18 ms·
Librarians are dangerous
- murrayb 2y agoFelt sure that this thread would reference Terry Pratchett, he was a man who understood the danger of librarians.
- ThinkingGuy 2y agoThis is consistent with my experience. One of the most impressive and inspiring presentations I saw at last year's HOPE conference [1] was from members of the Library Freedom Project [2]. 1. https://hope.net https://hope.net 2. https://libraryfreedom.org https://libraryfreedom.org
- cagey 2y agoEbooks and Internet sources of all forms of media have rendered public libraries moot as book providers: every person alive (in the US) has a cell phone, and most have laptops, and can with a modicum of bootstrapping access these sources, without having to travel to a special building (partially) filled with paper books, to obtain a copy of almost any book in existence. > Today’s dangerous librarians are much more. They are part educator, part tech wizard, part data analyst, and part myth-slayer. > They host storytimes, teach kids about misinformation, explain how to 3D print a prosthetic hand, and calmly help a grown man named Todd recover his Gmail password for the seventh time. All before lunch. > [Librarians] are dangerous to: Misinformation, Censorship, Outdated printer settings, Small thinking, apathy, loneliness Who asked them to play these roles? If the public school system has failed to the extent that people are incapable of using online methods to find books or other resources, or login to their Google account, why is it the role of a librarian to backfill these gaps (and for taxpayers to be forced to fund such a peculiar backfilling approach)? And some of the touted roles ("dangerous to: Misinformation, Censorship, Small thinking, apathy") are clearly social activist in nature; the meaning of all of these is in the eye of the beholder. So why are taxpayers obligated to (unquestioningly) fund people who clearly perceive their role, at least in part, as activist in nature? IMO you are welcome to engage in activist activities on your own dime, not mine. So I certainly wonder where the value is in "libraries" since, say, 2010 (and yes, I read the article). If not for "book banning" stories, I doubt librarians would be a topic of conversation. Libraries and librarians are like some weird 20th century anachronism which persists into the 21st century largely because it's part of a (by definition well-established) bureaucracy (and lobby/union).
- owl_vision 2y agoLibrarians are very dedicated, this was missed in the article. They are the first defenders against our freedom to think, read and express our thoughts. Recently, I interviewed 2 librarians for an essay about recent book banning. They are vehemently against book banning, specially classics as seen in recent media. https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill https://www.ala.org/advocacy/intfreedom/librarybill https://pen.org/banned-books-list-2025/ https://pen.org/banned-books-list-2025/ https://www.ala.org/news/press-releases/2023/03/record-book-bans-2022 https://www.ala.org/news/press-releases/2023/03/record-book-... https://www.heinz.cmu.edu/media/2023/October/book-bans-may-have-unintended-consequences-in-increasingly-polarized-united-states https://www.heinz.cmu.edu/media/2023/October/book-bans-may-h... edit: newlines to separate links
- cryptoegorophy 2y agoThis works if you actually have dangerously good librarians. I had one that could remember every single book location but she was extremely rude and treated everyone as a mentally challenged. Her daughter lived under severe dictatorship with no confidence and self esteem.
- rpmisms 2y agoI've never met a librarian like this article describes. I have met people like this in many other walks of life, but I've never met a librarian who seemed like anything but a scold with a stick up their ass.
- fknorangesite 2y agoWhy were they scolding you?
- pyfon 2y ago[flagged]
- SanjayMehta 2y agoStalin was no librarian himself but owned over 25000 books/pamphlets and invented his own classification scheme. 1. Stalin’s Library by Geoffrey Roberts 2. https://youtu.be/aa-00IN1b6g https://youtu.be/aa-00IN1b6g
- josh-sematic 2y ago> Librarians are dangerous Anybody who has been listening to “Welcome to Night Vale” could have told you that years ago.
- sghiassy 2y agoWhat if your primary way of learning isn’t reading? Are librarians still as necessary?
- GuB-42 2y agoBut don't call them "monkey" or they may become really dangerous. ... I expected more Diskworld references when talking about dangerous yet highly skilled librarians.
- satoru42 2y agoI thought the author was describing a chatbot when reading the first half of this article.
- hoseyor 2y agoIf they were actually dangerous, the regime would not be allowing them to support and reinforce the regime narrative that it wants to spread and would instead have aggressively attacked them. No, the fact that the regime has not a single time moved against libertarians tells anyone with some sense that the regime very much sees them not only as not dangerous, but useful.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- joshka 2y agoThis would make an excellent kids book...
- noisy_boy 2y agoIn my university, I spent more time in the library than anywhere else reading all kinds of books ranging from encyclopedia brittannica to religion to course books to magazines and everything else in between. I do regret not working harder on my course subjects but the decision to spent hours at the library was a life changing one which resulted in me opening my eyes to a world beyond my hometown.
- aj7 2y agoIn the stacks of the Main Branch of the Brooklyn Public Library, if you went to 612.6, you saw that a librarian had direct view of that aisle from her desk. But she was often not at that desk, so timing was involved.
- switchbak 2y agoThe last two libraries I’ve visited have been taken over by homeless … err, the unhomed. The first one had one dude watching porn and farting an impressive amount. The second one has been taken over because it’s close to a homeless encampment - becoming more of a secondary housing site and less of a library. This is in two separate cities in the PNW. I can’t even really enter into the debate about librarians since the library experience has been so entirely off putting for me. It’s most certainly not a place I’ll take my kids, even though it consumes a significant percentage of my municipal taxes. I’m envious of the folks who have a maker space-like experience, that sounds nice!
- dfedbeef 2y agoPlaces have been passing laws that prohibit people from sleeping and hanging around outside.
- dfedbeef 2y agoShelters usually close during the day, also.
- Arcuru 2y ago> it consumes a significant percentage of my municipal taxes. That's interesting, I assumed it was only a small percentage everywhere. What percentage does it consume? I live in Seattle (King County) and our library system only costs 3.5% of our property taxes. https://kcls.org/library-funding/ https://kcls.org/library-funding/
- silexia 2y agoAnd that is enormous.
- yesfitz 2y agoI hope you meant "enormous" as in "commendable" because it's a fantastic bargain compared to what they get for that money. $151,360,905 of King County's property tax revenue in 2024 went to the library.[1] From Wikipedia[2]: "KCLS consists of 49 branches, one standalone book locker, the Traveling Library Center, ABC Express Vans, a mobile TechLab, and 11 bookmobiles." "As of 2023, the library system serves a population of 1.6 million residents and has 3.7 million items in its collection . . ." "Circulation 21.5 million" And according to their 2025 budget, employs 842 people.[3] I encourage you to review those statistics, and then look at the library system's website[4] for a sample of the events, access, and services they provide. 1: 2024 Property Tax Distribution for King County, Washington: https://cdn.kingcounty.gov/-/media/king-county/depts/assessor/buildings-property/reports/annual-reports/2024/24pies.pdf?rev=c4670722e49b474d874694edb80cf13e&hash=B87146C079D57E20336B1AFC52FD6C5E https://cdn.kingcounty.gov/-/media/king-county/depts/assesso... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_County_Library_System# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_County_Library_System# 3:https://kcls.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2024/12/2025-KCLS-Budget-121824.pdf https://kcls.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2024/12/2025-KC... 4: https://kcls.org/ https://kcls.org/
- phibz 2y agoSimple: information is power. Why else would so many go so far to control it. Also librarians are some of the most overeducated and underpaid people out there. Thank you for what you do.
- ask2sk 2y agoVery well written. Thank you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- svennidal 2y agoOok
- booleandilemma 2y agoNew York City libraries are a cross between homeless shelters and daycare centers. And they're closed on Sundays.
- gamificationpan 2y ago[dead]
- cornhole 2y agoayn rand is a menace
- amol_s 2y agoSchools should include psychology, neuroscience, and some other books which help to bring courage and confidence to survive in real life problems.
- mark336 2y agoI thought you said "Libertarians"...
- Peteragain 2y agoAwwe! I teared up! 'cause it's true!!!
- lysace 2y agoI really loved the local library in the 80s/very early 90s (as a kid without network access). I probably spent like 20-25 hours per week there. Now when I visit it's always meh. They have sacrificed breadth and density for "curation" and "experience spaces". The space between the book shelves seems to have almost doubled. Why? Bring back super high dense book shelving filled with interesting stuff.
- whatshisface 2y agoMy local library on the other hand got a lot better.
- revx 2y agoProbably depends on if your local community - which includes you! - has valued (and funded) libraries. Ours is really well done.
- Goronmon 2y agoMy local library was much denser as a child as well. Except that's because the library was tiny. The denseness was a necessity and the library was constantly trying to get rid of books to make room for newer books. Thankfully they eventually replaced that tiny library with a much bigger one. And the one we live near now is also much bigger and much better. I think the kids section of the library is probably double the size of the entire library we had growing up, with more books as well.
- wnevets 2y ago> Bring back super high dense book shelving filled with interesting stuff. Sure thing but your community would have to pay insignificantly more in local taxes
- lysace 2y agoTo be crude: Books and shelvings are very affordable compared to employees. Every part of each library doesn't need to curated by a local librarian. The primary goal of libraries is to educate the public - not to employ librarians, right?
- lightedman 2y agoLibrarians are wonderful. I married one.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoHa ha, so did I as it happens.
- charlieyu1 2y agoI’ve moved to UK and I’m annoyed by lack of STEM books in libraries.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 2y agoIndeed https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_War https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_War Joking aside, librarians have always been facing so much. Kids and parents are a whole topic, but many adults coming to a public library aren't just there to spend some time, they can be at a pivotal time in their life with a specific need, and getting enough info or access to the proper resources is so critical. I still remember a clerk at our public library talking to an old lady who's husband was hositalized, and trying to guess what medical book covered the proper stuff.
- irrational 2y agoI expected this to be about the Brandon Sanderson teen series that starts with Alcatraz vs The Evil Librarians.
- mrits 2y agoI've been working in the space the last few years and what I've gathered is Librarians themselves often hate what libraries have become. The ones working in University libraries seem to enjoy their job a lot more than the ones in large cities that act as homeless shelters.
- jadar 2y agoThe tragedy of the modern library is that no one has the attention span for good books. Libraries are getting rid of the classics to make room for new books, the majority of which are not worth the paper they’re printed on. We would do well to heed C.S. Lewis’ call to read more old books for every new book that we read.
- KittenInABox 2y agoI find that old books can often take away more than they give to me. They often have outdated ideas on women or race and are usually far clumsier with depicting homeless, disabled, or sick people. Engagement with fans of old books often is a set of very sheepish defensiveness when I point these out.
- nathan_compton 2y agoYou're lucky these days if all you get is sheepish defensiveness and not revanchist conservatism.
- nathan_compton 2y agoI think this is a somewhat wrong framing, and its also shitty to blame libraries for this shift. Tech companies, for the most part, are responsible for the destruction of attention spans, if that has really happened. And I'd be happy to bet that by whatever criteria you choose to select there are more great books written per year now than in 1240 or whatever time you think they only wrote great shit. Its just that now there is much more to wade through and the media environment is totally different. At any rate, I just think that its a very strange thing to do to use "old" as a substitute for "good." There are tons of old books that are moronic and if the population of the world back then had been the same as now there would be tons more.
- jasonlotito 2y ago> The tragedy of the modern library is that no one has the attention span for old books. Fixed that to mean what you say. Luckily, people still have the attention for good books. Which is why libraries still stock good books, classic or otherwise. They also stock books that people want to read. Which might seem odd until you realize that libraries are there for the community to use. However, you are free to setup a library that stores books that no one reads.
- kmoser 2y agoI thought this was going to to be about how librarians were instrumental in forming the OSS, which helped the US win WWII (yes, this is real). https://www.harpercollins.com/products/book-and-dagger-elyse-graham https://www.harpercollins.com/products/book-and-dagger-elyse...
- romaaeterna 2y agoI have begun taking my children to the local library, and I am shocked at how bad the selection is. There are very few books of lasting value in any part of the library. Nothing of serious or intellectual interest. And were I to give a factual description of the childrens and teens sections, I would get banned by dang. This is wildly different from the collections that I grew up with, in libraries trashed now by standard publishing spam, despite having vastly more money and space than they did when I was a kid. Poorly curated libraries (though often staffed to the gills with "librarians") are a gaping cultural void and vacuum, while well-curated libraries are an important treasure. Good curation has little or nothing to do with "battling" misinformation/censorship, which in practice always seems to be about librarians championing a very bland and particular political monoculture. Good curation is the art of discerning the important, the unique, and the interesting, and avoiding the vast flows of spam that overwhelm everything these days.
- kccqzy 2y agoI don't doubt you, but in many locations you don't have to take your children to the local library. For example I lived in Sunnyvale for a long time, and yet after visiting the nearby libraries I decided to get a library card at the Mountain View public library. It doesn't matter I don't live or work in Mountain View.
- romaaeterna 2y agoIn this particular city, at least, it's cultural malaise, and one that is hard to escape just by going to another branch. That said, there are some good used bookstores out here (not the big chain stores) that have great collections.
- Amezarak 2y agoThat’s because librarians have been making a concerted effort to “deaccession” (throw them into the dumpster or send them for pulping) old books, no matter how valuable. Often this teeters into ideological territory - old books might contain unacceptable thoughts. Libraries are now seen as entertainment centers by many librarians, not as a place to educate yourself. In some places it’s particularly absurd, for example, here’s one that had the school libraries junk anything written before 2008: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/peel-school-board-library-book-weeding-1.6964332 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/peel-school-board-lib... A second awful thing is this usually goes along with the idea that “well, it’s available online” - even as those resources are lost. There’s a lot of long tail works on niche historical, scientific, and technical topics that have been lost forever, aside from the loss of serendipity from discovering this books in your library and reading them. In the past 20 years, my local library system has deaccessioned nearly every work from Ancient Rome and Greece. This is happening not just as small local libraries like mine, though, but even at large, old research libraries.
- delichon 2y agoIdeas are dangerous, librarians just stockpile and distribute them. In terms of potential energy books are more disruptive than nukes. The keepers who wrangle their power should have proportional status.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoYou could say they are the censors of the ideas that get into the library. So they should be accorded status based on that power, but there also should be accountability and transparency.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> You could say they are the censors of the ideas that get into the library. But I wouldn't. This context incorrectly implies librarians are working from a position of restricting knowledge. In modern times, librarians are working against the factions that do that. > but there also should be accountability and transparency. There is. 'Books on the shelf' is a gold standard of transparency. They are showing their work in the fullest possible measure. In short, librarians are extraordinary examples of good faith. The appropriate accountability for that is letting them do their jobs.
- AnIrishDuck 2y ago> In modern times, librarians are working against the factions that do that. A thousand times this. People who think that librarians are secretly censoring the flow of information are completely out of touch with how librarians work. Librarians take their responsibility to their community seriously. This responsibility, to them, is nothing less than presenting their patrons with all of the information (books and beyond) that they are trying to access, regardless of their personal feelings about said information.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> People who think that librarians are secretly censoring the flow of information are completely out of touch with how librarians work. Absolutely. My farthest r-wing years overlapped with my heaviest library patronage. Libraries were a space where my overactive, fault-finding radar was quiet. Seriously. Librarians have always been there for everyone.
- elashri 2y agoI used to skip school for at least two days to go to the big library in my city. I taught myself a lot of things. Did have access to books and high speed internet (by this era standards anyway) that I couldn't have or afford at home. I wouldn't encourage people to skip school to do that of course. But I owe this period of my life a lot of what I am today. Someone with interest in science and tech. I have known some of the people working there and they were happy helping me navigating the library (and grap books for the short boy who is too short for most of the shelves). I wasn't happy with how it turned out the last year when I visited.
- tianqi 2y agoA fun fact that please excuse me if off-topic: Mao Zedong was a librarian before he started the Bolshevik Revolution in China, and then he changed all of China. So it's often said in China that it's really dangerous to upset a librarian.
- deathlight 2y agoMy understanding is that Mao was a rural peasant from the distant Countryside who was looked down on and marked by his more (self declared) socialist Coastal betters along China's Coast who were contesting with the kmt and later Japanese invasion. The idea that Mao invented the communist or socialist revolution in China is laughable because that revolution had been ongoing prior to Mao's entrance into it. My understanding is that Mao was the guy that stood up and said look, the peasants in the Hinterlands are an Unstoppable Army that is going to come flooding from distant and Central China on to the coast and push all opposition aside and so Mao was basically saying that that the Communists should be attempting to position themselves as favorably as possible in relation to the rising peasant tide of discontent in China. If anything the concern is that if you say anything that the modern Chinese Communist party does not like or agree with they will disappear you to all the corners of the Earth. It is probably only in Taiwan that you could speak openly and honestly about the nature of modern Chinese history from let's say 1900 to the current day. They probably have a better accounting of what was actually going on, and that will soon be deleted by the now dominant Communist Party of China. You can see how they have treated their assimilation of Hong Kong, and Macau before them to imagine what awaits Taiwan.
- Pooge 2y agoIs it known which kind of books he read?
- tianqi 2y agoMany of his readings are mentioned here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mao_Zedong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mao_Zedong
- justanotherjoe 2y ago
- dijit 2y agoI always found it interesting how hacker culture is largely propped up on the protections society has carved out for librarians following world war 2 (where certain sections of society had been identified based on what books they had looked at). The hacker culture of “information wants to be free” is largely predicated on the librarian mantras of the same sentiment and only given protection by western europe after clear and serious abuse. Librarians are the very forefront of information access and the privacy of looking up certain information, we owe them a lot.
- nimish 2y agoLibrarians are also at the forefront of censorship and shaping information, so we also must put them under the greatest of scrutiny. We don't live in an age where access to information is limited. Curation (retrieval) is more important than ever.
- pyfon 2y agoMaybe true in 1999? But now the library is a tiny fraction of where people get information from.
- karaterobot 2y agoWhat's an example of librarians banning books? I typically see library books being removed due to regulations passed by federal, state, city councils, school boards, etc. There may be some examples out there of librarians refusing to lend out books, but I think they're pretty rare, and you may be thinking of those other groups.
- StopDisinfo910 2y agoThat’s in a lot of way a reversal. The default state of thing before World War II was very little data collection and even less aggregation. Everything pretty much started in the 30s with data processing mechanisation and World War II didn’t end with more protection. It ended with states having the tools to collect and feeling ready to use them with things like the generalisation of passports, social security numbers becoming standard. It has actually pretty much gone down hill from there since. I think people overestimate what’s appropriate to collect and misunderstand how things used to work which is why they tolerate so much monitoring.
- SamLL 2y agoIt seems relevant to this article, and its portrayal of librarians as dangerous, that the national Institute for Museum and Library Services was recently essentially destroyed by Presidential executive order and DOGE, probably illegally, its grants largely or entirely revoked, and its employees laid off. See, e.g., https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/11/trump-administration-ends-libraries-museums-grants/83028248007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/11/trum... https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/libraries/article/97563-imls-staffers-cry-foul-as-new-leadership-continues-to-slash-and-burn.html https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/l...
- paleotrope 2y agoMy local libary is great for me at the point I am at life. Clean bathrooms, 3d printers and laser cutters, video conference rooms, free videos to watch, comfy chairs, a huge manga section. Not a lot of physical books anymore. I guess I can just use an e-reader and check one out that way. No more discovery.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jruohonen 2y agoSo I kind of hastily posted this one as a follow-up: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43737275 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43737275 While librarians can be "dangerous", libraries can be extremely beautiful (or vice versa, who knows...?). When traveling, I often try to visit ones, and, of course, we have some iconic photographs of them too.
- jruohonen 2y agoSo it might have been what they call a Freudian slip... ;-)
- frostyel 2y ago[dead]
- cs702 2y agoIndeed. Power-hungry authoritarians, demagogues, and ideologues of all stripes (ethnic, religious, etc.) have always viewed books as dangerous. Just look at the long list of major book-burning incidents throughout history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_book-burning_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_book-burning_incidents Books are dangerous, because knowledge is dangerous -- dangerous to ignorance, censorship, and misinformation.
- mpalmer 2y agoLook, I love the sentiment, and the illustrations are charming. Unfortunately, the writing. It's...stilted. It's presented as a letter/email, but it reads as though the author wants you to hear someone with good comedic timing... DELIVERING IT LIKE STANDUP! But ellipses...do not translate to funnier text. The text just has to be funny! "Pauses" only enhance what's already there! > write a quippy, funny letter from a "concerned citizen" to their community highlighting the "danger" posed by librarians. said "danger" is their vendetta against ignorance, illiteracy. style should involve SUDDEN CAPS FOR EMPHASIS, ellipses...for...artificial comedic timing. But there's something more important to the style. Something being demonstrated in this very sentence. Yes - it's *short, narration-like rhythms". These shorter sentences should occupy their own paragraph. If you can replicate a blog post with a single LLM prompt, you start to wonder whether the author had the same thought.
- JasserInicide 2y agoYeah I see this kind of paternalistic condescending style of writing in many left-leaning circles. It sounds like it's geared for children but no they're actually writing for adults. They see themselves as moral beacons and they need to proselytize the stupid unwashed masses because they just don't know any better. I despise it.
- xhevahir 2y agoThe style of this blog post probably owes a lot more to the author's career as an author of kids' books rather than to his political tendencies.
- bowsamic 2y agoIt’s millennial speak
- gadders 2y agoIt's like one long Reddit post. Very cringe.
- ryandrake 2y ago
- tonymet 2y agoTreating “knowledge” in the abstract is dangerous. “Knowledge” consists of manuscripts . A book store or library is merely a curation of those manuscripts (or their copies). Librarians actually are dangerous, in that they present “knowledge” as neutral, and “more knowledge” as an unquestionable good. Nearly all librarians and book store clerks share a skewed ideology. Everyone expects a Christian, Muslim or Jewish book store to be filled with a tailored curation of books. Libraries and book stores are ironically treated as neutral “knowledge repositories”. My point is that every collection is curated according to the taste and the agenda of the curator or librarian. It is the quality of the collection that makes it good, not the volume. Librarians are dangerous because they’ve convinced the public that they are gatekeepers of knowledge, when they are actually just curators.
- StefanBatory 2y agoBecause I saw others here speak about their libraries, I will too. I'm Polish, I live in a big city. My libraries around, are, to say it mildly, awful. At best, they'll contain old school readings, some history book from communist period and old tech manuals (old as in, Win 95 guides or for tech that is no longer used). I really envy Americans in this aspect.
- ravetcofx 2y agosounds like underfunding issues, but they're trying their best with what they have. And as others have said, they are important community spaces for studying, meetups etc.
- StefanBatory 2y agonot in here - they aren't a place for that :( at best, events for primary/secondary school, and that is it and yup, they are certainly underfunded and i don't envy them, i do believe that most of them are trying to do as much as they can. :(
- gbolcer 2y agoThat was enjoyable. And the artwork doubled it.
- lurk2 2y agoThis reads like the sort of self-congratulatory articles journalists were fond of writing about themselves in the late-2010s, just as public trust in journalism was reaching an all-time low. I suspect the same thing is happening with librarians as they’ve begun to abandon all pretence of being impartial guardians of information in favor of larping as members of The Resistance. Ironically, the experts never seem to learn that you can only play this game for so long before no one cares what you have to say anymore.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoResistance against book banners has always been part of their core ideology, there is nothing new about that.
- lurk2 2y agoThey are not resisting anything.
- altcognito 2y agohttps://www.ala.org/advocacy/fight-censorship https://www.ala.org/advocacy/fight-censorship https://www.findlaw.com/legalblogs/law-and-life/librarians-find-themselves-on-the-frontline-battling-against-censorship/ https://www.findlaw.com/legalblogs/law-and-life/librarians-f... https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/03/libraries-trump-federal-funding-cuts/82598580007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/03/libr...
- FrontierProject 2y agoNothing huh? I guess I'm hallucinating a literal percentage point of the country hitting the streets every weekend.
- anannymoose 2y agoNo one is banning books, you can go buy as many copies as you want yourself and no one will come for them or you. Forced spending on garbage content is not a human right.
- trollbridge 2y agoI wish much of the lore about librarians were actually true, but these days they seem to be mostly focused on either filling up dumpsters full of old books for sale (why are they getting rid of all of the old books), stocking the shelves with DVDs (why are libraries in the movie-rental business?), or else organising things that seem to be quite tangentional to being a "library". For example, I think it's fine to take family photos or ID photos for kids... but is this really the primary mission of a library? When I need an inter-library loan of a hard-to-find book, they say they can't do it since the Amazon price of the book is over $1,000. (Of course, we all know the Amazon prices are basically made up - offering books for sale that aren't in stock, and on the chance they get an order at an outrageous price, go try and find it cheap on the secondary market.) Nonetheless, they're always asking for money - whether applying for grants, putting property tax levies on the ballot, attempting to raise sales taxes, despite the ever-decreasing levels of service, alongside requisite threats "If we don't pass this item, the library will close!!!" I view librarians as ones that completely missed the boat when it comes to their traditional domain of organising indexes to literature, which has been eclipsed first by Google, and now by AI in general.
- cryptoegorophy 2y agoDVDs? Probably incentives. They get some kind of kick backs or “points”.
- kmeisthax 2y ago> why are libraries in the movie-rental business? Because why not. Books and DVDs have similar footprint and cultural relevance.
- justin66 2y ago> When I need an inter-library loan of a hard-to-find book, they say they can't do it since the Amazon price of the book is over $1,000. That's extremely odd. My experience is that libraries will sometimes exclude their particularly rare books from the interlibrary loan system (or from lending more generally), for the obvious reasons, but I wouldn't have thought the library you're trying to use to place the request would have anything to say about it at all.
- lr4444lr 2y agoI miss the days when they shushed people. Nowadays, librarians where I go (to several local libraries) are invariably the loudest, most shameless talkers in the place.
- plemer 2y agoVaries heavily by location. But I’ve experienced the same - maddening.
- patcon 2y agoHoly shit librarians are fucking wonderful. Many of my coolest collaborators have been library science or information studies people. They are just the people I trust the most to have a sensible balanced worldview between theory and action, and with enough distance to understand the false idols of capital and power. I feel librarians so often get to be the sort of people that teachers wish they could be, if those teachers weren't so micro-managed by the state and the system
- Peteragain 2y agoOkay. The point is that someone, yes, SOMEONE, needs to make the call as to what goes on the shelves. Mien kampf? The Anachist's Cook Book? Lady Chatterley's Lover? Is is librarians who make the decision AND IT IS NOT THE SAME FOR EVERY LIBRARY GOER!!!! Yep. They consider who's asking and why. They are some of the few remaining trusted professionals, and they remain so because we think they're harmless drudges. Power to 'em!
- pyfon 2y ago[flagged]
- electrosphere 2y agoJust a comment that the library has become my "third space" these days. I am sooo grateful my local University library is open for public visitors. I visit every weekend and enjoy fast internet, a pleasant and quiet environment and can plug my laptop into one of many large desktop monitors here.
- kleiba 2y agoOn my campus, almost all institutional libraries have been closed down over the course of the last 20 years. There's still the main campus library and I went there quite a few times to work in peace and quiet. However, I have to admit that I never needed any of their books.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lurk2 2y agoThis reads like the sort of self-congratulatory articles journalists were fond of writing about themselves in the late-2010s, just as public trust in journalism was reaching an all-time low. I suspect the same thing is happening with librarians as they’ve begun to abandon all pretence of being impartial guardians of information in favor of larping as members of The Resistance. Ironically, the experts never seem to learn that you can only play this game for so long before no one cares what you have to say anymore. This comment got flagged within minutes after I had originally posted it, which is an indication of how seriously freedom of information is valued by those on the other side of this issue.
- alganet 2y agoAh! It makes a reference to Rose, the Hat (character in the Doctor Sleep movie). "My head is a library [...] you're just a fucking child". Hence the drawings looking like children homework. So, if it is an AI that wrote it, maybe it has movie script training. That would be a smart move. Movies themselves draw specific personas to the foreground of a human mind and could put them in specific moods. Or is it a human who wrote it? Maybe it was an angel. -- Ok, no movie business. Is there a difference between biblioteconomist and librarian? I think one is more akin to that notion of classifying without curating or censoring that so many here aluded to. In practice, I wouldn't know! (fun oversharing fact: I actually considered biblioteconomy as a degree). I think the post is good and kind for a general audience. It's a good message that I truly believe in. But I believe it could be harmful for those diagnosed with conditions such as Havana Syndrome, Schizophrenia and similar disorders. That is due to the fun ambiguous tone of "dangerous", which could have unexpected effects in someone going through a psychotic episode (I had one once, not a pleasant experience). There must be a better, less snarkier way of promoting literacy without creating those potential side effects.
- edverma2 2y agoWhy do people speak online as if the library is a place anyone goes to? I understand some people still go to libraries, but this cannot be considered a commonplace activity like it once was. Librarians do not hold any meaningful position in society because so few people come in contact with them.
- mpalmer 2y agoKind of the point of the post, isn't it?
- nathan_compton 2y agoDo you have kids? Virtually every parent I know (myself included) visits the library at least once a week with their kid. In my community the library is very well trafficked.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoThis sounds like some upper middle class white Boston shit. This is 1000% not the experience of most parents in America, especially the browner and poorer parts of America. Good luck getting one library attendance a year from most American children…
- badc0ffee 2y agoAre these the same American children who graduate high school without anything above basic literacy?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- riffraff 2y agoI love libraries and I credit the library of my home town for being who I am. I don't remember much that the actual people in the library did for me, beyond letting me take books at a time than was allowed. But still, they did let me do that, and asked me for books to buy. Maybe they did more for me than I thought.
- puppycodes 2y agolong live librarians
- phendrenad2 2y agoI thought this was going to be about how librarians are exposed to raw knowledge that is true goes against the current-year narrative, a.k.a. "malinformation", and librarians should be monitored for signs of wrongthink.
- ZoomZoomZoom 2y agoIt's interesting to note that at the core of Asimov's Foundation (spoiler: Va n frafr, ng gur pber bs obgu bs gurz.) was a bunch of librarians that were supposed to help restore the galaxy to order after a prolonged period of decline brought by disintegration of the galactic Empire.
- casey2 2y agoI really dislike fiction where the author tries to convince you it's real but has so many holes that it reads like more like a hastily conceived debate premise than a real work. In reality libraries are one of the most conservative classes of people, especially odd the distinction since I'm sure there are plenty of progressive minded librarians. Doesn't help that the average age gap between a reader and their librarian is greater than average life expectancy.