20 ms·
Three European Countries Block Tax on Tech Giants
- 7000skeletons 8y agoI didn't even need to click the link to know that Ireland was gonna be one of the three. It's like they have a vested interest, or something.
- Lio 8y agoYes they're an obvious one. I was surprised though that Luxembourg wasn't listed whist Sweden and Denmark are. I'd be interested to here their objects if anyone can point at a fuller article or discussion of the issues.
- 7000skeletons 8y agoThis is from earlier this year, so the debate may have progressed since then, but Sweden and Denmarks' concerns seem to stem from the way in which the EU aims to apply the tax. >“A digital services tax deviates from fundamental principles of income taxation by applying the tax on gross income, i.e. without regard to whether the taxpayer is making a profit or not,” Swedish Finance Minister Magdalena Andersson, and her counterparts from Denmark and Finland, Kristian Jensen and Petteri Orpo, said in a joint statement on Friday. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-digital-tax/nordic-countries-oppose-eu-plans-for-digital-tax-on-firms-turnover-idUSKCN1IW337 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-digital-tax/nordic-cou...
- exDM69 8y agoI guess the reason for applying the tax this way is that tech giants (and non-tech corporations) use creative accounting tricks to avoid making a profit and thus paying taxes to the countries they operate in. It's either disguised as loan interest repayment or licensing fees, but the goal is tax avoidance.
- friedman23 8y agoI'm so happy the people of Sweden are sane, my biggest problem with these taxes is that they are on revenue which essentially makes all low margin internet businesses unprofitable. How does that benefit consumers?
- Ragnarork 8y agoFacebook, Amazon and co. are "low margin internet businesses"?
- friedman23 8y agoFacebook no, Amazon started as one yes.
- klez 8y agoHonest question: why should I as a person be taxed on income (the closest I guess I can get to the concept of revenue) but a business should be taxed on profit? Can anyone explain to me the basis for such a distinction?
- friedman23 8y agoIncome taxes are a badly implemented tax so you wont get an argument from me there. We shouldn't be extending bad policy.
- 0xffff2 8y ago(The following based on US income taxes) You as a person don't have a clear "profit" to tax. I would argue that the system of deductions is the nearest equivalent to taxing your individual income on your profits.
- CompelTechnic 8y agoLet's say you operate a low margin business, such as a gas station. All numbers are before tax. For the year, you spend $1,000,000 paying for fuel, convenience store supplies, electricity, wages, etc. You get $1,050,000 in revenue from your customers, for a fairly realistic margin of 5%. Now let's say you run a software business. You pay $500,000 in electric bills, computers, wages, etc, and collect $1,000,000 in revenue for a margin of 50%. Would you rather live in a society where the gas station pays MORE tax than the software business? This would be the case if you taxed revenue instead of profit. If the revenue-tax rate were 4%, the owner of the gas station would be left with $10,000 at the end of the year, and the owner of the software business would be left with $460,000. Bringing these numbers back into normal, profit-based terms, the gas station owner would be paying an effective tax rate of 80%, with the software business owner paying an effective tax rate of 8%. If businesses were taxed on revenue instead of profit, low margin businesses and capital intensive businesses would be punished disproportionately. Businesses often face unplanned expenses or loss of revenue. This would have the effect of forcing businesses to raise prices to compensate for the increased risk, and would force lots out of business. This reduced economic activity would be bad for consumers, producers, the government, and society as a whole. Individual people's income taxes cannot be treated this way, because the closest analogy to "business expenses" for a person's lifestyle is their cost of living. If cost of living were deductible it would be highly gameable and ripe for abuse by numerous parties.
- mabbo 8y agoIt's an intriguing concept. What effect would a tax purely on size (income rather than profit) have on the world economy, if everyone were to adopt such policies? It would discourage large companies and encourage small ones. It seems like employees do better when there is a bigger and more diverse marketplace for work, ie, many smaller companies. So they would win out, hopefully. Customers may or may not do better. It would encourage companies to keep prices low to reduce gross income, and give an advantage to incumbents in the same marketplace. But one Amazon with it's fulfillment centers, delivery networks, etc, is more efficient than two overlapping half-sized Amazons. Twice the delivery trucks means twice the delivery costs and pollution. Overall I'd be for such a system, provided it were not too onerous and didn't target specific companies.
- friedman23 8y ago>What effect would a tax purely on size (income rather than profit) have on the world economy, if everyone were to adopt such policies? It would discourage large companies and encourage small ones. How so? Your argument makes 0 sense because the tax is proportional regardless of size. What it will encourage is high margin business and it will discourage low margin business. Larger businesses are able to increase their margins because of increased efficiencies.
- mabbo 8y agoNo, taxes are based on profits. I work for Amazon, which notoriously has nearly zero profit most years. The company pours money into investments instead. That's how it's gotten so big. What I'm saying is that if there were a small additional tax on giants based purely on their company value or gross sales, it would 'level the playing field' for incumbents who don't have the efficiencies of scale that the big companies have, which I think is beneficial to society.
- jopsen 8y agoIt seems more like companies would have stronger incentives to keep the profit margin high.. I would be concerned if low profit margins is a problem.. companies with a low profit margin is the reason we can afford so much stuff.
- ionised 8y agoWhy should we care whether they are making a profit or not? There are so many ways a company can legally and artificially lower its profit numbers.
- EpicEng 8y ago>Why should we care whether they are making a profit or not? Because it is generally in everyone's best interest for companies to invest in themselves rather than increase margin at all costs. Growth is good. Many companies would simply go under if you tax them on revenue. >There are so many ways a company can legally and artificially lower its profit numbers Then you try to cut those off as much as possible. Like most things in the real world, there's no perfect solution, but we weigh the pros and cons and make a decision.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoThe way tech companies are reducing income to zero by shifting around IP and IP license costs it's sadly impossible to tax income. So either tax revenue (or at VAT to digital goods delivered in a country like ads) or close IP license loopholes.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y ago"Yet the Nordic countries, which are home to several large digital companies like Sweden-based music streaming service Spotify (SPOT.N) [...]"
- kawsper 8y agoBoth Apple and Facebook have announced that they are opening datacenters in Denmark, so that might be part of the equation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tyu1000 8y agoGood for them. France and Germany take endless steps to protect their domestic economic interests regardless of what any EU legislation or sense of fairness says, Ireland is well within their rights to do the same.
- digianarchist 8y agoIreland have already been given some lucky charms by the EU. For example, they were given permission to set their corporate taxes to a ridiculously low 12.5%.
- rusk 8y agoSpoken like somebody who knows very little about the topic. The effective tax rate is far lower than this, but also, most countries have an effective tax rate for megacorps far lower than what they advertise once exemptions, subsidies and tax-breaks come into play.
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y agoYes but a lot of that is done by allowing large companies to offshore their profits.
- rusk 8y agoNo, that's not completely true. It's a part of the picture but there's plenty more strokes going on than that.
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y agoHence "a lot" which allows for other processes. We agree.
- rusk 8y agoTo me “a lot” signifies “most of” which I think understated the amount of other skullduggery going on.
- adam_klein 8y agoThe way to go Ireland. A ridiculously stereotypical statement from the French finance minister: “It just remains for me to offer Paschal a beer in a Dublin pub, and then I think we’ll be able to move toward a decision,” he said, referring to his Irish counterpart, Paschal Donohoe
- simias 8y agoI don't really see it that way, to me it sounds like he's trying to sound like he wants to have a friendly discussion with the Irish finance minister (and not sound too coercive or aggressive). People routinely drink beer in Parisian bars and pubs as well, if he's playing on an Irish stereotype it's a very mild one.
- dev_north_east 8y ago"Country looks out for its interest, more on page 2"
- swarnie_ 8y agoWhen one country can hold up the progress of the entire 27 member bloc because of their own self-interests the project looks very weak.
- ainiriand 8y agoCan you elaborate? What kind of progress?
- swarnie_ 8y agoIn this case its a tax on US technology companies.
- pfortuny 8y agoEver heard of Brexit? Some people are a bit upset about that kind of governance. Me too.
- swarnie_ 8y agoHaving voted for Brexit i can almost certainly say I've heard of it yes.
- raverbashing 8y agoOh you mean the EU is not an authoritarian nightmare that just imposes their will on unsuspecting member states as some are lead to believe?
- growlist 8y agoAsk the Greeks how it's working out for them
- mrleiter 8y agoWhen it comes to taxation, a central sovereign measure, every member has to agree. Although the EU itself is something sui generis (or colloqually supranational), certain areas demand unanimous votes, especially those that are inherent to a nation‘s sovereignty.
- lordnacho 8y agoI wonder if the placement of data centres has much to do with it? There's a bunch being built or in the pipeline at least in Denmark.
- gcb0 8y agoevery country is using this as a populism election marketing ploy to look like they will come out of brexit on top, being the new "london" for tech company jobs. all while getting elected on the empty flawed promise and getting money under the table to lower companies data center and telemarketing center costs.
- 8fingerlouie 8y agoThere are 2 Apple data centers being built in Denmark, and rumors of Google and Facebook ones as well. As for the rejection of the tax, i honestly think it has more to do with avoiding double taxation. Company taxes are at 22% in Denmark. Denmark already collects 25% VAT on everything sold. If a 3% tax was to be imposed on "tech giants", it would ultimately end up being passed on to the consumer, effectively increasing retail price by 3% or more (depending if it's calculated as cost+28% or cost+3%+25%) In the end it fails to accomplish the goal of forcing companies to pay local taxes instead of transferring them to wherever they can pay the least taxes, and instead drives up sale price and ultimately inflation.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoIts a revenue tax not a sales tax - easier to enforce and less problematic legally than forcing profits to be booked locally. and its not clear how paying taxes on local profit would have any more effect on consumers than taxing revenue
- mrleiter 8y agoIt‘s interesting to note, albeit probably being irrelevant here, that both Sweden and Denmark are not in the monetary union (Euro) and have certain priviliges in certain areas of EU law (like the UK has).
- ckastner 8y agoThe article doesn't say why Denmark, Ireland and Sweden opposed, but from a referenced article [1]: > Spearheaded by France, the plan has met resistance from countries such as Ireland and Sweden, which question the wisdom of the EU going it alone given the global nature of digital services. First, not all services are digital, especially not Amazon packages. Second, the "global nature" is a technological aspect. The corporations themselves are local to some jurisdiction, as are their clients. This argument is similar to computing in the "Cloud": Technologically, the service is perhaps global, but the physical manifestation of it certainly isn't. That data center is located somewhere, and when it goes down, one is reminded of the limitations of the "global" aspect. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-05/eu-s-divisive-plan-to-tax-facebook-amazon-returns-to-spotlight https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-05/eu-s-divi...
- logifail 8y ago>> The corporations themselves are local to some jurisdiction, as are their clients My latest invoice from AMZN says "Sold by Amazon EU S.à r.l., UK Branch". Amazon EU S.à.r.l. is based in Luxembourg. My order was one (single) LTO cleaning cartridge. Does anyone here think that cartridge even went anywhere near Luxembourg at any point between manufacture and reaching me? I doubt it.
- gaius 8y agoA company that leverages the favourable infrastructure and institutions of a country without paying its fair share is quite simply siphoning money from the taxpayers of that country into the pockets of its shareholders, the money that maintains that infra and those institutions. Politicians need to take a step back and realize that whatever jobs these companies bring, they are still a net loss to the country as a whole, the country would literally be better off if those people were unemployed!
- antidesitter 8y ago> whatever jobs these companies bring, they are still a net loss to the country as a whole, the country would literally be better off if those people were unemployed! That’s quite the claim. Got anything to back it up?
- gaius 8y agoThat’s quite the claim. Got anything to back it up? Pretty easy really. Multiply the cost of unemployment benefits * number of company employees in that country. Then look at the tax evaded by the company. "You do the math". JSA in the UK is £73/week, or £3796/year. Let's say a company dodges £1Bn/year in taxes. How many people would they need to employ before the country breaks even?
- Bantros 8y agoIt really is that easy folks
- 7000skeletons 8y ago"TECH GIANTS HATE HIM."
- antidesitter 8y agoUh, what? Stop being vague and describe exactly what you mean. Response to edit: Please describe the full calculation (with factual numbers) of "national wealth", and then we'll talk.
- 0xfaded 8y agoApple and Facebook are currently building massive datacentres in Denmark, and Google has bought two plots for future datacentres. They have definitely been wooed to denmark, labour and consumer electricity prices are some of the highest in the world. https://facebook.com/OdenseDataCenter/ https://facebook.com/OdenseDataCenter/ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-denmark/apple-to-build-second-renewables-powered-data-center-in-denmark-idUSKBN19V0MJ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-denmark/apple-to-bu... https://stateofgreen.com/en/partners/state-of-green/news/google-invests-in-second-data-centre-location-in-denmark/ https://stateofgreen.com/en/partners/state-of-green/news/goo...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shaki-dora 8y agoI doubt that some data centers make much of a difference. Those tend to be employ maybe two cleaners, one depressed robot and one or two jaded administrators, plus their pot dealer. They also don't buy anything locally, except electricity at negotiated prices close to or below the costs of production. Maybe they lead to some earnings/profits to be at their location? Considering the issue discussed here, I doubt that.
- ryanmercer 8y ago>one depressed robot Eh, I've always seen them more as Kryten than Marvin.
- barrystaes 8y ago> Those tend to be employ maybe two cleaners, one depressed robot and one or two jaded administrators, plus their pot dealer. You just wrote the plot to The New IT Crowd..
- silvestrov 8y ago> consumer electricity prices due to taxes which companies don't pay, so that doesn't matter. Look at the following graph (you need to expand it). Denmark has the lowest prices. https://www.statista.com/statistics/263262/industrial-sector-electricity-prices-in-selected-european-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263262/industrial-sector... Price of electricity in Denmark is less than 51% of the price in Ireland!
- divbyzer0 8y agoThe EU was strongly against any trade tariffs. What differentiates this 'tax' from a tariff?
- themihai 8y agoEverybody pays tax. The issue is that some companies avoid paying it in the EU, basically stealing from the EU citizens. The difference between the taxes and tariffs is that the tariffs target a specific country while the tax is same for everyone (working in a specific industry). Tech companies seems to be the most notorious tax evaders so this was just a push to make them pay a fair share of tax in the EU. >> Traditional tax systems have so far failed to capture revenue from companies with global reach but limited physical presence
- divbyzer0 8y agoI agree that tech companies do not pay their fair share of tax. But this is an EU tariff against US companies. Will any EU company be affected?
- cyphar 8y agoIn order to get tax breaks from a country you must be incorporated in that country. So, tautologically, any company that would pay these EU taxes must be an EU company. In the most pedantic sense, this cannot affect US companies. However US (and other multinational) companies set up subsidiaries and then funnel money through them to get tax breaks thanks to bilateral double-taxation-avoidance agreements. These would be affected, but they've structured themselves this way intentionally so that their profits are collected in a company headquartered in the EU. (Though it should be noted that headquartering EU operations in an EU country is generally a requirement for dealing with EU consumers without tarrifs and so on, but many multinationals funnel their international money through the EU company). You can't have it both ways. Either you're an EU company which gives you certain tax breaks, or you're a US company that has no tax benefits in the EU for global revenue.
- martinald 8y ago
- ThomPete 8y agoDenmark is a taxhaven in its own sense for holding companies which might be surprising to many. The country primarily tax income not companies and have a high (deductible for companies) sales tax.
- kodablah 8y agoTo save some of us outsiders from researching, can someone give a brief overview of the proposal? Specifically why new taxes are needed and how the targeting is specified (i.e. who is affected).
- jpdus 8y agoIts relatively easy. All the big tech crops are paying effectively below 1% of their profits in Europe and are moving almost all of their profits to tax havens. As these companies are very creative when measuring their localized profits, its easier and more fair to impose a tax at the revenue level. I don't understand all the negative comments here. Look at the big profit margins of all big tech companies (maybe with the exception of Amazon retail) and ask yourself whether a moderate, unavoidable tax is really unjustified or will have negative effects on anyone (except maybe the shareholders). I don't think so and in my opinion tech workers should be a bit more mindful when thinking about these taxation topics. I prefer paying high taxes strongly to further social segregation, which will lead to the development of civil unrest and lower quality of life for everyone sooner or later...
- kodablah 8y agoI was trying to avoid giving my opinion. My curiosity was specifically around what conditions make a company subject to this new tax and its purpose. Aside from my opinion on corporate taxing and government approaches towards it in general, I will give an opinion on new taxation policy in general developed as a counter to avoidance. More and more frequently, legislation is drafted to combat the lack of enforcement of existing statutes. And that same legislation is similarly unenforced like its predecessors. Most watch this history repeat and cheer it on with incredulity towards disagreement. Some believe this time will be different, others believe the same institutions that are failing at their obligations shouldn't be given a mandate to fail using the same approaches. It adds more codified word and less substantive meaning. Replace tax structures (only if you must), enforce, move on. Don't pile on, leave unenforced, and keep giving pitchforks to the citizenry while ignoring the responsibility of the collectors.
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoCan we change the title to "Denmark, Ireland and Sweden block Tax on tech giants" ?
- bsaul 8y agoAs a french, seing french government officials trying to impose their knee-jerk « let’s tax it » reaction to any kind of problem makes me absolutely sick. They’re just a bunch of jealous incompetent insufferable pompous politicians than don’t understand a thing about the private sector and so instead of trying to fix the numerous reason why we don’t have any competitor to google / facebook etc ( such as our best engineers fleeing to silicon for the last 30 years) , and how come all those companies HQ in europe are in ireland, prefer to add tax. That will solve absolutely NOT A SINGLE ISSUE , but it’s just another income to feed the bureaucracy. Thanks to the three countries that stopped this madness. PS : i also find it outrageous that gafa don’t pay taxes, but let’s fix the tax heavens in Europe then. Don’t start making special taxes on revenue ffs. EDIT : changed "income" to revenue.
- kachurovskiy 8y agoPlease help me understand why is it okay to tax people on income but not corporations?
- scatters 8y agoCorporations aren't consumers, so corporation tax is passed on: to customers, employees, or shareholders. Levying taxes via corporations disguises the true level of taxation.
- visarga 8y agoDepends, when the corporation is a multinational, then they can evade local taxes by various tricks and send all the profits outside the country. Thus it is necessary to close this loophole, to keep the tax money in the source country.
- slededit 8y agoIn that case the economic efficient form of taxation is an expatriation tax.
- polskibus 8y agoI wonder what are the reasons opposing countries gave.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y ago1. I knew Ireland was on the list without reading the article 2. Sweden is lobbied by Spotify 3. Denmark tries to attract Google. Cui bono.
- kryptiskt 8y agoSweden has a successful tech economy and doesn't want to be held back by lumbering continental countries and their fears.
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoYes, every other country would do the same, but it does explain Sweden on list which was my intention. This tone "lumbering continental countries" wasn't called for though. Could we be civilized here without insults and hate?
- snidane 8y agoYou're never gonna implement an income based tax system which would be fair to both corporations and employees. Corporations are currently taxed on profit, while employees on 'revenues'. So to make it fair you would: 1. tax corporations on revenue too. Which this thread is about 2. tax employees on profit. Food, gas, utilities, ... - these are basically cost of operation of a human being, aren't they? Income taxes will never work. Monopoly taxes are a solution though. Monopolies behave as money sinks in economy. Their prices are not competed down, so you can't talk about monopolized system as capitalistic. The more monopolies and wealth concentration you get the more you approach something like feudalism. Which is where we are heading as a civilization right now. Monopolies are usually created and maintained by heavy regulation, because you don't allow small projects to challenge them. Also monopolies influence regulation in such a way to make it so. So why not embrace monopolies, but tax them for the service of letting them be monopolies? You can then even not call it tax, but a pay-per-use license granting certain social privileges. Perfectly progressive tax. The more you use, the more you pay.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoIf generalize that a bit you’ve basically got geoism. An ideology that unfortunately lost steam a century ago. Would be nice with a come back though.
- zhengyi13 8y agoIf any given org is a monopoly, I'd fully expect that org to pass any new costs on directly to their captive consumers. Monopolies ought to be actively broken, not worked around.
- snidane 8y agoGood point, but it is wrong. That applies to sales taxes. Not to monopoly taxes. In well functioning market with many competitors, the price of good would be determined as costs + margin. Over time given enough competition the price should converge to that sustainable minimum basically. If you introduce sales taxes into the equation, then obviously you hike up the cost, therefore you shift this minimum. Monopoly goods prices are not determined by cost, because there is no competition which would make it go lower over time. Monopoly prices on the other hand have opposite tendency - ie. to maximize to the point where almost all disposable income of its customers gets eaten up. That's why you get the phenomenon of rents being ever so higher. They just catch up to increases in wages and eat it all away. There is no sufficient competition to compete the price away, simply because there is not enough land to house the people, especially in cities. House rents are the biggest of the monopolies, because everyone has to pay it and often it is significant portion of a paycheck. Back to the point. Introducing monopoly taxes has the exact opposite effect - it lowers the prices for consumers. Explained further here http://blog.lvrg.org.au/2011/08/why-land-tax-cant-be-shifted-onto.html http://blog.lvrg.org.au/2011/08/why-land-tax-cant-be-shifted...
- dalbasal 8y agoWhether this policy is good or bad will depend on the details. But generally, in Europe, this kind of priposal is a populism magnet and a dancefloor for cheap politics. "Standing up to multinational corporations and making them pay their fair share (ra! ra!)" is exactly the type of rhetoric our most generic politicians love. An American equivalent might be some "government out of your hair" initiative to reduce professional liscencing.. or somesuch. Once you've got something like that on the table, all the cheapest politicians come out of the woodwork. On a serious not though, I think it's a good idea if (and only if) this names and addresses the problem which this actually intends to fix: company tax. Companies have always been difficult to tax properly for 2 reasons. (1) "profit" is whatever your accountant says it is, and this is a manipulatable figure. (2) companies operate in multiple tax jurisdictions. Between these two things, these companies don't pay tax. Besides denying the taxman her due, this gives bigger piles of money and advantage over smaller ones. Not fair. Sad. I just don't see how modern democracies can address something like this. It's at the nexus of all the things we suck at (politically) at the moment. Cheap idealogy, corporate interest groups, and complicated systems.
- bluecalm 8y agoThis is because taxing profit is a very bad idea. It leads to situations where two companies doing exactly the same thing pay different taxes because one uses less efficient (and often more polluting) technology or just chooses to buy luxury cars for the employees instead of showing profits. The tax on profits is a tax on honesty in accounting and even if accountats are honest it's still impossible to determine fair value of things like offshore licensing. Once you accept taxing corporate profit is a very bad idea the solutions magically appear: tax consumption and things we don't want (pollution, land usage etc.) It's very easy to make consumption tax progressive if you want that (higher rates for luxury goods, refunds up to X amount per month, funding social services with it etc.). There is no reason to debate what a company based in country at the end of the world should pay or how your neighbors choose to tax their companies. If they do business in your country the revenue is collected by consumption tax. If your country is nice to live in people will move and pay tax there. The incentives are right for the politicians: make your country businesses friendly and a nice place to live and for the companies who move to places which are more business friendly and better to operate in as tax rate isn't an issue anymore - everyone sets their consumption tax rates and everyone who sells there must oblige. The countries setting their corporate tax to near 0% have the right idea. I hope they won't be bullied of their position.
- discordianfish 8y agoI didn't follow this particular solution to taxing tech companies as much as I probably should have, but I feel like it's not addressing the root problem. Wouldn't it make more sense to tax the revenue where it was earned (as oppose to the physical location of the european HQ)?
- residentfoam 8y agoThis is one of the reasons EU is never gonna fly. Countries like Ireland are allowed to offer lower corporate taxation but still benefiting of the EU common market. No wonder why most companies have/move their tax domicile in these countries (like Nederland). This is unfair competition and EU should stop this s*t show. Businesses should be taxed based on where the revenue is generated and not where their tax domicile is placed.
- purple_ducks 8y ago> This is one of the reasons EU is never gonna fly. You mean a single market??? > Businesses should be taxed based on where the revenue is generated and not where their tax domicile is placed. How would that make sense? If a product is built & sold in country X to a person in country Y, then only sales tax is paid to country Y. Revenue goes back to country Y to cover the costs and then tax is paid on what remains. That's like one of the fundamental things tying EU together.
- adamlett 8y agoPlease correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t the sole reason multinational corporations can avoid paying taxes, that they “have to” pay surprisingly large royalties to some sister company in a tax haven that “owns” all the rights to the mother company’s trademarks and other IP? Isn’t this the reason that a company like Google mysteriously isn’t able to turn a profit in most European countries? And if I’m right, couldn’t we make that illegal? Couldn’t we for instance require a company to prove that the IP it licenses is owned by someone who is not controlled by the same entity that it is itself controlled by?
- tananaev 8y agoBut they should be able to pay something to sister or parent company because they actually use the software developed there. The question is how much. Probably not all of the profits. I guess it's really hard to determine and define strict and fair rules in this area.
- MagnumOpus 8y agoIt is rather likely that the intellectual property for the google or Starbucks brand or the work that led to Pfizer patents etc were not developed in Bermuda, Bahamas or Panama. It’s hard to exactly apportion where but rather easy to point out that near-zero IP work was done where it was declared to be taxable.
- adamlett 8y agoIf we were talking about something that had a non-zero marginal cost such as tangible goods or services, I would tend to agree. The problem with (or benefit of, depending on your perspective I guess) IP is that apart from a fixed upfront investment (which granted can be substantial), it costs nothing to "produce" or transfer. Allowing a company to in effect pay licenses to itself, is therefore IMHO nothing but an invitation to the company to choose where it wants to get taxed.
- Faark 8y agoI wonder if those sales could be force to an open market. A bit like anti trust laws. I'm sure they would pay a lot more for their trademarks if other companies could otherwise snitch it for like a year. Or why not having to accept or at the least pay taxes on the best offer you get, when you want to sell to some IP and later lease it from some other company? Yes, that seems unrealistic. It might at least be possible to use this in e.g. the court of law to test for abuse.
- wimgz 8y agoA smart move would be a corporate tax at the European Union level
- qaq 8y agoI think people forget this cuts both ways there is trade imbalance between US and France in France's favor so if both sides apply similar measures it will be net loss for France. I am sure this is something politicians forget to mention.
- xps 8y agoI feel that if that law was to pass, the affected companies would simply add that 3% tax to the prices European consumers pay, especially since this is a tax on the revenue and not on profit. It's not like US tech giants have much competition to fear from European companies anyway. A 3% price increase isn't going to get anyone to switch to another service (except maybe in the case of Amazon's physical sales). In the end, consumers would pay and this would add to the already large price difference between the EU and the US, due to the much higher applicable VAT in the EU, as well as other similar taxes applied in some EU countries (private copying levy [0], eco-participation [1]...). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy [1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Éco-participation https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Éco-participation
- Natela 8y agoBut what is this price we pay for FB and Google services ? 3% increase on 0€ is still 0€. We don't pay for Google with money but with our privacy. I'm perfectly fine with making my privacy more expensive to buy for Google.