13 ms·
U.S. science agency moves to restrict foreign scientists from its labs
- samrus 9mo ago> Sources at NIST contacted by ScienceInsider say they have yet to see any written versions of the proposed rules, which have been conveyed in meetings. Patrick Gallagher, a former NIST director now at the University of Pittsburgh, says the lack of clear communication and the short notice being given to foreign scientists is creating a sense of chaos. “I’m as disappointed as to how this is unfolding as to what is unfolding,” Gallagher says. “At the very least NIST owes an explanation to the country. If there is a good reason for what they are doing, they should flat out say what it is.” This is the sort of "high agency", not waiting for permission mentality that works great for a startup thats making tinder for cats, but is really bad for foundational institutions that provide a critical service to not just the nation but humanity in general. I feel like musk and his DOGE initiative infected the government with this move fast and break things bullshit. Or they were at least correlational with it
- avs733 9mo agonot only that but they leveraged the 'compliance' mindset that comes with government institutions to do so. This was first reported at least a week or two ago and only now are they getting aroun dto thinking about making it an actual rule (which takes time and process). The rules that aren't really rules for plausible deniability serve several purposes including normalizing compliance in advance. I'll set aside opinions of the rule because people can really feel differently about the long and short term balance of security and soft power...but not rule rules is an approach to government I really struggle to see both sides of.
- mrtesthah 9mo agoRead about the administrative state vs prerogative state. This is what the latter looks like.
- mikkupikku 9mo agoProbably the most direct way to kick out the people they're actually worried about without invoking legal process for each one specifically, not least because if they did it on a case by case basis there would likely be an undeniable ethnic/national signal that right now is getting hidden in the noise. In other words, instead of targetting researchers for being Chinese nationals, and then subsequently having to defend ethnic discrimination in court, they're just going to throw the baby out with the bath water. That's my guess anyway.
- this-is-why 9mo agoIt’s the trump admin. They don’t care about the decorum you’ve described. They would have no qualms about looking racist. Have you not seen what ICE has been doing? Racism is a badge of honor, and so is flipping off the courts and public opinion. No I believe this is simply paranoia and racism driven by Miller and his cronies.
- titanomachy 9mo agoIt's not about "looking racist"; or at least, it's not about public opinion. A racially targeted measure would violate specific laws and would be challenged in court, likely successfully.
- sigwinch 9mo agoThe Kavanaugh rule specifically permits it. If you’re taking odds that this Supreme Court will challenge the Kavanaugh rule, I’ll wager 1:1 against.
- rolandog 9mo agoIt could also be a signal that they intend to take on the world; so they could technically not be racist if "everyone else is a threat".
- pixl97 9mo agoThat was so years ago, this is the point we're at now. SCOTUS: Nothing Trump does is illegal. Trump: "does illegal things" Courts: You can't do this, it is illegal. Trump: "ignores courts" Courts: "shocked pikachu face"
- yieldcrv 9mo agoits real war time now, so makes sense I know the administration was already doing that and largely xenophobic, it just also makes sense now that the same administration went to war
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- AreShoesFeet000 9mo ago[flagged]
- j16sdiz 9mo agoLast time I checked, only congress can declare a war.
- mono442 9mo ago[flagged]
- vkou 9mo agoHis regime needs the benefit of the doubt, but his behavior makes it clear that it doesn't actually warrant it.
- ggm 9mo ago> NIST researchers do not carry out classified research. As a result, Gallagher says, “It’s very difficult to see the security benefit this might have.”
- collabs 9mo agoIt makes no sense. Foreign scientists usually can't work on classified projects because they require clearance that is very difficult if not impossible for non citizens to obtain. Restricting foreign scientists from US labs is in my opinion a stupid move. What am I missing?
- lukan 9mo ago"What am I missing?" That nationalism is the new state doctrin? Foreigners are inferior by definition, so they cannot really help with research anyway, all they want to do is steal secrets. If you think like that, then it makes sense.
- drops 9mo ago[flagged]
- mc32 9mo ago[flagged]
- drops 9mo agoNazi scientists were brought in _after_ WWII, not during it.
- mc32 9mo agoI think there is a difference between bringing in key proven talent at the apex that’s already proven itself and talent that needs to be developed. Both the US and USSR picked up proven talent from the Nazis, they weren’t siphoning up green talent on the hopes they’d develop into good scientists. We have our own population we often overlook and misdirect into Hollywood entertainment rather than achievement.
- drops 9mo ago
- FpUser 9mo agoNot administration sympathizer but: I think there are of course valid security concerns and this could be logical solution free of way more problematic issues of dealing on case by case basis. On the other hand this will play more to people choosing some other country to advance their science aspiration and slowly but surely erode pool of talent for the US to help it stay dominant. Practically the US have used people like Wernher von Braun on good scale and very sensitive areas and it worked just fine for the country. Qian Xuesen might of course have couple of words on the subject of course
- bronlund 9mo agoReminds me of this one :D https://www.b4x.com/android/forum/attachments/usteam-jpg.114031/ https://www.b4x.com/android/forum/attachments/usteam-jpg.114...
- direwolf20 9mo agoThis isn't a meta–commentary about the Cloudflate block page?
- rmm78 9mo ago[flagged]
- michaelmcdonald 9mo agoDoes the 1 day old account have any type of source or information to back up this claim?
- brookst 9mo agoYep, NIST does open, unclassified research. Hard to see the point.
- hnthrowaway0315 9mo ago> Scientists from China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela, and Syria are considered “high risk.” I think this makes sense from a national security perspective (although I doubt there is any scientist coming from these countries who are working on sensitive projects, maybe except China). Since there is too much trouble to figure out who is a spy, might as well ban all of them for the moment. I do feel a strong nostalgia about the globalization era between the 90s and the 2010s, when I spent most of my life. But I understand it comes to an end, and I'm going to spend my second half of life in a much more splintered world.
- ajewhere 9mo agoBut aren't they happy you bring them democracy? I am confused..
- lyu07282 9mo ago[flagged]
- AdamN 9mo agoThat was indeed the logic then. Keep in mind though that the internment was based on 'race' and 'ethnicity'. This action is based on citizenship and it's a job limitation not a forcible relocation into an open air prison.
- AlecSchueler 9mo agoI'm with you on the difference between labour limitations and imprisonment but > Keep in mind though that the internment was based on 'race' and 'ethnicity'. This action is based on citizenship a You say this like it's a meaningful distinction?
- clippyplz 9mo agoSurely it is? It would be a very different policy to say "anyone vaguely asian is banned from the lab, even if they're an American citizen"
- bdangubic 9mo agoPresident Biden’s Executive Order 14117 is related https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-03-01/pdf/2024-04573.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-03-01/pdf/2024-0...
- MyHonestOpinon 9mo agoIf it was done by any other administration you can assume it went through a few layers of professional bureaucrats that considered multiple alternatives. But based on persistent observed behavior of the current president you just have to assume the worst possible intent.
- bdangubic 9mo agoI am not the defend the worst president in the history of the presidents of all mankind but I work in scientific community and this particular news is not “new” - spans both parties. EO 14117 resulted in 6+ months of work for my team
- RobotToaster 9mo agoOh, we're the John Birch Society, the John Birch Society Here to save our country from a communistic plot Join the John Birch Society, help us fill the ranks To get this movement started we need lots of tools and cranks https://youtu.be/pG6taS9R1KM?si=QqquYHFG2S7o7-73 https://youtu.be/pG6taS9R1KM?si=QqquYHFG2S7o7-73
- OutOfHere 9mo agoNothing that NIST produces can be trusted. In modern times, NIST is effectively an arm of the NSA. The job of NIST is to add vulnerabilities to everything for NSA to exploit. It's no wonder that they don't want foreign workers. Industry would be better off completely ignoring them.
- kypro 9mo ago[flagged]
- pixl97 9mo ago>Citizenship laws in the West are hardly very robust. Guess you don't pay much attention. The administration has been stripping citizenship from naturalized citizens left and right. They simply don't give a fuck.
- booleandilemma 9mo agoI couldn't believe the surrogate thing you mentioned but it's true. https://www.wsj.com/us-news/chinese-billionaires-surrogacy-pregnancy-7fdfc0c3 https://www.wsj.com/us-news/chinese-billionaires-surrogacy-p... We really need to wake up. China, India, etc. are walking all over us and we're still acting like it's the 1950s.
- luses 9mo agois not scary yellow chinese, and brown indians you need to worry about dude. Please put your priorities straight
- kypro 9mo agoInteresting people are down voting you for doing little more than posting a WSJ article... I kinda get why what I said could be viewed as controversial because my comment is clearly opinionated, but yours really isn't. Would be interested in hearing from those don't believe this is something to be concerned about.
- booleandilemma 9mo agoPeople are downvoting me because I said we need to prioritize American citizens over foreigners, which shouldn't be a controversial stance, but the problem is there's this white guilt that pervades American society and people jump to thinking you're a racist at the first chance they get (see the other reply on my comment for example). China, India, etc. aren't stupid and they take full advantage of this and push the racist angle every chance they get. I'll say it again though: people need to wake up. These countries know they don't stand a chance at defeating us militarily so they're going to try a psychological approach, in addition to underhanded sabotage. I have another comment in this thread saying "great news" and it was flagged. That's how brainwashed Americans are at this point.
- jmyeet 9mo agoSome years ago I came to the conclusion that the US would ultimately consider it a security risk to employ mainland Chinese born people (or even just people who had family in mainland China still) in any classified or sensitive industry. I think I've now reached the point where it doesn't matter. Capitalism itself has made maintaining any kind of technological or scientific edge impossible. You don't need to break into some lab or plant sleeper agents or even coerce someone who has family back in the home country. No, it's far simpler than that. When the US developed the atomic bomb some in American policy and military circles thought the Soviets would never get the bomb or it would take 20 years. It took 4. The Soviet hydrogen bomb was detonated th eyear after the US detonated ours. In that case, the Soviets did run a sophisticated operations but also a bunch of people just gave them stuff for ideological reasons. Let's compare that to EUV. The US restricted both the export of EUV lithography machines from ASML to China as well as the most advanced chips. The second was a mistake (IMHO) because it created a captive market for Chinese alternatives and it became clear to China that it was in their national security interest not to be dependent upon the US for chipmaking or chipsd. Now China doesn't need to do anything sophisticated. It just needs to throw a bunch of money at some key reserarchers and engineers from ASML and elsewhere and say "hey, come work for us". What are you going to do? Also, the US likes to paint this picture that China engaged in industrial espionage. And maybe they did. But they did so with the full knowledge and cooperation of US businesses who outsourced to China knowing this was going to happen but hey, it increased short-term profits, so who cares? At the same time as the US cuts science funding so Jeff Bezos can be slightly wealthier, Chinese universities are surging in global rankings for research [1]. There's no getting this genie back in the bottle. It's too late. [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/15/us/harvard-global-ranking-chinese-universities-trump-cuts.html https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/15/us/harvard-global-ranking...
- NickC25 9mo ago>Also, the US likes to paint this picture that China engaged in industrial espionage. And maybe they did. But they did so with the full knowledge and cooperation of US businesses who outsourced to China knowing this was going to happen but hey, it increased short-term profits, so who cares? At the same time as the US cuts science funding so Jeff Bezos can be slightly wealthier, Chinese universities are surging in global rankings for research [1]. This is the crux of the issue. We've allowed extremely short term capitalistic interests of the wealthiest of the wealthiest to dictate our national policy in a great many areas, including taxation, academics, immigration, etc. I liken the situation to a game of chess - on one hand, you have a team of Grandmasters and a supercomputer taking the time to evaluate each move and understand the positives and negatives of any possible move. On the other hand, you have a pigeon, who is there because someone who has already been the beneficiary of tremendous luck has convinced their side that putting a pigeon on the board is good for everyone involved.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- TomMasz 9mo agoIsn't this the same sort of thing that the Nazi's did?
- righthand 9mo agoAmerica loves Nazis they’ve been obsessing over them for decades to the point they’ve been romanticized. And if there’s one thing Americans love more than not-thinking it’s romanticism and propaganda.
- mrguyorama 9mo agoAmericans loved Nazis in the 30s too, they never wanted to invade Germany and plenty held up Hitler as just the best guy who could ever be and saving Germany. Tons of American leaders and industrialists and what we would now call "Thought leaders" openly and proudly talked about how awesome Hitler was and how great the Nazis were for dealing with the jewish problem. This wasn't because nobody knew Hitler was a hateful and Bad guy, they were proudly declaring how important Mein Kampf was to them and how well it described the "problem" Henry Ford bought a local newspaper so he could print the fabricated propaganda "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion" to an American audience. This is not a fucking joke, this is accepted history! A decade later, Smedly Butler made credible accusations that several top Bankers had worked with the literal fucking Nazi party of Germany to overthrow FDR and install a Fascist government under Butler, because FDR was a communist or some bullshit. It was screamed and cried as a "Hoax" in the news at the time, but most historians agree that there was a conspiracy to do that, but it did not get close to execution. These people only shut up when Germany finally declared open war against the US and started killing Americans and really only when the death camps became public knowledge and really turned some of america sour on the whole "The jews are the problem" thing. But they never stopped hating. They continued their hate quietly, raising hateful kids and families, pushing local institutions to support hateful educations like "Slavery wasn't even that bad and the North was the aggressor in the Civil War" because they really are fine lying to your face. They fly the Confederate flag "for heritage" while they descend from french canadians in a northern state. They obsess over affirmative action "Taking up seats in top universities" as they actively avoid getting educated because education is a "Liberal propaganda" thing and meant to "brainwash" their hateful kids into being less stupid. They build an entire alternative media ecosystem, going all the way back to Henry Ford's bullshit, and literally never ending, where THEY are always the victim, always suffering from oppression, always having a "War on christmas" or other horseshit for when their blatantly unconstitutional desires are shut down, or a business stops prostrating itself for them. They teach their kids that scientists are all part of a socialist satanic conspiracy to lie to them about everything from evolution to plate tectonics to (of course) global warming, and when that turns away supporters, they cover it up with a claim that science is all a fraud because the scientists want a "paycheck", as if there is any money in government funded science, because uneducated America is apparently so hard up and failing that a middling salary in a high pressure environment is considered worth selling your entire world for.
- stogot 9mo agoThat’s not what the headline says. Changing headline is a violation of hackers news rules
- notaharvardmba 9mo agoThis whole thing feels like a troll. We should assume any new HN account created in the last 18 months is much more likely to be a bot, and now we got OpenClaw to worry about. Nothing stopping our true adversary or troublemakers from giving OpenClaw a plausible new identity and telling it to argue about given world view. Or pass whatever false information it can to try to change public opinion. Can you tell which replies in this thread are real vs propaganda?
- booleandilemma 9mo ago[flagged]
- analog31 9mo agoThis is part of a plan to bring back inches, pounds, and the quarter-twenty.
- est 9mo agoHistory rhymes. The same happened in the 30s to Albert Einstein, Max Born, Lise Meitner, Hans Bethe, Edward Teller, Leo Szilard, etc.
- trimethylpurine 9mo agoMisleading headline. They are moving specifically to restrict high risk countries like China, Syria, North Korea, etc. Not all foreign countries, as the headline threatens.
- fsh 9mo agoFrom the article: > Researchers from lower risk countries have been told they could lose access beginning in either September or December if at that point they have been at the lab more than 2 years or, under a waiver, 3 years.
- trimethylpurine 9mo agoAlso from the article: > Sources at NIST contacted by ScienceInsider say they have yet to see any written versions of the proposed rules, which have been conveyed in meetings. And: > Many researchers from these countries—particularly China—have been informed that their lab access will be reviewed by 31 March, and terminated if they have been at NIST for more than 3 years or pose “too high a risk” So, the high-risk limitation is actual, and affected researchers were already notified by NIST. While no low-risk limitations are mentioned by or attributable to NIST. That part appears to be hearsay and speculation confidently jammed into the headline. I find that to be misleading. Bob should be ashamed of himself. I hope he can do better. It took me a single paragraph to more clearly reword the article, and I'm not a professional writer.
- rsfern 9mo agoIt’s all foreign guest researchers by the end of September, high risk countries by the end of March. Your first quote doesn’t imply the NIST sources for this article don’t have firsthand knowledge that this is coming, it’s just that it appears the lab management is avoiding putting things in writing
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- dghughes 9mo agoHere in Canada when the new CPC took power its leader PM Harper muzzled scientists from speaking about most things but most of all anything about climate change. It also destroyed climate data claiming the ledgers were old fashioned, but they were the only copies. The CPC political are the old centre-right PC party that combined with more right secessionist and (evangelical) Christian political parties. Harper is still lurking in the shadows and pulling strings decade after being ousted as Prime Minister.
- e40 9mo ago> Harper is still lurking in the shadows and pulling strings decade after being ousted as Prime Minister. Do you mean he still has an impact or he is actively impacting things now?
- goku12 9mo ago> It also destroyed climate data claiming the ledgers were old fashioned, but they were the only copies. I don't know how long ago the library of Alexandria was burned down. But what I do know is that we never learn the lesson. It's rather stupid to store public research data (i.e, excluding classified info) at a single location. There are any number of unpredictable future scenarios that can lead to this same unfortunate outcome. Scientists and politicians should work together and agree to store and host such research data in multiple countries, including with rival nations. That should make it a lot more resilient against such eventualities. It won't cause any security risk. After all, you were going to publish it anyway. Why waste the information worth a lot of money and effort? But instead of that, many governments and greedy corporations go after independent groups who do exactly that - scihub and internet archive, for example. We as a species possess the stupidity of stubbornly avoiding the obvious right path.
- bluegatty 9mo ago[flagged]
- goku12 9mo ago> Comparing a government intervening on data they challenged with one of their own agencies to the 'burning of Alexandria' is beyond delusion. holy cow. I'm talking about precious data being destroyed by anti-intellectuals because their predecessors didn't foresee that possibility. There are no delusions here. You're just being unimaginative, hyperbolic and histrionic. > For gosh sake, the internet is public, nothing is being truly erased, published papers will be there for literally all of time. The publishing industry may control some distribution for a very short period of time but it's not relvant in the grand scheme Is that what you see happening here? Didn't the Internet Archive race to save the data from the websites of US research institutions before they were deleted by the current regime? They could have done it with ease if they had started as soon as the election results were out. This is not to say that IA is inefficient. It's to point out that while the Internet has a great preservation ability, it's not perfect and hardly always the case. There are a lot of data that aren't sufficiently protected. Instead of trying to even understand that possibility, you go on a shallow and low-effort dismissal with excess drama. Is that the quality of discussion now?
- lo_zamoyski 9mo agoI am noting two extremes in the comments which miss essential truths. The first extreme begins with a true premise, but arrives at a false conclusion. The premise: as with manufacturing, the US should be minting more of its own scientists. This is true. The US should have a more robust manufacturing base of its own. It should be educating more scientists. However, the conclusion does not follow, namely, that the US should ban collaboration with, invitation, or employment of foreign scientists. You don't build such things by going cold turkey. You cannot rebuild American manufacturing overnight, and you can't increase the number of home-grown scientists overnight either. This takes time and requires deeper shifts in the culture. The second extreme is one that denies the premise above, or at least seems to deny its importance. Collaboration with foreign scientists is good. That is unquestionable. There's also nothing wrong with attracting scientists. The problem is not collaboration or attracting talent, but rather a kind of parasitism that tries to make up for a country's own deficiencies in this manner as a permanent policy.
- DudeOpotomus 9mo ago[flagged]
- goku12 9mo agoI'm aware of the political landscape in the US right now. But I must ask. What exactly are the policy makers thinking? Do they hold some sort of delusions about the intellectual superiority of their race? Or do they believe that they don't need scientific talent, research and knowledge to be a great nation and civilization? Or do they believe that these deficiencies can be resolved with money alone? I'm puzzled by autocrats beyond a certain limit. Their actions don't really seem to fit any logic, if their intention is to be become unchallengeable and unassailable. This seems like ceding the advantage to any future rivals.
- 1234letshaveatw 9mo agoAre US citizens considered a race now?
- goku12 9mo agoI'm talking about those in power. Isn't that what they want?
- cindyllm 9mo ago[dead]
- ornornor 9mo agoEvery day the US looks a little more more 1933 Nazi Germany when all the xenophobic polices started. What even is a foreigner in a country where virtually everyone is descended from foreigners and immigrants?
- tsoukase 9mo agoDisallowing foreign talent and relying on domestic potential the USA will inevitably fall to the scientific level of the rest of the competing nations. The latter are not attracting talent due to various reasons like language barrier or low economic motive. Now the USA has its own reason. The next scientific leader will be the one that poses no barrier.
- hjkl0 9mo agoIt’s worth mentioning that even if you find it possible to agree with some aspects of this, it’s impossible to reconcile the way everything is being done and the way its communicated with any kind of well meaning positive intentions.
- Ylpertnodi 9mo ago"Y'all asked for the truth".
- ottah 9mo agoAt this point it feels like the Trump administration is just trying to turn us into the hermit kingdom. Isolated, and brutally autocratic.