17 ms·
A rent-stabilized 1 bedroom apartment for $1,100 In NYC? broker's fee is $15K
- grugagag 3y agoHow is that legal?
- paulgb 3y agoIf it weren't legal, we'd instead just see deals like this go to friends/family of the owner, or the payment would be under-the-table instead of an upfront broker's fee.
- wordpad25 3y agoYou could make the same argument about any law. Why don't we just make murder and rape also legal to better track it?
- paulgb 3y agoMy point is not that it should be legal (as an NYC renter I’d be glad to see a cap on broker’s fees), but that we shouldn’t delude ourselves into thinking that artificial price ceilings would work if only we plugged one last loophole. For every loophole you plug there are two more. This is not true of, say, murder! Whenever we artificially manipulate the market with ceiling prices, it necessarily means there will be some demand unfulfilled. A better approach is to build enough housing to satisfy the demand.
- mistercheph 3y agoElect this man immediately!
- the_optimist 3y agoBecause humans can’t legislate utopia. Economics and social suasion dominate the law.
- gnopgnip 3y agoNY passed a law banning broker fees but it was overturned by the courts. Broker fees are legal as long as the tenant contacts the broker. https://www.brickunderground.com/sites/default/files/901586_20_Real_Estate_Board_of_N_v_Real_Estate_Board_of_N_JUDGMENT_64.pdf https://www.brickunderground.com/sites/default/files/901586_...
- formerly_proven 3y agoRent control fundamentally cannot work, which is why it never works. Malicious noncompliance is a red herring.
- anovikov 3y agoIt can and does work in many places. Whole cities like Stockholm mostly consist of rent-controlled apartments which have same rents paid since WWII era, which now amount to almost nothing. It creates awful social distortions and indirect costs, but it certainly does work.
- Our_Benefactors 3y ago> It creates awful social distortions and indirect costs, but it certainly does work. I don't think this meets the criteria most would consider “working”.
- hedora 3y agoSweden is often used as a case study in how rent controls lead to housing shortages. Rent control tries to make housing more affordable by reducing the cost, which immediately reduces the supply. At that point, rent control ends up increasing housing costs. Theory and real-world case studies mean that this is so obvious, that I just assume anyone that's passed economics 101 and is advocating for rent control is either grossly incompetent, currently very drunk, or is disingenuous and actually wants to use the power of the government to make sure other people cannot obtain secure and stable housing.
- matwood 3y ago> Theory and real-world case studies mean that this is so obvious, that I just assume anyone that's passed economics 101 and is advocating for rent control is either grossly incompetent, currently very drunk, or is disingenuous and actually wants to use the power of the government to make sure other people cannot obtain secure and stable housing. Or they are one of the lucky few living in a rent controlled apartment.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWhat does one have to do to secure a $1100 a month apartment in NYC? I'm sure everyone else wants it. Get drawn from a rental lottery at random? Offer your first born child? Supplement your rent with sexual favors to the landlord?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tekla 3y agoLottery and pray that your God is real.
- misiti3780 3y agoI lived in NYC for 8 years in a rent-stablized APT in the lower east side, my rent was < 1200 when I left. The price was great but it was in an old building, it was only 220 square feet, and I live there w/ my then gf, now wife. (most of my friends thought we were crazy, but they still rent and I own w/ the money I saved) I was able to get the apartment by subleasing someone else in apartment in the building. I always paid my rent on time, and caused no issues for the landlord (parties, etc). When a new apartment opened up, I was giving first dibs.
- ethanbond 3y agoThis doesn't answer how you got the apartment, which is invariably either luck, knowing someone, or having rich parents (in which case you can buy one of those income-controlled units that make zero sense for anyone except a nepo-baby -- e.g. need to earn <$30k as a household, but have $250k for a downpayment). I also had a time in a rent-stabilized apartment in NYC (East Village, probably not far from yours) and the answer of how I got it: luck. It happened to be available when I was looking and I happened to beat everyone else to the seller's agent by physically sprinting with my deposit check in hand.
- misiti3780 3y agoread the last paragraph ...
- werber 3y agoI thought this seemed fair till i read it was in flushing. Nyc is the worst, but, if you’re American where else can you get a city that international and walkable
- charlie0 3y agoWell, if it's "international" you're looking for, there are other cities abroad like that. But I get your point, the US has very few walkable cities with high levels of diversity.
- whynotminot 3y agoSan Francisco. International and walkable, good transport. The homeless are a problem, but New York has them too.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoNew York's homeless have to contend with winter. That makes for a far less bleak street scene.
- Solvency 3y agoSF homeless isn't even REMOTELY comparable to NYC, and I've lived in both cities for 8 years each. Not even the same planet.
- whynotminot 3y agoI've also lived in both, and currently live in NYC. I think they're on the same planet.
- alephnerd 3y agoChicago, DC, Boston, SF, Philly (depending on "international"), Portland (walkable but not really international - it's just 90s-2000s white Americans doing 90s-2000s white American stuff, you'd think Kurt Cobain still roams the earth) Though if you want affordability, that leaves Chicago and Philly. NYC sucks in that sense though, as a lot of industries that are conglomerated in NYC haven't ensured salaries keep up with those in High Finance and Tech At least Boston has relatively affordable suburbs and Bay Area level wages, DC has plenty of federal jobs that pay competitively, and SF has the larger tech industry (which is still going great despite a couple high profile layoffs)
- Mozai 3y agoGothamist: "The page you're looking for doesn't appear to exist. Please check out our latest stories below."
- greenyoda 3y agoWorked OK for me.
- mgaunard 3y agoIf rent keeps going up, why don't people just buy to let?
- samstave 3y ago[flagged]
- maxlamb 3y agoBecause people can’t or don’t want to pay the huge down payment + broker fees especially if they are not sure how long they will live in the city
- user3939382 3y agoTo clarify, you're asking why people don't buy apartment buildings in Manhattan?
- lazide 3y ago1) buying to let is even crazier, and requires major capital - cost to purchase is nowhere near actual current cashflow. Even in the Bay Area, when it was running up it was 3-5x rental cashflow to buy. In places like manhattan or the Bay Area, landlords are often only able to justify buying in based on speculative future property values (aka market only ever goes up, and in 20 years this will be all fine). As to if they can actually ever make money on this? Good question. If it was clearly penciling out in a spreadsheet though, competition would ensure it wouldn’t for long in the most in demand markets. Other markets are saner because there is less competition, usually. This started changing nationwide about 10 years ago, as competition nationwide got out of hand due to easy money. 2) renters do all sorts of crazy bullshit sometimes, and unless you’re really good at managing it as a landlord you’re screwed. Sometimes even then you’re still screwed. Markets like Manhattan especially so. Landlords which know how to manage these kinds of tenants often turn these kinds of tricks against all tenants to increase returns, and the courts adapt to be even more tenant friendly in many areas or political pressure makes things like rent control inevitable. Which amps up the game. Eventually market conditions shift (either due to changes in money supply, or because the well is ‘poisoned’ on the landlord or tenant side), and we see things like 70’s era NYC or SF which nukes most of the property values for so long, the speculative players are forced to give up - either because they are broke, or because they have ‘greener pastures’ they are pursing. In RE, usually the former due to market liquidity issues.
- vr46 3y agoThe UK has completely abolished fees (I think) for tenants - I am a reluctant landlord - and I completely agree with that, the power asymmetry in finding housing is already bad enough without allowing blank-cheque negotiations. In my section of Germany, housing is even worse with rent caps and tenant rights, plus a lack of housing. Tenants are hard to move on, so landlords are painfully cautious about getting the right tenants - and there isn't a lot of money to maintain properties either, it seems. Our place has the worst decor and electrics, terrible ventilation and mould. And I think we're at the high end. Systems geared up for incumbents, like "council houses for life" in London, ought to be sunset, just to get housing moving again. I don't think rent control works well, but I don't think open market rent works either. Anything critical with a limited supply needs to be externally regulated in ways that keep the wheels moving.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoThat sounds terrible. What "section of Germany" are you in? Berlin?
- vr46 3y agoHamburg. The previous tenants left a mess, the landlord put in a new kitchen for us, new fences around the boundary, new back patio tiles. Ventilation is a problem as extractor fans need replacing and I’ve replaced a bunch of electric switches and sockets, but no fun. Classmates with income only from the job centre are unable to find a place to live, although that’s hardly better anywhere. In London the rents are astronomical and competitive but the cycle of finding, viewing, renting and moving is still running fine. In Hamburg people can’t even find apartments for rent.
- belter 3y agoThe landlord put in a new kitchen for you? When I lived in several different towns in Germany every single flat was rented without kitchen...I bought more than one and had to dismount the kitchen when leaving. One of German absurdities I don't miss... "Apartments don’t come with kitchens in Germany" - https://alisajordanwrites.com/2018/08/06/apartments-dont-come-with-kitchens-in-germany/ https://alisajordanwrites.com/2018/08/06/apartments-dont-com...
- paxys 3y agoThe reason I live in a large managed building in NYC is that while such corporate housing may be bad, the broker cartel is infinitely worse. Every independent unit wanted at minimum $7-10K in broker fees, despite the fact that in most cases I didn’t even interact with the broker in any way. So what value are they adding to the system exactly?
- Fripplebubby 3y agoThe article explains that they are pre-vetting renters and handling showings and such. They add value for the landlord, not for you. But, they are also probably extracting the maximum amount of blood from you, because they can...
- euroderf 3y ago> they are pre-vetting renters Equifax, check. Ten minutes and done. Maybe also all those things you did in high school that went on your "permanent record" ?
- koolba 3y agoThey also kick back some of the fees back to the landlord. Not openly or directly of course because that would be illegal. But only an idiot would think that landlords are not getting a cut of those fees.
- karaterobot 3y agoThe last time I hunted for apartments, the landlords did all that themselves for no money, so I guess things have changed. I guess I can see charging some money, but pre-vetting renters is probably just a matter of submitting their application to some service, and maybe doing a Google search, right? How much would you pay someone for that? About $7500? And I imagine that in an $1100 rent-controlled building, you don't have to do too many showings before someone bites, so how much of a burden is that? A few hours? Would you pay me $7500 for that? I guess I could see $1000 being a generous amount of money for brokers fees in this situation, if everything was being fairly run. So, in my view, the difference between the asked-for $15000 and the generous $1000 is the amount of inefficiency in this process introduced by what amounts to greed. Greed is to be expected, but when it starts to look predatory, regulators sometimes step in—which means it may be short-sighted and ultimately self-destructive greed. To be fair, probably nothing will come of it, and the market will just dictate these costs. But, it's still a shitty thing to do.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoFor an $1,100/month apartment in NYC, a $15k fee is worth it, even if you have to take out debt for it.
- zeroCalories 3y agoFor real. That's almost free by NYC standards. Even if I wanted to move out I would keep renting so that I could let family use it or something. Plus, if historical trends on rent stabilized units are anything to go by, it will only get better. Honestly, I don't mind brokers. I think many people feel wronged by them because of huge bills for little perceived work, but they're not exploiting any monopolies or regulations to exist, like say for example a lot of trade workers do. If you're concerned about NYC housing you should be advocating for ways to make more housing, not killing the market with rent stabilized units and regulations.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SnorkelTan 3y ago> Even if I wanted to move out I would keep renting so that I could let family use it or something Example of why price controls on goods always seem to produce shortages of that good. Solving issues on the supply side is generally a better idea than fiddling with market prices.
- zoover2020 3y agoI think the article isn't about whether or not this is a good deal — rather it argues that people who actually need it have to pay extraordinary fees (for the average Joe, not tech folks on HN) in order to join the market. Most people don't have 15$k laying around.
- nemothekid 3y agoA 15k personal loan at 12% (no idea what loan rates are now, but 12% seems high enough) with a payback period of 3 years would be an extra $600/mo. Heck at 1 year its an extra 1,332.73/mo - you would still come in under median.
- jacknews 3y agoA huge fee in order to start paying rent to an 'owner'? This whole deal has very much jumped the shark.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fnord77 3y agoif you plan on staying there several years, I think this works out pretty well
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoIf landlords are scum the brokers can be dragged out to the street and shot. If a politician wanted to score major brownie points, breaking the broker cartels would be a major win. Put up with this sheisse in Boston. First, last, security, and broker fees. It's the reason I left the east coast and never looked back.
- rcpt 3y agoNYC recently tried and failed.
- IAmGraydon 3y agoA broker’s fee for an apartment? I’ve never seen that. I own a house now, but when I used to rent, the process was to visit the websites of local well known management companies, pick a few apartments you like, and have the manager show each to you. Then you pick one and apply. Why are people injecting the expense of a broker into such a simple transaction? And the renters are the ones paying?
- _fat_santa 3y agoI think broker fees are only a thing in NYC. So far I've rented in Atlanta and Denver and in both cases you can just contact the property, arrange a rental and sign the paperwork and boom you got the keys.
- post- 3y agoThey're also a thing in Boston and a few other areas in the US. It's blatantly exploitative, to say nothing of the obvious corruption pointed out in other comments. There was supposed to be a crackdown on the practice in NYC in 2020, but the brokers lobby was too powerful.[0] One can only hope that such legislation eventually passes -- and has teeth. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/27/nyregion/broker-fees-real-estate.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/27/nyregion/broker-fees-real...
- jurassic 3y agoIt’s basically impossible to rent a place worth living in Boston without paying a broker fee. Even the listings you find yourself on craigslist won’t rent to you unless you pony up the fee. When I rented a place in Cambridge in 2019, the rent was $3200/month. To get the lease signed I had to write a check for 4x that amount (first+last+security deposit+broker fee). $12,800 before even dealing with any moving costs. The worst thing about it is that it increases the cost of moving very significantly. So people are coerced into accepting large rent increases as long as the increase is less than forking out another broker fee to move to a cheaper apartment.
- alexambarch 3y agoBrokers fees for the apartment in Cambridge I rent were $4k. This was in addition to first and last months’ rent. Extremely annoying but when every other apartment is doing it too, you don’t have much of a choice if you want to live in the area.
- lacoolj 3y agoNY brokers are pretty ruthless. Our basement 2Br/1Ba apt in the Bronx cost us $2200/mo and broker got $2200 on top. And that was 15+ years ago now
- Scubabear68 3y agoWe left NYC in 2012 due to layoffs, but getting an apartment back then was incredibly difficult. I don’t think people who live in other areas of the US would understand it (except maybe SF folks). Competition for apartments is fierce, and pricing was through the roof even then. We lived in Manhattan for 9 years and then got priced out. A brief move to Sunset park, then further out to Bay Ridge. Bay Ridge was reasonable and not too hard to find a place, but it is an hour from Manhattan via subway. The situation seems to be much, much worse now 12 years later from what I have read.
- davidw 3y agoNew report dropped recently that vacancy rates there are like 2% or less. That is far, far below healthy levels. NYC needs more housing, as does much of the US in places where the jobs are.
- jebarker 3y agoI'm not familiar with NYC other than a few visits, but my impression is that the city is already very densely populated. Where would new housing go? Is it just more skyscrapers?
- HDThoreaun 3y agoVast majority of Queens is single family housing. All of these could become 5 story walkups easily, especially the western parts and stuff close to the subway. Doesnt have to be skyscrapers.
- loeg 3y ago1.4%. And yes, it is clearly unhealthy and indicates a lack of supply. https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/news/007-24/new-york-city-s-vacancy-rate-reaches-historic-low-1-4-percent-demanding-urgent-action-new https://www.nyc.gov/site/hpd/news/007-24/new-york-city-s-vac...
- davidw 3y agoThat is amazingly low. 5-8% is considered healthy, and the higher it is, the better for renters.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoOr we need remote work for those who can, but the rich will lose their real estate investments so…
- bradlys 3y agoI'm sure both would be fine but a lot of people want to live in a place like NYC. They just need to build more housing to accommodate it. For instance, I'm a single man. I could get numerous remote jobs. This wouldn't help my chances of dating a young professional woman though if I moved out to BFE. Thus, why I'm in NYC. They just need to make more housing. A ton of the projects here in the city are completely frozen.
- financypants 3y agoReminiscent of gyms that say they won’t raise the monthly rate but charge a “rate guarantee fee” every 6 months equal to a few months rate.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoIn a past life, I was the make-ready electrician for a top local broker. I had to quit this life for a multitude of reasons, primarily that of feeling parasitic to a parasitic industry. What ever happened to the class action suit against 3% fees... did that ever go anywhere [2023 recollection]?
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoWhen I see people complaining about never being able to purchase a house my response is always the same. move. $1,100 is considered "well below market rates" for a 1 bedroom apartment in NYC? That's _nuts_ to me. I'm paying $1,600 for a 3 bed, 2 bath 1800 sq ft house with a 2 car garage. Vaulted ceilings, my neighbor is a police officer and I'm on a corner lot across from a park. fire department is literally 3 blocks away. IOW, I pay more because of the neighborhood. Granted, I live in a LCOL area, but that's kind of the point. If you feel you don't have the buying power, move. Hell, I know a woman who has a mortgage that she pays off of a fixed income and a bit of side work (600/month I think? in that ballpark) and she's buying more house than that.
- thebruce87m 3y agoEdit: rethought this but can’t delete
- cpuguy83 3y agoMoving doesn't tend to change much. Yes housing prices go down but so do wages. Also you'll have the added expense of a car (and all the stress that brings along with it).
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agothat's true in theory, but not practice. It assumes housing availability is a constant across the US As I mentioned, I know a woman who is buying more house than that and her income is technically below the poverty line. In addition, I work remote in tech and looking up the average salary in NYC, I'm making more and it's not close. Not everyone can do that and I understand that, but my point is that people around here don't feel as though house ownership is out of their power.
- bosie 3y agoHouse ownership statements are always with a location in mind. I want to walk or take public transport for 15-20 minutes to have most medical docs around, multiple different cuisines, park etc. What i do not care is a 2 car garage. That already implies a lifestyle i really do not want. So where wpuld i move to in the US?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Throw73747 3y agoThis is pretty common in Prague. Rent contract has some value, so you pay compensation to original owner. Pretending otherwise is just lying. Here is an example from centre of Prague. 400 euro per month, 20k compensation https://www.sreality.cz/detail/pronajem/byt/2+kk/praha-smichov-na-neklance/2965890380 https://www.sreality.cz/detail/pronajem/byt/2+kk/praha-smich...
- tasuki 3y agoWho pockets this "odstupné nájemného" of 20k eur? If it's rent-controlled, shouldn't this be forbidden?
- iancmceachern 3y agoThe apartment broker thing in NYC is such a racket. We used one once, never again.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoOh new york. The whole concept of a broker being able to get a lower price than you as a person is just classic mob.
- cvalka 3y agoOne of the fundamental problems in politics is that taxation is usually more efficient in terms of economics and public benefit but regulation is more effective in terms of electability, PR and public support
- 2-718-281-828 3y agobut you need a competent and well-connected broker to find someone who'd want to live there