21 ms·
USB4 Specification
- holy_city 7y agoThe Serial Time Link Protocol (STLP) looks really cool to me - I've thought for awhile that the next-gen in audio gear would be more modular front ends that sit on top consumer protocols, which is where things are moving in broadcast/commercial audio installations today. I can imagine a whole host of consumer and professional devices that solve real problems at lower costs than we can today. Really interesting stuff. edit: one weirdness, STLP has a recommended packet rate of 62.5kHz (actual quote "A Router shall periodically transmit a Serial Time Link Packet on TMU_CLK_OUT. The period between transmissions is implementation specific, but it is recommended that a Router transmit a Serial Time Link Packet every 16 μs"). If the only application domain (besides compliance testing) is audio, how did they arrive at that recommended rate, where it is rather different from standard sample rates (44.1k/88.2k and multiples of 8kHz)? I'm not sure how that affects clock synchronization.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoUSB already supports isochronous transfers for audio.
- MBCook 7y agoGood. USB3 is still a mess, better make a new one before that gets sorted out.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoUSB4 is basically Thunderbolt 3, i.e. USB3.x + PCIe + DisplayPort. See the diagram in the linked spec, "Figure 2-1 USB4/USB3.2 Dual Bus System Architecture"
- djsumdog 7y agoI remember hearing that on .. Dave2D I think? Or Linus Tech Tips .. one of them said USB4 is Thunderbolt 3. I assumed the standards were just combining and the two would be equivalent protocols, but I assume that's not true then? Does USB4 basically just add PCIe onto the USB bus? How will that work with AMD board that still don't officially have Thunderbolt/PCI Hotplug support?
- AceJohnny2 7y ago> Does USB4 basically just add PCIe onto the USB bus? Yes. Which is kinda what Thunderbolt 3 does (except encapsulated in the TB packet format, not USB). The silicon world has been gradually converging on its Serializer-Deserializer/PHY technology. I don't know quite the family history, but I believe the PCIe PHY is very similar to USB3 which is identical to Thunderbolt 3. Since the link layer was the same, it was then "just" a matter of protocol design to make everything just use the same link. And that's how you got Thunderbolt 3 / USB 4.
- tarheelredsox 7y agoPCIe uses different rates than USB, but both at their basics use NRZ (Non-Return to Zero) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-return-to-zero https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-return-to-zero. The bigger differences are in the channels they target. The channels characteristics drive the complexity of the signal processing circuitry required (eg Power and Cost) in the PHY devices. Hope that adds a bit of clarity to your PHY question.
- kalleboo 7y ago> How will that work with AMD board that still don't officially have Thunderbolt/PCI Hotplug support? They will have to add it. It will be easier now that Thunderbolt doesn't have to be licensed from Intel.
- chx 7y agoNot... quite. Thunderbolt 3 did not carry USB 3.x over its bus, it's just PCIe and DP signals. All the Intel TB3 controller chips used in enclosures have a PCIe switch and a USB root hub attached to that. This switch was ... not flawless ... to be diplomatic. It was utter shit, to be less politicaly correct. TB3 eGPUs famously struggled with their occassionally lagging and hiccuping USB ports so much so that the Visiontek Mini and the Razer 2 has two TB3 controllers to avoid this mess with the second TB3 controller solely providing the USB 3 root hub and almost all other eGPUs just gave up on them. USB 4 will carry 10gbps USB multiplexed with PCI Express and DisplayPort, native USB instead of hotplugged controller. Simpler.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoThanks for the correction!
- kryogen1c 7y agoI know youre being funny, but that seems like a pretty good option. USB3 did its best to remove the U from USB. Starting over wouldnt bother me at all. The only usbc devices i have is a phone, and new phones come with new cables. Lets abandon this monstrosity and move on.
- wlesieutre 7y ago>"Once the specifications are released, there will be a new round of confusion," the source told TechRepublic. "It's going to be USB4, but you have to qualify what USB4 means, because there are different grades. USB4, by definition, has to be [at least] Gen 2×2, so it will give you 10 Gbps by 2, that's 20 Gbps. There's going to be USB4 Gen 3×2, which is 20 Gbps per lane. 20 by 2 will give you 40 Gbps." https://www.techrepublic.com/article/usb-if-to-continue-confusing-name-scheme-with-usb4-gen-3x2/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/usb-if-to-continue-conf... They really needed to take a page from the WiFi Alliance on the branding. But no, USB4 Gen 3x2. Awesome.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 7y agoPlease father Christmas may I just have one present? A standard that is actually standardized in practice. To this day I still don't know exactly how to buy a cable for my raspberry pi 4s. (Yes more a USB c than USB 3 issue but you get my point - a standard that isn't standardized fails at it's raison d'etre)
- AceJohnny2 7y agoThat's also because the RasPi 4 failed to implement their connector according to the standard. [1] Now, why that passed muster is a valid question. [1] https://medium.com/@leung.benson/how-to-design-a-proper-usb-c-power-sink-hint-not-the-way-raspberry-pi-4-did-it-f470d7a5910 https://medium.com/@leung.benson/how-to-design-a-proper-usb-...
- jay_kyburz 7y agoStandards bodies need to sue to protect their standard. If a device does not adhere to the full standard, they should not be able to call it USB or use any of logos or imagery.
- dbuder 7y agoYou have to pass a test and pay to write USB on it, so I find the Pi4 thing confusing on many levels, PoE and usbC were both botched implementations and there are active communities associated with Rasp Pi full of people who could have done a proper job.
- MikusR 7y agoRaspberry pi foundation being too cheap to buy two resistors in place of one is not a problem with standard.
- ergothus 7y agoI'm not qualified to say anything about the Pi OR USB, but I've definitely gotten the impression that USB has a standardization problem (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20443765 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20443765 for some convincing-to-me material) If that's wrong, can you clarify?
- Zhenya 7y agoSo basically, they are attempting to redo the mess that is 3.x very cool. "When configured over a USB Type-C® connector interface, USB4 functionally replaces USB 3.2 while retaining USB 2.0 bus operating in parallel. Enhanced SuperSpeed USB, as defined in USB 3.2, remains the fundamental architecture for USB data transfer on a USB4 Fabric"
- AceJohnny2 7y agoApple Inc. Hewlett-Packard Inc. Intel Corporation Microsoft Corporation Renesas Corporation STMicroelectronics Texas Instruments Honestly, I'm a bit surprised at how short this list of authors(?) on such a wide-impact standard is. Where are other silicon designers? Where's Synopsys, or Mentor Graphics (who often provide the Hard IP used by chip designers)? Where's Qualcomm or Samsung? What about Google, for Android? Edit: actually reading a bit further to the "Acknowledgement of Technical Contribution", this is the list of promoter companies. The contributors list is way longer and includes everyone you'd expect.
- Zhenya 7y agoLook further down. You showed just the promoters list, there is a much longer contributors list. Google and Samsung are both there.
- perlgeek 7y agoAs a consumer, can I please have a standard where I don't have to chase a new version every few years? I know that many are backwards compatible, but they aren't forward compatible -- my MicroUSB cables don't help at all with USB-C, and type A and B connectors are still around. By the time all of my micro USB devices have disappeared from my household, I'm sure a new thing will have emerged that's incompatible with USB-C, and so I'll still have to have several different cables around.
- Jonnax 7y agoType C is the intended replacement for Micro, A and B.
- jbverschoor 7y agoNo... usb-c is just a connector
- function_seven 7y agoMicro, A, and B, are also just connectors.
- bsamuels 7y agothen they should stop including USB C to USB C cables in every new phone I buy
- zamadatix 7y agoIt's the intended replacement, why would they stop including it in new purchases?
- NullPrefix 7y agoI think OP tried to argue that if USB-C is just a replacement for Micro and Mini then why USB-A -> USB-Micro is replaced with USB-C -> USB-C instead of USB-A -> USB-C. This proves that USB-C is a replacement not only for Mini and Micro, but for -A too.
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoReading through this, I'm left unable to see the underlying forces. None of the people working on this spec are idiots, so how did they arrive here? What are the forces and unstated requirements behind the scenes that I don't understand that have led to a USB4 spec with this many potential flavors and absurd naming conventions to express them? Is it something about cost? Or patents? Or some random company who won't budge on something but needs to be included?
- AceJohnny2 7y agoI suspect the underlying force is "A Committee".
- mtgx 7y agoWith Type-C and USB 3 they obviously tried to cater to everyone's mother and their dog from the USB consortium. 99.99% of consumers will never know what speed their type-c cable will have or what type of connections it actually supports. And then the whole fiasco with USB 3.1 and 3.1 gen 2 and 3.2 or whatever that whole mess was. That was beyond idiotic - it was just pure corruption. The group obviously worked with the OEMs so they can both lie to customers about getting a "next-gen" connection. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/usb-3-2-is-going-to-make-the-current-usb-branding-even-worse/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/usb-3-2-is-going-to-...
- throwaway156503 7y ago> None of the people working on this spec are idiots There are a lot of very smart people in the world that lose sight of simple concepts and their value, however.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoI've witnessed some Standards negotiation in a previous job, involving the Khronos OpenMAX standard (which is DirectShow/GStreamer for mixed HW/SW multimedia codecs). My company and another had opposing solutions to a problem, which made opposite tradeoffs and opposite implementations (ours worked better for a more HW-focused solution, theirs for a more SW-focused solution) How does one choose? In the end, it's backroom negotiation, diplomacy, and compromise. In other words, politics.
- andrekandre 7y agoprobably really dumb question with a really obvious answer that i don’t see, but... why not have a packetized protocol like ip over the cable and devices just go over that? wouldnt things like enumeration, identification, connect/disconnect, interleaving protocols and encryption be much simpler since it’s a known domain? wouldn’t that be more “universal” than cramming usb2, usb super speed, pci-e, displayport (which afaicr also wraps a few things) etc over a single cable? am i missing something or is this just a cost issue...? [edit] slightly answering my own question: pci-e is a packetized protocol... so i guess cramming everything in is more backwards compatibility to get all the other connectors subsumed into a single cable...?
- shawnz 7y agoUSB is packetized. But without those seperate modes of operation, every single adapter would need a microcontroller in it.
- andrekandre 7y agoi see, makes more sense then... thanks!
- nightfly 7y agoIs that really a problem?
- shawnz 7y agoImagine a world where the reliability of your devices significantly depends on how much you paid for your USB 3->4 adapter. Is that a better situation than what we have today?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt already does in terms of USB cables. Buy a wrong cable, and your device won't charge, or won't charge fast enough, or won't communicate. And you can't tell the good/correct cable from the bad ones visually. The standard can have any number of optional modes to be implemented by devices. I don't care. What I want is for it to have one cable type. Because it's kind of a point of an universal port that people will use cables from one device with another.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoSo USB 4 is basically Thunderbolt 3, got it. (per Fig 2-1 "USB4/USB3.2 Dual Bus System Architecture") Edit: with Gen3 speeds (20Gbs/link) and with optional Dual-Lane Bonding for increased bandwidth.
- aloknnikhil 7y agoWhy would they attach this as a zip file? Makes reading on an iPhone impossible (CORRECTION: cumbersome) EDIT: Learnt something new. But the spec on an HTML page would be a lot more convenient than having to install more apps just to read this document.
- OJFord 7y agoIs it truly impossible? No fs access has been one of the things stopping me becoming an iOS user, I thought it'd make some things harder, but I didn't realise something so regular seeming (as in I don't have to be a tech nerd to want to open a .zip) would not be possible.
- theclaw 7y agoYou can save downloads to the Files app, which then has folders for all the storage apps you have installed, like dropbox or icloud or whatever. You can also save to the device local storage, but for some reason only in folders created by other apps.
- jedieaston 7y agoiOS 13 allows you to store any file on your iPhone and unzip/zip it, without a certain application.
- tinus_hn 7y agoIt is of course not impossible, there are unzip apps for iPhone. It’s just a hassle. Normal people typically don’t want to open zip files on an iPhone and Apple isn’t in the ‘can open any file’ market. They expect others to provide files their devices do open and mostly that strategy works.
- theclaw 7y agoSave it to Files, tap ‘preview content’ then swipe over to the second document.
- pkaye 7y ago
- aetherspawn 7y agoWhy not standardise on USB-C and just make -C with the 2 added Thunderbolt pins (ala Apple) the norm? Why more specs
- ghostly_s 7y agoHuh? Apple does not sell any devices with "2 added Thunderbolt pins".
- aetherspawn 7y agoYes they do, USB-C cables with Thunderbolt is different from regular USB-C on account of the 2 data pins added. So none of the USB-C cables I bought would enable me to use external monitors with my hardware because it supported 2 displays over TB only. But the connectors aren’t even keyed so it’s just an irritating mess to keep track of what is and isn’t. However it would be a great system if TB over USB-C was the default and only probably.
- chx 7y agoYou are mistaken. Thunderbolt alternate mode does not require any additional pins, it does require special cabling though. Most Thunderbolt cables are not capable of any 5-10(-20) gbps USB but they are still using the exact same connector. USB 4 will change this in that Thunderbolt cables will now be compatible with everything. The only thing you possibly could think of is VirtualLink which repurposed the existing USB 2.0 pins for two more high speed lanes but even that is using the exact same physical connector.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoUSB-C is not a protocol. It's just a connector spec.
- Dunedan 7y agoWhen the USB-IF announced that they're going to incorporate Thunderbolt into USB4 I already worried that this might further complicate USB hardware and software. Turns out: My worst nightmares just became true. We now have running USB over Thunderbolt. I don't even know where to start facepalming about this clusterfuck. Take DisplayPort for example: Up to now we had the DisplayPort alternate mode for USB-C. That just worked for most devices with USB-C. Now we also have the tunneling of DisplayPort over Thunderbolt (as Thunderbolt-enabled Macs offer since Apple introduced Thunderbolt in its devices and which they use when connecting to Thunderbolt-enabled monitors). Both methods seem to be optional for USB now, so in future a host and a peripheral device might support "DisplayPort over USB", but while one might only supports the USB-C DisplayPort alternate mode, the other one might only support DisplayPort tunnels over USB4, causing them not to be able to talk DisplayPort to each other. I guess I'm going to facepalm for a few hours now, while I read the specification in more detail.
- Dunedan 7y ago> A USB4 host and USB4 peripheral device may optionally support TBT3 -Compatability. That sounds good from an implementors point of view, but offers another area of possible incompatibilities for connecting USB4 and Thunderbolt 3 devices. Imagine both devices support tunneling DisplayPort signals, but the USB4 device doesn't support the Thunderbolt 3 compatibility layer: As in the example before they won't be able to establish a DisplayPort connection, while other USB4 devices, which offer Thunderbolt 3 compatibility might.
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoHow is this better than VGA again?
- user5994461 7y agoVGA caps at 2048 pixel wide if we are to believe a quick google search and the fidelity of the image may vary depending on the cable and graphic card in use.
- 7y ago
- pvorb 7y agoWhy does USB have two seemingly unrelated versioning schemes? There's USB 1, 2, 3 and now 4 as well as Type A, B and C. This mess looks like manufacturers wanted to create a way to trick the average customer into buying the wrong cable or adapter, whereas initially the reason for creating USB was to increase compatibility.
- msbarnett 7y ago> Why does USB have two seemingly unrelated versioning schemes? There's USB 1, 2, 3 and now 4 as well as Type A, B and C. They decoupled the standards for the protocol and the connector. "USB C" is just a port/connector shape -- there's no guarantee that any cable or port that is USB C shaped supports any version of USB-the-protocol. This is the case with eg) dedicated Thunderbolt 3 ports and cables. It's every bit as silly and confusing as it sounds in practice.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzo38computer 7y agoI think USB is terrible. One problem is that USB addressing is not by the physical port that it is connected to (among other things, this is a security problem, but there are many other problems with this too); does USB4 correct that? Another problem is how vendor codes and that stuff is work; it should instead be identified by protocol type, and to allow the user to override the protocol type with the operating system functions. There is other stuff is better, such as RS-232, and Compact Flash (unfortunately it lacks a write protect switch; SD has it but only the full size SD cards and not the smaller size; SD card has other problems though), and then also add some of my own specifications too, such as IMIDI and Digi-RGB, and you can have separate ports for each of these four thing.
- h2odragon 7y ago"rs232 is better" only if you ignore the incredible mess of horror that has been committed under the name "rs232". What we have today is only the most sensible bits that survived 40+ years of ablation in the real world. Even now its not a great situation: what voltages will your two chips of different types be able to be use for their "rs232" conversation? TTL? will you need +/-12v? 15v?
- zbraniecki 7y agoWill this bring higher PD? A lot of laptops require 100W-130W of power (see, Lenovo X1E or Dell 7590), while the highest PD I've seen from usb is the Apple charger for 86W. I know Dell produces proprietary 130W usb-c charger, but I'm wondering if usb4 will help make it a standard.
- cesarb 7y agoThis specification is only about the data bus, not the power bus, since they're separate in USB-C. So no, this will not bring higher power (and higher power won't need to wait for a future USB-5 standard).
- zbraniecki 7y agothank you for the explanation! Do you happen to know if there's any work on bumping the power bus to 130W? I see that USB PD rev 3.0 allows up to 100W - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB#Power-related_specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB#Power-related_specificatio... Is there any work on rev 4?
- Causality1 7y agoGood job completely failing to address actual problems, USB-IF. What do people actually need? They need to be able to easily tell what the port on their device is capable of doing and they need to avoid buying chargers, cables, and devices that violate the specification, especially when they do so in a way that might destroy a device or even endanger the user. Unfortunately the only thing the USB-IF cares about is "Moar megabits! Moar!"
- squarefoot 7y agoThe more I look at the USB mess the more I feel that a revised faster Ethernet with provisions for both insulated and direct connections (magnetics-less == cheaper chipset, lower power consumption etc) for board to board communications then a smaller/sturdier connector plus PoE built in would solve every problem USB tried to solve including the ones it introduced.
- boznz 7y agoHad to read the USB1 spec in 1998 to make a HID Device using a small micro, took me over 3 weeks to get it working and was debugging shit for months afterwards. Would never go there again and for future projects I decided ignorance was bliss and just used whatever stack the chip designers supplied, I suspect that covers 99% of all devices out there.
- spancap 7y agoHave fun when your product falls on its face because the vendor stack got the corner cases wrong.
- gumby 7y agoThe real crimes are: 1 - non-mandatory labeling. What does a given port support? What about a given cable? 2 - the name "USB4 Gen 3×2". Honestly I have never had the faintest idea what any of the various absurd names invented by the USB IF might mean. Superspeed? High speed? USB 3.1?
- adtac 7y agoSomeone for the love of god, please introduce the USB committee to the concept of semantic versioning. Stop this Gen madness.
- wtallis 7y agoSemantic versioning as it usually applies to software is a bit awkward for numbering the USB specs. The challenge is that USB has two largely orthogonal features that need to be described: link speed, and everything else that has been layered on top as the standard has evolved (power delivery, OTG, etc.) USB 1.1 supported low speed (1.5Mb/s) and full speed (12Mb/s). USB 2.0 added high speed (480Mb/s) but didn't make it mandatory; you can have a USB 2.0 compliant keyboard that only supports low-speed or full-speed operation. USB 3.0 did the same thing with the introduction of SuperSpeed (5Gb/s). What they should have done was keep making point releases on the 1.x, 2.x etc. specs when they added things like On The Go and Power Delivery, but keep the major version number representing the maximum supported link speed. By that scheme, we would have all 3.x devices capable of 5Gbps and no more, and what's now being introduced as USB4 would be more like USB 6.5 (if the minor version numbers were kept in sync across the speed grades). But this would deprive many companies of marketing opportunities, and instead force them to advertise USB 3.x support years after USB 4, 5 and 6 come into existence.
- jobigoud 7y agoThey had the right idea by using a different symbol set for protocol vs ports with USB A B C. Maybe they could use greek letters for speeds.
- ytch 7y ago
- kaetemi 7y agoIs this a universal serial bus, or a universal docking station port?
- CharlesMerriam2 7y agoThe Grrranimals standard worked. People would match up symbols to see what worked together. Why cannot technology do the same? Yes, the cables plug together, but one has a turtle icon and one has a car icon?
- klausjensen 7y agoI am genuinely curious to read more about this, but a google search for Grrranimals doesn't give me anything to work with. Can you provide a bit more info, please? (if this was a joke, consider this my admission of egg on my face)
- spc476 7y agoIt's "Garamimals". It's a clothing line for very young kids where they can match the tag on a shirt with a tag on the pants and have an outfit that "goes together."
- baalimago 7y agoUSB3 and thunderbolt (unsure about their exact relation) enabled eGPU's, which is very cool. What will USB4 enable?
- 345218435 7y agowhy the bloody fuck don‘t we get a new, clean thunderbolt bus — as it was invented by apple/intel — and leave the usb folks play their mindless games? jesus.