37 ms·
New York City will charge drivers going downtown
- giantg2 3y agoNobody really wants to drive or park in that sort of congestion. If they would just make public transit better, then there would be less congestion naturally.
- insanitybit 3y agoHow could it be better?
- giantg2 3y agoCheaper, cleaner, on-time, expanded service (times and locations), and better safety (either real or precieved).
- paulgb 3y agoI agree, but it goes both ways -- you need to reduce congestion to improve transit. In the past NYC has even suspended service around the Holland Tunnel because of gridlock[1] [1] https://www.amny.com/news/mta-bus-traffic-holland-tunnel-congestion/ https://www.amny.com/news/mta-bus-traffic-holland-tunnel-con...
- giantg2 3y agoUnless they use other methods or restructure the current infrastructure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ErikAugust 3y agoJavaScript, and ad-free version: https://trimread.org/articles/38893 https://trimread.org/articles/38893
- DirectorKrennic 3y ago[flagged]
- elmerfud 3y agoYes I agree let's fundamentally eliminate the right of free travel from place to place through the public thoroughfares on the conveyance of your choice. Because it's that pesky fundamental concept that we have of freely moving about through cities through county borders through state borders without being stopped and harassed that's actually the fundamental problem of it all. So instead of just pissing around and banning cars from using the roads that their taxes pay for let's just eliminate the entire concept of allowing people to move from place to place without permits and papers. Because that is a great model for a country to have. But we're talking about New York city so you've already granted the port authority wide latitude and restricting your movements and controlling the population.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wussboy 3y agoYour free travel is free only because its true cost is heavily subsidized and carefully hidden. Pay what it costs and you can travel all you want. I’m done with my tax dollars paying for your bad habits. “Free” my ass.
- pierat 3y agoHow are motor vehicles subsidized? ---------------------- Loosely enforced speed limits Arbitrary setting of speed limits Free, off-street parking mandated in building codes Low Housing density induced sprawl and car requirement Exempting pickup trucks and SUVs from emissions laws Lack of vehicle safety laws to protect pedestrians and cyclists Aftermarket products exploit a lack of regulations Mandatory Insurance law: payout requirements A mortgage interest deduction drives suburban sprawl Tax laws favor car ownership Tax formulas favor car commuting over public transit, biking, and employer van pools Pedestrians have limited ability to sue drivers Pedestrians can’t sue car makers for defects Hit and runs are rarely prosecuted Out-of-pocket car expenses don’t cover the cost of roads .... Is this a good start, wussboy?
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- Tinyyy 3y agoI’m a fan of charging market efficient rates for shared goods. The congestion situation in the Holland Tunnel is awful and bleeds out into various streets of Manhattan as well. The cost of sitting in crawling traffic with aggressive drivers cutting around is probably much more than an extra $20.
- DaveExeter 3y agoI agree! Let's get the poors off the roads. The peasant class belongs on public transport, not on taxpayer-funded roads.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoThere's nothing wrong with public transport. The subway is frequently faster than driving anyway.
- bombcar 3y agoDiscrimination is much easier once you take a racial aspect out and just use socioeconomic status instead.
- pierat 3y agoAbsolutely true. In fact this was the 1980s republican plan. Lee Atwater has a great hot mic moment about this. You start out in 1954 by saying, “Ni*er, ni*er, ni*er.” By 1968 you can’t say “ni*er”—that hurts you, backfires. So you say stuff like, uh, forced busing, states’ rights, and all that stuff, and you’re getting so abstract. Now, you’re talking about cutting taxes, and all these things you’re talking about are totally economic things and a byproduct of them is, blacks get hurt worse than whites.… “We want to cut this,” is much more abstract than even the busing thing, uh, and a hell of a lot more abstract than “Ni*er, ni*er.” https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/exclusive-lee-atwaters-infamous-1981-interview-southern-strategy/ https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/exclusive-lee-atwa... --------------- And you also have New York City and the racist/classist bridges. Bridges were built too low for public transit to get out to Long Island. It did a VERY effective job at keeping black people and poor people away from the middle class and higher areas. " In one of the book's most memorable passages, Caro reveals that Moses ordered his engineers to build the bridges low over the parkway to keep buses from the city away from Jones Beach—buses presumably filled with the poor blacks and Puerto Ricans Moses despised. The story was told to Caro by Sidney M. Shapiro, a close Moses associate and former chief engineer and general manager of the Long Island State Park Commission." Who would have thought that building a bridge could be racist and classist? https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-09/robert-moses-and-his-racist-parkway-explained https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-09/robert-mo...
- cj 3y agoSee also: London congestion charge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_congestion_charge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_congestion_charge Singapore Electronic Road Pricing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Road_Pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Road_Pricing Stockholm congestion tax: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_congestion_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_congestion_tax
- jmclnx 3y agoWhen I saw London doing that, I expected cities in the US to start that. I am surprised it took so long. I expected this because of the push of toll roads to make people use EZPASS. Depending upon the City, I think this makes sense. But, in the US, I wonder if this will cause another mass migration of people out to the suburbs ? In the US, people are more addicted to their SUVs than heron addicts are to their drug.
- stefan_ 3y agoMigration to cities is whats causing this. When it was just black people homes you had to bulldoze to build your freeway straight to downtown there was obviously no concern. Now that people living downtown are rich and powerful they are starting to wonder why a huge chunk of prime space is reserved for storage of suburbian commuter metal boxes.
- LeanderK 3y agonot only this, it just decreases quality of life in the downtown. You want less space for cars, less traffic, less noise, less pollution, less parking and more bike lanes, public spaces, space for outside dining on former parking places etc.
- milsorgen 3y agoYou sir, know nothing of heroin and it's work.
- 3y ago
- shrubble 3y agoSo despite the massive ridership of the subway and the fully paid infrastructure and rights of way from 100 years ago, it can't throw off enough cash for modernization of its systems? And instead politicians decide to tax the successful mode of transportation, which is cars. Note that given the density and NY gas taxes, it is a certainty that cars in this area generate surplus cash.
- colejohnson66 3y agoI see ads on the LIRR all the time from NYC saying "we love having a driver's license for everything but driving". The city doesn't hide that it wants to get rid of cars. I don't blame them; cars in the business district are a nightmare for pedestrians and drivers.
- raldi 3y agoDriving is hugely subsidized. This proposal is simply to slightly reduce that subsidy, which will continue to be hefty.
- MAGZine 3y agowut? in manhattan, calling 'cars' the successful more of transportation is very weird. the train is almost always faster, cheaper, and more consistent. The pitfalls are accessibility sucks (most stations are not ADA compliant), and frequency drops off later at night, but if you just plan a little it's not a big deal.
- lom 3y agoI’m sorry what? Cars are the most subsidized thing in America today, you can’t speak of success when they get billions of blank checks handed to them in many different ways. See here: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921800921003943?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092180092... Meanwhile public transit: https://www.apta.com/research-technical-resources/research-reports/economic-impact-of-public-transportation-investment/ https://www.apta.com/research-technical-resources/research-r...
- bequanna 3y ago
- fellowmartian 3y agoWhen I moved to NYC from Kyiv, I was actually surprised by how chill the traffic in New York is. Obviously it can get annoying around bridges and tunnels, but outside those areas it’s pretty easy to get around, and I live on the west side of FiDi. Not against this legislation, I think it’s a good idea, but I personally spent more time in traffic on Long Island, and upper Manhattan. I don’t own a car though, I just rent when necessary.
- bequanna 3y agoI guess I always thought the two challenges in the city were entering/leaving and parking. There doesn’t seem to consistently be TOO much traffic when you’re just trying to get around Manhattan.
- fellowmartian 3y agoYes, that’s been my experience as well.
- ghaff 3y agoIt depends a bit on when and where. But, yeah, all the choke points in and out and then finding/paying for parking are at least among the biggest pain points. I almost never drive to Manhattan from Massachusetts even though it would be faster from my house and that's driven in no small part by the pain of driving into Manhattan from the north.
- dangus 3y agoThis anecdote is basically another way of saying the incentives of urban design align and become self-fulfilling prophecies. Suburban dwellers stuck in the automobile mindset automatically assume that big cities must have the most horrendous traffic. It's seems like a logical conclusion: if traffic in my 50,000 person suburb is horrendous, it must be downright horrific in the big city. But that's not really how it works. In NYC one two track subway tunnel can handle 15 lanes-worth of car occupants. Ironically, making transit, cycling, and walking more convenient than driving and "punishing" the automobiles actually makes traffic and driving more pleasant. I think a lot of suburban folks would be really surprised that a two-lane 25mph road can comfortably handle traffic for neighborhoods that have 10x the density of a typical automobile-designed connected with large arterial roadways. When you design a place to only accommodate vehicles, vehicles are what you get.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoFirst we had segregated roads for the rich, then airports and and terminals, and now it's full on cities. Welcome to dystopia.
- digbybk 3y agoYou’re allowed to come to New York. Just leave your car at home.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoYou're allowed to drive on the $10 a mile toll road, just use your credit card.
- nimbleplum40 3y agoIronically, public transit (which congregation pricing encourages!) is way less segregated, at least in NYC. Subway cars into Manhattan are filled with everyone from low-income workers to high paid investment bankers. Moms with kids, elderly. Immigrants from all kinds of countries speaking many languages.
- coin 3y agoThe part about airports is valid
- dangus 3y agoThere's an important concept to the success of city planning: the alignment of incentives. When transit is faster and cheaper than driving, people don't drive as much. The individualistic personal freedom of the automobile doesn't outweigh those practical aspects of getting around. People generally make pretty logical decisions about what they want to do. I'm definitely in favor of congestion charges in certain areas of NYC. If you're downtown in a car you are taking up some incredibly valuable real estate that could be alternatively dedicated to space for human beings. I think about cities that have implemented taxes for disposable plastic bags. I find it somewhat hilarious how many people consider these policies to be anti-freedom government money-grabs. They make a libertarian's blood boil! Even assuming those folks are correct, it doesn't really matter, because these taxes are incredibly effective. It's eye-opening to see how a nearly insignificant tax (literal pennies per bag) changes the behavior of everyone. In cities with bag taxes, cashiers don't default to throwing your stuff in a bunch of bags, they ask you what you want first. Without the bag tax, some people who don't even have a strong preference to receive bags will end up with them just because the cashier put their items inside automatically. Then, customers start bringing their own reusable bags, use their existing backpacks and totes that they already own, and/or people will just carry a few items without a bag. The end result that the tax was going for has occurred regardless of how mad the individualists get: thousands of single-use disposable items stay out of landfills. This is the same idea for congestion charges: people in NYC who might default to taking an Uber or taxi to get somewhere that's often the same speed or faster to get to on a subway or bus are going to think twice, because there's the psychological knowledge that their behavior is being punished, even if only by a few dollars or cents.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoLibertarians are usually much more in favor of taxes to on externalities rather than outright bans. So I dispute your characterization. I agree with the rest of the post though, I think taxing externalities is the right thing to do. Cars have gotten a gigantic subsidy for far too long. A car is allowed to take up 140 sq ft of land for free in one of the most expensive places on earth.
- 3y ago
- automatoney 3y agoFor those unfamiliar with NYC, street parking is free basically everywhere so the space cars take up is already heavily subsidized.
- dgrin91 3y agoIn the city, especially downtown its basically not free anywhere. It's always metered. Only free at nights and weekends
- automatoney 3y agoMaybe I'm oblivious to them, but I don't think I've seen meters in Soho/Chinatown/LES and I definitely don't remember them in the East Village. Are they more in the Tribeca/Fidi area?
- marcja 3y agoThe classic meters at every spot are largely gone and have been replaced by block-based, app-enabled meters run by ParkNYC [https://www.parknycapp.com/ https://www.parknycapp.com/].
- silverlake 3y ago$4.50 for 1 hr, $12 for 2 hr street parking.
- pests 3y agoYou can continue to buy in one hour increments to save a little too if you remember to keep checking the app.`
- tarikjn 3y agoThis 100%. Free public parking in NYC is the elephant in the room that no one wants to address. Tolls won’t fix that. In some areas of the outer boroughs, 40% of the traffic at any given time are people looking for a spot. The city also still hasn’t figured out utilization of the curb for deliveries and drop offs resulting in normalized double-parking almost everywhere. Curb space need to be efficiently priced and this would fix a host of issues — same goes for outdoor dinning, otherwise its value will be captured by landlords anyways.
- Eumenes 3y agoHopefully this comes to NYC: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12011507/ULEZ-Blade-Runners-want-one-Sadiq-Khans-low-emission-cameras.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12011507/ULEZ-Blade...
- tacticalturtle 3y agoWhy did the federal government have to sign off on this? Assuming the tolls aren’t on federal highways, shouldn’t a state be free to decide where to enact tolls on its own roads?
- CydeWeys 3y agoBecause there are Federal highways in the impacted zone.
- jffry 3y agoAFAICT there are highways affected by this congestion charge. Federal Highway Administration's Value Pricing Pilot Program [1] is the means for state/regional/local governments to institute programs like this. The specific signoff was for an environmental assessment [2] showing that the proposed program complies with relevant environmental laws. [1] https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/congestionpricing/value_pricing/index.htm https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/congestionpricing/value_pricing/ind... [2] https://new.mta.info/project/CBDTP/environmental-assessment https://new.mta.info/project/CBDTP/environmental-assessment
- evanb 3y ago42nd Street between the Midtown and Lincoln tunnels is part of I-495. That's why the last exit on the westbound LIE is #15, Van Dam street. Exits 1-14 are the avenues from the west side of Manhattan (where the numbers reset because 495 crossed a state boundary) to the east side. If you look carefully you will see I-495 signs on some streetlights or traffic lights.
- devb 3y agoIn addition to other reasons given, the big one is interstate commerce.
- tlogan 3y agoSo rich people (who really do not care about few dollars) will be able to drive to downtown just for fun. while poor people who truly need to come to downtown by car will struggle. This is an unfortunate reality of life: wealth equates to more available time.
- krasin 3y ago> So rich people (who really do not care about few dollars) will be able to drive to downtown just for run while poor ones which need it will suffer. The first part is true, the second part not necessarily so, if combined with improved subway. Theoretically, it should be even possible to setup the system, where these taxes on cars to downtown directly fund subway expansion and modernization.
- aqme28 3y agoPublic transit has always been the cheaper option. This just makes the difference a little larger.
- tharne 3y ago> Public transit has always been the cheaper option. Only if don't value your time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw__away7391 3y ago[flagged]
- mgbmtl 3y agoThere are also rich and poor people using the subway. Improving it will improve the situation for everyone. I'm (sincerely) curious though, who are the poor people affected? Parking downtown is crazy expensive, and there are already expensive tolls around Manhattan. There are easy solutions though: charge by the weight/size of the car (the weight should already be on the car registration).
- endisneigh 3y agoCharging should be a function of either car book value as well
- jupp0r 3y agoThe point is to reduce traffic and raise revenue.
- endisneigh 3y agoYes, more reason to adjust to car book value.
- jupp0r 3y agoDo expensive cars create worse traffic?
- endisneigh 3y agoNo but their drivers can pay more thus increasing revenue for public transit, like income all taxes should be progressive :)
- jupp0r 3y agoFrom the article: "Drivers who make less than $50,000 a year or are enrolled in certain government aid programs will get 25% discounts after their first 10 trips every month. Trucks and other vehicles will get 50% discounts during overnight hours."
- endisneigh 3y agoGood start but nothing about luxury vehicles :)
- lkbm 3y ago
- teakweazel 3y ago[dead]
- satvikpendem 3y agoWe should just ban private vehicles in the city as well, bringing back more cyclists, walkers, and generally increasing metro usage.
- RobinL 3y agoBanning is equivalent to an infinite price. Better off setting a very high price, such that the revenue is far higher than the negative externality
- rightbyte 3y agoFor practical reasons I guess you want to be able to move furniture etc. That is about the only time you need a motor transport in dense cities?
- HWR_14 3y agoBanning means you don't need to maintain the infrastructure. You can let people walk all down the street. The pavement doesn't need to withstand thousands of pounds of vehicles. And so on.
- robben1234 3y ago>The pavement doesn't need to withstand thousands of pounds of vehicles. It has. It'd be illegal and extremely dangerous to design a city without properly functioning infrastructure for emergency services, garbage disposal, physically impaired accessibility. Also very inconvenient to not include commercial deliveries and public transit into that list of essential road use scenarios. Most of the vehicles performing these services are heavy. For the most part only private ICE cars are light enough to be a drop in a bucket on the road maintenance. Private EVs, and especially EV SUVs, are likely making an impact on the maintenance schedule though.
- hnboredhn 3y agoI sorta hope they find some streets or avenues to convert to bike lanes. I do sorta feel like having a congestion fee without much added ways to get around for pedestrians leaves the typical person unchanged from this.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoHopefully this money goes to policing the subway too, people have a lot of valid safety concerns leading them to take their car or a cab. In India, you have to pass through a metal detector to ride the metro. It seems like in US, we are trending towards needing to do the same thing.
- brailsafe 3y agoI would assume you're right in NYC, but I feel like this claim is made A LOT to sort of excuse car driving in many cities with different degrees of transit availability and threat risk. I feel like most of the time it's more accurate to say "people fear for their safety" rather than that their concerns are actually valid. Fear can be driven by only a few extreme examples that get a lot of coverage, meanwhile a lot of the time it would be much more likely to be concerned for the likelihood you'll get into a terrible car accident. I'd doubtful that there's some sufficient level of policing that would make fearful people change their mind, because they're not jsut overcoming what they perceive to be extreme risk, but also overcome what they perceive to be very comfortable travel. Much like how to lose weight, you can't just go and do a bicep curl once in a while, you have to totally change your diet and habits for the long-term.
- welshwelsh 3y agoViolent crime might be rare, but unpleasant interactions with strangers are common. Panhandling, for example, can make people feel unsafe. You can never be sure how a person will react if you say no. It's illegal to panhandle on the subway, but still happens all the time.
- brailsafe 3y agoI guess my point was the delta between how unsafe people are and how unsafe they feel. While it's important to build and improve systems like transit in a way that helps people feel comfortable, a whole lot of any given car driving majority that would make an argument against safety are probably some of the same people who'd buy a gun to ward against a hypothetical situation where someone is targeting them with another gun. I never had these fears, the car I already had was just the easier option, until it broke down. If someone were to consult me about my transit experience (albeit in a very different place) I'd tell them "Ya, sometimes there are panhandlers, sometimes there are super drunk people, but tbh I can't remember any specific examples because they're just random background noise from time to time". Meanwhile there are plenty of times I've almost been killed by cars in relatively mundane situations that I can remember specific examples of, including those I almost caused while driving and making a trivial mistake. Should people be more concerned about hypothetical discomfort resulting from someone asking for money, or the very predictable consumption of time, energy, money, and every day life altering risk of one wrong move by anyone around them? The latter doesn't mean I never drive, but for the 2-3 weeks a year I might need one, I just rent it, and then I'm reminded of why I don't want one, but it's nice sometimes.
- superseeplus 3y agoA big proportion of the opposition is coming from New Jersey where former Governor Chris Christie systematically diverted public transit funding to constructing more roads leaving NJ Transit with a maintenance backlog, inadequate infrastructure and unhappy workers who were poached by the MTA. This resulted in a mismatch where the infrastructure is designed to favor driving on one side of the river and a fee designed to discourage driving and encourage public transit on the other side.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoThe opposition from NJ is the double dipping of already high bridge and tunnel tolls along with the new congestion toll. They also have a really meager fixed discount for motorcycles which has diminished in value as the tolls have risen over the years.
- Jolter 3y agoWhy should motorcycles have a discount? How big should it be in your opinion, and why?
- chrisweekly 3y agoNot OP but: mcycles don't contribute as much to congestion given their smaller size and maneuverability. Also they get about 50mpg.
- throw__away7391 3y agoMotorcycles should be charged according to the decibel volume of their engine.
- eyelidlessness 3y agoI’m extraordinarily noise sensitive and I find this appealing for emotional reasons. But I don’t think it’s good policy nonetheless. IME motorcycle drivers are generally among the most respectful about the noise they make, relative to all drivers of all vehicle types. They scoot through and move on. I’d definitely like to charge drivers for their relative noise impact, but I’d start with the recreational sports car drivers and work my way up to industrial vehicle operators who don’t seem to give any fucks, before I even bat an eye at anyone on two wheels.
- kazinator 3y agoCharging drivers for going downtown is effectively a thing in most cities everywhere due to parking. The only drivers not paying to go a downtown just about anywhere are ones just going for a cruise, without stopping to do any business for any length of time. Here is a better idea: ban driving from downtown entirely, except for certain service vehicles.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoPlacards.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoLiving in the part of Manhattan that's covered by this, I'm absolutely looking forward to paying $17 to drive a quarter-mile to the FDR early on a Sunday morning /s. The thing that's interesting is that the average vehicle on the roads in lower Manhattan (in my experience) is not a luxury car. It's a taxi or a ride share or a delivery truck (or other commercial vehicle: contractors etc) or what is essentially an economy or mid-tier private vehicle. EDIT: not a popular observation apparently.
- steveBK123 3y agoMy main concern as NYer is the governments inability to build transit, and not for lack of money. NY will find it relatively easy to institute a new tax on drivers, but will the billions collected actually make transit better in any tangible way? NYC is also hamstrung by having its streets controlled locally by our DOT, but our transit & bridges controlled by a state agency. We just caved (again) entirely to the transit unions in the last contract negotiation. We have subway lines & trains wired up for 1 man operation but run them staffed with 2 due to union work rules. We have for years instead of building elevators, paid 3rd party access-a-ride minibus/van drivers to provide Uber-like service to anyone in need. We are planning to spend something like $3B/mile to expand a single train line a few stops further north. The MTA estimates they can put in platform doors like other developed world cities in only 1/3 of stations, at an average cost of $50M/station. We spent something close to $10B building an entire new terminal for LIRR underneath an existing Metro North terminal when there was enough capacity to serve both out of the existing station. Bureaucratic squabbles between divisions of MTA serving LI & NY/CT were mitigated by spending $10B. Oh and for the average LIRR rider, despite having 2 Manhattan terminals they can get a train to, the net service has actually been reduced in terms of trains per day. We basically need a modern era Robert Moses to consolidate NYC DOT/MTA/Port Authority and whatever other agencies and bring us into the modern era.
- Hikikomori 3y ago>We basically need a modern era Robert Moses to consolidate NYC DOT/MTA/Port Authority and whatever other agencies and bring us into the modern era. Idk about that, maybe a less racist one. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Power_Broker https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Power_Broker https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236323/episode/part-one-the-man-who-ruined-99056594/ https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236...
- steveBK123 3y agoYeah, he was a terrible guy and all. But stuff got built. The current inability to build anything is almost a direct result. They delegated decision making to an alphabet soup of agencies at different levels of jurisdiction so it's impossible to get anything done. Because there are so many agencies, you can't for example easily put in a busway because you need NYC DOT, MTA, NYS DOT, city council and mayor to all be on board. Too many people have veto, so nothing gets done. Living in NYC for long, it quickly becomes apparently the vast majority of our built infrastructure was built from 1930-1960 and has frozen in time since.
- Reason077 3y agoGood move. London has done this for many years with its congestion charge zone (and, more recently, the T-charge for high-emissions vehicles). Helps cut down on traffic congestion, reduces air pollution, and helps raise funds for transport projects.
- Jemm 3y agoWhat if you live in the toll area? Do you have to pay everytime you drive?44 Toronto has considered putting in a congestion tax, but no one wanted to way in on how that tax would affect people living downtown.
- Symbiote 3y agoIn London, residents of the congestion change zone get a 90% discount on the congestion charge.
- zhoujianfu 3y agoNow, ideally they take the revenue from the congestion charge and distribute it evenly among the residents!
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- pkulak 3y agoWow. So much negativity. As far as I’m concerned, even if the city burns every dollar it collects, if this gets some cars off the island, it’s a win. It’s time to stop tolerating personal vehicles in our most dense urban centers.
- isatty 3y agoIt’s never that simple. There are loads of people for which a personal or work vehicle is a necessity. Public transport cannot, and is never designed to catch every edge case. I’m all for better public transportation but strong statements and mishandled public funds just sways the support of the average joe.
- nostrebored 3y agoIt really is. Have you been in New York? In the area that this is being implemented in, you can absolutely survive without ever setting foot in a car. Other cities should have been planned around density. Instead we have suburban hellscapes where kids can’t be kids and there’s no real community. The car has been the single most destructive piece of mass-adopted tech for urban planning and lifestyle. If we have to start new cities to replace the disasters we created, better to rip off the bandaid now. Sucks that we used some of the best land in the country.
- eBombzor 3y agoCouldn't agree more. I moved out of LA to get the fk away from car culture. Now I live and work near dt Seattle where everything is relatively walkable, and my car is used at most twice a month for random things that I honestly don't need anyways. Obviously Seattle is not even close to a real walkable city like Amsterdam but miles better than LA. Going back to LA, it is exactly what you describe. Just a concrete hellscape. There are stretches where every single peice of the ground has a layer of concrete on it. Don't even get me started with Houston.
- hifromLA 3y ago
- xyzelement 3y agoIt's a nice way for the city to make additional revenue, and to reduce driving by those who can't afford it. Let's be real, nobody drives into Manhattan when a truly better option is available, so the only deterrent this offers is how much of a pain $20 really is for someone. If I am a doctor or a wall street guy and driving saves me an hour a day, I am still gonna drive if that costs me an extra $20. If I don't make a lot and $20 is a lot for me, maybe I'll suck it up and take the two busses and two trains that it takes to get to my job from my house in outermost queens. Yeah 5% reduction in traffic volume sounds about right, it will come from the absolute poorest but of course the real play is the extra revenue from those who'll continue to drive in.
- gWPVhyxPHqvk 3y agoI’m a Wall Street guy (well, my office is nearby on Broadway, I’m a dev, but easily able to justify an extra $20) and the thing is that driving in is almost never faster or easier than taking the train! The PATH, which starts in NJ where parking in cheaper, goes right into Lower Manhattan, and it’s a short walk to the office from there. Every time I’ve driven into Manhattan it’s slower than taking the train, except nights or weekends. I really don’t understand the type of person who drives a personal vehicle into Manhattan during the work week.
- xyzelement 3y agoLikewise I've also never had a life where it made sense to me to drive in, but I recognize that others may. Presumably their story sounds different than yours .
- ethics13 3y agoWell, now it will be easier. Those poor sops who can't afford the new pricing are that much less on the road to compete with.
- ethics13 3y ago>>If I am a doctor or a wall street guy and driving saves me an hour a day, I am still gonna drive if that costs me an extra $20. And this really helps this WS guy who has freer roads without those who can't afford the pricing.
- busymom0 3y agoThis would probably get challenged in court as an undue infringement on mobility rights. Only the rich will be able to afford mobility because of this.
- jasmer 3y ago[dead]
- neilv 3y ago> Proposals range from charging vehicles $9 to $23 during peak hours, and it’s set to go into effect next spring. Sounds like a giveaway of use of public streets to the wealthy.
- jijji 3y agoNYC is overrated... The good people left decades ago. If you are one of the unfortunate ones who has to actually take the train every day downtown, I can't tell you how many times I've been in fist fights in the train simply because I was wearing a suit on the wall street train, or the christopher street PATH train. People spit on you, they want to fight because you represent corporate america. The trains are BS. Better learn jiu jitsu before getting on one. lol.
- xyzelement 3y agoI assumed "downtown" means below 14th st or something like that - an unusual area to focus congestion charges on. They are actually talking about all of downtown and midtown - south of 60th street - which is yea the busier part of the city, just not what an actual NYer refer to as "downtown"
- osigurdson 3y agoForcing people to drive to an office just to type on a computer and take phone calls is the thing that should be disincentivized.
- elihu 3y agoI suppose governments could mandate that businesses provide their employees with a stipend to cover tolls in addition to their regular wages if they require the employees to be in the office.
- osigurdson 3y agoI suspect governments want it both ways: property tax and road tax. Naturally all in the name of doing something good for the citizens.
- xyzelement 3y agoBy the way, the congestion of the city makes life much easier for bikers and pedestrians than if the vehicles were moving faster, all things considered. Non-car NYers instinctively jaywalk and otherwise dominate the city because we don't have to deal with anything moving too fast. Other cities may have faster traffic and relatively fewer cars, but they are still way less walkable than NYC and scarier w/o a car. As I mentioned in another post, this is mainly a way to extract more revenue from the 95% (their own projection) of people who will continue to drive in the city. The 5% that will be priced out... I am not totally sure how noticeable that will be. Busses aren't going to all of a sudden fly down the avenue just because a handful of poor shmuks now have to take 2 busses and 2 trains to get to their job.
- nostrebored 3y agoGood — let drivers pay for their share of infrastructure and space required to support their existence. So much space in NYC is taken up by roads and parking, subsidized by people who don’t use it.
- xyzelement 3y agoI am curious whether you actually live in NYC. In the parts of the city this article is talking about, there's no free parking during busy times. Those lanes are reserved for either special parking situations (teachers, police), business (loading/unloading trucks, taxi stands) or turn into driving lanes. It happens that on Sundays and evenings, that capacity isn't needed and is given over to parking. 30 years in NYC, I didn't ever feel this resentfulness that your post implies. I didn't have a car but I benefited from taxis, ubers, deliveries, ability for people to visit, etc etc etc. I assume that people who chose to drive into the city do so because it's their best option. For my lifestyle in NYC, I could always walk to work and taxi/train to get laid, but that's not everyone's situation. The self-righteous hatred of cars and roads and parking is weird.
- nostrebored 3y agoPrice per square foot in Manhattan, a parking spot is a steal.
- xyst 3y agoWould be nice if we can as a country move away from car centric transportation. Tolls do nothing but put a tax on the poor. Rich (or well off) people will continue to pay the toll and their lifestyle won’t change. Now slowly remove highways, reduce street ROWs, invest in bike lanes, bus infra, train infra, shaded areas, and make living in the city more attractive while penalizing suburban people with extremely long commutes. Over time habits will change. Hopefully a migration back into the city and getting rid of costly suburbs
- elihu 3y ago> Proposals range from charging vehicles $9 to $23 during peak hours, and it’s set to go into effect next spring. That seems pretty expensive to me, but maybe that's typical of toll road prices these days. There are none where I live, so I don't have anything to compare to. It's unfortunate that it's effectively a regressive tax. There's an alternative that I like in principle, but I'm not sure if there's a way to actually implement it that wouldn't be a dystopian surveillance nightmare. The idea is that everyone in a region gets a fixed number of "car trip tokens" per week. You use one token every time you drive somewhere, regardless of how many passengers you have. Parents get tokens on behalf of their children, because they have to drive them places sometimes. Unused tokens may be sold to people who want them through a public auction system. Employers who require their employees to be in the office must provide their employees with the tokens. This shifts the burden of transportation externalities on to the employers. Employees can either use the tokens or sell them if they decide to take public transportation or ride a bike instead. This gives them an incentive to not drive even when they're provided tokens for free. The total number of tokens in the system can be set low enough that congestion is rarely a problem. Handling out-of-state cars is a problem. Maybe they can just pay a fixed toll if there's no interstate agreement set up. Maybe there could also be some rules like non-peak trips only use a half token, or oversized vehicles use 2 tokens.
- xbar 3y agoA regressive tax that burdens NYC citizens in the interest of business. The voices of the outer boroughs have been quelled.
- mock-possum 3y agoA regressive tax?
- LeanderK 3y agoThe whole situation seems quite chaotic for me, as I've read here in the comments. Different tolls on different tunnels/roads, different transit providers etc. It seems suboptimal. I wonder why this is not better designed? At least the public transit situation can be improved, I think. While public transit in germany is quite complicated, I think it stems from a similar federalistic design and maybe the solutions can be translated? We usually have local public transit owned on the local level, with regional rail owned by the state or the federal railroad company. So different actors like MTA or NJ transit, as I've understood (are there more?). But we usually have another layer, a transport association. For example in munich it's the mvv, which is owned by the state of bavaria, the city of munich and the neighbouring districts, or the VBB in Berlin, owned by the state of Berlin, the neighbouring state of brandenburg and the districts of berlin and neighbouring of berlin in brandenburg. The transport association usually doesn't own tracks or rail cars, but it's responsible for uniform pricing, ticketing, coordinating schedules and distributing the money to the actual transit providers, which can be federal, local or the state (or multiple states as with berlin). It is quite complicated and usually in germany nobody knows the difference between the transit providers and the transit association etc., but maybe this system can be translated? It usually leads to a situation where the transport association is perceived as a uniform system and hides the federalists structure behind a common front, and also as a common actor and formal way to coordinate on the future of the system between the different actors.
- leach 3y agoTaxi and Uber drivers watching all their income for the night evaporate to the tolls
- fennecfoxy 3y agoNothing new, London has congestion charge/ULEZ, it works decently well apart from the Tory corruption that allows all the assholes here to drive giant range rovers/SUVs in London, they should've banned new registrations drivable in London for SUVs in like mid 2000s or something.