16 ms·
Man spends entire career mastering crappy codebase
- nsxwolf 3y agoI am Mr. Westbrook. AMA.
- throwaway2990 3y ago[flagged]
- Aeolun 3y agoIt’s humor.
- mrob 3y agoHumor with a serious message.
- bjord 3y agoI don't think it's supposed to be a "real" article about a real person, I think it's art (that speaks to some of our fears) do you believe that something has to be purely "productive" to be deserving of space on the internet?
- throwaway2990 3y agoThere’s too much crap on the internet now. So yes.
- andrejguran 3y agoyou must be fun at parties
- mikrl 3y agoMost of it exists to sell you stuff and make people money
- bjord 3y agoare you also opposed to higher education/research in anything other than hard science, or do you think people in those fields should just stick to pencil and paper?
- throwaway2990 3y agoAre you suggesting art is crap and that I think it shouldn’t be on the internet because you deem it crap?
- bjord 3y agoactually, no, I'm suggesting that you think art is crap and that thus you also think it shouldn't be on the internet honestly, I don't think that's a huge leap given your previous comments—am I wrong?
- throwaway2990 3y agoWell I guess it depends on what we define as art. I don’t think putting a piece of cheese on a table in the middle of a room is art or thought provoking beyond “this ‘artist’ is fucking shit”. Or running and jumping while drawing a line on the wall. That’s just insulting to actual artists who have talent that we can appreciate.
- bowsamic 3y agoI think it's quite inspiring rather than invoking fear. I would take a job like this any time.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThere was a Dilbert once (no longer available, for some reason), where Phil, the Prince of Insufficient Light, curses Dilbert to select one of two choices: 1) You will be paid well, but your code will be destroyed every night. 2) You will be poorly paid, but your code will be useful and appreciated. Dilbert says "Hey! They're both better than what I have now! Wally, you should come and get some of this!"
- throwaway2990 3y agoWhy do people get stuck on these soulless jobs?
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoLots of reasons. Many folks are afraid of the unknown, so it's the devil you know, kind of thing. That's why most folks aren't entrepreneurs. There's a ton of risk, involved in that kind of stuff, and most folks are risk-averse. In my case, my job was sort of soulless, but only in parts. Many folks here, would say that it was a horror show, but I also worked for a company that gave me business cards that would open doors, I worked with some of the finest engineers and scientists in the world, enjoyed considerable trust, and had great stability. Nothing comes for free. There's pluses and minuses to everything. I find it doesn't do me a whole lot of good to judge others on the choices they made, and, in the aggregate, there's not much in my life that I regret, and that's worth more than money.
- bjord 3y agothat's the beauty of art—it can mean totally different things to different people
- jna_sh 3y agoHi Arthur
- greensh 3y agoit's a fable
- mysterydip 3y agoThere's plenty of low effort garbage on the internet that I would consider a waste way before this piece. Just the reactions of some other commenters making them rethink their career trajectory shows it has value.
- devX3 3y agoawww, you're so gullible
- bjord 3y agoI'm worried this will be me someday. I suppose that's the point.
- antupis 3y agoDoes somebody work 35 years in same company, it is usually 2-5 years -> new company grind rather than working at same company.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoYes, I know many people in software/tech who have been 20+ years with the same company. Hopping every 2 years is not common. That said, it is a red flag for me if most people in the team have been there for very long: it means that as a new comer I will always be bottom of the pile and have no career growth opportunity.
- the_lonely_road 3y agoThat’s a common story on HN but not at all a reflection of real life. Be careful letting the internet convince you of something without doing your research. There are lots of us with deep tenure at a single employer. It would not surprise me to find it’s still the majority of professionals.
- kypro 3y agoI've seen it. Some people are weird and just want a stable job that pays them alright so they can focus on their family and other things they care about. A few times in my career I've seen people with a decade-plus experience leave companies they would have stayed at for another two decades if it were within their control. It's sad. They struggle a bit because they often realise that they've over fit their skillsets to that single company. One guy I knew was hired as a "web developer" in ~2005 because of his HTML/CSS knowledge. He continued to do basically just HTML/CSS until he lost his job in 2020. Lovely guy, but he saw his job as just a job and couldn't give a damn about learning new technologies. I often wonder what he's doing now... I doubt just knowing HTML/CSS is a hireable skillset anymore.
- baz00 3y agoThis is where I am heading. The article is motivating me to change that.
- gorpomon 3y agoWhy does Taylor have to play Arthur like this, poor man will need burn cream after this blog post.
- boredumb 3y agoOne of the scariest short stories i've read all year.
- emptyfile 3y ago[dead]
- mawadev 3y agoMy boss straight up told me a couple of juniors could do my job the other day
- HL33tibCe7 3y agoFind another job
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whoisthemachine 3y agoMost coding is pretty mechanical... and most juniors can pick that up easily. In spite of the mysticism surrounding software development, higher level languages are actually intended to be easy to pick up. If you have good problem solving skills, those are harder to replace with a couple of juniors (or ChatGPT).
- zelphirkalt 3y agoIf coding is mechanical, then the code will often turn out to be overheady, uninspired suboptimal solutions á la everything is a class, not well extensible and maintainable, or the task at hand truly not fit for the skill of a good developer. Coding is a craft. There is an art aspect to it and there is a lot of room for inspiration and ideas to improve things.
- dtx1 3y ago> Coding is a craft. There is an art aspect to it and there is a lot of room for inspiration and ideas to improve things. True but often enough great code is not needed just working code will do just fine.
- d-lisp 3y agoI honestly never found a private codebase in any of my jobs that was great and clean and arty.
- whoisthemachine 3y agoFunny, but there's nothing wrong with that if Arthur was/is happy (which isn't mentioned).
- emptyfile 3y ago[dead]
- Otek 3y agoExactly this. Guy had a comfortable stable job for years. Probably knew codebase and technology enough to have lots of time for family/friends/hobbies. More than this story scares me how HN reacted
- bowsamic 3y agoI can only assume it's because HN is full of young, inexperienced people whose main wish is to stay on the cutting edge of technology rather than sinking into a stable profession
- version_five 3y agoYou may be right, but I don't think experience is what makes people prioritize stability over anything else. I'd be so depressed at a real job like the one described, it would be irrelevant that it was stable and gave me extra time. Some people are ambitious, some just like variety.
- bowsamic 3y agoVariety for the sake of variety is foolish though. If variety is not required, injecting it where it's not needed is just called "breaking things"
- Double_a_92 3y agoMost jobs are like that though... Unless maybe if all you do is develop very small applications, that your company just sells and forgets.
- bowsamic 3y agoThis is the dream imo. I love this kind of work
- acosmism 3y agoactually terrifying. feels like the onion. let me laugh it off hahahaha
- alecco 3y agoThe things people do for "job security".
- hliyan 3y agoFor ten years, I worked on codebases written in C++ without using any third party libraries (no, not even STL -- we needed faster, thread safe versions of strings and maps which were not available at the time; Boost? What's that?), its own custom messaging middleware built directly on sockets, its on distributed process management system built with unix syscalls (obviously). There was not a single line of HTML, Java etc. anywhere. It was a comfortable, high-paid life and I solved cutting edge problems (HFT, distributed, concurrent computing). In 2013, I forced myself to quit, start with a small company that paid me half the salary so that I could learn the web tech stack from the ground up. It was all to avoid this fate. I'd like to think I've succeeded.
- Aloha 3y agoWas it something that ran in an embedded environment?
- hliyan 3y agoHigh frequency algorithmic trading. Often ran on colocated hardware within the exchange / trading system data centers. Started with stuff like Sun SPARC, Solaris and Oracle and we slowly made our way to Suse, Intel and... surprise, our own database optimised for fast writes.
- eamonnsullivan 3y agoBloomberg? Comdb? If not, sounds very similar, anyway. Been there, done that!
- bboygravity 3y agoNaive question: is this like creating fancy tech that is helping rich people to front-run the poor and middle-class? Because that's what a lot of people think online. Maybe it's more nuanced. I'm curious how someone from that carreer sees it?
- semi-extrinsic 3y ago
- time0ut 3y agoThere is something to be said for stability. Since our protagonist retired early, the pay must not have been bad. The glass is half full, or so I tell myself.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoI thought so at first too, but the planned "street performance and dumpster diving" tells a different story.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 3y agoI know people who enjoy street performance and dumpster diving. Bringing your juggling balls (or guitar) to a street corner and trying to make money gives some pressure that makes it fun - and that you don't need the money means if people don't like you enough to pay it doesn't matter. Likewise people throw away a lot of treasures that you can fix up and sell/give away. If he needs to be a street performer and dumpster diver to make ends meet that isn't good. However people do those things as a hobby all the time.
- sumtechguy 3y agoI worked with a guy who made easy into the 200k range in the early 2000s two separate pension plans. Total dumpster diver. He loved the thrill of finding stuff. Wore complete rags at work. Drove a car from the early 70s. Ate simple homemade leftovers ever day for lunch. He loved the idea of racking up a high score.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoTrue, but people usually don't start with this on retirement. And the end of the story is about him planning to eat cat food(?). Not sure how to take this, as it also talks about Soylent and Premium Mix, which are not the cheapest.
- zabzonk 3y ago> Westbrook believes he grapsed over 4% of the entire codebase He's doing well
- pavlov 3y agoHow did Arthur avoid promotion to management?
- ourmandave 3y agoThey couldn't hire any replacement VB6 programmers.
- arexxbifs 3y agoHe was sufficiently good at programming: > Westbrook once touched legacy code without ending the company.
- morelisp 3y agoThis strategy doesn't work, I did this twice and then got "promoted" to Architect so now I sit in meetings >24 hours a week.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steve1977 3y agoAs long as it's not >24 hours a day, there is still room to grow.
- 0x008 3y agousually "architects" are just people there to keep the communication rolling and make sure devs or teams don't work in silos all their life. probably your communication skills were too good for management to passt up the opportunity of promoting you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- generic92034 3y agoThat is one extreme. The other one is developers hopping from new project to new project without ever even seeing the product going live or getting user feedback/bug reports from the live product.
- rkwz 3y agoUnrelated: this link opened almost instantly, what’s this magic? Even HN takes longer!
- sneak 3y agoIf you serve plain static HTML from S3 or Cloudflare Pages (or even a vanilla nginx on a vps) and put a decent CDN in front of it (and don't load 3p resources), it will astound people how fast your page loads. I regularly get this feedback on my own webpage. It's not rocket science - it's how we made webpages in 2001. Browsers are really good at that.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoLife is too short for working with crap code. Unfortunately there is more crap code out there, than there are opportunities of working on beautiful code. At least in most jobs there will at minimum be compromise and part of the job will be dealing with ugly code.
- yaky 3y agoMost developers see and work with crap code because good code runs well and rarely needs to be touched. At least that’s what I tell myself.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoMakes me wonder how many of us work on things, that are actually relevant and not just reinventing things or adding to future dystopia.
- SanderNL 3y agoNow that I'm older this sort of comment actually makes me laugh. Thanks for that. Good code.. oh, sweet sweet summer child.
- thisismyhna 3y agoNothing like working on crap code that past you wrote.
- bubbleRefuge 3y agoIs this humor LLM generated ?
- ourmandave 3y agoHis manager noted, “Arthur had a knack for working hard without learning transferrable skills." ^^^This! Arthur was lucky to retire at 58. He probably made fat bank which turned out to be golden handcuffs. If he ever got downsized, he had been f*d.
- jstx1 3y ago> He probably made fat bank which turned out to be golden handcuffs. This is a big assumption, not everyone in this field is a high earner - plenty of people make okay-ish salaries without being anywhere near highly paid.
- ourmandave 3y agoHe retired at 58 so I'd assumed. Maybe he's got a side hustle or embraced the super frugal lifestyle.
- firesteelrain 3y agoThat's what Dan did at my old job. Retired at 50. We would go on per diem travel and he would bring food from the hotel. We called them 'Dan-wiches'. He was smart and frugal. Now living his best life.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoThat's not how it works. Those who've been there 20 years and who would have difficulties finding another job are those who get low salary increases. On the other hand they've been there for so long without looking elsewhere that they probably have no idea that their pay is low.
- World177 3y agoFor $666/day the author also sells infinite exponential growth. [1] [1] https://taylor.town/hire-me https://taylor.town/hire-me
- bspammer 3y agoThe site says $1000 for me. Regional pricing perhaps?
- World177 3y ago> Estimates > 3m $60k double your daily active users
- cmeacham98 3y ago3 months is ~60 work days assuming a 5 day work week.
- World177 3y agoI think you are correct. It seems like all of the other prices align with the weekly rate as 5 days. It also makes the daily rate seem more reasonable, at a yearly rate of $240,000. In a better interpretation of this, I could have maybe also assumed that this is just a fun way of stating something like "hiring to work on doubling users costs this much, but there isn't actually a guarantee that the userbase will be doubled."
- deliriumchn 3y agoPage says 1000 though. Anyways this is crazy, who he thinks he is lol
- matsemann 3y agoThat's a varied set of stacks they're comfortable taking clients for.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- benoliver999 3y agoHowdy, that's almost me! AMA! I've spent 10 years as the lone dev at a small medical facility, writing database software and dealing with lab hardware etc. I guess I've touched 100% of the codebase because I wrote it all, but I always wonder if my skillset is so niche that I'll always be at small companies. Here's the deal though, work isn't everything and I'm at a job that recognises that.
- overthemoon 3y agoYou wrote it all? By yourself? That sounds ideal to me. The horrible part of this to me is that he inherited a mess and left without having done much to it, evidently being unable to do so for whatever reason. The headline says he "mastered" it, so clearly other forces were at work than his skill. That's the depressing part to me, pulling my hair out to try and understand someone else's antediluvian code base which was built under duress. I think devs imagine someone else out there is having a better time at their computer than they are. I definitely do.
- bagacrap 3y agoIt also said he only wrote hundreds of lines in 35 years. So maybe one line a month. Either he's a wizard that spins gold from straw or "mastered" is being used ironically. Given that he could be replaced by two juniors I'll assume the latter.
- benoliver999 3y agoAah so Arthur is the guy after me!
- ornornor 3y agoI envy you. How did you get I to this gig?
- mgranados 3y agoFinally something funny for once! thank you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smslyng 3y agoI just learned ASP Classic 3.0.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kypro 3y agoI swear this guy exists at every company I've ever worked. He's the guy you go to when you find some legacy code which you have no idea how the hell it works and end up getting a 2 hour history lesson into a decade of company politics and failed replatforming projects. They're hard not to love.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y ago"... And the AIX machines were a real beast. We had 20 of those things, and each had its own 20 amp circuit. Had a tendency for the grounding to the steel case to fail. If you wanted to upgrade it you'd first need to grab a pair of thick leather gloves...."
- foobarian 3y agoI for one do not mind that part of computing getting abstracted away by the cloud, whatever its other failings. :-)
- bayindirh 3y agoWorking on the hardware directly is more than half of the fun.
- foobarian 3y agoAn old IBM tech told me that hard drives failed when power cycling equipment could be temporarily resuscitated by placing the drive on the floor, twisting it hard by hand, then as quickly as possible connecting it back into the machine and powering on. Apparently getting the platters to spin helped them get around a worn out motor that couldn't make the initial spin-up.
- bayindirh 3y agoI would believe them. I have heard a similar story. A data center had to go through a planned power cycle event. All systems were working when they shut down, but ~40% of the disks failed to spin up due to worn down motors. That's a lot of disks.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoDon't live to work, work to live. I bet Arthur partied his ass off back in the day, stumbled into work without sleep, napped during retros and refinement. He might be the least useful dev but he's a king at Burning Man. Now with his flush 401k, he can finally retire to make little wooden figurines to sell at the farmers market, where he really just wants to regale people with stories of the biggest fish he ever caught, or his dream of opening up a ramen food cart if his in-laws will go in on it with him. Arthur's lived a life - just not at work.
- saiya-jin 3y agoYes that would be great and I do hope for mr A the reality is some variant of this. More often than not though, its not so rosy. Arthur would be overweight, riddled with medical issues, solitary guy with unhealthy attachment to XYZ (anime, gaming etc). But if he had kid(s) and raised them well, well as a parent too I do have tons of respect for him for that alone, rest are details when looking back.
- dxuh 3y agoHard to do if most of your life is work. I find it very hard to find space for an actual life after subtracting a full-time job, exercise, personal hygiene, nutrition, etc. from my waking hours. It's essentially ~2h a day + the weekend, which often also consists of getting stuff done you didn't manage during the week. I hate the thought of my life starting in retirement. Especially if I might be 67 by then, which is the legal retirement age, where I live.
- surprisetalk 3y agohttps://taylor.town/10-minutes https://taylor.town/10-minutes
- jjice 3y ago> Especially if I might be 67 by then, which is the legal retirement age, where I live. When you say "legal retirement age", what do you mean? Is this to receive some sort of retirement benefit like Social Security in the US? Or is it something else?
- naillo 3y agoLife sucks and then you die, I don't need constant reminders of it from the internet though.
- birracerveza 3y agoYou gotta do what you gotta do.
- lifeinthevoid 3y agoI don't get these threads, it's impossible for everyone to do a job that they love and that is meaningful ... it's the ultimate luxury. Try to find an alternative way to give meaning to your life. (I have not yet succeeded in doing that by the way ...)
- systems_glitch 3y agoIt's just their minds screaming "oh no that's me in six months!"
- weinzierl 3y agoEveryone can build something new and shiny on the green field. If it doesn't work out you can always find someone or something to blame, because what you set out build was an awesome, highly innovative[1] endeavor anyway. Moving on to something else new and shiny after a while is not only ok, it is expected. Sticking to something, through good and bad times, on the other hand, that's not something many people can do, and while it is by no means sufficient in most cases it seems to be necessary for sustainable success. Examples: Guido van Rossum[2], Linus Torvalds, Daniel Stenberg [1] You wouldn't even have to put the "high risk" nature of it in the fine print, because it's readily understood. [2] I could not find the source but I remember him saying in an interview when asked about Pythons's breakthrough, that it never had one but that it constantly and steadily grew.
- athrowaway3z 3y agoYou're examples have very little to do with an average org's IT projects. Not in scope, definition of 'success', or definition of 'finished'. If you're company is building a programming language or operating system you need to make sure that is what you love doing.
- weinzierl 3y agoMy point is that grit is undervalued. It exists within and outside organizations but if I'd tell you my examples from inside you wouldn't know them. Also perseverance is not the same as being stubborn and pivoting is not giving up.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThis is me. 30 years grinding it out on a very small esoteric system. Hard to explain to people "no, really, my skills translate". Paid well enough, but can't move, locked in. But, the small esoteric system is being replaced, so I'm running out of runway and might not make it to retirement.
- nonrepeating 3y agoThis article may and should be the trigger for thousands of life-affirming resignations.
- poisonborz 3y agoI think that was the point, but see all the sympathising comments here. Being full-on driven by your day job is only one way of having a good professional life, and I wouldn't say it's the best or the most common by far. The way how software development is democratised and slowly becomes the next blue collar job, the engineering hero ethos will fade.
- prepend 3y agoThis is like the programmer equivalent of WH Auden’s poem, The Unknown Citizen [0]. When I first read this poem I thought it was sad and about a person who wasted their life on mundane, average things. But now I think it’s a positive for a person who lived an average life on the outside but likely had a rich internal life that they didn’t share with the world and that we shouldn’t expect people to have metrics that we can externally measurable as to whether they were great or not. I think it’s fantastic they this man’s passion is Soylent cat food hybrids for human consumption. He worked all those years and finally broke free for his passion. [0] https://poets.org/poem/unknown-citizen https://poets.org/poem/unknown-citizen
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAlso : Sisyphus. The concept of life as meaningless, to be happy with the drudgery, or repetition, instead to be happy with the 'journey', to be in each moment. Very common throughout literature/history. I'd like to think we are somehow different, that modern man with technology is reaching some new level, to find some purpose. But now, not so sure, it's still just day-in-day-out, then you die. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisyphus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisyphus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Sisyphus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Myth_of_Sisyphus
- sh4rks 3y agoI'd argue that modern technology takes us out of the moment more than anything.
- bagacrap 3y agoThat sounds like a well above average life. No problems and a functional member of society in every respect? Good relationships? Five children?! It seems obvious this guy was in fact happy, despite the last lines of the poem, or else he would have acted out at work, become an alcoholic, divorced, or whatever. That or a supreme stoic.
- tumetab1 3y agosome old verses that rhythm with the current zeitgeist > Our researchers into Public Opinion are content > That he held the proper opinions for the time of year; > When there was peace, he was for peace: when there was war, he went.
- 2-718-281-828 3y agostarts promising but ends unnecessarily snarky and condescending. why dumpster diving? and those guys cannot be replaced by any number of junior devs - that is exactly the problem with them retiring. they know the legacy stuff nobody wants to touch but everything depends on. so, from that angle this writing reflects very poorly on the author and his work experience. having said that - the title could fit just about any lawyer. law is the crappiest codebase that you have to spend a lifetime learning. especially the german tax law - but it guarantees a very comfortable income. also in defense of people like that man i'd even argue that mastering a legacy codebase is mentally and motivationally not that different form mastering a game like chess.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoMaybe dumpster diving is extreme, to drive home a point. But, there are a lot of old people that are hungry, and work as Wal-Mart greeters. If you didn't save/plan well enough, and 30 years of cool software development ends as being a Wal-Mart greeter, that can seem equivalent to dumpster diving.
- 2-718-281-828 3y agoguys from that generation (with its past financial opportunities and real estate prices) and of a character required to even work like that - humbly and diligently maintaining a complex legacy code base, very rarely fall victim to financial issues when they retire. those men (and women) are usually very zen and collected. loneliness and suffering from a feeling like no longer being needed is probably the biggest (mental) threat. but the aforementioned personality traits will provide for developing new opportunities like voluntary work or maintaining some open source repo. don't worry about them ... worry about yourself (if you are young and in IT) and especially about those poor junior devs put in place for this guy.
- bagacrap 3y agoIf you are the kind of person who thinks the future of IT looks bleak right now, imagine what it must have looked like in 2002 when NASDAQ was in a three year death spiral and down 80%, which is an experience this guy lived... and then in 2009 when the stock market was down at levels previously seen in 1997... If anything, the lesson should be not to worry about yourself because the only way this man could be forced to resort to dumpster diving is if he was given too much to worry about his retirement accounts.
- quickthrower2 3y agoIt is satire but I think people like this are heros. Not doing the flashy fancy stuff but keeping the world ticking over nicely.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI don't think it is satire. Or reality has become the satire. This seemed entirely real to me.
- quickthrower2 3y agoPoe's law strikes again!
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoHadn't heard of Poe's law. I'd say the best sarcasm does contain a lot of truth. Think it used to be that the best sarcasm did leave you wondering a little if it was meant to be sarcasm. Interesting idea. It can be that everyone has different knowledge base, so everyone has individual interpretations. For the post in question. I've seen it in real life, so it didn't seem 'extreme' enough to be obviously 'sarcasm'. Though, I could tell it was sarcasm, it was perhaps the good type of sarcasm in that it contained a lot of truth.
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoThere are talented people everywhere, the probability of somehow being ground breaking and world impactful is ridiculously small. Anyone pegging their self-worth on that goal is setting themselves up for a lot of mental health struggles. My levels of ambition and relentlessness absolutely shifted after having kids, I used to be absolutely furious about being the best. Now I am very much "fuck you pay me" and my priority is having as much free time as possible for family and friends. I for one would be fine with Mr. Westbrook's career although thankfully I haven't had as crappy colleagues as him throughout my career. There are people of all types who will want different things, no point in judging. As the great thinker Alicia Keys once said: 'you do you boo!'
- taude 3y agoAgree with you. I don't understand the point of this article other than some sort of tongue and cheek snobbery. Hope it maybe made the OP feel better about themselves.
- surprisetalk 3y agoAuthor here! For context, I recently wrote a tongue-in-cheek guide on how to coast in large companies. [0] https://taylor.town/corporate-camouflage https://taylor.town/corporate-camouflage That got me thinking about what happens when people, especially engineers, coast too much, or fail to plan out their careers. I know plenty of smart people that are enchanted by comfort, then chain themselves to companies that take advantage of them. If you've developed transferrable skills, this parable probably isn't for you :) I personally think it's okay to be ambitious, and it's also okay to chill.
- sramsay 3y agoHonestly, I just thought it was hilarious -- a sort of parodic counterpoint to the Story of Mel.
- HenryBemis 3y ago
- rqtwteye 3y agoThere will be a lot of these people maintaining the currently fashionable microservice/multiple languages/use as many AWS services as possible/scalable systems in a few years.
- baz00 3y agoThis is my retirement plan.
- TheRealDunkirk 3y agoI have a friend who just started a job working with AS400's, learning RPG. He's not much of a programmer, but I am, and this made me think, hmm... maybe I should learn it too. There's going to be some serious job security in that field, once AI is writing all the CRUD web apps from scratch in Nodejs.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoI 100% believe crud will be automated
- ornornor 3y agoI’ve tried to look for the COBOL and other legacy languages jobs where there is a shortage for. I came short. And the few I found didn’t pay like there was any kind of shortage. There was a lot of willing offshore sweatshops offering their services though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oaiey 3y agoIn our company we do medical devices. It is a hard SDLC business. Once a colleague of us left and shifted over to another (much bigger) medical device company. I met him some years later and he told me, retroperspectively, our company is a high-performing, super agile group. His new employer needs a year for a two line code change without really changing but only adding something. And that despite him pushing and pushing. To be fair: to modify blood dialysis systems is no joke business.
- KWxIUElW8Xt0tD9 3y agoAT&T 5ESS switch had a similar atmosphere back in the day (no idea about now). The rule was no function deletion so you delete the code in the function instead. I remember reading about a very talented guy from Bell Labs being on the 5ESS team and writing some ridiculously small number of lines of code in one year due to all the rules in place to prevent major telephone system issues.
- mindentropy 3y agoThere is a lot of analysis that goes with it. I worked in both medical devices and also transportation.(Rolling stock signalling systems). It is definitely not a joke when you are moving such huge mass of metal with people in it.
- yreg 3y agomirror: https://archive.is/12eOI https://archive.is/12eOI
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoRetiring at 58 would be awesome. Some people live to work and others work to live. I like what I do but I also have hobbies which I really enjoy. I get that the post is satire but at some point in your career there are diminishing returns on learning new things. If you are somewhat specialized say in backend systems involving scaling, message queues, clustering, etc. it probably isn't a good time investment to learn whatever is new in the frontend world. And by learn I mean to become proficient professionally and get a job doing it, not just a "hello world" learning. Doing "hello world" learning on a technology is like learning how the yolk and rudders work in an airplane, you're not going to be flying professionally anytime soon.
- bluGill 3y agoLearning new things is how you keep your mind working. People who sit around doing nothing in retirement tend do die sooner than those who keep busy. What you keep busy with doesn't matter, just do something challenging.
- bagacrap 3y agoAgreed. I feel the need to learn new things just to keep my learning muscle strong. Sometimes I actually need to learn a new thing, and if I haven't done it in a while, it's scarier.
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoStrong agree. There is enough to learn in one's professional career that keeping up to date on tangential technologies may not be worth it until you have a need. Having hobbies where learning and applying things is not just fun but can also scratch that itch to keep your mind fresh.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheRealDunkirk 3y agoThat THAT is the internet as she is spoke.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- systems_glitch 3y agoSpend time digging deep into something, or spend time skimming the surface of a bunch of things, I guess.
- nirav72 3y agoThe headline reads as if it was from The Onion.
- dxxvi 3y agoIf he already mastered the crappy codebase, then "two junior devs and a Keurig to replace him" or even a senior dev might not be able to replace him in a short amount of time.
- heyblackduck 3y agoThere is something admirable about someone who commits to maintaining a codebase, no matter how crappy it is. We don't see this often in tech and often being a person who is more reliable and stable is more desirable than two junior devs and a Keurig machine. Speaking from my first hand experience when reverse engineering a poorly documented product for a small company these people were the real heroes. Thanks to all the "Arthurs" that keep the world spinning.
- pelasaco 3y agoI thought it was the conclusion for every single developer in the world when they retire, no?
- hnrodey 3y agoCtrl+F the comments for `dailywtf` ... no results. Sad.
- Namari 3y agoEinstein once said "Once you stop learning, you start dying". I feel like in IT it's the case for most what people are thinking. In my case I have been switching tech because I felt I wasn't learning anything new or simply because it's was dying. I feel like these guys like him are probably too confortable in their confort zone or too lazy to learn anything new (the less you do the less you've got motivation + you can't teach old dog new tricks).
- dlisboa 3y agoTo be fair you can learn outside your job. I wouldn't call him lazy just because he stuck with a company for a long time. Most jobs will only require a small percentage of a programmers' knowledge, so people supply their urges with outside endeavors. Hence reading books, doing Open Source, side projects, etc. Lots of significant inventions in computer science began as a side project only the creator cared for initially and had to borrow his own time to do it.
- ants_everywhere 3y agoThis is quality satire :) it also works somewhat for larger codebases, even non-crappy ones. > Arthur had a knack for working hard without learning transferrable skills. He will be dearly missed When I was at Google during the pandemic, I noticed more and more people saying they needed to learn open source tooling so they can have skills that transfer to the outside world. That company is full of brilliant engineers who have mastered (part of) a great code base but have to start at the beginning with popular non-Google tools.
- James54 3y ago[dead]
- zafka 3y agoThis is quite funny in a painful way. I identify on a few different vectors. I started my "professional" career in telecom. There I really did become an expert on some very small percentage of code. It was exhilarating to do patches in 286 assembler for an obscure language (CHILL). Now many years later, I work in NPD at one of the small divisions of a giant Medical device company. I wrote 90% of the legacy code. It is embedded and I have not needed to update any of it in 10 years. With changing management styles, the new push is to buy new products from smaller companies, and just to the required paperwork for regulatory approval.
- janmarsal 3y agoWould be a dream to retire at 58
- smashedtoatoms 3y agoThis checks out.
- projectileboy 3y agoI got bad news for some of the folks in this thread: just about _everyone_ can be replaced with two junior devs and a Keurig.
- coliveira 3y agoProgramming is a job, it is not a mission to save the universe. A few programmers become famous for a combination of talents and luck, but nobody can control either of these things. In the end, 99.99% of programmers do the same things that this guy is making fun of.
- neoyagami 3y agoI feel personally attacked
- rattray 3y agoThis was a funny title but not a nice post. Ick.
- agentultra 3y agoMan spends entire career convincing himself the reason he keeps job hopping is because everyone else is writing crappy code. Karl Hackerman shows up to each meeting complaining. He seems sour that he hasn’t been given the go ahead to rewrite the system in Rust. He knows a lot about bleeding edge frameworks and best practices and always seems annoyed that he can’t use them at work. He thinks it’s because everyone else has settled in to becoming wage slaves instead of striving to be the best programmers they can be. Everyone puts up with him because they know he’ll quit in six months anyway. Karl is 47 now. Hasn’t held a job for more than a couple of years. Has mostly been freelancing lately and trying to sell books on tech and frameworks nobody cares about anymore.
- JackMorgan 3y agoI did not expect to wake up and be attacked like this. Not even a warning. Savage. Good thing I'm not in my 40s yet, still time to recover from my wayward path.
- appplication 3y agoYeah this is ruthless. On the other hand, I feel ok with my present course because the intermittent chance to use new shit is the only thing that keeps me interested anymore. That and the exorbitant pay, I guess.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hfhfhfhfhfhfhf 3y agoFYI, Karl has been reincarnated as MyCurrentIntern
- surprisetalk 3y agoAuthor here! I love this so much. I've totally been this guy :) Learning how not to be an insufferable doucheb*g was a surprisingly hard challenge for me I've been writing a longer fiction piece about overzealous know-it-all engineers in the style of Confederacy of Dunces. Probably won't be done for a while, 'cause there's a lot more of my soul in it haha
- submeta 3y agoI've done something like this for a couple of years, albeit not full-time. The project was written in Symfony 1.x and got stuck there, as Symfony moved on to higher versions and wasn't backwards compatible with 1.x. The codebase consisted of thousands of lines of poorly documented and commented code, intermingled with custom JS modules that nobody understood. When management wanted to implement changes, it would take days to comprehend the potential effects on different parts before I could initiate any modifications. The project would have required a complete rewrite, but the management was staunchly against it. This has been the most frustrating and unsatisfying tech work I've ever undertaken, alongside past tasks of migrating MS Access apps. I sometimes find myself pondering why I didn't cease working on it, especially given the compensation wasn't particularly impressive. It's crucial to recognize and act when you sense that a project is no longer benefiting you, and simply move on.
- danesparza 3y agoI love that your response to this article is to try to prove you're that guy. We get it. You're that guy. :-)
- greymalik 3y agoAlternately, Man Earns Enough to Comfortably Support His Family and Retire Years Early
- gerbilly 3y agoWasn't this a bit of a self deprecating summary of his own career? Many of the comments seem to assume that it was written by his colleagues and that the description of his career is condescending or snarky. Personally, I find it really funny, and that it probably describes many of us, despite the fact that we think we are way too cool to ever be like the character described in the piece. Most of today's new tech will become tomorrow's 'legacy'. Imagine how your awsum multi lambda hairball deployment will look in 30 years. (If it's even around in three decades.)
- dsm4ck 3y ago"Most of today's new tech will become tomorrow's 'legacy'" Only the successful ones
- vsareto 3y agoThis is how it should be on salary. If you're good enough then you can get time back from the job and work less per week. It starts to look crazy good when you are doing like 5-10 hours per week because you're so familiar with a code base and have a decent understanding of the business. If they aren't going to give meaningful raises for doing maintenance, then time is the only thing you can get more of. If companies want people to work harder, they'll have to give more compensation that scales better with performance.
- jmull 3y agoI mean, a lot of people work on things that, despite being billed as a Great New Thing, are throwaway projects that will disappear without a trace in a few years (once management changes, the market turns, or the founders/VCs cash out, or the SEC comes knocking, etc.) At least a 35yo codebase probably actually does something more useful than sell a narrative whose purpose is to enrich a few random jackasses.
- kriro 3y agoNothing against Arthur Westbook and his career choice [;)] but I think the proper way of turning mastery of a crappy codebase into a career is joining a bug bounty program. Some are big enough (think Yahoo's scope) that you can earn a living mastering them and finding bugs. But won't those bugs dry up eventually you ask...well thankfully new features, API endpoints, (sub)domains etc. are intruduced constantly.
- commandersaki 3y agoI'm unfamiliar with bug bounties but how often do you get to peruse codebases? I thought most of the time you're working in a blackbox setting with just an outside interface that you peek through?
- alecfreudenberg 3y agoOften times great ambition requires moral concessions that are untenable even in the face of the end result. Politics is a helpful lens. Either you compromise and muddy the purity of the result, or you take the high risk path of being uncompromising and greatly reduce the odds of achieving any result at all. When facing this, many individuals optimize for lower-risk self-fulfillment over great ambition.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoRecently on a call my client introduced me to his $BigCorp whale client as "my IT guy" and his client said "oh yeah I have 12 of those here on my team". I'm cool with that. I keep doing work valuable enough to pay well for, and the rest is semantics.
- commandlinefan 3y agoAnd for this, I spent six years of college...
- blq10 3y ago"Two junior devs and a keurig" - that will totally wreck the system by refactoring it to "modern patterns" without bothering to understand what it actually did. But it's OK, they're younger and therefore better. Thus, the cycle begins anew.
- misja111 3y agoI found this on his site https://taylor.town/-10x https://taylor.town/-10x, I like it even better
- sonorous_sub 3y agoBit of a threadbare post
- retrocryptid 3y agoHarsh.
- angarg12 3y agoIf this is a jab to supposedly mediocre programmers, it fails to be funny. I have a friend, let's call him AP, who is a programmer in a local java shop. He's been working in the same place for 12 years since he graduated. He kind of fits the description on this article, but he is one of the happiest people I know. He gets paid above average wage, and his work is easy and not very demanding. He knows the codebase inside out, and gets along well with his colleagues. Outside work he goes out cycling or for a beer with his friends or travels the world with his wife. Different people have different priorities, and some are not obsessed with excelling at work.
- surprisetalk 3y agoAuthor here! I agree with you :) here's some more context [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36985316 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36985316
- pphysch 3y agoIt's making a jab at "minimum effort" employees who manage to coast for years or decades. Note the "hundreds of lines of code". There are many fantastic engineers who work on otherwise boring, rotten codebases. No shame in that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 3y agoGuaranteed to be C++
- jandrese 3y agoThe idea that two interns are going to be able to take over for this guy was the funniest part of the article. Maintaining a large old legacy code base is a hard job because there is so much to learn before you can even start. Codebases like that live that long are often used in important places where a YOLO approach of “test it in production” can cost tremendous amounts of money or even lives. The article makes fun of the guy for only committing hundreds of lines of code, but they worked perfectly the first time and every time.
- fullshark 3y agoThis type of cynicism/snark used to be a lot more funny before it dominated all internet discussion and interaction. Maybe the people who spend all their time online are the bitter/angry ones and it just has taken over all discussion? In any case it's just a job, and anyone harboring illusions otherwise will learn the truth soon enough.
- hfhfhfhfhfhfhf 3y agoI left my previous job because it was obvious this was my future (or would be my future if the company could stay in business, which was unlikely). My mandate was to fix all the problems without changing any of the founder's work that caused the problems. My new job is terrific.
- GrumpyNl 3y agoThat's me, got fired 4 years before retirement. Made them rich. Young guys came in, it all had to be rebuild in microservices. Last press release, they have tripled their staff, financial turnover went down, the new system is working but is lacking the functionality of the old systems. All the pitfalls i warned them fore and got me fired, became reality.
- hackernoteng 3y agoI am this guy
- hindsightbias 3y agoIt will be interesting to see how the average HN'er is doing when they're at 58.
- duffyjp 3y agoI'm that guy at work. I solved the problem by completely rewriting our huge and aged out internal application. The plot twist is that I also completely wrote the original crappy codebase.
- aqf0 3y agoFor decades, Arthur raised flags to upper management about the high complexity of the codebase, and begged them to hire a couple of junior devs. Only then could he delegate enough work for him to take on the refactoring project. The software's uptime and stability - he reminded them - was critical to the survival rates of children stricken with spinal meningitis. But management churn and budgetary chaos at the org resulted in the project fluctuating between "investment" and "divestment" states for decades, leaving him to fend for himself. He told his manager that the data access layer - consisting of 5k LOC batch scripts calling Microsoft Access - needed to be brought up to speed. Maybe they'd consider PostgreSQL this year. Containerization, he protested, isn't going to fix the problems inherent to the system's labyrinthian integrations with countless software vendors and proprietary components. He also reminded them that it's 2023 and Windows containers still don't support RDP. They still needed a replacement for "Bob". Bob left the org back in 2008. Under duress, and impossibly tight sprint deadlines, Bob was asked to make surgical modifications to the WingdingsAbstractFactory.java class - to be deployed directly into production no-later-than-end-of-sprint. Bob complained that there were no conceivable DR plans, or QA engineers assigned to the project. After a ten hour deployment - and a highly blameful postmortem - Bob exited on record-short-notice. Arthur was forced into an early retirement under the recommendation of his physician. It was said that his stomach issues were brought on by the stress at work. Only Soylent and tinned meat were within tolerable levels of discomfort. Arthur will be remembered by his loved ones for his patience, steadfastness, and creativity.
- mikewarot 3y agoFrom 1997 to 2012 I was the sole IT guy at a trade show company. We had a database called Smiley.... I wrote 3 different replacements for it, they were always afraid to convert over, even though I was fully prepared to run them both in parallel. I've been this guy, sorta. I've been afraid to even try personal projects since then... that job broke me.
- Vvvk 3y agoIs there anyone who is accessing this page via a command-line text-based browser?
- runeks 3y agoHonest question: how many HN'ers have worked on a codebase they considered non-crappy? Or, put a better way, for all the codebases you have worked with, how many were crappy and how many were not? I'm increasingly convinced that there does not exist a large codebase in actual use that isn't crappy in some way or another.