13 ms·
Not really, because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version -- the ownership
by crazygringo 4y ago
Not really, because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version -- the ownership model of software can be awfully feast-or-famine for developers' income, it's a very tough/risky business model.
Generally speaking, I'm happy to pay a subscription because this way I get a steady stream of all the updates, and it's much more likely the company has a sustainable business model. And I don't have to agonize over whether paying for a major upgrade is worth it.
Not to mention that a yearly subscription is cheaper than buying outright, and I find that in some cases I no longer need the software, or now prefer to switch to a competitor. So I feel like in the end, a greater proportion of my money goes to the software companies who have actually continued to earn it.
By this point, the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album.
- ngoilapites 4y agoAgonise? Seriously, capitalism is based on your decision power, and you give it away and call it Agonise? I might need to write a new book, about consumer disempowerment phenomena.
- lapcat 4y ago> I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version Do you have examples? Most new businesses fail regardless of their business model, so you'd have to argue that this phenomenon was somehow worse for non-subs. > Not to mention that a yearly subscription is cheaper than buying outright Not in the long term.
- Gigachad 4y agoNot going out of business, but on the iPad there is a drawing app called Procreate which is a one time purchase. It’s decent, but in the two years I’ve had it, nothing has really improved and there is a whole lot missing or to be desired. Meanwhile some subscription apps have come to the iPad and they are absolutely packed with every feature you could possibly want. For any well run company, the more the users are paying, the better the product is likely to be. With a once off purchase, any future improvements are based on a Ponzi scheme requiring constant new users which is unsustainable.
- lapcat 4y agoBy this principle, every physical product in the world would be "a Ponzi scheme".
- duckmysick 4y agoI thought about it and a lot of physical products we use everyday are either perishables themselves or require perishables for a regular maintenance. Yes, we aren't forced to buy from the exact same brands like in a subscription model. Practically, we end up buying the same products in a predictable schedule, to keep the wheel spinning.
- lapcat 4y agoA lot? Furniture? Clothing? Cars? Electronics? Appliances? Physical books? [takes off glasses to think] Glasses? Physical products wear out eventually, but they can last for many years. They're not necessarily perishable.
- duckmysick 4y agoYes, for the second category I mentioned: "require perishables for a regular maintenance". Cleaning products, washing powder, fabric softener, bleach, fuel, windshield wiper fluid, tires, batteries. Books, sure, they seem to be maintenance-free. I guess glasses too.
- lapcat 4y agoCould you explain how clothing needing to be cleaned is relevant to subscriptions? After all, you don't have to buy the cleaning products from the clothing manufacturer. Same for car tires, etc. So the clothing companies and car companies aren't making any extra money from this.
- throwaway2037 4y agoI agree with your original post. Very thoughtful. The subscription version of glasses is contact lenses. Plus, most people need a tweak to their vision prescription every year (or two), so they need to update lenses.
- AlexandrB 4y agoIt's so much worse when a subscription business fails. You can lose access to your data with very little notice to migrate. At least standalone software keeps working for a while after the company maintaining it is gone.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- redox99 4y agoThat's a cloud vs desktop distinction, not a subscription vs buy once. If Adobe went out of business, you wouldn't lose any local stuff.
- sllabres 4y ago"Well, is officially illegal has an Adobe products if you live in Venezuela" (Okt 2019) [1] From [2] (due to sanctions from the US to Venezuela) [1] https://twitter.com/AenderLara/status/1181291242531020800/photo/1 https://twitter.com/AenderLara/status/1181291242531020800/ph... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/7/20904030/adobe-venezuela-photoshop-behance-us-sanctions https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/7/20904030/adobe-venezuela-...
- sebazzz 4y agoThat’s really a DRM issue for non-SaaS software: how do you activate software.
- aussiesnack 4y agoI don't have many subscriptions (most of my software is FOSS, and I don't do media streaming), but the few I have I'm quite happy about. None of them are corporate behemoths, they create quality products that I like to use, as far as I can see from the outside they're decent companies that treat their employees well. I quite enjoy the fact that I can make a small contribution to these products/companies continuing to be sustainable. And I'm at the extreme end of anti-capitalism. I'd prefer to see everything employee/citizen-owned. But in the world we actually live in today, I see no inherent problem with subscriptions. There can be contingent problems. I won't, for example, subscribe to any music streaming services because they give musicians an unfair deal. But that's little to do with subscriptions per se.
- phrom 4y agoYou don't have to agonize over paying for major upgrades because you're being made to always pay, whether you get an upgrade or not. It's a nice bonus when you get an upgrade for your payments. But other times you're an Adobe subscriber and lose access to your colors, because turns out you should also be subscribing to Pantone for those. And who knows what you'll have to pay for next.
- Kuinox 4y agoExcept as a user, the next version had to be better, or I wouldn't pay for it. Now they can just downgrade my product, and I have to continue paying for it.
- flandish 4y agoLike what happened with Stronglifts 5x5.. yep.
- gog 4y agoWhat happened? Isn't that just a body weight exercise routine?
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoI don't know anything about it, besides knowing that my dad and brother used to use that app but switched away from it for some reason.
- flandish 4y agoNo, but the app migrated from purchase to “life supporter” to subscription with each prior tier getting less. Now, “buy version 1.3.0” I can get not including updates post 1.3.x. But “life supporter” faded to “subscribe” after more time went by. Much like the mirc thing really. I kinda miss the days of “buy version X. Get X. X always works… tease with upgrades to get user to buy upgrade.”
- watt 4y agoOf course you do. It was fantastic while it lasted. It's not a great model for software developer though. I have no idea how Beyond Compare guy (scooter software) survives, for example. I paid for it once, maybe 10 years ago? He should've taken more money. I paid for Sublime Merge, but it's nowhere as useful or great (so far) as Beyond Compare.
- phendrenad2 4y ago
- thot_experiment 4y agoWhat the heck subscription models are you using? In my experience the software gets broken over time and you can't do anything about it, including RUN THE OLD VERSION WHICH WORKED. There's no longer as much incentive for companies to improve because they'll get paid anyway instead of payment being contingent on actually delivering something useful. Yes subscription models are good for developers, no this doesn't make the software better, it makes it worse. (or at the very least to improve much slower) I basically pirate everything that requires a subscription now or us a FOSS alternative, even though there was a period of time where I would pay for software between when I was poor and had to pirate everything and now when I can afford to pay for subscriptions but the situation with lack of control over SaaS is so fucking untenable that I just can't. I don't believe SaaS is moral, it basically removes all the power from the consumer and allows the software providers to rake you over the coals over and over. I'm not interested in funding such things. I feel more comfortable with piracy than I do with SaaS on a philosophical level. SaaS companies don't innovate, they buy competitors because they're using an abusive business model with bad incentives. P.S. SaaS can probably be implemented in a decent way, and some SaaS does actually provide an ongoing service, but in general I believe my point stands.
- solardev 4y agoNot the OP, but I have to disagree too. Creative Cloud, IntelliJ, Figma, Google Workspace, Postman, Spotify, Vercel, Adguard, Google storage space, Alltrails, 1password.. They're all subscriptions and getting better all the time. Meanwhile it's the old purchased software like Windows and Office that get worse with every version.
- LaserDiscMan 4y agoI once worked in a small company developing niche but expensive Windows software. The company enjoyed (probably still enjoys) relatively limited competition in it's space. During start up, the program checks for the version of Windows which it's being run on and refuses to boot if it's different to the one specified for that version. This software was mainly sold to mid-large size companies, so although it could be trivially defeated with minimal reverse engineering, I doubt this was ever a real issue. Every new version of Windows that Microsoft released would coincide with many customers purchasing the latest version of our software.
- bombolo 4y agoI use debian and i get a steady stream of updates! And I also don't get microsoft bugging me every day to install windows 11.
- PetahNZ 4y agoI am on Ubuntu and it constantly bugs me to upgrade: > New release '20.04.5 LTS' available. > Run 'do-release-upgrade' to upgrade to it.
- bombolo 4y agoAt least it doesn't say you must buy a new computer to update :)
- ahepp 4y agoDespite being pretty similar under the hood, Ubuntu and Debian seem very different in their approach to this kind of thing. The Debian package manager telemetry is opt in, for example. Whereas iirc Ubuntu used to bundle an Amazon store in their default release? And who could forget that guy who got a cold call "hey, we saw you spun up a Ubuntu VM in Azure. Want to buy support?"
- joe_the_user 4y agoNot really, because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version Aside from the other points people raise, the idea that someone continuing to pay money for software is going to keep the company from going out of business seems misguided. I still subscribe, pay fucking money, to Meetup.com but over the years, despite a large subscriber base, the site become a buggy moribund piece of junk (but still the only thing in it's area). Such drift into worthless is typical for just about all subscriber software because software needs maintenance and because once a subscriber model reaches saturation point, the primary approach of management is to simply milk it for all the money possible by reducing labor costs to the minimum (look what Musk's doing to Twitter, it's not weird it's typical).
- dmitrygr 4y ago> I'm happy to pay a subscription because this way I get a steady stream of all the updates Who needs that? I use office 97 with Microsoft’s office converters package for modern formats. Super fast and does all I need I use photoshop cs2. Local. Fast. Offline Software can easily reach “good enough”. What is it with people today that makes them think that no updates or no recent changes is bad? I WANT my tools to be stable and not change from under me.
- chillfox 4y agoAnxiety about security would be my guess.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoCynical worry/prediction: companies still selling software, or that have a backlog of previously sold old versions people still use, have an incentive to publish detailed descriptions into security vulnerabilities they've already patched in the newer/current versions, but which they won't patch in the older versions.
- OkGoDoIt 4y agoStandalone software keeps working more or less forever regardless of the company. I still use Jasc Paint Shop Pro X from something like 15 years ago as my image editing software. It might not be as good as more modern software, but I know how to use it and I don’t need to retrain on something new, which means I can be very fast with whatever I need to do. Subscription-based software including updates is a downside as far as I’m concerned. Especially when they phone home and realize you’re not on the latest version and refused to work until you update. I don’t generally want to update. Stability and muscle memory is way too underrated in the tech world.
- hermitcrab 4y ago>Standalone software keeps working more or less forever regardless of the company. That may be true for Windows, but it isn't true for Mac (unless you never upgrade your computer). I have been writing and supporting the same piece of commercial software since 2005 on Windws and Mac. v1 of my software probably still works on Windows 11. Not a chance on Mac (it has gone PowerPc -> Intel -> Arm in that time!).
- urthor 4y agoThis is one of the joys of command line tools. They almost never stop working on you, and are far easier to maintain cross platform. Using the same thing on Mac at work and Linux at home is a joy. Increasingly, I actively try to use the command line approach to all my software. Not because it's better (often it... isn't. FFmpeg is actually remarkably annoying for example), but it's bloody reliable.
- pjmlp 4y agoThis is one of the joys of command line tools using fossilized UNIX APIs, that is.
- lamontcg 4y agoYeah the problem with software these days is the constant upgrade cycle. Own-it-for-life means "I expect free updates for the next 20 years" which as we've seen with the mIRC author isn't the best business model. Turns the software developer into indentured servitude to all the people who bought it in the past. The JetBrains model where you own it up need to rent it to get upgrades seems to work reasonably well, but given how languages like C# and Rust are moving forwards all the time you want get those upgrades. Since I want to see the developers doing that work for me, it seems rational that I should be paying them.
- acaloiar 4y agoI'm curious what you know about the mIRC author's story. As a former mIRC user, I imagine it's interesting lore from the shareware era. Writing mIRC scripts was some of the first "programming" I ever did. Good times.
- Izkata 4y agoThis was posted on here two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33864660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33864660
- lamontcg 4y agoI think this is a link to the mIRC issue: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33864660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33864660 (Whatever perf issue HN is happening makes it hard to figure out right now)
- hermitcrab 4y agoOffering free upgrades for life is almost always a terrible idea: https://successfulsoftware.net/2008/09/08/should-i-give-free-upgrades-for-life/ https://successfulsoftware.net/2008/09/08/should-i-give-free... And offering upgrades for life and then trying to backtrack on it is even worse.
- urthor 4y ago
- soulofmischief 4y agoI get that modern software is a living breathing thing, but it's absurd to compare that to music albums, which should not be constantly modified and reissued post-release.
- InCityDreams 4y ago...remasters? Conversion of tape to plastic to mp.... Newer, better(?), tech available for engineers. Zappa [iirc] made his plastic lp's 22 minutes a side as that gave the optimum wiggle room for needles, both at the presses and domestically. Led Zep (ahem) re-released an awful lot of original material.
- meatmanek 4y agoand anybody who cares about that (or just wants to support the artist) will buy the new version.
- soulofmischief 4y agoThat's not what I'd define as constantly. And I have no problem with an artist wanting to release their own music this way, but if it were the industry norm I imagine I'd find it insufferable.
- allarm 4y ago> And I don't have to agonize over whether paying for a major upgrade is worth it. What’s so agonizing about it? You check the release notes to see what’s been added, what’s been removed. Then check the reviews and make a simple decision. > as strange as "owning" a music album. Physical copies of music albums exist. It’s much stranger to me to rely on the streaming provider to listen to my favorite albums when everything in the streaming world can be removed tomorrow over some copyright issues.
- oytis 4y ago> the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album. Is it still alright to own a book?
- vinyl7 4y agoDon't give them any ideas. Could you imagine having to have separate subscriptions for O'Reilly, Shuster, and Penguin, etc.
- phrom 4y agoThey already got the idea. Look up the "O'Reilly Learning Platform"
- chillfox 4y agoUsed to be some of my favorite tech books, but these days it's so damn hard to figure out what books they still print if any, so I have mostly moved over to No Starch Press as my default goto for tech books.
- oytis 4y agoI find that alright actually. It gives one access to a lot of books, not just O'Reilly ones. You can scan trough a lot of books there, and buy paper copies (elsewhere) of those you want for your bookshelf
- phrom 4y agoOh, I don't mind it either. It's not like they're stopping to sell paper copies. I used it a long time ago, my employer had a company account, it was great.
- b1ue64 4y ago> as strange as "owning" a music album. praying that this is a joke rn
- khiqxj 4y ago> Generally speaking, I'm happy to pay a subscription because this way I get a steady stream of all the updates, and it's much more likely the company has a sustainable business model. software was (marginally) better before than now. congratulations, you fell for their trick
- pdntspa 4y ago"You'll Own Nothing and You'll Be Happy"
- enw 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200420054424/https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/11/shopping-i-can-t-really-remember-what-that-is/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200420054424/https://www.wefor...
- urthor 4y agoAs a user, software companies are usually not producing good enough software to justify paying for the price of incremental updates ;). In many ways, I feel much software needs to transition to "be maintained," very quickly. So much engineering time and energy is spent releasing not very useful, incremental features. Engineers... ironically, need to give up sooner in many cases. The hubris of "the thing I make is genuinely useful, surely" is the profession's Pandora's box. Pride is most dangerous sin etc etc.
- prepend 4y ago> because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version Really? How many companies did you see do this? Because I see lots of companies still around who have been selling software for decades. Because the marginal cost of software is near zero it’s possible to make money off upgrades and new products because it’s not a linear function of labor to customers. I think it’s more profitable to charge as a service. Adobe and Microsoft weren’t at any risk of bankruptcy when they switched to subscription.
- mancerayder 4y agoSoftware companies made no money before subscriptions? How did they last decades?
- eb0la 4y agoThe sold licenses, and yearly maintenance. The subscription model killed the one-off purchase of licenses. Suddenly if you didn't have a subscription like Red hat did, you had to pay a lot in CAPEx plus maintenance. That meant that even with the same TCO you were out of business.
- roody15 4y ago“ By this point, the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me” Just my two cents but your comment here seems like it was pulled out of a future corporate dystopian novel. Most “subscription” models I see these days are more cash grabs than actual continued support and feature enhancements. Just take a look at the ios app store if you want to see simple apps exploiting a “subscription” model.
- SanjayMehta 4y ago> By this point, the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album. I still own the very first music album I bought, an LP purchased in 1979. I still play it on the same turntable which my dad gave me.
- yucky 4y ago> Not to mention that a yearly subscription is cheaper than buying outright This is false. Software companies aren't switching to subscription models to make less money. > the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album. This is so non-sensical I'm going to assume it's a typo.
- porknubbins 4y agoHow old are you that the idea of owning a copy of music is strange? Do you feel same way about books? I still buy albums and books that I consider particularly excellent.
- lumost 4y agoMy two cents is that this is why big tech outcompetes small tech. At a small tech you need great people to build the core product.. then there might be a period where the business rightfully just wants to get paid. Going from layoff to layoff sucks for the engineers. At a big tech you can just transfer to the newest thing.
- paultopia 4y agoI don't think this is correct. Two points against it: 1) Upgrades aren't all that valuable in lots of cases. Why should software require constant upgrades to work right? Lots of rarely upgraded software works just fine. The easy example here is Sublime Text. One of the best text editors, bar none. It had how many years between major upgrades? And old versions work just fine. Maybe for security sensitive software constant upgrades are important, because there are adversarial actors trying to break it. But that doesn't apply to things like Photoshop. 2) My best guess is that the real reason for companies moving to the subscription model is effectively as a form of seller-provided financing. Remember how much Photoshop used to cost when you could buy it? After googling around, I see prices in the $700-800 range. Now it's like 20 bucks a month, so Adobe makes the same amount after a few years of a subscription, but in addition probably gets a lot more casual users who don't quite realize that the monthly payment still adds up over the end. (Edit) Also, one other point on the whole notion of software companies going out of business because people didn't buy the next version. Isn't that just the same thing as planned obsolescence in the non-software world? Don't we get mad when non-software companies insist on forcing people to re-buy their products over and over again in order to make money? Also, how do non-software companies manage to pull it off? Honda cars last a famously long time, yet we don't see people shedding tears for them because once you buy a Civic you don't have to buy the "upgrade" in a year.
- altereds 4y ago>Not really, because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version -- the ownership model of software can be awfully feast-or-famine for developers' income, it's a very tough/risky business model. If the Monthly Recurring Revenue is a make or break for companies that provide the software, then inversely the Monthly Recurring Expense would also be a make or break factor for customers or business using the service. Buy once may reduce the overall cost for customers and allow them to invest in upgrades only when their revenue is better. There has to be balance and empathy for the customer too..
- trinsic2 4y agoIMHO it feels like the subscription model in many cases (not all of them) protects a developer from having to innovate and deliver other products. In the real world you shouldn't expect to get unlimited income from one type of product regardless of Whether or not you are maintaining it. There is a saturation point.
- Rastonbury 4y agoThat's not true at all, for most modern software with newer products, competition on product and winning competitors customers using X new features is ruthless. Messing up your product or falling behind will send your company to the grave, unless you are Adobe.
- sebazzz 4y agoAgreed - every time a license or a prepretual subscription (like JetBrains) needs to be repurchased is a natural moment to evaluate the usage and state of the software in question: Do we still like it, do we still use it as much, do new versions offer enough improvement to upgrade. If not, we don’t renew. With subscription based software there is no set moment to do that, so there are naturally a lot of sleeping subscriptions and otherwise subscriptions which are rarely re-evaluated on its value. In my opinion this makes the vendor lazy.
- seanp2k2 4y agoI feel that the “support / updates” subscription model allows a constant stream of income for devs while still allowing one to “own” a given version. There are things like Bitwig (DAW) that sell the initial product for $300ish and that comes with 12 months of updates and priority support. You get to “keep” the latest version that falls within that update window (and IIRC that means major versions, so you get any future point releases / security updates). If you want to renew, it’s something around $120-160 for another 12 months of updates. This seems more or less fair to me; active users who continue to benefit from updates contribute to development, and people who just need it for a while plus occasional users not getting that much value out of it get to use that again in the future if they need, without “losing” anything unlike with traditional subscriptions.
- bhauer 4y ago> Not really, because I saw too many software companies go out of business because not enough people wound up upgrading to the next major version -- the ownership model of software can be awfully feast-or-famine for developers' income, it's a very tough/risky business model. How is a subscription model any less volatile to the long-term support of an application from the end-user's perspective? To my mind, a subscription service is equally likely to close up shop if the subscriber count dips low enough, which is something that can happen as easily as a "new version" failing to sell well in a purchase model. The downside is compounded, however, in a subscription model because when a subscription service fails, every user is impacted, both those who would have upgraded had it been a purchase and those who would have kept plugging away with an outdated version. At least with the purchase model, abandonware continues to function for some time. Funny you should mention owning music because I also prefer to do exactly that rather than pay for a subscription service. And this preference is for two reasons: (a) I like being able to use the music where-ever and whenever I want, and (b) I like that more money goes to the artist via Bandcamp than say, Spotify.
- torgian 4y agoYou must be young. I would much rather own the software, books, and music I buy in a hard copy form than a "digital" form that can be removed without my consent.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoYou are contradicting yourself. You cannot have it both be cheaper and have the developers earn more money.
- magic_hamster 4y agoI feel like this comment was written by the head of monetization from Mythic Quest. It's clearly very biased against the consumer. > a yearly subscription is cheaper than buying outright That depends on how often you buy. If you bought every update for full price, maybe you're right. If not, the consumer has much more freedom to decide on their course of action, consider alternatives or just save money while sticking to the old version. Consumers are completely deprived of choice with the subscription model. > in some cases I no longer need the software, or now prefer to switch to a competitor Have you met Adobe? Those guys are great. They let you pre purchase an entire year of their subscription with no other options. Oh and you can't cancel in the middle, or rather you can, but don't expect a refund. It's so great they have this business model that allows them to rake in money while basically handcuffing their customers to their plans! The shareholders are ecstatic. > the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album. This is starting to feel like a generational gap. I don't know how old you are, but perhaps being accustomed to subscriptions from a young age will make you more tolerant towards this business model. I think that anyone who owned their own music, and software, having total liberty and no dependencies on when you and how you can access your stuff, will find letting go of this liberty a difficult prospect.
- saiya-jin 4y agoTo sum it up - good for the companies, not so good for many users. I fail to grasp why as a user I should care about increasing salaries at given company though, my priorities are elsewhere, even orthogonal since its my cash they so desperately want. The company part - just look at how Adobe increased profits when they moved to subscription model. Many vocal users hated it since day 1, but majority goes and buys it even if they complain, even if it costs them much more long term. Why? Well if you are a photographer, you will need Lightroom or Photoshop as today as in 10 years. Nobody at Adobe cares that you would be perfectly fine with same version as purchased, not enough cash can be squeezed out like that. As for users part, it has 2 subparts - quite a few really benefit since they get cheaply access to otherwise expensive tools (like say editing 2 videos per year in Premiere if we stay in Adobe realm). But most simply see increased TCO long term on product they are sort of 'stuck' with, in sense they have workflow and tool they are good at, fast, and understand it, possibly even paid for some plugins or similar. Very few people migrate away from Lightroom for example, competition would have to create something remarkably similar which normally is not how product strategy looks like. At least they didn't start requiring you to move all your assets to their cloud in order to use them, that's outright slavery sold as added value. I am sure companies like Adobe would be very happy to put this in place. So yeah, companies do it because they can, if they feel that market will accept this move and move on, and not stop using its products. Kind of semi-monopolies. I do expect Microsoft will come up with similar model for OS if it hadn't already done so.
- kmano8 4y ago> But most simply see increased TCO long term on product they are sort of 'stuck' with, in sense they have workflow and tool they are good at, fast, and understand it This is my exact issue with lightroom. I have 9 yrs of edit history, and workflows setup + a mobile app that seamlessly imports everything from my phone into my main catalog alongside my "big camera" shots. If there was a competitor that migrated all of this cleanly, I'd be happy to modify my workflows to break out of the lock in.
- taffronaut 4y agoI get what you're saying but I'd like to highlight an example of the opposite business model. For 25 years, Image Line have been shipping the FLStudio DAW as a one-off purchase with free lifetime updates, and since I've been receiving those updates for a significant chunk of those 25 years since I bought the Producer Edition, it seems pretty sustainable. In their words "Why? Because we believe you should get the program you paid for, bug-fixed and updated for as long as we develop FL Studio." [1] [1] https://www.image-line.com/fl-studio/lifetime-free-updates/ https://www.image-line.com/fl-studio/lifetime-free-updates/
- ryandrake 4y agoI’ve never understood this desire to keep having sortware get updated over and over. Ideally, I want to buy a working version of a software once and never update it again. I want that software to work the same way as it did when I bought it, forever. I don’t want to worry about waking up one day and finding that, because the company’s chief designer needed to do something to justify his salary, the whole UI of my software was redone and everything was moved around. I don’t want to find that it now runs 2x slower because an update brought unwanted features. It’s like buying a hammer and a week later the handle is shorter and it turned into a hatchet.
- ratorx 4y agoHaving the ability to do seamless frequent updates means that bad software can cause excess churn. They are not intrinsically linked. The problem with not having solid infrastructure for updates is security issues. Of course, there is a class of software where this is not a problem, but determining whether software falls into that category is pretty difficult given the structure of modern OS and the propensity for things like static linking. You have 3 choices: * leave software vulnerable. * track security vulnerabilities is all your software and its dependencies and manually update. * Bite the bullet and have robust auto-update infrastructure. I’d argue the bigger problem is that implementing robust, dependable and user configurable auto updates with easy rollbacks etc. is a complex problem, so every piece of software ends up implementing its own shitty variant that sacrifices user control and doesn’t distinguish between necessity and churn.
- Ylpertnodi 4y ago>that implementing robust, dependable and user configurable auto updates with easy rollbacks etc. is a complex problem So very true, but the complexities can be considerably reduced by not forcing updates - whether security, dependability, or UX. So many updates I see nowadays are the very 'churn' you mention.
- ryandrake 4y agoI'd be 100% in favor of automatic software updates if there were some guarantee that it was just used for security fixes and nothing else. But if you leave it up to the software vendor to decide what gets automatically pushed, you inevitably backslide back to where we are today where everything gets jammed down the user's throat.
- ahartmetz 4y agoIt kinda seems like most software has arrived in the area of diminishing returns, right? Sometimes, the next version even gets worse. So there either aren't so many new useful features to put into the next version and / or the implementation complexity gets overwhelming, so it's only possible to add new useful features with disproportionate effort... It's disappointing - is what we have really all that is possible...? I actually don't think so, but what will improve the situation? Some kind of AI thing? With my FOSS desktop software background, I think the disappearance of "applications" in favor of a more integrated system also holds some promise. Without companies, there is no need to have marketable distinct pieces of software.
- scaradim 4y agoBy these days, what is worth "owning"? What do assure yourself that you "own" instead of having a subscription of?
- user_7832 4y agoThe entire comment feels weird, but this part strikes me as particularly odd - > By this point, the idea of "owning" software feels positively archaic to me, as strange as "owning" a music album. You would have to be very young to not have owned (physical) music albums - and I'm a pretty young person myself. I really hope this isn't a bot/paid PR thing, because boy would someone have wasted their money.
- t0suj4 4y agoSubscriptions are fine for services I can live without. The barrier to entry is lower than a full cost of the software and I can cancel the subscription whenever I want. This is to me a win-win situation. I would absolutely reject a subscription for using my operating system though. So yeah, subscriptions are fine but not for everything.
- timka 4y agoHow old are you?