34 ms·
Is developer compensation becoming bimodal?
- ilaksh 9y agoWhether you were aware of it or not, there have always been programmers working for elite companies making high salaries and programmers working for medium or small companies making average salaries as well as programmers just getting by working for unfunded startups or online bidding or whatever they can get.
- eksemplar 9y agoAs a manager I’d probably advice against picking programming unless you love it. In our educational system the increase in short-length programming classes at academy level has exploded and I doubt the market will keep up. Really great comp science or engineering students won’t ever have a problem, but I fully expect the short-length, autodidact or mediocre students to be entering a saturated market within the next five years.
- make3 9y agodo you have any quantified evidence of this or is it just a gut feeling
- eksemplar 9y agoWell, it’s anecdotal from experience and my network. 10 years ago we would get 1-5 applications for a programming job, and most would frankly be underqualified. The last position I put up for a regular .net, jboss and sharepoint position had over 300 applicants, several vastly overqualified. I work in the public sector, so it’s not exactly because we offer what most developers consider “dream positions” and we certainly don’t offer a good salary.
- computator 9y ago> The last position I put up ... had over 300 applicants, several vastly overqualified. Interesting how this contrasts with the widely-held perception that there is a programmer shortage.
- randomdata 9y agoIs that really the perception in 2018? If we go back to the early 2010s, I would agree. That the message was spread frequently back then. I really haven't heard it recently. And it makes sense that the market over the last 5+ years should have started to close the gap. That is plenty of time to allow people to become able in development.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thesmallestcat 9y agoFew if any of the 300 applicants were overqualified for that garbage opportunity. Can you describe on how they were overqualified? List a bunch of certs and techs? Good programmers aren't fighting over scraps for underpaid government positions working with JBOSS, they get snapped up immediately when they hit the market. Five years to saturation? Yea right. Readers who just deleted emacs in despair should keep in mind that parent is hiring for Danish government position, not exactly the hotbed of software development or skills demand.
- jnbiche 9y agoWhile I can't speak to the GP's experiences, I'm guessing you're in SV (most likely), NYC, Chicago, RTP, or Austin based on your remarks on how quickly developers get snatched up. However, those of us living outside that handful of cities have a totally different experience, regardless of how good we are or how much experience we have. There just are far, far fewer jobs outside that handful of American cities. And many of us are unable to just up and move due to a personal situation (sick relative, illness, spouse's job, etc.). It's just worth bearing in mind that your experience as a developer is somewhat the exception in the US, not the rule. At best, it's a 50/50 split between devs in the cities I mentioned above and the rest of us.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoI've had similar experience finding on-site work in a healthy market as I have as a remote worker. I don't think parent's advice is sound, claiming that software eng. is a dead-end path for most, with a five year fuse. Clearly if you're not excellent or willing to move to a city with jobs in your industry, you're going to be in for a rough time. Not specific to software eng.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alixander 9y agoThat point hasn’t been hit yet. Discouraging people from learning programming because you anticipate that point to come soon is unfortunate coming from a manager of programmers. Regardless of job opportunities, which I disagree with but is beside the point, being able to program increasingly allows people to create value and bring ideas to existence.
- gaius 9y agoAs a manager I’d probably advice against picking programming unless you love it. That is the dirty little secret of our industry. You need to do your day job AND on your own time, keep your skills up to date, and/or work on open source and/or write a blog or something. There was a post on there the other day on how keeping up to date with k8s is a full-time job in and of itself, well you need to do that - and a bunch of others - in your free time, in the full knowledge that what's hot today might turn out to be worthless in a year or two. People on the outside, even those aspiring to get in, I don't think fully realize the commitment of those making the headline salaries in this field. Just as you won't make it as a banker unless you LOVE making deals, so much that you'd even do it for free...
- collyw 9y agoYes, the occasional expectation that you should have a blog to make you a decent developer annoys me. I am pretty poor at writing and don't have a lot to say that I want to broadcast to the world. Answering Stak Overflow questions suits me better as a way of demonstrating that I know something.
- gaius 9y agoa way of demonstrating that I know something It's the expectation that you need to demonstrate it at all, is the problem. How many lawyers sue people for fun so they can blog about it, how many doctors do surgery at home and stream "live cutting"? We have created a treadmill that we can't step off
- Consultant32452 9y agoI think this is largely a myth. I don't have any of my work in a public space. In my area I'm in the top 5% of the salary range. Maybe this is more prominent in silicon valley? I've personally never even been asked for any kind of portfolio.
- intro-b 9y agoto be fair, the bimodality in the population of lawyers/doctors is an "are you in or out" system that comes from the generally outdated and arduous graduate credentials for these careers administered by bureaucratic boards. medical school, law school, and so on, are all extremely costly investments of time and capital for a shot at attaining that professional certification, and there's generally little recourse if you continually fail. "software developer," as a label, doesn't signal that kind of credentialing (although something like advanced degree might), so our labor to differentiate ourselves goes elsewhere. i don't want to imply that this isn't a problem for our profession, but the amount of "wow we software engineers have it so difficult" sentiment in this thread seems high
- dagw 9y agoAs a manager I’d probably advice against picking programming unless you love it. I would definitely advice people to learn programming, but not necessarily to aim to become programmers.
- laichzeit0 9y agoProgramming for the sake of programming gets boring after a few years. At least for me, this was the case. There is only so far you can go with it as a pure discipline. Once you've mastered design patterns, higher order functions, etc. you end up with writing "just another" app, service, CRUD thing, etc. What I found really interesting was going one step further and using programming to solve "higher order" problems, such as data science or artificial intelligence related problems. I'm not talking about implementing something in Tensorflow. That again is just programming. I'm talking about implementing something in Tensorflow to solve a specific problem and seeing the result of that. The programming part is beside the point, it is a means to an end. I think you really need to dig deep and ask yourself why you are writing code at all. The act of writing software itself is not that intellectually stimulating once you've mastered it well enough. It is just one layer of abstraction. Think about what is the next layer of abstraction you can build on top of your programming layer.
- ryanianian 9y agoThis sounds like natural career progression (and also perhaps why some get bored doing the same thing for so long). You want to move up the lever of impact. For many this means applying their experience to a growing field (e.g. lots of interest in AI/etc recently) or helping other developers be more productive and not have to solve the same problems they did (e.g. growing k8s, cloud, ci tooling, new languages, etc.)
- toddan 9y agoThis is my opinion as well. Many people still believe that programming equals a unique and high paying job. It is not ut is quite boring and you have to be the guy that always says yes and deliver no matter what, much like a factory worker.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cvsh 9y ago>I fully expect the short-length, autodidact or mediocre students to be entering a saturated market within the next five years. That cuts against every labor demand projection. Frankly, even mediocre programming jobs are a great option for most people. The lower mode is still much more than most entry-level jobs pay.
- wetpaws 9y agoThis is what I heard about 10 years ago, and advise I got is to go into engineering because programmers would be "just another over-saturated marked like lawyers". I'm glad I did not treat it seriously.
- CryoLogic 9y agoIn Seattle, salaries are definitely bimodal (at least from my experience over dozens of offers from me and fellow classmates). Many mid/small corps are paying ~75-120k base with x stock which is of course not worth anything yet. Most large competitive firms are paying more around 115-150 with 15-75 in stock. So an explicit divide between the mid/small companies and the large tech giants exists here.
- banku_brougham 9y agoare those new-graduate salaries? what experience level?
- Kephael 9y agoThose look like new grad compensation packages, I believe Amazon total comp is ~145k/yr for new grad SDE1s.
- kenhwang 9y agoI'm partial to the O-ring explanation. Software engineering is uniquely multiplicative because it's possible for a software engineer to create software that does software engineering. Chemical/electrical/mechanical engineers can't use their field to automate their field. Doctors and lawyers are almost exclusively service jobs, unlike the manufacturing nature of engineering. Automation is a force multiplier, and software engineering benefits from being able to create automation, apply automation to others, as well as being able to apply automation to itself.
- litzer 9y ago> Software engineering is uniquely multiplicative because it's possible for a software engineer to create software that does software engineering. I think you misunderstood the O-ring explanation by citing that idea as an example. It doesn't mean building AI. It applies to any of those fields you mentioned. Good people in field X work together with other good people in field X in top firms -> multiplicative productivity.
- Kiro 9y agoWho said anything about AI?
- litzer 9y agoMost people would consider software that "does software engineering" AI.
- Swizec 9y agoA compiler is software that does software engineering. Saves a lot of time and effort. Package managers, that used to be hard to do by hand. Bundlers and linkers, that stuff used to need skilled engineers. Many other examples
- gaius 9y agoChemical/electrical/mechanical engineers can't use their field to automate their field. A mechanical engineer designing a new manufacturing technique or robot is most certainly using their field to automate their field. Most of computing exists because electronic engineers used their field to automate their field. Software is not unique in this respect.
- akhilcacharya 9y agoHow do I know which mode I’m in?
- zbentley 9y agoTry to make rent in the bay area. If it's easy, you're in the right-hand mode. ~/s
- meuk 9y agoIMHO, the title should be fixed to mention that it is only about developer compensation in the USA. I am always surprised at the salaries in the USA. I have two bachelor degrees and two master degrees from two well established universities, and earn about 2k euro a month (before 20% tax deduction), which is considered fairly decent for a starter. Even then, many corporations outsource software development to Eastern-European countries.
- expertentipp 9y agoMost of the developer salaries in EU would be below the scale in the bar chart "Programmers in 2015".
- gurkendoktor 9y agoI'm not familiar with the larger EU market, but I would guess that German IT salaries skew low as well - and yet I regularly meet freelancers/contractors who can ask for more compensation than most traditional employees ever could. Collecting that data and adjusting for the fact that contractors have to deal with more taxes and insurance, but less restrictions about vacations, seems impossible.
- expertentipp 9y agoBeing contractor in Germany one still pays the social contributions the same as a person on employment contract, it's hardly the lightweight variant. Contractor in large business in Germany is at the complete end of the development chain (hourly rates 30-80 EUR/h). Have some super old system in obscure technology/stack? Outsource it to PL/CZ/RO/UK. The super high earning rockstar contractors are some unicorns I'm yet to meet in my life.
- gurkendoktor 9y agoIndependent IT contractors in Germany don't have to put any money in a retirement fund, but hopefully they do, plus they pay 100% of their own health insurance, IT equipment (sometimes), insurance for their business (occasionally required)... A contractor making 10,000 a month is not comparable to an employee making 120,000 a year, probably closer to 90,000? I didn't mean to imply that it's a lightweight model, it just shifts the burden to the contractor. Thankfully 80 EUR/h is not the upper limit if you can cut out the middleman. Speaking of which, I've heard third-hand horror stories of Polish SAP contractors where the middleman(!) made 65 EUR/h, which was probably more than half of the client paid - ouch.
- lordnacho 9y agoO-ring sounds reasonable. Also, consider what kinds of firms hire these professionals. For almost all professions, there are firms that do what the profession is called. There are accountancy firms that do specialist account. There are law firms that do specialist law. And there are software firms that make software ordinary firms don't make. But then there are also firms that happen to have a lawyer, and accountant, and a software developer. They might be some industry firm like a widget manufacturer. In these firms, the professional is not quite the most important resource. Sure, you need some, but you don't think of widget factory as requiring the top professionals. Often you'll hear the firm considered as a sort of lifestyle choice: less stressful than the law/accountancy/software house. And of course if you need specialist help you'll know which external firm to get it from.
- banku_brougham 9y agoTo the puzzle about developer comp outstripping EE or other engineering disciplines pay (ie Civil Engineering god help me), I agree that the student in those fields could apply themselves to become able programmers. So why the huge disparity in pay? I have two ideas: 1. Lots of technically able people still don’t enjoy plugging their mind into a machine. Its probably hard to believe in the HN community but many people don’t enjoy the work, I’ve met a few. Maybe its too abstract or boring, its a mystery to me. 2. What multiple is the market putting on the ‘tech industry’ vs semiconductors or mineral extraction? We can actually look that up. AMZN 220; MSFT 69; FB 33; SOXX 4.7; XOM 25. Investors are paying more to fund the work of programmers than most other industries.
- xyzzyz 9y agoAMZN 220; MSFT 69; FB 33; SOXX 4.7; XOM 25. Investors are paying more to fund the work of programmers than most other industries. Large compensations enjoyed by engineers in the AMZN, FB, or MSFT is not derived from "investors paying more to fund their work", as these companies haven't been dependent on investors' capital in a long time.
- chrisweekly 9y ago"Investors paying more to fund [developers'] work" strikes me as the wrong perspective for analyzing compensation. As an alternative, consider "revenue generated per developer". Anecdote: I worked on a team where gross revenues per FT software engineer were north of $4 million USD.
- banku_brougham 9y agoInvestors float the stock to levels that alllow the company to pay generous compensation. At amazon for example, salary tops out at $160K. 1/2 or more of comp is in RSUs. Senior Devs are making $300+ in total comp.
- meuk 9y agoI recently started working as a programmer and don't like it. I started coding when I was about twelve, and did a CS bachelor and CE master. I like coding. I don't like, however, my work as a programmer. The tasks are just too mundane. I spend multiple days on a RESTful CRUD controller, just because there are so many (IMO useless and even obfuscating) layers of abstraction. The only challenging aspect is the lack of conventions and documentation.
- jandrewrogers 9y agoYes, it is. And the example used in the article of chemical engineering reinforces the point. It ties into computer science quite nicely. To become a chemical engineer, you first have to complete the course work for a degree in chemistry. Chemistry as chemistry is an extremely modular subject matter; you can solve most problems in discrete steps in isolation. In a computer science sense, chemistry is about pure functions. Very easy to analyze, as material side effects (like spontaneous detonation) are rare. Chemical engineering, on the other hand, is about analyzing systems that leak their state everywhere and have effects that feedback into other parts of the system. But it needs to be extremely efficient nonetheless. There is no isolation because it doesn't exist in real-world complex systems. I have seen excellent chemists absolutely fail to grok chemical engineering even though it is literally the same subject matter. The only difference is that chemical engineers are required to reason about complex distributed systems; as with computer science, only a minority of practitioners ever seem to grok it despite their best efforts. Same problem, different domain. And chemical engineers are paid on a different scale than chemists as a result. In engineering, bimodal distributions are the sorting of people that naturally have the ability to easily reason about complex distributed systems with many concurrent moving parts and people that cannot. Increasingly, the market is discriminating on this characteristic and it is reflected in wages. Anecdotally, it is somewhat well-known that people competent at chemical engineering find advanced software engineering to be intuitive; it is a very easy second "language" to pick up. An inordinate number of chemical engineers end up in high paying software engineering careers -- it comes very naturally and lends itself to the abstract analytical toolset you develop as a chemical engineer.
- bjourne 9y agoTbt, I haven't seen that much evidence that correlates developer ability with salary. For example, developers living in the Silicon Valley are paid the most. Not because they are the best, but because they are living in the Silicon Valley. Geographical factors play a much bigger role in compensation than developer ability.
- vemv 9y agoBut that 'greater' SV salary for a junior developer can give you less purchasing power than a 'lower' salary for a senior somewhere in Europe, due to cost of living. Granted, money is 'absolute' if you use it to e.g travel around the world, but most people don't do that. In general money is 'relative' to one's environment.
- deorder 9y agoIn the Netherlands the average salary for a senior developer is 40.000$ (~24.000 after taxes) while the cost of living is not that much different from the UK and US, may be except for healthcare. What exactly justifies the difference?
- gota 9y agoI'd guess this is due to the million aspects that configure that purposefully abstract 'Quality of life' metric. In the end, it all comes down to: why are these people, who could do it, not moving from the Netherlands to the UK or US? They are probably 'comfortable' in the Netherlands, whatever that means.
- maximumkek 9y agoTry to compare the profit per tech company in Netherlands vs the US. I claim the stakes are higher in the US so they are better paid.
- js8 9y agoMaybe the whole U.S. is becoming bimodal, geographically. I also think that the software "productivity" is in fact "multiplicative". That is, more software written means more complexity which takes more SW engineers to maintain. I actually think that there might be too much software. This is similar to lawyers, who can generate more work for other lawyers (supply generates its own demand). Weapons also have this property.
- dx034 9y ago> Maybe the whole U.S. is becoming bimodal, geographically. That's been the case for at least a century. A lot of people at the coasts with few in the middle.
- indubitable 9y agoThere seem to be a couple of major similarities between software development and other jobs with bimodal incomes: - You do a job that is, in many cases, a company itself. Lawyers, doctors, and developers can all start independent operations since the product of their work, or the service they provide, is monetizable in and of itself. - There is a very significant skill gap, often driven by enthusiasm at least as much as intelligence, that people rarely transition between. Compare these fields against something like electrical engineering. There the skill itself is generally a part of a product, rather than a marketable skill in and of itself making independent work difficult. And I don't know that many electrical engineers, but I'm unsure how big of a skill gap there is and, more importantly, what percent of engineers manage to transition upwards in it. If one electrical engineer is, more or less, the same as another - then you're going to see that reflected in income distributions which I would expect look more bell curvy weighted mostly by just years of experience.
- collyw 9y ago"There is a very significant skill gap, often driven by enthusiasm" Honestly I think its more down to experience. I know relatively inexperienced developers chasing every new tech on the hype train. And I know others that have been around a while and recognise the new tech as a rehash of something from 20 years ago, with some new marketing. (To be fair I think you need some enthusiasm as well as the experience otherwise you get the "1 year of experience ten times" developers).
- billysielu 9y agoDeveloper salaries in the UK are very modest. Companies don't even know how to identify good developers, so they have no hope of competing over them.
- expertentipp 9y agoThey filter out the people by offering less and less, for shorter and shorter contract periods. After a period of intense job search in UK couple of years ago, I'm still receiving recruitment mail (or spam?) for "initial 2 weeks contract" in Angular/React with "an option to extend" - I'd just have to relocate to London:D
- fahadkhan 9y agoAccording to www.itjobswatch.co.uk a senior Java developer earns £70k. But can command day rate of £575. That works out at about double. Suggestion it is bimodal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 9y agoIt contractors and engineering contractors in the UK have always been able to demand a decent multiplier for contract work 2-3x normaly. Though some industries (advertising publishing marketing) that formerly did not have to consider on technical excellence and where used to relaying of cheap Oxbridge liberal arts students with a 1st seem to want to pay temp technical roles at straight time instead of the real contractor day rate.
- Helmet 9y agoYeah, but given current exchange rates £70k is ~$100k. ~100k is nothing to sneeze at...
- baud147258 9y agoApparently, UK IT salaries are still above those in France, even if there is an (apparent) lack of IT professionals in the current market. Source (in French): http://bfmbusiness.bfmtv.com/emploi/metiers-du-numerique-les-talents-francais-sont-sous-payes-1369156.html http://bfmbusiness.bfmtv.com/emploi/metiers-du-numerique-les...
- yuzulicious 9y agoAlmost all professional and semi-professional salaries are becoming bimodal. I'm too tired at the moment to look this up, but the NY Times had a piece sometime in the last couple of years where they were discussing income distributions, and had an interactive, and what they looked like, almost across the board, was a bigger lower mode, and then a second, smaller, more spiked mode much higher. What struck me about that piece was that it was framed in terms of skewed incomes, but the bimodality of it didn't get discussed much at all, nor the fact it was so widespread across different disciplines. To me it was very disturbing, because it suggested that there was a growth, across disciplines, of two "classes", one established, with a relatively large income, and another, larger class, with a much smaller income. I was very curious about this, and have wondered what the groups are--if it's because of older, senior individuals and younger, junior individuals. Maybe the latter are trainees? Maybe the latter came into the labor market at a less favorable time? Maybe there's just a kind of winner-takes-all sort of phenomenon? It was really disturbing to me, and seems difficult to explain in terms of any specific features of any field, because it was so, so widespread across labor areas. It was partially disturbing that it was sitting right here in these graphs at a major news outlet about income distributions, and was not being acknowledged even then. It was probably more disturbing to me than the general long-tailed skewed income distribution that gets discussed, because it suggested (at least to me) very unnatural about how incomes were being allocated, even more so than the stereotypical long-tailed but unimodal curve.
- jgtrosh 9y agoI can imagine a simple explanation where one mode of gratification aims to pay as low as possible to keep the workforce willing to work at all, and another mode is to use pay amount to avoid talent from going away. Pay is thought about and used differently in both modes, and it's a simple enough management pattern that it could translate to every field. This is an over simplistic hypothesis and it would need more info to confirm but it seems potentially reasonable to me.
- tclancy 9y agoI think that's true from the management side. I also think it reflects personalities on the employee side: you have to be able to risk rejection and possibly worse to ask for a significant raise which means you either need to be very risk tolerant or in a situation where you can afford to fail.
- nullc 9y agoGoods distributed as software and, to a lesser degree, online services have phenomenal scaling leverage arising from very low marginal costs. I can write some software publish it and in a matter of months have it improving the lives of hundreds of millions of people. Engineering aptitude is rare, or at least we haven't learned how to mass produce high end engineering aptitude. It's hard to argue that any other domain of engineering has anywhere near the kind of leverage that software does. Automation has also radically improved the effectiveness of top software performers. Even a one man 'team' with a moderate level of skill can have pretty comprehensive set of automated tests. There is design automation in other engineering fields, of course, but it's especially potent for software because the automation can capture basically everything and because software engineering is also the skill needed to improve the automation itself. Some of the bimodality may be due to binning what really is functionally separate fields under one name. I've known people who were great at wiring up prefabricated functions to build UIs and simple processes, but wouldn't have constructed a novel datastructure if their lives depended on it. It's hard to draw bright lines because there is a bit of continuum and people grow and change... but there seem to be some pretty distinct categories out there.
- xstartup 9y ago1. You do not need a degree - This puts more pressure on the developers who are employed, now they've to face pressure from uncredentialed people who for some reason fell in love with the software craft. So, quite a lot of people feel inadequate and practice relentlessly to keep their skills sharp, improving visibility. Some are practicing DS/Algo daily while contributing to opensource, improving their GitHub. Boosting productivity, driving up revenue. 2. Taught the wrong way - The CS degree way is bad outside of a few key institutions. Everything which is taught sounds too abstract and complex. It's simply not taught well. The candidates from those key institutions will not take a low ball offer, they'll prefer being unemployed or going into business chasing their dreams. Most are from well off background. This keeps supply low. 3. Greenfield - After working at a software compare, you'll realize that making a new small business around software is not that hard. Afterall, the dumb people who give you requirements are doing it, how difficult can it be? So, after gaining bit some expertise, you are able to set yourself free. I don't think this is possible in other professions without taking a massive hit in compensation. With my new companies, I am always confident that we'll be 100% successful. I wouldn't have gone to pursue it if I didn't believe success was evident. Lots of smart folks leave for their dream, leaving non-experts in the workforce. So, the money is chasing very small pool of candidates. 4. Robbers - After working at the small business, you'll quickly realize that skill matter much less in business. To make a ton of money, you'll have to be at the right place and at the right time, yea getting to that place does require some skill. You'll find some guys have found a way to convince millions of users to upload their pics on your website and you can sell their data to advertisers making tons of money in the process. This is all new and regulators have no idea what to do, there are no rules - so you rig auction in your favor, yet winning more money from advertisers. There is potential to do lot more evil in CS. There are some companies who have built massive leverage. If you do not work for them, you'll simply do not earn much regardless of your skills. 5. Hire more coders what whatever cost - Once startup is growing is growing, you'll find that you need to exploit faster and simplest way to to do is leverage opensource, existing vendors, investment etc... You've no time to reinvent the wheel, the reservoir of nearly infinite free money will not wait for you. So, you'll hire plenty of smart coders at whatever price, you'll use wizard level DS/Algo questions and experience in gluing tons of different opensource technology/vendors etc... If still there are some holes, no problem, contracting someone is the last resort. Here is the biggest cost alone is time. So, companies are willing to bet as high as possible or risk being unseated. 6. Fast nearly free exponential distribution, creating a copy of iPhone still need some labor, distributing same software to 100K people need much less effort. The software scales faster. We design a system to scale 10x by default. How many other manufacturing plants can scale 10x? 6. Leverage ecosystem - Opensource technology/Vendors/Investors/ and internet is the fastest medium to advertise. The biggest thing -> Lack of regulation. No, one is verifying your code to make sure that it's not doing anything evil or not extracting something from a user which you didn't have a permit for.
- stablemap 9y agoLots of discussion in 2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12588202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12588202
- athenot 9y agoI think the reason for high compensations is that software is the enabling factor for capital. If software can automate, reduce inefficiencies and generally be the means to accomplish the business goal, then it makes sense for the business side to invest heavily into what is essentially a competitive differentiator. The bimodal compensation reflects a growing split between software activities that are seen as an necessary operational burden, and those which are the "secret sauce" of the business. That's why fintech has traditionally been the highest paying field, as the return on investment is the most obvious for them. Edit: typo (thanks tzahola!)
- tzahola 9y agoYou meant "increase efficiencies" or "reduce inefficiencies".
- meri_dian 9y agoThis seems like a key component of the answer. Of course, salaries are largely determined by the industry one is in. If you can position yourself at a place in the economy that attracts large amounts of money (per person) then you will be able to siphon off a relatively large amount for yourself. As software embeds itself in everything we do, developer earning potential will reflect the industry one is in. High tech firms like Apple and Google make huge amounts of money per employee, so people that work for them make huge amounts of money too. Not just software developers, but also people in sales and strategy, etc. Same for people in finance.
- geodel 9y agoI agree. I wonder why people do not make this correlation more often that cloud/fintech companies etc have likely put huge number of people out of work across the world. And disproportional chunk of that compensation has been collected by cloud companies and their employees.
- masen 9y agoit is could because it is easy to build your own startup in software industry in the US without the i18n for eu.
- YPCrumble 9y agoA good answer to why software pays more than industries like law or medicine is that profit per employee in software is enormous. Of the 12 American companies on this chart of the highest profit per employee, 6 are software companies: http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-facebook-alphabet-most-profitable-companies-per-employee-2017-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-facebook-alphabet-most-... I would love to hear an economist explain why this might or might not lead to higher salaries. My hypothesis is there is an element of human nature: if you're rolling in cash you don't have to be stingy.
- MagnumOpus 9y agoHigh profit per employee leads to a higher divergence in salaries - same as it does for industries like financial trading and research. If profit per "average" developer is $1 million, then the company is way better off paying $100k extra (i.e. double) to get developers that are 20% more productive than the average - and if the company doesn't do that, then their best people get poached by companies who do. And while it is impossible to hire the mythical "10x developer", it is not all that hard to find the "1.2x developers" if you are willing to pay double to get them...
- TwoFactor 9y agoI'm not sure that list is a fair way to determine an industry's profit per employee. Law firms aren't allowed to form C corps, which limits their size and would keep them off that list. I would expect top law firms to be in those ranges in for profit per employee, but they're much smaller so it isn't a fair comparison. 2 of the top 6 in that list are in medicine.
- heedlessly2 9y agoat my university's law school, which is a T14, the average starting salary is 125-150k. Which is a lot, but not as much when considering that most law grads have mountains of debt plus the opportunity cost of not being the workforce for 3 years. Plus they average 55+ hours per week. And usually cannot work from home. You're better off doing CS undergrad and working for a Big 10. The hours are on average and can be flexible if you're an efficient worker.
- ataturk 9y agoThe reasons underlying the bi-modality are pretty clear to me. There are a couple of major factors at play: 1) Inflation. My starting salary out of college many years ago was $35K. Today's starting salaries are double that. Double in less than 20 years. A $50K salary in the early 1980s is equivalent to $120K today, not controlling for geographic location--HCOL areas are actually far worse than that. Let that sink in as you plan for retirement. My take is that you are never going to save enough for retirement because inflation is insidious and never sleeps. 2) The mythology of the higher salary range. How do developers get past that second mode? They start their own company! Only a few rarified corporate people and independent consultants can pull down pay in the 200s. Again, I'm not thinking about SV where the pay is so skewed due to the HCOL. So everyone else works a number of years and ends up in the 120s-150s and they think they are doing great, but they really aren't (me included) due to #1. Any way you look at doing software development as a career you come to see that it stinks. I'm not going to recommend it to my kids. I think it's important to know how computers work and how code works and not to be afraid of tinkering with those things or coming to believe that you have no control over it, but as a business, it's nasty and getting nastier.
- Kephael 9y ago> Only a few rarified corporate people and independent consultants can pull down pay in the 200s New grads at Facebook who received a return offer as an intern get a bit over 200k/yr total comp. to start. > Any way you look at doing software development as a career you come to see that it stinks. I don't see how being able to make several hundred thousand dollars a year with a few years of experience while working at a major company in a safe and clean environment is a bad choice.
- workthrowaway27 9y ago> Any way you look at doing software development as a career you come to see that it stinks. I'm not going to recommend it to my kids. What are the alternatives though? Lawyers work much longer hours and only the ones who went to top schools and get into top firms make more. Doctors make more but have 6+ more years of education and training. Finance is competitive and also has long hours. Programmers have it pretty good.
- notacoward 9y agoIt would be interesting to see if compensation is bimodal within a market. There's clearly a bimodal distribution between the US and the rest of the world, and has been for a long time. I think we're also moving toward a bimodal distribution between the top five or ten unicorns and everyone else even in the US. Quite simply, the companies with billions to spend are bidding up the price of talent willing to work there, while growth for everyone else remains slow. While the same has happened with fintech for a while, that has remained too small to show up on graphs. MAGA/FAANG/whatever, on the other hand, are collectively large enough to create a very visible second peak. There are effectively two markets now. People don't expect to carry their compensation packages from one side of that fence to the other. I should know, since I made such a transition myself within the past year. In terms of effect on personal income, it's not that different than changing careers.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoYep, I switched from fintech to another industry (still software development) and took roughly a 50% paycut to do so. It let me live in a much nicer part of the country (given my non-work interests), but I might go back since the pay is so much more.
- aphextron 9y ago>Another possibility is that U.S. immigration laws act as a protectionist barrier to prop up programmer compensation. It seems impossible for this to last (why shouldn’t there by really valuable non-U.S. companies), but it does appear to be somewhat true for now. I feel like this is the real issue here. The reason that the US has great companies is simply from the availability of large amounts of capital. And if the millions and millions of Indian, Chinese, and Eastern European programmers who are inifinitely more talented/driven/intelligent/educated than myself were able to simply move here and seek employment with no immigration restraints, I know that I would be out of a job instantly. In that sense it feels perversly exploitative and priveleged to make so much more money than practically anyone else on earth due to nothing but the physical location I was born.
- jcadam 9y agoTruth be told, most software development doesn't require a high amount of intelligence, skill, or innate talent. I'm not afraid of a superior person taking my job. They would be no better at it than I am. I would probably be more productive if I were less intelligent (or on booze, but employers frown on that).
- ryanianian 9y agoThis is wrong. Even simple software requires a radically different way of thinking than the way most are trained. I've taught 6th graders how to code and it is clear that the way of approaching problems and creating solutions (i.e. creative thinking, intellectual curiosity, and willingness to collaborate and ask questions) really separates the students from who "get it" and thse who don't. Don't sell it short because the industry has made tools and languages that abstract over some of the simpler concepts for entry-level tasks.
- randomdata 9y agoPerhaps he means in relation to other careers? As someone who is both a software developer and a farmer, software isn't exactly easy, but in comparison to the knowledge and skill required to farm successfully, it is a breeze.
- jcadam 9y agoYes, this is true. At some point which I seem to be unable to identify in retrospect, I became too expensive for about 2/3 of the market. Ah well.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- foamflower 9y agoOne (semi-pedantic) quibble with the article: there absolutely are barriers to entry for programming. Programming is hard! These barriers may not be artificial, but they are real. To use a non-software example, there are barriers to entry to chip manufacturers and power companies even under anarchy. Fabs are tremendously hard to build. Power plants are extremely hard to build. Building up knowledge and skills about computers is also very hard, especially when our genes don't seem to guide us toward thinking highly logically. And programming is hard because it requires us to understand a bunch of modular systems and then the systems they're built on, all the way down, and in some cases, all the way up. Then, we have to understand the whole integrated system of the individual modules. Not all programming problems require this level of difficulty, but these problems do exist. I've been on teams where I'm the only one who understands what the OS is doing or the CPU is doing or what the network is doing or why some other distributed component might have stopped working. Most of my teammates in these cases seemed to enjoy programming, but didn't care to become overall experts in computers as a whole. I once had a top-tier business school grad friend claim that programming really isn't that hard and that we're all whiners. He is a genuinely smart person. Today, he himself is trying to code in JavaScript on the client side. He's a friend so I help him, but the problems he has are junior-level or even entry-level. Suffice it to say, I haven't heard much more about how programmers are "whiners" when we say programming is hard.
- Clubber 9y agoNot only is it hard, but the landscape changes frequently. You wouldn't design a system like you designed it pre-mobile, and you wouldn't design a system pre-mobile like you designed it pre-internet, and those are just the big shifts. Cloud is another big shift. A lot of people read how so and so design a system. So and so is successful, so I will design my systems that way. That's rarely ideal. Also, designs can change company to company, depending on what the company structure is, who they serve, etc. Designs can change when a company changes, so hopefully your software can change with it. Sometimes you inherit a bad system, so how do you fix it while keeping your releases in stride. That's not easy, especially when then original designers aren't there anymore. Speaking of which, what's the best release stride for this company? You might have to adjust design for that too. Was this weird code done on purpose, is it a bug, or were they trying to hack around a mistake somewhere else? Time to roll the dice, because you need to change it. How do you minimize the collateral damage if you are wrong? You also need to consider your limitations like network and persistence storage. That's a huge part that many haven't even considered yet. How are networks designed today? How is data persistence designed today? What are my options and what are my limitations with this company? What type of reports does this company need? That's a big one. How about failover, what does your system do when the network or database quits? Do you lose any data? Are you sure? How important is it to not lose data? It's not that bad if Facebook loses a post, but it sure is bad if a bank loses half of a transaction. Programming has a lot of levels that we don't even realize until we hit a new one. Turning good specs into working code is level 1. It takes a hell of a lot of brainpower and abstract thinking to just do that.
- coldtea 9y ago>Another possibility is that U.S. immigration laws act as a protectionist barrier to prop up programmer compensation So, US operating as a country (an entity with citizens, which it prioritizes other foreigners) rather than some arbitrary free-for-all geographical space?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- adultSwim 9y agoIt has long been bifurcated. Most of us are working shlubs making a fraction of what A-list companies pay. Among us on the B-team are some (but certainly not all) very talented engineers.
- sjg007 9y agoIt's probably a function of going to a brand name school + killing the Google style interviews. If you do that and have multiple offers you probably get the average up. SV in general is nuts wrt to housing and rent so that's going to steadily push things up as well. Then certain markets are winner take all so it makes some sense to "over" pay for talent. This would create a bimodal distribution as well. If you work as a software eng in a biotech your pay will probably be less than at Google on average b/c the biotech has less need for a highly qualified say distributed systems engineer. So they will accept a different candidate out of the talent pool. Also the talent may want to work at the biotech for reasons other intangible reasons. H1B is just a guarantee for some employees over some term. So H1B sets the bottom of the market really. There is no reason to work a job or somewhere that pays less than an H1B level wage unless you've got some crazy stock options or something.
- alkonaut 9y agoIsn't part of the bimodality here just a "Silicon Valley Effect", where a few companies in a few very expensive areas compete for talent that has to pay ever more for housing? If one factors out the major tech hubs and only look at e.g. any random city, is the bimodality there too?
- workthrowaway27 9y agoThis is the most perceptive comment in the thread. Based on moving from NYC to a much smaller metro area without any major tech companies I think you're right. Compensation here is roughly half of NYC compensation. The big tech firms are driving the high salaries. I'm sure you'd see the same pattern if you looked at finance grads. The top ones who went to work for investment banks, hedge funds, etc. are pulling down large salaries, the rest are making much less working for small to medium size companies.
- southphillyman 9y agoI believe the article addressed this with the Madison WI example. The high paying company in Madison was still Google, but if they are paying above average salaries to 100 engineers in a city that may only have 1000 that's still a significant spike in a "random city"
- vinceguidry 9y agoThe article gives as a potential reason for high developer compensation the possibility of a shortage of talent. That seems obvious to me, but the author goes on to suggest that if there was a shortage, you'd be seeing more people go into development. Does this actually happen? My understanding is that skill supply is simply not elastic in this way. Kids generally pick what to do based on their aptitude and what they like to do, remuneration is a distant secondary concern. Changing careers is something people only do when they absolutely have to. It appears altogether clear to me that supply and demand explains programming compensation perfectly, and that these dynamics aren't going to go away any time soon, for the same reason doctor and lawyer compensation stays healthy, lawyers less so.
- ryanianian 9y agoI've seen lots of teen-aged students take up an interest in coding simply because they heard it was a well-paying and in-demand career. It's no longer a nerd thing to do living in your parents' basement. This has likely steered some students who otherwise might have found a niche in other fields to try out coding and choose it as a career (out of both satisfaction and salary prospects).
- sevensor 9y ago> It appears altogether clear to me that supply and demand explains programming compensation perfectly My thoughts exactly. Demand for programming is growing faster than the supply of programmers. Not only is demand growing because ever more devices demand an ever-growing amount of software, but also because every already existing line of code in production needs somebody to keep it from falling over. This compounding effect further escalates demand.
- southphillyman 9y ago>My understanding is that skill supply is simply not elastic in this way. Kids generally pick what to do based on their aptitude and what they like to do, Right. You see this in 1st year CS major attrition rates and programming related MOOC completion rates.
- salmonfamine 9y agoI think the explanation for bimodal dev salaries is pretty clear, and is similar to the explanation for the bi-modality in Lawyer salaries. Google, Facebook, Amazon, and whatever other big name you want to throw in the pot, are competing for developers. However, they are not competing for the same developers as Epic Systems, for example. FAANG (or whatever) are competing for a highly skilled subset of devs that can meet their demanding hiring criteria. Similarly, top law firms are only competing for a subset of all law grads -- those that meet their demanding hiring criteria. The difference here is that, in law, that criteria is focused around a prestigious degree. Presumably, this is because it is hard to thoroughly test a lawyer's competency as a lawyer in an interview setting. However, in programming, many top companies, apparently, find that a series of intense whiteboard interviews are sufficient to determine whether or not a dev meets their high standard. However, we also have a shortage of devs across the board, for all companies. If CS enrollment increased by 100%, then presumably the "lower" distribution of salaries would stabilize at a lower number -- probably close to what traditional engineers make nowadays. However, the salaries of the GooBooks of the world will only be affected if a sufficiently high proportion of those grads can meet a very difficult hiring criteria. Similarly, law schools have seen a dramatic increase in enrollment over the past few decades. Lower salaries have stabilized, since the market is now saturated. However, the salaries for top law firms remain high, because a similarly low number of candidates meet their difficult hiring criteria: Harvard, Yale, and etc. are producing more or less the same number of law grads as before, with respect to demand. This is why Google can open an office across the street from Epic and yet still pay devs twice as much. This is also why I don't think immigration is a huge factor. Sure, if companies were able to immigrate significantly more workers, then salaries at top companies might drop to a degree. But the real drop would be seen in the salaries of devs at typical companies. EDIT: grammar
- dhd415 9y agoI think skill differentials in programming is a contributing factor to the bimodal distribution. I think there's also another factor which is the degree to which one is an active "curator" of one's own career. I've known some devs who were quite talented but were perfectly content to stay at low-paying jobs where the value they generated for their companies for developing CRUD or other low-multiplier apps was moderate. Others who were much more deliberate about developing skills in areas of software where much higher multiples were possible and choosing jobs strategically to build their careers made MUCH more money than the former despite not necessarily being more technically skilled. These latter developers are much more likely to be the ones working at FAANGs (or whatever) for $200k+.
- SkyPuncher 9y agoPerhaps anecdotal, but my opinion is this basically comes down to two general types of workers: those who know what competitive salary rates are and those who don't or don't care. The first category knows exactly what they're worth and they'll push to get that worth. They know that if their current company won't pay that, they'll easily find another company that will. They end up switching jobs relatively frequently and get a raise each time. On the flip side, you have the people that simply don't pursue higher salaries. They tend to get a job and stick with it for a long time. They'll take the 2 to 3% COL adjustments and an occasional promotions, but typically they'll stay with a company for years. While they certainly could find a better paying position, they won't. Perhaps because they like the lifestyle, the type of work, or even unaware that other companies are paying significantly better.
- expertentipp 9y agoIn most of the EU one hits the local ceiling and that’s it. There are very few regions where the ceiling is above 100k EUR, in most regions it’s much lower.
- duderific 9y agoThat's pretty reductionist. There are more factors that go into choosing a job than the salary. Commute time, work life balance, perks, liking the people you work with, quality of the work, etc. It's a balance between all these aspects and the salary.
- m3kw9 9y agoYeah there things are starting g to be filtered down to just easy and very hard in software. Easy is when all the high level apis helping us to a lot of work on easy tasks. The hard part is when you really want to customize it and have many different parts work together nicely and workable. So there is a big gap in knowledge between those 2, hence we sometimes get bimodal payments.
- mizzao 9y agoThere's a difference between a bimodal and a distribution with a long tail (like a lognormal). The new hire distribution doesn't really give a sense of this because there's an implicit cap to how much companies are willing to pay new hires.
- jtolmar 9y ago> The most common response I’ve gotten to this post is that we should expect programmers to be well-paid because software is everywhere and there will be at least as much software in the future. [...] Yet electrical engineering comp isn’t in the same league as programmer comp, [...] and there are more processors sold than ever before. What drives the demand for engineers isn't the number of things sold, but rather the number of kinds of that thing. The variety of chips is still growing, but not proportionate to chips sold, because the numbers are mostly coming from the handful of chips used in servers and mobile devices. > What is it about some software companies that make a similar amount of money that prevents them from funneling virtually all of the wealth they generate up to the top? We don't have a union, so the only way a company can be punished for low compensation is if developers leave for higher-compensation companies. Salaries in the games industry are much lower for longer hours, because developers are unwilling to leave the industry to go work on something boring. I don't know the specific case with Epic Systems, but if their employees are older (have families) they might be less willing to relocate. I also know (being from there) that people from Wisconsin have a specific aversion to leaving the state, and it could be that Epic is exploiting that fact.
- badpun 9y ago>> The most common response I’ve gotten to this post is that we should expect programmers to be well-paid because software is everywhere and there will be at least as much software in the future. [...] Yet electrical engineering comp isn’t in the same league as programmer comp, [...] and there are more processors sold than ever before. > What drives the demand for engineers isn't the number of things sold, but rather the number of kinds of that thing. The variety of chips is still growing, but not proportionate to chips sold, because the numbers are mostly coming from the handful of chips used in servers and mobile devices. This. What matters here is not ubiquitousness of software, but rather it's bespoke nature. Every major corporation is employing thousands of developers (either in house or via some outsourcing arrangement) to write and maintain software according to the company's unique needs. This is the most important driver of demand for developers, and what differentiates us from other technical fields.
- geodel 9y agoMaybe it is not polite to talk about but I do not think most of Epic systems, or any generic IT employee can simply be hired by Google if they are willing to move where Google offices are present. Most people I know in IT industry understand this deeply even if not talk openly that their 1/4-1/2 of Google pay is decent case scenario. It is also reinforced by the fact average salary for software engineer in valley is about $120K and not $500K + unlimited meals, bus rides and what not. People here are select bunch and talk about 500K pay so often, it starts to look common when clearly it is not.
- cimmanom 9y agoHypothesis: there aren't two clearly differently skilled populations of programmers. There are two different populations of companies that are willing to pay different amounts. Lower pay being at startups and large non-technology companies in lower-cost-of-living markets; high being at the big prestigious tech firms, banks, and the like.
- Terr_ 9y agoYeah, I'm kind of disappointed to see this interpretation so far down. Bimodal compensation probably says more about corporations than it does about innate skill issues.
- User23 9y agoWhy do companies pay so much for computer programmers? Because on average they make a massive net profit per programmer, that's why. There aren't many other fields where one person can increase productivity by orders of magnitude. When was the last time a clever doctor reduced the number of nurses required to handle a fixed number of patients by a factor of a hundred? Good developers do this routinely!
- doktrin 9y agoOddly,this is only even potentially true in the US. The rest of the world, including Europe, pays devs at the low end of the distribution showed here.
- adventured 9y agoI was curious which countries (out of the wealthier developed economies), for programmers, are the most out of line vs the median income for that country (based on a full-time job median wage). The best are the US, Denmark, Israel. Germany has a higher median income than the UK, but the UK pays better in programming. Sweden's median income is quite a bit higher than both Germany and the UK, but Germany and the UK pay close to what Sweden does. Canada is at half the rate of the US, drastically below where it should be based on median incomes. The worst is France by a wide margin. The average software engineer salary there is around $38,000. Almost one third that of the US. Switzerland pays very high (still below the US), but their median income is extremely high. New Zealand has a considerably lower median income these days versus Australia, but only pays about 15% less for programmers than what Australia does.
- egman_ekki 9y agoWould be interesting to hear what data sources you used. There was an article on bloomberg about the same metric, but it's 404 now. Seems like the data has been used in this map, though: http://ramiro.org/map/world/income-software-engineers-countries/ http://ramiro.org/map/world/income-software-engineers-countr... (Results are quite different to yours, but this data is 4 yrs old)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mr_toad 9y ago‘Another possibility is that programming is uniquely hard in some way, but that seems implausible to me.’ Seems to be the fatal flaw in the article.
- doktrin 9y agoI wonder if it's possible to put a $ value on how much impostor syndrome has benefitted employers. I suspect it's in the billions, but that's little more than a hunch.
- nojvek 9y agoI just want to say I really love how simple his site is and how fast it loaded. Visual aesthetic not so much but UX is amazing. I definitely want to read more sites like this focused on simplicity of the content.
- __bjoernd 9y agoQuite a long piece of text for that he essentially says that he doesn't have enough data to answer the question. Also: if your article is headed with a question, the answer usually is no.
- krschultz 9y ago"One possibility is that we have a shortage of programmers. If that’s the case, you’d expect more programmers to enter the field, bringing down compensation." This is true. I was a mechanical engineer professionally. I moved into software engineering, and the increase in compensation was a dominant factor. I know several other non-CS engineers that have made the same move. While it's not driving down compensation per-say, the difference in demand between disciplines is startling.
- SZJX 9y agoI think the simplest explanation is that the number of jobs has been exploding but the number of people who really know their stuffs isn't keeping up. It takes time for any population to adjust to a new situation. Surely it's hard to master EE etc. as well but how many companies really need EE engineers anyways. I've been keeping explaining to others that in EE etc. many probably get a PhD before they apply for a job in a company like Intel or maybe at least a second-rate OEM company which truly needs somebody to design/test their hardware, while literally every company needs somebody who can program. The talk of "not understanding" this thing just sounds like exaggerated posturing. I don't think there's anything very hard to grasp about it. The situation might well change in a few years with the maturation of AI-based program generation technologies and the saturation of population. We'll just have to see. Also most foreign programmers actually already have to pay a fortune (many via their rich parents) to study in the US in the first place before they get the OPT/visa, so they already came from rich families and it's a kind of like the situation with lawyers/consultants/financiers where such an elitist circle gets elitist pay as well.