55 ms·
An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 7y agoNice try, but in $CURRENT_YEAR's rules of engagement, any explanation for gender discrepancy in STEM besides misogyny is itself evidence of misogyny.
- danharaj 7y agoThe fact that women shoulder the primary economic burden of raising children is structural sexism. Sexism is not merely about personal conduct but also how we structure society. For millenia across many cultures women have had their participation in broader society curtailed to the sphere of reproductive and domestic labor. That is injustice. As Morenz notes, we don't have to accept that. We can structure our work so that women are not disadvantaged for having kids and men aren't penalized for taking a greater role in raising them. This seems like violent agreement. I think Scott was trying to dismiss the people who criticize them by inviting Morenz to make a guest post. Perhaps his dismissiveness is the reason why this is so acrimonious.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoThis assumes that men and women en masse want equal roles in raising children. I'm not convinced that this is the case.
- danharaj 7y agoWhat does? I made a few claims.
- TheAdamAndChe 7y agoI was responding to the main premise of your comment, that "the fact that women shoulder the primary economic burden of raising children is structural sexism." This implies discrimination due to external forces that make men and women behave differently.
- danharaj 7y agoWhat do you mean by external forces? These are all interactions between human beings. We behave that we do in large part based on our interactions with others. Would you say that it is "external forces" that cause us two to communicate in English? What is the alternative position you're suggesting?
- TheAdamAndChe 7y ago"Structural sexism" implies nonintrinsic forces causing discrimination, hence why I called it an external force, as it's a force not generated internally. I think the effects of evolutionary biology need to be considered when looking at behavioral differences. Evolutionarily speaking, women invest much more energy into growing, giving birth to, and caring for children than men. This leads to innate differences in behavior separate from social forces you are describing.
- deyouz 7y agoThen how come some women don't want children and even dislike children? The reason why women are more involved in childcare after giving birth/nursery years is purely societal factors. It's expected of them to behave in that way in more conservative places and it's strongly implied in other places.
- csb6 7y agoSure, many more women may choose to take the more active role, but it’s important to consider that these conscious choices are affected by implicit social pressures and expectations that are placed on men and women from childhood onwards, such as men being expected to be breadwinners and women being expected to be caregivers. These are pretty arbitrary social constructs that are not universal or intrinsic to nature or even human societies. So it follows that what men and women would say they desire is not the full picture, since they may be unaware of the implicit forces acting on them.
- darawk 7y agoIt's true that these social pressures exist, and they are certainly sexist. But I think it's important to distinguish that the pressure is what's sexist, not the impact of the choice.
- csb6 7y agoThen let’s make an effort to expose and reform these sexist structures! That is the goal of people trying to reform the mindset of STEM institutions. These structures are not fixed, and so can be changed.
- fred_is_fred 7y agoAlthough I love my kids I would go clinically insane if I had to do the stay-at-home raising of them full time. My wife OTOH loves it and would rather do nothing else. I know that this is swapped for many couples, but I still argue that reality is more skewed this way than the other. Maybe that will change over time.
- volak 7y agoPeople downvote but I assure you many dads agree. IMO dads don't achieve the same level of bonding as women do to their babies and therefore we are able to tolerate less of the crap babies get into during the day. Its not sexism, its just biology. If I had a project I worked on for 9 months I would have more desire to continue working on it into the future. My investor is an interested party, but ultimately its entirely my drive which moves the project forward
- empath75 7y agoI'd love to spend more time with my kids and my wife would prefer to spend more time at work. I make 3 times her salary, though, so it's not really economically feasible for us to switch roles. She could afford to not work or work part time for 2 years. We couldn't afford it if I did it.
- darawk 7y ago> The fact that women shoulder the primary economic burden of raising children is structural sexism. You seem to be making a fairly subtle point here that I think others might be missing. Which is not that women choosing to take on the burden of childcare represents sexism (which is an argument some people make), but rather that the fact that their making this choice impinges upon their personal economic future is sexist. That is maybe a more interesting point than the former, but I don't think it really holds up to scrutiny. Choosing to take on the burden of childcare is choosing to spend less time working. In any other context, if a person chooses to work less, that negatively impacts their earning, and we consider that perfectly reasonable and fair. If I choose to play video games for 8 hours a day and work part time, basically everyone accepts it's reasonable that I make less money. Now, if women are being pressured or forced into accepting this childcare responsibility at their own economic expense, then yes. That is 100% structural sexism. Also, if society would have treated men making this choice differently than women, then that too would represent structural sexism. But there are men making this choice, and their careers are generally just as negatively impacted as the women who make it.
- clairity 7y agoto compare it to playing video games all day is (unwittingly?) falling prey to the very systemic sexism you're trying to fathom--that "women's work" such as childcare is not "work"--that it's economically unproductive and should be "free".
- darawk 7y agoNo, that was not the point of my analogy. Whether it is work or not is irrelevant. When I clean my home, that is work, but nobody pays me to do it. I do the work because I receive the benefit of that work. People care for their children for the same reason. And many (most?) couples consider the income of the breadwinner to be shared between the two of them for precisely this reason: Because the couple values the childcare that the childcare-r provides. I'm not arguing that childcare isn't valuable. I am arguing that it isn't valuable to any employer of the person doing the childcare, and as such, they shouldn't pay for it.
- zajio1am 7y ago> Sexism is not merely about personal conduct but also how we structure society. What does raising children have to do with society? Decision of having and raising a child is a fundamentally personal, not societal decision. Each pair should decide how they want to split responsibilities of raising a child before its conception, based on their preferences, and society should not force them to any model. Also, it seems to me that society already prioritize child-raising too much compared to other non-work activities. If people would leave STEM/some other field due to work-life balance for some other personal goals than child-raising (say part-time working in a non-profit), would anyone care?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- untog 7y ago> What does raising children have to do with society? Decision of having and raising a child is a fundamentally personal, not societal decision. Of course it isn't. Every society needs an up and coming younger generation as the older generation stops working. That is absolutely a problem on a societal level.
- zajio1am 7y agoWhile i agree it may be a concern of a society to be stable, it does not automatically translate to necessary concern for society as a whole. Many things necessary for a society work even if society does not intervene in them. People would have children for emotional reasons even if society does not intervene. Also, if a societal stability is a goal, then having more than replacement number of children is as problematic as having less.
- untog 7y ago> People would have children for emotional reasons even if society does not intervene. Yes, but the success of those children is still a societal concern. You want some of those children to be a new generation of doctors, teachers, etc. etc... without supporting them at a young age (i.e. providing education, a welfare safety net) there's no guarantee that would ever happen, and they might end up being more of a drain on society than a productive member.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>Sexism is not merely about personal conduct but also how we structure society. Great. But my personal experience is that this notion seems to vanish as soon as we look at things like rates of workplace deaths, life expectancy, hours worked, imprisonment, or numerous other areas. And even if they don't vanish, the level of attention devoted seems to be remarkably different. Would the way we structure society in regards to structuring our attention for social ills also possibly include sexism? And I guess such notions can be dismissed as being off topic. As they aren't relevant to the actual issue under discussion. But when we start viewing larger more structural things as sexism, then wouldn't even such dismissal potentially qualify as sexism?
- danharaj 7y agoThis might surprise you but a lot of feminists are also strongly in favor of workers' rights and prison abolition. For example, bell hooks and Angela Davis. I have never met people more passionately invested in the wellbeing of men than the feminists I read and live with. It is a shame to me that decades of propaganda have buried those voices and raised the voices of those who insist that feminism is a zero sum game.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>prison abolition As in, no criminals go to prison? I wonder what these feminist feel should be as the punishment for rape. >I have never met people more passionately invested in the wellbeing of men than the feminists I read and live with. Many of those who want to ban abortion are very passionate about protecting the women seeking such, as they believe it is far better for those women to be denied such an opportunity (such as saving them from doing something they will regret, at least per the belief of the people supporting anti-choice legislation). Intentions and passion shouldn't be ignored, but neither do they provide a complete picture.
- tathougies 7y agoHave you considered that the primary enforcer of this curtailment is not adults but infants? I mean, I took long paternity leave, I am with my daughter at night, and am with her whenever I am home. She still wants to nurse on her mothers breast when she's sick or in pain. This makes sense as not only is it comforting to her (and a childs emotional need is very real) but it is also physiologically beneficial (nursing reduces stress hormones and helps her heal from disease faster). She enforces this dichotomy of roles by screaming if i try to comfort her and shes already decided what she wants by screaming mama. She'll take comfort from me only if shes decided that its something that doesnt require something no man can give. And her cry is meant to change both of our emotional states to fulfill her every desire. Is this injustice? Perhaps you could characterize it this way, but since the perpetrator is beyond reason and lacks expression, I'm not sure how youre going to fix this.
- csb6 7y agoStructural sexism is not perpetuated by infants. I mean come on. Children wanting to nurse is not the big issue; children grow up, and do not need nursing when they become toddlers. So why are women still expected to be caretakers of toddlers, middle-schoolers, and tweens? Surely, there isn’t a physiological reason. There is clearly something larger going on. In reality, men and women’s roles are arbitrary, and the sexist structures present today are not the result of children asking for it. You are overestimating the intrinsic qualities of human social and family interactions, which are not as set in stone as you claim. Even the concept of the nuclear family - with one possible nurse and mother figure - isn’t a universal construct of human societies.
- eej71 7y agoWhile its not a universal construct - it is challenging to look at the history of many cultures who arrived at a similar distribution of labor and the behavior of other mammals and not wonder if men and women aren't inherently different in some generalized way that isn't readily alterable. For those of us on the other side of the debate, there is always this vague sense of some people are underestimating the impact of these intrinsic differences.
- hurricanetc 7y agoBiology isn't sexist. Men can't get pregnant so therefore only women can deal with pregnancy. Men can't breastfeed or pump, either. People want reality to reflect their world view but biology is biology. It's not an indictment on society that only women perform certain biological functions.
- amanaplanacanal 7y agoThe century is young. Who knows what the future might bring?
- breischl 7y ago>We can structure our work so that women are not disadvantaged for having kids Can we, though? It seems that there is some amount of time that women are unable to work due to the physical rigors of pregnacy, child-birth, and (in many cases) infant care. Taking time away from work, no matter what the reason, necessarily affects the trajectory of your career. We can try to minimize that in various ways (as the original article discussed) but it seems impossible to reduce it to zero barring sci-fi tech like artificial wombs. It might be reasonable to say that we can structure out work so that women are disadvantaged _as little as reasonably possible_ for having kids.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI find this a bit pointless- Scott Aaronson has his views that are not the views of a sizeable majority of women in STEM, who find that their career progression is hindered by institutionalised sexism. At some point Aaronson finds or receives a dissenting opinion from a woman in STEM. He publishes it, with a preface suggesting that _this_ is the _real_ view of a majority of women in STEM (the opinion "dovetails with what I’ve heard from many other women in STEM fields, including my wife Dana"). Fair enough- but how often has Aaronson published, or publicised, an opinion from a woman who disagrees with his view? Er. Not often. Probably because he disagrees with them and so will tend to find that they do not marshal "data, logic, and [their] own experience in support of an insight that strikes me as true and important and underappreciated". So what have we learned from the fact that Scott Aaronson has published this opinion on his blog? Absolutely nothing. We knew his opinion, he still has the same opinion. We know there are other people, including women in STEM, that have the same opinion as Scott Aaronson. Here is one of them and her opinion. We have learned nothing new. This is just preaching to the converted.
- insickness 7y agoSee: Ad hominem (Latin for "to the person"), short for argumentum ad hominem, typically refers to a fallacious argumentative strategy whereby genuine discussion of the topic at hand is avoided by instead attacking the character, motive, or other attribute of the person making the argument, or persons associated with the argument, rather than attacking the substance of the argument itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
- lidHanteyk 7y agoI agree, to the point where I wish that we'd just talk about the original article instead of this repost, instead. Maybe the URL could be changed to [0]? [0] https://medium.com/@kjmorenz/is-it-really-just-sexism-an-alternative-argument-for-why-women-leave-stem-cccdf066d8b1 https://medium.com/@kjmorenz/is-it-really-just-sexism-an-alt...
- dang 7y agoOk, we've changed to that from https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4522 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4522. Let's focus on the author's own argument now please.
- gbrown 7y agoJudging by what happens most times gender in tech comes up on HN, I’m sure this thread will be buckets of fun.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't make the thread even worse by posting unsubstantive comments about it. It's a divisive topic, so fractiousness is not easy to avoid, but everyone should make sure they're up to date on the site guidelines before posting. They include: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gbrown 7y agoFair enough
- deyouz 7y agoThe article is about women in STEM in Academia, not just STEM. And I don't understand why people absolutely need to have biological children. I think more people should just adopt if they want to raise children. I also think sexism in the US is the biggest factor for women leaving Academia or not entering STEM. In other countries more than 50% of the researchers are women and 40% of the students studying computer science are women.
- larrik 7y ago> I think more people should just adopt if they want to raise children. As someone who has adopted 3 children, I assure you that the biological route is way easier and cheaper. It's not like rescuing a dog from the pound...
- pgeorgi 7y agoExcept for birth and family planning related complications that are minimized in exactly the time frame where career effects tend to compound (or so the article seems to claim)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 7y agoThe desire for biological children is pretty ingrained in our psyche.
- tathougies 7y agoThere are few infants to adopt due to the success of americas adoption programs and the willingness of americans to adopt. The ones that are 'easy' to adopt almost universally have special needs that most people (especially working parents) simply cannot meet.
- icandoit 7y ago>And I don't understand why people absolutely need to have biological children. Consider these possibilities: 1. A best case scenario is that what you have expressed is a personal opinion that takes your genes out of the future in a Marty McFly fading away fashion as this opinion hardens. Fine. Your choice. More pie for the rest of us. 2. A worst case scenario where this opinion accumulates in the market place of ideas and inevitably leads to human extinction. Impossible right? Well, know that disgust with sex is climbing in rich nations (like Germany and Japan) and the number of births per woman is falling. Is this a function of wealth, or technology? South Korea has fewer than 1.1 births per woman. That can only translate into a poorer, older, and smaller country for the future. [1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/KOR/south-korea/fertility-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/KOR/south-korea/fertil... (I tell people that this was the thickly veiled premise of the movie Bird Box.) If that is true, then can it be called a choice? Are people actually choosing to have fewer sexual partners than their parents generation? Are people really choosing to feel disgust at the thought of intimate contact? Maybe repulsion-to-sex is a bigger threat to continued human existence as nuclear weapons. Another fun article: https://medium.com/migration-issues/how-long-until-were-all-amish-268e3d0de87 https://medium.com/migration-issues/how-long-until-were-all-...
- o_p 7y agoIts almost like they are biologically and mentally hard-wired to have children! How dares nature to create a unequal duality with specialized roles.
- krastanov 7y agoI, and many others, hold the expectation that we are quite capable of overcoming our animal instincts (in this, but importantly in many other aspects also) to make a better world. Especially if the presence of the instinct is used as a pseudo science excuse.
- lonelappde 7y agoWhat would I want to overcome the core reason for my existence?
- krastanov 7y agoMaking kids is not even remotely the core reasons that many people have chosen for their existence. And this is not some egoistical selfish decision: there are many more ways in which you can take care of the next generation and make their lives better, without having to give birth. These are noble pursuits independent of gender.
- o_p 7y agoBut it will really lead us to a better world? Theres a reason why we have instincts, its so arrogant from the enlightened westerns to think they know better than literally every other society in history. Take it as anecdotal experience, I dont have a study right here and women are free to do whatever they want. But a childless life is much more likely to be a less happier and a unfulfilling life.
- krastanov 7y agoSure, some instincts are good, like gagging at the sight of rotten food. But also, our instincts tell us to eat sugar, be tribalistic, and (for men) to do stupid stuff to impress mates. We are designed to live in caves and chase herbivores. But for millennia we have been doing much more than what our instincts relegate us to. And no, this is not a westerner with a superiority complex thing. See how relatively egalitarian the cultures of various settlers and natives have been throughout history. Lastly, while I understand that for you and many others a childless life would be unfulfilling, please do not assume this to be even nearly universal. Moreover, not having or wanting your own (biological or not) children does not mean you can not help the next generation, through mentorship and teaching and community service.
- GCA10 7y agoThanks, Karen Morenz, for providing a unified, panoramic view of the ways that the standard academic career progression short-changes many female scientists, even if each step along the way seems to make sense. It's worth taking a look at three other professions with long, high-intensity pathways from apprentice to master --all of which have been wrestling with the same challenges. They are management consulting, law and medicine. I've written about them elsewhere. In medicine, there's been a surge of female participation (and leadership) in specialties such as dermatology, psychiatry and radiology, where it's relatively easier to rearrange hours and training regimens to be family compatible. There's been less progress in surgery, where hellish hours are considered part of the journey. In law, some firms have been experimenting with a blurring of the boundaries between associate and partner, so that there's a middle level at which women can enter into motherhood without tanking their career chances. (In the traditional model, close to 40% of entry-level associates are female, but few of them stick around to make partner.) I'm wondering if either of those models is transferable to STEM academia. Are there particular sub-disciplines where professional success and sane hours might be more compatible? Similarly, are there tenure-track or quasi-tenure track job titles that split the difference in tolerable ways? I haven't researched these well enough to have clear answers. But it's worth discussing.
- toufka 7y agoThere is an unfortunate distinction between those other professions - STEM fields rarely pay even close to what consulting, law and medicine pay. Peers of equivalent talent in those 3 professions are generally making double to triple (if not more) by the time STEM graduates reach the same moment in their personal lives. And that 'moment' is generally delayed in STEM compared to those professions; you start generating your first real paycheck in STEM, with some stability in your career path at your early-mid thirties. Even medicine (which is longer than consulting & law), stability can be reached before that.
- fizwhiz 7y ago> STEM fields rarely pay even close to what consulting, law and medicine pay. Peers of equivalent talent in those 3 professions are generally making double to triple (if not more) by the time STEM graduates reach the same moment in their personal lives. These statements couldn't be further from the truth. You don't need to hang out on HN for long to figure out that FAANG SWEs comfortably make upwards of 400k in their late 20s[1]. Barring FB and perhaps Netflix, most tech companies tend to have fantastic work-life-balance if you prefer to take it easy. L5s at Google make what Partners at McKinsey make. If you normalize by the number of hours worked, SWEs make a hell of a lot more than their peers in consulting (management or the Big4) and about the same as the median cardiologist with maybe 20% of the effort. [1] https://drive.google.com/file/d/19ne7ccUdOWewD4rFDQjjnQEJDgsmgFID/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/19ne7ccUdOWewD4rFDQjjnQEJDgs...
- corporateslave5 7y agoThe truth is men are more mathematically inclined. Why we as a society make up all sorts of fantasies is beyond me
- vorpalhex 7y agoThat is clearly not the only reason, and likely isn't even a major factor in and of itself. Yes, we might expect to see slightly more men in general in math heavy fields, but that women tend to drop out as they approach not heavier math, but more time consuming/worse work/life balance situations (management) suggests the issue isn't just "men are more mathematically inclined". Like any complex phenomenon applying to a multitude of people there are several effects happening in different proportion at the same time.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> I’ve got a big scholarship, and a lot of people supporting me to give me the best shot at an academic career — a career I dearly want. But, I also want a family — maybe two or three kids Oh. Up to this point I was keeping notes with my criticism of this article, but this caused me to stop and reconsider. If I may advise the author, I understand how difficult it is to balance life decisions that seem to be at odds, but trying to deny the very reason why those life decisions are hard to combine will not make the choice any easier. It is stupid and sexist that you have to think of pursuing a PhD and having two or three kids as an either/or option, when the (probably) man you'll want to start a family with will not have to do that, even if they are also a PhD in STEM. This is part and parcel of the sexism that people complain about. It's not just inappropriate behaviour by senior male academics. There is no reason why a woman must put her career on hold to start a family when a man in the same career does not need to. There is no reason why women are expected to be the ones most concerned with the business of having and raising children when men are expected to be the most concerned with advancing their careers. How is that not sexist? How is that not the sexism that's keeping women from advancing their careers in STEM academia?
- blub 7y agoYes, nature and sexual selection were sexist and designed women so that they have to bear the brunt of having children. That's reality, I don't see how it helps in any way to call reality sexist. And having a career is not the most awesome thing in the world. Many fathers would very much prefer to spend time with their families, but can't because they're expected to first and foremost provide for them.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoNature and sexual selection have nothing to do with it. A complete lack of societal support for women who want to have children and maintain a career in STEM academia (or similar) is all there is to it. >> Many fathers would very much prefer to spend time with their families, but can't because they're expected to first and foremost provide for them. Why do the fathers "have to provide"? Why is it so difficult for a man to stay at home and take care of the kids, after they're born (which he can obviously not really do)? Is that nature, again?
- amb23 7y agoMothers--the vast majority of mothers, not the aristocracic ones we model our current family structures off of--have always worked. They'd strap the baby on their back and go to the fields to plow or gather the harvest or cook or weave or chop firewood. Motherhood as as a full-time job is a modern invention; historically, it was a side gig. I'd love to see a startup tackle this problem: think a benefits platform that allows companies to offer daycare as a benefit, or a Wonderschool-like daycare for working parents. Even an improved work from home policy for new parents would go a long way to plugging the talent "leak" that's prevalent right now.
- blub 7y agoHistorically, the extended family and neighbors were contributing to raising children. For a couple that doesn't have family close by and lives in a city, parenthood is at least a part-time job.
- Jagat 7y agoAlso, mothers didn't have to keep an eye on the kids all the time past infancy. It was fairly common to leave them on their own with other kids to play, only ensuring they're fed on time. And once they reached a sufficient age (10 or 12), children usually helped the family with their craft. Before the industrial revolution, what's considered norm today was the norm only for aristocrats.
- nimajneb 7y agoI'm 37 and the oldest of 4 kids and your first paragraph is for the most part how I grew up. I don't remember my mom following any of us around past a certain age, like 5 or so. She cleaned the house etc. while we played inside or in the backyard. I remember going up the block to the park with my friends without any adults at the age of 10-12 or maybe a little younger.
- astura 7y ago>It was fairly common to leave them on their own with other kids to play, only ensuring they're fed on time. This was the norm 25 years ago, it's how I grew up.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoThere's a big tendency to ignore the price at which career success is sold. You have to give up more fulfilling and creative work, perhaps, or spend long hours in front of a screen on difficult yet boring tasks, or put in years and years of all-encompassing work in various qualification gauntlets. Not having paid the price for fame in academic STEM, I have no jealousy of the success these people have found - they have their fame, I have my free time. I think a big issue in the study of gender differences in work is that it is much easier to quantify the salary earned than the price one must pay in order to be successful in the field. About the best you can do is compare sub-populations that have paid roughly the same price - eg, urban childless single college-educated adults. At that point, studies generally show an insignificant gender difference in wages and success. So, why is there a gendered component to participation in high-pay/high-sacrifice fields? I've not seen any sort of hard data, so I'd have to speculate. If you made me single out a candidate for investigation, I'd have to look into the how the heterosexual dating market will asymmetrically treat career success. People respond to incentives, and dating success is one hell of an incentive.
- aratakareigen 7y agoYeah, I'm super uninformed here, but single men's expectations of potential partners are totally the prime suspect here. Anecdote: My uncle explicitly stated on his dating profile that he was looking for women with masters degrees who were willing to stay at home. I have no idea why he wanted that or why my dad's sister agreed, but this kind of demand is oddly common.
- ThrustVectoring 7y ago> single men's expectations of potential partners are totally the prime suspect here. It's both genders; women do not lack agency in the dating market. It'd be as fair to make "my partner should be willing to give up their career to start a family" as the default and blame the dynamic on women - after all, they prefer men who are unwilling to compromise in the pursuit of their career. I try to avoid either, and just mention that this axis has a gendered component in terms of both what people do and desire.
- oefrha 7y ago> We spend billions of dollars training women in STEM. By not making full use of their skills, if we look at only the american economy, we are wasting about $1.5 billion USD per year in economic benefits they would have produced if they stayed in STEM. So here’s a business proposal: ... With all due respect, I don’t understand this call to action. Faculty position is basically a zero sum game. If more women end up as faculty, fewer men will. So, unless it costs more to train women than men, I doubt any “investment” would be saved (and that’s not the point of gender equality anyway). Btw, this maternal wall idea is nothing new. I talked to my mother about gender inequality in hiring many years ago and she was quick to point this out (didn’t call it “maternal wall” though).
- pgeorgi 7y ago> With all due respect, I don’t understand this call to action. Faculty position is basically a zero sum game. If more women end up as faculty, fewer men will. So, unless it costs more to train women than men, I doubt any “investment” would be saved The assumption is that aptitude for these positions is roughly the same between genders, so if there's a significant imbalance, society doesn't get the best people on the given set of seats. The later calculation is along the lines of "society is pouring so much money both into these positions and into getting-women-into-STEM programs without reaching this supposed goal, so here's a counter-proposal to use this money more wisely" > Btw, this maternal wall idea is nothing new. She's quite upfront that she borrowed the term as well, so the idea can't be new. But it might be time to reiterate that point (as opposed to the popular reduction of the problem to sexism only), and since she did a good job (IMHO) to collect sources...
- allovernow 7y ago>The assumption is that aptitude for these positions is roughly the same between genders, so if there's a significant imbalance, society doesn't get the best people on the given set of seats. An assumption which I have to point out is absolutely not verified. In fact, there are mountains of circumstantial, statistical, and biological evidence to the contrary - which policy makers in the west are increasingly ignoring as they ram gender parity down industry's and academia's collective throats, possibly to the detriment of the institutions and society at large.
- trynewideas 7y agoThis is a good model for why women capable of or wanting to have children leave but won't do much to explain anything to women aren't capable of having children, or who don't want children, and still can't break past middle management into product/exec/C-suite roles over younger, less qualified men.
- deyouz 7y agoThis! Not all women want children/can have children/are straight.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe author seems to ignore the fact that plenty of women do work while pregnant and have children and go back to work after a little as 3months hiring childcare.
- daotoad 7y agoYou are ignoring several facts: 1. Pregnancy is very hard on women's bodies. It is not uncommon for health effects like high blood pressure, joint inflammation, and gestational diabetes to become temporarily disabling for expectant mothers. 2. Infant childcare is incredibly expensive. Even at professional levels of compensation, the expense is likely to outweigh the added income from continuing to work. Costs drop significantly once children are potty trained, but remain quite high. 3. Three months of paid maternal leave is very rare. Even with saved time off, taking large amounts of unpaid leave is hard on a family. 4. Breast feeding a child while working full days requires a huge amount of work, above and beyond the exhausting labor involved in having a new baby. If a nursing room is not provided, women often resort to spending a large amount of time pumping milk in the restroom. Which is uncomfortable, unsanitary, and disheartening. Just because some women have the resources or the stark need to return to work so early does not mean it is possible or desirable for everyone. We need to have better maternal leave and accommodations. Fathers need to step up and do more of the work. We need to have better paternal leave and accomodations. We need to support affordable child care options. We need to make the above 4 items available to everyone.
- tharne 7y agoI think the author buried the lede here. My biggest takeaway from the article is that you'd have to be an absolute sucker to work in academia given how poorly you'll be treated. Each person that puts up with this only makes the problem worse, giving at least tacit approval to the status quo. If folks were to start opting out of academia in larger numbers for jobs in private industry, schools would be forced to improve working conditions. Unlike lower-skilled workers, the kind of person who even has the opportunity to get a PhD is also likely to have other good opportunities should they choose to take them. Academics should improve their lot and that of others by voting with their feet.
- theflyinghorse 7y agoAgreed. I am completely failing to understand why anyone would willingly go into academia provided other options are available.
- __jal 7y ago> Academics should [...] vot[e] with their feet. You do see the problem here, don't you?
- stale2002 7y agoI don't see a problem with that, no. It would result in more people going into successful careers in industry. That's a good thing.
- __jal 7y agoThe problem would be that they would no longer be academics. For a lot of people who head down that path, they consider it more of a vocation than a job. It may well be a good thing for all the next folks who consider the path, but it choosing that would come at a large personal cost for them. Most folks are not that altruistic.
- conanbatt 7y agoVocation does not pay. It's fine if they prefer the grueling life, and should be left to it.
- balls187 7y agoMy note to the author, enjoy your career. If and when you feel ready to start a family, you will. And if it doesn't happen, you'll be okay too. Maternal Age seems like a boogie man story to scare women. Perhaps STEM women who are early career (24-28) would benefit from meeting mothers (both who are in STEM and not in STEM careers) who had children at age 35+. > ...Women who stay in academia expect to marry later, and delay or completely forego having children, and if they do have children, plan to have fewer than their non-STEM counterparts (Sassler et al 2016, Owens 2012). Men in STEM have no such difference compared to their non-STEM counterparts I would love to see the figures regarding the partners of STEM Women vs STEM Men. Is it due to the old sexist notion that women must "marry up" so a woman with a successful career have partnered with someone who also has a successful career? Having family shifts perspective. Perhaps some of these women no longer felt a strong desire to further their career, and family matters became more interesting? As a father, I love my job, but I gladly set aside my career to raise my kids.
- hurricanetc 7y ago>Maternal Age seems like a boogie man story to scare women. It's just a biological reality. It is certainly possible to have a healthy birth after the age of 35 but the rate of health problems and birth defects don't go up linearly with age. The rate of pregnancy loss is 35% after the age of 35 and is above 50% after the age of 45. This is just reality. If women want to have multiple children it is wise to start before age 33.
- balls187 7y agoThe statistics do not tell the whole story. A reason I suggest young women speak with women who started families mid-late career would hear actual experiences, giving perspective that it's not as bleak as the statistics show. We had two children, both healthy, after mom was 35. We also had a pregnancy that didn't go to term. I surmise women might take some comfort in knowing that pregnancy complications are normal.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
- jkingsbery 7y agoI'm totally on board with making changes that address concerns for women specifically. That being said, as someone not in academia, it seems like a crazy path for anyone, male or female. As the article said, you're usually 34 before you have a lab established and the research program really gets going. Is there any way the system could be changed/simplified so that talented researchers could start earlier?
- hinkley 7y agoI can't speak for women, and I'm just smart enough not to try. But what I can say is that I don't hold all of the values that I did as a young man. I'm not excited about the same things, and today I find some of those ideas uncomfortably naive or even off-putting. As I've engaged in more activities, as I've socialized with more people, I've encountered many more ideas and a lot of nuance. Nothing has simple answers and there are other solutions to problems besides code, or tools, or pills, or surgery. And one of the consequences of this is that I'm not confident that if I show up to interview at a startup that I'm going to exhibit the degree of 'passion' they're looking for. I have plenty of passion. Too much, some will tell you. I just know beyond all doubt that your new iOS app is not going to save the world, and quite bluntly, that you have some unresolved issues that you need to work through if you so desperately need to believe how transformative your work is going to be. And I know that's not just STEM - all the 20-somethings who I've seen doing volunteer work - and bless you for showing up - feel exactly the same way. I'm gonna change the world. I have to change the world. Otherwise my life is empty and I am nothing. It can be discomfiting to be around and I'm sure I telegraph it. They say that young women socialize a little ahead of young men. Maybe they just get a whiff of my reality before all the rhetoric gets piled on so thick that's all they can see.
- hinkley 7y agoI did not mean to imply that there isn't a ton of other unwarranted bullshit they have to deal with. Reading it back to myself, that wasn't clear at all.
- slumdev 7y ago> And one of the consequences of this is that I'm not confident that if I show up to interview at a startup that I'm going to exhibit the degree of 'passion' they're looking for. This is good, though. If you faked the passion, you might wind up surrounded by lunatics who actually believe their iOS app is going to save the world. Also, this "passion", most of the time, is just a word that has been co-opted by the owner class to mean "working nights and weekends".
- hinkley 7y ago
- rdlecler1 7y agoI wonder if shorter PhD programs, like they have at Oxford might give women more time in the workforce before they start becoming concerned with starting a family. Maybe starting earlier puts them in a more senior position at a younger age.
- scottlocklin 7y agoShorter and fewer Ph.D.s (aka constrain the supply the way the AMA does) would actually solve all the problems mentioned here. Might even kickstart stalled scientific and technological development.
- selimthegrim 7y agoHow do you figure the latter? Redirecting resources elsewhere?
- scottlocklin 7y agoOne of the possible reasons for lack of progress; too many people. If you look at something like a consensus algorithm, many work much more slowly with "too many participants." Or it could be an insufficiently high IQ test at present; dumb people get in the way and cause problems.
- ixtli 7y ago> When you ask women why they left, the number one reason they cite is balancing work/life responsibilities — which as far as I can tell is a euphemism for family concerns. At least in america women are, in this way, almost always asked to choose between their career and having children. This is asymmetrical with men's experience because whether or not they are comfortable with it, its considered normal for them to spend most of their time at work even if they have a newborn. I'm not sure what else you'd call this status quo aside from "sexist." It's a systemic sexism that has deep roots in how we organize the aesthetics of our society.
- allovernow 7y ago>It's a systemic sexism that has deep roots in how we organize the aesthetics of our society Or it's a systematic sexism that has deep roots in human biology and thousands of generations of sexually dimorphic specialization, and I can't believe we've successfully convinced multiple generations of westerners now to pretend that men and women are equally suited for all roles, including child rearing. Now we need an article which takes an honest look at the possibility that gender imbalance in STEM (and other fields) is at least partly a result of similar specialization for cognitive tasks, where researchers like the author of the article are closer to extremes of an ability distribution. But I'm relieved to see a take that questions the tired, pervasive assumption that STEM is simply not welcoming to women because old white men are sexist.
- deyouz 7y ago>Or it's a systematic sexism that has deep roots in human biology and thousands of generations of sexually dimorphic specialization Are you saying women are naturally more nurturing than men? And more inclined towards childcare? Because I vehemently disagree. >I'm relieved to see a take that questions the tired, pervasive assumption that STEM is simply not welcoming to women because old white men are sexist. It can definitely be a factor. And even a more important factor is the fact that women can feel unwelcome in tech. At Oxford only 10% of the undergraduates accepted to study computer science were women. Now imagine being a woman in that class. You might feel like you don't belong, although you might be friends with your predominantly male classmates. Some of them will make jokes at the expense of your gender, others will hit on you, and the list goes on. Obviously not all of them will treat you differently, but some of them will, and that's enough to feel unwelcomed. And thus, you might be more inclined to leave tech for a field with more women, like biology.
- whatthe2 7y agoOnce a woman has a child, that is her main concern, not work. Simple.
- klyrs 7y agoI'm not a fan of this title. Throughout the piece, sexism is regarded as a key factor. The thesis of the article, and indeed the article's title, suggests that sexism isn't the only factor. This isn't an "alternative argument," it's another piece to the puzzle.
- e12e 7y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but this seems to be typical sexism: there's work at work which is paid, and work at home which is not. Men do little enough of the latter, that doing the paid work isn't a problem. Women do such a large part of the former, that they feel the need to chose between which part get done. Sure, the positive way to change this, is to reduce the unpaid work (child care professionals are paid, cleaners are paid etc) - that is, to acknowledge it as work that needs to be done, is productive, and should be part of what society rewards/share resources to get done. But the equal rights / equal opportunity path indicates that we also need a (bigger) culture shift so that the unpaid work of running a home is more equally divided.
- Terretta 7y ago> this seems to be typical sexism: there’s work at home which is paid, and work at home which is not If it’s not paid, how do those doing it live? Tax documents call the salary worker + home maker combo “household income”, which may be an appropriate way of thinking about the household getting paid and the household looking after the home. This applies regardless of the genders of the happy couple, so I’m not sure it’s ‘sexism’.
- jfengel 7y agoIt's notable that in general, even when paid, "women's work" is less valuable than men's work. The younger a student is, the more likely they are to be taught by a woman, and the less they are likely to make -- but is teaching a high schooler harder than teaching a first grader? Cleaning, child care, and nursing are all both female-coded and low-paying. Women are often pushed towards professions involving some kind of care -- and it's expected that they'll want it because they have an emotional attachment rather than for money. Being a homemaker is the limit case: absolute attachment and zero pay. I wonder what would happen if we simply made the purely numerical correction of counting homemaking in GDP. Would we value it more? Would it make it more attractive to men? Would we develop better infrastructure?
- 40acres 7y agoThis seems like a really long argument just to end up at the main point being: "It really is sexism". The light bulb moment here is that it's not necessarily sexism on an individual level but on an institutional one. I believe there is an obvious difference men and women which, on a general level, incites women to weigh family responsibilities over career prospects. However, industrialized nations exacerbate that difference by making it very difficult for women with children to spend the time necessary for career advancement. The key here isn't necessarily throwing your hands up and saying there's nothing you can do about it, but more robust programs for parents to help lessen the load of parenthood.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> more robust programs And by “more robust programs”, you mean more related confiscatory taxation. Meaning that, again, men must surrender even more, and accept even less, to accommodate women.
- icandoit 7y agoWould you think a tax levied on the childless and payed out the child-possessing to be sufficiently gender neutral? Why are childrens well-being not the concern of men? You have assumed something to be true, that I haven't, maybe.
- deyouz 7y ago>again When did men surrendered something to accommodate women? From what I remember women were the ones who accommodated men for thousand of years.
- alharith 7y agoWoke twitter after reading this article: Having children is a tool of the patriarchy! Another way that men keep women down! Why don't they have the biological maternal desires to have children? Technocratic twitter after reading this article: We must solve the “maternal tax” gap! Normal people after reading this article: "yes, this is what we have been saying for years. Promote the family."
- SuperFerret 7y agoPerfect article for sexists to use to justify being sexist.
- tus88 7y ago> women leave the field at a rate 3 to 4 times greater than men, and in particular, if they do not obtain a faculty position quickly Wait what....you mean by STEM you just meant academia?
- cpitman 7y agoExactly my confusion with this article. I have multiple female friends who have earned doctorates in STEM who have either left or are planning on leaving academia to go to industry. However, they are still all going into STEM jobs! So maybe the problem is that industry STEM is offering an overall better benefits package than academia? We're seeing the same thing in fields like AI, where academia can't retain top talent.
- fiftyfifty 7y agoYeah it's unfortunate that the author of this article uses the term STEM over and over again and is really only talking about the S. I wounder if the issues mentioned here are as common in private industry for women in the TEM fields? It seems like at least some companies are far more generous with things like maternity leave than what you might find in academia.
- daenz 7y agoAnother sunken cost taxpayer bill? "Just spend a little more money to unlock all the money you already spent." No thanks.
- WalterBright 7y agoBefore modern times, the grandparents fulfilled much of the role of watching the kids while the moms worked. In fact, some have posited that this is why humans live long enough to be grandparents - it's an evolutionary advantage. But in modern society, we tend to cast off our grandparents.
- commandlinefan 7y agoNot necessarily cast off, but we’re so mobile now that we move too far away from our grandparents to be able to lean on them for childcare (my wife’s parents live in a different country…)
- WalterBright 7y agoAfter my mom passed, my dad decided to move to Seattle, which turned out great for both of us. I greatly enjoyed having the old man around.
- icandoit 7y agoI wonder how much the feeling is one-sided. I visit my grandparents more often than they visit me (even generously discounting for physical ability, income, and the one-to-many relationship). I think the way to measure this might be grandparents moving out of state of family (think Arizona and Florida). Obviously the stigma of aging should get the bulk of the responsibility here. Any got any advice on how to re-norm grandparents? I'm hesitating on moving out of state during my kids early childhood.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Any got any advice on how to re-norm grandparents? I'm hesitating on moving out of state during my kids early childhood. Living in the same neighborhood as your grandparents would be best. I know families that do that, and the payoff is great for the kids, the parents, and the grandparents. The kids love their grandparents, the grandparents love taking care of the kids, and the parents get safe, reliable, and free help. It's a win all around. It's the way things ought to be.
- shkkmo 7y agoSo it seems that in addition to fighting sexism, we need to combat ageism, the viability of non-standard career paths with breaks, and the friendlines of the workplace in general to families.
- throwaway894345 7y ago> Heck, let’s spend 99% — $1.485 billion (in the states alone) on better support. That should put a dent in the support bill, and I’d sure pick up $15 million if I saw it lying around. Wouldn’t you? According to PEW (https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/01/09/diversity-in-the-stem-workforce-varies-widely-across-jobs/ https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2018/01/09/diversity-in-the-...) there were 17M STEM employees in 2016, so this leaves less than $1000 per employee for childcare. According to Fortune (https://fortune.com/2018/10/22/childcare-costs-per-year-us/ https://fortune.com/2018/10/22/childcare-costs-per-year-us/) the average cost per child is $9K/year (probably more if you adjust for the distribution of STEM careers?). I'm guessing STEM employees have at least one child on average (some have none, others have multiple, etc), so that only covers about 1/9th of the bill. That's a dent in the bill, but I'm not sure it's enough to make even a proportional dent in the pipeline. Note that this assumes the money finances a benefit that must be offered to all employees; if you can target the women in question, the calculus clearly changes; however, I suspect that would be difficult under current US discrimination law (IANAL). That said, I'd rather that money go to employees where it would certainly be useful as opposed to the current programs which, as far as I can tell, is squandered (to put it nicely).
- AlexCoventry 7y ago> I suspect that would be difficult under current US discrimination law What statutes do you believe would stand in the way of an organization offering excellent daycare services to its employees, as suggested in the OP?
- alexchamberlain 7y agoI believe the GP was simply saying you couldn’t only offer it to women.
- throwaway894345 7y agoThis is correct; that's what I intended to communicate.
- JDiculous 7y agoGreat article, and the same dynamic applies to all genders. I was listening to a podcast the other day where a founder said that the most successful people he knew (eg. entrepreneurs) all had the worst family lives - multiple marriages, bad or non-existent relationships with family, etc. Work and family is a trade-off, their is no way around it. One can live a balanced life and be moderately successful. But to be among the best, the most elite, something generally has to give. That's not to say that we can't reform the systems to not make it as "winner-take-all", sort of like how the author suggested.
- rudolph9 7y agoI wonder how often women in STEM have children with men who earn significantly less? I ask because my partner Is a software engineers. She plans on continuing to work and I plan on staying home with the kids. Practically speaking it doesn’t totally make sense since I currently earn more being a few years older in the same career. It’s just what we both have wanted since we found one another and we’re willing to make the life adjustments necessary to make it happen I can’t help wonder how often women partner with men with lower incomes. Obviously the physical toll of baring children tips the scale a little but given couple where the woman makes significantly more than her partner I would imagine the decision would be logical for her to continuing work and wonder what percentage of women leave stem in this particular subset of the group?
- rdiddly 7y agoTL;DR - It's babies.
- naiveprogrammer 7y agoI appreciate the author's piece but motherhood is not an alternative argument for why women leave STEM, it is THE argument. It is, in all likelihood, the strongest factor to influence women's decisions to leave the field. The evidence is getting overwhelming, just check the most recent publications by Harvard Professor Claudia Goldin (most recent: https://test.openicpsr.org/openicpsr/project/113672/version/V1/view https://test.openicpsr.org/openicpsr/project/113672/version/...) Sexism is real but its importance is far from being large. It is really tiresome to see the news regurgitating the talking point on wage gap without properly giving context. What is clear to me is that the wage gap as measured by the average earnings by gender (even drilled down by field) is very hard to be fixed given the obvious biological differences between males and females (in which motherhood reigns supreme). Women also need to be honest about their prospects, it is very hard to juggle a career and motherhood. You can't have your cake and eat it too. So there needs to be an honest confrontation on the trade offs of motherhood and having a career and the cope that comes with it.
- proc0 7y agoYes, this is what I was thinking. Feminism is ruining women by mistakenly telling them they want something that might make them unhappy. What do women gain by having 50% professional nuclear physicists or 50% coal miners?
- bArray 7y agoI think people have been hinting towards the point that it's generally maternity and not sexism that mostly creates the differences in career progression. Of course there was a time in history where sexism played a major role, but I think that in modern times this is mostly gone (although I know of recent cases). We can take several actions to balance the books, but the important point I would like to ask is: Do we really want to stop/de-incentivize intelligent women from having children and having an active role on raising them? Of course there are lots of compromises that can be made to balance the work-home life, but ultimately a decision does need to be made. Spending time with your children in those crucial fundamental years before pre-school is incredibly important and rewarding.
- howling 7y agoI think people are arguing that to be fair, time spent on raising children should be shared equally between father and mother.
- toasterlovin 7y agoTime spent raising children should be shared in a way that the parents mutually agree on. Society has no legitimate interest in which gender does the work, as long as it's a mutually agreed to arrangement that both parties are equally happy with (or, probably more accurately, equally least-unsatisfied with).
- badfrog 7y ago> Society has no legitimate interest in which gender does the work That's not really true. If all women chose to raise children instead of working, many products would have poorer design due to lack of diversity in ideas. And if 95% of women chose not to work, the 5% who want to work will have a harder time in many respects.
- toasterlovin 7y ago> And if 95% of women chose not to work, the 5% who want to work will have a harder time in many respects. Why should the preferences of the 5% override the preferences of the 95%? A widespread norm of two incomes per household makes it much harder for women to be homemakers and full time mothers (since single income households have to compete with dual income households for positional goods like housing).
- thrower123 7y agoI do find it interesting that there is so much focus on academia - it's probably natural when the the people that are talking and writing about this are so often academics. In business, one thing that I have seen a lot of people crash aground on a reef on is that working in professions that require STEM credentials is a night-and-day difference from the process that one goes through to acquire those credentials. I've known a lot of people that loved their computer science programs in university, and then found actually working as a programmer such a shock that they noped right out into something else.
- chadlavi 7y agoSo... it's not sexism, it's the structurally sexist way that child-rearing is handled? I mean, it's a more actionable level of detail, but it's still sexism, no? Just maybe more structural rather than at the level of individual hiring or advancing decisions?
- badfrog 7y agoYes, the author seems to have a very narrow (and incorrect) view of what sexism is.
- epicureanideal 7y agoI think a larger percentage of society would be willing to call this "structural gender-based inequality" rather than sexism, because most people including myself use the word "sexism" to refer to a belief that one sex is less capable or somehow worse than the other. Similarly, men live fewer years than women, and so receive less retirement benefits. This is a structural gender-correlated inequality (maybe gender-correlated is even better than gender-based) but I don't think many people would call it "sexism against men". They would just say "oh, yeah, that's odd... maybe we should adjust that now that you've brought it to our attention".
- badfrog 7y agoYour framing seems to suggest the entities that established the unequal structure are blameless, which I do not think is the case. The leave policies and overall working environments that most of us have came from the belief that men should be dedicated to work and women should stay at home. Whether the people who established these norms had malicious intent or not, they were incorrect and harmed society.
- lordnacho 7y agoOne thing that she touched on that I've thought a lot about recently is the age at which we have kids. My father passed away a couple of weeks ago, and I compare him to his brother. My uncle had his first kid 10 years younger than my dad, and he ended up with the fourth one being older than me. He's got 10 grandchildren, the oldest of which is an adult now. My dad's grandchildren will never know him in any real way. Since the funeral I've thought about this a lot. Our later-life relationships will be affected by the age at which we had kids. I'm sure this is in the minds of a lot of people in this economic age. There's a lot of "investing in your career" where the equation doesn't account for this. I wish we could have an economy where this was easier. Say you could have your kids early, in your 20s, yet still progress your career. Perhaps pay for it with working to an older age, which should be possible with some improved health outcomes. Along with a flexible education system that allowed you come in and out. And perhaps incentives for firms to let people in and out, instead of the constant career grind that requires people to constantly push. Some of the finance and legal tracks seem to be for people who are expected to die at 45, like some weird victorian dystopia.
- burlesona 7y agoI think about this a lot as well. My wife and I decided to have our first child at 30, which is fairly early compared to our peers. Economically it would have been better to wait, we’ve each had career opportunities we couldn’t take advantage of because of having children, and if somehow we could have waited until 40 I think we would have had an easier time economically. But, physically and emotionally, I wish we could have had kids at 22 or so. Of course we hadn’t even met so this is pure wishful thinking. But still. Raising a family is a real joy, but it’s also very physically demanding (even for men), and the younger you are the easier the physical aspect is. Also, we know a small number of people who had children very young, and now in their 40s their children are grown. It’s a really fascinating relationship, with somewhat more ability to relate to each other and a really cool ability to live life together. Especially when this is across generations, it’s amazing to have an extended family with three generations not just alive but still well. I have no idea how society could ever adjust to make something like that work out - I think it might be easier to “fix fertility” to give more people the option of starting a family in their 40s. But still, I wonder about it often.
- scarmig 7y agoOne tactical approach: a high achieving woman could prioritize finding a partner who is interested in deprioritizing his own career for the sake of supporting her and raising children. This is a strategy high achieving men have used for a long time. So, pursue men involved in "child friendly" careers. Nurses instead of doctors; teacher aides over academics; tax preparers over management consultants. Or even men who are passionate about the idea of being a stay at home dad.
- golemiprague 7y agoAnybody who is doing this is going to loose his woman or at least makes her resent him and loose any attraction to him. You can write stupid articles and researches and whatever, it is not going to change the basic nature of men and women. Women job is to bring children and raise them, men job is todo the rest and until biology changes in some magical way it is not going to change. Women are still mainly attracted to care taking and value transference jobs, they don't like stem and not very good with creating value, whether it is physical or theoretical jobs, how many women music bands do you know? Even art they don't create much. Whoever wrote the article didn't ask themselves why women doctors don't leave their jobs, it is also very hard and demanding, but they like what they do because it is care taking and care taking was always the traditional job of a woman. Modern thinking demand us to ignore those simple facts and just pretend that things are different, it is just a stupid phase that will eventually disappear like communism or any another stupid ideology
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI think hospital work is unsuitable for people with children. Strangers spilling their blood and guts all over the place; and the hours suck rotten eggs.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoThe dating marketplace is two-sided; one reason why high-achieving men use this strategy is because there are a lot of women in this niche competing for high-achieving men. There aren't nearly as many men in this niche competing for high-achieving women, likely in part because there are relatively fewer high-achieving women using this strategy. A big part of strategy in marketplaces is choosing something that has a lot of participation so that you can find enough counter-parties to make your strategy work. There's also a biological asymmetry in terms of age and fertility. A man who is single until age 45 and then gets a lot of economic success can marry a younger woman and have children.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dustinmoris 7y agoMaybe some people value spending time with their children and seeing them grow up more than chasing a stupid meaningless promotion at a mundane STEM job somewhere. If you have one child then you have only one chance in life to answer all their curious questions when they are 6 years old, only one chance in life to see them learn how to swim, etc. etc. Life is about collecting wonderful memories with the people who you love, not about maintaining some idiotic excel spreadsheets in an open plan office. Maybe we should measure how many women are happy with their life rather than measure how many of them have a certain job title in a certain field. If we can maximise the former then who gives a shit about the latter.
- falcor84 7y ago>Maybe we should measure how many women are happy with their life rather than measure how many of them have a certain job title in a certain field. If we can maximise the former then who gives a shit about the latter. Because if women don't participate in the industry, the men who do will continue building a world designed for men. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/feb/23/truth-world-built-for-men-car-crashes https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/feb/23/truth-w...
- dcole2929 7y agoA lot of people would argue, imo correctly, that this is just a different form of sexism. The idea that progressing in your career means sacrificing work/life balance and more importantly family could absolutely be construed as the end result of a sexist mind state that doesn't value motherhood and family rearing to the degree it should. Obviously this affect men who want to be present and active participants in their children's lives as well, but as the author points out in many cases the inflection point at which ones career can really take off also overlaps with prime childbearing years. There is a lot of pressure on woman to have families and in circumstances where their right and ability to both do that and progress in their careers isn't respected and protected we end up with the current system. One in which woman drop out of less flexible fields earlier, and even in them don't get promoted as fast as their male counterparts who don't need to bow out of the field for months at a time to have a child.
- knorker 7y agoIt's sexism that the more time and effort you put into your career the more you're progressing? I don't disagree with most you said, but if you weren't there then no amount of artificial thinking will compensate for that.
- tomohawk 7y ago> I would presume that if we made academia a more feasible place for a woman with a family to work, we could keep almost all of those 20% of leavers who leave to just stay at home... That one word 'just' speaks volumes. People grow up. People change. Perhaps they want a different challenge than what academic achievement can provide. Raising children is challenging, daunting, and rewarding.
- codingmess 7y agoIf 1 Billion was spent in 2011 to support and encourage minorities and women in STEM, it really suggests that some of that money should be poured into providing childcare rather than propaganda.
- daotoad 7y agoMy only quibble with this article is that the fact that there is a wall related to child bearing and rearing IS institutional sexism. It's just a different form of it than the "my coworkers constantly stare at my tits and don't take what I say seriously" variety. We've put women largely in charge of child rearing duties. Obviously, men aren't able to get pregnant and bear children. We are, however, perfectly capable of changing diapers, singing lullabies, and doing laundry. I'd bet that we would see the same kind of impediments to women rising to the tops of their professions in many demanding fields, fields where if you take too much time to have a life, you are considered broken and uninterested in excellence.
- theFeller00 7y agoFaggot alert
- jccalhoun 7y agoI agree. The article says "What if it isn't sexism?" and then goes on to describe institutional sexism.
- blub 7y agoThe absence of the significant additional support required for women to both have children and get tenure as a professor is not sexism. That support was never there in the first place and men don't get any support either, so there is no discrimination happening.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- proc0 7y agoWhy do we care that there are equal women and men again? Why does representation actually matter again? I would find it more exciting to see a field with no representation because I could make a greater impact! This whole ideology of having representation everywhere is very dumb and conformist.
- Nouser76 7y agoBecause diverse opinions lead to better end products. Having homogenized groups of people means you're leaving some viewpoints out, and those viewpoints have sometimes been extremely helpful for me as a software developer.
- proc0 7y agoSure, however this isn't false otherwise. Non-diverse opinions aren't bad by default, and ultimately the main concern here is thinking the opposite, that diverse opinions are always right.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoIt's an error to assume any opinion is always right. Ultimately institutional sex discrimination is counter-productive to human life, so you will generally see a higher quality of life, lower violence, better health outcomes, reduced chemical toxicity, in places where both sexes have equal social mobility.
- commandlinefan 7y agoMaybe (although it's hard to imagine how somebody's non-education related upbringing could lead them to optimize software, for example), but at what cost? The linked article is suggesting that it's going to cost billions of dollars (more!) to bring in these diverse opinions.
- pnako 7y agoYes I've observed that it's useful to have people like physicists or electrical engineers in a software development team, because they have a different perspective on things.
- Misdicorl 7y agoAcademic careers in STEM require almost exclusive focus on your career for the first two decades of pursuit. This is simply because that is what the competition does. My anecdata suggests women are less willing to allow a single aspect of their lives to entirely dominate over all others. Child bearing happens to be one of the bigger alternative endeavors, but it's not the only one. Supporting women (and men!) who want to pursue an academic career in STEM while raising a family is a laudable goal. I hope it is more effective than I expect it to be.
- tylermenezes 7y agoI think it's still a form of sexism to assume women are the ones who need to care for a child. That's something that very few diversity-in-STEM folks are really thinking about. Many years ago an ex-girlfriend, who works in STEM academia (and is otherwise a liberal, progressive feminist), expressed concerns similar to the author about having kids. When I brought up that it wasn't written in stone that she would need to be the primary caregiver, she said she'd never even thought of the alternative! (Anne-Marie Slaughter touched on this in a 2012 Atlantic article called "Why Women Still Can't Have It All" for anyone who's interested.)
- naasking 7y agoA woman would still need almost a year of special work consideration for the pregnancy, appointments, and post-birth recovery, even if they're not a primary care giver afterwards.
- tylermenezes 7y agoThat's a really small part of the problem. The article actually cites data from Italy, which already requires 5 months of maternity leave.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThat's per child. It's really not a small part of the problem.
- hyperdunc 7y agoWomen are more likely to want to be the primary caregiver to something that actually came out of them. It's biological and there's nothing sexist about it.
- tylermenezes 7y ago> it's biological "It's biology" has a long history of being used to justify everything from sexism to racism to genocide. Please provide a source for your claim (and for the implied claim that men do not have the same drive).
- vondur 7y agoI can’t speak for women, but the pay for science degrees kinda sucks. I’m guessing it would make sense to leave to another field that pays better. My wife was a bio major and her first real job was selling HPLC columns. She ended up not liking sales so pivoted into teaching where the pay is decent.
- ianai 7y agoCorporate America largely sucks. Family building and wealth are being attacked at many levels. I just wanted to add that.
- iron0013 7y agoI’d love to be wrong, but my gut feeling is that a huge proportion of HN readers are men—probably even a larger proportion than in the tech industry in general. It makes it feel kinda weird when these articles the gist of which are “women are wrong about women’s issues” come up. That applies equally to the “all men’s problems are women’s fault” articles that seem to be just as popular around here.
- trowaway54321 7y agoI was discussing this not long ago and hypothesized that we have swung the pendulum so far in encouraging women into STEM that they feel pressured into the decision, ultimately leading many of them to go down a path in which they have no interest.
- choeger 7y agoAs a male that dropped out of the academic career path I can absolutely confirm that the author has a point. I made the conscious decision not to attempt to become a professor because it would be nearly impossible for my wife to have a qualified career at the same time due to the required flexibility. Add children to the mix and you are pretty much confined to a single-career family. Which would be arguable if it wasn't for the extremely high risk if that particular career path.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoMy dad spent almost all of my waking childhood at work and I still feel really sad and hurt about that. I suspect everyone has similar repressed resentment towards their providers, and professionals should really consider that when they're planning their families.
- pencilcode 7y agoI remember seeing, I think in Netflix’s Explained series, that the salary differences between men and women were the same as the differences between women with children and women within children, making raising children the primary cause for the average salary disparities. This article rings true with that.
- toohotatopic 7y agoHow about the variance difference: men and women are equally intelligent on average. However, the variance is different so that there are more stupid men but also more intelligent men. Could the drop-out rate simply reflect the higher share of men who are able to fulfill the functions that are required at those higher positions?
- azangru 7y agoNot related to the thesis of the post, but this: > And yet, if you ask leading women researchers like Nobel Laureate in Physics 2018, Professor Donna Strickland, or Canada Research Chair in Advanced Functional Materials (Chemistry), Professor Eugenia Kumacheva, they say that sexism was not a barrier in their careers. — is such a bizarre argument to make. How can one conclude anything about sexism by asking leading women researchers whether whether it has been a barrier in their careers. The very fact that they’ve achieved leading positions says that it wasn’t; it says absolutely nothing of whether it was for those who have left. _(I am not claiming anything about sexism; I was simply mystified by this paragraph)_
- yellowbeard 7y agoGood point, this seems like a case of survivorship bias. However, I think it does seem to show some sort of upper bound on the level and pervasiveness of sexism? That it's at least _possible_ for women to achieve at the highest level in these fields means sexism didn't stop everyone.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoBut these women did not experience sexism. Of course it wouldn't stop them.
- herostratus101 7y agoHigh IQ women completely exiting the gene pool is pretty bad for the species.
- m0zg 7y agoThe fundamental unaddressed issue in our society is that having children is treated as something that's optional, a luxury, and even though the society fundamentally depends on its constituents procreating, we continue to pretend that having children is not a necessary part of one's life. Which is true individually, but not true on the macro level. Anecdotally, observing my own family and that of my (mostly well-off STEM) social circle, I can tell you that this is when women really take a hit career-wise. What's less obvious in the graphs is that many of them take it deliberately, and _choose_ to focus on things other than career. This, ironically, puts pressure on men to provide, and compete in the workplace. I know it put pressure on me like you wouldn't believe - we "settled", got a mortgage, monthly expenses went through the roof. I've roughly tripled my earnings between the time my son was born and his 10th birthday. It came at a tremendous personal cost - I basically didn't have a life for a decade, and our marriage nearly fell apart. I like where we are today, though, thanks to all that effort. My wife took a couple of years off work, and did not aim for a quick career progression afterwards, preferring lower stress and more family time. Was my career progression done at the expense of someone less motivated at work? Quite likely, yes. Was it worth it to my family? It was, although there were many times when I was in doubt about that. This is something the workforce percentage graphs do not communicate at all.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoThere is no explicitly agreed upon objective function for humanity. However there is kind of a default one baked into our DNA and it's the desire to reproduce and see our offspring reproduce. Modern society is conflicted however because enlightenment philosophy, which is baked into everything, as well as some Eastern traditions teaches us that knowledge or enlightenment is the highest virtue. So when it comes to agreeing on how to align society from the perspective of governance, time allocation, what to promote socially etc.. we have this existential crisis where people try to saddle the fence between reproduction (aka "family") and enlightenment style "progress."
- mirimir 7y agoI've known a few women who had kids very young, and didn't get serious professionally until their kids were in school. But the problem is that they ended up being single parents, at least for a while.
- xerxex 7y agoHer argument just shows how entrenched sexism runs in our society. Anecdotal evidence/sample size one story: My wife has a doctorate in chemistry and 2 postdocs under her belt, but she had to leave her field purely due to sexism she encountered during her post docs. The PI (her boss) was quite abusive, outright sexist and a horrible racist. My wife wanted to move on to industry jobs but her wouldn't let her leave. So he kept giving bad references. We didn't know about this until after my wife looked into why she got rejected.
- DreamScatter 7y agoAcademia is generally abusive, regardless of whether you are male or female.
- xerxex 7y agoThat's very true...
- api 7y agoCould people stop using Medium? I refuse to sign up and give them any data since they're basically an unpaid magazine.
- godelzilla 7y agoPretty sure that the systemic bias against motherhood is a crucial part of sexism, rather than an alternative explanation.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThe author is missing the forest for the trees. She argues that a specific kind of sexism (harrassment) is not sufficient to explain why so many women are forced out of their careers in STEM academia. She argues that the real reason is that those women want to start a family and they can't do both at once. She herself is considering leaving academia to start a family (she wants to have two or three children). Yet she never for a moment stops to wonder why it is that a woman like her has to make a choice between family and career, why that is a choice that so many women have to make and why it is a choice that so few men have to make. The answer to all that is sexism, of course, the kind of sexism that the author is so used to she doesn't even consider it sexism anymore, just the normal order of things. Yes, of course a young, talented researcher _has_ to leave academia to raise her kids. Because she's a woman. And that's what happens to women. That is sexism. It is clear sexism, it is classic sexism and it will not go away by pretending that it is not. And I agree very much with the author that it is the real reason behind the constant stream of promising female researchers leaving STEM academia.
- deyouz 7y agoI completely agree with you. I just wanted to comment to tell you that you are absolutely right.
- wilg 7y agoI agree with you. However, I think slicing up the various types of sexism in the way the author does is tactically useful for solving the issue in the fastest possible way.
- kendallpark 7y agoAgreed. How many times have you heard a man say he had to choose between his career and having kids? The fact that it is predominantly women who feel they have to choose between children and career IS institutional sexism. We say we've achieved "equal opportunity" when women are allowed to participate in career fields that had originally evolved around the male workforce. Is that parity? That women can succeed in certain industries as long as they are like men in that they never become pregnant? Jobs and industries designed by women for a female workforce would look a lot different. We need to--as much as we are able--change societal expectations, workforce expectations, and the way jobs are structured so that women are not at a disadvantage. These changes can also benefit men (eg, equal parental leave and other policies that it more affordable and feasible for people to have children). It hurts both sexes when workplaces are biased towards this archetype of a male breadwinner that is content putting in long hours away from his family. You could view this as anti-family bias, which, due to society and biology, disproportionately affects women.
- HammockWarrior 7y agoSeems like much of the problem could be solved by just having the working world chill the f' out for women and for men. For example, a 32 hour workweek along with generous paid parental leaves. Everyone should have time for a life outside of work, not just women of childbearing age. Also, The whole idea of having young people work like dogs in order to have a shot at making partner, or gaining tenure, or gaining a medical degree is both outdated and ageist.
- barry-cotter 7y agoShorter workweeks would unavoidably lead to lower economic growth. People get better at things the the more they do them and the more hours they work the more they get done. The marginal value of an extra hour worked only turns negative around 60 hours. No one is forcing people to work that hard to gain money and social status. They do it to themselves.
- virtuous_signal 7y ago32 hour workweeks might work but there will always be the issue of defection. If a company allows employees to take unlimited leave, then worker A who avails him/herself of it, will be at a disadvantage to worker B who keeps working like a dog, when it comes time for promotions. If company A mandates 32 hour workweeks, then they will eventually lose out to their competitor company B who mandates 40 hours (or more informally). If country A says ALL companies must have <=32 hour workweeks, then country B, with no such law, will become more productive. And on and on. There will always be some less enlightened competitor to take advantage -- and do we really think America is ready to stop being #1?
- chadcmulligan 7y agoYou can use tariffs to correct the imbalance, although they seem a dirty word until recently
- satyrnein 7y agoWouldn't these concerns apply just as well to minimum wage laws, OSHA regulations, environmental protections, etc?
- epicgiga 7y agoMaybe they're just not as into it? Does anyone ever stop to consider that? Maybe women are doing what's best for themselves, sticking to things they like, and screw your arrogant western leftist ideas of what YOU think they should do? Let's just pretend women like shoes and handbags more and men like engines and guns more just for purely random reasons. Despite global perpetuity. Everywhere ever. Let's just pretend engineers and nurses is inflicted, not chosen, despite what ultra high gender equality Scandinavia says. Let's all pretend that only the North Koreans are brainwashed and that only they care little for facts and human flourishing. Let's all just slosh in wierd western religious fervour. Or actually, how about no, and hop on a plane to the civilised world.
- alexithym 7y agoThis was an unnecessarily aggressive comment, and the tone with which it was made detracts greatly from the intended message.
- epicgiga 7y agoFair, but calmly worded reason hasn't budged these bunch or their regime for decades, so "repeating the experiment" etc
- satyrnein 7y agoThe impression you got from the article was that author just isn't into STEM? If you want to make an argument based on women's preferences, you might consider a closer reading of what they're saying.
- jariel 7y agoThe fundamental differentiator between early and late stage in those graphs is that there are far fewer positions as time moves on, in the 'higher' cohorts. It's not people just graduate along the path from A to Z - it's viciously competitive. Issues of maternity et. al. I think are just one important artefact of the nature of competition which for whatever reason I think is still going to favour men. Risk taking, hubris, aggression, physical endurance, combativeness, a certain kind if confidence, social expectations, possibly even the acceptance of those things by others - these things mean a lot at those later stages.
- adjkant 7y agoI find it quite interesting that an article focusing on raising children versus careers uses the word "father" or "man" exactly zero times.
- belorn 7y agoWhy not look at how we are all similar rather than a unique attribute to explain the leaky pipe? The Swedish government order a study a few years ago in order to explain why the teacher profession are so gender segregated. The study found that initially the applications are almost 50/50 men and women, but then every year men start to leave. Once graduated and starting to work, every year men are a few times more likely to leave the profession than women. They even called it a leaky pipe. They had multiple explanation in order to explain it, like how more academic focus rather than pedagogic helps retain men, and how higher salaries might help, and they also did similar to this study and asked the men who left why they did so. A lot of answers were that the profession did not fit their life, they felt the environment to be alien and uncomfortable, and they didn't feel like they fit in the work culture. What the study also found was that the remaining male teacher that did stay tended to enter specialties such as PE and STEM subject, and away from subjects like langue and social studies. Many who left did so for similar profession outside of the education system such as sport. So here we have women and men, both being described as a leaky pipe, both leaving at similar rates, both describing similar reasons for leaving, both finding specialties where they are not a minority. Could there be a common theory rather than two separate theories to explain this? And the government study had such suggestion. There is research that is now about 50 years old that observed that people who are in an environment as a minority does not feel same confidence in themselves as those being part of the majority. When faced with a failure such as a missed exam, and making a decision to continue, being part of a majority increase the probability of the person continuing. The government study suggested that if you apply this theory over the time frame of a teacher career from the point of student to being a long term employee, what you get is a leaky pipe. It also suggested the solution that mentor ship programs helps in reducing this. I also recall that a while back a women in IT imitative that said that of all their work, what had actually produced results was their mentor program. Seems like a pretty good evidence to me, and as a universal theory it seems pretty good explanation to explain the situation for both men and women.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoI have always been skeptical of the need for the intense career paths in management, law, medicine, finance, and academics. I totally understand the need to put in hours to become an expert, but a lot of it seems gratuitous. I wouldn't call it hazing. I think these careers are structured as championship systems, where the winner takes all, for the sake of the winner. Winner takes all is a very male attitude, and I think it gets back to men being more expendable because their sexual refractory period is orders of magnitude shorter than women's. But does it make sense? Does the 80th hour on the ward as a resident make you a better doctor? Does the fifth publication make you a better professor? Does another fifteen minutes of billable time make you a better lawyer? I don't think they do. I think these careers are needlessly intense and stupidly so. I contemplated going down a couple of those paths and recoiled because it seemed so unnecessary and gratuitous, and I didn't want to spin my wheels fitting into a nonsensical system.
- steelframe 7y agoWhen I was an engineering manager at one tech company 6 years ago, I fought like hell to get a woman who had a CS Ph.D. to join my team, and I somehow pulled that off. Her husband also had a CS degree (B.S. or M.S., not recall which) and worked for another tech company. Every time there was a contractor that they needed to have someone at the house for, or every time their kid got sick and/or couldn't go to school, guess which of the two of them always took the time off work to handle it? Now I had no insight into their family dynamics, and it felt it wasn't my place to pry. But over dozens of "time off" incidents through several years, it was very clear to me that my female employee was the "default caretaker" for anything relating to the house or the child that came up. This was despite the fact that she had a higher-paying position than what he had (based on what I can now see on levels.fyi).
- nhumrich 7y agoWhile you are very likely correct, your perception could also be biased. If the father took time, you wouldn't know about it. So from your point of view, it was always her, but it could have also been only half the time.
- throw7 7y agoDaycare is not the answer. Not even "High Quality Daycare" (whatever that means?) is something to be proud of???... unless by "high quality daycare" you mean a personal nursery next to your executive office. High quality parenting is the goal. We could provide adequate time off for anyone wanting to spend their time parenting THEIR child. Will they lose their job? No. Will they not get a raise or promotion? Yes.
- pc2g4d 7y agoI'm just not sure how upset to be that there is still some difference in typical roles between men and women. It may be a norm for women to be more likely to be the primary caregiver for young children, but is that bad or wrong? It may even be a biological drive for all I know. Is 50/50 representation at all levels of all fields really the goal we want to shoot for?
- alfor 7y agoThose are very high status, high demand 'job', you need a lot so sacrifices to achieve tenure professor, and I think they are not compatible with family raising for most people. Why, because you are competing with the best people that are willing to sacrifice life balance, family, leisure time, etc. But the thing is, it's a choice, no one is forced to go into super high status occupations. Those that choose so must be very bright and completely dedicated to one thing. I think most women know or realise later on that this level of competition is insane, and that's why they quit and find something that is not as high status, but is more enjoyable. A very small percentage of men are willing to ditch everything else to be at the top, some get there, most don't, most women find out that it's not worth it. Oh, and I think it's crucial for children to bond with their mother and skipping this and putting them in daycare early is not in their best interest. I also think that motherhood is more valuable than most engineering job or paper publishing.
- teatree 7y agoCurious, by this logic would 2 Heterosexual partners as parents make better parents than 2 homosexual partners ?
- jstewartmobile 7y agoBrand-new planes that crash, bridges that fall on the first day, the subordination of computing to advertising and surveillance, iatrogenics, plastics/xenoestrogens, environmental destruction, species extinction, paper-upon-paper of non-reproducible p-hacked astroturfing, and this crazy over-privileged broad is going to whine technocratically over how her gender isn't proportionally represented in this systematic destruction of nature, beauty, and civilization? Break out the tiny violins.
- bookAlot 7y agoThey aren't and weren"t qualified nor were they prepared to really and actually INVENT the new cure and/or resolution. They want timid results and a hasty resolution. They lucked out that China was still just in the middle of rehearsing their squash for results in office but they fucked up when they crossed me. I got my my 7billion return in sentiment, I require no women in STEM and we have a reason to exist since we were able to scientifically allow them to do that and treat the problem as them being it. Good night you. America! And Japan! Hooray Britain!
- peteretep 7y agoSolution: compulsory paternity leave for male academics.
- rolltiide 7y agoI like how she "catches readers up" on women's biology. Since she went out of her way to do that I think this would be further supported by why women want to bear children. Or thoughts and perspectives from the women that do not have children. The article does a good job of identifying the funnel. It reiterates what we already know about society: women are aware of their biological clock and people desire to make children. But it does make an assumption that the women that stay in the funnel are childless victims, or at least portrays them that way. "Meanwhile in the Netherlands, woe!" This is hyperbole, but barely. It is okay to assume an even distribution of wants and desires as the non-STEM women, but what if there isn't? Let's get some perspectives. Additionally, freezing eggs, surrogacy, and adoption are options followed by additional help with nannies and au pair, costly options which could be supported and subsidized by the very arguments that this article is making. I think the case would be even stronger if we added the perspective from the child free women, along with a perspective about cultural tweaks that women could also consider. Distinct from only pointing out what organizations do not do to address the maternal wall.
- billfruit 7y agoPerhaps I am feeling more like this an exclusively American problem than a universal one. For example I suggest to study the situation in India. Many factors are at play here: * Most Indians tend to marry young and have kids before 30. * most families have either one or two kids only. * Parents support their children for life, i.e, grandparents have a major role in supporting the care and rearing of kids. * Daycare isn't expensive. * Government mandated maternity leave with full pay and no loss of seniority.
- shawndrost 7y ago(The "maternal wall" is sexism. If it impacted men, academia would not be shaped liked this. This is not to detract from the article, which is awesome.)
- tensionhead 7y agoThis 'scissor diagrams' are a gross misrepresentation of what is really going on in academia. It conveys the the misleading message that 'the pipeline' is only leaking for female STEM aspirants. In fact, if you start with 100 woman and 100 men, so 200 STEM students in total, only around 1-5 people will make it to the end of these scissor diagrams (professorship and alike). Let's assume a very strong imbalance, say we have 4 man and 1 woman making it (80/20). That means the drop out rate (or 'leakiness') is 96% for men and 99% for woman! So yes, in this case it is 4 times as likely for a man to become professor compared to a woman. However, it's still very unlikely (4%) for an individual man to succeed and hence the majority of men also drop out of STEM academia.
- knorker 7y ago"alternative"? Thanks for the better and more specific data, but didn't we already know this? Men and women also pair up with the man being older. So this isn't going away until the government forces equal-age mating.
- Jemm 7y agoone of the aspects of being bullied, and sexism is a form of bullying, is the the bullied person is humiliated, made to doubt their own capabilities and made to fear repercussions. The result being that women leave and cite personal reasons for, their departure. Surveys like this are not necessarily honest as the participants are not necessarily being honest.
- bakerrac 7y agoIt is my opinion that women should marry men who support their careers, maybe that means they find a guy less educated then they are.
- RobKohr 7y agoThis is a societal problem of promoting career instead of family, and delaying parenthood. In your early 20s, your time is worth so little compared to your later career, and your parents are young enough to be more involved. Having children while being an undergraduate is better than when you have an advanced career, substantial earnings, and little support from parents. The best time to have kids is when you are getting your undergrad degree.