13 ms·
Welcome to the ad-free internet
- Keegs 3y agoThis is nothing new but the article hits hard. I don’t want to live in a world where everyone is after my attention but a good chunk of the economy seems to depend on it. There has to be a better future than this?
- zerbinxx 3y agoThe solution, at least for me, is finding things/places, both on and off the computer, where you can avoid having your attention stolen and just focus on something you like. I think the ad-saturated parts of the world are one of those things that you don’t really need, you just get trapped by them if you open yourself up to being swayed by them. Nobody is in my kitchen trying to sell me shit when I’m cooking, nobody is on my bike ride grabbing my attention, and at least for now, my DAW is safe
- asoneth 3y agoThe challenge highlighted in the article is that adds are increasing in areas that are harder to avoid such as billboards, hotel rooms, airline seats, ride-hailing apps.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoBillboards? Is that a new thing? Airline seats? First-time ryanair flyer? If you're determined to never see an ad in your entire life, that was never possible, but if you just want to spend a lot of time without seeing ads this is just as easy as ever.
- pixl97 3y ago"without seeing ads this is just as easy as ever." No. It. Is. Not. The problem is you've internally moved the goalposts on what you consider an ad, from what would have more historically been considered an ad. Those clothes with a big nike swoosh on them, those are ads. Individuals wear ads around everywhere. Objects are covered in their own advertising. If you have any electronics on you, god only knows what metrics they are collecting. Hell, these days if you're with anyone else that has electronics there is a non-zero chance those devices are spying on and tracking you.
- figassis 3y agoEventually those places will be premium real estate for ads. Some one will find a way to bring ads to our kitchen or to mount fiji. Maybe they will fly planes overhead, or do crop circles, put put them in hiking trails.
- amelius 3y agoIf advertisers could turn the Moon into a giant Pepsi logo, they would definitely do it.
- pklausler 3y agoR.A.Heinlein novella, The Man Who Sold The Moon.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oarfish 3y ago> Maybe they will fly planes overhead I once was at Miami Beach and there was a boat mounted with giant-ass LED screens riding by. Where I live, there's new electric "bikes" with large boxes mounted to them and 3 sides of the box display ads. People get paid to just ride this through everyone's field of view, or park it for a while at conspicous locations. I feel impotent rage at this increasing terrorization of the populace.
- zigman1 3y agoGood luck avoiding all adverts on bilboards in public places while riding your bike
- zerbinxx 3y agoI mostly ride on back roads and side-streets, my city banned billboards and is very small and close enough to the woods to not feel like one. But I get what you mean.
- zigman1 3y agoThis makes sense. City I am coming from haven't done this and the billboard/advertising agency is very close with the city mayor, meaning, all the (main) streets are littered with advertising. Everytime I come home for holidays (from a large EU city, mind you), I am overblown by just how many billboards are around. Crazy.
- bsenftner 3y agoAnd the V/R entrepreneurs are just drooling at the prospect of turning these last refuge places into ad-saturated environments too.
- bonton89 3y agoUntil now they couldn't track your eye movement to determine if you might be susceptible to their manipulation.
- zerbinxx 3y agoThis is true, but I have to buy in to open myself up to it. Until they start giving away whatever VR headset it is, and until hell freezes over and I actually put it on, I’m safe. But the thought of it does make me sick/sad.
- avgcorrection 3y agoThe Ted Kaczynski approach works until you want to engage with the world outside your kitchen and you step outside and realize that the dynamic (personalized?) billboards are now across from your apartment complex. And the local park.
- zerbinxx 3y agoYeah I get what you mean. I’m not like, a luddite, or anything, I just don’t agree with the authors notion that advertising is particularly all-encompassing, especially when you’re not actively using a computer.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoYou are, with or without ads. The web is a struggle for attention. No website can survive that doesn't addict you to check it again and again.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoThe route I've gone down is to build the quiet spaces on the web myself. Works decently well.
- account42 3y ago> No website can survive that doesn't addict you to check it again and again. What is that supposed to mean? There are plenty of websites that are not out to earn any money. It doesn't take anything for them to "survive".
- skoocda 3y agoThat's false. Every website needs a server to survive. Serving can be cheap, but it ain't free.
- ouraf 3y agoUblock is more convenient and i don't need to pay one subscription per site. In the past, it was about selling convenience. Netflix, for example has beaten conventional torrent sites because it had almost all movies you'd ever want in a single place, steady connection and a good UX. Now there are a dozen different services to juggle, each with a constantly changing library and torrents became more convenient again.
- 0xd1r 3y agoIronic that this article is paywalled. Here's a non-paywalled link: https://archive.is/0C0RQ https://archive.is/0C0RQ
- freediver 3y agoNot really, that fact supports the premise of the article.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoBut then fewer people can read it and the author's arguments reach a smaller audience, which does seem like a major disadvantage.
- blitzar 3y agoThey should put open it up for free to reach the maximum audience, but to compensate for the lost revenue they could get a company to fund the article in exchange for prominently placing an image or text about said company ...
- readthenotes1 3y ago"Social networks are not the only medium allowing the group that advertisers most covet—the better-off with money to splurge—to wriggle beyond their reach" I wonder what the median disposable income of people who use archive links to circumvent paywalls is?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gnyman 3y agoAlso disabling JS works. And if that is a hassle my little hack to selectively view pages with js disabled works great here https://noscript.it/?p=0#https://www.economist.com/business/2023/12/11/welcome-to-the-ad-free-internet https://noscript.it/?p=0#https://www.economist.com/business/...
- mcny 3y agoIs it just me or does it feel like this is actually a submarine article by WPP to kind of console its clients and tell them that it’s OK. Everything is OK and WPP is in control?
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThis is such a lame argument to make, because it could apply to an article about anything. Don’t agree with the analysis? It must be paid for by {insert lobby agency}. Was there anything that was discussed that you disagree with?
- gmuslera 3y agoGood luck with that. The ones that can afford an ad-free internet are the same group as the ones that can afford the product you are trying to sell. Promoted links, selection/ordering of posts and other mechanisms will be use to lead ad-free people to the ads, in ways that won't look like ads. It's like gravity, there are forces in play that will make things end in the same way.
- nojs 3y agoYou could argue that unless the $10/mo subscription offers a dumb chronological feed then it’s not really ad-free. On the other hand consider YouTube - you pay to remove the annoyance, not the algorithmic bias, and a lot of people are happy to do that.
- pierat 3y ago> You could argue that unless the $10/mo subscription offers a dumb chronological feed That's around what I pay to the maintainer of the Mastodon server I'm on. And I get that nice dumb chronological feed. Oh, and it's ad-free. For everyone. It's amazing seeing Ublock Origin with "nothing blocking". The true ad-free internet exists. But it doesn't exist within the FAANG space.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- littlefish444 3y agoDoes anyone know why there doesn't exist a micro-transaction capability to buy one marginal ad-free item at a time? E.g. buy just this Economist article for $0.25 rather than subscribing for the whole month? I know there are significant issues with micro-transaction cost but I figure you could set up a little token service with minimum cash-in and cash-out amounts (say $5). Do companies like the Economist crunch the numbers and find that they earn by more by having paying subscribers as opposed to also selling per-article? My friend and I thought about attempting a startup in this space but it seems so clearly useful and lucrative that there must be a good reason why e.g. Stripe doesn't already provide this service.
- radicality 3y agoAlso wish something like that existed. I imagine friction of payments could be an issue. I would only use something like that if it was as easy as doing an Apple Pay transaction.
- Retr0id 3y agoI'm guessing it's mostly a psychological thing. You make the decision to purchase a subscription once (and ideally for them, forget about it soon after), but if you know you're paying $.25 per click, you'll make a decision every time - and perhaps not bother.
- littlefish444 3y agoAgreed -- my concern is that subscriptions are really negative in long-term expectation for the consumer, and companies are profiting off that and don't want to lose all the people who are paying $10 for only $4 monthly utility. My coworker hates the subscription era and pines for the days of buying a CD-ROM with software lol
- DaiPlusPlus 3y agoRight. I've been a subscriber to Adobe's Creative Cloud for almost 10 years now - which means I've paid them upwards of $6,000 by now - even though I only use 3 programs (Acrobat, Photoshop, Illustrator) and even then I only really use base-level functionality that's been present in those titles long before they became subscription-only: if it weren't for (normal and understandable) platform-obsolescence (high-DPI support, support for new formats/codecs, etc) then I'd still be happy with a boxed edition of Creative Suite I could have bought for $1200[1] back in 2013 [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20130808023019/http://www.amazon.com/Adobe-65163194-CS6-Design-Standard/dp/B007R0RJ8W https://web.archive.org/web/20130808023019/http://www.amazon...
- willwinger 3y agoA 'path to profit' is the time tested lifeline of any enterprise. However this is never highlighted as it doesn't bode well with the general social psyche of humans. For last 20 years, tech enabled startups, chose 'postpone profit' strategy adopting 'free to use' or 'ad supported' approach helped by raising high capital to build moats around the target market. Now this trend can be either seen as a moment where the moat is complete and 'path to profit' is through captive customers. (Or) a decline/failure of the 'postpone profit' strategy accelerated by the current economic recession. All social media and any other free to use switching to subscriptions is quite a probability now.
- Buttons840 3y agoAn ironic thing is that companies that choose to postpone profits will find that when the time comes to charge for profit, they will have burned all good will, and people might finally be coerced to pay, but they'll pay any other company.
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoIt’s so stupid because there already is a playbook for being profitable and still giving your product away for free. It’s the free trial. Hey, we want to earn your trust, so here’s a free month of the service. If you like us, great! Here’s the price at the end. Otherwise no hard feelings. Instead, the playbook now is: WE ARE FREE. YES, FREE AS IN NOTHINGBURGER DOLLARS. WE ARE BETTER THAN FREE! WE WILL PROMISE YOU ANYTHING YOU WANT! PUT ALL YOUR INFORMATION HERE AND WE PROMISE TO MAKE YOU FAMOUS AND RICH! lol jk gimme that data. Also you’re locked in/addicted to our platform. Give us your money.
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> 'free to use' or 'ad supported' These things are completely different. Facebook became profitable 4 years after its funding.
- sakras 3y agoI resonate hard with this, and I'm glad it's being flagged as a trend. I didn't quite realize how soul-crushing ads were until I got rid of them. Now I'm on YouTube Premium and Twitch Turbo and look forward to getting rid of more ads.
- jamiedumont 3y agoOver the past 2 months I've switched from a YouTube Premium subscriber, to a regular logged-in YouTube user and finally to a no-account user. The increase in ads, particular transitioning to no-account; is staggering. YouTube adverts have always been prominent and irritating but without an account they are downright aggressive. I think an 18 minute video I watched last night had a pair of adverts served every ~2 minutes. I stopped Premium and deleted my account to disincentivise watching YouTube as it became a huge time sink and procrastination tool for me. My solution will either work because the ads make the entire experience unpleasant enough to not bother with YouTube at all, or I'll be driven back to Premium just to save some time. Of course this is exactly the situation that YouTube wanted to engineer, and have succeeded in doing so, but it just seems such an awful way to incentivise subscriptions.
- wildrhythms 3y agoThe advertisers want to make the internet like TV: the thing all us internet users tried desperately to escape from.
- jamiedumont 3y agoUpdate to add they've found a way to make me want Premium again. Serve the same brain-dead weight loss advert EVERYTIME!
- alex_young 3y agoAd free internet costs ~$40 one time fee. Raspberry Pi + pihole dns.
- zetsurin 3y agoI also run this, and it's pretty worth it, but 40$ discounts the time, and makes it sound like the perfect solution. While it is good, it isn't perfect.
- isoprophlex 3y ago2$/month for NextDNS for dns adblocking as a service. Works outside of your home, too.
- fastest963 3y agoGenuinely curious what you do when a site asks you to turn off your adblocker? PiHole doesn't have an option to whitelist an individual site like an extension does. Do you just leave the site or do you temporarily turn off PiHole?
- uneekname 3y agoA lot of folks just temporarily disable their pi-hole. This happens rarely depending on where you hang out on the internet, I can't remember the last time it happened to me
- Moldoteck 3y agoDifferent options. Turn off pihole for that site. Or using something like archive.is or wayback machine. Sometimes just blocking the banner with ublock works too. Other times there are link previews like telegram quick view
- cwales95 3y agoYou can whitelist domains. What I do is toggle reader mode for that site if on mobile. That always bypasses it. I can also select the overlay on uBlock origin. If that doesn’t work I’ll disable JavaScript for the site since these popular need JavaScript. If all that fails I’ll simply not use the site.
- system2 3y agoThe ads would disappear if people rejected the services and sites showing a crazy amount of ads. I haven't seen an ad for more than a decade because I curated my devices around ad blocking. I still don't understand the fight against ads. Do not use social media already and use adblockers for YouTube and Twitter. People do not know how to use the internet and still use the services which means they are okay with the ads. They are not bothered. It is not our problem to solve other's problems if these are not problems to them. Similar to cigarette smoking.
- spookie 3y agoPeople access a webpage for content, not noise. Ads are noise. Smarter noise will still sound like noise. Perhaps, making it even more obvious, the kind that irritates people. Gradually, the noise took more and more center stage. And then, users were forced to silence the noise. Blurring the lines of content and noise is completely backwards. Be transparent, place ads aside the content (not within it), and everyone will be happy. Paywalls might work for some, but the key here is being ethical. Respecting the user. The user will reward you if you respect it. It may even respect the brands that respect its attention. As with everything, the problem here is greed. I wish more ads were respectful. I would take them more seriously if they were.
- matrix87 3y ago> Ads are noise. Not necessarily, maybe as a general rule If the ads are high effort enough, people will actively seek them out, just the effort won't scale
- marcus_holmes 3y agoDoesn't this end up spiralling, though? As we've seen with Netflix, nothing stops the service from adding ads to a subscription feed. Sooner or later the pressure to grow revenues is going to force Meta to do ads on their subscription accounts (especially since they can charge a premium on those ads). Then they introduce "premium" subscription accounts with no ads, then those get ads, then there's the "excelsior" subscription account with absolutely no ads, and so on.
- vGPU 3y agoOr how the twitter premium and extra special super premium+ subscriptions both still have ads.
- FerretFred 3y ago>then there's the "excelsior" subscription account with absolutely no ads Or rather their AI will by that time have disguised ads as to be not recognisable as ads :)
- saghm 3y agoRecently I've noticed that the Uber app (which I grudgingly use instead of Lyft due to a decline in drivers over the years in various areas near where I've lived to the point where it wasn't a viable option most of the time) will show me adds when I open it to check the ETA during a ride. This is something where I'm not paying a subscription but literally paying for the ride itself, because I obviously don't check the ETA of anything when I'm not riding. I guess this is their way of trying to find a path to profitability other than self-driving cars, but I'd genuinely rather pay an extra dollar or two per ride than have an ad take up close to half my screen.
- echan00 3y agoThat's Reddit. It's actually not bad
- hightrix 3y agoAre you suggesting Reddit is ad-free? It is not, at all. Using the official app or the website that is not located at old.reddit shows a promoted post every 5 or so posts for me. Yes, you can use old.reddit and not get those ads, but then of the content, I'd estimate about 1 in 10 or so posts on r/popular are native advertising. Reddit is one of the worst and covered in commercial, paid content. Some of it is labeled as an ad, much of it is not.
- neonate 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20231213052011/https://www.economist.com/business/2023/12/11/welcome-to-the-ad-free-internet https://web.archive.org/web/20231213052011/https://www.econo...
- DeathArrow 3y agoI benefit from ad free internet since the first ad blocker extension was made.
- bambax 3y agoSame. It's a bit weird to write a whole article on ads on the Internet and not mention ad blocking once. I don't want to see ads, any ad, ever, and so far I'm succeeding, but I wonder how long this is going to last.
- DeathArrow 3y agoAs long as companies like Google, Meta won't succeed in pushing new web standards that make ads impossible to block. But even then, the browser can prerender the page use AI to find and remove the ad and do the final render. :)
- avgcorrection 3y agoThe article is effectively an ad[1] for the tech startup scheme: 1. “Give away” access to build a network effect 2. Get a network 3. Act with righteous indignation when some killjoy like the EU comes and says that you cannot just harvest whatever user data you want at will and users don’t opt to pay the proposed ransom money [1] Presenting their worldview as just a given, something obvious.
- wrasee 3y agoI'm amazed that ad-blockers are not more popular. They do require a certain degree of technical understanding, but the extension system on most browsers is fairly mainstream so I don't think it's for this reason alone. Can it be as simple as the idea that almost all of media is universally disincentivized from talking about them? Of course there is a lot of content on ad-blockers out there, but the pressure may still be high enough to suppress cut-through to the mainstream. If that's the case it would be a nice example as to the extent of media influence more broadly. This article is a case in point, where you would have thought that ad-blockers may have been relevant. And as a side point, perhaps also a good example of where you don't even have to be rich if you are knowledgable. Technical literacy is in itself a kind of digital affluence.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pammf 3y agoI’ve been using ad blockers for years now, mainly on DNS level. Last week I decided to test Apple’s private relay and for 5 minutes I had to deal with internet with ads. Disgusting experience.
- jonchurch_ 3y agoNot directly mentioned in the article (although this is essentially what the article is about), but it’s struck me lately as very dissonant that I pay for Spotify and Youtube in order to avoid the ads, and then still have to fast forward through the sponsorship and ad reads that the content creator records into their product. It’s a fair price to get someone’s content, and I know the revenue from that is much higher than what they’ll get from the platform’s ad share. Yet still it is irritating. The majority of content I consume idly I would never pay for. So again, a fair bargain I suppose. There are content creators whom I’d happily support directly for the sake of the value I ascribe to their content, not just to remove their ads, but they don’t offer the option. I understand there are many reasons for any given creator why an ad supported business model may be preferable/simpler/earn more. And maybe this is just a shift in the creator economy which is more slowly dispersing than I personally would expect. But truly from a superfan or consumer point of view, I end up valuing the paid podcasts I subscribe to on Spotify which are ad free over many pieces of content that I arguably enjoy more but are forced to skip through their ads. I’ve paid for Ben Thompson’s content for almost 10 years now, and listen to his podcast via Spotify. I remember when he said he’d never put his podcast on Spotify, but their private/paid feed feature got him to jump and Im so glad I got to delete an extra app because of it. I’ve been listening to the McElroy brothers’ stable of podcasts for just as long, but am irritated every time I have to skip through the ad reads. I do support them through the podcast network they are a part of, Maximum Fun, but I honestly pay less than I could because I know that it doesn’t directly support them (it supports the network which in turn supports them). That’s ironic because really I should give _more_ because of that fact, but the indirection makes me uninterested in paying much above the minimum. I love both these podcasts, and their ability to monetize are clearly different based on the product each are producing. At the end of the day though there is (in my experience) a value add provided through Ben Thompson’s business model of directly charging me for the good. Please don’t read this as a typical HN “why doesn’t the industry cater specifically to me and the very narrow niche I inhabit”, I’m aware of many of the incentives and challenges inherent in these different business models. But as of late, with so many content creators giving the option to pay them directly in exchange for ad free experiences, paying for an ad free service like Spotify but being unable to skip ads from the creators themselves has started to really stick out to me. I don’t know what a solution would be, nor do I look forward to paying for the majority of content I consume. In fact Im fairly confident that there is no good solution exactly because nobody wants to pay for most content and people’s time is not free. In a world where increasingly folks are putting up paywalls for content consumers see as differentiated, it starts to look more and more bleak on the ad supported side of that wall.
- EZ-E 3y agoIronically The Economist shows me ads on the app despite paying 28.99 euros a month in subscription fees
- andirk 3y agoThe repeating issue in these comments: very small fiat transactions are difficult. Crypto solves this. The barrier to entry is cumbersome because of KYC, but after that the whole ecosystem is ready to go. People talking 25 cents for an article. The ad revenue from viewing a single page with a few well sold ad impressions at $40 CPM is like 4 cents, and more often more like < 1 cent. I keep hoping to see Basic Attention token BAT get traction for exactly these microtransaction use cases.
- Nursie 3y ago“Crypto solves this” Does it? Transaction times and transaction fees on some of the more well-known cryptocurrencies would seem to exclude them entirely. There’s no particular reason that it has to be a decentralised cryptocurrency that operates in the manner required - preloading a few bucks here and there, which are transferred between accounts in small amounts. As with many things that “crypto” solves, it is neither necessary nor sufficient. Some cryptocurrencies could form part of a solution. It’s not clear they bring any specific advantages to the table though.
- Hamuko 3y agoEvery time I've paid with crypto, the fees I've paid to Coinbase and the network have been massive.
- andirk 3y agoCoinbase is famously expensive at ~5-10%. I use them but not for transferring much. Bitpay and Cash App are some 1-3%. When I could use Bitcoin with Overstock.com it was also minimal. But whenever bitcoin is trading heavily, it's not worth the cost. Hey why not put some ads on the transaction.
- orbital-decay 3y agoThe last time anyone seriously considered crypto as money was 2016. Even Steam started accepting Bitcoin. You can see how it went for them [1]. Fraud, volatility, transation delays and fees were unacceptable. And that was the time before the total KYC pressure. While some of these issues might have been solved (kind of), there's no way anyone touches crypto for end-user microtransactions with a 10-foot pole today. [1] https://www.pcgamer.com/50-of-transactions-were-fraudulent-when-steam-accepted-bitcoin-for-payments-says-gabe-newell/ https://www.pcgamer.com/50-of-transactions-were-fraudulent-w...
- brutal_chaos_ 3y agoWelcome to a niche of the web, which is a niche of the Internet, of which wants all of your money pls. Oh? The fight (ad-free or ad-ridden) alone makes more money, because, "ad money or subscription money pls", which in turn equals more clicks for them. You can argue, "yeah, but what about ublock origin (or another ad blocker)?" To you, they'd (speculatively) say, "ye are few, why bother."
- jacooper 3y ago> You can argue, "yeah, but what about ublock origin (or another ad blocker)?" To you, they'd (speculatively) say, "ye are few, why bother." Well clearly YouTube thinks it's worth it to go after AdBlock users now.
- figassis 3y agoThis seems like a legal issue. There needs to be a clear definition of ads, then a requirement for companies to offer ad free options to their services with a clear, fast way to report offenders.
- _pvxk 3y agohttps://www.datatilsynet.no/en/news/aktuelle-nyheter-2023/the-norwegian-data-protection-authoritys-decision-against-meta-is-extended-to-the-eueea-and-made-permanent/ https://www.datatilsynet.no/en/news/aktuelle-nyheter-2023/th... > the Norwegian Data Protection Authority strongly doubts that Meta's proposed ‘consent’ mechanism, often dubbed ‘pay or okay’, complies with the GDPR. The EDPB’s decision is therefore important to avoid Meta's infringement continuing while the company is exploring its options. https://www.theregister.com/2023/11/28/metas_eu_privacy_fee_triggers/?ref=';drop%20table%20referrals https://www.theregister.com/2023/11/28/metas_eu_privacy_fee_... > noyb (None Of Your Business) has filed a data protection complaint against Meta over the "Pay or Okay" subscription model
- amadeuspagel 3y agoIs it illegal to charge money for a service in europe, or is it only illegal if you also offer an ad-supported free version?
- Kbelicius 3y agoAs far as I understand it consent must be given freely. Currently facebook offers two options, either pay or consent to tracking. In this situation consent isn't given freely since the option to not give consent requires a monetary payment.
- jacooper 3y agoIt's illegal to force people to pay to exercise their legal right to privacy.
- Yujf 3y agoIt is illegal to offer an ad supported version that has no way to turn off personalized ads.
- avgcorrection 3y agoThere’s this local newspaper. While I’m on a logged in account (EDIT: paid) the ads seem to take up at least 25% screen real estate at all times. The best ones are the ones that graciously show up while scrolling, dynamically—it’s like wathing TV (again)! My favorite place though is the gym. Which costs a lot when you just go there to use frickin’ weights and cardio equipment. LCD screens with ads running (for local businesses—how nice and cozy) so that your peripheral vision gets distracted by irrelevant stimuli (for some reason I automatically have to look when it seems like something is “happening” all of a sudden, an urge I have to repress). I wonder if this ad/paid dichotomy is some tech startup fairy tale. Like, [we burnt capital on building an effective monopoly]^W [gave away our product for free] but now the [entitled lusers]^W [users]^W don’t want to pay 10$ a month in order to be on a social network that mostly only their one-generation-or-older relatives are daily active on.
- avgcorrection 3y ago(author here) I’m sorry but this looks like fake news. :/ I visited the webpage again (it’s not every day) and there were barely any ads this time. Did I misremember? I usually notice when I log in since I can barely click on any stories without getting told that it’s for subscribers only.
- DarkNova6 3y agoBut is this not a fundamental problem if you expect everything to be available for free? For journalism, this has become an existential threat as web-users generate nowhere near as much revenue than selling printed paper.
- avgcorrection 3y agosigh What? I just described two scenarios where I’m on a paid plan and I still get ads. > For journalism, this has become an existential threat as web-users generate nowhere near as much revenue than selling printed paper. Printed, paid-for newspapers also have ads.
- 3y ago
- maurits 3y agoThere is no world in which corporations will resist the temptation to serve ads to people who have demonstrated to both invest time and money in their platform. Don't worry, you will only get the best artisanal premium ads, you will learn to love them [1]. [1] https://youtu.be/hVYArjS-Ee0?si=NtJ5fzRzQXqXXf_Z&t=19 https://youtu.be/hVYArjS-Ee0?si=NtJ5fzRzQXqXXf_Z&t=19
- redder23 3y agoDoes Netflix has ads? Why does it show a little dark blue?
- cracrecry 3y agoThe problem with ad-free content is that rich people do not just want just "no adds". They do not want to be tracked, in order not to be stalked and harrassed by companies(or individuals like gold diggers or sellers or bankers). And they are rich so companies want to track them. This is the reason you could not trust Google or Meta with ad-free stuff. They are already private intelligence(spying) agencies that already have the spying tech. Temptation is just too high. Just pay people that create products and services without spying on you.
- dist-epoch 3y agoI know from insiders that some sports bookies would look up your address (that you are required by law to provide to betting sites) on Google Maps to figure out if you live in a rich people's house. If so, they would immediately pass the account to their most experienced seller.
- lobsterthief 3y agoWhy Google Maps? You can just use Zillow or similar to find out exactly how much you paid for it and when.
- dist-epoch 3y agoZillow is for US. These bookies were in Europe.
- lobsterthief 3y agoAh yes, makes sense
- totallywrong 3y ago> Just pay people that create products and services without spying on you. Sadly this is nearly impossible for digital products or services, at least those worth paying for.
- Prickle 3y agoThe 5 minute airplane ad is nightmare fuel for me. How long until they kick up the brightness to wake you up. Imagine you are stuck in the window seat, forced to watch an ad you can't turn off? I am exaggerating obviously, but I do find it egregious that they would dare show more ads when ticket prices are already extremely high.
- zigman1 3y agoQuestion. Would you be okay with being shown an add if in turns your plane ticket price is noticeably cheaper?
- lkramer 3y agoThat would be how it starts, but eventually the ad-free option would go away and your ticket is back to its original price + inflation
- 3D30497420 3y agoThe challenge is that there won't be any transparency with this sort of thing. Prices for flights are so variable that you'll probably never know if it is cheaper due to the advertisement, or because of other variables. My main issue with advertising driven models is that the company will respond to the needs of who pays them, advertisers, and not who actually uses the service. Want to juice profits? Just sell more advertising slots, make them more intrusive, etc. Delivering quality service to customers becomes a cost burden rather than a way to gain more customers.
- grishka 3y agoAirlines have already come up with a way to make sure you understand what you're saving on. They'd sell you a ticket for some base price, and then extort you for extras upon online check-in. Seat choice, extra legroom, meals, etc.
- jacooper 3y agoMaybe, but that's not going to happen, they are going to have their cake and eat it too.
- zigman1 3y agoIf anything, I like the fact that big media outlets are picking up on the ever increasing problem of ads on internet. Seems like YT seriously poked something big with their scheme of blocking ad-blockers, I noticed there recently, there were much more articles even on HN about this issue
- RGamma 3y agoAlso see https://contentpass.net/en/publications https://contentpass.net/en/publications for an ad-free, tracking-free (mainly German) websites flatrate. Currently has 322 sites for 4€/mo.
- tjpnz 3y agoDon't denigrate the poor. They're just as capable of blocking ads and getting an ad free experience as everyone else.
- d-z-m 3y ago> In the same month TikTok, a fast-growing[...]video app, announced that it was testing an ad-free subscription. This feels like calling Facebook a fast-growing social network.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Privacy campaigners say that the price is so high as to be prohibitive; expect more legal battles in the new year. I struggle with this: you have three options: ad-supported, paid, or don't use it. What's the legal challenge?
- RugnirViking 3y agothe option being discussed at that part, the meta offering, only came into existence because europe mandated that users must be able to use the full functionality of a site without tracking/personalized ads. The paid option was facebooks attempt to do that - the question is over whether a paid option follows the intent of the law. Note the mandate is not "no ads" but rather "no personalised ads"
- robertlagrant 3y agoAh okay - that makes sense. But still - I don't understand why if one of the options is "don't use it", an option I exercise almost every day of the year, there is a legal privacy claim. This isn't a system we'd consider access/participation in it to be mandatory, like healthcare or government.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dghughes 3y agolol first thing "We use data to create the best experience for you. Together with our 172 trusted partners". Just 172 close friends? That's what burns my gears not so much ads as the tracking. How did the Internet become a thing that follows you everywhere? An ad I Can take I look and click or not or buy or not but it's the invasive collection and tracking I hate.
- AlienRobot 3y agoIsn't this because they're using a middleman as an ad network, so the data goes to the middleman, and then it goes to 172 companies that interact with that middleman? Imagine if a TV channel listed to you every company that paid to show an ad that whole day. I guess it would end up being quite a high number as well.
- dghughes 3y agoI get what you mean but for the context of the situation/story it was amusing. That's 172 companies wanting my info not so much showing me an add or the site would be unreadable. A TV channel advertisement doesn't track me.
- alwayslikethis 3y agoThe ad-free internet has already been here for a long time if you are willing to spend 10 minutes install ublock origin. Paying is actually worse on all aspects, even if you ignore the cost, because it shows the fact that you have some amount of disposable income and are willing to pay for things, which greatly increases the value of advertising to you specifically.
- Habgdnv 3y agoAh, this takes me back! I remember the days before Facebook, YouTube, and heck, even before Google was a thing. Anyone else remember using Altavista? Those were simpler times online. When you opened a webpage, it was all about the content – dense, to the point, and no beating around the bush. It was high-quality stuff and, best of all, ad-free. I really miss those days. There was something special about the internet back then. It felt more like exploring a vast library full of hidden gems rather than being in a mall bombarded with ads and clickbait. Dreaming of a return to that kind of internet feels like wishing for a time machine, but hey, a person can hope, right?
- haswell 3y agoWhile I use ublock and ad blocking DNS, this particular ad-free Internet isn’t sustainable. For better or worse, the business model behind many of these sites rely on the ad revenue to continue existing, and ad blocking only works as long as most people still aren’t doing it.
- oldpersonintx 3y agoDon't worry about sustainability. There was life before YouTube and Facebook and there will be life after. I am not sacrificing my mental well-being for a false economy. If the internet rots out its own Ponzi Scheme, we will build something else
- haswell 3y ago> The ad-free internet has already been here for a long time > Don't worry about sustainability. There was life before YouTube and Facebook and there will be life after Which is it? The point is that this version of the ad-free doesn’t actually exist in the long run. In a discussion about a move away from the “false economy” you highlight via paid subscriptions (presumably not a false economy), it seems odd to say that this already exists while also admitting that it doesn’t/can’t.
- filipezf 3y agoThat's funny, because I'm a PAID subscriber to The Economist, and on opening the page, there is a big ad banner on the top and other on the right, filling more than half the space. (I don't bother using adblockers,though). Newspapers have always shown ads even for paying consumers. As the very article ends with: "Users who pay to block ads in some areas are still likely to find them popping up in new ones."
- alwayslikethis 3y agoAs a non paying ublock origin user, I don't see any ads. The ad-free internet has already been here for a long time if you are willing to spend 10 minutes install ublock origin. Paying is actually worse, because it shows the fact that you have some amount of disposable income and are willing to pay for things, which greatly increases the value of advertising to you specifically.
- filleokus 3y agoI have never really used an ad blocker for any kind of time. I've tried on multiple occasions but then just range uninstall it whenever some random site breaks because of it and I don't realise it's because of it. Last time it was some online shop... Regardless of the morality / philosophical questions, the modern web feels to janky and unstable for me to trust the house of cards staying standing if you throw some Adblock in there. (But maybe I just didn't tweak the blocker enough...)
- pixl97 3y agoJust wondering what you're using for adblockers? I find the web far more unstable NOT using a blocker. Far too often the ads themselves break the layout or gobble up as much CPU as possible.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIf a site breaks from adblocking it wasn’t worth my time to begin with. If an online shopping site breaks I look at it with a heavy side eye and am thankful I didn’t provide my credit card information to such a poorly engineered and secured service.
- AndrewSwift 3y agoThe second you've paid for an ad-free version of software, you've proven that you're in the top 0.1% of people worth showing ads to. Very few companies can resist the temptation to exploit their best users. See all streaming services as an example.
- loughnane 3y agoI treasure my attention and so I've spent some time to opt out of ads. 5 years ago I couldn't tell what DNS was, now I've got an OPNsense router at home running ZenArmor/Unbound and I can can link to it from my phone over wireguard. Using ublock I've made a point to prune the pages I visit, so classes like "header" "breadcrumbs" "recommended" "sponsor" &c. are hidden. I self-host my media collection so I avoid spotify et al. It all leads to a deeply pleasant digital life for me and my family; I saw fewer ads/distractions in 2023 than any year before. I know most people won't go through all the steps I did, but I'm surprised there isn't a pricey service rich folks can buy to get this sort of experience out of the box.
- ActionHank 3y agoMissing some Invidious and Yattee for youtube there friend. Adfree and crowd-sourced sponsor segment skipping is a glorious experience.
- dicknuckle 3y agoor ReVanced. it's a beautiful project. Also, I've been using AdNauseum (based on Ublock) over the last few months and love it.
- loughnane 3y agoForgot to mention, I've got an invidious instance set up too. I also make much use of yt-dlp. Also miniflux for rss, a remarkable tablet w/ rmfakecloud for my ebooks, and prob some more stuff. On the YT side it feels good paying a few bucks a month for each channel i like and getting to skip the ads. I hope that picks up. I don't like paying for YT premium because then my identity is tied to my watch history.
- jdpedrie 3y agoI'm interested in running Invidious on my NAS. The docs make it seem relatively resource-intensive. Any experience with that?
- loughnane 3y ago
- lproven 3y ago1. Free websites, hungry for revenue, get so full of ads that free users tune out 2. Formerly free websites go paid 3. Opening up opportunities for smaller sites to underprice them but get paid for ad-free material 4. Mission. Fscking. Accomplished. https://xkcd.com/810/ https://xkcd.com/810/
- tannhaeuser 3y agoWe used to have (and still kind of have?) carrier billing for receiving assets such as ring tones but also paid web content via MMS for small money, even though the powers-that-be in the mobile space have worked hard to establish verticals and subscriptions without micro-transactions. Also "we" (as in "hackers") have now for I don't know how long seen greedy telcos as our natural enemy, embracing supposedly open TCP/IP-based protocols, and turning a blind eye towards new monopolies, even though telcos live in a highly regulated market while new monopolists do not.
- cjcole 3y ago“Our clients understand that a two- to three-minute ad load is more valuable than a nine-minute ad load,” says Mark Read, head of WPP, the world’s largest ad company and Groupm’s parent firm. It's appropriate that even the chief of the purveyors of advertisements uses the same language ("load") that clinicians use for viral infections.