21 ms·
Coworkers are less ambitious; bosses adjust to the new order
- nine_zeros 4y ago> At law firm Nixon Peabody LLP, associates have started saying no to working weekends, prompting partners to ask more people to help complete time-sensitive work. Working weekends was never sustainable. I don't understand why companies think that they can deliver for their customers by forcing their employees to work weekends. That said, America has a huge problem. The way American laws are written, it causes a lot of red-tape. The only reason anything gets done is because there are time bounds on the red-tape. But getting through more and more red-tape with fewer and fewer people, in a time limit, is extremely hard. This shows up in pressures on workers to finish what appears to be solved problems, such as payroll, compliance and, taxes. The result of American red-tape is: > The company, based in Columbus, Ohio, recently moved about 20 remote engineering and marketing roles to Canada and India, where she said it’s easier to find talent who will go above and beyond. America needs to reduce red-tape before the labor force declines in this decade.
- unity1001 4y ago> The company, based in Columbus, Ohio, recently moved about 20 remote engineering and marketing roles to Canada and India > America needs to reduce red-tape before the labor force declines in this decade. That's more due to the deregulated free market sucking people dry in the US over basic needs, forcing them to live with outrageous rents, childcare, healthcare, living costs. The corporations that profit from basic necessities are literally, actually, physically damaging the interests of every other corporation and sector in the economy. And when the cost of living is so artificially exaggerated, outsourcing job to a remote location where deregulated corporations cannot suck people dry over their basic needs becomes cheaper for every corporation. Housing, healthcare, childcare, transportation, communication, education, military, justice, police, food, heating et al are social infrastructure. They must be prevented from profiteering. Otherwise the profiteers destroy the society while maximizing their profits over those.
- repsilat 4y ago> deregulated free market sucking people dry in the US over basic needs, forcing them to live with outrageous rents, childcare, healthcare, living costs. Hilarious. Those are all expensive because of government constraints -- the profit-seeking free market is unable to drive prices down because regulations have raised barriers to entry and dramatically reduced competition and innovation. Meanwhile more lightly-regulated sectors show clear negative inflation. But even before getting to the mechanism, I don't think the actual reality totally matches what you've deacribed. Rents in the US are generally not "outrageous" (obvious exceptions excepted), and living costs are low -- fuel is cheap, electricity is cheap, food is cheap. Far from "sucking people dry" the corporations in those industries are providing for people much better than any government agency. See this famous chart for the receipts -- which things government interferes with, and which are becoming more expensive: https://inflationdata.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Inflation-1996-2016-by-category.png https://inflationdata.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2019/1...
- unity1001 4y ago> Those are all expensive because of government constraints There are even more government constraints in Europe, China, Japan. The real estate sector, healthcare, education etc are not out of hand in those places like they are in the US. > the profit-seeking free market is unable to drive prices down The profit-seeking free market is unable to drive prices down because driving prices down is anathema to profit-seeking. > See this famous chart for the receipts -- which things government interferes with A blog post from Randians in contrast to actually existing reality does not an argument make. Let me reiterate: There are more government constraints everywhere else around the world. Nowhere else those critical sectors are out of hand.
- jcampbell1 4y agoI ended up in a hospital in Urumqi China. It was the most capitalist thing I have ever experienced. You put money on a card and pay for services individually… the nurses all had a card reader. $35 for a CT, $6 IV penicillin, (repeat 6 times), $20 see an ENT, $5 for Augmentin. Government matches the amount paid, and poor people get a card that is very discounted. Family members typically moved the patient since orderlies were an additional charge.
- scarface74 4y agoYou act like indecipherable laws are uniquely American. Have you seen the 99 section 11 chapter GDPR?
- nine_zeros 4y agoI never claimed the EU is better. IMHO, EU is worse than America due to the monetary federal structure and heavy-handed government. And it shows in their economic decline. That said, America is heading to a shitty future much like EU, unless America gets its act together.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s easy for America to get its act together because everyone wants to come here still. Once that changes, doomed.
- nine_zeros 4y agoPeople may have wanted to come to America in the past. Today they are choosing various alternatives because America is shooting itself in the foot with insane red tape in legal immigration. And good people don't want to come illegally. It's so backwards. It is easier to enter illegally than legally.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAmerica is overwhelmed with illegal immigration so there are zero resources left to help with legal immigration.
- nine_zeros 4y agoIf America makes the legal immigration system not-so-kafkaesque, people will try to apply for the legal way instead of the illegal way. Right now, the legal system is not humanly accessible.
- mbg721 4y agoThe WSJ, being the WSJ, phrases this as though long weekend nights chained to a desk should be the expectation, but in a wider sense, we're living through a good old fashioned race-to-the-bottom. The US has an unhealthy society where nobody believes in what they're doing, and we're not very far from the "We pretend to work, and they pretend to pay us" disease that we scoffed at in the Soviet Union.
- piyh 4y agoUnlike the USSR, the US doesn't have state owned enterprises making up the majority of it's GDP. The companies that give a shit win markets.
- rmk 4y agoI think the more relevant part is that people have realized that harder work does not necessarily pay better or lead to advancement. Companies can win markets while not paying their employees top dollar, and this fact is now clear to most if not all.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf your company's costs are significantly larger than your competitors, you aren't going to win markets. You're going bankrupt. > harder work does not necessarily pay better or lead to advancement Smarter work does, though.
- DangitBobby 4y agoNo, smarter work doesn't either. Increased productivity does not necessarily lead to better pay or advancement.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Increased productivity does not necessarily lead to better pay or advancement In a free market, supply&demand set employee compensation at about 85% of the value the employee produces. The reason is simple. If the company overpays, the company goes bust. If the company underpays, his competitor will hire the person away. If you believe you're underpaid, make your case to your employer. If he agrees, good for you. If he doesn't, and you're not convinced, quit and work for his competitor.
- scarface74 4y agoI was able to read the entire article via my Apple News+ subscription After spending most of my career as your standard enterprise dev, I fell into a remote mid level role in the cloud consulting department of BigTech. After a year and a half of finding my bearings, the next logical step was for me to work toward a promotion where I would have more “scope” and “impact”. I soon realized that I didn’t want the headache. My wife and I had more than “enough”. On top of that, my wife and I decided to become “digital nomads” this past year. We bought a professionally managed “condotel” in Florida so we would have some place to nest during the winter and fly across the US the rest of the year and stay in hotels. We got rid of our house, cars and everything we own that couldn’t fit into three suitcases. It’s been the most freeing experience in the world to get out of the rat race while watching my coworkers chase after promotions.
- dayvid 4y agoI’d also say people are more cutthroat and there’s more politics as you go through promotions as well.
- zdragnar 4y agoThis is largely the reason I favor small companies and startups. The team is small enough that you can leave your ego at the door, instead of having a career based on metrics that are only loosely correlated with anything resembling a positive change.
- rmk 4y agoThe most vicious, sharp-elbowed, cutthroat colleagues I have seen have been at small and growing companies, particularly those in which growth slows. They often have much poorer management (very high proportion of first-time managers vs. larger companies) and are much more cliquey (lots of hiring in small pools of people who know each other).
- zdragnar 4y agoThose same people exist in larger companies. The difference is they either fail up, or there are more people for them to spread their shit on. The outsized impact of a bad employee is definitely a potential of a small team / company. Maybe I've just been lucky, but for the most part the closeness of a small team also invites more visibility and accountability from owners. Bad managers and employees, in my experience, tend to have shorter careers in small companies. On the other hand, I've seen "staff" engineers at large companies who clearly have "leaves feedback on PRs" as a performance metric, because they would add trite, useless requests for changes that would conflict with feedback they left on other PRs, and would be exceptionally petty when confronted. These same people would be lauded because they lived up to artificial expectations, despite probably having a negative impact on the teams ability to deliver if anyone really looked at what they were doing. On a small team, you can't get away with that for very long before it becomes apparent that something isn't working.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/58TgA https://archive.ph/58TgA
- ramraj07 4y agoCry me a river. I personally love to work more than 40 hours a week (simply because if I’m immersed in a topic I just like thinking about it more) but will never for a moment judge or question a colleague for “quiet quitting” so to speak. You do you buddy, you owe nothing to this company or any work ethic.
- downboots 4y ago"My mother, drunk or sober" "Who am I to judge?"
- x0054 4y agoI am the same way, when I am compensated accordingly. And when I am not, my mind drifts to other things. It’s like manic :)
- myself248 4y agoYeah, that term is such crap. I've heard "rational disengagement" and find it much more descriptive.
- idontwantthis 4y agoI like to call it “doing the job I’m paid to do”.
- swader999 4y agoI like that term. Caring too much is just as bad. You become a pita to work with and you can't relax and remain objective about things.
- nmeofthestate 4y agoThere's an established term for it: "work to rule". It involves following the rules set down in your contract. It's a form of industrial action below eg striking.
- nprateem 4y agoThat's when you actively draw attention to the fact you're not doing anything more than in your contract.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoBecause when merit is punished with more work, nobody wants to work more. You deserve what you incentivize.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoThis article was a really interesting read, because I've been thinking lately that companies tend to succeed off the back of people caring a lot and putting in extra hours but I haven't seen this verbalized before. I think the young guy they interviewed whose dad makes barely more than he will summed it up perfectly. You realize that if you put in all that extra work you get paid fuck all extra. It doesn't make any sense to work so hard for so little reward in most fields. I feel like tech, finance and maybe law are the only corporate careers where it makes sense to work really hard because there are outsized rewards for high competence, but even then it doesn't always make sense. Millenials kind of realized this Zoomers have fully realized this. Probably related to most fields stagnating heavily career-wise and having relatively poor pay. It's interesting to see a lot of Millenials and Zoomers cottoning onto the fact that tech pays well. It's surprisingly common on social media and IRL to see something along the lines of "someone is making a lot of money = most likely works in tech", and vice versa.
- jiveturkey 4y ago> I think the young guy they interviewed whose dad makes barely more than he will summed it up perfectly. actually i found that to be the most flawed part. they didn’t describe the industry the dad was in, nor the dad’s wage when he had the son’s YOE. it’s fair to report the feelings of the son to the revelation, but intellectually dishonest to leave out some basic objective analysis around it. that said, flaws or not, yes it seems that is the crux of it. people are done with working to improve the lot of the masters. something i think would help is to reduce CEO to median worker compensation multiple.
- coliveira 4y agoMillennials are the first generation to see the full impact of the brainless and soulless policies enacted by the US government in 40 years. They understand that what the government says are complete lies that are making people poor and destroying their livelihood.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhen I was young, people dismissed engineers as "nerds". Then those nerds starting making lots of money, and attitudes changed.
- darth_avocado 4y agoI don’t know about all of the industry but tech is definitely not in the same boat. The looming threat of recession and layoffs has handed companies back the leverage that workers had in the last couple of years. Less pay and more work is becoming the norm, unlike say two years ago where everywhere you go, companies were trying to entice you with a ridiculous pay or a great amount of flexibility.
- gambiting 4y agoWhat tech? Where? Like a couple big companies in US? It's definitely not true everywhere. I work for a global corporation in their UK office and we're struggling to find talent to a point where our offers and benefits keep going up and up and up to attract and retain the talent that we have.
- Wolfenstein98k 4y agoAs someone in the article explains, she was happy working hard (and getting pay rises) until she spent time on TikTok, which quickly convicted her to work less hours and demand higher pay. TikTok, a Chinese app, is not allowed to show you such content in China and must instead show pro-work, pro-family messaging. Coincidence?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoSo what you're saying is TikTok is a psychological operation designed to weaken the economy of western nations? Honestly I wouldn't even be surprised if that was the case. Doesn't invalidate the "less for more" philosophy though. This is what everybody should strive for. The chinese will too, in time.
- Spivak 4y agoYou’re taking the side of state sponsored brainwashing over organic content created by TikTok users about workers‘ rights? People change their behavior when presented with new information, this isn’t a grand conspiracy.
- propogandist 4y ago>over organic content created by TikTok users about workers‘ rights? the algorithm can be easily influenced to push propaganda and sway opinions. From the Twitter Files (and even prior) we know the old Twitter regime, for example, existed to push woke leftists agendas, including working with the whitehouse and various govt agencies to push propaganda.
- alphabettsy 4y ago> From the Twitter Files (and even prior) we know the old Twitter regime, for example, existed to push woke leftists agendas, including working with the whitehouse and various govt agencies to push propaganda. They didn’t reveal anything like what you describe. And the admin in the White House when the supposed collusion happened was the Trump admin.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe rewards of capitalism are now being irrationally and disproportionately showered on a select few individuals. Why bother putting in extra work when all that effort won’t afford you a house? And at the same time, you know that someone is going to make millions in weeks because they bought some memestock or crypto or sold their pics on Onlyfans or convinced Softbank that they were the next Alibaba. American capitalism has become too irrational for real work.
- swader999 4y agoIt doesn't even feel right calling it capitalism.
- etchalon 4y agoI've noticed an absolutely fantastic increase in the number of my employees who just refuse to work beyond 40 hours without compensation. Many refuse to do it even with compensation. It used to be I had like 1 dev who was that way. He come in at 10. He left at 6. Period. Any "overtime" was an immediate PTO accrual, without exemption. He'd work a Saturday, but he was taking off Monday. The rest of the team worked whatever was required of them. It created a lot perverse incentives for me, my co-owner, and our clients. If we kept hitting impossible deadlines, why wouldn't our clients keep asking it of us? Why wouldn't we keep saying yes to them? It made fiscal sense to do so. Clients were happy. We made more money. Staff largely didn't complain. Now, the "workaholics" are a lot more rare, and we're a lot more careful about it. If someone works over 40 hours, we compensate for that, salaried or not. It's called overtime, and we actually take a lower-margin on the hourly rate. If we're making our team work more than 40 hours, we fucked up. We deserve to make less money. We also charge a "rush rate" to clients, because while we're happy to help them out, the team deserves to be compensated. We've only had one client push back on it, and we fired them. The staff is a lot happier, our clients have adjusted to the new expectations, and our staff churn has lowered.
- zmgsabst 4y agoCompanies have treated me as fungible and no better than the terms of my contract — which says par 40 hours per week. Why do employers expect to treat me in that clinical way, but not have me mirror that behavior doing things exactly by terms to my maximal benefit? You get the dance you lead, boss.
- karaterobot 4y ago> Many workers say they see little connection between working hard and being rewarded. This has been my experience, and my personal theory to explain this change in productivity is that it's taking younger people in the workforce less time to figure it out than it took people my age. There normally comes a time around middle-age, when you say "I've been working like a dog for 15 years now, and what has it gotten me, and what good has it done in the world, and how much worse would it be if I coasted from here on out?" Now that's happening a few years sooner. The pandemic probably accelerated this introspection. > An ADP Research Institute survey conducted in November 2021 found that U.S. workers said they were doing 8.4 hours of unpaid overtime work each week, down from nine hours the prior year. Lazy so-and-sos. Makes me sick to my stomach.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoDefinitely happening much faster than middle age. My friends and I have realized this and we're <25. One of my friends busted his ass the first year he started working, got an average performance review. 2nd year he chilled out a lot and got a better performance review. Performance reviews at most companies are useless and it doesn't take long to figure it out. Another friend told me that it's not possible to get the top performance rating in his company. They just don't give that rating out. My take is that a lot of Gen Z are entering the workforce and thinking "you expect me to do all this work for an ok salary I will never be able to afford a house on? that's a bad deal".
- boredemployee 4y agoTo me, the funny part of all this is that I'd never work in a place that write me a performance review to begin with.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoWhat companies don't do performance reviews?
- 4y ago
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> days of unpaid overtime and working through weekends > Where have all the go-getters gone? Oh please. Pay more.
- habibur 4y agoAlso note that more than 40 hours a week workers don't do it year round. Only during the peak of a project and then they fall back to almost no work for rest of the year. The average still remains sub 40 or sub 30.
- foepys 4y agoThe average of what? Only full time (30h+/week, ~40h/week) or all workforce including part time (<30h/week)?
- gnicholas 4y agoIf younger workers are deciding that most fields don’t offer high-flying compensation, will they also decide to spend less money on higher education? No point going tens or hundreds of thousands in debt if you don’t have a plan to pay it back.
- 10hr 4y agoYoung men have already picked up on this trend. This is why college attendance is now 60-40 female-male
- gnicholas 4y agoIt’s not because girls have higher grades and test scores (which they do)?
- DangitBobby 4y agoYeah, I don't think men are suddenly having a hard time getting into state colleges.
- throwaway6734 4y agoHigher test scores? On which tests?
- gnicholas 4y agoMy mistake here — they do have higher scores on verbal, but on math they lag boys. However, girls with high math scores tend to have higher verbal scores than boys, which makes them more well-rounded and attractive to colleges.
- throwaway6734 4y ago>Should it be expected or disheartening that proportionally 45% more males are in the 1400-1600 score range than females? https://www.compassprep.com/new-sat-has-disadvantaged-female-testers/ https://www.compassprep.com/new-sat-has-disadvantaged-female... I don't think that's true either
- 082349872349872 4y agoIn the days when I was overworking, I had an office with a door and windows, rare (sub-weekly) meetings, and in-the-money options. Why should anyone in an open plan, with substantial coordination/micromanagement overhead, but without significant equity do the same?
- the_only_law 4y agoShit, half the time it feels like the bureaucrats don’t want me to work at all, let alone overwork.
- nowherebeen 4y agoToo many people have been burnt by this before. All the reward goes to the boss and not the employees. I used to work 70+ hours and I didn't even get a thank you. I will only work those hours nowadays if I am working for myself. If not, there is no chance I will do it. It's not nice to know you are being used for someone else's personal gain.
- WalterBright 4y agoStart your own business and you'll find out how much you're really worth!
- tester457 4y agoAnd yet it's still not a good measure. Most businesses succeed on luck and connections. A person's worth is contingent on neither.
- WalterBright 4y agoSuccessful businessmen make their own luck.
- incone123 4y agoI read this as a euphemism for corruption.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you've convinced yourself you cannot succeed, you won't.
- tuyiown 4y agoYour fairy tales ignores all the people that tried correctly to build the their luck and yet ended in a worse situation by pursuing success based on incorrect world view. This is irresponsible.
- jxf 4y agoPeople are less ambitious because they, generally speaking, aren't getting compensated for being more ambitious. Not only that, they aren't even getting compensated for being more productive [0]. [0]: https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/23410.jpeg https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/23410.jpeg
- oxfordmale 4y agoPeople are less ambitious, as hard work is rarely the path to promotion. Promotions are highly political and also rely on a good amount of luck.
- marssaxman 4y agoWhy is promotion a goal?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Rury 4y agoPeople like when things go their way, and it's easier to get things to go your way, when you're in a position of power. Promotions can help put you in such positions.
- nirvdrum 4y agoIt's the only way to get a raise at many places. At least, the only way to escape your current salary band. It's also generally accepted as a primary mechanism for determining how a company values your work, unless you hit one of those "career levels." If you're a junior person stuck at a low level for a few years, something is probably askew. It'd be fantastic if positions had a wider salary band and you could earn raises for productivity without having to constantly climb the corporate ladder. I've not really seen that outside of union jobs and even then, you don't have a band so much as a guaranteed raise every few years. This is all based on US companies I've seen in the tech (salaried) and construction (union, hourly) sectors.
- 4y ago
- broknbottle 4y ago> Since the onset of the pandemic, several employees have asked for more pay when managers asked that they do more work, she says. “It was not like that before Covid at all,” she adds. what an out of touch statement..
- dang 4y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Not that you owe out-of-touch employers better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- throwaway123yt 4y agoI dont give more than 50% of my best to any employer. I don't respect anybody as long they need me more than I do them i win all the time.
- josephd79 4y agoIt’s called boundaries. You owe them nothing more than what you signed up for. Call me lazy or not committed, that’s your opinion. I don’t care.
- nitwit005 4y ago> A decade ago, new hires would typically ask within weeks what it took to be promoted to manager, he says. Now, more times than not, he says, managers need to proactively identify candidates for higher positions—and seek them out, instead of waiting for workers to raise their hands. Probably because HR posts the job requirements on an internal website now, because every single person in the company asked about it.
- zwaps 4y agoI will (and have) happily worked 80 hours per week, if you compensate me. Instead, my real wage has decreased this year. Of course, this means I substitute free time for work. My work time budget has been reduced. Since real wages have been falling consistently for most workers (US Swe excepted maybe) this should not be surprising. Profits are up, real wages and wealth share of younger workers decrease. Who is to say which causal direction this has with work time? Back in the day, sinking in all that free time paid off. Now it pays off less. For me, it has nothing to do with ambition. Sad to see that many decision makers are apparently wrong on this.
- the_only_law 4y agoBetter not job hop to make up that lost income though. That makes you untrustworthy.
- _s 4y agoMost CV's I come across now average 18 month stints before a bump in level and change in company. That is not them being untrustworthy, it's signalling that they will move if they are not recognised for their work and growth. Generally it takes 3-6 months to get productive at a new role, another 6 months to generally show competency / growth, and the last 6 months is spent waiting for recognition that you are willing to move up. Unfortunately the most common growth structures dictate that people need to "act" as if they're in a more senior role already, alongside doing their existing one, and maybe they might get the title and salary bump. Often they don't, or are promised at their next review. Most just move. If there's a group of 3-6 month (or shorter) spots, then I'm certainly asking about the work that happened during those.
- grog454 4y ago> Unfortunately the most common growth structures dictate that people need to "act" as if they're in a more senior role already, alongside doing their existing one, and maybe they might get the title and salary bump. This policy was explicit at my first corporate job, and it was a major contributor to my decision to work for myself. Imagine a system where an employee is identified as a candidate for a higher position and tentatively promoted to it to see if they can adjust to the role. Sadly it seems the only place this system exists is the role of startup founder.
- neilv 4y ago> A group of first-year analysts at Goldman Sachs Group Inc. complained to bank leaders last year that they were working an average of 95 hours a week and that job stress had harmed their physical and mental health. I'm pro-ambition, pro-commitment-to-the-team/mission, and a recovering workaholic. But don't do crazy hours like this. It's permanent damage. Target 40 hours a week. Make those hours productive towards the org's goals and not misaligned individual goals/metrics (experienced engineers and the manager and PM should be blasting the inefficiencies out of everyone's way). Keep stress low, and only for good reasons (again, stupid reasons need to be fixed promptly). If you've got people being actually productive and on-track towards org goals at 40 hrs/wk with low stress, that's a great environment. And when some rare emergency happens that can't just mean slipping the schedule, then some people will have the time/energy/morale to surge their effort to to whatever sweat/magic is necessary. Then they get flex time after. And we educate new people about how we were able to handle the emergency, and the importance of not breaking this hard-earned effective organization.
- yodsanklai 4y ago> Target 40 hours a week. Not as easy as it sounds. For me, doing 40 hours of actual work means staying 60h near the computer or in the office. I take too many breaks chatting with colleagues, or browsing HN. Well, this is my problem... Plus my company measures "impact". Unfortunately, lot of work which has to be done is not impactful from management's perspective, and requires working more in order to generate impact and have something to say in your self-assessment. Of course, everybody in my team do work more than 40h, so you have to keep up in order not be in the 15% of low performers in line for the next layoff.
- jen20 4y ago> I take too many breaks chatting with colleagues, or browsing HN. Have you considered remote work, from a timezone 2-3 hours ahead of others? It’s nice to have mornings free from distraction…
- nerdawson 4y ago40 hours of total work. Not 40h of your best work, 40h of output. If that lands you in the bottom 15%, I’d start looking for other opportunities. I’ve been in your shoes. We had time tracking and for me to consistently log 40h of actual work in a week, I’d have to sit in front of my computer from morning to night. Even weekends sometimes to catch up on what I’d missed. What a fool I was. I did that for years for mediocre pay (although I couldn’t see it at the time) to the detriment of everything else around me. It wasn’t worth it. Now I couldn’t care less. The whole “quiet quitting” phenomenon resonates deeply with me.
- irrational 4y agoOh, hey, look; I’m such a hipster I was avoiding promotions before it was cool. I’ve worked in the industry for nearly 25 years. I’ve pushed back against every attempt to promote me into lead or manager type roles. I’ll happily work as an individual contributor until I retire. One of the things that did me in was working insane hours (like 80 hour weeks) to get a project done on time. It was completed on time. My thanks was a satisfactory on my yearly review. When I pushed back on my manager, he said sorry, I deserved it, but they were required to give a certain percentage satisfactory and he had had to give the exceptional review to someone else. That is when I learned that the whole system is rigged. That was about 15 years ago. I’ve been coasting ever since.
- lastdong 4y agoThe ridiculous bell curve… I was also quite surprised early on my career. I was asked to rate my colleagues, when I said they were all top performers, as we had such a tight team (we could really depend on each other) and it was a very homogeneous group skill wise, my manager presented me “the bell curve”. I couldn’t really grasp it, context wise it made no sense. I thought things were changing a bit: https://www.forbes.com/sites/joshbersin/2014/02/19/the-myth-of-the-bell-curve-look-for-the-hyper-performers/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/joshbersin/2014/02/19/the-myth-... My take on work is have fun (yes, I can do some extra hours now and then), never neglecting physical and mental health.
- plasticchris 4y agoSo they are saying the hiring process is no better than selection at random from the population?
- criddell 4y agoIf I’m ever running a company that does annual reviews, I’m also going to have underlings review their managers.
- lupire 4y agoGoogle luck making them feel safe enough to be honest.
- poulpy123 4y agoI'm not going to lie, it's quite funny to see th eHN crowd discovering the concept of class struggle
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Blackstone4 4y agoFirst company I worked for, I worked hard and was rated star of project out of 40 people…I was training people on a super technical project who had 10-15 years of more experience than me. I was client facing and traveling to sites in multiple countries. The company was hiring people for $8k more than my salary with similar experience to me (Java and security clearance). After 1.5 yrs had my first pay rise of $400 for the year…what a joke. I received a job offer in finance and for almost double my salary….told my employer I was leaving. They asked what can we do to keep you and I said you can double my salary…and the project manager said yes..to be honest I didn’t believe them. Since then I’ve gone on to work at different companies for good pay but little upside since the companies were not growing (often shrinking!). This makes it difficult to get promoted as quickly since the organisations are not growing so senior management ranks stagnant and no one leaves and new roles are not created. Right now there’s no incentive to me working hard…it won’t make a meaningful difference.
- Blackstone4 4y ago>> “Comments by Home Depot Inc. co-founder Bernie Marcus that “nobody works, nobody gives a damn,”” Corporates have been squeezing employee who give a damn…with little in the way of pay rises. Corporate profits and stock prices have been off the charts while people struggle to look after their families if they can even afford to start one altogether! Companies need to adapt and start actually rewarding hard work…and I don’t just mean giving out employee of the month awards..I mean cash money…
- throw234239842 4y agoI've spent the last 3 years studying for a postgrad while working full-time. I literally can't find a higher paying job than what I'm currently doing that looks like this: * relaxed environment in huge enterprise * absolutely never do overtime (except i used to do on- calls which they paid me reasonably well for) * no major responsibilities * easy to complete work Guess what I'm going to do when i finish studying? The same job! I'll also start side projects on evenings/weekends and make investments. It's not that I don't want to work more, it's just that I want my work to bring in money when I'm on the beach. Being a wage slave exchanging time for money is so obviously not worth it. Neither is getting 'promoted' to a job with more responsibilities, longer hours and barely any more money.
- drewcoo 4y agoWell . . . 1. What work are they doing (unspecified in article) and . . 2. How well are they paid (factor in COLA if you'd like some extra fairness monkey wrench) Also . . . 3. Why the *@#!$(&#? should I care about how bosses do or do not adjust? Apologies. I forget this is "manager news" and not "hacker news."
- penguin_booze 4y agoIt wasn't all passion; it was a rat race, chasing the dream.
- DangitBobby 4y ago> That's why they call it the American Dream, because you have to be asleep to believe it. - George Carlin
- pdimitar 4y agoFor my previous-previous job my onboarding project was to do 100% of the backend of an NFT-selling project: Stripe payments, storing payment details, the smart contract calls sub-system, storing and managing half-done orders, monitoring the ETH blockchain to confirm minted NFT, the _whole_ shebang. It was an almost impossible amount of work and I managed to do it just 2 days before the near-unreachable deadline. My reward? 500 EUR bonus. I mean I was 41 at the time already and was mostly immune to illusions but still felt bad. But I guess the media will never stop with the propaganda how the workers must try ever harder. Meh.
- tyingq 4y agoMaybe they are just less ambitious about promotion within, and plan on leaving the company for any upward mobility.
- danabrams 4y ago“Workers unwilling to work hard at types of places where bosses willing to go talk to a national newspaper about how lazy their employees are” is my preferred headline.
- olliej 4y agoAre you paying me to work the weekend? if not why do you expect me to work the weekend? Are you expecting me to work 80 hours a week? are you paying me twice a 40 hour a week job? People aren't "becoming less ambitious" they're becoming less willing to work for free - this seems like a new version of the "silent quitting" posts from a few months ago where a bunch of abusive companies were calling people only working the contractual terms normally used to abuse them as somehow "quitting".
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoThe title is misleading. Having read the article (about unpaid overtime, all-nighters etc.) I believe the more correct one should be "Employees are becoming more reasonable."
- smeej 4y ago> In a recent job listing for a property-and-casualty insurance agent, TGS laid out those expectations: “If you’re just OK with getting by, or are a ‘quiet quitter,’ this will be too fast paced for you. We’re looking for people that want a new Mercedes.” No wonder they aren't inspiring Gen Z. A Mercedes isn't a status symbol for Gen Z, and it barely is for Millennials. I'm glad to see people recognizing the emperor has no clothes. Sacrificing yourself for a company you don't own--at all, never mind completely--won't make you wealthy. The company wouldn't employ you if you weren't providing them more than you cost them. It's never been easier to create enough value on your own terms to sustain yourself and not let someone else siphon out your value on their terms.
- mfuzzey 4y ago>The company wouldn't employ you if you weren't providing them more than you cost them. Yes that's true of course. >It's never been easier to create enough value on your own terms to sustain yourself and not let someone else siphon out your value on their terms Not so sure about that part. Maybe it's easier today but if you mean things like freelancing the problem is that you then have to do lots of stuff that isn't interesting to a lot of technical oriented people (like finding clients, negotiating contracts etc). The advantage of working for a company is that you can concentrate on the things that interest you and leave the rest to others. Sure you'll end up earning less but, in my book at least, its worth it. But nothing says you have to "sarifice yourself" you can work for a company but still have a decent balance to have time for other things.
- kodah 4y agoSpeaking for myself, I disagree with OP. I have a price for nights, weekends, and overtime. That price, however, went up beyond the average salary. Second to that, even if they do want to pay that money it needs to be in writing. No amount of lip flapping will get that out of me. I have goals and those goals require money. They either pay, or I do what I'm paid to do. What I'm paid to do is still a good and needed job. From my perspective, workers learned their value.
- briHass 4y ago
- xwdv 4y agoThe way to break through this problem is to offer different rewards beyond money in order to make people more ambitious.
- DangitBobby 4y agoLike free coffee, ping-pong tables in the break room, and a jelly-of-the-month club membership?
- buttocks 4y agoTake-away: this is the time for the ambitious, the clever, the go-getters to… go-get. What better time to stand out above the crowd.
- anonzzzies 4y agoI was fired a few months ago from a well paying swe job; they said my performance was lacking because I was only doing my job and not more. Because the company is actually on my linkedin (they insisted on that to have my name there), my potential replacements contact me. I tell them it is nice work with quite a bit of responsibility over the technical side of their products, but they hire people (and this was true for all my colleagues) that will go the extra mile without the extra compensation. They don’t give out shares or bonuses so it’s literally without benefit. I took the position because it seemed like it was exactly that; pay for a 40 hour week, no shares, inflation indexed raise yearly and that’s it, so there is no reason to work more or over 40 hours. This expectation is pretty weird.
- i_am_toaster 4y agoI feel like this was written in such a way that many won’t realize it’s satire.
- beastman82 4y agoWall Street journal, bastion of satire
- i_am_toaster 4y agoI know you’re making fun of me, but I still had a chuckle myself.
- Bennynichs 4y agoI am curious how this will play out for small startups which usually forgo higher pay for stock options and other less tangible benefits, usually propped up by motivated young professionals. As both a manager and contributor myself, I can say from experience that (perhaps obviously) management of highly motivated persons is much easier than those putting in the work strictly for a paycheck. There is a clear "us vs them" mentality for a growing group of contributors burned-out from capatalism (see r/antiwork) and the vicious cycle for this cohort is that the more apathetic a person becomes, the more mamagement intervention they're likely to receive, putting them more at odds with the same forces they oppose.
- hcmacro 4y agoI get the sense that cultural malaise and managerial rent-seeking afflict many legacy firms (outside of tech). In some ways, such corporations feel like they're converging with peers in Japan---a gerontocratic society with limited social mobility (not a novel observation). If corporate America is indeed undergoing a process of "Japanification," such a phenomenon would likely result in outcomes at odds with received wisdom on career success. The type of worker "unruliness" documented here then should be unsurprising. (As an aside, I find it interesting that Japan has had pretty low levels of unemployment over the past twenty years. One might even expect this in a paternalistic society that bolsters rent-seeking incumbents. Hence, individuals can feel "stuck" even as the media superficially assesses data to fit the narrative of a "hot economy."). (Another observation, it's funny for the article to cite an executive comparing Americans to people in a country where menial workers are paid slave wages.)
- fancymcpoopoo 4y agoyou can thank Donald Trump's mismanagement for the new order. One of the presidents of all time.
- fundad 4y agoThe Proto-Quiet-Quitter
- dbg31415 4y agoEverything used to not feel as shitty. Like... healthcare, for starters. But it's also a huge one. You go to the dentist, and it used to be $20 co-pay. And that was that. Now it's like a $50 co-pay... AND they send you a bill after the visit for gauze or something random that the insurance didn't cover. And the point is you have no idea if it's going to be $35 or $900. And even if you have the money it's all the time you have to spend figuring out how to pay the damn bill (like some random online payment system), and stress knowing a bill is never what you can predict. It takes energy to worry about this shit. And by the time you're done stressing, the last thing you want to do is go back and work a weekend for an employer who's just going to find a way to make your insurance suck more the next year, all while blaming insurance companies for raising rates. And it's shitty fucking mortgage companies that sell your loan every 6 months to a different shitty fucking mortgage company. And make you switch payment systems. And it's just like, "Man, I thought auto-pay meant I didn't have to stress about this shit or ever check my mail or read messages from companies I didn't recognize..." But any more, that's how you get late fees. And it's all the fucking upsells on things. Nothing feels good by default. And finding anything that feels like a good deal is impossible. All the fucking "optimizations" companies have made over the years all just make life miserable. More shit to stress about... I can't just hop on a plane, if I forget to upgrade to the right plan (which varies by airline), or change flights mid-trip, I then it's another bill for bags, or meals, or so my knees don't get crushed by the seat in front of me. Meh, all this just ends up sounding like some cranky old person complaining shit used to be better. The perpetual state of American decline. "Get off my lawn!" But like... bottom line, as a Gen-X-er I want to work, and do my best, and I get annoyed when people don't buy in to the shit I've been sold. But I also get why a lot of people younger than me are over this shit. Life just feels way too unpleasant with all the BS, nobody has your back. Why would anyone want to work harder than they have to in the system we've built?
- DangitBobby 4y agoYes. What we are all experiencing is a nation in decline.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trilbyglens 4y agoSounds like Europe! A step in the right direction if you ask me.
- dqpb 4y agoWant ambition? Give equity.
- jensensbutton 4y agoThis is the crux of it and rings true in my experience. Significant increase in effort usually results in only marginal increases in comp, if any. ROI simply isn't there. > Many workers say they see little connection between working hard and being rewarded. About half of the 1,071 respondents to a May survey by The Wall Street Journal and NORC at the University of Chicago said they don’t have a good chance of improving their standard of living, compared with 27% who said they do. The 27% figure was a 20 percentage-point drop from a year earlier. About 60% said they were pessimistic about most people’s ability to achieve the American dream.
- dqpb 4y ago(meta) Does WSJ realize how idiotic this page looks to a non-subscriber? It gives one paragraph and then ends with a bunch of links to other stories. As if that one paragraph is the whole story. You have to scroll down to see that you've been paywalled. Clearly there are some decision makers at WSJ who fit into this low-ambition category.
- dqpb 4y ago> Comments by Home Depot Inc. co-founder Bernie Marcus that “nobody works, nobody gives a damn,” with possible implications for the future of capitalism The implication being that founders don't understand capitalism? You get what you pay for.
- xchip 4y agoSo bad there is no free lunch anymore
- lakeshastina 4y agoI think one way to slice people at work is: (1) those who work for money in order to pay for their lifestyle(hobbies, family, etc) and (2) Those who seek to define their identity through success in the workplace. It appears that lately there is less of those who seek to define themselves through work, and care more about their life(and identity) outside of work. For such people, trying to incentivize them through money and career growth will likely not work.
- taylodl 4y agoLove how they portray balancing the Work/Life balance towards "Life" as being "less ambitious." No. We're not less ambitious. We're more balanced. We're also not all that interested in working for no pay to enrich somebody else.
- CosmicShadow 4y agoMy wife works a decent white-collar job at a giant company and negotiated a 20% pay decrease to go down to 4 days a week. She's never been happier, she doesn't even feel like she needs to take vacations very often as that simple switch is life altering. She's the only one she knows that will say No to overtime. If she wasn't so valuable, she wouldn't have been approved at a company like that, and even now it still seems unheard of to do such a thing, but people are finally starting to try. Her boss is asking her quarterly about her goals with the company and more specifically about taking over his director level job, to which she says "no way" every time. She can see how shittily bosses are treated at the company, they are forced to work insane overtime without pay, deal with personnel issues, eat shit from above constantly, deal with all issues, can't fire the dead weight (which is everywhere), are expected to work over lunch every day and be available to work on vacation, which they usually can't take. Yet they don't seem to grasp that anybody with a brain can see this is an awful trade off for like 10-30% more pay, which just gets taxed away anyway and which you never have time to spend. You can see it in the faces of these folks, they look prematurely aged. You know how you see a picture of someone's face and say "they look like they had a hard life"? Yeah, go on facebook and see which of your colleagues took the management job and go back 5 years and be blown away at how they aged. It's both sad and shocking. Misery loves company, why wouldn't young employees want to be as "successful" as us?
- mythhouse 4y ago> negotiated a 20% pay decrease to go down to 4 days a week. Is this in USA? I want this but haven't been able to convince any of my employers to let me do this. They said its a legal/HR issue and need approvals from those orgs within the company. I have a question for you. Are you also doing this? Do you feel extra pressure to now climb up and be ambitious now that the spouse has let her foot off the accelerator.
- CosmicShadow 4y agoThis is in Canada. Bosses will always defer to legal/HR and it's usually just BS. Oh this isn't policy, but policy is just made up for the company so they a) don't have to think, and b) can refer to the policy and say it's iron clad rule. businesses can do almost anything, it's that they _don't want to have to do the work_ to figure it out for you. Maybe they'll actually miss some rule where you are now "part-time" vs "full-time" if there is a legal distinction in your country based on hours worked and you can catch them in some loop hole or something and they don't want to try and figure it out, but in 99% of cases, it's just that they don't know what to actually do without thinking or researching, so they won't do it. If they make a mistake it's their ass on the line, and they don't know or care about you. The best way to get away with this is to find an employer who is open to it from the start (good luck), or be so valuable that if you threaten to quit if you don't get it, they'll relent and do it for you. In my wife's case, they can't afford to lose her so they'll push HR into making the change. It wasn't painless and there was some annoyances and nuances to fix in the HR system, but it was worth it. I've been self-employed for almost 15 years so that I would never have to deal with this kind of bullshit. I do consulting and work on my own business ideas. I've run several startups in the past, some of which were funded, so I've seen the back end of all this kind of stuff. My wife makes more money than I do and I work on finding businesses that can free us both from having to work. It sucks that she is making less now and we can feel it a bit, but it's not a huge blow as we aren't big spenders. It was 100% worth it, she is by far happier than she has been in years. They did a very poor job of reducing her workload with her time though, so watch out for that if you can get your 20% reduction. They'll pay you less, but expect you to work the 5th day in the 4. This is mainly a staffing issue on her team however. I do feel some pressure to finally get something working so she can just leave her employment and in the last year I've managed to grow my latest business to twice her annual gross salary. If I can keep it up we'll be able to meet our goals, but a business is an ongoing monster with it's own risks and expenses, so it'll take some time before the leap can be made. I hope you can achieve what you want, sometimes it takes some serious pressure to get your way, or you have to be willing to walk if they don't agree, but man that 3 day weekend every week is that much better and she still talks about how great it is a year later.
- joeman1000 4y agoIt’s incredible: the mental gymnastics people will perform to avoid even contemplating the fact that our wages are Fucked (capital F intended). Want people to be enthusiastic about working? Pay them enough! Want ambitious people? You won’t attract them by offering dogshit compensation. Hire /less/ people, but pay them /more/! How bloody hard is that?
- CosmicShadow 4y agoI remember when a now very large startup cold emailed me to try and recruit me (I'm self-employed). Lots of new funding, out of the Valley, I asked if they paid Valley wages since I wasn't living there, and they said, "oh, if you care that much about the compensation and not the mission, then you are the wrong type of person to join our team". LOL, sorry for not wanting to give my life for _your_ dream and not be paid fairly. Startups are some of the worst abusers of people's time and effort and they hide behind the trope of extreme effort and long hours for little pay that people come to just expect with the territory. I imagine nowadays they are having a bit of a harder time then they once did, but there are always dreamers and fools and examples of those that did and came out very well.
- dreamcompiler 4y ago“I spent the first 15 years of my career climbing that ladder, being ambitious,” he says. “I don’t want this to be what’s written on my tombstone. And I certainly don’t want the stress to be what puts me in a grave.” 100 years from now historians of labor will mark the COVID-19 pandemic as the time of the great reset, when labor finally got fed up with -- Being constantly told to "do more with less" after yet another round of cost-cutting -- Being loyal to companies that weren't loyal to them -- Being exploited for some vague promise of reward in the future -- Having no social or family life I'm glad this has finally happened; I'm just sorry it took a global pandemic to force the issue.
- chrisgd 4y agoI am in the finance industry and at the very least, they seem to understand that harder work should result in higher rewards (cash comp). For a lot of these startups or more standard work environments, the ask seems to be to work harder with little visibility into how it helps the worker. Ultimately, there will be turbulence but I think it is moving towards more equality and less economic inequality. Which I think is great. This thread from antiwork on reddit was pretty insightful https://www.reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/1000wnk/profits_more_money_work_harder_i_3_elon/ https://www.reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/1000wnk/profits_m...
- chrisgd 4y agoI would also note that it was supposedly the son of a TPG partner(one of the largest private equity firms in the world) who spearheaded the Goldman Sachs analyst revolt mentioned in the article
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nightshadetrie 4y agoCovid made people realize your work ethic is less important than your health.
- escapedmoose 4y agoMy partner and I have already agreed that now that we’re financially comfortable, the next career move for both of us will be aiming for more PTO so we can start enjoying our earnings. It’s been so difficult to find companies with reasonable leave policies in the past. I hope trends like this will give us more opportunities to find what we’re really after.
- thw09j9m 4y agoI worked a TON of overtime last quarter and I'm not going to make that same mistake again. If I work over 40 hours a week, that time is going to be devoted to prepping algorithm and system design interview questions so that I can easily find another high paying job if I were to get fired here. My real job is to be highly employable and sought after at all times, not fulfilling the needs/wants of my current company.
- SergeAx 4y ago> Many workers say they see little connection between working hard and being rewarded. At the same time, in most tech companies I see a lot of backpressure against performance reviews, which is exactly the instrument of rewarding hard work.