31 ms·
Porsche boss faces software woes keeping VW a step behind Tesla
- yalogin 4y agoI wonder if the exact same story as the iPhone vs Nokia/Motorola/Microsoft/et al is happening in electric cars. At least the article hints at the exact same thing happening. May be folks more knowledgeable with the auto industry might be able to comment
- kmac_ 4y agoIt's the same story: no matter if it's phone, TV, car, home, washing machine - it comes to product vs product. The core functionality is the most important, but all things around also matter. TVs are quite similar, so competition moved to the smart functions, phones become smartphones, etc.
- metaphor 4y agohttps://archive.ph/3an1z https://archive.ph/3an1z
- primeblue 4y ago
- mixmastamyk 4y agoI don't want any of this in a car. I want analog/tactile nobs, zero connectivity, and at most a power cable and holder to plug in a smart phone. Anyone left that provides this?
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoUsed car dealers
- gumby 4y agoThe rot is deeper than just the UI, unfortunately.
- ricardbejarano 4y agoI believe new Mazdas come with no direct connectivity and have no touchscreens. You can still connect your Android Auto or CarPlay device though, and control it with a knob. It is the balance I like. I don't own one (yet).
- mixmastamyk 4y agoHmm, that smartphone integration implies there is something at the other side communicating. Don't think I want that either. Guessing many folks would be fine with bluetooth audio for music and directions.
- OttPeterR 4y agoI’ve got a new and somewhat-old Mazda. The new one does have an internet connection but it really only seems to be used for remote start and door lock status/control. Its using the Verizon network (in the US) and it also pings a location when you power off the car. (All these things are available through a python api so thats fun)
- jcdavis 4y agoGot a Mazda3 this year and the "no bullshit" infotainment stack was a huge selling point for me. Airplay integration using a knob is a little wonky in places (primarily interacting with maps), but I consider it a feature not a bug because I basically don't do any interaction I can't do via voice commands. Physical buttons for all climate etc, not a capacitive "button" to be found in the car.
- orangepurple 4y agoNew Dacia cars fit the bill and they use modern Renault drivetrains under license. Funnily they get poor safety ratings because they don't include many electronic driving aids (lol) Their structural safety is great.
- i80and 4y agoCalling their structural safety great seems like an overstatement -- I can't find a Dacia model on EuroNCAP that doesn't have sketchy dummy kinematics, and one new model (Spring) performs startlingly poorly in crash tests The best appears to be the 2021 Dacia Logan[1] which has a crash test littered with "marginals": > [...] structures in the dashboard presented a risk of injury to occupants of different sizes and to those sitting in different positions, and protection for this part of the body was downgraded to marginal. Chest protection was also rated as marginal for both front seat occupants, based on dummy readings of chest compression. > In the side barrier test, representing an impact by another vehicle, chest compression indicated a marginal level of protection. > ...geometric analysis of the rear seats indicated marginal whiplash protection. I think Dacia makes great cars for what they are and their price, but there are much better options for crash mitigation. [1]: https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/Dacia/Logan/42505 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/Dacia/Logan/42505
- petre 4y agoDacia Spring is actually a Chinese car. It's called Dongfeng Spring and is available on Alibaba. Dacia makes cheap cars. They're okay but they drive like a cart, the chairs are crappy and the clutch pedal is quite annoying in how it feels.
- orangepurple 4y agoI drove a brand new SEAT this year as a rental which had a clutch that was almost impossible to actuate smoothly due to a very bizzare non linear bite profile. I wonder if it's similar for Dacia cars. The only Dacia stuff I'm personally interested in is the stuff with the new Renault hybrid drivetrains
- 762236 4y agoI wish that car reviewers would do their job and be critical. They rarely mention how bad the modern cars are becoming.
- alephxyz 4y agoThe simultaneous trends of bigger SUV/trucks with higher hoods and poorly designed "infotainment" systems is terrifying, especially for pedestrians and cyclists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- geodel 4y agoWell, reviewers busy fiddling with ten thousand settings in 14 INCH TOUCHSCREEN. While 2021 model has only 12.4 inch screen. So new one is best thing that happened.
- gumby 4y ago> Well, reviewers busy fiddling with ten thousand settings in 14 INCH TOUCHSCREEN. Instead of looking at the road.
- rad_gruchalski 4y ago> I wish that car reviewers would do their job and be critical. Well, it’s all about Youtube clicks now. Who shows more new cars faster. Being honest and critical does not help those individuals because that will cause that they’ll stop receiving cars for reviews. You see. Today to review a car, you have to get s special press car. Can’t pick up a random rental and do a review for it.
- dontknowwhyihn 4y agoThis is exactly what I want. I think there’s a huge, untapped market for an electric car with minimal software. A car that doesn’t need software updates and doesn’t track you.
- cycrutchfield 4y agoJust like that huge, untapped market for a cell phone with minimal software. Yup, people will be lining up around the block for the modern equivalent of a Motorola razr or Nokia brickphone. There’s dozens of us! Dozens!
- panick21_ 4y agoIts always funny when Hackers think their obscure tastes are universal.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoWhen these choices don't meaningfully exist there's not enough information to know whether it is viable or not. The present situation exists due to increased monetization, not because people are clamoring for blue-sceens, dangerous distractions, broken bluetooth, and pervasive surveillance in cars. "Hey wouldn't it be great if my disgruntled ex could find out where I am every minute!?"
- cycrutchfield 4y agoYou neo-luddites sure are strange people. You always have the most convoluted hypothetical scenarios you use to justify your weird beliefs.
- thriftwy 4y ago1st gen Huyndai Cretas on anything but the highest trim levels are just that.
- CobaltFire 4y agoI drive a Mercedes-Benz Metris and it’s exactly that.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoIt’s like trying to find a cathode ray tube TV anymore: technically possible to produce, but economically infeasible in terms of costs. Chips are just cheaper than going analogue, even with the current shortages.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThese things were in $10k econo boxes, they’re plenty cheap.
- polishdude20 4y agoI mean, buying a used 2015 model of any major car manufacturer does basically that. Sure it's "used" but it still works and you can get it cheaper.
- dependsontheq 4y agoI wouldn't call it "woes". I have been driving an VW ID 3 since last year, it runs their custom Android OS System and should have all of the latest features. It has been quite an experience. The car is fine, basic driving functions are fine, even the driver assist features are generally fine if they are running. The software running all the displays and the "augmented" heads up display is ridiculous. The car one did shut down all displays (including speed) while driving on the Autobahn (error message: no input), I stopped in the next town, charging the car was no longer possible. I tried to find out how to do hard reboot, my wife found a thread in a forum, "leave the car with all smart keys, go at least 50 meters from the car, wait for 15 minutes". That did the trick. Sometimes the voice recognition comes on and does something weird, I have no idea why or what it tries to do, sometimes it starts a specific radio station, it has not once recognized anything I said. Some Update added a blue light glowing in front of the driver in the small LED strip, it just ominously glows for a second. It looks a bit like a warning, I have no idea what it is warning about, it just happens sometimes. Sometimes in the night the alarm starts and wakes the neighborhood, but I was able to solve that by disabling the proximity features in the smart key system. The navigation forgets that I can charge the car at home after every update. 20 kilometers before I am home it recommends I should charge for 2 hours. The UI/UX is unintuitive and ugly. It shows a lot of useless information in weird places and a lot of stuff is hard to find. The list of weird experiences I had with this car is endless, and a lot of is just just bad software development, like the issue on the Autobahn.
- temac 4y agoSome of the bugs and ergonomics problem you describe seem dangerous. The regulators should come in and ban those cars until they are fixed.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoI've been driving a 27-year-old Range Rover for a year. Sometimes I need to hold the ignition key close to the receiver in the rear window for it to lock. Sometimes I need to jiggle the steering lock a little for the flappy door to close and tell it the key is out, before it will lock. Sometimes I need to poke the "petrol flap" button a couple of times before the flap will open. Sometimes the radio doesn't really get a good signal on Radio 4 and I need to press the SEEK button on the steering wheel. The dashboard displays were fuzzy and hard-to-read, but I wiped the dust off and they were fine. They did go totally dark once when I was fiddling with the brightness control, but I turned them back on. It has never need rebooted. It has never forgotten how to be fuelled up. It has never just turned off all its electronics at speed on the motorway. The UI doesn't show any information beyond speed, engine RPM, coolant temperature and fuel level, unless there's some sort of fault indication up. I am really not convinced about buying a modern car. (My last car was also a 27-year-old Range Rover, which I still have)
- adventured 4y agoProducing really good software is really hard. Here's a tip for all the backwards big companies in Europe: pay your software engineers a lot more. Whatever you're paying now, increase it by 2x-3x. If you want the best, you're going to have to pay for it, or you're going to suffer the predictably mediocre results indefinitely (to the benefit of Tesla & Co.; Tesla's sales are now up to $67 billion; that's closing in on the size of BMW's consumer auto division).
- melony 4y agoNot just the software, so many cars don't even have a functional touchscreen while requiring use of it for many core features. Hyundai for example like to use really low quality touch screens that are even slower than my old Nokia's resistive display. What is the point of pan-and-zoom in a GPS maps app if the screen can barely keep up in real-time?
- rapsey 4y agoCars have very high temperature requirements for screens. Cars and their screens must survive very hot and very cold temperatures and last decades. Keep in mind the screen is right there under the sun on a hot day. A fancy beautiful tablet screen would last a very short time under car conditions.
- redox99 4y agoMany cars have decent touch screens so it's clearly something doable.
- gumby 4y agoThe salaries are a symptom of the problem, not the cause. Most companies in the world (though Europe in particular has no excuse) don't understand that software is a strategic (and existential) issue, so pay for it like any other thing in their BOM. cf my long comment on this subject.
- 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoI've been following this debacle in the German press and I think there's a structural problem that they will struggle to dig their way out of. And by "they" I don't mean just VW, but much of European industry. Software is simply not valued in Europe, and not because there aren't amazing developers there -- there are many. But software isn't considered important Let's start with cars. Back before cars were just computers with wheels I was briefly involved in a software project at $SERIOUS_GERMAN_CAR_COMPANY. Mechanically their cars were outstanding -- I still drive this company's cars today. This project was some cool "by wire" stuff, all modeled in Matlab, just as the ECU code was. But it was clear that the mechanical guys were the top of the pyramid; the safety guys were all mechanical engineers with some programming experience. All the user-visible electronics (radio, controls, etc) was subbed out to a low-price bidder because "who cares about that stuff anyway?". This wasn't VW, but I have some family exposure to VW specifically and that mentality still comes through deeply: electronics are added to the vehicle, not integral. The mental and organizational rewiring will be very hard. These are not companies who believe you should "eat your own lunch before someone else comes and eats it for you". The long institutional problems seen in yesterday's post about Nokia and the "Burning Platform" memo are pervasive throughout Europe (and most places, including a lot of USA): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32698044 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32698044 You see this in the salaries. Sure, take-home salaries in the EU are lower than US ones in across the board, but the delta in the high value professions is extreme and quite telling. My son's partner's parents in Europe are offended by what Amazon pays him in the US because "he just works in IT". Well, he's a developer in their highest revenue area, so Amazon think it's worth investing in. Tesla cars ship with all sorts of fit and finish bugs, and are above average in mechanical problems. But ("FSD" excepted) they spend more of their attention on what really matters: treating their vehicle as a modern electronic device. But the European car companies are still stuck in the mid 20th century and make the opposite branch cut. The rest of European industry is the same. Andreeson wrote "Software is eating the world" 11 years ago. Apparently nobody on the continent of Europe has read it. Sure, software is considered important, but it's just another part of the BOM, not something strategic. IMHO the only countries that really understand software at both a technical and business value add level are US, AUS, Canada, China, with India less so but in that group and Japan just barely getting in. Pretty damning. FWIW I've worked in France and Germany (and non-European countries), including some car business, but most of my career has been in the Valley (starting 38 years ago). I am not from Europe or USA so in that sense I don't have a preference for either side. I prefer living in Europe but vastly prefer to work in the US.
- tsunamifury 4y agoI had a Porsche Taycan almost kill me and my entire family due to the absolutely negligent engineering team at porsche. An update was applied which killed the motor due to a stack overflow error — while driving! Porsche set up the error handling to kill the engine immediately with even the slightest error. I testified along with fellow owners to the NHTSA and got all Taycans recalled. The arrogance and denial that Porsche put owners through was shocking through the process. They displayed a complete lack of understanding of the basics of control systems and software safety. Needless to say I sold the Taycan and would never buy a VW electric product. I wrote them a letter and spoke to the safety team saying people will die from this sloppiness and lack of professionalism. Someone will pay. Turned out I was right
- jliptzin 4y agoWow, good for you and thanks for the warning
- gregsadetsky 4y agoIs this the recall you’re referring to? [0] Is there a report somewhere / investigative details on the recall? Thanks! [0] https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/porsche-recalls-flagship-electric-model-taycan-over-software-issue-2021-07-02/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/porsch... —— EDIT I found https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/rcl/2021/RCLRPT-21V486-3851.PDF https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/rcl/2021/RCLRPT-21V486-3851.PDF “Due to a software issue that has since been corrected, the software designed to continuously monitor end-to-end communication between the safety-related ECUs in the vehicle can, in certain instances, incorrectly and sporadically detect a potentially faulty communication, set an error memory entry, and trigger a shutdown of the power train, resulting in loss of motive power.”
- tsunamifury 4y agoYes, but what they didn’t say in that statement is they were attempting to correct the issue post-incident to cover their tracks before the owners got together and gave testimony. They kept telling drivers it was a one off issue that no one had experienced, while in reality many had been affected. They even offered significant payoffs to some. It was well past negligence and into active harm. When advised cars were bricking on the highway, the report states “Porsche did not consider this a safety concern”
- mkl95 4y agoThe state of European software is not good. The strategy at the average European company is to spend most of the money on a sales people army and have a few engineers build the product. This strategy often fires back as the customer base grows, because customers want software that actually works. Paying your tech debt is not feasible when your engineering department is small and they are also expected to build new features nonstop. Unfortunately, most of these companies react by partially or completely outsourcing their bad software to bodyshops at developing countries. Those companies maintain the initial quality at best -which was already poor- and at worst they keep making it worse until it becomes unmaintainable and it collapses on itself. The biggest problem of them all is Europe's failure to learn from its own mistakes. This pattern has existed for decades now but it keeps getting worse.
- gumby 4y ago> The strategy at the average European company is to spend most of the money on a sales people army and have a few engineers build the product. Did you mean "average European software company"? A lot of the German Mittelstand companies are the opposite. Instead they sell into a niche through trade shows (another thing probably going away).
- mkl95 4y ago> Did you mean "average European software company"? A lot of the German Mittelstand companies are the opposite. Instead they sell into a niche through trade shows (another thing probably going away). I do. My area has Mitteltstands as well, mostly in biochemistry. I had a bizarre experience interviewing for one of those where they posted a Python job offer but they actually wanted me to write Java and a dozen other things on top of it.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoThat seems a popular sentiment in this thread. But there are of course quite a few unicorns that emerged out of Europe and there is of course the notion that a lot of the mobile networks in the world are running on software that came out of Ericsson or Nokia, which are the dominant options if you don't want to go with Huawei instead. There is of course the notion that Silicon Valley has produced a lot of amazing companies. But it should be noted that a lot of these companies are staffed, and lead by people from all over the world. E.g. Amazon CTO Werner Vogels is from my home country the Netherlands. Both MS and Google have Indian CEOs. etc. And of course US companies have long been outsourcing just about anything complicated to India, Eastern Europe, China, etc. That's not just European companies doing that. That game was pretty much invented in the US. A lot of silicon valley based companies have most of their development departments in different continents. Mot surprising, the local market is very expensive and you can get a full team for the same money that a single developer costs there elsewhere. And you'd be wrong to assume the local developers are better/smarter. There are of course a lot of talented developers there. But I've worked with and been impressed with teams all over Europe. And I've dealt with some US companies where I wasn't so impressed with their engineering. The state of software development in legacy car manufacturers is not good. That's simply because they are historically not software companies and they are all struggling to adjust. What little remains of the US car industry after the Japanese and the Koreans took over is basically being disrupted by Tesla just as badly as the European manufacturers.
- flyinglizard 4y agoIt’s not just the ID and electric stuff that VW messed up software on. I’ve heard the same complaints regarding Mk 8 GTI, a very petrol car. It’s just a systematic failure and I’m not the tiniest bit surprised. I can’t see how they come out of this easily being that their SW/HW platforms are probably rotten to the core, and in automotive it takes a product cycle to fix (5-7 years).
- prng2021 4y agoI hate that auto companies are trying to copy Tesla’s awful product design philosophy of controlling everything via a screen and software. It’s the worst thing to happen to the industry since its inception in my opinion. 1. We’re now introducing so many brand new problems to automobiles or tremendously exacerbating existing ones. I’m referring to problems inherent to all complex software. Bugs, updates causing various regressions, fragility, a whole new set of attack vectors for hackers, [insert 1000 other problems here]. 2. Consumers are unable to appreciate craftsmanship and engineering prowess of creating physical interfaces (dials, buttons, materials, textures, precise stitching and assembly). People love and definitely pay for craftsmanship in things like mechanical keyboards and mechanical watches. We used to be able to enjoy this in cars too, but that’s rapidly fading. 3. It’s just so distracting and time consuming (and therefore dangerous) using a touch screen. Touch screens only make sense on devices that you’re expected to focus your eyes on. That’s why they work on phones but not to replace physical keys of a keyboard, for example.
- im_down_w_otp 4y agoThis is basically what had us choose the Polestar 2 over a Model 3. The Polestar 2 felt like someone with a lot of intent and diligence sat down in the cockpit of the vehicle and asked some flavor of, "Should this feels like a traditional car or should this feel like new technology?" about every single little thing. The UX of the car is Swedish "functionalism" at its finest. We drove a VW, a Tesla, a BMW, a Hyundai, a Kia, a Porsche, a Ford, and a Chevrolet too. For both my spouse and I it wasn't even a close race. We ordered the Polestar. We took delivery of it a couple weeks ago, and even though the $7,500 tax credit expired after the recent legislation passed in the US, I would gladly pay $7,500 more for it than its competitors. The drive feel and the cabin UX are the parts of any car that you're constantly interacting with. To me those two factors outweighed pretty much everything else.
- _nhynes 4y agoI also vastly prefer to use physical controls than a touchscreen, but I’ve found voice control to be even more convenient (when it works, which should only improve over time). I don’t get all of the hate for cars with screens and voice when the latter is a very natural interface when driving.
- bamboozled 4y agoPut less software in cars, build a nice car that's fully electric. It's simple. I'd much prefer a nice, solidly built low tech car, rather than an iPhone with wheels.
- etempleton 4y agoI don’t think much of the world realizes yet just how important silicon and software is and will be moving forward. People think we are reaching peak silicon are wrong, demand is going to continue to grow for the long term. Software developers are going to be even more in demand. Europe, to wildly generalize, doesn’t seem to grasp this. Whether it be German automotive companies or Russian military contractors, the slow response is killing them—in Russia’s case—quite literally. Chips and software, software and chips. Access to chips and good software make all the difference.
- xyzzy_plugh 4y agoThis is funny to me, in a perhaps sad way. I've interviewed quite a few Tesla software engineers and worked with several ex-Tesla software engineers in various capacities. The impression I have is that Tesla software is fucking terrible, generally. I'm sure there are some smart folks there and I don't mean to disparage anyone working there but, the stuff I've seen or heard is enough that I would never purchase one of their vehicles for those reasons alone. That being said I've worked with even fewer folks from other automotive companies, and the impression I get from them is that for the incumbents it's nearly as bad as one could imagine, so the article doesn't surprise me. All of which makes me pretty sad. My most recent vehicle purchase was largely driven by the desire for the least "smart" features possible. But why is this? In software, the closer to metal you are, the harder the problems are (mostly due to constraints) but the worse the job is -- pay, culture... it's all bad. Why?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notimetorelax 4y ago> the closer to metal you are, the harder the problems are (mostly due to constraints) but the worse the job is -- pay, culture... it's all bad. Why? Not saying it’s universal, but I’ve seen this being related to lacking economics of scale. You write software for a limited fleet of widgets and have to constrain your expenses.
- redox99 4y agoI don't know what software you are referring to. But with the IVI, which is what users interact with, the difference is night and day. Most cars have shitty, laggy IVI that will get no meaningful updates. You are on many cases almost forced to use Apple/Android Car. Teslas give you more of an Apple treatment. You will receive meaningful updates for years. It is mostly fluid and good looking. It is exciting for the people looking for the latest gimmick, the same way people look forward to iOS 15 or whatever.
- TMWNN 4y ago>Teslas give you more of an Apple treatment. You will receive meaningful updates for years. What is the cutoff for Tesla cars receiving software updates? Are the early models no longer supported?
- nbzso 4y agoI guess that the energy problem in EU will solve all the questions. When you charge your electric skateboard with black plastic and touchscreen fingerprints, and you pay more than people at the pump, all will be good. Germany with closed nuclear power plants, lack of cheap gas, lack of fertilizers for agriculture, and stopped chemical industry, will never be considered as a strong economy. The future will be dominated by Chinese manufacturers. And transition to "green energy" will result in coal burning, cold winters and service economy. You will own nothing. You will rent everything. Owning a new vehicle will be for privileged ones.
- softwaredoug 4y agoThere’s other successful hardware+software companies (Apple, Tesla) but they have had strong guidance (micromanagement even) from very strong minded leaders. Whereas a company like VW will get a new CEO every few years. How can you really create deep organizational change without a strong top down leader that understands what needs to get done?
- NonNefarious 4y agoHave you worked on a German car? If so, you're likely tired of the "German engineering" myth. Most often, you'll find overly complicated, failure-prone designs that are worse than their simpler domestic counterparts. This isn't just in such things as emission control, but even in what you thought were solved mechanical problems generations ago: hood releases and power windows. I'm not shocked that their software sucks as well. Then again, other cars aren't exactly paragons of software engineering either. Nothing exemplifies that better than the shitshow that is built-in Bluetooth and "infotainment" systems.
- erdos4d 4y ago> Herbert Diess’s master plan for beating Tesla Inc. hinged on replacing calloused factory hands with the nimble fingertips of 10,000 software workers who would transform Volkswagen AG into a tech player. How can any product with 10K developers on it NOT collapse under its own weight?
- avtolik 4y agoWell, for a start it is not a single product. VW is a huge group consisting of a lot of brands, and hundreds of products(vehicles). I guess he wanted to bring the software development of all of these under a single company.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- up2isomorphism 4y agoTesla does not make money without subsidy, and their car is barely usable: none of people I know just own one Tesla, they all need some ice car to back up.
- panick21_ 4y agoNonsense. Tesla has industry leading margin and they actually get less subsidies then many other car companies. Tesla while selling 1/10 the cars of Ford/GM has has profits higher then those companies combined, or will very soon. That everybody has an ICE backup is just not true whatever your personal opinion is.
- leobg 4y agoThis thread isn’t even about that. Tesla has a 20% plus margin on their cars. Zero emission credits put Tesla actually at a competitive disadvantage. And I own a Model X, arguably the most complex model of their lineup, and it hasn’t “broken down“ on me even once. I’ve done roadtrips with it, thousands of kilometers, through heat and cold and mountains. And when you do that, you meet other owners all the time at the superchargers. Up to this day, I have not met a single one who didn’t love his Tesla, much less anyone who had experienced any of those service center horror stories that you read on the internet in posts like yours.
- wumpus 4y agoTesla did make money for a couple of quarters only because of incentives, now they're solidly profitable. It's fun to watch how many years people will post this former "fact" for!
- nikanj 4y agoTesla vs VW is basically iPhone vs Nokia.
- momos 4y agoSpotted the Tesla fanboy.
- jbverschoor 4y agoNo need for 10x / 100x developers, right?
- mihaaly 4y agoNot only car manufacturers but any other appliences and products relying on software struggle. It is 'only' more prominent with safety critical products like cars and airplanes. The absolute and relative (fit to purpose) quality of software are awful in more and more products, incerasingly so. I myself experience it in phones, computers (operating systems and applications), dedicated media players daily, while avoiding app heavy things like robotic vacuum cleaner not working without connecting to the network and a mobile phone (crazy!!), dishwashers with firmware update, etc. All this despite that I make my living on software. Very badly made unfinished and not thought throw implementations are shipped while the content is artificially inflated pumping too much and too complex into, and sometimes - when the ideology of the organization sets it on flags as strategy - simplified on the surface (UI) to the level destroying essential functionality. Squeezing unnecessarily amount of functionality into "clean and streamline" interface not adequate to handle that complexity while accepting the culture of unfinished/incomplete products: advertising the product update - which many times ruin not improves - as good thing and not in its place: the praising of an unfinished product. Software that is supposed to make life easier making life harder and ruining previously good concepts (e.g. substandard touch screen instead of buttons). Instead of just doing something easy smoothly the user increasingly have to tinker and tune the product (configure, setup) long to bring it to the minimum level of functionality making it a very high maintenance thing (also bringing in risks and security concerns unheard of before). It is a daily struggle that badly designed and executed software ruins the experience. The internet is full with workarounds for products, there are sites making living on that. Looking for household appliances like vacuum, dishwasher, fridge now is more difficult because of novelty but unnecessary software supported features sweep into the picture making the search and usage more difficult than necessary (but basically just avoiding those having faulty software) and the product unreliable. Forcing software everywhere is making things worse. Not to mention the rushed and poor quality, intentionally incomplete release of software that escalates the troubles even more. Software is not the holy grail, far from it! It is just a tool to be used in the proper setting, in the proper level or amount, and should be made properly for that.
- derfabianpeter 4y agoI've been working in the field - and for VW specifically - for the past couple of years and am constantly amazed by how far they are actually behind in terms of software and overall technical infrastructure. Especially germans are too stuck in their industrial past - we don't really understand the value and leverage of software for business cases. The car industry is built upon great designers and engineers, outsourcing the actual production of parts to other entities - they're not really used to building anything on their own, they just assemble things. I've written about this here [1]. While this way of thinking isn't limited to automakers, they're the ones that will suffer the most from it in the future. True innovation has been lost to the industry decades ago and is additionally blocked by holding on to the status quo instead of experimenting with and developing new things. I believe this stems from the fact that most of our big businesses are run by MBAs with no real understanding for trends and even less for the speed at which the world moves forward in terms of technology. Diess himself at least tried to push something forward others have neglected since the 90s. Not sure how Blume will approach this, but since he's grown inside the VW bubble for almost 30 years I would not assume that he can drive any kind of real innovation forward. [1] https://derfabianpeter.substack.com/p/europe-and-the-cloud https://derfabianpeter.substack.com/p/europe-and-the-cloud
- halotrope 4y agoMost car infotainment is so bad that Apple just asking to surrender all screens does not seem like a bad proposition at all.