21 ms·
Tesla Wins Contract to Help Power the California Grid
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI think its important to note, for those who complain Tesla can't compete against pumped storage or other utility scale storage methods, that Tesla is able to have this deployed in 3 months (this is partly because Tesla can just drop racks of batteries on site and be up and running, and partly because of the regulatory environment after the Aliso Canyon natural gas storage complex leak fiasco). Edit: This will replace the need for peaker plants first (generators of last resort, very expensive, only run a handful of hours a year), and as the cost drops, will slowly push out base load coal and natural gas (by increasing the capacity factor of solar and wind). "Batteries are the new peaker plants", as it were. [1] [2] [3] This is what it looks like when batteries are used to offset fossil fuel generators (instead of curtailing excess wind and solar, it'll be soaked up by utility batteries such as these). Frequently, depending on renewables output, the spot of price of power can go negative. This means someone gets paid to use that power. This is where utility scale battery storage shines, as its happy to gobble up that power, being paid to do so, and can later be paid to release that power when demand is high. Edit 2: If Tesla can book this revenue in Q3, combined with their vehicle sales push, they're going to be GAAP profitable for the quarter, which will allow them to close the Solar City acquisition. Well played. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant [2] http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/dueling-charts-of-the-day-peaker-plants-vs.-green-power http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/dueling-charts-o... [3] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-22/batteries-gaining-favor-over-gas-peaker-plants-in-california http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-22/batteries-...
- spectrum1234 10y agoProbably can't book the revenue in Q3 though given it won't be realized. But outside of GAAP it can still help gain confidence.
- dba7dba 10y ago> Well played. Well planned for sure too. These things don't happen by chance. I'm sure they were planning for this all along. Good for them.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoSo this is only financially viable because of Californian risk aversion after last years gas leak. If you have a reliable natural gas distribution network, like the rest of the world, batteries don't make any financial sense versus gas power plants. I mean, this entire plant can supply 20 MW and will cost somewhere around $20 million. For that price you can buy two General Electric LM2500 gas turbine generators that can supply 47 MW and will fit in the same space as three 40-ft shipping containers. (These are basically just aircraft engines modified to produce electricity.) So while this particular sale is of course good for Tesla, I don't see how one can justify this as Tesla "transitioning to a clean energy company". They saw a profitable, but likely one-time, opportunity localised to CA and they took it.
- greglindahl 10y agoGas power plants and batteries have different timescales. Grids with a lot of renewable energy need a slice of capacity that can ramp up faster than a gas turbine. "The fastest loading gas turbine models produce 30% load delivery after 7 minutes" -- http://www.wartsila.com/energy/learning-center/technical-comparisons/combustion-engine-vs-gas-turbine-ramp-rate http://www.wartsila.com/energy/learning-center/technical-com... If you've driven a Tesla, you may have noticed that they can reach peak a bit faster than that.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI'd encourage you to spend 15 minutes researching what the costs are of running a peaker plant. There's a reason they're the most expensive generation method per MWh (peakers run for under 100 hours per year). Revenue is revenue. If Tesla is able to cannibalize the peakers to contribute towards its enormous capital expenditures, and continue to reduce costs with the Gigafactory, it only makes utility battery storage more affordable. There is no scenario where the cost curve per kWh of battery storage goes up.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoSure peakers are expensive, but they are profitable, otherwise no-one would build and run them. Supply and demand etc. I'm not sure what you mean by Tesla cannibalizing the peakers? Do they already own traditional peaker plants? I agree revenue is revenue, I'm just saying this is perhaps unlikely to provide more revenue from sales outside CA.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoTake a look at this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/power-plants/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/power-plant... The fact is, most parts of the country don't have good energy storage options. Plenty, like Florida for example, are almost exclusively coal + natural gas and some nuclear. The advantage of these battery facilities is that they enable transitions away from coal and natural gas.
- charlesetc 10y agoWhy do you all rely on oil? Just use batteries... \s I think it's important to note that they are not "replacing fossil-fuel electricity generation with lithium-ion batteries". They are putting fossil-fuel supplied electricity into batteries to use at a later date.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoThat's 99% true, but Southern California also has periods of time when there's too much _solar_ power and they need to take some solar systems off-line! (See http://www.vox.com/2016/4/8/11376196/california-grid-expansion http://www.vox.com/2016/4/8/11376196/california-grid-expansi...) This may alleviate that problem
- Mao_Zedang 10y agoChicken meet Egg, we have to do both things does it matter in what order it is done. Oil can be stored in a tank, renewables really are playing catch up in terms of storage. This is a great step forward for getting off oil.
- crottypeter 10y agoExactly. Thermal power stations (oil, coal, gas, nuclear) cannot start up or shutdown quickly so they have to run enough to meet peak demand 24/7. Lots of energy is wasted in the small hours.
- pyoung 10y agoThe biggest need for storage is to offset the intermittency of solar and wind, and to help shift peak solar generation (typically 12-2pm) to match peak demand (typically 4-8pm). Reliable and affordable storage is a prerequisite to wide scale solar and wind generation. http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/californias-duck-curve-will-encourage-innovation http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/californias-duck...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoSure you want to smooth out intermittencies, but this plant is way too tiny to actually store energy when it's windy and releasing it when it's not. It's more likely to handle peaking on a minute-by-minute basis. Considering that a single big wind turbine produces 8 MW, this 80 MWh storage facility can only store 5 hours of production from two wind turbines! And one of those turbines only costs about half of the Tesla storage facility.
- allendoerfer 10y agoI find it weird how technological process sometimes plays out. We have been complaining for decades about how green energy is unreliable and that we need innovative storage solutions. And now batteries somehow seem to be good enough and we are like: "Hey, why don't we put a bunch of batteries in a container?" Proving ones again that economy trumps technology. The next really big thing after green energy will be recycling. Not that it matters to our generation.
- itengelhardt 10y agoI think this is very much a success of technology. I see it as battery tech having advanced enough (at a slow, but exponential rate) to bring us to a point where this is technologically possible AND economical
- allendoerfer 10y agoI guess what I am trying to say is that the future is rather lame and predictable. When imagining the future we are sometimes thinking there will be some giant jump forward, while in reality it is just decades and decades of minimizing microchips, increasing photovoltaic efficiency, improving batteries. This technology (except the microchip) is from the 19th (!) century. On top of that we are using some statistical methods and are trying to emulate neurons. This has a positive and a negative side: Everything is already there, we just need to implement it, but this does not really encourage you to dream. There is no magic. For me that is part the reason why careers like research or medicine were not attractive to me: You can progress further or save more lifes by just using stuff that has been here for centuries. I believe everybody can make a difference, because we are wasting our potential by not implementing stuff. I know that this view is oversimplified and there is indeed fundamental research (e.g. new materials), which leads to some of these gradual improvements.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe day a room temp superconductor is developed (and is scalable to mass production) you'll see that change in a crazy hurry. Assuming we're alive then, which is probably not a safe assumption. There are a few things like that which could change the game almost overnight, but a room temp superconductor would be one of, if not the biggest.
- 1024core 10y ago> Tesla's contribution is enough to power about 2,500 homes for a full day This is < 0.1% of the total number of homes in SoCal, just to put it in perspective.
- elliotec 10y agoYeah... seems odd to describe it as "massive"
- nl 10y agoIt's pretty important to realize that this isn't the problem that needs solving. Batteries aren't great for large amounts of power for long periods of time (yet). What they are good at is smoothing out the supply curve from potentially intermittent suppliers like solar and wind, and that is one of the things that causes price spikes.
- WalterBright 10y agoHaving real-time pricing of electricity coupled with users who can adapt their usage automatically to real-time prices will also considerably moderate power demand.
- nl 10y agoYes. Also, trading off the reliability of power. This seems outrageous to many of us in the West, but here in Australia our power utility already cuts power to neighborhoods in half hour blocks during peak power consumption during summer (I believe they exclude hospitals and some other sites like that from this policy). The infrastructure savings made by this are huge (think of 99% reliability vs 99.99% in software), and the few that really need it can invest in backup solutions for those times.
- andruby 10y agoHow huge are the savings? Do you have any numbers or sources? Do those power utility savings translate into savings to the people who are cut off? I for one would not want to trade electricity price for reliability.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoWhy doesn't Panasonic just cut out the middleman here? Are they afraid of making their own deals in america?
- dangrossman 10y ago"Panasonic is quietly selling grid batteries in the U.S." http://fortune.com/2015/09/10/panasonic-batteries-america/ http://fortune.com/2015/09/10/panasonic-batteries-america/ They've also done some larger grid storage projects in other countries, and with partners other than Tesla.
- wallace_f 10y agoBecause the world we live in has certain types of people -- politicians, lawyers, business executives -- that don't solve problems for the world as in, "what is the most efficient way to accomplish this;" rather, they solve problems as in, "what is the most efficient way I can enrich myself. I guess it's maybe rational in a self-interested way--no longer do we live in a world of many competing tribes advancing ourselves for our own survival among competition for scarce resources. We live in an increasingly globalized world with a class structure and an overabundance of resources. Or, in other words, "the scarcity problem," as Keynes put it, has pretty much already been solved--at least in terms of survival we have enough resources to feed, cloth, provide shelter and basic healthcare to every person on the planet, but we don't. The answers to that are some of the same reasons.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>certain types of people -- politicians, lawyers, business executives I forgot how altruistic software engineers, web developers and IT consultants were.
- wallace_f 10y agoIn a general sense is it not better for all people to be in he business of creating value than to quarrel over transferring it from one to another? I believe that if you care about human welfare, then it is obvious that it is.
- pkaye 10y agoI wonder what happened to Bloom Energy. Wasn't their technology suited for this kind of use?
- jonah 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12511632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12511632
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoOP seems confused, claims these battery packs will 'replace fossil fuels'. Under some misconception that the batteries get charged for free or something.
- jonah 10y agoSolar and Wind aren't fossil fuels. That said, we need a whole heck of a lot more of them to replace fossil fuels. But, as other commenters have stated, if you can charge these batteries during the day and use the power at night, then yes, you can replace the 24 hour nature of gas/coal.
- URSpider94 10y agoThey do displace fossil fuel generation to some degree, since utilities use natural gas turbines to respond to rapid load shifts. If all these batteries do is buffer short-term demand spikes, then base load can be supported by e.g. nuclear power, which is very slow to spin up or down.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoOne of the things I wish I could buy would be a Bloom Energy 2kW natural gas fuel cell and a 50kWh LiON battery pack with whole house inverter. The nice thing about the Bloom fuel cells is very efficient conversion of natural gas to electricity, the weakness is that it's response time is long (an hour or more to change its output by 50%). The nice thing about LiOn battery packs like the ones in Tesla cars are that they respond instantly to various power demands, can deliver massive amounts of power in a short period of time, and recharge again and again. This combination would let me supply all of my house power under all circumstances using nothing but natural gas. That would take my house completely off the grid infrastructure for PG&E (although I would still be a gas customer). C'mon Elon, make it possible! :-)
- mrfusion 10y ago50kwh seems high for your needs. Wouldn't five or ten be enough if you're constantly replenishing from the fuel cell?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 10y agoNot only does Chuck want to own & charge an electric car, but he also wants to be able to take advantage of many days of sunny weather in a row. A smaller battery means a bigger gas bill.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoExactly right.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIf you can get the Bloom fuel cell, you could already do this with several PowerWalls ganged together and the proper inverter. Why the fuel cell though instead of solar? Trying to sidestep the monthly electric utility charge? If so, I'd still go solar, and rely on a natural gas generator as your supply of last resort.
- h4nkoslo 10y agoMusk really does seem to be following his pattern of maximally engaging government contracts and subsidies. (That's not necessarily a criticism, just an observation, and one others have made before.)
- peteretep 10y agoSuspect there aren't all that many non-government contracts of that size
- greglindahl 10y agoThis is totally incorrect - in most parts of the US, the power company/companies is/are private, and needs similar devices.
- mturmon 10y agoI heard Richard Branson's business projects described the same way. (One link: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jun/10/truth-richard-branson-virgin-rail-profits https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jun/10/truth-...)
- hkmurakami 10y agoSimilar to Son Masayoshi of SoftBank. (Wireless spectrum, solar subsidies)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aggie 10y agoYou could also frame this as his companies align well with government initiatives because their success is largely in the public interest (or at least the success of the markets they are in or trying to establish).
- greglindahl 10y agoPrivate power companies have similar constraints and needs.
- foota 10y agoThere was a really neat class I took in college on the economics of elctricity markets, and one of the things you discuss is base vs peak power generating plants (as discussed other places in this thread) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor seems to be a nice introduction to the idea.
- contingencies 10y agoA few years ago, one of the more interesting responses I had to an announcement of a project in to modern asset-generic, topology-generic, risk model-generic, actor-perspective oriented transaction protocols[1] was a US academic engineer interested in applications to electrical grids and embedded power systems in resource-constrained environments. I would like to have continued further and still believe in the currency of such a system (especially given rapidly evolving, complex risk models in infrastructure systems of all types), unfortunately my employer had other priorities and I have not had reason to return to the project. The IFEX protocol notes in particular may be interesting reading for those in the area, however. [1] http://ifex-project.org/ http://ifex-project.org/
- prawn 10y agoFrom the Tesla blog: Addressing Peak Energy Demand with the Tesla Powerpack https://www.tesla.com/blog/addressing-peak-energy-demand-tesla-powerpack/ https://www.tesla.com/blog/addressing-peak-energy-demand-tes...
- KamiCrit 10y agoI love Tesla and Elon Musk as much as the next person. But isn't it a little crazy how much Elon is betting on 18650 lithium ion batteries. I really hope I'm mistaken and they have a homemade battery package made up.
- greglindahl 10y agoSpaceX rockets don't have the most "advanced" engines, but they sure are cost-effective. Tesla's done some pretty good things with 18650 cells and cars, and now they're hitting some serious volume. I'm surprised that that cell works for utility-scale deployments, but...
- ccorda 10y agoThey do (although only slightly different), the 2170: http://fortune.com/2016/07/27/tesla-bigger-battery-gigafactory/ http://fortune.com/2016/07/27/tesla-bigger-battery-gigafacto...
- marvin 10y agoFascinating, thanks for this link. This is a pretty obscure but heavy decision.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- whamlastxmas 10y agoWhat's wrong with the 18650 form factor? Or lithium ion batteries?
- Dylan16807 10y agoIsn't it a little crazy how much beverage companies are betting on 12 ounce cans? I don't understand what risk you're referring to.
- dragontamer 10y agoTo put some numbers into perspective. Texas recently purchased 317MW of CAES. http://www.apexcaes.com/project http://www.apexcaes.com/project ----------- Pumped Hydro is 3GW (Giga-watts): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bath_County_Pumped_Storage_Sta... And has a storage capacity of ~10 hours (that's 30GW approximately). --------- 20MW isn't exactly "massive" in the utility scale.
- esemor 10y agoI think Tesla is a better contractor than when California tried something similat with Enron in the late 90's.
- xyuuu 10y agoNo doubt that Tesla is a great company although it face many serious problems right now. Tesla represents tomorrow and future.
- oneplane 10y agoI don't understand why there are so many power grid issues in the USA. It's not that hard to generate power and make it go from A to B, yet for some reason (political? commercial? geological?) there seem to be decades of general issues in generating enough to meet demand. Does someone know what the actual issue is?
- adventured 10y agoFamously the US had an extraordinary power grid for many decades. Among the most reliable of any nation. Blackouts used to be very rare in the US, now they're still rare but not nearly so. Since the 1980s there has been a significant under-investment in the grid. Since the 1970s there has been a significant under-investment in production. The outcome to that is what you see now. Good article on the rising blackout phenomenon from 2010: http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/innovation/08/09/smart.grid/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/innovation/08/09/smart.grid/ind...
- icc97 10y agoMusk was commenting on this point in his YC interview yesterday. There can be no assumption that technology will always get better. If people aren't focussed on improving it then the current level of the technology will fall.
- klakier 10y agoWhat a bullshit. I'd call this Russian way of doing business, where you benefit from unhealthy connections with state. 2500 houses? Go find out how many houses are there in California.
- Faaak 10y ago"will supply 20 megawatts (80 mWh) of energy" Confusing milli and mega is not very serious for bloomberg..
- tantalor 10y agoAlso, watts = power, not energy
- tbarbugli 10y ago"The deal fits into Tesla Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk's long-term vision of transforming Tesla from an an electric car company to a clean-energy company. That's the same motivation behind his pending deal to acquire SolarCity Corp., the rooftop solar company founded by his cousins, of which he is also chairman and the largest shareholder." Yeah man, what a lucky coincidence your cousin can help you saving the planet!
- Daishiman 10y agoThis has been his plan for a decade. It was publicly known, no secret whatsoever.
- refulgentis 10y agoSolar City was retconned into a vague document that takes a mile-high view of the problem. This was unambiguously poor corporate governance, unless you completely ignore the business side of...the business?
- Roritharr 10y agoWithout reading this somewhere or having anything to back it up: This, combined with the acquisition of SolarCity, looks like a move to get Tesla into a different Asset Category to make it even cheaper to loan money. If they can be seen in the same risk/asset-category as a power utility, they can rely even more heavily on loans. Does anyone know if that would be a viable strategy?
- wbc 10y agounless they're having trouble getting funding w/o loans, this shouldn't matter: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/modigliani-millertheorem.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/modigliani-millertheorem... TLDR: market value is based on earnings power and independent on cost of capital. i don't think the risk of underlying assets change much in this case
- Lagged2Death 10y agoA positive development, sure. But 80MWH is a little less than the amount of energy a 1GW power plant produces every five minutes. I want alternative energy to work, but it's sobering to see the scale of the problems involved. It doesn't seem to me that laptop batteries scale up so well. If I were forced to place a bet on the future of grid-scale storage, I'd look for something else.
- giovannibonetti 10y agoI wish reporters would know that (mega)watts is not an energy storage unit. I think they mean (mega)watt-hour.
- kayamon 10y agoI think they mean Joules.
- PatentTroll 10y agoIt isn't mentioned in the article, but one of the advantages of something like battery storage is the ability to regulate consumption and production on a millisecond timescale to regulate grid frequency. Anyone know if that is a part of the project here?
- mirekrusin 10y agoSo California gets big rechargeable batteries, interesting. Does it mean Solar City (pending acquisition by Tesla) will speed up building Gigafactory and that's how Tesla will deliver it? And does it mean that the market was wrong with recent Solar City stock drop? I'm assuming this is just a "pilot" and, if executed happily, can keep doubling capacity every x months, driving battery prices down, leveraging it as an further advantage over fossil alternatives. I'm assuming I'm completely wrong because I don't see any spikes in Solar City stock prices? ps. Bit off-topic but when opening this article I've decided to disable adblock for bloomberg, just because they made bucklescript :P
- nardi 10y agoThere are two different Gigafactories. Tesla is building the one in Nevada for batteries, and that's the one you hear about in the news the most often. SolarCity is building a different Gigafactory for solar panels in Buffalo, New York.
- jgalt212 10y agoMore corporate welfare for the Corporate Welfare Queen.
- mikeyouse 10y ago> More corporate welfare for the Corporate Welfare Queen. Southern California Edison is a subsidiary of a publicly traded energy company.. Where exactly is the subsidy here?
- nraynaud 10y agoSo maybe it's time to re-open the debate on AC vs DC in power distribution? :p
- zymhan 10y agoThis was brought up in a Fresh Air interview I listened to recently. Nowadays most of our devices use DC, and our grid is also on the verge of becoming much less centralized. You could reap some easy efficiency gains by omitting the DC-AC-DC conversion of a solar panel powering a house that charges a laptop.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoDC sucks for transmission over more than a few meters. I'm thinking, even in a house, you still want AC in the walls.
- nraynaud 10y agocan you explain a bit more?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoHeat in wire is ~ current squared times resistance. If you use low-voltage DC, and you're supplying any significant power, then the current is high and the losses to wire heating are high. Inefficient and dangerous (fires). AC at high voltage can be low current, you can use much smaller wires for a given power.
- hx87 10y agoDC doesn't have to be low voltage though. Before high power solid state electronics became reliable, it was difficult to do DC-DC voltage conversion without going through AC first, but that isn't true today. Plenty of power is delivered across different grids using HVDC.
- 10y ago