17 ms·
How many EV charging stations does the US need to replace gas stations?
- nottorp 2y agoOf course, whatever Wired says only works if everyone lives the suburb life style. In Europe you'd need a lot more public chargers.
- moooo99 2y agoOne could argue that in Europe, you’d have a much easier time to design the infrastructure in such a way that reliance on cars in general is substantially reduced, hence also removing demand for EV chargers of any kind
- redserk 2y agoEurope isn’t this monolithic 100% hyperdense urban utopia Americans tend to think it is. There are a lot of suburbs and rural areas where people still use cars.
- moooo99 2y agoI am aware that this is the case, especially since I am European. However, this is a non-argument against my initial claim. The top comment made a point implying that having home charging stations is only possible if you're living that suburban lifestyle (i.e. single family home/duplex with designated parking) but in a city with on street parking it is not. Howver, most (bigger) european cities have some resemblance of decent public transport infrastructure and are less car-centered than US cities, making the move to non-car transportation much easier than in the US. For rural areas and suburbs, where people have to rely on cars, the initial argument doesn't even apply considering they are living the "suburban lifestyle" that has been deemed a non-issue from the go
- nottorp 2y agoNice theory but while Europe is better than the US in that respect, I believe the only place where that actually works is the likes of Japan... [Bet that some Japanese HNer will show up in 4... 3... 2... 1... to complain about their traffic though.]
- Symbiote 2y ago> As a result of the early efforts to make the switch to EVs, the US currently has 188,600 public and private charging ports, and 67,900 charging stations, according to data collected by the US Department of Energy and > There were more than 630,000 charge points in the bloc at the end of 2023 (https://www.transportenvironment.org/articles/most-eu-countries-on-track-to-meet-charging-targets https://www.transportenvironment.org/articles/most-eu-countr...) so Europe (the EU) is already well ahead.
- azinman2 2y agoThe title literally says the US. Every country is different.
- rootusrootus 2y agoWell over half of the population owns or rents a detached or semi-detached home with plausible driveway charging. Yes we need to work on the people who don't have that option, but it is totally valid to observe that a huge chunk of people only need public chargers a couple times a year.
- dymk 2y agoSeattle is rapidly installing EV chargers on power poles for public use in dense urban areas
- 201984 2y agoOnly 25 for the whole city so far, and with a 60% markup over standard electricity rates (0.21/kWh vs 0.13/kWh).
- MostlyStable 2y agoThat's about half the price of commercial DC fast charging in my area ($0.40-$0.50/kWh), and, according to the math in another comment, about half the break even price with gasoline. It's certainly more expensive than what I pay to charge at my house, but I wouldn't be mad about it if I had that available to me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 2y agoThis is assuming that electrical cars are "filled up" the same way as gas cars are. This is very far away from being as fast and convenient as filling up a gas tank in 1-2 minutes. I like the model that you swap your low charge battery with a fully charged one. That would require some new technology.
- sgt 2y agoIn Norway, people charge at home. EV stations are mainly for roadtrips. The gas station comparison does not make sense.
- xenospn 2y agoI’m actually confused about Norway, you see a lot of electric cars parked down the street but no one has a garage in Norway (in the city, at least), and I haven’t seen many cars actually plugged in. Where does everyone charge?
- pornel 2y agoIn the UK supermarkets have fast chargers. You park, plug in, go shopping, return to a fully charged car (similarly at pubs, cafes, gyms, etc.) BEVs don't have to be plugged in like cellphones. In city driving one full charge can suffice for a whole week of commuting and errands.
- t0mas88 2y agoHow is the price for fast chargers in the UK? In the Netherlands it's crazy, something like 3-4x the price of home charging and close to 10x what you would "loose" on using your own solar power instead of selling it to the grid. For most hybrids using a fast charger is over 2x more expensive per mile than using petrol.
- sgt 2y agoMost people live outside the cities, so the more common scenario is having a house and a garage. If you live in an apartment building, there might be charging points. People parked on the street in the city streets have fewer options.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoYou need to calculate how many charging stations you need at time of peak demand, like Thanksgiving weekend when half the country is making a road trip.
- sloowm 2y agoI don't think building a bunch of year round useless charging capacity is useful. But I also think relying on car infrastructure for Thanksgiving is a bad idea and that hasn't stopped the US.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoSo what is your solution? Because if your answer starts with "people should just stop traveling for holidays" then it's not going to work.
- mdorazio 2y agoIf people want to drive during peak seasons, let them wait a few extra minutes at chargers? This seems like a problem that supply and demand will solve pretty efficiently.
- bitmasher9 2y agoThe concern is that problems like Thanksgiving will decrease the demand for EVs.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoSure, if it's just a few minutes. I've heard of 4 hour waits at Thanksgiving. If it's that or worse "supply and demand" will result in people buying gasoline vehicles instead of electric vehicles.
- sloowm 2y agoThere are other ways to make sure people can travel but I understand those are hard to imagine if you live somewhere where you only have hammers.
- redserk 2y agoAnecdotally, in conversations with other drivers, it seems that far too many people overestimate their driving habits. A standard wall outlet will charge a car perfectly fine for your average driver assuming you can park the car for several hours. I would hope the vast majority of Americans who have access to a driveway will be able to find a block of time for this. Perhaps this duration may be found overnight when one sleeps. If the worst happens and you need to travel for an emergency, you just need enough juice to get you to a DC fast charger. You’d only be spending 10 minutes charging anyways to carry on. I would place bets that most people do not keep their gas cars filled to 100% in case they need to do that weekly emergency 300-mile drive that everyone seems to have. The bigger and most realistic issue is capacity for travel rushes. When everyone’s driving to relatives for the holidays, finding a line at chargers isn’t ideal. Fortunately this isn’t a problem in the vast majority places today and I hope continued investment in fast charging networks ensures this remains a limited problem.
- NegativeK 2y agoI was charging my car on a 120V, 15A circuit (12A draw to the car) for over a year. I'd use about 8kWh per day with a 20 mile round trip commute + extras; that translated to needing about 5.5 hours of charging. It really was fine, but it was near the limit of what's practical without using a fast charger. Extra trips around town would put me at a deficit, and it'd take a few nights of charging to bring things back up to my set point of 80%. Additionally, I had to think a few days out for when I'd know I'd be doing a bunch of driving to make sure I gave myself enough buffer. Now, having a charging circuit that can put out over 9kW means I can think about it a lot less. But I thoroughly agree with you: a normal mains outlet is often fine, and holiday road trips can be messy.
- b112 2y agoYou know, there's a car train between the northern US and further south. Your car goes on one train car, you get to relax in the train. And I know the UK/france tunnel is like this too. Seems like an optimal solution in some respects, if optimized. For example, millions of Canadians travel to Florida each year for the winter, a lot by car. If such a train ran once a day, it would help many with range anxiety for such cases. But imagine if major cities had such trains between them daily? These can still carry commuters without cars, too! And of course, we don't need everyone to be covered by this solution today, because the goal is to keep the transition to electric happening. This would help.
- grecy 2y agoHeadline 100 years ago: "How many gas stations does the US need to replace Hay and farriers?" Obviously for the first few years it was difficult to drive an automobile very far.. and every year it got better and better.
- xenospn 2y agoThe difference is, you can create a gas station with a barrel and a pump. No need for infrastructure.
- theshrike79 2y agoAlso every single house in the civilised world has an electric outlet, the infrastructure is already built.
- erik_seaberg 2y agoSure, but the curbs three blocks away do not, and around here there's been no progress towards building it.
- theshrike79 2y agoCurbside parking is shit for everyone. I would be really hesitant to leave any car I'm not willing to lose on the curb.
- rootusrootus 2y agoYou can (and people do) create a charging station with just a battery. Using the same metric as the gas station, which will indeed need more than just a barrel to make it work.
- pornel 2y agoYou can create a charging station with solar panels and a battery. Gas stations don't fill up themselves out of thin air — a massive infrastructure has been built (and wars fought for) for extraction, refining, and supplying the fuel.
- jmpman 2y agoMy concern is the number of charger stations required between LA and Phoenix in the remote sections of I-10. Replacing all the cars with EVs that need to charge at a minimum of twice and you need two parking garages the size of the mall of America’s parking lot - each spot with its own supercharger. The power consumption is equal to a nuclear power plant for each garage. And this is only required for the peak Thanksgiving traffic. The rest of the time, 90% of the chargers would be idle. Oh, and this would in Quartzsite, a town of 2500. There aren’t power lines capable of this power. All the infrastructure would need to be built.
- LargeWu 2y agoIf this is so heavily traveled, then maybe rail is a better option. We need to dispense with the idea that auto traffic is the only option, or that we need to optimize for a particular mode.
- epolanski 2y agoAmen, we ain't gonna get much greener either by making a hundred million EVs per year..
- derwiki 2y agoWouldn’t rail also be idle 90% of the time?
- bastawhiz 2y agoRail can haul cargo as well. The cost of idle rail is very very low compared to the cost of maintaining charging infrastructure.
- rootusrootus 2y agoThe intercity rail part is the easy part. Getting people to actually use it requires a pretty decent city transit network on each end. On top of that, cargo and passenger trains don't really coexist that nicely. Nobody really wants to spend bullet train money on cargo, but that's what you need if you want to have bullet train speed for passengers on the same track. Nice thing about charging infrastructure is that another name for it is "the grid." It already exists everywhere. And in rural areas that don't have enough grid capacity for high peak loads, use batteries (which are getting much cheaper) as a buffer.
- simonjgreen 2y ago> the US currently has 188,600 public and private charging ports That seems... very low. Admittedly I'm from UK, but I don't know a single EV owner that doesn't have a home charger.
- Tagbert 2y agoYea, not sure about that number for private charging ports. They certainly don’t know about the Level-2 charger in my garage. I wouldn’t even include private chargers since the numbers would necessarily be unreliable.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoPrivate chargers may refer to e.g. those on Apple’s campus available only to their employees.
- xutopia 2y agoI'm hoping for a less car centric future. Cars seem so limiting to me.
- johnea 2y agoIn the US, ~70% of people live in single family houses. Most people already have an EV "gas station" at home...
- radley 2y agoUpgrade all parking spaces to wireless charging. (I don't know if it exists yet, but it will. Same with charging strips on roads. Death Stranding forever.)
- theshrike79 2y agoWireless charging is shit and snake oil. What you need is a law that requires every apartment parking spot to have a charger - or at the very least a law that explicitly allows people to install chargers in their parking spots themselves[0] Also a certain percentage of public/store/corporate parking should be mandated to have chargers. One stop at Target is enough to charge more than it took to drive there and back even with a Level 2 charger. [0] by hiring a licensed electrician of course, not by themselves
- Animats 2y agoChargers are not going to be a problem as long as they are profitable. Looking a few years ahead, there's enough going on with solid state batteries that somebody, probably Toyota or one of the Chinese manufacturers, will ship that in quantity. Charging times should drop to 10 minutes. Chargers will have to have more power, but might not be more than the current number of gas pumps. We won't need more real estate for charging stations. This matters.
- mike_d 2y ago> as long as they are profitable Which will be a big part of the problem. Gas stations aren't profitable. The convenience store with $6 bags of chips next to it is. We also learned in the early 2000s with the "datacenter in a shipping container that can go anywhere" fad that highly dense power isn't available in most places. As EV charging chains try to scale externalize costs onto the grid we will just end up subsidizing corporate profits.
- Animats 2y agoMcKinsey claims charging stations can be.[1] That was written before 10 minute charging looked possible. If charge times get down to 10 minutes, a gas station model works. Hour-long charging requires something for the humans to do. [1] https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/our-insights/ev-fast-charging-how-to-build-and-sustain-competitive-differentiation https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/...
- mike_d 2y agoSorry I should say gas stations are profitable standing alone. Once two gas stations exist it is a race to the fixed price floor (all stations buy from the same distributors in the same way all charging stations will buy from the same grid). There is no brand loyalty or product differentiation. McKinsey also thought it was a good idea to produce a report for the Saudi government that brought their attention to Jamal Khashoggi, ultimately leading to his murder.
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoUnrelated to the article....but I can't ree myself getting an EV currently. 1. They just don't sound like the muscle cars. 2. For me personally, battery density isn't good enough, and I don't like how you can't just buy replacement batteries for some cars.... 3. With the lack of energy density comes the range issues in extream weather. 4. Software. Iv seen the software on some of these cars....I'd rather bike somewhere than drive in those. 5. Some vehicles with the one pedal driving have an issue where can can be slowing down, yet not hitting the brake pedal, yet no break lights are engaged. 6. Safety, gas isn't safe but I fear those EV battery's more than explosives or florine. EV battery's are big, bulky, and despite how big they are are not as energy dense as gasoline....yet they are a magnitude worse to put out. Also electricity isn't cheap where I live...and while charging to 100% is cheaper than gas....combined with the density and safety factors it's just not viable for me to be a consumer yet
- spullara 2y agoThis is the most uninformed comment I have ever seen at the top of HN. So much so I think it is likely trolling. Somehow you all fell for it.
- gambiting 2y agoLiterally every single point is wrong(other than 1 which is obviously true and 4 which is subjective). It absolutely has to be a troll, or someone who is genuienly tragically uninformed.
- throwbadubadu 2y agoThat's human... there will always be the kind of people that have their lists ready why the future will right now and also never in the future work for them, fortunately there is a long time perspective in evolution also in regard to ideas&thinking.
- hnbad 2y agoWell, first of all, you should definitely consider biking some places rather than taking a car, EV or not. Even e-bikes are more energy efficient than most other modes of transport. There's also nothing that could really convince you if you want your cars to be noisy because there's no need for EVs to be noisy. I guess the only way to check that one off the list would be environmental regulations controlling noise pollution which would ding most ICE vehicles (and having lived and worked near busy roads I'm surprised those aren't already much stricter). But I'd still like to address some of your worries: > battery density isn't good enough I guess you mean "range isn't good enough" as battery density isn't really a meaningful stat by itself. I agree, there are few models available that have a good range comparable to an ICE. However with "super charging" you often don't spend more than 10 or 20 minutes at a charging station and these stops can often work nicely as toilet breaks or food breaks when making longer trips. But the real answer is that for longer trips you just need to plan your trips differently. With home charging you also ideally don't need to use public charging for most day-to-day trips. EVs certainly excel more at shorter ranges and frequent trips than occasional long range travel. > replacement batteries This really depends on the make and model. Some brands offer batteries for lease which means your battery will be swapped out before it reaches its end of life. If you buy the battery you might save money in the long run but will have to take care of replacing it yourself. Some Chinese manufacturers are fielding technology that allows swapping out batteries instead of charging them so that may also become a thing in the US and EU in the future. > range issues in extreme weather This one is true to some extent but varies by model. There was a lot of FUD about this earlier this year because it makes for good (i.e. high engagement) news stories but the short of it is that EVs behave differently than ICE cars and you need to take this into account. Cars generally don't handle extreme cold well and running your heating/aircon on max will drain your battery/fuel in either case. > I've seen the software on some of these cars Not much I can say to that as you're not giving me much to respond to. Yeah, some early models (e.g. Fisker Ocean) are notorious for software issues but these are usually mostly annoyances, nothing safety relevant. > Some vehicles with the one pedal driving have an issue where can can be slowing down, yet not hitting the brake pedal, yet no break lights are engaged. This is a common misunderstanding of how EV braking works: most EVs have a form of regenerative braking that recovers the energy from deceleration by releasing the gas pedal. If the brake lights came on every time you took the foot off the pedal, that would confuse everyone involved, so usually the brake lights will engage only on a delay or when actively braking using the brake pedal. Think of it like switching gears in a stick shift to "engine brake" - that wouldn't trigger the brake lights to come on either. Usually regenerative braking can't do a full stop so it will cut out at a certain minimum speed and require manual braking to stop the car. This has in some cases led to confusion because the stop in deceleration will be misinterpreted as the car accelerating again, especially when regenerative braking happens while manually braking using the brake pedal. It's 100% a matter of what you're used to. > gas isn't safe but I fear those EV batteries That's absolutely correct. EV batteries, once burning, will keep burning and will need to be submerged and kept submerged to ensure they don't catch fire again. I guess the positive is that they can't leak. A fuel leak might result in combustible fumes spilling into the interior whereas a battery will only catch fire exactly where it is. But realistically I'd rather hope we can move away from lithium in the future. > electricity isn't cheap I think that's the crux of it. EVs work best in urban or suburban environments with private charging infrastructure and cheap energy sources like rooftop solar. Gas is also notoriously cheap in the US compared to most EU countries where EVs can be significantly cheaper. But the killer app really is at home "slow" (i.e. over night) charging.
- ttfkam 2y agoSomeday… someday… (sub)urban dwellers will wake up to cars being the problem, not the type of car. Yep, EVs are better than ICEs. Public transportation and proper infrastructure is far better (and cheaper overall). Get the public transit in order, and you don't need so many charging stations.
- freddref 2y agoHow about self driving cars as public transport?
- hotpotatoe 2y agoDoesn’t solve the underlying problems that are caused by having car-centric cities. Walkable cities where most people’s needs are meet within walking distance and the mass transit for times you need to further is the real solution.
- freddref 2y agoAgree on walkable, although I really like the idea of personal public transport that would be door-to-door and on-demand. I expect it would distribute cities more, and alleviate the hub-and-spoke model that public transport is sometimes built to, e.g. Dublin, Ireland.
- hotpotatoe 2y agoWhich would still cause traffic issues, wasting public land on building more roads and wasting energy and resources. Plus propping up the auto industry that caused the problem in the first place.
- baggy_trough 2y agoWhat if you don't want to live in a city as dense as that?
- ufo 2y agoCars are carry less people per area of road than buses do and it's even worse for self driving cars that are empty half the time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- api 2y agoI live in the Midwest and the biggest issue I see here is that all the fast chargers are in the cities, which is precisely where you don't need many of them. There are not nearly enough along interstates between cities, which is where you need them for road trips. We charge our EV in our garage and that's fine for 95% of all driving. For apartments having outlets or simple L2 charging would be perfectly adequate.
- ProjectArcturis 2y agoHow hard could it be to add chargers to most gas stations? Just add them to the front of the building where the row of parking spots is. Bet they'd sell a lot more snacks, too.
- bottle_roket 2y agoYeah but who wants to spend 45 minutes sitting around in a gas station parking lot? It be much nicer to install them in roadside rest stops, city/state parks, or near dense clusters of businesses.
- pornel 2y agoEVs can be charged while parked, and there are nicer destinations to park at. Shopping malls usually are in a better position to add charging, because they already have high-power grid connections, more parking space, and more things to do while the car is charging.
- Bulkington 2y agoThis deals mainly with commercial vehicle electrification, but the broader discussion is on topic: Grid not ready, not close. https://www.fleetowner.com/emissions-efficiency/video/55020457/is-the-us-power-grid-ready-for-electrification https://www.fleetowner.com/emissions-efficiency/video/550204... Money chart (2022) is here: https://www.fleetowner.com/perspectives/running-lights/blog/21255007/us-grid-not-prepared-for-electric-truck-avalanche https://www.fleetowner.com/perspectives/running-lights/blog/...
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- markus_zhang 2y agoI'm wondering if there is a way to calculate the peak KW amount during Christmas or Thanksgiving or any national holidays, for Quebec. My friends said it's going to break the infras but I'm just curious. It's actually pretty frequent, not just once a year, not two, but probably 4-6 per year.
- p1necone 2y agoAnecdotally - probably not that many. I have a 2018 leaf with ~220km of range on a full charge, and my commute is about 20km each way. We probably travel far enough to actually need a fast charge maybe once every 6 months or so? It will charge to full overnight on regular wall power from ~30% so it never runs anywhere near low enough to be a problem. The convenience factor of never having to spend time stopping at a petrol station can't be overstated, now I just spend 10 seconds plugging the car in after work every two or three days instead (although I do still stop for junk food sometimes). And to preempt the "it wouldn't work for me" comments - sure, but "how many chargers do we need" is a whole population average question, and I suspect (although I have no hard data) that the vast majority of driving is work commutes that aren't long enough for most EVs to come close to running out of charge. Although I live in a country with 240v power - I imagine you might want to hook up a dedicated full 240v socket similar to the wiring for ovens/stoves if you were in the United States?
- dbcurtis 2y agoHere in NorCal it is common to have the laundry in the garage. If you have an electric dryer, then sharing the dryer circuit makes some sense. Sure, you can’t dry clothes and charge the car at the same time. I can live with that.
- steelframe 2y agoI'm a fairly early adopter of EVs, and my family's current collection includes 2 BEVs, 1 PHEV, and 1 ICE. Road tripping more than about 250 miles in an EV with today's class of 18650-like cells doesn't give me the experience that dino juice does, which is what I want. So when I'm going out of town, I'm either in the PHEV or the ICE car. For example, a couple of weeks ago I headed out from Seattle to Walla Walla for the weekend. This is a 275-mile trip through the Cascade mountain range with speeds close to 80mph for most of the drive. BEVs that can do that without stopping tend to cost between 3-5 times the cost of either my PHEV or ICE. If I were to take my $25k (current value) BEV from 2019 I'd need to stop at least once, likely in Yakima, to roll the dice with the Electrify America stations in the Walmart parking lot. When I get there I can expect that several of the stalls will be ICEd because nobody in Yakima gives a flying fsck about anyone else, especially jackwads in their fancy weird EVs passing through town on their way to anywhere-but-Yakima. There's no practical enforcement of the "Pretty please only let people in EVs use these stalls" signs. There's a better-than-not chance that at least one of the chargers will be broken. Depending on when I get there -- say, late afternoon at the end of Memorial Day weekend -- I will find that there is a line of BEVs waiting to charge. And by "line" I mean people arriving and parking in whatever haphazard way they can somewhere near the chargers and then maybe following some vague resemblance of "first in first out" queuing as stalls open up. Maybe they will form an actual line snaking through the parking lot blocking regular parking spots. I don't know, but for me at least being in a crowd of people trying to get a charge will at least be awkward and stressful. When I finally get into the stall to charge I will need make sure I have cell phone reception so I can activate the charger, unless maybe I got lucky and found a charger that actually works with a credit card. Then hopefully the charger will successfully handshake with my EV from 2019, start charging, and keep charging without faulting out. It takes about 45 minutes to get enough charge to make it to my destination. Depending on how long it takes to wait for a stall to open up and then get enough charge, my 4-hour trip has turned into what's likely to be a 6-hour trip each way, making a total of 8 hours on the road look more like 12 hours. It will cost about as much as it would have cost to use gasoline instead. So that's what needs fixing. The charger capacity we have now wouldn't be horrible if (1) "charging EVs only" rules were swiftly and regularly enforced, (2) the chargers that did exist were reliable, and (3) my $25k EV were capable of charging 10% to 90% in about 15 minutes. Bonus points if I can walk up to a teller, hand them cash, and then charge without my car reporting its identity or anything like that. Because, you know, people should be able to travel without having their comings and goings tracked by data brokers. But I'm just one of those old-school privacy freaks who thinks where I'm going and when isn't anyone's business but my own, I guess. We're getting there, gradually. Very, very gradually. I am frankly very disappointed in how things have turned out since I bought my BEV 5 years ago. I'll continue driving in around town because it's so convenient to have the proverbial "full tank" pulling out of my garage every morning. I simply don't care about any rapid charging infrastructure any more. I can and will just drive my gas car when doing road trips for the foreseeable future.
- kazinator 2y agoHere is a crazy idea: maybe cars need easily removable, standardized, commoditized batteries. At a charging station, you don't charge, you swap to a charged battery, leaving the discharged one there. The silly status quo has to be abolished, that the battery is an expensive part that is semi-permanently attached to a particular car, until that battery becomes worn out, and is then replaced at great expense and difficulty. Charging stations should charge batteries. Not only can they do that 24/7, whether or not there are any customers present, but a given charging lot can accomodate a lot more simultaneous batteries than parked cars. If too many spent batteries accumulate, they can be taken away for charging in some charging warehouse.
- mandeepj 2y agoGas stations aren’t going anywhere. On the contrary, the end of EVs has already started. Just wait a couple years, they’d be labelled as a failed idea.
- maherbeg 2y agoI think most 2 car households could have a full EV and a hybrid combination and basically never use gas throughout the year. We moved to 2 full EVs and have no problems getting anywhere (Texas to Wyoming to Illinois and back was easy)
- healthdare 2y ago[dead]