13 ms·
There's no part of AI that is being swallowed up by copyright. AI companies can ask for permission if they want to train their models on other people's works. I
by jeroenhd 4y ago
There's no part of AI that is being swallowed up by copyright. AI companies can ask for permission if they want to train their models on other people's works. It's not that hard, various image hosting sites have already added an opt-in/opt-out toggle to their services. Sites might even get away with using this stuff as compensation for free hosting.
The fact of the matter is that the AI companies don't want to ask for permission, because people will say no. Or worse, ask for attribution or even payment. There is plenty of copyright free/public domain material out there, but what the customers of AI people want isn't available under those terms.
The code to train an AI is not enough to make a product and these people have nothing to add themselves, so they take what others made and use that to make a profit. They can make or pay for their own paintings, their own pictures, their own music, but that would require putting in too much work or paying too much money.
It's very possible that a judge will rule that AI models do not violate copyright. If that is the case, I hope new legislation will correct that oversight very quickly.
- scheeseman486 4y agoThe outcome you want will inevitably lead to entrenched intellectual property holders having an effective monopoly on the best AI tools. You know that Stable Diffusion lawsuit? Go check who the lawyers behind that work for; Disney wants that same outcome.
- jeroenhd 4y agoPeople who made or bought out the content get to have the content. I don't necessarily see the problem with that except for the ridiculous amount of time copyright remains valid. If a company invests $250 million into an original movie, I don't see why they shouldn't have some say over their content for at least a couple of years. Not until 2150 or whatever the end date for modern works is supposed to be, but give it some time at least. OpenAI is the result of billions being thrown around. When it comes to billions, it doesn't matter if they come from Disney, Google, Microsoft or Amazon. None of these companies have our individual rights at heart, they only care about profits. In this rare occasion, the interests of the people and Disney align. The laws protecting the independent writers/programmers/artists are the same ones that protect Disney. The tools themselves work on arbitrary data sets. Anyone who can dig up enough public domain/attribution free pictures/code/text can train their own AI without even coming close to copyright issues. Hell, had these super smart AI people managed to find out a method of attribution, the data set would include massive amounts of works released under Creative Commons or open source licenses.
- loa_in_ 4y agoOpenAI is the result of slow and steady progress in ML. It's not even a good product. It is astonishing in itself though.
- scheeseman486 4y agoI don't see any of these companies caring about artists, but something like Stable Diffusion is more of a weird accident. Like how IBM managed to create a platform with that became an open standard, something almost diametrically opposed to their own corporate values. Good quality data and more of it means better output. Disney is almost certainly doing their own thing internally, benefiting from their ability to use both free as well as their own IP and the capital to hire cheap workers to train it directly. It's not that I don't understand why artists might be upset about a company scraping copyrighted art, I just think that the longer term effects of legally kneecapping open source variants while handing over the most powerful versions of it to the existing intellectual property giants are A Bad Thing.
- pigsty 4y agoIt’s strange to me that there’s a lot of overlap between people who think AI training should require explicit consent for every piece of training data, and people who think copyright and patents are insanely restrictive in the music/movies/literature/software world. It’s also worrying that requiring consent to train an AI model will inevitably lead to requiring consent to make handmade art that’s a little too similar to some other existing artwork (ie, how all art works through reference, training, and inspiration). A world where Getty and Disney control even more than they already do.
- profile53 4y agoI don’t personally think it’s that strange or internally inconsistent. People seem to be saying “within the current copyright system, consent should be required, but I still think the copyright system is broken”.
- sacrosancty 4y agoIt's probably those same people who publish their code under open source licenses instead of giving it to the public domain. I don't understand why people cling so hard onto every worthless little bit of code they write while also sort of half giving it away to almost everyone for almost any purpose.
- bombolo 4y ago1. People who use copyleft licenses do it because they know that the end result will be using a good license forever. 2. People using non-copyleft license just do it because public domain seems to have a complicated legal status across the world.
- yakubin 4y agoMost non-copyleft licences require attribution. That's significantly more than than public domain. Copilot breaks even permissive licences.
- _ph_ 4y ago
- kirse 4y agoAI companies can ask for permission if they want to train their models on other people's works Do you ask for permission when you train your mind on copyrighted books? Or observe paintings? Or listen to music? Do you ask for permission when you get new ideas from HN that aren't your own? Humans are constantly ingesting gobs of "copyrighted" insights that they eventually remix into their own creations without necessarily reimbursing the original source(s) of their creativity. Time to put the horse back in the barn, cars and trains are here.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI'm not a computer program.
- tehcheat418 4y agoI don’t think one can know that for sure. ;)
- oneeyedpigeon 4y agoThis is a better argument than your smiley implies. Given a work, we can't (or soon won't be able to) tell whether its creator was a human or an AI. So the only important thing that matters is whether the final work infringes copyright or not. Unless people are seriously arguing that nobody should be able to use AI to produce images even for their own private use.
- owlbite 4y agoI can't be trivially copy/pasted and replicated at scale.
- tehcheat418 4y agoDoes that mean once you can be there is no ethical responsibility not to?
- 4y ago
- em3rgent0rdr 4y agoBetter title: The advancement of AI is being slowed by copyright. But "eating" is a fun word.
- bombolo 4y agoEven better title: tech giants don't want to pay copyright to small creators, but will easily be coherced to pay it to disney.
- FranzFerdiNaN 4y agoIt’s up to the courts to decide if this is a copyright infringement. The EU at least already allows the use of copyrighted material for research purposes into text and data mining, so the main question will hinge on whether or not the result of such research can be commercially exploited.
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- usrbinbash 4y ago> but what the customers of AI people want isn't available under those terms. What the customers of AI want is accurate predictions of the models, and they can get that even if everyone demanding to get removed from the training set would be removed. The makers of generative AI could remove every living artist who wants to from the dataset, the model would still develop a general solution of color theory, composition, almost every artstyle in existence, ... because fact of the matter is, there is just that much data out there. Our species collectively has spend DECADES recording, storing and categorizing everything and the proverbial kitchen sink. There are god-knows-how-many petabytes of data available in images alone, so even if just 1% of that could be used to train generative models, it would still be more than adequate. And soon after that, there is an explosion of new generated art, filtered through the aesthetic sense of millions of humans, that can just be fed back into the models, to make them better. The end result is the same: High-quality image generation on a scale hitherto unseen, running even on consumer grade hardware. And what lawsuits will be filed then?
- wokwokwok 4y agoThen do it! I swear when I see this argument because it makes me angry. You’re right, but they didnt, because they were too lazy and cheap to do it that way. …and that’s why people are angry, and rightly so. Fully licensed models are the future, and it’s both irritating and disappointing that we are where we are right now because the people training these models were too lazy to assemble a training dataset that wasn’t problematic (ie. full of porn and copyrighted material). You can argue the “but at the end of the day it’s all the same…” argument if you like, but clearly from the lawsuits it isn’t ok They’ve completely messed it up. There’s a reason the openai api terms of service says that “the Content may be used to improve and train models”; they’re setting themselves up to have a concrete defence for the source training data for their models. Good job. Stability can burn in a fire. They’ve really trashed the reputation of generative AI in a way that is going to be very difficult to recover from.
- usrbinbash 4y ago> but clearly from the lawsuits it isn’t ok Well, a lawsuit isn't a decision, we will have to wait for the courts to decide wheter it's legally okay or not.
- jsemrau 4y ago>It's very possible that a judge will rule that AI models do not violate copyright. Somehow we have managed to come full circle to the first episode of HBO's Silicon Valley.
- luxuryballs 4y agoHow is it much different from a search index? it’s just a new interface to get at some info, rather than Google and Firefox, it already pre-browsed the web for you, and is displaying back the content. If the end user gleans some actual copyrighted work from the search they still need permission to use it, but it’s also likely it’s just a derivative, or the end user is just reading an example and learning from it at consumption time. Is a web crawler violating copyright? Or is it the user who sells a copyrighted image?
- smallerfish 4y agoIt's not displaying back the "content". It's training a model with statistics based on the writing that was either paid for by a site publisher in the hope of earning ad revenue, or contributed to the community for free. If a model was to add attributions to each of its answers, then perhaps the search engine analogy would hold. But, they don't (and right now, to my understanding, can't.)
- ForestCritter 4y agoThe AI art models are scraping imagery made by human effort and skill and then more humans label and tag it so it can be indexed, ( because you can show a computer an image all day long and it still won't 'learn' what it is unless you tag it) and then another human puts in their wishlist of art they want (without any cost or effort to learn skill) and the 'AI' displays back a collage of the content from the wishlist. And then presto all sorts of merchandise are available with this art taken without permission from the people that made it. People do the physical action of creating imagery, AI indexes it.
- alpaca128 4y ago> How is it much different from a search index? A search index usually links to the source. Without that a search index is worthless, you can't use content if you don't even know where it comes from and who holds the rights. Google search links to sources like Wikipedia in its info boxes, because without that you can't know whether the info is reliable or sourced from my brother's coworker's imaginary flat-earther friend.
- realharo 4y ago>It's very possible that a judge will rule that AI models do not violate copyright Would that mean you can simply use one AI (or more) from anyone else to train another AI? Of course access can always be limited to an API with rate limits and per-request costs, which would make it difficult to straight up copy the whole thing, but it would be hard to justify any legal protections against it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- metacritic12 4y agoRegardless of whether one agrees or not with paying creators of the training data, I think the deeper issue here is about societal wealth distribution and who gets paid for X now that X is being done very well by AIs. A less equitable world has Google or billionaires getting paid. A more equitable world has the artists. But I want to argue here that for purposes of this latter question, your proposal of copyright enforcement (or anything similar) is too little to late. -These "copyright violating" AIs have demonstrated the proof of concept and the damage is done. Even if these AIs are banned, the companies will just parallel reconstruct it by running the 80/20 rule: pay tiny amounts to get most of the data. After all the creators of the data were doing it for free and are in such fierce competition there's no bargaining power. - More nefarious AIs will just do transfer learning on intermediate neurons, very difficult to prove stealing here. - Even if you get the system to work, what about future artists and writers? Are we just creating an entrenched historical group of creatives getting royalties forever? The distributional problem is not well solved by copyright, and better solved with e.g. corporate taxes, income taxes, VATs.
- techdragon 4y ago> - Even if you get the system to work, what about future artists and writers? Are we just creating an entrenched historical group of creatives getting royalties forever? The boat has long since sailed on this… ands it’s globally entrenched as a norm of international trade that we are all “ok with this” regime of 75 years or century plus copyright terms … And arguably the entire copyright vs AI/ML training datasets debate is founded on the notion that the artists individual copyright will last long enough that it’s going to outlive the average artist. If we look at one of the old copyright regimes, for comparison… in a world where copyright is a short default/implicit/automatic term (14 or 28 years) and the copyright owner can elect to register and pay for extensions (for a more modern twist, preferably combined with increasing incentive to prevent perpetual renewal abuses by Disney, et al)… now imagine how much data from up to 28 years ago there is, the catalogue of art and photographs and text and books and academic writings… all public domain because the authors didn’t consider them of sufficient value… all free for the ML model training… this gets even larger with a 14 year term… Suffice to say that we are seeing systemic impacts already, culturally we’re seeing more and more money put behind less and less content controlled by fewer and fewer people due to a slow death spiral off copyright stranglehold across multiple industries, written, visual, audio and video arts are all dominated by large corporations holding IP … yes individuals continue to create, but other than rare breakthrough chance successes and internet age viral success (which are often just completely arbitrarily/random and have no real quality) these companies decide what will be popular culture… My prediction is that the AI/ML models will be allowed but heavily scrutinised, under the simple legal doctrine that the user is the one committing the infringement since the primary purpose of these models is not infringement but unique creation, but suspicion will linger by artists and it will become a normal part of contracts in the art word…effectively an artist equivalent of the way police in many places view spray cans… just as the primary purpose of spray paint is not to create illegal graffiti, which is the justification many places used to overturn poorly justified civic bans on possession of spray paint. I’d like to see any more draconian spread of derivative work rights (style rights etc) to be accompanied by drastic reductions in the automatic copyright term, as the ability to churn out lots of automatic content drastically lowers the value of long long terms, and the counter argument that it makes the existing rights more valuable is fucking insane as we do not need to pass copyright down to the great-great-great-great-grandchildren… the terms are already too long.
- jefftk 4y ago> It's very possible that a judge will rule that AI models do not violate copyright. Current market odds for that are at 77%: https://manifold.markets/JeffKaufman/will-the-github-copilot-litigation https://manifold.markets/JeffKaufman/will-the-github-copilot...
- anotherman554 4y ago"No" includes the litigation being dropped with no ruling.
- jefftk 4y agoGood point! The market isn't exactly trying to answer my parent's question. But it's reasonably close: the litigation is unlikely to be dropped if it would win.
- xwdv 4y agoYou don’t need permission. If you want to prove your data was used to train an AI, the onus is on you to prove it. Good luck. The AI who follow the law strictly will be at a disadvantage to those that do not.
- chii 4y ago> the onus is on you to prove it which would be easy during a law suit - the process of discovery means you get to check out the training dataset. The allegation isn't that the AI trainers are hiding, but that what AI trainers are doing _itself_ constitutes copyright violation. AKA, they want the right to use the works to train an ai model to be a right that must be explicitly granted.
- xwdv 4y agoTraining data sets are way too massive to be searched in any reasonable time.
- chii 4y ago> If that is the case, I hope new legislation will correct that oversight very quickly. i hope that legislation is not introduced to prevent training, as this right would stifle progress.
- williamcotton 4y agoI’m going to wager that the percentage of people in our society who would like to extend copyright to restrict these tools, favoring the needs individual copyright holders over the needs of the public domain, is much smaller than you realize. By the time this reaches judgment and goes through the appeals process there will be a vast industry of non-infringing uses that are clearly transformative and in fair use (Sony v Universal) You cannot say that the person using ChatGPT to control the lights in their garage is infringing on anyone’s copyright in any manner whatsoever. The point of copyright is not to gain a permanent monopoly on certain speech. The point of copyright is not to make sure that people are fairly compensated for their work. Their work might be terrible but contain a good idea that is later reimagined in a better way (Baker v Seldon) but that’s for the market to decide. The courts will probably concur that these models are fair-use and I will agree with their judgement.
- Aerroon 4y ago>AI companies can ask for permission if they want to train their models on other people's works. It's not that hard Yes, and then people say "no" or "pay me". End result of this is that the only ones with good AI models are megacorporations that will DRM the heck out of it. Years later those same artists will complain that they now have to pay $1000 a year to Disney/MS/Adobe to create art. Because these megacorporations can afford to pay for it. They're the ones that will benefit the most from this, because it creates an insurmountable moat for them. Copyright exists to encourage the creation of more art and to progress science. AI is clearly a helpful step in that direction. Humans learn from others' works. Should we make that illegal too?
- talentedcoin 4y ago> Copyright exists to encourage the creation of more art and to progress science. AI is clearly a helpful step in that direction. Humans learn from others' works. Should we make that illegal too? I find it astonishing that people continue to make this argument. A machine is owned by someone, a human is not. Why should the law treat machines the same way as a human? Sounds like some corporate flim-flam to me.
- Aerroon 4y agoCopyright is not about protecting people. The purpose of copyright is: >To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries; The purpose of copyright is not to protect the authors, it is to promote the progress of science and art. The current situation for AI image generation is pretty much the only way these technologies will be available to everyone. Most other paths will simply lead to billion dollar corporations acting as gatekeepers to this technology. Megacorps can afford to hire artists to generate specific art for their AI models, everyone else cannot.
- talentedcoin 4y agoMy point is that this quasi-legal argument about how “humans learn so why can’t machines learn” is a non sequitur. This is a case where quantity has a quality all its own. Copyright law was not invented with anything like this situation in mind. You end up with billion dollar corporations gatekeeping this technology either way (who else has the capital to best train the models?). This isn’t about the little guy.
- peanuty1 4y agoDeviantArt is opt-out by default in my experience. It's honestly a bit frustrating because I always choose to opt-in.
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoThese things should cough up money for the authors whenever something is generated with their data or make the whole thing (source code and models) accessible to everyone. So easy :D.
- randombits0 4y agoOversight? Hardly. You don’t seem to understand the purpose of copyright to begin with. The purpose of copyright is to progress science and useful arts. Period. Any action taken in the name of copyright that does not progress science and useful arts is unsupported by law. What else do we know about copyright? A copyright can apply only to creative expressions. While the bar for sufficient creativity is intentionally low, it is non-zero. Another thing we know is that purely functional expressions are not copyrightable. When does an expression go beyond being a function expression to a creative expression? That’s up to a judge. Since code is math and math, by itself, cannot be copyrighted, when an expression reaches the level of creative expression must be beyond the math. Updating a database field, factoring primes, or using data correction algorithms are not creative expressions. Now for AI. Only humans may own copyrights. The output of an AI is not copyrightable. But what if the input was copyrighted? When it comes to software code, AI will value expressions that are commonly used more so than uncommon ones. But software code is, by it’s very nature, an intertwined collection of copyrightable (creative) and non-copyrightable (functional) expressions. If AI values commonly used expressions, those expressions are highly unlikely to be creative enough for copyright protection in the first place. So we have a circumstance where AI is trained on copyrighted but Open Source code. Yet the code itself is comprised of both creative (presumably) and functional code, with no clear delineation of what is and what is not protectable. Lastly, many authors do not understand what constitutes a creative expression that is protectable by copyright. The amount of work required to create the expression is meaningless. Manipulating data to thresh out something interesting is not creative. Let’s just face it that most software is comprised of mostly functional expressions that are not protectable. Back to that “math” problem again! The big take-away? The purpose of copyright is to progress science and useful arts, not to build walls around ideas and concepts (which, by themselves, are not protectable).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]