27 ms·
YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation financially impossible
- benologist 8y agoThere are more than 400 hours of video uploaded every minute to the platform, and putting the onus of responsibility on platforms like YouTube to catch every video isn’t fair, according to Wojcicki. Sounds like they could solve this really easily by just hiring a lot of people, which is also very easy to do when you stashed over $100,000,000,000 and revenue is still growing and taxes are still diminishing and employees are still called contractors.
- j-pb 8y agoThat sounds like something out of an black mirror episode... Where an unprivileged worker class has to go through hours and hours of video material of the upper societal levels in order to make sure that they satisfy the grotesque utopian "always happy no conflict" image of an all seeing censor, including the denial of their own existence.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoAmazon has people do this for Alexa inputs, to label whether responses were good or bad.
- wafflesraccoon 8y agogenuinely curious, do you have a source for that?
- stedaniels 8y agoIt's built into the app. It asks you to grade each response positively or negatively.
- spullara 8y agoCool. We can just ask the uploader if it is copyrighted or not.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoI know someone with this job. I don’t think it’s advertised anywhere as such. But it appears the role is called “data associate” or “speech and language annotator”. Basically they listen to the phrase after the keyword and then the response, marking whether or not it was helpful (maybe more detailed than that, not sure). It’s a data labeling job in some shape or form. Anecdotally, a lot of people seem to like saying the worst possible (offensive) things to Alexa and some people use it to sext. I don’t know if the latter was transmitted because messages are fair game or if because the user incorrectly tried to use the messaging feature. The only thing about this that really surprises me is that it isn’t outsourced to a cheaper labor supply. I don’t have a Glassdoor account to confirm what this is saying but I think you’ll find at least circumstantial evidence here if you can view it. https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Amazon-Data-Associate-Reviews-EI_IE6036.0,6_KO7,21.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Amazon-Data-Associate-Revi...
- anticensor 8y agoA brigade[0] of retired old pensioners could do this review as a full-time unpaid labour. [0]:Infantry-equivalent numbers are used.
- nindalf 8y agoThis work isn't remotely fun. It's stressful, and the people doing it often have to deal with depression and drug abuse later. https://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderator-history-youtube-facebook-reddit-censorship-free-speech https://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderat...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anticensor 8y agoRetirees have less of a concern of future, hence they are less likely to abuse drugs. Pensioners also have the necessary income, and will not suffer income-related problems.
- ska 8y agoWhat's in it for them?
- ahje 8y agoI think you've hit the nail on the head here, and it's not even limited to retirees: Why would anyone want such a job? One might get someone unemployed and with no other choice to do it for a while, until another job comes by, but I don't really think anyone wants to do this for a living.
- Vehemental 8y agoall the uber/lyft drivers can go home at night and get to work for youtube
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 8y ago> Sounds like they could solve this really easily by just hiring a lot of people They could catch the obvious stuff like people uploading Hollywood videos, but the reality is that humans will let tons of stuff through, and also accidentally block stuff that should have been allowed. There's far more copyrighted content than a human can even view or listen to in a lifetime. There's just no way for a human to know what's in violation and what isn't.
- phkahler 8y ago>> There's just no way for a human to know what's in violation and what isn't. People can host their own stuff. Simple. Don't host content you don't know the origin of and can't document you've got the right to do so.
- ggggtez 8y agoAha, so, your solution to people uploading copyrighted content to youtube, is to force them to go back to hosting their content on their own PC, like... Napster and Bit Torrent? How exactly would that solve the problem? Is there a step 2 where they also cut all the cables into and out of Europe?
- jerf 8y ago"Sounds like they could solve this really easily by just hiring a lot of people," Who are you going to hire who can watch a video and instantly know every copyrighted piece used to produce it, judge whether or not the piece is one or another sort of "fair use" correctly/consistently etc., and be correct enough that YouTube feels safe taking on the corporate liability? Getting this right is more than just "a human views the video once". Sure, there's some obvious piracy, but a loooot of things that are not obvious piracy would require active research.
- manfredo 8y agoAssuming each content checker can process 8 hours of video a day, you'd need 180,000 (wrong, 100k as corrected by the commenter below) people working to review every video. Sure, YouTube doesn't need to review every video, but that 8 hours a day figure is being very generous. Account for management, documenting the results of review, appeals process, training, etc. and the throughput of reviewers is probably less than half of 8 hours per day. Even if only 1% of videos get flagged for review, YouTube is still looking at ~50% of all it's employees working on reviewing video.
- Aloisius 8y ago105,120 if working 8 hours a day, 5 days a week, 50 weeks a year. Of course, that don't work for copyright protection since there isn't a person alive who can recognize every copyright protected image/video/audio on the planet and whether the person uploading owns/licenses the copyright in every territory.
- manfredo 8y agoMaybe feasible if < 1% of content requires human review. (~1,000 reviewers). But seeings as a lot of people treat report buttons as a "mega downvote" I don't think this is feasible in practice. If this law is rolled out, I highly suspect that YouTube in the EU will consists solely of large channels that have a low rate of videos that violate policy.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Sounds like they could solve this really easily by just hiring a lot of people, which is also very easy to do when you stashed over $100,000,000,000 and revenue is still growing and taxes are still diminishing and employees are still called contractors. 400 hours a minute is 400x60x24x365=210,240,000 hours a year, equivalent to ~100,000 full-time employees. Anything less than $15/hour and they'll be hearing from Bernie Sanders, plus FICA and any employee benefits. Then they need real estate to work, utilities, parking, furniture, computer equipment, HR/IT/accounting support staff etc. The cost is in the ballpark for the estimates of YouTube's total revenue. Profits would be a fraction of that after all the existing expenses for hosting infrastructure and staff. And the $100B in cash is across all of Google. They would have to be pretty dumb to spend it down continuing to operate something that could never be expected to turn a profit again.
- Aloisius 8y agoMmm. Even with $100 billion, I don't think they could do it at the rate people are uploading at... There are three major problems: 1. Audio, video and image recognition systems are nowhere near close to perfect and the upload volume means even a small error rate will result in a large amount getting through. 2. Users are constantly coming up with new ways to avoid the filtering systems making it a game of tag, but where one side is made up of tens of millions of people. 3. There isn't a central registry of who owns what type of copyright in each territory so there is no good way to know if the person uploading has the right to or not. Then there are the issues of compositions... someone has the right to a music track, but only when synchronized to a particular video or someone inserting a frame of a copyrighted image inside their video. And this will affect far more than YouTube. Copyright extends to all creative works including this comment. Image hosting services, forums, reddit, social networking sites, comment systems, review sites should all worry.
- s3r3nity 8y agoI'm curious: are there any supporters of the copyright regulations around HN that can provide some thoughts on the "pro" side of this? I'm trying to get my head around both sides of the argument, and I just can't see why it might be a good idea - but I may be biased by the strong "against" views from HN posters.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoMy take on the general issue of platforms and their lack of any meaningful regulation so far: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18434784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18434784 I am not particularly big on the overreach our copyright system has. Chasing down people supporting orphaned works or trying to fix stuff for personal use, or whatever else is not cool, and our copyright system has a lot of problems, mostly because of the House of Mouse. But things like posting current, paid content does hurt the businesses that create that content, and short-term, relevant copyright is there for a reason, and beneficial. Without some form of copyright, the movie and TV industry would not exist. And YouTube channels commonly post full episodes of Game of Thrones or Last Week Tonight the same day of, and often go unchecked for months or years before YouTube takes action.
- trevyn 8y ago>Without some form of copyright, the movie and TV industry would not exist. We don’t actually know if that is true. (Or if it would be a bad thing, heh)
- api 8y agoI think it would exist, but it would be even more ad and propaganda driven than it is today and the content would be even lower quality. The goal would be to achieve literally 100% ad time by transforming even ordinary content into stealth advertising. Basically today you have two models: paid content and ads. Without copyright there would be only one model.
- naravara 8y ago
- gaius 8y agothat puts the responsibility on the platform instead of the user What did they think would happen when they started making editorial decisions about what content to show and what to ban or at least bury? They made their bed, let them lie in it.
- Aqua 8y agoAlthough you are obviously right and YTs censorship is well known, these are two unrelated things and an argument like that to justify bad law (which will not only affect YT, but other platforms as well) is inappropriate.
- xfitm3 8y agoI believe the comment is referring to safe harbor law, which I think is loosely related here.
- gaius 8y agoMy point is - they are demonstrably perfectly able to control what content is played and choose to ignore copyright to make more money.
- anticensor 8y agoCivil law copyright does not have enough safe harbor provisions for that.
- tengbretson 8y agoI don't see how you can consider them unrelated. If you are going to exercise editorial control over your platform you become responsible for (and potentially liable for) what makes it through to the public.
- gaius 8y agoIt seems so obvious to everyone who isn’t a Silly Valley bro. Total monoculture.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lgleason 8y agoThey kind of brought this on themselves. At one time they said that they were a neutral platform, and were fairly neutral. Now they very actively curate content, so naturally people are starting to want to make them liable for everything on their platform. Of course this will significantly reduce their profitability etc., but you reap what you sow.
- matt4077 8y agoSince someone else went to the trouble to explain to you why that argument is neither the law, nor logic[0], I’ll spare us the repetition and just assume you are arguing in bad faith. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18319358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18319358
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lgleason 8y agoWith all due respect, I'm currently working with a bi-partisan group that is looking into this issue. While you may not agree with my interpretation, there are many who are more well versed with the intent (IE: know the people who wrote the original bills) and the law who agree with my interpretation. A concentration of power among a few tech companies is very worrying, but that along with the moralizing of these large pseudo monopolies is a major problem. IE: When your platform has 80+ percent market share, and is actively censoring people for espousing views expressed by the elected president of the United States. Now this does not explain the European situation, but their position does not surprise me. With all of the EU's flaws they do have better anti-trust provisions, and in this case it doesn't hurt that it is a foreign company...
- vatueil 8y ago> censoring people for espousing views expressed by the elected president of the United States To the extent that's true, that says a lot more about how far the office of President has fallen than anything else. In a sane world, there would be bipartisan consensus that many of the views Trump expresses should rightfully be condemned: https://www.weeklystandard.com/stephen-f-hayes/donald-trump-is-crazy-and-so-is-the-gop-for-embracing-him?_amp=true https://www.weeklystandard.com/stephen-f-hayes/donald-trump-... > The degree of this normalization is stunning. The Republican nominee for president made comments Friday that one might expect from a patient in a mental institution, the kind of stuff you might read on blog with really small print and pictures of UFOs. And yet his remarks barely register as news. There are no condemnations from fellow Republicans. His supporters shrug them off as Trump being Trump.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoCopyright infringement is just one of the ways platforms profit off illegal activity as a standard practice of business. Scams and malware are prevalent in paid advertising, fake news is propagated and shared on a mass scale impersonating legitimate sources and individuals, etc. all because platforms can hide behind blanket immunity for what's posted on their platforms. I'm well into the opinion that if platforms can't operate within the law that they take some responsibility for what the environment they build and the problems they cause, they should be shut down. I think the world would be a better place without YouTube. In the US, I think removing Section 230 is an absolute imperative. These platforms currently have no legal responsibility to police content, and many of our problems today stem from the fact that they aren't going to do what's necessary until they're legally responsible to do so. If they're turning a profit on a user submission, and they aren't legally required to remove it, they have no incentive to do so. Platforms must be held responsible for their content, and if that changes the landscape of the Internet, so be it.
- mcphage 8y agoEven if YouTube could afford to do this, nobody else could, which would lock us into an EU-sanctioned YouTube monopoly...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jerf 8y agoMarket leaders are generally in favor of regulation, for that exact reason. Sometimes they'll play the protest game in public, but privately they are happy to see regulation. If YouTube is actually lobbying against this both in public and in private, then I would personally consider that extremely strong evidence this is really bad. However, I have no inside info on their private position.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoWell, they can be, but what if the regulations substantially shrink the market as a whole? May be more profitable to have 30% of a large market than 90% of a small one.
- alex_c 8y agoA lot of tech industries seem to be winner-take-all, so aiming for 30% might not be a sustainable plan in many cases.
- AJ007 8y agoWell at least that’s what companies that are losing lots of money like to tell their investors. I’ve heard it many times and can’t think of any definite examples.
- bduerst 8y agoNot really. Vimeo shows that you can corner niche markets successfully. Profitability and growth aren't dependent on market dominance, even in tech.
- resters 8y agoIronically, in the US pressure is mounting for content platforms to police "fake news" which is a moralistic mission, rather than enforce something fairly obvious like massive content piracy and systemic copyright violation as a service. Even in 2018 it seems that Youtube is being funded by the "Napster model" of allowing de facto circumvention of copyright law. Or, put another way, Youtube is profitable mainly because of vastly imperfect enforcement of laws.
- naravara 8y agoI feel like this criticism of YouTube is about 5 years out of date. At this point most of their traffic is original content by content creators. It's not the Napster model so much as hoodwinking young creatives into shouldering all the risks of producing a service for YouTube's users and using their monopoly power to freeze them out of being able to make anything resembling a decent cut of the revenues for their efforts. Call it the "Uber" model.
- will_brown 8y ago>At this point most of their traffic is original content by content creators. That’s not my experience. Name me a non-obscure movie, show, or song and I’ll bet I find it on YouTube. Except of course YouTube’s paid content...good luck finding a pirate version of say YouTube original series Kobra Kai, They seemed to have figured out a way to police their own content without issue.
- naravara 8y ago>Name me a non-obscure movie, show, or song and I’ll bet I find it on YouTube. With songs, at least, most of the time it's posted there by Vevo, so the recording industry put it there themselves. It's unlikely to be a big driver of their traffic or revenue. The incentives aren't even there, they're so quick to demonetize or send DMCA takedowns that anything people are likely to search for are at high risk of being taken down. You really only see the flowering of pirated content in the early days after live events, like when a new movie trailer drops.
- 8y ago
- ronilan 8y agoA little tangent nugget from the original text: > Kurzgesagt — In a Nutshell recently became the number one channel in Germany by creating videos that help others fall in love with science. If the number one channel in Germany is in English, then maybe YouTube still has some more fundamental challenges to overcome in Europe.
- whatshisface 8y agoThere are a lot more Germans that know English than there are Americans that know German. In fact I have never even talked to a German who did not know English. ;)
- DoreenMichele 8y agoCan confirm. As an American who lived in Germany decades ago, this was actually a substantial barrier to me improving my German. It was usually easier for them to converse in English than for me to converse in German, they jumped at the chance to practice their English with a native speaker and it made it difficult for me to find opportunities to practice my German.
- mrep 8y agoGod it is easy and convenient being American/english speaker. Cue old joke: "bilingual" is someone who speaks two languages, "trilingual" is someone who speaks three languages. What do you call someone who can only speak one language? An American.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYeah, but that's usually presented as an ugly American characterization. I actually wanted to be multilingual. I failed in part because I'm American. I know a little German and a little French. I know a smattering of Spanish and Russian. I wanted to be fluent in all of those. I fell far short of fluency.
- what_ever 8y ago
- geggam 8y agoor maybe this levels the playing field so smaller companies can compete
- zamadatix 8y agoIf YouTube can't make the margins I don't see how it could level the playing field for smaller companies to compete.
- stirlo 8y agoWith a better product? Imagine if you got rid of the whole user generated poor quality content and toxic comments section and simply uploaded a few hundred human reviewed best of the best videos per day. I don't see why we need 400 hours of video uploaded every minute when the vast majority of revenue and views is comings from a handful of videos.
- icebraining 8y agoI don't see why we need 400 hours of video uploaded every minute when the vast majority of revenue and views is comings from a handful of videos. What a depressing statement. So there's no value in having a diversity of choice, points of view, taste, etc? Or in allowing anyone to share what they've made, without gatekeepers? Do you only listen to the top handful of musicians, or read the top handful of books? Hell, HN is not in the top handful of sites with the vast majority of revenue and views, does that mean it has no value? I'd say it's actually the only value it has; it's what distinguishes it from TV, which is otherwise a better system in other ways.
- tcd 8y ago> the vast majority of revenue and views is comings from a handful of videos. Every channel started with 0 subscribers once and were part of that "400 hours of video uploaded every minute".
- beefeater 8y agoCongrats on the dumbest comment of the day. Youtube's copyright filtering is going to be better than any competitor just because of the sheer amount of resources they can sink into it. Assuming any video hosting company can survive this legislation, this will do the exact opposite of leveling the playing field. It will turn what is currently a fairly level playing field into one that massively favors Youtube.
- golemiprague 8y agoFrom the people who brought us the cookie warning, the most useless piece of regulation ever. No wonder they want brexit in the UK. If the EU was in charge of the internet we would probably have to still use union protected doves to transfer bits and bytes encoded with an authorised pencil on paper.
- alanlamm 8y agoI regularly see a number of videos of clearly copyrighted content that have been up for years, with several million views, for fairly mainstream search terms and that would be relatively easy to filter algorythmically (real example - via the characteristic sound & image of the HBO intro in a pirated tv episode). Hard to look at that and believe that Google is doing everything it can to bring them down. That they reject copyright violation reports that come from anyone other than the actual rightsholders (sure, they’d have to make sure someone is not reporting by mistake - it is not a perfect, but still a valuable signal, and if they really wanted to they could encourage it) is further evidence. Further, where these specific videos are not monetized via ads, they bring traffic to YT which is then monetized in other videos, therefore this pirated content is being used commercially, even if indirectly. Like many here I’m no fan of copyright law, but that is no excuse for a multi-billion listed company to make a fortune deliberately flaunting it and then play coy.
- dahdum 8y agoI'm not following. By your example, HBO content is being shared and Content ID can trivially determine it's HBO content. Do you have evidence that HBO wants those videos gone, but isn't capable of filing the request? Isn't it just more likely they are getting royalties instead?
- alanlamm 8y agoNo, I don’t have evidence. But I find it unlikely that HBO wants grainy versions of full TV episodes (eg filmed from a VHS recording playing on a TV) on the page of some random YT uploader (not an HBO page or influencer or etc) even if somehow in exchange for tiny CPM royalties. That is only one of several examples I have seen. Perhaps in the case of HBO they could be doing a better job given their size & resources, but for smaller creators it would be a challenge and why should the burden be on them anyway?
- icebraining 8y agoCan you link to one of these videos filmed from a VHS recording playing on a TV which has several million views?
- hedora 8y agoYouTube only really exists because the structure of DMCA safe harbors essentially legislated centralization of user-posted content. Live by the pen, die by the pen. Hopefully this legislation will lead to re-decentralization of media distribution, or at least a move away from surveillance-capitalism business models like YouTube’s.
- macspoofing 8y agoEurope just can't stop making dumb regulations to punish American Tech giants. They created the stupid cookie law and now half the sites have an annoying cookie notice ... and nothing got better. GDPR is shaping up as a boondgle that is either going to be (is) ignored or result in blacklisting Europeans. And now this poorly thought out regulations will continue this 'winning' streak.
- bepotts 8y agoWhat I love most about the EU and Europeans on this site is that they think that all these regulations will mostly hurt companies like Google and Facebook, and sure they'll be hurt. But the US is the largest market for most US companies, so they're unable to really hurt them like they want to. Instead, the people most affected are European companies that become successful enough for those onerous regulations to apply. There was a Hacker News thread about a new research paper that showed that GDPR is hurting European investment, and there were plenty of Europeans in that thread saying "Good, stop using my data." Like really? Wouldn't it be better to stop data usage without hurting investment? It's such a self own.
- mcv 8y ago> What I love most about the EU and Europeans on this site is that they think that all these regulations will mostly hurt companies like Google and Facebook On which site? HN? Many Europeans here are well aware this will mostly hurt smaller sites and independent content creators. Many MEPs seem to hope that European newspapers will get some of Google's money, but I honestly don't see how that's going to happen. GDPR is a different issue. It's less unreasonable and better intentioned, but the implementation is incredibly annoying. I'd rather see browsers handle this for me in a way I can easily control. EU data protection laws are excellent. Far better than those of the US, which do pretty much the complete opposite.
- macspoofing 8y ago>Many MEPs seem to hope that European newspapers will get some of Google's money, I'm surprised Google News doesn't stick ads on news results and do some sort of 70/30 profit sharing like YouTube. That's the best way for newspapers to profit from a Google Listing. Instead Google News sidesteps copyright issues by not monetizing news results at all. >EU data protection laws are excellent. Far better than those of the US, which do pretty much the complete opposite Forget laws. Are things better in practice? Because people tend to get enamoured with regulations because they sound great (I mean, who doesn't want low emission, high efficiency cars in 5 years) that are disconnected with reality.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYouTube's objection seems to be primarily a business model problem - they assume consent and then provide original content creators with a share of YouTube's profit from that work. It's no surprise that they wouldn't want to have to get permission first. What stops YouTube from doing cursory scans and then relying on a user agreement to protect themselves from liabilities, like "you agree to pay to us sums sufficient to cover all legal costs including any copyright charges, fines, etc., arising as a result of uploading this work"?? However, the Wikipedia page on the Directive [1] mentions that Art.13 : >"extends any licenses granted to content hosts to their users, as long as those users are not acting "on a commercial basis". That would be massive as videos uploaded to YouTube would then be able to be downloaded, and even shared, as works for [personal] non-commercial use. This would be a huge change in favour of the people and against copyright rights holders -- perhaps Wikipedia editors misinterpreted? The article mentions the "Fair Use Act", what's that a reference too? The para it's in is about EU, and the USA Fair Use Act never survived. We don't have a Fair Use in Europe. It would really help to know which companies are trying to push this and what specifically they're trying to protect from?? --- [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_Digital_Single_Market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_...
- karmenblack 8y agoWhat is wrong with state approved videos if it was performed by specialists? This would solve the copyright problem as only government could upload content and it will be safe for everyone.
- exitcode00 8y agoWhere was the Google CEO when all of this was being voted on? Where were the Google home-pages telling people to get active?
- jsmeaton 8y agoI wonder if it’d make financial sense for YouTube to provide ContentID as a service for other video platforms.
- MikeGale 8y agoThe legislators in the EU are an example of what happens when the clueless, make law. Their GDPR has apparently only benefitted Google, with Facebook taking the smallest hit of the rest. Many want these behemoths to get less power but these EU guys give them more. Now this. One answer it to ghettoise Europe and block them from receiving your content. For one thing that would get rid of those stupid "we use cookies things".
- koboll 8y agoSome sites are doing this. I logged into my Slickdeals account on vacation and they had an automated system that locked my account and forced me to affirm that I didn't live in Europe or else they would close my account.
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoI so hate the cookies thing. It's led me to have to actually read popups rather than immediately close them, and sometimes I end up accepting something that I thought was a cookie popup but was something else. Absolutely infuriating. Most every site uses cookies, I know that, I don't need to be told that, and your average user doesn't even care.
- anoncake 8y agoWhat everyone implements has nothing to do with what the "cookie law" actually requires. You are supposed to be able to reject tracking cookies and it does not affect other cookies (e.g. for logging in) at all. The problem is that the law is not being enforced.
- germanyhater 8y agoYou can install Ublock Origin and add cookie notification blocker list, then you will see much less those annoying boxes.
- mcv 8y agoI just want my browser to know how to manage my cookies. And to some extent, my browser already does that: I refuse third-party cookies. Only now I get popups telling me to accept third-party cookies because otherwise they won't be able to remember my choice to reject their cookies. It's a mess. I want smarter browsers that give me more control over this stuff.
- throwaway487548 8y agoThe same problem again - disconnected from reality humanities majors and liberal arts academics trying to regulate ecosystems they do not comprehend or understand. They are guided by abstract nonsense instead of careful judgements based on the scientific method (measure, make and test your hypothesis).
- consumer451 8y agoI watch a decent amount of YouTube, but if it went away, I don’t think that it would be a net loss to humanity given what YT shows to children [0], and how YT radicalizes viewers [1]. It’s actually Patreon that pays my favorite creators, not YT, so they could protentially distribute videos via any other site. A new site for discovery would likely rise up, if Patreon didn’t do that themselves. This is the entire platform vs publisher argument that tech companies have been hiding under for years. No one is responsible for content, and look what that’s gotten us. I would shed no tears if YT ended operation in the EU, where I live. [0] https://www.wired.co.uk/article/youtube-for-kids-videos-problems-algorithm-recommend https://www.wired.co.uk/article/youtube-for-kids-videos-prob... [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/10/opinion/sunday/youtube-politics-radical.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/10/opinion/sunday/youtube-po... https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/03/youtube-extremism-and-the-long-tail/555350/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/03/youtube... https://www.thedailybeast.com/inside-youtubes-far-right-radicalization-factory https://www.thedailybeast.com/inside-youtubes-far-right-radi...
- microcolonel 8y agoThe Alternative Influence Network thing is based on outright fabricated data by the way. Becca Lewis draws direct links between people who have never collaborated or appeared on eachother's channels (the criteria described for the linkages), to draw the absurd conclusion that Richard Spencer and Tim Pool are part of some conspiratorial "network". Anyone who takes the AIN report seriously either hasn't verified the claims, or agrees that these people should be misrepresented and smeared. Your view of YouTube is myopic, and ignores the immense cultural resource that exists there. You have no idea what would be lost if the EU chased it away, but you're willing to find out just to spite some people you resent; and you resent them based on false information you accepted because it fit your lens.
- lake99 8y agoI don't watch children's videos, so I'll leave that factor aside. All your citations are to opinion pieces written by people with an agenda to push, i.e. not fact, not by a long shot. I watch YouTube for education and entertainment. The loss of all the educational content, by itself, would be a massive loss to humanity. If YouTube were to go down, some educators will re-upload their content to other places. Moreover, radical activists would be the among the first to adopt YouTube's replacements, thereby solving nothing. > No one is responsible for content, and look what that’s gotten us. I suspect your views are coloured by the kind of things you watch. YouTube's algorithms have adapted to your viewing profile. Most of my recommendations are for science, math, and music pedagogy. From where I stand, YouTube has gotten us to a great place.
- tinkerteller 8y agoWith current state of things YouTube will be toast virtually with any copyright regulation. Huge amount of popular content on YouTube is stolen and retrofitted for your viewing pleasure. This is a raving cottage industry on YouTube and unthinkable just couple of decades ago when studios were going crazy over copyright infringement. You can find several old TV series, movies etc posted by others and comfortably ripping of ad revenue.
- em3rgent0rdr 8y ago‘No company could take on such a financial risk’ Even worse, no individual can take on the risk of self hosting their own videos.
- xhruso00 8y agoFunny how they threat cutting Europeans and at the same time want to comply with Chinese laws so they are able to enter the market. Is it really impossible Google?
- akie 8y agoThey just don't want to.
- dayaz36 8y agoIf youtube doesn't have the resources to handle these regulations, then imagine a start-up trying to. Ironically these draconian laws help youtube have a monopoly. They have billions to absorb any mistakes/law suites, etc...draconian laws always help the entrenched large corporations and destroy start-ups.
- dools 8y agoI'm sure they'll figure it out
- KaiserPro 8y agoSo, Youtube, who _still_ make a large amount of money from infringing other people's copyright, are not keen on being held liable for what they allow on their website?
- amanaplanacanal 8y ago> So, Youtube, who _still_ make a large amount of money from infringing other people's copyright Do they though? Other people are saying that also, but the evidence I've seen isn't very good.
- KaiserPro 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=how+its+made https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=how+its+made https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=mythbusters+full+episodes https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=mythbusters+ful... https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=simpsons+full+episode https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=simpsons+full+e... With the exception of the last one, which has paid options, all of those do not have permission.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoWait, how do you know that they don't have permission? I would assume that the owners of those copyrights are just as capable of using the contentID system as any of the rest.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoHilariously the Verge website doesn't like me blocking all their trackers. It was supposed to be a choice, not just "I accept". I rather type out this comment than take the 10 seconds to open this article in an unmodified browser.
- kachurovskiy 8y agoThat would free up a few hours of my time each day I spend watching stuff like https://youtu.be/FFBhoojrU_M https://youtu.be/FFBhoojrU_M :-)
- sam0x17 8y agoYoutube could continue to exist just fine without "youtubers". I miss the good old days when thumbnails weren't curated, and it was random users with a day job uploading videos instead of today's career spammers.