35 ms·
Seattle could become the first city to ban caste discrimination
- triyambakam 4y ago[flagged]
- bitL 4y agoUntouchables weren't invented by the British.
- triyambakam 4y agoThey did, yes
- 4mitkumar 4y agoAll the more reason not to keep it anymore, right?
- ComputerGuru 4y agoWhy do people do that? Just blindly repeat something when they can just look it up and see they’re wrong or fight back with a citation if they’re not? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalit https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalit It’s hypothesized to have started around 400 CE. It clearly predates British India.
- triceratops 4y agoIt's easier to believe a lie that makes someone else look bad, than the truth.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SharifZ 4y ago[dead]
- MughalLuvr 4y agoOh man, Mahmoud's not gonna like this! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_South_Asian_Muslims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste_system_among_South_Asian... Paraphrasing: Muslims who invaded/robbed the subcontinent were ALREADY divided into vocation based social "classes" , including priests, nobles and others. Further, a racial segregation demarcated the local Muslim converts from foreign origin Muslims . The foreigner Muslims claimed a superior status as they were associated with the conquerors and categorized themselves as Ashraf ("noble"). Remember two things before you post next time: 1. Wikipedia is well-cited, and social strata issues are rampant amongst all people, including Muslims. 2. Messenger of Allah said “Even if he observes Saum (fasts), performs Salat (prayer) and claims to be a Muslim, the hypocrite does three things: When he speaks, he lies; when he makes a promise, he breaks it; and when he is trusted, he betrays his trust.” Awaiting your well-cited rebuttal, ComputerGuru.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roguecoder 4y agoThe oppression of the caste-less was not new: it is described in both Dharmasutras and Manusmriti. The English exploited it, certainly, but they didn't need to invent it. We wouldn't have all the saints of the Warkari tradition, who fought against caste oppression, without caste oppression to fight against.
- Gibbon1 4y agoI saw an abstract where they did genetic testing of various castes. They haven't intermarried significantly for ~2000 years. Newsy article discussing. https://hms.harvard.edu/news/genetics-proves-indian-population-mixture https://hms.harvard.edu/news/genetics-proves-indian-populati...
- kazinator 4y agoSteak and kidney pudding? Stargazey pie? Beef Wellington?
- fooker 4y agoThis is categorically false. Caste has been hereditary for ~800-1200 years. Sure, it was considered more flexible in the 4000 year old literature, but it doesn't really make sense to blame the British here.
- politelemon 4y agoNot so, the discriminatory aspects have existed for thousands of years. However it is always convenient to blame an unpleasant aspect such as this on a foreign scapegoat.
- triceratops 4y agoEven if that's true (which it's not), what's the excuse for keeping it after they left?
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThe British saw a highly fragmented society with fragmented territories, and realized that all the Divide and Conquer work they had to do was essentially already done. They just had to get the ball rolling by making each group fight each other. Good job! You did over 50% of their colonization work for free. Stop discriminating each other :-)
- lern_too_spel 4y agoOh, so that's why the British American Foundation is fighting this law instead of the Hindu American Foundation.
- theHiddenLayer 4y agoShowcasing the work of Rajiv Malhotra who has dedicated around 40 years (working full-time) to researching this topic... https://youtu.be/5iD9-dIypl4 https://youtu.be/5iD9-dIypl4
- unmole 4y agoRajiv Malhotra is a deranged conspiracy theorist who should not be taken seriously.
- ghltshubh 4y agoI know most people working in tech aren't known for reading history books but this book should help Castes of Minds https://a.co/d/b55ZoJ9 https://a.co/d/b55ZoJ9
- tradethedelta 4y agoYes, legislative actions will magically get rid of racism and discrimination.
- eynsham 4y agoAre you just here to sneer or do you have an actual point as to how effective this legislation is likely to be? Anything from obviously effective to utterly pointless laws can be derided as an attempt to ‘magically get rid of’ a problem.
- seanw444 4y agoDidn't you know? Anything and everything can be solved by adding another law to the pile!
- HyperSane 4y agoMaking it illegal gives people who are discriminated based on their caste a method of seeking justice.
- woodruffw 4y agoLaw doesn't do anything "magically." It does things by shifting incentives and establishing punishments. You can't legislate bigotry out of a bigot, but you can minimize the suffering they cause other people. This is what anti-discrimination laws aim to do.
- reilly3000 4y agoGotta read this post. It’s a quick one and explains how India’s caste system is being used at the workplace by fellow Indians to remind the that they are still ‘untouchables’ and do so in a matter that materially impacts employment.
- roguecoder 4y agoLegislative action moved women from holding 13.97% of professional roles in the United States in 1966 to holding 50.56% of professional roles in 1996. Even rarely- and poorly-enforced laws can, over a period of just 30 years, dramatically shift the corporate landscape.
- voz_ 4y agoProgress here is good - however Seattle is so deeply fucked across so many axis of policy, that I am not sure this is a good focus at the moment.
- whitepoplar 4y agoI don't live in Seattle. How is it fucked?
- RandallBrown 4y agoIt's not. It's a great city.
- nodra 4y agoThe homeless crisis and crime. It has gotten increasingly worse. Edit: typo
- mulmen 4y agoAnd the time, resources, and expertise required to solve those timeless problems are relevant to discrimination policy how? Could we solve homelessness and crime by repealing all discrimination laws?
- nodra 4y agoThe context of the question isn’t about how it’s related to the caste policy. Maybe I missed something? Not addressing the homeless and crime issues is a kick in the face to us tax payers in her district. Not to knock on the caste system policy but there’s biggest issues to tackle before anything else. Just my .02
- mulmen 4y agoI guess you didn’t read my comment. How is discrimination policy detracting from efforts to reduce crime or homelessness? From where I sit you invoked unrelated issues to a discussion on anti-discrimination policy. Is there a connection I missed?
- testfoobar 4y agoNot a lawyer. - How is this implemented? - How is caste defined under American law? - Is there an enumerated list of all castes? - How does one demonstrate under American law that person A is of caste X and person B is of caste Y? - How is caste "assigned"? - Can one switch castes? Is ones caste immutable? - Does one register a caste like a political party? This feels like a massive green field of legal questions under Western law.
- woodruffw 4y agoThese are all reasonable questions, but probably irrelevant for this kind of law: the law is not (necessarily) interested in determining a person's caste, but instead whether the defendant acted under a belief about a person's caste.
- roguecoder 4y agoThe thing someone is discriminated on the basis of doesn't need to be defined to make the discrimination illegal. What matters is that the person who did the discrimination based it on the perceived characteristic of the person they discriminated against.
- nice_byte 4y agoit doesn't matter. caste discrimination is very similar to racial discrimination - of course, race, as well as caste, has no strict definition under law. in fact, i would go as far as to say race cannot possibly be defined in a way that is useful. to put it differently, if you don't actually belong to "race x", but fulfill someone's stereotype about "race x", you can still become a victim of racial discrimination. the exact nature of what race or caste is, doesn't matter at all - it's the intent to exclude people based on one's preconceived notions of caste/race that does.
- Spooky23 4y agoHow do you know that someone is gay? Or an alcoholic? Or Dominican? If someone believes that you’re a gay Dominican, but you’re actually a straight Puerto Rican, it’s not relevant. The action is the tort.
- 4y ago
- onphonenow 4y agoFantastic. I do hope Seattle also attends to what used to be kind of core govt functions for qol items. Been a bit bummed at big govt performance on crime, education etc
- TMWNN 4y ago[flagged]
- yding 4y agoI have lots of Indian and Indian American friends and coworkers. Not once have they suggested that we hire someone on the basis of caste or not hire someone on the basis of caste. I'm not saying caste discrimination doesn't exist, but let's not paint 1.4 billion people with the same brush.
- it_citizen 4y agoWhile I agree with the point of your message, I don't think your personal experience and relationships with Indian is a good argument. There are many stories of employees or managers that could not believe that their sweet quiet coworker bullied other coworkers of a different cast for months or years. People are complex and sometimes end up doing stuff we never thought they would be capable of. That's also probably why this is such a hard problem to fix.
- oceanplexian 4y agoThe problem with this thought process is the same reason systemic racism is often brought up (Which I don’t entirely agree with, but there is probably an element of truth to it). Most people are not going to openly admit to being discriminatory. And they might not even be self aware enough to realize they are being discriminatory. So it’s not even a thing of explicit bias but your coworkers could be making decisions subconsciously because they perceive a caste a certain way.
- oneoff786 4y agoA lot of Americans say this and don’t realize their Indian coworkers all belong to the same couple groups and that it’s actually pretty insular
- smt88 4y agoSo your solution to caste-based discrimination is to replace it with racism, which would harm a far larger number of people? It's repulsive to think I'd ever work with you or someone like you.
- roguecoder 4y agoI wish the article had pointed out the Hindu American Foundation's long history of support for Hindu-supremacist nationalist causes, in addition to its denial of the impact of caste discrimination. It is good to see Seattle stand up for what is right here.
- desi_ninja 4y agoHindu American Foundation works against Hinduphobia in USA. You are falling in the same trap of working for Hindu causes = modi supporter which borders on racist attitude. Raising voices for Hindu representation doesn't mean that person is batting for Indian govt in US. This is actually racist thinking. Japanese faced the same thing during WW2, russians and chinese during the red scare and now Hindus in America.
- roguecoder 4y agoIt actively supports a narrow, reactionary view of Hinduism, including (unsuccessfully) suing Hindu activists who actually are fighting against Hinduphobia. Hindu nationalism is a massive problem, just like Christian nationalism is a massive problem here in America. Supporting Hindu nationalism is not required to support Hinduism any more than supporting Zionism is required to support Judaism.
- desi_ninja 4y agoHindu nationalism in US doesn't make sense. HAF works in USA. Your argument is flawed. Why should I care about India and connect it to HAF ? That is as i pointed out, flawed and racist thinking.
- x-complexity 4y agoThere is no possible positive justification for the existence of castes: It's plainly just a softer version of slavery. It should be of the utmost importance to not only prevent the spread of castes, but to utterly destroy them as a concept.
- mulmen 4y agoWhile I agree with you in this case we do have to acknowledge that such a statement can only be made from a position of moral superiority. That’s an uncomfortable position to take in the general case.
- coolestguy 4y ago>moral superiority I don't feel bad about objective moral superiority. Just beacuse the caste system is ingraind in Indian culture doesn't mean it should be respected or allowed.
- mulmen 4y agoThere’s no such thing as objective moral superiority. Morality is subjective.
- coolestguy 4y agoIncorrect. Your sentence is what a typical fence sitter would say, where they think you can go through life not offending bad people and thinking that makes you tolerant.
- mulmen 4y agoI’m not fence sitting. I am committed to spending lives to achieve my preferred geopolitical goals.
- Manuel_D 4y agoI'm totally comfortable in asserting the moral superiority of emancipation, both of slavery and caste.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoI used to work in a FAANG and witnessed caste discrimination firsthand. It’s one of those things that most don’t notice at all unless one is either directly involved or a direct witness to it in America. Since the concept is so culturally foreign to a lot of people it simply goes unnoticed in the workplace to a lot of people who are not privy to the possibility of it happening.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 4y agoThe headline makes it sound like it's a municipal thing, like dogs pooping on sidewalks, rather than a constitutional issue.
- emodendroket 4y agoBecause the proposed law is a municipal one.
- tw1984 4y agoAs a Han Chinese, what caste I would be in when dealing with those abusers who openly discriminate their peers?
- ramesh31 4y ago>As a Han Chinese, what caste I would be in when dealing with those abusers who openly discriminate their peers? Congrats, you get the good kind of discrimination in tech.
- meowtimemania 4y agoBy "good kind of discrimination" do you mean affirmative action? Han Chinese is pretty over represented at a lot of tech companies, so I doubt they'd be sought out based on any diversity initiative.
- ramesh31 4y ago>By "good kind of discrimination" do you mean affirmative action? I mean the kind that doesn't need affirmative action >Han Chinese is pretty over represented at a lot of tech companies Yeah exactly
- tw1984 4y ago> Han Chinese is pretty over represented at a lot of tech companies Probably because both the Han and Anglo Saxon cultures are investing techs in trillions?
- zapdrive 4y ago[flagged]
- tw1984 4y agoSimply by being Han Chinese? That itself sounds like a discrimination to me.
- sitkack 4y agoI have worked in the Seattle tech scene since 1997 and sex and caste discrimination is rampant in the Indian tech community. I only know this 2nd and third hand as I am the stereotypical cis male white guy. The biggest one to me is the sex discrimination across dev and qa, with a women making up the vast majority of qa even though they graduated with the same degrees as the men from the same Indian universities. Even Indian men that I respected on multiple levels, when they get on an interview with a women they are overly harsh in ways they were not with men. So much so that I stopped interviewing all together. I reported to HR and they of course didn't know how to handle it. It really makes me sad. I try to talk to my Indian colleagues about this and they stay extremely tight lipped about this for a multitude of reasons. I applaud this action. This shit has to stop, leave it in India, America is better than this. Discrimination is fractal. All interview should be truly double-blind. https://www.cancer.gov/publications/dictionaries/cancer-terms/def/double-blind-study https://www.cancer.gov/publications/dictionaries/cancer-term...
- brailsafe 4y agoNow that you mention it, on my non-American fully remote team, while we have no Indian men as engineers, I believe all our QAs are Indian women.
- meowtimemania 4y agoI never realized it, but on my team we have several Indian male engineers, no female engineers, and 4 Indian female QA
- codegeek 4y agoSee my comment above about "women in QA". Also, "no female engineers" is laughable because that is 1 anecdote. There are plenty of Indian female engineers. You know that right ?
- Dylan16807 4y ago"on my team" does mean anecdote. That's not laughable.
- brailsafe 4y agoSeems like a decent idea if it can be enforced, but is Seattle itself all that significant? What about Redmond and Bellevue?
- no_butterscotch 4y agoI live in SF, and I've had co-workers here open "brag" about being able to tell whether someone is a brahmin or a kshatriya (sp?). I had one co-worker who would brag that he isn't discriminative to anyone, except other Indians. We (non-Indians) would kind of have a response of "ah ha ha ha yea... you could do that we can't". Because of course as team members who aren't minorities we can't be found to do any of that stuff, but there's plenty of minorities who have taken over in discriminating against others based on their own cultural criteria and seem to get a pass.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoReport them to HR. That is not normal.
- emodendroket 4y agoI would imagine a big reason why you can get away with this is that most people who are not Indian have very little understanding about it and would find it hard to detect a pattern of misbehavior.
- pancrufty 4y ago> seem to get a pass. I don’t think there’s anything wrong in being able to identify certain groups. The issue is when the identification is followed by a different behavior. I can identify different breeds of cats but it doesn’t mean I will mistreat bengals.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- locusofself 4y agoSo I work at Microsoft and I live in Redmond (Seattle suburb). I live in a large neighborhood that is 95% Indian families. My family is white and my daughter is the only white girl on the playground. It's a weird change from growing up in a place that was 95% white people for most of my life. Everyone is friendly but it hasn't been easy for us to integrate hyper-locally. I sometimes feel like our family is intruding in this neighborhood with our non-Indian-ness. I've noticed that there are lots of teams that are primarily Indian folks and this is true not just of the contractors and India based teams. I really don't know about the dynamics of the caste system and whether not they are at play within MSFT, AMZN or other Seattle/tech companies, but just like most (all?) ethnicities there is certainly a tendency to stick together and live in the same areas / work on the same teams from what I've seen. On a mostly unrelated note, Seattle proper (as I mentioned, I live in a suburb which is an affluent one) has really gone downhill in the last 10 years. The homeless/drug problem is very bad and the local government seems so entirely incompetent to do anything other than woke signaling.
- emodendroket 4y agoWhy wouldn't the caste system be in play? If you imagine a company in a foreign country that hired a lot of Americans, would you not expect the same problems with racial discrimination that happen in the US to arise among these American employees?
- locusofself 4y agooh, I assume it definitely is, I just mean that I'm not really privy to the dynamics of it myself. My comment was mostly only tangentially related
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rippercushions 4y agoHaving worked at the overseas operation of an American company that had a lot of American expats, no, not really, because those expats are not a random sampling of American society: they're overwhelmingly white and Asian, and the few that weren't were all upper class/highly educated and not viewed as threats. You can see the same effect in the Indian diaspora in America as well. I'm having trouble finding stats on this, but by and large it's also highly educated, from the upper crust of society in India, overwhelmingly Brahmin and many groups (eg. Gujaratis) are statistically overrepresented compared to the Indian population at large. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/nri/us-canada-news/gujaratis-6-of-indians-but-20-of-us-indians/articleshow/45746350.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/nri/us-canada-news/gujar...
- password11 4y ago> The 39-year-old immigrant from India, who works in Seattle on a H-1B visa, said as soon as he heard the question “Do you eat meat?” from his Indian manager he knew he was in trouble. > By admitting to eating meat, the tech worker had exposed himself as a member of an oppressed caste, or a Dalit, formerly known as an “untouchable,” in the social hierarchy that is pervasive in South Asian countries. (EDIT: if the article and allegations are true) I say the following as an outsider, an American, and with the utmost respect for other cultures and their right to dignity and the integrity of their traditions within our society: Jesus Christ. What the fuck is wrong with this person. This is an unacceptable behavior, and it should be banned as a condition of entry to the country. This supposedly enlightened and woke country. Although this is a cultural tradition -- and it's not our place to judge what may or may not go on in India -- all humans are equal here, and this tradition should not be allowed in the United States. (EDIT: Maybe this story is a false flag, maybe this is all fake, to justify layoffs, purges, etc... but if not, the above is my opinion as an anon.)
- uptownfunk 4y agoUh, there are a lot of supposedly upper caste people who eat meat. Maybe in the old days but I thought the caste stuff was no longer a thing. It’s really the wokeism / sjw finding their next supposed cause.
- mulmen 4y ago> This is an unacceptable behavior, and it should be banned as a condition of entry to the country. Or, we could embrace everyone, establish equal rules for participation in our society and show them a better way. I think this “Jesus Christ” you invoke would agree.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cmurf 4y agoPrivately held businesses are treated as persons and can have sincerely held religious beliefs, Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores. I have no idea if the conservatives on the SCOTUS would permit caste discrimination as a sincerely held religious belief, or if they consider only Christian religious beliefs as sincere.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoAh yes interesting. There was a Christian political party in the Netherlands that refused membership to women. The Dutch high court obliterated their religious beliefs. Constitution preempts all.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoLatin America also had a caste system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casta Today, it evolved into nepotism and corruption.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoThe Dutch constitution explicitly mentions faith based discrimination. "Allen die zich in Nederland bevinden, worden in gelijke gevallen gelijk behandeld. Discriminatie wegens godsdienst, levensovertuiging, politieke gezindheid, ras, geslacht of op welke grond dan ook, is niet toegestaan" I assume the US Constitution does not?
- tobinfricke 4y agoIt's not in the US constitution, but it's in federal and state laws, especially concerning employment and housing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_group
- ch4s3 4y agoThe civil rights act covers faith based discrimination in employment, housing, public accommodation, etc. The constitution here prohibits the establishment(or preferential treatment) of a religion by government.
- Georgelemental 4y agoThe US Constitution sets out what our government can and can't do. And one of the things it can't do is discriminate based on religion. But there is almost nothing in our Constitution restricting the actions of private citizens; that is left for normal laws to take care of.
- Reptur 4y agoDoes this include people with disabilities? The normal interview process is setup to weed out people with neurological disorders, since it requires you to be personable and make a "good impression". 85% of college grads with autism are unemployed. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/most-college-grads-with-autism-cant-find-jobs-this-group-is-fixing-that-2017-04-10-5881421 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/most-college-grads-with-au...
- emodendroket 4y agoNo but discriminating against people with disabilities would violate other laws.
- Reptur 4y agoExcept it isn't provable, therefore it isn't enforced.
- emodendroket 4y agoRace, sex, and caste discrimination are also difficult to prove and give rise to successful lawsuits less frequently than they happen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roguecoder 4y agoPart of the challenge is that the ADA is different than other anti-discrimination laws. We do usually allow discrimination on the basis of ability. That is, after all, what an interview is trying to do: establish whether someone has the ability to do the job at hand. What the ADA requires is that a company make accommodations for specific disabilities, in both interviewing and the job itself, to ensure the ability being screened for actually is relevant to the work. https://www.hireautism.org/resource-center/interview-accommodations https://www.hireautism.org/resource-center/interview-accommo... has examples of accommodations you may request. "Getting questions ahead of time" and "perform an at-home work sample" are the two I've seen have the most success in our field. Being able to communicate effectively on Zoom is often a part of our day-to-day work in remote positions, especially as either a junior engineer learning or a senior engineer effectively mentoring junior engineers, but being able to type in front of other people is only relevant in shops that practice pair programming and outside of incident scenarios we almost always know what we are about to work on.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoMy experience has been that even beyond caste, huge tech companies get these weird race/ethnicity based fiefdoms embedded within them. The company might be “improving diversity” but there are whole teams from director down that are 90% Indian immigrants and the Indian team members are promoted from within, same for East Asian, haven’t seen Slavic type yet but probably out there. Had some strange experiences where 7/8 coworkers were Chinese and routinely spent the entire day talking together in Chinese and excluding me from like regular work convos high impact projects and general progress early in my career.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 4y ago>...and routinely spent the entire day talking together in Chinese and excluding me from like regular work convos high impact projects and general progress early in my career. Outside the US, I've seen companies with a diverse work force implement "english only" policies in the office.
- JenrHywy 4y agoThat's the policy where I am, for any work-related conversations. Private conversations obviously are different.
- midoridensha 4y agoMaybe that's considered "racist" in the US or something.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoIt’s not that it’s racist to bring it up, it’s that if your an IC eng experiencing this your manager, skip level and 2x skip are likely in on the whole race based fiefdom thing and the next person to talk to is a senior director/VP who is a very important person that you rarely see and never talk with.
- cld8483 4y agoThose polices are flagrantly ignored.
- zapdrive 4y agoWhereas in India caste based discrimination is written in the law. Yes the so called "upper caste" are discriminated against at every step of their life. Be it college admissions or government jobs or getting elected, almost 50% seats are reserved for the "lower caste". This was written in the law at the time of the formation of republic, as a temporary measure to uplift the lower castes. But no party in power has even talked about removing these even 75 years later, because you know.... Votes!!! It would be a political suicide for a party to undo these reservations. Now I'm not against giving reservations to weaker sections of the society. But these must be based on economic status, not caste. There are many cases where even the third generation is taking benefits. I personally know a few where the be grand father retired from a plush govt. job that he got under reservation, the father is currently in a top bureaucratic job and the kids are getting reservation seats in medical college admissions. This makes 0 sense. This is only giving rise to more division among caste lines as the upper caste feel like being discriminated against.
- emodendroket 4y agoAgree with it or don't but this is obviously a measure intended to redress an extreme historical imbalance up until it was instituted.
- zapdrive 4y agoRead my comment again. I agree it was necessary at some point. But not anymore. Does the third generation need to take these benefits? Do you think the children of a Deputy Commissioner, or an MLA are being discriminated against? They are the most privileged already with best educational opportunities. Why do they need reservation for college admission?
- roguecoder 4y agoIn the absence of a system to correct for historical and ongoing injustice, you get the English system where 73% of all government jobs are held by people with the generational wealth to attend elite high schools (who are otherwise only 7% of the population). And then you end up with the horrible mess of class-anxious governance by mediocre-but-born-rich folks that is the current disaster England is living through. I'm not sure why people would aspire to that.
- russelldjimmy 4y agoI want to share a personal anecdote here. It may be tangential, but I think it’s worth sharing anyway. I live in a cosmopolitan city in India. I am an “upper caste” Hindu. I have been brought up in a relatively liberal environment and have not experienced much first hand caste-based discrimination (because of my sheltered upbringing no doubt). I have always thought of my family as liberal. A few years ago, I wanted to marry a girl who was out of my caste. My family did not accept her immediately. They never uttered the word “caste”, but made snide remarks about “her community”, and about how “our community” is full of “ambitious intellectuals” and hers is not (implying moral superiority to ambition and intellect). They had not even met her. They just knew her surname and had seen pictures. Made me wonder where all of these assumptions came from. She was not privy to these conversations but she realised that something was not right, and asked me if caste was being an issue. And that’s when it struck me that maybe it was caste that was being the issue. My mind swirled with nasty thoughts for a few weeks. “Should I marry this girl who is outside of my caste?”, “What if no one accepts me? I’ll be alone”, etc. For someone who is fairly liberal, well educated, and well travelled, I was shocked at the kind of thoughts appearing in my mind. They were more powerful than I ever thought they could be. Thankfully, due to my meditation practices, I had developed the ability to “witness” my thoughts without simply giving in to them. That way, I could let my thoughts flow, and wait for my fear to pass. After the fear had passed, my mind would settle down and I’d think rationally again. What’s the point of this anecdote? I had an important realisation. It is quite possible that the things we call “casteism” is nothing but a flavour of the fear of abandonment, or the fear of being expelled from society by not conforming to societal standards. I realised that the standards can be absolutely absurd, but it is the mere fear of being abandoned by society that can make a human being conform and commit the most ridiculous actions. All out of fear. Take whatever conclusion you may from this. It is an insight into the mind of someone who never thought would discriminate on the basis of caste, and yet my mind veered into that abyss, if only for a short duration. I escaped and lived to tell the tale. Thanks for reading.
- abc_lisper 4y agoOstracism is a well known punishment in the western world. Greeks used to practice it. So are the recent woke cancellation standards. It is not unique to India.
- Georgelemental 4y agoImport the world's people, import the world's problems
- roguecoder 4y agoIt's how America got slavery: importing Europeans.
- Ndymium 4y agoSlavery existed among Native Americans before Europeans already.
- notRobot 4y agoBut also the world's talent
- vjust 4y agoI am an upper caste (meat eating) American Indian. This stigma attached to caste, eating meat, is real among upper class Indians, especially Brahmins (me), and this needs to be put up as an issue, to hold a mirror to this community. Many many Indians of these upper castes, especially if they're not meat-eating, tend to be conservative in their cultural and religious values. They disapprove of American culture. They consider meat eating a sin. Some, or many of this upper caste group will support the current Indian government's policy against meat eating. These people live in a bubble. About caste in India, my upper caste has been discriminating over the lower castes for more than a thousand years. And growing up we never once had these conversations, either at school or around the dinner table. These traits are ingrained in me, and one way I handle it is by embracing Americanism, and minimizing contact with Indian cultural groups (i'd be an oddball politically anyway). 70% of India is not upper caste. Only now are Dalits (lower castes) waking up in India . And I had to remind my vegetarian wife, 70% of India is meat eating (which she was reluctant to accept) - so you want to judge 70% of Indian people?. She grew up in a Brahmin area of Bangalore where most of her school mates were Brahmins, I grew up in a catholic school where most of my classmates were meat eating Christians. Such factors can dictate cultural attitudes. (I've managed to tutor her well, and bring her around). Many ancient religious texts mention our gods feasting on meat, beef, etc. Yet we act as if we are some holy sacred shit. I've debated disowning my caste (brahmin) but that would offend my SO. Thankfully my 2 kids are a healthy mix of American questioning of such bullshit, and non-religious. The only defense I can offer is that Indians operate with a mob-mentality - too timid to standup and take a bold stance, and secondly it takes a generation to wear down this kind of ingrained thinking. Critical thinkers we are are not, especially in our personal lives, we tow the line, the existing lines. We're not trailblazers. Our excellence is within the straitjackets of corporate structure, within already established frameworks. The desensitized, one-dimensional corporate American culture is fertile ground for our achievements. We lead our lives inside the elite tech bubbles, where all that matters is academics, tech elite jobs, and toxic out-dated traditions. We politely smile, but in private within our upper caste living rooms, our families look down on 'other' cultures for their meat consumption, for sexual openness , for the lack of 'spiritual enlightenment' etc. I welcome this naming and shaming of my community. This flaw in our community should be brought out and talked about. That's healthy.
- screye 4y agoAs a non-veg Indian who does not come from an upper caste and has worked in Seattle, I have yet to experience any instance of caste even being mentioned in Indian circles, let alone experience any semblance of discrimination or see it happen near me. > By admitting to eating meat, the tech worker had exposed himself as a member of an oppressed caste This is backwards. Most upper-caste people eat non-veg food, and continuing to be pure-veg is viewed as being behind the times in urban India. On the contrary, I know many people who started eating non-veg food because they didn't want to be seen as prudes. > dominant castes are unwilling to eat with those from oppressed castes I'd believe it if someone told me IITians didn't eat with those from other universities. Or that 2nd gen Indian-Americans didn't eat with 1st gen immigrants. But this sort of thing is practically unheard of. Our Indian circle is pretty huge, and I haven't ever even so much as heard a whisper about this. > Cisco Might be that such stuff is prevalent in certain companies. I don't know anyone at Cisco, so I won't know. It must suck to have caste follow you from your rural town in India. But, these stories sound pretty cherry picked to me. I find that Americans have some bizzare views and opinions about India. Like they read some colonial era British report about the nation, watched slum dog millionaire and that's it. India has changed an insane amount since independence, and it has changed even more than that just in the last 20 years. I consistently find that HN threads about India are among the lowest quality of discourse on this forum. Highly opinionated while still being misinformed. The worst combination. > Kshama Sawant if you know, you know....... why am I not surprised
- belltaco 4y agoMy experience mirrors yours. In my large groups of Indian coworkers, family and friends, mention or discussion of caste comes up zero times. It's so bizarre to read HN articles and comments on caste and they feel surreal. I think there is a certain section of HN'ers who make a big deal of this and upvote nonsense posts so it helps them compete against Indian Americans for promotions to managerial positions. For disclosure, I am not a high caste Indian, and both sides of my family eat meat.
- yutijke 4y agoHave you spoken to your American colleagues about their opinions on these topics (unfiltered)? My experience on the internet essentially has been that you cannot discuss a topic even peripherally related to India with Americans on the internet without a mention of Hindu Nationalism, Caste, Religion and "It's not racist if it's actually true"-isms. Does this belligerant ignorance extend to IRL interactions (maybe more polite). The HN discourse on India and related topics is giving me a serious feeling of Gell Mann amnesia. The lack of intellectual rigour and over generalisation of a few cases has been making me adjust my priors on the weight of any discussion here on other unfamiliar topics which can't be proven to be objective fact. A lot of the supposed cases of casteism seem to be willful ignorance of linguistic/regional/other cliquey behaviour that is common among Indians (and the rest of humanity). This makes it hard for me as an Indian who hasn't worked/lived in America to actually judge if these people actually know what they are talking about.
- emodendroket 4y agoThere's a striking scene in Naipaul's "An Area of Darkness" where he describes a team "cleaning" a staircase, and really all they're doing is sloshing dirty water around and making it as bad or worse than when they started -- but no matter, it is "clean" because persons of the right caste performed each step of the work.
- 10g1k 4y agoEverything about that article is ridiculous. It's not just the Dalit that eat meat. McKFCburgers are everywhere in India. Asking if someone eats meat has nothing to do with castes or oppression.
- meowtimemania 4y agoWhen I visited a few McDonald’s in south India they didn’t serve chicken or beef, just paneer. At the time I assumed paneer just meant chicken. I soon was sad to learn I was mistaken.
- ryloric 4y agoI call bullshit, every McD always served chicken in the southern and western India. I know a few people who work on the corporate side of things. You can find beef too in many parts of southern India, but it will most likely to be buffalo meat. Kerala has all sorts of meats iirc.
- bongoman37 4y ago[dead]
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoThat diversity stuff OUSD really working out great. We now have a diverse set of problems, not just all of the original problems too. How wonderful that when we imported India, we also got the diversity of India problems. No, guys, it’s fine. This OSS a great thing to have all kinds of diverse problems of all the different cultures from everywhere all at the same time.
- yeahbutiguess 4y agoThese problems don't go away if you ignore them. And your solution of not "importing different cultures" sure sounds like you want an ethnostate...
- roguecoder 4y agoThis but unsarcastically. Think about how many white Americans will be able to see that this is wrong, when they think anti-Blackness is a matter of culture and assume people who speak African-American Vernacular English are less educated. When we have a mix of problems, we can build large enough anti-discrimination coalitions to make none of those discriminatory beliefs advantageous to hold.
- fooker 4y ago>By admitting to eating meat, the tech worker had exposed himself as a member of an oppressed caste. This seems to be fabricated to push an agenda. The vast majority of Indians of all religions and castes eat non vegetarian food.
- chanakya 4y agoThis may sound crude, but I think is pretty close to reality. This is Indian activists trying to muscle in on the massive DEI industry in the US, from which they are currently excluded. There is zero evidence that caste is a causal factor in the US, in the sense that those of lower castes can have signigicant discrimination imposed on them by upper castes. Of course there will be many casteist Indians in the US. There are many in India, so moving to the US will not make their numbers zero. But their ability to impose casteist discrimination in the US is pretty close to zero. I moved to the US 40 years ago, have dozens of Indian friends, but have never heard of even a single significant case. There is a grand total of one case (the Cisco one) in court, and that's still to be decided.
- dotnet00 4y agoCaste discrimination in the US manifests more as social "discrimination", where people from a caste lean towards others from the same caste than others due to perceived brotherhood. I feel like this especially manifests in groups where there are already a large number of Indians, such that being Indian itself isn't enough brotherhood. Eg, when choosing between two equally qualified Indians, choosing the person from the same caste (which is slightly ironic since a similar idea applies to diversity initiatives). As another commenter said, it's a sort of "fractal" discrimination.
- lolinder 4y ago> There is zero evidence that caste is a causal factor in the US ... There is a grand total of one case (the Cisco one) in court, and that's still to be decided. The plaintiff in that case is presumably putting forward evidence, so "zero evidence" is putting this rather strongly. You say that you've never witnessed it, but I've never witnessed overt racial discrimination and I don't try to claim that therefore such things don't happen. Here's what I see every time this topic comes up: I read plenty of horror stories from victims and from non-Indian witnesses, and plenty of fervent denials from admittedly-upper-caste Indian Americans. Could there be some massive astroturfing campaign propping up false anecdotes? It's conceivable. But a much simpler explanation is that there are lots of lower-caste people who are discriminated against and lots of upper-caste people who are blind to it or won't admit they perpetrate it.
- trieste92 4y agoAnother thing I've noticed aside from caste discrimination (as a white guy) is how much Indians talk about marriage (and the way it's talked about) I saw this post on blind a couple months ago where a woman engineer reported her manager to hr because he asked her if she was married point blank. Most of the top voted comments were really nasty towards her, calling her mentally ill etc. I have other examples on top of this from work or uni but this was the most poignant one Then I saw this* article like a week later, good read * https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/world/asia/india-single-women-apartments.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/world/asia/india-single-w...
- unmole 4y ago> Then I saw this* article like a week later, good read * https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/world/asia/india-single-w https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/world/asia/india-single-w... > Many landlords see renting to single women alone or in groups (and single men, to a lesser extent) as a risk — to the stability of families, to the reputations of neighborhoods. Yeah, no. Landlords don't like renting to single people of either gender. The rental listings usually say Families only or No bachelors. I don't know from where the author got the idea that single men are less likely to be seen as a risk. But that doesn't match my lived experience of more than 7 years in Bengaluru . In one particular instance though, the landlord was willing to rent to spinsters but not to bachelors. Indian women face plenty of structural issues and discrimination. But this particular issue is not gendered. And it is disingenuous that the article tries to spin it that way.
- anovikov 4y agoAlways makes me wondering - why do these people work in Indian-managed companies? Outside of Indian expats, no one knows or gives a damn about castes. And this is probably the most toxic environment to work in, anyway - Indian companies are known for their power games and nepotism. Why choose them?
- yeahbutiguess 4y agoI would assume that anywhere you work, the opportunity for discrimination exists independent of who is a manager.
- anovikov 4y agoJust not caste discrimination. No one who isn't from India or Bangladesh (and partially, Pakistan), has a slightest idea what a caste is and which of them are "better".
- yeahbutiguess 4y agoMy point is that people other than management influence your career. From interviews to mentorship to peer feedback there's lots of places where discrimination can creep in.
- anovikov 4y agoWe Russians face the same problem (except all us are a "bad" caste). Solution is to try hard to work in environment with no other Russians or Russian-speakers.
- unmole 4y ago> why do these people work in Indian-managed companies? Let me get this straight: You are wondering why people work for companies like Google, Microsoft, VmWare or Adobe?
- hackerthrow 4y agoI'm a very senior person (20+ years) industry experience in India in companies like Msft, Goog etc. In all these kinds of Multinational companies and even more so in startups (new or old) never see any 'caste' aspect being played out. If it is there it may be happening in more bottom of the rung companies where meritocracy is not really thing during hiring and then when planning for growth of the employees. In these places one would also typically see 'company veterans' who have minimal tech skills but hold power positions. Also, the article is not factually correct - being non-vegetarian does not indicate that one is from lower caste. Infact in eastern part of India people from 'higher caste' eat meat and fish. India also has substantial population of non-vegetarian, only 19% are vegetarian https://twitter.com/Stats_of_India/status/1583331135060205568 https://twitter.com/Stats_of_India/status/158333113506020556...
- skataz 4y ago[dead]
- roguecoder 4y agoA belief in meritocracy is associated with higher rates of discrimination: https://gap.hks.harvard.edu/paradox-meritocracy-organizations https://gap.hks.harvard.edu/paradox-meritocracy-organization...
- sgustard 4y agoI wonder what the first non-Indian complaints under this law will look like. Is "blue-collar" a caste that office workers can no longer discriminate against?
- skataz 4y ago[dead]
- chemmail 4y ago3 2 1 where are the SJW crying about suppression of culture.
- moresjwbs 4y agoAnother “feel good” measure that will impart zero change on any caste discrimination in the area. Sad. Sadly this is about the only thing that Seattle knows how to do anymore; the politicians know that it keeps them elected.
- juanani 4y ago[dead]
- penguin_booze 4y agoImmigrants take note: "Leave your garbage at home". Sincerely, By another immigrant.
- reactspa 4y agoFor what it's worth, caste has fortunately ceased to have meaning in a tiny number of social and geographic circles. But upper castes are in denial about how caste plays out in the rest of India. They will claim it was something in the past. Wrong. Upper castes still often whisper about so and so being a *** (impolite way of referring to someone of a lower caste), or about such and such work (e.g. cleaning dishes) being the work of a *** and not a Brahmin like themselves. Some now claim that caste was created by the British. Wrong. Al Biruni (traveler from Persia) in 1020 wrote in Tarikh Al-Hind (History of India) about how when there was a communal meal in the village, a barrier needed to be put up between people of lower castes and people of upper castes. My own personal experiences with caste (as someone exposed to it very late in life) were described here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31035615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31035615
- hobabaObama 4y agoCasteism is something which you cannot comprehend unless you are a lower caste person yourself. Imagine how so many things are designed for right handed person and most of us never see that issue which left-handed people face on day-to-day basis. That is why when you have discussion on caste-discrimination, you have so many upper caste indians defending with sort of "It does not exist anymore" Its a legit vice in Indian community and I understand most liberal indians dont practice it. But by denying its existence, you are doing a greatest disservice to the community.
- jscipione 4y agoSeattle is a third world city filled with rampant vandalism, used drug needles, and drug addled vagrants lining every street corner in makeshift tents. The city government may have banned the caste system but they have made the city worse to live in than the poorest parts of India.
- known 4y ago[dead]
- dementis 4y agoThis is all virtue signaling. If they really cared about stopping discrimination then they could change it from being a civil issue to a criminal issue. Right now if someone is discriminated against they still have the same old two choices; either they ignore it or they sue. Suing anyone much less a company with deep pockets costs a ton of money and in order to win there has to be a "smoking gun" or a mountain of evidence to prove there was discrimination. And the problem with collecting that evidence is that such discrimination usually happens in person and without any written evidence to show for it at a later date. Video evidence of personal interactions is very hard to collect in Washington state because it is a "two party consent state"[1]. And people's personal behavior changes when they know they are being recorded[2][3]. I think a better solution to this is to get US Federal "Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964" updated[4] to include caste based discrimination as that will bring this issue to national attention and hopefully enable other people that are not being directly affected by this discrimination to be cognizant of it. Once enough people become aware of the problem then it will start changing the US culturally and societal accepted behaviors which is the only real way to stop this type of discrimination. Of course while dreaming of a better and brighter future I might as well add the removal of all cliques to the list as they are another form of discrimination. [1] https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/washington/washington-recording-law#:~:text=Washington's%20wiretapping%20law%20is%20a,Rev https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/washington/washington-recor.... [2](2014) https://hbr.org/2014/09/how-being-filmed-changes-employee-behavior https://hbr.org/2014/09/how-being-filmed-changes-employee-be... [3](2019) https://www.bodycamera.co.uk/blogs/news/what-is-the-observer-effect-and-why-people-act-differently-when-they-are-being-recorded https://www.bodycamera.co.uk/blogs/news/what-is-the-observer... [4](2021) https://harvardlawreview.org/2021/06/title-vii-and-caste-discrimination/ https://harvardlawreview.org/2021/06/title-vii-and-caste-dis...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lashkhi 4y ago[dead]