12 ms·
Dust from car brakes more harmful than exhaust, study finds
- xqcgrek2 2y agoWhile I'm sure brake dust is harmful, this study was done on cells in a lab (not even mice).
- helsinkiandrew 2y ago> researchers grew human lung cells in a lab and exposed them to dust from car brakes and from diesel tailpipes, finding that brake dust caused greater injury to the cells. I couldn’t tell if the study found that car brakes are more harmful than exhausts, or that car brake chemicals are more harmful than exhaust fumes - but that may not be significant because they are produced in less quantities.
- shkkmo 2y ago> I couldn’t tell if the study found that car brakes are more harmful than exhausts, or that car brake chemicals are more harmful than exhaust fumes None of these. The actual linked study found that the presence of specific metal particulates (copper, zinc and iron), which are found in modern brake dust, correlates with increase risk of asthma and allergy in kids. I'm personally wondering if the article linked the wrong article? Because the article describes the study as "researchers grew human lung cells in a lab and exposed them to dust from car brakes and from diesel tailpipes", but the linked study is a cohort study of correlation, that doesn't involve any experimental manipulation.
- perlgeek 2y agoI suspect it's even more complicated; if the particulate matter is different in size, the relative amount delivered to a human lung might depend on the distance. So if you want to model somebody being 10 meters away from the street, you might need to use different ratios than for somebody being 100m away.
- rajnathani 2y agoOne other point is that brake dust is probably larger in size than particulate pollution from exhausts, and thus the nasal and breathing passage leading up to the lungs would do a better job at filtering them over more fine-sized particulate matter.
- mbrochh 2y agoooph. wouldn't the dust particles go through a whole lot of other bodily defense mechanisms before they reach actual lung cells?
- barryrandall 2y agoNot if you're breathing through your mouth. Inhaled asthma medication has about the same consistency as brake dust.
- dweekly 2y agoI wonder if this will spur mandatory regenerative braking in all cars, eventually, as a means of reducing pollutants?
- thatcat 2y agoYou can gear down in a manual transmission ICE to achieve similar reduction effects, but I doubt they will bring back manuals.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoI have a newer automatic ICE and they use cylinder deactivation for engine braking on low speed coasting.
- oynqr 2y agoIsn't cylinder deactivation for when you are at constant speed at low throttle?
- landgenoot 2y agoThey open the exhaust valves of every cylinder while coasting. Therefore, the engine keeps running, but there is no combustion. You can see your live fuel consumption go to 0 when you lift the gas pedal on a modern ICE car.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoThat is whats always happened when you lift your pedal on a manual car at least.
- garaetjjte 2y agoCylinder deactivation is for reducing losses when coasting, not braking. You want more losses if you actually intent to slow down. Some trucks have retarder that open valves at TDC, so it dumps energy from compression instead of pushing piston back down.
- ManuelKiessling 2y agoI wonder if this means another advantage for EVs in terms of environmental friendliness.
- muchosandwich 2y agoOr even just HEV and PHEVs with slightly larger battery packs.
- lnsru 2y agoIt’s not about battery pack. It’s about size of the electrical motor.
- jeffbee 2y agoYou don't even need a huge battery pack for dynamic braking. It's the architecture of hybrid cars that allows them to regeneratively brake, even if the battery is full, by using the engine as a pump. Although this doesn't arise in practice, hybrids could dynamically brake down a grade of any length, which BEVs can't guarantee.
- sQL_inject 2y agoThat's the fly in the ointment, they're not. The increased mass and torque actually produces more tire dust than a ICE car.
- Hnrobert42 2y agoI wonder how much more. And if the increase is offset by the reduced exhaust, brake dust, oil leaks, and pollution from oil and gas production and distribution.
- vehemenz 2y agoProbably proportional to the weight difference. It's more, but either way it's an apples-to-oranges comparison.
- 2y ago
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoI think this is missing out on the big issue - tyre pollution which contains really nasty chemicals that inevitably get washed into rivers and waterways. Also, car-shaped EVs often use regenerative braking which will reduce the amount of brake dust pollution, but with their increased weight and powerful torque, they produce a lot more tyre pollution than ICE vehicles. https://earth.org/tyre-pollution/ https://earth.org/tyre-pollution/
- shkkmo 2y agoThis study is looking at the health effects, not particle count per mile of car use. A similar study looking at tire dust would also be interesting.
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoYes, the quantity and hazardous nature of different forms of pollution does need to be taken into account. Unfortunately, tyre pollution seems to be more hazardous and produced in greater quantities: https://e360.yale.edu/features/tire-pollution-toxic-chemicals https://e360.yale.edu/features/tire-pollution-toxic-chemical... https://www.theengineer.co.uk/media/mgmeqm3b/tyre-wear-particles-are-toxic-for-us-and-the-environment-0223-2.pdf https://www.theengineer.co.uk/media/mgmeqm3b/tyre-wear-parti...
- shkkmo 2y ago> Unfortunately, tyre pollution seems to be more hazardous and produced in greater quantities None of your linked studies even come close to supporting this claim. I don't doubt that tire particulates have negative health impacts on humans, but we don't really know which is worse yet.
- gnz11 2y agoThe Guardian did a piece on this two years ago: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jun/03/car-tyres-produce-more-particle-pollution-than-exhausts-tests-show https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jun/03/car-tyre...
- iterateoften 2y agoHaving lived next to a semi-main street through a smallish California coastal city without much rain it is pretty eye opening how much black dirt and junk just coat everything next to the road. Walk down the street and touch a bush or any plant leaf and get a nice black hand in the process. The plants are covered, parked cars get covered and the inside of my apartment was covered. It wasn’t until I moved out that I saw the extent of the problem. I only lived there a few years but every surface of my apartment had a coating of the same black dust. I’m now very worried my short time there considerably affected my health.
- bobsmooth 2y agoI live on the second floor near a road and my balcony furniture is always covered in black gunk.
- caycep 2y agoThere was that whole study with some additive in tire compounds, killing whole rivers of salmon until they figured out what it was
- Scoundreller 2y agoEVs can be pretty bad for tire wear, not just due to vehicle weight, but the amount of torque available (and consistently available) that leaves most ICE vehicles in the dust. Depends on driving style of course
- aaron_m04 2y agoIf you have an EV and you care about health and the environment, use regenerative braking as much as humanly possible. Hint: driving fast or tailgating both increase the odds you'll have to use the friction brakes.
- michaelbuckbee 2y ago
- deadbabe 2y agoOne solution could be to require ceramic brakes which produce far less dust and may be more environmentally friendly, and even has greater performance which EVs will need for their extra torque.
- pornel 2y agoEVs on public roads must still obey the same speed limits and common sense behavior. Having more torque doesn't mean drivers have to slam brakes like on a race track. In normal driving regenerative braking takes away most of the energy, leaving very little work for the friction brakes. Sometimes EVs even have the opposite problem — brakes rust due to very low use.
- millerm 2y agoRegenerative braking FTW!
- shkkmo 2y agoI think the article linked the wrong article? Because the article describes the linked study as "researchers grew human lung cells in a lab and exposed them to dust from car brakes and from diesel tailpipes", but the linked study is a cohort study of correlation, that doesn't involve any experimental manipulation and is nothing like that description (at least as presented in the abstract I have access to.)
- djaychela 2y ago> with their increased weight and powerful torque, they produce a lot more tyre pollution than ICE vehicles. This has been shown not to be true in a number of studies.
- prododev 2y agoCan you share them? Because physics says that damage to roads scales quadratically with weight. Not sure why tires would not experience a similar increase. At the very least, these tires are subject to higher forces due to the heavier weights of EVs. Intuitively, consistently applying higher friction forces to an object would cause higher wear.
- uxp100 2y agoThe weights aren’t really that much higher than ICE cars, but I don’t think anyone who has owned an EV would say they don’t go through tires faster. They do. How much due to weight, how much due to better acceleration, I don’t know, but they definitely are harder on tires.
- Schiendelman 2y agoThree or four years ago, yes. Newer EV specific tires don't seem to be wearing faster.
- uxp100 2y agoUnfortunately Nissan did not put such a tire on my Ariya. Good range and very quiet but very soft and only 9/32 from factory means lots of people have to replace em after 15 to 20k. I’m replacing earlier given poor snow and rain performance. They can have em back when my lease is up.
- Schiendelman 2y agoUnderstood, but that's Nissan sucking.
- jeffrallen 2y agoAnother good reason to drive electric: Regen decreases brake wear enormously.
- smm11 2y agoNASCAR and drag racing ...
- thih9 2y agoI'm conflicted about declaring something as "more harmful" in such a narrow context. The article says that human cells react worse to dust from modern brakes than to exhaust or even dust from asbestos brakes. But this ignores the impact of exhaust on city pollution, or the hazards of asbestos production process, etc. I guess this only tells us that dust from modern brakes can be dangerous and we should keep an eye on it. Which is valuable information, even if not as sensational.
- tomrod 2y agoPM2.5 is pretty bad. Implicated in exacerbating childhood asthma, heart disease, diabetes, and basically a ton of other issues. Proximity to large roads (like US Interstates) is known to be a bit higher in PM2.5.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thih9 2y agoMy point exactly; no need to compare brake dust to other things for it to sound bad.
- jlnthws 2y agoThis is the regular current taboo. Micro-dust from tires and brakes contributes to half of an ICE vehicle’s pollution, with the other half coming from exhaust emissions. The amount of this micro-dust scales with a power of the vehicle’s weight, typically between the square and cube for cars, and up to the fourth power for heavy trucks. EVs are 30–60% heavier than their ICE counterparts. Assuming all other factors remain constant, EVs thus generate more particulate pollution than ICE vehicles. This does NOT even include the environmental impact of battery production and electricity generation.
- nameequalsmain 2y agoDon't most EVs use regenerative braking though? That should offset their weight a fair bit I imagine.
- kraftman 2y agoAll other factors arent constant though: EVs use their brakes much less.
- dao- 2y agoThey have slimmer tires as well, right? I wonder though, do they deteriorate faster as their surface would carry more weight? edit: https://earth.org/tyre-pollution/ https://earth.org/tyre-pollution/ answers this, as mentioned elsewhere in this thread.
- mrtksn 2y agoHow about recuperation? Do electric cars use as much breaking as an ICE vehicle with the same weight?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- garrettr_ 2y agoEVs are heavier than similar ICE vehicles, but they also have regenerative braking, which greatly reduces wear on the brake pads. I suspect EVs produce much less particulate pollution from brake pads, but somewhat more from their tires.
- orev 2y agoThe Yale article and the paper both highlight the fact that EVs use regenerative braking and produce less dust. I was worried that this was a rehash of the astroturf campaign from a few years ago focusing on EV weight and how that was so bad for the environment because of tire and road wear. Unfortunately you need to read through the whole thing (instead of the headline and a few paragraphs) to see that information.
- akoboldfrying 2y ago>astroturf Is the much greater weight of EVs not worse for tire and road wear?
- malfist 2y agoRoad wear? Not really. Tire wear? In the strictest sense, yes. But keep in mind, a lot of those studies measured "ev" tire wear by throwing a bunch of weight into the trunk of a gas car. Not exactly the same thing. Holistically, particle emissions from EVs are lower than gas powered cars due to reduced breaking (even above hybrids) and reduced exhaust. At the end of the day, the vast vast vast majority of road wear and particle emissions are semi trucks. Not only do they weigh a heck of a lot more, but they also wear their tires until they disintegrate, when was the last time you saw an exploded tire remains on the side of the road and it wasn't from a semi?
- patmorgan23 2y agoIsn't road wear scale with the 4th power of vehicle weight? EV vehicle weight definitely moves some needles in the wrong direction. A Toyota Corolla weighs about 3,000, the Tesla model 3 weighs 3,500-4,000 depending on which model you buy. So a 16-33% increase in vehicle weight. A Corolla will do 8.1 x 10^13 'damage points' A light model 3, 1.5 x10^14 'damage points' And a heavy model 3, 2.6x10^14 So moving to EV vehicles would move the damage done by the average commuter by an order of magnitude. There are of course much heavier vehicles on the road as well, such as a standard empty garbage truck weights around 33k pounds and will do 1.2 x 10^18 damage points. So significantly more wear per mile traveled, but there are also far more vehicle miles traveled by those lighter class vehicles as well. EV are probably still a net positive, but the real solution is to stop designing our cities and transportation systems exclusively around low occupancy vehicles. Walking, biking, and transit, also need to.be options for getting around.
- BurningFrog 2y agoThink of this as a triumph of making car exhaust many orders of magnitudes safer over the last 50 years!
- m463 2y agoalternatively, this article sponsored by brake-vac, the #1 mechanics brake-change vacuum system.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoCars on roads are like 10% of all vehicle emissions. Most comes from vehicles not on roads, like industrial, farming and mining vehicles. Of those emissions, the emissions from tires and brakes have the most impact. But it is imperative that you should buy an EV and charge it with electricity from the power grid, and then take a destination trip that involves burning a giant amount of jet fuel. There is no logic.
- kazinator 2y agoHow many kilograms of brake dust does the average IC car produce in a year, versus gasoline burned? March of Dimes Syndrome here. We're entering the end of the gasoline car era. Anti-car activists need something else in order to continue kvetching, so it's down to tire and brake dusts, battery recycling and whatnot. When that is solved, it will be about the harms of exterior paint, and inhaling the "new car smell". Transportation that is not powered by one's own muscles can never be virtuous.
- quotemstr 2y ago> Transportation that is not powered by one's own muscles can never be virtuous. ... unless said transportation puts users in close physical proximity to strangers, some of whom are loud or dangerous. Such transportation is very virtuous: the more numerous, dangerous, or annoying the strangers, the more virtuous the transportation. This exception is not applicable to transportation that flies or floats.
- circuit10 2y ago> loud or dangerous This seems to be mostly a US problem, I only really see people from the US worried about this... As someone from the UK who travels on two trains and a bus both ways (6 journeys total) most weekdays to university, I never had any problems with other passengers, I guess very occasionally there might be a loud baby or something but then you can just put headphones in, and the worst thing that ever happened to my property is my bag got accidentally handed into lost property when I wasn't paying attention because I got on really early and the staff assumed it was left there from the last trip
- nntwozz 2y agoThere's a simple solution to this, just don't brake! With AI we can use predictive acceleration to stop the car just in time. Thank you, I'll show myself out.
- dang 2y agoRelated. Pretty sure there have been other major threads - if anyone can find more, let me know! Tire-related chemical responsible for salmon deaths in urban streams (2020) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41450563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41450563 - Sept 2024 (37 comments) EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after partial ban - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39746806 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39746806 - March 2024 (393 comments) Vehicle brakes produce charged particles that may harm public health: study - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39683351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39683351 - March 2024 (302 comments) Car’s tires are swirling donuts of pollution - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36660138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36660138 - July 2023 (28 comments) Pollution from tire wear is worse than exhaust emissions? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22517621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22517621 - March 2020 (319 comments)
- hristov 2y agoThis article is flat out wrong. The study they cite does not state the things the article says it states. And the study they cite certainly does not compare the harm from brakes to the harm from exhaust. The study simply says that brake dust can cause asthma and hay fever in children. There is no comparison made to the harm from exhaust. Exhaust is certainly more harmful than brakedust in the quantities one may encounter in the real world. Exhaust contains many chemicals that are actual poisons. Iron is not poisonous and copper can only be poisonous in large amounts. It is true that they can cause sensitivity and autoimmune diseases in the lungs especially in children, but this is much more remote harm than the actual poison in exhaust. Nobody kills themselves by sniffing brakes but many people have done it by closing themselves in a garage with a running car engine. (They say that is harder now with catalytic converters but it still happens).
- silisili 2y agoAnecdote related to last paragraph...20 or so years ago I drove a then 20 year old truck some guy had cobbled together. It was a real hunk o junk, rusty, the speedometer didn't work, etc. But it did have a new engine and carb, but it had no cat. It had several exhaust leaks (judging by noise). I was lucky it even had mufflers. Went through a taco bell drive thru one night that had a weird tunnel portion. It was a slow line, and even sitting in that tunnel a couple minutes, my friend and I got lightheaded and a bit teary eyed. It's scary we didn't even realize it til we got through the tunnel. That was the moment for me of realizing how awful these things are for the environment. If we have to be enclosed with our own emissions it will literally kill us, but we just blow it away in the open air as 'not my problem anymore.' I'm glad emissions are better now, and that electric has a viable path forward. Shame we weren't at this point a few decades ago.
- bovermyer 2y agoI wonder about the larger context here, though. No matter what academic studies discover or examine, the rise of anti-intellectual culture suggests that we as a species are going to need to pivot to documentary efforts, in a hope that what we learn in isolation now survives to be acted on in a future, more exploratory, generation.
- lolinder 2y agoWe could also try to fix the anti-intellectual culture instead of just griping about it and/or retreating. It didn't emerge out of thin air, it emerged as a reaction to a mostly-accurate sense among non-intellectuals (i.e., the people who make most of the world actually work) of being constantly condescended to by the intellectual class. What we need isn't to go all prepper for some kind of dark age, what we need is a new breed of intellectual that actually makes an effort to understand what life is like for the 65% of the population without a 4-year degree and then attempts to bridge the gap rather than trying to run the world from within a filter bubble.
- bovermyer 2y agoWhat you suggest is worthwhile. But it shouldn't be our only card. Let's do both.
- staplers 2y agoWe could also try to fix Not gonna happen with lobbyists and shareholder corps benefitting from an intellectually stunted populace. The unregulated economic system incentivizes this.
- lolinder 2y ago> intellectually stunted populace Case in point. Go out and meet some of these people and then report back.
- staplers 2y agoYou know nothing about me or where I come from. You're not making the point you think you are. You can lead a horse to water. It's not my job to encourage intellectual rigor. It's political leadership's. Pushing that burden onto imaginary everyday philosophers you've conjured up is futile.
- oftenwrong 2y agoAccording to this 2020 paper, "resuspended" particulate matter may be a major, previously unaccounted-for contributor to pollution from roads. https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/17/8/2851 https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/17/8/2851 >Traffic-related resuspended dust is particulate matter, previously deposited on the surface of roadways that becomes resuspended into the air by the movement of traffic. >Results show that the inclusion of resuspended dust in the emission and dispersion modeling chain increases prediction of near-road PM2.5 concentrations by up to 74%. The weight, speed, and volume of traffic, are therefore considerable factors even beyond the pollutants the vehicles leave behind.
- johnea 2y agoAnother argument for regenerative braking.
- wat10000 2y agoThis sounds similar to claims that cancer rates are increasing. Which is to say that it may be true but it’s a symptom of improvements. Cancer rates are increasing because people are living longer and dying less of other things. Similarly, a huge amount of work has been done to reduce the harms from car exhaust, and modern vehicles burn really cleanly. It’s no surprise that other factors start to become relatively more important.
- dv_dt 2y agoCancer rates are increasing in younger people in many types of cancer, likely due to increasing pollution. Some types of cancer are being seen in increasing numbers due to more people living longer.
- datavirtue 2y agoWhen I worked as a mechanic I had to chisel this stuff out of my nostrils each night.
- Synaesthesia 2y agoOh and automotive tyres cause rubber to accumulate in the ocean. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/25/tyre-dust-the-stealth-pollutant-becoming-a-huge-threat-to-ocean-life https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/25/tyre-dus... There are just so many arguments for public transport over cars where possible.
- fromMars 2y agoWhen I hear someone's brake's squealing, I try and avoid them at all cost. I've been behind an old car that when it braked, I was coughing for hours afterwards.
- crazygringo 2y ago> For the study, published in Particle and Fibre Toxicology, researchers grew human lung cells in a lab and exposed them to dust from car brakes and from diesel tailpipes, finding that brake dust caused greater injury to the cells. That seems like an overly narrow way of defining harm. E.g. what if brake dust is bad for your lungs but your lungs can repair the damage, but diesel fumes are harmful to your brain and the damage is permanent? I'm not saying that's the case (I have no idea), just that studying lung cells in a lab doesn't tell you anything about the full-body harmful effects.
- jimnotgym 2y ago>This limits the need for conventional brake pads. Sure this limits the wear, but not the need! Can we get rid of EGR and DPF now, and go back to diesels that worked better?
- smegsicle 2y agostop signs considered harmful
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoI wonder whether washing streets, especially in summer when it doesn't rain as often, would solve two problems at the same time: urban heat islands (through evaporation) and dust spreading around the streets (washed away).
- more_corn 2y agoElectric cars generate significantly lower brake dust levels due to regenerative braking.
- MagicMoonlight 2y agoEnvironmentalism really is just a slippery slope ideology. We have electric cars that don’t pollute and are an amazing experience… but oopsy woopsy they have tires so I guess we need to ban them too. Might as well just keep people burning diesel because the electric cars aren’t ideologically pure enough. How about we just solve the actual problem first? The planet is burning. People used to burn coal indoors for heating, that’s way more fucking harmful than 1 micron of brake dust.
- hulitu 2y ago> Dust from car brakes more harmful than exhaust, study finds Since 60 years. But they just found out today. /s Money well spent.
- fdb345 2y agoThis has been known for years.
- khelavastr 2y agoPartially fraudulent. These researchers look at green power without looking at emissions increases from heavier batteries.
- 486sx33 2y agoCeramic brakes are great!