25 ms·
Apple Music Classical
- m3kw9 4y agoClassicals are a bit like different bands playing covers for a song.
- lesterchixi 4y ago[dead]
- johndill 4y agoLooks nice but I have to play with it more. It has certainly been "Appleinzed". Playlists feature single movements of pieces that make little musical sense outside of the context of the whole composition they were meant to be a part of. For new users looking to dop their toes in the Classical world the absolute first, featured piece you see is Mahler's 9th symphony. Certainly not something new listeners would likely enjoy as a starter piece. Search looks good and the browse part offers good choices of the various genres. It imported all my classical albums and only my classical albums from Apple music. Good start
- reaperducer 4y agoPlaylists feature single movements of pieces that make little musical sense outside of the context of the whole composition they were meant to be a part of. That's a fundamental flaw of playlists, and not unique to this app or to any music created before the streaming era.
- pwinnski 4y agoWhile you're thinking about playlists, I should introduce you to classical radio. Out-of-context movements are the norm there!
- tzs 4y agoHow is Apple Music playback on Amazon Echo devices? Does Apple have anything as nice as Spotify Connect? My current setup is that I have an Echo Dot connected by the line out to my A/V receiver, with the microphone turned off. With Spotify Connect the Spotify on my computer or phone can tell the Spotify on the Dot to play a song, album, or playlist. The Spotify on the Dot then streams that music from Spotify. I can turn the computer or phone off and the music keeps playing. Spotify on my computer or phone will show what is playing on the Dot and let me control it. This works really well. (In fact, it works way better than Amazon Music from my computer or phone works with the Dot. I just finished a 90 day free trial of Amazon Music and one of the reasons I did not subscribe was how poorly Amazon Music works with Echo devices. Spotify completely blows Amazon out of the water there). What I really like with this is that once I start playback the computer or phone no longer needs to be involved. I know that there is an Apple Music app for Echo that lets Apple Music be a source for Echo, so that I could say "Play Foo on Apple Music" and Alexa would use Apple Music do do that, but I don't want to choose my music by voice. I want to do the choosing on my Mac or phone/tablet.
- fckgw 4y agoThis is a very niche and very specific workflow you have. Spotify is the only thing that can do what you want as far as I know. Ironically Apple used to offer a product to do this more than a decade ago, the Apple Airport Express. It's a wifi access point with a line out. You can still pick one up for ~$20 on eBay and I believe it will still work with Apple music as a target device.
- piperswe 4y agoBelkin also currently makes a version with AirPlay 2, which allows for syncing multiple speakers together (among other improvements): https://www.microcenter.com/product/640273/belkin-soundform-connect-airplay-2-audio-adapter-receiver-for-wireless-streaming https://www.microcenter.com/product/640273/belkin-soundform-...
- CharlesW 4y ago> I know that there is an Apple Music app for Echo that lets Apple Music be a source for Echo, so that I could say "Play Foo on Apple Music" and Alexa would use Apple Music [to] do that… Yes, this works great. > …but I don't want to choose my music by voice. I want to do the choosing on my Mac or phone/tablet. This also works but requires using Bluetooth. There's no way to "hand off" from an iPhone/iPad to Alexa as you can with a HomePod.
- mustacheemperor 4y ago>Does Apple have anything as nice as Spotify Connect It sure doesn't. I generally love Apple Music, but you can really feel the neglect Apple pays to its non-preferred platforms once you attempt to use it on 3rd party hardware. Listening to Apple Music on the PS5 while playing a videogame is way more kludgy than it needs to be. The little pop-up card in the dashboard never seems to completely match the recently played on my phone, and only provides about a dozen shortcuts to recent plays and albums apparently randomly selected from my library. Launching the full app will often close the game or disconnect it from the internet and send it back to the homescreen. Attempting to use Airplay will, of course, completely exit the game and take over the entire PS5 with Apple TV. By comparison, the Spotify experience was: Start game. Open spotify, tap Connect. Tap PS5. Play whatever I want, done. This feature was the single biggest factor keeping me on Spotify but after getting an AVR with Atmos support I just couldn't stay on that platform, which seems to get less investment into music related features relative to everything else every year.
- amacbride 4y agoIt’s definitely not perfect, but I’m enjoying it, as someone who has been unhappy with Spotify’s haphazard approach to classical music. I was exploring the “Harpsichord“ category and Bach’s Toccata No. 6 in G Minor, and saw a performance by Glenn Gould: “Glen Gould on the harpsichord? Oh, how interesting! [listens] How...not a harpsichord.” So there are still a few bugs to be worked out.
- betagam 4y agoSame on YouTube. Even when I'm searching specifically for harpsichord music, the first result is harpsichord music played on piano. That's not the instrument the music was composed for. It's surely interesting to hear what a piece sounds like when played on an other instrument, but it should't be the norm in my opinion.
- laserson 4y agoHow does this compare with Concertmaster? It's basically a skin on top of Spotify for browsing classical music. It's free and pretty good. (There's also an app.) And I believe there is a version for Apple Music already? [1]: https://concertmaster.app https://concertmaster.app
- gumby 4y agoI installed this last night and i immediately found it a much better experience. Apple did the right thing by using a separate app (and by buying it, as they did with iTunes— somehow this isn’t in their DNA).
- singularity2001 4y agoThis app is available only on the App Store for iPhone. (not ipad)
- eddieroger 4y agoThat is true, but what is also true is that the iPhone version works just fine on iPad, albeit a little skinny. But I'm currently listening to it and it works just fine, Spatial Audio and all.
- EntrePrescott 4y ago> "For example, from the formal Beethoven’s Piano Sonata No. 14 to the popular byname of Moonlight Sonata, or in multiple languages, such as Mondschein Sonata in German." "Mondschein Sonata"? WTF Apple? Not only is that factually wrong, but… that's not even German - neither as a whole, nor the "Sonata" nor the space (Deppenleerzeichen). Maybe Apple should ask someone else than Siri or a marketing intern to write texts with factual claims outside of their fields. The actual popular German sobriquet for that Sonata is "Mondscheinsonate". As for "Sonata", that's part of the (Italian) title of its first published edition: "Sonata quasi una Fantasia".
- anecdotal1 4y agoApple didn't write this, the company they bought this app from did
- HeavyFeather 4y agoSo Apple wrote this. Worse yet, their specialists in classical music wrote this. The page is littered with Apple logos and it lives on a .Apple TLD, no need to be an apologist for 2.5 trillion dollar company.
- d35007 4y agoI mean, there’s also no need to freak the fuck out over a minor issue in German text on a predominantly English page. Ok, so “Mondschein Sonata” isn’t exactly the same as “mondscheinsonate”, but it’s damn close and it gets the point across: Some works have different names in different languages. Guess what happens when I search Apple Classical for “mondscheinsonate”. In fact, don’t guess. Try it.
- prvc 4y agoIt may not be a consequential error, but it a revealing one.
- 4y ago
- mbo 4y ago> There’s no separate subscription for Apple Music Classical. It’s included at no extra cost with all Apple Music subscriptions except the Apple Music Voice Plan. Bit of a missed opportunity here to provide a cheaper subscription just for Classical. Apple could have captured Spotify users who would be willing to pay a small premium for a nicer classical UX, but would be unwilling to take out an additional full-priced music subscription. Inevitably some Classical only users would end up migrating entirely to Apple Music to amalgamate their subscription costs.
- reaperducer 4y agoBit of a missed opportunity here to provide a cheaper subscription just for Classical. I don't think the people this app is for are all that price-sensitive. I look at Apple Music as a classical music subscription, with 90 million other tracks included for free.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- natdempk 4y agoI think if you really care about a great classical streaming experience, that probably outranks a small extra monthly fee. I sort of doubt the category of people who care about a few extra dollars a month yet really love classical music to the point of wanting a very tailored experience exists.
- cush 4y agoMissed opportunity.... Cheaper... You know we're talking about Apple right? In all seriousness, they don't like creating multiple SKUs for things. For simplicity and user friendliness sake.
- bmmayer1 4y agoBeyond pricing, what's their strategy here trying to unbundle music? Are they going to release a different music app for every genre? If it's just a classical app, does that mean I now have to use two apps to switch between music based on genre? What benefit is there other than slightly better UX which presumably could be bundled in an existing app.
- whalesalad 4y agoThe domain applemusic.apple is outstanding. It’s giving Tim Apple energy.
- HeavyFeather 4y agoThe best part is that it isn’t even set up: https://applemusic.apple/ https://applemusic.apple/ This awkward press release lives at https://learn.applemusic.apple/apple-music-classical https://learn.applemusic.apple/apple-music-classical Drop the pathname and you get a nice 404.
- piperswe 4y agoIt does seem to be set up now; it redirects to https://www.apple.com/apple-music/ https://www.apple.com/apple-music/, which is reasonable behavior.
- cyberpunk 4y agoAm the only person who finds it completely ridiculous that not even APPLE can launch the iPad version of this app at the same time as their iOS one? I launch it on my iPad (which is hooked to my external dac/amp setup via usb-c) and I see.. This: https://imgur.com/a/cAX0zZA https://imgur.com/a/cAX0zZA
- lolsal 4y agoThey are being pretty agile and releasing something for iOS and will iterate to release a custom iPad version later, relying on the fallback mechanism that has existed for years for app scaling. Why does this upset you so much? Just because they are big doesn't mean they have to do everything all at once, all the time. They are dog-fooding their own multi-device app tech. I think it's great.
- cyberpunk 4y agoI mean I'm not really upset or anything -- I will live with it of course. I only mentioned it as.. Well. Don't you find a crappy experience from a company that obsessives so much over user experience a little surprising? You'd have thought if anyone could nail an iDevice software release it would be Apple..
- twobitshifter 4y agoI agree, this is another indication that the app may say Apple but it’s really not developed inside Apple. Steve Jobs would have fired someone in 2023 if he saw a tiny screen on his gigantic iPad. If they’re okay with doing this then why isn’t there a phone-sized calculator available to install on iPad?
- e28eta 4y agoI’m still upset every time I run into a iPhone-only interface on iPad, but my anger level has gone down somewhat now that I’ve started using Stage Manager more.
- hbn 4y agoI played around with the app a bit and so far it seems great. So it's pretty disappointing I can't use it on my Mac where I'd most want it, cause I'm most likely to listen to classical music while working.
- 015a 4y agoOn the one hand: Apple has released (at least) two new "major" consumer "apps" over the past year (Freeform and this). This gives me positive echos of "old Apple"; a company that took the software as seriously as the hardware, that apps like Aperture and Logic were critical to the Mac becoming what it is, and that they should have a hand in creating not just the platform and technologies, but the actual experiences that drive productivity (and now entertainment) for the people who join their platforms. This can solve a real problem for a lot of customers; I am not one of them, so I'm unqualified to say if it actually does solve those problems, but I'm really happy that it exists. On the other hand; release is step 1, and given this is based on an acquisition I think its totally fair to be skeptical. I shared this with my dad this morning, who is an old classical music nerd and pianist for the symphony orchestra in town. His first reaction: Does it have a Mac app? (It doesn't). And see, that gap is actually really significant when you think about it, because people like him, in that niche; they are appreciators, for better or worse, of audio quality. Hi-Res lossless, awesome, that's table stakes. He has a Mac Mini wired up to a Schiit Yggdrassil and some amp that weighs 50 pounds and a set of speakers that he drove 300 miles away to "get a deal" on (he paid $18,000 for them. that was a "deal". my mother was not happy about it). Using an iPhone is a complete non-starter. He uses Qobuz primarily, alongside an obscene collection of SA-CDs, and despite this app being 90% there toward being something awesome he could use; he won't. So I think that's what I mean by Step 1; developing "niche" software like Freeform or Apple Music Classical isn't an obvious step for Apple. They won't get insane metrics for these apps. They won't drive measurable revenue. But I really deeply believe that this kind of niche investment is what separates companies like Microsoft and Apple from companies like Google; as they say about Google, if its not a billion dollar business it won't even get a team. Microsoft and Apple do understand the insane power of network effects, and the power that solving one niche really freakin well can have on bringing customers into the fold of their platforms, and keeping them there. Microsoft for M365 and Apple for their consumer software. I think that's the era we're entering in software; we've solved a ton of the problems that have "100M users" as their TAM. As an example: note taking. Its solved. It can be iteratively improved, but everyone has their favorite app, we switch every once in a while, and its best for me that that improvement happens within the context of a platform I've already adopted. Large software companies should really be open to moving down the TAM ladder; what problems do 10M people have? 1M? Freeform is one stab at that: diagramming and flowcharts. But we also can't accept these apps having 10x fewer features or 10x less quality just because they have a 10x smaller TAM; software is multiplicative, and potentially exponential now that we have generative AI capable of helping out.
- ak_111 4y agoAm wondering if something like this should exist for jazz and even a separate one for techno?
- tiffanyh 4y agoWhen did Apple start using the .apple TLD? This seems confusing, and something out of the norm for their marketing strategy.
- otabdeveloper4 4y ago> applemusic.apple > not music.apple Good Lord! You had one job.
- CydeWeys 4y agoOh it's even worse than that: learn.APPLEmusic.APPLE/APPLE-music-classical Three repetitions of "apple"! And the learn subdomain is meaningless. I like that they're using their .brand TLD but their URL strategy still needs some work.
- HeavyFeather 4y agoGive them time, it’s not like they can afford to hire capable people.
- dcdevito 4y ago[dead]
- web3-is-a-scam 4y agoThis actually sounds pretty cool, I was actually thinking of this the other day: classical music is an entirely different beast of finding things to listen to, you can't just "pick a band and album in a genre". For example: if I want to listen to Mozart, and I've never listen to any of his compositions before where do I even start to look to find a "good interpretation". You can't just search for Album/Artist. Weird how Apple can read my mind.
- lifefeed 4y agoI would love to see something like this for jazz, which has musicians constantly moving through groups and albums as musicians and composers and writers. Like take "Take Five", one of my favorites. It was written by Paul Desmond for the Dave Brubeck Quartet, with solos by Desmond on alto sax and Joe Morello on drums. Those are all fun pieces of information that I wish I could click through to see more of. Just like classical music, it's not impossible to represent this with a generic interface, but it would benefit by something more geared to how jazz fans like to browse.
- CE02 4y agoI second this! Couldn't agree more. In all honesty, some of the best parts of jazz lie in its history. For example listening to Clifford Brown might make you think "huh this is neat". But understanding his relationship to gillespie, early death, etc, puts his career in a unique and fascinating frame.
- MavisBacon 4y ago+1 on Clifford Brown. I think he wrote some of the most brilliant bop melodies and his death was probably one of the more tragic that music ever saw
- lostlogin 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clifford_Brown https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clifford_Brown
- CE02 4y agoWhat aways amazes me about Brown is how much he accomplished in so little. I play trumpet, in high school was in California All State Jazz and Classical. I'm by no means a prodigy, I merely brought that up to say I know a lot of musicians. When you ask any trumpet player to name their top 5 go-to artists if they want to sit down and listen, I'd say that 95% plus would have Brown somewhere in that list. This would be true of people ranging from myself to pro studio musicians. Heck I don't know anyone who's dedicated to the instrument that cant hum along perfectly to Jordu or Joy Spring including his solos. In only 26 years of life, he has become one of the most iconic names in hard bop, a genre containing the likes of Freddie Hubbard and Horace Silver. To think he did that in 26 years, one can only imagine what he'd have done if he made it to 60+!
- CE02 4y agoI understand the concern about this being rather useless fluff with no real differentiation beyond a cute and UX. However, as someone who grew up playing music, I truly believe that listening to "difficult" music exercises the brain in a way similar to reading a good book. Because of that, I am all for any lipstick on a pig that might bring the general public deeper into classical music.
- vachina 4y agoWished there is an option to control the dynamic range.
- kridsdale1 4y agoMy main hope for this was that it would be as wide and deep as possible. We can then apply our own Dolby compression filter if we want to, in our listening hardware.
- nanidin 4y agoPretty irritating that for the last week or so, when I search classical music on my iPhone, the first result was an empty playlist that told me there is a classical music app coming. Great. I have an app for listening to music from Apple called Music. I don’t really want yet another app and the mental overhead that comes with it.
- jshaqaw 4y agoI’ve been on the app all morning and loving it but it’s not even full size on my iPad. Come on Apple you can do better than that!
- romeovs 4y agoThis might be off topic but has anyone else noticed the sloppiness in Apples' websites lately? On both Safari and Firefox on my machine the titles on this page appear without the correct fonts (falling back to Times). On apple.com a lot of buttons (eg. the buy button on https://www.apple.com/mac/ https://www.apple.com/mac/) lead to 404 pages. Trying to report these issues seems impossible, of course.
- pivo 4y agoThe buy button and titles work for me on Safari and Firefox
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vjulian 4y agoHave TV and cinema solved the cataloging issue or at least the categorization issue? If so, why can’t music adapt it and serve all genres? We can easily analogize to studios, seasons, episodes, years, directors, actors and so forth.
- perceptronas 4y ago>Which devices is Apple Music Classical available on? >Apple Music Classical was built exclusively for mobile and is available on iOS with Android coming soon. I wish they made an app specifically for MacBook as well
- CharlesW 4y agoI'd expect that one of their next steps is a "larger screen" user experience that should work for both iPads and Macs.
- mariodiana 4y agoI'd like to see them make an app for Apple TV, as well. The sound system setup with my television is the main one in my apartment.
- AJRF 4y agoAnyone noticing there is serious view caching issues with this app? Every menu I click into will briefly show me a previously navigated to screen. Say root is View A which has two sub views B and C I go into B, then back to A, then into C - it will show me B for a second.
- tempodox 4y agoThis has to be a joke, right? Given Apple's enmity towards headphone cables, I don't see the point. Their Bluetooth EarPods can never ever render the necessary sound quality.
- ubermonkey 4y agoWhy would it be a joke? First, surely you grasp that many people use these things called "speakers" to listen to music. Not all consumption is done with headphones. Second, even if we narrow the question to headphone listening, the "failure" or "unsuitability" of Bluetooth for headphones is profoundly overblown. In 2023, gGood headphones, wired or wireless, sound fine if given a decent source. I was definitely a skeptic, and while I couldn't set up anything like ABX testing, I have spent time trying to honestly compare my AirPods MAX to my price-peer wired Sennheisers run through a FiiO headphone amp. The tl;dr is that it's POSSIBLE the traditional wired setup might sound a tiny bit better, but both sound REALLY REALLY GREAT. Any edge possibly enjoyed by the traditional setup was thin, and only evident in fairly narrow cases. I was pretty surprised given my original bias against wireless headphones for critical listening, but here we are.
- kridsdale1 4y agoYou can plug a DAC in to an iPhone. And AppleTV can output 24bit 192khz PCM, or Dolby Atmos over HDMI to a receiver.
- mihaaly 4y agoThose who want and appreciate the sound quality already using better than Apple speakers or headphones. If you read carefully the footnotes referenced state the need of proper external DAC. They know it is not for everyone and not forcing it on everyone unnecessarily, still allowing those in need to have it.
- meerita 4y agoWhy this and not using Music App?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rwalle 4y agoDid you even open the web page before posting this comment? The answer is very clearly written in the page.
- Aeolun 4y agoOf course… “This app is not available in your country or region.” Silly me, why would I ever think something like that spplies to me. > Available worldwide, wherever Apple Music is offered, excluding China, Japan, Korea, Russia, Taiwan, and Turkey. ??? Why are Japan and Taiwan listed together with a bunch of terrorist states?
- m3kw9 4y agoI don’t really listen to classical but this app gets me interested a bit especially with the instruments feature, also the era selection. You can also choose by conductors but that’s something fanatics would be able to hear lmao, it’s the same song, but conducting is supposed to make a difference?
- shadowtree 4y agoThis is great - it being a separate app solves some core problems! It's a hard firewall between my "normal" music library and classical, which means risk free shuffle play. I never want Bach and Slayer in sequence. They can optimize the UI, recommendations, etc. based on music that is all about reproduction, rather than being performed by the original artists. Going against the grain and honing in on a total niche is so awesome and hopefully a sign of things to come. I enjoy this split with movies too, the Criterion Apple TV app is such a nice break from the noisy HBO Max, etc. stuff. And yes, I agree, Jazz would be an obvious next niche to target with a dedicated app!
- basisword 4y ago>> It's a hard firewall between my "normal" music library and classical, which means risk free shuffle play. I never want Bach and Slayer in sequence. It's actually not. The library is shared so your classical music will still appear in Apple Music. It's just that your pop/rock etc. music will not appear in the Classical app. e.g. add a playlist or album to your Classical library then check recently added in the standard Music app - you should also see it there.
- WorldMaker 4y ago> I never want Bach and Slayer in sequence. I've found interesting, creative serendipity in sequences like that. With dynamics controlling tools such as ReplayGain (and Apple Music has something similar built-in today though less well documented) to avoid massive "loudness war" shifts it doesn't even break a flow state for me sometimes and can be really interesting to my flow.
- danhau 4y ago> and Apple Music has something similar built-in today though less well documented Can I enable that somehow, or is it enabled by default?
- WorldMaker 4y agoMy understanding is that it is enabled by default. I wish it were better documented. Apparently, the official feature name is "Sound Check": https://www.cultofmac.com/622492/apple-music-volume-sound-check/ https://www.cultofmac.com/622492/apple-music-volume-sound-ch...
- earthnail 4y agoOh my, 192kHz/24bit. One would expect Apple would not need snake oil to sell their product. To those not so familiar with audio DSP: 192kHz and 24bit make perfect sense if you intend to mangle the audio a LOT afterwards. At 192kHz, you can pitch shift your audio down by two octaves and still have frequency content in the entire CD spectrum. Very useful, and common, for movie effects. And 24bit, or better even 32bit, basically eliminates any floating point errors when you have a DSP chain with lots of multiplications. But for playback, you need around 32-40kHz sample rate and 10 or 11bits. Even 16bit is already overkill.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoApple was one of the last streaming providers to adopt lossless audio. Even then, the "high res" part is optional. You can disable it and stream normal 44.1/16
- explaininjs 4y agoHave you personally tested this in a blind study? I have, and the higher quality made a noticeable difference and I was able to identify it and prefer it across all test cases. The others I tested with did not notice any difference. It could be one of those cilantro things idk. But other accounts are in line with my experience: https://audiophilereview.com/audiophile-music/yes-19224-files-do-sound-better/ https://audiophilereview.com/audiophile-music/yes-19224-file...
- astrange 4y agoYou probably didn't blind it correctly, eg if you converted 24-bit to 16-bit then it has two levels of dithering and would naturally sound different. This guy seems to be doing an unblinded comparison between 16-bit, 24-bit, and DSD which is 2.8 MHz 1-bit. IIRC DSD converts to PCM at around 96KHz/20-bit, so comparing it to 192/24 is kind of funny. But you can just look up dynamic range - 16-bit dithered audio is enough to record someone whispering in your ear while using a jackhammer without protection. That should be enough for music.
- bryanmgreen 4y ago
- antiviral 4y agoSounds tempting, but Apple Music has been a terrible experience for me. I recently signed up for the Apple Music subscription and was asked to 'sync my music with the Cloud Music Library" before I could create any playlists. Shortly afterwards, I noticed that most of my music, which I had bought for over 10 years, just disappeared from iTunes with no explanation. I am still trying to figure out how to get it back, and regretting I just didn't stick with Spotify. I'm glad that Apple is working on these new features, but I'm going to have a hard time trusting them with any new music related products until this gets fixed. I am most probably going to cancel my Apple Music subscription, although I have no idea how I'm going to get my music back.
- tw600040 4y agoPlease if someone from Apple is listening: Please pay some attention to Indian music as well. I mostly only listen to Tamil songs and when Apple came out with iTunes Match or something where they analyze your library and match it to what they have in cloud, they just incorrectly matched songs with the Telugu version and ones from other languages and totally messed up my collection. And, this day and age, why should all Indian music be clubbed under "Foreign" genre by default?
- calf 4y agoDoes the Apple Classical app include non-Western traditional music? It's interesting, what even is classical music? I bet there's music that crosses boundaries, like jazz-classical or pop-classical. Are those subgenres on the app?
- _venkatasg 4y agoI've noticed that soundtracks show up in this Classical music app, so some (not all) of my Tamil songs (which are songs from movies because that's how most pop/commercial music in India is released) are listed there now.
- thewebcount 4y agoYou can file your feedback for Apple Music here: https://www.apple.com/feedback/apple-music.html https://www.apple.com/feedback/apple-music.html That's the only way your voice will get heard.
- pradn 4y agoEven JioSaavn, which is focused on Indian popular film music, doesn't do anything special. It's a bit more similar to classical music than American-style pop in terms of organization. Music directors are responsible for the entire album of a film, with singers being brought on for a track or two. So one might want to slice by music director, just like looking at all Bach pieces. It's not quite the case with pop producers, who are usually behind-the-scenes. Fans of Indian popular music often follow their favorite music directors, even if they have little interest in the films the music is a part of. However, even then, this slight difference is well papered-over by just including the music director in the list of artists who made a song. Indian classical music, however, has a wholly separate and more intricate form of organization. You'd at least need raga and the properties of the raga (like the dominant rasa & associated time of day), along with the various singers and instrumentalists in the ensemble and their instruments. It would be great to search for "morning"-raga-based Carnatic vocal concerts with the lead singer being Sudha Ragunathan.
- AlbertCory 4y agoFor a while a long time ago, I had a Naxos subscription ($20 a year) where I could listen to anything in their catalog. It was great for headphones at work. This might be, too.
- nishad_g 4y agoNow make one for Indian classical music. Indian classical is as rich as European, with it's ragas and talas and so many instruments (tabla, sitar, sarangi... )
- thewebcount 4y agoAs mentioned up-thread: https://www.apple.com/feedback/apple-music.html https://www.apple.com/feedback/apple-music.html
- m348e912 4y ago>>Only a brand-new app — with specialized features and a beautiful interface designed for the genre — could remove the complexity and make classical music easily searchable, browsable, and accessible for beginners and experts alike. Just thinking out loud. Was there a need for a separate app music? Instead add a "classical mode" to the traditional apple music app that enables features for classical music lovers.
- deanCommie 4y agoCompanies ship org charts. It's just what they do. But typically it's a benefit to customers - it means you get MORE features faster. At the cost of inconsistency.
- EricE 4y agoCool - I have been looking forward to this since the first rumors of it possibly being a thing started to circulate.
- ehPReth 4y agoI wonder why "applemusic.apple" and not just "music.apple", is it a trademark thing? The latter is certainly more cleaner
- cpeterso 4y agoReturn of the Beatles' Apple Corps v Apple Computer lawsuit? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Corps_v_Apple_Computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Corps_v_Apple_Computer
- gwbas1c 4y agoJust want to point out that the human hearing range goes up to 28khz, not 20khz as is commonly claimed. I can still notice a very subtle difference when I downsample 96khz to 48khz. It used to be more pronounced when I was younger, but I always thought that was the placebo effect. It wasn't until I went and read the Wikipedia article on the human hearing range that I realized that I wasn't imagining it. Basically, music that correctly reproduces up to 28khz has a sparkle effect that's also very noticeable in a live concert hall.
- mosburger 4y agoI worked on a project for Sony Music called "Ariama" a little over ten years ago that addressed this very problem w/ metadata, and organizing classical music differently than the artist/album/track way. I worked on the search piece! We also offered FLAC downloads. Looks like we were just ahead of our time. :-/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LeoPanthera 4y agoIt's very surprising there's no iPad or Apple TV version of this. iPhone only is a bit of a shock.
- themadturk 4y agoMobile only. I have a copy of it sitting on my iPad right now. It's the iPhone form factor, but seems to work.
- codetrotter 4y agoA little bit off-topic perhaps but.. does the domain applemusic.apple look funny to anyone else? Like, why not just music.apple or applemusic.com or apple.com/music or music.apple.com lol
- erfgh 4y agoHas anyone used Apple Music on Windows? Probably the worst experience of my life.
- tomsmeding 4y agoThe banner image they have showing a collection of album covers is ≥58% Goldberg variations. I wonder how large a catalogue they have, or whether perhaps the creators of this are just big Bach boys.
- mike_d 4y agoThere is different licensing and clearing for promotional use. For example Apple can display album art beside a song while it is playing or in a search listing under their streaming rights license, but they need to pay more to feature it in a TV ad or a promotional website.
- dwighttk 4y agoI'm liking this app generally, but man, I was listening to St. Matthew Passion (~ 3 hour piece) this afternoon and the app crashed. It relaunched immediately, but started playing at the beginning. I couldn't find a play history so I could at least start at the track I left off. Also one little fiddly bit... when I searched for SMP it lets me view all the albums, but includes a bunch of albums that include a single track from the work, which I get why they included them, but it'd be nice to sort them to the end or something. I'm usually interested in listening to an entire work.
- mark_l_watson 4y agoWow, the app is nice. I subscribe to both Apple and YouTube Music, love them both, and I don't mind having an extra music app on my iPhone.
- jemmyw 4y agoIs the app bug free and good? I thought to switch from Spotify to Apple music recently and started a trial with Apple music. The music selection is good and the sound quality is good but the client Apple music client for Mac is unbelievably buggy for first-party software. I had to get onto Apple support just to get my account going as it would just sit there constantly syncing. It feels sluggish doing things like adding to playlists, and there are numerous little quality of life bugs like the search box not focussing properly sometimes. I'm on the fence about the idea of switching now. I guess part of it was that the apps would be significantly better than Spotify.
- robomartin 4y agoNot sure if this fixes a problem that has plagued Apple music products since probably day one: You cannot play an album as it was recorded. Not sure if this has changed in any way. I abandoned Apple music offerings a long time ago (iPhone 3 time scale). You can't play "The Wall" or "Dark Side of the Moon" or the "Brandenburg Concertos" as a unified piece of work and listen to each in order from start to finish. Apple thinks in terms of songs, not albums. Albums exist in classical and popular music. Not sure why Apple thinks this way. In a sense, it represents total lack of respect for the artist and their work. It's like a book reading app not having a way to read a book from start to finish. Imagine if it showed you a massive list of chapters from different books and you had to manually find and order chapters to make-up a unified book. Windows Media understands albums. My entire CD collection is digitized under WM. I can create playlists that consist of of them and play them that way. To continue with the example, I can add Pink Floyd's albums into a playlist and play them one-by-one, in the order they were recorded.
- pallas_athena 4y agoI want to know how these pieces are scroobbled to last.fm Yes, I still use it and my (flawed) choice for classical music is: - Artist: the composer ("Ludwig van Beethoven") - Album: difficult, usually either the whole piece ("Symphony No. 5") or a larger collection ("Symphonies") - Track: the movement ("I. Allegro con brio") Of course this has A LOT of issues: - The performer is totally ignored - The "album" categorization is - Should the "album" include other descriptors? ("... in C minor" or "Eroica" (yes it's not the same symphony)) - Should the "track" include also the piece name? - In which language? Sadly a standard does not exist (afaik)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- westcort 4y agoA free alternative, based on LPs streaming from the Internet Archive, can be found here: https://locserendipity.com/LP.html https://locserendipity.com/LP.html
- sameya 4y agoYou can try www.Musconv.com to transfer your playlists.
- n0tahacker 4y agoFunny, you recognize sometimes that they took tracks from Youtube: https://classical.music.apple.com/de/album/1553740049 https://classical.music.apple.com/de/album/1553740049 Here, look at "J.S. Bach: Cellosuite Nr. 1 in G-Dur, BWV1007: I. Prelude (Transc. for Guitar), which is recorded by Ana Vidovic. At 1:28, she is making a small error, which she is also making at this YT video at 1:40: https://youtu.be/zBdK-ailioA https://youtu.be/zBdK-ailioA
- motohagiography 4y agoThere seem to be some extra notes from the implied counterpoint, which I think pretty much every Bach interpreter make of their own, but it made me think it would be nice if Apple would credit arrangements as well. Maybe that's a clustering job for an ML tool?
- coldtea 4y agoWaiting for the destined to be equally popular "Apple Music Polka"
- 876978095789789 4y agoDid you read the announcement: > Why a separate classical app? > Classical music often involves multiple musicians recording works that have been recorded many times before and are referred to by different names. For example, from the formal Beethoven’s Piano Sonata No. 14 to the popular byname of Moonlight Sonata, or in multiple languages, such as Mondschein Sonata in German. Such complexities mean that classical music fans have been ill-served by streaming platforms. Until now. A distinct app, included with an Apple Music subscription, gives these classical music lovers the editorial and catalog content they’ve been missing. > Only a brand-new app — with specialized features and a beautiful interface designed for the genre — could remove the complexity and make classical music easily searchable, browsable, and accessible for beginners and experts alike.
- tjpnz 4y ago>a beautiful interface We'll be the judge of that.
- egeozcan 4y agoClassical music isn't the only category that is not well served by a library of audio files though. Many types of folkloric music and rap has similar problems. Actually, pushing many audio files to clients with just album context only serves the pop music well, perhaps. On the other hand, limiting it to classical music hits that "do one thing well" spot, and would be hopefully a good testing ground for more such individualized apps.
- TylerE 4y agoEven in pop it could be a lot better. Like, for instance it would be neat when listening to a song to have easy access to cover versions by other bands.
- 4y ago
- timeimp 4y ago>Available worldwide, wherever Apple Music is offered, excluding China, Japan, Korea, Russia, Taiwan, and Turkey. Err... why?
- egeozcan 4y agoProbably licensing, if I have to make a guess.
- comprev 4y agoMost likely licensing and not technical - we were one of the only classical music apps which streamed high quality audio through The Great Firewall of China, and as such was praised by a few magazines. That was back in 2018/19 though and the delivery infrastructure may have changed since being acqhired.
- mrtksn 4y agoInterestingly, the enforcement is through App Store and not through Apple Music account or ip address locality. So, users from these countries can simply sign in with an Apple account from any other country, install the app, switch back to the actual account and use it just fine. On any other service, including Apple TV plus, it's the other way around: You can access the app or the website but the content will be limited to your current physical location(ip address actually). Which makes me believe that it's not about licensing. I haven't checked but probably the same songs are available on Apple Music anyway. It's a mystery why Apple wouldn't release the UI for classical music in countries where they do offer the music catalog already.
- geff82 4y agoWow. I will try this product today as I am exactly in the target group. I often listen to different recordings of the same music to find the best one, I want to dive into certain artists or genres and indeed - with Apple Music and Spotify, this is not easy.
- throwanem 4y agoI'm finding that very easy so far. This is the best discovery tool I've yet used, which is almost frustrating given that if I'd found anything like it in the last decade, I wouldn't need it.
- FredPret 4y agoBrilliant. I kept my classical music in a separate playlist because it's so unwieldy. This is the perfect solution for me. By the way, I love the serifed font - hope those make a comeback.
- eDameXxX 4y agoActually, I think it's a good thing they've built a separate app for that. We used to think that one app that rules all of them is a good idea. Not always. Classical music has a lot of nuances (some of which are listed on the announcement page) and from UI/UX perspective it would be quite difficult to mixed all these details in the standard Apple Music app. I'm now wondering what Spotify thinks about this matter. Do they plan to highlight classical music like Apple did. I don't know.
- behnamoh 4y agoOk, but why do they desperately repeat the link to their app SEVEN TIMES on this page? It doesn't feel "Appley".
- pwinnski 4y agoSpotify has been busy shoehorning their "podcasts" (on-demand audio shows) into every nook and cranny of the app people use to listen to music. If they notice or think of classical music, one can only imagine how they'll try to "highlight" it.
- throwanem 4y agoIt'd be foolish of them, I think, because we're a small, weird, and highly demanding audience. But they've done plenty of foolish things before in their apparent quest to own and monetize every imaginable audio waveform.
- augustl 4y agoMaybe we'll finally get a music app where classical music isn't categorized by Album/Artist :) Classical doesn't really fit that well into a schema, since you have composers, performers, and then under performers there's soloist, or multiple soloists, which orchestra, which conductor, and so on. And it would also be nice to have things like "show most popular recordings of Beethoven's 5th".
- dagw 4y agoMaybe we'll finally get a music app where classical There have been plenty of third party apps built on top of Spotify that have offered this.
- spokeroni 4y ago> And it would also be nice to have things like "show most popular recordings of Beethoven's 5th". This app has that. You can browse composer's works and view popular/all recordings.
- cannam 4y agoThere is the slightly awkwardly-named idagio (https://www.idagio.com/ https://www.idagio.com/), which has been doing the same kind of thing for a while. (I'm not well placed to compare them, since I let my own idagio subscription lapse a couple of years ago due to lack of income, I never tried Primephonic before Apple bought it, and I don't have an iPhone so can't try the Apple service... aside from all that, I'm right in the target market!)
- rodelrod 4y agoI was going to chime in with "also Primephonic" and learned that Apple bought them a couple of years ago and this basically is Primephonic.
- afandian 4y agoIt fits perfectly well into a schema, it's just been ignored for some reason since the dawn of ID3. It's crazy Apple considered it better to write a completely new app rather than improve their existing product.
- kieckerjan 4y agoIf the app is only half as good as the Primephonic service that Apple acquired and shuttered and on which it is probably based, it will already be an asset for classical music lovers worldwide. Apps like Spotify are hugely inadequate for browsing classical music. Hell, in those you often even cannot read the entire title of a track because it is overstuffed with (meta) info.
- Aissen 4y agoIt's good that they finally released something on the back of the Primephonic acquisition: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/08/apple-acquires-classical-music-streaming-service-primephonic/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/08/apple-acquires-classi...
- favsq 4y agoapplemusic.apple? why not music.apple? smh
- pwinnski 4y agoBecause that's already a redirect for the standard Music app? My guess is that the team developed the site without knowing whether they'd have permission to deploy it on *.apple or not, so they put apple in the domain basename and it was deemed not worth it to take it out once they knew the deploy target. Just guessing, though.
- dharma1 4y agowhy the serif headline font tho? Because it's classical?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jen729w 4y agoErr… downloaded on my iPad. It launches as a scaled iPhone app. You must be f’ing kidding me?
- pasc1878 4y agoIt does say it is iPhone only and in the FAQ "Classical fans who want to listen on their MacBook, iPad, or in their car can open Apple Music to enjoy the tracks, albums, and playlists they saved in Apple Music Classical, thanks to the shared music library." Which does not help me as I share from my mac - so hoiw do you do this?
- bippingchip 4y agoYes I ran into the same thing - It's disappointing, though maybe understandable as this is an iteration on the Primephonic app they acquired a while ago. And though I cannot find any reference to it anymore, if memory serves right, that was mobile only too? I hope that over time Classical will make it onto the Mac as well. I listen to a lot of classical music while I work and it's more than a bit annoying that the play/volume controls on my Mac don't work...
- meghan_rain 4y agolmao
- substation13 4y agoI get it, but I also wish they could make one app that gets all of this stuff right. They could start by improving on the data model. "Unknown Artist" would never pass code review!
- lelag 4y agoStrange feelings looking at this... This is almost exactly the product I failed to get into YC with back in 2017... All the same ideas as far as the UX goes with one main difference: the business model. I wanted to apply the Steam business model where people would actually buy album again (and not tracks a la iTunes). The issue is that while it's nice to have a UX tailored for classical, this won't likely help the classical industry to thrive again. To simplify a bit, the classical music industry is composed of: - the majors labels (Universal Music, Sony, Warner and EMI) - A dozen large independent labels (Naxos being the largest) - hundreds of small labels The majors mostly care about promoting a few star performers and milking their huge existing catalog. They have no problem with putting everything on subscription services for pennies. This what you find on all subscription services. The larger independent labels also have significant catalog and some will also put part of it on subscription services but mostly won't. However, it is totally financially impossible for the smaller labels which are actually recording most of the interesting new records to survive on the pennies they would get from subscription services. Most of them have rejected that model and caters to the increasingly niche market of audiophile still ready to buy new high quality music. As a classical music fan, I'm happy to see that there will finally be an offering offering a good experience and massively increasing discoverability (which is terrible in mainstream services). But unfortunately, this wont change the fact that the classical recording industry is dying and that the sector is only surviving thanks to public and private subsidies.
- lwhi 4y agoSo a band camp for classical music is required?
- leviathant 4y agoMy wife composes choral music and "new music". (what many here would consider classical) and has been using Bandcamp since 2009 with pretty good success. But even that gets tricky, as she is not the performer for any of the recordings. It's a strange world though, when so many people focus on centuries-old music by dead German men, that's going to be harder to market. My first glance at Apple Classical a few weeks ago suggests that it's trying to cater to that crowd. Bandcamp is better for living composers (and preforming musicians) than a lot of other traditional options. For example, if you have a successful performance is a piece, Parma Records will reach out to you and offer to do a "professional" recording. They'll ask for $20,000 and you'll get a box of CDs (not sure if they do that last part anymore but I would not be surprised). A surprising amount of musicians go this route, because they don't know any better. Anyway, point is, Bandcamp is awesome.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThis looks ok, but I can't be the only person suffering Content Fatigue. Between access to infinite music, infinite movies and TV, infinite gaming, and infinite news - and that's just leisure - I'm not sure how much time I have left for a finite life.
- bowsamic 4y agoThat's really your responsibility
- troad 4y agoRun with the assumption that everything is always infinitely available, and become judicious with your attention. Boring podcast? Don't think twice, delete it. Good TV show, but not amazing? Move on, there's better out there. You won't even remember its name in a year. Book dragging on in the middle? Skip ahead. Every now and again you'll find something you want to give a chance to, and for those things do slow down, take it in. But don't waste that on any random thing just because it's new and being pushed hard by some giant media conglomerate. Or alternatively give it five-ten years before you engage with any cultural product. Time is a very effective filter for quality.
- falcolas 4y agoThis is the way. It’s perfectly acceptable to bounce off a book after five pages. Off a podcast with poor production quality. Off a song after the first measure. Tastes differ, so don’t feel bad if you dislike something the zeitgeist adores.
- ninkendo 4y agoBack when scarcity was a thing, the act of powering through with media you didn’t initially like was one of the primary ways of maturing your taste and learning to like new things. Only consuming media which hooks you instantly is a good way to achieve the media equivalent of a sugar-only diet. I don’t have an answer for this to be honest, it’s just an observation.
- CrlNvl 4y agoQobuz won't be too happy about this I guess
- butlertronica 4y agoThis treatment would also be very welcome for Jazz - I want to hear My Favourite Things but I don't want Julie Andrews
- repler 4y agoExactly! I’m so glad you posted this. It’s “covers” all the way down.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cschmidt 4y agoI'd like that as well. For a while I thought https://jazzed.com/ https://jazzed.com/ would eventually be this, even thought it was just available in the UK. But now they seem like they've moved to focusing on live performances.
- graphcolorer 4y ago[flagged]
- vixen99 4y agoYes but it hasn't traveled all that well for whatever reason while Western Classical music (WCM) has been adopted on a massive scale by China, Korea and other countries in Asia, to such an extent that considering the numerous cutbacks for orchestras and classical music generally in the West, WCM itself is being kept alive by these communities. Some argue that Lang Lang lit a fuse. "Today China is experiencing piano frenzy with an estimated 40m children now learning to play. The instrument is increasingly in vogue among China’s burgeoning middle classes, who have the money to splurge on steep lessons and expensive fixtures. Spurring them on is the phenomenal success of the Chinese superstar concert pianists Lang Lang and Li Yundi" https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20131022-piano-mania-grips-china https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20131022-piano-mania-gri... https://www.ludwig-van.com/toronto/2019/08/13/feature-the-piano-market-is-booming-and-its-all-because-of-china/ https://www.ludwig-van.com/toronto/2019/08/13/feature-the-pi... "With direct government involvement, the Chinese strategy to conquer the world of classical music includes a coherent strategy that operates from the ground up, including building the infrastructure for their booming classical musical sector. There are stunning new concert halls in Shanghai, Beijing, and Harbin to showcase classical music." Perhaps no need to say that I am here referring only to the relative extent of the universal appeal of very different musical genres not to their intrinsic aesthetic rewards for fans.
- LegitShady 4y agoThey probably have their own names for their own music and fewer people demanding they change it because its too centered on their culture.
- imwithstoopid 4y agowell to be pedantic, "classical" isn't even a style, its a time-period if you want to be nitpicky, this app should be called Apple Symphonic most of the symphonic music I prefer (late 19th century) would be considered from the romantic era i.e. I don't consider Wagner to be "classical" like...Philip Glass is not "classical" music...but he's a symphonic composer
- dewey 4y agoFor those asking why they "didn't just" improve the existing music app. This is the rebranded version of a service called Primephonic which they acquired last year. This is obviously way less work than trying to jam it into the existing app, so I don't think it's an entirely unreasonable decision. https://www.apple.com/hk/en/newsroom/2021/08/apple-acquires-classical-music-streaming-service-primephonic/ https://www.apple.com/hk/en/newsroom/2021/08/apple-acquires-...
- joseph_grobbles 4y ago[dead]
- cschmidt 4y agoI hadn't looked at Primephonic in a while, but their site is now just a letter on how they're working with Apple: https://www.primephonic.com/ https://www.primephonic.com/
- russelldjimmy 4y agoFrom a different thread on HN about the same topic, some commenters mentioned that the information architecture and navigation required for classical music is different enough from other music to warrant its own app. I would be surprised if Apple made a decision to cut corners on work and ship a product faster (because from their other products, they seem to be a company that believes in taking their time and delaying releases till they are done to a level that they deem satisfactory)
- tonguetrainer 4y agoA sign of the times. Classical and ambient music are getting more popular as we are all stressed out, and there is no end in sight.
- ot 4y agoThis might be the thing that makes me jump ship from Spotify. Catalog there is not great and the track listings are all useless, you need to wait 30 second for the text to scroll before you get to the useful piece of information.
- throwanem 4y agoThey actually haven't really improved on that, but I don't mind, because search and discovery are excellently done.
- activitypea 4y ago...why not just music.apple?
- pwinnski 4y agoThat redirects to the non-classical music app page already.
- bouke 4y agoProbably because they're branding it as "Apple Music", not "Music (by) Apple".
- tinus_hn 4y agoAlso there is a record company called Apple Records that has a litigious history with Apple, it could be not worth the potential trouble.
- _thisdot 4y agoOn an iPhone the app is just called Music (similarly Google Maps is labelled just Maps on Android). This is exactly as weird as google maps domain being googlemaps.google.com
- dbbk 4y agoI've never seen googlemaps.google.com?
- _thisdot 4y agoSorry. Should’ve been clear. It’s not the case, it would’ve been weird if it was
- bouke 4y agoThe iPhone Music app can play music from Apple Music, amongst others. It is not synonymous for Apple Music. You can still have your local library without subscribing to Apple Music.
- snickmy 4y agoI salut a major company focusing on classical music. That said, how many small startup / scale up will be dead in 1 year because of that ?
- jzb 4y agoAre there start ups that you’re thinking of this competes with directly?
- narenkeshav 4y agoSo... it would be my go to music app to get wired in.
- can16358p 4y agoFelt excited to see Fazıl Say (from Turkey), just to see that the app is not available in Turkey facepalm.
- mrkwse 4y agoI'm really keen to dive into this however as someone knee deep in the ecosystem it's baffling that it doesn't have proper native integration with Apple TV/HomePod. You can Airplay with your phone as the source, but not with the receiving device being the source (which is typically a nicer and more reliable approach as some phone applications can interrupt the streamed audio).
- jon-wood 4y agoI was also really excited for this, coming from the angle of someone who's never really got into classical music. It seemed like a nice opportunity to dig into it a bit with some (hopefully) good curation. The lack of a macOS app is baffling to me, most of my music listening is done while working, using the nice pair of wired headphones I have connected to the dock on my desk, but apparently Apple think I'll only want to listen to classical music on a pair of AirPods, which while alright are not the best. At the very least make a slight nod to the fact you own the entire stack from hardware to app and allow me to install the iPad app on my laptop.
- _cenw 4y agoThere is no iPad app. It runs in iPhone compatability mode.
- 8ytecoder 4y agoAtmos doesn’t carry over on airplay either.
- lynx23 4y ago192kHz/24 bit, what a wonderful piece of snakeoil... What do they actually record with this frequency, bats talking to each other about classical music?
- gregwebs 4y agoIt’s not that high- some music streams with higher sampling frequencies and bit depths. The main snake oil phenomenon that goes on is up sampling cd quality recordings to these levels. That doesn’t accomplish much other than confusion. Certainly the majority of systems out there are not high end enough to appreciate higher quality recordings unless they are wired headphones (a quality setup there doesn’t cost too much).
- wwalexander 4y agoThere is no system high-end enough to allow your ears to magically hear 96kHz, or even 48kHz. Unless you’re very young with golden ears it’s extremely doubtful that you can hear a 24kHz tone. It is absolutely snake oil. https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html is an overview by the creator of Ogg and Vorbis explaining exactly, scientifically, why these inflated sampling rates are snake oil. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cIQ9IXSUzuM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cIQ9IXSUzuM is a longer video by the same person that debunks a lot of digital audio myths.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gregwebs 4y agoThanks, I really appreciate those references. There are still subtleties in a real world setup that may be missed in those explanations though. A bit depth of 16 would be enough if everything in the system from recording to speaker was working properly. But for example with digital volume control there is effectively a loss of bit depth. Starting with 24 bits might help here. This isn't necessary if you control the volume in the DAC and the DAC has a larger bit depth, but this doesn't always correspond to what exists and is convenient in every setup. https://www.thewelltemperedcomputer.com/Intro/SQ/VolumeControl.htm https://www.thewelltemperedcomputer.com/Intro/SQ/VolumeContr...
- kashunstva 4y agoI was skeptical of the idea when it was announced a few weeks ago but I like what I see. Music discovery on the classical side is different from popular genres. Often I’m trying to discover new/different recordings of works I’m already familiar with. Different players, conductors, etc. Here, it’s a success. For example I’m playing the Beethoven Op. 97 at a festival this summer. I have my go-to recordings but I’m curious what’s out there. The search here yields complete works; rather than a movement here and a movement there, album here and and album there. This is priceless compared to the classically-oriented search elsewhere.
- lesterchixi 4y ago[dead]