. It seems disrespectful to Feeney's vision for his own life - he can give away so much and still be fine. Not broke. I don't know why the author had to cross the line into falsehood with the title. It's a great story about a great person, why sacrifice your integrity with an utterly false headline, particularly when the story doesn't need it?
- andys627 6y ago> I don't know why More scandalous title gets more clicks. Sucks...
- js2 6y agoThe author very likely did not choose the headline and the story itself never refers to Feeney being broke. It does use the idiom “go for broke” meaning to give something your full effort, which Feeney certainly did. Perhaps the headline was a lame attempt at a pun on the idiom or perhaps it’s just a clickbait headline.
- blahblah4332 6y agoAnd if someone were to audit those "anonymous" 8 Billion, I'm sure they would find that all of it made it to the front lines right? Right? Definitely no issues with corruption and oversight occurring within charitable organizations around the globe.
- cmwelsh 6y agoIs there any law that prohibits converting your wealth to cash and going on government aid? Is it legally fraud if you gave it to a 501(c)?