5 ms·
Get your staff's consent before you monitor them, tech inquiry warns
- moron4hire 3y agoEmployers will just put it in the employee handbook and, as they already do, require accepting and signing the employee handbook as a condition for employment. A lot of companies have some really nutty stuff in their employee handbooks. One of my previous employers had a "professional appearance in public at all times" provision. Even when you weren't on the clock, you were expected to dress in a suit, not drink alcohol (even in restaurants), and several other things I don't remember, because "a client could see you". Places like that are likely chomping at the bit to get tracking software installed on your personal computer.
- d1sxeyes 3y agoI know the UK adopted GDPR, but I'm not sure about any changes which might have happened since Brexit. However, in the EU, where the GDPR was written, consent must be freely given (which means that it must also be possible not to consent without negative consequences). Especially for employees, the prevailing opinion is that employees cannot give consent freely in most circumstances (https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection/reform/rights-citizens/how-my-personal-data-protected/can-my-employer-require-me-give-my-consent-use-my-personal-data_en https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection/r...) I'm surprised to see a recommendation to gather consent in this context. (BTW: the report itself is hidden behind a link fairly far down in the article: https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41099/documents/200210/default/ https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41099/document...)
- izacus 3y agoNote that GDPR does have some carveouts for workplaces (meaning, it doesn't always apply in full as you'd expect). As always, it really leans heavily on why people are recorded and how that data is used.
- temac 3y agoI'm not sure what would people expect for GDPR to apply in "full" in the workplace. (TBH I'm not even sure what would most people expect from GDPR, apart from being annoyed with cookie questions while browsing the web, but let's concentrate on people who know their rights and would potentially want to exercice them.) And even then, GDPR applies, and in a good amount of cases require even more strict measures than "baseline" GDPR. E.g. employees are considered "vulnerable" because of the employee / employer relationship, and that often implies that Privacy Impact Assessments are required (fulfil one criteria and as soon as 2 are presents, PIAs are needed). That you can't use GDPR to e.g. delete random company data just because you are somehow associated to it is only logical, but I would not really count that as "GDPR not applying in full". That was understandably never the intent of the law, and it is detailed enough to avoid silly scenarios.
- PeterisP 3y ago> GDPR does have some carveouts for workplaces Can you point me to any? IMHO it does not have any explicit clauses mentioning more lax conditions for consent in case of employment relationships, and there have been multiple cases of GDPR enforcement re-asserting that anything that you require from all employees doesn't count as consent. An employer might assert a "legitimate need" basis for processing (in which case you need to only inform the employee, not their consent), but that is inherently limited and there have been large fines assessed for employees trying to push constant monitoring with this justification; the employer has a duty to minimize the invasiveness of achieving that legitimate need (e.g. surveillance for theft prevention can monitor only places relevant for that, and doesn't permit using the same videos for any other purpose e.g. measuring employee activity).
- askl 3y agoJust not monitoring staff might be an option too.
- hef19898 3y agoHypothetically, but that would be outragious, wouldn't it?
- knallfrosch 3y agoIt's important to eat breakfast at your computer to simulate activity. If you're not remote, you should be in the office 9 hours, browsing Facebook on your phone (as to not get logged.)
- locopati 3y agoThere is no consent when it comes to the employer/employee power imbalance. Agree or be fired is coersion.
- jdietrich 3y agoThat might fly in an at-will state, but in the UK it's going to end up at an employment tribunal. "Agree or be fired" falls down if the law strictly regulates how, when and why someone can be fired and those laws are readily enforced. An employee asserting their statutory rights is absolutely not a legitimate grounds for dismissal. The Data Protection Act does allow for monitoring without consent, but only where that monitoring is specific and limited to an absolutely necessary purpose that overrides the rights of the data subject: for example, the detection and prevention of crime, the protection of life or limb, or the fulfilment of a legal obligation. For any other purpose, consent must be given; for that consent to be valid, it must be fully informed, freely given and freely revocable. Where consent is relied upon as the basis for data processing, the burden of proof is upon the data processor to demonstrate that the consent was legitimately given.
- Jochim 3y agoIt won't in most cases. People either don't know or don't want to risk their job for the possibility of a payout at tribunal. That's assuming the employee is even aware that they're being monitored in the first place.
- verve_rat 3y agoMostly it will be rolled out over time. Not "agree or be fired" but rather "agree or don't get hired". It will become a standard cause in employment contracts that people will be "free" to negotiate, just like everyone "negotiates" their employment contracts now.
- linster 3y agoYes, a voice of commonwealth reason. Not everywhere is an at-will employment type of place, and it’s refreshing to see people be reminded that employee rights exist in parts of the world and that employment isn’t a one-way street.
- ethbr0 3y agoHearing the British government care about "the risks of excessive surveillance" is a new one. Although I guess it's because they're talking about companies, not the government itself.
- KnobbleMcKnees 3y agoPresumably consent is an obligatory contact amendment and easily introduced to new contracts too. And British people will accept it like they accept every kick to the balls by government or big business.
- isaacremuant 3y agoTrying to ban encryption while they gaslight you about privacy being important and what companies can do but, as you say, they're one of the most abusive and potentially one of the most careless in relation to the sensitive nature of the data as well (see voter leak).
- jdietrich 3y ago"The British government" is not a monolith. We have an incredibly dysfunctional cabinet for various dull political reasons, but there are a lot of smart and sensible people in committees and the civil service.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThat's an important point that's not always visible from the outside. I worked on implementing payroll system for a federal government and it was eye-opening in my ignorance - I always thought of "The Government" as a monolith with unified voice. nothing could be further from the truth. And different parts have explicitly different goals and prerogatives so its not even necessarily contradictory if e.g. Environmental Agency and ministry for interior development have completely opposite points of view.
- hkt 3y agoFor those in the UK, you should join the United Tech and Allied Workers - see https://utaw.tech https://utaw.tech Aside from normal union activities, they have a very active interest in employee surveillance and are looking at how to fight it. Go and join, before you end up wishing you had done it sooner.
- ddmf 3y agoWe had a situation where we had to use monitoring software to try to catch a very random issue that we suspected was user error, but the user was very obstinate it was a system error. The software we found, the "features" are abhorrent in my opinion - the screen recording was what we purchased for, and we disabled everything else. Thing is, we've discussed this with the specific employee involved and shown them exactly what we can see, and exactly what we can't see. Informed them that only I can see the data and will only use it when that specific problem is reported. Watching seems to have reduced the incidence of the error, it was happening once or twice every 3 weeks, but it's not happened within the past 7 weeks at all. It's "saved" us about 5k so far, so I can see why it's attractive.
- ZephyrBlu 3y agoAn employee was making a mistake that was costing the company thousands of dollars, and was insistent it was a system error not their fault? I'm really curious about what they were doing now, and why they would blame it on system error.
- pc86 3y agoIt's possible they do believe it's a system error, but now that there's new monitoring in place, they're being very careful about that part of their job. Or perhaps it was a conflict with some personal software that they uninstalled after hearing about the new debugging/monitoring.
- ddmf 3y agoWe have a print job "triplicator" that I wrote about 12 years back to replicate three part dot matrix paper on a laser/mfp. The employee works at a branch office that used to have a really good connection but now has an awful 50/12 adsl link. They connect to our remote desktop server to our accounting software - create a proof of delivery that is printed via the triplicator to their local mfp machine which can take a moment to actually print. When we moved from the 100mbps mpls link to the crap adsl there were some issues with printing the delivery notes, which we had to work around, but this is now recorded in people's memories as an ongoing issue - which it's not. So, the issue is they believe they've processed the delivery notes and printed them, but they never appear. We can prove they've not been processed or printed due to database entries and logs, but the employee is adamant she's done them, and she's a great employee bar this one thing so hr and her manager don't push back.
- Simulacra 3y agoEven before I got my security clearance, it was always in my employment agreement that my employer may monitor my communications while at work. Is notification the same as consent under these circumstances?
- mytailorisrich 3y agoWell, if it's in the employment contact, which you agreed to and signed, it's not 'notification', you agreed to that term.
- tssva 3y agoGoing back to the mid-90s every company I worked for had a computer use policy which I had to sign as part of onboarding. These always included a section regarding monitoring and that signing the policy was agreeing to the monitoring. This included small businesses up to large global enterprises.
- incomingpain 3y agoIf you're in Canada, you can't even get consent, you cannot monitor your staff. Supreme court ruling is what it is. I had a collegue recently tell me how he was monitoring employees and 1 of the staff was working from home, but in reality watching porn all day. Despite an HR derpartment, for some reason they required him to be the one who fired the person. Bizarre... infosec people should never be firing people. They did it because he ought to have known what he was doing was illegal.
- bob1029 3y agoOur system is pretty straightforward. We are 100% WFH. Whatever you do on the virtual/cloud work desktop is considered entirely property of our company. Your incidental Spotify, Youtube and 4chan visits are included in this scope. We actively encourage our employees to minimize their cloud desktop and use their thin client/MacBook/2nd computer/whatever for non-work things. To go even further - the physical hardware we provide to our employees is no longer enrolled into IT policies. If someone uses the actual work machine to play counterstrike, we literally don't care about this anymore. It wouldn't show up on any report. We seriously don't give a shit if someone is listening to music, having Netflix playing, etc. The only thing that matters is the work product at the end of the day. Some people are incredibly productive while listening to death metal at reference volume. Others are not. Who are we to judge? Even though we have access to deep digital forensics on our employee's virtual desktops, we would only ever use them if there were some criminal or civil proceedings brought forth. If you feel like you have to use the digital panopticon to micromanage your tech/knowledge employees, you are potentially a really shitty manager.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoOk, for these employees, do you also consume audio and video? My biggest concern is that WFH bringing company hardware home is inviting employers the opportunity to monitor employee home-life, recording private conversations, for example. It might be one thing to have that sort of monitoring go on at the work place, but WFH own their office, and pay for it too. Incidentally, I feel the same way about kids bringing laptops home from school.
- reaperman 3y ago> Ok, for these employees, do you also consume audio and video? Clearly GP's firm doesn't run a webcam and microphone capture on the thin client. They could potentially monitor audio/video I/O from the cloud workstation that the thin client logs into.
- pc86 3y agoIf you're concerned about this isn't the simple answer just to shut down at the end of the day? While I'm sure there are exceptions, thinking about the IT departments I've worked with in the past and how cost-conscious they were, the last thing any of them would want to do is waste the time and money to record non-work related employee conversations at their home.
- thelastparadise 3y agoEmployer: Employee, you must consent to monitoring. Employee: What if I don't? Employer: We will fire you.
- BurningFrog 3y agoConsent is a two way street!
- toastal 3y agoThe beatings will continue until morale improves
- isaacremuant 3y agoWe've been hearing authoritarian minded people for years saying things like "actions have consequences" and "you had a choice, no one forced you to" but coercion (pushing someone to an unwanted choice using an imbalance of power/threat) is simply an illusion of freedom and fairness.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoMy personal 'favorite' replies in that vein include thinly veiled threats to RTO. 'You come back or we find someone else to do the job.' What is interesting is that those same people no longer add 'your job will be outsourced'.
- capableweb 3y agoEmployee: But what about my health insurance? Employer: Better not make us fire you
- axus 3y agoIt's more like "Read this 50-page employee handbook and send us your signature acknowledging it. You must do this every year." (It is the mostly identical to last year's version but with the employee monitoring added to a clause, and we aren't mentioning what's changed)
- nemo44x 3y agoI don’t understand why a manager wants to waste their time monitoring this. Workers are measured by their outputs. You should be able to clearly identify a contributors outputs. There’s many ways and popular tools to track this. So long as you make your meetings during “regular business hours” and produce agreed upon outputs then who cares if the contributor is fishing half the day. Their ambitious peers will take on more work if they being underutilized and when it comes time to distribute merit increases and promotions it is obvious who earned it. Manage outputs and distribution of labor and build your metrics around this instead of trying to determine if someone looks busy.
- Neil44 3y agoWhenever I'm asked to help look at a specific person it's because they suspect cause or are looking for cause to get rid of them. TBH I usually find it.
- nemo44x 3y agoWhat in particular are they doing? This seems different than watching day to day work. I understand that if the company is suspicious an employee is doing something that’s an fireable offense then they need tools to take action.
- jstarfish 3y agoI have to fight my own team to keep them from turning on "screenshot everything" tools for everyone we suspect might be doing something. The concept of probable cause as a requisite for more-invasive monitoring is foreign to most people.
- Neil44 3y agoRunning a side business with company resources, sending leads out to their friends or possible future employers instead of pursuing them, watching TV all day, sending mass company data / PII to their personal gmail, just straight up not doing any work... Porn hasn't come up that often surprisingly but spending time on other work inappropriate time sinks does. Etc Etc
- helpfulmandrill 3y agoConsent meaning "sign here or we fire you"...
- tpoacher 3y ago"Consent"
- pc86 3y agoIMO a business/manager cannot get "consent" from an employee because that employee is always under threat of being fired. Any consent given should be considered under duress, e.g. not actually consent.
- reaperman 3y agoReally need to see more of this attitude in the workplace. I'd like to think it's not controversial but I'm surprised at how often it seems to be overlooked for workplace romances as well.
- pc86 3y agoI think it will make a resurgence. In boom times when you could work somewhere for 6 months then go anywhere else and make a 10-15% raise, there was at least some validity in the "if you don't like it, don't work here" argument. But if the employment market tightens, or if a) we actually have a recession and b) it meaningfully affects the tech sector (which seems to be unlikely regardless of the broader economy), you'll see people start to behave as if they can't be guaranteed a job somewhere.
- backendanon 3y ago> you'll see people start to behave as if they can't be guaranteed a job somewhere. I'm trying to follow the thread, are you saying that people who don't want to have every mouse click tracked or their private home network, outside the work VPN searched, are behaving in an entitled manor?
- pc86 3y agoNo. It's reasonable to expect some sort of fluidity in what employees are willing to accept from employers, and part of what factors into that is how easy it is to get another job. If it's very difficult to go to another employer, employees will naturally accept more "bad" things from their employers than they might if they could make a phone call and get another job.
- Neil44 3y agoMorally the equipment and services belong to the employer so to assume you can use them for personal reasons is a big assume. Whenever I'm asked to look at someone I always tell the owner to consult with a HR professional before using anything directly. Nobody cares about your personal business. Just don't do dumb stuff like watching porn at work, email company data to your personal account. Or sit watching Netflix all day.
- vladvasiliu 3y ago> Or sit watching Netflix all day. Meh. I know a bunch of people who like having the TV or the radio on in the background. They're not actually listening to it, but they say they like the feeling of not being alone. My mom does that when working around the kitchen. She'll have some news channel or similar on. She'll hear the same bulletins 10 times a day. And when in the evening something comes up at the dinner table, she'll have no recollection of ever having heard about it.
- Neil44 3y agoOK, but if someone's looking at you because of performance or whatever then having Netflix or YouTube open all day is not a good look.
- tedajax 3y agoThat's precisely the point of their comment though. There's more context than just how long Netflix was open. It's not a "bad look" if it's literally how you do your job and are productive.
- gampleman 3y agoJust because someone owns the hardware doesn't remove your right to privacy (neither morally nor legally in the UK/EU).
- johnny99k 3y agoAt my first job about 15 years ago, my coworker in the cubicle next to me showed me this strange program running on his computer. We saw that it was running on a weird port, so I tried to telnet into it (and the software crashed). The next day, he was fired and I was brought into a room and basically interrogated. They asked me if I intentionally crashed their monitoring software (which I didn't, I just was curious about what was running on his computer). Come to find out, they were monitoring all of us all the time. I suspected this was the case a few months earlier because one of my managers started randomly bringing up topics I had in a private AIM (aol instant messenger) conversation. That day, they told our entire team we were being monitored and we had to sign a consent form or be fired. I signed it and promptly started looking for work during my lunch hour the next day (I would drive a few miles away and use my laptop in my car). I left two months later. This was all about 6 months before the 2008 downturn and the company I left was in the loan business. I would have most likely gotten laid off in the cuts.
- londons_explore 3y agoA good chunk of monitoring of work computers is to detect malware/evil actors. Your work antivirus probably keeps records of every file opened and saved for example, every URL visited, every password entered, etc. Thats pretty invasive monitoring. Yet that information is only used to determine if you have accidentally fallen for a phishing attack or accidentally installed malware on your machine. It isn't the employee who is the target of the monitoring, but the possible evildo-er they might be letting into the corporate network acting under the employees credentials.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]