12 ms·
Journalists turn in access badges, exit Pentagon rather than agreeing new rules
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bigyabai 1y agoAre there any good-faith justifications for an American military censor?
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoThey want to use the journalists to spread their propaganda rather than have them uncover inconvenient facts.
- charcircuit 1y agoThis is no different than pretty much any company. Do you think Apple lets reporters wander throughout their campus looking for new hardware, and allow them to ask engineers information about what they are working on? No. Apple does not let them wander around, and they advise all of their employees to never talk to press.
- lelandfe 1y agoHey you’re on a roll, don’t stop there. How does Apple respond to FOIA requests? They’re not subject to FOIA you say? Perhaps there’s a difference to the organizations after all.
- exe34 1y agoApple is a private company that answers to shareholders. The DoD is a government department that used to answer to the people.
- charcircuit 1y agoAnswering to the people doesn't mean that every secret must be made immediately public.
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoThis is about not wanting the journalists to even ask for information from e.g. generals. No-one is saying that they want immediate disclosure of all secrets - I'm concerned that you're building a strawman.
- charcircuit 1y ago[flagged]
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoI completely disagree. Their job is to uncover truths that may not be immediately obvious and they may not even know the classification status of sensitive information before asking about it. The military should instead say something like "that information is classified". Why would the public want journalists to not even be able to ask the questions, never mind actually get the information?
- exe34 1y ago> Why would the public want journalists to not even be able to ask the questions, never mind actually get the information? because "the public" in this case are cult members that agree with whatever the eternal leader wants.
- wtfwhateven 1y ago>Journalists asking for classified and sensitive information are acting in bad faifth. How? >They know that these people are not allowed to give away the information, Not true, nor is everything is classified. It appears you've not actually read the article, or what the new restrictions even asked for. You're acting as if journalists were allowed to go rummaging in office drawers and journalists dislike being told they can't do that anymore.
- bigyabai 1y agoFor Apple that makes sense as there are financial damages. Can/should the US be able to sue for defamation if the claims aren't libel?
- f33d5173 1y agoApple doesn't demand ideological conformity from news oganizations before letting their reporters in, no.
- troupo 1y agoWell, it kinda does. Reporters Apple doesn't like get cut off from early access, interviews etc. However, Apple is a private company and can do whatever it pleases, however shitty that behavior is.
- esseph 1y agoApple doesn't own a monopoly on violence. Your argument doesn't carry any weight.
- lm28469 1y agoGovernments are companies now? The capitalism brain rot is in its final stages
- wtfwhateven 1y agoWhat possible relevance does what companies do have? I can't believe you're arguing this in good faith.
- j4coh 1y agoIf Apple had the ability to deploy military forces on behalf of my democratically elected government I'd actually be pretty concerned with them locking out the press too.
- RobotToaster 1y agoWe've already seen Musk boasting about the CIA organising a coup for him, so it wouldn't surprise me https://www.counterpunch.org/2020/07/29/we-will-coup-whoever-we-want-elon-musk-and-the-overthrow-of-democracy-in-bolivia/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2020/07/29/we-will-coup-whoever...
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> We've already seen Musk boasting about the CIA organising a coup for him I had a friend go deep into addiction. I think there was a period when every headline was his doing, too.
- virtue3 1y agoApple doesn't require you to pay a significant portion of you paycheck to them either.
- uncletammy 1y agoUnless you're a developer
- blitzar 1y agoYou are right, Apple should have its own nukes and bombers.
- croes 1y agoApple is neither a state nor a democracy. The journalists and the government are there to aserve the same boss: the people. Now one of the people's employees sabotages the work the other employee.
- ok_dad 1y agoThey’ve started bombing fishermen, you tell me why they want one. It’s not in good faith.
- newfriend 1y ago[flagged]
- cycrutchfield 1y agoFunny jokes about extrajudicial killings, ha ha
- croes 1y agoSource: trust me bro.
- nutjob2 1y ago> They’ve started bombing fishermen The word you're looking for is 'murdering'.
- guerrilla 1y agoDon't be silly. That's obviously what they meant. Not everyone is your enemy, relax.
- _factor 1y agoWith the blatant disregard for any rules and decorum, and a proven self-serving track record, I wouldn’t bet on it. You want to censor in the armed forces? Classify. You don’t tell reporters they can’t publish anything unapproved. Tomorrow the director gets caught stealing and toppling regimes and you can’t publish a word. After a long time of obeying this, you will fear doing so. Brilliant strategic play on the Trump admin. Win or lose, the pentagon is more opaque. I just wish they would used some of that brilliance on things that improved the world and adhered to why we have governments in the first place.
- DeepSeaTortoise 1y agoThe rules were updated on Oct6 to allow media outlets to report using any information even if classified and unapproved for release, as long as they didn't solicit it or were given it with the premise that it won't be released. So if they were to be approached by a whistleblower or happened to hear the right conversation or find the right documents, it'd be fair game.
- somenameforme 1y agoI think people are being slightly hyperbolic. It's basically stating that if a news outlet publishes unauthorized information then they won't be allowed access to the Pentagon. In general I think this is a good thing but not because I think it's a good idea. Rather, I think that the government, regardless of who happens to be in power, and the press should have an adversarial relationship, but the deep intertwining of the government and the press undermines this, even without corruption. You're generally going to be reluctant to frame entities that you have a positive relationship with in a negative way. And this agreement is essentially formalizing adversarialness. I just have this feeling that in modern times if the Pentagon Papers were leaked to the NYTimes - but in the context of Ukraine, and especially if the previous administration was still in power, they very possibly might have instead alerted US intelligence instead of publishing them. WaPo repeatedly pat themselves on the back for playing a key role in tracking down the person who leaked the Pentagon documents in 2023. They mostly ignored what was leaked and instead framed everything as a story of tracking down the source and why he might do such a thing. We have a very broken media system, and this, probably unintentionally, might be a big first step in fixing it.
- croes 1y ago>if they sought to report on information — classified or otherwise — that had not been approved by Hegseth for release. Any information that isn't approved by Hegseth is unauthorized. In other words, only what Hegseth allows could be written. To call the bad would be an understatement.
- DeepSeaTortoise 1y agoThere is an updated draft of the rules from october 6th that rectifies this and some other prior issues. I'm honestly not sure which rules the media outlets actually want changed.
- ben_w 1y agoI get the same feeling, but I don't think I can justify the feeling. IMO at best this is frogs* jumping out of water that was boiled too fast. * an idiom based on a stupid truth, as the real frogs were sans-brain at the time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
- blitzar 1y agoWhat is the point of being a Journalist (except for easy money and not having to do anything other than copy + paste) if you are only allowed to "write", word for word, the article they give you to publish?
- parineum 1y agoThey're still allowed to write whatever they want, they just won't be invited to Christmas parties anymore.
- croes 1y agoYou mean they are cut of from an important source of information so the adminstration can always claim hearsay
- vintermann 1y agoIf you identify sufficiently with the people giving you the article to publish, it's not a "they" but an "us". Even if the decisions are taken in rooms you don't have access to. Maybe they think they'll get access to them eventually if they're loyal. It might seem cowardly, but it isn't that different to what happens every day in business. Society is full of organisations working on the "make the boss' opinions your own" principle.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> If you identify sufficiently with the people giving you the article to publish Then you aren’t a journalist.
- vintermann 1y agoNot a good journalist maybe, but if you identify too little with them, you probably don't even get to "sit where you're sitting", as Chomsky said.
- 1y ago
- intended 1y agoThere can always be good-faith justifications. There’s always a good reason, or good intentioned idea. It’s why the saying about paver stones on the road to hell is all about. There were certain norms that America counted on, to hold its governance mechanisms in check. Those checks and balances are being broken. It is possible, that nothing will happen. People have fallen out of planes and survived. Maybe this will be America’s experience. The country I knew, that many others used to be angry with, but also respect - would NEVER have left such a thing to simple chance. There used to be many who stepped into the breach. And perhaps people are. It may simply be that this new information environment - geographically, financially consolidated, but ideologically divided - is ensuring that people who are solving problems and figuring things out, are unable to coordinate or gain traction. Gain traction in a manner that used to cross party lines.
- solatic 1y agoThis is a hyperbolic take. In countries with military censors, articles are submitted, from the newspaper's offices, to the censor's office for approval before publication. Nothing under this arrangement stops an American colonel from walking into the NYT's offices, dropping a folder at reception, and persuading the NYT to publish the contents of that folder. While it does prevent investigative journalism in the military, which is despicable on its own merits, the fact that it turns newspapers solely into PR outlets is neither new (i.e. as a general phenomenon in American media) nor limited to only the officially sanctioned point of view.
- jrflowers 1y agoI like your reasoning. There’s nothing stopping a news outlet from publishing anything other than the clearly outlined consequences. In a similar vein there’s nothing stopping anybody from finding out what happens if you swallow a D battery but for some reason none of my friends are doing that
- solatic 1y ago> In a similar vein there’s nothing stopping anybody from finding out what happens if you swallow a D battery but for some reason none of my friends are doing that Nice caveat, noting that none of your friends are doing that. But plenty of people do really dangerous, stupid shit and upload it to YouTube for the advertising dollars. Because news media is usually ultimately financed by advertising or partisan donors pushing a specific viewpoint, they're incentivized to publish dangerous stuff - but only the kind people want to see, which is why outlets like the New York Times didn't host video clips showing the outright gore from Charlie Kirk getting shot. The democratic value of an independent media rests on editorial discretion finding content that shocks its audience but not its advertisers.
- omgmajk 1y agoThese quotes are crazy to me, what kind of world are they living in? > “I think he finds the press to be very disruptive in terms of world peace,” Trump said. “The press is very dishonest.”
- 28304283409234 1y agoThis is what Trump has been saying for years. What exactly surprises you in this?
- skrebbel 1y agoDoesn’t make it any less crazy
- noir_lord 1y ago> “The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command” 1984
- kergonath 1y ago> what kind of world are they living in? It’s projection, as usual.
- CobrastanJorji 1y agoIt's always fun to compare Trump quotes against other presidential quotes. Jefferson: “The basis of our governments being the opinion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter." Reagan: "There is no more essential ingredient than a free, strong, and independent press to our continued success in what the Founding Fathers called our 'noble experiment' in self-government" FDR: "If in other lands the press and books and literature of all kinds are censored, we must redouble our efforts here to keep them free." Trump: "The press is the enemy of the people."
- deleted 1y ago
- 0dayz 1y agoI'm pleasantly surprised that journalists are doing this due to how tepid news companies generally are.
- ruszki 1y agoThey couldn’t do anything else. The power grab happens even when they would have succumbed. At least they quit with a spine. If they don’t go back in a week, which can be seen from several examples, like Hungary, that it doesn’t work. I think compared to the Hungarian government, this was a misstep of Trump (which I hope they make it more). In Hungary, when something like this happened, you always lost when you didn’t succumb to authoritarianism. You lost your previous privileges no matter what, but you lost more if you protested. They tried to keep up a facade that nothing changed, while everything changed. In this case it seems to me as an outside observer, that nothing value was lost by quitting compared to signing up. Or Trump and co don’t want to keep a facade at all. But then they need to bet on that most people in America are really fascists.
- buyucu 1y agoa rare instance of american journalists showing spine.
- chrneu 1y ago[dead]
- alkonaut 1y agoWhat's next? Asking hard questions, or follow up questions? If Trump says "I've ended 7 or 8 wars" or says "I've lowered drug prices 800, 900, 1000 percent" and no one says "Sir, how is it possible to lower a price by 900 percent" or "Could you specify which conflicts it is you refer to by those 7 or 8 wars?" then you aren't a journalist. If you go to an event where such things are said and there is no opportunity to ask these obvious follow up questions, then you stop going there, or you aren't a journalist. If someone asks these questions and that leaves them excluded from those events - then you also stop going there in solidarity, or you aren't a journalist.
- harvey9 1y agoTime was when the liberal press looked down on journalists who were embedded with the military. The article mentions one who has had a desk in the pentagon for almost two decades. I would question the independence of someone so well embedded and note nobody is resigning here, just moving to other offices.
- bongodongobob 1y ago[flagged]
- alfiedotwtf 1y agoI used to watch Donald Rumsfeld daily giving his briefing… the hardest questions asked to him by the beacons of democracy in the press corps was “how are you”.
- trenchpilgrim 1y ago> I remember how then-Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld was ecstatic after the fall of Baghdad in 2003, insisting that it showed the success of the U.S. invasion. Not long after, I ran into an officer at the Pentagon who told me, "No, Tom. It's not a success. Saddam Hussein's supporters are attacking our supply lines. Now, we have to send more troops back to guard them." That was because the United States, at Rumsfeld's insistence, never sent an adequate number of forces to Iraq to begin with — a fact another Army general warned me about, unsolicited — and I reported on, before the war even began. > Instead of toeing the official line, that reporting helped people understand what U.S. troops were really facing. Far from being a success, the fall of Baghdad marked the beginning of an insurgency that stretched on for years. https://www.npr.org/2025/10/14/g-s1-93297/pentagon-reporter-opinion-press-policy https://www.npr.org/2025/10/14/g-s1-93297/pentagon-reporter-...
- StackRanker3000 1y agoWhy would they resign? Their beef is with the government, not their employers
- 1y ago
- cyberax 1y agoAh, "We are currently clean on OPSEC"
- cycrutchfield 1y agoWe are currently clean on triple sec
- nakamoto_damacy 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- croes 1y agoYou are confusing journalism with media. That make your whole rant wrong from the beginning.
- nakamoto_damacy 1y ago[flagged]
- cycrutchfield 1y agoI am 12 and this is deep
- nakamoto_damacy 1y ago[flagged]
- cycrutchfield 1y agoPlease stop, your enlightened contrarian takes are blowing my little 12 year old mind.
- kennywinker 1y agoRational argument: the government has lied innumerable times. The reason we know about a handful of them is journalism. If you want your spin straight from the tap, you can read press releases on the DoD website. If you want critical analysis, verification, and other perspectives you’re gonna need a healthy fifth estate. Journalists have biases, but so do governments.
- 1y ago
- carbonbioxide 1y agoThis is move by the journalists is inspiring to be honest, ending press freedom is what they want.
- dogleash 1y agoThe pentagon and jornos embedded there were always playing the access journalism game all along. Nothing new is happening, this was just the secdef being so thick he asked them to put the punches they'll pull in writing. It should be seen as a union walk-out.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoSecwar, right?
- johncolanduoni 1y agoDon't encourage them...
- johncolanduoni 1y agoI don't doubt they're doing access journalism, but being part of the press pool wasn't really an element of that it the past. When's the last time a journalist got kicked out of the Pentagon? The access journalism is usually about what happens behind the scenes (e.g. embarrass someone in the Pentagon and you won't be getting off the record statements).
- hshdhdhehd 1y agoAnother brick in the wall
- hunterpayne 1y agoThat's not what the song is about. Its about mental illness. Pink was shutting out the world, one brick at a time.
- hshdhdhehd 1y agoNot at the time but they later said it could be applied to more
- defrost 1y agoIn (Part One), sure. In (Part Two) it was external actors laying bricks that isolated Waters' protaganist, and in (Part Three) cause passes the Rubicon as everyone and everything is lumped together as just more bricks in the wall.
- ben_w 1y agoWhat I want to know is: why would anyone else bother staying given these new rules? If you did agree to the terms you'd be limited to publishing the official story (and can't talk to anyone for off-the-record stuff), but you get that for free anyway even if you never show up, so why bother with the extra expense of actually going to the Pentagon?
- toyg 1y ago> can't talk to anyone for off-the-record stuff Obviously this rule would apply only to real journalists. Members of the party will get free roam. They will stay. Just another day in the life of a regime.
- burkaman 1y agoThey'll get exclusive interviews, they'll get to be visible on TV asking questions to important people, they'll get invited on trips where they can film in front of a cool background like a military base or something. I think it's worth it for anyone that cares about the aesthetics of journalism more than actually reporting anything of value.
- almostgotcaught 1y agoLol you're making it out like the individual reporters make these calls. If anyone stayed it's because their employer believes there's money to be made in staying. The end.
- Swenrekcah 1y agoThis sentiment is just simply not true. People care about more than money, even people who run companies.
- almostgotcaught 1y agoSo those news agencies made the decisions to stay in the press corps just as a nice treat for those reporters (nice trips etc)? Is that what you're saying?
- Havoc 1y agoFirst sign of a profession having a backbone in months. Although the silent treatment the generals dished out at recent meeting wasn’t bad either
- newsclues 1y ago[flagged]
- apples_oranges 1y agoBut that's a separate issue, different circumstances and, mostly, different people. Similar to how they (in part) reported during epidemic. But now they did something good and it's somehow nullified by the other things? Also: You are promoting that we keep a grudge. Are you planning to let go of it sometime?
- n4r9 1y agoAlso, in some cases the press did apologise, e.g. https://archive.ph/F3Ra1 https://archive.ph/F3Ra1 . Fox news were notoriously the worst propagandisers in this case; I searched but could not find any apology from them.
- justacrow 1y ago> Also: You are promoting that we keep a grudge. Are you planning to let go of it sometime? Sure! Once the people responsible for the wars have been punished. Any day now...
- newsclues 1y agoYour right it’s different, but the problem is that I want a fair and consistent standard. Shouldn’t telling the truth and apologize when you “accidentally” misinform the public be the standard? They collectively have proven themselves to be untrustworthy and now they can’t be trusted anymore but some people continue to pretend they are authoritative sources of truth despite the facts that they help lie America into a war that kill many and caused massive financial damage to the economy. I’m saying that people and corporations should be held accountable and responsible for their actions?
- qqxufo 1y agoCurious how long this will actually last before the outlets cave under access pressure again. Has anything like this worked before?
- crocowhile 1y agoIt has worked in the UK. The then government had decided to unilaterally exclude some "hostile" media from the room and all the others walked out in protest. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/feb/03/political-journalists-boycott-no-10-briefing-after-reporter-ban https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/feb/03/political-j...
- rob74 1y agoNot sure if it this was ever tried before by any US government entity - but, if the condition for remaining an accredited Pentagon reporter is only reporting the official statements of the Pentagon (which you can also copy from their press releases), then having the accreditation seems largely pointless to me?
- postexitus 1y agoNaive way of thinking. If authorities hold on to power long enough, nearly everybody will cave under - some minority will go indie route. I've seen this happening in Turkey first hand over 20 years, first some select reporters got banned, than some news organizations got bought out by friends of the president, then a handful of more liberal news orgs lost money, they got bought by some other friends, who actually kept their "opposition" mask, but actually made them a false-flag opposition and fired all the real reporters, some of which went to jail for made up reasons, others went on to be indies on youtube. Just check how quickly the elite has switched sides. You would have expected some more backbone.
- chinathrow 1y agoNot a US citizen but affected by the current trajectory of the policies by the current administration. I wonder at what point in time people will have enough with what they are changing. How does the HN crew based in the US think about the current administration?
- actionfromafar 1y ago”Let’s not talk politics, it’s just inflammatory. Hey, cool LLM model. Shiny!”
- jacquesm 1y agoThat would be very funny if it weren't disturbingly close to the truth.
- esperent 1y agoAnd when people do talk about politics it's exactly the kind of hot takes you'd expect from people who think they're very smart (and probably are when it comes to choosing a database) but are completely uninformed about the current topic and only capable of parroting referred opinions, or making statements they expect the group to agree with. Nobody comes out of the conversation smarter than they went in. Honestly, I think it's better that we do keep conversation here to shiny technology. If you want to talk politics, go and find a group of people who know what they're talking about. That way you might learn something.
- aa-jv 1y agoThe American people need to start prosecuting their war criminals, plain and simple - and this has to begin with a willingness to comply with the mandates of the International Criminal Court. The notion that American exceptionalism inoculates America's war criminals from facing justice at the hand of International bodies set up specifically for that purpose, is incorrect and anti-human. It is time for justice. You can't maintain this culture of warrior narcissism, Americans. It will end in tragedy - as it has already brought chaos and calamity to millions of innocent people across the globe, this century. The USA and its allies are, by a huge margin, the #1 cause of terror and war on the planet at this time. Nobody even comes close to the level of criminal war-mongering that occurs at the behest of the US' political establishment. No, not Russia. Not China. The USA and Five/Nine Eyes states are #1 at illegal war and murder of innocent human beings, bar none. Come to grips with the crimes of your state. It is the #1 most important thing for Americans to do, for the rest of the world. The American people are the only force on the planet which can reign in their monsters. It has to be done by the people, for the people.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> this has to begin with a willingness to comply with the mandates of the International Criminal Court Totally disagree. The ICJ makes sense within the scope of geopolitics. The ICC is, best case, a mechanism by which a country can cleanse itself of a bad former leader. More realistically, it is a relic of the unipolar world of the 1990s. America needs to deal with itself through its own laws. (Same as Russia, China and India will.) > USA and Five/Nine Eyes states are #1 at illegal war and murder of innocent human beings, bar none Ah, got it.
- aa-jv 1y agoYour position amounts to "but ma' America Special". If the ICC is good enough for Laurent Gbagbo, its good enough for Obama, Bush, Biden, Trump and Clinton. The ICC delivers one thing Americans refuse to deliver: justice for victims of war crimes. That this is not obvious, or prioritised, clearly belies the situation vis a vis American Exceptionalism.
- alkonaut 1y agoThis kind of boycott needs to happen for the WH press corps. If there is a fear of not being selected to ask questions, or being expelled from the room for asking tough questions, then everyone needs to walk. Immediately.
- rob74 1y agoWell, the White House press corps has already been changed to (how do I write this in a way that won't get me downvoted?) include more reporters friendly to the current administration since the White House asserted the right to determine itself who gets access (formerly it was the White House Correspondents' Association), so the chances of such a more-or-less unified boycott are slim. And I don't have any doubts that the Pentagon will also quickly find enough "warm bodies" (besides those from OANN) to prevent an embarrassing almost empty room at the next press conference...
- TimorousBestie 1y ago> (how do I write this in a way that won't get me downvoted?) It’s sad that your speech has been chilled by the misuse of the karma system by some large faction of users here.
- emsign 1y agoIt's less about having an effect but all about moral integrity. They want to signal that they still abide to their professional standards in order to keep their reputation among their peers and the public, those who aren't gleichgeschaltet (yet).
- cabirum 1y agoPathetic posturing. With an access badge, at least you can leak something important anonymously.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> With an access badge, at least you can leak something important anonymously You think generals leak to journalists at press conferences?
- 23david 1y ago[flagged]
- ibash 1y agoBecause it's interesting. We don't need to censor everything.
- refurb 1y agoThe news article is interesting, but political discussions on HN rarely are.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoSo just read the article?
- refurb 1y agoThen you agree we should be flagging discussions?
- cosmicgadget 1y agoNope. People don't need to flag something that disinterests them. The proper move is to not spend time on the uninteresting thing.
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoFrom HN Guidelines: > Please don't complain that a submission is inappropriate.
- contrarian1234 1y agoWhile what the government is doing more widely is quite scary, this in isolation seems sensible? I don't really get what the journalists' role is? To goad and harass employees of the Department of defense in to slipping up and saying more than they should? To encourage people to leak information? Given the secretive nature of the whole institution, It seems sensible that there is some formal process for deciding what information should and shouldn't be shared. The previous setup seems sort of insane. If the army is putting babies on spikes and it needs to be leaked.. it seems that that should happen outside of the Pentagon itself and shouldn't involve getting some government approved badge...
- postexitus 1y agoFree Press is part of checks and balances. If you are going to rely on leaks for this stuff to come out, you are going to have a bad time.
- contrarian1234 1y agoisn't what they're doing at the pentagon essentially getting people to leak stuff?
- postexitus 1y agoby questioning them publicly and holding them to account. That's not a leak. That's keeping people in check (or force them to lie in front of camera). Remove that and you only rely on Edward Snowdens of the world.
- contrarian1234 1y agoMy understanding is they want off-the-record information from unnamed sources. These aren't public questions like at a press conference. Those can still occur under the current rules.
- 1y ago
- Gud 1y agoI am so proud of the journalists for standing up to what is right. It seems to me there is some hope for America after all.
- Xss3 1y agoAre we sure this isnt exactly what the current administration wants to happen? Less press so they can get away with more?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Less press War journalists will keep reporting. This just means the government’s position doesn’t get a say every time.
- prmoustache 1y agoWell every step they do seems to be copy/pasted from North Korea. Since nobody is protesting now you can expect that 5 years from now the regime will start making disappear people vaguely opposing the gov decisions or being suicided on a regular basis.
- projectazorian 1y ago> Since nobody is protesting now Not the case, there are quite large protests, one is this weekend I believe. As for disappearances, ICE is already doing that. Although in Chicago their attempts to disappear people are going increasingly poorly, since ICE's appearance in a neighborhood now typically draws dozens of people onto the street to protest.
- lawn 1y agoAnd Russia of course.
- ruszki 1y agoThe government gets that even if journalists agree.
- lm28469 1y agoWhy is there always someone to hint that Trump &co are 280 IQ geniuses and all of their batshit insane actions actually are a 8d chess move we're too dumb to understand ?
- Ekaros 1y agoGood. Journalist should not have some special access compared to your any person off the street. Such things only lead to un-democratic ends.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoAll of those newspaper-led coups d'etat throughout history...
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoThe Pengagon Press Corps was born out of WWII censorship [1]. Shutting down this institution may be for the best. [1] https://brendonbeebe.substack.com/p/history-of-pentagon-press-access?utm_campaign=posts-open-in-app&triedRedirect=true https://brendonbeebe.substack.com/p/history-of-pentagon-pres...
- c3ns0r3d_sgain 1y ago[dead]
- kykat 1y agoI couldn't find what the restrictions are? Does someone here know?
- actionfromafar 1y ago" if they sought to report on information — classified or otherwise — that had not been approved by Hegseth for release"
- tjpnz 1y agoYou're not allowed to use leakers or leaked documents when reporting.
- ReptileMan 1y agoIsn't that easily circumvented by being antonymous source to a colleague that is not accredited?
- jimjimwii 1y agoIts a foot in the door. If you dont slam the door shut quickly, you'll find yourself thrown out of your house and locked out (remember what android's safety net was when it got introduced and look at ehat it has become now) Any kind of restriction, no matter how trevally exploitable will become legally and technically insurmountable if given time to metastasize.
- skc 1y agoMaybe I'm not thinking this through clearly enough but isn't this "just fine" for the current administration? From their perspective what exactly is the downside to this?
- Dumblydorr 1y agoOf course they’re fine with it. They pushed the policy. They’re enemies of truth and reality, journalism and reporting information is their natural enemy.
- ohdeardear 1y agoThe US is preparing for war and disinformation is a tool in such a war. The Pentagon just wants the same level of control as the other authoritarian regimes. It kind of shows that "democracy" was never real to begin with. Certainly with Sora 2 level of technology they can just claim whoever they don't like has blown up a federal building while they were asleep. It's not like you can have an alibi when you sleep and everyone sleeps. In a way, this AI nightmare necessitates protocols for protection against false accusations like only being able to open the door exiting a house when three other witnesses are present. There are cryptographic solutions like verified cameras, but almost nobody has those now, not even news crews publish signed videos. Journalism in war time has no real meaning, because if it's secret information the journalist basically becomes an adversary and at some point it becomes cheaper to kill them. Those waging wars have historically always been corrupt. So, that leaves repeating whatever the Pentagon wants you to know. Also, calling the US a democracy is like putting lipstick on a pig and saying it's a hot babe. Perhaps Switzerland still has a democracy, but most kind of suck in various ways (and most importantly, don't do anything to improve their democracies). In a real democracy, there would be continuous improvement with better checks and balances. At some point you start to wonder whether democracy just exists to give people the illusion that their voice means anything. Also, in a real democracy there would be equal opportunity and advertising budget for all political parties. That's just not the case in many democracies. So, blatantly obvious autocracies are probably worse than our current "democracies", but let's not pretend democracy is a thing right now.
- nojs 1y agohttps://archive.is/slfnP https://archive.is/slfnP
- perihelions 1y ago> "When the new policy was issued two weeks ago, news organizations were concerned that signing the rules conveyed agreement with them, including to a restriction that they not report on any news — even if unclassified — without official approval." https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-journalists-new-restrictions-hegseth-b9e70801f7d7930251a0740e7168f775 https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-journalists-new-restrict... Awfully reminiscent of a certain *other* autocratic regime, and its tyrannical control over public discussion of its armed forces. > "These laws establish administrative and criminal punishments for "discrediting" or dissemination of "unreliable information" about the Russian Armed Forces, other Russian state bodies and their operations, and the activity of volunteers aiding the Russian Armed Forces, and for calls to impose sanctions against Russia, Russian organizations and citizens.[1][2]"... The adoption of these laws resulted in the mass exodus of foreign media from Russia and the termination of war reporting by independent Russian media. More than 10,000 people have been prosecuted under these laws,[4]..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_2022_war_censorship_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_2022_war_censorship_la... ("Russian 2022 war censorship laws")
- rufus_foreman 1y ago>> news organizations were concerned that signing the rules conveyed agreement with them, including to a restriction that they not report on any news — even if unclassified — without official approval Where in the memo does it restrict journalists from reporting on any news without official approval? Can you quote me the relevant section? I see a section about "unauthorized disclosure of CNSI or CUI", but CNSI and CUI are specific classifications of information that the government is required by law to protect.
- perihelions 1y ago> "“Information must be approved for public release by an appropriate authorizing official before it is released, even if it is unclassified,” the directive states. The signature form includes an array of security requirements for credentialed media at the Pentagon." https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-press-media-restrictions-nondisclosure-8420d3a80de20a39605c588d9990c582 https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-press-media-restrictions...
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoRelated: New York Times, AP, Newsmax and others say they won't sign new Pentagon rules https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45575755 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45575755 The Pentagon Press Corps Is Gone https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45600281 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45600281
- whamlastxmas 1y agoWhy do we need journalists in a military building that is presumably full of classified information and people having conversations about said information? I was surprised to hear this was even a thing, it seems really odd to me. If I was tasked to start the Pentagon from scratch and was asked, “should we setup a system to provide offices and constant access to journalists?” I’d be like, fuck no, what a dumb distraction. Members of the military should not be talking to the press about their work while at work. Sure, talk off the record, just don’t do it at work. And talk as an individual, not as a representative of the military. Unless of course your job is literally PR for the military. In which case maybe go to the journalist.
- tencentshill 1y agoBecause a large chunk of your taxes goes into projects planned and executed in that building. You have the right to know how it's used, and they decided they didn't want to disclose it themselves.
- hypeatei 1y agoYou understand the Pentagon is like its own city, right? There are various chain restaurants within it. Officers aren't walking the halls discussing top secret war plans -- that's for the Signal group chat. Joking aside, for discussing classified information, there are dedicated areas called SCIFs[0]. Journalists aren't allowed into those areas. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitive_compartmented_information_facility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitive_compartmented_inform...
- dsabanin 1y agoThe whole thing Trump and his minions are doing is so very reminiscent of what was happening in Russia during its turn to fascism. Similarities go to such an extreme degree across the board that I now feel there has to be at least a consultant from Moscow working with the current admin, if not full blown department at the FSB. Blatant lying, complete disregard of any laws, open rejection of norms and mockery of process, justification of extreme cruelty , obsession with some made up concept of “liberals”, and blaming everything on the predecessors (Putin is still trying to blame all the problems on the collapse of the Soviet Union). I sincerely hope that people of the United States reject being treated like mindless cattle and choose freedom instead of what appears to be a complete and utter national-fascist tyranny.
- NoGravitas 1y agoThe recent TrueAnon podcast on Peter Brian Hegseth is very entertaining and informative. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7nA-9wWAi8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7nA-9wWAi8
- mizzao 1y agoHow does this help at all with transparency about what the government is actually doing? Now they can just get away with anything...