25 ms·
We have places on Earth, which are probably 10x if not 100x or 1000x more habitable than Mars, which we still do not and cannot inhabit long term with more than
by ryandrake 4y ago
We have places on Earth, which are probably 10x if not 100x or 1000x more habitable than Mars, which we still do not and cannot inhabit long term with more than a handful of people. I'm not sure how we expect to establish any kind of working colony on Mars, where there is no atmosphere or accessible oxygen, food or accessible water, magnetic field to keep radiation away, reliable supply chain for delivering anything else we need.
Let's figure out how to house and sustain, say, 20K people in Antarctica for 100 years before we even dream about doing the same on Mars.
- nonethewiser 4y agoThat doesn't solve the scenario where everyone on earth gets wiped out.
- thelamest 4y agoMars is on (or above) a wiped out Earth level of difficulty already
- bryanlarsen 4y agoMars is more habitable than Earth would be during an extinction event. After the event the wiped out Earth would certainly be more habitable, but if there aren't any humans available to repopulate...
- droopyEyelids 4y agoWhat extinction event could possibly make Earth less habitable than Mars?
- legel 4y agoThere is a broad range of possible human extinction events, e.g. asteroid impact, large-scale volcanism, viral epidemic, nuclear annihilation, biological warfare, ecological collapse, and autonomous robots [1]. Humans actively monitor and defend against each threat. In the U.S., NASA is committed to detecting asteroids, and recently successfully altered the course of one [2]. I believe we are most powerful to overcome extinction events as a united species on the planet we’ve evolved to live on over billions of years. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction [2] https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/news/2022/9/22/the-science-behind-nasas-first-attempt-at-redirecting-an-asteroid/ https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/news/2022/9/22/the-science-behi...
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWithout humans. Redundancy is important.
- nonethewiser 4y agoTrue, but irrelevant to the point that it's a different basket.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIt's not irrelevant. Virtually the only conceivable thing that could make Earth even temporarily as inhospitable to humans as Mars is today is an impact close to the one that created the Moon. For any other scenario, some places on Earth will continue to be more inhabitable to humans even during the event itself than Mars is today. So, having humans on Earth + Mars at best only marginally improved the chances of humanity surviving long term than only having humans on Earth, by a tiny amount.
- mlinsey 4y agothe "eggs in one basket" argument only makes sense if Martian colonization is itself just step 1 on a list of dozens of similarly-difficult leaps to get us to terraforming and interstellar colonization. It's a very exciting, multi-generational project to think about. Though frankly I think we're going to get AGI + brain/computer interfaces + cloud mind uploads before we get martian terraforming; and dropping the bag-of-meat related requirements would make extraterrestrial colonization much easier.
- m4rtink 4y agoI think we will do both - and everything in between! Even just because you can never get all people top agree on something. :) That's also the best option, not betting on a single idea or technology.
- Retric 4y agoDepends on what would kill everyone on earth. More importantly, if everyone on earth dies having a 100,000 people living on Mars isn’t enough they also all die.
- sacrosancty 4y agoIf they're self-sufficient, they could survive. Human population on Earth has bottlenecked to less than 100,000 in the past and we recovered.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoAre we sure that getting to 100,000 self-sufficient humans on Mars will take less time than getting to 100,000 self-sufficient humans on the Moon? The conditions on the Moon are harsher, but our ability to move people and supplies there seems much greater. And what exactly is the extinction event that would threaten both Earth and a self-sufficient Moon colony?
- magicalhippo 4y agoSelf-sufficient seems like quite the bar though. I guess they wouldn't need fancy electronics etc, but I imagine they'd still need non-trivial metallurgy, chemistry and similar in order to survive. That is, they can bring a lot of fancy stuff with them, but to be self-sufficient they'd have to be able to maintain, repair and ideally rebuild what they need indefinitely without resupplies from Earth.
- mcbits 4y agoIf we ever get to the point where thousands of people are moving to Mars, thousands will also be moving to the Moon, and vice versa. I don't see it as being just one or the other because the problems that need to be solved are approximately the same, and the cost of shuttling people and supplies is far from the hardest.
- Retric 4y ago
- _Microft 4y ago> We have places on Earth, which are probably 10x if not 100x or 1000x more habitable than Mars, which we still do not and cannot inhabit long term with more than a handful of people. That’s because there are places on Earth that similarly better than e.g. Antarctica or some desert. The main reason for Mars is that it is not on Earth. Make „not on Earth“ a requirement that cannot be dropped and suddenly Mars makes a lot of sense.
- woodruffw 4y agoI'm not following the reasoning here: we should explore Mars because, unlike the Mars-like places on Earth, we stand no chance of rescuing explorers on another planet? The GP's point, as I understood it, is that we haven't even figured out how to make missions 1/1000th as complex as a Mars mission on our own planet viable.
- spiderice 4y agoThe reason people want to colonize Mars is because it solves the problem of an extinction event on earth wiping out all of humanity (assuming the Mars colony eventually becomes self sustaining). Populating Antarctica doesn't solve that problem. From what I can tell people are talking about two different things here. Group 1 is talking about how we prevent humans from going extinct in the long term by setting up a Mars colony. Group 2 is talking about doing something easier before we jump to something harder (Antarctica -> LEO -> Moon -> Mars). I don't know why these two groups always feel so at odds with each other online, as it seems like both philosophies end up in the same place. Group 3 are the people who think we should save Earth INSTEAD of going to Mars, and I think they miss the point entirely.
- kibwen 4y agoIt's difficult to think of extinction events that satisfy both of the following criteria: 1. An event that affects the Earth without affecting Mars. 2. An event that leaves the Earth more uninhabitable than Mars, even temporarily. A gamma ray burst or rogue star that destroys the Earth would just as easily destroy Mars. Meanwhile, even a colossal meteor strike such as the one that killed the dinosaurs, despite leaving the Earth a shattered ruin for millenia, would still result in a planet that is more habitable than Mars. The bottom line is that Mars is an awful backup for life.
- idlewords 4y agoThis is such a good point. Whenever I read about a technology that's supposed to make Mars livable, I ask myself "why aren't people doing this already on the Balleny Islands?" (a lovely but remote as hell archipelago off of Antarctica). Usually there's no good answer; something about the exoticism of Mars makes people think problems that are hard on Earth get easier to solve there.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIf we discovered something quite valuable on the Balleny Islands, a viable colony would be established to exploit it very quickly. Hard problems on Earth get solved regularly, but they only get solved when there is sufficient payback to justify the costs of finding those solutions.
- kibwen 4y agoIf the goal here is to suggest that Mars contains any natural resources of significant economic value, it doesn't.
- moloch-hai 4y ago"Broadcast videos of basketball games there" is the best proposed export I have seen. But the moon is better for that.
- knodi123 4y agoWhat are you going to find on mars to justify a colony? Best answer I've heard is "a portion of the raw materials you'd need to build a colony", which isn't even a circular justification - it's an incomplete circle!. Without the added justification of "because it's another planet, and that's so cool", I don't think a mars colony makes a lick of sense.
- oceanplexian 4y agoMars has a weaker gravity well, so getting to space is a lot easier than it is from Earth. And while the moon might sound better, unlike the Moon, it has enough gravity where the human body might be able to adapt without crippling bone and muscle loss. This makes Mars pretty ideal as a home base, if you assume that in the future we are planning to mine and process asteroids for rare minerals and metals.
- jackmott 4y agoSustaining 20k people in Antarctica isn’t a problem people can’t solve, it just isn’t at all useful. Sustaining a colony on mars would be useful to mitigate planetary scale natural disasters. The problem is humans as we exist bow are not likely to either spend the resources necessary or take the risks necessary to colonize mars for a long term and uncertain risk mitigation. We can’t even get a large % of humans to stop buying SUVs with vastly excess horsepower to avoid ruining our planet in a relatively short time frame. The societal/political problems seem larger to me than the engineering ones, which are just a matter of effort.
- moloch-hai 4y agoYou are saying because we can't solve problems of magnitude x, we should count on solving hundreds of problems of difficulty 1000x, and also those x.
- colechristensen 4y agoThere’s no great point to having 20k in Antarctica. Becoming a multiplanet species does have a great long term point, but it’s more of a thousand year vision than a five year vision. Many of Mars’ shortcomings can be improved upon but they’re slow and take a lot of scale. Open bodies of water and a breathable atmosphere are entirely possible and more of an challenge of developing the scale than solving a scientific obstacle. If you don’t want to do it, don’t do it, but don’t stand in the way of people who want to try.
- moloch-hai 4y agoPeople who don't want to do it would be expected to pay for it. The people who want to try don't have enough money.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway290 4y agoWhat about preserving what we have left and trying to not expand humanity footprint on the planet? Barren landscape of Mars is unremarkable compared to Earth's ecosystem which we still mostly don't understand but keep ravaging nonetheless
- akiselev 4y ago> Let's figure out how to house and sustain, say, 20K people in Antarctica for 100 years before we even dream about doing the same on Mars. Why? We established a colony there in the 50s and by now the population of Antarctica ranges from 1K to 5K people depending on the season. We could build nuclear reactors and mining facilities and indoor vertical farms and a whole bunch of other industry to make the continent self sufficient and import more people but... why? We really won't learn much more there than we can from the ISS agriculture experiments, McMurdo's existing research, how Saudi Arabia and the other rich states grow and survive in extreme environments, and so on. And you want to delay everything while we twiddle our thumbs for another century? We need to aim higher to create the kind of cross disciplinary projects and environments that lead to real "innovation." We need to go into space - not Mars yet because there really is nothing to do there until we get our non-robotic space-footing closer to home - but we need to move on to a less pedestrian approach that pushes the boundaries. We need near Earth asteroid mining to understand the complexities of resource extraction in space, we need lunar colonies to study the day to day realities/psychology/etc of space colonization, we need orbital manufacturing so we can start adapting the lessons and tools of the industrial revolution to zero-G and convection-less environments, we need to continue nuclear rocketry research to improve our ISP and get real SSTO to solve the recovery problem once and for all, and so on. We're not going to make any progress on those problems in Antarctica and Mars will always be two decades away just like fusion.
- giantg2 4y agoThe obvious answer to "why" is that you can use Antarctica as a low(er) cost, low risk, practice run. Similar to space tech of the 60s, the tech developed this way could have a big impact on many areas of life. And yes, it won't solve everything, nor give us a second planet. Why should anyone do anything, really?
- saberdancer 4y agoHard thing in living on Mars is not the cold, it is the lack of oxygen or easily accessible water. All of these are abundant on Antarctica so it is not really a practice run. I see little point in exploring this on Antarctica which is why I believe no one really is entertaining idea of this type of test run on Antarctica.
- kortilla 4y agoOnly because we don’t care to. What does a colony of 20k in Antarctica achieve? It still has all of the same shared fate issues by being on Earth.
- strken 4y agoHas anyone come out and said "we should deliberately avoid sticking a colony in Antarctica or the Sahara or on the moon, and going to Mars with no trial runs is a great idea"? Hazarding a guess at what other people think, colonising Mars is a decades- to centuries-long guiding star that will necessarily involve putting self-contained colonies in a lot of different places. In fact, Maciej points out that reaching Mars will require a moon base, which for some reason he thinks is a negative. The argument from the article about the relative cost-efficiency of putting people on Mars versus doing pretty much anything else is a good one, but the argument that a Mars base is in itself bad is nothing but a couple of paragraphs of ad hominem attacks about "subsistence-farming incels". I'm not convinced that there's a good reason to abandon our dreams of space colonisation, just because NASA is doing some unrealistic and wasteful things.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> Has anyone come out and said "we should deliberately avoid sticking a colony in Antarctica or the Sahara or on the moon, and going to Mars with no trial runs is a great idea"? Yes, at least with their wallets (and quite possibly worth words too, though I can't be bothered to trawl through interviews to see if anyone asked).
- djur 4y agoAs the article mentions, NASA talks about landing on Mars in the next 2 decades. Elon Musk has suggested even shorter timelines. Who else is working on Mars missions? It's not unreasonable for Maciej to limit his criticism to the foolish Mars missions that people are actually spending money on, not the wise ones we wish existed.
- russdill 4y agoJust to be pedantic, Mars is absolutely covered in oxygen. It's the most abundant element in the atmosphere and second most abundant in the crust. It's part of the reason they planet is red.
- tsimionescu 4y agoTo some extent that is true, but it's important to note that it's a sliver of Oxygen in absolute terms. Thee is more CO2 in Earth's atmosphere (by weight) than all of the gases in the Martian atmosphere combined, if I remember correctly.
- Quindecillion 4y agoBecause learning how to do it in the inhospitable environment of Mars will teach us lots about how to do it better on Earth. > We choose to go to the Moon... We choose to go to the Moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard; because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we are willing to accept, one we are unwilling to postpone, and one we intend to win, and the others, too.
- imiric 4y ago> Because learning how to do it in the inhospitable environment of Mars will teach us lots about how to do it better on Earth. That seems backwards. I would switch Mars and Earth in this sentence. Doesn't it make more sense to take the easier steps first, which will prepare us for eventually taking bigger steps? I'm not against Mars exploration. There's no reason we couldn't do both: keep sending probes to Mars, maybe even humans in a decade or two, but make a Lunar base the priority. Then apply the lessons we learn on the Moon to establishing a colony on Mars. And literally use the Moon as a springboard for Mars missions. I think this is pretty much universally agreed to be the sequence of events. A lot of discussion about this seems to imply we'll just proceed with some Mars colonization mission before we understand the challenges it poses, and before we're certain we can tackle them. BTW, that JFK quote seems out of place in this context, considering it was made at the height of the space race. The speech was politically motivated, and was meant to inspire a nation to not "lose" the race, while instilling fear in the enemy.
- clnq 4y agoWe will inevitably learn more about adapting our environment to our needs, as well as what our needs are when we are challenged by life on Mars, similarly to when we were challenged by life in LEO, on the ISS. I do not know a space equivalent, but in medicine, treating severe diseases teaches us a lot more about treating their mild cases than the mild cases alone could. As for space races and political motivations, if you look at China's advancements in space recently, both in terms of launches per year and the pace of their construction capability in LEO, it is clear that we are in a race. On both counts (launch count and construction in LEO, demonstrated by Tiangong SS missions), the US is losing it. There indeed does not seem to be political motivation to do much about it.
- bboygravity 4y agoHow does establishing a colony on Antartica help the survival of humans upon reset-level astroid impact/super vulcano/other?
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe technology for that colony would also be applicable to underground vaults, or we could first build those. Either way, events such as these that would have wiped out humanity as it exists today have not yet happened in the ~1.6 billion years of eukaryotes existing on Earth, so there are good reasons not to worry too too much about it. Note that the asteroid that "wiped out the dinosaurs" would still have left humanity as it exists today in a much better shape than a Mars colony is likely to ever be in. Also, note that much smaller meteors/asteroids pose a huge risk to a Martian colony than they do to Earth, as they burn less in the almost non-existent Martian atmosphere, and since a Martian colony will be much less geographically spread out than the Earth. An asteroid wiping put all of the people in North America would still not destroy life on Earth, while a similar impact would easily destroy any human life on Mars for any kind of foreseeable future, if it happens to hit the colony itself.
- m4rtink 4y agoOn the other hand, due to basically no hydrosphere and very thin atmosphere, there would be much less shock waves, no trees to burn, no post-impact winter and a lot of the ejecta might end up in space due lo lower gravity. instead of falling back to bombard the planet. So certainly a bad news for the one spot, but another outpost a couple hundred km distant could be fine.
- nine_k 4y agoThe point of building a colony in Mars is, to my mind, first and foremost in that it would not be under direct control of any Earth 's government. At least, eventually. I think this will drive the proper colonization of Mars. Science, of course, but it won't require a large self-sustained colony, much like Antarctica, or oil / gas fields of Siberia, or oil rigs in the ocean.
- tsimionescu 4y agoWhy do you think so, even in some far future? It's far more likely that Earth governments, having spent hundreds of years propping up such space colonies, would expect to rule them in perpetuity, and have easy means to do so (such as threatening to send nuclear bombardment or even troops - both far easier than actually establishing the colony in the first place). Especially since it seems very likely that colonists would not be allowed in any way to have access to weapons while they are still under Earth governments' control. Not to mention, the Martian colony would forever be far far more frail to attack than any Earth society, since it has to spend so much of its nature wm resources just to keeping humans alive.
- moloch-hai 4y agoAll they would need to do is threaten to stop sending any of a thousand essential commodities that make life tolerable (never mind what makes it possible), and any resistance collapses instantly. Mars colonists would be more directly under the thumb of Earth government than anybody outside of prison, an antarctic base, or navy ship.
- tsimionescu 4y agoI imagine the GP included "in the long run" to refer to a hypothetical future where the colony were truly self-sufficient (so able to produce any good that they want or need).
- nine_k 4y agoNot any good they want, maybe, but any good needed for their indefinitely long survival.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoLunar dust caused Apollo astronauts problems that they thought weren't chemical. They were wrong. [https://www.livescience.com/62590-moon-dust-bad-lungs-brain.html https://www.livescience.com/62590-moon-dust-bad-lungs-brain....] But that Martian dust that gets all over the solar panels is also loaded with toxic perchlorates. Every time they wear a suit out, they have to absolutely insure that none of it gets into the living space. Good luck. "Anybody who is saying they want to go live on the surface of Mars better think about the interaction of perchlorate with the human body. At one-half percent, that's a huge amount. Very small amounts are considered toxic ...." [https://www.space.com/21554-mars-toxic-perchlorate-chemicals.html https://www.space.com/21554-mars-toxic-perchlorate-chemicals...]
- bena 4y agoRight there. That's the issue we're facing with any extraplanetary excursion. It's not the stuff we know. It's not even the stuff we're aware we don't know. It's the infamous "unknown unknowns". Stuff we're not even aware we should be aware of. Stuff that will fuck us up in new and interesting ways. If we ever do make it to colonizing any other planet, the road will be paved with the bones of the dead we sacrificed to find out what we shouldn't have fucked around with.
- somenameforme 4y agoIt also goes the other way. Antibiotics, which have likely saved more lives than any discovery - ever, were developed less than 100 years ago, by accident. A guy accidentally left his bacterial cultures exposed on a holiday. He came back and noticed one had grown a type of fungus that was repulsing the bacteria. That fungus was penicillium. In another fun example, the idea of using microwaves to heat things up was also discovered completely accidentally. A [self taught] engineer working on an active-radar system noticed the system he was working on was melting a Hershey's Mr. Goodbar in his pocket. He then used it on a few other foods to confirm, and the microwave oven was born. I think one of the biggest benefits of colonizing Mars will be things we can't even imagine. We'll find all sorts of great new ways to kill and maim ourselves, but we'll also discover plenty of new amazing tools we can use to do awesome things with. Over time the former will be mitigated and the latter exploited. Colonizing, as always, will be a game for those who are willing to accept a few decades being lopped off their average life expectancy in exchange for making way for a greater life for those to come.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 4y agohow about let's figure out who to house and sustain 20K homeless people in established cities.
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y agoWe have 8.x billion people on Terra, an environment with circa 4.x billion years of evolution for eukaryotes to thrive, and still we have about 1.x billion people undernourished with around 20,000 people dying of hunger each day [1], not to mention the other eukaryotes. Our species has proven again and again it's inability to care for the extended tree of life, heck, we still believe there are sharp and crisp delimitations inside our own species (the blacks, the Jews, etc.). Why then this gaslighting about "we must save civilization"? Just because some of the billionaires, those who our system lets to own the world, are afraid of dying? Hey, rich guy [2], got news for you: we don't have a civilization, we are barely a bunch of pseudo-evolved tribes, infighting for trivial resources and perceived boundaries. Let's figure out how to have a civilization, then, maybe, we can try to save it. However, as it stands, "we must save civilization" is doublespeak for "you, hoi polloi, go and build an Elysium for me and my friends", just as the Qataris said to the slaves to build them stadiums [3]. And if you own less than $30 million [4], don't kid yourself, you are still hoi polloi. [1] https://reliefweb.int/report/world/humanitarian-organisations-estimate-one-person-dying-hunger-every-four-seconds https://reliefweb.int/report/world/humanitarian-organisation... [2] There are no rich gals https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/012715/5-richest-people-world.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/012715/5-ric... [3] https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2016/03/qatar-world-cup-of-shame/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/campaigns/2016/03/qatar-wo... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra_high-net-worth_individual https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra_high-net-worth_individua...
- mlindner 4y ago> However, as it stands, "we must save civilization" is doublespeak for "you, hoi polloi, go and build an Elysium for me and my friends", just as the Qataris said to the slaves to build them stadiums [3]. And if you own less than $30 million [4], don't kid yourself, you are still hoi polloi. This is farcical on the face of it. There is no situation where the "hoi polloi" are going to be building colonies. This is a creation of science fiction with no basis on reality. You need fundamentally significant amounts of money to leave the planet. We're talking hundreds of thousands per person. Some rich person is not going to ship off people who are unwilling or don't want to go..
- sneak 4y agoWe haven't done so because it does not benefit us. Establishing a self-sufficient city on Mars does benefit us, even if it is more difficult.
- moloch-hai 4y agoWho, exactly, is this "us" who benefits? In particular, does it include any of the people asked to pay for it?
- sneak 4y agoAs far as I can tell, the majority of the cost of the development of the technology to take millions of tons to Mars is being funded by a private company. That company's revenues, insofar as they result from what were once public funds, are primarily a result of projects related solely to the Earth (and perhaps one planned mission to the moon). NASA is not paying for SpaceX to go to Mars. NASA is paying SpaceX to take stuff to Earth orbit.
- moloch-hai 4y agoWho will actually pay to ship "millions of tons to Mars"? SpaceX certainly will not. Almost all of SpaceX's income, absent Starlink subscription fees, traces to tax dollars.
- m4rtink 4y agoUhm, they do a lot of purely commercial space launches (comsats, LEO missions, commercial dragon flights) even including for some of their direct competitors to Starlink (OneWeb)!
- mlindner 4y ago> SpaceX certainly will not. That's always been a stated goal of SpaceX to do exactly that. That's why they funded on their own dime the development of a massive reusable vehicle that has literally no reason to be that large unless your explicit plan is to design it for interplanetary cargo. > Almost all of SpaceX's income, absent Starlink subscription fees, traces to tax dollars. Not true. As stated explicitly by SpaceX in several years ago, the revenue split of SpaceX was 1/3 NASA, 1/3 other government and 1/3 commercial. But in recent years the commercial fraction has dramatically increased (simply as evidenced by the tremendous numbers of missions happening from non-government customers).
- holoduke 4y agoOur destiny is total domination in the universe. Mars is most certainly part of those first steps.
- dotnet00 4y agoThis comes off as extremely disingenuous. We aren't unable to inhabit Antarctica for the long term, we just aren't interested in doing so. We don't have much left to learn about living in space from living in Antarctica that we haven't already learned from the people who live in the various other parts of the world which do have permanent settlements and experience extreme cold for large parts of the year. Thus there is no real point to doing much else there in terms of human spaceflight. Just like how America hasn't outright been unable to develop the means to go to the Moon again for the past 60 years, it just has had other priorities. In fact, following your logic, Artemis also should be cancelled until we've spent the arbitrary duration of 100 years sitting around in Antarctica just to prove that we can do it. An additional point being missed is that when we started talking about going to the Moon the first time around, we didn't really know how to do it, we sent out several impactors just to learn enough about the surface to decide where to go. By setting that goal we gathered data for the purpose and eventually managed to do it. Similarly, there will never be a time where we are 'ready' to go to Mars or any other distant celestial body if we just keep waiting for arbitrary requirements to be met. Right now it's living in Antarctica for 100 years, then it'll be something more ridiculous and arbitrary like maintaining an artificial atmosphere for 1000 years. Right now we're in a similar phase for Mars as we were for the Moon in the early days of Apollo. We've been studying the surface for decades now, have got rovers storing away reference samples and testing oxygen production, we've even been testing how much mileage we can get with less conservative choices in hardware (eg Ingenuity's processor being much more modern than Perseverance's and Perseverance's landing footage being mostly off-the-shelf industrial cameras made possible by the more modern coprocessors being used to compress the video onboard before transmission). A stated goal of Artemis is to use the Moon as a step to Mars, which it's turning out to be given that the only vehicle remotely capable of making the trip survivable is on the critical path of establishing a long-term presence on the Lunar surface. Everything that has to be developed for missions to Mars will end up tracing back to something tested or learned from Artemis, just as many aspects of Artemis are based on things tested on, developed for or learned from the ISS.
- moloch-hai 4y agoThis 1960:moon :: 2022:Mars idea is a convenient assumption, but gets less plausible the closer you look. Mars is just way, way harder, and we have not improved our capability by anything like the difference.
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago>Let's figure out how to house and sustain, say, 20K people in Antarctica for 100 years before we even dream about doing the same on Mars. you argue that it isn't economically viable to do this, and this is the reason it hasn't been done. Currently the people in Antarctica are there on research projects, increasing it to 20K people would imply what? Something other than research? What do you think will be required to make Antarctica housing of 20K people for 100 years economically viable. Finally, what do you think will be the effect on climate change of at minimum quadrupling the people in Antarctica and providing them some sort of economically viable reason for being there? What do you think the effect of putting an output on Mars will be on Climate Change? I'm thinking negligible in comparison. Aside from all the other arguments that we CAN put people in Antarctica the complexity and side effects for our environment are more dangerous than putting them on Mars.
- uuvs8 4y ago> What do you think the effect of putting an output on Mars will be on Climate Change? I'm thinking negligible in comparison. If you are seriously saying that getting 20k people to Mars is impacting Earths climate less than getting them to Mars then you need a reality check. Hint: You can't not just not walk there, but anything apart from sunlight to support life isn't there which even Antarctica has in abundance (oxygen and water).
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago>If you are seriously saying that getting 20k people to Mars is impacting Earths climate less than getting them to Mars then you need a reality check. no I'm saying their excess heat generated in a polar region will be more detrimental than the excess heat generated on Mars will be. Among other things. Basically that the day to day living in the area being damaged is going to be more damaging than the one off transportation. That said I haven't done the calculation, but since I was the first one to even bring it up I doubt anyone has done it either.
- littlestymaar 4y ago
- uuvs8 4y agoOr even figuring out simpler things like how to avoid destroying rain forest to grow palm oil. You know where palm trees don't grow? On mars.
- balaji1 4y agoLet’s figure out a solution to plastic. Oceans and rivers clean up. Sustainable agri. These are not cool tho. I’m a fan of Mars and beyond also eventually. Expanse TV series does great at near future sci-fi and solar system scale humanity.
- Buffout 4y agoI can relate to this argument in principle. Building base here : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pole_of_Inaccessibility_research_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pole_of_Inaccessibility_resear... for example would be a great exercise for building base on Mars. We could learn great things, and maybe reuse technology for going on Mars.
- m4rtink 4y agoThe Russian Vostok base base or the european Concordia base are already in quite similar environment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vostok_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vostok_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concordia_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concordia_Station And IIRC Concordia already tested some water recycling technology from ESA for example.
- ianai 4y agoWhat about the very remote villages in the colder/harsher parts of the world? Ie the disputed islands north of Japan, the easternmost parts of Russia, the vast northern parts of Canada, etc? Figuring a way to make those worthy/capable of growth to cities seems still lower lying fruit than Antarctica. Basically, an Earth that’s capable of colonizing the moon or mars is probably already capable of further settling those conditions on Earth. That stage of humanity probably needs to have a stronger sense of community than current, too.
- 4bpp 4y agoThe problem with running a colony of 20k in Antarctica is a human/political one, not a technological one. We have been running one of over 2k on Spitsbergen, which is not terribly different in terms of climate and accessibility, for a long time. Assuming you even get your hypothetical Antarctic colony past whatever international treaties that apply, good luck resisting the inevitable backlash from environmentalists who will find the potential disturbance to a dozen penguins in a 100-kilometer radius of your proposed site an unacceptable risk. One of the advantages of a Mars colony is that the argument for it infringing upon any existing interests is much weaker than for anywhere on Earth. Of course, to some people, the idea that someone could just go somewhere and do a thing without anyone (who those people of course claim to speak on behalf of) being in a position to claim injury is disturbing in itself.
- XorNot 4y agoThis is what strikes me as notable: there are no Frontiers anymore (arguably there never were without massacring the existing inhabitants). Space actually is one. And there are no (sentient) existing inhabitants. IMO our current civilization has no way to account for, nor price, that reality - yet.
- bena 4y agoThe oceans are our frontiers. We know more about deep space than we do about deep water.
- TchoBeer 4y agoAdditionally, an underwater civilization would make Humanity more resilient to some kinds of extinction events, if you care about that.
- ETH_start 4y agoAn underwater civilization would be much less resilient to a nuclear attack originating from Earth, than an extra-terrestial civilization would be. Submarines and nuclear tipped torpedoes can strike any point on the sea floor with almost no warning.
- wheelerof4te 4y agoI don't think the first people who visit Mars need to be there more than few hours. Just repeat what was already done on Moon. We need to do some basic expreriments, take the soil samples and drill few meters down in order to check for water ice deposits. But before all that, we need to send more rovers.
- m4rtink 4y agoBased on their Earth->MArs trajectory, they might have to stay for possibly a terrestrial year or more, waiting for the next launch window to Earth. Provided you want to get the crew back to Earth of course, if not then "don't need to be there more than few hours" takes a whole another meaning & makes mass optimization of the mission much easier! ;-)
- api 4y agoIt’s illegal to settle Antarctica. If that were not the case someone would try. There are really no frontiers left on Earth that are not locked up by existing states. That point is missed by the whole “space makes no sense because nobody lives in Antarctica” argument. That and settling another planet is much more interesting than trying to settle a less friendly area of Earth where people already can live.
- ajmurmann 4y ago"Can we do it" is only part of the question, the other is "what's to gain compared to other options?". I'm not sure I know the answer for Mars, but am pretty sure properly colonizing Antarctica compared to more densly settling Siberia or Alaska has no advantages. Settling Mars might though. Besides research, there might be good mining or advantages from let gravity. These might be better though on the moon or astroids.
- LinuxBender 4y agoWe have places on Earth, which are probably 10x if not 100x or 1000x more habitable than Mars, which we still do not and cannot inhabit long term with more than a handful of people. Exactly this. It has been tried many times and every time the project ultimately fails. There have been many greenhouse / biodome projects that tried to simulate living on mars or the moon and they always go sideways. These projects also assume everyone involved has passed a physical and mental health screening. Society as a whole does not align with such tests. One bad neighbor will cause an atmospheric loss and take everyone out. If we are going to spend a lot of money in space ventures I would rather see that effort put into something that could save life on Earth from real risks such as getting really good at mining asteroids and controlling the trajectory of asteroids and even that should be 99%+ robots. Humans should be hanging out in near-by spacecraft to have a low latency control and monitoring of the robots and have smaller rescue ships that could be used to extract people from the control spacecraft when things ultimately go wrong. Rescue and maintenance drones should also be robots. Mars should be a distant stretch goal when our technology advances to the point where we can transform the land and the atmosphere in one or two human lifetimes. We are obviously not there yet as we can not even clean up our own atmosphere here on Earth.
- bratbag 4y agoYou have this back to front. The concentration of resources involved in getting people to and on Mars, will as a side effect also open up these areas on Earth for habitation. The same effect occured with the space race. Instead of standing around saying it's impossible, our species rose to the challenge and as a side effect the technologies developed ended up altering our lives on earth in fundamental ways. We are doing it because it is hard. Because we know the payoff for achieving difficult things.
- philwelch 4y agoThe primary reason Antarctica is uninhabited is because it’s effectively against international law. Unfortunately there are similar laws affecting outer space.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoBut there are no taxes on Mars! https://taxfoundation.org/tax-court-antarctica-not-foreign-country-tax-purposes https://taxfoundation.org/tax-court-antarctica-not-foreign-c...
- nrclark 4y agoAgreed 100%. The worst places on Earth are still better than the best places on Mars because you have free gravity and oxygen here. Even for a self-sustaining colony, it would be nice for a dome-crack to not be immediately fatal. Once we have thriving biodomes in the Outback, then talk to me about trying to do it on Mars.
- justsomeuser 4y agoI think Elon is betting on AGI, and is merely bootstrapping the initial delivery systems.
- twelve40 4y agohe's betting on adjusted gross income?
- justsomeuser 4y agoNo no no. He is betting on Association For Geographic Information
- jerryzh 4y agoIt is because no one would invest same as much money to do a pointless habitat challenge. Given same funding as used in Mars plan, of course we can manage to habitat in Antarctica.