21 ms·
It's insulting to read AI-generated blog posts
- noir_lord 1y agoI just hit the back button as soon as my "this feels like AI" sense tingles. Now you could argue but you don't know it was AI it could just be really mediocre writing - it could indeed but I hit the back button there as well so it's a wash either way.
- rco8786 1y agoThere's definitely an uncanny valley with a lot of AI. But also, it's entirely likely that lots of what we're reading is AI generated and we can't tell at all. This post could easily be AI (it's not, but it could be)
- Waterluvian 1y agoAh the portcullis to the philosophical topic of, “if you couldn’t tell, does that demonstrate that authenticity doesn’t matter?”
- noir_lord 1y agoI think it does, We could get a robotic arm to paint in the style of a Dutch master but it'd not be a Dutch master. I'd sooner have a ship painting from the little shop in the village with the little old fella who paints them in the shop than a perfect robotic simulacrum of a Rembrandt. Intention matters but it matters less sometimes but I think it matters. Writing is communication, it's one of the things we as humans do that makes us unique - why would I want to reduce that to a machine generating it or read it when it has.
- cubefox 1y agoThat's also why in The Matrix (1999) the main character takes the red pill (facing grim reality) rather than the blue pill (forgetting about grim reality and going back to a happy illusion).
- noir_lord 1y agoAye I always thought the character of Cypher was tragic as well, his reality sucked so much that he'd consciously go back and live a lie he doesn't remember and then forget he made that choice. The Matrix was and is fantastic on many levels.
- DaiPlusPlus 1y agoIt’s a shame they never made any sequels
- yoyohello13 1y agoI’ve been learning piano and I’ve noticed a similar thing with music. You can listen to perfect machine generated performances of songs and there is just something missing. A live performance even of a master pianist will have little ‘mistakes’ or interpretations that make the whole performance so much more enjoyable. Not only that, but just knowing that a person spent months drilling a song adds something.
- Waterluvian 1y agoTwo things this great comment reminds me of: I've been learning piano too, and I find more joy in performing a piece poorly, than listening to it played competently. My brother asked me why I play if I'm just playing music that's already been performed (a leading question, he's not ignorant). I asked him why he plays hockey if you can watch pros play it far better. It's the journey, not the destination. I've been (re-)re-re-watching Star Trek TNG and Data touches on this issue numerous times, one of which is specifically about performing violin (but also reciting Shakespeare). And the message is what you're sharing: to recite a piece with perfect technical execution results an in imperfect performance. It's the _human_ aspects that lend a piece deep emotion that other humans connect with, often without being able to concretely describe why. Let us feel your emotions through your work. Everyting written on the page is just the medium for those emotions. Without emotion, your perfectly recited piece is a delivered blank message.
- Planktonne 1y ago> Ah, but a man's reach should exceed his grasp, Or what's a heaven for? https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43745/andrea-del-sarto https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43745/andrea-del-sart...
- embedding-shape 1y agoI do the same almost, but use "this isn't interesting/fun to read" and don't really care if it was written by AI or not, if it's interesting/fun it's interesting/fun, and if it isn't, it isn't. Many times it's obvious it's AI, but sometimes as you said it could just be bad, and in the end it doesn't really matter, I don't want to continue reading it regardless.
- shadowgovt 1y agoI do the same, but for blog posts complaining about AI. At this point, I don't know there's much more to be said on the topic. Lines of contention are drawn, and all that's left is to see what people decide to do.
- z7 1y agoHypothetically, what if the AI-generated blog post were better than what the human author of the blog would have written?
- philipwhiuk 1y agoBetter how?
- 4fterd4rk 1y agoIt's insulting but I also find it extremely concerning that my younger colleagues can't seem to tell the difference. An article will very clearly be AI slop and I'll express frustration, only to discover that they have no idea what I"m talking about.
- Insanity 1y agoOr worse - they can tell the difference but don’t think it matters.
- rco8786 1y agoI see a lot of that also.
- jermaustin1 1y agoFor me it is everyone that has lost the ability to respond to a work email without first having it rewritten by some LLM somewhere. Or my sister who will have ChatGPT give a response to a text message if she doesn't feel like reading the 4-5 sentences from someone. I think the rates of ADHD are going to go through the roof soon, and I'm not sure if there is anything that can be done about it.
- noir_lord 1y ago> I think the rates of ADHD are going to go through the roof soon As a diagnosed medical condition I don't know, as people having seemingly shorter and short attention spans we are seeing it already, TikTok and YT shorts and the like don't help, we've weaponised inattention.
- larodi 1y agoADHD is going to very soon be a major pandemic. Not one we talk about too much, as there are plenty of players ready to feed unlimited supplies of Concerta, Ritalin and Adderal among others.
- mrguyorama 1y agoADHD is a difference in how the brain functions and is constructed. It is physiological. I don't think any evidence exists that you can cause anyone to become neurodivergent except by traumatic brain injury TikTok does not "make" people ADHD. They might struggle to let themselves be bored and may be addicted to quick fixes of dopamine, but that is not what ADHD is. ADHD is not an addiction to dopamine hits. ADHD is not an inability to be bored. TikTok for example will not give you the kinds of tics and lack of proprioception that is common in neurodivergent people. Being addicted to Tiktok will never give you that absurd experience where your brain "hitches" while doing a task and you rapidly oscillate between progressing towards one task vs another. Being habituated to check your phone at every down moment does not cause you to be unable to ignore sensory input because your actual sensory processing machinery in your brain is not functioning normally. Getting addicted to tiktok does not give you a child's handwriting despite decades of practice. If you do not already have significant stimming and jitter symptoms, Tiktok will not make you develop them. You cannot learn to be ADHD.
- edoceo 1y agoI do like it for taking the hour long audio/video and creating a summary that, even if poorly written, can indicate to me wether I'd like to listen to the hour of media.
- icapybara 1y agoIf they can’t be bothered to write it, why should I be bothered to read it?
- abixb 1y agoI'm sure lots of "readers" of such articles fed it to another AI model to summarize it, thereby completely bypassing the usual human experience of writing and then careful (and critical) reading and parsing of the article text. I weep for the future. Also, reminds me of this cartoon from March 2023. [0] [0] https://marketoonist.com/2023/03/ai-written-ai-read.html https://marketoonist.com/2023/03/ai-written-ai-read.html
- trthomps 1y agoI'm curious if the people who are using AI to summarize articles are the same people who would have actually read more than the headline to begin with. It feels to me like the sort of person who would have read the article and applied critical thinking to it is not going to use an AI summary to bypass that since they won't be satisfied with it.
- array_key_first 1y agoAre people doing this or is this just what, like, Apple or someone is telling us people are doing? Because I've never seen anyone actually use a summarizing AI willingly. And especially not for blogs and other discretionary activities. That's like getting the remote from the hit blockbuster "Click" starring Adam Sandler (2006) and then using it to skip sex. Just doesn't make any sense.
- alxmdev 1y agoMany of those who can't be bothered to write what they publish probably can't be bothered to read it themselves, either. Not by humans and certainly not for humans.
- AlienRobot 1y agoNow that I think about it, it's rather ironic that's a quote because you didn't write it.
- elif 1y agoI feel like this has to be AI generated satire as art
- thire 1y agoYes, I was almost hoping for a "this was AI-generated" disclaimer at the end!
- xena 1y agoPeople at work have fed me obviously AI generated documentation and blogposts. I've gotten to the point where I can make fairly accurate guesses as to which model generated it. I've started to just reject them because the alternative is getting told to rewrite them to "not look AI".
- the_af 1y agoWhat amazes me is that some people think I want to read AI slop in their blog that I could have generated by asking ChatGPT directly. Anyone can access ChatGPT, why do we need an intermediary? Someone a while back shared, here on HN, almost an entire blog generated by (barely touched up) AI text. It even had Claude-isms like "excellent question!", em-dashes, the works. Why would anyone want to read that?
- dewey 1y agoThere's blogs that are not meant to be read, but are just content marketing to be found by search engines.
- CuriouslyC 1y agoIn that case, I'd say maybe you didn't have the wisdom to ask the question in the first place? And maybe you wouldn't know the follow up questions to ask after that? And if the person who produced it took a few minutes to fact check, that has value as well.
- the_af 1y agoIt's seldom the case that AI slop requires widsom to ask, or is fact-checked in any depth other than cursory. Cursory checking of AI-slop has effectively zero value. Or do you remember when Facebook groups or image communities were flooded with funny/meme AI-generated images, "The Godfather, only with Star Wars", etc? Thank you, but I can generate those zero-effort memes myself, I also have access to GenAI. We truly don't need intermediaries.
- CuriouslyC 1y agoYou don't need human intermediates either, what's the point of teachers? You can read the original journal articles just fine. In fact what's the point of any communication that isn't journal articles? Everything else is just recycled slop.
- 1y ago
- latexr 1y agoThis assumes the person using LLMs to put out a blog post gives a single shit about their readers, pride, or “being human”. They don’t. They care about the view so you load the ad which makes them a fraction of a cent, or the share so they get popular so they can eventually extract money or reputation from it. I agree with you that AI slop blog posts are a bad thing, but there are about zero people who use LLMs to spit out blog posts which will change their mind after reading your arguments. You’re not speaking their language, they don’t care about anything you do. They are selfish. The point is themselves, not the reader. > Everyone wants to help each other. No, they very much do not. There are a lot of scammers and shitty entitled people out there, and LLMs make it easier than ever to become one of them or increase the reach of those who already are.
- JohnFen 1y ago> They are selfish. The point is themselves, not the reader. True! But when I encounter a web site/article/video that has obviously been touched by genAI, I add that source to a blacklist and will never see anything from it again. If more people did that, then the selfish people would start avoiding the use of genAI because using it will cause their audience to decline.
- latexr 1y ago> I add that source to a blacklist Please do tell more. Do you make it like a rule in your adblocker or something else? > If more people did that, then the selfish people would start avoiding the use of genAI because using it will cause their audience to decline. I’m not convinced. The effort on their part is so low that even the lost audience (which will be far from everyone) is still probably worth it.
- JohnFen 1y agoI was using "blacklist" in a much more general sense, but here's how it actually plays out. Most of my general purpose website reading is done through an RSS aggregator. If one of those feeds starts using genAI, then I just drop it out of the aggregator. If it's a website that I found through web search, then I use Kagi's search refinement settings to ensure that site won't come up again in my search results. If it's a YouTube channel I subscribe to, I unsubscribe. If it's one that YouTube recommended to me, I tell YouTube to no longer recommend anything from that channel. Otherwise, I just remember that particular source as being untrustworthy.
- dewey 1y ago> No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations I think that's the best use case and it's not AI related as spell-checkers and translation integrations exist forever, now they are just better. Especially for non-native speakers that work in a globalized market. Why wouldn't they use the tool in their toolbox?
- j4yav 1y agoBecause it doesn’t just fix your grammar, it makes you sound suspiciously like spam.
- dewey 1y agoIt's a tool and it depends on how you use it. If you tell it to fix your grammar with minimal intervention to the actual structure it will do just that.
- kvirani 1y agoUsually
- cubefox 1y agoYeah. It's "pick your poison". If your English sounds broken, people will think poorly of your text. And if it sounds like LLM speak, they won't like it either. Not much you can do. (In a limited time frame.)
- geerlingguy 1y agoLately I have more appreciation for broken English and short, to the point sentences than the 20 paragraph AI bullet point lists with 'proper' formatting. Maybe someone will build an AI model that's succinct and to the point someday. Then I might appreciate the use a little more.
- YurgenJurgensen 1y ago
- DonHopkins 1y ago> lexical bingo machine I would have written "lexical fruit machine", for its left to right sequential ejaculation of tokens, and its amusingly antiquated homophobic criminological implication. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fruit_machine https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fruit_machine
- VladVladikoff 1y agoRecently I had to give one of my vendors a dressing down about LLM use in emails. He was sending me these ridiculous emails where the LLM was going off the rails suggesting all sorts of features etc that were exploding the scope of the project. I told him he needs to just send the bullet notes next time instead of pasting those into ChatGPT and pasting the output into an email.
- larodi 1y agoI was shouting to my friend and partner the other day, that he is absolutely to ever stop sending me LLM-generated mails, even if the best he can come with is full of punctuation and grammar errors.
- jihadjihad 1y agoIt's similarly insulting to read your AI-generated pull request. If I see another "dart-on-target" emoji... You're telling me I need to use 100% of my brain, reasoning power, and time to go over your code, but you didn't feel the need to hold yourself to the same standard?
- latexr 1y ago> You're telling me I need to use 100% of my brain, reasoning power, and time to go over your code, but you didn't feel the need to hold yourself to the same standard? I don’t think they are (telling you that). The person who sends you an AI slop PR would be just as happy (probably even happier) if you turned off your brain and just merged it without any critical thinking.
- bitbasher 1y ago[flagged]
- nbardy 1y agoYou know you can AI review the PR too, don't be such a curmudgeon. I have PR's at work I and coworkers fully AI generated and fully AI review. And
- gdulli 1y ago> You know you can AI review the PR too, don't be such a curmudgeon. I have PR's at work I and coworkers fully AI generated and fully AI review. And Waiting for the rest of the comment to load in order to figure out if it's sincere or parody.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kacesensitive 1y agoHe must of dropped connection while chatGPT was generating his HN comment
- Simulacra 1y agoI've noticed this with a significant number of news articles. Sometimes it will say that it was "enhanced" with AI, but even when it doesn't, I get that distinct robotic feel.
- chasing 1y agoMy thing is: If you have something to say, just say it! Don't worry that it's not long enough or short enough or doesn't fit into some mold you think it needs to fit into. Just say it. As you write, you'll probably start to see your ideas more clearly and you'll start to edit and add color or clarify. But just say it! Bypass the middleman who's just going to make it blurrier or more long-winded.
- CuriouslyC 1y agoSorry, but I 100% guarantee that there are a lot of people that have time for a quick outline of an article, but not a polished article. Your choice then is between a nugget of human wisdom that's been massaged into a presentable format with AI or nothing. You're never going to get that raw shit you say you want, because it has negative value for creator's brands, it looks way lazier than spot checked AI output, and people see the lack of baseline polish and nope out right away unless it's a creator they're already sold on (then you can pump out literal garbage, as long as you keep it a low % of your total content you can get away with shit new creators only dream of).
- __alexander 1y agoI feel the same way about AI generated README.md on Github.
- doug_durham 1y agoI don't like reading content that has not been generated with care. The use of LLMs is largely orthogonal to that. If a non-native English speaker uses an LLM to craft a response so I can consume it, that's great. As long as there is care, I don't mind the source.
- olooney 1y agoI don't see the objection to using LLMs to check for grammatical mistakes and spelling errors. That strikes me as a reactionary and dogmatic position, not a rational one. Anyone who has done any serious writing knows that a good editor will always find a dozen or more errors in any essay of reasonable length, and very few people are willing to pay for professional proofreading services on blog posts. On the other side of the coin, readers will wince and stumble over such errors; they will not wonder at the artisanal authenticity of your post, but merely be annoyed. Wabi-sabi is an aesthetic best reserved for decor, not prose.
- keiferski 1y agoYes, I agree. There's nothing wrong with using an LLM or a spell-checker to improve your writing. But I do think it's important to have the LLM point out the errors, not rewrite the text directly. This lets you discover errors but avoid the AI-speak.
- ryanmcbride 1y agoYou thought we wouldn't notice that you used AI on this comment but you were wrong.
- olooney 1y agoHere is a piece I wrote recently on that very subject. Why don't you read that to see if I'm a human writer? https://www.oranlooney.com/post/em-dash/ https://www.oranlooney.com/post/em-dash/
- philipwhiuk 1y ago[flagged]
- ryanmcbride 1y agoThat wasn't actually why I posted that I was just guessing and thought it'd be funny if I was right.
- aeve890 1y ago>No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations, or for whatever else you think you are incapable of doing. Make the mistake. Feel embarrassed. Learn from it. Why? Because that's what makes us human! Fellas, is it antihuman to use tools to perfect your work? I can't draw a perfect circle by hand, that's why I use a compass. Do I need to make it bad on purpose and feel embarrassed by the 1000th time just to feel more human? Do I want to make mistakes by doing mental calculations instead of using a calculator, like a normal person? Of course not. Where this "I'm proud of my sloppy shit, this is what's make me human" thing comes from? We rised above other species because we learnt to use tools, and now we define to be "human"... by not using tools? The fuck? Also, ironically, this entire post smells like AI slop.
- dev_l1x_be 1y agoIs this the case when I put in the effort, spent several hours on tuning the LLM to help me the best possible way and I just use it answer the question "what is the best way to phrase this in American English?"? I think low effort LLM use is hilariously bad. The content it produces too. Tuning it, giving is style, safeguards, limits, direction, examples, etc. can improve it significantly.
- charlieyu1 1y agoI don’t know. As a neurodivergent person I have been insulted for my entire life for lacking “communication skills” so I’m glad there is something for levelling the playing field.
- rcarmo 1y agoHear hear. I pushed through that gap by sheer willpower (and it was quite liberating), but I completely get you.
- YurgenJurgensen 1y agoIt only levels the field between you and a million spambots, which arguably makes you look even worse than before.
- siva7 1y agoouch... but it's true.
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agoI’d rather be insulted for something I am and can at least try to improve, than praised for something I’m not or can’t do, despite my physiological shortcomings.
- tpmoney 1y agoOn the other hand, your perspective is shaped by not being dismissed by the vast majority of the people you encounter for that shortcoming. I would imagine you might feel very differently if every person you met treated you as an imbecile because you were't articulate enough, especially if your best efforts at improving don't move the needle much. I can't speak for the OP's experiences, but my early schooling years were marked by receiving a number of marked down or failing grades because my handwriting was awful, it still is, but at the time no matter what I did, I couldn't get my handwriting to stay neat. Writing neatly was too slow for my thoughts, and I'd get lost or go off topic. But writing at a pace to keep up with my thoughts turned my writing into barely understandable runes at best, and incomprehensible scribbles at worst. Even where handwriting wasn't supposed to count, I lost credit because of how bad it was. At a certain point I was given permission to type all of my work. Even for tested material I was given proctored access to a type writer (and later computer). And my grades improved noticeably. My subjective experiences and enjoyment of my written school work also improved noticeably. Maybe I could have spend more years working on improving my handwriting and getting it to a place where I was just barely adequate enough to stop losing credit for it. Maybe I have lost something "essential" about being human because my handwriting is still so bad I often can't read my own scribblings. But I am infinitely grateful to have lived in a time and place where personal access to typing systems allowed me to be more fairly evaluated on what I had to say, rather than how I could physically write it.
- retrocog 1y agoThe tool is only as good as the user
- alyxya 1y agoI personally don’t think I care if a blog post is AI generated or not. The only thing that matters to me is the content. I use ChatGPT to learn about a variety of different things, so if someone came up with an interesting set of prompts and follow ups and shared a summary of the research ChatGPT did, it could be meaningful content to me. > No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations, or for whatever else you think you are incapable of doing. Make the mistake. Feel embarrassed. Learn from it. Why? Because that's what makes us human! It would be more human to handwrite your blog post instead. I don’t see how this is a good argument. The use of tools to help with writing and communication should make it easier to convey your thoughts, and that itself is valuable.
- furyofantares 1y agoPeople are putting out blog posts and readmes constantly that they obviously couldn't even be bothered to read themselves, and they're making it to the top of HN routinely. Often the author had something interesting to share and the LLM has erased it and inserted so much garbage you can't tell what's real and what's not, and even among what's real, you can't tell what parts the author cares about and which parts they don't. All I care about is content, too, but people using LLMs to blog and make readmes is routinely getting garbage content past the filters and into my eyeballs. It's especially egregious when the author put good content into the LLM and pasted the garage output at us. Are there people out there using an LLM as a starting point but taking ownership of the words they post, taking care that what they're posting still says what they're trying to say, etc? Maybe? But we're increasingly drowning in slop.
- kirurik 1y agoTo be fair, you are assuming that the input wasn't garbage to begin with. Maybe you only notice it because it is obvious. Just like someone would only notice machine translation if it is obvious.
- furyofantares 1y ago> To be fair, you are assuming that the input wasn't garbage to begin with. It's not an assumption. Look at this example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45591707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45591707 The author posted their input to the LLM in the comments after receiving critcism, and that input was much better than their actual post. In this thread I'm less sure: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45713835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45713835 - it DOES look like there was something interesting thrown into the LLM that then put garbage out. It's more of an informed guess than an assumption, you can tell the author did have an experience to share, but you can't really figure out what's what because of all the slop. In this case the author redid their post in response to criticism and it's still pretty bad to me, and then they kept using an LLM to post comments in the thread, I can't really tell how much non-garbage was going in.
- giltho 1y agoHey chatGPT, summarise this post for me
- ericol 1y ago> read something spit out by the equivalent of a lexical bingo machine because you were too lazy to write it yourself. Ha! That's a very clever spot on insult. Most LLMs would probably be seriously offended by this would thy be rational beings. > No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations, or for whatever else you think you are incapable of doing. Make the mistake. OK, you are pushing it buddy. My mandarin is not that good; as a matter of fact, I can handle no mandarin at all. Or french to that matter. But I'm certain a decent LLM can do that without me having to resort to reach out to another person, that might not be available or have enough time to deal with my shenanigans. I agree that there are way too much AI slop being created and made public, but yet there are way too many cases where the use is fair and used for improving whatever the person is doing. Yes, AI is being abused. No, I don't agree we should all go taliban against even fair use cases.
- ericol 1y agoAs a side note, i hate posts where they go on and on and use 3 pages to go to the point. You know what I'm doing? I'm using AI to chase to the point and extract the relevant (For me) info.
- portaouflop 1y agoIt’s a clever post but people that use so to write personal blogposts ain’t gonna read this and change their mind. Only people who already hate using llms are gonna cheer you on. But this kind of content is great for engagement farming on HN. Just write “something something clankers bad” While I agree with the author it’s a very moot and uninspired point
- maxdo 1y agoTypical black and white article to capitalize on I hate AI hype. Super top articles with millions of readers are done with AI. It’s not an ai problem it’s the content. If it’s watery and no style tuned it’s bad. Same as human author
- rcarmo 1y agoI don't get all this complaining, TBH. I have been blogging for over 25 years (20+ on the same site), been using em dashes ever since I switched to a Mac (and because the Markdown parser I use converts double dashes to it, which I quite like when I'm banging out text in vim), and have made it a point of running long-form posts through an LLM asking it to critique my text for readability because I have a tendency for very long sentences/passages. AI is a tool to help you _finish_ stuff, like a wood sander. It's not something you should use as a hacksaw, or as a hammer. As long as you are writing with your own voice, it's just better autocorrect.
- curioussquirrel 1y ago100% agree. Using it to polish your sentences or fix small grammar/syntax issues is a great use case in my opinion. I specifically ask it not to completely rewrite or change my voice. It can also double as a peer reviewer and point out potential counterarguments, so you can address them upfront.
- philipwhiuk 1y ago> I specifically ask it not to completely rewrite or change my voice. And LLMs always do what you say, absolutely always, no issues there.
- yxhuvud 1y agoThe problem is that a lot of people use it for a whole lot more than just polish. The LLM voice in a text get quite jarring very quickly.
- fullshark 1y agoThe complaint is because people (marketers and people marketing themselves) are not using it that way, and instead are using it to generate low value blogspam.
- carimura 1y agoI feel like sometimes I write like an LLM, complete with [bad] self-deprecating humor, overly-explained points because I like first principals, random soliloquies, etc. Makes me worry that I'll try and change my style. That said, when I do try to get LLMs to write something, I can't stand it, and feel like the OP here.
- chemotaxis 1y agoI don't like binary takes on this. I think the best question to ask is whether you own the output of your editing process. Why does this article exist? Does it represent your unique perspective? Is this you at your best, trying to share your insights with the world? If yes, there's probably value in putting it out. I don't care if you used paper and ink, a text editor, a spell checker, or asked an LLM for help. On the flip side, if anyone could've asked an LLM for the exact same text, and if you're outsourcing a critical thinking to the reader - then yeah, I think you deserve scorn. It's no different from content-farmed SEO spam. Mind you, I'm what you'd call an old-school content creator. It would be an understatement to say I'm conflicted about gen AI. But I also feel that this is the most principled way to make demands of others: I have no problem getting angry at people for wasting my time or polluting the internet, but I don't think I can get angry at them for producing useful content the wrong way.
- buu700 1y agoExactly. If it's substantially the writer's own thoughts and/or words, who cares if they collaborated with an LLM, or autocomplete, or a spelling/grammar-checker, or a friend, or a coworker, or someone from Fiverr? This is just looking for arbitrary reasons to be upset. If it's not substantially their own writing or ideas, then sure, they shouldn't pass it off as such and claim individual authorship. That's a different issue entirely. However, if someone just wanted to share, "I'm 50 prompts deep exploring this niche topic with GPT-5 and learned something interesting; quoted below is a response with sources that I've fact-checked against" or "I posted on /r/AskHistorians and received this fascinating response from /u/jerryseinfeld", I could respect that. In any case, if someone is posting low-quality content, blame the author, not the tools they happened to use. OOP may as well say they only want to read blog posts written with vim and emacs users should stay off the internet. I just don't see the point in gatekeeping. If someone has something valuable to share, they should feel free to use whatever resources they have available to maximize the value provided. If using AI makes the difference between a rambling draft riddled with grammatical and factual errors, and a more readable and information-dense post at half the length with fewer inaccuracies, use AI.
- 1y ago
- jayers 1y agoI think it is important to make the distinction between "blog post" and other kinds of published writing. It literally does not matter if your blog post has perfectly correct grammar or misspellings (though you should do a one-pass revision for clarity of thought). Blog posts are best for articulating unfinished thoughts. To that end, you are cheating yourself, the writer, if you use AI to help you write a blog post. It is through the act of writing it that you begin to grok with the idea. But you bet that I'm going to use AI to correct my grammar and spelling for the important proposal I'm about to send. No sense in losing credibility over something that can be corrected algorithmically.
- futurecat 1y agoslop excepted, writing is a very difficult activity that has always been outsourced to some extent, either to an individual, a team, or to some software (spell checker, etc). Of course people will use AI if they think it makes them a better writer. Taste is the only issue here.
- iamwil 1y agoLately, I've been writing more on my blog, and it's been helpful to change the way that I do it. Now, I take a cue from school, and write the outline first. With an outline, I can use a prompt for the LLM to play the role of a development editor to help me critique the throughline. This is helpful because I tend to meander, if I'm thinking at the level of words and sentences, rather than at the level of an outline. Once I've edited the outline for a compelling throughline, I can then type out the full essay in my own voice. I've found it much easier to separate the process into these two stages. Before outline critiquing: https://interjectedfuture.com/destroyed-at-the-boundary/ https://interjectedfuture.com/destroyed-at-the-boundary/ After outline critiquing: https://interjectedfuture.com/the-best-way-to-learn-might-be-starting-at-the-end/ https://interjectedfuture.com/the-best-way-to-learn-might-be... I'm still tweaking the developement editor. I find that it can be too much of a stickler on the form of the throughline.
- whshdjsk 1y agoAnd yet, Will, with all due respect, I can’t hear your voice in any of the 10 articles I skimmed. It’s the same rhetorical structure found in every other LLM blog. I suppose if to make you feel like it’s better (even if it isn’t), and you enjoy it, go ahead. But know this: we can tell.
- iamwil 1y agoThe essays go back a couple years. How did I use LLMs to write in 2021 and 2022? If you're talking about something more recent, there's only two essays I wrote with the outlining and throughline method I described above. And all of essays, I wrote every word you read on the page with my fingers tapping on the keyboard. Hence, I'm not actually sure you can tell. I believe you think I'm just one-shotting these essays by rambling to an LLM. I can tell you for sure the results from doing that is pretty bad. All of them have the same rhetorical structure...probably because it's what I write like without an LLM, and it's what I prompted the LLM, playing a role as a development editor to critique outlines to do! So if you're saying that I'm a bad writer (fair), that's one thing! But I'm definitely writing these myself. shrug
- amrocha 1y agoTangential, but when I heard the Zoom CEO say that in the future you’ll just send your AI double to a meeting for you I couldn’t comprehend how a real human being could ever think that that would be an ok thing to suggest. The absolute bare minimum respect you can have for someone who’s making time for you is to make time for them. Offloading that to AI is the equivalent of shitting on someone’s plate and telling them to eat it. I struggle everyday with the thought that the richest most powerful people in the world will sell their souls to get a bit richer.
- Charmizard 1y agoIdk how I feel about this take, tbh. Do things the old way because I like them that way seems like poor reasoning. If folks figure out a way to produce content that is human, contextual and useful... by all means.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jdnordy 1y agoAnyone else suspicious this might be satire ironically written by an LLM?
- iMax00 1y agoI read anything as long as there is new and useful information
- keepamovin 1y agoSo don't read it.
- Frotag 1y agoThe way I view it is that the author is trying to explain their mental model, but there's only so much you can fit into prose. It's my responsibility to fill in the missing assumptions / understand why X implies Y. And all the little things like consistent word choice, tone, and even the mistakes helps with this. But mix in LLMs and now there's another layer / slightly different mental model I have to isolate, digest, and merge with the author's.
- throwaway-0001 1y agoFor me it’s insulting not to use an AI to reply back. I’d say 90% of people would answer better with an AI assist in most business environments. Maybe even personal. It’s really funny how many business deals would be better if people would put the requests in an AI to explain what exactly is requested. Most people are not able to answer and if they’d use an AI they could respond in a proper way without wasting everyone’s time. But at least not using an AI shows the competency (or better - incompetence) level. It’s also sad that I need to tell people to put my message in an AI to don’t ask me useless questions. And AI can fill most of the gaps people don’t get it. You might say my requests are not proper, but then how an AI can figure out what I want to say? I also put my requests in an AI when I can and can create eli5 explanations of the requests “for dummies”
- snorbleck 1y agothis is great.
- neilv 1y agoI suspect that the majority of people who are shoveling BS in their blogs aren't doing it because they actually want to think and write and share and learn and be human; but rather, the sole purpose of the blog is for SEO, or to promote the personal brand of someone who doesn't want anything else. Perhaps the author is speaking to the people who are only temporarily led astray by the pervasive BS online and by the recent wildly popular "cheating on your homework" culture?
- magicalhippo 1y agoWell Firefox just got an AI summarizing feature, so thankfully I don't have to...
- bhouston 1y agoI am not totally sure about this. I think that AI writing is just a progression of current trends. Many things have made writing easier and lower cost - printing press, typewriters, word processors, grammer/spell checkers, electronic distribution. This is just a continuation. It does tend to mean there is less effort to produce the output and thus there is a value degradation, but this has been true all along this technology trend. I don't think we should be a purist as to how writing is produced.
- philipwhiuk 1y agoThere's a bar somewhere to what serves meaningful benefit, surely?
- causal 1y agoLinkedIn marketing was bad before AI, now half the content is just generated emoji-ridden listicles
- hiergiltdiestfu 1y agoThank you! Heartfelt thank you!
- nickdothutton 1y agoIf you are going to use AI to make a post, then please instruct it to make that post as short and information-dense as possible. It's one thing to read an AI summary but quite another to have to wade through paragraphs of faux "personality" and "conversational writing" of the sort that slop AIs regularly trowel out.
- frstrtd_engnr 1y agoThese days, my work routine looks something like this - a colleague sends me a long, AI-generated PRD full of changes. When I ask him for clarification, he stumbles through the explanation. Does he care at all? I have no idea. Frustrated, I just throw that mess straight at claude-code and tell it to fix whatever nonsense it finds and do its best. It probably implements 80–90% of what the doc says — and invents the rest. Not that I’d know, since I never actually read the original AI-generated PRD myself. In the end, no one’s happy. The whole creative and development process has lost that feeling of achievement, and nobody seems to care about code quality anymore.
- wouldbecouldbe 1y agoI've always been bad at grammar, and wrote a lot of newsletters & blogs for my first startups which always got great feedback, but also lots of grammar complaints. Really happy GPT is so great at catching those nowadays, saves me a lot of Grammar supports requests ;)
- whshdjsk 1y agoOr just get better? I don’t know how someone can be nerdy enough to be on Hackernews, but simultaneously not nerdy enough to pickup and intuit the rules of English language from sheer osmosis.
- wouldbecouldbe 1y agoIm not a native english speaker, but even in my own language I make many mistakes. I'm happy I can spend my time coding instead of going back to school :)
- holdenc137 1y agoI assume this is a double-bluff and the blog post WAS written by an AI o_O ?
- braza 1y ago> No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations, or for whatever else you think you are incapable of doing. Make the mistake. Feel embarrassed. Learn from it. Why? Because that's what makes us human! For essays, honestly, I do not feel so bad, because I can see that other than some spaces like HN the quality of the average online writer has dropped so much that I prefer to have some machine-assisted text that can deliver the content. However, my problem is with AI-generated code. In most of the cases to create trivial apps, I think AI-generated code will be OK to good; however, the issue that I'm seeing as a code reviewer is that folks that you know their code design style are so heavily reliant on AI-generated code that you are sure that they did not write and do not understand the code. One example: Working with some data scientists and researchers, most of them used to write things on Pandas, some trivial for loops, and some primitive imperative programming. Now, especially after Claude Code, most of the things are vectorized, with some sort of variable naming with way-compressed naming. Sometimes folks use Cython in some data pipeline tasks or even using functional programming to an extreme. Good performance is great, and leveling up the quality of the codebase it's a net positive; however, I wonder in some scenario when things go south and/or Claude code is not available if those folks will be able to fix it.
- rphv 1y agoYou don't need to understand code for it to be useful, any more than you need to know assembly to write Python.
- bluSCALE4 1y agoThis is how I feel about some LinkedIn folks that are going all in w/ AI.
- parliament32 1y agoI'm looking forward to the (inevitable) AI detection browser plugin that will mark the slop for me, at least that way I don't need to spend the effort figuring out if it's AI content or not.
- namirez 1y agoNo, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations, or for whatever else you think you are incapable of doing. Make the mistake. Feel embarrassed. Learn from it. Why? Because that's what makes us human! I do understand the reasoning behind being original, but why make mistakes when we have tools to avoid them? That sounds like a strange recommendation.
- arresin 1y agoThese days a spelling mistake actually increases the chance I’ll keep reading. I know you didn’t just shit this out with chatgpt then fart loudly and call it a day.
- luisml77 1y agoWho cares about your feelings, it's a blog post. If the goal is to get the job done, then use AI. Do you really want to waste precious time for so little return?
- nhod 1y ago"I'm choosing to be 'insulted' by the existence of an arbitrary thing in the universe and then upset by the insult I chose to ascribe to it."
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 1y agoI like the author's idea that people should publish the prompts they use to generate LLM output, not the output itself.
- vzaliva 1y agoIt is similarly unsulting to read an ungrammatical blog post full of misspelings. So I do not subscribe to the part of your argument "No, don't use it to fix your grammar". Using AI to fix your grammar, if done right, is the part of the learning process.
- dinkleberg 1y agoA critical piece of this is to ensure it is just fixing the grammar and not rewriting it in its own AI voice is key. This is why I think tools like grammarly or similar still have a useful edge over just directly using an LLM as the UX let's you pick and choose which suggestions to adopt. And they also provide context on why they are making a given suggestion. It still often kills your "personal voice", so you need to be judicious with its use.
- arresin 1y agoMuch less insulting than AI slop. I can imagine it’s hard to see the nuance if you’re ESL but it’s there.
- jexe 1y agoReading an AI blog post (or reddit post, etc) just signals that the author actually just doesn't care that much about the subject.. which makes me care less too.
- mucio 1y agoit's insulting to read text on a computer screen. I don't care if you write like a 5 years old or if your message will need days or weeks to reach me. Use a pen, a pencil and some paper.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- saint_fiasco 1y agoI sometimes share interesting AI conversations with my friends using the "share" button on the AI websites. Often the back-and-forth is more interesting than the final output anyway. I think some people turn AI conversations into blog posts that they pass off as their own because of SEO considerations. If Twitter didn't discourage people sharing links, perhaps we would see a lot more tweet threads that start with https://chatgpt.com/share/ https://chatgpt.com/share/... and https://claude.ai/share/ https://claude.ai/share/... instead of people trying to pass off AI generated content as their own.
- Kim_Bruning 1y agoI think the problem is lazy AI generated content. The problem is that the current generation of tools "looks like something" even with minimal effort. This makes people lazy. Actually put in the effort and see what you get, with or without AI assist.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- saltysalt 1y agoI'm pretty certain that the only thing reading my blog these days is AI.
- mirzap 1y agoThis post could easily be generated by AI, no way to tell for sure. I'm more insulted if the title or blog thumbnail is misleading, or if the post is full of obvious nonsense, etc. If a post contains valuable information that I learn from it, I don't really care if AI wrote it or not. AI is just a tool, like any other tool humans invented. I'm pretty sure people had the same reaction 50 years ago, when the first PCs started appearing: "It's insulting to see your calculations made by personal electronic devices."
- latchkey 1y agoAs a test, I used AI to rewrite their blog post, keeping the same tone and context but fewer words. It got the point across, and I enjoyed it more because I didn't have to read as much. I did edit it slightly to make it a bit less obviously AI'ish... --- Honestly, it feels rude to hand me something churned out by a lexical bingo machine when you could’ve written it yourself. I'm a person with thoughts, humor, contradictions, and experience not a content bin. Don't you like the pride of making something that's yours? You should. Don't use AI to patch grammar or dodge effort. Make the mistake. Feel awkward. Learn. That's being human. People are kinder than you think. By letting a bot speak for you, you cut off the chance for connection. Here's the secret: most people want to help you. You just don't ask. You think smart people never need help. Wrong. The smartest ones know when to ask and when to give. So, human to human, save the AI for the boring stuff. Lead with your own thoughts. The best ideas are the ones you've actually felt.
- cyrialize 1y agoI'm reading a blog because I'm interested in the voice a writer has. If I'm finding that voice boring, I'll stop reading - whether or not AI was used. The generic AI voice, and by that I mean very little prompting to add any "flavor", is boring. Of course I've used AI to summarize things and give me information, like when I'm looking for a specific answer. In the case of blogs though, I'm not always trying to find an "answer", I'm just interested in what you have to say and I'm reading for pleasure.
- jquaint 1y ago> Do you not enjoy the pride that comes with attaching your name to something you made on your own? It's great! This is like saying a photographer shouldn't find the sunset they photographed pretty or be proud of the work, because they didn't personally labor to paint the image of it. A lot more goes into a blog post than the actual act of typing the context out. Lazy work is always lazy work, but its possible to make work you are proud of with AI, in the same way you can create work you are proud of with a camera
- throwawayffffas 1y agoI already found it insulting to read seo spam blog posts. The ai involved is beside the point.
- adverbly 1y agoAs someone who briefly wrote a bunch of AI generated blog posts, I kind of agree... The voicing is terrible, and the only thing it it does particularly well is replace the existing slop. I'm starting to pivot and realize that quality is actually way more important than I thought, especially in a world where it is very easy to create things of low quality using AI. Another place I've noticed it is in hiring. There are so many low quality applications its insane. One application with a full GitHub and profile and cover letter and or video which actually demonstrates that you understand where you are applying is worth more than 100 low quality ones. It's gone from a charming gimmick to quickly becoming an ick.
- jschveibinz 1y agoI'm not sure if this has been mentioned here yet, and I don't want to be pedantic, but for centuries famous artists, musicians, writers, etc. have used assistants to do their work for them. The list includes (but in no way is this complete): DaVinci, Michelangelo, Rembrandt, Rubens, Raphael, Warhol, Koons, O'Keefe, Hepworth, Hockney, Stephen King, Clancy, Dumas, Patterson, Elvis, Elton John, etc. etc. Further, most scientific, engineering and artistic innovations are made "on the shoulders of giants." As the saying goes: there is nothing new under the sun. Nothing. I suggest that the use of an LLM for writing is just another tool of human creativity to be used freely and often to produce even more interesting and valuable content.
- pertymcpert 1y agoNo that’s complete rubbish, it’s a bad analogy.
- pessimizer 1y agoCounterpoint: It's a fine thought, and an excellent analogy.
- pertymcpert 1y agoBelieve it or not, your two's wrongs don't make a right.
- npteljes 1y agoI agree with the author. If I detect that the article is written by an AI, I bounce off. I similarly dislike other trickery as well, like ghostwriters, PR articles in journalism, lip-syncing at concerts, and so on. Fuck off, be genuine. The thing why people are upset about AI is because AI can be used to easily generate a lot of text, but its usage is rarely disclosed. So then when someone discovers AI usage, there is no telling for the reader of how much of the article is signal, and how much is noise. Without AI, it would hinge on the expertise or experience of the author, but now with AI involved, the bets are off. The other thing is that reading someone's text involves a little bit of forming a connection with them. But then discovering that AI (or someone else) have written the text, it feels like they betrayed that connection.
- masly 1y agoIn a related problem: I recently interviewed a person for a role as senior platform architect. The person was already working for a semi reputable company. In the first interview, the conversation was okay but my gut just told me something was strange about this person. We have the candidate a case to solve with a few diagrams, and to prepare a couple slides to discuss the architecture. The person came back with 12 diagrams, all AI generated, littered with obvious AI “spelling”/generation mistakes. And when we questioned the person about why they think we would gain trust and confidence in them with this obvious AI generated content, they became even aggressive. Needless to say it didn’t end well. The core problem is really how much time is now being wasted in recruiting with people who “cheat” or outright cheat. We have had to design questions to counter AI cheating, and strategies to avoid wasting time.
- wenbin 1y agoIt's similarly insulting to listen to your AI-generated fake podcasts[0]. Ten minutes spent on them is ten minutes wasted. [0] AI-generated fake podcasts (mostly via NotebookLM) https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/listennotes/ai-generated-fake-podcasts-spams https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/listennotes/ai-generated-fak...
- jackdoe 1y agoI think it is too late. There is non zero profit of people visiting your content, and there is close to zero cost to make it. It is the same problem with music, in fact I search youtube music only with before:2022. I recently wrote about the dead internet https://punkx.org/jackdoe/zero.txt https://punkx.org/jackdoe/zero.txt out of frustration. I used to fight against it, I thought we should do "proof of humanity", or create rings of trust for humans, but now I think the ship has sailed. Today a colleague was sharing their screen on google docs and a big "USE GEMINI AI TO WRITE THE DOCUMENT" button was front and center. I am fairly certain that by end of year most words you read will be tokens. I am working towards moving my pi-hole from blacklist to whitelist, and after that just using local indexes with some datahorading. (squid, wikipedia, SO, rfcs, libc, kernel.git etc) Maybe in the future we just exchange local copies of our local "internet" via sdcards, like in Cuba's Sneakernet[1] El Paquete Semenal[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakernet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakernet [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Paquete_Semanal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Paquete_Semanal
- gosub100 1y ago> thought we should do "proof of humanity" I thought about this in another context and then I realized: what system is going to declare you're human or not? AI of course
- tasuki 1y agoUhh, that's a lot of links: https://download.kiwix.org/zim/wikipedia/ https://download.kiwix.org/zim/wikipedia/ Where are the explanations what all of them mean? What is (nothing) vs `maxi` vs `mini` vs `nopic`? What is `100` vs `all` vs `top1m` vs `top` vs `wp1-0.8`?
- hamdingers 1y agohttps://download.kiwix.org/zim/README https://download.kiwix.org/zim/README Mini is the introduction and infobox of all articles, nopic is the full articles with no pictures, maxi is full articles with (small) images. Other tags are categories (football, geography, etc.) 100 is the top 100 articles, top1m is top 1 million, 0.8 is (inexplicably) the top 45k articles. My recommendation: sort by size and download the largest one you can accommodate in the language you prefer. wikipedia_en_all_maxi_2025-08.zim is all wikipedia articles, with images, as of 2025-08 and it's a paltry 111G. Kiwix publishes a library here, but it's equally unhelpful: https://library.kiwix.org/ https://library.kiwix.org/
- somat 1y agoIt is the duality of generated content. It feels great to use. But it also feels incredibly shitty to have it used on you. My recommendation. Just give the prompt. If if your readers want to expand it they can do so. don't pollute others experience by passing the expanded form around. Nobody enjoys that.
- marstall 1y agoalso: mind-numbing.
- rootedbox 1y agoI fixed it. It appears inconsiderate—perhaps even dismissive—to present me, a human being with unique thoughts, humor, contradictions, and experiences, with content that reads as though it were assembled by a lexical randomizer. When you rely on automation instead of your own creativity, you deny both of us the richness of genuine human expression. Isn’t there pride in creating something that is authentically yours? In writing, even imperfectly, and knowing the result carries your voice? That pride is irreplaceable. Please, do not use artificial systems merely to correct your grammar, translate your ideas, or “improve” what you believe you cannot. Make errors. Feel discomfort. Learn from those experiences. That is, in essence, the human condition. Human beings are inherently empathetic. We want to help one another. But when you interpose a sterile, mechanized intermediary between yourself and your readers, you block that natural empathy. Here’s something to remember: most people genuinely want you to succeed. Fear often stops you from seeking help, convincing you that competence means solitude. It doesn’t. Intelligent people know when to ask, when to listen, and when to contribute. They build meaningful, reciprocal relationships. So, from one human to another—from one consciousness of love, fear, humor, and curiosity to another—I ask: if you must use AI, keep it to the quantitative, to the mundane. Let your thoughts meet the world unfiltered. Let them be challenged, shaped, and strengthened by experience. After all, the truest ideas are not the ones perfectly written. They’re the ones that have been felt.
- tasuki 1y agoHeh, nice. I suppose that was AI-generated? Your beginning: > It appears inconsiderate—perhaps even dismissive—to present me, a human being with unique thoughts, humor, contradictions, and experiences, with content that reads as though it were assembled by a lexical randomizer. I like that beginning than the original: > It seems so rude and careless to make me, a person with thoughts, ideas, humor, contradictions and life experience to read something spit out by the equivalent of a lexical bingo machine because you were too lazy to write it yourself. No one's making anyone read anything (I hope). And yes, it might be inconsiderate or perhaps even dismissive to present a human with something written by AI. The AI was able to phrase this much better than the human! Thank you for presenting me with that, I guess?
- wltr 1y agoIt’s a cherry on top to see these silly AI-generated posts to be seriously discussed in here.
- dcow 1y agoIt’s not that people don’t value creativity and expression. It’s that for 90% of the communication AI is being used for, the slightly worse AI gen version that took 30 min to produce isn’t worse enough to justify spending 4 hours on the hand rolled version. That’s the reality we’re living through right now. People are eating up the productivity boosts like candy.
- ath3nd 1y ago[dead]
- nazgu1 1y agoI agree, but if I would have to type one most insulting things with AI is scraping data without consent to train models, so people no longer enjoy blog posting :(
- deadbabe 1y agoIf you’re going to AI generate your blog, the least you could do is use a fine tuned LLM that matches your style. Most people just toss a prompt into GPT 5 and call it a day.
- RIMR 1y ago>No, don't use it to fix your grammar, or for translations Okay, I can understand even drawing the line at grammar correction, in that not all "correct" grammar is desirable or personal enough to convey certain ideas. But not for translation? AI translation, in my experience, has proven to be more reliable than other forms of machine translation, and personally learning a new language every time I need to read something non-native to me isn't reasonable.
- KindDragon 1y ago> Everyone wants to help each other. And people are far kinder than you may think. I want to believe that. When I was a student, I built a simple HTML page with a feedback form that emailed me submissions. I received exactly one message. It arrived encoded; I eagerly decoded it and found a profanity-filled rant about how terrible my site was. That taught me that kindness online isn’t the default - it’s a choice. I still aim for it, but I don’t assume it.
- netule 1y agoI’ve found that the kinds of people who leave comments or send emails tend to fall into two categories: 1. They’re assholes. 2. They care enough to speak up, but only when the thing stops working as expected. I think the vast majority of users/readers are good people who just don’t feel like engaging. The minority are vocal assholes.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoI mean, if you used an AI to generated it, you shouldn't mind if my AI reads it, rather than me.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- akshatjiwan 1y agoI don't know. Content matters more to me. Many of the articles that I read have so little information density that I find it hard to justify spending time on them.I often use AI to summarise text for me and then lookup particular topics in detail if I like. Skimming was pretty common before AI too. People used to read and share notes instead of entire texts. AI has just made it easier. Reading long texts is not a problem for me if its engaging. But often I find they just go on and on without getting to the point. Especially news articles.They are the worst.
- voidhorse 1y agoIf you struggle with communication, using AI is fine. What matters is caring about the result. You cannot just throw it over the fence. AI content in itself isn't insulting, but as TFA hits upon, pushing sloppy work you didn't bother to read or check at all yourself is incredibly insulting and just communicates to others that you don't think their time is valuable. This holds for non-AI generated work as well, but the bar is higher by default since you at least had to generate that content yourself and thus at least engage with it on a basic level. AI content is also needlessly verbose, employs trite and stupid analogies constantly, and in general has the nauseating, bland, soulless corporate professional communication style that anyone with even a mote of decent literary taste detests.
- madcaptenor 1y agoai;dr
- inflames123 1y ago[dead]
- johanam 1y agoAI generated text like a plume of pollution spreading through the web. Little we can do to keep it at bay. Perhaps transparency is the answer?
- tasuki 1y ago> It seems so rude and careless to make me, a person with thoughts, ideas, humor, contradictions and life experience to read something spit out by the equivalent of a lexical bingo machine because you were too lazy to write it yourself. Agreed fully. In fact it'd be quite rude to force you to even read something written by another human being! I'm all for your right to decide what is and isn't worth reading, be it ai or human generated.
- hereme888 1y agoYou are absolutely right! Jokes aside, good article.
- throwawa14223 1y agoI should never spend more effort reading something than the author spent writing it. With AI-generated texts the author effort approaches zero.
- gr4vityWall 1y agoIs it just me, or is OP posting a bunch of links on HN for karma farming? Some of seem to be AI-generated, like this one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45724022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45724022
- OptionOfT 1y agoWhat am I even reading if it is AI generated? The reason AI is so hyped up at the moment is that you give it little, it gives you back more. But then whose blog-post am I reading? What really is the point?
- corporat 1y agoThe most thoughtful critique of this post isn’t that AI is inherently bad—but that its use shouldn’t be conflated with laziness or cowardice. Fact: Professional writers have used grammar tools, style guides, and even assistants for decades. AI simply automates some of these functions faster. Would we say Hemingway was lazy for using a typewriter? No—we’d say he leveraged tools. AI doesn’t create thoughts; it drafts ideas. The writer still curates, edits, and imbues meaning—just like a journalist editing a reporter’s notes or a designer refining Photoshop output. Tools don’t diminish creativity—they democratize access to it. That said: if you’re outsourcing your thinking to AI (e.g., asking an LLM to write your thesis without engaging), then yes, you’ve lost something. But complaining about AI itself misunderstands the problem. TL;DR: Typewriters spit out prose too—but no one blames writers for using them.
- rideontime 1y agoFor transparency, what role did AI serve in drafting this comment?
- corporat 1y agoAI was used to analyze logical fallacies in the original blog post. I didn’t use it to draft content—just to spot the straw man, false dilemma, and appeal-to-emotion tactics in real time. Ironically, this exact request would’ve fit the blog’s own arguments: "AI is lazy" / "AI undermines thought." But since I was using AI as a diagnostic tool (not a creative one), it doesn’t count. Self-referential irony? Maybe. But at least I’m being transparent. :)
- philipwhiuk 1y ago[flagged]
- rideontime 1y agoI'd merely noticed that your comment mimicked the writing style of popular LLMs. Guessing you spend a lot of time with them?
- LeoPanthera 1y agoAnyone can make AI generated content. It requires no effort at all. Therefore, if I or anyone else wanted to see it, I would simply do it myself. I don't know why so many people can't grasp that.
- pasteldream 1y ago> people are far kinder than you may think Not everyone has this same experience of the world. People are harsh, and how much grace they give you has more to do with who you are than what you say. That aside, the worst problem with LLM-generated text isn’t that it’s less human, it’s that (by default) it’s full of filler, including excessive repetition and contrived analogies.
- _smfg 1y ago> Not everyone has this same experience of the world. People are harsh, and how much grace they give you has more to do with who you are than what you say. You okay friend?
- pasteldream 1y agoYes.
- foxfired 1y agoEarlier this year, I used AI to help me improve some of my writing on my blog. It just has a better way of phrasing ideas than me. But when I came back to read those same blog posts a couple months later, you know after I've encountered a lot more blog posts that I didn't know were AI generated at the time, I saw the pattern. It sounds like the exact same author, +- some degree of obligatory humor, writing all over the web with the same voice. I've found a better approach to using AI for writing. First, if I don't bother writing it, why should you bother reading it? LLMs can be great soundboards. Treat them as teachers, not assistants. Your teacher is not gonna write your essay for you, but he will teach you how to write, and spot the parts that need clarification. I will share my process in the coming days, hopefully it will get some traction.
- tdiff 1y ago> Here is a secret: most people want to help you succeed. Most people dont care.
- animanoir 1y ago[dead]
- Wowfunhappy 1y agoI agree with everything except this part: > No, don't use it to fix your grammar How is this substantially different from using spellcheck? I don't see any problem with asking an LLM to check for and fix grammatical errors.
- vesterthacker 1y agoWhen you criticize, it helps to understand the other’s perspective. I suppose I am writing to you because I can no longer speak to anyone. As people turn to technology for their every word, the space between them widens, and I am no exception. Everyone speaks, yet no one listens. The noise fills the room, and still it feels empty. Parents grow indifferent, and their children learn it before they can name it. A sickness spreads, quiet and unseen, softening every heart it touches. I once believed I was different. I told myself I still remembered love, that I still felt warmth somewhere inside. But perhaps I only remember the idea of it. Perhaps feeling itself has gone. I used to judge the new writers for chasing meaning in words. I thought they wrote out of vanity. Now I see they are only trying to feel something, anything at all. I watch them, and sometimes I envy them, though I pretend not to. They are lost, yes, but they still search. I no longer do. The world is cold, and I have grown used to it. I write to remember, but the words answer nothing. They fall silent, as if ashamed. Maybe you understand. Maybe it is the same with you. Maybe writing coldly is simply compassion, a way of not letting others feel your pain.
- invisibleink 1y agoYES and, also let's not use printing press, photography, word processors, spell checkers, internet and search engines because they lack human touch, make us lazy, prevent deep thinking blah blah...
- philipwhiuk 1y agoJust because all those other inventions didn't wreck humanity doesn't mean this one won't.
- invisibleink 1y agoThe point is, every new technology attracts its share of romantic skeptics, and every time they fail then they retreat to the same tired line: "Just because all those other inventions didn't wreck humanity doesn't mean this one won't" But that’s not an argument, it’s an evasion. Given past inventions didn’t destroy us despite similar concerns, then the burden is on you to show why this one is fundamentally different and uniquely catastrophic.
- arresin 1y agoLLM generated emails are probably the worst
- jeromie 1y agoI had to go take a two-hour walk to calm down after my boss sent me a project proposal that was just ChatGPT gobbledygook.
- akst 1y agoWith the exception of using AI to proof read, I agree. In terms of proof reading, I just mean proof reading, not rewriting anything. especially not using the output verbatim for suggested fixes. And the author should ensure they retain their writing style & be assertive with their discretion on what corrections they should make.
- gngoo 1y agoI’m very happy that I can post ai generated blog posts from my writing. And I’m now averaging 500 unique daily visitors and quite some repeat visits and subscribers with it too. If it wasn’t for AI, then I’d go back to where it was before AI… 10 visitors per month? I don’t like writing, so I collaborate with AI to write entire blog posts. I don’t have AI “refine it”, I usually tell AI to take what I’m rambling about for 1000 words and rewrite it in my own style, cadence, rhythm and vibe. So I can generate 3-5 blog posts per week. Which surprisingly rank well, get posted on LinkedIn, Twitter and Reddit by others. So the amount of people that enjoy reading AI-generated blog posts likely is starting to outpace those who don’t at this rate.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jibal 1y agoI see no evidence or logical argument here. You have feelings ... fine. Mine are different.
- dankobgd 1y agoNormal websites are not even findable now
- jdlyga 1y agoIf you use AI to write a blog post, I'll use AI to summarize it.
- dustypotato 1y agoBy all means , use AI. Just don't make it longer than it needs to be
- K0balt 1y agoIt wouldn’t be so bad if it wasn’t unbearable to read.
- sinuhe69 1y agoDeepL has the option “Correct only” and it can become quite handy for non-native speakers.
- yalogin 1y agoThis is unavoidable. Individual blogs may not use AI but companies that live on user engagement will absolutely use them and churn out all types of content
- fullshark 1y agoI avoid it by not reading open web blogs. Eventually open web message boards (like this one) will be fully contaminated as well and I'll move to discord or group chats I suppose.
- blackhaj7 1y agoI used to be really good at spotting it but my AI radar is getting less effective now. Often I don’t notice until late in an article which is very annoying. There are some videos on Instagram that I didn’t notice were AI until my wife told me! If I want AI content, I will go to an AI. The only good outcome is that I am spending way less time on social media because so much of it is now AI
- anupj 1y ago[dead]
- kirito1337 1y agoIt's insulting to read any AI generated content.