19 ms·
TV doctors say annual checkups save lives – real doctors call bullshit (2016)
- neon_electro 3y ago(2016)
- golemiprague 3y agoI don't know, in Japan they do a mandatory yearly checkup for every employee, obviously the doctors there believe it is good, they also live very long.
- winrid 3y agoMost of my medical issues I caught were do to me being proactive. Even HMO is very lax in actually taking care of people.
- bigthymer 3y ago> Even HMO is very lax in actually taking care of people. Makes sense. The premium\cost is largely already paid so the less work is done, the higher the profit. It is FFS where you have to be careful about doctors ordering too much work.
- astrea 3y agoSo what's the alternative? Just wait until something bad happens to come in? Seems a lot more unproductive.
- dogma1138 3y agoI think this isn’t about specific screenings rather than the most basic physicals people get. Screenings for specific diseases like cancer and regular blood checkups do definitively catch things early.
- chx 3y agoSo if this article is not against regular blood checkups then what...?
- xboxnolifes 3y ago"“From a health perspective, the annual physical exam is basically worthless,” Zeke Emanuel, an oncologist at the University of Pennsylvania, has written after reviewing the research. "Almost nothing in the complete annual physical examination is based on evidence," Michael Rothberg, who directs the Cleveland Clinic Medicine Institute Center for Value-Based Care Research, wrote in the esteemed Journal of the American Medical Association in 2014. "Why, then, do we continue to examine healthy patients?""
- Something1234 3y agoAt the turn of the century in the early 1900s we were nuking babies' thyroids cause the only corpses they could find had diseased thyroids and the healthy babies had them. So obviously something must be wrong. There's always value in the counter example to see where our processes breakdown and fail. What we learn tomorrow in how abnormal our bodies are from another?
- chx 3y agoSo bloodwork yes but no touch...?
- crazygringo 3y agoBut I would never get screened or do blood work if it weren't for my annual checkup. Your annual physical is where those things happen, or get scheduled. That's what baffles me about this article. My annual checkup is pretty much the only time I ever see my doctor at all.
- lazide 3y agoIn most cases, you’re far more likely to get a false positive than a real positive with those tests - unless you feel or notice something wrong already. That is what is being pointed out.
- searealist 3y agoOr maybe it's exactly the same?
- pavon 3y agoMake a list of which screening do appear to be beneficial, and setup doctor visits based on the recommended schedules for those screenings instead of annually.
- recursive 3y agoDoes this list exist anywhere? I would have assumed so, but I'm struggling to find it.
- jdietrich 3y agoIf it ain't broke, don't fix it. Most diagnostic tests have good sensitivity (they pick up most cases of real disease) but relatively poor specificity (they pick up lots of false positives). Actively looking for asymptomatic disease does identify some diseases earlier and improve outcomes for those patients, but it also subjects a large number of patients to expensive, inconvenient, painful and risky tests and treatment. The benefits to the former group are matched almost exactly by the harms to the latter group, so (with very few exceptions) just waiting for symptoms to emerge gives you the same net benefits at significantly lower cost.
- CogitoCogito 3y ago> So what's the alternative? Just wait until something bad happens to come in? Seems a lot more unproductive. Maybe it does seem less productive, but really it’s just a reminder that surprising results that contradict are intuition need not be wrong.
- synaesthesisx 3y agoA big problem with healthcare is it tends to be reactive rather than proactive; folks generally tend to seek out care only when they’re having issues.
- searealist 3y agoWhat does proactive medicine look like? Or do you just mean eating healthy and exercising? Everyone knows you should be doing that.
- fooker 3y agoIt’s data driven. You get tested every few years and adjust diet/supplements/exercise based on the findings.
- lostlogin 3y agoThe devil is in the detail. > It’s data driven. Good. > You get tested every few years Not always good. Many screening tests just increase unnecessary procedure except in very specific situations. Eg MRI screening generates a ton on unnecessary biopsies and associated complications, stress. The data says when screening is appropriate, so as you say, use the data.
- zouhair 3y agoRandom screening are more harmful than useful. Overdiagnosis[0] is a thing. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdiagnosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdiagnosis
- rqtwteye 3y agoCorrect. Proactive medicine would be to prescribe a healthy lifestyle that’s customized for an individual. Traditional medicine like Ayurveda tries to do that. It’s kind of baffling that western medicine doesn’t really think like that.
- haldujai 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lr4444lr 3y agoUh, no. Hypertension is a silent killer. Mole checks? Colonoscopies? Testicular cancer screenings? These are all worthless? Preventative medicine has a long way to go, but it's currently the best it's ever been. Thank God I don't see any of these doctors.
- tapland 3y agoThose things are checked and screened for even in places where yearly checkups are unheard of.
- crazygringo 3y ago...when? If you're otherwise healthy you're not visiting the doctor at all. So where are these checking and screenings happening for adults?
- mbostleman 3y agoAccording to the study cited, they concede that annual checkups result in more diagnosis, but not in a decrease in morbidity. What you consider worthwhile, or worthless, is up to you I guess.
- massysett 3y agoSo to take this to an extreme, if the cohort that got checkups lived a healthy life until age 80, and the no-checkup cohort lived with diabetes and dialysis until 80, this study would say “checkups lead to no decrease in morbidity.” More relevant for the insurer (which might help explain why an insurer is urging checkups) living until 80 with diabetes and on dialysis is much more expensive than living healthily until 80.
- apsec112 3y agoMorbidity is not mortality, it means "suffering from disease". The dictionary definition is "the condition of suffering from a disease or medical condition". So being on dialysis would not be "no decrease in morbidity", no.
- hollosi 3y agoThe real question is why the insurance companies are pushing the annual exams very hard, not just in consumer ads, but using lots of incentives for primary care physicians. One would assume they would not want to pay for unnecessary tests for healthy people. So either their own research shows they save money with annual checkups in spite of what the article says, or more sinisterly, they do want to spend money to be able to justify higher premiums, because in several states they are required to spend around 80% of the premiums, and this is one easily plannable way. Does anyone know? Perhaps someone working for an insurance company?
- InvaderFizz 3y agoWild speculation is a combination of one insurance company offering it and it becoming a relatively low cost competitive bullet point on one hand. On the other hand, insurers probably have better actuarial data because of annual checkups and can better align their profit margins with fees. Thus reducing their own reinsurance fees.
- londons_explore 3y ago> insurers probably have better actuarial data Imagine you are an insurer and advise free annual checkups. Some of your patients don't bother. Those patients have a higher mortality. You conclude the annual checkup is good. But you might be deceiving yourself - the kind of people to ignore health advice about getting an annual checkup might also be the kind of people to ignore the health advice on the back of a cigarette packet...
- nradov 3y agoMajor medical insurers are not naive about this stuff. They employ expert actuaries and data scientists who understand statistics and causality.
- londons_explore 3y agoSure, they understand the problem... But is there anything they can do about it? I'm not aware of insurance companies being too keen on getting into medical experiments like 'people with a birthday on a Thursday don't get the free annual checkup'.
- arisAlexis 3y agoThis is really a bad article, one that can actually have a net negative effect on the world. Vox is trash.
- Retric 3y agoConveying accurate information is hardly trash, they’re simply talking about counterintuitive effects. Annual checkups for healthy people on average cost as many lives as they save. It’s better for people to know what kind of symptoms they need to seek medical treatment for than simply suggest an annual checkup is all that’s needed. I just went to the doctor 2 weeks ago and he said I was healthy…
- Spivak 3y ago"True but misleading." Telling people information in a manner that leads people into take the wrong conclusion from it -- "they're useless stop going to them" is really dumb. You can say damn near anything citing only true information along the way.
- Retric 3y agoHealthy people shouldn’t have an annual physical. That is 100% the correct messaging. There is age related things that should be checked regularly but a healthy 22 year old doesn’t benefit from an annual physical. It’s not just a waste of money but also an unnecessary strain on the medical system. Under the age of 50 and in good health, every 3 years is fine at 50 once a year. Data suggests even that may be excessive but it’s still better than every year.
- Spivak 3y agoYes but this already happens, my dad was told by his primary at 25, "you look good, see you when you turn forty." If your insurance is paying for them it's for whatever bean and counting reason they want and they pay you not insignificantly to do it. So if your doc schedules them, usually because you're a woman and age related care starts at like 25 go to them, and if your insurance pays you to go, go. And generally it's an uphill battle to get men to go to the doctor at all because obviously they're "healthy" so I can't really bemoan the "unnecessary" visits.
- haldujai 3y agoThis is a bit of a loaded topic and the authors are intermittently conflating "annual physical" with what is now better called a "periodic health maintenance visit". Aside from semantics, a periodic health maintenance visit is intended to provide an opportunity for age-appropriate evidence-based screening and preventive counselling as well as minimizing loss to follow-up and missed screening opportunities (pandemic-related patient access issues has been a great reminder of why screening is important). How often and when to do this is debatable, but specific tests have recommendations (the USPSTF is a great source). In contrast, palpating an abdomen in the hopes of opportunistically catching an asymptomatic tumor or putting a stethoscope on someone's neck to listen for carotid artery narrowing as part of an annual screening physical exam is arguably negligent and homeopathic at best. Other than blood pressure and BMI, I can't think of another component of the physical exam that would have potential clinical utility in an asymptomatic patient (granted my residency days in primary care are many years behind me now). Using the article's example of an abdominal aortic aneurysm, we have evidence-based recommendations on screening[0] which notably do not include a physical exam. Current recommendations (expert opinion, weak evidence) for periodic health visits will vary but are typically something like every 3-5 years for patients < 49* without chronic conditions and annually > 50 which coincides with roughly when we start to screen for most malignancies and worry about cardiovascular disease. There are many safe and useful investigations (e.g. colon cancer screening, cholesterol) and interventions (e.g. vaccines) that can be done in this visit so calling an annual visit 'bullshit' is facetious although this is very accurate for the physical part. *Women between 40-49 should also be getting an annual mammogram although this does not necessarily need an associated visit. [0] https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/recommendation/abdominal-aortic-aneurysm-screening https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/recomme...
- crazygringo 3y agoAs a layman (not a medical professional), I've never heard the term "periodic health maintenance visit" before reading this comment. I've definitely heard "annual physical" and "annual checkup" before though. And that's what my insurance pays for once a year for free, in my understanding. It seems like "periodic health maintenance" is necessarily a part of an "annual physical/checkup", just the same as a quick physical inspection is part of your annual as well. But that Vox is ignoring the "periodic health maintenance" part? Why? Out of ignorance or is there an agenda here?
- wilg 3y agoMy assumption is that this is wrong but I guess I can’t find any evidence that disputes this conclusion. Seems like the AMA doesn’t recommend them or anything. Surprising!
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoI can also see why people like it when getting an "unplanned" appointment takes weeks and you have to do telephonic battle with a Combat Receptionist daily at 8am until you get a slot.
- wkat4242 3y agoWell.. I don't know. Early detected illness is usually much more easily treated and has much less serious effects. When I read this counterargument: > Rothberg, the Cleveland Clinic physician, wrote a journal article about his father's experience a decade ago, when an annual checkup triggered a number of follow-up tests that cost $50,000 and ended up doing more harm than good. Well, yeah... Not every country has a crazy overpriced healthcare system like the US where minor problems cost thousands. Also this sounds very much like a 'worst-case example'. Here in Spain everything is free. Yes, the state pays for it, but the state also pays for treatments that will be more expensive when things get out of hand. And a yearly check is pretty standard and even required by employers. It has happened twice that they found a problem in my blood check. Both cases it was nothing but if it had been, knowing it early could have saved my life. > In the physical, the doctor used his hands to examine the patient’s stomach. He thought the aorta felt a bit enlarged there and might be an abdominal aortic aneurysm. This led to a cascade of tests — even though the patient turned out not to have an aneurysm — and during one, he nearly bled to death. Yes medical tests can go wrong. But a scan would have been a much safer option here than just to go poking around. > This means that in the midst of a primary care shortage in the United States, doctors are spending several hours on visits that evidence suggests are a waste of time and could be harmful. A primary care shortage should be fixed. Not used as a reason to not do checks. Especially in older people cancer is one of leading causes of death.
- simfree 3y agoPhysical manipulation is cheaper than a scan tho! Besides, the insurance would only cover a brisk walk by the general vicinity of an MRI machine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0URHKdXMmwo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0URHKdXMmwo
- haldujai 3y ago> Physical manipulation is cheaper than a scan tho! This relies on the assumption that the physical examination has useful sensitivity or specificity as a screening tool which is untrue. As an aside, MRI screening is not supported by evidence with the exception of select patients for breast cancer and people with hereditary cancer syndromes.
- duffpkg 3y agoI think there are valid questions about the medical efficacy of annual checkups that are heavily weighted by individual patient characteristics such as existing conditions, age, weight, etc. Seperate from medical efficacy there are a lot of reasons why insurers want you to have an annual visit with a medical provider which has to do with: 1) Assignment of you to a provider. Many, many people are autoassigned a primary care provider by their insurance, they often change this when they actually schedule a visit. Allocation of patients to providers is a very large aspect of manging health plans. 2) Data aggregation and validation of your information. People sign up with unbelievably garbage information and it tends to persist, even on employer provided plans. 3) Baseline medical status such as weight and vitals. Insurers aren't looking at this information directly but it comes through via billing codes for the exact types of exceptional cases insurers want to measure. These have a huge impact on the actuarial aspects of developing and managing health plans. PS: Depending on the patient pool, for lots of pools insurers no longer put much economic weight into prevention as it has played out that insurers end up paying for the prevention but patients change insurers so often that they change before the insurer benefits from the effects of the prevention. Incentives are a very messy thing in healthcare between patients, providers and insurers.
- grogenaut 3y agoI'll agree with this... I had one dumb/obstinate nurse who mis-measured my height 4 inches below my real height... claimed it was that I'd gotten shorter... 2h previous a seperate facility measured me at the real height. that height is showing up again on my charts. Last 2 visits they measured my height and said, huh chart is wrong, I told story, they were like "we'll fix it". Still not fixed. She also wanted to put me down in the system as a smoker as I had been in smoking resturants.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoAt one point someone mis-entered my height as about 4 feet. This obviously caused my BMI to trigger all sorts of alarms! That impact is probably why it got fixed pretty quickly.
- brian_cunnie 3y agoMy annual checkup uncovered that I was a raging type II diabetic with an A1c of 8.7 (higher is worse, 4-6 is normal). I changed my diet. Cost to my insurer over the last eleven years? ~$600. My friend Leroy Nova didn't find out he had diabetes (no annual checkup) until he passed out on a BART (Bay Area Rapid Transport) platform. He spent a month in the hospital in a coma. At $10k/night (typical), it cost $300k.
- refurb 3y agoYes, but you're ignoring the population aspect. Let's say an insurance company has 1M members, so if you screen everyone for diabetes each year, it 1M * $100 = $100M. Or you don't screen everyone, but just pay the costs when they get so sick they are admitted. So it's 1M * 0.01% (diabetes that results in 30 days of hospitalization) * $300K = $30M You just saved $70M by not screening everyone. And it's not just private insurance companies that do this, government paid healthcare systems do too. It's just basic health economics. Of course, the goal is to include all costs, lost work, etc. It's an entire field of study. The thing is - when you look at how best to allocate healthcare dollars, what's great at a population level can suck at the individual level because you're just one patient out of millions.
- siliconc0w 3y agoJust had a recent physical - I got a low value for a test and it kicked off more tests, a visit to a specialist, more tests and no conclusion besides 'let's wait and see' which I could have done without draining my HSA. If the price of care was reasonable, sure, let's be proactive but because PCPs don't really seem to do anything but refer you to a specialist and any visit to a specialist + tests will immediately trigger thousands of dollars in bills, even if you're insured you're going be paying your deductible plus like 10-30% after that. I got a random lab bill for like $650 (discounted from $2500) and in the follow up visit everyone agreed that was high but no could explain why it was that expensive - medicare's fee schedule has the same code costing $90. Until we stop this madness of providers basically charging whatever opaque negotiated random amount they want to insurers who then pass that down to charge payers after collecting a % the prices are just going to continue to go up and the broken medical system will stay fucked - with the consequence that the economics aren't going to make sense to seek proactive care.
- mahathu 3y ago> any visit to a specialist + tests will immediately trigger thousands of dollars in bills, even if you're insured you're going be paying your deductible plus like 10-30% after that. (In the US)
- omgwtfbyobbq 3y agoYou can likely get labs and imaging for significantly less by going to specific stand alone lab/imaging facilities. Health care groups tend to refer you to onsite services and/or specific companies they have relationships with. It is a pain though because you have to call around to get prices. Generally, the places with the lowest cash prices will also be the places that are least expensive after you've reached your deductible, but it's good to confirm with your insurance. Medicare's fee schedule is almost always lower than what you can get, even with all cash, because the US government can set the rates they pay to some degree. It's up to doctor's/medical groups if they'll accept that or just stop taking Medicare completely.
- creatonez 3y agoSpecialists are great, but it would be so much better if healthcare systems did a better job at properly looping back in the patient's primary care / family doctor in on important health decisions. Primary care physicians, when not stifled by the system, have a remarkable ability to keep track of a patient's health over the course of several years and provide a balanced, realistic view of what might be needed. The way that PCP visitations have become shorter and shorter in a more overworked and hectic environment has done a great disservice to patients.
- A1kmm 3y agoThe Cochrane review referenced was updated in 2019 and if anything the conclusions are stronger now: https://www.cochrane.org/CD009009/EPOC_general-health-checks-reducing-illness-and-mortality https://www.cochrane.org/CD009009/EPOC_general-health-checks...
- mrangle 3y agoA half-lifetime of experiencing and observing modern medicine, in good faith, has taught me that participating in the medical system while not in need of emergency care is risking one's health and life. Assuming that one doesn't engage in risky behavior, the smartest path is to avoid the medical system altogether. That doesn't mean "seek alternative medicine". It's just what I said. The Medical system doesn't highlight its failures. It obscures them, and only speaks in bullshit PR terms. Its failures (premature suffering and death) are almost always attributed to causes other than the malpractice that caused them. Even families are hoodwinked. Laugh at anyone quoting "evidence" without citing it for critique. The medical profession hasn't had broadly-intact scientific integrity for decades. Much of medicine is charlatanism for billing. Doctors know this though most won't admit it. The consequences range from annoyance, to minor malfunction, to catastrophic.
- opportune 3y agoThe real hack is having friends and family in the medical field. You can skip the chicanery of medical “intake” and diagnosis outside highly specialized conditions, get advice without extortionate bills or misaligned incentivizes, and they can help you get appointments with specialists/tell you who’s the best to see, even write you rx’s directly. I recently had an infection that, due to being geographically isolated from my typical medical network of friends and family, resulted in $1k of bills after insurance for something that was essentially routine and which I would have been able to treat myself if I had the ability to get medicine without an rx. The general public who don’t have the scientific/medical literacy to self-serve and lack the network to get treatment without going through the formal process are getting fleeced.
- cube00 3y agoFriends and family need to be off the clock too, be respectful if anyone chooses to do this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- toxicdevil 3y ago> People walked out of their appointments having been told they had a condition they might not have known about before. But those additional diagnoses didn’t seem to save lives. Knowing about a particular condition didn’t, in these studies, correlate with better health outcomes. Duh... I am guessing a lot of these diagnoses require lifestyle changes (instead of med) that the patients wont do, e.g. pre-diabetes, high cholesterol, obesity etc But it would be wrong to say that these visits are a waste. > Annual physical exams can “do more harm than good” Key word being "can", one can say this for literally for anything. They chose one bizarre case that led to expensive follow-ups and a bleeding during the procedure. Most annuals likely dont lead to any follow-ups at all. Let alone follow-ups for a possible aortic aneurysm. > “I'm not sure you need an annual visit to the physician. You're very unlikely to have any serious diseases that haven't shown symptoms.” A disease does not have to be life threatening to show symptoms and even life threatening diseases (e.g. certain cancers in women) can have no symptoms until you are beyond the point of no return. Sometime a person has "symptoms" that they think is a part of life and would never go to the doctor for if not for an annual physical. e.g. I personally know people who have had serious vitamin deficiencies found out through annual tests which they got after many years. Their "symptoms" were lack of energy, focus, hair loss, mood swings, sadness etc. Something most people probably wont go to the doctor for. A few months on high potency supplements and their quality of life changed considerably. Would this be classified as a "serious disease"?
- kbos87 3y agoSomething I find interesting is that more and more single-service, tech enabled medication providers are popping up. Example - if I want ADHD medication, there's a service for that, and there's another service for hair loss medication, yet another for weight loss medication... How do PCPs feel about this? It has to represent a loss of control for them when their patients can basically go out and get what they want in such a low-friction way.
- jdietrich 3y agoI'm not a PCP, but some of this self-service healthcare is very concerning from a public health perspective. One of the biggest problems in American healthcare is overtesting, overdiagnosis and overtreatment. Quick and convenient access is obviously very good for some patients, but there's a significant risk of harm if patients are given easy access to treatments that may be ineffective, unnecessary or actively harmful to them, based on commercial imperatives rather than medical need. The most tragic example is the proliferation of pill mills, which were one of the fundamental drivers of the opioid crisis. I'm obviously opening myself to accusations of paternalism, but unnecessary healthcare causes real harms on a drastic scale. By some estimates, as much as a third of healthcare spending in the US is on treatments that offer no medical benefit; all of those unnecessary treatments carry some level of risk. The consequences of inappropriately prescribing ADHD medication might seem trivial if you once took a few ritalin or adderall to get through your exams and suffered no serious adverse consequences, but these drugs can cause devastating harm in patients at risk of mania - bipolar disorder and cyclothymia can look a lot like ADHD if you ask leading questions and don't take a thorough history. The US healthcare system is obviously broken, but the proliferation of self-service healthcare offers at least as many risks as potential benefits. https://www.choosingwisely.org/ https://www.choosingwisely.org/
- TrackerFF 3y agoHaving lived in three countries with universal health care, annual checkups is a bit foreign concept. I mean you could ask to get tests whenever you want to, but it is not something doctors will recommend. Most people go to the doctor when they experience symptoms. I don't know how to compare these systems, but I guess if we look at life expectancy, similar European countries are doing pretty well.
- ALittleLight 3y agoI think life expectancy is distorted by Americans being fat, driving more, and drug deaths. Probably violence factors in too, but I'm not sure if that's big enough to meaningfully change things.
- lazide 3y agoA lot of Europe smokes like a chimney too. Smoking in the US has been dying out very rapidly.
- runarberg 3y agoThe US health care system fails on many metrics. Life expectancy might be distorted, but all these other metrics paint a pretty clear story of the failure of the US health care system to provide health care to the general population. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35516775 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35516775
- hackeraccount 3y agoHealthcare or lack there of is something that kills you when you're 50 or 60. Drugs, suicide, homicide, auto accidents are the kind of things that kill you when you're 20. People dying their 20's skews life expectancy way more then people in the 50's or 60's.
- runarberg 3y agoSome of these metrics take that into account, for example Life expectancy at age 60 in years is still lower in the USA then most other comparable countries. This metric eliminates the potential bias you described by not counting anyone who died before the age of 60. But the point of having a variety of metrics is that other potential biases might be present in some of them, but across all of them, the most likely explanation is a health care system (or health care norms) that work worse compared to health care system in other countries. To summarize, there may be a cultural reason for some of the metrics (say higher drug usage among pregnant people causes higher infant mortality rate), but if you have higher number of preventable deaths, higher treatable mortality rate, uniquely a negative trend in maternal mortality, higher deaths from suicide, etc. etc. than the evidence that this is the fault of health care system instead of culture starts to become overwhelming.
- x62Bh7948f 3y agoI live in a country where annual checkups are mandatory (companies are fined by the government a lot of money for each employee who does not get it done). I've been told a couple times now that something is a bit off, not too concerning by itself, but it requires more tests to rule out suspects from a list. had a lot of blood tests done, nothing unusual came up, still being regularly told to keep doing tests in between checkups. I can say perhaps one of the upsides is I get nudged by the doctors to keep a healthy lifestyle.
- thehappypm 3y agoI feel like an annual blood test, done at a cheapo outpatient facility, would be far more useful than a typical physical.
- zaptheimpaler 3y agoThey only looked at death, and only two causes of death - cardiovascular and cancer over 10 years. That makes for a pretty stupid study if you ask me.. There are tons of other problems that won't cause death but nonetheless will bother you or subtly impact QOL without you even knowing. Thyroid issues are one. It won't save your life but it will make it a lot more enjoyable and maybe make you more productive too. There are other causes of death too.. so the conclusions they are trying to draw seem completely invalid to me. The study showed equal mortality from 2 sources, it did not show that checkups are pointless.. A lot of the complaints about unnecessary follow-up etc. are down to cost not inconvenience. In most cases, the only follow up is a blood test which is quick and easy. Even a ultrasound/CT is like 1hr. It only becomes a problem when you have to pay $1000s for it. Whole article is just a gross misrepresentation.
- rocket_surgeron 3y agoApropos to a submission about Vitamin D that was a couple of links above this article is the fact that it ignores quality of life. Sometimes it seems that medical researchers don't actually care about health, they only care about numbers, because numbers are easy. During an annual checkup a couple of years back I mentioned that I had "been feeling down and sluggish quite a bit lately" and my doctor said "hmmm, might be vitamin d, we'll see with your bloodwork". Wonder of wonders my vitamin d was low, I started supplementing it, and once my levels got back to normal I unquestionably, irrefutably, CAUSATIONALLY, felt better. My quality of life improved. I didn't know Vitamin D was tied to energy and mental health issues. Sure there are at-home tests now, but there weren't any back then and I wouldn't have known to take one anyways. How many people are living shitty lives because of something simple that could be caught during an annual blood test? Researchers: "We don't care, those numbers are hard to get. Deaths are easy to count."
- thescriptkiddie 3y ago> "Almost nothing in the complete annual physical examination is based on evidence," Michael Rothberg, who directs the Cleveland Clinic Medicine Institute Center for Value-Based Care Research, wrote in the esteemed Journal of the American Medical Association in 2014. The American Medical Association is not a research institution, it is a lobbying group and price-fixing cartel. I would not trust any doctor that is an AMA member.
- nirui 3y agoBack in the day, there was a strong earthquake occurred in China. During that time, some experts brought up the idea of Triangle of Life, and claiming that "If you found the Triangle of Life of building that you currently at during an earthquake, you'll likely survive it's collapse". Problem is, the Triangle of Life was "selected" by the building during the earthquake. That means whether or not you can "found it" is largely down to chance. The same thing is true for medical checkups. Because there are so many things occurring inside that biomass, whether or not a checkup can discover abnormality is largely down to educated chance. Here in our city, a full-body checkup in the city hospital costs around $2,000. It includes blood and urine test, MRI & X-Ray & B-Ultrasound scan for conditions that are common, cardio stuffs, endoscopy from both directions and a few others. But even that kind of test still has misses, so again, it's down to chance. On the other hand, when done correctly, checkups do have it's benefits. There are stories that I've heard claiming medical checkups (some full-body, some just good old regular) saved their life. So I guess you just have to manage your expectations, change it from "This will definitely help me" to "I'm playing a Whack 'em All that comes with a few risk factors all by itself". > Annual physical exams can “do more harm than good” There is a fun story: I had an endoscopy a long while back. In the middle of the operation, the doctor in charge decides to hand me over to a med student (which is a common practice in China's state/city funded hospitals during graduation months) who I assumed should just be there doing observational study among the other classmates. Long story short, that dude, has blown too many air into my colon and it was painful. But still, I was not in a "bled to death" situation, the doctor was quick to correct it, and he also kindly told me to "just fart it out". I hope the student learned something that day.
- pipes 3y agoAnd the link titles on hacker news are following the same trajectory that Reddit did about a decade ago. It's depressing.
- HeartStrings 3y agoAnnual PSA checkups absolutely save lives.
- EGreg 3y agoI remember seeing this: https://nyulangone.org/conditions/breast-cancer/screening https://nyulangone.org/conditions/breast-cancer/screening And this: https://www.webmd.com/oral-health/features/dental-checkup-every-6-months https://www.webmd.com/oral-health/features/dental-checkup-ev... What gives y'all?
- borissk 3y agoThink there's plenty of evidence that the countries in which the average person sees a doctor more often have higher life expectancy.
- amelius 3y agoPerhaps because they can see a doctor when they need one?
- xvilka 3y agoOr just get yourself some chronic disease and be regularly checked monthly.
- WeylandYutani 3y agoAmerican healthcare system is for profit. That's why you should always be suspicious when they say something. You're dealing with a used car salesman. In the Netherlands doctors are not concerned with renumeration- only science and statistics. Efficiency and productivity are necessary for a public healthcare system.
- yboris 3y agoMost people probably do not need an annual checkup: https://nutritionfacts.org/2021/04/20/is-it-worth-getting-an-annual-physical-exam/ https://nutritionfacts.org/2021/04/20/is-it-worth-getting-an... > many health authorities “have all agreed that routine annual checkups for healthy adults should be abandoned”
- ivanhoe 3y agoThing is, however, that statistics don't deal with the individual outcomes. Just because statistically the health checks are claimed not to make a significant difference, it doesn't mean that they couldn't save your life at some point.
- arisAlexis 3y agoIncredible how much contrarianism flourishes on HN just for the sake of it
- CogitoCogito 3y agoWhat contrarianism are you referring to? Are you saying that those who find the idea that recommending everyone get annual checkups might be suboptimal health policy are just being contrarian? Or is it because you are bothered by the idea that your preconceived notions on healthcare policy might be wrong?
- arisAlexis 3y agoYes the idea is false and contrarian and the article puts under checkup everything undoing centuries of medical science. But OK, it's against the mainstream thinking bruh
- CogitoCogito 3y agoAre you claiming that centuries of medical science have supported the idea of the annual physical? Honestly I’m having trouble following your point. The article is pretty clear in its arguments. Which do you find so unreasonable? Could you quote to me a part of the article contradicted by centuries of science?
- arisAlexis 3y agoJust 2 simple things:a) the article under annual checkup is a Mashup pop science.b) annual exams and preemptive medicine are worth it, all medical science is based on either preempt and treat early or late. Now if you think that doing annual exams is harmful and catching diseases early is harmful and everyone believes it OK, humanity believed earth is flat for a long time. Doctors believed covid is nothing, you can find videos of doctors saying that early etc. Skip doctor, go only when you have pain brother.
- 3y ago
- rpep 3y agoIn the U.K. it is not normal to go for an annual examination at all. Here, once you hit 40, you get an examination every 5 years unless you have some specific health condition which would requires you to be seen more frequently.
- jl2718 3y agoThere’s a website that can pass the test to become a doctor now. Why can’t I order my own diagnostics?
- esskay 3y agoNot really surprising. The biggest giveaway should be for Americans to look at other countries. Annual checkups really are not at all the norm in most places. In the UK for example, the last time I saw a doctor was about 16 years ago when I broke my wrist.
- eatonphil 3y agoKorea and Japan have high quality cheap health care and people there visit all the time. https://www.statista.com/statistics/236589/number-of-doctor-visits-per-capita-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/236589/number-of-doctor-...
- jiggywiggy 3y agoCheckups save lives. It's a bit ridiculous to speak of needing evidence for that. Catching cancer early is of great importance. Hence the yearly breast control checks. The question is one of cost benefit in this regard and wether the annual checkups proposed can be more efficient regarding types of tests and demographics
- glfharris 3y agoIt's not as simple as you're suggesting. Take cancer screening for example. Doing more investigations and more procedures for things that weren't going to become problematic puts people at risk for the complications of those procedures. Screening programmes need to be carefully thought out, not only from a cost-benefit, but from an actual risks vs benefits perspective.
- lol768 3y agoWhich is why in other countries, such as the UK, the NHS will look at the potential for preventing disease/extending QALY based on peer-reviewed evidence, the risks of harm and overall cost-effectiveness before then coming up with a model for the whole population when it comes to screening which targets patient demographics most likely to benefit. The following conditions are pro-actively screened in this way: - Abdominal aortic aneurysm - Bowel cancer - Breast cancer - Cervical cancer - Diabetic eye screening Patients with early symptoms of e.g. skin cancer can get moles checked out free of charge, and the yearly dental & vision check will screen for conditions like oral cancer and glaucoma. The harm of something like a yearly colonoscopy in the general asymptomatic population would far exceed the potential benefits.
- DanBC 3y agoYes, and the screening committee publish their methodology and evidence. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/uk-national-screening-committee/about https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/uk-national-scre...
- jiggywiggy 3y ago
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoThis is black-and-white thinking. The metric was, saving lives from cardiovascular or cancer causes. Nothing to do with quality-of-life. I often don't see my doctor but once a year for that annual visit. We cover lots of ground, make adjustments, give me heads-up on what I can expect as I age, and so on. You know, what a GP is for. An expert collaborator on my health decisions. For god's sake, visit your doctor sometime. Maybe not as often as you visit your dentist or hell, your auto mechanic. But maybe your body is worth some care and maintenance visits? Think about it.
- newZWhoDis 3y agoExactly! This headline/article is harmful in my opinion. We need people to get checked more not less!!!
- wintermutestwin 3y agoI have a doctor that was essentially assigned to me by the fact that they were the only local doctor accepting my insurance and new patients. It takes two months to get an appointment and my annual check ups are with random physician assistants - not actually with the doctor, whom I have never met. As an American, I look forward to retiring in some other country with a functional healthcare system.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoI don't use an HMO, I have a regular doctor with regular doctor offices and hours and so on. That's an important part of it - somebody I know who knows me, asks about my activities, about my family, who's doing well, how are my brother's kids getting along and so on. A family GP.
- Eumenes 3y agoUnless you have some pre-existing medical condition or are over 45 years old ... I don't see the purpose of annual visits. I'm in my late 30s and haven't gotten a physical in a decade. Why would I? I'm heathy, exercise, sleep enough, have a good diet, etc. All they do is weigh you, make you answer 1000 questions, engage in some impersonal small talk, and push unnecessary inoculations on you (oh, and suggest expensive blood/lab work). I feel fairly attuned with my body so if something is wrong, I can go to a doctor, but "preventive" medicine, just seems like a money making scheme.
- alakep 3y agoIf you read the financial plans of these direct primary care clinics you’ll see that they intentionally lose money on primary care with the strategy of making up for it in increased referrals business. Healthcare is so greedy. Thanks for sharing this.
- m3kw9 3y agoJust by the fact that they recommend 1 year which is just an arbitrary number of days picked(365) is a red flag. Every person should have different days, say you have family history then after age 50 visit more often even less than a year. They are just lazy to apply individualized care
- JoshTko 3y agoI've started to use chatGPT4 as a major part of my routine healthcare. I can comfortably ask question I want at my pace to really probe each symptom and likely cause, tailored to me. Easily better than most general practitioners I've had.
- sjckciodjcr 3y agoMy partner was trained in primary care and basically said the same. Obviously it’s not so black and white - there are patients with risk levels that warrant regular checkups, but most people do not need them and for them risk of false positives outweighs an undiagnosed positive. The regularity of checkups should be a call made by the medical team and patient, not something pushed by insurance. Some people in the comments are complaining this article encourages the other extreme, never visiting your doctor, but I think most researchers and doctors would argue that the frequency of checkups should be based on their view of your health and risks. Too frequent or too rare check ups are both a problem.
- oblak 3y agoEven the title is baffling to me. It has "TV doctors" in it. TV doctors! I can't even begin to imagine all the possibilities, almost none of them good, of having such a thing in the first place. This has to be on the same level as tv shamans and what not. [proceeds to the article, finds about they mean "tv show doctors", then realizes this changes nothing. literally nothing]
- qgin 3y agoThis is very goofy. I had no idea I had high cholesterol or high blood pressure. I have a healthy diet and exercise, but it just runs in my family. A checkup found that very early and now I'm on medication that controls it. I believe they didn't find a change in 10 year mortality, because none of this was going to kill me in 10 years, nor would finding out about it 10 years before my death help very much. But finding out now while I'm relatively on the younger side has a real chance to move the needle.
- stefantalpalaru 3y ago[dead]
- Asooka 3y agoOne thing that definitely makes sense is yearly eye checkups, including eye pressure. I had undiagnosed glaucoma for a year or two until my eyesight got bad enough to go to the Dr. No headaches or anything. Fortunately I still have enough vision left to read most normal sized text, but it was close. Get your eyes checked out, you can get glaucoma at any age.
- jamesgill 3y agoI’m not a care provider, but I’ve worked in healthcare for a long time. The real answer is: there is no consensus among doctors about this. Opinions vary widely. The article alludes to this. One thing I do know: tests are not the reliable gold standard they’re believed to be, and even when ‘accurate’, interpretations of results vary and evolve over time.
- natmaka 3y agoScreening by mammography increases the incidence of breast cancer: https://twitter.com/daniel_corcos/status/1659854579993903106 https://twitter.com/daniel_corcos/status/1659854579993903106
- spydr 3y agoAbout a year ago I went in for a regular checkup after my wife reminded me I had not had one. I thought, I’m 25 don’t really need one. Turns out my blood cell count was slightly elevated. 2 months later I do another test, it’s off the charts. Turns out I randomly developed leukemia. 11 months of chemo later, and I’m in remission. Not sure what would have happened if we had not caught it so early.