17 ms·
Large Hadron Collider discovers three new exotic particles
- FabHK 4y agoCould someone put this in context? Is this big news that could lead physics out of its long stasis? Or "just" relatively small details?
- bradrn 4y agoI’m no particle physicist, but this doesn’t look like anything too fundamental — no new elementary particles, just some new and interesting combinations of existing elementary particles (in this case, quarks). It might have lots of further relevance, but it might not just as easily.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoThey are not elementary particles, just permutations of a higher number of quarks.
- nxpnsv 4y ago"just"
- gus_massa 4y agoCloser than business as usual. The problem to get out of the current "long stasis" [1] is to find a new elementary particle or an experiment that can't be explained with the current elementary particles and can be refined to discover a new elementary particle. They discover two new composite particles. There are hundred of composite particles, so it's somewhat business as usual. Anyway, most composite particles have 2 or 3 quarks, but the new particles have 4 or 5 quarks. So they are weird new composite particles. Making calculations of particles made of a few quarks is very difficult, borderline impossible, so it's interesting to find new particles and verify that the current approximations for particles made of a few quarks are good enough or fix them. Also, the approximations for particles made of a few quarks use virtual particles that appear and disappear. And some of these virtual particle may be a unknown new particle. So if the calculation is too wrong it may be an indirect way to discover a new elementary particle and escape the "long stasis". But I'd not be too optimistic about a groundbreaking discovery. [1] I don't think it's a problem yet. The current "long stasis" it's overrated IMHO.
- fhars 4y agoWhat makes these kind of particles interesting and "exotic" is that they are not the kind of particles the Standard Model was originally developed to describe. Those particles, mesons and baryons, consist of two and three quarks, respectively, with some quantum numbers that must obey certain rules for the particles to exist, and we have found that (almost?) all of the two and three quark combinations allowed by the rules are in fact observable as particles in experiments. But those rules for the quantum numbers can also be fulfilled with certain combinations of four or five quarks, and there is nothing in the Standard Model that either forbids or requires these combinations to exist as real particles. So it was new information when the first resonances that could be interpreted as those kind of particles were discovered and it is interesting that there are more of these. But it is not unexpected, either, the earliest paper on pentaquarks cited on the wikipedia page is from 1987. So it is indeed close to business as usual. It is interesting, and new, but is is still filling out the corners of the Standard Model.
- macspoofing 4y agowho ordered that?
- frutiger 4y agoThis is a reference to the famous quip by Rabi: > The eventual recognition of the muon as a simple "heavy electron", with no role at all in the nuclear interaction, seemed so incongruous and surprising at the time, that Nobel laureate I. I. Rabi famously quipped, "Who ordered that?" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon
- dkural 4y agoThe Standard Model did, in the 50s.
- tux3 4y agoIs it possible, even it principle, that some of these exotic hadrons could be long-lived (let alone stable)? They're probably interesting to study on their own, but the engineering instinct is to want to build something out of them, or use them as tools, which seems pretty hard if they disintegrate in a quintillionth of a second!
- willis936 4y agoOn the surface they might not seem useful, but these discoveries develop sub-atomic models, which help predict atomic, and in turn molecular, models, which helps materials research. There are countless materials we haven't discovered/invented yet. We don't know how far we can push it.
- morbia 4y agoI'm not aware of any predictive power the standard model has over nuclear physics and atomic physics directly. In principle, yes the standard model should be able to predict things at those energy scales, in practice no one has a clue how. To use a more relatable analogy, it's a bit like using quantum mechanics to build a skyscraper. In principle it should be possible, it practice it is incalculable. Newtonian physics does the job fine in that scenario.
- peteradio 4y agoIf you wanted to build a skyscraper taking into account quantum mechanics then maybe you are hoping to induce a scaled quantum mechanic effect? Perhaps in the ultra-modern evolution of buildings the structure of the building itself will have a communication aspect associated with its natural largess and to accomplish this quantum mechanics is used to derive the appropriate building structure. Just because it sounds far-fetched or hard doesn't mean it won't be humdrum engineering decades or a century in the future. It all starts somewhere.
- snovv_crash 4y agoYou use the quantum mechanics to design the graphene conformation that yield the best loads, and then infuse the concrete in your skyscraper with the graphene. Everything needs abstraction layers otherwise of course the complexity becomes mindboggling.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoDiscovers? Or invents? I've only studied particle physics at undergrad level but strikes me that these tetraquarks and pentaquarks could be combinations never created by any [other] natural process.
- tsimionescu 4y agoBy my understanding, the LHC isn't doing anything different from what's happening in the upper atmosphere every microsecond, when solar rays are hitting the Earth; except that the LHC is much lower energy than some of those collisions.
- easygenes 4y agoYep, there's a class of thing called UHECR (Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays). We still have barely a clue what generates them, but they hit our atmosphere with roughly ten million times the energy of what LHC can muster.
- lumost 4y agoIsn’t it more accurate to say we don’t know their primary sources? It’s extremely likely that the are generated in stellar processes and black hole ejects, no?
- semi-extrinsic 4y agoI mean, saying something in the universe is generated in a stellar process is borderline tautological, no? We are all stardust and we derive all our energy from the sun, after all.
- shagie 4y agoKind of... maybe... there are some interesting problems with various sources. First, not sure about the process that generates them. Saying "they came from an active galactic nuclei is ok... but how did they get accelerated to such energies? The next problem is that being so highly energetic, they should be interacting with the cosmic background radiation if they're traveling about 160 mLy which would drain off some energy ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greisen–Zatsepin–Kuzmin_limit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greisen–Zatsepin–Kuzmin_limit ) and there are some observations that appear in violation of that limit ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oh-My-God_particle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oh-My-God_particle ) https://www.quantamagazine.org/cosmic-map-of-ultrahigh-energy-particles-points-to-long-hidden-treasures-20210427/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/cosmic-map-of-ultrahigh-energ... is also interesting to look at (very neat visualization). Part of the problem is that we're not entirely sure what they're made of. Most theories have been working on the "they're protons" assumption, but other approaches with having them be heavier nuclei means that they don't need to travel as fast to have the same amount of energy (which also changes the equation for the GZK limit as that applies to protons).
- mkr-hn 4y agoI assume this isn't from the run that started today.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI'm pretty sure they go over their data for quite a while before confirming new particles, so no it wasn't today's run.
- fnands 4y agoDefinitely not.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoThings I didn't get from article: What changed to make a slew of new discoveries possible? Is it pure chance like Bitcoin mining? If so, what's the chance of discovering nothing for years and then, like London buses, three all come along at once? What are the implications of a new "particle zoo"? Can I do anything with these, like build new atoms, or use them to detect something?
- adregan 4y agoI believe it’s due to the fact that after several years of upgrades, they started running it today at much higher power (13.6 trillion electronvolts).
- stevenwoo 4y agoThere's another article floating about how they increased energy of collisions recently at LHC. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01388-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01388-6
- dicknuckle 4y agoFairly sure this was scheduled to happen today, July 5th.
- 4y ago
- peteradio 4y agoLHCb != LHC LHCb refers to the specific detector and group responsible for measurements related to b-quark.
- logicalmonster 4y agoGiven that all of these exotic particles that are apparently discovered are extremely short-lived (at the limits of human technology to even register them) is it possible that scientists are radically misinterpreting the meaning of these experiments and finding particles where there's some other force or phenomena being observed? I'm very skeptical that it's apparently just smaller and smaller particles all of the way down, and every time they get bigger and badder technology to collide atoms, they tell us that they coincidentally discover new particles. What if everything here about reality is being misinterpreted? Here's an analogy that might not make sense to everybody, but to me, this feels a bit like the famous memes from the Chernobyl movie. "3.6 Roentgen. Not great, Not terrible." where the real answer about the radiation exposure was radically different. Some the people tasked with coming up with that 3.6 answer might not have had a bad intent, but they were at the limits of their technology to provide an answer and radically misinterpreted what they were seeing partially because of that.
- lisper 4y agoThese aren't really "discoveries". These particles were already known to exist (or, to be precise, whose existence was predicted by the Standard Model, just like the Higgs boson). This is just the first time they have actually been observed. The headline is misleading, but the first sentence in the article gets it right: "The international LHCb collaboration at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has observed three never-before-seen particles."
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoI think I would be very happy to be the first person to observe a new particle, its discovery enough for me :) It does not need to appent all of known physics or be unexpected for us to call it a discovery
- lisper 4y agoI get what you're saying, but it's not like someone looked through a microscope and actually saw one of these things for the first time. It's computers crunching trillions of data points and spitting out a result. So it's not clear who "the first person to observe this" actually was.
- coldcode 4y agoPhysics is not my thing, but I love that the more is discovered, the more is discovered that there is more to discover.
- alberto7 4y agoIs that true?
- benreesman 4y agoThe top few comments are reasonable but not written by ATLAS folks: what’s the layman’s takeaway by an expert?
- davrosthedalek 4y agoThis is from LHCb, not ATLAS ;)
- benreesman 4y agoI think I lowered the bar a bit on “layman” there but I difinitely got critical expert information ;) Well done sir.
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoTo quote Alan Watts, "There is no end to the minuteness that you can unveil through physical investigation. For the simple reason that the investigation itself is what is chopping things into tiny little pieces. And the sharper you can sharpen your knife, the finer you can cut it. And the knife of the intellect is very sharp indeed. And with the sophisticated instruments that we can now make, there’s probably no limit to it." It's almost as if we're looking at a continuous functions that can generate an infinite number of discrete segments.
- nxmnxm99 4y agoNot surprising you're downvoted on HN, but your comment is the only one that makes sense in this entire thread. I wonder at one point our collective consciousness will wake up to the fact that we've completely hit a wall in our understanding of the universe, and that spending billions detecting more particles isn't magically going to explain reality.
- timbit42 4y agoLet's keep going until we figure out how to harness gravity.
- Lapsa 4y agobut not before we get pocket sized hadron collider kid toys costing around $5
- JetAlone 4y agoI think you're both quite right that we're not likely to find much in this subdivision. It seems to me that the people who want to detect more particles are not driven by a desire to explain reality itself. No, I think the research is done in the hopes of cataloguing particles that could be useful, as other comments have said. Is there a way to even begin to assess the likelihood that research on esoteric subatomic particles is going yield useful results for energy, health care, or transportationn? Or are we just digging away ad nauseum with zero idea if the next rock contains some precious ore?
- mrlonglong 4y agoSo if atoms are composed of electrons, protons, and in turn electrons, protons are composed of these particles, can we potentially drill down a bit deeper into these hadrons, might they be composed of further sub particles yet unknown to science yet?
- drexlspivey 4y agoThat's the premise of string theory
- centilliard 4y agoBased on this comment on reddit [1], it looks at some point one needs to use the mass of a solar system. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/vri4ih/eli5_what_would_happen_if_we_could_zoom_in_with_a/ https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/vri4ih/e...
- mrlonglong 4y agoExcellent article, many thanks.
- davrosthedalek 4y agoAs far as we know, both leptons (electrons, positrons, muons, taus) and quarks are fundamental, i.e. not composed out of other particles (also, they are pointlike, i.e. they have no extend). That's not true for protons (which are made out of quarks and gluons. It's a little bit complicated because of vacuum polarization, but if you count a certain way, you'll find it's composed out of two up and one down quark). They also have a measurable size. These new particles are also made from quarks (4 for the tetra quark and 5 for the pentaquark), and they also have a size.
- ars 4y agoIt's not known if quarks are fundamental, nor is it known if they are pointlike. We've never seen a free quark, so we just don't know.
- croes 4y agoSo crisis averted? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30516078 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30516078
- Koshkin 4y agoI wonder if this discovery constitutes "new physics" to any degree.
- lamontcg 4y agoNo, not "fundamentally". This all fits within the framework of QCD. Like the wikipedia article on pentaquarks says, a five-quark bound cluster was considered by Gell-Mann back in 1964.
- layer8 4y agoNope. It just further confirms decades-old predictions within the Standard Model of particle physics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentaquark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentaquark
- immmmmm 4y agocomposite particles: quarks and gluons in weird configuration :) still the desert otherwise, a higgs and nothing else :(
- sylware 4y agoAllright, at high energy, the LHC manages to observe some particule configuration never seen before. Anything to "milk" something interesting from those?
- ChrisArchitect 4y agoSpace marketing is tough as it is with space station updates, rovers, Mars etc from NASA et al, but this is just a whole other struggle. Is the general public supposed to care about the LHC starting up again etc? Higgs Boson was a total 'meh' moment ten years ago after a bit of hype. I suppose particle physics etc is just too obscure.
- OseArp 4y agoIt may need clarifying that "exotic hadron" simply and specifically means "hadron with more than three quarks." What's being reproted is finding new particles belonging to a family that already has several known members. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_hadron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exotic_hadron
- tonymet 4y agowhatever they did 10 years ago opened up pandora’s box . can we please return to the pre kony 2012 timeline ? Ever since Harambe died it’s been a total apocalypse
- tonymet 4y agocan someone explain where Cern gets the $50B+ to build and operate the LHC? their discoveries have a dubious theoretical and practically zero commercial application. there must be a hidden weapons / military application to justify a massive money hole
- jamesmaniscalco 4y agoYou are off by a factor of ten [0]. [0] https://home.cern/resources/faqs/facts-and-figures-about-lhc https://home.cern/resources/faqs/facts-and-figures-about-lhc
- sampo 4y agoIt's been a tradition for 90 years now. Since first "high energy" particle accelerator in 1932, we have used particle accelerator to smash and study subatomic particles. First we found a whole zoo of them, but then 1961 Gell-Mann's quark model explained how all those subatomic particles are not elementary particles, but made of various combinations of quarks. From 1975 we've had the standard model of particle physics, and after 2012 with the experimental discovery of the Higgs boson, now we've found all the particles in the standard model. But the road up to 2012 was: Keep building bigger accelerators, keep adding more energy, keep finding new particles. Why stop now? Some skeptics say that now we have maybe found them all. And we don't have a good theory that would predict new particles, so maybe we won't find new elementary particles, no matter how we go on. Maybe we should pause and reconsider. Work on new theories. But, we also have theories: Supersymmetry, and string theory. Supersymmetry predicts the existence of the superpartners of all the 17 elementary particles. Maybe their discovery is just behind the corner, if we just keep going? Or maybe supersymmetry is wrong, and the superpartners don't exist at all. Timeline of discoveries of the elementary particles: 1800-1895 photon 1897 electron 1937 muon 1956 electron neutrino 1962 muon neutrino 1969 down quark 1969 strange quark 1969 up quark 1974 charm quark 1975 tau 1977 bottom quark 1979 gluon 1983 W boson 1983 Z boson 1995 top quark 2000 tau neutrino 2012 higgs
- tonymet 4y agoagain what is the practical value of any of this ?
- formvoltron 4y agoSo.. maybe it's a good time to pause the collider and see if we can use this discovery for any practical purpose. If not, that money could go towards clean energy research or lab grown meat research, anti cancer or anti aging research... something that might do people some good.
- 4khilles 4y agoI think a species of 7.8 billion individuals can afford to do things in parallel.
- formvoltron 4y agoI guess so, but there are not 7.8B scientists that can develop the next battery or solar breakthrough, which is actually what is needed in a very big way right now.
- davesque 4y agoI understand the sentiment, but can't you imagine that advances in our understanding of fundamental physics could lead to advances in some of the areas that you mention? For example, new particles -> better models of chemistry -> better cancer drugs; or new particles -> better fusion models -> cleaner energy.
- alberth 4y agoOff topic: what’s the convention on what your root is for a branded TLD? I see CERN is using “home.cern”. Google has “.google” but I’m not sure what the root is since they have many. What’s the convention for the root of a companies branded TLD?
- sph 4y agoI don't think there's one. I am only aware of `blog.google`. The root is `.google` itself, everything before that is conceptually like a subdomain.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI had a great conversation this evening with a marine biologist studying the recent collapse of a 100,000 sq km California kelp forest. The grants for the science of ecosystem stewardship are in the 10k-50k$ range. Over the past few years, something killed over 5 billion giant starfish and “science” has no idea what did it. Without the starfish, the sea urchin population exploded, turning kelp forest into desert. I love the LHC. But we need to seriously grow the science pie and prioritize the science of ecosystem collapse and management. There simply aren’t enough trained scientists.
- pishpash 4y agoTo grow the science pie you need to shrink the military pie. To shrink the military pie you need to make profiting off of science much more lucrative than profiting off of slaughter.
- civilized 4y agoI get where you're coming from, but honestly, I'm not sure there's even that much logic to it. The US federal government seems to have a largely arbitrary budget. No real experience or rational principle restrains it. We have never seen a clear case of negative consequences related to spending too much, so no one is quite sure how much might be too much. Sometimes a politician sees political advantage in grandstanding about fiscal responsibility, but seconds later, that same politician will be found funneling some arbitrary number of billions of $$$ in pork to their district. I suspect the truth is that politicians mostly just don't care that much about science because they aren't smart enough to understand its value, or decent enough to care. We could and should 10x the science budget, and it would have vastly more impact than almost everything else the government spends money on. But we don't because politicians see it as some amusement to fritter a limited amount of money on. Occasionally Republicans will publish a list of ridiculous scientific projects and no one wants to be caught in the crosshairs of that -- even though tens of billions are probably being simultaneously spent on murdering people in a country you've never heard of, or flushing thousands of tons of soybeans down a toilet. Defense-related science gets an exception to this, which is why a big war is often also a big leap forward for science.
- therealbilly 4y agoAre these really new particles? It appears to me these are quarks in different combinations. I ask because this hadron collider machine needs to show amazing results but this announcement seems kind of forced.
- numlock86 4y ago> The collaboration has observed a new kind of “pentaquark” and the first-ever pair of “tetraquarks” Does this in some way (maybe even indirect) help us with solving any of the environmental challenges we are facing right now?