18 ms·
In ‘The Book Against Death,’ Elias Canetti rants against mortality
- xvector 2y agoI am so incredibly envious of the future humans that will live in a world without death. I have decided that soon I will quit my job ($1M+ TC at FAANG), and I will dedicate the entirety of my remaining life (I am ~30) to helping humanity solve death, even if I never benefit from it. This is a difficult decision for me because I am giving up a life of guaranteed luxury and comfort for a moonshot that almost certainly will not pan out. But I can think of no greater and more meaningful pursuit. This is my Zero Dawn. Moving the needle here is the only thing that will let me - ironically - die happy. I think there are a lot of engineers out there looking for something more meaningful than their FAANG or tech job. Immense potential to be leveraged here if we come together.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoDelay death as you will, but thermodynamics will always have the last laugh.
- xvector 2y agoOne dollar or a million - which would you rather have?
- YurgenJurgensen 2y agoIronically, your example shows the main flaw of your position: Dollars are only worth what you can buy with them.
- ThrowawayTestr 2y agoNearly all of humanities pursuits is giving the middle finger to entropy. Yes, we're accelerating it's eventual win, but in the short term we're comfortable.
- goatlover 2y agoForget quantillions of years, It would be nice to live a few centuries without the ravages of old age.
- grishka 2y agoThermodynamics only applies to closed systems. Living beings are open systems because they constantly exchange energy and matter with their surroundings. Earth is also an open system because it receives energy from the sun (and, to a much lesser degree, from other stars), and sometimes things from outer space fall here.
- YurgenJurgensen 2y agoHubble expansion makes everything a closed system in the long term.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoEntropy applies across the universe. We know the minimum entropy it started with, where we are now, and the maximum entropy possible. We are about halfway there.
- makeitshine 2y agoIt's not possible to escape death, and all timelines will feel short when it comes to their end. Reducing the suffering of life, whether mental or physical, seems a more achievable pursuit. To die without cancer, dementia, chronic pain or the so many other ailments would be amazing.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThey go hand in hand. Any reasonable path to eliminating mortality will entail eliminating aging and degenerative conditions. Often, when people first imagine living much much longer, they imagine having more years feeling 90 or progressively worse, rather than having more years feeling 50 or 30. But much of what makes 90 feel 90 is the degenerative problems of age that also end up killing you.
- zerocrates 2y agoIf the pathway to where you're looking to go runs mostly through a fight against age-related degeneration, why not pitch it that way and just avoid the controversy that "ending death" attracts as a concept? Who's out there handwringing against fighting, just to pick a random example, dementia?
- stale2002 2y ago> why not pitch it that way and just avoid the controversy that "ending death" attracts as a concept? There are both drawbacks and benefits to the controversy of "ending death". You have mentioned the drawbacks, but the benefits are that it attracts the interest of the individuals that care about the most important problem in the world, which is specifically this problem of ending death.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThat's the idea behind marketing campaigns like "healthspan". It's a trade-off. It's very easy to get dragged into a pivot that focuses on one specific condition rather than mortality and age-related degeneration in general.
- farseer 2y agoFuture humans will live in a world where some can purchase an extended life span. Death will still be there.
- jaharios 2y agoWe already live in a world where you can extend your lifespan with money. Millions die from lack of healthcare or from poor childhood.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThank you for taking the problem seriously and working on it.
- knodi123 2y agoor at least resolving to. :-P
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y ago> I think there are a lot of engineers out there looking for something more meaningful than their FAANG or tech job. Immense potential to be leveraged here if we come together. Amen. I want to build dyson spheres myself. Gathering the money right now for it. Of course I know it won't happen in my lifetime but you got to start.
- seletskiy 2y agoI will never understand people who say that mortality is what gives life a meaning. It is exactly opposite. If I can't observe effects of my actions (and most likely "I" would not be able to do so after death), then it does not matter for me what I do during life, since outcome is all the same. There should be no death. For whatever reason, it is incredibly hard to find people thinking the same, despite, paradoxially no one wants to die. Can we chat? My e-mail is in the profile.
- pwnOrbitals 2y agoFully aligned, and would love to join forces on such a project. Let's have a chat :)
- jajko 2y agoYou are confusing You-level and mankind-level, it was never about You. Meaning is there, but its not kind to people who think themselves as center of universe and mandatory part of it (we all are of our own version of reality but thats not what I mean). Life well lived is a life thats easier to let go, believing in afterlife or not. Now what does that mean is highly individual but for most its around friends, family and children, mostly children. Most prople with kids have no problem seeing that meaning in mortality, plus there are even more logical and potent arguments (resources, selfishness, not ending up with immortal dictator forever etc but thats for longer)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Viliam1234 2y ago> I will never understand people who say that mortality is what gives life a meaning. Same here. I wonder why they don't give even more meaning to their life by killing themselves right now. Oh wait, it doesn't work that way. Death gives a meaning only when it is in a distant future... or some other excuse like that. But for some people, that future is now, or very soon. They would probably also prefer to have a "meaningful" death later rather than now.
- lisper 2y ago> I am so incredibly envious of the future humans that will live in a world without death. A world without death is also necessarily a world without birth once the whole biosphere has been converted to immortals. I'm not sure living amongst a bunch of old people is something to be envied. I also don't think that people who think that immortality is enviable have really come to grips with how long forever actually is.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>A world without death is also necessarily a world without birth once the whole biosphere has been converted to immortals. You think no one is ever going to die from accidents or murder or natural disasters?
- forgetfreeman 2y agoYou think those numbers are enough to keep the population from ballooning to entirely unmanageable numbers? Consider the global population is increasing now and we're talking about removing a big chunk of all-cause mortality from the field. So unless there's a plan to replace natural causes with artificial causes (which moots functional immortality entirely) some form of population control is an absolute requirement.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>You think those numbers are enough to keep the population from ballooning to entirely unmanageable numbers? If we keep reproducing at today's rates, of course not. However, birthrates are in free-fall worldwide due to many factors, with the biggest ones probably being education, women's rights, and access to reliable contraception. As the high birthrate countries improve in these areas, their birthrates fall; we've seen this universally in countries across the world. Of course, there's other factors too, like high costs of living, gender divides in some cultures, etc. The latter ones might be solved eventually, but I truly hope we don't regress on the former ones. With life-extension research, I think it's highly unlikely someone is going to find the Holy Grail anytime soon that suddenly makes humans biologically immortal. Instead, it'll probably be a slow process of incremental improvements. So while those improvements chip away at the death rate, cultural changes will continue to decrease the birthrate: people will continue to choose to have fewer children, people will wait longer to have children, etc.
- forgetfreeman 2y agoIs this sarcasm? Functional immortality without a complete redesign of the economic system guarantees the least ethical among us would come to own and control everything with no failsafes. Beware what you wish for.
- adastra22 2y agoEmail me (address in profile). I’ve already made this step. I am presently launching a molecular nanotechnology startup, under the not unreasonable assumption that better tools are required to fully solve the problem. Edit: not saying we should join forces or that you should work on nanotechnology, but we are clearly value aligned and should connect.
- placebo 2y agoI think the part of "even if I never benefit from it" is a key point in living a meaningful life and transcending the fear of death, though hopefully you have carefully considered your decision from a financial perspective since material aspects are obviously also a part of being able to carry out your plans in this life. I don't think there is anything wrong in seeking the longest healthiest possible life, but suspect that in many cases that the motivation for it comes more from fear of personal death than the love of what life is. It's great to be an agent in this incredible adventure but my take on it is that when the means (a specific localized self consciousness) become the end ("being me is the most important thing and it should be great forever") then that is where you get stuck in a local maximum and some sort of suffering is bound to follow. Another aspect is that of how much more time do you think will be enough? 1000 years? 10,000 years? As someone has already stated, you will not be able to avoid death forever and even in the most optimistic case (at least from this myopic view of immortality) you won't win against entropy. No matter how long of a good life you are granted, it will never seem enough because from the subjective point of view it will seem to be over soon at which point personal death will again become very real and very alarming. It seems the only way out of this is to be able to transcend the personal sense of self and see that your real immortality lies in realizing that in a very real sense you are also something much greater than just a localized version of it. I'm not some Zen master and am probably afraid of my own personal mortality as much as the next person, but after a long time of thinking deeply about it, this seems to be the most probable conclusion.
- xandrius 2y ago10,000 years could be good, especially if you still get to choose to get out if you change mind.
- tayo42 2y agoIf you're making 1m +, just work for like 1 or two more years and you have retire to work on this passion project and have your life if comfort. With so much money idk how you couldn't have both?
- dsign 2y agoYou are not alone. I can't retire yet to start working on this, but I'm looking forward to when that day comes. In the meantime, I'm working my day job and writing at night speculative fiction on the intersection of this topic and our current value systems. A big chunk of the problem is that most people are extremely conservative when it comes to death... and perhaps for good reason. But the time has come when more of humanity should leave the shelter of resignation and faith and go into that battlefield.
- myworkinisgood 2y agoLack of death just means that people won't have the courage to take risks against injustices anymore.
- khafra 2y agoThis seems approximately as likely as people not having the courage to enact injustices (since their victims will have unlimited time to plot a perfect revenge and gather all the resources that would require).
- myworkinisgood 2y agoReal life accounts always say otherwise. Death is a limited liability card that people can use to commit anything. People who commit injustices, even today, are often confident enough that they will be in a position to kill themselves before suffering at hands of others.
- khafra 2y agoThat doesn't contradict my point: universal mortality means the potential losses of an oppressor are bounded, and the bound is acceptably low to many people. Immortality removes that bound.
- 8372049 2y agoLife in itself is worthless. The only reason why life is valuable is because it is a canvas, a vessel through which you can find happiness, meaning and so on. This means that if you have a life that isn't worth living, you are not at risk of losing anything of value, and so the potential loss is still bounded. Sure, there is the potential that life can change in the future, but whether you have 10, 100 or 1000 years left of potential life, you don't really care much about that if your life is an agonizing living hell. Don't ask me how I know.
- khafra 2y ago
- kbrkbr 2y agoFor now it looks like death can't be "solved" at all. You may be able to prolong individual human life, even by a lot. But how to solve entropy and the end of an empty, cold universe? There is even speculation that life is from a certain angle only an effect to accelerate entropy under the umbrella of the Maximum Entropy Production Principle (but I do not remember the source). So from the standpoint of current knowledge of how nature works this seems to look dire. I also personally disagree. I do not think that the beautiful chaos of life is strictly preferable to the requiem eternam of death. I'll go when I have to, without hesitation and regrets. It's not the things that terrify us, but our opinion of the things.
- bboygravity 2y agoYou should see what they can do with mice/rats nowadays: -- Immunity to prion diseasy by epigenetically silencing the prion gene, -- Cure (almost) all cancers -- life long HIV AIDS immunity with 1 vaccination (based on a modified virus) -- Extend life by a factor 2 (if I'm not mistaking) -- Make them light up in the dark with a human ear growing on their back (this one is decades old already). And all of the above is without considering the AGI singularity. Human immunity is really not that far away. Depending on how AGI will respond to us we will soon either be wiped out or be immortal IMO.
- zeofig 2y agoAGI singularity is science fiction and, while interesting, none of that research comes close to biological immortality in humans. Don't deceive yourself.
- ben_w 2y agoEvery tech is science fiction until it's done, and sometimes continues to be present in fiction even while also being deployed. Not fooling yourself is hard, because it goes both ways.
- kbrkbr 2y agoThanks for your reply! I am not argumenting against curing stuff and prolonging life. I just think it is not immortality. I don't think immortality is to have given our current knowledge. It's like saying: "and then we build the perpetuum mobile. We're just short of it. One or two more breakthroughs". I like ambition, I just don't think we even have a trace of a path
- crngefest 2y agoA world without death would be the worst nightmare I can imagine.
- Ygg2 2y ago> I am so incredibly envious of the future humans that will live in a world without death. There will never be a world without death. Not, unless you have a way to reverse the laws of thermodynamics, on a universe scale. Only world where people die later. Also, keep in mind, your most disliked people will probably remain in power for longer. Next, Putin or Xi will remain in power for centuries.
- komali2 2y agoWhat's the pathway you're thinking in this effort? I had a similar plan I envisioned in my early 20s, which led me to become an engineer. I'll be ready to go down the same path pretty soon, would love to chat with more people in a similar mindset. Email in the profile if anyone wants to talk more about this.
- bboygravity 2y agoHoller if you want some help, lol. I like that.
- qsdf38100 2y ago"Solving death" won’t help humanity. Isn’t that obvious to you?? For a starter, birth rates and death rates should be about the same otherwise it’s not sustainable. If you "solve death", birth rates will need to drop a lot. Do you want to live in a world with almost no children? Just very old people all over the place. Sounds like a nightmare to me. You need to let go, accept your mortality and leave some room for new humans to live. At some point you’ll have had your time, death is part of life.
- kevlened 2y ago> birth rates and death rates should be about the same otherwise it’s not sustainable In 1798, Thomas Malthus predicted famine due to overpopulation, because he didn't predict the discovery of nitrogen fixation, which allowed scaling food production. There are likely many technological leaps we've yet to make which will change your definition of sustainable.
- grugagag 2y agoAll technological leaps come at a cost. Future technological leaps have unknown costs.
- kevlened 2y agoTrue, but maintaining status quo has unknown opportunity costs.
- qsdf38100 2y agoDo you know about exponential growth? If birth and death rates are not about the same, it means the population will double every X years. You’ll need a major breakthrough in food production every X years. For ever. Even if we achieve that, at some point there just won’t be enough square meters on earth. But I guess it’s okay to you since we’ll have solved space travel and we’ll just send billions of people to Mars? Then other planetary systems? Then other galaxies? In any case, as I don’t buy we’ll ever be able to send billions of people to other planets, let alone make them habitable, this is exponential growth with finite ressources. Doesn’t sound sustainable to me.
- disambiguation 2y agoThis is so monumentally stupid I want to believe it's a joke but something tells me it isn't. Alas, I wish you luck captain Ahab.
- mchinen 2y agoI'm also ex-Google working in the space on the funding and company formation side. Would love to chat.
- elsewhen 2y agoI am truly humbled by your decision. If you haven’t done so already, check out the folks at vitalism.io who share your view and are very ambitious.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoDeath is no big deal.
- cageface 2y agoFear of death is a misunderstanding of what life is.
- xvector 2y agoIn my personal opinion: Life is an incredible adventure. I do not feel that the value of it is increased by death. I also do not feel that I misunderstand life.
- cageface 2y agoIn an eternity all individual events lose their meaning. An endless life is a meaningless life.
- voxl 2y agoyou've painted yourself into a corner, how exactly are you going to define meaning? As far as we know the universe is infinite, and as such all actions fit your description anyway, so why not be infinite along with it?
- lucianbr 2y agoI'm sure I read multiple times that the universe is finite. Both in space and time. Not that I agree with the "infinite life destroys all meaning". Just nitpicking.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> In an eternity all individual events lose their meaning. An endless life is a meaningless life One, we don't get an eternity. It's thermodynamically impossible. Two, we're mortal beings with mortal minds. Our trying to comprehend--let alone judge--what an immortal being would consider meaningful is hubris. Three, how does this scale? Is a child's life more meaningfully if it ends early? Why is our present life and healthspan the sole optimum?
- borbtactics 2y agoTime to revisit Mitchell and Webb’s brilliant immortal kids skit
- blast 2y agoThat calls for a link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wt6nwvGJiN8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wt6nwvGJiN8
- jokoon 2y agoI don't understand people who don't want to be immortal. At five years old I cried because I learned that I was going to die one day.
- block_dagger 2y agoWorld weariness hits many who live past middle age.
- keiferski 2y agoIt’s not so much that I don’t want to be immortal - although I do think it’s a huge positivist assumption that your current human existence is the “peak state”, the best possible thing to continue being forever. It may turn out that this life is just an unpleasant dream of a superior consciousness. Maybe it’s not, and this life is all you get. But we don’t know that and it seems extremely self-absorbed and myopic (a common trait throughout human history) to consider this existence as the only real thing. My concern is more that the world required to keep people immortal is almost certainly one removed of all risk, danger, adventure, and dynamism. I don’t want to live in a world where people hide inside staring at screens, because they’re afraid of physical accidents ending their otherwise immortal lives.
- dexwiz 2y agoI remember reading an analysis that if people only died by accident then the average life span would between 900 and 2000 years. That assumes no more conservative living than today. Surely things like cars and guns would be much less prevalent.
- lucianbr 2y agoDo people really think that death is optional, and the problem is that we're opting into it?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- goatlover 2y agoSome people see death from aging as eventually being curable. Obviously, something is going to kill you sooner or later. But why must it be old age? Assuming you survive long enough, who wants to spend their last years in body that's breaking down, with diminished cognitive and physical abilities?
- DaoVeles 2y agoWhile I get the desire of folks to live forever, IF it is possible I still think it is a VERY long way off. All I advocate for is quality of life. It feels like every time we make an advancement, we discover two new things to solve. Eventually we will get there but it might be a lot longer road than we anticipate. Sorry Aubrey De Gray, I don't think this is something that can be solved for a billion dollars like he has claimed. Eat your fruit, veggies, nuts and whole grains, but don't over do it on the food! Move it or lose it. Build bridges, don't burn them! I don't say this so you can have smaller pants or live an extra decade, that would be a neat side effect, I say this so that you can live a happy fun life as much as possible.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Do people really think that death is optional, and the problem is that we're opting into it? It's material to the question of researching aging and longevity. A lot of people will come out singing death's praises.
- inglor_cz 2y agoIf I reframe your question slightly, too many people think about aging as an inevitable, unstoppable, undelayable process. That is why we only have serious longevity research now, and that is why much of it is sponsored by billionaires or venture capitalists, because governmental agencies don't even comprehend the potential utility of it and relevant research must be reframed as anti-Alzheimer or whatever. Once humanity gets rid of this prejudice, a venue towards much healthier and longer life is open.
- ein0p 2y agoYou can rant against it all you want, but we already live much longer than is justifiable from the evolutionary perspective. If it was up to the evolution alone, we wouldn’t live past 50. So try to make something of your life while it lasts. Or just enjoy the festivities, that’s perfectly valid, too.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> If it was up to the evolution alone, we wouldn’t live past 50 What is the other factor pushing it up?
- ein0p 2y agoWe’re probably just using the “overengineering” that the evolution put into us to account for much harsher living conditions that existed previously. I have no other explanation, in any case. That’s also why a lot of us are fat.
- naveen99 2y agoThere used to be more age difference between husbands and wives. Men who outsmarted and out gunned the competition to live longer got to reproduce a lot more… evolution does select for men who reproduce more later.
- ElFitz 2y agoHere: https://www.nature.com/articles/428128a https://www.nature.com/articles/428128a
- komali2 2y agoSince humans are very social creatures I think it's possible that variations of humans that live longer were selected for since the elderly can help care for the younger, teach things, etc.
- galaxyLogic 2y agoI don't want to sound mystical or religious, but 'self' really is an illusion. It is a word that pops up in the LLM of our brain. It is a word that describes what we perceive as happening. What "we" really are are our thoughts and especially memories. And they can live on beyond our physical death. But does that make us happy? Of course everybody wants to go to Heaven, but no-one wants to die. But rationally thinking, 'self' is an illusion. StarTrek taught us that you can transfer Kirk and Spock to a different place by re-assembling their atoms in a different place. But is it really the same Spock that pops up there? Or a copy? A copy obviously. Such a copy cam then live on practically forever because they could always re-assemble a younger Spock. But since it is aa copy would Spock really be happy that his copy lives on forever? Yes I believe if he thinks about it rationally. And Spock does.
- 9dev 2y agoA copy living on is meaningless to the original consciousness, since the subjective experience of the copy is decoupled from the original. There is no more connection than between you and me. You can dress this arbitrarily in grand words of leaving a dent and so on, but no matter the phrasing: once you’re gone, you’re gone. I don’t care if people remember me, if I cease to exist, I cease experience the world, and it’s all void.
- zeofig 2y agoI don't identify my "self" (or consciousness) with memories or anything the supposed LLM in my brain might babble about. If you took those things away, I'd still be here. Rationally speaking, self is the only thing that certainly isn't an illusion. Anything you perceive could be a hallucination, memories can change or disappear, and thoughts are mere dust in the wind, but you can't have any of those things without something to perceive them. It's the only thing you know is there, whatever it is.
- galaxyLogic 2y agoThe feeling off "self" is not an illusion, we all or most of us have it. But it is just a word and one whose meaning is not very well defined, it is like you say "whatever it is". Which kind of hints at that we don't really have a good definition for it. I am "me" and the definition of "me" is what I am. Somewhat cyclical right? If you lost all your thoughts and memories, what would be left? You can call that "self" but is it the same "self" as what you thought of yourself as before losing all thoughts and memories? There are people suffering from schizophrenia who alternate between different "selves". At least to their experience those are totally different "selves" which need not be aware of the other selves at all. So would it mean there are multiple "selfs" within one brain?
- woodpanel 2y agoI'm torn between the argument that the gift of life is such a precious one that eliminating death is one of the most virtuous endeavors at all – and the other argument where this is peak escapism and a fundamental not-getting-it-what-life-is-about. At least one can be sure: Death is such a fundemantal part of life that every social norm we take for granted (thus not even noticing it exists) will be uprooted. Technically that doesn't need to be a bad thing. It just makes it so much more likely that advocats of ending death are overlooking the bad parts. Plus, I can't think of a scenario where, once this technology exists to extend life indefinetly, the state's monopoly on power won't turn into a dystopian monopoly on life.
- ElFitz 2y ago> Plus, I can't think of a scenario where, once this technology exists to extend life indefinetly, the state's monopoly on power won't turn into a dystopian monopoly on life. And the wealthy’s monopoly on wealth will only consolidate. It reminds me of two quotes: “Science progresses one funeral at a time” (paraphrasing Planck’s principle). “[…] Death is very likely the single best invention of Life. It is Life’s change agent. It clears out the old to make way for the new. […]” That’s probably what worries me most, when it comes to extended or unending lives.
- keiferski 2y agoAlso Kuhn’s idea of a paradigm shift. Good luck getting a new paradigm adopted when the decision makers at academic and scientific institutions never leave.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI wouldn't be so cynical. Many power structures rely on death to drive churn. But there are other mechanisms, e.g. sequential term limits and retirement. (Retirement doesn't mean you can't do anything anymore. Just not that thing.) Moreover, while longer lifespans may drive calcification, they would also promote long-term thinking. How would we vote about the climate differently if we knew we'd be around for a couple hundred years?
- southernplaces7 2y agoThe narrow mindedness of some of the comments on this thread is strange, especially on a site read by people with a supposedly open minded interest in the frontiers of interesting new technology. It's absurd to think that one must be arguing for or desiring an infinite span of life just because they detest the shortness of the one we have as humans, and want to find a way around that natural limit. I or others might only want a few hundred or even a couple thousand extra years to enjoy ever more fascinating adventures, without ever seriously considering the idea of literally striving for eternity. Yes, we have entropy, the current known limits of human biology and the laws of thermodynamics and so forth as superficial arguments against drastic life extension, but none of these at all firmly block the notion of humans developing ways to extend their lives by centuries or longer, even if not something like practical eternity. Just in the natural world of today, there are animals like the giant tortoise, who live for over 200 years and spend much of that robust, sexually active and healthy, or the Greenland shark, which lives over 400 years and doesn't even reach adolescence until it's about 150. Our current technology gives us no means of doing the same for our bodies, but the possible limits of technology and physics are nowhere near definitive enough for calling such a thing impossible. That alone and anything leading up to it would be an incredible improvement for so many lives that could be lived to a whole new degree of freedom and marvel for themselves and others. And before anyone considers the very tiresome argument that multiple centuries of life would get boring, i'd suggest you internalize that yes, there are people who would have no trouble filling them with things that fascinate them to the very last minute of that extended existence.
- DaoVeles 2y agoWhile I don't think it will happen in our lifetime, I agree with you. I could definitely fill a thousand years comfortably.
- southernplaces7 2y agoSadly, neither do I. I'm optimistic about the benefits of our current technology explosion (at least some parts of it, less so others) but I can't quite seriously imagine myself seeing aging reversal and life extension to beyond 120 years happening before my statistical natural lifespan ends by the middle part of the 21st century.
- WalterBright 2y agoEvolution is what has made death mandatory. We'd be living much longer lives if it gave our species an evolutionary advantage. For example, in many species, the male dies promptly after mating. Evolution has no further use for him, so his life is forfeit. In fact, survival of the progeny may be advanced by getting rid of the old folks. The reason people live to be grandparents is grandparents turned out to be useful in ensuring the survival of the grandkids. Beyond that, off to the ice floe. These ideas are not mine. See "The Red Queen" by Matt Ridley https://www.amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/0060556579/ https://www.amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/0... for the various strategies around sex and mortality that evolution has produced. Nothing says, however, that we cannot tinker with our genes to produce what we want.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Evolution is what has made death mandatory. We'd be living much longer lives if it gave our species an evolutionary advantage. Thermodynamics makes death mandatory. Evolution set the timer to 100 to 120.
- WalterBright 2y agoWe all know about the heat death of the universe. It is irrelevant to this discussion, however. May I suggest taking a look at "The Red Queen". I'd be surprised if you were disappointed in it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> It is irrelevant to this discussion My point is there is a dial. We have to die. But we don't have to die when and in the manner that we do. > May I suggest taking a look at "The Red Queen" Ordered. Thank you!
- WalterBright 2y ago> But we don't have to die when and in the manner that we do. I believe I made that point with: "Nothing says, however, that we cannot tinker with our genes to produce what we want." > Thank you! Welcs. It's a fun read, and makes you think differently about life.
- FiatLuxDave 2y agoI enjoyed the last line of the article: "An unfinished book is the only thing I know of that never dies." A short story against mortality: https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon
- latexr 2y agoSame story in animation form, from CGP Grey. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY
- disambiguation 2y ago>An unfinished book is the only thing I know of that never dies. The author clearly hasn't seen my ticket backlog.
- kumarvvr 2y agoDeath is a preferable outcome to immortality. If there is no death, there will only be more suffering, as suffering is in human nature. We experience pain, and want to return that pain.
- rowanG077 2y agoBy that same logic non-existence is vastly preferable to living. Life is suffering.
- elfelf11 2y agoNo.
- manmal 2y ago> We experience pain, and want to return that pain I disagree. We absorb pain for our community/tribe or our own goals. Ideally, we don’t pass it on.
- yard2010 2y agoA few hundred years ago people would punish the sick and sometimes throw them into wells, making the rest of the village sick. I wondered if violence could be modeled as a plague. Once you're exposed, you're starting to catch it. Imagine that being violent to violent people spreads this disease. That resonates with what you said - if we could absorb violence and not pass it on we can contain it. Unfortunately, the western world handles violence with more violence, which is the same as throwing a sick person into the village well.
- InDubioProRubio 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Men_Are_Mortal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Men_Are_Mortal a great book on this. It shows how the immortal are withered away by time and futility of there attempts to change history and be a permanent influence. Meanwhile, the mortal while shortlifed and with only one poker chip in the game, play and win/loose with all the passion they have and form a sort of river, that withers the immortals plans and dreams down to zero.
- rrgok 2y agoI'm not afraid of death, but I'm sad I cannot see how the world will be in 100, 200 or 500 years from today. I wish people invented a reliable cryogenesis machine, so that I can go to sleep, come back after a century, live for 5-10years, and go back to sleep. Repeat the cycle. I don't care about living a long life, it only burdens the body and mind. I want to see fast paced changes happening in front of my eyes. Evolution takes millions of years, technological advances takes century. Being awake for that long only makes you miserable, because of all the shit happening in life. Let's admit that life is for the most part a shitty deal, with some moments of excitement.
- dualogy 2y ago> I wish people invented a reliable cryogenesis machine, so that I can go to sleep, come back after a century, live for 5-10years, and go back to sleep. Repeat the cycle. Some SF author here wanna pick up on this theme? This has potential, if the cryo is available equally to all comers in society, because I can't imagine how the world would look like — who'd "shape the time they're in" as some-specific-generation when people pop in and out of the progression of time liberally, century-hopping, taking a gander for a few years, then sleep through many more, then respawn once more. Maybe one can leave specs for when to not thaw (wars, pestilence, famine, recession). No one's around for the bad times! Including whoever'd manage the cryo and thawings. Paradoxical, someone go write that SF!
- Devasta 2y agoFor the life of me I cannot remember where I saw it, but there is a comic that once explored the theme, a man wakes up from cryo 1000 years in the future to find that anyone who wanted to endeavor in any field figured they'd jump on the pod and wait for someone else to do some of more of the groundwork, that history and technological progress had basically stopped.
- dualogy 2y agoIf you ever remember the name of that, gimme a ping!
- goethes_kind 2y agoI think, most people who want to be immortal are actually motivated by either the fear of death, or the desire to travel far and experience life in the future. But these are distinct motivations. Immortality itself does not compute. It just does not make sense. You are a product of your time. So if you end up 10000 years in the future, what is going to happen? It wouldn't be good if you were still you, a 2000 millennium person. So lets say you managed to evolve entirely to become a 10000 millennium human (if that's even a thing). Then, you're not really you anymore. There is no discernible continuity. So in effect it's like you died and were reborn multiple times over. "Immortality" only really makes sense over smaller timescales on the order of centuries, at most. I can tell you, I have relatives who were alive before WWII and although they are alive, they are not part of the present. They are not fascinated by AI, they are not on Instagram or TikTok, they are not really partaking in the present, but mostly reminiscing the life they used to have in their childhood and early adulthood.
- agumonkey 2y agoI do think our brain as a somehow fix structure / existential path that would struggle to make sense over multiple centuries[0]. Beside reminiscing times gone, there's also the absurdity of cycles and "forgettance", where stupid things come over and over[1], which is not pleasant. [0] if you don't just go insane because your memory capacity is reached and you just can't organize new ideas without losing others or causing damage. [1] that said this might be due to equal demographic waves, but in the case of immortal population, young ones would be less and less large % wise.
- the_cramer 2y agoDepends on the type of immortality. If we can fight typical aging processes, then a big part of the problem you state would go away. Old brains don't learn and think as fast as young ones do, this has purely to do with ageing and cell/dna defects over time. Old people are not hyped by AI and new tech, because most of them don't understand them and i think this has much to do with the reason stated. Not to say there is not a possible psychological problem for us when living forever, it just cannot be researched right now because, you know, we tend to die. Let alone the implications.. insurance, prison sentences, housing, population and control of it...
- omnicognate 2y agoSo many references to thermodynamics here, which is entirely irrelevant unless you choose "immortality" to mean surviving the death of the sun. The world in which we live and die is very far from thermodynamic equilibrium. A reasonable definition of escaping mortality is being able to continue to live as long as the environment continues to support life, which involves it providing suitable energy gradients, which the sun will continue to do for a very, very long time relative to a normal human lifespan. The second law of thermodynamics does not preclude this. The second law of thermodynamics is also not some quasi-mystical curse of doom, and it's not about "disorder" either, but that's a whole other discussion.
- geodel 2y agoEver since I read book about Scaling by Geoffrey West where human's average age is about 40 years I feel tons of problems of modern society are due to stretching human life far beyond 40. From population rising, declining, pension gap, bankrupting social security, care for old people, loneliness, old age diseases and so on and on. Before life was nasty, brutish and short and now for large population on earth it is still nasty, brutish but long. And I am just not fan of long.
- Nursie 2y agoHow old are you now, out of interest?
- wiether 2y agoIf they are <35, they are too young to realize how fast goes by; and if they are >40, they are selfish to still be alive while preaching for a shorter lifespan for others?
- Nursie 2y agoIt's more that I can't see a philosophy in which people should die at around 40 surviving in a person that nears that age, because it's tantamount at that point to saying "My life isn't worth living, it provides neither myself nor society any value". This is not something most people think of their own lives, and as a result would be more interesting than someone saying (in effect) "I think it would be better if other people died off".
- marcheradiuju 2y agoIn some forums, "post body" is used to rebuff arguments. The implication is that, when the user posts their physique, it will be lesser than your own, and your subsequent takedown of their ideas will include a photo of your own larger physique to reinforce the superiority of the responder. In your question, there's even less of a fair shake: your own age has no part in it and the GP would simply look a fool for any answer under 40, due to the context. What's sad is that you think that appearance would be anything but an underhanded jab on your part, the immortality-conversation equivalent of "and yet you live in a society, hmm!" Say GP was 20. So what? Have you dismantled any of their points about the inherent non-fit between the natural engineering of the human body and a society dominated by adults 40+? The GP at least brought one new idea to the thread, and it's rude of you to try to shuffle them off for immaturity. Maybe you're the type to say "it was just a question!", but its obvious to anyone who would read here that you were trying to subvert actual argumentation with a character attack.
- terryf 2y agoWow these comments are depressing here. Of course I want to live as long as possible! Because life is awesome! I want more of it! The fear of death is of course real, but that's not the main reason for wanting to live longer. I want more experience, I want to see what happens in the future! I want to understand more, learn more and be able to do it at a more relaxed pace without the feeling that time will run out!
- olalonde 2y agoI think it's a bit similar to the deaf community hating on hearing aids or bald people hating on hair transplants. Psychologically, it's challenging to accept certain conditions, so our brains create rationalizations as a defense mechanism. Similarly, with death, we have no option but to accept it (at least for now), and so we develop rationalizations to convince ourselves that it's actually desirable.
- keiferski 2y agoNo, it’s not similar at all. The modern technological world has a certain approach to the individual Self and its experience of the world - it ought to be focused on almost to the exclusion of anything else. Nothing else ultimately matters, as long as your personal life experience continues - is what this philosophy ultimates boils down to. Other people, in other places, value different things. Merely existing as long as possible is not their primary goal. And in fact, the lack of such ways to “use” one’s life and death in a meaningful way other than simply existing is one major cause of the modern malaise affecting many developed nations. To live and die for a purpose other than extending your own personal experience is something many people hunger for in current times.
- olalonde 2y agoI personally wouldn't embrace that philosophy but if we solve death by aging, "dying for a purpose" would still be an option: suicide, accidents, etc.
- 2y ago
- 2-3-7-43-1807 2y agonote to myself: strictly stick to technological subjects on hackernews or accept the suffering from having to read nonsense by keyboard philosophers.
- disambiguation 2y agoIt helps if you make a drinking game out of it!
- PaulRobinson 2y agoReading the comments, it feels like almost everyone here might benefit from WeCroak - I definitely recommend it. https://www.wecroak.com/ https://www.wecroak.com/
- gradschool 2y agoAre those arguing for immortality assuming that aside from physical decline we improve monotonically with age? That's not at all clear to me. For example, the general consensus among linguists is that the ability to acquire native fluency in a language is lost after a certain age. Could there be other less obvious deficits in neuroplasticity that people striving for immortality would need to address? Sticking with the same example, how do we know it doesn't confer some evolutionary advantage to repurpose the language acquisition firmware (whatever that may be) to more age appropriate ends later? Oddly enough, a couple of star trek episodes I'm too lazy to look up got me thinking about all this. In one of them, captain Picard gets a chance to relive a regrettable incident from his youth and ends up ruining his life, and in the other, captain Janeway goes back in time to help her younger self and finds out they both have something to learn from each other. Relatedly, someone asked William Shatner what he wished he knew when he was younger and he said a better question would be about what he's glad he didn't know. Disclaimer: I had an unexpected sudden cancer scare last week so maybe you should discount my comment as a rationalization.
- socialoutlaw 2y agoMaterialistic people are so consumed by the fear of death that they yearn for immortality, craving endless time to create and acquire more distractions—little toys to appease their restless minds. It's ironic that in their quest to escape mortality, they lose touch with the essence of life itself. Humanity, as a collective, has driven us to this point, where the pursuit of material wealt overshadows the potential for deeper connections and meaningful experiences. Our struggle against it reveals this deeper disconnection which is evident from the our so many attempts to "enhance" life - to extend it further all the way to infinity. We became so preoccupied with that task that we often fail to fully embrace the current truth: finite life. In this quest to conquer the inevitable, we miss the opportunity to find meaning and peace within the natural flow of our existence.
- scandox 2y agoIt's clear from many of these discussions that there is an unbridgeable discursive gap between the "why on earth would you ever want to die" and the "life would become an intolerable nightmare" groups. Realistically if we do find ways to extend life then people will take advantage of them and all kinds of weird consequences will follow, and the two groups will argue about just how long life should be while trying not to die. Cosmically speaking all that will happen is that human development will slow down: after all if it requires a generation of human scientists to die so that new ideas can be accepted then [1]... My personal preference is pro-death. I enjoy life but it's important to my enjoyment that there is a terminus. The fact that it's not under my control also makes me feel calmer - it's out of my hands. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle
- litenboll 2y agoWhat if reluctance to accept new ideas later in life stems from mortality in the first place?
- ted_bunny 2y agoEnough people deny their mortality that I doubt this is the case.
- Filligree 2y agoPeople can deny their mortality all they like; they’re still mortal, and things like lower learning rates are likely to be genetic.
- scandox 2y agoWell who knows. My bet is on the very long-lived being fairly risk averse. And new ideas are risky.
- waterhouse 2y agoIf you're going to retire in N years, then that gives you an upper limit to how much you can benefit from learning (or even experimenting with) a new and potentially better approach, versus sticking with what currently works for you. As N gets smaller, the cost-benefit analysis increasingly favors the latter.
- abcde777666 2y ago"There is no such thing as death at all for this body. The only death is the end of the illusion, the end of the fear, the end of the knowledge that we have about ourselves and the world around us." "There is no such thing as permanence at all. Everything is constantly changing. Everything is in flux."
- kessog 2y agoThere is absolutely zero scientific, empirical basis for the materialist presupposition that nothing happens after we die. So why does seemingly every commenter here assume this to be the case? With the limitations of the scientific method, we can never discover what happens to a human consciousness after death. A human consciousness is undetectable in the brain, it isn't some loose arbitrarily defined amalgamation of chemicals and electrical signals. We will never develop technology sufficient to look into a human brain and see the neuronal pathways or materia that make up Logic, or Reason, or Ethics, or an individual's Sense of Self, and all the concepts that make up a human mind, because these things are immaterial, universal, and exist transcendent of the material human brain or the scientific method. So why are so many here running on the assumption that what happens after death is that consciousness (which can't be observed anyway) either disappears, or somehow ends up in a worse state than the here and now? This is a baseless assumption. Perhaps instead of chasing after the arbitrary religion of materialist Scientism, Hacker News readers should study a little philosophy and question their presuppositions.
- qsdf38100 2y agoWell we know that the physical brain is the support of mental abilities, because brain damage causes loss of abilities. It’s very reasonable to assume that you can’t be conscious without your brain.
- nhinck3 2y agoBasic extrapolation of known facts?
- qsdf38100 2y agoEdit: was answering to the wrong comment, sorry.
- keiferski 2y agoI mentioned this in my reply to another comment,[1] but for reference, this attitude is called Positivism and unfortunately is a common assumption nowadays. Another useful concept is the immanent frame, which is an idea by the philosopher Charles Taylor in his book A Secular Age. The basic idea is that society is increasingly becoming focused on this world (immanent) and losing interest in things outside the "frame", like the afterlife. And so the default assumption becomes something like, "There is no afterlife and only this life matters," even if there is really no scientific or philosophical justification for that belief. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41188210 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41188210 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positivism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positivism 3. https://ubcgcu.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/taylor-and-immanent-frame.pdf https://ubcgcu.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/taylor-and-imm...
- DiscourseFan 2y agoI don’t know what the big deal is, I’m never going to die. The rest of you, however…
- bobim 2y agoDon't forget that death is a required feature for a specie to evolve. It might be the case that immortal organisms lived on earth, the fact that we don't see them around just confirms that dying is a competitive advantage, not a problem. We are not the end of evolution, we need to overcome our individual desire to stay here an leave to make room for the next iteration.
- sbelskie 2y agoI don’t really have an opinion one way or another but why would we need to? There doesn’t really seem to be any plausible practical or moral imperative to do so.
- jcfrei 2y agoCompletely missing the mark here, sorry to be so blunt. But modern medicine has taken away almost all evolutionary pressures except for regions where healthcare is not available or for some very rare and serious conditions.
- bobim 2y agoYes, but if we stop producing new minds with better capability we miss the opportunity to get the next Einstein that will enable warp drive and save humanity from its fate.
- tavavex 2y agoIf we made sure Einstein's mind never lost its youthfulness, why would we need a next generation? Imagine the outcomes if any of the well-known, world-renowned geniuses got basically infinite time to pursue any projects of their choosing. To think of new ideas, build atop what they've already discovered. Hell, think of everyone else - one could study or research for decades, with professionals in their fields joining forces with anyone who studied enough to join with them. Needing a constant flow of new generations for new innovations seems like a self-imposed limitation, not an actual necessity.
- istjohn 2y ago
- haunter 2y agoNor the title or the article has the word “rant” anywhere > A Nobel Prize winner’s brilliant tirade against mortality Why does the submission has to be editorialized when the original is perfectly fine? Whenever that happens on HN I always think the OP has an agenda to push otherwise why make an editorialized change.
- keiferski 2y agoTirade is a synonym of rant. I don't think there's much of a change in meaning here. Tirade: > a long, angry speech of criticism or accusation.
- haunter 2y ago> I don't think there's much of a change in meaning here. Thanks to agree that it was unnecessary to change the title then
- keiferski 2y agoThe HN title is shorter and avoids the vague author description of "Nobel Prize winner" and the biased adjective of "brilliant". So it's pretty typical for a HN link.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pvg 2y agoThat title wasn't really 'editorialized' (at least, in spirit). The other comment explains the removal of clickbaity stuff but another HN title convention is putting the title of the book in book review articles which probably drives most of the changes here since there's also a length limit.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoI read somewhere once that if we removed all disease and consequences of old age from the equation, life expectancy would be about 400 years, but at some point you would die due to some accident, violence, or natural disaster. Wish I could find a source on this, maybe an actuary can chime in. I don't need immortality, but I could do without the long slow failing of my body until it gives out around 80 or so.
- KrautFox 2y agoI don't wanna be a buzzkill but: I don't see how living (potentially) forever is anything but a horrible, horrible ego driven idea with 0 rational thought put behind it, you may enlighten me here: - Unlimited human life expectancy vs limited resources? How would that work? - Do we really want the next dictator of XYZ to rule forever? - The lack of control young people experience when it comes to their own lives (voting, etc) will worsen, if the median age is 80+ or older. - Saying stuff like "There should be no death" is a clear example to me why humans in general are problematic. As long as we consume resources and need space we are still part of this ecosystem and cannot just simply change the rules of how it all works just because we would like to. - I suck at Bingo. Edit: I just want to clarify the following: Don't feel attacked, I am curious to hear your take on this and I never said that I am right on this, I know too little to ever make that claim. I wasn't aware how emotional this topic is to many, this happens to me IRL alot too (I am also aware of why). I am just looking for exchange of ideas, i don't need to be right on this.
- foxhill 2y agoso, when do you want to die, then? really, i’m not trying to be mean here. you assert life must be finite, and all i’m asking is how finite it should be.
- satvikpendem 2y agoWhile I am all for immortality, an oft given answer I've seen is, when I can no longer support myself, physically. That means old and frail and unable to walk or move. With immortality though could also come anti aging, so I'm not sure how strong that answer really is.
- financetechbro 2y agoLife is not life without death. Personally, I don’t necessarily want to die, I love to live. But also, death is the only thing that makes life precious.
- kiba 2y ago
- marcheradiuju 2y ago'Denial of death' is a nice philosophical treatise on this topic by an anthropologist. It's ideas would likely change many of the minds of posters here.
- person101x 2y ago[flagged]
- scubbo 2y ago> There is abundant evidence of some kind of life after death. Is that evidence in the room with us right now?
- coding123 2y agoWe've made life WYSIWYG
- digging 2y ago> Every major world religion asserts that it is evident that humans have an afterlife. There is abundant evidence of some kind of life after death. I'm sorry but I can't see how the first sentence supports the second in any meaningful way. It's easy and pointless to shit on religion and I'm not doing that here, but "evidence" is something other than common stories. Consider that the evidence for a non-evolutionary origin of humanity is equally abundant, in religious traditions. Would you say that evolution is still dubious because so many traditional beliefs exist that don't include it? Would you hold up "we're molded from clay, because a lot of people said so" next to centuries of living and fossil evidence for an evolutionary origin of humanity and say, "Well, they both have a lot of evidence."? I believe the source of your confusion is that death is such a black box. But the failure of current science to pierce that veil doesn't make non-evidence-based theories any more valid. It only means, "this is still unknown." Could there be an afterlife? Sure, it's possible, but there's not yet any significant evidence for one.
- person101x 2y ago> I'm sorry but I can't see how the first sentence supports the second in any meaningful way. It's easy and pointless to shit on religion and I'm not doing that here, but "evidence" is something other than common stories. > Could there be an afterlife? Sure, it's possible, but there's not yet any significant evidence for one. First off, you can discount "common stories" all you want, but even science operates on "common stories", i.e. we use a "common" method, record our observations, and make educated guesses about what those observations imply, and share our results. When we begin to come to a "common" consensus, we say the stories line up and that therefore we've likely hit upon some truth. It's so easy to find the evidence I didn't think I'd have to mention them. Off the top of my head, we can observe the numerous accounts of near-death experiences across cultures and religions which share striking commonalities. Then you can also point to paranormal phenomena also universal across cultures and religions. Another line of thought would be to read some Plato, particularly the Phaedo which gives several very convincing arguments for the immortality of the soul.
- pavlov 2y agoLook at the gerontocracy that already exists in the United States, both the politicians and billionaires like Rupert Murdoch. A ruling class will always stick around as long as they can. Do we really want to make those rulers immortal too? Seems like a tremendous risk that the cure for death will ossify one generation's rule. Those immortal 0.1-percenters who own everything will then fear nothing more than a violent revolution because they can still be physically destroyed. They'll do everything to keep the less fortunate in place under their thumb, forever. The world of immortals would make Nazi Germany look like child's play. When death is no longer inevitable, avoiding it can become a dominating obsession. Who's to say how many people an immortal human would be prepared to kill to ensure his own survival?
- kiba 2y agoThe ruling class is a function of their social class. It is the immortality of the social class that is the problem. If the children inherit their parents' wealth, it is likely that the ruling class will persists. Also, stability and stagnation of social system be factored in. More dynamic society can outcompete and ultimately destabilize stagnant and morbid societies. North Korea and South Korea came to mind. The dictator of North Korea is younger than South Korea's president who was born in the 1960 as opposed to the dictator being born in 1982. The dictator continues his family's legacy of ruling over a stagnant and increasingly irrelevant country while South Korea continues to be a vibrant and dynamic society. South Korea definitely has problem, notably a looming demographic crisis, but it is not an inevitability in how they choose to deal with their problem.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoWhen successful, wealthy people die, they usually pass that wealth to more than one person. Those people in turn pass their more modest wealth down to more than one person. So it goes exponentially until the fortune dissipates. With the wealth goes the influence and power. Additionally, most rich people will now set up foundations that get the majority of their wealth, so the kids lose any claim to that pool of money. The timescale on which this happens today is surprisingly rapid compared to the lifespans that many immortality-lovers want. For example, the infamous Rothschild family is collectively worth only $1 billion now. That is the whole family, not any one individual. A modern example of the beginning of this process is the Walton family. Going back further, the descendants of many 1600s English barons have middle-class lives, but one person from each family retains the fancy title. The only societies that keep concentration of wealth are ones with primogeniture and other unequal distributions of wealth to children.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- financetechbro 2y agoWhenever I think about living forever, my first question is… who is going to pay for it? To me, it feels like the idea of living forever, at least in modern capitalism (and post 1776), is just a way to keep on feeding the capitalism machine. So is the end game here to be enslaved forever to a job? Unless we somehow become enlightened enough to have UBI or simply move away from a capitalist system, living forever seems like an endless hell for the majority, and yet more opportunity for the wealthy to compound their wealth and maintain their reign on society. The real question here is who are true beneficiaries of living forever, and how do the rest of us pay for the repercussions.
- vslira 2y agoAll those in favor of eventually dying are welcome to do so at their own convenience, after a long and fulfilling life. To the rest of us, the stars, please.
- tengbretson 2y ago[flagged]
- rbanffy 2y agoThe article mentions the book was compiled from his notes with the help of his daughter.
- tengbretson 2y agoInteresting. Though now looking at his 2.5k word obituary it does seem that his daughter was given the honors of being mentioned in a single parenthetical for existing. I was mistaken because I couldn't find any mention of children from his Wikipedia. I suppose theres only so much space in an article, and what would you cut? The section that lists the famous women with whom he cheated on his wife? No way!
- usixk 2y ago[flagged]
- rbanffy 2y agoI believe death is a nuisance. I am tired of burying people I love. I already miss the time I won’t spend with my family after I die - with love comes loss, because we know death is unavoidable. Between my wife and I we kind of agree that the one who goes first is the lucky one. Would I enjoy 10 trillion years of life? I don’t know. My human mind has limits about how much information it can hold. Will I by then have forgotten my first love? Will I forget holding my first child? Will I have forgotten cuddling up in my mom’s lap? Will I miss having forgotten these things? If I can still remember all those moments, so long in the past, will I still be human in any sense?
- VeninVidiaVicii 2y agoYou’re way more likely to stop making any new memories.
- rbanffy 2y agoThen it’d be eternal dementia, a fate probably much worse than death.
- kiba 2y agoWe already forget people, places, events, and things even as young adults.
- cannonpr 2y agoI don’t think you have any evidence to say that. Our understanding of memory and complex evolved neural networks like the mind is fairly poor. On top of that, we have more evidence of the mind still acquiring new memories and choosing to compact or drop irrelevant memories while it remains healthy.
- otikik 2y agoYou must have a very good memory, then. I was made painfully aware of how not great mine was yesterday. I met this woman through my wife. It turns out I already met this person 5 years ago, because we share a common friend. She remembered me quite clearly, but I had completely forgotten her, as well as the event where we met. So far all good, it was 5 years ago after all. However, she also told me that we had met before that! 20 years ago! Through a work acquaintance of mine this time. We apparently did some hiking through the countryside together. I remember nothing of that. I don't remember that second acquaintance either. Apparently it was the same situation 5 years ago; she told me all of this, I apologized for forgetting her and everything around meeting her. And then I forgot her. And that was only the first time. To me my memory is not a "bucket that eventually gets full". It's more like a "dark corridor". Memories are on the walls. As I move forwards, the parts of the corridor behind me get eventually darker, until only the brightest memories remain visible. I have forgotten most of my highschool classmates. I have forgotten most of my past coworkers. I have some memories from my childhood, still. But only the very bright ones. And they are continuously dimming. I am completely fine with this. I am still me. I think forgetting is part of what makes us human. Or at least, of what makes me human. Going back to this person that I forgot twice. Apparently she remembers everyone she has ever met, even if just once. I have met at least another person with this capacity. I can't but consider those people freaks of nature, and in consequence a potential danger for society. We should watch them closely. And perhaps we should watch you closely as well. At least until I forget all of you again. I have no doubt in my mind that my memory will never "fill up". More like the opposite: the danger is that it empties too fast at some point.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoI love that egotistical billionaires with a god complex go to bed afraid of dying. I wouldn't want to take that away from them.
- jaharios 2y agoΌσα δεν φτάνει η αλεπού τα κάνει κρεμαστάρια
- Aaronstotle 2y agoI really loathe the hubris of modern people who think we shouldn't die like everyone did for millennia before us. Yes, we live longer and we have better medicine, stop trying to live forever.
- cannonpr 2y agoI loathe the hubris of modern people that feel they should impose their way of life and morals on others.
- opvouste11 2y ago[flagged]
- tavavex 2y agoOP: "Stop trying to live forever" Commenter1: "Stop telling others what to do with no justification" Commenter2: "Did you just tell us to stop? Sounds like you're the real problem here, 1"
- foobiekr 2y ago"you should die because our ancestors did" "you should be/keep slaves because our ancestors were/did" etc. Your logic is weird and false. There's nothing holy about dying.
- littlekey 2y agoDying is one of the most holy things there is. Every major religion is deeply concerned with the question of mortality and imo would collapse without it. Christianity means basically nothing without the death of Christ, Buddhism nothing without the cycle of reincarnation, etc. Whether that's good or bad is a different question, but the point is getting rid of death is not a trivial thing. It would cause such huge changes in the human experience that I think we'd cease to be human and would become some other, different thing.
- 2y ago
- cannonpr 2y agoI want to live forever. That doesn't mean I want to remain static and unchanging or to stagnate. I want death through change, not because my mind collapses due to biological causes. If I ever stagnate, that's a form of death, and I bet sooner or later I'll choose to check out, or become irrelevant enough for society and my peers to check me out, directly or indirectly, through social exclusion. I strongly resent those who try to tell me what's best for me or predict what will happen if I live a long time. If you think death within 40-90 years is best for you, choose that path, stop trying to validate your life philosophy by imposing it on others and leave the rest of us alone to develop technology and strive for something more than what we are today.
- tomalaci 2y agoAgreed. The amount of people trying to tell that dying is the right way of life is baffling. Vast majority of natural deaths arent graceful, they often are quite painful and ugly. If we develop means to at least extend the average -healthy- lifespan that would be a great achievement by itself.
- tavavex 2y agoSomehow, people in real life are pretty capable of recognizing why arguments based around what others think is "natural" are completely useless - yet this is ignored completely in discussions of prolonging people's lives. Suddenly, the natural is all that matters. And here, natural means "precisely the current status quo" - no one's eager to return to the life expectancy of the past.
- scubbo 2y ago> The amount of people trying to tell that dying is the right way of life is baffling. Vast majority of natural deaths arent graceful, they often are quite painful and ugly Both statements are true, but they are not necessarily causally related. _Even if_ all natural deaths were graceful, painless, and beautiful, it would still be a horrific senseless tragedy that "lives have to end"
- walleeee 2y ago
- epx 2y agoImagine being able to live forever... in the dungeon of a dictatorship that is forever as well.
- useerup 2y agoDeath is a moral responsibility. You owe your existence to evolution. Evolution would not work if we had to compete for resources with all of the organisms that came before us when they didn't die off. Death is an integral part of living a bringing our species forward. Your responsibility is to make the best of your time here. Have fun, love, and contribute to society and science if you can. Then die and make room for the next generations.
- cannonpr 2y agoA moral responsibility under which moral framework ? Why do I owe anything to my genes or the process that created me nearly by accident ? Why do I not have a moral responsibility to find a better path than random evolution ?
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoEvolution doesn't have a "forward". If we were unable to outcompete our ancestors, then we simply wouldn't be better adapted to our environment than they.
- tavavex 2y agoEvolution isn't a person, or an entity to be compensated. It's a natural process. If humans can surpass it, find a new way to improve themselves, then do it. All of this argument seems like one extended appeal to nature, combined with some backwards-justified reasoning as to why being limited in time is a good thing - start with the premise that our lives are short, and then find a way to make that sound appealing.
- whythre 2y agoI don’t think you get to ‘surpass’ evolution with regards to increasing life span. Maybe you can retard the process. But I think that is just kicking the can down the road. Its like an old growth forest not being allowed to burn, it’s caretakers keeping it in media res for as long as possible until it eventually burns anyway and the natural cycle continues.
- drawkward 2y agoThe insane amount of hubris and entitlement on display among the pro immortality crowd here is enough to make me terrified of the tech sector.
- meindnoch 2y agoLiving forever is impossible, period. On a long enough timescale, any nonzero probability accident will kill you. But actually the heat death of the Universe will happen even earlier than that.
- FlacoJones 2y agoAsimov said this was his favorite thing he ever wrote, and it addresses this same idea. The Last Question - Isaac Asimov - Read by Leonard Nimoy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XOtx4sa9k4&t=544s&ab_channel=CoolPsychoFacts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XOtx4sa9k4&t=544s&ab_channe...
- knodi123 2y agoThis is silly. People who talk about wanting to achieve immortality aren't talking about doing it through a genie wish that gets ironically turned against them, leaving them hovering in agony in deep space after the heat death of the universe. Any reasonable discussion of immortality really just means the end of senescence.
- jewayne 2y agoI mean, even having your biological age somehow suspended at age 30 is a monkey's paw-type wish, especially if all the people you love age normally. Your spouse turning into an old husk of their former self before your eyes, as your children become your peers, then your elders. After awhile, you think of your spouses like dogs, knowing each time you take a new one that one day they will be gone.
- knodi123 2y agoHaving your biological age suspended at 30 doesn't preclude death. You can always kill yourself whenever you want. If you don't want to, it's because you think there's a reason to keep living. > After awhile, you think of your spouses like dogs, knowing each time you take a new one that one day they will be gone. I still love my dogs with all my heart, treasure the time I have with them, mourn them when they're gone, and still find happiness in my life. And still choose to adopt new ones on occasion. Plus, I'm not sure why you think, in this scenario, that the immortality technology is only available to me and not any of my loved ones.
- FlacoJones 2y agoThe Last Question - Isaac Asimov - Read by Leonard Nimoy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XOtx4sa9k4&t=544s&ab_channel=CoolPsychoFacts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XOtx4sa9k4&t=544s&ab_channe... Even if the longevity obsessed manage Earthly immortality, non-existence will forever loom. Will they be happy with 100 years? 500? 1 million? Non-existence remains a theological not scientific hurdle.
- mmmBacon 2y agoI’m not sure it’s the length of our actual lifespan that matters as much as how we experience the passing of time. I believe that our human experience of the passing of time intervals is exponential with age. With this view, if we lived 1 million years, our lives would probably still feel too short due to the acceleration of time we experience as we age.
- Beijinger 2y agoI check it out. But isn't this an old story? "After Enkidu dies of a disease sent as punishment from the gods, Gilgamesh becomes afraid of his death and visits the sage Utnapishtim, the survivor of the Great Flood, hoping to find immortality. Gilgamesh repeatedly fails the trials set before him and returns home to Uruk, realizing that immortality is beyond his reach."
- evgwugegwhwgeg 2y agoIt's the ego that dies. Awareness is eternal. You the awareness is already here and now for eternity. Ego is the idea of you. The loosely connected memories that you consider as you.
- jewayne 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- latexr 2y agoYale has an interesting philosophy course on death, available online. https://oyc.yale.edu/death/phil-176 https://oyc.yale.edu/death/phil-176 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEA18FAF1AD9047B0 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEA18FAF1AD9047B0
- pyuser583 2y agoElias Canetti is best known for “Crowds and Power”, which is best known as the inspiration of the poem “On Reading ‘Crowds and Power’” by Geoffrey Hill. Canetti had only written that one book when he got the Nobel Prize, and was mostly unknown. It’s hard to imagine the Nobel Committee elevating an obscure journalist, giving him the highest honor for a writer, and then him returning to perpetual obscurity. If it was in a fictional book, it would be dismissed as unrealistic.
- ETH_start 2y agoThe vast majority of healthcare spending is incurred at the end of life, because when death really approaches, almost everyone wants to avoid it. People who are explicitly pursuing immortality are just thinking on a long-term basis instead of only reacting once they face the reality of mortality, in their impending death. But amongst the popular left, there seems to be an aversion to competency and rationality, as they are symbolically linked to high status and social dominance. This anti-rationalism, born from a desire to challenge existing power structures, leads to a disdain for those who work deliberately to eradicate aging and illness—as the effort is a reflection of a rational, results-oriented mindset.