19 ms·
What happens when clergy take psilocybin
- quantified 1y agoPretty much nothing of substance in the writeup. All about studying and flaws.
- jbm 1y agoYeah I was honestly taken aback with how devoid of content this was. No personal stories or research. The New Yorker version looks more interesting. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/05/26/this-is-your-priest-on-drugs https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/05/26/this-is-your-p...
- Kilenaitor 1y agoAlso has a way better headline heh
- swyx 1y agomichael pollan, one of the best in the biz
- electroglyph 1y agoheh, didn't expect this line: Finding willing rabbis, however, was easy—the challenge was finding ones who were “psychedelically naïve.”
- cluckindan 1y agoThere are videos of such religious devotees riding around cities in a van, blasting psychedelic trance, and stopping at lights to dance around the intersection, offering acid to onlookers.
- nikcub 1y agothis should probably be OP - much better original story, not a reblog, and it's written by Michael Pollan.
- kevinwang 1y agoMuch better, thank you!
- elevaet 1y agoI had to scroll up and down for a while, looking for the rest of the article. There wasn't any.
- bookofjoe 1y agoHere you go: https://archive.ph/2Za2J https://archive.ph/2Za2J
- RobRivera 1y agoYea I was wondering if there was some UI issue on mobile bc I kept scrolling down expecting more. I stopped and read the whole thing to be disappointed. A blurb about [thing i am interested in]. I now feel like yelling at some clouds.
- quantified 1y agoI feel badly that I didn't warn you sufficiently.
- anigbrowl 1y agoYeah, total clickbait
- calibas 1y agoIt also makes some mistakes: > Many of those who chose to participate were also considering leaving the profession at the outset and so could have been seeking a way to reconnect with the divine From the study: > 8% endorsing that they were currently considering leaving their vocation https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044#sec-3 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044#sec-... 24 completed the study, so that's 2 people.
- worik 1y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment
- worik 1y agoI am no fan of Timothy Leary, I think he put the cause of Psychedelics back decades. He was also a very flawed researcher, which effected this study. Nevertheless, it was ground breaking for 1962 and had a huge impact. Not so significant in the twenty first century.
- chiefgeek 1y agoYes. Came here to to say this has been done before. It was too much for the Establishment to stomach. Ram Dass, Tim Leary’s associate (Richard Alpert at the time) talks about it here - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ram-dass-here-and-now/id518366323?i=1000369921333 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ram-dass-here-and-now/...
- bravesoul2 1y ago> Almost a decade ago, a Baptist Biblical scholar, a Catholic priest, several rabbis, an Islamic leader, a Zen Buddhist roshi, and more than a dozen other religious leaders walked into a lab—and took high doses of magic mushrooms. Wild. Maybe what the world needs.
- BitwiseFool 1y agoQuite frankly, that quote sounds like the premise of some new Netflix original series.
- jjulius 1y ago>Maybe what the world needs. One line that's been recurring between my wife and I for the past half-decade or so is that the whole planet needs a good hotboxing.
- robocat 1y agoThat's the scattergun controlled approach of seeing like a state - give everyone medication even though it's only some that need it. There's a small percentage ruining it for most: a few defectors when most are cooperators. How do we identify the defectors? What do you do if you identify defectors?
- Spivak 1y agoIt's maybe inefficient to hotbox everyone but I think I would rather that than give my government the green light to define and identify defectors. If humanity has proven one thing over and over and over again to itself it's that we're terrible at witch hunts.
- readthenotes1 1y ago"William James, considered the father of American psychology ...., is said to have to come to many of his own most central ideas at least in part through hallucinatory experiences with nitrous oxide" That's a pretty good explainer for psychology. We have a Coke addled Freud who is the father of it all and another drug abuser shepherding the USA. I wonder how many people have tried to replicate their experiments and succeeded?
- kevinsync 1y agoYeah, keep in mind that significant abuse of the drugs mentioned are, uh, let's say, prone to inflating the ego rather than killing it and showing a different path. Kinda fills in some unspoken gaps about the 'discipline' of psychology...
- hsbauauvhabzb 1y agoCan you explain this for those of us with minimal background in psychology? Is there a substantial amount of pseudoscience in modern psychology, or just historically?
- 7thaccount 1y agoThis is a little blunt, but I knew a lot of people who went into psychology and got degrees. They were not very gifted academically (C students in highschool) and went into psych as it was an easy major that let them coast and party for four years. I'm sure this isn't the case for all psychology majors of course, but it was very different on average than what I was used to in engineering or the hard sciences where you generally had 4 years of excruciating math classes including calculus and differential equations that weeded out most. Psychology is very dependent on statistics and experiments. That can be complicated and after going through those classes I simply don't trust the majority of students (or their professors) to get any of that right. It's why I roll my eyes every time the radio guy talks about the results of another pop psych study. I knew some psych majors big into new age crystal stuff and legitimately believed it all as well as a bunch of additional pseudoscience garbage. That kind of thing is a lot more rare in say physics where it's really hard to get through the program without a rational brain. Again, there are probably some brilliant folks drawn to that field who knows how to do solid research, but my experiences suggest that the signal to noise ratio may be suspect.
- caycep 1y agoa corollary is - can a clergy still practice if implanted with a neuromodulator device, i.e. deep brain stimulation, for epilepsy, or Parkinson's, or depression?
- selfhoster11 1y agoI don't see why not? If it alters the function of the brain towards the default, natural state, instead of away from it, then that doesn't distort clear perception of reality. It's much like with glasses - the lenses alter the light in a way that helps the retinas receive the light more like the default, natural human perception does.
- caycep 1y agoThis is true assuming it is just a matter of abnormal vs default state. Sometimes I wonder, especially as people are doing more studies using these implants for conditions like major depressive disorder...there are also concerns re even for motor symptoms like Parkinson's, there may be subtle cognitive/psychiatric changes - we have accidentally induced noticeable mania in some patients at least temporarily, until we were able to correct the settings on the device...
- xwowsersx 1y agoPromising title, but the article felt hollow... all surface, no depth. Skimmed anecdotes without probing them, offered no real insight or new perspective, and left me with absolutely nothing I couldn't have guessed from the headline alone :(
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- aspenmayer 1y agoThere’s also this guy who you might have heard of, who created a little thing called Alcoholics Anonymous: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_W.#Psychedelic_therapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_W.#Psychedelic_therapy https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-5922.13027 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-5922.13027 Apparently he was so serious about the potential for LSD to help alcoholics, that he almost got thrown out of Alcoholics Anonymous, the recovery group he helped create. He had written to a Catholic friend about this. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/aug/23/lsd-help-alcoholics-theory https://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/aug/23/lsd-help-alc... > LSD, by mimicking insanity, could help alcoholics achieve a central tenet of the Twelve Step programme proposed by AA, he believed. It was a matter of finding "a power greater than ourselves" that "could restore us to sanity". He warned: "I don't believe [LSD] has any miraculous property of transforming spiritually and emotionally sick people into healthy ones overnight. It can set up a shining goal on the positive side, after all it is only a temporary ego-reducer." > But Wilson added: "The vision and insights given by LSD could create a large incentive – at least in a considerable number of people." > His words were found in a late 50s letter to Father Ed Dowling, a Catholic priest and member of an experimental group he had formed in New York to explore the spiritual potential of LSD.
- ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 1y agohttps://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044
- patrickmay 1y agoWhen clergy take psilocybin . . . God sees them?
- 867-5309 1y agowhen you eat too many shrooms .. the shrooms eat back at you
- 867-5309 1y agoI vaguely remember some televised British experiment in which a clergyman replaced his usual bread with poppy seed bread -- toast for breakfast, sandwich for lunch, etc. -- then at the end of a month or so tested positive for some opioid threshhold
- cnasc 1y agoFrom Brainiac: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9At-dgp0rQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9At-dgp0rQ
- 867-5309 1y agohmmn, possibly
- kayodelycaon 1y agoOpium is made from same plant poppy seeds come from.
- 867-5309 1y agothat's the premise, yes
- nathan_compton 1y agoI don't know if my brain is just wired up differently, but I've taken both LSD and Psilocybin many times and I did not find the experiences spiritual at all. I don't even know what people are talking about when they talk about spiritual experiences.
- esseph 1y agoI know people personally that psilocybin, LSD, and other substances do nothing for. All of them also have existing mental health disorders (extreme generalized anxiety, depression, bipolar, etc.).
- kbenson 1y agoNothing as in there is no outside noticeable change in behavior and they report no change in speaking, or nothing as it relates to the topic of this thread, in that they have no profound or spiritual experiences?
- esseph 1y agoThey might get a slight body high even on what would otherwise be considered heroic doses for their weight. Things like lemon-tek to make the psilocybin more bioavailable were also not impactful to them, while being apparently extremely impactful for others.
- vermilingua 1y agoIt may be worth noting that antidepressant medication has a strong suppressing effect on psychedelics.
- ghxst 1y agoDepends on the type! Generally might be true for SSRIs but not always for TCAs or lithium which can have the opposite effect. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8788508/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8788508/ (just one example)
- Projectiboga 1y agoIt was done at Harvard Divinity School in 1962 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment The Marsh Chapel Experiment, also called the "Good Friday Experiment", was an experiment conducted on Good Friday, April 20, 1962 at Boston University's Marsh Chapel. Walter N. Pahnke, a graduate student in theology at Harvard Divinity School, designed the experiment under the supervision of Timothy Leary, Richard Alpert, and the Harvard Psilocybin Project.[1] Pahnke's experiment investigated whether psilocybin would act as a reliable entheogen in religiously predisposed subjects.[2]
- 50208 1y agoWhy do people insist on complicating all this so much ... just take a hit of whatever and experience it for yourself.
- worthless-trash 1y agoI believe people complicate it because brain chemistry modification is mostly a one way change.
- dymk 1y agoThere’s plenty of reasons but that’s not a great reason for or against - there is no process you can do to your brain that isn’t a one way change.
- worthless-trash 1y agoThere is always a lesser change, which may be what you want. Nobody wants brain damage.
- gchamonlive 1y agoI go to raves, I take very modest amounts of LSD (100 maybe 150 micrograms), and the whole experience turns into very spiritual session where I dance with my entire being and let myself disolve into the Great Void. It has lasting effects that go way beyond the effects of the drug. However I think it's complicated to derive generalisms like saying it's a drug for everyone and everybody should take it. It's definitely not for everybody. I'm also not going to be a hypocrite and say that you shouldn't do it. What I'll go and say is that it's your journey to figure out what you are going to invite into your life. In any case, depending on what you believe, you aren't actually here to figure things out. You already did. You are here to remember. In more secular terms, you are here to do the required work to understand yourself, your circumstances, stand on the shoulder of giants and study the great minds that came before you. That will give you the necessary foundational philosophy to withstand and understand these experiences, should you choose to go through them. This is the only way to acquire a foundational respect for these substances and these experiences. Have I done this work? Have I achieved the required level of understanding to make heads and tails of these experiences? Not for a while at least. It was rough the first couple of times. Very violent and crude, like rushing naked through a sea of people while being completely sure that that night is the last night of your life (I wasn't actually naked, it just felt like that and that everyone was eventually going to merge with me and that I should feel ashamed of it). But with time and with the necessary exposure to understand the basics of existencialism I think I managed to pin down a more gentle form of this experience that can help me remember how to lay myself bare to the goddess and just be there when I dance. So I think I can extend this invitation to anyone that feels brave enough to lift the reins of existence and reality and expose yourself to the truth. That everything is a story about the end of the world. About the beginning. And about everything at once. It's scary, it's blissful and it's totally worth it.
- thinkingtoilet 1y agoI would go as far as to say most people should have a psychedelic experience at least once in their life. There's nothing like it. It's one of the great pleasures of being alive.
- 1y ago
- kazinator 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_of_the_people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_of_the_people What are the odds that peddlers of religion would turn to promoting chemical drugs on the side ...
- cluckindan 1y agoThere’s that word again: ”drugs” - you just know anyone using that word in earnest is suffering from a narrow and naïve world view imposed upon them by generations of propaganda. There is a huge experiential chasm between opiates and psychedelics. These two groups of substances have nothing to do with each other.
- kazinator 1y agoReligion is not literally opium; Marx was speaking/writing figuratively. He just referred to a popular recreational of his time.
- cluckindan 1y agoNo, he was referring to making the people unwilling and unable to revolt. This is literally a thread about psychedelics, not allegory.
- kazinator 1y ago[flagged]
- cluckindan 1y agoMmkay, you don’t think that’s a bit condescending?
- rendall 1y ago> you don’t think that’s a bit condescending? Honest question: are you self-aware? That is, do you feel yourself to be of the world, or uniquely separate from the world? I'm asking, again, sincerely, because I'm wondering how one could scold about condescension immediately after posting this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44295152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44295152
- motohagiography 1y agoif you are interested in a rabbit hole, look up the appearance of the acacia shrub in the bible, a source of DMT, and how some people associate it with the burning bush. quite a trip. I've said before that I think the geometric patterns in hallucinations resemble analog signal feedback, inside an analog signalling system (your brain) that has been impaired by a chemical. other dimensions and beings aren't necessary to the explanation. there are theraputic uses for breaking cycles of thought, but I'd argue a non-spiritual view of drugs based on signalling feedback and channel impairment is sufficient to describe their effects.
- elevaet 1y agoI 100% agree with you on the "signal feedback inside an analog signalling system". I've done a lot of tripping, and I've come to this same hypothesis independently. I believe this explains a great deal about the visual geometric and fractal patterns you can see on psychedelics and also that analogous things happen within the auditory processing system, memory, emotions, and so on when you trip. So much of tripping comes down to turning up the gain on signalling in your brain, which causes feedback pathways to start resonating. This results in colour saturation, tracers, geometry, exaggerated patterns and edge detection, echoing, reverbs, increased impact of thoughts, and following thoughts down deep rabbit holes etc. None of this is to reduce the experience, I love psychedelics and think they are super important. But that's whole other discussion.
- moneywaters 1y agoIf this topic lights you up, you have to watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mn0itlgBZAA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mn0itlgBZAA. It dives deep into the geometry of hallucinations, the mechanics of feedback loops in the brain, and how altered states might just be us tuning into the signal of ourselves. It bridges neuroscience, pattern recognition, and philosophy in a way that makes the whole psychedelic experience feel less like “woo” and more like elegant system dynamics. Whether you’re team “signal feedback” or leaning toward the mystical—this video gives both sides something to chew on. I promise, it’s not just trippy visuals—it’s insightfully grounded.
- 1y ago
- guicen 1y agoWhat I find interesting is that the line between a religious experience and a brain chemistry event seems a lot thinner than we usually think. The clergy didn’t lose their faith after taking psilocybin. Instead, they seem to hold their beliefs a bit more loosely and focus more on what they feel in the moment. In some ways, this feels like something humans have always done. Whether it's prayer, meditation, fasting, or psychedelics, people keep looking for ways to quiet the noise in their heads and feel connected to something bigger. The methods change, but the need stays the same.
- leptons 1y ago>the line between a religious experience and a brain chemistry event seems a lot thinner than we usually think. George Gurdjieff wrote about this many, many years ago (1890 – 1912). He called it "The Fourth Way". This is the relevant passage from the book "In Search of the Miraculous": “So that when a man attains will on the fourth way he can make use of it because he has acquired control of all his bodily, emotional, and intellectual functions. And besides, he has saved a great deal of time by working on the three sides of his being in parallel and simultaneously. “The fourth way is sometimes called the way of the sly man. The ‘sly man’ knows some secret winch the fakir, monk, and yogi do not know. How the ‘sly man’ learned this secret — it is not known. Perhaps he found it in some old books, perhaps he inherited it, perhaps he bought it, perhaps he stole it from someone. It makes no difference. ‘The ‘sly man’ knows the secret and with its help outstrips the fakir, the monk, and the yogi. “Of the four, the fakir acts in the crudest manner; he knows very little and understands very little. Let us suppose that by a whole month of intense torture he develops in himself a certain energy, a certain substance which produces certain changes in him. He does it absolutely blindly, with his eyes shut, knowing neither aim, methods, nor results, simply in imitation of others. “The monk knows what he wants a little better; he is guided by religious feeling, by religious tradition, by a desire for achievement, for salvation; he trusts his teacher who tells him what to do, and he believes that his efforts and sacrifices are ‘pleasing to God.’ Let us suppose that a week of fasting, continual prayer, privations, and so on, enables him to attain what the fakir develops in himself by a month of self-torture. “The yogi knows considerably more. He knows what he wants, he knows why he wants it, he knows how it can be acquired. He knows, for instance, that it is necessary for his purpose to produce a certain substance in himself. He knows that this substance can be produced in one day by a certain kind of mental exercises or concentration of consciousness. So he keeps his attention on these exercises for a whole day without allowing himself a single outside thought, and he obtains what he needs. In this way a yogi spends on the same thing only one day compared with a month spent by the fakir and a week spent by the monk. “But on the fourth way knowledge is still more exact and perfect. A man who follows the fourth way knows quite definitely what substances he needs for his aims and he knows that these substances can be produced within the body by a month of physical suffering, by a week of emotional strain, or by a day of mental exercises—and also, that they can be introduced into the organism from without if it is known how to do it. And so, instead of spending a whole day in exercises like the yogi, a week in prayer like the monk, or a month in self-torture like the fakir, he simply prepares and swallows a little pill which contains all the substances he wants and, in this way, without loss of time, he obtains the required results. https://archive.org/details/dli.ernet.5892/page/49/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/dli.ernet.5892/page/49/mode/2up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Way
- testemailfordg2 1y agoBetter to stay sane...Have seen a lot of these kinds of articles, surely funding comes from somewhere...
- easymodex 1y agoAre you saying you are sane but you also believe secret orgs are funding to push psychedelics to people to make them insane? I have bad news then.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bondarchuk 1y agoThis magazine (nautil.us) is funded by the John Templeton Foundation, which seeks to promote "the intersection of religion and science". (Noone talked about "secret" orgs, the GP poster which you imply is not sane actually made a correct guess based on common sense)
- OhioMan2943 1y agoI've noticed a pattern in which "type" of outlets push this content the most
- summer_glue 1y agoThere's not much information in this article.
- SlowTao 1y agoRam Dass said that back in the 1960's when they were doing study of LSD they would try to randomize/double blind these tests but it was very funny to see. There were one where they had clergy involved and it basically went, one person would be like "I think it is doing something" and another would be wandering around going "I SEE GOD! I SEE GOD!". It was obvious who had what.
- fuzzfactor 1y agoThat's about the time Catholics stopped having their Mass in Latin . . .
- harry8 1y agoCartoon about that which made me laugh. https://www.altaonline.com/culture/cartoons/a42179654/weekly-cartoon-altatude-11-issue-22-paul-noth/ https://www.altaonline.com/culture/cartoons/a42179654/weekly... so hard to track these things down with google nowadays. Treats every word you add as an "or" like yahoo used to when google took their search market. The move from search engine to suggestion engine has been a disaster from my point of view. Hard to see how it would be more profitable. edit: better link
- SlowTao 1y agoThe cartoon is a 10 out of 10!
- sznio 1y ago>Hard to see how it would be more profitable Queries use less compute time to complete, saving money. Why provide quality if there's no competitor for users to escape to?
- 1oooqooq 1y agoit's even worse. revenue per query is up if they can search more keywords for advertisements to display. their lists aren't as comprehensive as before.
- 1y ago
- Animats 1y agoSo where's the follow up in which others evaluate the participants? The results all seem self-reported. But did the participants improve in some measurable way as seen from the outside? Without outside evaluation, it's just people who took drugs reporting they mostly liked the results.
- rajies 1y ago[dead]
- agold97 1y agoit's no surprise to me that people who believe goats talks like to trip lol
- deepsun 1y agoI swear psilocybin affects the sense of importance, sacredness, meaningfulness. One can be staring at the most boring thing and see the Universe in it. Doesn't mean there's really anything important nor useful in it. Just like a shot of dopamine affects feeling of pleasure, psilocybin affects the brain's feeling of "importance".
- quchen 1y agoYou make it sound very negative. It’s a strong experience, and after a strong experience most people have it on their mind, and talking about it is one way to integrate the experience. Previously insufferable people have a new channel to be insufferable, scientific people will analyze what their brain chemistry did, dull people will brag about how extreme it was, and so on.
- Unearned5161 1y agoI wonder if a similar thing to the dwarfing high of heroin applies to these psychedelics. Would the amazing awakening experience I'd have with an LSD trip make all other mentally exciting moments and smaller awakenings I come across in day to day life more boring in comparison?
- hyperadvanced 1y agoI don’t think so. I’ve done it probably 20 times and I feel like it bleeds out into the rest of your life. It forever altered my appreciation of clouds and postmodern fiction/philosophy
- Unearned5161 1y agoRight, that sounds reasonable enough. Maybe that's because it's more of a semi-permanent neuron rewiring and less of hitting a dopamine receptors rev limiter?
- quchen 1y agoHave you been to a really long opera? It’s quite impressive. After hours of pretty intense performance and singing, can you not appreciate the street musician the day after? Do you have a strong desire to go to the opera again the following days?
- flkenosad 1y agoHonestly, kind of.
- Unearned5161 1y agoI get the direction you're trying to go in, but I think this metaphor is flawed. If all I've seen in life are mediocre street musicians, and then one day I go to some concert and it's the best thing ever, sure that's going to change how I see the street musicians from before. Replace with food and its even clearer. Going to some top of the line Micheline star restaurant _will_ alter how you look at food for the rest of your life. Watching a movie in blue-ray full quality no compression _will_ alter how you appreciate streamed movies for the rest of your life. You can still appreciate it for what it is, but it will forever have that relative smallness.
- socceroos 1y agoThe article opening sounds like a bar joke. Also, I think this point is salient: > He pointed to the risk of selection bias: those who volunteer are likely to be “spiritually hungering for a mystical experience,”... I would go further and suppose that any Christian elder or leader who volunteered to do this had already demonstrated their unsuitability to speak on the matter of psychedelics and God.
- rendall 1y ago> I would go further and suppose that any Christian elder or leader who volunteered to do this had already demonstrated their unsuitability to speak on the matter of psychedelics and God. I have honest questions. Would you mind expanding? Is there a theological basis for your stance? What would a suitable Christian elder or leader say on the matter of psychedelics and God?
- nooneinpart 1y agoFor example, it has been written in the letter to the Ephesians 5.15-21: Therefore watch carefully how you walk, not as unwise, but as wise, redeeming the time, because the days are evil. Because of this don’t become foolish but understand what the will of the Lord is and don’t be drunken with wine, in which is dissipation, but be filled with the spirit, speaking to one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs; singing and making melody in your heart to the lord; giving thanks always concerning all things to God, even the father, in the name of our lord Jesus Christ; subjecting yourselves to one another in the fear of Christ.
- rendall 1y agoWould you say the issue is intoxication in general, or is there something categorically different about psychedelics compared to alcohol?
- nooneinpart2 1y agoThe letter to the Galatians (5.19-23) may distinguish between drunkenness and drug use depending on if you consider φαρμακεία (pharmaceia) to include the use of psychedelics: Now the deeds of the flesh are obvious, which are: adultery, ... sorcery (φαρμακεία), ... drunkenness (μέθαι), ... and things like these; of which I forewarn you, even as I also forewarned you, that those who practice such things will not inherit God’s kingdom. But the fruit of the spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faith, gentleness, and self-control. Against such things there is no law.
- pjio 1y agoThose studies should also include if the individuals taking substances become better or worse for the lives of the people around them in a sustainable way.
- billynomates 1y agoThey did, if you read the study linked in the article. The individuals who took psilocybin mostly became more open, compassionate, and grounded in their spiritual roles. They reported feeling more deeply connected to their faith communities, more empathetic in their pastoral care, and more authentic in how they engaged with others. And the changes were still evident over a year later, long after the acute effects of the substance had passed. What shifted wasn’t just mood or perspective but the felt sense of purpose and interconnection. Many described themselves as more present, more patient, and more attuned to the emotional and spiritual needs of those they served. Their beliefs became less rigid, their egos softened, and their sense of service deepened. For the people around them the net result was almost universally positive. Not in a grandiose or abstract way, but in the quiet, daily patterns of being more available, less judgmental, and more aligned with what they had always claimed to teach. “Participants often described becoming more open and understanding toward others’ beliefs, feeling greater love for those they serve, and experiencing renewed clarity in their spiritual leadership.”
- flanked-evergl 1y agoI have taken boatloads of psychedelics in my life. If I could do my life over again I would have traded every single trip for having read Orthodoxy and the Everlasting Man by Chesterton before I was 25. Tripping gives you zero insights into the divine, it is not revelation, you don't get closer to God. There are real answers, but we as civilization have been deliberately moving away from under false premises, and the world has gotten worse and worse. Drugs can't fix this. If you want a better world, you should not dull your perception of it. Something that would be much more beneficial for all humanity is if more of the clergy actually preached the bible, instead of trying to explain it away, which is almost exclusively what the clergy I have engaged with tries to do.
- jwrallie 1y agoI take this book was life changing to you, would you mind explaining a bit more on why? If you read it before 25, do you think it would have the same effect, given your different experience at that age?
- flanked-evergl 1y agoPsychedelics caused me to isolate from society and those around me. It makes you feel more connected while actually becoming less connected, it makes you feel that you understand while actually understanding less. I see now that the real pleasure in life is in being connected with your local community, with those around you — not because you agree with them, not because they think or look the same as you, but because they are yours, and you are theirs in a very deep sense. I also see now that the Church of Christ makes this possible, it's a vehicle for fulfilling our purpose in life. No other thing exists which provides the same avenue, nothing else even comes close. The specific changes the books made in my life is that it helped me get over my superficial objections to Christ (I was an atheist from the age of about 14), it helped me see the whole, and thus helped me adopt Christ as my saviour, and the Church as my Church, and it brought me to a point where I have faith without doubt. > We know better than the scholars, even those of us who are no scholars, what was in that hollow cry that went forth over the dead Adonis and why the Great Mother had a daughter wedded to death. We have entered more deeply than they into the Eleusinian Mysteries and have passed a higher grade, where gate within gate guarded the wisdom of Orpheus. We know the meaning of all the myths. We know the last secret revealed to the perfect initiate. And it is not the voice of a priest or a prophet saying, ‘These things are.’ It is the voice of a dreamer and an idealist crying, ‘Why cannot these things be?’
- _1tem 1y agoBy taking drugs they immediately invalidate their legitimacy and licenses as clergy, so not sure this means anything.
- stared 1y agoI highly recommend the whole book "Sacred Knowledge" by William Richards (one of the author of the studies). “To most people who are even moderately experienced with entheogens, concepts such as awe, sacredness, eternity, grace, agape, transcendence, transfiguration, dark night of the soul, born-again, heaven and hell are more than theological ideas; they are experiences.” - Thomas Roberts This phrase is quoted in "Sacred Knowledge" by Richards, yet I find it the most suitable summary of this overview of scientific research on psychedelics and religion. We hear about mystical visions from LSD ("acid"), psilocybin ("shrooms"), and DMT from many "spiritual but not religious" people and self-proclaimed shamans. But how does it relate to vision by ordinary people (ones who never tired, and wouldn't try if it weren't for legal, scientific research)? And how does it relate to prayer, mediation, and mystical visions by Christians, Jews, Buddhists, and Hindus? How do monks and priests compare their psychedelic experience with their regular practice? Do they all turn to Zen Buddhism, or entrench in their religious background? Regardless if you are deeply religious, or a non-spiritual atheist, I believe you will reconsider a few things after reading this book.
- quickthrowman 1y agoI have taken LSD and mushrooms about a dozen times each. They’re just drugs. Drugs that mess with the way you perceive things, there’s nothing spiritual or profound about any of it. I very much enjoy hallucinogens but any ‘meaning’ or ‘spirituality’ about the experience is nonsense. I still think the experience itself has positive effects overall.
- Dumblydorr 1y agoMeaning and spirituality are personal experiences, seems close minded to deny what others avowedly profess as their true first person experience.
- quickthrowman 1y agoIt might be close minded, but it doesn’t mean I am incorrect. I’ve done enough varieties of drugs (multiple types of every class of recreational drugs) to know it’s just altering your brain chemistry to make you perceive things differently. There’s no higher meaning or purpose to tripping. Other people may believe there is, but I think they’re wrong and misinterpreting their experience due to what they’ve read and heard about hallucinogens. Staying grounded when you’re doing powerful psychedelics is a good idea. As an experiment, next time you trip, write down your ‘profound’ thoughts and then examine them after the trip is over.
- A_Duck 1y ago@dang can we change the article link to the much more detailed New Yorker article? Several comments noting the current link is a pretty thin summary https://www.newyorker.com/newsletter/the-daily/michael-pollan-on-what-happens-when-priests-get-high https://www.newyorker.com/newsletter/the-daily/michael-polla...
- stared 1y agoOr the actual paper (open access): Effects of Psilocybin on Religious and Spiritual Attitudes and Behaviors in Clergy from Various Major World Religions (2025) https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/psymed.2023.0044
- yboris 1y agoMaybe related, a book Varieties of Spiritual Experience by David B. Yaden and Andrew Newberg - the title pays homage to William James, considered the father of American psychology and author of The Varieties of Religious Experience. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/019066567X https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/019066567X
- alex-vlasis 1y agoI come from a Muslim family but aren’t deeply religious myself. My first LSD trip felt deeply spiritual and echoed themes from the paper on psychedelics and religion. Here’s what I took away, which might interest anyone curious about this topic: - Prophetic Sensation: It was so profound that, 5,000 years ago, I could’ve thought it was a prophetic vision. I didn’t feel like I was speaking to God, but I got how prophets might’ve felt something divine. - Inner Peace & Clarity: LSD brought pure joy, warmth, and peace. It stripped away mental filters, showing me the world as it is, not just how I see it. - Accepting Death: I felt at peace with death, seeing it as a natural part of life. I’d never really thought about it before, but there was no fear—just acceptance. - Divine Music: Music felt heavenly, amplifying the moment’s emotional and spiritual depth. It was like it carried the experience. - Spiritual Connection: I didn’t think about whether religions are “true,” but it felt spiritual, like touching something bigger—hard to explain, but so meaningful. - Right & Wrong Philosophy: I realized “right” and “wrong” are labels we create. Right feels like harmony, wrong like harm, but they’re fluid, shaped by context. Things just are, and we use these ideas to navigate life.
- aljgz 1y agoDude, I needed to double check to make sure this is not my comment, all the way to being born in a Muslim family. The prophetic part is spot on, I stop right here ;)
- PunchyHamster 1y agoPretty sure giving them to non-clergy eventually created clergy
- lo_zamoyski 1y ago“Almost a decade ago, a Baptist Biblical scholar, a Catholic priest, several rabbis, an Islamic leader, a Zen Buddhist roshi, and more than a dozen other religious leaders walked into a lab—and took high doses of magic mushrooms.” I seriously wonder what this Catholic priest was thinking. According to a natural law view, the reason for taking a psychoactive substance is a major component in determining whether taking it is licit. A bad intent corrupts the act. So, if I have a martini in order to calm my nerves, or choose to savor the goodness of a glass of beer, then knowing what we know about the effect of alcohol in moderation and our own personal response to the quantify in question, there is nothing wrong happening. (Catholics are not teetotalers. We like our wine.) Indeed, if you are in a state of high anxiety that impedes the use of reason, taking something to calm your nerves would be therapeutic and restorative. But if we consume alcohol in order to get drunk or buzzed, then this is morally illicit, as the intended effect — the distortion of perception and the impeding of the operation of our rational faculties — is immoral. This is because, on a natural law view, our nature is to be rational animals — to know reality as it is, which is what the senses and reason are for — and to intentionally thwart our nature, and especially that which is most essential to our humanity, our rationality, is bad for us as human beings. (It also produces emotional distortions, which are, again, something bad for us.) That is why it is an affront to human dignity to trip, and we intuitively perceive this when we see a drunk or someone who is high. They disgust us, they arouse pity in us, or, in less serious cases, we laugh at them, because the comedy is the result of them failing to be rational and thus human. The principle of double effect also tells us how and when taking a substance with harmful side effects is licit. The intent is, again, an essential component, and recreational drug use is simply never licit for that reason as explained above. The idea of using drugs to produce a “spiritual experience” is also nonsensical. That is because it isn’t a bona fide spiritual experience. It is a hallucination, a corruption and suppression of the perceptive and rational faculties which is how we come to know reality. It does not clarify our perception of reality per se, but darkens it by producing mental and emotional distortions. A true spiritual “experience”, if you want to call it that, would involved the heightened or elevated operation of perception and rationality, not their diminution. So the real McCoy is exactly opposite. That people subjectively report having gained insight is either a side effect of the hallucinogen disrupting some pattern of denial or whatever, or merely an error of perception (which is expected, as people high on drugs aren’t thinking clearly and have a poor ability to appraise the validity and value of their thoughts). True spiritual maturity is sober. Hallucination is the exact opposite of sober. It is a fraudulent ersatz, not some royal road to the divine or whatever.
- nashashmi 1y agoNo Islamic leader in their right mind would try taking magic mushrooms or any forms of intoxication. That is a red line. So I seriously doubt the experience of the person who went in and took it. Which means the question remains unanswered: how would a person of the Islamic faith describe the experience obtained from magic mushrooms? By the words of the Quran, the response is They ask you about wine and gambling. Say, “In both there is great sin, and some benefits for people. And their sin is greater than their benefit.” And they ask you as to what they should spend. Say, “The surplus”. This is how Allah makes His verses clear to you, so that you may ponder. Benefits are acknowledged, but it emphasizes the sin (likely meaning a curse aka perennial harm) is greater. My protest to the context of HN, this study furthers the idea that God/religion/belief is a mystical hallucinated idea (and does not belong any greater in rational belief than does the experience of magic mushrooms). But such equivalencies being drawn here would be hasty and ignorant and a logical fallacy. First, if Person A believes in X and Person B believes in Y and goes through an experience causing Person B to also believe in X and calls Y a similarly relevant belief, does not make Person A and Person B similar, nor does it make X and Y similar. It just means the experience is mind altering. Second, these studies observe the outcomes, describes the outcomes, and hypothesizes the empirical causes, but in the case of this study it is observing hallucinations in believers of faith and finding similarities in reasoning to their preconcieved beliefs, causing it to claim that hallucination is equal to belief.
- hshshshshsh 1y agoLot of words and blind beliefs. 0 experiential knowledge.
- thendrill 1y agoIt’s worth clarifying a few points about Islamic teachings and history regarding intoxicants. First, the Quran does not categorically declare all intoxicants haram (forbidden) in the legalistic sense often assumed. The verse commonly cited (2:219) does not prohibit wine or similar substances outright — it acknowledges both the harm and potential benefit: > "They ask you about wine and gambling. Say, 'In them is great sin and [yet] some benefit for people. But their sin is greater than their benefit...'" This is moral guidance urging caution and reflection — not a blanket prohibition. The prohibition as we know it today comes from later jurisprudence built atop evolving interpretations, often informed by societal conditions, not an explicit Quranic ruling alone. Second, many prominent Islamic thinkers in classical times engaged deeply with altered states and substances — sometimes even celebratory of them. Avicenna (Ibn Sina), arguably the greatest polymath of the Islamic Golden Age, wrote on the medical and philosophical effects of opium and other psychoactives. Other thinkers — like al-Ghazali, Suhrawardi, and Sufi poets such as Rumi and Hafiz — explored the boundaries between mystical experience, reason, and sensory perception. In some cases, this included symbolic or actual engagement with intoxicants to describe the ecstasy of divine union. The idea that “no Islamic leader in their right mind” would ever touch such substances overlooks both historical nuance and the breadth of Islamic thought — from orthodox jurists to radical mystics. The same diversity of perspective exists today. If you are interested in learning more about the topic there is a great book about it : "Tripping with Allah: Islam, Drugs, and Writing Book by Michael Muhammad Knight" Finally, equating religious belief with hallucination because both may involve altered cognitive states is philosophically flimsy. That a mushroom trip can lead someone to perceive “God” doesn’t invalidate faith any more than a dream invalidates memory. Experiences can reinforce prior belief without reducing them to mere neurochemistry. Correlation is not causation — and even if it were, that would not necessarily diminish the meaning of the experience.
- hshshshshsh 1y agoAll spiritual experiences are nevertheless an appearance in consciousness. So consciousness can generate an infinity of experiences. So no reason to think one experience is somehow more special than any other experience since all experiences passes and go no matter how profound you feel. Even profound feelings are just appearance in consciousness. Even if you die and go to heaven that's still appearance in consciousness. Even time is an appearance in consciousness. So given all that, is there anything to chase? Are we stuck here forever? Nothing to gain or loose.
- notarobot123 1y agoNihilism, not even once. It's a hell of a drug that'll wipe out all meaning and purpose from life leaving you cold, detached and suicidal. Meaning is emergent and constructed from our experience of being physical beings in the real world. Just because that's mediated through our thoughts and senses doesn't suddenly strip it of existence or relevance. Even reflecting on the nature of consciousness is contingent on so many other more fundamental lived experiences and mental abstractions. It's turtles all the way down and meaning is found/constructed in every layer.
- hshshshshsh 1y agoNo. I don't feel suicidal. Actually completely opposite. I have never been more freer. To try new things and experiences. I was not talking about meaning. I think it's a false assumption that you need meaning to have a fulfilling life. Meaning just creates a feeling. So you are really focused on the feeling and not the act itself or implications. Like you don't want to do an act which is logically meaningful and feel depressed after doing it. You want to feel good after doing meaningful act. So it's all about feeling. And not meaning.
- ecshafer 1y agoThese studies are all deeply flawed. They find willing participants, give them some drugs, then ask how they feel about it. Of course they say they feel spiritual and connected with the world and all of that, that's what the drugs do. But I know plenty of people who claim that mushrooms or lsd were spiritually awakening and connected them with the world, who wouldn't think twice about stealing from an old woman's purse, robbing people, or worse. I know alcoholics who claim they don't have a problem and think drinking is just good fun, but are also violent assholes when they drink.
- Whitespace 1y agoI did not read the study so I don't know if you're referencing a specific claim in it, but I do not understand your comment. What does being immoral have to do with TFA?
- ecshafer 1y agoThis is making the claim that psychedelics are making people more spiritual, that these are spiritual awakenings. Morality and spiritually are intrinsically linked. There is also a flaw in the research when they only ask the participants how they feel and do no outside measurements.
- kobenni 1y agoI think you are making a very important point here, but unfortunately getting downvoted for stating it so cynically. A more productive way to phrase it would be that people's self-report on a drug's effect (beyond the pure subjective experience of the trip) can be very misleading about alleged positive effects, and can be very incomplete about any negative effects.
- abeppu 1y agoFrom the results paragraph in the top of the linked journal site: > Furthermore, 42% rated one of their experiences to be the single most profound of their lifetime. > Although no serious adverse events were reported, 46% rated a psilocybin experience as among the top five most psychologically challenging of their lives. From skimming the paper, it looks like they don't do a correlation analysis between the various questionnaire responses, only between the groups and responses (perhaps correctly due to insufficient data), but I wonder: are you more likely to find the experience profound if it was challenging?
- sachin_rcz 1y agoThey are called mind altering drugs for a reason. Because you are actually somewhat aware of your mind being altered and loosening of the restrictions and rules that are created in mind for physical world. This conscious or unconscious realisation during and after the trip leaves a profound impression on you that everything is about perception.
- cozyman 1y agoLord have mercy, I reject satan and all his pomps.
- throw18376 1y agosome people should never take psychedelics. in the last few years' surge of popularity, I found that your typical psychedelic advocate* would never admit this category of people exists. they were committed to the idea that everyone can, should, and must take these drugs. this attitude is currently on a downturn, which is a good thing. people now admit that these drugs are not for everyone. however, there's little solid understanding of exactly who should avoid psychedelics. it would be good to have a more solid scientific understanding of this. i imagine psychedelic advocates (which includes many scientists working on the topic) would be wary of such research, because it seems to similar to the history of government-sponsored propaganda "science" finding exaggerated harms of various illegal drugs. however, scientific knowledge about who most likely will have adverse effects would be useful. that way people at low risk could use psychedelic drugs with the confidence that they are very likely safe. people at high risk can avoid them. this would be a great outcome. The only problem here would be that if someone chooses not to use psychedelics, this might mark them as having certain traits that most people judge negatively. For example, history of severe trauma, family or personal history of psychotic disorders, and so on. Given this, I think anyone who wants to normalize psychedelic drug use in their local community, ought to really fight to destigmatize such traits (and most communities won't accept this), or else more practically, promote an extreme commitment to privacy and personal choice. *: I don't just mean people who do drugs, I mean people who think that doing drugs is mandatory to fix various spiritual/mental problems that prevent you from being a fully ethical being.
- Centigonal 1y ago> people who think that doing drugs is mandatory to fix various spiritual/mental problems that prevent you from being a fully ethical being. I don't doubt that these people exist, but this premise boggles the mind. Does that mean fully ethical beings didn't exist outside small geographic pockets where specific cacti and fungi grow before ~1960?
- throw18376 1y agoI think they would say (reasonably accurately, tends to be exaggerated though) that traditional cultures all around the world did have psychedelic practices of one kind or another. a lot of places on earth have some kind of psychedelic plant.
- WastedCucumber 1y agoJust a little PSA for anybody getting curious about psychedellics from this post. If you have a family history of psychosis/scizophrenia etc., don't fuck around with it. Especially if you've tried before and you've felt paranoid (or same with weed) then really, it's just not for you. On the other hand, if you have some psychosis in the family tree, or felt paranoid from LSD/MDMA/THC, then try out meditation, cause you might find the divine is already close to your sober mind.
- srameshc 1y agoI don't know if I should share it here, but once travelling, I shared a smoke with a fellow traveller and I thought I could handle anything because I thought it was weed. It was something more than I know. I felt paranoid and felt everyone was watching me. I don't know how I was sane, but I decided to go and sleep and never will I dare touch anything so called weed.
- Argonaut998 1y agoIt was probably K2/Spice. The same thing happened to me as well as a panic attack and borderline disassociation. I never touched weed, real or otherwise after that.
- gchamonlive 1y ago100%, tried my best not to recommend it universally. Hope I haven't failed at that. Having said that, I used to have lots of panic attacks and dissociation episodes but with cannabis. These effects went away over time and now it just gives me the sense of relaxation. Full disclaimer I have a medical prescription for cannabis use and I do regular damage reduction routines. I also don't use opioids, cocaine, tobacco or alcohol (not anymore). I used to enjoy MDMA, but I grew disinterested in it because it makes it very difficult to rest after the sessions. So hypothesis: maybe cannabis can be used to help mitigate and treat these psychotic effects by safely exposing the user to them.
- kelipso 1y agoI’m pretty sure a heroic dose of mushrooms made me lose 20 IQ points, so…”it’s definitely not for everyone” lol.