19 ms·
YouTube Addiction
- water8 4y ago[dead]
- omgmajk 4y agoI am sort of also addicted to YouTube, I don't watch as much as this person every day but on days that I'm off I easily do. Almost all educational content (science, programming, new tech), tech news or essays of various kinds.
- eloff 4y agoI’ve been warily watching this grow in my own life. At first it was just some podcasts in the background while working. Then it became all kinds of videos. Then it became while taking breaks, preparing food, eating food, using the bathroom, etc. It consumed all my quiet time. I managed to break the habit as a side effect of upending my whole life and digital nomading around for a year and a half (side note, that was a very positive experience, and actually helped, rather than hurt my career.) Now I feel it coming back, and worse thanks to YouTube shorts. I’m going to uninstall the app after writing this.
- nicbou 4y agoInteresting fix! My addiction tends to get worse when I'm on the road, because I'm usually alone and tired at the end of the day. At home I have more options.
- jadia 4y agoI agree with you on all fronts. This issue isn't just with YouTube the numbing down of the mind via digital stimulation has taken a toll on a lot of people. I myself am struggling with the same. I can relate to how easy it is to slip back to the old ritual of consuming endless hours of video content which doesn't even make you feel good. I thing the key is to consume in moderation. Just like we take care of our body by exercising and limiting junk food, we need to meditate and be aware of our digital media consumption. Someone people don't have this problem but like you and me there are people who are struggling with this problem.
- juujian 4y agoI have to be honest, whenever I get busy and do not watch any video for a couple of days, and then I get back to youtube, I am somewhat disappointed by the content. And recently the algorithm has been really insistent on having me watch certain videos. I just open the page and see a couple of videos I did not want to watch the last time around.
- omgmajk 4y agoI also think the algorithm has become worse. It recommends that I watch a lot of stuff that I don't want to see and buries channels that I subscribe to and watch every video of.
- juujian 4y agoSame experience. First it was just showing recommendations first and burying subscriptions. But those recommendations seemed decent. Now it is just a bunch of stuff I have no interest in. And recently I got a new device that I did not want to sign into youtube with, and it tried to sell me Jordan Peterson after just a couple dozen videos. F'ed up.
- layer8 4y agoYou can mark suggested videos as "Not interested".
- everdrive 4y agoIt seems like all ad (and tracking) supported companies know how to do is optimize for engagement, which effectively means becoming addictive. This business model is too easy and too profitable to ever go away, so all we can do is learn to recognize it, and learn how to it responsibly. Like other addictions, sometimes this means restricting, and sometimes this means wholly abstaining. On the topic of Youtube addiction specifically, "letsblock.it" has some Youtube-specific filters which can be placed in uBlock Origin and help cut down on Youtube's addictiveness: Hide Youtube shorts: https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-shorts https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-shorts Hide Youtube recommendations: https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-recommendations https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-recommendations Hide Youtube videos you've already watched: https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-watched https://letsblock.it/filters/youtube-watched
- jjj123 4y ago> so all we can do is learn to recognize it, and learn how to it responsibly Or we can regulate it.
- atonse 4y agoI prefer this method. Even something as simple as the regulation requiring the site to make it EASY to turn those things off (But give the choice to consumers via big, easy to see toggles in the right places). Rather than having them put in browser extensions.
- clnq 4y agoIf there were only a way to slow down the internet connection to 1mbps or so, a lot of that instant-gratification habit-forming engagement psychology wouldn't be very effective anymore. Even before YouTube, people could have spent 9 hours a day watching rented VHS and DVDs. It just took too much effort to form a habit based on instant gratification with that. So not many people did. And people were much more selective of what they consumed, too, which is an added benefit for mental health.
- Apocryphon 4y ago
- aliswe 4y agoI suggest to all of you todisable and clear your YT viewing history, search history, and be mindful of what you like/add to lists like "watch later". Then you will get significantly less addictive content suggestions.
- izzydata 4y agoI've found that I only watch less Youtube over the years as their suggestions got worse for me. Now I feel like I only ever see a handful of the same suggested videos and they are all from years ago.
- RSHEPP 4y agoWatching Gophercon videos this morning, majority of my suggestions were Jordan B Peterson, Andrew Huberman and JRE. How the hell does it make that jump. I only watch software related videos at this point.
- gatonegro 4y ago> majority of my suggestions were Jordan B Peterson I'm interested in psychology and philosophy, so I'll watch videos on those subjects every so often. Naturally, the Algorithm™ becomes obsessed with recommending me Peterson videos soon after. I'm 98% sure the "Do not recommend" and "Not interested" buttons are just there for show, because I keep seeing those suggestions whenever I wander off into psychology and philosophy videos.
- halkony 4y agoPeterson's direct and indirect presence on social media is so varied it must be hard to get rid of him.
- 65 4y agoYeah. YouTube's algorithm does a really great job of stopping me from watching too much YouTube. For me it's a lot of videos I've either already seen, am not interested but continually get recommended, or are just short, low quality videos. I would like to be able to watch more YouTube videos, but their recommendations are so bad at this point that I have to find other things to do.
- suzumer 4y agoI used to be addicted to youtube, and the most effective method I found to limiting my consumption was using an extension called Unhook. It removes all recommendations and the shorts and trending tabs, so the only videos I can watch are those from channels I'm subscribed to, or videos that I search for.
- breadchris 4y agoi can’t believe how effective this has been for me. I’ve noticed that instead of being continually “interested” in youtube and going down the rabbit hole constantly, i actually get bored of youtube pretty quickly once i have watched all the content my subscriptions have put out. i still spend way too much time on my phone, but i guess i need to have the phone equivalent
- danuker 4y agoIn NewPipe, you can customize the main page and disable recommendations (from "Content"). But of course Google won't let it on the Play Store. Here it is: https://newpipe.net/ https://newpipe.net/
- theteapot 4y ago> I actually get bored of youtube pretty quickly once i have watched all the content my subscriptions have put out. An addict in denial. Sad.
- Phemist 4y agoSome time ago, a nice fellow HN user @boriselec wrote a browser plugin for, in the end, my personal use (as barely anyone uses it), that redirects all video links to their /embed variant. /embed links are meant to be embedded in other pages and do not show any UI clutter. As it happens, they also work perfectly well if (re-)directly opened! Comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23148026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23148026 Extension here: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-embed-link/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-embed...
- knaik94 4y agoThis is a very dramatic framing. A much more resonable explanation is that YouTube was being used as an escape. 10K Subs is an accomplishment, a real community. The less talked about half of parasocial relationships is the one that goes the other way, where people feel validation from the likes and views they get. Generally, taking a break from an escape means you face the real issues you have been avoiding and ignoring using YouTube. At the same time, I think it's great the author is reflecting and take actionable steps to working on themselves. Stepping away or slowing down is a tough decision once you reach the size this author has. I have higher weekly hours, in the Youtube app on your phone, you can see weekly view stats. On wednesday my stats say 15 hours. I have ADHD and I leave YouTube running in the background while I work and when I sleep. I know for a fact that 5+ hour on wednesday was "10 Hours of Hotel AC White Noise (High power setting)". 80% of the time it's on in the background, either figuratively or literally white noise. Taking a break is always beneficial, but I think this might be a situation where an escape becomes unhealthy and makes the situation worse but isn't the underlying cause. I strongly dislike the trend of using the word addiction to describe a bad or unhealthy habit. Unless watching YouTube held you back from performing other life function or you feel physical or mental withdrawal symptoms, I'd hestitate from using that word. Not just a craving, but also some sort of anxiety from being away or cancelling plans with friends or being late to work. People are fulltime Youtubers, being a creator can be everything from a hobby to a profession. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQdhL-XuKLY&t=17668s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQdhL-XuKLY&t=17668s
- sillysaurusx 4y agoHi fellow addict! https://imgur.com/a/TaaKY87 https://imgur.com/a/TaaKY87 Mine is Star Trek. It’s not so much an escape as a habit, for me. I started young. When I was 13 or so, I was watching voyager while hacking on game engines. Then I never really stopped. Nowadays it’s a mix of anime (hello berserk https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLD85eRe7NELF7EFIl4YMQOxFw_3S7LNaR https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLD85eRe7NELF7EFIl4YMQOxFw...) and trek. Also gothamchess. Like you, I don’t see anything wrong with it. Wish I was addicted to books instead, but as far as addictions go, I’d rather it be this than smoking.
- 4y ago
- lettergram 4y agoI've seen this happen to A LOT of people, particularly with TikTok. What's worse is the algorithms are effectively there to (a) keep you watching and (b) manipulate you (in some cases - i.e. increase addictive tenancies, change mood (see facebook studies on this), etc) That said, I have seen this cycle both spiral (as in this case) and be broken before. I've also helped a cousin who had this issue. IMO and this is going to sound harsh, but bare with me -- the problem isn't YouTube, TikTok, etc the issue is you. If you have this "addiction" it's because you're enabled. For instance, I cannot just decide to watch 8 hrs of youtube videos a day, I have to wake up & let the dog out, feed the family, go to work, take the kids to sports classes, spend time with my wife, etc. At the end of the day, I have maybe an hour I could listen to something as I'm doing some maintenance on the house before bed. I'm happy, busy and have purpose. If you have responsibilities you'll be happier -- period. Yes, sometimes it'll suck, it is work after all (I had to clean up my dogs diarrhea the other day -- blah); but the process is rewarding. You can see what you've accomplished, people will care about you and you'll be happier. Few thoughts on how this can be broken (and how I've seen it done) 1. Uninstall all your social media apps 2. Get an extension on your browser to block social media 3. In an extreme case, change your password to non-sense you don't know and to an email you create on the fly and don't know. 4. Get a pet 5. Make a list of objectives (small to large); make a plan to execute. You can fail, over and over again, but if you work towards them you'll eventually get there. 6. Go outside for a 30-60 min walk every day and force yourself to leave your phone. Cold or hot, doesn't matter. Remember, your ancestors lived outside 24/7, even 100 years ago, there was no AC. 7. Join communities -- could just be people at the gym, a church / w.e., archery club, it doesn't matter, just get social connections 8. Clean your house and room at least once a week and make your bed every day. Discipline is key and once you have a clean house for a while, you'll want to keep it clean. 9. Go to the gym every day if you can. Pick the closest one and just go every day for an hour. Use the machines as they're less likely to hurt you and you don't need any training. Build up to free weights (or if you know how to use them, go for it). 10. Eat healthy -- meat, veg, fruit.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoTikTok is amazing. You can rip it from my cold dead iPad. :) My pet Pip! https://imgur.com/a/vAFOZHd https://imgur.com/a/vAFOZHd Also, HN is just as much social media as any other. How often do you glance at your karma the moment the site loads? (Didn’t downvote though.)
- ClassyJacket 4y agoThis is going to sound sad but I'm aiming to hopefully have a YouTube addiction. I had a severe reddit addiction for many years which wasted the best years of my life, that I recently replaced with a TikTok addiction (reddit banned me anyway). Now I'm trying to step up and wean myself onto longer form video content instead. That's how deep I've gotten myself into this... self-induced ADHD spiral. I can barely even play videogames for more than 20 minutes at a time anymore.
- clintfred 4y agoIt's not sad. You have identified a problem in your life! That's awesome. No one has a life with no problems, so you're like the rest of us humans. Now you can decide how you are going to change your behavior. You might consider talking to a friend or maybe a counselor to help you identify changes and unhelpful thinking patterns.
- cm2187 4y agoTo cure your youtube addiction, just disable your adblocker. Works very well.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIs it just me or is Google quietly in serious distress? Ads have been getting a LOT worse very quickly. Almost every ad I saw in a day when my UBlock wasn’t working was advertising an actual fraud. Whether crypto or recession get rich quick or “aluminum is giving you cancer.” Advertising frequency is cranked way up. On mobile 5 second unskippables are 6-7 now. I’ll do a search and my ENTIRE screen is advertising until I scroll down and find results.
- cpsns 4y agoSame nonsense on Facebook. It’s all payday loans, crypto scams, and magic mushrooms. People say it’s based on your history, but I don’t buy that as none of what it shows me is even slightly relevant. It just seems like they don’t have enough relevant ads to show, so they throw shit at the wall.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoInteresting. It’s the same on my end. I’m not interested in any of the stuff I see and I have no idea why an algorithm would think so. Crypto is relentless. Payday loans are around, but not as prevalent. I get a lot of ads for weird novelty toys too. I’m not sure I’ve ever clicked one, let alone looked them up. I’ve wondered if it’s because I’m into 3d printing and many other people who are into are interested in action figures/minis/what have you. Possible connection? In any case ads do seem to be getting less relevant and skeezy themes are developing. The worst one I’ve been seeing a lot of is “single Ukrainian women”. One went as far as showing a quick and easy process of selection and “purchase”. I have no idea how that would be targeted at me, but it see a lot of them.
- vorpalhex 4y agoMaybe there's a "HN User" stamp on your ad profile? Jokes aside, if you do your data request from FB you should see your advertising selectors come back. Before I deleted my account, FB thought I was a 17 year old girl interested in boy bands and makeup.
- LegitShady 4y agoYoutube is so bad at suggesting videos for me that it mystifies me how people could be addicted to it. "Oh you watched one video about [x] by creator [y]. Here are 100 more videos by creatory [y]. Here are 100 more videos about [x]" ...uh I watched a recipe for cheesecake. I don't need 100 more cheesecake videos, or even 100 more recipes by that youtuber.
- manimino 4y agoI have this problem with recommendation engines generally. Spotify, Netflix, Steam, etc. They are very bad at making novel, interesting recommendations. They will also blindly recommend popular things, which is irritating. Steam is an exception here - it has a slider bar that allows exclusion of popular content in favor of niche / indie stuff.
- LegitShady 4y agooh you watched one video about MMA? Here's 10 million things about MMA. Oh you watched a video about the war in ukraine? Here's another 10 million videos about the war in ukraine. When I first studied recommendation algorithms I remember the classic "people who buy hamburgers and hamburger buns also buy ketchup and mustard" sort of things. On youtube its more like people who watch a video about anything are doomed to be recommended further videos about that thing forever, and adjacent 'also watched' related topics aren't really a thing.
- schizo89 4y agoI quit YouTube around a month ago because it tried to shape my political views.
- braindead_in 4y agoYouTube videos will soon be generated by an AI which will know exactly what your interests are and it will keep you hooked in such a way that you will live in an alternate reality made up of a images bein projected to your eyes by a video monitor and will completely lose yourself. And one day someone will offer you a choice between a blue and red pill. Choose the red one and a new rabbit hole will start. Back to square one.
- johlits 4y agoYou are already in it. Joking.. or not.
- aizyuval 4y agoAddiction is a black and white kind of thing, and it’s hard to comprehend it. But once you do, you are on the right path.
- ProllyInfamous 4y ago"The opposite of addiction is connection." —Gabor Maté
- TexanFeller 4y agoI'm the type to become addicted and I had a big problem with spending vastly too much time on YT. A few months ago I cleared my search and watch history and subscriptions to start fresh. Now I only allow myself to watch videos about math, science, or playing instruments I'm interested in learning to play. If I ever see a politically leaning recommendation I tell YT to never show it to me again. If I slip up and watch something off my diet I immediately clean it from my search and watch history. It's improved my life a lot removing the toxic content and replacing it with slowly understanding pieces of modern physics from listening to Leonard Susskind.
- gunshai 4y agoI wish there was a way to transpose someone else's "YouTube diet" so to speak. this probably exists through tag matching ect. but it would be nice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PebblesRox 4y agoHah, sounds similar to a fecal transplant to restore the gut biome.
- pythonguython 4y agoI likely have some degree of YouTube addiction as well. While I hope your tactic is working well for you, I believe this way of thinking can be a deceiving. Almost all the YouTube content I consume is related to science, engineering, math or chess (I’ve watched many of Susskinds’s lectures too). I used to rationalize my excessive use by telling myself that the content I watched was useful. In reality, my time would be FAR better reading a book, doing a project, socializing, doing chores, or really anything other than just being a YouTube zombie.
- goostavos 4y ago>can be a deceiving I think that's a great way of describing it. Watching "educational" content feels better or more productive than watching a Let's Play, but it's all basically empty entertainment -- the medium and the algorithm sort've necessitate it. Which is definitely not to say there's not awesome resources on youtube for actually learning things, but, for the most part, I'm not watching things that actually take mental effort. I'm more often just letting trash wash over me while also convincing myself that it's OK because "I'm learning" (even though whatever trivial factoid being discussed is immediately ejected from my brain when the next video starts) I've realized that the internet has a numbing effect on me. It all washes over me until I feel absolutely nothing and I'm just mindlessly consuming. My ISP was recently down for a day, and it actually made life (at least temporarily) more interesting. Rather than just sitting in front of a screen and having content pumped into my veins, my SO and I had to leave the house to seek out things to do. Then the internet came back and now we're both back on the drip.
- superkuh 4y agoNope. Stop using the medical word addiction in contexts where it's highly inappropriate. Youtube isn't even a single thing. It's just a video hosting service. The types of videos on it are extremely wildly varying. Video addiction is not a thing. See how stupid it sounds when you say it like it is?
- yladiz 4y agoNope. Stop using the medical word addiction in contexts where it's highly inappropriate. The Internet isn't even a single thing. It's just a collection of content. The types of content on it are extremely wildly varying. Internet addiction is not a thing. See how stupid it sounds when you say it like it is? Outside of lampooning how absurd your comment sounds, I don't think it's your place to call if something is a valid addiction or not, and addictions don't have to be strictly medically defined to be considered as such. Just because there isn't some ICD-10 definition for "YouTube addiction" doesn't mean it can't exist, because addiction fundamentally just means a dependence or habitual occupation with something. And so, is Youtube addiction as debilitating as something like alcoholism? I think most people would say absolutely not, but presumably it's distressing enough to the writer of the post that they have formed a habit around watching (a lot of) it, perceive it as a negative, and want to change it. I would colloquially consider this an addiction.
- superkuh 4y agoAbsolutely. There is also no such thing as internet addiction. When you compare drug based addictions to things people enjoy the difference is clear. The drugs create increased incentive salience even without enjoyment. This is very different from say, watching a video where you actually have to enjoy it intrinsically many times before it alters incentive salience. There's a reason the DSM5 and ICD-10 don't have any of the "internet addiction" "video game addiction" "porn addiction" or other cult concepts that scammers use to defraud people of their money. They aren't actually addiction.
- yladiz 4y agoPlease define addiction for me. My point was not to say that all addictions are equal (they are not), and they act differently, but I think it's too simplistic to flippantly state that Internet addiction is not a thing.
- sebastianvoelkl 4y agoI think the YouTube suggestions got worse over time. In 1-2 weeks I will launch www.EduTube.app a platform to discover hand picked educational YouTube videos for those who are interested in it
- ProllyInfamous 4y agoWill your platform be "making suggestions" after users watch any hand-picked content? How do you plan to monetize this?
- sebastianvoelkl 4y agoNot making any suggestions. A couple of categories are free to watch and for a 20$ one time payment You can have access to everything
- broAhmed 4y agoRead Cal Newport’s Digital Minimalism. If you’re like me, you’ll substitute one digital addiction for another when trying to give up something; his book is helping me to break that cycle. Products like YouTube and most social media are finely tuned billion dollar machines aimed at capturing and holding your attention; our fleshy brains require more than a simple detox to break that grip.
- atonse 4y agoThat's been my experience. I stopped using Facebook and twitter, and hacker news doesn't keep me occupied for hours. So YouTube has taken over all that desire for content. I don't think it even matters that most of the stuff I watch is educational, fascinating, and helping me learn new things. It affects my sleep and is still a bit of a passive time suck (like I could just be experimenting with wok cooking in the hours spent watching dozens of videos of others learning how to cook with a wok). So will check out these various extensions that remove recommendations, etc.
- vibrolax 4y agoI occasionally watch "let's play" videos as a harm reduced alternative to actually playing games. A half hour spent watching someone play a game/sim totally relieves my FOMO. It also dissipates my urge to build a gaming PC. As a maker and musician, there's tons of inspiring and informative content on YT. I feel that I'm quite net positive on my use of YT to enrich my life.
- smoldesu 4y ago> a harm reduced alternative to actually playing games. There's probably some merit to this statement, but I sorta laugh at the difference in harm between 'watching' and 'playing'. Maybe the most candid thing for us to do is acknowledge that the "harm" we're talking about is a lack of gratification.
- theptip 4y agoI think the idea is 30 mins watching scratches the itch, 30 mins playing and you are going to play for hours more. (At least, this is how it is for me, can’t speak for the GP.)
- nightski 4y agoYeah it's all down to the individual. I used to play all the time when younger but now I play in pretty short bursts and it works fine. I just avoid any games as a service type games. The PS5 is really nice at this because you don't even have to exit the game. Just send it into rest mode and when you come back your game is still running ready to pick up where you left off. For me it's a lot more satisfying than watching a YouTube video, but YMMV.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 4y agoSure. Impulse control plays a major part in both though, which is mostly why I find it funny. My ex-boyfriend had ADHD and swore off video games for the same reason, but he'd end up watching YouTube for hours if I left him unchecked. Nothing necessarily wrong with that, but I feel like the difference between both addictions is smaller than it seems.
- extasia 4y agoChanging my phone to black and white mode helped, I was previously watching 3+hrs of yt a day as was OP. Also making a mental note of how long you spend helps, even if you don't have the willpower to stop then and there. Over time You keep making that same note and eventually build up the fortitude to modify your behaviour / fight your addiction. Good luck to you all.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoWhere is black white mode in ios?
- daggersandscars 4y agoSettings -> Accessibility -> Display & Text Size -> Color Filters. Turn Color Filters on and select the Greyscale filter.
- gorgabal 4y agoIt’s in the accessibility settings. Accessibility > viewing and text size > color filters I have my phone on Dutch so I loosely translated those. Hope it is helpful.
- atonse 4y agoYou can also set it so that triple tapping on the sleep button brings up the accessibility menu so you can turn black and white mode on/off quickly if needed
- SunlightEdge 4y agoFor addictions I've wanted to get rid of I have: 1. Keep a spreadsheet of the hours I have spent on the activity, or 2. Kept a running log of how many days I have not done the activity - goal is usually 28 days
- greenpeas 4y agoIt seems like you've worked out a system. How many addictions/unwanted behaviors did you manage to eradicate this way?
- layer8 4y ago> wordless videos of food being prepared in the morning in Japanese restaurants Oh my god I need to watch this. Any recommendations?
- pushedx 4y ago“Japanese food craftsman”, “DancingBacons”, “I Will Always Travel for Food”, “Japanese Noodles Udon Soba Osaka Nara” In that order. Yes, these are all channel names.
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoYou might like https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL20OXrIf7YRjOJr54uci7hDBKwA-9KujG https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL20OXrIf7YRjOJr54uci7... It's not so much interesting for the recipes being prepared but rather for its composition and filmography. I find watching them rather soothing.
- ryandrake 4y agoPeople are (and should be) questioning the use of the word addiction. One of the components of addiction is: is it causing a harmful, unwanted effect on one's life? OP laid out his: > I've been struggling with my mental health during the summertime, a time I traditionally have fewer problems. I wasn't recharging like I should. I was waking up tired, napping during the day, and generally not feeling at all prepared when the day started. Yet, some people do activities excessively, even compulsively, but they're not addicted because it's not causing them any harm. My elderly parents have the TV on 16 hours a day, basically from the time they wake up to the time they go to bed. It's CNN and cooking shows and blah blah blah just to have a head on a screen talking in the background. It irritates me, but they're not addicts. Same with my daughter and YouTube. Streamers talking about nothing for hours, but her grades are great, her social life is fine, she's healthy and growing properly, so I can't really object. Some people just like to have blah blah blah as background noise all day, and I've come to just accept that it's not for me.
- tommica 4y agoThen the question that has to be answered is what unwanted and harmful effect consists of.
- erikerikson 4y agoAnd are they relative to individual values and preferences?
- thenerdhead 4y agoIf you are using a word by its most common definition then sure. Addiction has more casual definitions in the dictionary. Language evolves and the word addiction has evolved. It's used casually all the time like this blog post although there's no formal diagnosis. Your examples bring up a good point. Many parents have the TV on all day in the background because they were raised with it. Many kids today will likely have streamers on all day as they grow up because they were raised with it. It doesn't matter if they are good citizens or doing well in life, you can argue the perspective that it could be "harmful" if using the most common definition that many common mediums (radio, TV, internet, live streaming, etc) removes the sense of reality from people and promotes them to engage in consumerism/capitalism. That can be pretty harmful over the course of one's life although it's non-obvious. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Arguments_for_the_Elimination_of_Television https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Arguments_for_the_Elimina... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusing_Ourselves_to_Death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusing_Ourselves_to_Death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowling_Alone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowling_Alone
- nikhilsimha 4y agoOne invaluable hack I found is to use ad block to block the recommendation section of landing page. That way I don’t habit jump into a YouTube marathon but still search for specific topics when I need to. I do that with hacker news too.
- lairv 4y agoI don't know why the author spends half of the article justifying how can youtube addiction be a thing, it seems to me that social media addiction is now an established thing, which a large proportion of people are subject to If you own an Android phone there is a "Digital well being" settings which allows you to block applications after a certain amount of time spent every day, it also work for time spent on certain website on chrome, and it contains other features (focus mode, black and white mode) which I've found really useful. There are equivalent browser extension for desktop Though blocking websites/apps is not a magical solution, in the past I've found myself just disabling the blockers when I really wanted to watch something, I think it only works combined with discipline
- theshrike79 4y agoI've set myself Screen Time on iOS for this exact reason. Yes, it takes discipline to stop, but it's still a good thing that the OS notifies "You've spent a hour on social media already".
- lairv 4y agoGreat to know that iOS has the same kind of thing, I was honestly surprised when I discovered it on android, it seems to go against the "engagement maximization" trend and all, I guess it shows that it's a serious enough topic
- jna_sh 4y agoThey tell you why they spend so long justifying it as a thing, because people around them said it wasn’t a thing.
- johnchristopher 4y agoDepending on how the subject if framed or the angle chosen by the author those kind of posts attracts the crowd of people for whom it's one's sole responsibility/fault to be addicted or to fail to ward off addictive products or to restrain themselves. It often happens in threads about sugar and diet. "There's no addiction because nobody is forcing you so it's your fault". Something like that.
- tnamef 4y agoI found YouTube exciting around maybe 2015, when content was novel and less commercialized. Now most content is repetitive, streamlined for ads and with sensationalist ugly thumbnails. Basically like the Internet at large, which has turned into a gigantic tabloid.
- YoutubeAdct56 4y agoHi, I have this problem. I started using YouTube soon after it launched, in mid-2006. I still use the account that I created at that time. I am subscribed to over 900 channels, and as I scroll through them I can remember fondly watching each one of them. Some of them haven’t produced content for many years. According to the watch statistics in the YouTube app, in the last 7 days I have watched for over 43 hours. I would say this is a typical weekly watch time for me, with some weeks going up to 70 hours, if there is time off of work. I have a full time software engineering job (at a fairly high level), and I don’t think that many of my coworkers would guess that I have this problem. Most of these hours are spent actively watching the content, although I do cook, clean, and work out while watching YouTube as well. I really want to reduce or elimiate the time I spend on YouTube. I have tried most of the tricks mentioned here: changing my phone to black-and-white mode, using alternative apps with no recommendations, deleting the apps, setting the time limit setting on my devices. Somehow, I always find myself in a habit of “getting around my own system”, to the point that it’s almost laughable how I’ve built up muscle memory for it. I seriously feel as though I have a problem. Spending 40-70 hours a week on something that you don’t want to be doing is pretty severe. It is certainly affecting my health and other aspects of my life. A true local, in person, twelve step program for this type of thing is something that I have been seeking for years.
- nier 4y agoI’m very ill equipped to get addicted to anything that shows ads.
- charles_f 4y agoI'm assuming that spending that much time on it, they may be shelling out premium or using revance
- thenerdhead 4y agoI like that this author called out YouTube as a specific type of addiction. It seems their main way of combatting the consuming side of their addiction is by creating. I spent the last year writing a book about technology addiction. Through that process, it has helped me find better ways to fill my days and moderate how much time I spend on devices. There's also a good book called "Stolen Focus" that outlines a number of these challenges of quitting. The main way I found to combat addiction was to change the consumer mindset to one of creation. Create something everyday no matter how shitty it is. Share it with the world when you're ready. While in that process of creating, find ways to block the outside world from invading your creativity so you can stay focused.
- cmehdy 4y agoI tend to agree with you a lot, and find the process entirely terrifying. I've grown up with a history of being shut down and bullied when attempting to create (by teachers, peers, or mistakenly by family), and have as a result become an permanent observer to nearly everything. Only in the workplace have I turned things around because I could invoke the necessity to bypass everything else in order to make something tangible, but the private sphere is an endless battle to simply "feel" allowed and able to make something, and for it to be bad. As a result I also have a lot of respect for people who just do that constantly and got into the habit of it, and I think this is something we should encourage in others.
- thenerdhead 4y agoIt is terrifying. The permissionless mindset comes with enough creating regardless of quality. Most people who don’t think they can create are often the best creators.
- MobiusHorizons 4y agoI struggle with wasting large swathes of time on YouTube. I think I would call it an addiction, although I’m sure not everyone would agree. The harmful effects I see are that I don’t feel I enjoy the content after a certain point, but I find myself unable to stop and do something else. I also often find YouTube content is not restful. Hard to pin down exactly why, but it feels too fast paced or too stimulating. I feel the same way about most recent shows as well. Every year during lent my friend and I do a media fast, where we abstain from YouTube, Reddit, HN, and other escape sites. It is a supremely rewarding experience, but I always go back.
- c7b 4y agoThe intro feels like it's also from around 2011, the time OP described first noticing having a problem. In 2023, I think few people will doubt that you can get addiction-like problems with social media. It's actually become such a common trope, especially post-lockdowns, that I've read some arguments trying to rein in the debate a bit (not everything that releases dopamine will get you hooked, it basically just means that it's pleasant). Psychiatrically, I think the only behavioral addiction recognized in DSM-5 is still gambling. But that may change of course, and I think many of us have noticed that social media use can get troublesome. To the OP or anyone experiencing similar issues, one strategy that has some evidence behind it is pre-commitment: make a conscious decision to limit or stop your use of whatever is causing you troubles, and take concrete steps to lock yourself into that commitment. In the case of websites, that could mean using browser extensions that block access to a certain site or block them after a specified use time (if the latter exists, not sure). For smartphone apps, I think modern OS include some tools with similar intentions, but you could also just uninstall them. Of course, you could circumnavigate the block, but often that one extra step can be enough to remind you of why you made the commitment and help you stick to it.
- okdood64 4y agoBy OP's standard I'm what you would consider a YouTube addict. I can spend hours just watching it in a single day. And I do this regularly. It doesn't warp my view of the real world, or disconnect me from my work/social circle/ability to keep myself healthy. 90% of what I watch is educational anyways. What I disagree with overall is that notion that doing something a lot & compulsively is an addiction. If you're doing something that knowingly causes you or other around you harm and then doing it anyways because you can't help yourself, only then is it really an addiction. I can think of tons of other harmless interests/hobbies that people spend hours of their day on, in lieu of doing other activities, but no one considers those addictions.
- c7b 4y agoNot sure who downvoted you, not me, but if you're interested in the debate of what counts as addiction this might be a good starting point: https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/internet-gaming https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/internet-gaming In general, yes, keeping doing something despite it having negative consequences is generally required in most definitions of addiction.
- aviavi 4y agoThanks for talking about this.
- BizarreByte 4y agoI am seriously addicted to the internet in general and while it may not be an addiction in the physical sense, it has caused major issues in my life. The amount of time I spend on the Internet is insane and no matter how hard I try to will power through it and cut down my usage I always fail. If I ever figure out how to overcome it I'll have to write a book or something, because I've wasted years of my life and missed out on too many oppertunities. People will call me weak, or pathetic, or say I haven't tried hard enough, but as someone who did use tabacco I have found Internet 'addiction' a much tougher beast to deal with.
- px1999 4y agoYou are not weak, you're battling against groups of some of the smartest people in the world who spend their days doing nothing other than figuring out ways to manipulate you to steal and keep your attention, in order to maximise their engagement metrics/ad dollars. It's an incredibly difficult and unfair fight. I'd recommend Stolen Focus by Johann Hari, I've found it personally really helpful.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoI spend way more time random surfing than I probably should. Honestly we probably are both dealing with ADHD, depression, or some sort of anxiety disorder.
- cpsns 4y agoI actually do have an (adult) ADHD diagnosis, though I've always been a bit sceptical of it. It seemed too easy to get and I really didn't think the testing criteria were very good. I have wanted to try medicine to see if it helps me at all, but I've never been able to do so. My GP was willing to perscribe me something, but decided my BP was too high and that was that. There are definitely anxiety issues at play as well, but I don't know to what degree.
- dmlerner 4y agoCombine with a blood pressure medicine? Guanfacine is specifically an ADHD treating blood pressure medication.
- cl3misch 4y ago> It's scary to think about having a hole and not being able to fill it with that comfortable "zoning out" feeling. That is exactly my experience. I've also rather recently came to the revelation that this behavior and dependence on "zoning out" is addiction. It doesn't matter that the object of addiction is a website with silly popular videos. The pattern of behavior _is_ addiction.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoWould it make sense to say that the pattern of behaviour (zoning out) is coping rather than addiction, and that addiction is what manifests when we lose control over coping strategies? They seem like different things to me. Coping strategies are normal and can be healthy. Harmful strategies we depend on without much agency are more so what I’d classify as addiction within this lens.
- vorpalhex 4y agoI gave up alcohol as part of an experiment. Prior to that my routine on Fri and Sat night was usually to have a few drinks and zone out and watch youtube or a movie. For me, one of the unexpected hard things was that zoning out to watch youtube or a movie was no longer entertaining! I could do it for an hour or so and that was it. Now I read, work on projects or otherwise am more "engaged". I still enjoy youtube but my ability to be entertained by it has dwindled dramatically.
- kerryoco 4y agoI think many addiction treatment programs looks specifically at the negative impacts of your "zoning out" though. Zoning out is just a brainstate, probably as old as (human) time. But if it's causing your self esteem to drop, to miss deadlines, etc, then -those- are specifically the problem. I think it's no surpise that as we continue to remove nature from our environment, we turn increasingly to digital media to get these pseudo-meditative experiences, and we should not entirely blame ourselves for this dystopian state of affairs.
- boredemployee 4y agoI wonder if all the addiction related to internet (porn, gaming, surfing, you name it) has anything to do with our daily routine (aka work) that is so boring that we want an immediate and constant distraction
- maksimur 4y agoThis is a problem (arguably more so) for unemployed people as well.
- the_only_law 4y agoYeah it’s been killing me lately. My sleep schedule is incredibly erratic too because I don’t have anything to do tomorrow, so why not stay up till 4am watching YouTube. Unfortunately I have some confounding factors rn that make it all the wise.
- the_only_law 4y agoI mean if I had something interesting or fun to do that was remotely as accessible as YouTube I’d probably be more interested in that. Unfortunately “interesting” stuff tends to be really inaccessible and COVID did a great job of killing off “fun” stuff, at least around me. At the same time I get really complacent really fast if I’m in the same place for more than a few years and I think it’s about time for a “soft” reset again.
- boredemployee 4y agoIdk. I think the pandemic changed me and my general view of the world. And I didn't even notice when it happened. I lost at least 5 people close to me that I remember in a blink. I'm not depressed but it's like I lost the joy of many things that I like, anything corporate-related is all BS to me and serendipity is something really rare these days. Or maybe I'm just getting old.
- nicbou 4y agoI'm still addicted without having to work much. It's just so easy to access YouTube compared to starting a more rewarding activity
- ttul 4y agoYouTube is addictive, as is much of what the internet has to offer. It’s hard to fight the algorithm, which is always finding new things it knows will pump the dopamine cycle. If the internet has you so addicted that it’s wrecking your life, it’s time to see an addictions specialist. I don’t think there’s any easy trick, just as there is no easy way to quit smoking or drinking. The causes of addiction are various and it doesn’t make sense to try to figure this out yourself, just as much as you wouldn’t be well advised to fix your own cancer.
- anthomtb 4y ago> I got into self-help and meditation I know it can be expensive but consider a real live therapist alongside self help resources. Talking out your problems to an actual human, who is trained to listen, can provide the quantum leap needed for resolving a whole host of personal problems. Personally, Apples screen time limits and Downtime features have been a god send for my overwatch issues on Instagram. I have most non-work apps blocked from 7:00AM to 6:00PM and a 15 minute per day limit on Instagram. Since doing that, I feel much more engaged and efficient at work and have also managed to knock out some technical reading on the Kindle app (one of the few apps that I allow myself to use at any time).
- tayo42 4y agoHow do you you find a good one?
- anthomtb 4y agoTrial and error. I wish I knew a way to find a good therapist without that process. But I do not. And unlike dentists, doctors, counter installers, pet sitters, window cleaners and most other services, folks will not fall over themselves to give you a therapist recommendation (maybe that is a peculiarity of my circle of acquaintances). To find a therapist, Psychology Today worked well enough. To me, having one is better than having none.
- mtbcreate 4y agoI experienced the same thing during middle/high school. In three years I watched a fourth of a year of YouTube on my main account. I broke it by asking my dad to block youtube on the dns level and disable it using screen time on my iPhone (I still had to stop myself from using TOR and free VPNs). Ever since I have spent my free moments on HN or working on personal projects - I have learned so much. I also have friends now.
- epalm 4y agoSomething that really helped me with YouTube was installing the Unhook browser extension https://unhook.app/ https://unhook.app/ Unhook can remove all 'suggested' videos. The home page will just be blank, and when watching a video, there will be no other video links on the page. This means I can still use YouTube, but I have to search for what I'm looking for. This alone has completely solved the endless video merry-go-round sessions.
- rob81777 4y agoHere's how you can stop the youtube algorithm: step 1) install libredirect (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/libredirect/?utm_source=addons.mozilla.org&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=search https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/libredirect/?...) step 2) on invidious go to settings and uncheck show related videos, set default homepage and feed menu to "search" on your phone you can install newpipe (https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.schabi.newpipe/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/org.schabi.newpipe/) and do the same.
- clnq 4y agoI successfully reduced time wasted on YouTube by making the website much less appealing. I unsubscribed from everything, emptied all of my playlists, unliked every video I liked, deleted my comments, and disabled my YouTube history. I also turned off ad blocking for YouTube. Now the algorithm isn't targeting me enough to serve attention-grabbing content. And the time it takes to get gratification with pre-video ads has broken up my habit of clicking through videos. It's interesting to note that YouTube is still surprisingly good at suggesting relevant content to me, even on the home page. But much, much worse now than how it used to be. If there was some way to slow down the internet speed back to around 1mbps, I think that it would cure a lot of internet addiction without much effort from the addicted. The habit-forming craving -> action -> random reward/outcome loop has to happen quickly for the habit to be formed. If it becomes craving -> action ->1 0-20 second delay -> random outcome, I think the brain soon decides it's going to take too much effort and time (maybe hours) to get the favorable outcome, and other things are better for a dopamine boost - like exercise (10 minutes of work and then the dopamine rush is guaranteed). The same thing worked for me with food - I ended my snacking habit by not keeping unhealthy food in the house. It is just too much effort to go to a convenience store (10 minutes) for a little 10-second dopamine boost. The brain is good at this algebra. An outcome's correctly or incorrectly estimated value needs to be higher than the effort to get that outcome. Otherwise, the effort becomes unappealing.
- drdaeman 4y ago> I unsubscribed from everything, emptied all of my playlists This is probably enough. I've never subscribed to anything except for a friend who doesn't post anything, some random dude who hacked an old LG TV (he doesn't post anything either) and a couple of channels. I've just checked and all the recommendations I see are completely useless; I'm indifferent at best or sometimes even repulsed. Even though I can see how they were picked (Google search history). > It's interesting to note that YouTube is still surprisingly good at suggesting relevant content to me This is what really baffles me. I don't know what is wrong with me, but I don't remember ever seeing a relevant and useful recommendation from a machine (except when the search domain was already constrained to something very niche). Here's what I see if I open YouTube's home page: - "Razer Blade 16 and Razer Blade 18 - they finally did it". Yes, I bought a Razer laptop. Of course I've searched for a bunch of things related to their hardware, so Google must've caught it. I don't intend to buy a new one anytime soon. It's a prime example of a "meatbag bought a sofa, must love sofas, show them all the sofas"-style recommendation. - "The most mysterious band in the world. Enigma." (title translated into English by me). So, long story short, based on my wife's recommendation I watched a channel with two radio DJs telling some interesting trivia about music. Like about how some popular songs are actually a covers of some obscure ones, or how The Prodigy songs were made (where are all the samples are from), etc. Fun stuff, but I don't watch every single video from them. Enigma is a miss for me, sorry. Good try, recommender system - given that this channel is one of a few I've actually cared to subscribe to, hah. - Some podcast with a name and face that doesn't ring any bells to me. - "Things I Wish I Knew Earlier In Horizon Forbidden West". Played, finished and uninstalled long time ago, doubt the replay value. And I've already checked the wikis when I was done playing. So, nope, not watching this. - "Unusual Feature in UltraLoq Smart Lock" by LockPickingLawyer. I think I've watched a couple of LPL's videos when I was randomly wondering about some lock mechanism - so I wanted some quick visual explanation how it works. I sure don't need to see any videos to learn how some IoT is a mess. - "1 Min Synth Review // TB-303 #shorts". Must be because I've watched that channel about music I've mentioned, since they sometime invite various music experts. I can't carry a tune in a bucket, so this is meaningless for me. - "Lord of the Rings from Sauron's perspective". So, some time ago me and my wife decided to re-watch Peter Jackson's trilogy. And I've searched for The Battle of Helm's Deep because it felt weird and I wanted some expert opinion from Reddit's renown medievalists (lol). I don't think I'd care to watch a fanfic. - "UE5 - How to create a Radial Weapon Menu - Tutorial Part 6". Never in my life I've ever coded for Unreal Engine. And last time I've did something with 3D game engines was two decades ago, when I was a school kid and played with a DIY Quake 1 map renderer, learning BSP (as well as other space partitioning algorithms) and some OpenGL. - "10X Your Excel Skills with ChatGPT". So 3 months ago this meatbag needed to figure out how to make a certain one-off chart to visualize some data (and Excel is as good as anything). And this meatbag was not impervious to recent ChatGPT hype. Automated recommendation engines work in a mysterious ways! Obviously, I'd pass. And so on and so on. I know I'm sometimes a pretty grumpy person, I've had some assholes for role models during my student years, and while I'm not that angsty kid anymore, sometimes something still gets through. And I went to YouTube with an expectation that I won't likely see anything interesting, so there's a bias. But then I've also honestly tried to find something worth watching. It's a good afternoon, I'm done with my dose of HN and I was certainly open to watching something entertaining. It's not just YouTube for me. Spotify, Kindle, various streaming platforms, Amazon product recommendations and so on - all bad, to the extend I really believe that either I'm a weird outlier or all this "big data" that's supposed to predict my every sneeze is just one big lie from the naked kings of the industry. The thing that prevents me from thinking I'm just a negative person is that I've got a plenty of human-curated recommendations (even non-personal, but just some online posts) that I've genuinely enjoyed. And I think I know how to waste my time responsibly (aka not screwing up other obligations too much), so I'd even pay for a good recommendation system that'd bring me something I'd be always interested in, on demand, to fill an hour or two when I want it. So I wonder - how YouTube looks to someone who says the recommendations are good?
- Decabytes 4y agoI am addicted to mindlessly scrolling YouTube as well. What has worked well for me to break this are these habits 1. I use iPhone focuses to set times during the workday where time wasting apps are hidden 2. I have blocked YouTube.com so I can't see recommended videos and instead get redirected to https://www.youtube.com/feed/subscriptions https://www.youtube.com/feed/subscriptions. That way if I do watch YouTube it's only who I'm subscribed to and feels more intentional. 3. I use the momentum extension so that new tabs don't show me my most frequently accessed websites (usually time wasters) 4. I use leech block for Firefox (stayfocusd for chrome) which limits the time I can spend on sites in my addiction category (where YouTube resides) 5. I generally try to be more conscious when I'm on YouTube. I stop and ask myself questions like "can I be working on something else?" "Is this actually helping me right now?", "is there something more important I can be working on?" Lastly as with any reduction you need to fill that time with other things. If you cut out 3 hours of YouTube a day then don't expect to spend those 3 hours doing something more productive. You'd be better off if you took those three hours and did 1 hour of reading (nothing super productive, non fiction, thrillers, drama, etc), one hour with going for a walk or chores or something easy, and one hour of actually working on a project or goal. The break down can change, but the most important thing is not expecting to be hyper productive during all the extra time you have. You still have to balance it out if you want it to be sustainable.
- tuduka 4y agoHi JT, please reach out to me if you'd like to try the Tuduka Method, free of charge: https://tuduka.com https://tuduka.com I'm announcing it a bit too early (I just started it a few weeks ago) but the method works.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI fall asleep to YouTube -- not watching, I just put on a boring documentary with a monotone narrator, just loud enough that I can hear the voice. I don't even really discern the words. And it distracts my brain from whatever else I'd be thinking about and I fall asleep more easily. Not sure why this is, I guess it's like having someone read a bedtime story to a kid. I have a premium account so there are no ads.
- forinti 4y agoI had some trouble sleeping during lockdown and found out philosophy videos got me sleeping very well. Especially the ones about Kant. Still managed to learn a bit though.
- aswanson 4y agoPhilosophy and Fall of Civilizations are great channels to learn/sleep to.
- jdthedisciple 4y agoPro tip: uBlock origin - no ads for no cost :)
- criley2 4y agoPro pro tip: Creating content on the internet is not free and if a creator says you can watch their video in exchange for watching ads OR paying for premium, if you care about those creators you'll honor that request.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- moffkalast 4y agoThere are billions of absolutely fantastic videos that took exactly zero in production cost, nobody's forcing anyone to invest more than that. If people want to base their main income on making free online videos than that's their problem. Some will then try to disingenuously guilt trip people on patreon and similar, and there are those who go get themselves some sponsors like a proper advertising business does. Do these creators classify themselves as a non-profit org? Because that's who runs on donations.
- oramit 4y agoWhile the author compares his problem to Alcohol addiction I was struck by the sentence: "It's gotten to the point where I don't really enjoy the video as much as the numb hypnotic state from consuming that much content." This to me matches up most with gambling addiction. There is a great book on the subject that I recommend to the Author called "Addiction by Design" by Natasha Schull. The main thrust of her argument is that machine gambling addicts don't care about winning at all but have found gambling machines (slots, video poker mostly) as a reliable way to activate that "flow" state where the rest of the world falls away. It's mostly a study of the problem, very sobering, and there are some good resources at the end for getting help. I think we're all addicted to this "flow" state. When it happens during programming it's the best feeling ever. Hours go by, no technical hurdle is too big, I can make more progress in 4 hours than 4 days of regular work, and everything just makes sense. I come out of it always wishing I could activate that feeling on command, but it never works reliably for productive things. Only vices, unfortunately.
- mancerayder 4y ago>This to me matches up most with gambling addiction. There is a great book on the subject that I recommend to the Author called "Addiction by Design" by Natasha Schull. The main thrust of her argument is that machine gambling addicts don't care about winning at all but have found gambling machines (slots, video poker mostly) as a reliable way to activate that "flow" state where the rest of the world falls away. Maybe to escape anxiety?
- oramit 4y agoAnxiety is certainly part of it but I think it's simpler than that. We can't be "on" all the time. We need hobbies, distractions, and escape just as much as we need productive work. As the author notes though, this escape can become all consuming and ultimately hurt the person.
- wincy 4y agoInteresting, I get this flow state where the world falls away when I have a good programming task for work and I can accomplish a Herculean amount of work in a day. At the end of the day it feels like it was in a blink of an eye and I feel super good about myself. I got into a great flow state earlier this week the day after seeing my relative in hospice care. I didn’t have to think about the pain of that for a day and it was pretty great.
- mikewarot 4y agoI use YouTube as a juke box, or background noise quite a bit. However, thanks to Long Covid, I really have a LOT of time on my hands that I can't otherwise use actually outdoors doing things, nor do I have the budget that I'd otherwise have from a job to be able to buy stuff and work..... Ok... maybe I do have an addiction ;-) ;-(
- yinyang_in 4y agoSimilar for me, found solution by removing distractions. 1. Cleaned Home Screen on YouTube with adblocker with only search bar. 2. Somehow YouTube still has RSS feeds for channels. So for channels like oversimplified have RSS feeds like other feed. 3. Also no youtube app just using it in mobile browser. I think I’m most distracted one, but using this all is resolved for me.
- Egidius 4y agoHuman are addiction machines
- racl101 4y agoI definitely am addicted to YouTube. I watch it more than Netflix, Disney Plus, Amazon Prime combined. I just like documentaries.
- yakshaving_jgt 4y agoI think YouTube cured my addiction to YouTube. It seems like every video recommended to me now has the same YouTube thumbnail face thumbnail. I hate it, and it makes me feel like I’ve already seen everything on YouTube, so there’s no point visiting.
- nullc 4y agoI block any account that uses those sex-face thumbnails as soon as I see one. Makes the youtube front page less squicky.
- kjuulh 4y agoI am also quite addicted to youtube, however, for now I use it a tool for relaxation, even if it sometimes is somewhat excessive. I watch YouTube as a replacement for flow tv. And I know that the moment I remove the YouTube app on my tv, I will find something else to do, right now it is a convenience and routine thing to do. Also I get quite good benefits from it, I love watching conference talks, woodworking etc, on it. And in general it has helped with my overall understanding of the world, which is why I haven't removed it yet.
- aswanson 4y agoSame. I also use it to fall asleep to. PBS Frontiline and Fall of Civilizations channel episodes keep me educated and catching zzzzz's most nights.
- camdenreslink 4y agoFrontline has such terrifying content! I couldn't imagine falling asleep to that. My choice would be David Attenborough narrated documentaries.
- aswanson 4y agoListen to the Putin files with Kori Schake or Julia Ioffe or Masha Gessen. Put the volume low. They all have mom/bedtime story voices.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoWorked for me: 1) get rid of data plan. 2) wifi router blocks devices at 11pm. I get angry for a minute then relax. Importantly, I can’t connect to box to modify schedule until the next morning. Next morning I don’t care and time to work. This worked where “screen time” did not, since it lets you type a pin to bypass. Combined with night/red shift I sleep well again. P.s. read books and you’ll want to read more often.
- pfoof 4y agoI was addicted to meme websites, YouTube, online games, news websites and I have replaced it with HN. Now I'm addicted to HN and it seems just as bad.
- moffkalast 4y agoThe fact is, real life is boring as fuck. https://xkcd.com/1348/ https://xkcd.com/1348/ People will find ways to fill their time, the internet is just the best place for just about everything right now. As long as one mixes in some variety, education, and productiveness I don't really see the problem.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y ago"Number go up" is weirdly powerful, psychologically, whether it's the number in your brokerage account, or the number of karma points you have on Hacker News. Well, there's a number that people in Alcoholics Anonymous keep track of: The amount of time since your last drink. "Number go up." So how about keeping track of the time since you last watched a YouTube video?
- deepzn 4y agoI use YouTube for technical videos, and to gain other knowledge. And find the best signal to noise there than anywhere else on the internet. Occasionally, I give in to watch sports clips, movie trailers etc which is a decent short distraction. But do try to limit it, so the algo doesn't keep recommending those. Recently, Youtube is pushing it's "Shorts"(Short-form video) in it's own section that you cannot remove, which is as addicting as you think it is, aside from that, the signal-to-noise is really favorable for me. Compared to Twitter, Instagram, I find a lot more value on Youtube. The others I already used blocking extensions to stop me from visiting it. As sad and extreme as that is, it's worked out rather nicely for me. I occasionally need to check something, and circumvent it by going incognito, but mostly the blocking is helping me to redirect myself, and build better restraints, and habits.
- libraryatnight 4y agoI've been dabbling in making my own game on the evenings and weekends and youtube from that perspective is everything i wanted the internet to be. People sharing interesting knowledge and teaching each other things. It tries to ruin it with shorts and other low effort, usually 'creator' content, but if you're adamant about only seeing what you came for it's a wonderful tool.
- malinoal 4y agoyou can use "distraction free YouTube"[0] to block the shorts pushing and recommendations in general. It's been really helpful for me to not fall into endless YouTube spirals. [0] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/df-youtube/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/df-youtube/
- nullc 4y agoI'm surprised that anyone is addicted to youtube, -- I can hardly ever find anything remotely interesting to watch on it. I've even missed recent USCSB videos because it's so pointless to even check whats on there.
- password4321 4y agoSee also (two weeks ago): Tech execs who raise their kids tech-free or limit their screen time (2020) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34186349 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34186349 Including a recommendation of "Indistractable" by Nir Eyal. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PG2W6DC https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PG2W6DC
- dathinab 4y agoI'm not sure YouTube addiction is the right term. It's more like a media addiction. YouTube is one offender here. But "short" media is way more addictive(1) weather it's TickTock or YouTube shorts. (1: Easier flow to the next video, shorter attention loops, more randomness between hit and disappointment, etc.) I don't know how scientific funded the "way more" part is, but from speaking with people and personal experience I would _guess_ the potential for addictive behaviour for short form video is not just slightly (a few %) but hugely larger (like 200%-1000%). Through the long-term binding potential might also be shorter, but then that doesn't mean it's not a problem as you likely would just bounce between short form video and other media in your addictive behaviour (e.g. longer form video).
- jacooper 4y agoOne thing I can certainly recommend is using the subscription page instead of the home page. The algorithm is certainly the cause of the addiction, and minimizing it certainly will help. I personally use Libretube, which just fetches a list of your subscriptions stored locally or on the piped instance you use, and it will save you time by blocking ads and sponsorship segments(it auto skips, the extension is called sponsor block on the desktop) Libretube and newpipe are android only, if you're on iOS you may use this https://github.com/yattee/yattee https://github.com/yattee/yattee Or a PWA of piped/invidious
- ChildOfChaos 4y agoUgh. I have such a problem with this and the internet in general, I spend hours refreshing, trying to find something that might be useful in my life. I guess some of it comes out of a desire for self improvement, I watch videos, read articles etc, hoping to find an interesting idea, product, service, book, app etc that will improve my life, but in general there is just so much filler, however it's not like I haven't found semi cool/intreasting things, so there is enough there that really makes me feel like I will miss out if I cut too much of it off.
- vouaobrasil 4y agoI got a huge hack for making YouTube less addictive: use the uBlock Origin extension, and block the thumbnails! Now when I search for videos, I don't see any thumbnails and I have to read the text titles. I also don't get distracted by the end-of-video thumbnails either.
- blueblimp 4y ago> I'm sure some folks are thinking "what if you just limit yourself to 30 minutes a day?" An alternative to this that I've found more effective is to prescribe which modes of interaction are allowed. For example, in this case, the author JT has a YouTube channel, so he could say that he's allowed to post to the channel, interact with the comments, etc. But then also say that he's not allowed to go to the frontpage and browse recommended videos (or whatever habit it is that he finds leads to problematic overuse). I've used an approach like this when I find internet overuse detracting from the things I want to do. For example, I'll say I'm not allowed to just aimlessly browse my reddit homepage, but I am allowed to read a reddit thread if I came from Google search looking for specific information. That way I can still get the benefits without losing too much time.
- huy77 4y agoThis is exactly what I found myself to be just last night.
- smlavine 4y agoAs suzumer also commented, the extension Unhook has also been very helpful to me in curbing the amount of time I spend watching YouTube. I have it set to block the front page suggestions, sidebar suggestions, after video cards, etc. Everything except a particular video I'm searching for. And of course I always view youtube logged out. The first thing I did to try to curb my...addiction to YouTube was to consume the videos instead through RSS feeds. I wrote a script omnavi (https://sr.ht/~smlavine/omnavi https://sr.ht/~smlavine/omnavi) to help out with that. I would never watch videos on YouTube itself; I would click links that I got through RSS to channels I was subscribed to, and view the videos locally with mpv + youtube-dl. Honestly it's sad to look back at how many hours of my day I wasted watching YouTube videos. They're the sort of sort-of educational videos that make me feel like I'm spending my time valuably, but at the end of an all-night session, I really wouldn't have been able to tell you any of what I had watched for the past six hours.
- RMPR 4y agoI have to double down on this. Switching over my content consumption over to RSS has been proven to be beneficial. Every once in a while, I'll log in to the webapp to discover some new content creator (YouTube recommendation algorithm, despite all its flaws, is quite good). But more importantly, now I can spend days without feeling the urge to go on a YouTube rabbit hole, I can watch a video without the UI constantly pushing me to watch more.
- OwlsParlay 4y agoAS someone who watches a lot of YouTube, like the Let's Play content mentioned, I recognise and sympathise with the OP. But I think the problem isn't necessarily YouTube - thats just the drug of choice. It could be Twitch, it could be podcasts, or television, or any other form of entertainment offering a parasocial relationship. One that fill the gaping lonely hole in so many people's lives.
- toyg 4y agoYeah but television doesn't give you the choice that YT provides. If it's 2am and all available tv programs are shit, you go to bed. With YT, there is always a decent video a search away. (This obviously changed with streaming sites - but that's tv turning into YT rather than traditional broadcasting)
- 411111111111111 4y agoThat's true for online media in general, it's not specific to YouTube
- remify 4y agoYouTube is definitely trying to make you watch the absolute most they can.
- anteloper 4y agoBeen there - still am. self-control (https://selfcontrolapp.com/ https://selfcontrolapp.com/) is the nuclear tool in my anti-scrolling arsenal. If you figure out how to get around it please do not tell me - it's the best thing I've found for completely shutting myself out of youtube (and chess websites - bullet chess is a similar drug for me). Disclosure - I'm full time working on software that arms people with better tools for fighting compulsive digital habits (https://getclearspace.com/ https://getclearspace.com/) We have a chrome extension and an iPhone app and they're powerful for retraining compulsive habits - but can't honestly recommend them for full blow addiction (yet). Interestingly, in watching my own behavior, the most effective force for keeping me from wasting my life is knowing that people can see my screen (at the office for example). I'm starting to think that replicating this remotely might be a way to keep my phone usage in check. If I could opt-in to sharing my phone screentime with a pre-set list of friends that might change how I behave - particularly if they were notified if I ever deleted the app that was doing that sharing. I'll be all-in building some version of that for the next few months if you want to be on the beta list for some accountability experiments. https://screentimeaccountability.com/ https://screentimeaccountability.com/
- namaria 4y agoI think it's incredibly misguided and crass to plug websites and apps in a discussion about people sharing struggles with addiction to websites and apps.
- anteloper 4y agoI don't think I plugged anything. I shared the best thing I've found to partially solve this problem in my own life (open source software I have no relationship to), shared that my full time job is working on this problem (because it's the largest obstacle in my life, not because I am trying to grift) and what I've built so far, with the explicit note that I would not recommend as a single magic bullet for addiction, because it happens to be a really hard problem. And then shared what I am trying next - to address this problem in my own life and ideally as many others as I can.
- dudul 4y agoI watch a lot of YouTube, mostly Let's Plays, but it's just in the background while I do other stuff. Sometimes I work, sometimes I game (either the same game or another one). It's kind of listening to music I guess. I dont retain a lot of the content. No clue if it's harmful or not, but I wouldn't call it an addiction because I dont miss it.
- yumswiss 4y agoApproach has helped: - RSS Feed. Check only once a week - NextDNS block distracting sites during the week
- maerF0x0 4y agoMe too. I noticed this one night when I spent something like 2 hrs scrolling youtube on my TV adding "gotta watch" stuff to watch later list. My eye lids were heavy. I wasn't even watching the videos, just adding them to later. I was addicted to the find of a video that promised to make my life better. Though the obvious fact that 1) probably not and 2) even if so I'd have to watch it, not just queue it for later. It really hit me i had a problem when youtube failed to add to watch later. apparently 5k videos is the limit for that list. (And they dont give you any rapid way to clean it up either, lol). Books is my answer. Yes we can waste time with books, but the stimulation package is just so below the threshold that I'm not worried about. It's like yes you can get fat eating just fresh/roasted vegetables. But I dare ya to try.
- flir 4y agoHeh. First time I played Minecraft, I went to bed at 8AM the next morning (every block you mine, there's a tiny chance of a diamond). I suspect you were experiencing the same mechanism (the next video in the list might be worth saving), and it's also present in gambling (the next bet might be a big win). It's a Skinner box. If the reward comes every time, or never, the subject loses interest. It's when the reward only comes sometimes that the pigeon keeps hammering the button.
- lazycouchpotato 4y agoI've had my YouTube watch history paused for the past 3 years. I only subscribe to channels I consider educational/useful. It cuts down on a lot of garbage recommendations, and makes the YouTube algorithm work harder to find actually interesting stuff to keep me watching, instead of taking the easy route and suggesting me memes. I also spend a few minutes every once in a while going through my previously liked videos and unliking unhelpful/meme videos. I don't know if search history contributes to the recommendation algorithm, but I have it paused as well. There are downsides to this though. If there's something I've previously watched that I want to find, it's a lot harder. On a PC I have the browser search history, but there's nothing I can do for the mobile app.
- cleandreams 4y agoA friend told me about Internet Technology Addicts Anonymous. https://internetaddictsanonymous.org/ https://internetaddictsanonymous.org/ It's quite a new fellowship and the meetings are almost all virtual / zoom. I went to a few meetings and I liked them. Right now I am trying to control my internet use with freedom (the app). Looks promising. I want to get it down to 1.5 hours/day. I have other things to do! The internet is addictive by design and like other addictive substances (with which I have experience) it changes the brain. So I am quite serious about tackling this, one way or another. Good luck everyone!
- mmanfrin 4y agoLast night I went to a showing of a (youtube, lol) filmmaker's upcoming videos and sat down next to a woman who told me she was studying social media services and their addictiveness and she said that youtube was the absolute #1 most addictive in her findings.
- ranting-moth 4y agoPerhaps a legal question, is "causes addiction" used as a basis for prohibiting/banning/regulating things or substances? I know a lot of things are prohibited/banned/regulated, just wondering if addiction is the fundamental (or perhaps the sole) argument for the rule/law?
- siskiyou 4y agoMy YouTube addiction is scrolling the home screen looking for the viral garbage they promote to pollute my recommendations with things I would never want to see. I frequently don't watch any videos - I just play Whac-A-Mole on the recommendations.
- anthk 4y agoGet into books. No, not computer related books. Narrative. Sherlock Holmes' books are now under Public Domain. Get all of them, and try reading them in chronologcal in order. A Study in Scarlet The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes The Sign of Four The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes The Valley of Fear The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes The Return of Sherlock Holmes His Last Bow The Hound of the Baskervilles If you are a sysadmin, network engineer with vulnscanning experience, IT forensics expert or a reverse engineer, you might feel at home, because deductive reasoning it's right here.
- t0bia_s 4y agoGrab a plugin Unhook. Or use FreeTube. On both, I disable autoplay, suggestions, trends, any kind of recommendations... Now I watch YT only fof few subscribtions that I have. And thats it. Approximately 15-20 min. per day.
- memorable 4y ago(This is a bit of a thought dump) I'm also a Youtube addict whose only active social medias are Youtube and HN. I do use Discord and Twitter but quite lightly. I can't imagine the amount of time I have spent on Youtube. On my screen time tracking app, I have already spent 20+ hours on Youtube only. That's almost one goddamn day! Now imagine that plus my two years since I bought this phone. On Youtube, I get pulled in for things I don't really cared or have never heard about. Last week it was Bluey (which seems pretty good), now it was about Nardwuar. Last time it was Radiohead, now it is CS:GO histories. Youtube is so good at pulling me in and find the things I could be interested that sometimes I just wish Youtube's surveilliance tool will automagically knows exactly what I wanted and just served it up to my Recommendation, since for whatever reasion I refused to use the search bar. In my journey of beating my social media addiction, Youtube is the true final boss (HN is also a big boss but not on the same level). I have been aggressively and gradually reduced my Youtube time. Refused to use it until it's 10 AM. Only used it as a break between my pomodoro sessions. I have not fully remove Youtube addiction in my life yet, but I'm on the way.
- vladdoster 4y agoThanks for sharing. I watch mostly art, history, and tech videos (i.e., perspective & timeline channels). IMO, Youtube is king of diverse content when compared to streaming services. Regardless of content, I don't view it any different from spending the time listening to music or podcasts. For context, my time watched via YouTube mobile app: Today: 17 hr 6 min Last 7 days: 117 hr 35 min Daily average: 16 hr 48 min (19% down from last week)
- password4321 4y agoMaybe lock your phone + router using a time lock. https://amzn.com/s?k=time+lock+box https://amzn.com/s?k=time+lock+box
- luisapic 4y ago[dead]
- Alifatisk 4y agoI am addicted to Youtube and its content, even worse is Youtube shorts.
- garfieldnate 4y agoI just found a great video from Dr. K. the other day on how entertainment addictions work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wK-s2qBU40A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wK-s2qBU40A. The second half of the stream is missing, but there's a good comment there summarizing the advice for doing a dopamine detox.
- fithisux 4y agoYoutube has very good lectures on statistics + programming. If you spend many hours on these, does it count as addiction? I really doubt.
- Jakob-G 4y agoI was also spending way too much time on YouTube, but found a way to cut down on the time. I made my own YouTube app that simply removes the recommendations. Those recommendations get you to watch video after video, without them, YouTube turns from an addiction machine into a useful tool to learn new things. If anyone is interested you can download the app here: watchless-app.github.io
- HomeDeLaPot 4y agoFellow YouTube/Internet addict here. I'm trying a few things: - Disable the YouTube app on my Android. - Use Newpipe from F-Droid instead when I really need to watch a tutorial or something (very rare). I find it a little less addictive. - Leechblocker extension (available on Firefox on desktops & Android). - Use uBlock Origin filters to hide the YouTube feed and recommendations on my laptop. - Using a feed reader with selected feeds instead of binging HN/reddit/blogs. - Not using YouTube for music or background noise. Instead, use mynoise.net and download music from Amazon/Bandcamp/etc and build a music library. - Find alternative stuff to do. In my case, anything from hobby projects to trying to walk 10K steps per day to meeting up with friends to trying a new journal/knowledge base app (Logseq) to organizing/rearranging my apartment and shopping for furniture. - On a related note, take care of your health so you have energy to do the right things. Get an exercise routine, eat better, sleep at the right time, get enough time outdoors and with other people. I don't feel like I've really kicked my bad habits yet. But maybe the vulnerability never goes away entirely, and the important thing is to always keep trying.
- johlits 4y agoHow is it that much different to reading books (a healthy addiction) though?