25 ms·
Apple expands Self Service Repair to Mac notebooks
- mikece 4y agoSomehow I suspect Louis Rossmann will still be non-plussed by this and release a video explaining why... and he makes solid points. When Apple starts allowing him to order all of the chips (like charge controllers) to repair his customers' devices then this is just lip service from Apple meant to do the absolute bare minimum to look like they are accommodating Right To Repair while giving the middle finger to independent repair shops who are only being held back by lack of access to parts.
- M4v3R 4y agoFrom TFA: > Self Service Repair for MacBook Air and MacBook Pro offers more than a dozen different repair types for each model, including the display, top case with battery, and trackpad, with more to come So you can purchase the whole display assembly, top case (so basically the whole computer except the display assembly) and trackpads separately. Buying these parts in most cases will not be cost-effective and it's just pure waste to offer them instead offering components more granularly. So yeah, I fully expect Louis to roast this and he will be right.
- vehemenz 4y agoA lot of people seem to think Apple purposely made the components less modular for profit purposes, but I think the bigger reason is that Apple took was limited by the tolerances of the case design and took shortcuts with the component assembly to make manufacturing/QA cheaper.
- goosedragons 4y agoWhy not both? They certainly aren't pricing RAM and SSD upgrades from the goodness of their hearts. And I do wonder if continually making the base models have sub-par amounts of SSD and storage for the price gets people to upgrade the entire machine earlier. Doesn't help that you can't easily get a 1TB MBA either, that BTO, but you can pay an extra $1000 and get a 1TB 14" MBP right now.
- vehemenz 4y agoOf course. That's why I said "the bigger reason" instead of "the only reason."
- widowlark 4y agothey designed the case
- ben-schaaf 4y ago> Buying these parts in most cases will not be cost-effective Apple also requires a serial number when purchasing these parts and the parts are paired to the device. So even if you wanted to start a repair shop that just replaces those parts you can't stock or even install them.
- CarVac 4y agoAnd you can't harvest parts from a dead device.
- userbinator 4y agoSo much for Apple being "environmentally friendly"... As the saying goes, "reuse comes before recycle".
- pca006132 4y agoI remember there is a LTT video saying that buying components from this self service repair is more expansive than their official repair service, you need a device serial number to buy some major components. So it is probably not really for independent repair shops, just a lip service.
- xyst 4y agoI remember watching this video. If I recall correctly, he was including the cost of the tools to repair as well and not just components. I'll need to re-watch and update this comment. edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3kggpE9W8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3kggpE9W8A I was wrong, parent comment is correct. Program is priced to be more expensive and less convenient than taking it to an Apple Store or buying/upgrading to a new phone. this is why right to repair needs to exist. apple is just paying a lip service right now.
- copperx 4y ago> this is why right to repair needs to exist. apple is just paying a lip service right now. This "service" is how Apple is trying to fight right to repair.
- handonam 4y agoWrong link i think
- xyst 4y agocorrect link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdYzVaC6HSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdYzVaC6HSQ
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 4y agoOne of the problems is that truly 'fixing' a Macbook is impossible. If your Logic Board has water damage, 90% of the time you'll need to replace the entire board instead of the $0.50 component that's failing. That's why Louis (and other repair shops) have used donor boards to attempt actual repairs instead of just replacing your whole mainboard. I reckon that's what Apple is going to do here, too. Of course they don't have the gall to sell consumers their Texas Instruments ICs for board repairs, it's likely they're only going to sell piecemeal topcases, Logic Boards, and if we're lucky, batteries too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- r3012 4y agoI wonder why Apple would even want to protect a battery charger IC? All of the interesting stuff would be in software anyway. Maybe the reason repair shops can’t buy it is more mundane. Basically it’s an expensive part, particularly to Apple’s logic board, and distributors don’t believe there are enough Rossmanns out there to sell through a 100k part factory order. When I made PCBs for a large company I had parts I could buy direct from Maxim, at 250k parts minimum, that weren’t on Digi-Key for just that reason.
- jahewson 4y agoPlease name one device manufacturer that sells the individual electronic components on the logic board for repair.
- 120photo 4y agoI trust Rossmann, He will give Apple (or any company) credit when they do something right. Apple lost my trust years ago.
- amelius 4y agoDoes it mean we can now get individual M1 chips from Apple?
- nesk_ 4y agoI don't think it will ever happen, they are sold to the motherboard and their efficiency probably depends on that.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoThat'd be fairly standard with laptop CPUs in general as far as I know. Apple barely sells any actual desktops too (e.g. mac mini is really just a laptop build with some extra ports).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- api 4y agoIt would be hard to use such a chip since it's so customized for Apple hardware, and it's likely only available in BGA(?) or similarly consumer-unfriendly manufacturing oriented packaging. I would really love to see an ARM64 ecosystem similar to what exists for PC hardware with motherboards and chips and other parts available. The chip for that would probably be the Graviton or something similar, and apparently that chip is being sold to other vendors including high-end router vendors like Mikrotik. Unfortunately I do think the M1 beats the crap out of the graviton in at least single core performance, but I think that's because the M1 is optimized for fewer beefier cores for desktop work loads where single threaded performance matters more. Graviton is mostly for cloud and other applications where most work loads are highly multithreaded or multi-tenant.
- maven29 4y agoIsn't this what the RPi4 and other single board computers have already accomplished? They even support UEFI, ACPI and other modern amenities as certified through the SystemReady program. You have socketed peripherals through the compute modules as well.
- jbaczuk 4y agoWow this is unlike Apple. Is this a result of some legal action or legislation?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Gigachad 4y agoThey have had the parts available for the iPhone for a while now. The general consensus is that while the program is a good step forward, it isn’t nearly good enough and all the parts that authorised repair stores wouldn’t fix like charge ports or power buttons, is still not possible to fix.
- klabb3 4y agoFollowing the right to repair movement, Apple seems to only be providing coarse-granular self-repair, meaning that a large amount of small issues need expensive fixes. For instance, display cable broken due to normal wear -> replace entire display assembly @ ~50% of MSRP on an older model. Apple themselves are often doing the same thing when repairing in-house, replacing larger components and charging a premium. And why wouldn't they? Sure, they lose a bit to independent repair shops, but they win massively by having people buy new instead. In other words, democratizing the Apple-grade repairs is not enough, we need individual components to be replaceable, like with a car. Apple quite literally HUNT anyone selling those right now. This new stunt is an amazingly smart way of confusing legislators for a few years. It's even confusing tech enthusiasts. But apple is very much against proper repairability (like a car), no matter who does it.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> But apple is very much against proper repairability (like a car), no matter who does it. Cars are extremely hard to repair for an increasing number of tasks.
- jhugo 4y agoA lot of wear items on cars have been hard to repair for a long time. If we're judging "right to repair" by how easy it is to replace, say, a clutch on a front-wheel-drive car, I think computers are already ahead.
- jagger27 4y ago
- selectodude 4y agoI remember when stealing peoples iPhones and iPods on the subway was affectionately referred to as “apple picking” by the perpetrators. iCloud locking has cut that down to almost nothing. Rather not go back to the “fun” old days.
- reaperducer 4y agoAgreed. Thanks to the miracle of what is now called "Find My," I got to watch as my wife's newly stolen iPhone made its way from Rome to Tunisia. Unfortunately, in its early iterations, you could only locate an item, not take any action on that item. I suspect that wouldn't happen today, since I could now remotely lock the phone.
- raunak 4y agoSuch a strong pipeline of stolen Apple devices -> backdoor shady PC repair shops -> North Africa. I too got to watch my buddies iPhone’s live journey. At least it was a bit entertaining.
- jagger27 4y agoThe thing is that almost none of what I'm talking about are marked as stolen. They're just old devices bricked because they weren't removed from an account.
- selectodude 4y agoObjectively, what is the difference? With no real information, how can you tell?
- jagger27 4y agoObjectively, the result is a mountain of e-waste. edit: and of course, "Mark as lost" is a separate thing from iCloud locking. That's the difference.
- xyst 4y ago> Apple announced Self Service Repair will be available tomorrow for MacBook Air and MacBook Pro notebooks with the M1 family of chips, No M2 support? Also, no support for Intel based Macs? Seems like lip service to me. Although on the bright side, at least Apple is making an effort in the past 1-2 years towards repairability. Would be better if they pull their opposition for "right to repair".
- ericmay 4y agoI don't forsee Intel support, but M2 support will come. They're just slowly rolling this out. > Would be better if they pull their opposition for "right to repair". But then you'd be in the same position you are now with Apple where you'd just get the individual parts and fuck your computer up. Though maybe they should pull their opposition (if indeed they are opposed to this for no good reason) so then companies would have to support the right to repair products like dSLR cameras, TVs and computer monitors, Nintendo Switches, and Samsung mobile phones. I think this would be a nice little market advantage for Apple since these companies are fucking terrible at support for products beyond "send it in". Can you imagine Google trying to support repairing a Chromebook? Though I think what you'd find is just more throw-away electronics because a screen for a Chromebook individually purchased and sent to you will probably cost half as much as a new one. Good for the environment there. Another thing I wonder about is should we treat personal electronics differently? There's a lot of focus on them but most are cheap and disposable. I think there's significant issues with manufacturing or industrial scale products like the infamous John Deere tractors that you can't fix yourself.
- Apocryphon 4y ago> Can you imagine Google trying to support repairing a Chromebook? iFixit has Chromebook guides. Hobbyist communities and niche boutique repair shops arise to fit the needs. https://www.ifixit.com/Search?query=chromebook https://www.ifixit.com/Search?query=chromebook
- ericmay 4y agoThey have them for Macs and iPhones too, and there are a lot of device repair shops for their products. https://www.ifixit.com/Device/MacBook_Pro https://www.ifixit.com/Device/MacBook_Pro
- TacticalCoder 4y agoSo last week I was quoted, by Apple, 680 EUR to fix the cracked screen of my 1000 EUR MacBook Air M1. I'm giving them the finger but, to add insult to injury, I still need to pay 50 EUR to get the computer back. It's sad because I was satisfied by my two previous MacBook Air (non retina / non M1) and I was satisfied by my Mac Mini. But now the Apple love story at home is done. Now recommending Chromebooks to the 65 years+ around us (where we used to recommend Apple). In case there's any class action lawsuit in Europe over this new M1 bend-gate I'll be sure to join and donate to the cause. Typing this from my MIL-SPEC LG Gram, which is an actual proper, sturdy and lighter than any Mac laptop. This comment is what you reap for screwing people over.
- Toutouxc 4y agoWas this the case where the screen cracks on its own? You seem to [edit, reworded] be much more angry about it than I'd be if I'd damaged the computer myself.
- matsemann 4y agoIf I had damaged a small part of something I'd bought, I would be angry if the quote for fixing it would be nearly the price of the whole item new. If you buy a car, hit a kurb and destroy a wheel, wouldn't you be annoyed if it was only the manufacturer that could fix it, and they would charge you 70% of the price of a full car?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhy assume something that is a “small” part necessarily would result in a repair price that is less than x% of purchase price? There are myriad factors that affect repair place, especially for something as technologically advanced as the newest laptops. Labor prices, design of the laptop, parts supplies, etc. Of course, the ability for only one entity to source and supply those will tilt the scales towards a higher price, but that is unrelated to the “small”-ness of the damage.
- 4y ago
- moxplod 4y agoWill we be able to upgrade RAM on M1
- Toutouxc 4y agoNo.
- EugeneOZ 4y agoSounds good, but for now that store they provide only has "iPhone" in the list of supported products. I hope I’ll be able to purchase a new battery for my wife’s M1 Air (without buying the whole top case).
- mrpippy 4y agoAa the link says, the Mac program doesn’t start till tomorrow
- cromka 4y agoI was told at Apple Service that replacing the battery in M1+ generation laptops no longer requires replacing the whole case. Specifically I also have M1 Air and was told that battery is easily replaceable. Waiting for that one myself, too.
- EugeneOZ 4y agoUpdate: yes, it is possible to buy just a battery. Great!
- verisimilitude 4y agoCaveat: repair now available for Mac Notebooks "with the M1 family of chips" - this is reasonable, I think. However, I do feel badly because I have a 2017 with a noisy fan that needs to be replaced, but I don't think I'll ever be able to get the precisely OEM Apple-blessed one. This is important to me because of the non-annoying whoosh sound that the varied blade spacing of the OEM fans normally provide. My options are (1) used or (2) rando cross-your-fingers 'brand' fan. I guess I could just try a variety of those no-names and use the least annoying one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 4y ago3) take it in to Apple for repair.
- lstamour 4y agoAnd do it soon, or the 7 year “legacy” period might kick in. Apple has a cut-off past which they will not service or support their products. It’s usually 5-7 years from when they were first or last sold. (Actually, it’s a bit arbitrary if you ask me, because Apple is the one that sets whether a product is still serviceable or not, regardless of how long it’s been.)
- samatman 4y agoI'm not seeing the viable alternative to a clearly-stated policy on the duration of repair services. Ok. I can imagine a world where I could bring in an Apple II from 1980 and get it serviced at a shiny glass Apple store. That would be pretty cool in fact, leaving aside the small but entirely real population of enthusiasts who would lose income, livelihood in some cases. But it doesn't seem like a reasonable demand. At some point the specialist aftermarket takes over. Clearly stating when that will be in advance is the most one can ask for.
- 4y ago
- ramesh31 4y agoUnfortunately no support for previous gen Intel machines. The ones that were notorious for keyboard failures. Guess that means my keyboard will never work again.
- jmillikin 4y agohttps://support.apple.com/keyboard-service-program-for-mac-notebooks https://support.apple.com/keyboard-service-program-for-mac-n... The page says it applies for "4 years after the first retail sale", but in practice they seem willing to replace covered models older than the cutoff. If you've got broken keys, might as well take it in to see if they'll replace the keyboard for free.
- threeseed 4y agoiFixit has keyboards available if you want to repair it yourself. https://www.ifixit.com/Parts/MacBook_Pro/Keyboards https://www.ifixit.com/Parts/MacBook_Pro/Keyboards
- mihaitodor 4y ago> Apple will offer rental kits for $49, so that customers who do not want to purchase tools for a single repair still have access to these professional repair tools. Customers will have access to the tool kit for one week and it will be shipped free of charge. Shipping isn't free. It's just included in the cost. Wish it was possible to force companies to stop using bullshit marketing tactics.
- CGamesPlay 4y agoEh, I prefer to see one upfront total cost than a bunch of smaller fees that only appear later and later in the checkout flow.
- mihaitodor 4y agoIt also implies that you get no benefit from picking it up yourself from their shop. I might be tempted to check out some of their other products if I feel incentivised to drop by.
- tpmoney 4y agoYou can’t pick it up at the apple store yourself. They’re not stocking these kits in the retail stores, its online only
- mihaitodor 4y agoI’m based in Europe, where it’s more popular to go and pick stuff up from a physical store. Maybe they should consider having such an option in some countries, but this is a different issue.
- solardev 4y ago...this is really what you're upset about?
- dymk 4y ago
- GeckoEidechse 4y agoWhile the limitation to newer models sucks. The fact that thanks to (planned) legislation Apple feels pressured to make parts available to consumers is an absolute win for right to repair. Is Apple doing as much as they can to make this as unviable as possible? Yes, but it's a first step in the right direction :D
- mkagenius 4y agoI am from India. My 10 day old Macbook M1 Pro suddenly died with no signs of life. As sad that may sound its nothing compared to what happened next at the Apple Authorized service center. The lady at the counter put a giant scratch across the Apple logo going further ahead on the case. Now these service centers are so much afraid of Apple and its policy that she started parroting that its a cosmetic damage and Apple policy doesn't allow to replace it for that. I asked her I am not invoking my warranty, the scratch is done by you and you have to fix it. Days pass and they divert me to the seller, who refused to replace the laptop due to the scratch. The Apple Support in India is equally pathetic with no authority at all. Had it been the U.S. and someone at Genius store would have done that, it would have been much easier to get a new machine (it was just 10 day old) or atleast the display case replaced but welcome to India where consumer laws take the second seat and Apple's policy take the first. After all this, I had to call the police and when the police came the service center gave me in writing that they would replace the display. Filing consumer case now against Apple for the harassment, preparing the docs. If you are from India and want to join in - drop me a mail. Edit: forgot to mention the popping sound on my older macbook from 2017 with touchbar. Will apple do anything about that? Seems it is also clueless.
- Fradow 4y agoI'm surprised the popping sound doesn't surface much more than that. I recently bought a 2021 M1 Macbook Pro (so a 2K€+ machine) and this popping sound I get when I use the built-in speakers is awful. After Googling around, it seems this issue hits a lot of people and dates back to the first M1 Macs being released (nearly 2 years now) and has still not been properly addressed (and I never found a workaround other than plugging headphones and just not using the speakers). And as you said, Apple seems clueless about it.
- mkagenius 4y ago> popping sound I get when I use the built-in speakers is awful. My issue might be a different one, it comes when I touch the display back side (and sometimes just randomly). I did some research and it seems to be caused by expansion and contraction of some kind of metal inside the body.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jld89 4y agoApple quoted me 900 EUR to repair a motherboard problem (replace the whole damn thing). On a 3K EUR macbook pro. I went to a third party, 250 EUR, they just repaired the motherboard, works like a charm, and did it in 1 day. It's been 2 years. Fuck apple.
- oneplane 4y agoThat's great (for you), but there's no telling what "works like a charm" actually means, and no real way to tell if the specs as-advertised still match the specs-post-repair. This is also why Apple doesn't bother with board level repairs on an individual basis. For some people, that measure or metric doesn't matter, and that's fine, but it by no means is a universal "see this is better" approach. And I say this as someone who does board level repairs. On iPhones. (and that mostly came about because people tried to replace the screens on their phones with the power on, blowing the backlight circuit) Doing something as a one-off is nothing compared to doing something world-scale.
- CharlesW 4y agoIf there are 3rd parties who do inexpensive fixes quickly, what is the problem?
- josephcsible 4y agoThat Apple goes out of their way to make it harder for those third parties to do that.
- threeseed 4y agoBut they don't though. They go after third parties who are using counterfeit or non-OEM parts.
- fmntf 4y agoIt's repair versus buy. If you cut the power cord of your dishwasher, you can buy a new dishwasher from Bosch for 900€, or ask a 3rd party to repair it for 25€. I don't see any "fuck Bosch" logic here.
- idk1 4y ago
- nojito 4y agoIf they didn't send the exact same tools they use people will complain that they aren’t sharing the real tools. It’s a lose lose situation.
- groovybits 4y agoNo need to speculate. The LinusTechTips crew posted a video detailing what you get: https://youtu.be/F90q1WVZ2N4 https://youtu.be/F90q1WVZ2N4 I'm not an Apple employee or repair technician. They seem like professional tools - I would definitely need to reference the included instructions.
- snowwrestler 4y agoThe big case of equipment is optional. You’re not required to rent it to repair your own iPhone.
- kepler1 4y agoSo what would you have them do? Send you a kit with some janky aluminum foil, tools bought off Ebay, and instructions on how to scrounge around your kitchen for stuff that can be used to pry off the screen? For fucks sake, it's like they can't satisfy you no matter what they do. You wanted to be able to repair to the quality and assurance that the manufacturer does and now are griping about the cost of it. (or did you? and now are having 2nd thoughts?)
- idk1 4y agoI didn't criticize the price of it. If I had to say one thing it would be have the purchase of the items through the apple website and normal apple account. Not that strange third party thing. Just hook it into the apple eco-system like all of their other stuff. Imagine if they did the apple trade-in program or returns this way or applecare this way, created a whole new obtuse website to use. Also I don't appreciate the swearing and I don't have 2nd thoughts.
- status200 4y agoAs someone who has repaired Apple devices over the years, swearing under my breath each time they put new hurdles in the way, it is so refreshing to see a full repair manual for my relatively new phone [0]. Lots of negativity in the comments but it is so relieving to see Apple change course and lift the curtain. Also adding to the anecdotes with my own: I have never needed a case for my phones or computers, and have barely even scratched the shell. I go on adventures for a good portion of the year and still manage to keep it intact, so i scratch my head when people say they break easily or that they always shatter their screen, it really seems to go beyond accidental damage and stray into carelessness. [0] https://manuals.info.apple.com/MANUALS/2000/MA2074/en_US/iphone-13-pro-07300324A-repair.pdf https://manuals.info.apple.com/MANUALS/2000/MA2074/en_US/iph...
- soared 4y agoSome people fumble things in their hands, it’s not carelessness. Just differences between people, hand eye coordination, etc.
- paulmd 4y agoanecdotally there are two kinds of people, the people who break their phone twice a year and the people who break one maybe every 10 years. It'd be really interesting to see a probability distribution function of failure rates.
- srk_hn 4y agoThat's really not a fair comparison. There are plenty of people who are elderly or dealing with disc injuries where they are prone to losing their grip or slipping a phone when moving about, picking it out of their pocket, etc. While you may be in good health, it's important to remember not everyone is the same and some people are dealing with a variety of issues.
- pythonaut_16 4y agoParent comment seems more focused on the probability/distribution than in the reasons why. The anecdote seems true from my experience as well; people tend to either break their phones often or very rarely/not at all. Of course it could be that you are far more likely to take notice of someone breaking their phone if it happens often.
- widowlark 4y agoI am taking a look at the comments on this thread and im astonished. HN is full of intelligent, self-reliant people and yet, all throughout this thread I see so many users trashing people for complaints about price and service quality from Apple. So many users here have had obviously bad experiences with Apple Care and Apple Repair Services, why is it so hard to believe them? Also, why is it so hard to imagine that Apple is making some mistakes in their repair model? Commenters defending Apple here - they dont care about you at all, they dont need the assistance from you in defending them, and you dont get a discount for doing so, so what is your motivation for doing it? It is clear this 'Self Service Repair' model is designed to prevent independent repair shops from making money, therefore eliminating them. In what way is this good for the consumer?
- Ycombigatorz 4y ago
- kmlx 4y ago> It is clear this 'Self Service Repair' model is designed to prevent independent repair shops from making money, therefore eliminating them. how is this clear? do you think everyone will simply start fixing their own devices? from my experience a tiny tiny minority of people have both the necessary experience and the time to do this, thus leaving the independent shops mostly unaffected.
- shaan7 4y agoValve's approach to the Steam Deck has been a refreshing approach in all this. It is a well-built product and replacement parts are a few clicks away https://www.ifixit.com/Parts/Steam_Deck https://www.ifixit.com/Parts/Steam_Deck People keep asking me why I don't like Apple products. I actually like most of their actual products, but their attitude as a company is frustrating. I don't want to pay a premium to feel limited.
- zamalek 4y agoI recently ditched my OneWheel for an EUC because just look at this awesome stuff: https://www.myinmotion.com/pages/parts-and-accessories https://www.myinmotion.com/pages/parts-and-accessories
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoYou mentioned a wheel in the context of Apple and I thought you were talking about the Apple MacBook Wheel. https://youtu.be/9BnLbv6QYcA https://youtu.be/9BnLbv6QYcA
- MivLives 4y agoI was always surprised at how good the one wheel after market parts stuff was. Like you could replace almost everything besides the front foot pad, brains, and motor. I guess most of it is just injected molded plastic bolted on with screws but still it was nice to have the option of different rear foot pads, fenders, tires, etc. How have you found the switch? Still enjoy riding as much? I had to sell my One Wheel because I moved and the new area the roads were too annoying to cruise on. I've been considering it since the bigger wheels might make it easier to ride on the rougher roads.
- zamalek 4y agoThe learning curve is significantly steeper. I am already (2-3 weeks) feeling a more frequent urge to go for a ride, compared to the OW, but they say it takes about 6mo for it to really click and drag you in. It definitely doesn't feel as cool, though, and doesn't start conversations.
- Twisell 4y agoTL DR for comments: Apple damned if it does and damned if it doesn't
- crooked-v 4y agoI can't wait for the next big article complaining about Apple renting you exactly the same equipment they use, at cost, because it's all just too big and complicated.
- pbmango 4y agoIf you take two obvious leaders in manufacturing excellence (for this audience at least), Apple and Tesla, they both now in 2022 seem to be running up against repair and service problems. Part of this might be that they have so optimized the rest of the funnel that these blotches stand out in even more contrast. When the goods are cheap, late, or defective their lack of post-purchase service is taken for granted.
- closetohome 4y agoI do kind of wonder how much the new repair-friendly Apple has to do with the fact that they lose basically the entire laptop's margin every time they have to replace a battery under warranty.
- mcguire 4y agoInteresting. After Steve Jobs left Apple the first time, Apple became much more like the other hardware companies of the time, including opening up things that they had previously held tightly closed. When Jobs returned, they clamped back down. Now, Jobs has left Apple permanently and Apple is once again opening up. So here's a question: Is this a good thing, or is it a sign that Apple is returning to the mediocrity of the earlier non-Jobs era? Is Apple losing what made it great?
- httpz 4y agoI tried replacing a broken speaker on my old Macbook Pro. I followed a very detailed guide from ifixit and it involved removing the motherboard, disconnecting 7 different ribbon cables, and keeping track of the exact location of 30 different screws of various sizes. I've done a fair share of self-repair on various laptops and smartphones I owned and this was by far the scariest one. It didn't seem like something an average person can pull off easily.
- JohnGB 4y agoThat's because those laptops were specifically designed to not be easily repairable. The new ones are complying with EU regulations, and so are easier to repair.
- dmix 4y agoThey were designed to be as small as possible, which sacrificed internal access. I doubt they purposefully made repairablity difficult. It just wasn't a major factor when 90% of the time they just give you a new laptop when you show up at Apple with a broken one (with a warranty or Apple+).
- user3939382 4y ago> I doubt they purposefully made repairablity difficult I'm more cynical of Apple since they started doing things like soldering in RAM connections on the Mini totally unnecessarily.
- saagarjha 4y agoWhat about “the RAM is on-package” strikes you as being unnecessary?
- acdha 4y agoWhat makes you think it was unnecessary? Sockets are good for expansion but they increase failure rates and the extra distance increases latency so losing it is one thing helping push unified SoC performance.
- pphysch 4y agoThis looks a lot more like Apple finding additional revenue streams selling "genuine™" parts than a genuine attempt at making their devices economically repairable. What's the markup on the genuine™ sticker?
- asdff 4y agoProbably to stave off lawsuits for right to repair tbh. Tellingly they've only publicized the repair manuals for their newer machines, not their older hardware that certainly has a manual sitting in an internal server somewhere.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoDisclaimer: MacBookPro18,2 On the face of it, it would appear a big change from a PR perspective. Still though, you can't upgrade or change the RAM, CPU, SSD, or anything else. The parts are insanely expensive and it's designed for manufacturing (DfM), not repair or durability. Just ask any tech who has ever worked on a Thinkpad T-series vs. a MBP. Although it seems like they're going through the motions of R2R to quiet down the shrieks, only time will tell if they really mean to return to almost serviceable computers.
- jcadam 4y agoRemember when Apple made their computers intentionally easy to work in? The old G3/G4 Powermac towers with their drop-down side doors were really nice to deal with. The G5 Towers were almost as good.
- asdff 4y agoMy 2010 macbook pro had a nice door to access the battery and disk drive without any tools. Gone by the 2012, replaced with phillips head screws. After that it was it for user replaceable batteries. I'm glad I have this 2012 macbook pro that is still user repairable and upgradeable. I just gave it a fresh battery this summer and I'm hoping for another 10 years out of it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- supernova87a 4y agoI know this will be a item of only specialized interest, but I note that: It is important to know that while this new repair site now offers parts and instructions for repairing MacBooks for example, there is also a special activation/configuration requirement on M1 MacBooks now after certain kinds of repairs, like screens, webcams, boards, etc. Otherwise they will not work fully (disabled webcam, screen brightness/Trutone not working, etc). I don't know the specifics but it's some kind of calibration codes, secure component tying or something similar. The thing is that this repair site will not assist you if you do not buy the part from the site. I asked them about it because I was thinking of repairing mine with this new site. So even if you take a genuine original Apple part from another computer (not even ordering some 3rd party part, but a real Apple component) and use it in your own repair, you may not be able to activate it. That sucks.
- Jenny_Wengerd0 4y ago