15 ms·
How Did Sam Bankman-Fried Get Bail?
- xwowsersx 4y ago> Or maybe they just think that if he flees they can catch him and then they get to take a house away from two Stanford Law professors, which they would enjoy. Eh? This meant at all seriously or totally tongue in cheek?
- tptacek 4y agoKen's media partner Josh Barro sums this up in a way that makes a lot of sense to me: This is, in various ways, unfair. But the point of the bail system isn’t doing justice. It’s ensuring that people show up for trial. I hear a lot of movie theater plots about SBF evading trial, but he's a goober, and whatever happens, he's going to wind up in prison, and the threads here about his bail are in retrospect going to read a little silly.
- frozenport 4y ago[flagged]
- technotony 4y agoI hope not, life is precious no matter what someone has done. The bail conditions include mental health support so hopefully that will help.
- tptacek 4y agoThis is a lazy joke about Jeffrey Epstein, who Ken White is also quite certain killed himself; the conspiracy theories about Epstein depend on people's movie-plot misunderstandings of the competence of federal penitentiary workers and their managers (in his telling [and thus my belief]).
- peter422 4y agoBut why would a formerly super wealthy sex addict who always got whatever he wanted possibly want to kill himself when facing life in prison? It just doesn't make any sense.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIf this was meant to be sarcastic, you should add an /s tag. I've seen too many posts essentially arguing exactly what you are saying but that were actually serious.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoPrison conditions in the U.S. are such that I wouldn't fault someone facing down a life sentence from considering a quicker option out. Honestly, I don't even know what the point of prison in this situation is. It won't get anyone their money back, and he's unlikely to be in a position where he can reoffend in the future. I suppose there's the deterrent angle, but I'm not convinced that there's a meaningful difference between a 10 year sentence and a life sentence as a deterrent.
- whatshisface 4y agoA lot of people would be willing to spend ten years in prison in exchange for a chance to steal billions of dollars and get away with it.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoFair, but it remains to be seen if he was stealing for personal gain (embezzlement), or because he had a gambling addiction and was trying to keep his companies solvent. "I'll just borrow these customer assets until I make it back" probably isn't a thing that someone would be deterred from whether it was 10 years or life. People make crazy gambles all the time for a lot less, and end up indebted to bookies who kill them. He'll obviously never be in a position where he can make this mistake again, and I think life in prison doesn't fit the crime, especially for a first-time offender. If he was stealing for personal gain, then sure, throw the book at him. But the available information doesn't make it clear if that's the case yet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hibern8 4y agoThe US Justice system exists for retribution too, not just deterrence.
- kube-system 4y ago
- themitigating 4y agoWhy is life precious no matter what someone does?
- paulcole 4y agoEven if life is precious, isn’t it up to the person facing the situation to decide that for themselves? It’s pretty easy for me to tell someone their life is precious when I don’t have to live their life.
- mynameishere 4y agoYou are probably talking about the Frank Pentangeli or (real life) Jeffrey Epstein style of suicide, not the "boo hoo the mental health clinic needs to hand out free Prozac but doesn't" sort. But I don't think so. I'll give it a 1 percent chance of suicide, a 1 percent chance of flight to Israel (they likely won't want him) and a 98 percent chance of rutabaga patch guard duty at Club Fed for 20 years. Note that his girlfriend, despite her femme fatale good looks and secondary school level calculus knowledge squealed like a piggy to the law, allowing her to altogether avoid the nasty shared toilet at the women's lockup. Pretty sweet.
- wpietri 4y agoI agree it's not about doing justice. But I still think we need the overall system to be just. I don't object to pretrial people getting home confinement generally, and I can grudgingly accept it here on the theory that the Feds must be pretty sure he's not going to pull a Ghosn. [1] But I have real questions about exactly who isn't getting this kind of generous treatment. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/carlos-ghosn-inside-the-rise-fall-former-nissan-ceo-2022-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/carlos-ghosn-inside-the-rise...
- jbm 4y agoI am not sure if you are implying this, but Ghosn's case is far from clear-cut in the way that SBF's is.The hilarious implication that all the bad apples at Nissan were non-Japanese foreigners was far too convenient to be true.
- kasey_junk 4y agoAnd the Japanese criminal system is fairly suspect.
- jquery 4y agoYeah, they have an over 99% conviction rate…
- tzs 4y agoThat's not a very useful bit of information, is it? We'd expect a very high conviction rate in very bad systems because of corruption and because such systems might be meant just for show. However, we'd also expect a very high conviction rate in very good systems. Before a case gets to trial in a very good system first it would be investigated by police. Only if the police think there is a worthwhile case would it go to prosecutors. Then some prosecutor has to decide they have enough evidence to stand a good chance of conviction. There would probably be more review taking into account overall prosecutorial load to make sure they won't be devoting limited resources to a case they might lose. The only cases that reach trial should be cases that the prosecutor is very sure they will win, so of course we should see a high conviction rate if the prosecutors are competent.
- HuwytGreen 4y ago[dead]
- grecy 4y ago> and whatever happens, he's going to wind up in prison, and the threads here about his bail are in retrospect going to read a little silly. I think you're missing the point. The guy broke the law to the tune of BILLIONS of dollars, and he gets to sit around at home while waiting for trial. He is with his family, living however he wants. Eating great food, drinking, relaxing. Enjoying himself. Regular criminals who break the law to the tune of hundreds of dollars are forced to sit in jail while they wait for trial. Jail sucks. You do NOT get to enjoy yourself. That's the point.
- tptacek 4y agoHe hasn't been convicted. When he is, my guess is he spends essentially the rest of his life in prison. I don't much care what he's doing right now. It's unfair that people poorer than him spend the same time in lockup. But the bail system's treatment of SBF is so far from the top of my list of things to be concerned about, my first approximation of it is that it simply doesn't matter. You can feel differently!
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoThe rest of his life in prison? You'll be sorely wrong by a long shot. Have you looked at any precedents? Jeff Skilling, for one, is already out. More recently, Elizabeth Holmes only received 11 years.
- twblalock 4y agoThe better precedent would be Madoff.
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoYou are right. The amounts lost in FTX are also around the ballpark of Madoff's amounts, after inflation.
- trevyn 4y agoMadoff was sentenced when he was 71, so I doubt they spent much time considering the difference between 20 years and life.
- joe_the_user 4y agoThere are a lot of impoverished, incompetent criminals who should be getting bail if the "I couldn't run from justice if I wanted to" argument was reasonable.
- tptacek 4y agoSure. There are.
- eternalban 4y agoIn Bahamas, there were stories of how awful the jail SBF was held is, but only one (iirc) managed to let out the kitty that he was held in infirmary, and not in the scary cells every story talked about. One reason to stay within the law is that even due process can be a rather nasty experience, and generally to be avoided if possible. The threat of rape in US prisons is repeatedly referenced in "cultural products" coming out of LA. It is pretty odd when you think about it: systemic abuse is taking place and blockbuster films reference it and apparently the government doesn't care. So sure, the bail is for preventing flight. It is not about justice. But ultimately the "justice system" is also not there to do "justice": it is ultimately there to insure societal stability and harmony. When a people get the sense that "the system" is stacked, and gives preferential treatment to special people, it undermines the very purpose of a justice system. So tptacek, the justice people are talking about is simply the obvious this: If Joe Schmoe had pulled the scam of century, he would have had ample time to meet his cell mates in Bahamas in "scary prison", and, also get to know the fellows in cell block whatever over here, in the land of "sodomy in prison is a feature not a bug" USA. That kind of justice.
- gruez 4y ago>So sure, the bail is for preventing flight. It is not about justice. But ultimately the "justice system" is also not there to do "justice": it is ultimately there to insure societal stability and harmony. When a people get the sense that "the system" is stacked, and gives preferential treatment to special people, it undermines the very purpose of a justice system. Okay, but what's the alternative here? Have a bail/trial by public opinion so the results are maximally aligned with what the public wants? There's also the alternative of making the justice system more humane, but like you said: >One reason to stay within the law is that even due process can be a rather nasty experience, and generally to be avoided if possible. The threat of rape in US prisons is repeatedly referenced in "cultural products" coming out of LA. It is pretty odd when you think about it: systemic abuse is taking place and blockbuster films reference it and apparently the government doesn't care. The government doesn't care because the public doesn't care. It's hard to garner sympathy for suspects. I suspect that in the depictions you speak of, the thought that goes through the average audience's head is "criminal getting their just desserts", not "this is a failure of the criminal justice system because someone is effectively being punished before they're convicted".
- KennyBlanken 4y agoMovie theater plots like putting a CEO Nissan into a shipping container so he can flee prosecution in Japan? https://www.bbc.com/news/business-57760993 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-57760993 When you've got personal wealth in the hundreds of millions, yeah, "hollywood plots" are indeed a concern.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYeah they are a concern, but the justice system shouldn't look at anecdotes. It should look at overall statistics.
- lazide 4y agoHow many billionaires get arrested every year again for massive billion dollar frauds? When your sample size holds no statistical significant, there are no useful overall statistics.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI obviously don't have the numbers, but I would think a few billionaires a year, and lots of multimillioners. Add that up over 50 years and you probably have a pretty decent sample size
- lazide 4y agoIn any specific jurisdiction? Highly unlikely. There are only 3.3k billionaires globally. For those specific crimes? Even less likely. My guess (but numbers hard to come by, to my point), is there have only been a handful of billionaires arrested for anything, even in most states. Ever. There are several orders of magnitude difference between billionaires and multi millionaires. They aren’t even on the same page.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoOff the top of my head Elizabeth Holmes comes to mind and Sunny Balwani must have been close. Epstein was also pretty close. When I Google Billionaire arrested I get a flood of responses with names. I would argue that at least individuals with 100 plus million have the similar capacity for flight AS billionaires. You could probably come up with an extensive list of US celebrities that have been arrested in this category
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- benjaminwootton 4y agoDoes it ensure that he shows up to trial though? If a person ripped off a million people, it’s a tentative assumption that they wouldn’t rip off their parents too. If my child was facing decades in prison for a non-violent crime with mitigating circumstances then I would sacrifice my home in a heartbeat, so its tentative from that direction too. I’m sure SBF could also pay them back easily enough. He likely has substantial resources to aid any escape and a history of extradition. So he has the means. We have the ankle tag, but if that is a foolproof solution then there wouldn’t even need to be a bail system as pretty much everyone could be tagged until trial. If you were facing 100 years in prison after the fall from grace he has had, surely a private jet to Russia looks to have very appealing odds?
- twblalock 4y agoFrom the article: > His parents co-signed the bond, meaning they are on the hook for that amount (which they can’t pay, obviously) if he breaks the terms of the bond. In addition to that, they are required to pledge their home equity. If he flees, they are screwed. They have a very strong incentive to make sure he makes his court date.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>If he flees, they are screwed. Unless they flee too, to a country that doesn't have extradition. Given the good chance he has countless millions stashed somewhere, this is definitely a non-zero chance. It is also made more likely due to the political connections SBF and his family have due to the tens of millions of dollars he has funneled to politicians. While not necessarily likely, it is far from impossible (anyone who thinks it is should look up Mark Rich). If anyone should be locked up without bail while waiting trial, it is SBF.
- twblalock 4y agoEvery politician they gave money to is trying hard to distance themselves. Nobody is going to stick their neck out for SBF or his family. What on earth would be in it for them? Besides, why is SBF in the USA right now? He could have tried to stay in the Bahamas. He came here because he knows that his chances with other countries’ justice systems are far worse. And what country in the world would give him shelter? He ripped people off all over the world. Anywhere he might go, there is a strong chance he would be arrested there.
- GolfPopper 4y agoIf we're interested in justice, then bail reform is small potatoes: make fines for crimes scale based on income and wealth. It a billionaire, a decamillionaire, and a minimum wage laborer should all be proportionately penalized for breaking the law. Having large financial resources shouldn't reduce financial criminal penalties to irrelevance.
- edgyquant 4y agoThis incentivized hitting your political opposition with a ton of small time charges (which is notoriously easy to do)
- mathieuh 4y agoIn many cases rich people aren’t punished in real terms at all, they actually make money. How many times have we seen rich people defrauding the public or causing them harm, only for them to be given some slap-on-the-wrist fine years later. Meanwhile, they have been investing their ill-gotten gains and making more than the eventual fines.
- watwut 4y agoIt is huge potato, because being hold in jail before trial puts huge pressure on people. If the charges are small, they are very likely to just sign plea deal while in exact same charge outside they would fought a case. Layers and Criminal reform advocates talk about this a lot, actually. Being in pre trial jail is actively destroying their lives. It is one of reasons for why most cases enver even end up in trial.
- HyperSane 4y agoKeeping someone in jail until trial is the most effective method of ensuring that they will show up for a trial.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rhapsodic 4y ago[dead]
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoHe’s not going to jail. He might go to a country club where he’s not supposed to leave (but will for “special” occasions).
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoI get the downvoted. Now all you who downvoted: so you have eyes on all those other rich people in jail? Is there a webcam? So how do you know they are there?
- CircleSpokes 4y agoThe fact he didn't fight extradition from the Bahamas (which could have taken a very long time) helped his case a lot.
- prepend 4y agoOr perhaps he stopped fighting extradition when his lawyers set up a deal to avoid bail?
- tptacek 4y agoWhy on Earth would he fight extradition? The alternative to coming to the US was spending years locked up in a Bahamian jail.
- aliqot 4y agoBahamas aren't this terrible place to be. It's still jail in actual paradise. People in NYC would fork over a kidney for that type of view and square footage.
- alphabettsy 4y agoI don’t think people in NYC are going to the Bahamas for their jails.
- landemva 4y agoMaybe not int'l travel, but someone seems to be going to this national park in SF. "Island of Incarceration" https://www.nps.gov/alca/index.htm https://www.nps.gov/alca/index.htm
- Cerium 4y agoThey don't have AC.
- aliqot 4y agoneither does NYC
- ck2 4y agoRemember in 2008 when millions of people lost their homes and $30 TRILLION was destroyed in the financial markets because of Wall Street? No prosecutions. People argue there was one or two but they were incidental. Instead just fines were paid and probably made up for in months. So this in comparison might be amazing. https://features.marketplace.org/why-no-ceo-went-jail-after-financial-crisis/ https://features.marketplace.org/why-no-ceo-went-jail-after-...
- twblalock 4y agoWe don't prosecute people just because we don't like them, or because bad things happened. Not in a free society with the rule of law, anyway. In the case of SBF there is pretty clear evidence that he broke laws. If there was such clear evidence about anyone in 2008, they definitely would have been prosecuted. Prosecutors love to grandstand, and if they thought they could nail the people who "caused the recession" they would have been tripping over each other to be the first to do it. The fact that it never happened is convincing proof that they had no case.
- ck2 4y agoThere were endless stories pouring out after 2008 of laws broken with wild disregard, you can't make that much money and then not just burst the bubble but send a tidal wave of destruction across the world without a serious crime spree. Of course SBF should be prosecuted, but the fact no CEO was even charged after 2008 means there was something far more corrupt at play, it was politics, they feared the repercussions of inhibiting the profit makers, pension funds and retirement plans would have collapse. SBF is "easy" because no repercussions.
- wilg 4y ago> the fact no CEO was even charged after 2008 means there was something far more corrupt at play It doesn't mean that, but it might make you suspect that!
- Khaine 4y agoWeren't most of the law breaking done by people applying for loans and lying about their income? Losses in the market for private label residential mortgage backed securities (RMBS) were at the epicenter of the financial crisis from 2007-2009. Existing research has shown that a substantial portion of the poor performance of the loans securitized in this market was caused by fraudulent origination practices and that these practices were misrepresented to investors who purchased securities based on these loans. However, to date no paper has estimated the effects of mortgage fraud on losses from foreclosure in this market. This paper fills this gap by 1) Accounting for total losses from foreclosure due to no/low documentation loans which were known colloquially within the industry as Liar's Loans, and 2) Estimating what portion of these losses can be considered excess from the perspective of the investor. Losses are considered excess in the sense that they were higher than the expected losses for investors, had the loan quality information disclosed to them been accurate, instead of fraudulent. I find that Liar's Loans account for roughly 70% of total losses, and 36% of losses in Liar's Loans can be considered excess. Projected to the level of the entire market, this implies that $345 billion of the $500 billion in losses from foreclosure are accounted for by Liar's Loans. Roughly $125 billion, or 25% of total market losses, can be considered excess losses caused by fraud in Liar's Loans. From https://peri.umass.edu/publication/item/1008-liar-s-loans-mortgage-fraud-and-the-great-recession-working-paper https://peri.umass.edu/publication/item/1008-liar-s-loans-mo...
- photochemsyn 4y agoAny writer who tries to support their argument by calling the opposing position a 'conspiracy theory' is best ignored: > "The bottom line is that this result may shock people, but it is consistent with federal bail law. That’s likely why the government agreed and not — as conspiracy theorists are already shouting — because of some political pressure in his favor." The obvious counterpoint is that 'consistent with federal bail law' is not much of an argument, as there appears to be a great deal of discretionary privilege, aka 'choice', on the part of judge / prosecution - i.e. not granting bail would also be 'consistent with federal bail law' so that doesn't explain much at all. Incidentally, judges granting special treatment to members of the privileged Stanford community in criminal cases is not a very good look. Just ask ex-judge Aaron Persky.
- twblalock 4y ago> not granting bail would also be 'consistent with federal bail law' so that doesn't explain much at all. The article covers this. Federal bail law has a presumption that defendants will get bail unless there is a good reason to believe they are a flight risk or might re-offend before the trial starts.
- photochemsyn 4y agoI think there are a great many prominent counterexamples of bail being denied for people who pretty clearly fit that bill. Chelsea Manning comes to mind, being neither a flight risk nor potential re-offender. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/apr/22/chelsea-manning-federal-appeals-court-rejects-release-bail https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/apr/22/chelsea-mann...
- phire 4y agoChelsea Manning didn't go though the federal court system. As an enlisted member of the military, she went though a court-martial under Uniform Code of Military Justice, which are a different set of laws that don't even have the concept of bail. So different rules apply. But still, they do have roughly equivalent rules around pretrial restraint and needing to prove that confinement is actually necessary (especially since the military can eliminate flight risk by simply confining them to base). Even at the time there was much (justified) criticism that her treatment was a "degrading and inhumane pretrial punishment"
- arrty88 4y agoI assume SBF has secret unknown wallets of crypto that he can deploy for whatever purpose he wants without the government knowing. He could even pay back the folks that helped with his bail.
- gonzo41 4y agoYou, and me would probably do that. But this guy ain't as smart as the media like to boost him up as being. He's going away for a while over this.
- twblalock 4y agoHe doesn't have to pay anyone back because that is not how Federal bail works. Nobody had to put up a $250 million bail bond. He has instead agreed to pay the amount if he doesn't make it to trial. The article covers this in detail, including the fact that his parents had to cosign on the deal.
- pigtailgirl 4y ago-- "Bankman-Fried’s change in attitude is in part tied to the expectation that he’ll be able to get bail in the US." - legal podcasts seem to agree sam waive his extradition arguments in return for bail possibilities in the US -- https://fortune.com/2022/12/19/sam-bankman-fried-bahamas-court-appearance-confusion-jail/ https://fortune.com/2022/12/19/sam-bankman-fried-bahamas-cou... https://youtu.be/nmPS_ydgra0 https://youtu.be/nmPS_ydgra0 (around 1hr in)
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThanks very much for posting this, was very helpful in correcting some misconceptions I had, as the news headlines all lead with the $250 million number, but this is very different compared to state courts where the full bail amount must be posted as collateral or put up by a bondsman.
- peter_d_sherman 4y ago[flagged]
- busymom0 4y agoThe news is just breaking that the judge has stepped down due to her husband advising FTX. Can someone confirm if this is the same judge who granted bail or different one? https://twitter.com/WatcherGuru/status/1606445139399942144 https://twitter.com/WatcherGuru/status/1606445139399942144
- MrFoof 4y agoNot just Twitter accounts either. Bloomberg reporting it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-23/bankman-fried-judge-recused-because-husband-s-firm-advised-ftx https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-23/bankman-f... No-paywall: https://archive.vn/0HWBA https://archive.vn/0HWBA ----- Her husband didn't directly advise, but his firm did.
- CydeWeys 4y agoI don't like the framing of this article (though the facts it presents about how SBF's bail works are good). In particular these parts stuck out at me: > How, you may ask, does a dude who is so clearly impervious to reality, who had to be arrested in the Bahamas, and who is accused of billions of dollars in fraud, get out on bail? Fair question. Why shouldn't he get out on bail?? He hasn't been convicted of a crime. He's not posing an imminent risk to the community that requires keeping him locked up while he hasn't yet been proven to have done anything wrong. > So: is the bail surprising? Yes. Is it a travesty of justice? That’s a philosophical question. Is it legally wrong, or outside the scope of what can or should happen under the federal bail system? No. I don't find the bail surprising at all. Getting bail is routine. Sure, many people can't afford it, but obviously SBF can (and this article spells out exactly how).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gruez 4y ago> I don't like the framing of this article (though the facts it presents about how SBF's bail works are good). In particular these parts stuck out at me: > > How, you may ask, does a dude who is so clearly impervious to reality, who had to be arrested in the Bahamas, and who is accused of billions of dollars in fraud, get out on bail? Fair question. >Why shouldn't he get out on bail?? He hasn't been convicted of a crime. He's not posing an imminent risk to the community that requires keeping him locked up while he hasn't yet been proven to have done anything wrong. The article is framed that way because it seems to be a fairly popular belief that whether you're granted or denied bail should be dependent on the severity of the crime you're accused of (ie. you're accused of stealing billions, then you should be denied bail). Of course, that's not how the bail system works, but I can understand why people might believe that. To an first approximation, that theory fits with casual observations of when bail is granted or denied. For instance, shoplifting isn't a very serious crime and bail is likely to be granted, but murder is a serious crime and bail is likely to be denied.
- hackernewds 4y ago
- wereallterrrist 4y ago[flagged]
- paulpauper 4y agoThe federal bail system’s presumption of release makes it better and more humane than most state systems. But you can still see the impact of wealth. First, because Sam Bankman-Fried broke the law by (allegedly) stealing billions of dollars instead of by being paid a hundred bucks to transport half a key of black tar heroin, there was no presumption he should be detained. That reflects society’s values. Moreover, rich people are more easily able to satisfy elaborate bail conditions. He should be so happy he gets 6 months or so to live a semi-normal life under intense supervision and restriction of movement before he likely gets sent away forever like Madoff, Alan Stanford and many others. Being rich hardly means favoritism in the sense of avoiding justice.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI think that quote is accurate, but not unreasonable from the perspective of the justice system. My intuition is that alleged white collar Criminal is in fact less likely to commit a new Ponzi scheme while awaiting trial then an alleged drug Smuggler. The justice system should be blind, but not to facts and reason
- coliveira 4y agoThis will only get him the possibility of flying the country, or orchestrate some deal to get out of jail.
- akira2501 4y ago> Moreover, rich people are more easily able to satisfy elaborate bail conditions. Rich families are. I assume his accounts and assets are entirely frozen. His parents put up their house to secure his bail. [1] 1: https://archive.vn/QeZy7 https://archive.vn/QeZy7
- SicSemperUranus 4y ago[flagged]
- paulpauper 4y agohmm what about the fyre festival guy. all his victims were average people who paid for a non-existent festival, not rich ppl or those NFT scammers, whose victims are average people (average loss in the low thousands) ,not super rich people https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/24/22995107/us-arrest-charges-crypto-nft-rug-pull-frosties-ethan-nguyen-andre-llacuna https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/24/22995107/us-arrest-charge... Meanwhile, the Threnos fraud was allowed to run for 8 years, ripping off rich people undeterred, while the NFT scammers were arrested just months after pulling off the fraud. Same for Madoff..that lasted 2 decades, again, ripping off rich people despite repeated warnings to the SEC.
- coliveira 4y agoThis bail deal is just a travesty of justice and nonsense! He or his family promised to pay a bail of $250 million. But they DON'T HAVE this money, unless he uses money that was stolen from other people. Unlike a normal person, he didn't have to pay this money to leave the jail, just signing some papers. It is absurd that this is happening. The guy should at least pay upfront several million dollars, if hey really want to call this bail.
- jawadch93 4y ago[dead]
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoHe has lawyers and isn't black.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoBecause rich people are connected and have dirt on powerful people.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoI would say the rich part is all that matters. If you have assets to put up equivalent to the cash bail amount or get a bail bond, then no one cares. If you don't have zillions, then you're stuck in pauper's prison (pretrial detention) like some 800k people. The US has the highest incarceration rate on the planet except Seychelles.
- russellbeattie 4y agoJFC. Presumed innocence? What the hell is wrong with people. He didn't kill anyone. He's probably a criminal - but until he's convicted he's not a danger to himself or others and should not be in a jail cell. And I don't care if it happens to others - two wrongs don't make a right. We should scrap cash bail for the entire country and fix our justice system, not become a rabid mob demanding everyone suspected of a crime spend time in jail until proven innocent.
- jrmg 4y agoYes! Pre-trial imprisonment is not meant to be a punishment!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jquery 4y agoHow is SBF not considered a serious flight risk? Why is he being treated like some upstanding citizen, above trying to escape decades in prison?
- rosnd 4y agoHe waived extradition, definitely makes him seem like much less of a flight risk.
- jboy55 4y agoSo what you're saying is I can get a selfie with SBF and Elizabeth Holmes in a Starbucks in Palo Alto? Since even though Holmes was sentenced to 11 1/4 years, she has until April 23rd 2023 to turn herself in.
- apengwin 4y agoyes!!! though you're more likely to catch them at Philz, or the Verve on University ave
- nytesky 4y agoHow likely is he to pull an exit scam like cotton? a friend if the family was willing to sign a bond for $250m, I’m sure they have the means to find a doctor and a body and have him die from glutton poisoning or whatever weird diet he was on. Granted Cotton was in India so records are murkier, but SBF probably had 2 orders of magnitude more money hidden away on keys only he knows. He won’t even need plastic surgery — a decent haircut and no one would recognize him. https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/31/what-netflixs-quadrigacx-documentary-gets-right-and-wrong-about-one-of-cryptos-worst-scandals/?outputType=amp https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/03/31/what-netflixs-q...
- tasty_freeze 4y agoThe problem isn't that a rich guy can make bail. The real issue is that so many poor people are trapped by bail bonds they can not meet or which put extreme financial strain on a family that is barely making it to begin with. Part of it is that the bail bond industry can afford lobbyists, and probably a bigger part is that "tough on crime" grandstanding by politicians is nearly always a winning strategy. It is too easy to claim a politician that advances any kind of reform will be pilloried as someone who is trying to put savage criminals back on the street, your street.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoThe fact that bail bonds are even a private industry... ...I don't get it. In my country, technically there's a bail bond of $500 due to an archaic law, advanced to you by the Police, and you have to pay them it if you breach bail conditions. In reality, if you breach bail, your arrest will become high priority, and you're very likely going into the remand wing once arrested until you can appear in front of a judge, and then you'll also be facing a charge for breaching bail, in addition to the charges you already faced. And breaching bail is an offense that nearly guarantees that the judge will remand you into custody until your trial date, which could be 3 - 6 months away. So there's no need for monetary bonds, because the existing consequences are severe enough.
- edgyquant 4y agoThe problem is bail though. Bail bondsman are a life saver to a person who can’t afford their bail and have to work in the morning. Obviously being rough comes with the job, but most bondsman aren’t villains they provide a service during a time of bad policy.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The problem is bail though. No, the problem is not conditional release (bail), or even the financial penalty (bail amount) that is assigned in advance in the even the conditions are broken. The particular conditions may be problematic, especially when they (say) require, in practice, either a deposit or other security in the full value of the potential penalty or a contract with a licensed bail agent (which some states, and the federal system, generally do not.) But… > Bail bondsman are a life saver to a person who can’t afford their bail and have to work in the morning. Obviously being rough comes with the job, but most bondsman aren’t villains they provide a service during a time of bad policy. …except that bail bondsmen are a major force lobbying state governments for the policies which create the need. They are working very hard to set up, and preserve, the conditions that make them seem like lifesavers.
- pyuser583 4y agoIf a judge can honestly say “I believe this person isn’t a danger and will show up for trial” they should be required to grant bail.
- michaelteter 4y agoMy question is, how did he get so deep into obvious trouble (at least it should have been obvious to those close to him) without his presumably intelligent parents not having some kind of intervention? Surely they didn't know enough to be aware of what he was doing... The whole situation seems like a lesson about the dangers of hubris and entitlement.
- gnicholas 4y agoThe NYT is reporting that: > In that case, his parents’ house in Palo Alto, Calif., which was used to secure the bond, could be seized by the government. Interestingly, the home is not located in Palo Alto, but in Stanford — which is a critical difference because it means that his parents (both Stanford faculty members) likely do not actually own the property. Stanford sells time-limited ground leases to faculty, which means that they cannot sell the property (or promise it) to anyone who is not a qualifying (tenure line) faculty member, or the university itself. I don't know if the NYT is misreporting this, or if SBF's parents have signed a document promising something that they legally cannot make good on (grant rights in a property that they do not themselves hold). I'd guess it's the former, but who knows! Source: I am familiar with Stanford's faculty housing programs and live in restricted faculty housing
- AustinDev 4y agoNow this is wild. Is their property owned by Stanford? How could we get proof of this. It'd make this all completely different as you imply.
- gnicholas 4y agoMy understanding is that yes, the land is owned by Stanford. They would have granted a ground lease that lasts some period of decades when the home was purchased (reportedly in 1991). Rules may have been different then, but I don't think they were handing out fee simple interests at that time either.
- gene91 4y agoLately, a 3000 sq ft house in Stanford (which can be sold on the market, but only to eligible faculty and employees) sells for over $2.5M, whereas a similar home in Palo Alto (which can be sold on the market, to any one) sells for around $5M. As a result, while what you said is true, I don’t think it matters that much. At the end of the day, it’s an asset that’s worth millions of dollars.
- gnicholas 4y ago
- Godel_unicode 4y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u_aLESDql1U https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u_aLESDql1U
- 8bitsrule 4y agoTouch tip of thumb to tips of index and third fingers. Slide thumb-tip back-and-forth between fingertips.
- hellothere1337 4y agoHe said he was sorry, I think its time for us to forgive him, he didnt know what he was doing
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thayne 4y ago> But you can still see the impact of wealth. First, because Sam Bankman-Fried broke the law by (allegedly) stealing billions of dollars instead of by being paid a hundred bucks to transport half a key of black tar heroin, there was no presumption he should be detained. That reflects society’s values. I think it is more accurate to say that reflects the values of the people in power. And that is primarily people who have wealth.
- agluszak 4y agoI'm not from the US, could someone explain to me this part: "in federal criminal cases, bail is governed by the Bail Reform Act of 1984. That scheme starts out with a presumption that a person should be released on their own recognizance or on an unsecured appearance bond — that is, a promise to pay a certain amount of money if they fail to show up for court.". If someone fails to show up in court not because he forgets, but because, for example, he flees the country, how is he expected to keep the promise? In case of SBF, as I understand, his parents and some other people would have to pay some part of that 250m (because they can't afford the entire sum before going bankrupt), but is that it?
- twblalock 4y agoEveryone who would be on the hook to pay his bail, including his own parents, has a very powerful incentive to make sure he makes his trial appearance. In addition to that, there probably isn't anywhere he could flee to that would not put him on trial or send him back to the US. FTX screwed customers in many countries. Plus, the guy doesn't have any money. He lost access to FTX. How would he pay for his escape? Why would anyone be willing to risk helping him? Everyone who had anything to do with him or FTX is trying very hard right now to distance themselves. Given all of that, I don't think it's unreasonable for a judge to decide that SBF's flight risk is below the bar that would normally be required to deny bail.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoWhen Madoff pled guilty, he wanted to be released to his NYC penthouse while waiting for sentencing. The Court refused and he was sent to the Manhatten Correctional Center. Now I could be wrong on this, time will tell, but I was right about SBF being released on bail (Madoff was released, too): SBF is going to plead guilty. If he does, then, like Madoff, he will be sent to a detention center while awaiting sentencing. SBF should be thankful that he gets to spend one last xmas with his family. BTW, Judge Abrams has now recused herself from this case citing a perceived conflict of interest. Not sure how long it will take for this to hit the news. Her husband works for a law firm that represented FTX.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoCorrection: s/FTX/BlockFi/
- cm2187 4y agoThat still doesn't say how they got to 250m. Is it the norm to set the amount to an incredibly large number that neither the defendant or the family has any hope to pay? Or does the judge expect 250m to be in the realm of what he can pay?
- coolspot 4y agoYou don’t pay $250M, you borrow that amount providing some collateral proportional to your risk of flight. It is basically an insurance policy with $250M payoff. Or an option.
- cm2187 4y agoI understand but you need to be able to borrow $250m. I can't borrow 250m. No one is going to allow me to borrow 250m unless I have some serious assets, which is not what the article suggests.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThere’s an entire industry devoted to providing these loans and hunting the people who don’t show up at court and therefore cost the “bank” the loan.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I understand but you need to be able to borrow $250m. No, you just have to have the court believe the combination of penalty, security, sureties, and non-financial conditions is sufficient to assure appearance. In some state systems, the court may be constrained to only accept full secured bond when there is a penalty amount (or, if not so constrained, may have a practice of generally doing so), but that is absolutely not a requirement or the normal practice in the federal system.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> You don’t pay $250M, you borrow that amount providing some collateral proportional to your risk of flight. No, you don't. Even with a fully secured bail bond (which is not a norm in all US jurisdictions), you (or someone acting as your surety) provides the court with a legal claim on property with a value at least equal to the bail amount. When (as is the norm in many syate systems) you engage a bail agent as a surety, the fee may be risk sensitive, or it may be a fixed percentage set by law, depending on state law.
- twblalock 4y agoThe system is working, and it's working faster than normal! First, the conspiracy theorists said SBF would never be charged or arrested. Apparently he "bribed" politicians. (But even if that was true, how would one expect a politician to be corrupt enough to be bribed, yet noble enough to stick their neck out to assist a fellow criminal who got caught?) Then, they said he would not be extradited. Turns out he wanted to be, because being processed through the US justice system was preferable to being in jail in the Bahamas. Now, they are saying he will somehow manage to escape, even though nobody has an incentive to help him do that, and many people involved have very strong incentives not to help him -- and if he really wanted to go into hiding, he could have done that anytime before he was arrested in the Bahamas. Once that nonsense is over with and he shows up for his trial, people will claim that sure, SBF will be tried, but he won't be convicted! However, several of his close colleagues have just pleaded guilty to the same kind of crimes he is accused of, which is a very strong indication that they are cooperating with the prosecution and giving them all sorts of information. If he is convicted, people will say, sure, he was found guilty, but his sentence will just be a slap on the wrist! The same was said about Elizabeth Holmes, and it was wrong. On the other hand, the non-conspiracy-theorist mind sees the system working the way it is supposed to. Guy commits financial crime. Guy gets charged, arrested, and extradited to the US to stand trial for that crime -- in record time! It normally takes the US government a lot longer to put such a complicated prosecution together. So, again, the system is working, and it's working faster than normal!
- nailer 4y agoSorry I’ve read the article and still don’t understand how a 4 million dollar house can be used as 250M bail.
- 2devnull 4y agoNetwork effects.
- snshn 4y agoMoney.
- marcell 4y agoWhat’s actually surprising is that even in a highbrow forum like HN people don’t understand basics of the US legal system, for example: innocent until proven guilty.
- fmx 4y agoSo a defendent accused of massive fraud was released on the mere promise to pay $250 million if he does not show up to court? Money that he himself says he does not have? I get most of the reasoning, but that part really makes no sense to me. Yes, his parents would be bankrupted, too, but still.