10 ms·
How China's “debt traps” work
- csense 3y agoIf you're a small poor country and you borrow money from China to build infra on your territory, what happens if you simply... don't pay back the loan after the infra is built?
- green-eclipse 3y agoIf you read the article it answers this very question, with examples.
- slantedview 3y agoIt's worth pointing out that debt trap diplomacy was pioneered by the US backed IMF. While China has been exploitative, it goes without saying, that the US has been even moreso.
- throwaway29812 3y agoReally? What record does the US have leveraging aid for UN votes, political concessions, or just seizing ports and land?
- slantedview 3y agoLeveraging aid packages for UN votes and political concessions is standard geopolitics. For example, just a few weeks ago, it was discovered that the US leveraged an IMF deal to get Pakistan to back the war in Ukraine: https://theintercept.com/2023/09/17/pakistan-ukraine-arms-imf/ https://theintercept.com/2023/09/17/pakistan-ukraine-arms-im...
- throwaway29812 3y agoAid for pro-democracy or pro-US policies is standard practice, of course. But has the US threatened countries if they don't vote with them at the UN, or seized their land and/or assets for non payment of debt?
- slantedview 3y agoOf course. Even a tertiary google search will get you details, if you care to find and read them.
- throwaway29812 3y agoInfluencing other countries, which again everyone does. Have they ever specifically threatened to, say withhold vaccines if a vote doesn't go their way? https://apnews.com/article/united-nations-china-europe-ukraine-health-a0a5ae8f735b92e39c623e453529cbb9 https://apnews.com/article/united-nations-china-europe-ukrai... Have they ever put countries into debt then stolen land based on that debt? Your example btw was about raising arms for a third party conflict, not for something that directly benefits the US. Which weakens your argument.
- SenAnder 3y agoI wish it got the same attention. I heard only vague rumors about it. You can take this as an open invitation for stories about it.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoSince you went ahead and said what "goes without saying", how about you go further and actually demonstrate/document/prove what you say?
- slantedview 3y agoIn case you don't see the comment above, a few books that I know cover this topic include "Superimperialism" (Hudson), "Silent Coup" (Kennard), and "The Divide" (Hickel).
- wheelerof4te 3y ago"Confessions of an economic Hitman" is a first-person account of a man involved in these schemes. As an educated member of a developing country, I know that many so called "foreign investments" from the West are preceded (in fact, it is a requirenment) by huge loans from IMF and the World Bank. This money is then wired to the investor, who is paid in 10s of thousands euroes for each employee. Every large state-backed loan eventually ends up in the pockets of western investors.
- belltaco 3y agoAny quick sources to back that up? IMF appears to set some conditions to put the economy back on track before lending.
- hackandthink 3y agoDavid Graeber: Oh, absolutely. After all, the alter-globalization movement grew out of a broad global reaction to the Washington consensus, which was never any sort of consensus, but rather, a vision of the world forcibly imposed on the global South through the third world debt crisis. I was involved in “drop the debt” campaigns of various sorts since at least 2000. What got me interested in some of the philosophical issues I ended up ex- ploring in the book was the peculiar moral power of the notion of debts. So many oth- erwise sympathetic people, even when told of the terrible, almost unimaginably inhu- man suffering inflicted on people in the global South because of the depredations of the IMF, would still respond, “well, that’s terrible that so many children died slow and painful deaths, but still—surely one has to pay one’s debts! https://davidgraeber.org/wp-content/uploads/debts-history-implications-and-critical-perspective.pdf https://davidgraeber.org/wp-content/uploads/debts-history-im...
- slantedview 3y agoSure: two somewhat recent books that cover this are "Silent Coup" by Claire Provost and Matt Kennard, and "The Divide" by Jason Hickel. Another that covers this topic is "Superimperialism" by Michael Hudson. The purpose of the IMF is not to help countries out of some kind of benevolence, it's to use debt as a control mechanism over other countries.
- arandomhuman 3y ago[flagged]
- SenAnder 3y agoIt expands the discussion to a very relevant area. Speaking as someone highly opposed to China on this front, I did not interpret it as a defense of China.
- pphysch 3y agoThe article is about "global leadership". There has been 1 example of true global leadership so far in human history, based in Washington DC. To judge the flaws of a prospective new global leadership without reflecting on how they relate to the flaws of the only precedent is absurd. What is the point of reference??? "This car sucks because it doesn't fly" "My new MacBook sucks because it can't run local GPT-4 inference"
- axus 3y agoI checked the comments because I wanted some good sources on the what-abouts. Preferably from the countries affected. The link to Graeber supports the idea that debt, like power, is destined to be abused. It's not really telling me that the outcome was pre-meditated by the national leaders of the US or China.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 3y ago"They got land and money but lost in the end because now other countries don't like them" is not such a strong argument for having lost in the end, because, well, uhh... how many times has that happened?
- gruez 3y agoThe part you're missing is that they poured millions/billions into said projects. Taking those outlays into account it's very reasonable to conclude that they lost, even if they got some money/land.
- NicoJuicy 3y ago? China won, all that money invested was almost all to Chinese construction overcapacity. So that capacity was exported to useless prestige projects. Poor countries paid the bill ( mostly) and China is paid twice (foreign loans going to Chinese workers is a double win).
- havetocharge 3y agoI mean.. they did loan the money, with all the associated responsibilities and risks of loaning money. And they did do the work. All the agreements were entered voluntarily, so what's the fault here?
- Symmetry 3y agoClearly the Chinese construction companies that got the contracts won, but to the extent that the loans aren't paid back its money from Chinese taxpayers going to the people who own those companies. Japan had a big problem with this sort of corruption when they organized their foreign aid this way, which is why they no longer do.
- NicoJuicy 3y agoThe mostly state owned companies? :) And getting back the money from loans is also a win.
- hackandthink 3y ago"David Graeber: Oh, absolutely. After all, the alter-globalization movement grew out of a broad global reaction to the Washington consensus, which was never any sort of consensus, but rather, a vision of the world forcibly imposed on the global South through the third world debt crisis. I was involved in “drop the debt” campaigns of various sorts since at least 2000. What got me interested in some of the philosophical issues I ended up ex- ploring in the book was the peculiar moral power of the notion of debts. So many oth- erwise sympathetic people, even when told of the terrible, almost unimaginably inhu- man suffering inflicted on people in the global South because of the depredations of the IMF, would still respond, “well, that’s terrible that so many children died slow and painful deaths, but still—surely one has to pay one’s debts!" https://davidgraeber.org/wp-content/uploads/debts-history-implications-and-critical-perspective.pdf https://davidgraeber.org/wp-content/uploads/debts-history-im... Edit: responded to dead comment
- sickofparadox 3y agoOf course, the US is widely known for repossessing airports[1], seaports[2], and railways[3], then displacing local workers by flying in your own people. That totally happens all the time - its just that US biased media hiding it from you. The era of this kind of lazy anti-Westernism is over, China is only out for itself, and it will drag countries into its sphere of influence any way it can. "But what about this american thing?" I don't really have the time or need to respond to the thoughts of an "American anarchist activist" which is in all likelihood a nice euphemism for foreign agent or useful idiot. [1] https://www.africanliberty.org/2018/09/10/like-zambia-sri-lanka-also-handed-over-port-to-china-to-pay-off-debt/ https://www.africanliberty.org/2018/09/10/like-zambia-sri-la... [2] https://saharareporters.com/2021/11/26/china-takes-over-ugandan-airport-other-countrys-assets-over-207million-loan-deal https://saharareporters.com/2021/11/26/china-takes-over-ugan... [3]https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/kenya-china-funded-railway-embroiled-in-lawsuits-and-corruption-investigations-becomes-hot-button-election-issue/ https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/kenya-ch...
- teachrdan 3y agoThis is a very humorous comment for you to have made. OP posted a quote from David Graeber that precedes China's Belt-and-Road plans by years. Graeber was instead writing about the West's use of debt to further exploit the global south, and how debt has long had a supposed moral dimension that makes renegotiating it (in the literal and metaphorical sense) exceedingly difficult. As someone who sporadically did political organizing with David Graeber, I assure you he was sharply critical of US policy as it pertained to exploiting developing countries. He also happened to be a professor of anthropology at Yale and the London School of Economics. How you have determined he was a "foreign agent or useful idiot" is curious. But I know David would have found it as funny as I do.
- teekert 3y agoI guess the Chinese also read Confessions of an Economic Hitman by John Perkins.
- gruez 3y agoExcept if you read the article it's arguing that the opposite happened. >Note that although this is a debt trap, it isn’t really a case of “debt-trap diplomacy”, as some people accuse. Debt-trap diplomacy is where you get a country to owe you money, and you force it to make geopolitical concessions in exchange for loan forbearance. China doesn’t appear to be doing that; instead it appears to simply be walking away with as much of the money as it can, and thumbing its nose as it walks away, and leaving developing countries bitter and resentful.
- 3seashells 3y agoEh, China is using its influence in global "democratic" institutions to align votes towards outcomes it favors.
- gruez 3y agoAgain, from the article: >But in the long run, this is almost certain to hurt China’s image in the world. Back when the money was flowing, the countries of the Global South saw China in a highly positive light — after all, the West’s money always comes with strings attached. >But because the Belt and Road was so ill-conceived, this warm fuzzy feeling always had an expiration date. Now that the Belt and Road has basically failed, and the cash faucet has been shut off, delight at China’s seeming largesse is clearly going to be replaced with resentment and distrust. Acting like a mafia loanshark is not generally a way to win friends and influence people.
- teekert 3y agoHmm perhaps they should ready it more carefully then, like they did with 1984.
- ypeterholmes 3y ago
- xtian 3y agoSo if this is all accurate we should see a decline in new BRI projects and a preference for IMF and World Bank financing over institutions where China plays a larger role like the NDB. Let’s wait and see.
- NicoJuicy 3y agoThat's already noticable... why wait?
- kurthr 3y agoBecause it's mostly distressed lending, the preference is almost entirely on the lender not the borrower. IMF loans are required to be fairly transparent, while B&RI have so far been opaque (not clear what the terms, payment priority, or valuation of projects as collateral). The IMF won't even lend to countries where the lending would be used to pay off other creditors (since that's a transfer between creditors). It's unclear what China's response will be if the projects they claim are then nationalized (dams, ports and railroads are likely to be considered national infrastructure). Decisions to accept loans aren't made by the population that will pay and when governments change so do priorities. Since there's already a China debt problem (and ROI problem) though, it's more likely the loans just dry up. That already started in 2017 (see graph in article).
- 3seashells 3y agoThe multipolar World looks like the uni polar, it's just more of its crap.
- 0xDEF 3y agoThere is no multipolar world. It's just the US and China. Their combined GDP is bigger than the next 33 countries combined. As a Danish person I wish the EU had actual hard power but in the end of the day Denmark doesn't have the same geopolitical interests as Hungary, Bulgaria, and Slovakia. In fact their views are the polar opposite of ours.
- beebeepka 3y agoWhat do you mean our views are opposite? I am Bulgarian and I very much agree with you that we need an actual European army. Now, you can always assume I only say this because I live in a poor country that everyone pushes around. But when we zoom out a bit, the same could soon apply to the entire continent. We are not united and that's bad for all of us because our competitors are more much bigger and better integrated. Did you have something else in mind? I don't exactly pay any attention to US politics but I am sure their states are competing with each other because they have their own interests in mind. But that applies to cities too, does it not?
- 0xDEF 3y agoI was thinking in terms of Ukraine, Russia etc. Hungary, Bulgaria, and Slovakia have very pro-Russian populations according to opinion polls.
- beebeepka 3y agoWell, I don't know about the others in your list but russian propaganda is very strong here but even those who "support" them wouldn't want to live there, if you know what I mean. It's more of anti US thing than pro-Russia things. I guess people don't like hegemonies unless they greatly benefit from them. Go figure.
- Animats 3y agoIt's not just internationally. China has done that to its own people. Or worse. Look at Evergrand and Sunac. The government of China let developers sell un-built apartments to future residents. The residents not only paid down payments, but took on a mortgage obligation for an un-built building. "The majority of new properties in China — about 90% — are sold before being completed." - CNN. This produced a terrible incentive for developers to do huge numbers of housing starts and then not finish the building. In most of the rest of the world, developers have to finance construction with their own money or a high-interest construction loan, then sell the completed building. This gives developers a strong incentive to finish the job. Building quality control is often a problem, but unfinished projects less so.
- eklavya 3y agoNot in India, developers can sell before building but the money is in an escrow and released as the construction progresses. Also penalties and interest on any delays. I don't think selling unbuilt buildings is the bad thing, it's having no regulations or protections alongside that. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_Estate_(Regulation_and_Development)_Act,_2016 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_Estate_(Regulation_and_...
- rfoo 3y agoChina has > the money is in an escrow and released as the construction progresses. too. The problem is it doesn't work: the fund release schedule can't be perfectly aligned with each stage of the constitution on a cost basis. There's a large amount of unfinished buildings (rather than not started at all) at a certain stage - it's the point when the_amount_of_fund_released - the_construction_cost_so_far is maxed. I like the USA solution more - no mortgage for unfinished buildings. Developers can still sell it, but good luck.
- jxramos 3y agoThere's something very powerful behind incentives level thinking, it really does push you into second and third order effects and meta level interactions to think "if this then what next". I've been wanting to step up my level of engaging and contemplating incentives in the generic.
- pphysch 3y agoFor those who are curious about a serious analysis of China's foreign development policies, rather than a misinformational blog post: https://www.chathamhouse.org/2020/08/debunking-myth-debt-trap-diplomacy https://www.chathamhouse.org/2020/08/debunking-myth-debt-tra... That one is from 2020 but there are a lot of serious people looking at these complex issues.
- preciousoo 3y ago“As a Kenyan official put it: Every time China visits we get a hospital, every time Britain visits we get a lecture.”
- UncleSlacky 3y agoWhich led to this classic exchange: https://twitter.com/stillreezy/status/1507445282778206209 https://twitter.com/stillreezy/status/1507445282778206209
- greggsy 3y agoThat enrico account seems a bit iffy. Seems somewhat biased towards trump, Russia, China (maybe NK too?), and consistently against Biden and Ukraine (but nothing else?)?
- stale2002 3y ago> That one is from 2020 Then it is outdated. The new information related to the belt and road project's failures has only started to come up in the last couple years. I can understand why someone who doesn't have the updated information, based on recent economic data, would have a more nuanced view. But we have the new information now.
- littlestymaar 3y agoEven if it's not perfect, better have outdated informed point of view than “up to date” gut feeling from a pundit though…
- neilwilson 3y agoThe problem with listening to economists is that if your only tool is interest rates everything looks like a loan. No sovereign nation should be borrowing from anywhere other than itself. Instead firms should be selling equity denominated in the local currency for foreign currency - where they need foreign imported capital equipment. If nobody wants to invest on those terms then you have to build the equipment yourself. For a nation to develop successfully it needs patient money, not hot money.
- nradov 3y agoSmall, poor countries have no practical way to bootstrap and build equipment themselves. That might have worked in the 18th century but not today. Loans are patient money. As long as the borrower pays as agreed then they can do as they please. Whether the original lender holds the asset to maturity or sells it on to another investor makes no difference. Most of the high profile failures with foreign investment stem from corruption and incompetence. Switching from debt to equity won't cure that.
- paxys 3y agoIt didn't work in the 18th century either. Poor nations mostly entered the industrial age through colonialism rather than indigenous enterprise. The moment powerful nations could build ships and cross oceans, it was game over for the rest of the world.
- anon84873628 3y ago>Most of the high profile failures with foreign investment stem from corruption and incompetence. Switching from debt to equity won't cure that. It could change who gets left holding the bag, though. Presumably if Chinese firms held equity in the hydroelectric plants, they would care about whether they were built correctly and won't collapse. As it stands they get paid either way (according to the article).
- neilwilson 3y ago"As long as the borrower pays as agreed then they can do as they please. " That's not patient money then is it. That's money that requires regular service - mostly in a foreign currency. Patient money gets paid as and when there is profit to service it.
- csomar 3y agoI've recently rode through a Belt&Road project: The Lao high-speed train. In my opinion, it shows the complete failure of the Chinese government. The high-speed train is a reasonably great train that goes through dozens (hundreds?) of mountains and rivers (through tunnels and bridges). It does that while enabling you to work from the comfort of your chair. And while it's not high-speed (as in 300Km/h), it is reasonably fast. The train station locations, however, are just non-sense. This is because they are too far, and for many stations, there is no "road" to connect to the city. Couple that with the retarded system they have to check-in which requires you to be in the station one hour before your train departs and suddenly a 40 minutes ride becomes a 2.5 hours ride. Might as well just use a regular bus? In my opinion, the Chinese government is still living in the 80s (along with 80s technology). The Chinese economy (or parts of China) is living in a parallel reality with companies that are quite developed if not world-class. This means the Chinese government can "execute" quite advanced projects while being a peasant itself. It's not clear what's sustaining the central government in China, or what's the level of discontent in the productive provinces.
- ilickpoolalgae 3y agoI'm not sure if it's comparable, but the Japanese Shinkansen had similar issues when it's first built. A lot of the stations didn't go through the existing central stations due to costs and other logistical problems. This is why there are a lot of stations that the Shinkansen goes through that are called "Shin-XXX" (e.g. Shin Osaka). During a period of fast economic growth this isn't a big issue because the areas around these stations quickly become hubs or alternative downtown areas of their own. Now, I don't know if this will happen to CN but it is a somewhat repeatable outcome of building important railroad hubs in newly developed areas.
- evertedsphere 3y ago(for those who might not know, shin 新 = "new")
- csomar 3y agoI don't think this is a problem for CN because in China, you can take the subway after getting off the train. It's okay to have the station afar from the center. This is the not case with Laos but I don't think the people planning that really cared.
- neaden 3y agoIt seems like the very real risk for China here is if all these countries decide to act collectively on the debt. National debt isn't like other sorts after all, there is ultimately no higher authority that can intervene or that China can appeal too.
- mpsprd 3y agoThis article makes me think about "tofu-dreg projects" [0] Poor quality construction work prevalent in mainland china. If you look for content with this keyword, you will find jaw dropping videos of constructions workers bending or breaking "rebar" with their hands, Owners chipping away concrete in high-rise buildings like its sand, etc. Of course some of this can be propaganda, but considering it has a local name, there must be truth to it. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tofu-dreg_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tofu-dreg_project
- dexwiz 3y agoIt does have a propaganda feeling to it. I went thru the top 25 YouTube videos for tofu dreg recently, and they had that undertone of hoping for China to collapse. There are crappy building practices in any country. The real question is prevalence, which I can’t seem to answer.
- nonethewiser 3y agoThen where are the videos of western tofu dreg? China has a literal army of propaganda posters. Am I supposed to believe such problems exist and it never occurred to them to push it?
- l3mure 3y ago> In July 2021, another occurrence of tofu-dreg construction happened in Zhengzhou in Henan province where the entire city was put at a standstill due to torrential rains and flooding. The city was referred to as a “sponge city” because of how vulnerable the drainage system was. Some argued that the city was not to blame since they were experiencing unprecedented rain levels, but there was evidence later found pointing towards a weak infrastructure. Damn, sounds like NYC this past week. Here's one of many videos: https://x.com/OfficialWildX__/status/1707867092832378884?s=20 https://x.com/OfficialWildX__/status/1707867092832378884?s=2...
- mikrotikker 3y ago
- acyou 3y agoOur USA global empire from 1945 to present invests mostly in resource extraction in poor and underdeveloped countries. Aid comes in the form of providing food and medicine, probably the worst help that could be given to countries with virtually no infrastructure. China pays for infrastructure to be built of the type and scale in countries that haven't seen this type of investment since their respective post-war expansionary periods, which most likely ended 60+ years ago. We Americans don't like it, because this represents moves towards the attempted changing of the guard, but we can't do anything but complain. At this point we can't invest in our own infrastructure, much less improve other countries'. But it feels like these infrastructure investments should have happened decades ago, and their net effects would have been to raise the standard of living of millions, or billions. Agreed that this plan seems to be winding down, unfortunately it doesn't seem to work. It looks like China will actually pivot their economy to tech. Airplanes, computers, microchips, and soon, software...
- jorts 3y agoThe US is clearly investing in its infrastructure [1]. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/build/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/build/
- anon84873628 3y agoAs the article states, China does not actually invest in these projects. It simply finances them by providing loans.
- acyou 3y agoI'm surprised to see this level of confusion on what "investment" means, on a venture capital related forum of all places. If financing by providing loans is not investment, well, then we are saying that it's something like the article seems to imply, which is that you have to end up with an ownership stake in order for something to be an investment? If you were buying government bonds, would you not consider that to be an investment? Non-equity lending is definitely still investment, and is probably less predatory...
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _8j50 3y agoThis whole piece is remarkably silly depending on perspective. I mean I get it, China bad, sure. But when the author says "hospitals" ,"bridges" and such I think he does get that they exist in a place of desperation and poverty but can't seem to actually appreciate what that means. Not borrowing internationally, owing China money, poor quality constructions, chinese imported labor and conflicts with locals are all nothing when you consider just how bad poverty is. It's something. It's like rich people telling poor people to stop getting avocado toast in the US. Given China's hostility, you would think europe and america would wake up and get past their moral high grounds but having someone to look down on is hell of a drug. Starving and impoverished people don't want a lecture on democracy and human rights. To me, the most terrifying thing is considering how much of this democracy and human rights I enjoy here is dependent on our economy and military being #1.
- bilbyx 3y agoNot this China "debt trap" BS again. Deborah Brautigam had unbunked this a long time ago.
- nonethewiser 3y agoAppeal to authority fallacy. If you can disprove it then disprove it. Just asserting which conclusion to believe isn't going to work.