13 ms·
Why do so few people major in computer science? (2017)
- f0ld 3y agoWAT?
- AmIDev 3y agoI believe CS degrees shouldn't focus too much on industry skills. Sure it is good to have some engineering focused courses that are likely to be useful in long term(C programming, design patterns), but most courses should be theory heavy. If you take any specific domain of CS, there are only going to be few hundred good professors on that topic at most in entire world. Them spending their time on teaching undergrads industry skills is wasteful IMO. Profs should focus on creating next generation of researchers. Bootcamps/Corps/Youtubers should focus on next generation of developers.
- GianFabien 3y agoPersons who are interested in software development probably got started in their teens whilst still in school. So faced with taking on a huge student debt and delaying their career or start earning a good income straightaway makes the latter far more appealing. Besides, CS is seen to be a theory heavy course rather than practical software engineering.
- morkalork 3y agoHaving done all the theory and math, the pain is real when trying to explain a cool concept or why a piece of tech did something the way they did to a junior-ish dude who did some other degree or a boot-camp who doesn't care and doesn't need to care either. Worse is doing grad studies in CS, unless you are willing to move to one of a few specific locales for your area of specialization, there is no point at all in continuing.
- AdieuToLogic 3y ago> Having done all the theory and math, the pain is real when trying to explain a cool concept or why a piece of tech did something the way they did to a junior-ish dude who did some other degree or a boot-camp who doesn't care and doesn't need to care either. This is a really underappreciated perspective. Few things are more disheartening than wanting to share understanding of a neat CS concept and have it fall on deaf ears. Given enough experience and depth of knowledge, there comes a time where the gulf becomes insurmountable.
- bruce343434 3y agoI have a good dynamic with my dad for this, I share theoretical CS stuff which he never studied with him, and he shares OOP design pattern stuff which always went a bit over my head with me.
- MiddleEndian 3y agoAnecdotally, pretty much everyone in my CS degree program also started programming in their teens.
- re-thc 3y ago> Besides, CS is seen to be a theory heavy course rather than practical software engineering. The theory is important. You can often tell the difference between someone that's been through it and someone that hasn't. It's not just a copy and paste job without implications.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoI would slightly modify the statement: Someone who has been through it can often tell the difference between someone who has been through it and some one who has not. To the outside it is often a case of: "But this works too!"
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoIME people who learned the theory can adapt to new situations much better. Those that just learned a single set of skills like, say, Python web backends become lost quickly if they need to do something different, like optimise some multithreaded C++ service. And often in our jobs these types of things do come up, you can’t always get a specialist to cover every single type of work. Of course this could be mostly correlation, perhaps the type of people that seek degrees also enjoy learning more broadly in general.
- JSavageOne 3y ago> like optimise some multithreaded C++ service. And often in our jobs these types of things do come up What are the jobs where this kind of thing comes up? I've never had to do anything with multithreading or C++, and I'd estimate that the jobs where that stuff comes up is a tiny minority. I think it'd be cool to encounter these kinds of problems, but it just seems more like a niche thing to me these days.
- TillE 3y agoGame development, and really anything that needs fast native code.
- woodruffw 3y ago(2017)
- zach 3y agoVery much so — this was looking at graduation, so even its most recent data from 2015 represented students who applied to college no later than spring of 2011. Since then, computer science has certainly been growing: “The number of students nationwide seeking four-year degrees in computer and information sciences and related fields shot up 34 percent from 2017 to 2022, to about 573,000, according to the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/05/19/college-majors-computer-science-humanities/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/05/19/college-... Even at that rate, colleges cannot meet demand and CS majors are difficult to be admitted to even for the most competitive college applicants: https://www.geekwire.com/2022/it-is-not-acceptable-uw-computer-science-program-cant-keep-up-with-record-demand-from-undergrads/ https://www.geekwire.com/2022/it-is-not-acceptable-uw-comput... The major is so sought-after that as of last year, UIUC has closed computer science for transfer from other majors: https://cs.illinois.edu/admissions/undergraduate/transfer-students https://cs.illinois.edu/admissions/undergraduate/transfer-st...
- jcjr81 3y agoI believe Univ of Michigan has done the same as UIUC. At least that’s what they told my son when he applied
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoEven when I was applying in 2004 several colleges had restricted transfers. So I guess it was similar as a result of the dot com boom.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Blackthorn 3y agoWhen this was written, my school had quadrupled its graduating class size from when I went there...
- BMc2020 3y ago1. Computer science is hard. 2. You don’t need a CS degree to be a developer. 3. People aren’t so market-driven when they’re considering majors. 4. Immigrants are taking all the jobs. 5. Anti-women culture. 6. Reactionary faculty. 7. Anti-nerd culture. 8. Skill mismatch and lack of training from startups. 9. Quality gradient. 10. Psychological burn from the dotcom bubble. 11. No pipeline issues anymore.
- rationalfaith 3y ago[dead]
- jrflowers 3y agoCan you elaborate on anti-nerd culture?
- throwawaystress 3y agoThey just copied in the bullets from the article to save us a click :)
- jrflowers 3y agoI was hoping somebody would elaborate, the article pretty much says anti-nerd culture doesn’t exist lol
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cvoss 3y agoNote: This isn't the TLDR of the article. These are proposed answers to the titular question that the author finds unsatisfactory for one reason or another.
- lexarflash8g 3y agoYea this -- he is trying to disprove those pop culture claims like "immigrants h1b1s taking jobs" or "tech is unfriendly place for women"
- RajT88 3y agoMy first CS class saw half drop the class by the end. By the end of my second CS course it was similar. Probably 75% of people taking CS courses stopped taking them by the end of my freshman year. A smaller contingent dropped out in the later years, but still by the time I was at the 400 level, class sizes were quite small. Other sciences were like this (but not Biology or Psychology for some reason).
- scotty79 3y agoWhen I studied 50% dropped out after first year. Most after the first semester. It was solely because the course was very math heavy.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoAbout half had dropped when we got to pointers in Turbo Pascal.
- matwood 3y agoHah! Feel like we were in the same program. The pointer abstraction is the first big mental leap in CS.
- toldyouso2022 3y agoI wish we had cheap certifications for computer science topics. I don't want a whole degree, but I wouldn't mind improving in certain areas of cs if I get recognized for it
- mullingitover 3y agoPeople go into CS to get jobs in software engineering. This is misguided. CS is really a mathematics major, if you become a good engineer in the process of getting a CS degree it's purely accidental on the part of the CS department. It's like getting an astrophysics degree in hopes of getting a job in the telescope industry. Universities should really emphasize software engineering as a major rather than CS. CS is great, don't get me wrong, you'll come out of that program with a galaxy brain for problem solving. In addition, there's definitely overlap between the two areas. However, it's often totally irrelevant to the real work in the software engineering industry.
- PhasmaFelis 3y ago> People go into CS to get jobs in software engineering. This is misguided. I told my academic advisor I wanted to be a computer programmer, and she put me in CompSci. No one ever told me that that was the wrong discipline. My school didn't even have a Software Engineering program. I had graduated and was trying to find work before I fully realized that my degree had barely taught me anything useful and I was going to have to learn most of it myself. It's the system that's misguided.
- musicale 3y agoSome CS departments emerged from electrical engineering departments (and some such as MIT and Berkeley are still EECS) while others (Purdue, Stanford) emerged from math departments (and some such as Santa Clara are still departments of Mathematics and Computer Science.) Purdue seems to have had founded one of the first CS departments (1962) and it was originally part of the Mathematical Sciences division along with Statistics. In most departments, I that expect systems courses will generally be more aligned with engineering (and industry practice) while theory courses will generally be more aligned with mathematics. Given the origins of CS, it is disappointing that software practice typically seems to lack both engineering rigor (vs. circuits with predictable behavior) and mathematical rigor (vs. theory with provable results.) The math and engineering parts of CS seem to apply primarily to tiny components rather than the large, complex software systems that people actually build.
- re-thc 3y ago
- elif 3y agoI loved my CS degree. It let me deepen my understanding of programming in quite a few ways, introduced me to circuit drawing/embedded devices, AI, robotics, all kind of peripheral areas I would have never had an opportunity to engage with deeply. That said, there are about 70,000 reasons I can think of why someone would want to do something else for those 4-5 years. The first job I got out of college also wanted me to quit college and work full-time about 2 years before.. I knew full well I was getting the degree as a hobby.
- H8crilA 3y agoYeah exactly, Master's level degree is almost entirely unnecessary. I've seen lots people drop out past Bachelor's once they figured out that the degree is just a hobby, and a little bit of a status symbol. They wanted to earn instead. This was around 2014.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 3y agoYep. Got my bachelor's and stopped. Still don't see a reason to go further. Bachelor's is enough for green card and to be hired. Rest is interview skill. If I do go further.. it would be for fun. I did enjoy uni. But maybe not so much for the classes.
- robotresearcher 3y agoThere’s very little competent teaching of CS in high school, and very few teachers with CS degrees. Most graduating high school students don’t really know what CS is, so choosing a CS major feels risky.
- symlinkk 3y agoThere’s not teaching of law or medicine in high school either, should we start cramming that down students throats to depress wages in those fields too? Of course not, lawyers and doctors are smart enough to see through that facade. High schoolers should be taught how to cook, how to exercise, how to think for themselves, and basic history and math. Anything above that like Calculus is a huge waste of time if they don’t know how to fry a fucking egg.
- juujian 3y agoYup. I had a CS teacher who taught python for one term. At the time, what I took from the experience was that Computer Science is not for me. Now looking back I realize said teacher just wasn't a competent programmer (and Python 2 sucked).
- zelphirkalt 3y agoGuess I was very fortunate to have a lecturer/prof who worked on Python core, but said in the lectures, that he was not supposed to teach us one programming language, but programming in general. I have often wondered where I would be, if he had not introduced us to things like Prolog, Racket and others, next to of course Python and C.
- duped 3y agoHigh schoolers shouldn't really be taking CS. I get that that's a hot take for HN, but they need more time learning the basics of critical thinking, communication, and emotional intelligence before learning what the hell time and memory complexity are. I think we should be teaching kids how to code but the science side of it can stay put in higher learning. We're terrible at teaching young adults it, let alone children.
- benjaminwootton 3y agoI started in Computer Science. It was incredibly dry, and though I wasn’t looking for a training course, I did want to come out with hands on skills such as software engineering and SQL. I ended up flipping to something called Advanced Computing which struck the balance between theory and practice. As it happens, I subsequently veered into AI and “Deep Learning” before it had the name. That also seemed useless and very theoretical until about a year ago, at which point it became the most important skill in the industry out of nowhere. I might need to dust off the books again!
- jamestimmins 3y agoThe dryness of intro courses is underrated. I took CS101 in college (in C++) and it was painfully slow and boring and I could learn just as quickly from the book. Contrast with my bro who studied ME where they had a toy robot competition in the first month.
- benjaminwootton 3y agoIndeed. A sprinkle of some of the applied stuff in year 1, (e.g. Software Engineering, AI, Computer Vision) and it might have held my interest. Nearly 20 years later I think that would have been for the best.
- TillE 3y agoOur CS101 course (or maybe 102?) involved building a clone of the board game Carcassonne in Java, which was pretty fun.
- jamestimmins 3y agoIn mine we built a minimal deposit system that let people add/withdraw money. Yours sounds more fun for sure. Where was this?
- sky_rw 3y agoIn 2007 the president of the University ACM chapter told me not to toy around with languages outside the CS curriculum, and that Ruby was a waste of time. I'm grateful everyday that I ignored his advice.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoWe learned Ruby in CS. It was in a "sampling of languages" class, which also included Rust (for which I'm very grateful)! Ruby was a cute curiosity, but Rust is a paradigm shift. :p
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoIn the one I took we did Prolog which has not exactly proven useful. I don’t think I ever used anything in that class, unlike most of the rest of the CS classes I took.
- bagels 3y agoMine was: Python, Prolog, Scheme Lisp. I thought it was great to get exposed to other types of languages that were possible.
- RadixDLT 3y agoit's the same reason few people are interested in math, most people don't (or want to) think too hard
- mikewarot 3y agoWhen I enrolled at Rose-Hulman, in 1981, I wanted to be a professional programmer, but I KNEW there was no money to be made it it, as everything was shareware/public domain. I majored in EE instead. I ended up dropping out (it proved too expensive), and became a programmer anyway, without a degree. It seems to me that a formal CS education is wasted on those who don't have the urge to code in their spare time, and only get into the field for the money. Also, despite the annoying claims of many that they are "engineers", most people in the field are programmers with title inflation. Actual engineering requires far more attention to detail, and just plain drudgery than we programmers can put up with. You can't automate your job away if you're an actual State Licensed Professional Engineer... lives are on the line. [Edit/Expand] Would you blindly trust a program an engineer whipped up in his spare time to do all the appropriate checks on a design, instead of requiring him to check the math? Of course not. Actual Engineering demands far more rigor than programming. Strong agree with the comments of shrimp_emoji On the other hand, we're free to make build systems, and do whatever we want to make our jobs easier, because lives aren't on the line. [/Edit] So, no actual state license, no actual need to get a CS degree, why spend the money? Now, if you're going to be an actual State Licensed Engineer, a formal 4 year degree is worth the money.
- bosch_mind 3y agoLots of weird opinion in this statement, maybe insecurity from never getting your degree? Software has proven to automate things just as important as “real engineering” in many fields. Hospitals, power grids, entire financial systems.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoAs hard as CS is, I think any type of "engineering" is harder and that actual engineers are a way different breed than software engineers. Software, as a practice, is also the wild west compared to actual engineering disciplines which require licensing and have a much closer relationship to the phrase "regulations are written in blood".
- hnfong 3y ago
- satvikpendem 3y agoLots of people I know started off in CS and got weeded out as the college years went on. I doubt more than 10% of those in the first CS class in freshman year actually graduated in CS by the end. The vast majority switch to other majors. Funnily enough, most engineers I know (mechanical, civil, aerospace, etc) are now coding for a living, sometimes at engineering companies but oftentimes at tech companies.
- meroes 3y ago“people who go to college decide on what to major in significantly based on two factors: earning potential and whether a field is seen as high-status” Ya no wonder I wouldn’t like CS with these peers. You have to be a nerd and supremely interested in status and money apparently. I don’t know many like that. Makes me think of Zuck and Elon. But they are minorities in the grand scheme. Maybe the author is exactly right, right here, why CS falters.
- analog31 3y agoI don't think it's entirely true. Students are told, over and over, to follow their passions. They're inspired by charismatic teachers. They pick up weird ideas about which fields will have good career prospects. Parents who "push" more employable options, are ignored. Having two college-age kids, and knowing many more, all I can figure out is that it's utterly a crap shoot. Also, nobody at the high school level has any idea what CS is. I had a bit of a leg up (in 1982) because my mom had taken a bunch of CS courses, and was teaching programming at a nearby community college. But she thought I'd be better off studying a traditional field. I chose math, and taught myself to program.
- matwood 3y agoIs the passion thing new? I don't remember it when I was in school in the 90s. My only passion was not to be poor anymore.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 3y agoBecause parents are old and don't know what's profitable these days. Don't think my parents even knew there was a lot of money in CS.
- analog31 3y agoI'd say yes and no. For instance I'm a parent, and I'm also involved in hiring tech workers, so I'm aware of what's in demand. I'm not that old. When I started college in 1982, I'd argue that nobody knew. For instance, at that time my parents were also mid-career in STEM. Well, my mom was teaching programming at a community college, and her students were getting jobs after 1 year of her course. Based on where we lived, near Detroit, most of them were getting hired up by the car companies. But I don't believe anybody knew what was going to happen next. My mom thought that programmin was too easy to spend time learning at the college level, and that the market for programmers would soon be flooded. What happened next was the personal computer. I was keenly interested, but at my college, the CS majors used a mainframe computer. Most expected to work for banks, insurance companies, utilities, etc. Non-STEM parents, sure. I'll grant you that. I'm lucky to have been raised by two scientists. But they weren't thinking about money when they talked to me about careers and college majors.
- berkle4455 3y agoBecause it’s not worth the cost and time commitment unless you can’t read a book or follow one of the numerous excellent free online coursewares from better institutions than wherever you’re going.
- mikebonnell 3y agoThis premise destroys the whole argument for me: "I consider this a puzzle because I think that people who go to college decide on what to major in significantly based on two factors: earning potential and whether a field is seen as high-status." Based on my personal experience in the late 2000s, this was not true at all. People majored in CS because they liked solving the logic puzzles CS represents regardless of salary or stays
- Izkata 3y ago> Based on my personal experience in the late 2000s I think this time period is a slight outlier - for our parents the dotcom bust was recent memory and a lot were discouraged from going into the field. Mostly only those who really wanted to, like for the logic puzzles you suggest, went ahead anyway.
- diracs_stache 3y agoApplied Physics but found myself in an entirely unrelated analytics job out the gate, boss used to routinely brag about failing his freshman CS courses and still making manager. Happy to be free of that,point is he was convinced in the early 2000s that CS just meant banging at a keyboard and getting an easy salary. I process large sets of scientific data now and routinely come to terms with my ineptitude as a software engineer.
- julianeon 3y agoI think this article may be outdated. It was published in 2017. By 2019, the NYTimes was publishing articles like this, about the shortage of spaces in classes for people interested in CS: so popular students literally could't sign up. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/24/technology/computer-science-courses-college.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/24/technology/computer-scien... Here's an article from 2023, about a 12x increase (!) in CS enrollments at UC Berkeley from 2011 to 2021. The trend at other unis was also strongly, like double-digit percentage increase yearly, up. https://eighteenthelephant.com/2023/02/12/10-double-the-number-of-computer-science-majors-20-goto-10/ https://eighteenthelephant.com/2023/02/12/10-double-the-numb... I think there was a brief cultural moment where for whatever reason - uncool? nerdy? math anxiety? - CS wasn't where you'd expect it to be, in terms of enrollment. But the culture changed & now it's very popular.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoCS enrollment booms and busts. It was booming just before 2001, and then it was something no one wanted to do for a few years, then it was booming before 2008, and then...again...it fell out of favor for a few years before coming back again. This happened in the 70s, 80s, and 90s as well. It isn't just a culture change, we are simply in a cycle.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoAccording to the article, the peak was between 2004-2005 (I guess all the people who went into CS before the dotcom bubble exploded graduated then). Which means we're due for possibly the biggest cohort of fresh CS grads in about 3 more years. Fun times
- 9659 3y ago"Peak CS" was last year. Not every school has peaked, but many have. It will drop for the next 5 to 10 years. (FAANG hiring freezes will disincentive students...)
- 3y ago
- web3-is-a-scam 3y agoI question the value of my CS degree to be honest. I haven’t used any of the advanced mathematics to the point that I’ve forgotten al of it, and any of the CS topics that I do touch on has been cursory at best. Anything major has al been stuff I learned on the job.
- quirkot 3y agoOutside of the academic track, most work in CS or IT, etc is a craft, a trade skill. Apprenticeship programs are more appropriate and if you squint at advice directed to youths interested in a career in IT, it all sounds like roll-your-own apprenticeship programs. I often catch flack for this view, but I think it's that crafts and trades are considered lower status. Anyone doing the work to keep things running and improving them where they can is doing honest labor.
- TheBigSalad 3y agoIs accounting a craft/trade?
- pwpw 3y agoAfter passing the CPA exam, I had to work under a licensed CPA for a year in order to be issued my license. I felt that most of what I learned that applies to real-world issues was acquired while working during that year. The CPA exam was a mix of practical information and a bit of unnecessary gatekeeping in my opinion. I felt that I had already learned most of that information during my undergrad degree and that my graduate degree was overkill. Having to spend more time studying for the exam after two degrees and then spend a year working under someone was too much in total. I believe that accounting is a craft that can be learned while working under a master. I feel similar about my software engineering career now. My experience with all of the credentials to become a CPA is a big reason why I decided to self-teach computer science rather than pursuing another degree. I recognized that if I studied the fundamentals and then worked underneath someone highly skilled, I would be able to build up my skill set as a developer. So far I think that direction has worked out.
- 9659 3y agoMost of it is. The job is called "bookkeeper"
- Barrin92 3y agoHere in Germany it wouldn't get you flack, there's several vocational tracks for programmers and I've worked with a lot of people who didn't go through academia and they were just as good at writing software, sometimes better than peers simply because they did it for longer professionally. Academic CS programs make sense for people who want to go into research, the sciences, or theory heavy application, but I never understood the inflated college programs across the pond.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago(2017)!!
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSome previous discussion closer to the publish date: 3 years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676331
- letrowekwel 3y agoI think CS major makes lots of sense if you want to go really deep into research of some advanced field inside it. But otherwise I feel like there's more benefit from minoring in it, self-studying the more practical aspects, and majoring somewhere that gives you field-specific knowledge, which in combination with CS & programming skills makes you rare and valuable.
- mdmdmd 3y agoAt my highschool, which was a prestigious boarding school in the UK, I was told that CS is not a "real" subject and I should study Maths instead. This is terrible advice. However, I don't think my experience is unique and have to believe that many university applicants were given (and maybe are still given?!) similar guidance.
- pxeger1 3y agoEven if you're in the mindset that everyone should study a "real" (pure and academic) subject, I'd say CS fits that description fine. It varies by university (probably unlike maths), but there are still plenty of highly theoretical, mathematical, and academic CS courses
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 3y ago> In general, I would push on people to explain not just what the problems are in the industry, but how they deter college students from pursuing a major in CS. I think one of the major reasons is not that many people are interested in it. We like to sit and invert binary trees all day, so we naturally assume everyone else should be just as excited about this wonderful activity; and if they are not, something is wrong, we should worry, and figure out some way to trick them to switch majors. Imagine what programming looks like to a kid: "Oh wow, sitting all day looking at text on a screen? I can't wait to do just that for the rest of my life!". Compare that to being a doctor, a construction worker, nurse, engineer, or even a lawyer. Any of those other professions just look a lot more exciting.
- leoedin 3y ago> engineer Mostly sit all day looking at text on a screen. Diagrams if you're lucky. > lawyer Sits all day looking at text on a screen.
- chongli 3y agolawyer Sits all day looking at text on a screen. This is the reality but not the perception people have. Most people’s exposure to lawyers is from shows like Better Call Saul. What’s funny is that if they paid attention to the show, they’d see real work being done, in the form of endless hours of looking at documents. But those scenes are all done as montages with sexy music, so people don’t realize how boring they can be.
- rdtsc 3y agoAll of those professions (except construction perhaps) would probably involve lots of sitting and staring at screens, but that’s not what kids think they are. The engineer gets to design a thing, then gets to see it built. The lawyer does lots of paperwork but kids think of the trial when they argue their case in front of judges and jurors and win.
- Given_47 3y agoDefinitely not biased here but idk the prospect of building whatever u want and seeing it immediately realized seems pretty exciting. And all u have to do is hack at ur keyboard lol. I’m just struggling to envision construction work being more “exciting”
- financypants 3y agoIs the dropout rate higher among declared CS majors? I only have anecdotal evidence of this.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoI worked at a MAANG that shall go nameless. There weren't many people there with CS degrees and scant few with Masters' or PhD's. The other problem with this particular company is there were too much know-it-all egotism swirling around than rigor, curiosity, or interest in career development or regular tech talks. They didn't really respect the tech or nerd out. Compounding factors: 0. CS is a heavily male major and far fewer men (%) attend college than 25-30 years ago. The only major worse is EE. Finding a woman with EE PhD is like finding a real live US Navy SEAL or a monopole magnet. 1. General university enrollment is down by ~10% since 2010.
- PeterStuer 3y ago"Isn’t it reasonable to expect that people with an aptitude for math, physics, and engineering will also have an aptitude for CS?" You would expect that but it is not the reality. I've seen many students that were excellent at math, but just could not get their head around CS. I'm not sure why this is and having asked some of them, they also couldn't explain it. They just couldn't 'see' it, and found creating the programs very hard. Meanwhile they breezed through math classes that most CS minded students failed or found extremely hard (over here in the old days CS was a specialization of a Math degree before it became a degree in its own, so the CS undergraduate curricullum was very heavy on math)
- JCharante 3y agoI think this is because of too many abstractions. I think CS education should begin with assembly language and automata theory.
- msluyter 3y agoI'd be really curious to see a non-anecdotal exploration of this thesis. (My own anecdata points in the opposite direction.) I ran across this study via random googling: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318649651_Correlation_of_Mathematical_Ability_and_Programming_Ability_of_the_Computer_Science_Students/link/59753e63a6fdcc83488e8b13/download https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318649651_Correlati... Concluding paragraph: "Therefore, the data tabulated is sufficient to allow this study to draw several conclusions and inferences. First, it is reasonable to conclude that Mathematical ability of the students could be the basis of admissions for BSCS program. Second, students who performed well in math can, therefore, performed (sic) well in programming courses. Third, the Mathematical ability could be a predictor of student performance in programming courses." Of course, it'd be nice to see some other studies confirming/disconfirming this conclusion.
- IMSAI8080 3y agoMany years ago now, but I did electronics as I felt I could already program in several languages by university age and that was my perception of what a CS degree would do for me.
- kazinator 3y ago> Yeah, no doubt. But aren’t the departments of math, physics, and engineering also filled with nerds, who can expect just as much social derision on the basis of their choice? They are not filled with obnoxious asshole nerds.
- chongli 3y agoThis is my experience as a math student. The CS students and the engineers tend to be the loudest, most obnoxious bunch, right up there with business majors. People studying math or hard sciences tend to be reclusive nerds, rather than obnoxious ones.
- yesco 3y agoInteresting, my experience (as a CS student) was that other CS students trended towards arrogant but reclusive and Physics students were mean, very arrogant assholes. The other sciences were pretty chilled out though. Math students weren't much different from CS students but tended to be a bit nicer, even if arrogant.
- chongli 3y agoI mean I should say (which I had initially thought needed no explanation) that the majority of CS students I've met are pretty cool. It's just that the vocal minority "gigachad tech bros" were nearly all CS students. I think it's that desire to chase wealth and status which draws them to CS.
- yesco 3y agoI graduated in 2018 so maybe I just ended up missing this crowd. In fact I'm not quite confident I know what "tech bro" actually means despite how commonly I see it tossed around. Are they more of a west coast thing? I would generally stereotype a CS student from my memory as a timid high school graduate with an inflated ego from being "better" at computers than their HS peers, but this feels a bit disaligned with the "tech bros" you describe so I'm curious how things may have changed in 5 years.
- heisenbit 3y agoMSc EE here, self taught in the 8 Bit era. When deciding for EE vs. CS the decision was for something ‚real‘ and not so theoretical. Also I felt the field moved so fast a lot non-math content would outdate quickly. Then only worked with computers doing software all my career. Most of what I learned in universities I forgot. What stuck around and I still leverage today was appreciation for quantities and statistics. Understanding of basic dynamics in linear vs. non-linear systems. A vague feel for frequency and transition responses. An appreciation for materials, their limitations and trade-offs involved in their selection. Not much but very useful and valid forever. When hiring I admit I prefer engineering and physics majors over CS (provided they can code) as former often seem to have more focus on results outside the box while CS are more focuses on the insides. The key to good software with impact are getting the requirements right and that needs negotiations with people outside of the box and making trade-offs.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoIn my country, both EE and CS colleges offer a study of (what is basically) robotics. We have 'informational days' every year, where older highschoolers visit the colleges, and the colleges prepare informational packages, some intro briefs, labs prepare demos, and soon-to-be college stuents are shown around the building and labs. EE robotics had demos of real, industrial robots, 100k+ eur machines, filling glasses from a bottle, making pancakes, sorting stuff etc, while the CS labs had most of the robots based on some lego-like kit where the robots were clearly toys and made just for education. Technically it doesn't matter, it's all math, metrices, rotations, axes, sensors, feedbacks, derivations and integrations of numbers etc. but the difference of "real" vs "toys" was obvious.
- kazinator 3y agoThe article is off the mark. Software development isn't high status field. All of IT is just seen as an army of pee-ons whom you only need when something is wrong, and want them to disappear when the fire is put out. People out there are fed up with slow computers that have become incomprehensibly complicated, and the vast ocean of garbage that is the Web. When people are introduced to programming, there is a mountain of shit there now between them and their first hello, world. The products, tools and the whole scene of computing must be uninspiring and discouraging to newcomers. It's hard to imagine what people outside of our field associate with "computer science". Like, what do they imagine the content of a CS degree to be. Their view is directly influenced by their everyday experience. CS? That's four years of in-depth-studying that churning toilet bowl full of shit that has to do with why I can't connect to my Wi-Fi printer half the time? Or why Facebook feeds garbage into my timeline? Like, ewww ...
- tonyedgecombe 3y ago>It's hard to imagine what people outside of our field associate with "computer science". Money. That's what normal people associate with computer science. They don't understand what it is but they are well aware of the pay scales. >Software development isn't high status field. It wasn't before the money arrived. It is now.
- kazinator 3y agoMoney is connected to status but status isn't simply a linear function of money. These people potentially make decent money: - self-employed bathroom tiler - drug kingpin - pornographer
- maximus-decimus 3y agoyeah... no. Just look at Musk, Zukerberg and Bezos. They're worth over 100 billion and are the rockstars of the industry (probably the most well known people known in industry by normies) and they have zero social status. Normies don't respect techies no matter how much they make. I would argue techie don't even respect techies.
- liampulles 3y agoWhen I studied CS, I saw a number of people enter the degree for the job prospects but then come to realise that they hate programming. This carried on even into my first year or two at work. It is one of those things that people either love or don't.
- seahawks78 3y agoWhy do so few CS majors end up being professional Software Engineers even including the ones that graduate from top schools like MIT/Stanford/Harvard etc.? Even bigger question - among the few CS majors who do end up being Software Engineers why do so few of them remain Software Engineers 10+ year into their careers? Both of these two observations are based on my own anecdotal experiences but have nevertheless puzzled me for long.
- TheBigSalad 3y agoI don't have numbers, but in my experience you are much more likely to work within your degree with a CS degree compared to others.
- mcv 3y agoDo more people study mathematics and physics than computer science? That was certainly not the case at my university in the 1990s. CS was by far the biggest of the STEM fields. Maybe it has lost its magic since then?
- moomin 3y agoThere’s multiple explanations for this, all interlinked: 1) CS is not a vocational qualification like Law. 2) Other qualifications are just as good a route into the jobs described. Arguably maths and statistics is a _better_ route. These qualifications also offer more flexibility. 3) Of the standard routes into tech jobs, CS is the lowest status.
- sarah_eu 3y agoIn the UK, most CS degrees are actually Software Engineering, little maths content. There are probably a handful of universities where CS is treated as a branch of maths (top 3 or 4). Any kind of engineering or physics will leave you in a better place to do engineering design work or scientific programming than a CS degree.
- GnarfGnarf 3y agoBecause it's hard and uncertain. You can spend hours and days on a problem and not be sure of finding an answer. You need to be driven by a passion to overcome the obstacles. When my son was studying Electrical Engineering, he told me a story about how, at the beginning of every semester, a student would ask the professor if there was any programming involved in the course. The class would heave a huge sigh of relief if the answer was no. It's not that students were stupid. Rather, they had a big course load, were pressed for time, and could not afford the bottomless time hole of programming assignments. They knew that the time they invested in lab work or math assignments, would surely result in success. Not so with programming bugs.
- Roark66 3y agoI can only use my own example, but I'm very much of the idea point 2 in the article hit the nail on its head (there is no need for a CS degree to be a developer). For example in my own career. Back in the 1990s we used to have so called "technical high-schools" in my part of the world. These had a final year project, and upon finishing it one got an official "technician" diploma (in addition to the normal high school graduation stuff). I was always interested in electronics/computing etc so it made complete sense for me to go there which I did. I already knew few functional programming languages, but I can credit this school for making me finally understand OO programming concepts. I was quite happy that my official title I could put on my cv was "Electronics Technician specialised in Object Programming in C++" I then got accepted for a CS university course, but before it started I looked for a summer job. Which turned out into a 20+ year long career in IT. During subsequent time I did finish my remote B.Sc,but realistically the only reason why I needed it was not to loose out on future job opportunities that require a CS major. When I graduated I was already 8 years into my career. So is university pointless if you think you already have all the skills for the job? I wouldn't say that. I did learn _stuff_ during my course, but it wasn't programming that I already knew. I learned some design and math mostly. Also thanks to the "CS major" (despite it only being a B.Sc) I successfully applied for jobs that paid double of what I was getting at the time and I could work for much bigger companies (in my experience smaller businesses care less about formal education and more about what you can do, big companies for some senior positions have a prerequisite like "a CS major" and you can be a programming genius, but your application will get shredded if you don't have that CS major).
- anta40 3y agoAt least in Indonesia, computer science degree overall is still popular. Of course, in general the curriculum is pretty math-heavy. Some may say "too theoritical". In the end... most of us work as software developer/engineer, not computer scientist in the academia. We usually built products for consumers (typically the usual database and networking, not fancy stuff like AI, formal method, high performance cryptography bla bla bla). In this context, well yep "You don’t need a CS degree to be a developer".