26 ms·
Apple Has Removed Dash from the App Store
- MrSourz 10y agoYikes, I hope there's more to the story here, but it doesn't sound like there is. I use dash if I had done the wipe & reinstall I was planning to this coming weekend I would have to repurchase it.
- Aloha 10y agoIt sounds like just simple human error on Apples part.
- softawre 10y agoFYI - I went through the process described to migrate my license and it worked fine.
- koolba 10y agoHaving seen the internals of many an application that deals with both "human" and "group" accounts, I'm not surprised that something like this would cause an issue. Unless things are designed from the ground up to support it (which they never are), those types of migrations always have a bunch of edge cases that aren't properly handled. Sure it sucks but the real test of whether Apple gives a rats behind is if they fix it a reasonable amount of time. If this drags on for more than a day without a human response from their support line I'd say, no they don't care. I bet that happens.
- vonklaus 10y ago> I bet that happens. I imagine atleast once a day, some developer is having their worst day ever somewhere, cursing apple.
- zaphar 10y agoI'm trying to imagine the sort of system where a migration from "human" to "group" accounts results in a flag for fraud on that account. It's giving me nightmares. Surely they are more competent than the code/architecture I'm imagining it would take. I'm going to hypothesize that this isn't a technology glitch. It seems more likely that the move triggered a look at his account by some human who for reasons that are unknown to us decided his account looked fishy.
- brazzledazzle 10y ago>Surely they are more competent than the code/architecture I'm imagining it would take. Try dealing with Apple's joke of a bug tracker. Their backend systems don't exactly get the same smooth experience their consumer products get.
- izacus 10y agoThe question is - if it happens, why don't they factcheck the outliers and make sure they don't mess up the developer due to their buggy software.
- CaptSpify 10y agoBecause they don't really have an incentive to. People still keep handing over software to their store.
- davesque 10y agoKinda puts it in perspective how weird it is that companies have so much control over how software is distributed and sold these days. This would never have happened a decade ago.
- zymhan 10y agoWe also weren't using as many walled-garden devices and ecosystems a decade ago. There are certainly a lot of issues with the app store model. But using a service like download.com was also rife with issues.
- 1_2__3 10y agoAnd having lived through that, and now lived through the walled garden/App Store experience, I'll say with confidence the old way was better.
- blktiger 10y agoBetter for you maybe, but not better for the average user who ended up with malware infecting their systems left and right because they weren't technical enough to avoid it.
- givinguflac 10y agoExactly. I have personally been on the receiving end of plenty of phone calls from users who had no idea they couldn't necessarily trust an application downloaded from a 3rd party site. "But it's the same application!" Sure it is, but who knows what else you're getting, even if it's as 'benign' as shitty toolbars. Has no one ever seen a parent/grandparents nightmare of toolbar hell in a browser window?
- izacus 10y agoWe did. And somehow the computer revolution still happened even though people actually had to learn a bit about how their tools worked. Meanwhile in that crazy wild west the whole OSS infrastructure powering the most important global computer network was born. Tools, operating systems and software that isn't allowed to exist in app stores because they might be "dangerous" to the average user (whoever that is).
- DiabloD3 10y agoI find it ironic that the EU goes after Google for allowing third party stores (Samsung, Amazon, Nvidia, etc) and sideloaded APKs and allows you to build your own APKs for free... ... but Apple just randomly removes apps that people have purchased from the Apple Store (thus stealing their money and their product, doing everything short of uninstalling it, but preventing reinstallation), and the EU stays silent? This is some bullshit.
- krschultz 10y agoI simply don't understand this either. Sure Android has the larger market share by units, but Apple has a much higher share of revenue & profit in the market. Which is really the proper measure of market power?
- mwfunk 10y agoFor antitrust purposes, market share.
- dragonwriter 10y agoFor antitrust purpose, pricing power is, as I understand, the "gold standard"; various measures of market share (which isn't itself a single measure) are sometimes evidence which supports a conclusion about the likely existence of pricing power, especially when direct evidence one way or another on pricing power is hard to find.
- coldtea 10y ago>Which is really the proper measure of market power? It's not about market power by various metrics, it's about market penetration in numbers, period.
- cageface 10y agoApple apologists will pick whichever metric suits the current argument. Suing Google for running a far more open platform while Apple continues to exert as least as much if not more control on the direction of the market is just another case of misguided European regulatory overreach.
- sdegutis 10y ago> "I can’t update Dash for iOS anymore and I can’t distribute it outside of the App Store." Well, that's the problem with a walled garden in a nutshell, isn't it?
- vortico 10y agoThe OS X platform already has a stupid easy download-and-install process with their .app folders. It's a shame that some users prefer to instead use an alternative distribution method controlled by a centralized party rather than buying software directly from the developer.
- Sidnicious 10y agoNo standard update mechanism, no standard uninstall mechanism, and going from "I have this .dmg/.zip file in my downloads folder" to "I'm running this app from my Applications folder and don't have any leftovers in my downloads folder" is several non-obvious steps. .app bundles are great, just not a complete solution.
- Sidnicious 10y agoI'd love a to be able to download a single file representing an app, double-click to install it (it doesn't matter where it lives on disk, as long as it's predictable) and then have the system facilitate sandboxing, permissions, and one-click updates and removals. Just like the App Store, but without the App Store.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoI believe you can sandbox an app outside of the app store. I believe Office 2016 does this but I'm not 100% sure.
- Sidnicious 10y agoDefinitely — Chrome sandboxes its renderer processes, for example. The tools are all there, it would just be cool if something glued them together.
- coldtea 10y ago>No standard update mechanism Sparkle is the de-facto standard used by almost all apps. >no standard uninstall mechanism Deleting the .app file would do that for most apps. The config files might be handy to keep around if you re-install (and are inert anyway), else it's pretty easy to remove those too. It would be nice for the OS to be able to track "all files installed by an app" though in case those are installed by an installer (and thus, are not self-contained in the .app folder). >and going from "I have this .dmg/.zip file in my downloads folder" to "I'm running this app from my Applications folder and don't have any leftovers in my downloads folder" is several non-obvious steps. It's a few steps, but its still as obvious as things get in computing. If users can't manage that, how they'd manage USING the app?
- rezashirazian 10y agoSounds like a simple human error. I expect to see an update stating the issue has been resolved fairly soon.
- emeraldd 10y agoI wonder if this is as simple as a typo in the DUNS number on someone's part?
- wila 10y agoNo, it verifies your DUNS number at the moment you click "next" when going through the process. How do I know? I'm still waiting for two weeks to get apple to see my company DUNS number that was generated for me pretty much instantly. I try every day, but so far nothing happens.
- funkysquid 10y agoThis really sucks - just bought a copy of his MacOS app through his website to try and help compensate. At this point I'm starting to avoid buying software through the Mac App Store unless it's not available anywhere else. Even if it's slightly easier to make a purchase initially, you risk the headache of situations like this where you can't even migrate your license.
- feelix 10y agoAdditionally the apps outside the app store tend to work a lot better (nearly all the apps I wrote work far better in the website versions, not having the restrictions of the MAS versions), and also the developer gets more of the money, 95% instead of 70%. And then you're a customer of the developer, not of the app store, which is also better.
- donatj 10y agoI have had a ton of Apps I use every day just up and disappear from the App Store to the point that I am actively avoiding the App Store.
- LukasP 10y agoThis better be an error that they're going to correct. It is not acceptable behavior.
- whizzkid 10y agoEven though It might be a simple error on Apple's end, this is both morally and economically unacceptable. As long as it is not a top-high critical issue with the account or the application, a considerable time should be given to developer to solve the issue. They can even freeze the money that goes to developer until the issue resolved, but cutting the app from the market and failing on both app users and the developer? I don't think this is the best approach.
- st3v3r 10y agoSo fraudulent behavior doesn't fit under that?
- izacus 10y agoThe thing the pisses me of about these cases is this: "I called them again and they said they can’t provide more information." They terminate your account and then they even refuse to tell you why. A basic human thing, a chance to fix the issue, but no. Go f* yourself from Apple and that's it.
- eridius 10y agoOr it could just mean that the person they talked to couldn't see any other information beyond what had already been communicated to the developer (terminated for fraudulent activity). Assuming this was human error on the part of Apple this would make sense, because there was no actual fraudulent activity and so no info would be available beyond the fact that someone flagged the account as such.
- omginternets 10y ago>Or it could just mean that the person they talked to couldn't see any other information beyond what had already been communicated to the developer Which is, in and of itself, a problem. It's understandable that the information might not be immediately on hand, but then the correct response would be to direct the caller to someone who can help. Otherwise, yes, it does come off as a big "fuck you".
- derefr 10y agoWhy are you assuming there's anyone who could help? Machine learning is used heavily in anti-fraud systems. Machine learning is also relatively opaque—a spam filter can't be prodded to "explain its thinking." I suspect there's frequently not a single human being in the company who could pull up the raw score vector fed to their anti-fraud model and use it to tell you what exactly made you look bad.
- TheSmiddy 10y agoSo instead of fobbing him off they should have said "sorry, on the help desk we can't see that information, I'm escalating this issue to X who will contact you with more information in Y days"
- edoceo 10y agoI make a regulatory compliance software. Apple refused to list my App until I removed functionality at their request. Functionality that is required for compliance. Apple's arrogance in running their store may eventually cause it's decline.
- giarc 10y agoI wouldn't expect Apple to understand compliance for every possible use case. Apple doesn't have to bend their rules to comply with apps that want to comply with local/state/provincial/federal laws, they can just say "We don't support x feature, and therefore you can't distribute through our store."
- jonlucc 10y agoBut that will mean that they can't be too upset when industries that require whatever compliance they won't allow into software moves to another ecosystem. It seems arbitrary to me to ask devs to remove functionality (except for in-app purchases that evade iOS or similar), but it's hard to judge without details.
- simonh 10y ago> But that will mean that they can't be too upset when industries that require whatever compliance they won't allow into software moves to another ecosystem That is quite right, and they don't get upset at all. Apple don't pretend to compete in every market for every niche and have no interest in doing so. If the Apple way doesn't suit you, they'll quite happily wave you goodbye as you move to Android or elsewhere. I often see people get upset because Apple doesn't address their particular use case or preference, but the fact is Android, Windows and Linux exist and are fine options for many people. The only case where this is really an issue IMHO is when someone buys in the Apple but didn't realize the limitations they would be under or when the limitations change to become more restrictive but that's not very common. Usually restrictions actually ease over time, such as the explosion in cross application functionality and opening of access to the JIT javascript engine in iOS made possible by secure cross process communication in recent iOS versions.
- credo 10y agoInteresting flagging behavior :) The #3 item on the front page has (Longest humans can live) had 44 points and was posted more than 1 hour ago. The #4 item (Typora) has 42 points and was posted more than 1 hour ago. However, this post on the App Store is at #8 even though it has 172 points and was submitted 47 minutes ago.
- hellofunk 10y agoI hope we will see an update here or somewhere soon that provides more information on why it was removed.
- hellofunk 10y agoJust noticed that Dash offers iOS docs. I wonder if Apple has a rule against charging a fee to provide their own documentation?
- zwily 10y agoAFAIK, Dash does not distribute them. It's just a viewer.
- superfluid 10y agoI think it might download them for local use.
- idbehold 10y agoThat's still considered a viewer unless it the iOS docs were included in the application when you installed it.
- hellofunk 10y agoDash advertises offline use. And that it packages docs.
- tedmiston 10y agoOr perhaps they released beta docs too early?
- fred256 10y agoPresumably that would cause the app to be rejected due to not complying with the app review guidelines, not terminating the entire developer account for fraud.
- 10y ago
- projectileboy 10y agoI wonder if Apple knows how many developers use Dash. They probably don't realize what a high-profile faux pas they're making.
- stuaxo 10y agoThis is the first time I've heard of this (not a mac user but am a developer). At least as this is software for developers, I reckon most won't mind buying it outside the appstore, it sounds really useful.
- RBerenguel 10y agoI used to have Dash when it was still free and in beta, but had some use hiccups (was on an older machine) and recently considered getting a license for it and getting the iOS versions as well... So now I have a problem, because my main point was not the Mac version (I could even use the emacs compatible package to browse Dash documentation) but iOS, and that can't be maintained.
- kstrauser 10y agoA plug for it: I love Dash. I was on the fence for a while ("I'm not more than a terminal window away from 'man foo'; why pay for it?") but now I love having a common interface to lots of the docs I use. It also integrates nicely with common editors, so a single key combo in Emacs pops open a Dash window for the thing I was looking at. Yeah, I know Emacs has that built-in, but Dash in a separate window on a separate screen is still more pleasant to use and look at.
- chillacy 10y agoIt's a lifesaver on planes where you won't have internet. If only I could download an archive of stackoverflow too, then I'd be set.
- ChickeNES 10y agoDash already includes the ability to download offline Stackoverflow datasets by language.
- abrkn 10y agoCould this be related to using the same name as the cryptocurrency? [1] [1] "Dash (DASH) is an open sourced, privacy-centric digital currency with instant transactions." https://www.dash.org/ https://www.dash.org/
- seamusgalla 10y agoI would hazard a guess that you're right.
- makecheck 10y agoWhen a serious action is going to be taken for any reason, that action should be PRECEDED by at least an E-mail to the owner and the path to reverse the action should be clear. The E-mail should not just be a terse message, it should contain a wide variety of resources; something like: "Your account and applications will be disabled in 2 days for <reason>. Please select from the following links to attempt to resolve the issue, or call <number> as soon as possible.". It’s not just apps, either. There is frequently a “less disruptive” option for any major action; for instance, you can “delete” files by starting with the instantly-reversible "chmod 000", and after some period of time you actually go ahead and "rm -Rf". If, in between, a panicked user E-mails you back and says they really needed those files, you undo your "chmod" and instantly fix the issue. Why should anything on the App Store take days?
- codazoda 10y agoThey can't give you advanced notice for "fraud" though. If your app actually commits fraud it's got to go right away to limit the amount of fraud you commit. They at least think some kind of fraud was happening, correctly or not.
- makecheck 10y agoNo, they still could. The message could say: “We have received X complaints of fraud for your app, "Totally Not a Scam Lite", and it will be removed in 2 days unless you contact us immediately at <number>. In addition, if this is found to be true, any sales of your app will be refunded and not credited to your developer account.”.
- codazoda 10y agoSure, they could, but it doesn't make business sense. This scheme might even cause a class action lawsuit from the people who bought it AFTER they knew it was fraud but BEFORE they removed it. Refunds very likely cost money in the form of credit card transaction fees and wages (people doing the refunding as well as CS fielding calls for two days).
- jbverschoor 10y agoMaybe you bought ratings?
- Sk1pp 10y agoIs there a way for us to remark to apple that this is something we want to see? I would gladly email support. This might be an effective way to handle these as I've seen a bunch of them. EDIT: I would like to know the source, I have apps on the app store and I wonder if it is a simple as someone putting in a fraudulent claim of fraudulence.
- superfluid 10y agoIf I had to guess, I'd say there might have been a copyright violation with respect to downloaded docs.
- tedmiston 10y agoFrom another comment: > Just noticed that Dash offers iOS docs. I wonder if Apple has a rule against charging a fee to provide their own documentation? That seems like a good hunch.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoBut that's not fraud right? Just an app store guideline violation. Or a copyright violation.
- vsl 10y agoNot even that, copyright concerns distribution, Dash isn't distributing anything, it's a tool the user uses to download stuff. Even if Apple misunderstood it, that would still not result in marking the account as fraud.
- BoronCorps 10y agoNote that the version of Dash on the MAS is not sandboxed. Even after the Dash 3 (major update) release, App Sandbox was not adopted.
- butterfi 10y agoConfusing, but makes me glad I bought Dash outside of the app store.
- givinguflac 10y agoI really hope it's not the case, and would be a dick move, but perhaps this is another sign that Apple is bringing development tools natively to iOS.
- diskrisknbisque 10y agoApple is choosing to only support a few cryptocurrencies and hasn't given any criteria for their choices. This is all people want, Apple--reasoning! The sting from incidences like these, at least for me, comes mostly from the information scarcity that proceeds them. Unfortunately, it seems, the writing truly was on the wall once Dash had to be removed from Jaxx Wallet. I'm not even a Dash user, but choice in such a new space is important.
- kemayo 10y agoWrong "Dash". This is about the documentation-browser, not the cryptocurrency.
- diskrisknbisque 10y agoAh you are correct. I've had cryptocurrency on the brain the last few weeks and was hasty.
- duncan_bayne 10y ago"... all who draw the sword will die by the sword." This sort of thing will continue as long as people persist in developing for proprietary walled gardens like iOS. Once again, and despite my annoyance with the man in general, Stallman is right. This sort of thing is unethical, and we as developers shouldn't be supporting it by developing for iOS. https://xkcd.com/743/ https://xkcd.com/743/
- brandon272 10y agoI don't know why anyone develops apps for Apple's walled prisons. I can't imagine the anxiety of having a widely used app in the app store, and knowing that any day, for any reason that you may or may not understand or be privy to, an invisible hand can simply reach in and shut down your account or remove your app with nothing more than a curt message about your non-compliance of their terms. No thanks!
- Reason077 10y agoI don't know why anyone develops apps for Apple's walled prisons. It's because there's such a large (and arguably, wealthy and influential) incarcerated population.
- alanh 10y agoWhat a convenient license migration! Excellent.
- anonymous_iam 10y agoPerhaps this is just another case of Apple/USG assuming the name Dash is associated with terrorism. After all, Dash is similar to Daesh...
- charlesdm 10y ago-
- farslan 10y agoPopescu is a very common family name in Romania, don't think this has something to do with this. The same would apply for american family names as well.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DannyBee 10y agoThis is pretty much a smear with no actual evidence? These are pretty common names.
- ary 10y agoI conversed with the developer of Dash a while back and found him to be a rather cordial and frankly honest person. He's from Romania, and had you done a single Google search for "Popescu" you might have seen this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popescu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popescu "Popescu (Francisized as Popesco) is a family name very common in Romania"
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoTim Cook does whatever the hell he wants to do.
- norswap 10y agoAt this point, this is neither surprising, not unexpected. There is ample precedent, there are tens of stories like this every days (maybe even counting only those that hit the HN frontpage). To avoid these problems, don't sell on the App Store, it's as simple as that (and very sad). Apple's processes suck and Apple doesn't care, as it has had year to fix things, but hasn't. Complaining won't change it. People have complained, and it didn't change.
- joemi 10y ago> there are tens of stories like this every days (maybe even counting only those that hit the HN frontpage) As someone who comes here every day, I don't think tens (or even ones) of this type of story hits the frontpage every day. I'm not saying it's not a problem, though.
- dec0dedab0de 10y agoIt looks like Dash downloads documentation from various sources and displays it offline. I wonder if one of the documentation sources has a license that doesn't permit this use, and then they filed a DMCA notice.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoSeems like pretty coincidental timing considering their account migration. Also I'm not sure that a DCMA takedown counts as fraud.
- dandare 10y agoI am annoyed by something else: today Apple stepped on the wrong toe, the community will cry foul and someone from Apple who reads HN will rush to salvage the situation. We have seen this pattern before (usually but not exclusively with Apple). But what about the thousands of small and nameless developers that were crushed by some script bug or killed by operator misclick? Who will ever help them?
- vbezhenar 10y agoHuman support is supposed to help them. What I found unacceptable is "We are banning you and we won't tell you anything about it". This pattern is extremely common. And extremely frustrating. You can't put one in jail without telling why (and right to defend). In many developed countries you can't even fire a worker without a solid reason. It should be prohibited for companies to halt service someone without providing a reasonable explanation.
- sithadmin 10y ago>It should be prohibited for companies to halt service someone without providing a reasonable explanation. By US standards, that would require an absurd level of legislative and/or judicial overreach. I don't think I'd even want to do business in that kind of regulatory climate.
- brokentone 10y agoThis is very true. However, I wonder if we as engineers and the like can provide a better TLDR ratings guide for marketplaces. Kinda like https://tosdr.org/ https://tosdr.org/ or a BBB that works... Then we as engineers refuse to build apps for marketplaces below some kind of score. Or does it even matter if the Apple App store is the only marketplace of its kind?
- weaksauce 10y agoIf people are making money on a platform, people will develop for it regardless of these issues. Unfortunate reality.
- jerrycabbage 10y agoThis is why anytime you are dealing with things that anyone could conceivably find questionable you either develop a website or skip Apple. Their fanboys tend to have money, but let this be a lesson..
- techwizrd 10y agoThis is disturbing. I've been working on an open-source Dash alternative [1] for Linux (anything with GTK actually) that is compatible with Dash docsets. Dash is a really cool piece of software, and it's really surprising to see something like this happen. I hope that this is resolved, and that we are Apple take steps to change their policy in the future. 1: https://github.com/techwizrd/tarpon https://github.com/techwizrd/tarpon
- smegel 10y ago"Hi, Fred from Apple here..." Things I've never seen on HN.
- SmokyBorbon 10y agoMaybe we shouldn't judge Apple until the facts come out. Thank you for the down votes.
- lihebi 10y agoJust want to complain that I bought Dash 2, and there's no way to access it after the Dash 3 is out. I don't understand why the guy wants to make money this way. Good job Apple.
- jrobichaud 10y agoIs Dash iOS affected as well?
- dav- 10y agoOn a positive note, this post introduced me to Dash and I have purchased the MacOS app directly through the developer. And I'm sure I am not the only one :)
- Patriot 10y agoMaybe because it sounds similar to > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAESH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAESH O_o
- ThomPete 10y agoMan that sucks. I ended up removing my app from the app store after I realized that Apple would never actually allow me to do what I wanted to do without having me go through hoops to get it approved every time i made an update. Never been happier. I am sure Dash will do just fine outside the app store too.
- ezoe 10y agoHe decided to waste his effort on the locked-in closed platform. He totally deserved it.
- deathtrader666 10y agoWhy isn't there a class-action lawsuit against Apple on issues like these?
- fierarul 10y agoIt's also quite possibly a legal mixup. The company he most likely used for the iOS app is, I assume, KAPELI APPS SRL which seems to have been incorporated in September 2016. Which means that for the OSX app he used another company or he sold it as an individual. This conflict as well as the company having no history might have triggered something on the Apple side.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoSeems to me if Apple doesn't resolve this in a few days, he should move to the ad hoc build-your-blob and side load it like f.lux did. Enter a license key to prove you've paid. It's beyond Apple's intent for the free version of Xcode, but what does he have to lose? Fuck 'em.
- gtsteve 10y agoIf it makes you feel better, I'd never heard of this app before. I really like it, and I'll probably end up buying it (on macOS).
- amelius 10y agoIn my opinion, if an internalized market has more than (say) 10K independent people making a profit from it, the government should step in and require it to be opened up, and follow the rules of the free market. This should hold not only for Apple, but also Google, Uber, AirBnB, et cetera.
- mrmondo 10y agoDoes this mean I get a refund for my purchase?
- jheriko 10y agoi'm a little skeptical this is the right approach... everytime i've encountered a problem that someone couldn't resolve with apple over the phone, i've managed to resolve it by phoning them. i wonder how much effort the developer really made, and how he talked to the people he dealt with. my experience of apple, and infact most customer service is that if you are nice and sympathetic and explain thoroughly the nature of the problem, then people will do their best to resolve it.
- okket 10y agoUpdate: Apple contacted me and told me they found evidence of App Store review manipulation. This is something I’ve never done. Apple’s decision is final and can’t be appealed.
- ogsharkman 10y agoapple: "we found evidence.." them: "what exactly?" apple: "evidence" them: "..."
- funkysquid 10y agoThat's infuriating - is there some way we can contact the app review team to complain about their "final" decision?
- beamatronic 10y agoAMA Request, someone on the app review team at Apple.
- mokus 10y agoSo all it takes to destroy someone's iOS app business is to hire a shady marketer to shill for them?
- Aaronn 10y agoPhil Schiller's response (from this 9to5Mac article https://9to5mac.com/2016/10/05/apple-inexplicably-terminates-developer-account-for-popular-developer-app-dash-apps-removed-from-app-store/ https://9to5mac.com/2016/10/05/apple-inexplicably-terminates...): "Hi Matthew, Thanks for your email about this app. I did look into this situation when I read about it today. I am told this app was removed due to repeated fraudulent activity. We often terminate developer accounts for ratings and review fraud, including actions designed to hurt other developers. This is a responsibility that we take very seriously, on behalf of all of our customers and developers. I hope that you understand the importance of protecting the App Store from repeated fraudulent activity. Thank you, Phil"
- makecheck 10y agoI have to say, the way he has handled this has been fantastic. Within a day, he has published a license migration tool; fully explained the situation; and basically made it as painless as possible for all his users (versions 2 and 3) to start using non-App-Store licensing. I immediately paid $10 to upgrade from 2 to 3.
- madushan92 10y agoIs there a way to notify Apple about this like a petition or something? Lots of us would be happy to help
- aabbcc1241 10y agoNot mean to be offensive but I will think this way: App Store is a commercial service. When you post something there, you're solidating service from Apple. So if they reject to serve you, it's like a store reject to sell something to you (not because you cannot pay for it). My first response is why don't distribute it on your own, like an HTTP link to 'apk'... then I realised general user cannot install stuff without App Store. Why open source project bother to support people not using open source system? You cannot save to whole world (like someone lock himself intentionally during a fire, and reject to open the door. It might not be a good example but I hope you get my thought)
- tj4shee 10y agoI bought my version of Dash on the App store.... shame on me ! and this is the exact reaon I avoid the app store and buy things directly from the developers when I can. So Apple, how do I get my $$$ back so I can rebuy it from a reputable source ???
- tj4shee 10y agoApple has not only screwed the developer, but also EVERYONE that paid for this through the app store... I will no longer be afforded upgrades that the developer makes...
- zorrobyte 10y agoWell, that was a complete waste of time. I requested a refund or credit for Dash as I paid $29 for it. Chat and Phone T1 and T2 Advisors all said there is nothing they can do and kept suggesting I restore a backup. Too bad "Transfer Purchases" was removed in iOS 9 with App Slimming - meaning that there is no way to backup/extract an ipk file from iOS using native tools. They also couldn't offer any sort of iTunes Store credit or refund. Long story short, if Apple decides to remove an App from their platform, it's gone - period and they don't give a sh*t how much you paid for it.