13 ms·
This is a perfect example of an airport trying to have their cake and eat it too, and it's kind of diabolically clever. On the one hand, airports need to make
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is a perfect example of an airport trying to have their cake and eat it too, and it's kind of diabolically clever.
On the one hand, airports need to make money, and with people buying cheap airline tickets, airports have found a solution by turning themselves halfway into malls, and charging businesses extremely high levels of rent, which the airport justifies because it's a captive audience that can't go anywhere else. Most of the $15 sandwich is ultimately going to the airport as rent, not to the CIBO food vendor as profit.
But at the same time, there's public outcry over the absurd pricing, so the airport has to mollify lawmakers by insisting it'll come up with a policy where they won't charge more than 10% for what would be comparable in Midtown. The airport is trying to blame those greedy vendors! But this is a trick. Who could ever define that? Sure you can compare Starbucks with Starbucks... but you can't compare a CIBO sandwich because it doesn't exist outside of airports, which is by design. That's the whole point, that easy comparables don't exist, and when a journalist tries to use a FOIA request to get at the comparables, they're stonewalled.
The airport is trying to insist it's preventing jacked-up prices, when in reality it's the airport charging rent that generates those jacked-up prices in the first place, and it tries to pretend like it plays no part. Evil, but clever.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoYou are spot on and correct. Airports make about 2/3rds of their money with rent, and only 1/3rd with flights.
- andsoitis 4y agoWhere is that information from?
- danenania 4y agoAren’t airports also heavily subsidized? How much does that account for? There’s a special place in hell for the executives of taxpayer subsidized services that turn around and gouge their customers.
- kevviiinn 4y agoI wonder how much those executives make
- xnx 4y ago$15 sandwich is better than no sandwich available
- RC_ITR 4y ago> But at the same time, there's public outcry over the absurd pricing, so the airport has to mollify lawmakers by insisting it'll come up with a policy where they won't charge more than 10% for what would be comparable in Midtown. My related take in this is that airports are expensive to maintain because you waste a ton of space on vendors and seating areas. If airports were just shacks next to a runway, they’d be much cheaper to run. So you can’t really charge people for sitting/waiting (though the private clubs sort of do just that). Then you charge people for the other purpose (rent on vendors) and that pays for everything. But you can’t tell your customers “it’s actually really expensive to build these giant buildings to just hold CIBOs and Dufry” since they won’t believe you (or worse call for smaller more efficient airports to be built with fewer services). So you just sort of play this very bizarre merchandising game.
- anyonecancode 4y ago> If airports were just shacks next to a runway, they’d be much cheaper to run. Flew Ryan air once to, I think it was some airport nearish to Venice, Italy. And it was pretty much a shack next to the runway. Walk down the steps off the plane into a small building, notice a conveyor belt. Walk through the next door, pick your luggage off the same conveyor belt. Walk through the next door, you're at the bus stop.
- odiroot 4y ago> My related take in this is that airports are expensive to maintain because you waste a ton of space on vendors and seating areas. If airports were just shacks next to a runway, they’d be much cheaper to run. That was literally Berlin airport, before it sadly closed.
- Ekaros 4y agoAirports are pretty expensive. To run and build. Managing and up keeping massive land area isn't cheap. And the buildings themselves are also big and have quite a lot of staff and specialised stuff going around.
- kevviiinn 4y agoHow much profit do airports report?
- robocat 4y agoMy local example would be ~3% dividends for Auckland Airport, which is a premier airport within NZ (Wellington and Christchurch get fewer international flights). I don’t think they have done any share buybacks in the last decade. Auckland International Airport Ltd (AIAL) was floated on the (Australian) Stock Exchange in Feb-1999, making it one of the first gateway airports globally to be listed publicly. [Auckland city council has reduced its ownership] to the current 18% https://dividendyield.co.nz/viewdetails.php?loc=AIA https://dividendyield.co.nz/viewdetails.php?loc=AIA https://www.google.com/finance/quote/AIA:ASX?window=MAX https://www.google.com/finance/quote/AIA:ASX?window=MAX
- systemtest 4y agoYour average international airport staffs tens of thousands of people.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIn UK we have a very clever system - The taxpayer builds all the airports. We wait and see which ones turn out to have large demand and reliable revenues. Then we privatise large international airports.. Meanwhile the smaller loss-making airports stay in public ownership because no-one wants to buy them.
- kevviiinn 4y agoMake three people rich while making the government look bad at the same time. Brilliant
- brycelarkin 4y agoDo cheap tickets actually impact airport revenue? My understanding is that airlines pay a set price per takeoff and landing. So airports should generate constant revenue regardless of fluctuation in ticket prices.
- tomrod 4y agoSecond order effects of higher airline fees would include airlines running less flights as people choose alternative options when facing higher passthrough pricing (tax by another name). This impacts airport profits.
- lozenge 4y agoIs that per seat or per plane? Seats have been getting packed closer together.
- Symbiote 4y agoYes, at least in Europe. Ryanair is infamous for pushing a very hard bargain with airports, but it's common with all the low-cost airlines. Part of the airport's willingness to give Ryanair a discount is the expectation of full planes with a lot of seats, so there are more people to sell to. e.g. [1] Table 6, Warsaw Modlin airport charges Ryanair 6 PLN (€1.30) per passenger, vs the normal 40 PLN (€8.50). That's obviously significant when they sell flights for €15 or so. [1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317710545_International_tourism's_impact_on_regional_autonomy_Evidence_from_2004_EU_accession_countries/link/59e5358e458515250246f69a/download https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317710545_Internati...
- JadedEngineer 4y agoI wish airports didn't do that and Ryanair had to close down. One can only dream.
- incone123 4y agoIs your complaint with that airline or with budget airlines in general? I'm old enough to remember when a 1 hour flight in Europe would still have hot drinks and snacks served included in the ticket price, but I don't really need that for short haul and I'm glad to pay less for a ticket.
- MAGZine 4y agoany airport that actually cares will adapt a policy like PDX's street pricing, and then actually furnish the airport with places that exist out in the real world--not just these weird airport-only chains (who tf is wolfgang puck) or one-offs (e.g. "TrendyNeighbourhood Burger," "TouristDistrict Tavern") I guess a really nice, mall-like airport with amenities you don't want to use (because they're too expensive) is still slightly better than a smaller airport whose amenities you don't use (because they don't exist). At least you have an option, though it doesn't stop it from being annoying. Sidenote, maybe LAX needs $15 sandos if it means they can afford to unshit their airport.
- grishka 4y ago> actually furnish the airport with places that exist out in the real world I clearly remember a Burger King in one of Moscow airports, probably DME. It is a regular Burger King serving everything one would expect, except the 1.5x prices.
- martyvis 4y agoIn Australia most of the airports have Macca's or KFC selling at street prices. I think that sets precedent for the other food outlets to not price gouge.
- yibg 4y agoThere is a Burger King in sfo. But yea more pricey
- boring_twenties 4y agoThere is a Wendy's in the Vegas airport. It's conveniently located next to a bar
- inferiorhuman 4y agowho tf is wolfgang puck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfgang_Puck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfgang_Puck Just a guy who's got three Michelin starred restaurants.
- amadeuspagel 4y agoHow is a system that enables cheap airline tickets for everyone by selling expensive sandwiches to people who can afford it evil?
- mcv 4y agoIt's luring people into flying more than they should (which is polluting), and then trying to make up the difference by trapping those people in an area where they can only by ridiculously overpriced stuff. The right thing to do would be more expensive airline tickets that account for the total cost of flying (including the pollution they cause) and then charging an honest price for the sandwiches. I mean, this sandwich costs almost as much as some airline tickets.
- kevviiinn 4y agoHey just bring your own food! Oh wait, I guess you can't thanks to security theatre. Guess you'll starve or fork over $15 for a shitty sandwich Too bad we can't have nice trains. I mean Amtrak is okay but it doesn't even compare to the rail systems in other countries. Guess we're stuck polluting too. Thanks, Elon
- elijaht 4y agoI’ve never been denied bringing food through security for US domestic flights. Do other areas prohibit that?
- phendrenad2 4y agoI don't think this goes deep enough. The company ultimately putting the squeeze on is the company that makes the in-flight snack food. This company has raised prices consistently since 1960, and these price hikes are being passed on to consumers, by way of airlines demanding that airports take a smaller cut. If you want to look for blame, look there.
- hgsgm 4y agoHow can that be possible? The in flight snack company is in a highly competitive business -- airlines could buy store brand private label snacks.
- dlgeek 4y agoI think GP is referring to the stores in the airports post-security that sell take-away food intended to be consumed on the plane - e.g. Hudson News, etc.
- grogenaut 4y agoShow me an industry that hasn't raised prices since the 60s.
- illiarian 4y ago> ultimately going to the airport as rent, not to the CIBO food vendor as profit. In food services in general there's this weird thing that the ultimate price on the product doesn't matter. The food-selling place will have paper-thin margins regardless. It will either be rent, or equipment and cutlery, or the need for highly trained and specialised staff, or... (and often all of those, and more, coupled together).
- LegitShady 4y agothis hasn't been my experience at all - usually the cost of food is 1/3 overhead (rent, staff), 1/3 ingredients, and 1/3 profit. At least in places that last.
- csomar 4y agoThat’s spot on the calculation. A relative runs a place and he just multiplies ingredients by x3.
- crazygringo 4y agoAverage profit margins in restaurants are 2–6%. Not 33%. The actual rule of thumb is one third ingredients, one third labor, and one third overhead including rent. And you hope to have a tiny sliver of profit left over, by making them a hair less than a third. But that's also just a rule of thumb, as both labor costs and rental costs have a great deal of geographic variation compared to ingredient costs.
- LegitShady 4y agoaverage profits in the realm of 2% are for grocery stores not restaurants. Lets say you're a moderately successful restaurant that sells 200 breakfasts at $10 each. At 2% profit that means the total profit on 200 breakfasts is just $40 for the whole morning. You're just out to lunch and those are not the correct profit margins or realistic. You might be thinking about grocery stores whose net margins might be in that realm of 2-4%. I don't know where you got your understanding of how the pricing works but please don't run a restaurant. Your mistake is that you have separated overhead and labour, when they're out of the same 1/3. 1/3 overhead including rent, 1/3 ingredients, 1/3 in the pocket.
- 88913527 4y agoIf high sandwich prices are a tax to cover the operation costs, it's certainly an odd one. Why should people who pack their own travel food be subsidized by those who are not?
- TheSoftwareGuy 4y agoSeems like a convenience tax to me. People who are willing to pay the high prices at the airport, are probably less price sensitive, (read: more wealthy). So yeah, let’s let the rich subsidize the poor
- raydev 4y ago> with people buying cheap airline tickets, airports have found a solution by turning themselves halfway into malls This is entirely overlooking the fact that you are a captive of the airport as long as the TSA screening process exists. At best, going through security is annoying and adds anywhere from 5 minutes to 2 hours of wait time, and at worst it is legitimately traumatizing. Prices are high simply because people are punished for leaving on foot, and people are prohibited from bringing many goods through security.
- crubier 4y agoYeah, Airport security is not useless, I'm not against it, but at the same time it's undeniable that the airport shopping industry can thank terrorist groups for justifying the existence of this absolutely inefficient system that keeps millions of people captive of their greediness..
- noirbot 4y agoI would be curious to compare to the 90s though. I remember when I was younger, I'd sometimes just go to the airport back when you could just walk out to the gates, grab a snack and then watch the planes take off and land. Obviously that's not a "normal" thing to have done, but in a world with lighter security, I remember airport food being around the same level as mall food court options, so it was an interesting option for getting out of the house. I'd be curious if there's some lower-security path towards making Airports more of a common space, not that there's any chance of it happening.
- bobthepanda 4y agoChangi in Singapore is very much a common space, because the security is at the gate.
- paulmooreparks 4y agoNot really. A boarding pass is required for airside access.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> The airport is trying to insist it's preventing jacked-up prices, when in reality it's the airport charging rent that generates those jacked-up prices in the first place, and it tries to pretend like it plays no part. But that's correct. The rent charged by the airport has no impact on prices inside the airport. They are high because of the captive audience. Store revenue within the airport is determined by customer willingness to pay. Willingness to pay does not take store rent into account; it is a function of prices and alternatives. So the stores set prices at the level that maximizes revenue, and the rent charged by the airport is a fight between the stores and the airport over who gets how much of the revenue. If you limited the amount of rent the airport could charge, the first-order effect would be that prices would stay exactly the same, the airport would get less money, every store would get more money, and customers would be completely unaffected. If you wanted to return money to the customers, you'd need to increase the level of competition between stores.
- ajmurmann 4y agoThis seems true, since McDonald's prices inside an airport seem to be either three danger as outside or just a little more. They for sure never reach the astronomical heights of other airport vendors.
- legohead 4y agoSounds like basic capitalism to me. You have a captive audience, charge them until they refuse the price. Same thing happens at stadiums, although not quite as bad as airports, but the prices - especially for the quality - are pretty ridiculous. I've only been to a few bars, but I also scoffed at the prices there as well.
- jancsika 4y ago> Who could ever define that? The Port Authority: "based on the average of three lowest prices for Comparable Products at the approved Comparable Concession Locations" Per this definition from the specification, they were required to go out see what prices "comparable concession locations" charge for a turkey san, take the three lowest prices from that search, add them together, then divide by 3. There are parts of the SVG spec that aren't this well specified. > That's the whole point, that easy comparables don't exist, and when a journalist tries to use a FOIA request to get at the comparables, they're stonewalled. If that were true there would have been no reason to stonewall. Just release the three prices and the names of the vendors used, and watch NYC argue endlessly over the details of "comparable" turkey san vendors. But with the stonewalling this sounds a lot more like, "Let's just charge $14.99 and call it a day," and then forget about it-- because who in their right mind would ever do a Woodward&Bernstein on a goddamm' turkey san price at the airport? And then Christopher Robbins over here is like, "JFK airport, fuck ya' life, that's who!" Edit: clarifications
- Aeolun 4y ago> If that were true there would have been no reason to stonewall. Just release the three prices and the names of the vendors used I think you’ll find that the list includes things like “Airport stand A”, “Airport stand B” and “Airport stand C”
- Aeolun 4y agoIf this were the case it should be easy for the vendor to say that $9 of that 15 is based on rent.
- victor106 4y agoAdd to this the fact that TSA won’t even let you take a bottom water through.
- Spooky23 4y agoThe companies that owns these concessionaires have a reputation for lobbying practices that are pretty “aggressive”. There’s a handful of companies (Delaware North, HMS, OTG, etc) that are in this business and if you know the business, it’s usually pretty easy to understand the scope/requirements. It’s pretty easy for a journalist to get the RFP/extension/whatever. I’d guess that there are journalists figuring out the business now.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> The airport is trying to insist it's preventing jacked-up prices, when in reality it's the airport charging rent that generates those jacked-up prices in the first place, and it tries to pretend like it plays no part. Evil, but clever. The same situation applies to the rest of the economy - people celebrate their house going up in value, without realising that your plumber and coffee will also go up in price, because the plumber's and the barista's rent has just gone up! Even if you never have to buy a house, rising house prices mean that every service around you becomes more expensive because they've got to pay rent. Industry didn't just move out because western workers want too much money, they moved out because western landlords want too much money.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI would say another reason the sandwiches cost so much is because so many remain unsold. You have to start with the assumption that things like this are only intended for the very well-heeled to begin with, particularly in this price range where the difference between about $2 and $20 is not actually significant to the buyer. It is well-known that most travelers are not in this catagory, and plenty of millionaires will not ever spend close to $20 at the high end for something recognized as worth $2 at the low end. Even if they could do it without any financial pain. Sometimes that's how they got to be millionaires anyway. Anyway, you've got to have more than enough sandwiches for every one of the real high-rollers who might be passing through that day, you would never want to have less than enough. Plus every now and then someone else will get hungry enough to bite. There's no intention for there to be alternative choices which are more economical. So a lot of the sandwiches are going to go to waste. So they need to be able to afford to make enough to waste most of them. Which could only result in spiraling costs. Overpriced lower-quality outcomes follow greed in a self-fulfilling way when you do the math, but when all benefit is directed only to the greedy party, it does no-one any good since they are not capable of being fulfilled. Apply this to so many other parts of the economy, and look what we have. More greed and more waste to go with it, and ordinary workers can't afford what they once could.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoIIUC, there's essentially a few vendors that own the vast majority of space in most airports, and the reason rents are so high, is because they outbid everyone (knowing that they can charge $15 for a bologna sandwich)- not because the asking rent starts high. The problem is the business model - which could be considered price gauging - not the airport.
- solatic 4y ago> airports need to make money Let's start with this presumption: do they really? Are they privately held? Why? Were they built with private money or public money? Isn't the purpose of airports to facilitate access to the local economy, thus benefitting local businesses, and should thus be funded from general tax revenue? Like so much in the US, payment is demanded for anything of remotely private benefit, even if the majority of the benefit is to the commons. Take TSA Pre-Check, or Global Entry as an example. In other countries, these programs (electronic entry) are the default for all citizens, provided for free, because they make airport operations more efficient as a whole, which means the airport can service more people, more efficiently. But in the US, it saves the individual a few minutes, so be prepared to pay a yearly fee for the privilege! It's precisely for reasons like $15 turkey sandwiches that New York airports are to be avoided (i.e. as stopovers). Treating the traveling public as feudal serfs is practically the definition of mismanagement.
- illiac786 4y agoIsn't the airport tax fix per passenger and independent from ticket price? I remember flying discount airline and paying only the airport taxes (it was around 20-30€ in my y case) That would decouple airport mall rent prices from falling airline ticket prices.
- gymbeaux 4y agoAh so that’s why the premade food at airport shops is so weird. I remember eating a sandwich I’ve never heard of before at EWR. It wasn’t that good and I remember the ingredients were unusual.
- bogomipz 4y ago>"On the one hand, airports need to make money ..." Commercial airports in the US are owned by a local, state or regional public entity.[1] They need to be self-sustaining and break even but they don't need to be profitable in the same sense as a private business. Further, passengers at these airports pay a significant amount of "taxes and fees" on their fares that go to support operations at these airports [2]. These include a passenger facility fee, a segment tax(one per takeoff/landing), a Sept 11th Fee for security and Federal ticket tax(pays the FAA.) [1] https://yourmileagemayvary.net/2022/08/14/who-owns-airports/ https://yourmileagemayvary.net/2022/08/14/who-owns-airports/ [2] https://www.farecompare.com/news/airline-ticket-taxes-and-fees/ https://www.farecompare.com/news/airline-ticket-taxes-and-fe...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoThe airport opens 3 sandwich shops midtown with outstanding prices. Problem solved. Not every shop out to do no buisness is money laundring. Some are also regulator laundring.