21 ms·
NASA mistakenly severs communication to Voyager 2
- samhuk 3y agoTL;DR: 1. Voyager 2 has been pointing 2 degrees off from Earth 2. Been that way for a while and nobody noticed because very old computers. 3. Meaning that the probe has gone dark (ingress and egress comms are not possible) 4. However, both Voyager probes have software that tells them to routinely calibrate themselves every few months 5. Meaning that it should point at Earth in the next few months (most likely).
- Qem 3y agoCan we also regain contact through the yearly movement of Earth on its orbit? Like the planet just walking into the new beam position?
- OnACoffeeBreak 3y agoWouldn't work if the 2 degrees is not in the orbital plane of Earth. Right?
- ummonk 3y agoThe Earth is only about 150 million km (1 AU) from the sun, so nope the Earth can't move far enough to make up for a 2 degree miss from 32 billion km away, even if it's in the right direction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- samhuk 3y agoNo. 2 degrees error at such a large distance equals huge distance error. Also, empty space is huge and matter-things like Earth and the Sun are tiny compared to it.
- somenameforme 3y agoI think we can answer this exactly. To visualize this think about the plane shared by the satellite and Earth. We'll imagine this as a 2D unit circle. In this graph Earth is at (1,0) and the satellite is at (0,0). So we end up with a scale where the radius is the same as the distance from the Earth to the satellite. But instead of pointing at (1,0), the satellite is now pointing at (cos(2), sin(2)) or (0.9994, 0.0349). The distance from Earth (1,0) to the new location (0.9994, 0.0349) is about 0.0349. We need to scale that back up to "real" units so multiplying it by 15 billion miles. And we get about 520 million miles. The earth is about 93 million miles from the Sun, so its max positional shift (under extremely improbable absolutely perfect conditions) would be ~180 million miles. So there's no way we could regain contact with just yearly movement, even before we account for the fact that it's getting further and further away. 2 degrees intuitively sounds small, but on an astronomical scale it's huge and this sounds like a pretty major flub by NASA.
- Qem 3y agoGreat explanation. Thank you!
- jannyfer 3y agoI don’t think the article or the news release from NASA actually says #2. They could have known for a week but took a week to release the news.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iszomer 3y ago> 5. Meaning that it should point at Earth in the next few months (most likely). Provided that V2 still has enough propellent to make this adjustment.
- padjo 3y agoHope the re-calibration works. Would be a sad way to lose contact after all these years.
- midoridensha 3y agoTrue, but they only had enough power on-board for it to last until 2025 anyway, so it's already on its last legs.
- albert_e 3y agoThe power needs are mainly for radio communications back home? Or that includes navigation / propulsion / course corrections / reorientation also? (There is not enough "solar power" that can be harvested at that distance I presume) If we spread out the communications to be less frequent and say bring it down to essentially a heartbeat signal once a month ..would it prolong the service life. Mostly for emotional reasons at that point :)
- whaleofatw2022 3y agoThe 'battery' in this case is an RTG, so the amount of power drops whether it is used or not.
- phire 3y agoIt might be possible to use the remaining electrical heaters as some kind of crude thermal battery (assuming they have any heaters still running, they already shut down the heaters for most of the scientific experiments). Simply turn the heaters off before transmitting and keep any transmission periods short enough that the electronics don't get too cold. JPL probably have a bunch of tricks like this ready for when power levels drop. That 2025 estimate is 10 years old and I'd be surprised if it's final.
- jffry 3y agoVoyager 2 is approximately 20 billion km from the Sun Earth is approximately 150 million km from the Sun Sunlight intensity falls off with the square of distance (ignoring any additional small losses from space dust / scattering from gases etc), so twice the distance = a quarter the solar flux. At the Earth it's ~1361 watts per square meter. Voyager 2 is approximately 133 times further from the Sun than Earth is, which means it receives optimistically 1361 / (133^2) = 0.07694 watts per square meter. I found a JPL article [1] that says the RTG onboard Voyager produces 40% less power than it did at launch, and the Wikipedia article [2] says it produced 470W at launch, which means it makes ~280W now. Wikipedia [3] suggests the solar panels available at the time of Voyager's launch in the late 1970s could convert ~10% of incoming solar power to electricity. Modern panels bring that up to 30% but the designers of Voyager did not have access to time travel. So at present distance Voyager would need approximately 36000 square meters of solar panel to produce the same amount of power. [1] https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/a-new-plan-for-keeping-nasas-oldest-explorers-going https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/a-new-plan-for-keeping-nasas-o... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_2#Power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_2#Power [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_panels_on_spacecraft#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_panels_on_spacecraft#His...
- noughtnaut 3y ago> "the antenna on the spacecraft had been pointing two degrees away from the Earth [...] left it without the ability to receive commands or transmit data [...] NASA reckons the situation is temporary [...]" I wonder how it's temporary. Does the probe have a re-targeting function? The answer is in the original statement: > "Voyager 2 is programmed to reset its orientation multiple times each year to keep its antenna pointing at Earth; the next reset will occur on Oct. 15, which should enable communication to resume. The mission team expects Voyager 2 to remain on its planned trajectory during the quiet period."
- williamdclt 3y agoI wonder why the reorientation is so infrequent? Is it a long process or a strain on hardware that you wouldn't want it to happen every day or even every month?
- Dalewyn 3y agoReorienting requires using a reaction wheel or propellent to move yourself. Propellent is finite, so you want to use it as rarely as possible. A reaction wheel is by itself infinite (assuming it doesn't break), but eventually it saturates and you need to desaturate it, which basically means spinning the wheel the other way while spending propellent to maintain position. All of this is to say, reorientation is an expensive process especially if refueling isn't an option.
- curiousObject 3y ago>reorientation is an expensive process That’s true, but a failsafe automatic reorientation mode after two weeks with no communication from Earth might be a useful feature
- jjk166 3y agoOn the timescale of decades, does a 2 week vs a 10 week waiting period make much of a difference?
- Out_of_Characte 3y agoDoes anyone know how Voyager calibrates their antennas?
- NeoTar 3y agoNot in any detail, but as a hand-waving explanation it keeps tracks of the Sun and the star Canopus, so by two fixed reference points you can have a known orientation.
- potamic 3y agoI can't even begin to imagine how you would go about building an automated star tracker in the 60s.
- jjk166 3y agoThe Sun is the brightest star and Canopus is the third brightest star (Sirius presumably is not in an appropriate position to be detected), so you don't really need a proper star tracker, you just need a brightness sensor.
- whartung 3y agoBut the ICBMs did. They also had star trackers to help them navigate, and they needed more robust maps than just the Sun and Canopus, since they had to be able to fly 24hrs a day, 365 days a year. Different problem space.
- makomk 3y agoThere's a bunch of publicly available documentation about how the Canopus star tracker on the Voyager probes works out there, last I looked, and it's quite an interesting design by modern standards. It uses an image dissector tube, which is weird and long obsolete vacuum tube tech that can measure the light in an electronically-controlled section of an image, to scan a slice of the sky around the roll axis of the spacecraft looking for an area in the right intensity range (which is fairly easy for Canopus since it's generally the brightest thing in that part of the spacecraft's view so long as the roll axis is correctly aimed at the Sun), and there's a bunch of hardwired digital electronics to control it and use that to adjust the spacecraft orientation.
- waihtis 3y agoWould be very interested in any writeups on how NASA anticipates all the thousands of scenarios that can go wrong up-front and prepares for them. Sounds like there might be some useful thoughts there on how to write more resilient software
- Zealotux 3y agoI thought just that about the JWST; I remember an interview with one of the lead engineers saying he wasn't stressed about the launch because he knew they had done everything possible to ensure success and everything was in fate's hands now. For Voyager 2, 45 years of uptime in the hazardous space environment, billions of miles away, is simply incredible.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoI think it isn't about anticipating every possible scenario as much as designing a platform with enough redundancy and ability to measure, turn off/on, adjust, reprogram, etc. pretty much everything. Part of this is just necessary for ability to learn for future missions. If something fails in space, you want to be able to figure out what happened so that you don't make the same mistake the next time. And you don't have a chance to send a second mission just to "replicate" the problem. So you do things like build your test equipment into the probe so you can measure stuff while in operation. Or maybe make sure you have a switch for everything so that you can turn something on or off to see if the problem persists.
- alex_suzuki 3y agoIt’s so inspiring when you see how these things are just built to last. quote: “In the past, engineers have compared keeping the probes operational to keeping an old car running. The tech is severely outdated, yet it keeps ticking over – a trend often seen in the spacecraft of past decades.” At some point us humans will probably simply have forgotten how to maintain them.
- bayindirh 3y agoYou should read "The Machine Stops" by E. M. Forster. Also, "Pump Six" from "Pump Six and Other Stories" will also do fantastic job of diving into this "forgetting how to maintain them" reality.
- tass 3y agoRingworld
- skywal_l 3y agoFire upon the deep, where space ships runs on a future version of unix and only one guy knows what the unix epoch means.
- larperdoodle 3y agoI don't recall that in that book. Maybe you're thinking of A Deepness in the Sky? I haven't read that one yet.
- twoodfin 3y agoI think the reference is in Fire: It’s an offhand line about an ancient timekeeping system which the modern engineers mistakenly believe is calibrated to humanity’s first steps onto another celestial body.
- 3y ago
- eimrine 3y ago> The probe is currently around 32 billion kilometers from Earth, and gets 15km further away every second. I beg anybody to rephrase it understandingly with using some units similar to football fields. Is it possible to launch a little cheap rocket with a transmitter just to correct Voyager's position?
- zichy 3y agoNot sure if you are trolling.
- qingcharles 3y agoI'm think GP means we could launch a rocket to the place where Voyager thinks Earth is supposed to be (where its antenna is pointing towards) and fire off a signal to tell it to move.
- awestroke 3y agoHow to tell if somebody is an American
- chank 3y ago-
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beeforpork 3y agoIt will probably readjust. And power supply is expected to be dead ca. 2025 anyway. OK, OK, if the Klingons find it now, then it'd be a shame not to get some measurements. (The cameras, however, are off since decades.)
- foobarbecue 3y agoLet's just hope it doesn't make it to the machine planet.
- teddyh 3y agoThat’s Voyager 6, not Voyager 2.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoThis seems like a multi-reference to me: (1) Dune, (2) Turrican, others?
- WorldMaker 3y agoMost directly in the context of Star Trek (Klingons mentioned above), it will be a reference to Star Trek: The Motion Picture. (Which is about the hypothetical Voyager 6 probe's interesting history.)
- jabart 3y agoThey made some updates and expect it to go through 2026 https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/news/details.php?article_id=129 https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/news/details.php?article_id=129
- tivert 3y ago>> It will probably readjust. And power supply is expected to be dead ca. 2025 anyway. > Are you both misunderstanding that? Your link says: > Launched in 1977, the Voyager 2 spacecraft is more than 12 billion miles (20 billion kilometers) from Earth, using five science instruments to study interstellar space. To help keep those instruments operating despite a diminishing power supply, the aging spacecraft has begun using a small reservoir of backup power set aside as part of an onboard safety mechanism. The move will enable the mission to postpone shutting down a science instrument until 2026, rather than this year. > Switching off a science instrument will not end the mission. After shutting off the one instrument in 2026, the probe will continue to operate four science instruments until the declining power supply requires another to be turned off. If Voyager 2 remains healthy, the engineering team anticipates the mission could potentially continue for years to come. Going from 5 science instruments to 4 in 2026 is hardly "dead."
- moron4hire 3y agoAt 32 billion kilometers distance, 2° off target means the communication beam is missing Earth by about 1.1 billion kilometers. EDIT: This is about 7.4AU. If Jupiter and Saturn were in a line from Earth right now, this distance from Earth would be about the halfway point between the two gas giants. So no, we also won't be launching a rocket to go catch the beam just to re-establish comms.
- hutzlibu 3y agoIn short, it was remote bricked, by giving it commands to rotate a bit. After successfully executing those commands - no further commands could be received, as now the antennas are not facing earth anymore. But luckily it automatically readjust itself to earth automatically every half year exactly for these events. So on 15.10 we will know, if it is really lost. In either case, the end of its mission is near anyway, because the nuclear batteries are near its end. edit: Nasa has a blog post on this https://blogs.nasa.gov/sunspot/2023/07/28/mission-update-voyager-2-communications-pause/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/sunspot/2023/07/28/mission-update-voy...
- swarnie 3y agoAmazing that someone thought up a solution to a hypothetical problem 46 years ago, then fired it 30 billion km away
- behnamoh 3y agoSometimes we don’t give enough credit to previous generations.
- detourdog 3y agoI only give credit to previous generations. Firm believer that we only understand in retrospect.
- bumby 3y agoAerospace has a very high quality standard compared to other industries. Lots of formal processes capture what would otherwise be informal design decisions elsewhere. In this case, they probably have reams of pages detailing a failure mode effects analysis (FMEA). One mode is “oops, we sent the wrong command” and the document would define the specific design mitigation(s) for that outcome until it reaches an accepted risk threshold.
- aetherspawn 3y agoFMEDA probably. And in recent times, fault tree analysis seems to be better for complex systems.
- inopinatus 3y agoThat official statement seems incredibly light on detail, almost as if written for children, or worse, members of congress. I wonder, is there a technical publication elsewhere that has more substantial coverage for interested people?
- b112 3y ago[flagged]
- michaelt 3y agoWhat more is there to say? It seems like a pretty clear explanation to me.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- inopinatus 3y agoWell, congressman, I might be curious what the actual commands were, why they were issued, how it led to the unfavourable outcome, how they detected and measured the degree of misalignment, what a corrected command sequence might’ve been, and then cross-referenced to a hopefully existing article on how the spacecraft will eventually re-align itself, and perhaps some further reading on other commands that are routinely or not-so-routinely issued and how they are received, decoded, and executed on board the spacecraft. Basic stuff, y’know; after all, this isn’t rocket science. If there is such an archive, or some approximation thereof, it would surely be fascinating to pore over it.
- 5d41402abc4b 3y agoAre communications with voyager encrypted? Is it possible for someone to setup a big antenna in their backyard and take over the probe?
- yonatan8070 3y agoI don't think there's any encryption going on there, just because it's so old But I also don't think most back yards can fit an antenna that big... search "NASA deep space network" on google images to get a scale of the antennas that are used to talk to voyager
- arbuge 3y agoIt doesn't matter how big your antenna is if Voyager's antenna is no longer facing earth, as seems to have been accidentally induced here.
- bell-cot 3y agoUntrue, strictly speaking. So long as the combination of your transmitter's power and your antenna's directionality (aka 'gain') provide enough extra dB's of signal strength (to compensate for the dB's "lost" on Voyager's end, due to the off-axis antenna) it'll work fine. OTOH, dB's are effectively a log scale, and NASA's "not good enough now" transmitter & antenna cost quite a few $million. What's your budget? (Yeah - if the Arecibo radio telescope was still on operation, it might well have been capable of doing this.)
- guraf 3y agoI suspect it is true, strictly speaking. In optimal orientation, Voyager's signal peaks at -160dBm when received on the 70m dishes. Now it's shooting 2 degrees off which means the signal misses earth by hundreds of millions of kilometres. What kind of magical high gain antenna do you envision that could still receive it, assuming money isn't a problem?
- bell-cot 3y ago
- albert_e 3y ago> it is programmed to recalibrate its position a few times a year. October 15 is the next scheduled reset. Curious to know how this recalibration actually works. Any explainer that anyone can point to would be appreciated. Thanks!
- ZiiS 3y agoNot a rocket scientist; but I have tuned in a TV. I imagine it is simply programed to turn a few degrees then turn back to wherever it saw the strongest signal from earth.
- albert_e 3y agoMakes sense. So I presume it uses its thrusters to impart a very small spin on one axis, and then on an orthogonal axis. A mechanism records the signal strength as it sweeps all angles, and once the optimum direction is determined, the thrusters are fired in just the right way to counteract the spin and bring the craft to a halt at the optimum orientation. Given this was programmed decades ago - the electromechanical system that does all this jugglery and runs reliably for so long would be a great case study for systems design. Even the programming that ensures that this routine is triggered without fail every few months must also have gone through intense reliability testing.
- ilyt 3y agodoesn't even need thrusters if it has reaction wheels that are still operational
- j16sdiz 3y agoBut....How does it know it's the earth? It is billions km away.., is the earth that noisy compare to solar wind and cosmic rays?
- giantrobot 3y agoVoyager has a star sensor that is meant to align with the Sun and Canopus (IIRC). If both are properly aligned it means it's pointed in the right direction. At its current distance the beam width is wide enough to cover all of Earth's orbit. So really it just needs to point at the Sun anymore. The carrier signal from Earth is also powerful on a particular frequency and polarization. While there's definitely noise at the receiver it's looking for a very specific signal so can filter out everything it's not expecting. We do the same thing on the Earth side, filtering out noise to recover the very weak signal received from Voyager.
- kyberias 3y agoI find it hilarious that they're refering to the speed of the spacecraft.
- mark-r 3y ago"Voyager 2's trajectory is expected to remain unchanged" - I should hope so! There can't be any fuel left on board that would budge it, even if they wanted to.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sho_hn 3y agoDave from EEVBlog just visited a facility communicating with Voyager 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=586Zn1ct-QA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=586Zn1ct-QA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUvzgZt1Vug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUvzgZt1Vug There's a part 3 with a tour of the complex.
- silverscania2 3y agoIt's a re-upload from 2017, just in case anyone else thinks they are going crazy like me.
- whartung 3y agoI was fortunate to have the opportunity to visit Goldstone, up in the California desert on Fort Irwin. It's not open to the public very often. I got to visit most everything there, including the 70m telescope. It was just a cool space tech nerd day of tours, presentations, and sunshine. The dichotomy of the 70m antenna is interesting is that it broadcasts 450 kilowatts of power out into space, but has to receive and decode, "as small as 1 billionth of 1 billionth of 1 watt" signals from the space craft. One of the reasons its on a military base is to restrict the airspace above it so that they don't accidentally cook some aircraft that happens to overfly the antenna when it's transmitting. It's truly astonishing they're able to pull that off, frankly.
- kylehotchkiss 3y ago450 kilowatts? Is this the most powerful transmitter on earth? Where does it source the electricity for this?
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoOfficial blog post from a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36909736 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36909736
- KenArrari 3y agoaliens
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elif 3y agoI can't believe it doesn't attempt to auto-calibrate after x days of no signal in some kind of exponential ramp up
- chriswalz 3y agoIt does. It’s supposed to realign itself twice a year
- danbruc 3y agoJust two degrees off? Can they not wiggle the antenna a bit around [1] just as in the old days when you had to hold the TV antenna a bit above the TV to see anything but noise? [1] Joking aside, they obviously can not, Voyager is missing the Earth by 4.5 AE. How wide is the beam, how precisely do they have to aim the antenna to maintain communication?
- drmpeg 3y agoThe beam width is 0.65° at x-band. If it's off pointed by 0.5°, the signal will be 7 dB lower (which in this case, is a lot).
- idlewords 3y agoThis is why you always have a backup Voyager
- notyourwork 3y agoEvery time I read about space engineering, I'm amazed by how contingencies have contingencies. It's so much careful planning and rigor compared to my world. I can always re-compile, re-deploy and regularly realize that my job is not life or death.
- swozey 3y agoI like when people mention that they're "computer doctors." I have some stressful migrations that require a lot of planning and could cost a significant amount money if botched but I can't imagine the additional stress of someones life being at my fingertips.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoIt's tricky. Many moons ago when I was hands-on and stressed about migrations & config, my team lead at the time would say exactly the same thing - his wife is a doctor and her job is way more stressful - People die. And I bought into it as a relief for a while. But... I work on a payroll system. My team does impact people. Mistakes can have important negative consequences to real live individuals - from stress invoked in trying to call help centre and fix their paycheques, to disconnected utilities if they don't get paid correctly/timely, to other downstream consequences. Any number of other IT systems have significant consequences - e.g. airline ticket systems, airbnb bookings, etc. I feel the "nobody died" is a double-edged sword: it can help relieve people of the daily sense of artificial stress, urgency and grind that management may impose; but also builds a false dichotomy / unreasonably binary threshold on when our job matters / impacts ...
- mcguire 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_data_breaches https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_data_breaches
- whatshisface 3y agoI think one of the greatest contributions launch window aerospace neurosurgeons make to society is the way they cause nobody else to ever feel stress in any way.
- starkparker 3y agoJon Bois is probably livid and/or excited
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoI too know what this reference is
- Nifty3929 3y agoI used to do remote work in firewalls quite often, and after locking myself out once or twice, I came up with a new habit: before making any changes I would schedule a reboot for 5min out which would revert any changes. That way if I locked myself out I could just wait for the reboot and get back in.
- paulddraper 3y agoKinda like changing display settings in Windows. Changes will revert in 15 seconds....
- dang 3y agoAnd then if it worked for those 5 min before the reboot, you'd redeploy the change 'for real', without a reboot?
- 2snakes 3y agoYeah, there are different kinds of memory in firewalls. Like a running-config and a startup-config. If you just change the running-config and don't commit to the startup-config, when the reboot takes place it'll pull the config from the (non-modified) startup-config instead, reverting changes.
- Nifty3929 3y agocopy run start!
- Nifty3929 3y agoMy typical workflow was: - Schedule the reboot - do my changes - Make sure everything was working properly - Go get lunch - Notice a bunch of pages and alarms about a firewall going offline - Rush back to my office - Login to the firewall - Schedule the reboot - Re apply the changes - Test it again - CANCEL THE FING REBOOT THIS TIME - Eat my now cold lunch
- booi 3y ago
- dang 3y agoStub for arguing about what "bricked" means. These comments were originally replies to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36941191 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36941191, but we moved them because the offtopic discussion was choking the thread. Normally I'd have marked the entire subthread offtopic, but hutzlibu's comment deserves to be at the top, even if it does use the word "bricked" wrong.
- burnte 3y ago> In short, it was remote bricked, by giving it commands to rotate a bit. > But luckily it automatically readjust itself to earth automatically every half year exactly for these events. I remember when bricking something meant it was totally unrecoverable. Now it means "temporarily not working but will automatically heal".
- hutzlibu 3y agoA device that is acting as a brick cannot receive commands and is not useful at all. That is the current status of voyager 2. "Unbricking" will hopefully work automatically, because there is no other option. But that can also fail and there is no way to know, or influence it. I use bricking in the definition of mobile phone tinkerers .. there are many results for unbricking btw, but I just checked and with the first result it seems that Apple now uses unbricking for activating a new device. Because technically before, it is also just a brick - but here I would agree, that it is not a appropriate term, but rather should be for somehow broken devices.
- JdeBP 3y agoWhat this is telling us is that attempting to condense to "it was bricked" has actually introduced ambiguity, and that "brick" doesn't really explain a technical situation. The JPL doco (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36941433 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36941433 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36942321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36942321) calls it "Command Loss".
- 3y ago
- qingcharles 3y agoDoes NASA have any sort of emulator to test commands against before they run them on live? I mean, we're all human, I've made some really shitty fatal errors hacking untested code onto production servers.
- mcguire 3y agoIt's hard to find anything about older programs, but they currently put a lot of work into simulators. https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/ivv_grubb_nasa_ivv_software_emulator_technology_portfolio_090114.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/ivv_grubb_nasa_ivv_... On the other hand, at one time there was a physical "proof test model" of the Voyagers. https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/images/pia21734-voyager-test-model-configuration https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/images/pia21734-voyager-test-model-...
- travisgriggs 3y ago"severs" huh. A bit clickbaity maybe? I think I'd gone with "OOPS, NASA gave V2 the wrong number to phone home. Engineers of old have last laugh and reassure 'it's OK, V2 will sort it out'"
- bradgessler 3y agoThis will make for the ultimate "that time I brought down production" story for the engineers involved in this oversight.
- Aardwolf 3y agoWhy aren't there more space ships like voyager 2, going outside the solar system but still providing some signal? It's got to be possible to launch some in space now and have them go faster than voyager 2, so that the outside can be explored faster?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Why aren't there more space ships like voyager 2, going outside the solar system but still providing some signal? Because that part is a side benefit not worth launching for, and the main motivation (grand tour of the outer planets) for the Voyagers relied on a once-in-175-years alignment of the planets. But maybe we’ll have nice probes ready to launch in the 2150s next time the alignment happens.
- utopcell 3y agoSo, until Oct/15, some poor planet with intelligent life in our galaxy will be thinking that an alien civilization is trying to make contact.
- dcdc123 3y ago> which is currently almost 24 billion clicks away from Earth It makes no sense to use that term in this article not to mention it is usually spelled klick.
- Jamesmoorez 3y ago[dead]
- noelrock 3y agoOne thing that’s bothering me - the story text says it’s 32 bn kilometres from earth but looking it up it appears to be about 19 bn kilometres. Which is it?
- StillBored 3y agoWasn't there some conversation a few years back about how anyone with a big enough antenna could take the probe over because it doesn't really have any security measures and all the command/etc documentation is now public? In a way this sounds like a way to keep that from happening.
- js2 3y ago> The probe is currently around 32 billion kilometers from Earth No it isn't. It's 20 billion kilometers. It's closer than Voyager 1. https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/ https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/
- linsomniac 3y agoI'm surprised at this point that they don't have a "voyager simulator" akin to Kerbal Space Program, that they can try changes like this on before sending it to the real spacecraft...
- r2on3nge 3y agoThis sounds like a tragic incidence!
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]