13 ms·
European Commission fines Google €2.95B over abusive ad tech practices
- amelius 1y agoOk, now can we also have a three-strikes policy please, with prison sentences. Otherwise this is just the cost of doing business.
- reorder9695 1y agoAlmost 3bn euros is one hell of a cost of business though, that's approximately a euro for every 2.5 people on the planet
- isodev 1y agoGoogle has been serving a lot of ads over the years.
- thinkingtoilet 1y agoUntil the rich people who green light things like this go to jail it will literally never stop. Someone, somewhere needs to be responsible for policies that break the law and they need to go to jail.
- lucketone 1y agoMy company has a committee that votes on these kinds of things. You as a prosecutor, who will you take to jail? whole committee? Those who voted in-favour? Somebody who brought the proposal? Only CEO? Each of these decisions if done consistently over time, would invoke changes in companies, to get some fall-guys in right places.
- alkonaut 1y agoFor usual corporate crimes: Usually CEO and/or a few senior individuals who you could prove was part of a conspiracy and aware it was a crime, through emails, chat logs etc.
- thinkingtoilet 1y agoThe very easy and obvious answer is the people who are responsible. If there is a committee then the obvious answer is the people who voted for it. It's not hard. It's like saying what if I break the law but I do it with three other people, who goes to jail? The obvious answer is everyone who broke the law goes to jail. If a fifth person did not participate and said you should not break the law, the very obvious answer is the person who did not participate and who did not break the law does not go to jail. It's not complicated at all.
- udev4096 1y ago[flagged]
- djtango 1y agoHuh? Google generated 350B in revenues in 2024... 3B is pocket change to them
- jjani 1y agoIt's 15% of their yearly net profit in the region. Not even revenue. 3bn sounds like a lot because we haven't gotten used to the absurd profit levels that these monstrosities have reached.
- reorder9695 1y agoI actually do think that's significant, if someone took 15% of your yearly earnings this year that would definitely be noticed. I'm not saying it's the right amount, I'm saying that is enough to be felt and therefore isn't the tiny fines you often tend to see
- Anonyneko 1y agoFor Google that's a slap on the wrist.
- generic92034 1y agoBut a slap which can easily be repeated (even with more force), if Google does not comply.
- isoprophlex 1y agoAgreed. Megacorps where noone has actual honest skin in the game and every unethical decision can be paved over with money are bad news for most of us.
- roscas 1y agoJust another day in the office. European Commission... commission...
- roscas 1y agoOh no, someone from the Commission just down voted me. Bet it was those who were asked about corruption and cut the microphone to those who really care. We do deserve better in Europe. This one is for Google. But Facebook and others do the same. How can we let them do this. If you have responsability and let this happen, you just allow it.
- ranguna 1y agoNot the one who down-voted you, but I thought about it. I believe the reason you got down-voted was because you comment did not add anything of productive to the discussion.
- mc32 1y agoHow would that work? Infraction > Officers quit; new set of officers > infraction > officers quit; new set of officers…
- riku_iki 1y agoexecs will jump with golden parachute after first strike.
- 08327802347 1y ago[flagged]
- isodev 1y agoOh nice. I hope other countries follow suit. It’s quite a shame Google didn’t get Chrome divested from them in the US, would’ve been a “nature is healing” moment for the web.
- richwater 1y agoRunning a browser without an ecosystem behind it is a money pit and would be worth almost 0.
- isodev 1y agoDoesn’t matter, as consumers, we’re absolutely ducked from all sides as long as our “window into the web” is fully controlled by a single corp.
- mupuff1234 1y agoAnd if Chrome were to be divested it would have just gotten swallowed up by a different corp, most likely to end up in worse hands imo. Can you name any other company that if they owned Chrome it would've been better for the users and the web?
- isodev 1y agoThe issue is that Google is both the browser, the web standards, the ads, the mail, the search, the phone, the AI, the maps… not a chance to compete with any of that as long as it’s all in one. The only other barely approaching this level is Apple, and we know they have their own anticompetitive aspects. Allowing corps to grow so much should never have been a thing.
- lawlessone 1y ago>Can you name any other company that if they owned Chrome it would've been better for the users and the web? Mozilla? Red Hat? Valve?
- 1y ago
- richwater 1y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 1y agoYeah, its not like the US is also pursuing an antitrust actions against Google, including one for its abusive ad tech practices. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-prevails-landmark-antitrust-case-against-google https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/department-justice-prevails-l...
- richwater 1y agoLina Khan's success record is/was horrendous. In the most recent case, Google may have "lost" but the government got nowhere near what it was asking for either.
- orwin 1y agoHonestly, on this particular case that's on the judge and your current culture, not Khan. Before the 80s, Google would have been forced to separate its two ads divisions, to make some space for new companies and actors. If Lina Khan only victory is that people are now aware that having a government this friendly with monopolies isn't normal, that's probably better than most politicians since Clinton.
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Honestly, on this particular case that's on the judge and your current culture, not Khan. Before the 80s, Google would have been forced to separate its two ads divisions, to make some space for new companies and actors. The case in which the government didn’t get what it wanted was the online search case; the trial in the remedy phase of the ad tech case starts later this month, so talking about the difference between what Google would have gotten in the 1980s for that and what they are actually getting now is premature speculation.
- 1y ago
- vader1 1y agoVery fair. Doing anything with online advertising, either as an advertiser or as a publisher, without it involving any of Google's platforms is nearly impossible.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- balamatom 1y agoWhat's worse, doing anything at all without it involving any online advertising is nearly impossible, too.
- KebabKanaken 1y ago[flagged]
- mrtksn 1y agoThey should have force Google to sell to a EU buyer instead? Like the true, elected capitalist way?
- osigurdson 1y ago[flagged]
- octo888 1y agoDepends if it even gets paid. Probably a couple of years in dispute at least
- rednafi 1y ago[flagged]
- jjani 1y agoUS tech does everything it can to forcefully monopolize a market; US tech gets fined by countries who care about it.
- BDPW 1y agoThis is a ridiculous take, the EU has a budget of 180 billion a year. People keep repeating this but its just idiotic.
- thoroughburro 1y ago> EU needs money; EU fines US tech companies. No surprise there. And it’s just a coincidence that they chose a company engaged in wrongdoing which breaks their laws, huh? Please, with this cynical edgelord shit.
- 9dev 1y agoYou don’t seem to understand how the EU works, or what it even is in the first place. A hint: it’s not a singular entity when it comes to "needing" money.
- AdventureMouse 1y agoIt has nothing to do with money and everything to do with ideology.
- izacus 1y agoI'm looking forward to my north/south rail corridor funded by Google. Better than waymo.
- jjani 1y agoGoing to pre-empt the comments that always pop up in these topics saying "Google/Meta/Apple will just leave the EU at this rate": Google still has around $20 billion yearly reasons to remain active in the EU. Talking Europe yearly net profit here, post-fine. No, they're not going to say "screw this fine, you can take your $20 billion per year, we're leaving!". The second that happens, shareholders will have Sundar's access revoked within the hour. There is a number of countries where Google has to deal with large levels of protectionist barriers (not the EU, these fines aren't that) and they still operate there. Korea is just one example. Because there's still a lot of money to be made. China isn't a counterexample: Google stopped operating search in China because at that point there was not a lot of money to be made for them in search there.
- jaredklewis 1y agoI agree with everything you’ve said, but just would also point out that in addition to the fine, it is unclear how changing its practices is going to decrease existing (ill gotten) ad revenues going forward. Presumably these changes will hurt revenue or google would already be following them.
- nonethewiser 1y ago[flagged]
- devilkin 1y agoOh, you mean, standing up against full monopolies?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- perching_aix 1y agoThe only good thing about blatantly uncharitable comments like this is that at least one can discard them without remorse.
- 1y ago
- peterldowns 1y agoCan someone elaborate on the first accusation — "DFP favours AdX over rival Ad exchanges by e.g. informing it in advance of the best bid from competitors"? I'd be really curious to understand how it does this, like what information is actually shared that isn't also shared with other ad exchanges.
- seydor 1y agoAwaiting amusing tweets (truths?) from the american baby in chief
- bee_rider 1y agoJust a note, in case anyone thinks this is an insufficient punishment: > The Commission has ordered Google (i) to bring these self-preferencing practices to an end; and (ii) to implement measures to cease its inherent conflicts of interest along the adtech supply chain. Google has now 60 days to inform the Commission about how it intends to do so. It is on top of ordering them to fix the business practices. They can always issue more fines if Google doesn’t comply. IMO some of us here want to see these companies hurt. That’s a non-goal for the EU, they are looking for compliance, not vengeance or something silly like that.
- m4rtink 1y agoWhy not both ? ;-)
- bee_rider 1y agoHaha, yeah. But they probably benefit from appearing steady, measured, and fair-minded.
- summerlight 1y agoBecause the rule of law, specifically the principle of proportionality, does not allow us to penalize some entities only to hurt them. That might be something entertaining to see for many of us, but civilized societies typically limit the public power from being used in such a way.
- 1y ago
- greatwhitenorth 1y ago[flagged]
- tossandthrow 1y agoIt is not that the EU can't compete, it is that the US don't enforce their own antitrust laws - and that the EU has to step in to ensure fair competition.
- juajajajaj 1y ago[flagged]
- tossandthrow 1y agoOnly as a response to the US establishing anti competitive practices for their tech industry.
- bgwalter 1y agoIt is almost like a 15% tariff on Google. I wonder who did that first.
- Sammi 1y agoYou can keep your US tech companies. In EU we actually need our own. It's long overdue.
- jennyholzer 1y agochump change
- impossiblefork 1y agoI don't think this decision is wrong, I'm from the EU, and I think companies like Google have too much power anyway, but I don't like the ability of the commission to enforce things. Here in Sweden we have a legal tradition where the government doesn't have power over the enforcement of the laws-- parliament can make any law it likes, and it can be anything, but enforcement and the courts are isolated from the politicians. I really don't like that the commission can make up rules, or fine people etc. It's a bad system. It should be done by an impartial regular, or prosecutor or a court. This kind of system opens up the commission to political blackmail and threats from powerful states, it opens up for corruption, it opens up for uneven enforcement, and there's just no reason to have the system this way. You could easily imagine a world where Google was a big US government darling and where they put their weight on the commission and got an outcome that isn't in accordance with law, but with the right system, one more like the Swedish system, that won't be possible.
- benoau 1y agoThe problem with this is big tech companies are very adept at stringing court-based enforcement along, that would defer this punishment until well into the 2030s and even the 2040s for actually rectifying the issues.
- immibis 1y agoIt should at least have to be agreed by both the EU Commission and the EU Parliament.
- impossiblefork 1y agoThen you have to fix the courts in general so that such things are impossible.
- lucianbr 1y agoWho does "enforcement" in Sweden? Is the police somehow under the courts? Same for things like consumer protection agencies, environment protection and so on? Are prosecutors somehow in the same group as the judges? That may work for you, but I see some potential for abuse there as well. I think that is how it turned out in Japan, once you are prosecuted conviction is a foregone conclusion.
- acidrat 1y agoIts definitely not the first time google was fined by EU see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antitrust_cases_against_Google_by_the_European_Union https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antitrust_cases_against_Goog... I can't find any details about those past cases with regards to - did they actually ended up paying anything at all?
- npalli 1y ago[flagged]
- xandrius 1y agoOne comes from an orangutan because he wants to get it hard and please his fanbase and the other is because a specific company broke a law of a region. The two couldn't be more different than that. And I find it hard to believe your comment is genuine given the obvious difference.
- linotype 1y ago.
- immibis 1y agoInnovation consists of forming unbreakable monopolies and then jacking up prices apparently. What did Google do that its competition didn't?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- henryzhou 1y ago[flagged]
- StopDisinfo910 1y agoUS Tech Giants use tax optimisation created by the single market to avoid EU taxes to the tune of billions a year. That’s on top of them getting far too much access to public markets in the EU including for plenty of things EU companies are bared from by the Buy American Act in the US. The idea that EU is somehow a mob boss shaking down American tech companies is plain ridiculous. Just take a look at the EU-US trade balance in service and you will understand in which direction the money is actually flying.
- Workaccount2 1y agoWouldn't it be something if the EU focused on fostering a tech scene rather than attacking it. This is like the 4th time they have gone to the Google bank demanding a $1B+ ransom. And before we "Just don't break the laws" take note of the fact the the EU has a dead tech scene. I don't know how they expect competition to grow when they block all the sunlight in their tech fields. If you don't want Google dominating your populations technology, try creating conditions to grow a replacement.
- StopDisinfo910 1y agoThat’s a complete red herring. This is not Europe racketing Google. Google is losing the same kind of trial everywhere in the world including the US for one simple reason: they are actually using anticompetitive practices in the ad tech market. Honestly the most likely to benefit from this verdict are other American companies. You are welcome for us doing the enforcement your country refuses to do.
- dmix 1y agoAlmost all the most famous anti-trust cases in America like against Microsoft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp.#Settlement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor... were not about monetary fines, they are first and foremost about changing practices (behavioural remedies). Microsoft didn't even pay any money, they had to change how they operated their business in the US. Likewise with both the recent antitrust trials in the US against Google: In one government prosecutors wanted them to sell off Chrome, the other they are trying to break Google Ads monopoly by breaking it up. This is not a system extracting billions of the dollar for the 4th time in a couple years. Especially as others have mentioned that this commission is also the one inventing the rules, so it can keep doing it indefinitely for new reasons.
- alkonaut 1y ago> Microsoft didn't even pay any money, they had to change how they operated their business in the US. They had to do that, or else what? Some form of cruel and unusual punishment that doesn’t involve fines? Isn’t this process about compliance with laws too? They have had time to follow the laws but chosen not to.
- givemeethekeys 1y agoCost of doing business. If these fines are to have any teeth, they need to be of a magnitude proportionate to company size. Otherwise, they are more of a petty cash shakedown.
- UrineSqueegee 1y ago[flagged]
- fsflover 1y agoThat's a shallow dismissal, which is against the HN guidelines.
- nemo44x 1y ago[flagged]
- mentalgear 1y ago[flagged]
- tomhow 1y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment with another bad comment. Better to just flag and move on.
- tomhow 1y agoComments like this have never been OK on HN, and the people who have been making consistently good contributions since the earliest days do not attack other users like this. If you’re concerned about a decline of HN, we need you to observe the guidelines that have been in place since well before your account was registered. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- icanthulahoop 1y ago[flagged]
- nemo44x 1y agoNvidea has a market cap greater than ALL of Germanys stock market. They should figure this out instead of extorting non-EU companies.
- eth0up 1y agoI fully expect and won't blame the form of archery that will pursue this comment, but... Impulse must have its way once in a while. With the unprecedented extrajudicial approach the US has recently taken against certain recreational boaters in the Caribbean, perhaps they will realize Google is far worse and apply similar tactics. Lawsuits will never amount to anything. And they are taking over the world. And in my opinion, they're verifiably more hostile than any boater I've ever been made aware of, including people on jet skis. With the very substance of reality dissolving before our eyes, and considering we may be but a twitch of a jingo fingertip away from nuking the homeless, why not?
- belter 1y agoEuropean Commission fines Google an amount equal to three Meta ML Experts signing bonus...
- Xenoamorphous 1y agoIt’s amusing to see how HN, notoriously pro-privacy and anti-ads seemingly dislikes this kind of news.
- mbroncano 1y agoIt also traditionally heavily anti Europe, for reasons
- nemo44x 1y ago[flagged]
- hollerith 1y agoI've been assuming that most of the anti-American comments here were probably written by Americans, but I don't really know.
- lazide 1y agoThat’s my take as well. Europeans (in my experience) tend to be less, ahem, ignorantly optimistic, of how well it would go.
- rdm_blackhole 1y agoThey also started to support censorship and government approved social media content. See the recent thread about Nepal banning many apps and the comments are full of people saying that the EU should do the same or require that the content be even more moderated on all the platforms. It's very sad to see. I come here for the hacker news but it seems we are being overrun by a new kind of people who love when the EU intervenes to "regulate" the markets and fully believe that the EU is "pro" privacy (TM) and can't wait to impose new regulations all the while it's actually working to undermine encryption for everyone in Europe. I guess the old saying is true, War is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength.
- aucisson_masque 1y agoWhat the US couldn't do, Europe just did ? > The Commission has already signalled its preliminary view that only the divestment by Google of part of its services would address the situation of inherent conflicts of interest, but it first wishes to hear and assess Google's proposal. aka, breaking a monopoly. thanks god for Europe.
- dmix 1y agoThe US just won two antitrust trials in a row against Google in the past year. One for Google Ads and the other for Google Search (the chrome one).
- idle_zealot 1y agoYeah, and then we decided not to break them up. Discussed yesterday https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45120050 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45120050
- dmix 1y agoThey haven't yet ruled on the much more important Google Ads case
- dragonwriter 1y ago> What the US couldn't do, Europe just did ? The remedy phase in the US trial over similar ad tech issues starts later this month, so it is premature to call it “what the US couldn’t do”. (You may be confusing it with the recent partial ruling in the remedy phase of the separate search antitrust case.)
- ApolloFortyNine 1y agoI read this whole article a couple times and don't really u understand what was wrong here. Google is using their own ad exchange to fill ads? Isn't that... Their entire business model? Does the EU just want more intermediaries to exist? At the end of the day doesn't Google still get to decide how much an ad is worth when someone searches 'car insurance'? To me this reads like the EU should pass a law describing exactly what they want. >For example, Google Ads was avoiding competing ad exchanges and mainly placing bids on AdX, thus making it the most attractive ad exchange. I just don't know why Google couldn't do this. Is this an instance of if they just never used other ad exchanges at all no one would be mad? Like Google getting called a monopoly by requiring the play store to be installed on android phones, while Apple obviously does exactly this just on their own hardware?
- gitaarik 1y agoFrom what I quickly gather, these are the things Google did that are against the EU anti-trust rules: - Companies advertising through Google were not allowed to collaborate with other advertising companies under Google's contract. - Google runs an ad exchange (AdX) where advertisers and advertising spaces can connect, and Google didn't share platform's data with other members, giving them an unfair market advantage. - They also manipulated the way deals were made on the platform to their advantage. To me it sounds just wrong anyway that Google runs this platform where companies compete with each other but also Google itself, so they'll always have more control. I think it's a good idea having these anti trust rules, because otherwise you'll eventually get a a gigantic monopoly economy, and I just think that's not a good idea.
- oriettaxx 1y agoVery good: super good. Too easy to make business for monopolists. I seriously do not understand how Microsoft made it so far not to experience the same.
- oriettaxx 1y agoPenalties bases on income is a very good practice: it works this way in Finland. Can it be that any Berlusconi pays, for a speed ticket, the same amount as ordinary people?
- account42 1y agoAs much as I like to see google getting fined, it's disappointing that this is happening over them screwing over ad partners when ads are all about screwing over end users in the first place.