20 ms·
We all took the DVD boom era for granted
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 2y agoWhat I don't like about DVDs (I have a lot of them) is it's always a crapshoot if they play, or if they play for a while and halfway through the movie it sputters and hangs. The disk is pristine. Sometimes taking it out and putting it back in will get it to work, trying it in a different player will work, arggh. With streaming, you click on it, and it plays.
- kalaksi 2y agoMaybe your player is going bad. And blu-ray may be more resilient than DVD if memory serves. My experiences with streaming vary. - You need multiple services with the accompanying headaches. - some content will still get yanked - if you don't subscribe to netflix for 6 months they delete your account and you lose lists you had - quality can be poor depending on circumstance. Even with something like chromecast 4k, netflix doesn't offer way to enforce 4k quality but seems to decidw by itself. The picture looks bad with no way to tell why.
- WalterBright 2y agoI have several players, they all behave differently wrt which DVDs make them crash. You're right that the bluray players tend to be more robust, but they still randomly crash. I just bought the complete Dynasty series, about 200 episodes (so sue me over my bad taste), and so far about 5 of the episodes won't play all the way through.
- mrguyorama 2y agoBuy a $12 DVD drive for a computer, download handbrake, and never care about any media problem ever again. I have never experienced a problem with DVD playback that wasn't obviously caused by extreme scratches. I don't even understand how a DVD player could "crash" in most cases. They are just a pipe from a DVD drive to an ASIC that hasn't had to change in 20 years. There's nothing to crash. "Bad" data either fails a checksum and skips or will give you weird microblock artifacts. Are these actual DVD players or some sort of weird computer system that software decodes DVDs?
- WalterBright 2y ago> Are these actual DVD players Do you want a photo of them? :-) Sheesh!
- zeta0134 2y agoUnless anyone else in the house is doing anything at all on the internet. Then the stream has weird hitches and pauses, it buffers occasionally, and it'll "seamlessly" switch between glorious 4k and half-baked potato quality at random. Sorry did I suggest other people in the house were a requirement? Nah, it just does that anyway. Too many points of failure between the endpoint and the provider, and way too much distrust that the user may try to capture the footage once they have it, to solve all of the above problems, because the license holders don't like that.
- maccard 2y agoBearing in mind I only live with one person, and I'm lucky enough to live in a place with ample internet options, but this just isn't a problem for me. I've got gigabit fiber now, but in my last place I had 76mbps (but in practice it was more like 60 or so). We were able to watch two streams, with my wife's instagram and my reddit scrolling comfortably. The only reason we upgraded was when we moved 1) fiber was cheaper, and 2) I changed jobs and all of a sudden needed to download far more build files (hundreds of gigabytes a week) If we had 4 people streaming different things we might have struggled.
- astrange 2y agoYou probably have bufferbloat. Run https://www.waveform.com/tools/bufferbloat https://www.waveform.com/tools/bufferbloat
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xnorswap 2y agoYou have a bad DVD player and good internet. Lots of people have the opposite: crummy internet where there's no guarantee that they'll get through a streamed movie without buffering issues. On the article itself: indeed sometimes I enjoyed the directors commentaries as much as the films or shows themselves. In particular Requiem for a Dream, where the director's commentary adds a lot of context.
- Contax 2y agoI've watched Requiem for a Dream a couple times and you got me curious about the commentary, so I'll try to get a copy. Thanks for the unexpected tip.
- WalterBright 2y agoI hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
- WalterBright 2y ago> You have a bad DVD player As I mentioned, I have accumulated several DVD players over the years (different brands, even a blue ray), and all of them exhibit this characteristic. The only commentary I've enjoyed are the Eddie Mueller ones commenting on film noir. I'll watch the movie, then re-watch it with Eddie. Good stuff!
- layer8 2y agoThat’s odd, unless maybe you always bought very cheap players. I owned half a dozen players over the years, played a 4-digit number of discs, and barely ever had any playback issues. With streaming, on the other hand, I have intermittent hangs and stuttering every few weeks, and navigating the video is worse than with physical discs (no chapter stops, skipping forward/backwards often takes longer to resync/rebuffer the stream), switching subtitles and audio language takes more steps, and other inconveniences.
- WalterBright 2y ago
- eimrine 2y agoMy computer illiterate friends use to ask me to download this or that movie for them from torrents. I don't use streaming because I dont like proprietary software, but seems that there is not every movie on those services, also some kinds of censourship use to deplatform the content from time to time. From my experience, licensed CD and DVD plays well, music CD plays excellent even if it looks too scratched to be good, but any self-burned disc from 00s is a lottery and typically requires some error-recovery software to be read.
- WalterBright 2y agoI don't have trouble with CDs playing, even badly damaged ones.
- cladopa 2y agoYou should have invested in a good quality player. One with lots of buffer memory, and hardware acceleration of formats. People bought the cheapest they could find and then they ranted. At first good players were very expensive but then they became just a little more expensive that bad ones.
- WalterBright 2y agoI have several, different brands, different years. None will play all the dvds.
- guappa 2y ago> With streaming, you click on it, and it plays. Unless your provider or server is running low on bandwidth, then it stutters or lowers the quality :D With both disks and internet my method is to copy the entire content locally before watching it. I do it even for youtube videos (also because the browser doesn't prevent screen dimming but the video player does).
- cladopa 2y agoI didn't like DVD. Those screens and advertisements that only made you loose time. I used those to "learn" French and German and the subtitles never matched what was said. When you are advanced in the language you don't care, but when you are learning it is a big flaw. The DVD usually only had English (and another one) audio tracks, subtitles in several languages, but not audio. You had to buy another DVD from Amazon.de or something, when it was way harder than today. I find arcade games or classics like Sonic or Mario, brilliant, even today. Sometimes the emulator is not properly setup: Nobody saw individual pixels on CRT screens.
- guappa 2y agoEh at least on linux you could skip the ads. On windows or hardware players it was annoying. Not that VHS didn't have ads. I remember my little mermaid VHS that had a few minutes of promo for disneyland before starting.
- doublerabbit 2y agoYou still had the copyright warning: "this video could be a fake, mum the quality is all fuzzy, check for the shiny sticker thing" on Disney movies. But at least you could skip past it.
- guappa 2y agoIt was typing the warning letter by letter, slowly.
- astrange 2y agoSubtitles aren't designed to help you learn the language, they're designed to entertain you. They'll often be shortened or translate jokes so locals will understand them, and that's unavoidable.
- grahamlee 2y agoIt seems to me that the extra features on DVD were originally part of the marketing benefits driving people to adopt the format because the studios preferred it to VHS because of CSS and region-locking. Then they found they had painted themselves into a corner making all these extra features that people came to expect, until finally streaming let them get back to “just the movie”.
- guappa 2y agoVHS were dubbed… no need to do region locking.
- eru 2y agoSome VHS were dubbed.
- dspillett 2y agoMany VHS were subbed instead. Sometimes two versions of a popular film were released, one dubbed and one with baked-in subs. This did limit the desire to copy between regions a bit, though not as much as you might think given how many people speak one of a few languages as a second language. I suspect the cost of physical distribution and good copying equipment was the key issue until fairly late on in the life cycle of VHS as a common tech. Region locking just wasn't thought of because by the time it might have made significant difference other limitations of tape based media format were readily apparent and new systems were being designed and implemented.
- gapan 2y agoDepends on where you live. In Greece, I don't think a single movie other than kids cartoons were ever dubbed on VHS. Everything was subbed. On the other hand, in Germany or Poland, almost everything was dubbed.
- zorked 2y agoIt makes no difference. The question is if a Greek customer would buy a subbed movie from Lithuania for example.
- incorrecthorse 2y ago*Cinephiles took the DVD boom era for granted The reason it ended is because the general public doesn't care.
- openrisk 2y agosince when is the "general public" arbiter of wisdom? The masses will embrace anything that smacks of short term convenience and will tolerate enormous amount of abuse because caring for anything actually requires effort. This starts with thinking, collecting objective information among the torrents of marketing and misinformation, agitating for your rights and (horror, horror) even sacrificing immediate gratification. Because the general public "doesnt care" we are in a world you can own nothing, control nothing, repair nothing, keep nothing a secret, do nothing without going through gatekeepers. In short, idiocracy.
- browningstreet 2y agoThey're not the arbiter of wisdom, they're the arbiter of commercial success & market viability, which is always a bell curve to the bottom (see Stanley Cups and cupcake, boba, and dumpling retail [in the US]). I worked in the film industry, in DVDs, at the height of that market. Sales of DVDs tumbled. End of story. There was nothing for the studios to do because the ROI was dead, and their previous efforts (which were terrible natch) to manipulate the DVD market (cheaper, limited play product) were dumb. DVDs were great, streaming ate their lunch. Calling capitalism's market economics an idiocracy is.. tautological.
- openrisk 2y ago> Calling capitalism's market economics an idiocracy is.. tautological. Thats definitely not true. The most ardent and smart defender of markets argued that they operate and optimize within the boundaries that society decides. If you legislate that people should be able to repair, own, exchange etc. stuff then markets will deliver exactly that. If you let them race to the bottom thats also exactly what you will get.
- p0w3n3d 2y agoI still prefer to own movies I like and I have many of them. (no, not SO many as YOU have, my adversary). I think that having them will allow me one day to stop paying constantly more and more expensive subscriptions. By the way, for me, the DVD standard was very strange. I think that the engineering industry works differently than IT/CS guys. They think of "a product" which consists of the medium AND the "protocol" i.e. file format in this case, and they are inseparable in their (engineers') heads. When new codecs were created, the DVD could have been enhanced in terms of better quality, as normal DivX would allow maximally better quality on 4.7G (instead of 7GB available to DVD publisher). But when I am watching DVDs I find the low quality disturbing, and playing the interlaced movies (Futurama for example) without a decent player makes me nauseous. I would even think of converting them and storing on my local cloud but without decent player (like Cyberlink which was removing the interlacing) this looks like crap... Also probably today some AI upscaling would be nice... but I think I am asking for too much...
- p0w3n3d 2y agoAlso, DVD is still a standard in medical imaging, which baffles me, because many people do not own drives anymore, but I think this is as close to "owning your own test results" as possible. I cannot imagine someone saying "sorry, you have not extended your subscription to our health-cloud and your results are gone"
- soulofmischief 2y agoWhen I was 15 I discovered that my local doctor lost all of my medical records. Poof, all gone. Whoops, next patient please. My last doctor no longer had a copy of my files, either. I had to receive all of my vaccinations again over two sessions before attending public school.
- DoctorOetker 2y agodid you by chance undergo any operation you never consented too?
- 2y ago
- soulofmischief 2y agoOn the other hand, the rise of longform independent games and film journalism/criticism on YouTube has filled the gap pretty well. The other aspects of DVDs, the materialism/commercialism, DRM, I don't miss. My ideal consumption format is a fucking file.
- cubefox 2y agoI'm pretty sure DVDs didn't have any DRM. Netflix & Co do.
- aspenmayer 2y agoMemories of dumping, patching, and reflashing my DVD drive firmware to make it region free thanks to resources such as Doom9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doom9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doom9
- gadders 2y agoOr on some home DVD players, making them region free by typing a sequence of buttons on the remote control.
- weinzierl 2y agoLater reflashing blue-ray drives to rip 4K.
- aspenmayer 2y agoMakeMKV and the LibreDrive firmware ftw
- maccard 2y agoMy biggest gripe with DVDs is how loud they are. There's nothing worse than being in the middle of a quiet scene in a movie and hearing the drive spin up.
- actionfromafar 2y agoYou should try LaserDisc :)
- acuozzo 2y agoMy Pioneer LD-S2 is silent during playback.
- 23B1 2y agoNot to mention streaming/digital media is going to kill off actually good movies and content. This isn't the technology's fault mind you, but the streamers' business model, but you could rely upon residuals via DVD sales for movies back in the day and that money is gone, which eliminates the safety margin required to take risks. It's why I can't stand the 'information wants to be free' argument. Where the hell do you think that intellectual labor required comes from, the aether?
- liontwist 2y agoThe market for low budget DVDs would still be smaller without streaming because the entertainment market is more competitive.
- mindslight 2y ago> It's why I can't stand the 'information wants to be free' argument. Where the hell do you think that intellectual labor required comes from, the aether? Assuming your goal is to understand - yes, that thinking is a product of time when people were altruistically publishing very high quality content on the web. The time before adspam, blogspam, llmspam, etc. You could punch queries into search engines and find no-nonsense sites with detailed information, not trying to sell you anything but rather just wanting to be the most complete resource about a certain topic. I'm not saying that ethos works for million dollar movie production. But on the other hand the ethos of people needing to be paid evidently doesn't work for high quality informational content, given that it has all but disappeared in the torrent of commercialized/intermediated spam.
- Pet_Ant 2y ago> 'information wants to be free' This wasn't meant to be a moral argument. It's not the information yearns for liberation and we ought to provide it. It's a physics analogy. Like a ball 'wants' to roll downhill. Free is the lowest entropy state of information.
- karles 2y agoI have reverted back to owning movie-media again. I like watching movies, and thus, I have watched a lot. When I try to find a movie to watch on HBO/Netflix (I'm from Scandinavia - not the same selection as in the US), I have a hard time finding something to watch. A lot of newer movies doesn't cater to my taste. On the other hand, I can find a lot of classics from the 80s/90s/00s and even 10s in thriftstores for as little as 1-3$. I then get to keep the movies, that I often end up rewatching, and I get the added features mentioned in the article. I'm not to nostalgic about the cases, which I often just dump (I have considered keeping the fact-sheets though, just not the plastic casing). I'll soon cancel my remaining subscriptions, and only purchase them a month at a time when something I truly want to watch arrives...
- jbaber 2y agoOpinions from a DVD connoisseur (Angry Video Game Nerd): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VsdzaEVeFEE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VsdzaEVeFEE
- alt227 2y agoId love to hear his retrospective of DVDs from the streaming era.
- dzonga 2y agohope physical media makes a comeback. one thing with dvd era - it allowed small scale / budget movies to made. movies that were not blockbusters but allowed art exploration.
- liontwist 2y agoThat opportunity was a result of unmet demand for cheap entertainment, and only slightly by the medium. I’m sure that’s filled by YouTube, etc.
- alt227 2y agoThe problem there is discovery. When someone local to you made a low budget film or documentary and released it on DVD, you would see that for sale in your local stores and gas stations. Now if people put that stuff on youtube it just gets lost in the noise and rarely will get the local exposure it once would have.
- NoPicklez 2y agoAren't small scale / budget movies more available now? I don't need to make a DVD I can just upload it online They don't need to consider making DVD's and shipping them all around the world in the hope people will buy them. There is so much content we consume that is made by small productions that likely wouldn't have been seen my many around the world unless they managed to get their hands on the DVD.
- sourcecodeplz 2y agoWhy bother with DVDs when you have torrents and russian streaming sites...
- doublerabbit 2y agoI enjoy watching movies without having to wait four hours to download a Blu-ray rip on my 2mb ADSL. "I feel like watching a movie, NAS" vs "I feel like watching a movie, ETA: 4 hours" And besides my TV is dumb enough that I'm proud of it. It supports DNLA and works well.
- anentropic 2y agoJust plan ahead and download it before you want to watch it
- doublerabbit 2y agoBut that just ruins the spontaneous movie watching experience you get with DVDs.
- mikedelfino 2y agoSurely you mean the spontaneity after you have actually bought the DVD.
- doublerabbit 2y agoThat, or rewatching a pre-watched film for comfort. Not every movie needs to be new. I rewatched Firefly on the whim the other week and now Malcom In The Middle because I own them on DVD. Not available anywhere else digitally, at least with my subscription's.
- anentropic 2y agoif you watched it before you already downloaded it...
- cubefox 2y agoThat fact that all the bonus material on DVDs (documentaries, audio commentaries, story board drawings etc) was hardly appreciated at the time until it went away in the Netflix era is something that also reminds me of movie awards. Many film classics were only really appreciated years later, and we are left to wonder why they didn't won an Academy Award at the time while some other totally unremarkable movie took it instead. I think it's this: Often we assume that certain things (e.g. certain types of movies, DVD extras) just will be as good or better in the future, and often they do, but if they unexpectedly get worse, we realize that we did hit a high water mark in the past without noticing at the time.
- MrVandemar 2y agoThe Academy Awards are a poor indicator of movie quality, largely because the process is flawed and prone to all sorts of bias. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academy_Awards#Criticism_and_controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academy_Awards#Criticism_and_c...
- cubefox 2y agoThe phenomenon (underappreciating classics at the time) also occurs elsewhere, e.g. Blade Runner failed at the box office.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoI wish there were a way to just pay for a movie on a site and download it as an mp4 in 1080P or 4K. I hate streaming because I only want to watch 1-2 movies per month and they are very specific (like a specific martial arts movie or action movie). Streaming interfaces often have DRM and horrible interfaces and I don't want to pay a monthly fee for something I'll rarely use. Don't understand the DRM because pirates get a better copy anyway. Right now, there is no better and more convenient interface than piracy and I wish that weren't the case. Edit: there is such an interface for classical music, e.g. Hyperion. DRM free and one-time payment, and I've used it a lot.
- goosedragons 2y agoThere are places that still let you download movies like iTunes. They are of course riddled in DRM so it's not much help...
- vouaobrasil 2y agoyeah...I just want to pay for a DRM-free copy so I can play it and own it forever. That's it. No streaming accoounts, no tracking, no plastic packaging, just the file in exchange for money. I paid for Sublime text that way and it's a great model.
- episteme 2y agoSounds great, how do you propose stopping people from sharing that mp4 with the world?
- zild3d 2y agoI used to borrow my friends' VHS tapes. Trying to stop people from sharing is barking up the wrong tree, just make it easy enough for people to do the right thing that sending a large file around and getting it to play on their TV seems like a pain in comparison.
- 2y ago
- xtiansimon 2y agoDVD extras are the best! (And nearly required if you’re an art film fan).
- pro14 2y agohave you noticed that the quality of movies has been progressively declining? i think it's because the pirated movie boom ended. there was a theory that DVD movie piracy increases the box office revenue. bring back movie piracy?
- gwbas1c 2y agoI think it's because there's more movies made today than in the past. The streaming boom has lowered the barrier to entry. Also: There's always been bad movies, we just tend to forget them.
- shadowerm 2y agoThis is not correct. The loss of DVD sales has changed the type of movies that are being created. Matt Damon himself has explained how Good Will Hunting would not get made today because of this. It is really simple too if you think of yourself as the investor in the film getting pitched. "Will Hunting, a genius-level IQ but chooses to work as a janitor at MIT. When he solves a difficult graduate-level math problem, his talents are discovered by a professor" Only an idiot would invest in that in 2024 but we are way past that. I imagine no one would even bother pitching that at all in 2024. Certainly wouldn't get a meeting with anyone. There was a golden era of film not long ago and that era is gone forever. The Fountain might be the best example though. I love that movie but it lost millions of dollars even at the height of the golden era. The future is going to be AI Batman vs Superman part 276.
- prmoustache 2y agoI think with the success of streaming series have become more interesting to streaming platforms as their addictive nature can lock people more easily into a platform for a specific period of time. For this reason budget and revenues of series have increased dramatically and series are more and more produced like movies. This probably created an artistic and talent shift from movies to series. There were a lot of shitty movies too back in the days but some never even reached the theaters and were only sold on VHS and DVDs.
- 2y ago
- codedokode 2y agoThe problems with streaming services: - they do not allow anonymous usage (you need to provide a visa application worth amount of personal information) - stupid geographical restrictions - they tend to limit quality, both for copyright and traffic saving purposes As an intermediate result, a generation of people is growing who got used to watching digitally compressed audio and video (social media, especially for mobile platforms, use even worse compression). And new Apple headphones seem to use lossy compression as well, so we have a codec compressing another codec's artifacts.
- bamboozled 2y ago- You need to subscribe to ten different services rather than just having one subscription to see the thing you want to watch. Before you just needed a DVD player
- alt227 2y ago> Before you just needed a DVD player However you also needed to physically buy a copy of every movie you want to watch, instead of signing up for one service and having access to thousandsd immediately.
- robohoe 2y agoYes, and a lot of movies on DVDs cost $10-15
- vel0city 2y agoWhen DVDs were new, a new release around me would often be more like $25-30. Boxed sets would often be $50+. Of late 90s/early 2000's money, so $30 back then is like $55+ today.
- sumtechguy 2y agoI own lots of DVD's. DVD day was my jam. Most new releases were 20. Sometimes if they were some sort of special collectors edition they would be 25. Then usually after a few months on the shelf they would come down to 15-18. After that the bargain bin. Bluray/HD started around 25-30 when they came out. Box sets were usually like you say 50+ some as much as 200.
- rob74 2y agoStange that the article opens with a picture of the The Matrix DVD, but then doesn't mention it in the text. This was actually the first DVD I bought (even though back then I didn't have a DVD player, just a DVD drive for my PC) and spent hours exploring the extras. Looks like I wasn't the only one who was impressed: https://theextras.buzzsprout.com/1781599/episodes/9714540 https://theextras.buzzsprout.com/1781599/episodes/9714540
- alsetmusic 2y agoPink Floyd’s “The Wall” had extra menus that I couldn’t reach with a remote but could click with a mouse. I genuinely thought it was a bit unkind to fans who couldn’t access them on a tv.
- alt227 2y agoMaybe other DVD player remotes allowed those things to be accessed?
- tantalor 2y agoSame experience; I recall being disappointed with the extremely greeniness of the Matrix on DVD, to the point I thought my monitor or computer were busted.
- gwbas1c 2y agoOne of the turning points for me was when the extras went from captivating to drivel: Extras used to be based on promo videos that you'd find on 1990s cable TV; for example, a promo that would be on the Disney Channel or Nickelodeon to get you into the theater. Later, the extras turned into something that an intern would slap together, with a bunch of people involved with the movie back-slapping each other. I stopped buying DVDs around 2005-ish: With BluRay coming around, and everyone saying that film was closer to 4k, why would I want to invest in a disk, only to need to rebuy it in BluRay and then 4k every few years? I also realized that most movies I only watch once, so streaming makes a lot more sense. Now that I have a 4k player I've gone back to buying 4k disks if I think I'll re-watch them.
- fidotron 2y agoNot mentioning the non-skippable anti piracy noise that ironically made the legit product worse than the pirated one poisoned the well for interactive features later on Blu Ray. Who cares about getting extras if they are hidden behind obnoxious menus and abusive junk when the Internet will tell you anyway? That said I remember that era fondly because of things like the Tartan output. In the UK if you had a multi region player (and many did) you could get stuff from all over the place, on top of the local but now forgotten play dot com.
- hx8 2y agoIf I recall correctly these anti-piracy statements were like 10 seconds out of 2 hours of runtime. Hardly makes the product poisoned.
- fidotron 2y agoIf only. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_Wouldn't_Steal_a_Car https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_Wouldn't_Steal_a_Car That sound this made as well, not conducive to sitting down to be entertained. It was deliberately obnoxious.
- Retric 2y agoSlightly annoying everyone watching a movie in exchange for putting out their little bit of propaganda, doesn’t make it useless but it does make it worse. Enshitificstion isn’t about companies making products worse because they don’t like their customers it’s just they have different interests. Thus shelf life is generally favored over taste etc.
- darknavi 2y agoExperience matters, especially for consumer goods like media. Unskippable notices about piracy that are only shown to people who have pirated is silly and clunky. You can probably tell this by the fact that none of the streaming services show something similar. This will sound very silly, but one of my favorite features of my Tesla Model 3 is that it doesn't stall the screen for 5-10 seconds every. single. time. you get in the car reminding you to drive safely and to pay attention to the road.
- tom_vidal 2y agoHow in the world can you have a discussion about DVD packaging and special features without mentioning the Lord of the Rings trilogy extended edition box sets? Not only did the movies come in beautiful collector’s cases with two DVDs per movie, they were also completely packed with special features, the run time of which exceeded that of the movies themselves. Hours and hours of in-depth making-of documentaries. I used to watch the special features for all the movies in a row when I was home from college during the holidays. Probably because before the advent of streaming, this was the longest, highest-quality content I had access to. But the special features themselves… man. Getting to see the craft of filmmaking and propmaking was one of the biggest inspirations for me in pursuing a career as a maker. That was the first time in my life anyone had pulled back the curtain to that extent on what it took to create something as complex and powerful as Peter Jackson’s LOTR. You could tell the profound love and dedication that went into every inch of that film. To anyone who was involved in creating those special features and deciding to include them in the extended edition box sets, thank you.
- navbaker 2y agoI absolutely consider the EE discs to be the canonical version
- justinator 2y agoI consider the books to be canonical, honestly.
- gjsman-1000 2y ago+ 1 Here. I can hardly sit through The Two Towers, extended or otherwise, without cringing constantly at nonsensical plot changes. No, Faramir was not a moody nihilistic relativist who changes his entire outlook without any character development. No, there was no alliance, and getting from Lothlorien to Helm's Deep in the span of a few weeks, with a full army, is physically impossible even if the army were already assembled. (This was only in the movie after a last-minute cancelled attempt to turn Arwen into a warrior; seriously.) No, Treebeard didn't spend 2/3s of the book stalling. No, Frodo did not offer a wringwraith the ring, even for a second. And if he did, there's no way he would've survived afterwards. And on, and on...
- stevanl 2y agoFWIW my uncle still runs cinemaparadiso.co.uk - the last DVD rental service in the UK and possibly wider afield, in case anyone would like to explore the catalog.
- tmm 2y agoI wish Kaleidescape[1] was more affordable. It's a download rather than streaming service, with a comprehensive movie library (12,000+ titles) and you buy movies individually rather than a monthly subscription. But then you can watch the movies as many times as you want and they don't disappear from your library if Kaleidescape stops carrying them. I don't know if they include the extra content typically available on discs or not. You have to buy their player ($4,000) and their media server ($5,000 for 8TB up to $27,000 for 96TB). Then buy movies (about $9 - $30 depending on how new they are). If you have the money, you can buy a pre-loaded system for $98,000 which includes their entire 4k library (only about 2000 movies), two 96TB storage arrays and a 4k player. If the player was around $2,000 and I could use my own storage, I'd have bought one already and ditched all the streaming platforms. Edit: looking through their library, some titles do include extra content (special features, deleted scenes, music videos, etc). [1] https://www.kaleidescape.com https://www.kaleidescape.com
- ndileas 2y agoThat's really cool that it exists / is possible. Maybe someone will create a similar service that undercuts them - but I would imagine the licensing agreements somewhat require them to do drm with the player / media server. 9k entry cost is going to keep essentially everyone out of the market - and much of that sounds like total bs costs, in no way related to the cost of the components.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoWow! Imagine the margin that makes for the seller...
- throwaway743950 2y agoDon't you get the majority of that with buying movies from Apple? You can get 4K and Dolby Atmos. If there's DRM anyway, it seems like the difference isn't worth it.
- qingcharles 2y agoDoes it have some sort of digital cert on the system that has an expiry date, though?
- segmondy 2y agoFunny to see this, I bought 2 used DVD complete series from ebay last night instead of subscribing for it on prime even tho prime was a bit cheaper.
- latexr 2y ago> Designers came up with nifty animated menus Those user-hostile abominations were a great reason to have DVDs. They were slow, made starting to watch a movie more complicated than it need be, and frequently committed the cardinal sin of showing spoilers.
- giobox 2y agoFunny to see movie people going through the same pain PC gamers did (lamenting the loss of "big box" retail games - the reasoning is much the same), especially the complaints around the loss of things like booklets etc.
- nemomarx 2y agoweirdly I'm more in favor of it with steam - I guess there's not a really great equivalent for movies and music? I mean band camp is pretty close to gog but it's a little bit of a hassle to manage your library still, and easier to keep CDs in the car.
- giobox 2y agoSteam works great while the benevolent dictator (Gabe) is still alive and in direct control. What happens to the company and its services once he dies is extremely concerning to me given depth of my own investment now in game licences on the platform. Things may not be so rosy if/when Steam is sold to a publicly traded parent and has to do boring things like deliver quarterly growth for shareholders etc. Would a Steam/Valve owned and run by Microsoft be as good? It might not be Microsoft in the end of course, but that question is going to come up a lot sooner than a lot of Steam fans probably realise, especially as Gabe ages out. Big box games generally had very little of these types of concerns.
- NoPicklez 2y agoSo many of these things are purely nostalgic. I remember building a computer 8 years ago that for the first time I didn't need an optical drive. Not needing to dig around for 3-4 separate disks or worry if they were scratched was very handy. Yes the ownership piece is one thing, but I have yet to play a game in over a decade that was eventually taken away from me. Why do I want the booklets when there are other incredible sources of game info online, from Youtube tutorials though to subreddits and wiki articles.
- arielweisberg 2y agoI started buying Bluray/UHDs as a replacement for going to the theatre and purchasing/renting digital copies and streaming. I was spending the money anyways, why not own a copy? Streaming is primarily just for specific TV shows, subscribe, immediately cancel, watch the series, then resubscribe when something worthwhile exists. I can't stand the bugs, slow interfaces, forced ads in ad free tiers, bad audio quality, and bad video quality. I have a few continuous subscriptions, but they are for weird stuff and they are pretty inexpensive (5-6$ a month). Dropout TV and some D&D podcasts for example. What most streaming services are asking in no way aligns with the content they offer that is worth watching.
- pwarner 2y agoI've been ramping up on UHD Blueray lately, especially since I upgraded to an OLED TV. It's a massive picture quality upgrade. I think I have like 6 discs, all ~$10. A mix of newer movies I haven't seen, and 80s-90s movies I want to show the kids in a few years. It's been fun.
- selectodude 2y agoI want to rip them to NAS so I don't need to bother with the discs but goodness is that a project.
- walterbell 2y agohttps://b3n.org/automatic-ripping-machine/ https://b3n.org/automatic-ripping-machine/ https://github.com/automatic-ripping-machine/automatic-ripping-machine https://github.com/automatic-ripping-machine/automatic-rippi...
- Night_Thastus 2y agoI started doing it as well. Not only is the quality great (4k, HDR 10+ or Dolby Vision, uncompressed audio) but equally important is that it cannot be taken away. If I love a movie on X streaming service and they have some licensing problem or decide it's not worth what they're paying to host it, they can remove it at any time. I'm sick of that. I'm sick of what's available changing on a daily basis, and constantly getting split among more and more services that charge more and more monthly.
- BryantD 2y agoThis article is focused on mainstream cinema and I tend to agree with it; I miss the days when major studios were releasing DVDs packed with extras. Simultaneously, we're in the middle of a major boutique Blu-ray boom. I am not intimately familiar with the economics of this, but it's demonstrably true that it's possible to license and produce high quality Blu-rays with a lot of interesting extras in batches of 2-3K and make a living at it. We're probably all familiar with the Criterion Collection, which has been around for decades. Fewer of us have heard of Vinegar Syndrome, which has a highly successful business producing Blu-rays of mostly B movies and exploitation flicks. Arrow, based in the UK, has been releasing cult movies for a couple of decades and we're at the point where people who worked for Arrow are going and starting their own boutique companies (Radiance Films, for example, who produce 3-4 discs a month, mostly non-English genre movies). There are easily a dozen more companies like this out there. I think the model requires appealing to a collector mindset. The boutique Blu-ray subreddit often hosts fervent arguments between people who don't break the shrink wrap and people who care about the movies. Several of the boutique companies have subscriptions: for a thousand bucks you can get one copy of everything they produce in the year. Often a new release will be available in special packaging for a limited run, with no difference in the content: those sell like hotcakes. I don't know if it's practical to run this model for major studios. For one thing, it's a tiny market as these things go -- does Sony really want to make the effort to pump out cool material for a couple of thousand sales? They'd be doing it for prestige and marketing reasons, not financial rewards. There might be a niche for boutique companies to do an ongoing deal with a major studio for this kind of release, though.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 2y agoMany major music artists release limited-run vinyl records, with unique coloring and packaging and often booklets as well. It's often to monetize their back catalogue by giving people a way to buy a gift for a fan. I think there's totally an opportunity to do the same with films.
- BryantD 2y agoYeah, good call -- it's a very similar situation.
- stego-tech 2y agoHonestly not where I expected the article to go, but grateful for it. While I do kinda miss the old, glamorous packaging and pack-ins of yore, the modern media server-focused me appreciates modern releases that are thin on extras as they're easier to rip. I kind of think that if media ownership remained a priority, and the focus was on an improved home experience instead of increasing consumption via streaming, things would've turned out broadly better. Then again, I look at series that never would've had a chance in the old media environment (Invincible, The Boys, Hasbin Hotel, The Amazing Digital Circus, etc), and I'm reminded that nostalgia for the past is a powerful reality warp. All that being said, ultimately the strongest voice inside of me is that of the librarian: "Thank f*k all this media uses the same dimensions for a change. All those fancy-pants novelty boxes were a real pain to keep organized and pristine."
- liampulles 2y agoI really enjoy the process of ripping a disc to my hard drive, especially the process of finding the right combination of VapourSynth filters to clear up and fix any issues done in the mastering process. I also have discovered some interesting extra features. An interesting DVD set was the first season of The IT Crowd, which has base64 encoded subtitles. It was a fun little project to OCR those, combine them together, and then decode them. In terms of interesting DVD commentaries, Goodfellas and Catch Me if You Can have commentaries with the actual criminals who are the subject of the film, which gives an interesting perspective. There was also a hidden commentary track on one of The Simpsons episodes where the writers go into details about why there was a drop off in quality on the show. Actually the commentary tracks on The Simpsons episodes are generally excellent.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoKiller product would be a physical UHD player with built-in very powerful and accurate AI upscalling (better than Nvidia Shield) for all your discs - old and new.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoBut I guess that, in a couple of years, mainstream LLMs will know every pixel of every disc ever released by heart...
- LinuxBender 2y agoWe all took the DVD boom era for granted I did not take it for granted at all. My DVDs can not be cancelled, do not require internet or streaming accounts. Most of them have bonus features that the streaming providers do not always offer. Solar power and a portable player means I am not restricted to books during a prolonged power outage. Please do bring back a greater DVD boom but do not bring in any physical media that requires checking for a license.
- chillpenguin 2y agoIt's true. Streaming services are really a downgrade in this respect. I don't get why they don't include the same sort of bonus content that DVDs had.
- NoPicklez 2y agoThe difference today is that the bonus content doesn't need to come with the stream, they can release it on YouTube or an a separate release.
- NoPicklez 2y agoDid we really take it for granted? I don't remember complaining about it at the time as much as enjoying it.
- NoPicklez 2y agoI don't think I necessarily agree with this from my viewpoint. Back when I used to make digital copies of DVD's to watch on my PC, I used software that would specifically remove all of the menu's and bonus content and just digitise the movie itself to save space. Yes it was cool, but I just wanted the movie.
- ramesh31 2y ago> There was the rather strange Wake Up, Ron Burgundy: The Lost Movie, released shortly after the feature film came out in 2004. Essentially, director Adam McKay had shot so much material while making Anchorman: The Legend Of Ron Burgundy, and abandoned so many story ideas (including a whole subplot about a fictional terrorist organisation) that it was cut into a separate 90-minute release. (It wasn’t great, but an interesting curio nonetheless.) I miss when studios and directors would actually edit movies properly. If Anchorman were released today on Netflix, it would have been a 2 hour 15 minute slog, with 10 minutes of laughs here and there, rather than the sharp and hilarious 90 minute comedy that it was.
- devops99 2y agoAround when DVDs were the thing, Bit Torrent was super awesome (still is).
- pessimizer 2y agoPeople still haven't quantified the value of compilation and curation. Putting a bunch of related things together results in something that is a product of its parts, not the sum. You'd think that LLMs would have drilled that into our heads by now. Still, somehow, online archives are just document databases of mixed content. Just bags of crap and treasure that can be picked through using search engines if you can guess the correct magical incantation and the engine hasn't been told to selectively ignore what you've said. Archive.org and books.google.com are said to be valuable archives (and they are), but try to find all four volumes of a four volume set, or all of the works of an author in chronological order. I'll give you an hour. This could be solved by giving users the ability to add those connections, and providing a deliberative system to edit and cultivate those added connections. They'll do it for free. It mostly works on wikipedia, even when as they dramatically fail in other ways. Let people add links to content, and come up with deliberative procedures to avoid problems such as spam. "Community Notes" is a good attempt on Twitter. Wikipedia has a process for auditing references and links. Instead of using public deliberation, we have random drones or execs hardcoding "Jonathan Turley" into secret LLM prompts because somebody saw him on TV complaining about LLMs libeling him. Ad hoc authoritarianism is not the answer, but somehow it's the only solution we ever use because deliberation is hard and requires relinquishing a bit of control.