13 ms·
FUTO Swipe – A new swipe typing model
- nozzlegear 5mo agoThe swipe demo on the website is neat! I wasn't expecting to be able to use it with my mouse.
- satvikpendem 5mo agoVery cool, I use swipe typing almost exclusively so good to see open models. It just needs to preserve word history for custom words, not sure if it does that.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 5mo agoDoes anyone know of a FOSS keyboard that supports swiping in Korean? I'm yet to find one
- jawns 5mo agoI'm curious how it compares with Microsoft SwiftKey. Obviously, that's not an open-source app, but it would be an interesting benchmark.
- Mashimo 5mo agoI'm also a heavy SwiftKey user, but donated some money to futo last year in hopes they improve the keyboard. SwiftKey got annoying with pushing Ai image Gen and sometimes pop-ups.
- nh2 5mo agoI've been using SwiftKey for 10 years (typing not swiping), and test ran FUTO for the last month. FUTO improved a lot (I had tried it a year earlier also) but SwiftKey's suggestions are still a lot better in my opinion. With SwiftKey I can just type roughly in the right spot without looking and the correct words will come out most of the time. FUTO still suggests a lot of nonsensical next words that just do not follow after the previous in English. I hope it improves further so I can switch. The voice models are great though, and they can be used as part of the keyboard or standalone.
- jacooper 5mo agoIf only FUTO supported combined keyboard languages without duplicates. Why would there be two separate de and en layouts when multilingual typing is enabled.
- tekacs 5mo agoThis is amazing! It's driven me nuts for a very long time that so many mobile keyboards allow totally non-sequitur nonsensical sequence completions. In particular, if you end up using the voice input mode of it and have trouble with accuracy, I would giving a try to the biggest model that it supports. It's slower (although really not bad at all on my Galaxy Fold), but it's so nice to have it actually be as accurate as it is.
- prism56 5mo agoI settled on the middle model.
- james2doyle 5mo agoDo they still have that issue where it will randomly spit out a string of emojis when using voice to text?
- tekacs 5mo agoNot for me so far!
- HiPhish 5mo agoFor anyone wondering: the library uses the GPLv3 (good) while the Android keyboard uses the Futo License (shit). - https://gitlab.futo.org/keyboard/swipe-library/-/blob/master/LICENSE?ref_type=heads https://gitlab.futo.org/keyboard/swipe-library/-/blob/master... - https://github.com/futo-org/android-keyboard/blob/master/LICENSE.md https://github.com/futo-org/android-keyboard/blob/master/LIC...
- cge 5mo agoTo add to the license complexity, the model uses another FUTO-written license, though it at least does not seem as bad as the license for the keyboard: https://huggingface.co/futo-org/futo-swipe/blob/main/LICENSE.md https://huggingface.co/futo-org/futo-swipe/blob/main/LICENSE...
- rkagerer 5mo agoWhat's particularly objectionable about the Futo License? Is it this part? you may not remove or obscure any functionality in the software related to payment to the Licensor in any copy you distribute to others.
- mzajc 5mo agoThe clause you cited as well as the "Termination" section and the non-commercial restriction make it a non-free license. Besides the direct issues with that, it also means all software covered by this license is unsuitable for FOSS-only distributions like Debian or F-Droid. It's not entirely clear to me if the license is copyleft; derivative works have similar problems if so. As an aside, Eron Wolf, the billionaire behind FUTO, has some rather... out of touch views[0] on the meaning of open source, and seems very committed to diluting the term to mean something closer source-available by removing the most of the rights granted (as defined by FSF, OSI, DFSG and others). [0]: https://gitlab.futo.org/eron/public/-/wikis/Thoughts-on-Open-Source https://gitlab.futo.org/eron/public/-/wikis/Thoughts-on-Open... - please keep in mind that the RMS quote at the top is taken out of context; he is arguing for more freedom, not less
- 5mo ago
- Sebguer 5mo agoGreat timing given I just installed SwiftKey since Microsoft has started embedding ads and dark pattern redirects to Bing!
- speedgoose 5mo agoYou meant uninstalled, right ? It’s unfortunate that the Bing team at Microsoft has so much power. They destroy products for the glory of Bing, and some money. Perhaps it’s about the money. But I feel like Microsoft doesn’t have to make a lot of money on everything they do.
- ericol 5mo agoAssuming you mean uninstall, yeah I did the same because of that. I wasn getting a constant panel from them regarding using the backup feature, that will just keep re appearing. It was so bad I even moved to GBoard. Not the same, but I'm getting used to.
- madspindel 5mo agoMust say it's a little bit lame that they are boycotting iOS. I will not change phone just to use this app but it would be nice to be able to replace SwiftKey with this.
- smlacy 5mo agoboycotting?
- exabyte 5mo agotrue... there are many better reasons to leave iOS than for a keyboard
- zem 5mo agoI'm pretty sure there is no way for them to supply an ios version without having to go through some sort of apple approval process. hardly boycotting to say that you're not about to put up with that crap.
- eikenberry 5mo agoDon't they have to go through a Google approval process for (official) Android? I'm not sure I see this as a big win unless they are strictly supporting GrapheneOS and other de-Googled Androids.
- zem 5mo agothey do, but it's on fdroid too - at that point the play store is simply a nice to have. if google does anything they don't like they can just say okay and keep publishing on fdroid, they have not lost whatever efforts they have invested into android. apple has absolutely no way to just publish an app and let people install it, which at least to my mind delegitimises them as a viable platform. I'm pretty sure if I made open source mobile apps they would be android only, people would be free to take the source and release an ios version under different branding.
- 5mo ago
- oehtXRwMkIs 5mo agodemo seems worse than heliboard
- prism56 5mo agoI've used both extensively and it's a fair bit better, but was significantly worse preupdate
- prism56 5mo agoFuto with the new swipe model is the first android keyboard i've used that I don't feel like i'm compromising vs GBoard. Integrated speak to text, good autocorrect typing, good autocorrect swiping.
- spicyusername 5mo agoLove swipe typing. Nice to see more keyboards in the space.
- skeledrew 5mo agoI've been using HeliBoard for a while now, but IIRC the swipe library it uses is from Google (have to install it separately to comply with license). Wonder how this stacks up.
- Multicomp 5mo agoI am a heliboard user myself and im only just trying this new keyboard out but at least right now it feels faster and has all the goodies I want in a soft keyboard. 1. super responsive 2. arrow keys!! why this is impossible is beyond me 3. easy access to text editor and undo redo via the long pressing of the enter button 4. easy resizing and im using a floating mode so it's all near my thumb and no awkward bends, just my phone being too heavy for my pinky because phones are massive these days 5. offline voice is comparable at a glance to the offline voice input app I was using with heliboard. that's with their biggest ugliest English model and my phone is from 2022 at the newest. 6. have I mentioned how performance is great on this app yet? pleasantly surprised. y'all do you but I am keeping this FUTO keyboard.
- a022311 5mo agoI agree, it's by far the best mobile keyboard I've ever tried. I especially love the shortcuts for copy/paste/select all/cut which send the actual Ctrl-C. I can finally use terminals! :-P
- amelius 5mo agoOn the one hand snapping to the nearest English word is useful. On the other hand it will prevent our language from evolving.
- sheept 5mo agoI can't speak for this keyboard, but at least on Gboard, if you type out a word a few times, it'll be stored in its suggestions dictionary and you'll be able to swipe type it.
- functionmouse 5mo agoedit: NOT guaranteed to be free and open! seems to have a confusing license setup. Boooo! Works good though, I'll take it over Gboard. This is such a massive deal. This is, as far as I can tell, the first useful free and open Swipe model. This paves the way for things like swipe typing on platforms other than iOS and Android, a major pain point to newcomer OSes.
- functionmouse 5mo agoseems to be really good
- jordand 5mo agoI used the FUTO keyboard for a few months but ditched it as the word suggestions were either odd or random (one example: I'd write 'Jordan' and it would always suggest 'Peterson' as the next word), and I'd got a weirdly passive aggressive prompt saying I should really purchase a license. Went back to the de-Googled Android keyboard in GrapheneOS
- drewstiff 5mo agoFollowing "Jordan" with "Peterson" doesn't seem random in the slightest
- jordand 5mo agoIt never had my own surname as a suggestion, and there's many people, places and things called 'Jordan' in some way
- OsrsNeedsf2P 5mo agoSo you want it to randomly pick the next word, rather than suggest the most common word?
- jordand 5mo agoThe most common word I entered after my forename is my surname. All other keyboards handled this fine, but FUTO didn't. That's what's odd
- stavros 5mo agoI think that, for it to learn a word, you need to actually press the middle suggestion, not just space. I'm not sure, though. Couldn't you add your surname as a custom word?
- copper-float 5mo agoJust tried typing Jordan on mine, and my suggestions were "on", "is", and the Jordanian flag. So I'm pretty sure you had to have typed the words "Jordan Peterson" before for it to make that association. The donation prompt can permanently disabled with two taps, so I'm not sure why that'd be a reason to abandon it. It's a complete non-issue. "You've been using FUTO keyboard for X days. If you find this app useful, please consider paying to support future development. FUTO is dedicated to making good software that doesn't abuse you. This app will never serve ads or collect your personal data." I don't mean to be rude here, but this is an extremely bland, mild message. There's nothing passive aggressive about it in any way. What do you find aggressive about this?
- blopker 5mo agoI've been using this keyboard on and off for a while now. I've always switched back to gboard, however this update made me convert full time. It's really good. There are a few issues, like it randomly capitalizes words in the middle of sentences. Also, it doesn't seem to take context into account when suggesting words, so words that clearly wouldn't follow the last word will often show up. It's not as good as gboard yet, but close enough that I'm going to stick with it. Note that if you have a more powerful device, you can get larger models for voice and larger dictionaries from their site. They make a noticeable difference. The only fundamental issue I have with it, they seem to be ideologically opposed to adding a GIF search, which I miss occasionally. https://github.com/futo-org/android-keyboard/issues/293#issuecomment-3024858791 https://github.com/futo-org/android-keyboard/issues/293#issu...
- james2doyle 5mo agoWe sound similar. I have found that the voice to text can often just randomly start spitting out emojis. Did you find that?
- rpdillon 5mo agoWhich voice model are you using? I found that the english-74 is quite excellent. Used it to type this. Haven't seen the emoji issue with that model. Perhaps you're on english-39? https://keyboard.futo.org/voice-input-models https://keyboard.futo.org/voice-input-models
- globular-toast 5mo agoGood. That's a silly thing to have in a keyboard. No silly childish gifs that I can accidentally click on is a great feature.
- throawayonthe 5mo agoworse, there's silly keys you can accidentally click and type out flibbertigibbet. very childish
- 5mo ago
- popcar2 5mo agoAwesome. I've been using FUTO keyboard for two years now and it's the best free & private keyboard I found, but swiping has been really bad for all these keyboards which was such a pain because I use swiping a lot. Nice to see the hour of swiping I did adding to their dataset actually helped. I'm using it now and it feels as good as the Google keyboard. Edit: It is sending me a little that it keeps swiping "whats" instead of "what's" though, hopefully they fix that later.
- backscratches 5mo agoHeliboard has had great swipe for a while and has two finger swipe which is killer feature
- catelm 5mo agoMind blown. And brain broken as I try to swipe with two fingers
- backscratches 5mo agoI'm sorry, once you've tried it you may not be able to go back. For close to a decade have been using an unmaintained app called nintype that was apparently the inventor of two finger swipe until it stopped working on new android versions... Heliboard saved me from actual despair
- pmontra 5mo agoI'll look for a video. I like swyping because I can hold the phone in one hand and swipe with the thumb. The other hand is free. Two finger swiping would negate that advantage but maybe it opens up other usage scenarios.
- backscratches 5mo agoIts optional! One finger swipe on heliboard works at least as well as gboard or this futo one.
- Vingdoloras 5mo agoAfter experiencing Nintype on iOS many years ago, I can't use any other swipe keyboard anymore. I'm stuck using the stock keyboard for typing, and sometimes (rarely) swiping a word or two when I din't have two hands available. Swiping (with one finger) when holding my phone with both hands just feels unnatural and sluggish. I wish Apple had just bought/sherlocked Nintype and integrated it into the stock keyboard.
- PlotCitizen 5mo agoOmg I was using that too! I was actually wondering whether FUTO had any features that supported typing one word with multiple concurrent (or not) swipes. I guess it does not but dang what a blast from the past. I had forgotten the app name too! Was using it since before Apple started actually allowing third party keyboards officially
- backscratches 5mo agoHeliboard on f-droid does two thumb swiping!
- mightyham 5mo agoCompletely agree! The author made a buggy android port of nintype (called keyboard 69) that I used for years. The UX was incredible, and every swipe system I've tried since feels downright clumsy by comparison. Two finger swipe is peak ergonomics, but unfortunately I think it's an innovation that's simply too niche.
- backscratches 5mo agoI used nintype and keyboard69 for years, heliboard on f-droid supports two thumb swiping and works very well ! Not as good as nintype but extremely useful
- lproven 5mo agoNever heard of that one before, so I looked it up & watched a demo vid. Aieeee! I don't think I could ever learn to use that. I am from the 1990s fast-T9 entry era, and my thumb dexterity is poor. (And I'm left-handed with a badly-damaged right hand.) I think this is a text entry method solely or primarily for the 2-thumb console-gamepad generation. (I find gamepads really hard to use, too. Give me a joystick, or mouse+WASD.)
- ibejoeb 5mo agoI've been using the new swipe for a few days and it's truly excellent.
- sheept 5mo agoIt would be nice if there was a swipe typing keyboard that was similar to Chinese/Japanese IMEs where you can swipe out a full phrase and the keyboard can use it to fix short/ambiguous words based on context. Today, when I'm swipe typing sloppily, it can be hard to distinguish between pairs like on/in, of/if/I'd, it's/its, etc
- julianlam 5mo agoAs a FUTO keyboard user for about a year I'm quite excited for this! Their local voice transcription is top notch and proper swipe gestures would be icing on the cake. Now to fix that issue there tapping "Tuesd" sometimes suggests "Thursday"
- BosunoB 5mo agoI don't really get swiping. It's always going to be quicker and more efficient to type because you can use both hands, right? And you don't have to swipe your finger across the screen? Still going strong with Fleksy even though you can't even download it anymore.
- xp84 5mo agoSometimes you have one hand full. When my kids were small, especially, I REALLY benefited from swipe typing. I still often use it when I am holding something in one hand.
- nutjob2 5mo agoMaybe for you personally, but in a general sense I don't see how you can hold a phone and "use both hands" to type individual keys. One notable advantage of swiping is that you can be quite loose with each single swipe gesture whereas you have to hit the right key many times for each word. That swipe is also usually much quicker than finding multiple keys for most people. You preferences may reflect youth, eyesight, finger size, co-ordination, phone case usage or other advantages most people don't have.
- BosunoB 5mo agoI think it more likely reflects using bigger phones, where swiping across a while keyboard is quite slow, but also, I hate typing with two hands with any other app than Fleksy. You just have to hit within the general area of the key and it counts. I haven't had that kind of success with any other keyboard I've tried.
- egypturnash 5mo agoIf you have long nails then two thumbs on a tiny phone keyboard are pretty much impossible.
- ktrnka 5mo agoIt traces back to accessibility. Think of folks with shaky hands. The screen helps to stabilize the tremors. A similar thing applies to typing on a bumpy bus or while walking. That said, it also depends on screen size. Back when Swype first became popular, Android screen sizes ranged from 3-5". That was another factor driving it's popularity back in the day. Definitely not for everyone or in every situation though
- ktimespi 5mo agoIf this can learn my patterns, that itself is enough. Google Keyboard used to do this, but mysteriously doesn't do it anymore.
- gblargg 5mo agoVoice dictation is so much better than GBoard, which I've been using until now. It capitalizes and punctuates sentences without me needing to, and got several sentences perfect without any post-editing needed, and it's all a local model. The one downside is no real-time update, just batch conversion once you're done talking. Looks like they've fixed the swipe backspace and spacebar to not be over-sensitive like it was a year or two ago when I last tried (and allowed some customization).
- projektfu 5mo agoIt has gotten very good but my brain is much worse at producing intelligible speech than it is at writing. I end up having to edit a lot anyway, which is hard with voice.
- johanyc 5mo agogboard has voice dictation and it has real-time update
- gblargg 5mo agoYep, and it's pretty bad. The only benefit is real-time, which is why I highlighted that FUTO lacks that. If it made as many errors as GBoard, it wouldn't be worth using.
- johanyc 5mo agoNo it's pretty good. Pretty much always accurate. Was that years ago? Or are you talking about languages with less resources?
- killerstorm 5mo agoI'm actually surprised with how bad is Google's voice recognition - with all their immense compute resources, R&D, owning Android, etc, what prevents them from having SotA voice recognition?.. Even "it's not a priority" argument doesn't work as they are pushing Gemini assistant. (ChatGPT app works so much better.)
- nmstoker 5mo agoIs there some sort of swipe data standard? If there were, it feels like getting a few proper OSS projects going might start to shift things in the right direction (assuming they cracked a way to share a bit of anonymized data)
- jeena 5mo agoI always liked their voice dictation because it's better than Samsungs or Googles while it's on device. It's super fast and puts in punctuation in, etc. The keyboard on the other hand I never really liked for some reason which I can't even explain clearly. So for the keyboard I've been using https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard for ever, but it does not have sviping. I might try FUTO Swipe just to test it.
- flexagoon 5mo agoHeliboard does have swiping! You just have to manually download the GBoard swiping library and upload it in the app.
- backscratches 5mo agoNot only does heliboard have swiping, it has two finger swipe, which is more than 2x better than one finger swipe!
- kayson 5mo agoI've been using it for a while. The insistence of keyboards on having a large bar of autocorrect suggestions taking valuable vertical space annoys me to no end. I really liked using Fleksy which let you swipe up and down on the keyboard to change autocorrect results, including adding words to your dictionary. I'm still not sure if FUTO even has that option.
- stavros 5mo agoI really want to switch to FUTO keyboard but there are a few UX issues that prevent me. For example, SwiftKey lets you swipe left to delete a word, which is very useful, but FUTO doesnt, you have to start from the Backspace button. Or, SwiftKey will allow you to change a typed word's case by pressing shift, but FUTO just does nothing in that case. I really hope these get fixed, or I can just issue PRs myself for them.
- vzaliva 5mo agowhat languages it support? They only mention "language-agnostic".
- crazygringo 5mo agoI love swiping for speed, because it's usually faster than tapping and easy to do one-handed, but then there are always a bunch of words that are too similar that it can never get right, it doesn't deal well with doubled vs single letters, etc. So for the longest time, I've wanted a new keyboard layout specifically designed for swiping. In the same way that Dvorak was optimized for ergonomically typing English words, I want a keyboard layout designed to minimize word overlap/ambiguity when swiping. It doesn't even necessarily have to have 26 keys, e.g. maybe there could be one key overloaded for v/w/x/z (and you long-press it if you ever want to type a single letter). On the other hand, maybe there need to be separate keys for 'e' and 'ee', or a special key for "double the previous letter". Because I love swiping, but all my problems with it come from the fact that the QWERTY layout is far from ideal for it. I am 100% willing to learn a new layout if anyone will develop an optimal one for English so that swiping has a 99.9% accuracy rate instead of what currently feels more like 90% or 95%.
- jaggederest 5mo agoBlast from the past here for you, probably not relevant any more, but a cool reimagining of gesture interfaces: https://www.the8pen.com/ https://www.the8pen.com/ Edit: apparently there's a modern successor? https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=inc.flide.vi8 https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=inc.flide.vi8
- horsawlarway 5mo agoI really liked this in the day (and i just played with the version you linked and can still remember all the key patterns - I'm typing this comment with it now). But it just can't touch swiping for speed. Frankly, the keyboard I miss most is the T9 predictive text from my old school pre smart phone era. Nothing has come close to the same expressiveness and speed while being usable completely blind, only by feel. I do feel like mobile keyboards have stagnated in a bad spot, though.
- JdeBP 5mo agoI should have guessed. Of course someone has done this. (-: * https://github.com/sspanak/tt9 https://github.com/sspanak/tt9
- OJFord 5mo agoThe demo at least doesn't support tapping, which makes it a nope for me, even if the swiping experience hadn't been ~hank~ ~help~ hello world.
- Cider9986 5mo agoTry the keyboard or the training. It's better than GBoard in some ways.
- willconnelly 5mo agoThe first two words i tried to type were both "hello" and I got "help" and "hell" as first suggestions. I'm not sure if the web app is using the same algo but that's an immediate ick.
- h4kunamata 5mo agoFUTO is terrible! I run GOS and have tried it, you spend more time deleting works than actually using it. I was forced to install Google GBoard instead and revoke its network access. Gboard swipe typing works flawlessly, FUTO still an Alpha project.
- TranquilMarmot 5mo agoSeems like this is a new swipe model, though, so it should be more comparable. I also had to switch back to GBoard on GrapheneOS since I was spending more time fixing typos than actually typing with FUTO but I'm willing to give it another shot.
- copper-float 5mo agoThe early iterations of swipe were very inaccurate, yes. But the newest swipe release mentioned here is much more mature. It's not perfect, but it's practically on par with GBoard aside from a few blips here and there. It's enough for me to get rid of GBoard for good, and not consider reinstalling it.
- KomoD 5mo ago> Gboard swipe typing works flawlessly, FUTO still an Alpha project I agree. I find that swipe typing on Gboard feels much better than FUTO's because I think it adapts to my typing style. I tried FUTO about six months ago, and it was a bit frustrating so I switched back to Gboard. Hopefully, it has improved since then, but I haven't checked.
- wolvoleo 5mo agoSounds good but the big problem I have with futo key board is that it can only do one language at a time. With gboard I can swipe type al 3 languages I speak without having to constantly switch. I wish they could make that.
- seb1204 5mo agoI'm sure they will, version 3. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
- wolvoleo 5mo agoWell neither is perfect. But I really need that multilingual typing. Constantly switching is so annoying. I won't use the FUTO one until it can do that. It's not some minor nice-to-have. Gboard has obvious imperfections like data mining. Though on my phone I can just block its network access altogether which mitigates it a lot.
- windyan 5mo ago[dead]
- Humphrey 5mo agoWould love an iOS version! The keyboard landscape on iOS is grim, and gboard hasn't received updates in years.
- Groxx 5mo agoFinally! Usable! Between this and the excellent dictation, it's finally looking good enough that I can probably recommend it to anyone.
- t_gamer_kle 5mo agoOh frabjous day! I've waited YEARS for something like this. THANK YOU FUTO!
- sholladay 5mo agoThis keyboard seems to ship with a dictionary that includes a lot of curse words. No more ducking around.
- ta8903 5mo agoWhat dictionary are you using? I installed the app on android and am not able to type "fuck", neither with the inbuilt dictionary nor from an imported English (UK) dictionary from their site. Even typing it manually doesn't seem to add it to the dictionary, which makes it really annoying to use.
- a022311 5mo agoI can't see what's wrong with that (you choose whether to accept suggestions or not), but you can always blacklist predictions by long-pressing on them.
- Aachen 5mo agoI read it as a positive comment, as in that it types what you wrote
- RandyOrion 5mo agoI've been using FUTO voice input for several month. It's not perfect as I have to manually do the correction like always. However, it definitely saves me some time and effort. It also helps me to degoogle, starting from gboard. Apparently this new swipe function is tied to FUTO keyboard. I don't use the FUTO keyboard as there is no support for the language I use intensively. Nevertheless, this line of work deserves more recognition.
- kstenerud 5mo agoWhat I really want is a swipe model that can tune to multiple languages simultaneously when a keyboard layout can support it (English + German, German + French, etc). I rarely need more than 2 languages simultaneously, but the "switching between 2 languages" point is painful.
- dhruvbird 5mo agoThis would be cool. I suspect that people don't implement this model because it's a long tail of users requesting this. This is totally feasible technically.
- defenestrated 5mo agoTrilingual here. Gboard on my pixel 10 pro does support swipe type while code switching between multiple languages. Works reasonably well. Accuracy is a bit lower for words that are collisions across languages
- ComodoHacker 5mo agoWhat is "code switching"?
- deruta 5mo agoWhen you're multilingual, you'd switch between languages on the fly, mid-sentence even, just because the words in other language come to your mind quicker, seem to better match nuances, etc.
- johanyc 5mo agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching
- projektfu 5mo agoYes, this is a showstopper for me. Preciso escrever in several languages.
- tmach32 5mo agoFor us sad iOS people, what's your favorite swiping keyboard? I just use the stock Apple one because custom keyboards can still be a little buggy (eg not loading occasionally).
- eviks 5mo agoOccasional bug is worse than permanent suffering?
- tmach32 5mo agoWell, iOS swipe keyboard is not that bad. I would not call it “permanent suffering”. I tried gboard and swiftkey and they aren’t a giant improvement over the stock keyboard these days. They used to be. Wrt the “occasional bug”, what happens is that sometimes (enough to make it bad) the keyboard doesn’t render at all!
- eviks 5mo agoWhat happens is you simply toggle the keyboard field off /on in th the same or a different app, a simple albeit slightly annoying fix. But in general, there is no giant improvement, none of the major ones are even competent enough to figure out a grid of numbers is better than a row, but Apple is even worse - it doesn't even let you type a number on long hold, for some reason thinking that a letter ų you'll never type in your English life is a better alternative To me, not being able to type in numbers easily is a permanent suffering, though ok, not the end of the world And unfortunately don't think there is a single swipe keyboard that's properly customizable to fix those glaring issues...
- Squarex 5mo agoFor a long time apple keyboard did not support my language (czech), I would use gboard. And yes, it is still slightly better than the Apple one, but the switching is buggy and the problem is on the apple side.
- tmach32 5mo ago
- fowlie 5mo agoAwesome project!! I will migrate off from gboard when support for Norwegian gets better.
- utopiah 5mo agoAh nice they do have a VR demo https://swipe.futo.tech/vr-swipe-small.mp4 https://swipe.futo.tech/vr-swipe-small.mp4 ... now I'm wondering if there is a WASM version so that it can be used in WebXR.
- wxw 5mo agoApple’s swipe to text is so good that I forget there’s still work to be done in the space. Great stuff FUTO.
- smusamashah 5mo agoLooking at the example videos, specially the VR one, I can't help but think that this gives every word its own unique shape. For example, the word "model" got shape matching infinity symbol.
- farhanhubble 5mo agoAbsolutely cool demo. I used to love this feature in SwiftKey. It still works but after their acquisition by Microsoft they've gone downhill. I've since switched to iOS but would love to try Futo out when it's available for iOS
- globular-toast 5mo agoI used to use SwiftKey, but Microsoft acquired and ruined it years ago. It worked really well. Since then the only one that worked for me is Gboard. I've had this installed for a while but found the swiping too inaccurate. I'm trying it again now and I reckon it's as good as Gboard now. I've written this comment using it. Nice! Edit: I've noticed that, like Gboard, it's still hard to type words like "fuck" or even "tits" etc. Are these words just missing from the dictionary? It's always felt like I'm not allowed to type them because I'm not a big boy. I don't type those particular words much, as it happens, but other missing words is annoying.
- dhruvbird 5mo agoVery cool. I'm a big fan of swipe. So much so that a bunch of us a Grammarly re-implemented it using a similar technique about 2 years ago on the Grammarly iOS keyboard, so if you want to experience something similar on iOS, you can head to the app store https://apps.apple.com/us/app/grammarly-ai-keyboard-notes/id1158877342 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/grammarly-ai-keyboard-notes/id... and use the qwerty english keyboard layout to get this neural net version of swipe. See https://www.grammarly.com/blog/engineering/deep-learning-swipe-typing/ https://www.grammarly.com/blog/engineering/deep-learning-swi... for more details - it's very similar to the architecture described by the FUTO folks. One key difference is that the learned model does not decode in a context sensitive manner but does it a word at a time. The main reason is because we wanted to release this soon and wanted the user's personal dictionary (i.e. contact names, etc... to show up correctly when swiped). It would have been nice if we could have followed through with the context sensitive decoding as described by the FUTO folks. It would really help with accuracy when dealing with words like: 1. (food, good, hood) 2. (you, toy, rot) 3. (our, or, it) etc... (Disclaimer: I am one of the authors of the Grammarly swipe system as described in the linked blog post).
- serpix 5mo agoTried Grammarly, could you possibly include a few more onboarding animations and reminders to upgrade to the paid version? I almost finished typing a word.
- teiferer 5mo agoLots to be desired, unfortunately. I tried 3 different words. It nailed the first 2 but the third was impossible: The word "serverside" is impossible to swipe. I tried 10x, never did it even come close.
- xdkaplan 5mo agoI don't think server side is in their dict without a dash. I don't know how to type dashed words in swipe. SwiftKey cant do it either. Long words usually work very well though. That's most of what I use swipe for. Short words I tap, long words I swipe. e.g., Broadside Surfside integration financially illiterate calibration fantastical proliferation haphazardly horrifically striations proliferation (all typed first or second try except antidisestablishmentarianism which admittedly I got carried away)
- connicpu 5mo agoInteresting, I just tried it and it got server-side the first try, although it wants to insert a hyphen. I did download the larger dictionary from their site.
- charcircuit 5mo agoAt least the web demo doesn't work right if you swipe with multiple fingers at the same time.
- GL26 5mo agoFun fact for the first apple keyboard layout on the first iphone, the touchscreen hadn't the resolution to tell appart which letter you meant to type in, so it changed dynamically the "hitboxes" of the letter buttons when you typed a certain letter. (for instance if you typed the letter "i", the hitbox of "t", and "n" were changed to be bigger, because there is a high probability you were hitting those next. Here is an article that talks about it : https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/26/creation-of-the-first-iphone-touchscreen-interview-with-scott-forstall-tony-fadell-and-greg-christie.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/26/creation-of-the-first-iphone...
- InsideOutSanta 5mo ago>the touchscreen hadn't the resolution to tell appart which letter you meant to type in Is that really true? My memory of the original iPhone's touch screen is that it was pretty much pixel-accurate. The article mentions that the keyboard wasn't accurate enough: "But by early 2006, the iPhone keyboard still didn’t have the accuracy Apple needed to ship the phone." I don't think that means the screen wasn't accurate; all it means is that the original iPhone had a small screen, so the buttons on the keyboard were tiny, and hitting them precisely was difficult. That's why the hit boxes of more likely keys were enlarged.
- vlovich123 5mo agoI think OP is misremembering about the reason for the hit boxes. The base reason is the size of the keyboard compared with the size of thumbs and the imprecision of thumb typing. Adjusting the hit boxes results in a better error rate. It isn’t because of the resolution of the screen or touch detection.
- a022311 5mo agoFUTO keyboard actually has an option for this (enabled by default) called "Smart key-hit detection". It adjusts hitboxes based on dictionary predictions for what you just typed.
- superxpro12 5mo agoim fairly sure gboard does the same thing. it will bias towards certain subsequent keys based on the current input. im sure there's a whole bunch of tricks keyboard apps use to make typing "feel" accurate.
- eviks 5mo agoThis is building on quick sand, a truly new model would not use the same dumb old grid that's neither fit for hands nor for fingers. But kudos for the openness!
- selfawareMammal 5mo agoI wrote Hola in spanish and got holocaust
- red_admiral 5mo ago> Your keyboard shouldn't connect to the internet. Amen. Glad to see that companies like that still exist.
- atoav 5mo agoVery nice. FUTO is the keyboard I keep recommending. The only thing missing now would be a decent dual-swipe support. Injecting single letters with taps during a swipe or continuing a swipe with another finger makes it even faster since it let's you avoid awkward long horizontal "detours" just to hit one letter.
- backscratches 5mo agoHave you used heliboard's two finger swiping? Can't live without two finger swipe
- vulkoingim 5mo agoThat's neat! Would love to try it, but am also on iOS :/ With the risk of sounding like a broken record - what are people using on iOS? I've been using `SwiftKey` for a while as it has dictionaries for languages that the native keyboard doesn't have. But I would love to switch to something else, as M$ has been shoving AI features on it that I am definitely not interested in. So far in this thread I've seen Grammarly and Nintype. The former seems to suffer from the same things as SwiftKey, while the latter doesn't look it's maintained (last update 7y ago). I don't mind a paid app, as long as it doesn't invade my privacy.
- puttycat 5mo agoWhat do you mean? iOS has a native swift option.
- cloogshicer 5mo agoNative iOS is significantly worse than SwiftKey and doesn't support multiple languages without having to switch the keyboard constantly. In SwiftKey you can mix languages. I'd also be very interested in SwiftKey alternatives, since MS already almost killed it once.
- puttycat 5mo agoI have two languages defined in iOS (English and French) and the native swift keyboard recognizes which language I'm swifting in.
- vulkoingim 5mo agoPretty much what `cloogshicer` said. I am interested in something that has support for multiple languages + swipe support.
- puttycat 5mo agoiOS has that.
- TechniKris 5mo agoIf you'd prefer a swipe typing library under a truly open license, NLnet is funding [1] the creation of one by the HeliBoard [2] devs. HeliBoard currently uses a proprietary library extracted from GBoard, which you need to add manually (since the app has no Internet connectivity out of principle), but they're asking for swipe data contributions, to be then distributed under CC-BY-SA 4.0, which'll be then utilized by their own open swipe library. Check our more details here [3], [4] if you'd like to contribute. [1] https://nlnet.nl/project/GestureTyping/ https://nlnet.nl/project/GestureTyping/ [2] https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard [3] https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard/wiki/Tutorial:-How-to-Contribute-Gesture-Data https://github.com/HeliBorg/HeliBoard/wiki/Tutorial:-How-to-... [4] https://youtu.be/CyjumVTWtJA https://youtu.be/CyjumVTWtJA
- backscratches 5mo agoI have contributed to this. Heliboard also great because it supports two finger swipe which is huge ergonomic improvement
- backscratches 5mo agoCan it do two finger swipe like Heliboard? Must have feature for modern swipe keyboard
- deleted 5mo ago[deleted]
- arnorhs 5mo agoI'm curious to see how it deals with dual languages - ie. not switching between them, but using two languages in the same sentence like the google keyboard supports out of the box. my biggest issue is that i make up a lot of words as i type and the google dictionary for icelandic is .. well it can never be fully complete because of the way the language works, so dictionary words are always a mess.
- reddalo 5mo ago> because of the way the language works What's the problem of Icelandic? Is it because you stick words together like in Danish or German?
- jonasced 5mo agoThey have a multilingual input mode that also works with swipe input! I've tried it briefly with Swedish/English on a Swedish keyboard and it switched between languages in the same sentence in a way that made sense to me, but I had to download a separate dictionary.
- Jnr 5mo agoCan we please get this for iPhone? Their keyboard is extremely imprecise, I have to go back and correct each sentence.
- artisin 5mo agoFUTO has gone from tolerable to pretty great over the past year-ish. Sure, the (english) auto-completion still may not be the "best," but I generally find it better than my iPad auto-completion. Thou, my fav-features are pretty simple: the ability to pin dedicated action buttons like undo/redo/select-all, and direct control over my clipboard history. The clipboard does come with hard max limits of 100 items and 336 hours, but since FUTO is open-source, all one has to do is clone, patch, compile, and voila, unlimited clipboard history! And they say dreams don't come true.
- tgtweak 5mo agoswype was so good before it got destroyed by Nuance. Gboard's own swipe to type is decent but missing a lot of those features that made swype so much better (swipe once backwards to erase the previous word, loop a letter to double it, swipe up to the suggested word to select it, correct a previous word with the next few words context...)
- arusahni 5mo agoIt requires more precision than Swype, but GBoard supports multi-word word deletion if you swipe back originating from the backspace key. You get some haptic feedback, and can scrub to adjust the selected boundary. Unfortunately some of those Swype nicities are patented [1], so other keyboards can't use them. [1]: https://patents.google.com/patent/US7098896B2/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US7098896B2/en
- tgtweak 5mo agoI feel like a clean room opensource keyboard could implement those without any patent liabilities. Software patents are notoriously difficult to enforce and I don't think nuance is spending any money enforcing this given they stopped swype in 2018.
- arusahni 5mo agoThey're now owned by infamously-litigious Microsoft.
- lproven 5mo ago> swype was so good before it got destroyed by Nuance. 100% this. THE best text-entry method for touchscreens. Nuance enshittified it and then Microsoft killed it. https://www.theregister.com/on-prem/2022/06/06/microsofts-swype-still-the-best-software-keyboard-there-is/328522 https://www.theregister.com/on-prem/2022/06/06/microsofts-sw...
- ErikGulliksen 5mo agoI started using the main FUTO keyboard after seeing it mentioned here the other week. Then a few days later I tried to open my HSBC banking app and it refused to open because it detected FUTO keyboard which it treated as an insecure application, so had to remove FUTO after a couple of days of use.
- amelius 5mo agoCombine this with AI, and you only have to ramble a bit on your keyboard to get the collected works of Shakespeare.
- 3RTB297 5mo agoThanks for making this privacy-forward. I had been using Heliboard and then a kludge to get another language they don't support via Simple keyboard. It worked well as a workaround, and then an update last week broke my workaround. Futo just has all the languages I need, and does a better job with EN swipe than Heliboard. 100% convert. Plus, learning about Clearflow is a game changer.
- krunck 5mo agoThis is great! As someone with one thumb that can't bend at either joint and another that doesn't bend well I've been a single finger typer on my phone. Thanks to all involved for this privacy respecting swipe keyboard!
- yareally 5mo agoSwiping feels a bit more accurate than Gboard overall. I'm not seeing a way to add a word to the dictionary. Am I missing something?
- PennRobotics 5mo agoGboard has been messing with the emoji search recently. It is worse. Previously, if you type "fac" or "face" or "facep" or "facepa" or "palm" in the search box, you'd get the facepalm emoji among the results. Inexplicably, now the lying emoji, bacon, fondue are shown when you type "fac" but not the classic facepalm. It is only after you type "facepal" that the facepalm emoji appears in the results, which is a major... facepalm for the Gboard team. As a parent, I need to _constantly_ send the facepalm emoji to my partner, so I noticed immediately when it recently changed. I think they're now trying to account for multiple languages, misspellings, a larger list of synonyms that allows partial matches, sentiment/meaning/synonyms, etc. In any case, I've always felt like emojis should be weighted by overall usage patterns (I have never used the fondue emoji and don't know anyone who does) and now they need a better search trie, where the facepalm emoji is in the top results of "fac".