8 ms·
Punkt. Unveils MC03 Smartphone
- daneel_w 11mo agoWhy this instead of a Pixel 8 or newer running GrapheneOS and no requirement for subscriptions?
- wolvoleo 11mo agoPixel 8 or 9, from 10 it's getting iffy due to Google restrictions. 11 probably won't even be supported
- RamRodification 11mo ago[flagged]
- gruez 11mo ago>10 it's getting iffy due to Google restrictions ??? If you're talking about google delaying the release of android causing pixel 10 builds to get delayed, that's mostly fixed and there are experimental builds now. Moreover pixel 10 was released a few months ago and is already available on the latest android. Meanwhile this phone hasn't even been released and is supposedly (based on other comments) on Android 15, released a year ago.
- wolvoleo 11mo agoAs I understand the news from Grapheneos, there's also bootloader issues and Google stopped publishing the device tree of pixel devices. They're not even sure if they'll support the 10a when it comes out.
- jeroenhd 11mo agoIt's not for me, but: - Google is an American company - GrapheneOS Pixel support depends on Google's Pixel support (and has been affected by Google's decision to open-source less of their Pixel trees) - This OS promises to maintain the usable app store + cloud experience - OS maintenance isn't dependent on a bunch of volunteers/donations - You can just buy this from an official reseller rather than making your own or having a sketchy website pre-install a custom ROM for you. I think GrapheneOS has the better developers when it comes to privacy and security, but there are reasons to go for the reliability of a corporate entity you pay for support over hacking together an alternative.
- daneel_w 11mo agoI think these points kind of understate the size, funding and determination of the GrapheneOS project.
- hasperdi 11mo ago€700 for a locked down phone, excluding €10 / month subscription of a locked down OS. No thanks
- hrimfaxi 11mo agoI really loved the previous design with the physical numpad and it seems they've opened up the platform to support more applications beyond a few blessed ones (like Signal in the past). Really put off by this though: > If you don’t pay for a product, you are the product. With MC03, you pay to retain your data rather than paying with it. So you have to pay >$100/year to maintain access to your device? Why do I need to pay to retain data that is on my own device?
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- dingnuts 11mo ago[dead]
- observationist 11mo agoYeah, this is the opposite of being your device. This is pretending to own a device as a service. I'm building a portable pbx on a raspberry pi with some power banks I stick in a backpack and a dual sim 5g unlimited internet hotspot, and switch over to starlink 5g when that happens. I'll throw a media server in there (pirate everything), and use a small portable wireless streaming touchscreen. There are all sorts of useful UI and linux tools that can make it a far better experience than android or phones. If I need a camera, I'll buy a camera. I've got earbuds and bluetooth for peripherals. 2026 is the year I leave "phones" behind - not playing the subscription device game anymore. I left Windows last year. I'll get better service, real control, and no enshittification treadmill. It's too bad it takes an inordinate amount of tech savvy to break out - Linux is well beyond good enough for grandma or the average user at this point. There's no reason beyond exploitation for profit for the kafkaesque intrusion into people's lives and data. If you've got the capability, break out. This product is not breaking free. Same walls, different garden.
- antinomicus 11mo agoRe: media server. Yeah. I wish there was an alternative but the modern media landscape is so broken there is no other way to maintain digital copies of your shows and movies, while maintaining your own ability to curate your ow content on a plane that isn’t just another surface for those companies to drive engagement metrics. If you try to escape, you are forced into drm locked down Blu rays or even just shit out of luck in the case of a lot of direct to streaming tv. In which case you have two options, stay on the enshittification treadmill, taking more and more shit from bigass corporations who are actively poisoning the culture, or sail the seas. Or I guess just don’t watch tv. But I like tv.
- phoronixrly 11mo agoHas Graphene announced their 'major Android OEM to bring the OS to Snapdragon-powered flagships' [that is NOT fairphone] yet?
- fph 11mo agoNo, not yet.
- lucb1e 11mo agoBased on how they speak of competitors and potential partners alike (no matter how good or bad they are, so long as they're not perfect, and nobody has perfect security in this internet world, only grapheneos gets a free pass from grapheneos), I half expect that this 'major OEM' will sooner or later have one tiny slip-up in opsec that makes graphene's owner think they're conspiring against them and they abort mission and start looking for another partner to begin anew
- StrLght 11mo agoHere's what GrapheneOS said about AphyOS: https://xcancel.com/GrapheneOS/status/1893469596973220188 https://xcancel.com/GrapheneOS/status/1893469596973220188 > They have a fork of an old version of GrapheneOS merged with LineageOS. They heavily marketed it as being based on GrapheneOS, but it's a very outdated version. Their devices don't have remotely comparable privacy, security, usability or app compatibility to official GrapheneOS.
- lucb1e 11mo ago>> They heavily marketed it as being based on GrapheneOS Claim not found in article. If it was so heavily marketed, that would be in the announcement since they're mentioning other partners (Threema, Proton, the extra app store it ships...), and definitely on the product page (no mention of /graph.*/ there either) Edit: found the specs button. It says the OS is based on AOSP (Android open source project)
- Sayrus 11mo agoSearching for "site:punkt.ch grapheneos" returns results that don't exist anymore. Articles are linked in the thread which supports this as well. > They repeatedly said they forked it from GrapheneOS in their media interviews and marketing. They didn't keep following along with our improvements and have shifted away from presenting it that way, partly because we requested it. And that also matches what is claimed here, they used to market based on this, they don't anymore.
- lif 11mo agocan someone explain how a subscription-based product is a great option for privacy? or how being locked in to a black box vpn instills a sense of having gained reliable true privacy?
- endemic 11mo agoyeah, it seems like the target market for a privacy-focused device like this are the nerds who could do it themselves and be more confident of the results
- turtlebits 11mo agoIt's probably to pay for all the things Google provides for free, app store hosting, review, curation, backups, synced data, etc.
- mzajc 11mo ago> app store hosting, review Do they actually host anything at all? All I could find was their F-Droid repository with six (6) applications: https://store.aphy.app/fdroid/repo/ https://store.aphy.app/fdroid/repo/. The rest must come from elsewhere (F-Droid's main archive?), but they don't indicate if they actually use the rent you pay to fund the third parties they depend on. For comparison, the F-Droid archive consists of 4061 applications reviewed, built, and hosted by the F-Droid team for free.
- sanjayts 11mo agoI'm really struggling to see who this phone is aimed for. Why would someone pay a subscription for their "own" phone that is cut off from the major app stores?
- tensegrist 11mo ago>punkt.ch wants to send you notifications pretty bad signal
- the_gipsy 11mo ago> Like its forerunner, the MC02, the new model is a subscription-based smartphone stopped reading there
- lucb1e 11mo agoThis is a very interesting thread to read... I can't help but remember the wishes expressed in other news threads such as 'I wish I could just pay for things to not have tracking built in' / 'This vital software component is so underfunded, no wonder this happens' Now a company offers it and every 2nd comment has the vibe of 'Why would someone pay a subscription for their "own" phone'. I guess that means the former vibe is not something most people actually want?
- fragmede 11mo agoYes. Don't listen to what people say they will do, pay attention to what they actually do.
- mzajc 11mo agoI'm not sure if you find it genuinely surprising that the Hacker News populace is not moved by a device that you not only have to pay rent for, but that also seemingly does not support custom ROMs/firmware. Besides that, the software that they expect you to pay rent for is a fork of LineageOS/AOSP, but it doesn't seem to mention anywhere on the site whether they donate any of the rent to their upstreams.
- lucb1e 11mo agoThose are fair criticisms, but that's not what I saw mentioned when the thread was young and the comments were at the level of "wait I have to pay for them maintaining the OS??". It seems people have that as a gut reaction even though they have presumably also (on average) been exposed to sentiments pro paying for things that cost money
- tokai 11mo agoSo if you dislike Google's business model you have to love John Deer's?
- lucb1e 11mo agoPropose another model instead of just saying no to every option?
- mzajc 11mo ago> What happens if I cancel my subscription? > You can cancel at any time. Without an active subscription, certain core services and privacy features will be limited. To keep your MC03 fully functional, secure, and up to date, an active subscription is required. Out of curiosity (I'm definitely NOT going to buy a Phone-as-a-Service), what exactly happens when you cancel your subscription? Does the smartphone brick itself? Does it let you flash a sane operating system that doesn't treat you as a cash cow?
- Jolter 11mo agoMost people seem to be subscribing to a cell phone already. Not us techies, but most normies seem to have expensive phones on three year ”plans” while locked to an expensive network.
- cmeacham98 11mo agoFinancing a phone is dumb for most people imo, but at least it has an explicit end where you own the phone outright. This phone requires a subscription in perpetuity, on top of the full purchase price.
- MadnessASAP 11mo agoThe last couple times I got a new phone the price of the phone + plan without financing for 2 years was greater then plan with 2 years of financing. So yeah, I got the financing. This was in Canada however.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- wolvoleo 11mo agoYeah I'd never do that. I just buy it outright. I don't have a cell phone subscription either. I use prepaid which actually is cheaper.
- 11mo ago
- lucb1e 11mo agoThe product page (https://www.punkt.ch/products/mc03-premium-secure-smartphone https://www.punkt.ch/products/mc03-premium-secure-smartphone, click on "all tech specs") mentions a "SAR sensor". I have not seen that before, does anyone know what this does? Does the device try to estimate how much EM your body received while carrying it around or calling, or what is this for?
- AlphaWeaver 11mo agoYep, SAR stands for "specific absorption rate". These sensors are typically used to change how the antennas on the phone transmit (like how much power they use) by detecting whether the phone is held close to your body vs. sitting somewhere like on a table. Most phones have them.
- qwertox 11mo agoLike the coulometer they mention. This is a battery discharge sensor, nobody would mention this in the specs. SAR sensor and coulometer are standard by now.
- danpalmer 11mo agoWhich leads to a conclusion, either the makers don't know enough to know it's standard (which suggests they aren't well informed enough to make a modern smartphone), or they do know but decided to include it to pad their spec sheet (which suggests disingenuous marketing).
- mmooss 11mo agoThey could just be transparent and know their techy customers are interested in these sorts of things. Possibly, they want to assure customers that their off-brand phone includes such features.
- lucb1e 11mo agoThat would also be my reading. I'm the type of nerd who's interested in minute details of his devices. I'm looking for a new phone currently and my spreadsheet includes columns like the UFS version, minimal brightness (as measured by some independent news site), whether it has a barometer, dual-frequency GNSS, etc. It always requires retrieving info via third parties such as https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jXtRCoEnnFNWj6_oFlVWflsf-b0jkfZpyhN-BXsv7uo https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1jXtRCoEnnFNWj6_oFlVW... (GPSTest database), https://phyphox.org/sensordb/ https://phyphox.org/sensordb/, the video mode list on gsmarena.com, etc. I haven't yet found a manufacturer that publishes sufficient detail such that I can fill out all relevant columns from their official spec page. They're never detailed enough so I can only applaud including more details. There will always be fields that aren't relevant to different subgroups of the audience...
- A_Duck 11mo agoThe problem in Europe is that Whatsapp has become the standard for mobile messaging, and it's only available on Android and iOS This really nerfs the whole dumbphone movement for Europeans, which should be a key market. I went on holiday with someone a few weeks ago who is toughing it out with a no-Whatsapp dumbphone. He missed the train home because he got locked out of the holiday cottage and couldn't get in touch with anyone.
- Rohansi 11mo agoI don't understand - how could they not get in touch with anyone? Surely SMS would have still worked if they were available on WhatsApp?
- A_Duck 11mo agoTrying to do an ELIHN here... On a holiday of 10 people, everybody exchanging numbers means 10x9/2 = 45 actions, with many of those edges between strangers (higher cost edge) Each person adding their friend to the Whatsapp group is 9 actions, with all edges between friends (low-cost edge) So in practice, only the second one happens. He had one other person's number, but that particular person didn't check their phone.
- prmoustache 11mo agoWhat the heck is an ELIHN?
- A_Duck 11mo agoExplain Like I'm Hacker News
- prmoustache 11mo agoIf that is your friend he surely had your number right and possibly others? Then why couldn't he get in touch with you or others? Most whatsapp groups end up being muted by almost anyone because they are an annoyance so they are hardly the place where you would ask for help anyway because virtually nobody would get notified.
- speedgoose 11mo agoI find it amusing to see the Facebook, XTwitter, and Pinterest social buttons at the bottom of the article.
- metadat 11mo agoAlso the site attempts to get a geo ping from your browser. Icky, to say the least. Makes their claims surrounding privacy seem a tad dubious.
- evan_ 11mo agoI thought this was an eInk screen- all of the screenshots show a grainy black-and-white UI. I had to dig around to learn that it actually has a full-color OLED apparently.
- zsoltkacsandi 11mo ago€699 + €9.99/month for a smartphone that supposed to be a dumb phone, with a custom locked down OS. Punkt is losing the point what made their previous products successful. I have my iphone 13 mini for 4 years, having a Punkt MC03 for the same amount of time would cost me €1058. Thanks, but no thanks.
- damsta 11mo agoI got interested and checked their website, but it gave me a bad vibe, not to mention the hefty price tag in addition to the subscription.
- _spduchamp 11mo agoFor years I've been so close to ordering one of their previous generation phones, and now I feel like I've dodged a bullet by not buying from this company. This new phone is a huge step in the wrong direction. Can someone please release a nice Sidekick like device with physical keyboard that supports Signal.
- pmkary 11mo agoYes, I'm in the exact same location.
- lazzurs 11mo agoA physical keyboard like a Treo/Palm Pre, enough storage to store all my photos and say GrapheneOS and I would be in.
- layer8 11mo agoThis was just announced: https://www.clicksphone.com/en/communicator https://www.clicksphone.com/en/communicator Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46467057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46467057
- _spduchamp 11mo agoNow THAT is a nice looking device!
- dangus 11mo agoI cannot understand the nostalgia for physical phone keyboards. They are an objectively slower typing experience. I would rather just buy a $20 Bluetooth keyboard if I wanted to do some serious typing on a phone. Or maybe get into Samsung Dex and similar technologies.
- mistercheph 11mo agoIf trying to hawk a subscription-based closed-source fork of open source software as privacy preserving or being "Swiss-made" weren't sufficient red flags, search the web for MP02, their last phone. Basic functionality like calling and texting often don't work, and their Signal client never work, they are selling a dream. Punkt is basically a scam
- pmkary 11mo agoWell they really destroyed everything that I knew was Punkt: Great design, minimalist, e-ink like displays with an android cheap design, no e-ink, and Phone as a Service? are you kidding us?
- torginus 11mo agoI hope the Swiss broke with their traditions and its not a front for the CIA this time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG
- bflesch 11mo agoI was also thinking about Crypto AG because the punkt website goes a long way to not mention a single name of a human being who is involved with the company. For example the imprint in the footer and the about page does not list who is CEO of the company.
- fainpul 11mo agoHa. That caused quite some reputation damage. However I would say infiltration and spying is more of an intelligence agency tradition, than a swiss tradition.
- analogpixel 11mo agogo to website, "allow punkt to send you notifications", closed website. based on how they welcome new customers to their site, I can only assume this is the general vibe of the company also. (aggressively pushing crap)
- qwertox 11mo ago"Website `https://www.punkt.ch https://www.punkt.ch` would like to show notifications." Why? What is so important that they need me to notify about?
- ekjhgkejhgk 11mo agoEnable notifications and find out.
- schmuckonwheels 11mo agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46466171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46466171
- wiether 11mo agoI love the aesthetics of the objectives/flash looking like an induction cooktop!
- 7734128 11mo ago"www.punkt.ch wants to send you notifications" Why do websites still do this? It's an immediate red flag that the underlying company have no respect for their customers.
- vbezhenar 11mo agoThe first thing I do when setting up new Chrome instance, is disabling almost every API in its settings, including Notifications API. You can always enable it later for a few selected websites (I'm using it for Telegram Web), and rest of the websites will just silently rejected.
- sallveburrpi 11mo agoIt’s kind of a given that the average HN reader won’t have any problems with this (like who is opening a browser without ublock origin on it?) - but like 90% of the population are powerless against this literal cyber bullying; it’s really sad
- BizarroLand 11mo agoYou could also stop using chrome and switch to waterfox or some other mozilla derivative. If you have a site that "requires" chrome, you can easily add a user-agent switcher extension to fool whatever JS nonsense that claims to require chrome.
- rationalist 11mo agoI would bet money that 99+% of the population never goes into their web browser's settings. Unfortunately I don't know of any way to prove or disprove that.
- IshKebab 11mo agoI've done this for passkeys.
- margalabargala 11mo agoIt's so they can notify their customers about their upcoming payments for the subscription to continue using the OS on the phone they bought.
- jasonvorhe 11mo agoNot even close to security provided by GrapheneOS, ships Android 15 and the phone looks quite ugly with that big branding on it. I'll stick with GrapheneOS and Pixels.
- userbinator 11mo agoIf you don't have root access, you don't have full control.
- arximboldi 11mo agoI own a MP01 that replaced a Nokia 105 that got lost in the Berghain after 12 years of service. I regret buying the Punkt. It costs more than double than the Nokia and is worse in almost every dimension. It is all form over function, with various obvious UX issues. I would not buy from this company again.
- sallveburrpi 11mo agoTo be fair the Nokia 105 is pretty awesome. Did you find any other that is similar? I still have some ancient burner phones but it would be nice to have a recent one that is decent and not too expensive
- arximboldi 11mo agoI'm waiting for the Punkt to die one day before I buy a new one, don't wanna create unnecessary waste. In spite of its flaws, it is rather robust so it may take a while haha. There is a 4G edition of the Nokia 105 which would be my next option. But I'm thinking maybe if I move to a 4G phone I'd like it to have the ability to create a wifi hotspot, which none of the cheap Nokias can. But I dunno, I'm slowly kind of getting tired of the burner phone life... It's just getting harder and harder. I spent three months in the US this summer and it was impossible without one there, even the door of this workshop I was visiting needed a fucking app to open the door, so I did buy the cheapest Samsung (my first ever smartphone). I'm now back in Europe and using the burner phone again, I keep the smartphone for the bank app and what not. But... maybe when this new GrapheneOS device comes out this year (they promised a new non-google device with official OEM support) I may bite the bullet... Or maybe one of those ink-display devices...
- antics9 11mo agoI loved my MP01. However, GSM is not available anymore where I live. I used the CAT S22 for a while but it just isn't the same. If they release a 5G MP03 I might buy one. I don't see the point of a Punkt smartphone.
- metadope 11mo ago> got lost in the Berghain That happened to me once. Took me days to find my way out.
- sallveburrpi 11mo agoI immediately distrust anything privacy based that is marketed by the Swiss.
- ekjhgkejhgk 11mo ago> Like its forerunner, the MC02, the new model is a subscription-based smartphone Non-starter.
- davidhariri 11mo agoI bought and tried to use the MP02 as a daily driver. Quite different from where Punkt is heading now. The industrial design is gorgeous, but the software was pretty bad (laggy, unintuitive navigation - Android on such a low powered chip was a bad choice). I can guess why, but it baffles me they didn't jump on the growing demand for dumbphones. If they had just released an MP03 with identical form factor but improved battery life, latency and screen improvements, I would have bought one in a heartbeat.
- Abishek_Muthian 11mo agoSeems like this AphyOS is de-googled android, not sure if they use MicroG but apart from FAQ there's no mention of 'Android'. Being android the trade off between convinience and privacy might be lesser than a purpose built Linux Phone like Librem. Their marketing copy suggests it's not for the same audience as say Librem or Graphene OS phone. Ofcourse many of their advertised privacy features can be achieved for cheap with any LineageOS/postmarket OS phone with self-hosted Nextcloud.
- mvkel 11mo agoHuge disappointment that it's just a glass rectangle with a modified OS. What made previous Punkt models cool is that they were "dumb+" phones. They did what you needed them to, and nothing else. In exchange, you got a device that fit easily in your pocket. Now that it's a big touch screen, you've got apps, complexity, and ultimately no differentiator from any other smartphone.
- utopiah 11mo agoAphyOS? OK checking "Free & Open Source Software" cool... but no link to repositories on their Webpage, not a great sign. Found https://github.com/orgs/AphyOS/repositories https://github.com/orgs/AphyOS/repositories but 2024 so clearly not the main repos, found https://gerrit.aphy.ag/admin/repos https://gerrit.aphy.ag/admin/repos via https://aphy.guide/docs/developers/platform/source-code-management/ https://aphy.guide/docs/developers/platform/source-code-mana... So... FLOSS doesn't mean external contributions but did anybody review this, like security audit, submitting issues, anything? It's the first time I hear about it.
- dmitrygr 11mo ago> Like its forerunner, the MC02, the new model is a subscription-based smartphone Nope Nope Nope nope Nope Nope Nope
- MomsAVoxell 11mo agoHad me at “control your data”, lost me at “monthly subscription”. Damn, so close.
- ricardobeat 11mo agoLove the concept, hate the idea of a €120/year subscription for the OS alone. It’s also slightly upsetting that both Punkt and Apostrophy’s websites refuse to mention “AphyOS” is an Android-based OS, which is 100% relevant for a purchase decision.
- lucb1e 11mo agoIt could be more prominent but it's mentioned in the tech specs. And it assumes that readers know that AOSP means Android... I don't know either why they hide it so much but it's sorta on there
- fainpul 11mo agoIf they're going to provide updates or privacy as a subscription, it would be much more interesting to offer the device for free, with just the $/€/CHF 10 fee per month. Stop the subscription and you have to return the device. The fee includes some margin for insurance and refurbishing. Then it's clearly "renting a phone" and the cost is similar to buying an expensive phone and using it for a couple of years.
- 0manrho 11mo ago> If you don’t pay for a product, you are the product. With MC03, you pay to retain your data rather than paying with it. Ah yes, more dystopian "You'll own nothing, and rent everything, including your own data" products. That's a hard no, do not pass go from me. Technology has been enshittified enough, stop being part of the problem, and certainly don't try to pretend you're doing me a favor or protecting my privacy by holding my devices and/or data captive unless I pay an indefinite renters fee. If they aren't selling the data, then why the hell do they want it? Want to protect my privacy? Sell me the damn device, let me do as I please with it, and let that be the end of the transaction. Keep your damn telemetry, backdoors, dark patterns, bloatware and subscription bullshit off it.