26 ms·
Temporary pause of Bitcoin withdrawals on Binance
- LtdJorge 4y agoAh yes, very decentralized
- Jasonrams 4y ago
- jstx1 4y ago> due to a stuck transaction causing a backlog How convenient for a transaction to get stuck on such a bad day for crypto prices.
- edf13 4y agoDidn’t read his next message? > This is only impacting the Bitcoin network. You can still withdraw Bitcoin on other networks like BEP-20.
- shawabawa3 4y agoBut BTCB (Bitcoin on BSC/BEP-20) is not Bitcoin To actually withdraw Bitcoin like this, you'd have to bridge your BTCB to WBTC on Ethereum, and from there bridge it back to BTC (using a custodial bridge, AFAIK there are no WBTC/BTC decentralised bridges) You'd eat 2 sets of fees along the way plus gas, probably costing you 0.3% or more
- mhluongo 4y ago
- JCharante 4y agoIf you want to withdraw to protect yourself against binance mtgox'ing, WBTC is probably safe enough.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 4y agoBinance has DEX's, why would you trade it for WBTC -> BTC?
- dhsysusbsjsi 4y agoWhich is also not Bitcoin
- coryfklein 4y agoDays like today, when price volatility – and thus transaction volume – is high, are exactly the kind of days you'd expect systems issues to manifest. As opposed to some random Thursday where no price action is happening.
- dubswithus 4y agoHalf the days are bad days. The volatility is wild. So why don't they have more issues if they are committing fraud is the question?
- spywaregorilla 4y agoNot this bad
- wfhordie 4y agoSo what exactly is the point of holding BTC if it can be held hostage like this? Crypto continues to fail at its most basic premises.
- naraga 4y agonot your keys not your coins. nothing to see here
- wfhordie 4y agoCrypto is user hostile then? Got it
- rvz 4y agoNope. The point is you store your crypto on a non-custodial software wallet (Metamask) or a hardware wallet (Ledger Nano) and not on an exchange, so it cannot be 'held hostage'. It is not your keys, not your coins if it is on an exchange which uses custodial wallets, but doesn't apply if it is on a non-custodial wallet.
- dhsysusbsjsi 4y agoThis statement bugs me because it is a large source of confusion for new people. Your funds are spendable by your private key. Your private key is stored on Metamask, Ledger or a piece of paper. It’s an important distinction to make. Your hardware wallet is just a custodian of your private key.
- benjaminwootton 4y agoThat bugs me too. Almost every document out there talks about storing coins in your wallet. It’s actually a private key in there. Maybe with the right language, more people might be tempted to hold their own keys and eschew centralised exchanges.
- namaria 4y ago
- Lionga 4y ago30 Minutes mentioned now passed twice, no update. Well Not your keys, not your coins (not that they will be worth much soon anyway...)
- duttonw 4y agoif you left crypto on an exchange, you took a risk, this is the wild wild west.
- jtode 4y ago
- woodpanel 4y agoSweethaert, don't waste your popcorn watching that dumpster fire. The real show starts once Tether "de-re-pegs".
- xwdv 4y agoAgreed, that’s the one domino I’m waiting for to fall. Once tether collapses it’s instantly going to take about 25% of Bitcoins price down with it, and a whole other series of events will probably set in motion. Everything will start trending to zero.
- woodpanel 4y agoI'm wondering if it's just going to be 25%. How many investors actually understand the technology? Who (even here at HN) has read a whitepaper? I've read some, and have to say it became a personal running gag of how many pages it would take until the authors completely descend into fogging the reader with a mumbo-jumbo of made up words ("The Tangle"). But more specifically Tether stands at half the marketcap of Etheruem [0] and represents the largest trade volume (ie that of Bitcoin and Etherium combined) [1] [0] Marketcap ETH: 147 Bn USD, USDT: 72 Bn USD [1] Volume BTC: 63 Bn USD, ETH: 42 Bn USD, USDT: 103 Bn USD
- cryptoanon 4y agoI love how cocksure people are of Tether's decline. Do you believe reading a bitcoin (or IOTA) whitepaper is sufficient to understanding market structure because I get the sense that you do not understand it. If you are so sure, feel free to short Tether.
- woodpanel 4y agoUSDT ticks all the checkboxes of prior Ponzi's I've experienced but please, enlighten me. Stablecoins in principle face the issue of pegging against something that dillutes at will. But specifically USDT: How is Tether's peg supposed to work if it's alledged backing assets consist of other crypto assets ?! Shouldn't they seek less crypto exposure for stability? Assets which are BTW unsatisfactory disclosed considering a) comparison with established equity markets and b) that such disclosure only exists at all due to law-enforcement.
- jmoak3 4y agoYou really cannot make this up. As usual crypto in practice is the opposite of decentralized because people. Will. Not. Run. Their. Servers. Moxie nailed it
- artemonster 4y agoWhat is moxie?
- theIV 4y agoMoxie is a who. Probably referencing this blogpost, https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html.
- a4isms 4y agoWho is Moxie? Moxie Marlingspike. What is Moxie? A regional beverage that is the origin of the word, now the official soft drink of the state of Maine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moxie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moxie
- daniel-thompson 4y agoMoxie Marlinspike is a widely-respected security hacker and parent's comment is referring to this post of his -> https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html
- 4y ago
- basedgod 4y agoactually, this is good for Bitcoin
- throwaway4good 4y ago"stuck transaction causing a backlog" Can someone explain the mechanism here? What is going on? (Is it something interally at Binance or something to do with the Bitcoin network.)
- webinvest 4y ago1 guess: Transaction fees spiked and they didn’t pay enough for their transaction.
- thehumanmeat 4y agoDoubt it's that. They ran out of reserve for their fractional reserve. Crypto on exchange wallets has already been dwindling the past few months.
- cool_dude85 4y agoYou know how the internet is a series of tubes? Well someone clogged the bitcoin tube over at Binance.
- DonHopkins 4y ago
- rasz 4y agomore like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJklHwoYgBQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJklHwoYgBQ
- seanw444 4y agoIt all makes sense now.
- rocqua 4y agoTwo guesses: Guess one, they made a big transaction with most of their hot wallet, partially paying out to someone who withdrew, with the rest going back to the hot wallet. This transaction is in the queue but not finalized yet. The network won't accept any other spends of that money. Because that would be a double spend. So until that transaction is finalized (or it gets to old) that bitcoin is 'stuck'. Or alternatively their hot wallet is empty and they have an outstanding transaction to refill it from their cold wallet. (They have the cash, but they have to wait until they can get it from their 'vault', and there is a traffic jam on the way to the vault). I am not sure the first guess actually still works this way, I vaguely recall there are now mechanisms for one transaction to 'override' another non-confirmed transaction.
- bluedino 4y agoHow does a transaction get "stuck"? Internal system thing, right?
- Ekaros 4y agoBasically you bid for someone to deliver a packet for you. They promise to deliver it as soon as your bid is high enough to get into bunch of deliveries they are going to do. If others pay more they might end up never delivering your packet...
- buzzin_ 4y agoThere is an informational asymmetry, so rogue exchanges can lie all they want without you knowing for sure, and those that do not want to give you your money for whatever reason always do (lie that is). This happened with MtGox and permanent withdrawal problems, both with USD and BTC. With USD, it was "Oh, no, its the banks, they are limiting us to $50.000 per day, it's not us". With BTC, it was "Oh, no, Bitcoin network has a bug, we cannot process withdrawals, it's not us".
- pavlov 4y agoBitcoin is getting close to its Dec 2017 peak. That may be when the real crash starts.
- agilob 4y agoWhen I'm not sure I always google "bitcoin meme graph" and it's always correct, it's actually crazy how all major coins follow this pattern. Welcome to "capitulation" stage https://www.kraken.com/en-gb/prices/eth-ethereum-price-chart/gbp-pound-sterling?interval=All https://www.kraken.com/en-gb/prices/eth-ethereum-price-chart... https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=bitcoin%20meme%20graph&tbs=imgo:1#imgrc=caZwAx-dMbMuiM https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=bitcoin%20meme%20gr...
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoIn other news: Celsius Network pausing withdrawals as well https://www.barrons.com/articles/celsius-network-pauses-withdrawals-cel-coin-price-crypto-crash-51655107029#:~:text=In%20a%20%E2%80%9CMemo%20to%20the,their%20crypto%20off%20the%20platform https://www.barrons.com/articles/celsius-network-pauses-with....
- ceejayoz 4y agoOngoing discussion of that at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31723286 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31723286.
- Symbiote 4y ago> This is due to an earlier batch of transactions getting stuck from low transaction fees submitted and hence, resulting in a backlog of Bitcoin (BTC) network withdrawals. The Binance team is working on a solution to resume Bitcoin (BTC) network withdrawals soon. https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/8437dfd1c7bf49c2a4bf124bd03b0624 https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/8437dfd1c7bf...
- Ekaros 4y agoSo they were too cheap? And now their customers can't rightfully get their "money" out... Truly currency of future...
- fredgrott 4y agoCryptoCurrency Not only an oxymoron but not a safe investment in any fashion AND that was by DESIGN.
- circa 4y agohttps://celsius.network/ https://celsius.network/ is doing this too. Not good.
- tomcat27 4y agoIt's not in the spirit of decentralization to stop withdrawals
- dragontamer 4y agoIt actually is. Smaller banks are vulnerable to bank runs. So a lot of banks during crisis (before FDIC / Centralized Banking in the USA) would close up to stop bank runs. Closing up shop during a bank run only made people angrier, and exacerbated the problem. What was invoked as a solution, was for every bank in the nation to be FDIC insured by the central bank. The smaller and more decentralized banks are, the more frequently the bank-runs are, forcing the small banks to close to protect themselves.
- tomcat27 4y agoThey are not banks. They are forex traders.
- johntony678 4y ago[flagged]
- once_inc 4y ago?!
- johntony678 4y ago[flagged]
- shrubble 4y agoThe goldbugs' saying that 'if you don't hold it, you don't own it' seems to apply...
- once_inc 4y agoBitcoiners saying that 'if you don't hold it, you don't own it' also applies.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoWhile I somewhat agree, there's likely some irony in the upvotes since this is a mantra more often said than done. How many here self custody their gold? The problem is exactly the same as in crypto, where they also say "not your keys, not your coins": You can self custody and it's 100% yours, until someone takes it off you and then it isn't. Trusting third parties is a risk, but so is taking care of your own security. In reality it depends a lot on the situation, you have to weigh the pros and cons of different strategies. As always, it's a lot more important that people are informed, not that everyone follow the same advice. A computer illiterate person who has no idea what a private key is better just leave their coins on a reputable exchange (obviously not Binance). And if I had no place to safely store my gold, I'd not take the risk of self custody with any substantial amounts.
- HideousKojima 4y ago>How many here self custody their gold? I'll have you know I keep all 1 ounces of silver that I own in my physical possession
- lumost 4y agoI recently watched some traditional cable and was shocked by the number of crypto ads bombarding viewers. I have to imagine that this market was goosed up by retail investors trading on coinbase and binance just as the e-betting market was. The only difference between crypto and e-betting is that everyone got to be a winner on the crypto markets for a while. As users lose out, and exchanges stop ad campaigns - how long will that last? Crypto needed a tangible market/reason d'etre to be valuable. This required lower transaction fees, cheap audits, and a reasonable degree of price stability. We haven't seen any of that materialize except for cheap auditing. Cheap auditing isn't much use if there isn't anything of interest to audit. I'd doubt BTC will go to zero, but I wouldn't be surprised if the entire covid rally gets wiped out and we see BTC 6k again.
- mmastrac 4y agoI recall walking through an airport this year and seeing Crypto ads everywhere. That was my shoeshine boy moment (1) (1) https://www.businessinsider.com/how-to-spot-stock-market-bubbles-2017-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/how-to-spot-stock-market-bub...
- piva00 4y agoI visited Brazil recently (3-4 months ago), I got into cryptocurrency-talk or some shitcoin peddled by cashiers, Uber drivers, waiters in some restaurants, acquaintances that aren't tech-savvy at all, etc. That's when it downed on me how big this whole thing got outside of internet chatter, it downed how many vulnerable people are exposed to the fallout of a crypto implosion.
- DonHopkins 4y agoIt's so ironic how all those libertarian crypto-bros think they've got the inside track and they're so much smarter than everyone else, when actually they're just as gullible and common and deluded as random cashiers, Uber drivers, waiters, bartenders, used car salesmen, chiropractors, cosmeticians, shoeshine boys, and ordinary hoi polloi on the street, all being influenced by the exact same mass market ads and hype all over the world.
- seanw444 4y agoIn response to the usual comments about how "we need legislation on crypto, and we need it now!", can we just have one thing that isn't legislated to shit? Please? Yes, there are scams. If you fail to even do the bare minimum research, that's your fault. If you suck at detecting sketchy investments (or use crypto as an investment in general, rather than its intended purpose), that's your fault.
- shmatt 4y agoImagine if this was some Oceans 11 type heist where the BTC owner (Binance, not you plebs holding coins in someone else's wallet) thinks one thing is happening, all while someone unauthorized got a hold of some hot wallet keys and is draining them 30 minutes have come and passed, BTC still not in sight
- throw03172019 4y agoIt’s my understanding this is not effecting selling BTC? It would effect people buying BTC but not being able to send it to their own wallet? If they were preventing deposits of BTC, it would prevent people from selling.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kirbypineapple 4y agoThe only thing that comes to mind here is that there was a fee spike [1] and they've got too many unspents stuck in the mempool and can't initiate further withdrawals because their wallet is effectively "spent" until those pending transactions complete and they receive their change. I find this a bit hard to believe though...wallet management isn't simple when it comes to the scale that Binance handles, however I'd be shocked if they didn't have code written to trigger CPFP (Child Pays For Parent) [2]. [1] https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#BTC,30d,weight https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#BTC,30d,weight [2] https://bitcoinops.org/en/topics/cpfp/ https://bitcoinops.org/en/topics/cpfp/
- kirbypineapple 4y agoCalled it: https://cryptonews.com/news/binance-shares-what-caused-backlog-bitcoin-network-resumes-bitcoin-withdrawals.htm https://cryptonews.com/news/binance-shares-what-caused-backl...
- skohan 4y agoI can think of many of exchanges pausing withdrawals in times of extreme volatility - either close to peaks or during massive selloffs. I think Binance probably doesn't have enough liquidity to cover their withdrawals and you probably don't need to look much farther to find an explanation.
- wesapien 4y agoThey are moving from cold to hot wallet.
- hatware 4y agoI see we didn't learn our lesson from MT Gox.
- newobj 4y agoDeCeNTraLiZEd
- sergiotapia 4y agoI just liquidated my entire BTC position. Crypto failed and will never be anything but a grift. I'm out.
- m348e912 4y agoI have two buying/selling indicators for crypto. 1. When my mom or other people who have no business in investing in crypto ask me how much bitcoin they should buy. (selling indicator) 2. When people start liquidating their positions and call crypto a grift. (buying indicator)
- hectorlorenzo 4y agoWhat do you do when both are happening at the same time?
- 7steps2much 4y agoDevelop split personality disorder and begin trading with yourself
- danlugo92 4y agoLightning fixes this.
- santialbo 4y agoI'm seeing people removing the laser eyes from their twitter avatars.
- LightG 4y agoBro's! They're blocking us from our rights!! Our ... our ... FREEEEEEEEEEDOMMMM!!!!
- doomroot 4y agoReposting from the other thread: I would like to provide some context to people unfamiliar with how the bitcoin mempool works and what you can do to avoid getting your transaction stuck. The mempool is all of the transactions that have ben gossiped about but have not yet been mined (finalized) into a block. Each node has their own mempool. You can see [1] that there are roughly 6 hrs worth of transactions in this node's mempool (everyone should have a similar mempool, though not identical). So Binance's claims of network congestion are "true" on the surface, however there are a few interesting points that lead me to believe that they are acting fishy. 1. Why does Binance not have RBF enabled on their withdrawal transactions? RBF mean "replace by fee" and it's a way you can mark an unconfirmed transaction as replaceable by a similar transaction that pays higher fees. This is extremely useful when you need to ram a transaction into a block by increasing the fee you're willing to pay miners to mine your transaction. I highly recommend you only use a wallet that allows you to use RBF & to have RBF enabled by default. Of course Binance knows about RBF so why aren't they using it? 2. Why does Binance not use 'Child Pays for Parent'? CPFP is a little hard to understand if you don't understand that bitcoin transactions are linked together in a graph structure. In short, a bitcoin transaction is a data structure that points to previous transactions to spend. CPFP is when you make a new transaction that spends from your previous unconfirmed transaction (un-mined transaction in the mempool) and over pay in fees to cover the cost of both transactions. This incentivizes miners to include BOTH transaction in the same block. Once again Binance should be doing this. An ideal way to do this would be to batch a bunch of customer withdrawals in a single transaction. This would save a lot on network fees. They would make this big transaction payout a large amount back to themselves so that they could CPFP this batched withdrawal transaction. 3. Binance has their own mining pool with 11% of the network hash[2]. Binance could easily prioritize their "stuck" withdrawal transaction in their pool's blocks. Of course if they didn't subsidize their miners for this they risk them switching to another pool. One would think that halting withdrawals is an existential risk to their business so temporarily paying their miners to ram transactions through should be worth it? So what is the take away from all of this? There are numerous tools at Binance's disposal. Why did they not work/why are they not using them? My hunch is that they don't have all of their ducks in a row & are running a fractional reserve. (this is pure speculation on my part) They likely had a lot of (your) bitcoin tied up in "risk-free" interest accounts (Celsius) and are scrambling to get ahold of bitcoin to give back to customers. [1] https://mempool.space/ https://mempool.space/ [2] https://mempool.space/mining/pool/binancepool https://mempool.space/mining/pool/binancepool
- twawaaay 4y agoI am so happy about this. I hope this is going to sour crypto for "investors". I use quotes, because they really are not -- investing should be reserved for fronting cash to create some value (like buying stock to infuse capital into a corporation). As it is all crypto trading is purely speculation. The world would be so much better if money tended to be exchanged in good faith, to improve something rather than just to exploit market instability.
- danuker 4y ago> As it is all crypto trading is purely speculation. The reason I stay invested is the supply-side economics. The supply is well-known in advance, and is advantageous to Bitcoin. US M2 money supply grew 8.04% in the past year [0], while Bitcoin's grew ~1.75% [1]. Yes, demand has its 80% ups and downs, but each crash was to a level higher than the previous. [0] - https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_m2_money_supply_yoy https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_m2_money_supply_yoy [1] - https://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-inflation/ https://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-inflation/
- dehrmann 4y ago> Yes, demand has its 80% ups and downs, but each crash was to a level higher than the previous. You're actually looking at demand more than supply. You're right that supply isn't going up much, but you have no evidence or theory about why people will be more interested in Bitcoin in 5 years than they are now. You really have to look at both.
- legulere 4y agoWhat when demand goes to 0, when people realize that bitcoins aren’t useful for anything legal?
- danuker 4y agoThen I incur a 100% loss and move on. But so far, this crash has stayed above the 2017 top. So it looks like I'm holding the S&P at 4x leverage, but with no margin calls.
- mig39 4y agoLooks like they've resumed: https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/d312178e0fce43c9b8c457a31139f783 https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/d312178e0fce...
- Tade0 4y ago> Funds are SAFU I like how they embraced this term, even though it was originally a typo that went on to live a life of its own.
- 999900000999 4y agoThis really looks like a Bitcoin bank run. I reckon if the tide really goes out, the money isn't really there. We have FDIC insurance for a reason. Luckily this happened before Crypto became mainstream. Normal people aren't likely to lose their life savings.
- redm 4y agoWithdrawals resumed. https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/d312178e0fce43c9b8c457a31139f783 https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/d312178e0fce...
- eftychis 4y agoa) Think we are overreacting on the particular comment. It is like gmail or github saying service is down/issue in Binance. b) As other people commented to people's comments: unusual days is when bugs manifest c) The whole stock and bond market is down. Everything is down. It is the "reddest" state we have been. Feel free to check. We are watching the whole world economy going down. We can of course carry on burying Crypto, but let us not kid ourselves that the practices do not exist in the rest of the commodity space. Or that the world is booming meanwhile crypto is just getting what it deserves. Now if that is bad and scary, I agree. Good luck.
- jmartin2683 4y agoI believed very strongly in Bitcoin until the first time I tried to accept it as payment at by business. It’s fundamentally incapable of providing any real value… unless you’re into money laundering or tax evasion.