30 ms·
I remember feeling derisive about marketing as a young techie
- game-of-throws 4y agoIf only the well wasn't poisoned.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- manv1 4y agoYes. The problem with marketing people is it's hard to tell which ones are full of shit and which ones aren't...becuase they both sound the same.
- paulcole 4y agoBecause no full-of-shit engineer ever fools anyone…
- SilasX 4y agoIt’s definitely a problem for engineers too, spurred on by “fake it till you make it”/“all self doubt is just Impostor Syndrome”-ism.
- hammock 4y agoThat’s the other side (the consumer-facing side) of the coin, “half my marketing budget is wasted. I just don’t know which”
- secondcoming 4y agoNot just marketing people, look at the crypto space.
- vkou 4y agoCrypto is 90% marketing.
- mandmandam 4y agoMy breakdown would be ~50% marketing, 49% first mover advantage, 1% actual tech. Many coins are far superior to BTC and Ether, on basically every front.* BTC and Ether are whale oil and crude, next to green energy.* The vast majority don't have the patience to listen to what's going on under the hood. They don't have the background in math, in coding, in economics to make sound decisions amid the oceans of bullshit. And it's not reasonable to expect them to be competent in all required fields before dipping their toe in. The tech is what interests me* - I have no significant stake in any of them.* When I try to tell people [very rarely] about block lattice such as Nano, people don't believe me.* They say I sound like a marketer when I claim that it processes transactions in under a second with no fees.* If I try to talk about how important decentralization is, people claim that BTC is the most decentralized (!!). Bag holders will bullshit til the day things break completely. ... I'd love to fix all this, but when I talk about it - *. * - I sound like a marketer.
- davidatbu 4y agoDoes this count as poetry? Because I really like it.
- mandmandam 4y agoUmm, yeah.. Sure. Yes. Definitely. ... That's really nice to hear, thank you :)
- bsenftner 4y ago> They don't have the background in math, in coding, in economics And for those of us that do have backgrounds in every one of these fields, we notice the abuse of formal industry terms with crypto-exclusive definitions that weaken the economic structure or flat out fabricate fantasy. Cryptocurrencies are a great idea for a more mature civilization. We are not that civilization.
- Mordisquitos 4y agoMy pet theory is that marketing and publicity as a craft is subject to an unfortunate combination of two factors: 1) successful results are hard to measure quantitatively and 2) the skill itself is focused on selling stuff. As a result, once the market of successfully marketing products and services has reached equilibrium, marketing specialists are no longer competing and being selected for being better at selling marketable items—they are competing and being selected for being better at selling their own services to executives up to C-level. It's easier to optimise the ability to sell one particular service to a known and relatively homogeneous audience than to optimise the ability to sell any arbitrary product or service to a broad and infinitely diverse population. Hence for instance the truism of "no publicity is bad publicity". What better way for the marketing crowd to evade the negative consequences of unsuccessful, controversial or even broadly hated campaigns? Now I'm not saying that all successful marketing specialists follow this pattern. What I'm saying is that they are no longer at an advantage with regards to the bullshit sellers.
- etempleton 4y agoIn the agency world, this is absolutely true. The goal is to get more work, not to do good work. Those who are good in the pitch meetings get promoted. In an internal marketing department? Much less true. You still need people who are good at presenting and working with internal clients, but that is more based on communication skills then selling.
- Mordisquitos 4y agoYes, that does make sense. I'm sure the motivations and incentives of internal marketing teams are much better aligned, particularly if they have been established for a while.
- rapind 4y ago> becuase they both sound the same. Found your answer.
- etempleton 4y agoIt is true. As someone who has spent over a decade in marketing, only a small percentage really have any idea what they are doing. Most just parrot what people who know what they are talking about—it will sound good at first, but then you realize they don’t understand what they are saying beyond the surface-level detail. This is especially problematic when you are not a marketer and hope to hire a marketer or marketing agency. The good ones, bad ones, and nefarious ones will all sound pretty much the same. The best advice I can give if you are looking for marketing help is to find a trusted advisor. The second best is to trust the one who tells you hard truths. You will hate it when they say your product won’t sell at the volume you want in the current form, but most marketers develop a sixth sense for what will and won’t sell and often have some ways to estimate demand for a particular niche or industry. Most agencies won’t tell you that your product won’t sell because no one likes to hear that. It actually shows a lot of honesty and directness to tell a client that it won’t work.
- Clubber 4y ago>Most agencies won’t tell you that your product won’t sell because no one likes to hear that. Also, I think there is incentive for agencies to say a product will sell (other than people don't like hearing it). It's a lot easier to spend $100K if I'm gonna get back $500K in sales than if I'm just gonna get back $50K.
- etempleton 4y agoExactly.
- cynusx 4y agoI've been recruiting a marketer for some time and eventually gave up and assumed the role myself and I can concur this. The vast majority of marketers just know how to show activity but have no idea how to track, optimize and actually convert clients. Let alone find creative ways that are not just "test more ads" and "create more content". Even simply tracking ROI across the marketing/sales funnel is too much to ask
- rexreed 4y agoAssume they are full of shit unless they prove otherwise. Being actually good at marketing is pretty rare. Most marketers are those with poor skills and little talent who find marketing's ambiguity a perfect place to hide and do work in a startup without having to prove results. Even worse are so-called growth hackers.
- Pokepokalypse 4y agoUltimately, marketers market themselves. They may be good at it or bad at it, but at the end of the day, if they're dishonest about it, they can be successful also.
- awat 4y agoAgreed, and many of them don’t know when they are lying. It’s easier to sound really confident when you don’t have the domain knowledge to know if you are telling the truth.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoEh, there's marketing and there's marketing. Making stuff discoverable to people who do or would want it is great. Abusing psychological tricks to try and get people to buy your product regardless of value is less great. Spamming people because surely they need to know about your super special amazing product is worthy of derision.
- anonu 4y agoAs engineers, we all want to build the 10x product - the one that is so great that it cooks for you and does your dishes too. But most products don't reach 10x, maybe theyre only 1.1x or 1.2x - meaning small incremental improvements over whatever else is out there. I think if you can use a new tool and get "10% more of whatever" out of it - then thats still good, but the user friction you will encounter will be too great, switching costs are too high. I think this is where marketing comes in. Most successful marketing wont tell you about all the nice features, they will instead give you a feeling that using the product you belong to some higher strata of society or humanity. That is what makes great marketing. You can say its BS - but think about how the coolest products you use in your daily life make you "feel"...
- Jasper_ 4y agoMaybe we shouldn't try and impose great switching costs on society for things that are, at-best, 1.2x improvement. Marketing also tends to downplay the externalities, costs, and downsides to a new technology, because their job is to get you to buy things. In practice, I don't even think most 1.2x products even reach that in the long run once all the negatives are accounted for.
- rapind 4y ago> As engineers, we all want to build the 10x product - the one that is so great that it cooks for you and does your dishes too What? No we don’t. Maybe some of us I’m sure, but I’d wager only a small minority want to build a 10x product as a priority. I suspect the category is far too wide to generalize about this, but for myself (programmer and entrepreneur) I enjoy the “craft” as cheesy as that sounds. The satisfaction from pouring effort into something you can be proud of. Awesome if it pays the bills (even better if I no longer need to care about bills), but 10x w/e isn’t even something I’m thinking of.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat percent of products you buy you are sorry you bought?
- wpietri 4y agoI think bullshit is technically the correct term for that "make people feel superior" nonsense. Bullshit being "statements produced without particular concern for truth, to distinguish from a deliberate, manipulative lie intended to subvert the truth". What if we just trusted people to decide for themselves when the 10% improvement is good enough for them to switch? Rather than, say, manipulating them via cognitive flaws so that we can fill our own pockets.
- LordDragonfang 4y agoSome important context is that this tweet comes from John Carmack, "Consulting CTO" for Oculus/Meta VR. Oculus fairly recently got a lot of criticism for laying out its plan to introduce an advertising API inside of VR experiences. Many of the early-adopting developers actually pulled out of the pilot because the backlash was so strong.
- aabhay 4y agoI couldn't find any recent news about this -- the most recent article I found is Oculus' blog post from June 2021. So I don't believe this particular tweet is providing cover for any recent decision, but the implication you are making (that Carmack has to provide cover for the advertising efforts of Meta) is probably accurate.
- codegeek 4y agoYea but John Carmack's identity is not just about Consulting CTO for Oculus. He is much bigger than that.
- mrguyorama 4y agoHe chose to bolt himself onto the Facebook monster, so he loses all respect from me for that. You can be the smartest person in the world and still do stupid and harmful things. The world would be better if he did nothing, rather than making the Oculus platform more competitive. I think I'd rather see VR struggle to survive than Facebook have a de-facto stranglehold on the ecosystem.
- dale_glass 4y agoI'd have much preferred something other than Facebook, but it can't be denied that VR needed a lot of money to be anywhere near decent. I've got all the Oculus hardware starting from the DK1. * DK1 is 100% a proof of concept. It's not suitable for anything but really primitive gaming. * DK2 is the bare minimum acceptable to play games with. You have to squint at critical information in Elite. That was using a Galaxy Note 4 screen, from a high end, expensive phone. The modern tech is absolutely critical to giving it an enjoyable experience. Good controllers, excellent tracking without having to place cameras around carefully, high enough resolution that games can actually show text to the player.
- NhanH 4y agoIn the ideal world, people should be empowered to be able to retrieve what they are looking for when they need it (people pull and filter information, rather than being pushed information). The reason we can’t realistically do it right now is due to marketing effort manifested into spam, which turns it into a very difficult technological problem. I would still feel derisive about marketing as a field due to that reason. Marketing nowadays seems to focus on overwhelming the audience and hope they makes bad decisions.
- austinpena 4y agoOftentimes marketing is focused on those who aren't "problem aware" which can bring genuine value. These types of marketing messages focus on bringing a previously unknown problem/inefficiency to someone's mind and show the solution.
- NhanH 4y agoI had part of my comment responding to this point, but I wasn’t sure how to best phrase it so I cut it off. I don’t believe for this to happen enough at any frequency to be a valid reason. People usually knows their pain point, and go to great length trying to address that (normally spending a lot of time due to, well, spam-ish marketing). And to be frank, most products are not game-changing things that magically solve a problem no thing previously could have solved. People are already using tools and solutions for their problems, and if they are looking for a better thing, they already know which tweak it needs. They just can’t differentiate the solutions between a sea of junk marketing.
- drstewart 4y ago>People usually knows their pain point Exactly. I know my buggy is slow, I just need a faster horse.
- austinpena 4y agoI look at duckduckgo, they do tons of Top of Funnel advertising like billboards. Do you think that they should cease this type of advertising and just try and show up when people search "privacy conscious search engine"?
- micromacrofoot 4y agoWe have no choice but to be skeptical of marketing, because if we weren't they'd take every penny from us.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hikingsimulator 4y agoThe main issue I have with capital M Marketing is that it is very much about creating demand ex nihilo, not matching with already existing demand. I often think of [former French media CEO] Le Lay's 2004 take on the role of media w.r.t. advertisement: it's about selling "available human brain time." Marketing is about filling that void and entice consumption. And it rings so much truer nowadays with social media.
- hinkley 4y ago> creating demand ex nihilo For some religions, and a number of athiests, instead of a little devil on your shoulder, it's a tiny marketing person, telling you you're not good enough, you're not safe enough, you're not happy enough.
- EddieDante 4y agoOpposite the marketing person in the black suit is a marketing person in a white suit telling you that all you've got to do to be good enough, safe enough, and happy enough is to drink the Koolaid[0] and kiss Hank's ass[1]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_the_Kool-Aid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_the_Kool-Aid [1]: https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Kissing_Hank%27s_Ass https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Kissing_Hank%27s_Ass
- tootie 4y agoIf you work in pure marketing (like an ad agency) you also don't generally get to pick what it is you're selling. You pitch to everyone and sell services to the highest bidder. Sometimes you get lucky but most of the time you don't.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> If you work in pure marketing (like an ad agency) you also don't generally get to pick what it is you're selling. They're mercenaries, and mercenaries have a choice. "Oh no my boss said I have to advertise these cigarettes and I don't have a choice because... I work for this agency" Just walk out of the office and go find an honest job. A conscripted soldier might be said to have no choice, but mercenaries do. Marketers do. They chose the money.
- mola 4y agoI have a lot of respect for carmack but this sentiment is very tone-deaf. Maybe he doesn't experience the web and real life the same as me, I don't know. But honestly I don't see any problem of not knowing about new valuable stuff, I DO see a problem of knowing about every inane fake scammy deceitful manipulative useless thing without wanting to.
- ketzo 4y agoWait — you don’t see any problem not knowing about valuable stuff? If your product offered a 5x better way to do something, but nobody knew about it, wouldn’t you be a little frustrated for both yourself and them?
- powerhour 4y agoAre there any good examples of 5x products you've learned about through marketing efforts (and not, say, trusted colleagues)? I can't think of one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themacguffinman 4y agoHow do you think your trusted colleagues originally found out about the stuff they recommend you? Even if they searched for it, SEO is marketing too (no doubt the search engine listing would be a marketing optimized webpage). I'm pretty sure I found out about FreeTaxUSA through ads. The HN submissions for Notion seemed promotional to me and it's how I found out about it, I'd also struggle to think of how Notion would have been discovered if a marketing or sales team did not make efforts to spread mentions of it. GitLab markets pretty aggressively on HN (or at least they used to) which is how I found out about it too.
- permo-w 4y ago>How do you think your trusted colleagues originally found out about the stuff they recommend you? probably youtube or a course of some variety. the only times I ever gain anything from advertising is adverts for new series of tv shows
- jedberg 4y agoI'm a big fan of marketing as a consumer. Yes, it's mostly terrible and abusive, but also one of my all time favorite tech purchases came out of seeing an ad for it (my comma.ai running openpilot). That device has changed my life so drastically that any car purchase I make in the future (new or used) will begin by looking for cars that support openpilot. And it all started with an instagram ad.
- wpietri 4y agoThat seems a big post hoc ergo propter hoc to me. I'm glad that you found something you're happy with. But in a world without advertising, you can still find things you need, even novel ones. For example, I got a Garmin sports watch recently, and one of the reviews I found was from DC Rainmaker, who is exactly the sort of detail-oriented obsessive I love reading reviews from. That got me to read some of his other reviews and I discovered that there's now a whole category of bike radar units that let you know when somebody is overtaking you. That's amazing! When I return to cycling, I will absolutely buy one. Does that mean I have to be in favor of all blogs? Or that my life will be worse if that blogger stops reviewing? Definitely not. I could have learned about this product in many other ways. Bike stores! Bike forums! The manufacturer's website! Other cyclists! Review sites! Bike magazines! Etc, etc.
- jedberg 4y ago> But in a world without advertising, you can still find things you need, even novel ones. Sure, eventually. Maybe. But I'm glad this information was pushed to me when it was. > I could have learned about this product in many other ways. Bike stores! Bike forums! The manufacturer's website! Other cyclists! Review sites! Bike magazines! Etc, etc. It amuses me that at least two of the examples you listed are just other marketing channels by companies (magazines and their own website) and marketers definitely work in forums, review sites, sending information to stores, and other cyclists most likely learned about it from marketing too.
- davidivadavid 4y agoThat's the age old Hacker News fairy tale of the "fair and balanced reviews" approach to marketing. Businesses don't need to advertise! We'll find their products and generate word of mouth! Yeah, I'm sure people who put their livelihood at risk by starting a new business are going to entirely trust that to happen. Look, there's a lot of marketing scams. We know. But until someone here stops whining for a minute and explains to me how they would start a business with nothing they would call "marketing" I'll keep being very dismissive of clueless engineers who could not sell something to save their lives but who happily work at fucking Google (or something that feeds off of it) and criticize whole disciplines they've never practiced or studied.
- sarchertech 4y agoTrade magazines were essentially opt-in advertising that I think solve most of the problems that marketing ostensibly tries to solve. The problem is that when your competitor is everywhere, you need to be everywhere too. It’s an arms race. Maybe there’s a way to cap the arms race without overly favoring incumbents?
- permo-w 4y agoI'd like to see the results of a country banning advertising entirely, except for a few opt-in experiences like trade magazines. there would obviously be initial downsides, but I'd be really interested to see how (or whether) the artistic creative equilibrium reasserts itself. government investment? more paid services?
- Panzer04 4y agoI feel like there’d be consequences for up-and-comers against incumbents, who would have a huge brand lead.
- permo-w 4y agovery possibly, but I think possibly not too. if the government instituted huge grants for the arts and media - something they may have to do to sell this radical idea - the effect could be the opposite obviously in a democracy those grants are always at the whim of the day's government if we assume that doesn't happen, it would certainly screw over the little guy
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- QuantumGood 4y agoThere's a name (that I forget) for the concept that there is no system of law that cannot be gamed. Successful players of the game always emerge, and eventually gain and abuse power.
- 4y ago
- specialist 4y agoSturgeon's Law applies in every endeavor. Once you work with good marketing people, it becomes clear that most are terrible, or worse. I once worked with a "marcom" (marketing communications) person who was absolutely gifted. Completely remade the company's image with branding, copy, and misc materials. They some how created tasteful, engaging stuff with a very small budget. I once worked with a genius "bizdev" (business development) marketing person who worked magic. Surveys, determined market size, competitive analysis, turned some cranks to magically determine price points, budgeting, etc. All the stuff that feeds into sound (quantifiable) strategy and product planning. Older me tries (struggles) to not denigrate other professions, just because most of the practitioners are bozos.
- notahacker 4y agoI wonder what the comments about software developers look like on Marketer News :)
- mindtricks 4y agoThe reason most young engineers think this way is 1) they think their work is self-evident and doesn't require demand creation, 2) their management does not engage with marketing and therefore can't convey the value down, and 3) confuses "growth hacking" and "advertising" with the broader work that marketing supports. ...and for the records, they're completely justified here. They have a lot on their plate as a new engineer and this is not an area that has immediate value to them.
- davidivadavid 4y agoIn that case I would suggest not having such apparently strongly held (wrong) opinions about a whole discipline their paycheck relies on every month.
- byset 4y agoalso, young engineers are often working on features meant to address market needs discovered by marketers, but they don't know it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lbriner 4y agoThere can also be a problem at scale. A small team getting the word out to people who will be genuinely helped by your product and avoiding wasting time on people who won't be interested is great. However, at a certain point, with a multi-million pound marketing team, you start getting diminishing returns, hard-selling the brand and inventing BS schemes to justify your cost (Tropicana, Pepsi etc.). Corporates (or investors?) seem to struggle with the idea that a market can saturate and there is little extra value to find except at a much larger input cost.
- cm2012 4y agoIn the end, your product can't provide value for anyone if no one knows about it. Marketing is big and messy and illogical but overall it helps society more than it hurts, much like capitalism as a whole.
- sachdevs 4y agoRunning a small company and balancing time between marketing and building the core product is really hard - it's hard to see the immediate value in marketing when the opportunity cost is a worse product.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- buscoquadnary 4y agoTo quote Scott Adams in the Dilbert principal. "If you experience any ethical problems with [marketing] remember the [marketing] motto 'were not screwing the customers where holding them down while the Sales people screw them.'"
- bufordtwain 4y ago"Doing business without advertising is like winking at a girl in the dark. You know what you are doing but nobody else does." ― Steuart Henderson Britt
- xwdv 4y agoI hated marketing. Marketing always felt like the one thing that was in my way to achieving massive success. Too expensive and too difficult to compete amongst so many offerings, seems like you just had to build things and hope for the best. Even if I was willing to spend a lot of money, marketing was never an exact science.
- greggman3 4y agoMy experience with marketing comes from games. In games, if you show marketing a new game they'll tell you it won't sell. They only want clones of the last hit. Where-as, IMO, their job is to get people to want your new game, not to ride off the coattails of the popularity of a previous game. This one thing I've always admired about Nintendo. AFAIK (totally my imagination), the game dev team makes whatever they want and then they tell marketing "YOU WILL MARKET THIS AND MAKE IT A HIT!" Examples might be Splatoon, Animal Crossing, maybe Smash Brothers, Pikman, Where as I've been at plenty of companies where marketing effectively says "This is not a Call of Duty/GTA clone therefore it won't sell, therefore we will not waste time marketing it".
- golergka 4y ago> In games, if you show marketing a new game they'll tell you it won't sell. And they would statistically be right, as most games don't sell. On a serious note, though — there's plenty of marketing specialists in game industry that have a lot of experience with new and indie titles; some companies like indie publishing houses are built upon this. I've worked in one and seen this first-hand. Generalising negative statements like this about a whole profession seem like a product of arrogance.
- bsenftner 4y agoAfter decades in the industry, I'd say the arrogance and lack of professionalism is in the marketing side of the industry.
- golergka 4y agoArrogance and lack of professionalism is 80% of every profession on the face on the Earth.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoArrogance and lack of professionalism are what half my industry (security) works on. Arrogance in the sales process (yes we can break your shit), and a certain level of in unprofessionalism in the delivery side (we with actually break your shit) tends to convert to repeat business with competent clients.
- closedloop129 4y agoThis requires working markets. The problem is that the value of products and services is distorted and the highest margins that can buy the most marketing are not the products that offer the most value. What good is all the value if the knowledge about it is hidden by more powerful marketing. It would be a game changer if Carmack could convince Facebook/Meta to create an advertising market that would allow people to become aware of that amazing value. Meta has the power to structure their prices in a way that advertising is actually helpful. I am reminded of the OpenXanadu submission [1], where every referenced text receives a micropayment. Could value transactions become so frictionless that we change the way we interact? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32215551 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32215551
- sjtgraham 4y agoHow engineers feel about non-engineering counterparts in their business is a only reflection of their own maturity.
- disintegore 4y agoThere has to be a way to inform me about amazing value without employing any manipulation tactics, espionage tools, and psychological terrorism.
- mancerayder 4y agoAnd repetition.
- simonw 4y agoAn important lesson I've learned in my career: don't resist repeating yourself. You can communicate something to someone extremely clearly and they'll have forgotten a week later, because they have a whole lot of other things going on in their lives. When I worked at a large company I started out incredibly frustrated at feeling like I was having the same conversation over and over and over again. Eventually I realized that repeating myself was part of the job.
- disintegore 4y agoUnderstandable but I imagine you're not trying to sell your coworkers penis enlargement pills.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe problem there is that it's a fake product, not a moderate amount of repetition.
- RGamma 4y agoA concise, curated web directory would be nice. Sometimes I use Wikipedia lists of software; just something more general and standard.
- yifanl 4y agoThere is, it just requires that the field be clear of others employing any of those tactics, otherwise they'll naturally dominate with their much louder megaphone.
- maverickJ 4y agoMarketing is very important. As mentioned in my article on Nikola Tesla's breakthrough, "Doing brilliant work is not enough; Showing|demonstrating brilliant work is not enough. What is enough is showing your brilliant work to the right people. When your brilliant work is shown to the right audience at the right time, it triggers action for the next stage of the work. In Tesla’s case, it was the commercialisation of alternating current by George Westinghouse of the Westinghouse Electric Company in Pittsburg. When your work is shown to the wrong people, the merits of the work are typically dismissed" If you want to read more, the link is below https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/p/cracking-the-who-you-show-your-work https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/p/cracking-the-who-you...
- drewcoo 4y ago> how much amazing value is present that people just don’t know about. If only there was a way to bring it to their attention… People pay for marketing to convince other people of things. If Carmack is serious, he can hire marketers to espouse the wonders not enough of us know about. The tweet is just a deepity.
- beebeepka 4y agoMarketing is a broad term. I hate ads but welcome good marketing that is not based on tracking or brainwashing me. What I am saying is that PR works better for people like me. Unless a company has a groundbreaking product I never knew I needed, chances are I will read or watch a video about it. Even respectful sponsored content is better than ads
- itsoktocry 4y agoThe are an inordinate number of people in this thread who conflate marketing with advertising. Marketing is about creating a market for your product. You can't not do it.
- a_c 4y agoRegarding value creation, in economy there is the smiling curve [1]. It states that throughout the product development, the R&D stage and marketing stage create the most value in the sense of profit margin whereas manufacturing itself create the least. IMO there is a third kind of value which is management. Things like software maintenance, customer service and all sorts of people work that are considered chore by many software folks. Anyway, I agree with carmack. I used to think marketing is worthless. Now I realise how difficult is it for others to buy in the vision you have. Essentially what marketing does. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smiling_curve https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smiling_curve
- ericholscher 4y agoMarketing is a hard skillset, and I think it's important for folks in engineering to respect it. I think it looks really easy when it's done well, but so many devs have OSS tools or products that they've worked on and can't get users for. This is a marketing problem! I love book Obvious Awesome's tagline, which is "I know my product is awesome, but why doesn't anyone else?" This is the deep truth of marketing -- trying to explain your product to people in a way that shows it's value. We've struggled a lot with this on the small product we've been working on EthicalAds. Trying to build good landing pages, running free ads ("house ads" on our own network) that point to the landing pages, and optimizing these two together. It's incredibly difficult to write good ad copy and then landing pages that explain what your product does in a clear way. It's a super power when you have the skills though.
- oehpr 4y agoIt's funny how Carmack realizes that there's so much value that we're just missing, and doesn't realize the WHY of us missing it. We can't hear about it. There's a cacophony of self interested black hat actors blasting our communication channels with worthless noise. The moment any medium becomes an effective communication channel for valuable things for the wider public, it will be targeted by those self interested black hats for their own gain. And to be clear, this framing is assuming the best possible motivation of marketers. That they want to inorganically promote their product. When in reality they will lie, manipulate, and insult the general public if it shows statistical gains. They'll play on your fears, or even give you new fears, if it shows statistical gains. I hated advertisers when I was younger. I'm older now. Still hate them.
- sbf501 4y agoI read that as sarcasm.
- kmacdough 4y agoDidn't feel like sarcasm to me. I've seen a heck of a lot of people go through this transition, to the point that this tweet is indistinguishable from common opinions. Sarcasm that's mostly indistinguishable from real opinions is just intentional miscommunication.
- munk-a 4y agoYup, I'm perfectly aware of how valuable it is to a business while absolutely loathing marketing in general. The ROI is clear, but so is the fact that I value my own time and sanity and see marketing as a clear attack on my peace of mind. There is an aspirational claim of marketing: it's trying to raise brand awareness and make sure customers know that your product is an option when a customer decides to purchase a product in the segment (i.e. When a consumer needs to replace their knives we want to make sure CutsAwesome is on their brand radar)... but marketing in the modern world is much more about creating demand when there was none ("Feeling depressed and lonely? Well drinking our beer will surround you with attractive people!"). I think consumer oriented marketing is an externalized cost on society - we are lowering everyone's productivity so you can sell three extra cans of coke and it's hurting us economically.
- sbf501 4y agoI didn't understand marketing until I started running a company. It's great when your first product launches and you're riding on the first few years of success. Then you need to grow. And you know what that requires? Marketing.
- togs 4y ago> Then you need to grow Genuinely curious as to why this is
- sbf501 4y agoWell, if you don't sell a recurring subscription (or a consumable), once someone buys something, they don't buy it again. So how do you meet payroll? You have to constantly sell to make money and pay your employees. That's called growth. Kinda basic.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoMy experience with marketing comes most from being a consumer and being lied to by marketing more times than I can count. It's a profession of psychopaths who use deception and worse to move product, using any tactic no matter how immoral. Exploiting a teenager's confidence issues to sell product that will surely make them more popular with their peers? Nothing wrong with that, full speed ahead! Marketers are mercenaries, and most of them are willing to inflict any atrocity on anybody if there's money in it. Edward Bernays told women around the world that smoking would liberate them, but encouraged his own wife to quit because he knew cigarettes were lethal.
- phtrivier 4y agoAsk HN : is there something of _incredible_ value that we're really missing on because of a lack of marketing ? I'm more pessimistic. I think the reason we're not drowning in great stuff is that there isn't that much great stuff, and it does not stay in the shadow for very long. And that's okay ! The proverbial "99% of everything being crap" is a feature, not a bug ; producing lots of different stuff and being able to label it as "crap" is the only way to organically find good stuff, eventually. Still, what do you think we're really missing ? What is John Carmack thinking about when writing this tweet ? But if you know of an hidden gem, I'm interested !
- simonw 4y agoI think my project https://datasette.io/ https://datasette.io/ could be incredibly useful to a wide variety of people who haven't heard about it yet. I found myself nodding when I saw Carmack's tweet precisely because I'm finding myself at a point where my time may well be better spent marketing what I've already built rather than continuing to improve the product.
- kmacdough 4y agoBoth sentiments seem true. Absolutely, there is plenty of high-value stuff out there that people are unaware of. And marketing is how you'd bring awareness. But real value is irrelevant to a capitalist market; perceived value is all that matters. When customers have a diminished ability to assess value (i.e. consumers who cannot reasonably thoroughly evaluate every purchase decision), optimal marketing becomes a game of illusion and misperception. And modern marketing has evolved to the point where it's incredibly effective at hijacking known human biases and weaknesses to create perceived value where no practical value exists. In this way, the net-effect of many marketing campaigns is increased profits for companies, with no net value created for the community. The clothing industry is a prime example: Marketing pushes that their products are cheap and stylish, with the underlying implication that consumers will be happier and save $. In reality, though, they'll spend a lot more in the long run, and reinforce social insecurities.
- vba616 4y agoYou can't feel derisive, he said derisively.
- rexreed 4y agoMarketing, in the hands of skilled, experienced marketers should not be noticeable since it optimizes audience, message, channel, and delivery. Unfortunately most marketers are talentless hacks with poor skills who apply the same hammers to every problem, whether or not they are nails. Advertising? Email blasts? Social media? Influencers? Most so-called marketers these days just throw spaghetti at the walls and see what sticks. This is especially the case in tech marketing. The higher you go in the organization, the worse it gets. Some of the most incompetent marketers have titles such as Chief Marketing Officer and VP Marketing. That doesn't absolve lower-level titles who seem to just be skilled at "field marketing" or "event marketing" and hire PR firms who try to get "earned media" and pray to the SEO gods. Many of the reason why tech folks dislike marketing is not because of marketing, but because of the marketers.
- fmajid 4y agoIt's like the reverse paradox of AI: when marketing is good, it's not seen as marketing. Think of people lining up to see Steve Jobs' keynotes. We also underestimate the power of marketing, even the in-your-face annoying kind. I lived in Japan as a teen in the mid-80s. Even today, when I don't know the words to a song, I use the words from Calbee potato chips ads of that time that I barely understand, yet still remember nearly 40 years later. This is why it's so important to defend our sanity using things like ad-blockers. Sure, our brains have compensated to some extent with phenomena like banner blindness, but it's not enough.
- Consultant32452 4y agoYep, Tesla has a marketing budget of basically zero. It feels like Musk just does things that make headlines, and that's the marketing.
- soared 4y agoTesla may have a low advertising budget, but they do not have a low marketing budget.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sg47 4y agoI read a lot of books. None of them have been marketed to me. I hear it through word of mouth from people I trust. I wish I could find out about other things in life the same way. These days, if I need to buy something, I get recommendations from reddit which seems to be fairly effective.
- GrinningFool 4y agoWhat if the people you trust heard about the book through some form of marketing themselves, found that the book was a good one, and recommended it to you? To me that says you're still influenced by the marketing - just by second remove (or more).
- fartcannon 4y agoI wonder if all those years getting a paycheck from Facebook is helping him develop this framework.
- moffkalast 4y agoYou either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become a capitalist shill.
- Frost1x 4y agoMarketing and advertising is largely a propoganda game anymore. I don't disagree that there's value in awareness, discovery, and solution/need matching--I don't think any engineer is going to be upset if you hand them the perfect solution to their problem at a reasonable cost: they're going to take it and use it and move on. The issue is that those marketing and advertising are only partly about correct match making, they're also about deceit and the underlying goal is to drive revenue and ultimately profit in. Correctly matchmaking a need with your solution is just a side effect, ultimately they want to maximize how much they can extract from the population. Sometimes that's in providing a solid recurring solution, sometimes that deceiving someone to grab a few short term purchases, sometimes it's convincing someone they need something they don't and an array of other unscrupulous strategies. The issue is that in a competitive market, lying and deceit is often a relatively low cost effective strategy. You ultimately end with someone in the market who will stretch the truth to make their solution appear better than it is. Competitive forces make better solutions lower the bar and follow suit to some degree, either inflating their solution or debunking dubious claims from others (not too common due to liable cases). So we get the race to the bottom of advertising which is why now I can't believe anything that isn't highly regulated and even then have to pick through each word for ambiguities that may be hiding some truth. I'm perfectly fine if you provide me a nice list of solutions I need that make my life easier at a reasonable cost. I'm not so fine when your goal is to pretend to do this while just looking for ways to extract wealth from me.
- scubbo 4y agoThis perfectly articulates a lot of frustration I've felt with marketing, and why "why don't you want to be told about things you would enjoy?" is not a good argument in its favour. Thank you.
- cm2012 4y agoIn the end, centralized sources of business information just don't work. Top down planned economies don't do as well for a variety of reasons. Allowing companies to market themselves with some regulations is messy but better for the world as a whole.
- deleted 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- legitster 4y agoI've worked in Marketing for the better part of a decade. It's a constant pain point that even in this thread people are conflating marketing with advertising. The reality is that advertising is probably one of the lowest ROIs of a marketing department. If you are a young/solo techie, here is some marketing advice to save you a ton of time: - The number one source of new customers will be existing, stable customers. You make customers stable by offering tons of resources and post-sale updates. - You would not believe how many deals I have seen lost because a founder didn't respond to a inquiry or forgot to schedule a follow up meeting. Have some sort of process in place to make your marketing-sales pipeline smooth and consistent. - Have a specific plan for the kind of people you want to look at your company, and how you are going to get them to look at your company. Search ads are obvious but getting crazy expensive. Billboards are surprisingly effective. So is direct mail - you will never beat the ROI of sending a CTO a bottle of something fancy with a nice handwritten note. - In person events are great. So are tradeshows. People are literally walking around looking for interesting products. If you don't get leads from these, it's probably because your product isn't interesting. - Social media is a huge time and resource suck with limited opportunity for creating customers. - If your product is going to make people happier/better off than the alternatives, they will be happy you found them. If you don't believe this about your own product, quit right now - this is how you end up exploiting people.
- sizzle 4y agoThis is super insightful, especially the last point which makes a lot of sense yet feels counterintuitive in practice.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoThe tweet for those who do not use Javascript "full_text":"I remember feeling derisive about marketing as a young techie it wasnt creating the value. Nowadays, I often marvel at how much amazing value is present that people just dont know about. If only there was a way to bring it to their attention" Tweets are so short it makes me wonder why HN does not pin the text at the top of the HN thread, like it does with archive.ph links for articles on "paywalled" sites, instead of forcing people to visit Twitter. (The term "forcing" is used here as a figure of speech. As with most "paywalled" sites, there are workarounds for Twitter.)
- kelnos 4y agoA Twitter reply that really resonated with me: "Marketing is a zero sum game. You only compete against the marketing of your competition. If no one would market, the result would be pretty much the same. You kind of need it, but it doesn't realy CREATE value." (https://twitter.com/ViconDev/status/1551683678446690306 https://twitter.com/ViconDev/status/1551683678446690306) Marketing creates "value" for the people doing the marketing. It doesn't create value for the intended consumers. At best they buy something they hadn't heard of and hadn't realized they wanted/needed. At worst, you're manipulating people into giving you cash in exchange for something they wouldn't have otherwise bought. A lot of the takes I see here are from the perspective of the company, and I absolutely agree that if you run a company, you need marketing if you're going to compete. It's just a shame it has to be that way. If marketing (and especially advertising) didn't exist, we'd have the same situation we have now, except that people wouldn't pointlessly stretch their finances to buy things they don't need.
- Jommi 4y agoClassic mistake of conflating marketing with advertising
- 12ian34 4y agoIn this thread: engineers complaining about marketing Also in this thread: >90% Apple ecosystem users