41 ms·
Dozens of Companies Are Using Facebook to Exclude Older Workers From Job Ads
- golemiprague 9y agoI think all those laws are stupid, people will hire whoever they want, you can't force people to hire someone they don't really want. They should let companies discriminate as much as they want, if someone is valuable they will find a job, if not they won't. At the end of the day there are x amount of positions to fill up and y amount of people to fill those positions. Why do we care who is actually going to get the job, at the end of the day all people are equal and someone is going to miss, who said the old guy suppose to get it rather than the young?
- derekp7 9y agoIs this different than advertising in a magazine that has a specific reader demographic? Or would that get a company in trouble too, if a the court rules that the intent was to exclude a given group?
- danso 9y agoIt's against U.S. federal law for employers to discriminate against people aged 40-or-over on the basis of age. Having job ads that only younger people could see would seemingly fall afoul of that law: https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/adea.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/adea.cfm
- aggie 9y agoAnyone can pick up a magazine. The question is whether you can put an ad in Young People Monthly because you know it's likely to skew your audience in the direction you want. Without knowing much about the actual law, it seems like an area ripe for gray area maneuvering. Specifically ad-targeting to 20-35 year olds seems like a much more clear violation of the rules, simply because it is explicit.
- derekp7 9y agoIs there any case law regarding this when it comes to physical publications? Because that case law could come into play in deciding the Facebook case. Hypothetical example: a local employer puts up a job flyer at a college campus, but does not put the flyer up at the senior center across town. I could see a court ruling this illegal, if the employer did this specifically to try to attract younger workers.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoSeniors can still go to the college campus and see it. These ads are completely not shown by the system. Not a perfect comparison.
- greglindahl 9y agoSome college students are senior citizens.
- dantheman 9y agoI guess the question of targeting different ads at different demographics needs to be answered -- is that ok? Is it ok to recruit at a college job fair?
- ridgeguy 9y agoYes, I would think. While the college job fair demographic is statistically biased to the young, there are people over 40 who go to college. As long as the recruiting opportunity is made known to the over-40s as well as those younger, it would seem ok to recruit at a college job fair. Not ok would be to decline to interview those over 40, keep them from learning about the opportunity, or otherwise exclude them from the process, based on their age.
- baddox 9y agoThere are some older people who go to college, sure, but I would hope that the law concerns itself with the intent and/or the effect of the segmentation. There are probably some younger people who for whatever reason see the Facebook ads for older people too, but the intent of that segmentation is obvious, and I would hope the law would make provisions for that.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoSo Facebook has asked for immunity regarding discriminatory ads, it wasn't clear to me what the status of that was And the presence of a targeted ad doesn't prevent excluded people from actually going to a job posting site. If the job posting site was doing this with people's Facebook session (or other way of knowing age), I would be alarmed and appalled. If a company was doing this on their career site I was be up in arms. But Facebook running ads where some of them happen to be job related ads in the same place that other random ads appear? Ehhhhhhhhh
- smallgovt 9y agoI doubt it runs afoul of that law. Segmentation is a common characteristic of online advertising campaigns. A sophisticated advertiser never shows the same types of ads to young and old audiences (especially on Facebook) because the two audiences react drastically different. If your goal is to run efficient campaigns, you will always separate the two. As a result, the advertiser can simply claim that they separated the two, and then realized they simply couldn't afford the CPC of the older audience (i.e. the ROI didn't make sense). Alternatively, they could just set a very high bid for the older audience and never get any traffic to those segments. Overall, I think you'd be hard pressed to prove discriminatory intent even if it exists.
- tptacek 9y agoThe premise of the CWA lawsuit is that recruiting advertising is not like other advertising, and must comply with anti-discrimination employment law.
- danso 9y agoSomeone quoted in the article does make the case that the federal age employment law does allow for other considerations to a "reasonable" degree when targeting age -- i.e. discrimination isn't as cut-and-dry as it would be for targeting race or gender: > But some companies contend that there are permissible reasons to filter audiences by age, as with an ad for entry-level analyst positions at Goldman Sachs that was distributed to people 18 to 64. A Goldman Sachs spokesman, Andrew Williams, said showing it to people above that age range would have wasted money: roughly 25 percent of those who typically click on the firm’s untargeted ads are 65 or older, but people that age almost never apply for the analyst job... > Pauline Kim, a professor of employment law at Washington University in St. Louis, said the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, unlike the federal anti-discrimination statute that covers race and gender, allows an employer to take into account “reasonable factors” that may be highly correlated with the protected characteristic, such as cost, as long as they don’t rely on the characteristic explicitly.
- Y7ZCQtNo39 9y agoSo they can pay to show the ads to job seekers 40+ but not hire them. Facebook makes more money, and they get to say they did some social good. Seems like they should be advocating (at least in this use case) to stop the discrimination to increase profits.
- gumby 9y agoWell of course they could, just as people advertise jobs or loans to black people and then magically never hire / approve them. There are mechanisms for finding this -- just because it is possible to do, doesn't mean it's legal or fair.
- loeg 9y agoBut curiously, not illegal to discriminate against people under 40 on the basis of age (at least, under the same Federal statute)[0]. If these job ads were targeted at the 40+ demographic only, they would be totally ok. It's even been to the Supreme Court[1]: > In the 2004 decision General Dynamics Land Systems, Inc. v. Cline, the U.S. Supreme Court settled a conflict among the lower courts over the viability of so-called “reverse age discrimination” claims under the ADEA. Reverse age discrimination involves claims by younger employees who allege they have been discriminated against because of their youth. > ... > The Court observed that “if Congress had been worrying about protecting the younger against the older, it would not likely have ignored everyone under forty.” > ... > In the wake of the Cline decision, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued a new rule in July 2007, which specifically addresses reverse age discrimination and provides that employers aren’t liable under the ADEA when they prefer older workers over younger ones. ... > While a help-wanted notice can’t contain terms and phrases that limit or deter the employment of older employees, businesses may lawfully post advertisements that express a preference for older individuals. [0]: https://www.eeoc.gov/youth/age.html https://www.eeoc.gov/youth/age.html [1]: http://www.hrhero.com/hl/articles/2009/10/23/can-employers-discriminate-against-younger-workers/ http://www.hrhero.com/hl/articles/2009/10/23/can-employers-d...
- danso 9y agoI wonder if this one-way protection exists because otherwise it would be legally tenuous to post job ads seeking a minimum number of years of experience (e.g. 10+ years in professional Python development), which basically by definition discriminate against the very young.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoAny chance someone could point to a good explanation as to the argument for how this doesn't fall afoul of the Equal Protection Clause? I found a couple references to Massachusetts Board of Retirement v. Murgia, but the circumstances there seem different enough that the reasoning wouldn't directly translate.
- markbnj 9y agoIf they post the job opportunity on many different sites is it discrimination if one of those sites targets a specific age group? I'm a 57 year-old steadily employed software engineer/SRE so I am definitely in favor of less age discrimination :). I get that FB is a huge market, but for professionals LinkedIn and Indeed are probably just as important.
- 77pt77 9y agoOK. It's illegal. So what? What's going to happen to the companies that clearly engage in it? My guess is nothing and for some reason they think doing this is valuable. The end result is that they'll keep on doing it until it hurts them in any way.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's different in that there's no plausible deniability; the intent, which is critically important in adjudicating whether something is lawful, is laid bare by the Facebook interface.
- rdtsc 9y agoMaybe something in between that and say have a custom version of the magazine for each reader then have job ads customized for person's gender, age, sexual orientation, race etc. At some point that becomes illegal it seems.
- mastry 9y agoThe article mentions this scenario. It points out that anyone can purchase a copy of Teen Vogue (for example) but there's nothing you can do about ads that Facebook won't show you.
- derekp7 9y agoWell technically, anyone could conduct their online activities so that they fit into a profile that makes them look younger. Of course, now that I look at it again, the article did mention having a specific age selector in the ad, so that part I think would be definitely illegal.
- analog31 9y agoPerhaps it's different because it's actionable. For instance, there could be a class action suit on behalf of anybody over 40 who didn't receive the ad. Also, I'm not a lawyer, but as I seem to recall, the "corporate veil" doesn't apply to certain kinds of liability, and I think discrimination is an example.
- matt4077 9y agoThis strikes me as whataboutism... Just because there is a continuum from obviously illegal to obviously legal does not mean it's all tainted by subjectivity and nothing can ever be illegal. Intent matters, and judges and juries, while not perfect, do a reasonable job of assessing it. One factor that usually works in the favour of justice is that lawsuits usually target the companies, and there are always at least some employees who do the calculation and decide not to perjure themselves for the financial benefit of their employer.
- gerdesj 9y agoThe magazine might have a target market but anyone (within reason) can buy/read it.
- conanbatt 9y agoMeh, is it really important. There are many reasons to want younger workers, and there are many reasons you shouldn't want younger workers. I don't find it necessary for the government to step in to help one of the highest paid fields in america.
- tptacek 9y agoYes: it is illegal in the United States to discriminate in favor of younger applicants. Tech isn't exempt from the law because it's "one of the highest paid fields"; in fact, that makes it more important to enforce the law, not less.
- conanbatt 9y agoIts also illegal to carry lobsters of a certain size between states, its doesn't make it important. Being highly paid shows you that there is much competition for labor, which means some might discriminate and some might not. If people don't want to hire older people they wont, no amount of law will change that, but it will make it more expensive to hire in general.
- tmh79 9y agoIt is a violation of very important civil rights laws in the US. Imagine a company using Facebook to advertise job openings to white candidates only.
- conanbatt 9y agoOr to advertise to get large chested women to serve beer! Its just a preference. If they are making an unprofitable preference, the best punishment you can do is let them continue their policy and let other competition pick up where they leave money on the table. If the decision they are making is profitable, no amount of law will help against the desires of people.
- brianberns 9y agoThere may be "reasons", but are they ethical? I'd like an example of such a reason, if you have one.
- kirykl 9y agoIf the job application doesn't restrict on age, and presumably appears on their website, advertising for it is not really exclusionary
- kindatrue 9y agoKinda sorta. A consequence of the redlining era in Banking (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining), banks are not supposed to micro-geographically target their advertising. (So... blocking Florida is find 'cuz you don't have offices in Florida. But not buying ads for people in Harlem while you target the rest of Manhattan - not OK.) So there's precedent for saying that "not including" can be the same as "excluding".
- tmh79 9y agoI'm astonished that facebook is successfully able to pull the "we're a platform, its not our fault people are using it illegally" excuse here. There is a huge difference between allowing people to freely post content on places like FB, twitter, or Reddit, and selling access the attention of people that fit specific characteristics. How long until the tech giants are held accountable for willfully skirting decades of civil rights legislation.
- mc32 9y agoWell, i dunno. I think it's still on the advertiser to follow the law. Kind of like when some insurance co advertises some insurance product and that advert has to go through copy editors and legal to make sure it does not break any laws (representing product faithfully, not making false or dubious claims) before it gets okayed to be published. In this case HR should consult with legal before putting up job announcements. Or, here specifically these cos should consult with legal before making that job req buy.
- tmh79 9y agoFacebook is selling advertising. In this specific case, the product they are selling is illegal. Facebook should be held liable for selling illegal advertising. Do people find this challenging? Is there something wrong with this?
- Karunamon 9y agoWhat would happen in the physical world with, say, a classified ad in a newspaper? It's on the poster of the ad to follow the law, not the paper, is it not?
- slededit 9y agoNewspapers do review advertising both for illegal content and things that would negatively affect their brand. If you created an ad with "over 40 need not apply" most newspapers would reject the ad. However this case goes over and above. Facebook is actively adding a feature to screen users by age which increases their culpability.
- RomanPushkin 9y agoAlso: https://stallman.org/facebook.html#racism https://stallman.org/facebook.html#racism
- nerflad 9y agoImportant info. But Stallman's writing style is so idiosyncratic that I can't help but read it in his voice, which I find hilarious.
- fishmeat 9y agoAre there tells of race, sex discrimination?
- stevenwoo 9y agoFacebook was already in trouble for allowing people to place ads to whites only for housing - that is against the law in the USA. And after being informed of it - despites thousands of software engineers - Facebook was not capable or not willing to change it. https://www.propublica.org/article/facebook-advertising-discrimination-housing-race-sex-national-origin https://www.propublica.org/article/facebook-advertising-disc...
- mankypro 9y agoLaugh while you can monkey boys. That generation built the infrastructure you rely on daily. Way to pay it forward. Suddenly, they too will turn around and realize that they're above 40 and not in the preferred demo. It all comes around in the end. Sometimes the SDN boys need a salty old dog to ask if anyone has actually looked at the back of GigE interface to see if theres a cable actually plugged into it :)
- maxxxxx 9y agoDon't forget that nothing meaningful ever was built before Javascript.
- avs733 9y agoWhile at a certain level I can't help but agree with you, I think some self-reflection is in order. It is perfectly legal to discriminate against young people but not against older folks. Those laws were put into place by that generation you reference. Not to mention that the likely reason to target younger employees is because they can be paid less for the same job. That is a manifestation of the ongoing depowering of labor and individual laborers that was again driven by...that generation. Sometimes, a group reaps what they sow.
- tensor 9y agoHow is it legal to discriminate against young people?
- horsecaptin 9y agoDon't want to get discriminated against? Stop using services that can't exist without screwing you, and start paying for services! Create the market which will then enable others to compete for your dollars!
- fpisfun 9y agoI would do this before I deleted my Facebook account when I ran ads not to intentionally exclude people but because I figured people over a certain age probably wouldn't know the technologies I was looking for and I figured I would probably end up paying for false positive ad clicks
- loeg 9y ago> because I figured people over a certain age probably wouldn't know the technologies I was looking for This is precisely the kind of age discrimination the law is intended to prevent.
- iak8god 9y agoYep. I was hoping that sentence would end with "because I figured people over a certain age probably wouldn't be interested in entry-level positions," and I was prepared to think that was an interesting point.
- Consultant32452 9y agoWhy would that be any less discriminatory?
- iak8god 9y agoIt wouldn't really, but it would be significantly less douche-y, because it would ultimately be based in a less disparaging view of older job seekers.
- fpisfun 9y agoIt is factual that certain technologies are more used by certain demographics. If someone has a very small ad budget I don't understand why they should be forced to display ads to a demographic less likely to know the technology.
- deleted 9y ago
- poulsbohemian 9y agoIt's anecdata, but if I ask my teen daughter, Facebook is for older people, and the kids are all using things that I've never even heard of. So not sure how you can really prove discrimination. There is some demographic skewing if you advertise on Facebook vs. other channels, but not sure you can really call it an age issue. Not sure what to make of the social marketing guy in the article -- seems like if you are looking for a social marketing person, then Facebook would be a logical place to advertise...
- matt4077 9y agoQuote: The promotion was set to run on the Facebook feeds of users 25 to 36.
- dictum 9y ago> It's anecdata, but if I ask my teen daughter, Facebook is for older people, and the kids are all using things that I've never even heard of. So not sure how you can really prove discrimination Aren't they looking for young professionals (twenty-somethings)? Whatever teenagers are using right now will only become relevant to this debate in a few years, when they'll be the ones targeted by those companies* [*] I'm too cynical to believe they'll be out of business by then.
- mulmen 9y agoIrrelevant, this is an article about discrimination on Facebook.
- iak8god 9y agoDespite significantly increasing its total number of users since 2014, Facebook has many fewer users in the 13-17 and 18-24 brackets. The 13-17s dropped 40% in three years. https://isl.co/2017/02/2017-facebook-demographic-report-adults-on-the-rise-the-teen-question/ https://isl.co/2017/02/2017-facebook-demographic-report-adul...
- mulmen 9y agoFacebook knows the age of the people it displays ads to. Part of their value proposition is that you can use this data to show certain ads to people of a certain age. In the case of job postings this is explicitly illegal discrimination. The average age of Facebook users is completely unrelated.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 9y agoHmm. There is a valid use case for microtargeting: show potential candidates different perks. Young people will be lured by stuff like free food/beer, while older age brackets will be more interested in health benefits or "family friendly" work environment. The way to get it done legally would be to group the ads for different age groups and have them either all shown/approved or none at all.
- thecompilr 9y agoI think that is perfectly legal, ethical and acceptable. Those companies pay per impression, so they want to maximize the effect of the ad, and reach as many candidates as possible per each $ they pay FB. This is just an ad. No one can stop you from applying to a job directly with the company, irregardless of your age, or any other demographics. Just another sensational headline.
- keltex 9y agoActually it might be illegal. Read below regarding recruitment. https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/practices/ https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/practices/ Recruitment It is also illegal for an employer to recruit new employees in a way that discriminates against them because of their race, color, religion, sex (including gender identity, sexual orientation, and pregnancy), national origin, age (40 or older), disability or genetic information. For example, an employer's reliance on word-of-mouth recruitment by its mostly Hispanic work force may violate the law if the result is that almost all new hires are Hispanic.
- jklinger410 9y agoThis has to be one of the more under-enforced rules in America.
- thecompilr 9y agoSo the example is: "For example, an employer's reliance on word-of-mouth recruitment by its mostly Hispanic work force may violate the law if the result is that almost all new hires are Hispanic." In this case the employers probably rely on many sources of candidates, and want to maximize each source. In the end the result is what matters.
- jklinger410 9y agoPeople are constantly complaining that Facebook allows you to target ads at certain people. Ads have operated this way since their inception, yet critics are finding new ways to make it seem like Facebook is ruining everything by doing exactly what any sensible person would do if they ran Facebook. I am not a huge fan of Facebook. But I feel like this is the same trope as was hauled out in the "Facebook didn't tell me about my dead friend" post. I don't respect the downvote I received for this comment. Please argue with me instead of dismiss me.
- combatentropy 9y agoIt doesn't make sense to me to discriminate against people with more experience. Can someone explain it to me? I have heard that companies like recent grads because they are (1) more malleable and (2) can be paid less. But neither of those reasons seem to me strong enough. I'm talking completely about the company's own interests. Let's address the first reason: malleability. A recent grad presumably will adopt the company's culture faster, complain less, and in general pick up things sooner. Well, the hardest, meanest coworkers I've ever had were late twenties, early thirties. I've worked with people in their sixties, and they're sweet people. Even the grumpy old sysadmin had only a thin layer of spikes. After just a few days I could see through most of it, and he was 10 times more helpful than my other sysadmins. Not only was he softer (at least deep down) but he was smarter, having done it for decades. Even when he met a new problem, his keenly developed taste made him more likely to choose something that would be more maintainable long term. Now let's address the second reason: salary. I am 10 times better than I was when I started. I know, because I still work with some of my code from back then, and I desperately want to rewrite it all. How much more does a senior developer make than a new hire? 50% more? Seems worth it to me. 100% more? 200% more? Still maybe worth it. And if some old fella can't get work at all, maybe he would settle for something between 50% and 100% more. I mean, why not at least make an offer? It just don't make no sense. Other fields reward grayhairs. You see some sixty-year-old painter or architect or carpenter, you think he's probably pretty good. You see some straight-out-of-college twenty-something in . . . any other field, you think, "I sure hope he knows what he's doing."
- leggomylibro 9y agoIt's a race to the bottom. You could pay more for better work that gets done more slowly (fewer hours as people have families, etc,) or you could pay less for worse work that gets done more quickly. Well, iOS11 needs to ship on its annual schedule, non-negotiable. And the SVP will really complain if I ask for more money this quarter. So, cheap it is. If a bridge falls down, it's really obvious and people die. If billions of computers become vulnerable to malicious actors and a few hundred or thousand people suffer dramatic personal damages, well that's a nice and quiet problem which will be quickly forgotten in the 24-hour news cycle.
- 015UUZn8aEvW 9y agoI'm a grad student at an elite American university. Several weeks ago, some other students and I attended a recruiting presentation put on by a large multinational company I won't name. The woman who gave the presentation services her company's contract with a tech company, that, let's just say, has a big share of the search engine market. She emphasized that she was looking for diversity, because, as she said, "the type of people on the other side of the table from us are different than they used to be, and they don't want to be dealing with a bunch of 65-year-old white guys. So those aren't the type of people we're looking for." That's pretty much a direct quote. I was at a small company before I went to grad school. The company began working with a guy in his sixties who'd been laid off for a while and couldn't find work, even though he had a ton of experience. We brought him in on a contract basis, and his role gradually expanded as it became clear that he had both excellent technical knowledge and great people skills. He became a mentor to me and helped me out a ton. He's objectively better at our profession than I am in multiple dimensions, but right now I could find a new job ten times more easily than he could. I'd like to start a business in 3 or 4 years, and I'm seriously considering going out of my way to target people like him. It'll be my competitive advantage.
- user5994461 9y ago>>> I'd like to start a business in 3 or 4 years, and I'm seriously considering going out of my way to target people like him. It'll be my competitive advantage. He could be 10 times more expensive than you. Did you consider that?
- 015UUZn8aEvW 9y agoI know the local pay scale pretty well. He was out of work for a while, and he definitely would have taken a salary equivalent to what I was making.
- jorgen123 9y ago> He could be 10 times more expensive than you. Did you consider that? That is an assumption that may be invalid. Everybody is in their own private situation. Your assumption will be true for many but not for all. Many older folks may not need a top salary anymore and will take an average income for the pleasure of working with other fine people and doing interesting things. At some point in your life the career ladder will be less important than quality of life.
- macinjosh 9y agoFacebook is predatory. It is the Harvey Weinstein of social media.
- alasdair_ 9y agoDoes this mean that using Facebook to target tech company ads at women or an unrepresented minority group, or LGBT people would also be illegal, even if the goal is to reach out to these people to increase the diversity of the workplace?
- killjoywashere 9y agoNot a chance. The implicit paradigm in all these laws is an entitled, young, male, white, Anglo-Saxon Protestant. Think Trump or any member of the Bush clan in their younger years. By the time you're ready to enter the workforce, at whatever level, all other demographics have been beat down to some degree or another.
- danans 9y agoNo, because those are examples of protected classes. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group
- Camillo 9y agoUnder US anti-discrimination laws, _any_ group identified by one of those characteristics is a protected group, with the notable exception of age. For example, laws against sexual discrimination protect men as well as women. In practice, it is unlikely to be enforced for some groups.
- cm2187 9y agoIn that spirit should companies even be allowed to visit campuses, and have a graduate recruitment program? After all recruiting straight out of university means recruiting younger people.
- walshemj 9y agoRecruiting for experience or lack of experience is allowable but for example a few years back to keep the DHSS happy and to keep receiving benefits I went to an "Apprentice role" at HMGCC at Hanslope Park :-). The idea was that HR might think I was over qualified but think I might be worth suggesting for other roles. - BTW this was an avowed role so I am not breaking the OS act Yes that is the one mentioned in the Laundry files
- nickonline 9y agoHow did they publish an ad with incorrect grammar? "Here, your more than a number..." It should be you're
- mabbo 9y ago> “Used responsibly, age-based targeting for employment purposes is an accepted industry practice and for good reason: it helps employers recruit and people of all ages find work,” said Rob Goldman, a Facebook vice president. No, that's... that's literally the opposite of 'helping people of all ages find work'.
- walshemj 9y agoNo its not except in cases when its legally justified eg adds looking for child actors
- ec109685 9y agoPerhaps there are advertisements that work better for some age groups than others? So by targeting, they can deliver the right ad to the right user.
- shostack 9y agoThis happens. While I don't advertise for jobs, I do advertise a product, and the reality is that certain demographics perform better against our KPIs, and certain creative resonates better with certain audiences. What we have to reconcile is how to balance the targeting capability and advantage of using that targeting capability against the legal and ethical considerations. So for example, there's probably a difference between "let's target all of these age brackets with creative that is most relevant to them" vs. "let's target 18-34 men and explicitly exclude everyone else." The difficult part is there's a lot of gray area there. What if one segment performs horribly? Should you exclude them? What if someone has a bias? Can they just run intentionally bad creative or poorly targeted ads against the demographics they don't want to create a self-fulfilling prophecy? Things are not black and white, but it is encouraging to see the discussion being had.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoYes, some advertising will likely work better for some age groups than others. It happens. It is a part of well thought out advertising. The thing is that they weren't targeting the "right ad to the right user". It isn't like they were customizing ads to different groups hoping to increase their diversity. They were only targeting one group of people and excluding others upfront. No trying to show the ad to older folks nor investing in an ad for those folks. And even if you produce multiple ads targeting multiple ages, it is probably prudent to simply show them to everyone over 18 in the area you are advertising in - just to be on the safe side of the employment laws.
- imh 9y agoI once worked at a company that was having trouble finding women candidates. We were a tiny company that at that point largely recruited out of the people we knew, who were largely people we'd worked with before and people we went to school with. Mostly dudes. There was a discussion at some point about the legality of trying harder to get women engineers than men. My understanding is that you can try to get more people of a protected class to apply in the first place and it's only once they apply that you have to treat everyone equally. Is that correct? If it is, then this seems like the problem in the article would be legal on the same basis.
- baddox 9y agoI don’t know the law or the established ethics (if any exist), but I would hope that it isn’t frowned upon to focus recruiting efforts toward certain demographics with the goal of receiving qualified applicants at the same proportions as the general population (e.g. 50/50 male and female).
- otterley 9y agoNo, that’s not the law. While neutrally written, the intent is clear (and will be enforced as such) - it is to prevent discrimination against historically-rejected groups (women, minorities, the elderly, disabled, etc.).
- danjoc 9y ago"Young people are just smarter," he said, with a straight face, according to VentureBeat. "Why are most chess masters under 30?" he asked. Has Zuckerberg retired yet? He's old now. 33 in fact. He should have passed the torch to someone smarter. I guess he got old and dumb and forgot.
- Clubber 9y agoIf he were older at the time, he might have realized that saying something like that is not only short sighted, but would follow him for the rest of his life. I haven't heard him repeat it since. Of course, when I was young, I said plenty of short sighted, silly things as well.
- kindatrue 9y ago>I haven't heard him repeat it since. If the dude can afford to hire a $120K/year nanny to teach his kids Mandarin, he can afford to hire a guy to remind him to never repeat that.
- 40acres 9y agoThis is tough. Super targeted advertising is exactly why Facebook is so valuable. Add that to the fact that their marketing tech is so frictionless (it's my knowledge that you can get your ads up on Facebook relatively quickly w/o interfacing with a human) and you end up with situations like this. There are a finite amount of ads that can be shown on TV during a week and a finite amount of billboards, bus placements and other types of ads. With Facebook the number of ads on the platform at any given time may be infinite, how are you supposed to add a review process for these ads especially when they are not blatantly illegal / harassing?
- Clubber 9y agoif (isJobPosting) txtAgeRange.Enabled = false;
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trhway 9y agoi guess it is time to setup an FB profile where i'm a forever 20smthing with interests in ... what are youngsters these days interested in?
- walshemj 9y agoPopular Beat Combos I Believe :-)
- santaclaus 9y agoYouTube influencers
- gerdesj 9y agoI wanted to pontificate about how I don't hire like that etc etc however, I'll simply make the observation that an advertisement in a news paper or on a bill board is open to all. Just because you can, does not mean you should. Most countries have fairly strict discriminatory laws. This falls afoul of the lot. You should not be able to use an advertising platform to pre-filter your applicants. If you think I'm wrong then substitute "skin colour" or "disabled" or "sex" for "age" in this discussion. Substitute a combination of all of those ... This is wrong. So wrong that the perpetrators should be considered criminal.
- indus 9y agoMost of the conversation in this thread is around engineering, IT, and whether grey hairs code better than non-grey hairs, and whether there is an ROI vis-a-vis money and time. I'll add a few things about Sales. Through an acquisition, I spent a few years at one of the largest enterprise software company. As a PM, I interacted with a lot of grey hair sales professionals--right from Key Account Directors to Sales Ops to Sales Engineers to National Account Managers. These were some of the finest. Thanks to their mentorship, I have not measured, but in 2 years, I became expert at navigating the buyers of software at large companies, doing calls, replying to RFPs, handling exceptions, and to a certain degree schmoozing. Who else would you learn these from? Sales is not taught anywhere!
- MilnerRoute 9y agoI want to believe these companies don't know it's illegal to discriminate based on age. Because the alternative is that they're intentionally discriminating -- and thinking they won't get caught, because the ads are only appearing on Facebook. But any government agency that's investigating this can obviously just to ask Facebook for the company's ad buys, and there's an irrefutable paper trail. (It can't be that hard, since even Propublica was able to put all the pieces together without any special government powers.) Or is this a case where they're hoping Facebook's commitment to privacy for ad purchasers will end up shielding their illegal hiring practices?
- e40 9y agoI want to believe these companies don't know it's illegal to discriminate based on age. Are you serious? This is HR 101. There is no manager in the US that works for a company with an HR department (1 person is fine, that's all we have, and she's part time) could ever NOT know this.
- extrapickles 9y agoIn the US, an employer is even required to put up posters saying that its illegal to discriminate on age.
- yuhong 9y agoNot that I like these laws anyway. they were really designed for manual labor and the like.
- baddox 9y agoGenuine question: is it explicitly illegal to discriminate in your outreach for job applications? Surely similar behavior happens all the time without as much outcry, like recruiting at college career fairs.
- e40 9y agoIf you only look for employees in places with young people, that is likely illegal. It would take a pattern of this over time. If someone found out (e.g., an inside ratted you out), and a lawyer took it on contingency (because the company doing it has deep pockets), then it could be serious trouble.
- danschumann 9y agoI wonder if they thought of it in this light.. or if they just imagined who they wanted and targeted specifically TO them, as opposed to AGAINST older folks. In the law's eyes, it's the same thing, however. Something to remember if you're ever buying ads for hiring.
- hdjdjnxnxbx 9y agoThis seems like a problem with how Facebook sells ads, not a problem with the companies in question. I get weekly offers for interviews from most of these companies on LinkedIn and I’m pushing 50.
- coding123 9y agoI guess I have two takes on this: 1) Does this mean my local strip club will now have to hire 90 year olds? 2) Ignoring that joke for now - if pro-publica released this information we now have information that harm has been caused. And actually couldn't this be an indication that possibly billions of dollars of damage has been done... what's next?
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago1. No because appearance is "a bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of the particular business" for strippers, models, actors, etc.
- c3534l 9y agoTechnically the stripper rents the stage, the club doesn't hire a stripper.
- gexla 9y agoIf you are creating FB ads, you target by the segment which gives you the most leads. I imagine age is just one parameter of those segments. Personally, I would never think to find a job through FB. IF someone wanted to target me, being outside that age group, it would need to be a different platform.
- tomohawk 9y agoA lot of managers are threatened by experienced people because experienced people are a lot less shy about pointing out bullshit. People with 5 or less years of experience are much less likely to have a backbone. They're still getting over the school conditioning to complete whatever BS assignment needed to get the grade. Many managers would prefer to have an apparently smoothly running operation than have honest feedback. I once worked on a team with several people with 20+ years of experience. We got new management that did not appreciate that the experienced engineers were pointing out that pixie dust doesn't actually exist. They ended up "greening" the team. The new, much less experienced engineers that were brought on cranked out the code and learned lots of skills, but the product ended up dead within a couple of years. Those managers all got promoted though.
- killjoywashere 9y ago> experienced people are a lot less shy about pointing out bullshit. I've seen this backfire on the experienced person though. Pretty brutal to be a PhD in industry and find yourself out of a job at the age of 56 because you pointed out 'hey, this could kill people, maybe we should do an RCT before we go to market"
- le-mark 9y agoExperienced people don't necessarily point out bullshit though. Often times, we just keep quiet and watch the train wreck :)
- pixl97 9y agoWell, experienced people know how to CYA and let the boss hang themselves when they try to blame someone below them.
- tomvon 9y agoExclude? I would think people would advertise on Facebook to get employees over 40. No young people use Facebook.
- netheril96 9y agoThe comments here seemly to be focused on tech companies not recruiting the old. But the example in the article is actually a position of financial analysts.
- myf01d 9y agoif you're 35 yo in tech industry and not owning a small business, you're almost done unless you have good connections. That's how tech works, nobody just wants to admit that. tech workers are the diggers of their own graves.
- phil248 9y agoI hear this a lot, but I don't see it. A lot of people move in to management roles, but others just keep writing code. I also don't see why "owning a small business" is a virtue in and of itself. Owning a profitable company that doesn't consume my every waking hour would be great. But that's the exception.
- astura 9y agoMaybe in SV but certainly not everywhere. The vast majority of my colleagues are over 35. I mean like ~90%.
- hliyan 9y agoI'm almost 40, in the tech industry, own zero small businesses and am doing very well for myself. You just need to keep your skills up to date rather than resting on your laurels, and it works out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- joshfraser 9y agoThe only justice in this is that we all get old. The discriminators will learn what it feels like someday.
- danso 9y agoFWIW, FB has posted a rebuttal to ProPublica: https://newsroom.fb.com/news/h/addressing-targeting-in-recruitment-ads/ https://newsroom.fb.com/news/h/addressing-targeting-in-recru...
- thedatamonger 9y agoAt least there is cubeworld. That guy won't release it till it's perfect :) ... Seriously thou, there should be someone who's job it is is to put these things into perspective to the suits. bad design does cost money. engineers aren't MBA's (usually) and are bad at speaking their language (usually). And the "we're young therefore we know everything about technology" stereotype needs to go. The world is complicated, it can't be boiled down to buzzwords or stereotypes.
- carapace 9y agoFB got in trouble for this same problem awhile back, but it was for allowing ethnically-targeted ads. Couldn't find a reference, sorry. edit: references available here: https://stallman.org/facebook.html#racism https://stallman.org/facebook.html#racism (Thanks RomanPushkin )
- f4rker 9y agoI have a decade and a half of experience some of which includes fortune 100 and 500 cos. I've helped the UN, colleges, tv personalities, law enforcement, federal and local government. And some of my shitty code made it into a small Linux distro. If you don't want me because I'm over 30 then let's do each other a favor and never meet =)
- opticalflow 9y agoSo, I wonder how many ad placements were made by these companies that specifically targeted experienced talent OVER 40 years of age? I'm going to guess a big, fat, zero.
- rdiddly 9y agoFacebook already excludes older workers just by being the kind of terrible user experience older people are sick of dealing with!
- notacoward 9y ago"age-based targeting for employment purposes is an accepted industry practice" is not true. It's f-ing illegal and for good reason. The guy who said that should be fired.
- bilbosmegma 9y agoIt's because the pace of change leads to uncertainty and a lower demand for "specialists" and a higher demand for adaptability, maleability, and generalization. Thank me later.
- ForrestN 9y agoIt’s now perfectly clear that Facebook’s business is predicated on its ability to divide us up. This is already playing out destructively in more and more visible ways, but imagine all the invisible consequences of these categorizations.
- Tohan 9y agoVICTORIA FINANCIER HELP MY FAMILY WITH LOAN @ 2% INTEREST RATE with victoriafinancier@outlook.com VICTORIA FINANCIER COMPANY, offers all kind of loan, ranging from $5,000 USD to $100,000,000.00USD Max. if you need a loan amount quickly write to her Email now with ( victoriafinancier@outlook.com) . She helped me when i was so much in need of money. I lost my job. i and my kids were almost evicted from our house. I seeks assistance from all the people that i know but i could not even get drugs for my child. I also develop brain tumor as a result of stress and excess thinking. In my messed life, i look online for assistance there i found Mrs Victoria Financier Loan Lending company. I read how she always help different people from different countries. I urgently contact her, explain my situations to her same day and then i ask for any assistance that can give because i don't want my kids trow out to street; She advised me to get a loan amount with long term of 10years. The funds was sent into my bank account 4 days of contacting her and she also send the transfer confirmation slip to me and my bank gave me the money in full when i went to withdraw. Victoria Financier service is so amazing. I recommend Victoria Financier Lending Company to you, contact her today and be patient with to assist you because lot's of person contact her daily for assistance. She will help you urgently. Her Email is: victoriafinancier@outlook.com Full Name:_________ Address:_________ Tell:_________ loan amount:_________ Loan duration:_________ Country:_________ Purpose of loan:_________ Monthly Income:__________ Occupation__________ Next of kin:_________ *Email :__________
- Thinpad 9y ago"Used responsibly, age-based targeting for employment purposes is an accepted industry practice and for good reason: it helps employers recruit and people of all ages find work," said Rob Goldman, a Facebook vice president. Rob if you are reading this you sound like an idiot. What were you thinking before uttering those words. Please do all of us a favor quit that VP role you are definitely not a leader material :).
- lowbloodsugar 9y agoNo, he sounds like Trump, or Ryan. Here are some words. Those of you who are smart enough to understand the logical fallacy are a tiny minority. The rest of you will either parrot them or ridicule them depending on your own existing personal view.
- chishaku 9y agoIf you'd like to contribute to ProPublica's investigative journalism, you can donate here: https://donate.propublica.org https://donate.propublica.org
- vfc1 9y agoThe best w
- vfc1 9y agoThe best way to avoid this altogether is to start your own Internet business way before hitting 50. Why would you still want to be working for someone else at that age? Being an employee is not the only way to earn a living, internet entrepreneurship is a very realistic alternative, and a much better life in general.
- PopsiclePete 9y agoAnd everyone who starts a business is successful at it?
- vfc1 9y agoNo, but I think the failure rate of starting a business is deformed by the startup culture. A small business of one person plus a couple of part-time assistants is much more likely to work than a 20 person company, there's a spectrum to it and the 95% failure rate gulps everything together. What'qs the worst it can happen. You try for one year, doesn't work and back to the corporate world.
- geff82 9y agoMy colleague is a 64-years-old devops guy. He looks like 78, he sounds like 80, but his brain is working at full speed and his IT-knowledge is not only very current, but also backed by 35 years of experience. He is the most valuable guy in our team. Any company missing out on people like him is shooting itself in the foot.
- juicyfroot 9y agoThey want to pay less. You get what you pay for. Fuck them. Work somewhere that doesn't treat you like a child
- rootlocus 9y ago> It is against the law to discriminate against workers older than 40 in hiring and recruitment. So it's ok to discriminate agaist workers younger than 40? How does this work?
- xocyabencl 9y agoIt's just the way the antidiscrimination law is written. I have a visceral "that should be unconstitutional or something" reaction when thinking about it, but then I remember we have age discrimination written into our constitution.
- maltalex 9y agoThe discussion here is interesting, but I haven't seen any psychological and sociological aspects of hiring mentioned yet. Not all hiring decisions are rational. First, there's a culture thing - when a company is composed out of 20 year olds, it's natural for them to prefer working with other young people who they can relate to. That 40 year old job applicant, the one with the kids and the years of experience in companies that no longer exist doesn't look as relatable as someone your own age. Second, there's ego. In a company in which junior and even mid level managers are 25-35 years old, who wants to hire a 45 year old "veteran" that has 10 years more experience? Managing someone more knowledgeable than you is a challenge. It's much easier to get a fresh graduate and mold him into the employee you want him to be. Ego-wise, it's much nicer being the mentor than the mentee. There are many more aspects to this and I suspect that they play a more important role than at least some of the the purely rational reasons for ageism in our industry.
- gaius 9y agomold him into the employee you want him to be Exploit him or her with false promises. FTFY.
- maltalex 9y ago> Exploit him or her with false promises. FTFY. Yeah, there's that too. But let's not even go there and assume that everything is strictly aboveboard. Otherwise we'll derail the discussion, and I think that the cultural aspect is one worth discussing. I really am talking about "molding him into the employee you want him to be" in terms of getting him to work the way you think is right. As opposed to hiring someone with different ideas than yours as to how to do the work he or she is supposed to to.
- s3r3nity 9y agoI worry that the "culture" argument has dangerous implications if true, as it can be used to discriminate on so many grounds outside of age: gender ("If I'm with a bunch of my bro's, why mess it up with a girl?"), race, language, disabilities, etc etc. I thought the "hacker culture" would be supportive of the idea that "if you can do the job well, let's work together on solving interesting problems," rather than the cliche "would I want to grab a beer with this person?"
- EADGBE 9y agoWhat's the likelihood of multiple ads targeting multiple groups, probably with different photos? Did they investigate that, or just draw conclusions from one 25-36 y.o.'s Facebook account?
- jldevezas 9y agoConsider me excluded. :-)
- slantyyz 9y agoI'm rapidly approaching 50 myself, and while I get that what they're doing is wrong, I'm also not that upset about this either. At my age, I'm not interested in wasting my time with meat grinders that don't value work-life balance.
- rplnt 9y agoMaybe they have the same ad with a different picture for older people? Or have researched that it's only worth targeting this group - from the CTR point of view? There are so many legit possibilities where it would be absolutely OK to target job ad by age.
- JohnTClark 9y agoI don't see the problem with adds that are targeted to a specific age group or other characteristics of a person, and I am talking about the adds that pop up in my timeline or on the right side panel. But if I actively search for a job and it is hidden from me because I am not in the target audience then yes, that is discrimination. Ex: I am 25, male, Java developer, I don't want to be bombarded by adds about nursing jobs or adds about nail polish , but if I type in the search bar :"nursing jobs in <myArea>" then I want all nursing jobs in my area and the same thing about nail polish.
- fsloth 9y agoFun fact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ageism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ageism Age based discrimination has been us for at least decades, and it has been prevalent in all industries. I presume it's now getting more publicity as the baby boomers are entering the discriminated age segment. It's a more difficult problem than just a few CEO:s in their 30:s wanting to hire cheap labour.
- itsybitsyspider 9y agoI think one of the reasons is because fluid intelligence declines as people get older - it's maybe an unpopular and uncomfortable, but still, a scientific fact proven by many psychological studies. If I was an employer, I'd definitely prefer someone who's at the peak of their intellectual capabilities.
- princetman 9y agoCare to provide any links or elaborate further on such studies? I'm very curious about this.
- itsybitsyspider 9y agoSure, this page links to some studies on the topic of fluid vs. crystallized intelligence: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/fluid-and-crystallized-intelligence https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/fluid-and-... A lot of information can be found in psychological literature touching on Cognitive Psychology.
- Beermotor 9y agoOk so that answers the age question: a study found fluid intelligence starts to decline the 60s and 70s. I think OP's article is talking about people between the ages of 35 and 60 not being able to see ads. What is more likely is that more experienced workers have higher salary requirements and are less likely to work 90 hours a week.
- itsybitsyspider 9y agoThose studies don't necessarily give you a definite answer regarding age. Other studies suggest that it starts much earlier: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/000169186790011X?via%3Dihub http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/00016918679... Salary and work-life balance expectations definitely play a huge role in this phenomena - I'm just pointing out that there might be other factors too - factors that people often reject up front because they feel uncomfortable with them.
- troels 9y agoTo be fair, maybe they aren't deliberately discriminating. Advertisement isn't free, so with a limited budget you will want to optimise your ads for conversion. That's marketing 101. Maybe they think (or even have evidence to support) that a specific demography has a higher conversion rate. For example, the reasoning might be that there are more programmers amongst younger people. It would then be inefficient to advertise to other groups. Sure, there is a grey area here, but the intent might not be as malevolent as implied.
- wccrawford 9y agoI think they'd have to be pretty stupid not to realize the effect of their choice here. I'm all for Occam's Razor, but this is stretching that line pretty thin.
- user_rob 9y agoI think its great!: In the high tech software company I am at there seems to be a disproportionate number of people over 60 - and we are are leaders in our industry both in profit and tech. Very pleased that our competitors won't be poaching our best people!
- indymike 9y agoAdvertising is a tool. One person can use it to discriminate. Another can use it to invite diversity into the organization.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoMany years ago, I sold real estate. With some regularity, I'd e-mail a list of homes to an eager young professional couple. The sort who always say the correct things and always vote the correct way. One of the homes in that list would be so well shot, and so well priced, that they'd take time off of work--they had to see it right now! They chatter excitedly on the drive over. We slow down as we enter the neighborhood. Their excitement is at its apex. Then the excitement drops an octave. I scan the horizon, pondering, "What is this disturbance in the force?" Then I notice, we just drove by a black guy raking his yard. After the next black guy in his yard--silence. We pull up to the house. As I let them out of the car, I am met with the faces of two people searching for an excuse. One of them breaks, "It's not that we're racists. Some of my best friends are black. It's just that, um, we don't want to be the only white people in the neighborhood." They get back into the car. I take them back to the office, and I never see them again. Nice neighborhood, great price, neighbors that take care of their yards--obviously no rational reason to scrub the showing, no one screaming the n-word, no "far-right" politics, just a couple higher-level office slaves quietly reclining into the old tribalisms.
- ChicagoDave 9y agoI highly doubt this is the only avenue of age discrimination. At 54, my interview process this year was vastly different than in the past. I honestly felt like the token old-person interview and no one had any intention of recommending me for a job. The hiring people are all younger and looking for fun coworkers to hang out with and definitely don't want to work with people bogged down with experience.
- inimino 9y agoI'm no fan of Facebook, but I'm having trouble getting worked up about this. It is illegal to not hire someone on the basis of age, but what is so wrong about targeting ads at young people, for a job that older people would be unlikely to apply for anyway? That just seems like common sense. And getting outraged at not being shown ads, as though your constitutional right to have companies spend money to let you know about employment opportunities while you're frittering away time on Facebook were being violated, just screams entitlement to me.
- armandososa 9y agoAs I approach 40, I'm so scared that nobody would hire me whenever I have to look for work again.
- pm24601 9y agoTo anyone who thinks this action is o.k. - just remember you will end up older and discriminated against, rich and discriminating, or dead at an early age. 1 and 3 are much more likely than 2.
- chewyshine 9y agoIt's probably too late to contribute meaningfully to this conversation. But look at the tone of many of these comments. So many "know it alls." So many strong opinions about the right way to hire and work with developers. Owners and execs often don't want to deal with the jaded baggage that comes with experience. Many owners/execs want to have a person integrate with the existing work flows rather than having to repeatedly justify a workflow to a person who thinks he or she knows a better way to do things. Not saying it's right or wrong, it just is. It also probably violates the uniform guidelines on employee selection.
- python-guy-vt 9y agoJoke is on them, only grandparents and mothers of young children use facebook anymore.
- losteverything 9y agoSo i place a classified ad in Chinese Daily News but not one in the Daily News. Am i discriminating against non chinese workers? Im not a FB fan but this isn't discrimination if i, as the buyer of the ad, don't want my ad to go to any group. Do i want to place my ad for a day care help to any FB member that may have a criminal record or keeps track of megans law? We just have too much information now.
- patricklynch 9y agoNo, because the fact that I'm neither Chinese nor likely to read Chinese Daily News doesn't actually prevent me from seeing your ad. If you posted "Help Wanted" flyers in the middle of a college campus for a part-time cashier job, some 52 year old could--in theory--be walking by the quad on his way to a Frisbee golf game. It's when you explicitly add in logic to filter out a protected class that you may be in trouble.
- losteverything 9y agoBut the ad is targeting. Ads always target. So if this is indeed true then FB should simply splash enough protected classes to chalk off the requirement. That should not be hard. We have this really great machine to reach people. FB is just one way to attract talent. Why ruin it Remember, FB is voluntary
- patricklynch 9y agoI don't think it works that way. If you add logic that says: "here's group A, who we really want to target, and here's group B, the protected class we want to exclude. throw 10% of all impressions at group B so we're not violating federal law." Then I think you may still be breaking the law. Because you're explicitly favoring one group over another. Whether the ratio is 100%/0% or 90%/10% probably doesn't affect the underlying legal problem. > Why ruin it At some point many years ago society latched on to the idea that "equal opportunity employment" was a civil right worth protecting with federal law. One of the major draws of facebook, if you happen to be an employer not wholly committed to this idea, seems to be that you kind of have a way to effectively bypass it. There are people who would equate "ruining facebook" in this scenario with "protecting fundamental civil rights," which is more important than creating a favorable environment for recruiters. That's more or less the argument I think.
- Bombthecat 9y agoI talked to a Co worker quit awhile about that. I didn't wanted to buy a house, because of job insecurity. He told me that this is not a problem. Old people will get jobs in the future without any problem... Yeah...
- ybercyber 9y agoExcellent!! Who would meed an old expert in team who have the experience and knowledge?? Naah, we need new and young blood who do not have any experience.. that's how we roll!
- OliverJones 9y ago100 years ago the letters "NINA" were often included in newspaper help-wanted ads in the USA. Those letters mean "no Irish need apply." Now FB has figured out a better way to handle help-wanted ad market segmentation. They've also, basically, guaranteed that they will be regulated to bring their business practices in line with legal norms in the countries where they accept payment.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoSo, is anyone else wondering what will happen when the current crop of young people grow older? When everyone who's young enough to be employable now gets into their 40s and 50s, what's going to happen then?
- sandov 9y agoI don't use Facebook, should I feel discriminated against too?. Can't I put a job ad in a magazine about things that only young people care about? Isn't that discrimination too?. First, I don't think that discrimination by private companies is bad, and even if you try to forbid it, there's always going to be a way around it, and it's going to be hard to draw a line and say "this is where discrimination starts".
- tboyd47 9y agoSo what does this mean for people who don't have a Facebook or any kind of social media presence? Do they get excluded as well?