28 ms·
Microsoft plugging more ads into Windows 11 Start Menu
- nullcaution 4y agoMany people here are pointing out "Why would Microsoft do this to their customer base?" Well it's because they can, and people are not going to do anything about it. Most people don't know about or cant reinstall the OS. So the publics real decision is between an expensive MacBook, or well Windows. To make things worse most people are so used to ads, tracking and other bullshit, this is just par for the course... white noise. If you really want a change, your going to have to get the major OEMs to start distributing Linux on mass, but you bet that if that ever took off there would be trackers on their distros in a heartbeat.
- beej71 4y agoMy folks are in their 70s, but this might be the thing that finally pushes them to Linux. :)
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI got served malware on APNews.com from an ad. Twice... from the Associated Press Website. And thats when I regretfuly had to turn on my adblocker there. Now hopefully they aren't 3rd party JavaScript ads (yet), but I still dont like the security implications of this.
- FloatArtifact 4y agoIt's important to me the distinction that it's ads for Microsoft services. I dislike that as much as anyone else who hates ads, but it is distinctly different than just general advertising.
- bhouston 4y agoIt is still mental and visual pollution. I switched from Windows to MacOS 2 years ago after being a long Windows holdout and damn, MacOS is nice and the Mx series of CPUs/GPUs are also incredibly fine.
- AniseAbyss 4y ago[dead]
- FloatArtifact 4y agoI agree about the mental and visual pollution.
- snarfy 4y agoPollution is a nice way to put it. I prefer phrases such as 'cognitive assault', 'mental violence' and 'attention rape'. I really hate advertisement in all forms.
- wlesieutre 4y agoApple’s products aren’t perfect at this either, but they’re at least much easier to control. You basically just have to disable notification permission for TV. News is spammy also, but not strictly advertising Apple’s junk, it’s just regular attention spam. Meanwhile in the App Store guidelines: > 4.5.4 Push Notifications must not be required for the app to function, and should not be used to send sensitive personal or confidential information. Push Notifications should not be used for promotions or direct marketing purposes unless customers have explicitly opted in to receive them via consent language displayed in your app’s UI, and you provide a method in your app for a user to opt out from receiving such messages. Abuse of these services may result in revocation of your privileges. Not a great look, and it tells you that Apple is willing to compromise on their principles to make a buck. Here’s hoping your privacy isn’t worth selling out too. Windows is cramming their tabloid-news-by-MSN into the operating system in multiple places and making it a lot harder to get rid of, so for now macOS is still the better of the two. But I‘m not happy with either of them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 4y ago> Not a great look, and it tells you that Apple is willing to compromise on their principles to make a buck. I think they're holding a good balance here. For example, I do enjoy an alert from the burger slinger down the road when they put up a sale - but I had the choice between opting in or not. Meanwhile, on Android you don't have the choice, all you can do is mute notifications from that app in the future (and lose out on important notifications) or remove it entirely.
- anshumankmr 4y agoThat is (sort of) the status quo bias fallacy
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rolph 4y agohttps://www.marketingweek.com/mark-ritson-people-hate-ads/ https://www.marketingweek.com/mark-ritson-people-hate-ads/ [2019]
- Night_Thastus 4y agoTo anyone who hasn't I highly encourage setting up PiHole. Great for reducing the severity of these sorts of things, and helps to sanitize and clean up your internet. Don't need to buy a Pi either, it can run on a laptop or desktop just fine. It's great for catching anything that can't be by an in-browser adblocker, like in the OS or on other devices.
- esperent 4y agoHow does a pihole compare to NextDNS? I know you can set custom lists in a pihole, are there any other differences? NextDNS is very easy to set up. Pihole always feels like it'll be yet another thing to manage.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoI have no experience with NextDNS, but with PiHole I can say it has been very "set and forget". Logged into the router, set the DNS server IP. Then into Windows to disable IPv6. Now it just runs in the background quietly for years. It can be set up to do updates automatically as well if desired. I have occasionally disabled it, thinking it may have been the cause of some internet trouble, but so far that's never been true.
- brewdad 4y ago> I have occasionally disabled it, thinking it may have been the cause of some internet trouble, but so far that's never been true. I hear people say this about PiHole all the time but I have a hard time believing it. I run into a couple sites a week that don't work right with Firefox standard privacy settings and UBlock Origin. I certainly don't want to add another troubleshooting step when web sites break.
- Marsymars 4y agoIf you don't want to host your own DNS, there are also managed options. I pay for and use both Eero Secure (intercepts DNS requests sent to non-NextDNS servers) and NextDNS (set on my clients so it's also effective when away from home).
- spicyusername 4y agoThe only reason I use Windows in 2023 is for video gaming. Every other non-gaming PC I own is running Linux. Windows has become inferior to Linux in every other way. More upgrade headaches, worse resource utilization, worse desktop environment, more crashes, data collection, and now embedded ads. These technology companies have really demonstrated over the past few decades that they are unable to maintain reliable products over the long term. Every piece of good software (and even hardware in many cases) degrades almost immediately into an inferior product due to laziness and greed. These companies would rather destroy their flagship products chasing the smallest prospect of extra revenue, than leave what works alone and innovate on something new.
- surgical_fire 4y ago> The only reason I use Windows in 2023 is for video gaming. Every other non-gaming PC I own is running Linux. It was the same for me until a month ago. Thanks to the recent developments of WINE and Proton, gaming on Linux has been reliable enough that I could switch entirely to Linux and not look back. Couldn't be happier about it. Unless you only like to play the most recent AAA releases, I suggest you give it a try.
- Karsteski 4y agoI have an HDR monitor and Windows 11 autoHDR is genuinely great. I've been considering moving my gaming PC to Linux but I really don't want my monitor features to go to waste. Maybe I'll just sit in WSL2 unless absolutely necessary but I'm sure there's a bunch of random headaches that would come with that
- dimgl 4y agoCan I play Valorant on Linux? I don't think Riot Vanguard works on it.
- surgical_fire 4y agoNever played Valorant. A quick search tells me that the "anticheat" malware that comes along with this game is not supported to run with Proton.
- jzb 4y agoEvery time Microsoft does something (e.g. WSL2) that makes me think "maybe using Windows wouldn't be so bad" they counter with something that really puts me off (e.g. Ads in Windows, constantly trying to shove their browser down my throat, etc.).
- beembeem 4y agoI am not upgrading from Windows 10. These newer releases are turning the OS into an ad-serving platform, which is unfortunate because the user is essentially paying for the OS. Microsoft is trying to have its cake and eat it too. If I'm paying for the product, I don't expect to be flooded with ads.
- duffyjp 4y agoI've literally never touched a single PC running Windows 11. I've normally been an early adopter-- I even used Windows 8.0 and 8.1 but I just have zero interest in Windows 11. I earn my living on a Mac, do my photography hobby on a Mac-- Windows exists (for me) only for games, and Linux is closer to parity every day.
- beembeem 4y agoIt's unfortunate, because there are some improvements like WSA (Windows Subsystem for Android) [1] that I think are a big step in the right direction. The problem is the OS is becoming user-hostile in order to squeeze every last penny out of users. On a paid product (when there are an entire universe of free software), what is the point of paying for ads? [1] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/android/wsa/ https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/android/wsa/
- clnq 4y agoInteresting, I had the same experience. When 8 and 8.1 came out, I upgraded immediately because I thought I'd need to get with the times eventually. I suppose, in retrospect, 8 wasn't that bad. It had questionable design choices, but not anti-consumer design. Even Vista wasn't anti-consumer, it was just very unpolished. Perhaps it's easier to accept mistakes than it is to put up with malicious behaviour.
- dimgl 4y agoI really regret getting Windows 11. Not even auto HDR is worth this crap.
- websap 4y agoIt's outrageous that once a great OS builder, is now resorting to pushing it's subscription services through it's OS. Imagine MacOS and iOS showing in menu ads, I hope Apple never stoops to this level.
- dustyharddrive 4y agoApple’s nearly there.
- Marsymars 4y agoIn my day-to-day usage, ads in the core user interface in iOS are worse than in Windows. Windows ads can be disabled pretty easily. iOS App Store ads cannot be disabled at all and are often for utter trash. The Microsoft Store is entirely optional, and app installs/updates can be entirely handled via winget/chocolatey (or installs in some other form). The iOS App Store cannot be avoided for installing apps or for manually updating apps, and its ads are more akin to forced ads in the Windows Update settings pane.
- alistairSH 4y ago...ads in the core user interface in iOS... Where are you seeing ads in the main UI? I occasionally see a small ad near the top of "Settings", usually for an Apple service. I don't recall ads on the home page or lock screen, or in the main Apple apps I use (Camera, Photos, Files, Health, Fitness, Watch).
- Marsymars 4y agoSee my reply to other child comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615479
- sleepybrett 4y agoThe only time you get those notifications is generally when you install a new os version and they want to tell you about a new feature. That feature might be 'hey we launched apple news that you can pay for'. The only other time is when you are close to your apple cloud limit it will tell you that you can subscribe to more space.
- zeroego 4y agoI use Ubuntu for work, but my gaming rig runs windows. I went through all of the applications I use on my windows pc the other day and they're all available on linux now. With proton getting as good as it is, app availability on linux, and with the annoying occasional ads coming through my windows os, I'm starting to think I won't upgrade to windows 11 when 10 stops being supported.
- whalesalad 4y agoOnly thing keeping me on Windows is the anticheat software employed by games like MWII.
- monkaiju 4y agoI refuse to use software as intrusive as the anti-cheat stuff, just not worth it.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoThat's my position as well. Even if we just look at it from a hedonistic perspective. I play games to be happy and destress. Windows' abusiveness and anticheat software make me unhappy and/or stressed. For pure hedonism I'm better off with Proton and a smaller selection of games.
- whalesalad 4y agoMy friends and I live all around the US. The one game we all play together has anticheat. It also happens to be cross platform and they are on console. As far as being happy - being able to cross play with my buds and voice chat while we are thousands of miles apart is well worth it.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoThat makes sense. I guess if I were in your situation, the calculation could push me into using Windows.
- marcodiego 4y agoWindows users went through ME, Vista, 8... I'm sure they can handle ads.
- pwinnski 4y agoMost people will sign up for a Microsoft account, or already have, and so won't even see these ads. But let's say you use Microsoft Windows, but don't want a Microsoft account. You're going to leave Windows over this? And go where? Wait, is 2023 the fabled Year of Linux on the Desktop, at long last? I haven't used Windows in many years, and I'm not trying to defend Microsoft here. Still, the framing of this piece seems silly. Very rarely is any single thing reason enough for the average person to completely switch operating systems. The cost of switching is too high.
- belter 4y agoThe Desktop Experience on Linux is years ahead of Windows. Only users who have to use apps non available on Mac or Linux use Windows.
- pwinnski 4y agoOf course! I don't disagree. And yet here we are at 69.43% desktop market share[0] for Windows for March 2023, decades after I started hearing about how this year, for sure, was going to be the Year Of Linux On The Desktop™. Most people don't seem to be using the best possible desktop experience. Their desktop is decided by an employer, or whatever is pre-installed, or who knows what. But an ad in the start menu doesn't seem like it's likely to budge that number much. 0. https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/worldwide/ https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/worldwide...
- justsomehnguy 4y ago> The Desktop Experience on Linux is years ahead of Windows [citation needed] And is also relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35325280 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35325280
- belter 4y agoBetter than citation, it's beautiful: https://youtu.be/7JJmCAJs9pM https://youtu.be/7JJmCAJs9pM
- dwighttk 4y ago“More”?
- jmclnx 4y agoI have not used Windows at home at all. I always liked Text based interfaces and at home went from DOS/DESQview to UN*X. But these days I have surrendered and use X most of the time. But I think M/S only cares about Corporate Accounts, which is where the big bucks is. If I remember correctly, Corporate Windows builds do not have any of this crazyness. So, I guess this is just to squeeze as much as the can from private people and to get private information they can sell. Due to this, I have recommended my relatives on old Windows machines to move to MACs. I would suggest Linux or a BSD, but I do not need the headache of training/supporting them :)
- AraceliHarker 4y agoIf you've been following Windows 11 since the first leaks, you'll know that during beta testing, a glitch on the server side that Microsoft used to deliver ads to Windows made the shell unresponsive. Ads in Windows 11 aren't just an eyesore, they're also a source of glitches.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoPlease please MS just put someone in charge with taste who can veto this trashy rubbish. Whatever gains you're perceiving from this on your profit chart isn't worth the compounding deterioration of your products experience.
- jimbob45 4y agoOn the other hand, Windows is on a lot of computers these days. They may be making absurd amounts of money off of this arrangement.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoNo, they aren't. The windows division has consistently shrank to the point it isn't even a top line revenue source for the company anymore and is rolled up into the experience and devices group with office, Xbox, etc. Windows is less than 12% of MS quarterly revenue and continuing to shrink: https://www.kamilfranek.com/microsoft-revenue-breakdown/ https://www.kamilfranek.com/microsoft-revenue-breakdown/ The company could totally lose all windows revenue tomorrow and barely notice it. In a few years it will probably be into the single digits of percent revenue and near total irrelevance. Windows is dead as any meaningful business for the company.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIt still makes additional money rented on the cloud, does it not? Not sure how that is counted.
- asddubs 4y agoputting aside that 12% is still a fair bit, I wonder how much value it brings them in more intangible ways, that would only become obvious if they "lost" windows.
- zamalek 4y agoDeveloper mindshare. There are a huge amount of developers who want Windows (or really Visual Studio proper), and there is a meticulously tarred highway from Windows to Azure. The irony is that this bullshit will drive developers away, because they are some of the least likely to put up with it.
- NazakiAid 4y agoGotta love how the only dismissal option is "Remind me later" and gives no option to not show again.
- add-sub-mul-div 4y agoThat's how the UI usually works, but there's never not been a registry setting that disables undesirable behavior like this in Windows. Hoping that continues to be the case. There's no OS that doesn't make me jump through hoops to get it in an acceptable state.
- JohnFen 4y ago> As Microsoft puts it: “We are continuing the exploration of badging on the Start menu with several new treatments for users logging in with local user accounts to highlight the benefits of signing in with a Microsoft account (MSA).” What is Microsoft really thinking here? You have to go out of your way (and probably do a web search) in order to figure out how to install Win 11 without using a Microsoft Account. So those people deliberately chose that -- they didn't avoid the MSA because they were unaware of the benefits, they did it because they were aware of the drawbacks and want to avoid them. Harassing them seems more likely to make them angry than to make them change their minds.
- dylan604 4y agoSo you're saying Windows has become nagware?
- copper-float 4y agoAbsolutely, well beyond nagware at this point (with default settings).
- hef19898 4y agoI vaguely remember a time when browsers would install all kind of crappy add-ons, or any other software installer for that matter. Now we reached a point were the OS does it...
- dylan604 4y agoDid the browser do that install, or did the user install something on their own that came with additional software? the infamous purple gorilla or whatever it was that you thought you were installing one thing, but a whole other thing was installed at the same time. sourceforge's dark UI of downloading software, but also downloading/installing a whole other program hidden behind a vaguely worded auto-selected checkbox. i just don't remember being able to blame the browser for this.
- acadapter 4y agoThere is no point in fighting against BS. It needs to be abandoned like many people did with Facebook.
- JohnFen 4y agoI abandoned Windows on my own machines over 20 years ago. Sadly, however, I'm still forced to use it at work. If I could abandon it there, too, I would in a heartbeat.
- Animats 4y agoI left at Windows 7, Microsoft's last good operating system. Amusingly, I have a product which runs on Windows. I develop it on Linux, cross-compile in Rust, and test and package using Wine. Works fine, with no need to run Windows myself. Now if I can get the cross-compile to work for MacOS...
- gumballindie 4y agoMove over to linux. KDE has the eye-candy, XFCE has the simplicity and OpenBOX is distraction free. Games work well and so do dev tools.
- ziml77 4y agoHow's HDR working over there?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rwl4 4y agoIt's coming along. Valve's gamescope has initial support implemented. https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/HDR_monitor_support https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/HDR_monitor_support
- gumballindie 4y agoNot ideal but my dual alienware setup looks stunning. A lot better than the ugly windows desktop i used to play games on and a lot more permissive than a mac.
- hackinthebochs 4y agoAre fonts still ugly as sin? That was the biggest drawback last time I tried linux as my main desktop. That and having to muck around in config files for every little thing.
- JohnFen 4y agoThe font situation is (in my opinion) fixed -- but this is more about the DE than Linux itself, so may depend on which DE you choose. And you haven't had to muck around in config files for a very long time (unless you're doing something exotic).
- genpfault 4y agoSadly something in the last few years knackered the kerning on stuff like Tahoma :(
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bottlepalm 4y agoIt’s funny for what is essentially a ‘file manager’ Microsoft makes it hell to manage your files. My friends and family and constantly confused by the 10 different interfaces there are for file management. Desktops are a mess of of half trash files. The cloud integration the file explorer is a confusing mess. The UI for saving a file from Office is the absolute worst. I’ve had to help someone just save a file and it was difficult even for me to figure out the UI — borderline comical how bad it is.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoSo depressing because Explorer from the 2k/XP era was best in class and about as complete and discoverable as a shell ever got.
- sodapopcan 4y agoXP was the best OS and I miss it. You had to switch it to use the classic 95/97/2000 skin, of course :) I haven't used Windows since.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThe shell yes. Lack of a decent terminal would sink it—besides the other reasons it is not suitable any longer... software support and security concerns. Reply edit: Guess you could putty into Linux, but not worth the hassle at that point.
- sodapopcan 4y agoOh right. I was writing spaghetti PHP in those days so never had use for a terminal, so I guess that is required context.
- Dagger2 4y agobash in mintty is pretty decent. mintty can do some things better than many terminals on Linux, even: https://mintty.github.io/mintty-gnuplot.png https://mintty.github.io/mintty-gnuplot.png
- ipcress_file 4y agoOne solution is to use Open-Shell instead of Microsoft's start menu: https://open-shell.github.io/Open-Shell-Menu/ https://open-shell.github.io/Open-Shell-Menu/ Stardock usually makes a replacement start menu too.
- izzydata 4y agoI actually bought Start 11 because of how annoying the default Windows 11 start menu was. This marks the first time I've ever bought software. Good work Microsoft. I obtained copies of Windows through some University thing with Windows Vista and Windows 7 and then those keys have somehow just worked up until Windows 10 and then they gave me Windows 11 upgrade for free. In case you were wondering how I have not ever paid for Windows.
- blincoln 4y agoHow well-supported is it? Looks like the last release was almost a year ago. Replacing the Windows shell, especially in Windows 10/11, with their constant updates, isn't something I'd recommend for non-experts, but I don't even do it myself anymore because it seems like none of the replacements are ever consistently supported in the long term.
- wvenable 4y agoOpen Shell has been around for a long time -- it's basically done so it doesn't need many updates. That being said, it actually isn't designed to work with Windows 11 (as the entire Taskbar has been re-written) but it does it actually work with it. Requires some extra customization of the settings to get it to look right. I've used Classic/Open Shell since Windows 7.
- ipcress_file 4y agoThis is my experience too. I've been using Classic Shell and then Open-Shell on Win10 at work for years. I was using Classic Shell on Windows 7 before that. It seems to just work for me. I've had no problems. I have a little nuc-style Windows 11 box for my TV, and I'd say we're in the typical "wait to update" period with Windows 11. Microsoft always introduces unwanted changes (Vista bling and lag, the entire Windows 8 desktop, the dumbed-down Windows 11 start menu), and then reworks the system to produce a compromise that institutions, businesses and conservative users can tolerate. Just the other day, I noticed the return of task manager access from the taskbar. By the time I adopt Windows 11 for work, I suspect that the worst design changes should be fixed and the third-party add-ons should work perfectly. That's been my experience in the past.
- dmitrygr 4y agoIf you need windows for some software, windows works well in a VM, shared folders for data, NO internet connectivity, windows update and windows defender completely deleted (mount the disk in linux and kill the executables). All other uses of windows are insane.
- pengaru 4y agoMS Windows is the daytime television of operating systems: If you're still using it in 2023 you have only yourself to blame. It's not like there aren't better options at your disposal...
- yetanotherloser 4y agoOr you need a niche application that's only available on Windows, or you don't want to rebuy it or a near equivalent for the Mac.
- Kye 4y agoOr don't want to buy a Mac when you already have a perfectly serviceable PC.
- yetanotherloser 4y agoAlso a good point. My family desktop isn't quite grandfather's axe but it would be wasteful to just dump it, and if I convert it to Linux some of the games my wife and kids want to play can't follow.
- stronglikedan 4y agoIn a lot of industries, there really aren't, unfortunately. Sure, there are other options in some cases, but they come at the expense of productivity, so they're not really better.
- mypornaccount 4y agoI just want an OS where; out of the box, I can play any game made in the last 20 years, change my mouse scroll speed, or set my background to a solid color.
- warkdarrior 4y agoYou can do all of those in Linux. For example, here's how to set the background to a solid color. Open a terminal and type the following four commands: gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.background picture-options 'none' gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.background primary-color '#004000' gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.background secondary-color '#306030' gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.background color-shading-type 'vertical' Source: https://askubuntu.com/questions/1272120/ubuntu-20-04-change-background-to-solid-colour https://askubuntu.com/questions/1272120/ubuntu-20-04-change-...
- mattferderer 4y agoMicrosoft would be wise to focus on quality of service, especially now with their Open AI partnership. Make me more productive & I'll gladly go find how I can upgrade my Microsoft services when I need to, no ads needed that add negativity to my opinion of Microsoft. Same with their Bing division, which was mentioned yesterday somewhat on the terrible decision of forcing people to view awful clickbait, low quality news articles. How about find out what someone is interested in first, then show information that is top quality only. Why a company like Microsoft is wanting to hang out in the gutters with low quality journalism stories is beyond me... Is the ad revenue worth tarnishing your brand & pushing people away? Create value for me & I'll give you way more of my data than I should.
- joering2 4y ago99% of my problems with Windows 10 and 11 ended up the moment I install simplewall. Nowadays they even have option to block future updates. Kudos to Henry for a great piece of software, as I do donate $100 once a year for all the time he saved me on dealing with BS operating system. (totally unrelated and don't know him) https://www.henrypp.org/product/simplewall https://www.henrypp.org/product/simplewall one more tip re W11: when you installing fresh copy, go for offline option (no MS account) - you can find online manual on how to enable it. Your Windows will look totally different and work faster if you go with offline version (MS assumes its a computer without network access)
- toddmorey 4y agoInception: I couldn't really see the image about too many ads in Windows 11 because TechRadar had it all covered up with an Axe Body Spray ad.
- izzydata 4y agoThere was a giant popup as soon as I loaded the page. This is after using ad removal extensions. Ads are out of control. https://i.imgur.com/KOU98Bw.png https://i.imgur.com/KOU98Bw.png
- userbinator 4y agoprotip: turn off JavaScript and whitelist it only on the sites you absolutely trust. Irritations like those will disappear completely, as will a huge chunk of your attack surface.
- mperham 4y agoIronic that the techradar article is also chock full of ad cancer. Doctor, cure thyself!
- dzader 4y agoApple music popping up everytime I accidentally hit play on my keyboard is a far more annoying ad than anything windows is doing.
- wiredfool 4y agoHalf the time I use that key to stop my music, teams randomly calls someone. The play/pause keys should work with any media player, (and might, or might not) but they’re in no way advertising random crap on your face when you’re trying to work.
- its_ethan 4y agohttps://github.com/tombonez/noTunes https://github.com/tombonez/noTunes
- forrestthewoods 4y agoLots of Windows hate on HN this week. It’s largely well deserved. Unpopular Opinion: I still prefer Windows to both macOS and Linux by an extremely wide margin. For both normal use and development. I’m extremely annoyed at all of the ad crap. And I probably wouldn’t recommend anything other than an iPad to my mother. But for devs Win11 is honestly somewhere in-between “just fine” and “ pretty good”.
- windowsrookie 4y agoI moved my whole family to Mac OS years ago. I primarily run Mac OS, But I keep a couple windows machines around just to stay familiar with the OS. I think I will switch my gaming desktop over to Linux at this point. I actually enjoy Microsofts other products like VS Code, Xbox, Etc. But Windows has never been my favorite OS, and now I actually dislike using it.
- elforce002 4y agoI recently switched to Mac OS and I won't go back to Microsoft.
- raffraffraff 4y agoI really really wish Affinity Photo (and publisher and designer) worked ok in Wine. I think maybe they'll work better in a year, but right now you need a patched wine, a chunk of a Windows machine and you still have to out up with crashing.
- DevKoala 4y agoI installed Windows on my Steam Deck to run some games a couple weeks ago. It came pre-loaded with tons of apps I didn’t request, and basic functionality that required me to sign in with an account. What a joke of an OS. I gave up, no game was worth the hassle.
- sleepybrett 4y agoI hope the steamdecks popularity makes game companies think better of supporting photon out of the box or maybe even considering a pure linux target.
- runjake 4y agoI wonder if all this advertising is some way to help justify the costs of continued development of Windows? From what I've heard, it's not a cash cow anymore. Anyone have any insight?
- LAC-Tech 4y agoThe only thing I need windows for now is to sign contracts, that come in PDF form. I have a laptop with windows 11 for that kind of stuff. Is there any software in linux that can insert my signature in a PDF, like adobes "fill & sign"?
- Svip 4y agoIf all you need is to insert an image of your signature onto a PDF, you can use Xournal.[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xournal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xournal
- lesquivemeau 4y agoI wish there was a linux app as intuitive as Mac os's stock pdf viewer/editor, it's as good as it gets when it comes to signing and reorganising documents
- graypegg 4y agoPreview.app! It’s seriously awesome. It’s the one thing I miss when using a flavour of Linux. You can fill and sign, but also redact (actually removes vectors under the redaction blob), combine multiple PDFs and rearrange pages. Does everything I would ever want to do with a PDF and it’s hidden inside what most people think is just the image viewer.
- dang 4y agoRelated: Microsoft is slowly rolling out ads in the Windows 11 start menu - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35545566 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35545566 - April 2023 (201 comments) Windows 11 KB5023778 update adds promotions to the Start menu - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35346137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35346137 - March 2023 (251 comments) Microsoft is turning Windows 11's Start Menu into an ad delivery system - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33694202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33694202 - Nov 2022 (143 comments) Microsoft tests 'upsells' of its products in Windows 11 sign-out menu - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33532448 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33532448 - Nov 2022 (32 comments) Microsoft is showing ads in the Windows 11 sign-out menu - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33513622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33513622 - Nov 2022 (15 comments) Microsoft mulling cheap PCs supported by ads, subscriptions - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497625 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497625 - Nov 2022 (8 comments) OneDrive Ad in Windows 11 Logout Menu - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33497269 - Nov 2022 (26 comments) Microsoft accidentally reveals that it is testing ads in Windows Explorer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30711277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30711277 - March 2022 (168 comments) Microsoft says Win11 Explorer ads were ‘not intended to be published externally’ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30701289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30701289 - March 2022 (23 comments) Latest build of Windows 11 has ads inside File Explorer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30689526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30689526 - March 2022 (12 comments) Microsoft is testing ads in the Windows 11 File Explorer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30675908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30675908 - March 2022 (504 comments)
- pbz 4y agoThese kinds of changes just make the OS look cheap (like a bazaar of sorts). They're visually ugly, but easily ignored (I rarely open the start menu). What I'm more concerned / annoyed by is the trend of Windows fighting with you. For example, try to disable the real-time antivirus protection. The UI makes it look like it's off, but then it turns back on by itself. Then you go to group policy to make it explicit that you don't want it. It's off for a bit and then it freaking changes the group policy (resets it back). First time I noticed it do this I though I got hacked because I couldn't imagine the OS doing something so malware-ish, but it does. What's the point of having a setting at all?
- hef19898 4y agoMaybe time fro another, huge, anti-competitive fie from the EU, like when back when MS did all those shenanigans around internet Explorer? I wouldn't be surprised of we see similar proceedings in the next years around cloud services (everything from OneDrive to Azure and equivilants, Office, you name it) once the EU is done with mobile devices.
- CRConrad 4y ago> Maybe time fro another, huge, anti-competitive fie from the EU, like when back when MS did all those shenanigans around internet Explorer? ITYM pro-competitive. It was Microsoft's behaviour that was anti-competitive.
- yarg 4y agoI tried to play spider solitaire not too long ago. It used to be a clean simple application, now it's adware - literal adware in the professional version of a non-free OS. Utter fucking madness. I quit in disgust and had another go at Tumbleweed. Windows 11 made KDE better.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 4y agoValve (Steam Deck) using it and paying devs to fix things also helps.
- debug-desperado 4y agoMicrosoft Edge just created a logged-in profile on my machine for the second time. I'm not even sure how - maybe it's because I logged into Bing to play with their chat? I'm on a Windows 10 Local account and this is getting old. EDIT, think I finally found out the option under Profile Preferences: "Automatic sign in on Microsoft Edge If you're not signed in currently on Microsoft Edge, we'll automatically sign you in by using your sign in info from other Microsoft sites like Outlook."
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoDo you mean that by signing in to the Edge browser, Microsoft turned your local account into a Microsoft Account?
- bsnnkv 4y agoThis is pretty depressing. I'm pretty involved in the ricing side of the Windows ecosystem[1] and there is a lot of work going on in this space to allow users to get rid of the start bar entirely and replace it with something more functional. I would love for the day when there could just be a user friendly drop-in replacement. [1]: I develop one of the two main Windows twms (https://github.com/LGUG2Z/komorebi https://github.com/LGUG2Z/komorebi)
- mihaaly 4y agoI am already hanging on a thread about the user hostile ignorant practices making Windows acceleratingly worse working with. Introducing advertisements into an expensive, eroding usability, arrogantly formated system may tip me over if adverts are not easily and permanently avoidable. Will I need to give up my job as developer on Windows platform? It does not worth my health the rapidly increasing frustration and anxiety its everyday use causes. I will study the situation very closely and decide upon if I need to seek a different occupation soon. I only have this one life and I do not want to suffer through of it.
- szundi 4y agoThese leadership there will go until they hit the wall. Mr Cook is happy having an OS that just lets you work.
- bastardoperator 4y agoPlenty of us at MSFT won't even use a windows desktop because of decisions like this. I don't know who's in charge here, but way to go on killing the goodwill of everyone elses work with stupid features everyone actually hates.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoI dunno what it's like nowadays, but when I was at MSFT during the win8/early win10 times, the internal mailing lists where 10x as angry and vicious as what you saw in public. Microsoft employees loved Windows and were fucking pissed that it was getting ruined. I guess they've all been beaten into submission and/or managed out by now..
- Spivak 4y agoWell yeah, I would be pissed too if I couldn't go home proud of the work I did. Like what is even the point of pouring you heart and soul into a thing if by the time anyone sees it it's just a wall of ads?
- userbinator 4y agoPlenty of us at MSFT won't even use a windows desktop because of decisions like this. Unfortunately, doing that only reinforces the impression that that the people who use it like these abhorrent additions.
- skilled 4y agoFirst it was Apple who fucked up the butterfly keyboard and out of spite I just said "no thanks" and bought a HP laptop with a beefy GPU instead. Never looked back, until now. I'm using Windows on the said laptop and just in the last couple of months they have started adding more and more "interactive" horseshit that is simply meant to peddle their Edge browser and Bing search engine. I mean, did you know that Microsoft Teams can hijack your Dev Console and interpret a HEX color code as a phone number? It literally hijacks the console and interrupts you from doing any kind of debugging. My next purchase is 100% going to be Apple again since I've heard great things about the new chips and keyboard issues seem to be solved also. Microsoft is just doing dumb stuff right now, like really dumb and anti-user. Needless say, they have no shame to do this towards their paying customers, too.
- torh 4y agoA few weeks ago I got fed up with Windows 11. I remember I had to unplug my machine from the internet while installing Windows 10, and in a weak moment I must have accepted upgrading to Windows 11. It was probably bound to happen, because the question kept popping up all innocent looking: "Hey, want to install a security update... and while you're at it, Windows 11?" Well, back to me being fed up. I've installed Linux (Ubuntu, since it turns out DisplayLink drivers suck on anything else), and I'm quite happy with it. It works and it doesn't brother me too much. I don't see any reason to install Windows again.
- rochak 4y agoMicrosoft improves Windows Challenge: Impossible
- EntropyDenied 4y agoDo people not realize how easy these are to turn off? I've been running Windows 11 for over a year and haven't seen a single ad.
- barbazoo 4y agoPretty annoying how everyone chooses outrage instead.
- sleepybrett 4y agoHow about supporting microsoft with ad dollars being OPT-IN not OPT-OUT.
- barbazoo 4y agoThat would be nice, sure, but not a big deal I think either.
- softfalcon 4y agoI shouldn’t have to “turn off” ads in the first place. Why am I paying $100+ for Windows Pro if they’re still gonna plop ads onto my desktop by default?
- b800h 4y agoI keep on thinking about getting a gaming laptop running Windows in order to occasionally run some Win-only games and programs. This is probably the strongest factor preventing me from doing so.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoIn 2025, Microsoft will own search and Google will own the desktop OS
- deafpolygon 4y agoAnd we still won't have year of the Linux desktop, as Google will fork Windows 11 in an exchange deal with Microsoft.
- sleepybrett 4y agoremember when you paid for software to get rid of the ads?
- snapcaster 4y agoI haven't used windows in a really long time but are there really ads in the START MENU? jesus christ
- f6v 4y agoI only use it for games, so not paying too much attention. There’re definitely some local content being loaded by default(like news) which by itself is horrible.
- tored 4y agoMicrosoft, if I own a Pro license then why can’t I get a pro experience?
- widowlark 4y agothey believe us to be stupid
- userbinator 4y agos/believe/want/
- tacker2000 4y agoAt this point Windows is just Malware. You dont have any control over anything anymore, it keeps switching things back, force-logging you in etc…
- ok_dad 4y agoI recently bought a MacBook for myself, moving from Linux because it was a pain to manage with the amount of time I have to manage it (zero). My wife also got the same model, moving from Windows because of 11 being shitty. Where MS has changed the Windows UI look and flow a million times since I started using it with Windows 3.0 or so, I still recognize extremely similar or exactly the same UI on my MacBook as on a MacBook I owned in 2013, and on the Macs I used as a kid in like 1990! It's absolutely awesome that the UI is improved, but the same-ish.
- andrewstuart 4y agoIt’s sad that Microsoft does understand that the best windows is minimal, without bloat, trahware and ads.
- Rimintil 4y ago> bloat What _is_ bloat to people? Is it because it has Candy Crush pre-installed? The Settings menu? The install is bigger than Windows 3.11 so it's bloated?
- racl101 4y agoOne Step forward and two steps back.
- dahwolf 4y agoOld Microsoft is back, unashamed to aggressively push their own services from a still monopolistic platform. What this tells us is that tech regulation is a joke, fallen asleep. They were fined for this exact practice a long time ago. To simply do it again in this fearless way is really telling. They're confident that they can get away with it.
- jerry1979 4y agoDo people see Windows as a secure operating system for the purposes of corporate work? Is there a way companies can turn this stuff off so employees don't engage with the content and accidentally give away sensitive information?
- zamadatix 4y agoOf course. The Enterprise and Server versions of Windows are like a different world of user experience and OS control from e.g. Home.
- jeppester 4y agoWindows won't get better as long as their consumer unfriendly behaviour has no effect on sales. The EU (or some other authority) should force Windows licenses to be a separate purchase. The machines could still come with Windows preloaded, but then require a license key to unlock. It would open the doors for competition and force MS to make Windows a compelling product that users would want to pay for.
- npteljes 4y ago> Windows won't get better as long as their consumer unfriendly behaviour has no effect on sales. I agree. And MS agrees too - which is why they do the bundling thing with new computers, deals for schools, bribes for governments, and making their moat as wide as they can. The EU already does a funny thing with the licenses too. They come with the computer yes, but they are not married like how they are in the US. They are legally required to be able to be separated after purchase. So, the second hand market is full of licenses like this - you can pick up a Win 10 for $7, Office 2019 for $11, and so on.
- twelve40 4y agothis is a useful reminder for all the optimistic people who are dreaming that MS will take over web search to liberate us from Google ads.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDoesn’t Microsoft have enough money?
- oogabooga13 4y agoThe assault on the Start Menu continues as planned...
- robbywashere_ 4y agoIt’s interesting to see adware go from being this undesirable loathed and parasitic thing being covertly installed on a users pc to Microsoft now shipping their own.
- Wensio 4y agoMy computer was so old that I was able to log in on a local user account. After I upgraded, I couldnt believe that I had to stay online to use my computer. I messed with some settings and moved on. Then I right clicked and almost had a stroke.
- glonq 4y agoI am confident that somebody will very quickly produce tools for disabling these ads. In fact, thanks in advance!
- drbawb 4y ago>"Thinking realistically, every software I use with the notable exception of Windows and DaVinci Resolve switched to a subscription model. If Microsoft doesn't do that and pushes its OneDrive and 365 subs via the task bar every now and then I'm personally okay with that. Better than paying $$$ every month just to use the OS." OneDrive and Office is the subscription for Windows. Having worked in a repair shop I can tell you that the layperson thinks the OS is synonymous with "their data" and "their applications." If you said to them verbatim that you're "reinstalling their OS", and you give them back a computer with all their "Recently Used" menus empty, missing programs, all default settings, browser favorites are gone, their Outlook PST is missing, and the Office Key you ripped off the machine was an OEM license that won't activate through normal channels: that individual is going to be very cross with you. Turns out it's really hard to sell retail customers "nothing for something", and to the average person an empty Windows install is useless. Gate their productivity suite (input) and storage (output) behind a subscription, though, and suddenly you have a customer hooked for life. I've also seen this playout with Apple Users: their iCloud subscription lapses, or their storage on the free tier runs out, and it stops syncing photos and videos. Eventually the phone takes a dive in the ocean, or a toilet, or just dies of old age. The user goes to the Apple store and is emotionally devastated when they sign in to iCloud on their new phone only to find it is missing the last year of their life. Users aren't going to swear off Apple products, the backup and usability story on Android is a nightmare by comparison, they're just going to let the Genius Bar upsell them into the $2.99 protection racket. --- It's also worth noting that Windows Enterprise is already a subscription. To use Enterprise (GA servicing channel) you need to have an Windows E3/E5 license, or active Software Assurance. The problem is these subscriptions only work because Microsoft has the power to audit VL customers, and those customers tend to have the pockets to pay up remediation or legal fees. _The only reason Windows Home/Pro are not subscriptions is because Microsoft never figured out the economics of auditing retail consumers._ If consumers are leasing their storage and programs from you, though, it turns out you don't need to audit them.
- liendolucas 4y agoSometimes I feel so damn lucky that I use an OS like FreeBSD (or alternatively GNU/Linux when working) where literally nothing gets in your way. It's ridiculous that a paying product stamps ads in front of your face just like that. I really feel sorry for the people that are not techies that then they just get hit by the next furious wave of ads when they proceed to browse the web, without installing any browsing counter-measures. When I go back in time in my mind and remember the old days where I played on Windows 95/98/XP platforms, those were damn clean OSes by today standards. I can't understand how they have gone this way and ruined what is supposed to be their flagship product.
- pjs_ 4y agoI like the ads. They spice up my day and give me something fun and interesting to look at when I'm bored at work. Plus I find it positive to see adverts for useful and enjoyable products and services. Thanks Microsoft for putting these ads in my Start Menu where they are handy and easy to find. Maybe they could also put some adverts for products and services that are relevant to my interests into other parts of the operating system. I would personally enjoy the opportunity to see exciting new products in Explorer search results, or while making changes in the Registry Editor, for example. Just my 2c!
- umvi 4y agoSame, hopefully they can even figure out how to inject video adverts into Windows Media Player, i.e. when you double click one of your mp4s to play. That way it's almost like having an offline YouTube experience right there in your native OS
- booleandilemma 4y agoGood idea. I would love text ads every time I open PowerShell. Sort of like fortune on Linux, but obviously more practical.
- ragazzina 4y agoI personally would like ads in Teams, so that when I am talking to my coworkers, and mention for example, virtual machines, a nice popup tells me which virtual reality headset just got released. If I mention a user opening a ticket, the popup tells me which attorney close to me can help me fight traffic violations.
- koromak 4y agoWe might not be from the same species
- lumb63 4y agoGood. Please expedite the fall of Windows. It’s slow, bloated, buggy, and sounds like it’s about to become more so. I know it isn’t feasible for non-tech folks, but I haven’t looked back once since I left Windows for good. I haven’t touched a Windows PC since I left my last job last year, and I couldn’t be happier.
- bojangleslover 4y agoWindows is dysgenic
- rationalfaith 4y ago[dead]
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoThis makes me thankful that my desktop "isn't able to support" Windows 11 for whatever reason, despite having relatively decent capacity ( i7-6700K CPU @ 4.00GHz, 32gb DDR4).
- swayvil 4y agoAdvertising is so wretchedly filthy and vile. If it appeared in my os I'd switch. Have you tried Debian?
- JenrHywy 4y agoI just bought my first Mac in 20+ years, in no small part because of how terrible Win11 is. This seems to validate that choice.
- grogenaut 4y agowho even uses the start menu. on windows, mac, and linux I basically just hit windows key and type a part of the program name and hit enter, I don't see it. Half the time my start menu is on the monitor that's swapped to my work laptop.
- pmarreck 4y agoAs soon as most gaming is easy on Linux (which is arguably already the case, although it's still not as brain-dead simple as on Windows), Windows will lose its hegemony. So stuff like this will just accelerate that, which is great.
- userbinator 4y agoFriendly reminder that archive.org (amongst other places) has basically every older version of Windows ISOs you can download and try out in a VM to see what the experience was like in the "good old days".
- natnatenathan 4y agoThis is really easy to fix -- stop using Windows. Microsoft is going to continue pushing the boundaries as long as nothing bad happen to their core business.
- graypegg 4y agoNot easy at all, but every day it’s slowly getting easier.
- jaimex2 4y agoSwitch to Kubuntu for a really great Linux experience. Plasma Desktop is fantastic. Gaming? Install Heroid Launcher and Steam - you'll have a better experience than on Windows. Wine is crazy good these days as well for all the other corpo crapware we all rely on. Enjoy not having to reboot daily for stupid updates. The more people switching means MS will have to get their act together and Linux will get better support from big companies. Win win.
- FounderBurr 4y agoThis sticker is dangerous and inconvenient, but I do love fig newtons.
- gigatexal 4y agoThis was one of the main reasons I moved 100% to Linux and never thought about Windows + WSL as an alternative.
- wharfjumper 4y agoI hope Microsoft continues to degrade Windows which will result in improved competition.
- dgan 4y agoI can't even consider an OS with ads to be a valid candidate. If I have to choose between seeing stupid trash in my OS, or using a half-baked under-linux (which is how I call Mac), then half-baked under-linux it is.
- eljimmy 4y agoI wish Valve would try to build a desktop OS. They surely have the bankroll to do something like that. I'm curious what percentage of Windows users are only using it for gaming? Are there any stats on that?
- Barrin92 4y agoThe Steam deck already runs Arch and you can use the thing as a desktop computer, so that OS pretty much is just Linux. Valve has invested a lot to make the ecosystem better and I've little doubt they'll continue to do just that.
- somenameforme 4y agoHot take: We're nearing the peak size of corporations, and in 20 years the average corporation will be smaller, rather than larger. There's a simple reason. The reason Microsoft is doing stuff like this is because they're absolutely enormous. They have baseline costs in the tens of billions of dollars. You simply can't recoup that with individual product releases, where even a breakaway hit would cover a fraction of your costs for a single year. You need rent, and so they're rent seeking in every possible endeavor. And many other companies are in the exact same boat. But both advertising and direct rent (e.g. pay us $10/month for your OS license) have theoretic limits. $10/month sounds awesome (from both a creator and consumer perspective) for a product that might have otherwise cost hundreds of dollars, until you get into the domain of a million companies doing the exact same thing. $10/month * n subscriptions becomes unviable at some point, and probably a relatively low point for the vast majority of people. It's kind of similar to what happened to Netflix. As more Netflix competitors emerged (and Netflix itself began to struggle), the cost to simply watch what you want skyrocketed, and consequently - so did 'piracy.' And similarly with advertising. People can only physically watch so many ads. And for every advertised product, the value of advertising for a new company becomes relatively less. In other words if you're the only person advertising, in existence, everybody's going to know about you. If there are a million comparable products being advertised, then even a large advertising budget may yield negligible returns. It's a tragedy of the commons, or more precisely - of the commoner.
- jasfi 4y agoSurely they make a ton from their cloud services. I wouldn't think they needed to make more money from Windows over and above the license fees. This is more likely revenue optimization. I'm happy with my move to Fedora!
- jackvalentine 4y agoIf a 365 subscription is what it takes to never show me ads and just be an operating system, so be it. But it _isn’t_. There is still crapware pre-installed on a ‘pro’ edition. There is still tabloid news pushed in the taskbar for… reasons?
- wellthisisgreat 4y agoHot take: it’s not really Microsoft’s fault or responsibility, as there is no Microsoft to be responsible or faulted for this craziness. It’s one individual (or two? Or a small team, but really not that big of a group) who is rotten to the core and is so career-obsessed they don’t understand that they are making lives of millions of people worse with this, so that they can just show their PowerPoint to higher up. It is a personal responsibility of a PM / engineer (unlikely) to not come up with this cancer.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe org doesn’t promote PMs who have those ethics, so they never get to make these calls the correct way. The company wants this, long term at least, and select the people that will do it via hiring and promo.
- wellthisisgreat 4y agowell my point is that nobody can really pin anything on "Microsoft" but surely there are people who chose this kind of approach to advance themselves. Versus building new tools or experiences, etc. etc. This is on some specific people's conscience, nobody made them do it in a way an angry tiger makes people try to run away. It was some one or two people's choice. Were there other people in their place, we would have never had this problem.
- ChoGGi 4y agoI just wish I could open the new win 10/11 settings app without having explorer.exe running in the background.
- thewileyone 4y agoI turned off everything, removed, everything that I don't think I would use and Windows 11 is fine for me.