34 ms·
Who knew the first AI battles would be fought by artists?
- dredmorbius 4y agoContext, too long to fit into the HN title: "In order to protest AI image generators stealing artists work to train AI models, the artists are deliberately generating AI art based on the IP of corporations that are most sensitive to protecting it."
- yreg 4y agoInteresting approach, but is drawing fan art illegal? I would think that generating those images is okay by Disney, the same as if I painted them. The moment Disney would object is when I start selling them on merch, at which point it is irrelevant how they were created. Am I mistaken?
- onetrickwolf 4y agoFan art is pretty much illegal or infringement actually it's just not really enforced by most companies. There are some caveats for fair use but generally most fan art could be successfully taken down if a company was motivated enough in my opinion. Nintendo is pretty notorious for this but it has rarely gone to court as most people are too scared to fight takedown requests.
- Taywee 4y agoCopyright isn't level legal vs illegal, it's infringing vs non-infringing. Fan art very often could be argued to be infringing, but no company has any reason to pursue it in the vast majority of cases, so they just don't. It's very confusing, especially when you have to consider trademark as related but separate.
- jefftk 4y agoI don't get your distinction: copyright infringement is illegal, so "infringing" implies "illegal"
- dredmorbius 4y agoInfringement carries both civil (noncriminal) and criminal proscriptions and liabilities under much law, e.g., under US law, 17 USC Chapter 5: <https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/chapter-5 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/chapter-5>
- Taywee 4y agoFrom that link, criminal copyright infringement depends on specific circumstances that don't directly apply here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/506 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/506
- dredmorbius 4y agoIt's unclear whether "here" refers to the artists spoofing Disney, or other actors pirating / duplicating artists' work for commercial use. In the former case, I'd agree. In the second, there's a clear violation of 17 USC 506(a)(1)(A).
- Taywee 4y agoIt's civil vs criminal law. Illegal usually implies breaking a law and committing a crime. Copyright infringement is a civil matter, not criminal.
- dredmorbius 4y agoFalse. <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33999561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33999561>
- astrange 4y agoArtists have a complicated ethical system where 1. reposting/tracing a solo artist's images without "citing the artist" is "stealing" (copyright violation) 2. imitating their style is also "stealing" but 3. drawing fanart of any series without asking is fine and 4. any amount of copyright violation is not only fine but encouraged as long as it's from a corporation. The punishment for breaking any of these rules is a lot of people yell at you on Twitter. Unfortunately, they've been at it so long that they now think these are actual laws of the universe, although of course they have pretty much nothing to do with the actual copyright law. That actual law doesn't care if you're selling it or not either, at least not as a bright line test. (Japanese fanartists have a lot more rules, like they won't produce fan merch of a series if there is official merch that's the same kind of object, or they'll only sell fan comics once on a specific weekend, and the really legally iffy ones have text in the back telling you to burn after reading or at least not resell it. Some more popular series like Touhou have explicit copyright grants for making fanart as long as you follow a few rules. Western fanartists don't read or respect any of these rules.)
- dotnet00 4y agoJapan doesn't have fair use, so the only thing ensuring that copyright owners don't go after fanartists is that fanart is generally either beneficial to them or is not worth going after. However that would change if the artist were attempting to directly interfere with their revenue, which is why they won't do things like producing imitations of merch. Copying an artist's style isn't in and of itself looked down upon, any artist will tell you that doing so is an important part of figuring out what aspects of it one likes for their own style. The problem with AI copying it is that the way the vast majority of users are using it isn't in artistic expression. The majority of them are simply spamming images out in an attempt to gain a popularity "high" from social media, without regard for any of the features of typical creative pursuits (an enjoyment of the process, an appreciation for other's effort, a desire to express something through their creativity, having some unique intentional and unintentional identifying features). Honestly maybe the West messed up having such broad fair use protections since it seems people really have no respect for any creative effort, judging by all the AI art spam and all the shortsighted people acting smug about it despite the questions around it being pretty important to have a serious conversation about, especially for pro-AI folk. The AI art issue has several difficult problems that we are seemingly too immature to deal with, it makes it clear how screwed we'd be as a society if anything approaching true AGI happened to be stumbled upon anytime soon.
- gwd 4y agoBut the premise is just bad law. Disney does, in fact, hold a copyright on the Mickey Mouse character (at least until the end of 2023) [1]. It doesn't matter where the art comes from. Anyone making copies of something with Mickey Mouse in it -- whether drawn by a Disney artist, or drawn by someone else, or "drawn" by an AI -- is violating their copyright (at least for another year). On the other hand, nobody owns a copyright on a specific style. If I go study how to make art in the style of my favorite artist, that artist has no standing to sue me for making art in their style. So why would they have standing to sue for art generated by an AI which is capable of making art in their style? [1] https://fishstewip.com/mickey-mouse-copyright-expires-at-the-end-of-2023fishbits-mini-article-volume-22-issue-18/ https://fishstewip.com/mickey-mouse-copyright-expires-at-the...
- dredmorbius 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33999491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33999491
- agomez314 4y agoProbably because they disdain the use of AI being used to copy their IP and distribute it at "machine" scale? Not an artist myself but can imagine I'd be pissed off that a bot is replicating my art with random changes. HOWEVER, if a person were to ask for permission to use my pictures to feed into an AI to generate a number of images, and that person _selected_ a few and decided to sell them, I wouldn't have a problem with that. Something to do with the permission provided to the artist and an editing/filtering criteria being used by a human makes me feel ok with such use.
- alxlaz 4y agoWhat you're describing is basically copyright, which is exactly what artists are demanding: the legal protection to which they are entitled to. Edit: Silicon Valley exceptionalism seems to preclude some thought leaders in the field to remember the full definition of copyright: it's an artist's exclusive right to copy, distribute, adapt, display, and perform a creative work. A number of additional provisions, like fair use, are meant to balance artists' rights against public interest. Private commercial interest is not meant to be covered by fair use. No one is disputing that everyone, including companies in the private sector, is entitled to using artists' images for AI research. But things like e.g. using AI-generated images for promotional purposes are not research, and not covered by fair use. You want to use the images for that, great -- ask for permission, and pay royalties. Don't mooch.
- phpisthebest 4y agoCopyright (in the US) also includes fair use provisions of which education and research is a fair use of copyrighted work for which no permission from the artist is needed
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y ago> fair use provisions of which education and research is a fair use I don't think people are debating fair use for education and research. It's the obvious corporate and for profit use which many see coming that is the issue. Typically, licensing structures were a solution for artists, but "AI" images seem to enable for-profit use by skirting around who created the image by implying the "AI" did, a willful ignorance of the way that the image was generated/outputted.
- rvz 4y agoPeople who are not techies and have a clue about Stable Diffusion and DALL-E being trained on copyrighted images without their permission or attribution / credit knew this? This was absolutely unsurprising [0] [1]. Stability AI knew they would be sued to the ground if they trained their AI generating music equivalent called 'Dance Diffusion' model on thousands of musicians without their permission and used public domain music instead. So of course they think it is fine to do it to artists copyrighted images without their permission or attribution, as many AI grifters continue to drive everything digital to zero. That also includes Copilot being trained on AGPL code. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33902341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33902341 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33005559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33005559
- phpisthebest 4y agoAnything that weakens copyright is something that should be supported. Copyright has expanded well beyond its original goals to in fact be a harm to those goals Copyright (in the US) was NOT in fact created to protect creators, it was to encourage creation and advance science. Today copyright is being used to curb and monopolize creation and prevent advancement (case in point this very story)
- crote 4y agoOn the other hand, copyleft licenses are being used to protect creators. Without copyright protection, what is stopping companies from blatantly violating even more open-source licenses?
- phpisthebest 4y agonote I never said anything about elimination of copyright completely, I said weaken it. The original copyright term was for 14 years, not for Life.
- cardanome 4y agoI don't see the point. There is a copyright (and in that regard most of these images are fine) and then there is trademark which they might violate. Regardless, the human generating and publishing these images is obviously responsible to ensure they are not violating any IP property. So they might get sued by Disney. I don't get why the AI companies would be effected in any way. Disney is not suing Blender if I render an image of Mickey Mouse with it. Though I am sure that artists might find an likely ally in Disney against the "AI"'s when they tell them about their idea of making art-styles copyright-able Being able to monopolize art styles would be indeed a dream come true for those huge corporations.
- palata 4y agoWell Disney would probably sue Blender if there was a "generate Mickey Mouse model" button in it. It's not a totally fair comparison.
- subw00f 4y agoI'm sure it's easy to write an addon for that.
- gl-prod 4y agoThen the author of that addon would be liable. Not blender.
- SiempreViernes 4y agoTry it and see if it is blender or you as the addon creator that gets sued.
- idlehand 4y agoThese AI models are closer to Google in that regard, yes, you can instruct them to generate a Mickey Mouse image, but you can instruct them to generate any kind of image, just like you can search for anything on Google, including Mickey Mouse. When using these models you are essentially performing a search in the model weights.
- mattdesl 4y agoChallenging to navigate. These demonstrations are technically copyright infringement if done for financial gain (selling a T-shirt with Mickey Mouse icon). The same would be true if you were to draw by hand Mickey Mouse with a gun and sold it on a T-shirt. The only exception would be if it is a clear derivative, or satire, or parody, or personal use of course. The challenging part is that these artists are protesting the use of 'style' in AI synthesized media. That is, an artist's style is being targeted (or, even, multiple artist's styles are combined in a prompt to create a new AI-original work). This is not protected by copyright—if you draw a new scene in another artist's style, it would be perhaps unethical, but legally derivative work. If the artists who are challenging these AI systems do get there way, and they are able to legally copy-protect their "style" (like a certain way of brush strokes), this would inevitably backfire against them. To give an example: any artist whose work now too closely resembles the "style" of Studio Ghibli might be liable to copyright infringement, where before the work would be clearly derivative, or just influenced by another work, as is the case with most art over time.
- concordDance 4y agoTrademark infringement, not copyright.
- mattdesl 4y agoTechnically, sure, but the artists (who are not trademarking their work) are putting this in the context of copyright infringement.
- MetaWhirledPeas 4y agoChallenging legally, and challenging philosophically. I would think an artist doing it for the art would embrace the fleeting nature of all things, including art. Some artists demonstrate this by creating temporary art, or even throwing their own art away after making it. The desire to make money from art is certainly reasonable, but accepting a world where all art styles are immediately mimicked, where art is trivialized and commoditized, and where there's no recognition to be had let alone money... that's going to be a tough philosophical pill to swallow.
- turpialito 4y agoLuddites hopping on the bandwagon for reasons unclear to themselves. EDIT: Would Andy Warhol be sued by Campbell or Brillo?
- crote 4y agoNo, but his estate was sued by Lynn Goldsmith over his use of a photo of Prince - and lost. Warhol himself said that art "is anything you can get away with." He was clearly very much aware of the dubious legality of some of his work.
- nbzso 4y agoAs an artist, I already realized that the war is lost, without a fight. There is no way to stop the removal of human labor. At first, A.I. tools will need supervision and optimization, but soon they will do this by themselves. I moved all of my art related work into a real medium. If someone in the future finds value of owning an actual art, I will provide. If people are happy with metaverse A.I. generated images, projected in their minds, so be it. It is over. The rest is just an echo of human civilization. Transhumanistic clones are coming to town:)
- Taywee 4y agoThe war is not lost. The goal isn't to try to force people to never be able to use AI to generate art, but to force them to only use input that they gave permission to use. AI replacing artists functionally is just the surface fear. The real problem is using AI as an automated method of copyright laundering. There's only so much hand waving one can do to excuse dumping tons of art that you didn't make into a program and transform it into similar art and pretend like you own it. People like to pretend that it's like a person learning and replicating a style, but it's not. It's a computer program and it's automated. That the process is similar is immaterial.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wnkrshm 4y agoI'm thinking the same way, plein air painting is a nice activity. You get something nothing can take away from you, any kind of mark you make with your own body is yours. At least at the moment, using prompt- or inpainting-based tools feels like talking through Microsoft Sam (voice synth).
- sdiupIGPWEfh 4y agoSo they're protesting alleged copyright violations in the form of AI copying artistic styles (presuming an artistic style alone rises to the level of copyright protection) by committing trademark violations? Yeah, I don't get it. I can appreciate that there are all kinds of potential "intellectual property" issues with the current glut of AI models, but the level of misunderstanding in some affected communities is concerning.
- sidlls 4y agoOutside of lawyers, what communities do you think should have an "understanding" of intellectual property law, and to what degree? Or, maybe the fact that it takes a lawyer to truly understand it indicates that the complexity of applicable laws and regulations isn't beneficial to the communities they're ostensibly meant to protect?
- sdiupIGPWEfh 4y agoCommunities that generate and/or profit off of "intellectual property" ought to have a rudimentary understanding of the laws involved. Doubly so if they're protesting what they see as violations of those laws. It honestly does not take a lawyer to understand the distinctions at play here.
- Double_a_92 4y agoPeople that complain very vocally about some issue, should at least bother to research what they are talking about...
- avereveard 4y agoI fully expect self called artist to know the law that protect their own means of living
- Karawebnetwork 4y agoWhen I took my graphic design class in college, there was a big chunk about copyright and trademark. We had to be very cautious about images we were using and the difference between the two was drilled into our heads.
- 4bpp 4y agoSurely, if the next Stable Diffusion had to be trained from a dataset that has been purged of images that were not under a permissive license, this would at most be a minor setback on AI's road to obsoleting painting that is more craft than art. Do artists not realise this (perhaps because they have some kind of conceit along the lines of "it only can produce good-looking images because it is rearranging pieces of some Real Artists' works it was trained on"), are they hoping to inspire overshoot legislation (perhaps something following the music industry model in several countries: AI-generated images assumed pirated until proven otherwise, with protection money to be paid to an artists' guild?), or is this just a desperate rearguard action?
- Tepix 4y agoImagine you are an artist and you have developed your unique style. Would you mind if AI starts creating art like yours? What if your clients tell you they bought the AI generated art instead of yours?
- FeepingCreature 4y agoWould you mind if there was another person who copied your style? What if your clients...? Yeah, sure you'd mind. However, we have decided as a society that "style" is not protected.
- wruza 4y ago“We” decide on today’s issues, not on all future possibilities. The reason for that decision in the past was to allow many creators to create without being too held back by “private property” signs everywhere. The current situation allows AI to create but demotivates creators. Now it’s time to think what will we do when AI wouldn’t pick a new style and there are not enough creators anymore who can or want to do that, whether it is a near future problem or maybe not a problem at all, and what should we decide again. Simply hiding in an obsolete technicality is sure a wrong way to handle it.
- 4y ago
- spikeagally 4y agoDoes anybody else find the whole AI art generation thing both amazing and incredibly depressing at the same time? I’ve played around with it and it’s lots of fun. But I can also see a deluge of mediocre “content” taking over the internet in the near future. “Real art” will become a niche underground discipline. Most popular music will be AI generated and will have fake performers also generated to go along with it. And most people will be fine with that. I don’t think “real art” will disappear. People will always want to create (although monetising that will now be exceedingly more difficult). It feels like we are ripping the humanity out of life on a greater and greater scale with tech. Instead of replacing crappy jobs and freeing up peoples time to enjoy their life, we’re actually automating enjoyable pursuits. NB: when I’m referring to art I mean of all types as that’s where we are heading.
- sidlls 4y agoNear future? The internet is cesspool of mediocre and terrible content already. AI is going to have an impact on art and everything else in general. Artists may (and likely will be forced) to adapt to/adopt its use.
- karmakurtisaani 4y agoIf you think about how much content we're already getting from mediocre artists and writers, how many tv shows are complete garbage, how much governments and corporations are promoting and trolling in online discussions, how many search results are already ruined by lazy copied content, it's difficult to see things getting orders of magnitude worse. Good stuff will still be good stuff, and it will keep being rare. The biggest change will be that producing mediocre content will be cheaper and more accessible, but we're already drowning in it, so .. meh? > Instead of replacing crappy jobs and freeing up peoples time to enjoy their life, we’re actually automating enjoyable pursuits. That's an interesting observation.
- dredmorbius 4y agoFair assessment, and I agree with much of your premise, though regards "it's difficult to see things getting orders of magnitude worse": Please don't challenge them.
- ur-whale 4y agoArt has historically always been about copy and improve. This whole copyright / intellectual property idea is something that unfortunately cropped up in the 20th century, and the fact that it was codified into law is certainly not something 20th century humanity should be proud of or regard as progress.
- Juliate 4y agoNope. Intellectual property concepts in their current form started to appear as soon as prints, so about the 15th century. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright#Early_developments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright#Early_dev...
- Valmar 4y ago> Intellectual property concepts in their current form started to appear as soon as prints, so about the 15th century. Copyright is not the same as intellectual property. Copyright is not an intellectual property concept. They're very different things, though often conflated.
- Juliate 4y agoPerhaps not on your side of the planet, but in Europe, copyright is a part of intellectual property legislation.
- anonyfox 4y agoAbolish copyrights. At all. Unrestricted exchange boosts learning curves of societies and benefits everyone in the long run, except a few won't become too rich in the process. There are several downsides attached to that, but I am willing to accept that.
- nwoli 4y agoPeople should be rewarded for finding a unique artistic innovation that lots of people enjoy I’d think
- someNameIG 4y agoYes, people, not AI. I wonder if that could be a solution to this. Anything AI generated is public domain, no one can own the IP to it. It would allow it to be used for research and education, hobbyists, but hinder how large corporations could use it. Maybe even have it like GNU license, anything using AI generated stuff must also be public domain.
- benreesman 4y agoI’m going to be a broken record here: both of the words “artificial” and “intelligent are hellaciously difficult to define, put them together and you’ve got a real epistemological quantum on your hands. What we’re actually always talking about is “applied computational statistics”, otherwise known as ML. And if an artist wants to sample from the distribution of beautiful images and painting and photographs as a source of inspiration, why not? We do it in other fields. But using a computer to sample from that same distribution and adding nothing will be rightly rewarded by nothing.
- residualmind 4y agoYou don't need AI to create these, you just have to be a d*ck.
- vgatherps 4y agoAs a thought experiment, let's say that the next version of stable diffusion is able to integrate large text datasets into the training set and can generate an accurate Mickey Mouse without ever having to be trained on an image of Mickey Mouse since it's integrated enough information from the text. What then? Certainly an individual artist can't go and sell images of Mickey Mouse since it's still copyright infringement, but what claim would Disney have against the AI company? I wrote in another comment that if you make the training of such models illegal regardless of distribution, it's essentially making certain mathematics illegal. That poses some very interesting questions around rights, whether others will do it anyways, and the practicality of enforcing such a rule in the first place.
- crote 4y agoWould an SVG image count as text? How about an SVG automatically transformed into human-readable language?
- adenozine 4y agoNobody because these aren’t the first. Aviation, gaming, finance, logistics, etc… there’s huge industries that are already inundated with AI tools.
- meebob 4y agoI've been finding that the strangest part of discussions around art AI among technical people is the complete lack of identification or empathy: it seems to me that most computer programmers should be just as afraid as artists, in the face of technology like this!!! I am a failed artist (read, I studied painting in school and tried to make a go at being a commercial artist in animation and couldn't make the cut), and so I decided to do something easier and became a computer programmer, working for FAANG and other large companies and making absurd (to me!!) amounts of cash. In my humble estimation, making art is vastly more difficult than the huge majority of computer programming that is done. Art AI is terrifying if you want to make art for a living- and, if AI is able to do these astonishingly difficult things, why shouldn't it, with some finagling, also be able to do the dumb, simple things most programmers do for their jobs? The lack of empathy is incredibly depressing...
- fn1 4y ago> In my humble estimation, making art is vastly more difficult than the huge majority of computer programming that is done. That is only because the vast majority of computer programming that is done is not very good.
- CyanBird 4y agoLack of empathy is because we are discussing about systems, not feelings At the dawn of mechanization, these same arguments were being used by the luddites, I'd recommend you to read them, it was quite an interesting situation, same as now The reality is that advances such as these can't be stopped, even if you forbid ml legislation in the US there are hundreds of other countries which won't care same as it happens with piracy
- astrange 4y agoI recommend reading the part in Capital where Marx makes fun of them for being opposed to productivity.
- CuriousCosmic 4y agoRemember, luddites largely weren't against technology. What they were however was against was companies using that technology to slash their wages in exchange for being forced to do significantly more dangerous jobs. In less than a decade, textile work went from a safe job with respectable pay for artisans and craftsmen into one of the most dangerous jobs of the industrialised era with often less than a third of the pay and the workers primarily being children. That's what the luddites were afraid of. And the government response was military/police intervention, breaking of any and all strikes, and harsh punishments such as execution for damaging company property.
- namelessoracle 4y agoThe slice Im curious about is what happens, when you let loose your AI art generator and start copy/trademarking everything it creates to basically make sure all kinds of art that could have been created is potentially infringing for you? The art equivalent of patent trolling or domain squatting basically. Is that possible legally?
- cobertos 4y agoI hope that AI companies don't end up implementing another system like Youtube's DMCA system. Right holders and trolls alike can scrub these "black boxes" of whatever content they want, adding more garbage and uncertainty to their output. Then again, there should be some sort of solution so this can coexist with artists, and not replace them
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAI enables fast-fashion-like competition. There will still be winners and losers. Use these tools to 10x your own output and create new markets that arise due to the 10x modifier.
- amelius 4y agoNot just artists, also product designers like Jony Ive.
- bigbacaloa 4y agoOne traditional way of learning to make art was to go to the museum and copy the works of masters ... What's the difference in principle if one trains AI on them?
- dredmorbius 4y agoWork-factor, most obviously. Targeting and distribution as well. AI has the edge on individual creators here.
- avereveard 4y ago"images trascend copyright" https://cdn.vmst.io/media_attachments/files/109/512/541/929/356/944/original/3f2647016a3a727f.png https://cdn.vmst.io/media_attachments/files/109/512/541/929/... you can still copyright characters separatedly. he's feigning ignorance of how copyright work to make a sensationalistic point, which pretty much invalidate and poison what is otherwise an interesting argument at the boundary between derivative work and generative art.
- WanderPanda 4y agoI think what these generative models reveal is that the vast majority of art is just interpolation.
- crote 4y agoWas there ever any doubt about that? There are literally entire graduate studies on it. However, art isn't solely interpolation. The critical part is that art styles shift around due to innovations or new viewpoints, often caused by societal development. AI might be able to make a new Mondriaan when trained on pre-existing Mondriaans but it won't suddenly generate a Mondriaan out of a Van Gogh training set - and yet that's still roughly what happened historically.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoLots of people in these comments trying to reduce art in a way that is pretty hilarious. You hit the nail on the head. Art is only interpolation if you....remove the human that created it, in which case you would not call the image art. AI "art" is computational output, to imply otherwise is to mistakenly imply a family resemblance to human (and uniquely human I would argue) creation.
- dymk 4y agoThe human brain is just a model with weights and a lifelong training step. Seems like a distinction without a difference - even more so as ML models advance further.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y ago> Seems like a distinction without a difference This is giving ML models, more credit than they are due. They are unable to be imagine, they might convincingly seem to produce novel outputs, but their outputs are ultimately proscribed by their inputs and datasets and programming. They're machines. Humans can learn like machines, but humans are also able to imagine as agents. "AI" "art" is just neither of its namesakes. That doesn't mean it isn't impressive, but implying they are the same is granting ML more powers and abilities than it is capable of.
- Tycho 4y agoWhat about an AI that can write unit tests for any codebase… seems like the overall benefit of that would be huge.
- OctopusLupid 4y agoI find it weird how I don’t see any mention of the TDM exceptions (“Text and Data Mining”) that already explicitly allows AI companies to train on copyrighted data, in some cases even allowing them to ignore opt-outs (such as in research institutions). This is already implemented in the UK, EU, Japan and Singapore. It seems to me that the online discourse is very US-centric, thinking that the AI regulatory battles are in the future, when in some other countries it’s already over.
- mdrzn 4y agoThis should have (2019) in the title
- dredmorbius 4y agoUm, why? (As submitter.) The linked item was posted within the past 24 hours. The referenced images also appear to be current so far as I can tell. (I'd looked for a more substantial post or article without luck when submitting this.)
- mdrzn 4y agoMy bad, the mastodon thread is actually fresh, I got it mixed up with the article linked in the 3rd reply to it, which is a 2019 story: https://waxy.org/2019/12/how-artists-on-twitter-tricked-spammy-t-shirt-stores-into-admitting-their-automated-art-theft/ https://waxy.org/2019/12/how-artists-on-twitter-tricked-spam...
- dredmorbius 4y agoThanks.
- Juliate 4y agoLawyers. Lawyers are going to have a lot of fun$$ with the copyright/trademark violation flood that is coming (and not only for high profiles).
- BurningFrog 4y agoA fascinating angle I heard recently is that when the new tech of photography swept the world, it made tons of painters unemployed. And that was the main reason for "modern art". A camera can do a portrait or landscape instantly and more precise than a painter, but it can't compete on abstract or imagined pictures. Will something analogous happen when AIs takes over other industries? I have no clue, but it will, as always, be interesting to see what happens.
- dredmorbius 4y agoAny references you can recall on the emergence of modern art as a response to photography?
- BurningFrog 4y agoNot really. Don't remember where I read it. It was a few months ago. I like the explanation a lot, and I think the timelines line up pretty well. But sure, it could be one of those stories that sound true, but isn't.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThanks.
- anothernewdude 4y agoSo either they are hypocrites, or art can be made by AI. Probably both.
- jmyeet 4y agoOne bone to pick: this says "artists" are fighting this and mentions Disney, Nintendo and Marvel. "Corporations" would be more accurate than "artists". Training a model with artists' work seems completely fine to me. If something is out in the world and you can see it, you can't really control how that affects a person or a model or whatever. The actual issue is reproduction of trademarked and copyrighted material. There are already restrictions on how you can use Mickey Mouse's likeness in any derivative work. That's not an AI issue. It's an IP issue. The derivative works are no different than if I, a person, produced the same derivative work. It would be funny to me that we had to turn our attention to training AIs in IP laws.
- Imnimo 4y agoIf you create a trademark-violating image using an AI model does that demonstrate anything more than that that particular image is violating? Like it's also violating if I hand draw those images, the fact that they're AI-generated doesn't enter into it.
- throwawayoaky 4y agoSee you guys in five years!
- marmetio 4y agoMy memory of this is really fuzzy, so I'm probably getting the details wrong. I watched a documentary in roughly the early oughts about AI. The presenter might have been Alan Alda. In one segment, he visited some military researchers who were trying to get a vehicle to drive itself. It would move only a few inches or feet at a time as it had to stop to recalculate. In another segment, he visited some university researchers who set up a large plotter printer to make AI-generated art. It was decent. He saw it could depict things like a person and a pot, so he asked if it would ever do something silly to us like put a person in a pot. The professor said not to be silly. To jokingly answer the title question: everyone who saw that one specific documentary 20 years ago knew that AI art was way ahead of AI machines. Art is useful when someone subjectively finds it enjoyable or meaningful. While it might not achieve all of what humans can, the barrier to entry is relatively lower.
- fullshark 4y agoIf it was Alan Alda it was probably a Scientific American Frontiers episode https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_American_Frontiers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_American_Frontier... Edit: confused SAF with Nova!
- marmetio 4y agoWow, good call. The car part was probably from season 7 episode 5, which first aired in 1997. I skimmed the video and didn't see the art part, so maybe that was a different show. Apparently it's was 25 years ago, which explains my fuzzy memory of it. https://youtu.be/2aa6vMpMSho https://youtu.be/2aa6vMpMSho
- alexfromapex 4y agoIt seems like the least-regulated professions will be the front lines, due of course to the friction created by getting AI operating in regulated environments.
- Karawebnetwork 4y agoIf someone builds an AI self-driving car and feeds it images of Honda cars. Should the company be required, under threat of legal action, to remove the Honda from the model? What if this makes the model less accurate and causes more accidents? In other words, I am wondering if the current issue here is the model being trained or the model being able to generate images. Coming back to my example, if the car displayed the closest vehicle on the HUD. Would Honda ask the car company to replace the likeness of their car with a generic car icon or would they ask for the model to be scrubbed?
- yeknoda 4y agoIf regulation is found to be necessary, here are some options - government could treat open ai like an electricity utility, with regulated profits - open ai could be forced to come up with compensation schemes for the human source images. The more the weights get used, the higher the payout - the users of the system could be licensed to ensure proper use and that royalties are paid to the source creators. We issue driving licenses, gun licenses, factory permits etc. Licenses are for potentially dangerous activities and powers. This could be one of those. - special taxation class for industries like this that are more parasitic and less egalitarian than small businesses or manufacturing - outright ban on using copyrighted work in ai training - outright ban on what can be considered an existential technology. This has been the case for some of the most important technologies in the last 100 years including nuclear weapons.
- mwigdahl 4y agoWe already have a great example of a group that has fought technological development of a synthetic alternative to their product -- the diamond industry. For years DeBeers and other diamond moguls have run extensive propaganda campaigns to try to convince people that lab-grown diamonds are physically, emotionally, and morally inferior. They had a lot of success at first. Based on lobbying, the US FTC banned referring to lab-grown diamonds as "real", "genuine", or even "stone". It required the word "diamond" be prefixed with "lab-grown" or "synthetic" in any marketing materials. Technology kept improving, economies of scale applied, and consumer demand eventually changed the balance. The FTC reversed its rulings and in 2022 demand for lab-grown stones (at small fractions of equivalent natural prices) is at an all-time high. Artists (and writers, and programmers) can fight against this all they like, and may win battles in the short term. In the end the economic benefits accruing to humankind as a result of these technologies is inexorably going to normalize them.
- standardly 4y agoIt is pretty ironic. "AI will outdo us at repetitve, mindless tasks, but it will NEVER be able to compete with humans at, like, ART, and stuff"
- silent_cal 4y agoThe way these image generating neural nets are trained is illegal. They copy and use other artists' work without asking them or paying them. There's a lot of legal exposure here - why hasn't anyone taken advantage of that yet?
- ChadNauseam 4y agoIn the US we have fair use, and it's not clear at all to me that this wouldn't count. If I took every image on artstation and averaged all of them (creating a muddy mess), I think I would be legally able to distribute the result without compensating or crediting the original artists.
- OctopusLupid 4y agoWhat makes you say it's illegal? In the EU, UK, Japan and Singapore, it is explicitly legal to train AI on copyrighted work. I saw another comment say that AI companies train in those countries.
- esotericsean 4y agoThis will be a losing battle for artists. Anyone can train any data they want. It's the equivalent of a human learning to draw someone else's art style or take photos the same as a famous photographer. There is no stopping it now and it's only going to get better and easier. Video is getting close to being just as accessible as image or text generation. Regardless of how you feel about all this, there's no stopping it. It's the future.
- seydor 4y agoThe problem is copyright laws , not the models (which are inevitable and impossible to stop anyway). The sketch of a mouse should not be protected more than the artistic style of any guy. IP laws are ancient concept and it s a mystery why people still cling to them so tightly
- patientplatypus 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hectorlorenzo 4y agoI'm still organising my thoughts on the subject so please feel free to push back. This ongoing discussion feels classist. I've never seen such strong emotions about AI (and automation) taking blue-collar jobs, some shrugs at most. It's considered an unavoidable given, even though it has been happening for decades. The only difference now is that AI is threatening middle-upper class jobs, which nobody saw coming. I do not see the difference between both. Can somebody that does explain to me why now is "critical" and not so much before?
- pram 4y agoYou never heard of the Luddites?
- hectorlorenzo 4y agoYes I have, care to explain?
- automatoney 4y agoIt probably has to do with the desirability of the replaced jobs. There's definitely an element of classism, but also people /really/ want to be artists and make a living doing that specific thing. There's the "starving artist" who will take little pay just as long as they can do art, but I don't think we have a similar idea for lots of blue collar work. How much do factory workers have passion for their work, vs it being the best paying option for them? Not to say there aren't any, but there's for sure a desirability difference. Also I'm not sure most artist jobs are middle-upper class.
- hectorlorenzo 4y agoThat is true: that's why certain industries endure more mistreatment than others (acting, fashion, design in general). Passion can be a pain in the ass when it gets in the way of just making a living. However, these are individual reactions, not behaviours as a community/society. If you read comments around HN or some other liberal circles, you have the feeling that is our human-ness is being threatened, one of our core defining traits. It seems like "artistic creativity" is being enshrined as a circular argument (also I'm wary of calling startup-landing-page illustrators "artists" – more like craftpeople, although this distinction might hurt the conversation). My broader point is that ChatGPT is not "the beginning of the end", but another chapter in a history of automation and replacement that will pose serious challenges for humankind. That treating it as more critical than factory automation is demeaning to blue-collar workers and also untrue. Everything we do is what defines us as people: cherry-picking some skills is a relic from Enlightenment we should get rid of. > Also I'm not sure most artist jobs are middle-upper class. I do not have any data at hand, only my circle of friends and former colleagues (I was formerly a graphic designer). Few people endure being a "starving artist" without a little financial safety coming from above. Also, it is a profession that only provides status to a certain socio-economic milieu.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThe previous generation of illustrators got disrupted by digital illustration. The number of people required to publish a magazine, or to create an ad, went down significantly with digital tools.
- rozgo 4y agoIn our game studio, engineers are creating lots of developer art on their own. But the real productivity booster is coming from artists using language models to generate entire art pipeline scripts. Several Python scripts to automate Blender3D and offline asset post-processing. Many artists are also changing shaders by asking language models to modify existing code.
- cwkoss 4y agoIf a human wrote the prompt, how is AI different from a paintbrush or any other tool of the trade? Every tool makes some of the 'decisions' about how the artwork results by adding constraints and unexpected results. If anything I'd argue that AI art allows for more direct human expression: going from mental image to a sharable manifestation has the potential to be less lossy with art than with paint. This feels like a bunch of misplaced ludditism. We need to implement a UBI because 99.9% of human labor is going to be valued below the cost of survival in the next 50-100 years. Always fun to see people thumbing their nose at Disney though.
- rperez333 4y agoI think it is different because you don't need any pictures to create a paintbrush or a pencil. You can still have the AI code as tool, but without the dataset (images), it won't go anywhere.
- Double_a_92 4y agoYou would still need some reference images (or memories) if you e.g. wanted to paint Mickey Mouse.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoArt is now low value. It has no value addition. Technology in the palm of our hands and higher quality of life is also the reason. Let’s not forget the very impressive population explosion in the past century. Every ‘job’ is a skill that has been out streamed so the needs of the population are satisfied by skills of the population so resources are distributed evenly. Art is no longer a need and there are way too many artists simply proportional to the population. Further, a lot of ‘art’ taught is technique. It’s not creativity. Can creativity be taught? I don’t think so. Culture played a part in preserving artists and honoring their skills. But as ‘culture’ becomes global, mainstream is adopted more as it’s more accessible. And mainstream is subject to the vagaries of market as well as vulnerable to market manipulation. Contrary to population notions, our world is very homogenous. Somehow the promotion of diversity has ended up with the tyranny of conformity. How did this happen? This is the biggest puzzle of this past few decades.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoThis is the kind of post that I come on HN to read.
- charlescearl 4y agoThe title is an erasure of the minoritized workers who've been exploited in labeling and curation and moderation who've been raising concerns; it's an erasure of the many who've been raising concerns about the misogyny and predation involved in the construction of the data sets (e.g. https://www.image-net.org/ https://www.image-net.org/) which make these models possible https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.16923 https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.16923. Marx makes the case in Grundisse https://thenewobjectivity.com/pdf/marx.pdf https://thenewobjectivity.com/pdf/marx.pdf that the automation of work could improve the lives of workers -- to "free everyone’s time for their own development". Ruth Gilmore Wilson observes that capital's answer is to build complexes of mass incarceration & policing to deal with the workers rendered jobless by automation https://inquest.org/ruth-wilson-gilmore-the-problem-with-innocence/ https://inquest.org/ruth-wilson-gilmore-the-problem-with-inn... -- that is, those who have too much "free" time. In such a world, Marx speculates that "Wealth is not command over surplus labour time’ (real wealth), ‘but rather, disposable time outside that needed in direct production", but Wilson reminds us that capital's apparent answer to date has been fascism.
- kmeisthax 4y agoVaguely related: Mickey Mouse will actually be hitting the public domain in 2024. That's a year and a few weeks away.
- sdiupIGPWEfh 4y agoMore specifically, certain works featuring Mickey Mouse may actually be hitting the public domain. Mickey Mouse himself is trademarked, and there's no limited duration on trademarks.
- kmeisthax 4y agoYes, but a trademark only prohibits you from putting the word on a box or a store listing page. And only in source-identifying contexts - purely descriptive or nominative ones don't count[0]. This is the sort of thing where you would have to think ahead of time about the context of certain uses. But generally speaking, after January 1st, 2024, the balance is in the favor of the public domain: - If I draw an animation and post it to YouTube, and one of the characters happens to be Mickey Mouse, that will be legal. But I still can't name my channel "Mickey Mouse Official" or put the character's face in my channel profile, since that's source-identifying material. - If I just flat-out reupload Steamboat Willie to YouTube, with the (possibly incorrect) title "Walt Disney's FIRST EVER CARTOON", that also will be legal - because the title is purely nominative and does not imply that I'm licensed by Disney. - If I release STL or STEP files on Thingiverse for printing Mickey Mouse christmas ornaments, that will be legal - but I have to make sure that nobody thinks this is actually made by Disney. - Mass-produced merchandise sold in stores will be very difficult to sell legally, since generally speaking the whole object is considered source-identifying when you put it on a store shelf. About the only thing you could do is sell figurine blind-bags with no indication that there's public-domain Disney stuff in there. That last one is probably why Disney isn't trying to, say, push Mexican life+100 terms[1] on everyone. Mickey Mouse is more valuable as a branding and merchandising tool than as a creative work. Copyright law itself also has a preemption clause[2] which prohibits making copyright-shaped claims under other laws. This is usually mentioned in the context of state right-of-publicity laws[3], but the text of the clause would also apply to trying to "trademark a copyright" to keep the mouse in his cage. [0] This is part of "trademark fair use", which is an entirely different concept to the copyright fair use one. [1] Oh, yeah, I forgot - in all those YouTube examples you need to convince YouTube to block your upload in Mexico, which they are unwilling to do. The stated reason is that pirates could be harder to catch if they geoblocked their uploads. However, this already causes problems for, say, people reviewing anime - which is actually illegal in Japan! So I suspect that YouTube might have to change their policies on this at some point as more large publishers' work hits the public domain in certain countries but not others. [2] 18 USC 301 [3] https://www.sheppardmullin.com/media/article/753_CL%2025-4%20July%202008%20Chadwick-Vatanparast.pdf https://www.sheppardmullin.com/media/article/753_CL%2025-4%2...
- fallingfrog 4y agoTo be honest: I'm not generally a luddite, but in this case- I think we should nip this in the bud. I can see where this is going. You can argue back and forth about whether this will make the economy grow, but that's not the point. The profits from increased productivity do not accrue to the workforce but to the owners of the capital, in the absence of concerted, organized resistance, so I would not expect the quality of life for the majority of people to improve because of this. The question is: do you like human beings? Because there is really no job that can't be replaced, if the technology goes far enough. And then the majority of the population, or all of the population, becomes dead weight. I'm a musician; how long before an AI can write better songs than I can in a few seconds? This is fundamentally different than past instances of technology replacing human labor, because in the past, there was always something else that humans could do that the machines still could not. Now- that may not be the case. There is only one choice: I think we should outlaw all machine learning software, worldwide.
- smrtinsert 4y agoThis is like monks fighting the printing press. Sorry guys, this is only going one direction.
- quonn 4y agoIt‘s amusing how so many on this thread assume to be able know what will happen to this or that profession. We don‘t know. We just don‘t. It‘s too difficult to predict what, say, software developers will do in a few years and how demand or salary or competition will be. Look at this final video of the 2012 Deep Learning course by Hinton that I still remember from a long time ago: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FOqMeBM3EIE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FOqMeBM3EIE What I do know however is this: - Short term nothing special will happen. - In the actually interesting projects that I worked on I always ran out of time. So much more could be imagined that could have been done but there was no time or budget to do it. Looking forward to AI making a dent in this a bit.
- JetAlone 4y ago
- sircastor 4y agoI feel for artists who feel like they’re losing their livelihood. Art has always been a tough profession, and this doesn’t help because late-stage capitalism all but guarantees that a lot of potential customers will just skip the human-made article in favor of the “good-enough” mechanical production. That said, automation is coming for all of us. The problem is not “we Need to stop these AIs/robots from replacing humans.” It’s “We need to figure out the rules for taking care of the humans when their work is automated”
- rangersanger 4y agoThey aren't. the first battles were fought by victims of deepfakes.
- 1auralynn 4y agoTo me, it's an art vs. craft issue and there are many shades of gray to the discussion, because the root is really based in the question that every first-year art student is tasked with answering for themselves "What is art?" If art for you is primarily centered on fidelity of implementation (i.e. "craft") then you will be very threatened by AI, particularly if you've made it your livelihood. However, if your art is more about communication/concepts, then you might even feel empowered by having such a toolset and not having to slog through a bunch of rote implementation when developing your ideas/projects. Not to mention that a single person will be able to achieve much much more. I feel like it's possibly a good thing for art/humanity overall to stop conflating craft with art, because new ideas will rise above all of the AI-generated images. i.e. splashiness alone will no longer be rewarded. In an ideal future when we all live in the Star Trek universe, none of it will matter and whoever loves crafting stuff can do it all day long. Until then of course, it's tragic and lots of people will be out of jobs.
- 1auralynn 4y agoNot to mention it also may spur innovations in different mediums: More time-based art, installations, video games, etc.
- fleddr 4y agoI sympathize with artists on this matter, but they're really bad at protesting. AI Mickey Mouse is a possible copyright as well as trademark violation which would likely be enforced in the exact same way if you were to hand draw it. This type of violation is not AI specific. The main threat that AI poses is not that it outputs copyrighted characters, instead brand new works that are either totally new (idea is never drawn before but the style is derived) or different enough from a known character to be considered a derived work. Another way to put it: artists' current job is not to draw mickey. It is to draw new works, which is the part AI is threatening to replace. Sure, Disney may chase the AI companies to remove Mickey from the training set, and then we lost AI Mickey. That doesn't solve any problem because there are no artist jobs that draw Mickey. Even in the case of extreme success where it becomes illegal to train a copyrighted image without explicit consent, the AI problem doesn't go away. They'll just use public domain images. Or sneak in consent without you knowing it. As was the case with your "free and unlimited" Google Photos. Finally, if there's any player interested in AI art, it has to be Disney. Imagine the insane productivity gains they can make. It's not reasonable to expect that they would fight AI art very hard. Maybe a little, for the optics.
- itronitron 4y agoI think you are giving the AI too much credit in being able to pull out the trademarked bits. Artists can introduce trademark iconography into their work as a poision pill. Sort of like GPL but with more powerful allies.
- fleddr 4y agoI don't really believe that. An example: "Robot owl in the style of van Gogh". This will closely mimic van Gogh's style but nobody cares because style cannot be copyrighted in itself. So it draws a robot owl, which for the sake of this example, is a new character. Zero copyright violations. My point remains that AI users aren't going to aim for output that directly looks like an existing character. These artists are now intentionally doing that for the sake of the protest but this is not how AI is used. It's used to create new works or far-derived works.
- rafaelero 4y agoChill out, people. Humans are still great generalists. We are pretty capable of leveraging these tools to amplify our productivity. It's only the specialists between us that are going to suffer a lot with these new developments. All these AI innovation is truly showing us how pathetic our ability to deeply understand and specialize at something is. We are always going to lose to computers, be it in chess, go or art. Therefore, we should cultivate our generalist skills and stop fighting AI progress.
- NicoleJO 4y agoThis is false. Several people, including myself, have been fighting AI IP theft for years. I filed the first BBB complaint, in fact...
- NicoleJO 4y agoThis is false. In fact, I filed the first BBB complaint.
- Vivtek 4y agoI am laughing in technical translator.
- norwalkbear 4y agoI'm sympathetic,but the demon is unleashed. No one WANTED to pay artists to begin with if they could bring their own ideas to life. Artists should realize they were just a necessary evil to many other people's creative endeavors. Every single human being alive has the creative spark.
- kweingar 4y agoCopyright infringement is a backbone of the digital world. People remix others’ music, write fanfiction of others’ works, draw fan art of others’ characters, write and distribute clones of others’ games, etc. Much of internet culture involves drawing captions on others’ art and spreading it around, i.e. memes. Twitch pulls in multiple billions of dollars of revenue from video game streaming, which hasn’t been tested in court and may very well be copyright infringement. People regularly pirate games, movies, television shows, music, books, software, research papers, etc. I believe that the culture benefits tremendously from this. My question is, why should we draw the line exactly here, at AI generated images, code, and writing?
- smaddox 4y agoCopyright != Trademark. Independently generated images of Mickey Mouse are litigated under Trademark law, not Copyright law. Disclaimer: I am not an IP lawyer and have roughly no idea what I'm talking about.
- neontomo 4y agoAs an artist who makes money from selling art, I find the panic to be ridiculous. The tide doesn't wait for you. Find new ways of understanding and creating art, move with the flow, don't stand in one place, shouting at the Gods to, "stop this damn technological advancement!" serves no purpose. It's not protesting, it's fear of the unknown.
- rockzom 4y agoOne year ago: https://www.amazon.com/Realtors-are-Not-Allowed-Moon-ebook/dp/B09MQM7QPF https://www.amazon.com/Realtors-are-Not-Allowed-Moon-ebook/d...