37 ms·
The case for expanding rather than eliminating gifted education programs (2021)
- indymike 4y agoIntelligent kids are one of the most picked on and abused demographics in existence. Gifted programs for many is the only part of school that is positive for them.
- anthonypasq 4y agomethinks someone is projecting
- thebooktocome 4y agoI’m not aware of studies showing that gifted programs have a positive impact on student performance. My hunch is that the typical school district is looking for a palatable excuse to reduce funding needs.
- aantix 4y agoThey were the only interesting classes. Project based learning. Being with other students that actually gave a shit.
- edrxty 4y agoCan confirm, I went through several and they were all massively formative experiences. I wouldn't trade them for anything. If anything, children should be offered more opportunities to seek this kind of free form enrichment.
- _3u10 4y agoI can’t speak for everyone but they kept me from dropping out.
- thebooktocome 4y agoBut would you (and the statistical student like you) have been better served by a different intervention? That’s the thing I’m curious about.
- gcfff 4y agoI think a new intervention should be demonstrated to be an improvement before current interventions be cut.
- _3u10 4y agoGifted programs and advanced classes were what kept me in school, the only things that got my grades up tho were classes with rigid rules. I had one class and where if you showed up late once / didn’t hand in one assignment you failed. I got straight As that semester. The rest of school was just min/max’ing to average out with a C and not do any homework.
- wccrawford 4y agoI would actually say that my gifted classes probably brought my grades down, at least in those same years. But at the same time, they gave me a broader education and I learned more than I would have otherwise. At my elementary school, you were taken out of normal classes 1 day per week. You still had to do all the work from that day, but you didn't actually attend those sessions for those classes. Instead, you spent the whole day in a different classroom that was solely for "gifted" students. Of course, this meant that it really was only the top students that could handle it. Prior to being tested and accepted into Gifted, I was a pretty constant disruption in my normal classes. I would finish all the work in class, even the stuff that everyone else had to take home because it took them so long. That left me constantly bored, and clued them in that I needed more. TBH, I probably would have said I preferred being given a book and let sit in a corner and learned or just read fiction. But instead I was forced to be social and learn about things not usually taught in school, such as puzzle solving. I'm still very much an introvert, but I have to wonder how much more introverted I'd be if it weren't for that? Perhaps cripplingly so. I'm a huge fan of gifted classes for obvious reasons, but not at the expense of other students. If there isn't enough budget to teach everyone to a basic level, gifted classes are not a great idea. In fact, we should probably restructure everything so that everyone who isn't being taught at their full potential can learn more in school. I'm sure there were students around me that were almost in my same situation, but they weren't in Gifted. They were probably also bored and could have been both educated and entertained during those times, if we had the programs for it.
- danielodievich 4y agoSo this is a topic I have all kinds of interest and experience with. I live in one of those top 100 zipcodes of USA with very small school district. It's plenty diverse racially but completely homogenous financially (i.e. pretty much everyone is rich). I have two kids just a year apart. One just barely didn't make it into gifted & talented program at grade 3, and another one definitely did, and has been in one since then. [Edit] oh and I was in gifted/advanced class myself from grade 7 on, but not here, but in Russia. Plenty of parents pushed very hard for the kids to test into the gifted program, getting kids tutors and repeatedly testing in. There was one kid I remember who was bright as all get out but a complete asshole in social circumstances that apparently tested 3 times by his parents until he made it (2 highly focused doctors). My kid that tested in actually didn't start in it, but then about a month into 3rd grade complained that he was bored and we were able to move him in. We've been involved with the teachers on both regular and gifted track. We - and every parent with child in gifted class - are not happy about our school sunsetting it for the district. No teachers - certainly no teachers of advanced classes - were consulted on this effort. None of them are getting any additional help in now trying to teach to all levels, and result will be (already is) a dilution of quality all around. As with many schools everywhere, and with covid helping, there are some kids departing towards private education where your money talks and you do whatever. Where I live is increasingly unaffordable, too, so we have reduced enrollment because there are just less kids. I do fine but am not at economic place to afford private education, my offer to kids is where I live, which even with the dilution is still excellent education. We (and almost every parent around us) are very engaged with schools with volunteering and additional funding. In fact I am a treasurer of the schools foundation that donates up to a $1 million/year to school for all kinds of things, mostly general funding. That tends to help but really, even our little district needs like extra ~$20mil to fund what we're supposed to. Anyhow, on cleverness nd equity, what it boils down to me is that the world is becoming just one big lake now with talent being increasingly able to accrue huge benefits. This talent needs education and people who want best for their kids (including me) will do whatever is necessary to get that. This is why there is extra tutoring in china and private schools in USA and fancy boarding schools in UK for $$$. If public schools do remove this equity stuff, it'll just float via money to those other areas. It isn't bad/good, it just is. Anyhow, a bit of a rant/laundry list, but here you have it.
- _gabe_ 4y agoI would have loved to continue reading this, but he immediately claimed that "Black students are 66% less likely to be identified as gifted compared to white students with similar test scores". I clicked the link that supposedly contained the paper to back this up. The link takes you here[0]. That's a bit annoying since it doesn't take me directly to the source, but that's fine. Then I read the article and it says: "...found black students were 66 percent less likely to be assigned to a gifted program as white students. A black student whose test scores were on par with a white peer was still half as likely to be assigned to a gifted classroom." So, immediately the author of this original article saw the statistic 66% and the phrase "on par with test scores", and immediately conflated the two. According to this statement, it sounds like black students are actually 50% less likely to be identified as gifted with similar test scores. I'm going to assume that's just an artifact of non-diligent research and not a blatant lie. Well, I'm still curious where these stats come from, so let's see where this article in the Tennesseean is sourcing this stuff from. They've got several links on this article and... every single link, with the exception of the link to a randomly named professor at Vanderbilt, lead to other articles on the Tennessean. Let's see if we can find where they obtained these stats from. Alright, it looks like this is where they got it from[1], but I can't be 100% sure. This actually has a link to the paper as well[2]. It also has a nice disclaimer at the bottom of the article: > One such additional factor impacting minority assignment to gifted programs is the availability of these programs in schools attended by minority students. Black students are less likely overall to attend schools that provide gifted programs. Ninety percent of white, 93 percent of Hispanic, and 91 percent of Asian elementary students attend schools with gifted programs, while only 83 percent of African American students do. In other words, when the researchers took test scores into account for Hispanic students vs white students, the differences in the probability of being selected for a gifted program based on race reduced to 0%. With black students, they (seemingly) did not take into account whether a school even offered a gifted program. So they lumped together all the students who may not have had access to a gifted program, and then used that to conclude that teachers are racist and ignoring test scores. Right off the bat I'm done with this article. If you're going to cite research, then cite the actual paper first of all. Second, look at how they gathered the data. Once you take the anomalies into account, it looks like we may not have racist teachers, but rather incomplete data. I wish we could just have an honest conversation about this stuff instead of all this stupid indirection and trying to hide the actual research being done because it doesn't fully support your claims. The big issue here is a lot of black students don't have access to gifted programs, but instead we're fighting "racist" teachers that don't exist. [0]: https://www.tennessean.com/story/news/education/2016/01/19/vanderbilt-report-black-kids-underrepresented-gifted-programs/78963422/ https://www.tennessean.com/story/news/education/2016/01/19/v... [1]: https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2016/01/18/teachers-race-affects-gifted-program-selections/ https://news.vanderbilt.edu/2016/01/18/teachers-race-affects... [2]: https://cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-news/files/20190417222934/Grissom_AERAOpen_GiftedStudents1.pdf https://cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-news/files/20190417222934/Gris...
- whatshisface 4y ago>I agree that it is unacceptable to have eighth grade Algebra I classes and gifted education programs that disproportionately exclude Black and brown children. But if equity is the goal, we should be mandating that every eighth grader takes Algebra I—and then structure the entire pre-K to seventh grade student experience to ensure this is a legitimate possibility for every child. Since when does equity mean everyone gets nothing? I don't know whether Algebra I is above or below what eighth graders can be expected to do, but raising the difficulty of every class to what the most advanced student is capable of is not the answer either. Everybody knows someone else that is better at math than they are, and someone who is not as good. It is universal common knowledge that the ease with which one takes to math is different for different people. Why can't we just admit it and quit trying to make people who are unique the same?
- acchow 4y ago> Why can't we just admit it and quit trying to make people who are unique the same? America keeps conflating equity for equality.
- eej71 4y agoThe conflation is a very recent intellectual phenomena.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoI think it is part of an intentional replacement, the conflation is only temporary in order to muddy the waters and diminish opposition.
- readthenotes1 4y agoWhy intellectual? It seems more political to me (both in the sense of wanting to change policy and wanting to acquire power)
- eej71 4y ago
- _3u10 4y agoIt’s all Harrison Bergeron all the way down.
- slowhand09 4y agoUpvote for Bergeron reference.
- Bostonian 4y ago"The current population of students we identify as academically gifted and talented is unacceptably whiter and wealthier than the actual student population of academically gifted and talented students should be." A typical IQ threshold for a gifted program is 130. The average IQ overall is 100 with standard deviation 15. For black Americans the average score on IQ tests is about 85, which explains why blacks will be under-represented in gifted programs unless racial preferences are used. The makers of IQ tests would like to reduce racial differentials while maintaining the predictive abilities of their tests, but they have not been able to.
- paulpauper 4y agoI depends. I think the threshold is more like 120, but IQ may not be used anymore as a criteria
- wccrawford 4y agoIt's probably not used as the criteria for a few reasons, but I'd bet it still correlates pretty strongly in the end.
- jeremyjh 4y agoDid you read the part where he pointed out that black/brown students are 66% less likely to be in a gifted program with the same test scores ?
- zmgsabst 4y agoIs that because the program discriminates or because their family lacks awareness of such programs? Those have very different solutions.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoSchools literally send home papers to parents and communicate with them directly about the programs. Most school districts require parental permission before children are pulled out of class to be tested.
- zmgsabst 4y agoEliminating “gifted” programs because they offend the racial sensibilities of the managerial class is a blatant exercise in privilege and ladder-pulling. I think it’s grotesque how many privileged people are happily destroying the lives of others (often, those they pretend to care about) so they don’t have to think critically about or be uncomfortable thinking about race. Seattle is the epitome of “privileged White liberals hurt everyone for their comfort”: The bourgeois have become the baizuo.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoI'm pretty socially conservative, and the equality-of-outcome mindset is very unintuitive for me. It's very tempting (edit: for me) to lazily rest on the caricature, "I don't care how many people I hurt, as long as I can help just one!" Despite that, or maybe because of that, I make a conscious effort to understand where the other side is coming from. I figure there's little chance of finding a compromise if I can't even comprehend their viewpoint. So far I haven't been very successful. Maybe it's because the chasm is so large regarding values, understandings of human nature, predictions about how things will play out, etc. Or maybe I have blind spots that get in the way. I wish I were better at this. It seems like at a very zoomed-out level we want similar things.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> I figure there's little chance of finding a compromise if I can't even comprehend their viewpoint. I understand it just fine, but there’s a fundamental disagreement, in that I don’t support racism nor view people in terms of “racial tribes” — while proponents of equity do. That’s the frame they’re working from when they say denying an Asian student a place at Harvard in favor of a less qualified black applicant is “good”: that it’s okay to harm that person because they’re yellow and we need to balance between yellows and blacks — to accomplish their Utopian vision. Collectivism when applied to race inevitably leads to institutional racism. I don’t believe that’s something we need to “compromise” on: institutional racism was a disaster when we tried it before and modern attempts (eg, Netflix and Disney catering to those views) show that bigotry is widely unpopular and a poor way to run a company. Sometimes you just have to say “bigotry is wrong and we’re not trying it again — no matter how you dress it up in the language of civil rights or how righteous you feel about being a bigot”.
- basedgod 4y ago
- natly 4y agoThere's usually gifted programs in poor schools as well. This isn't a private vs public education thing. It's more about keeping bright students stimulated and not bored to tears and have their potential stunted.
- JaimeThompson 4y agoFrom the article. "Black students are 66% less likely to be identified as gifted compared to white students with similar test scores. Black, Latinx, and Native American students are far less likely to attend a school that even offers a gifted program. These are just some of the issues with which the gifted education field must grapple. "
- basedgod 4y agoyou're right, there's absolutely no systemic bias in testing, and the tests themselves accurately measure intelligence and giftedness
- moron4hire 4y ago> I do not doubt the good intentions behind the decisions educators make in the name of equity. I do. Or rather, I doubt the good intentions of the decision makers. I don't think educators are making these decisions. The more I experience the public education system through my child (I did not experience it myself, as I was homeschooled), and the more stories I hear from parents, the more it looks like school administrators are politicians looking to cut costs and get on a track to end up in city council. The actual welfare of the children doesn't really look like it ends up a part of the equation.
- Alex3917 4y agoAuthor cites the research on minorities being less likely be identified as gifted given comparable test scores, but selectively leaves out all of the research on the effects of eliminating gifted programs. I guess Teach for America assumes their readers are too dumb to notice?
- bloaf 4y agoI notice you've not cited it either. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001698629303700407 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001698629303700... > Results indicated that parents perceived that their children were experiencing a decline in energy, curiosity, and intrinsic motivation to achieve at high levels and were beginning to disengage from the traditional curriculum [after elimination of the gifted programs]. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1041608009000909 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S10416... > This review also found that the needs of many gifted and talented students are not addressed in many regular classroom settings across our country... A large body of research supports the finding that various forms of acceleration result in higher achievement for gifted and talented learners.
- derac 4y agoGifted programs are "unacceptably white". WTF does that mean? I had to pass essentially an IQ test to get placed into those classes. For me, it made a big difference in being engaged in schoolwork when every class consisted of reiterating content for days which I had mastered in minutes. Edit: I removed "I don't see what race has to do with it." I do see how race can affect this when the gatekeeper is a teacher with biases choosing who takes the test to be in the program. This does not however make it ok to say "unacceptably white"
- jeremyjh 4y agoJust read what he wrote? > Black students are 66% less likely to be identified as gifted compared to white students with similar test scores. Black, Latinx, and Native American students are far less likely to attend a school that even offers a gifted program.
- chernevik 4y agoHow is that an answer? If someone isn't meeting the qualifications they aren't in. What's "unacceptable" about that?
- jeremyjh 4y agoAre there qualifications other than test scores?
- fnordpiglet 4y agoApparently race given the assertion of similar test scores
- wccrawford 4y agoThere are unwritten ones, at least. As I said in my other post, in my school you were taken out of regularly classes, but still had to learn those things and do that work. That means the student has to agree to work 20% harder, usually at home, where they may not have that luxury. There are probably other considerations that aren't coming to mind at the moment, too, that also affect the number of children in Gifted programs.
- protomyth 4y agoEquity matters for education, but not the sports teams? If the conversation about gifted and talented programs doesn't include the other activities the school sponsors, then its not fair. We've eliminated voc-ed and now g&t programs. I bet sports cost a bunch.
- jimbob45 4y agoI'd say I learned much more from the elementary school and middle school sports programs I participated in than I ever learned from the gifted/talented programs I participated in. I find it to be a terrible shame that high school sports are so often limited in participation by elitism (e.g. basketball limited to 10 players, volleyball to ~12, cheerleading to ~20). I would wholeheartedly support removing limits on high school sports participation. The free market can suck away the elite athletes if they don't feel that high school sports are adequate for their professional development - that's fine, high school should cater to the majority, not an infinitesimal minority.
- protomyth 4y agoRegardless of the usefulness of sports in schools (and I do believe they are useful), you point out that they are "often limited in participation by elitism" much as I suppose the critics of gifted & talented programs would say of those programs. If so, then they must be studied to make sure they don't disproportionately exclude certain racial groups. If racial imbalance is a guideline for cancellation then it should apply to every program and activity.
- jimbob45 4y agoIn your equivalence, the "sport" is studying math (or something) and everyone is participating, simply on different levels. Your equivalence would only work if the non-gifted students weren't allowed to study anything at all.
- erichocean 4y ago? Everyone in school studies math and reading. Everyone is participating, simply on different levels. I guess I don't understand your comment at all.
- mikece 4y agoEliminating accelerated or gifted programs doesn't create equality any more than mandating a uniform maximum height will stop people from growing past 2 meters in height. All it does it rob society at large from the possibility of the exceptionally able from realizing their potential sooner. If we're willing, as a body politic, to eschew the possibility of an exceptional learner from discovering things like the cure for cancer in the name of equity then we'll reap the fruit of that collective decision.
- formerly_proven 4y agoEquity != Equality. Equity is semantically closer to equality of outcome than equality (of conditions/opportunities).
- mikece 4y agoI will agree 100% that words and terms are being thrown around without adequate or agreed upon definition of terms. Without an agreement on the definition of the words being used it's pretty much impossible to have a cogent exchange of ideas.
- TimPC 4y agoBut Equity also argues for treating people differently depending on their needs. Eliminating gifted programs so that all students are treated the same seems to me to be far closer to the equality bucket than any equity one.
- bendbro 4y agoComrade I see you have formed some misinformations, please allow me to reeducate you. The pupil-with-non-intrinsically-greater-test-performance does not need increased schooling, as she already has too much. To increase equity and goodwill in our society, it is best for the student to receive less education.
- systemvoltage 4y ago[flagged]
- colechristensen 4y agoStill bending over backwards to accommodate a racial equity narrative. How about you don’t look at a child’s skin color before you decide how they are educated and instead focus on doing the best you can for each instead of trying to make everything about achieving social justice goals. Anything else is racism.
- Kaze404 4y agoSo simple! We just need to stop looking at color and all inequality will go away! I wonder why nobody's thought of that before.
- whatevenisthat 4y agoWe were doing that for most of the 90s and early 2000s and it was working. It's only because of grifters and agitators and "thought leaders" who try to make a buck off of divisions and needless debates that we see this resurgence in these types of politics. And underneath the veneer of race concern-trolling there's a resurgence in communist ideas trying to use the wedge of race as the basis for justifying both the redistribution of wealth and the dissolution of merit-based systems.
- Kaze404 4y agoIt sure was working for white people. You're right about that.
- swader999 4y agoGifted kids can be quite a force of good and bad. Probably better ROI to keep them on the path towards the good regardless of the amount of pigment in their skin.
- paulpauper 4y agoThe kids of elites and the rich will always have opportunities regardless of aptitude. Is it any surprise actor's kids tend to also have many opportunities in acting. Opposing gifted education, acceleration, etc. seems like another way of pulling up the ladder, even if it's framed as being well-intentioned.
- chitowneats 4y agoExactly. The people hurt most by this are lower income Americans, many of them immigrants, for whom these programs are a golden ticket out of poverty. Absolutely shameful what they are destroying here.
- slothtrop 4y agoedit: misread, I agree
- havblue 4y agoI think a lot of the equity advocates fail to admit things just aren't working right now. So if you say you'll just pull your kids and send them private, they'll say that we need to force all kids into public schools. There's no middle ground.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- frgtpsswrdlame 4y ago>I agree that it is unacceptable to have eighth grade Algebra I classes and gifted education programs that disproportionately exclude Black and brown children. But if equity is the goal, we should be mandating that every eighth grader takes Algebra I—and then structure the entire pre-K to seventh grade student experience to ensure this is a legitimate possibility for every child. Since when does equity mean everyone gets nothing? I think this is the key. Obviously eliminating gifted programs and just tossing those resources into the wind is bad. But if instead we eliminated gifted programs, shifting those resources into remedial programs and then made the normal classes more difficult that seems like a solution that would satisfy almost everyone.
- TimPC 4y agoGifted programs are extremely important and the width of American gifted programs is a virtue. Canada has a much higher standard for gifted, and in Ontario we generally admit roughly the top 1% of students (many American programs cater to the top 10%). There a number of large benefits to gifted, not the least of which is it changes the character of a program/school. If you are surrounded by bright students with nerdy academic interests it's suddenly acceptable to nerd out on things. This single fact may be more valuable to the development of the student than the entire program itself. Outside of gifted, schools have substantial challenges with creating environments where academic excellence is encouraged and rewarded not only by the schools grading system but also by social behaviour of peers. While bullying has gone down, and acceptability of geeky interests have improved in the past 30 years there is still nothing close to a gifted program from encouraging and accepting academic excellence. As someone who just barely missed the gifted cutoff, my schooling was much too easy and I basically never had to study for tests or exams. I ended up developing poor academic habits that ultimately hurt me when the difficulty got hard enough that intellectual horsepower needed to be combined with hard work. I think being challenged early and often would have changed this behaviour substantially. Even creating an environment where I wanted to be around other students enough to participate in more extra-curriculars could have helped. I worry that we are going to create a lot of bright but unmotivated students by offering years of programs that are too easy for them. There are consequences far beyond just having these students occasionally act out out of boredom and I think it's a very bad idea to create an educational culture that suggests bright people should be lazy. This is ultimately what the removal of gifted programs do because classroom teachers generally aren't given adequate prep time or other resources to properly offer enrichment. I've even known some principals who encouraged their teachers to not offer enrichment as it created problems in later grades when other teachers didn't offer similar enrichment and parents expected it.
- Supermancho 4y ago> As someone who just barely missed the gifted cutoff, my schooling was much too easy and I basically never had to study for tests or exams. I ended up developing poor academic habits that ultimately hurt me when the difficulty got hard enough that intellectual horsepower needed to be combined with hard work. When you're little, you self-learn that if it's easy, it's not worth doing. If it's hard, it's probably impossible anyway. Your life is good and filled with fun. As you get older, when things get hard in school, you avoid or fail them with no strategies or habits around completing difficult schoolwork (which often feels as rewarding as easy schoolwork). Who would want to stop having fun? This is sometimes referred to as, the curse of the gifted.
- dottedmag 4y agoThis reminds me of a short story from Soviet times: Russia, 1917. A commotion on the street. A lady asks a servant to find out what's going on. The servant returns: - Revolution! - That's fabulous. My grandfather was a revolutionary too. What do they wish to achieve? - They want to make sure nobody is rich! - That's odd... My grandfather wanted to make sure nobody is poor. P.S: A sad irony is that Soviet education system was pretty good at maintaining gifted programs. (edit: formatting)
- TrackerFF 4y agoBut also pretty good at excluding for example Jews from certain prestigious schools, see: https://arxiv.org/abs/1110.1556 https://arxiv.org/abs/1110.1556
- 62951413 4y agoThe Jews were overrepresented among both students and teachers in top STEM educational institutions starting from magnet schools.
- spaced-out 4y agoWhat revolution was the 1917 woman's grandfather apart of?
- somedude895 4y agoThere was a peasant / worker revolt in 1905, which led to the Tsar implementing some democratic institutions: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1905_Russian_Revolution https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1905_Russian_Revolution
- dottedmag 4y agoThis one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decembrist_revolt
- dmeocary 4y ago
- robonerd 4y agoThe gifted program helped me immensely in highschool, although the hour or two I actually spent in the gifted classroom was mostly wasted playing board games. However being in that program gave me the ability to switch classes/teachers whenever one wasn't working for me, usually because some teachers could maintain a civil classroom and other teachers let the students run wild and taught nothing. Because I was in the gifted program, the school permitted me to switch out of those classrooms into classes taught by competent/caring teachers. This suggests to me that the advantage of the program could be conferred to students who score low on IQ tests but are nevertheless behaved in class. A better gifted program would be one that differentiates on the basis of civility, not IQ. Of course, deferring measurement of IQ to some licensed professionals is easier than objectively quantifying a student's civility, so I don't know how this would actually be implemented.
- whatshisface 4y agoIf you let students attend any classes they wanted, I bet they would sort themselves appropriately. The rowdy kids won't want to be in a classroom where everyone is quiet and the teacher is explaining the central limit theorem.
- abfan1127 4y agobut then the rowdy kids get left behind. You could argue that the rowdy kids are getting left behind either way.
- thorncorona 4y agoThat sounds like a parenting problem to me.
- abfan1127 4y agoI agree.
- anthonypasq 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoThere are so many topics that are hard to talk about nowadays without getting into politics but politics and structural inequality are at the core of this. For the benefit of non-US readers, know that how the US funds public education (K-12) is rather unique. It's done through property taxes essentially. Depending on your state and city your property taxes can vary a lot with the same value property. But what this means is the wealthier localities have more tax revenue and thus better schools. This can be a vicious cycle of improving property values by having better schools and thus generating more tax revenue and so on. I say "vicious" because it is absolutely exclusionary to lower-income people who cannot possibly afford to live in these areas. And that's by design. Twenty years ago Bush (43) passed the No Child Left Behind Act, which many dubbed the No Child Gets Ahead Act. A lot of this was also in the name of "equity". I know people who send their children to public schools in NYC. NYC seems to be in the mood to eliminate these "gifted" programs because of "equity" too. The result? Those who can afford to send their children to private schools will. For those who are left, there are no more gifted programs. How does that help anyone?
- mrexroad 4y agoI’ve always quipped that the idea that the highest property taxes fund the poorest areas, and vice-versa. While not feasible, the current situation is absurd.
- toyg 4y ago> While not feasible Well, that's effectively what happens in European systems, where schooling is basically run entirely by the State and funding is mostly distributed on a per-pupil basis - higher-income taxpayers effectively subsidize poorer areas. So it is, in fact, feasible. But Americans would probably call that illiberal or something.
- singlow 4y agoThat is what Texas does. Not 100 percent, but a majority of tax dollars for schools are paid to the state and redistributed to the districts based on attendance/enrollment. Rich areas might be able to use extra funds/donations for capital expenditures like fancier buildings or stadiums, but the tax money at largely redistributed.
- superb-owl 4y agoI've never understood this approach of "eliminating gifted programs" due to equity concerns. Why not just implement something along the lines of affirmative action policies - make sure the demographics gifted programs roughly match the demographics of the school district?
- jaywalk 4y agoHow does shoving a student into a gifted program they aren't otherwise qualified for solely due to their race actually help anything?
- superb-owl 4y agoThis assumes that current admissions are purely meritocratic, when, as the article points out, they're not: > Black students are 66% less likely to be identified as gifted compared to white students with similar test scores But even if we supposed that the top 10% of Black students were slightly less qualified than the top 10% of White students (say, due to socioeconomic factors), the program would simply adjust towards the mean student. So maybe the program slows down a bit, but it's still an accelerated program, and now it's helping to correct those socioeconomic disparities. The only case where this argument would break down is if the top 10% of Black students were _severely_ less qualified than the top 10% of White students, in which case the program would likely fail. But it seems pretty clear that this isn't the case.
- duxup 4y ago>we should be mandating that every eighth grader takes Algebra I—and then structure the entire pre-K to seventh grade student experience to ensure this is a legitimate possibility for every child. Just "make" everyone qualified / good at algebra? I feel like that glosses over the ALL the challenges with education ...
- zen_1 4y agoNever let reality get in the way of ideology
- chernevik 4y ago"eighth grade Algebra I classes and gifted education programs that disproportionately exclude Black and brown children" The absence of "Black and brown children" doesn't mean they were _excluded_, it means they weren't _selected_, or never applied in the first place. If they were deliberately not selected because of their race, that's wrong and should be fixed pronto. And what are the odds of that? If they were not selected because they didn't meet the qualifications, well, that isn't the fault of the gifted program.
- Jarwain 4y ago> Black students are 66% less likely to be identified as gifted compared to white students _with similar test scores_. Black, Latinx, and Native American students are far less likely to attend a school that even offers a gifted program. Emphasis mine. The likely thing going on is something subconscious or unintentionally discriminatory, or somehow related to the home family life.
- Jtype 4y agoIronically, this shows that we should be focusing more on test results and less on other factors, which is the opposite of the current movement.
- tejohnso 4y ago> If they were not selected because they didn't meet the qualifications, well, that isn't the fault of the gifted program. But it could be the fault of the government, the school administration, and an entire culture of systemic racism. And so there could be several problems to address. Does removing the gifted program solve any of the problems? No. Does it make some people feel as though they're doing good by equalizing everything? Yes.
- SpaceManNabs 4y agoIt took me two years to verify that I was gifted enough for the gifted program in middle school. In fact, they did so incredibly reluctantly because I achieved the highest math scores in my middle school on the state exams (two years in a row). It takes a lot of effort to be recognized as an afro-latino person that can be gifted even with higher scores. They also only placed me in the math/science gifted sections and would only be placed in the english/social studies gifted sections after much arguing as well. Guess what? I excelled there too. Now to get away from anecdotes: > If they were deliberately not selected because of their race, that's wrong and should be fixed pronto. And what are the odds of that? between 50 to 70% on an individual basis if some studies are to be believed.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhen I was in 8th grade, the teacher was still teaching the times tables. I suspect some of the students who weren't "getting it" were sandbagging it so they wouldn't be taught new material.
- hawk_ 4y ago> Latinx It's hard to take anyone who uses this term seriously. Latinos can't even pronounce it or care for it.
- jaywalk 4y agoLatinos almost universally despise it. It was made up by non-Hispanic leftists because... I don't know, something about not forcing gender? It's utterly ridiculous.
- scarmig 4y agoIf we insist on mutilating Spanish to satisfy intellectual fads, something like "Latine" would be better. The broader issue is that having grammatical noun classes/gender serves an important purpose: not enforcing the patriarchy, but instead disambiguating different words and antecedents (basically adding an extra bit or two of information to a word).
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- googlryas 4y agoCouple this with the fact that the whole "Latin[aeox]" terms aren't even inclusive to begin with. They are generally are used to broadly describe "a person from central/south America", except they are entirely Euro-centric, as if Latinos showed up to uninhabited open land. More than likely, the Qʼeqchiʼ person from Guatemala, who barely speaks Spanish, who has 100% Mayan ancestry, doesn't self identify as "Latino".
- IshKebab 4y agoIt's easy to pronounce. Rhymes with womxn.
- goatlover 4y agoNPR uses it. I turn it off every-time I hear them say it.
- weatherlite 4y agoHow effective are those young gifted programs anyway? I'm somewhat skeptical of the whole thing, especially in the era of the internet.
- giardini 4y agoGifted children are rare enough that they can be dealt with one at a time. I see no need for special programs. In contrast handicapped children may require special attention. OTOH I have seen students unwilling to attend a particular school b/c it has a reputation for behavioral problems and also low testing scores. So best spend money on improving education for all. I would like to see more usage of an old tradition: better students helping others during class. This promotes cameraderie and provides different perspectives for both parties. It always helps to "stand in another man's shoes" and see the world from that new perspective.
- brunoTbear 4y agoThis is a tradition that can go the way of other great old traditions like catching polio. In my experience it did nothing but find a way for me to be forced to spend more time with bullies and suffer trying to explain something to them that they were decidedly uninterested in learning.
- iisan7 4y agosometimes that can work but I have my doubts as to it being a good general policy. not at all guaranteed that it promotes camaraderie, over, say being called arrogant, teacher's pet, and ostracized by the others as 'too good'. Kids should be able to form friendships with those at different levels and help their friends, but shouldn't be asked to be their teachers or mentors. it's incredibly unfair to require students in the class to function as teachers. They are there to learn, and if they've learned everything on the curriculum, they should be able to learn more. Teachers used to handle this by letting the kids have 'free time' after assignments to go to the library, or whatever. Gifted programs do this even better by putting them in a class with kids at a similar level so they are less likely to need special treatment or to be called 'smart'. This can actually help them realize early in life that they aren't automatically special because they're at the top of their class.
- bena 4y agoSo why not have the normal needs students helping the children with learning dysfunctions? Promote that camaraderie all the way down. Let them see what it's like in another's shoes. Etc. All of your arguments for putting the gifted in normal classes, but applied to normal students and children with learning dysfunctions. Gifted students are special needs students. They exist on the entire other end of the spectrum than those with learning dysfunctions.
- hintymad 4y agoWhat's sad is that the US used to be the vanguard of modern civilization: science, technology, policies (making federalism work in a vast country like the US is an amazing achievement), and human wellbeing in general. And now we are debating common sense. Shame on the progressives.
- whatevenisthat 4y agoIt still is the vanguard of all those things, fortunately. The good news is that it seems the pendulum is beginning to swing the other way. For example, last night San Franciso booted the progressive soft-on-crime DA. This mirrors a trend in other progressive bases too. The mid-term elections will at this rate represent a chastising of the progressive left. Good riddance!
- burlesona 4y agoOne worldview is that progress is more important than equality, thus inequality is an acceptable side effect so long as life is genuinely improving for everyone. “Rising tide lifts all boats.” Another is that equality is more important than progress. “Take from the rich and give to the poor.” It seems mostly universal that we really want to raise the floor, not lower the ceiling. But so far history suggests that lowering the ceiling is easier. Since the decision to value progress or equality higher is ultimately a personal moral choice, I don’t see this debate ever being resolved.
- cato_the_elder 4y agoIt will be resolved, if not by debate then by the hard hit of reality. Happily, we don't live in a "one world government". So, if a society insists too much on silly ideas, it will be left in the dust by others.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- nova22033 4y agoIf equity is the goal, schools should spend some $$ providing extra tutoring for kids when they are younger..especially for kids with potential. But we can't have that because that may require a little more tax $.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoAt my high school, they were able to get funding for advanced program (for above average students) by arguing that there was already funding for programs for students who were struggling (below average students). That is, that is was unfair that one group of students were having their special educational needs met, but that another group wasn't. They succeeded and the program was very successful. The result was three levels for most subjects which students could choose based on their goals and abilities. They were also able to keep the bar for the advanced classes high so students who enrolled but found them too challenging would soon drop down a level -- as most preferred a high grade in middle level class then a mediocre or low grade in a high level class. I took classes at all three levels as I was strong in math and science but less so in the humanities, for example. I thought it worked great.
- DeathArrow 4y agoSo leftist are producing inclusivity and equity by forcing everyone stay at the lowest common denominator. Instead of trying to help disadvantaged people climb the stair, they are breaking the stair to be sure everyone remains down.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago[flagged]
- adverbly 4y agoGifted programs threads on HN are the new flame war battlegrounds... turns people into an armchair geniuses, ready to post solutions based on some anecdotal data. I pity the actual researchers in these fields. Must be tough to work in an area that everyone has an opinion on.
- thorncorona 4y agoIt’s easy to be passionate about education when it changes lives
- dpbriggs 4y agoWhy exactly is that a bad thing? It's repetitive but most people here are - former children - attended public education - hated or loved aspects of that education Of course they're going to discuss ideas.
- ohCh6zos 4y agoI don’t know but I suspect given the comments that a disproportionate number of HN posters may have been in gifted programs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- twirlock 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoThe elephant in the room: In the US, average East Asian IQ is 105, average white IQ is 99, average black IQ is 85-95. Nobody in politics can afford to admit that.
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoThe highest IQ in US history belonged to a man that spent his life as a plumber by choice. According to several studies, the greatest predictor of early academic advancement is the financial status of the parents. While scientific hubris and narcissism tend to quickly dominate competitive environments in colleges, the irrational pretense of a meritocracy quickly degenerates when you enter the faculty area. Note that most academically successful students will do well regardless of the curriculum or instructor, and the funding they bring in later makes anyone popular with staff. Perhaps you are asserting that “intellectual gifts” are justification for inflicting misery or undue burden on the general community? I speculate one could likely outrun a one-legged physicist or a one-legged golden retriever just as quickly… but not escape their own cognitive biases.
- slothtrop 4y ago> inflicting misery Is that what you suppose gifted programs do?
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoFrom one perspective, isolation or artificial peer group selection can lead to aberrant moral, social, and cognitive development. There is more to life than worksheets and exams.
- slothtrop 4y agoThere's no evidence that gifted programs are associated with those phenomenons. There is evidence that it helps students excel.
- 4y ago
- jeandejean 4y agoVery often equity at all cost means leveling down everybody. It also feels a bit contradictory to privilege already gifted students with a programme though.
- iisan7 4y agoI don't think it should be privilege to receive an education that challenges you. Punishing the kids for the sins of being born to "privilege" doesn't seem fair. And if kids of privilege are the only ones in the gifted program, you're not doing it right, which is the point of TFA.
- danans 4y agoModerators, please include a (2021) in the article title.
- guelo 4y agoI have read so many of these types of arguments but why is it so hard to find the pro argument? Where are the proponent's rebuttals and counterarguments?
- cato_the_elder 4y agoIt is equity, it's just that equity is an incredibly ludicrous and impractical idea.
- havblue 4y agoA lot of my friends in the city I went to college in would have been on the "equity" side of this debate as well, until they had kids themselves. It dawned on them that their kids in public schools may not be able to get algebra in eighth grade anymore. And good luck with long division. So after they realized their kids will get a worse math education than they had, they changed their tune.
- whatevenisthat 4y agoMost progressives end up changing their tune on all their major ideas when they collide with reality. For example, San Francisco last night booted the progressive soft-on-crime DA because of the increasing crime rate. Seattle recently saw increases in crime and had to walk back their tune on getting rid of law enforcement. Progressive ideas simply do not work in reality. Be it on law enforcement, dissolution of borders, dissolution of merit-based systems, equity as pertains to gifted programs...I've not seen a single progressive idea produce any good results when implemented. I'm hoping the SF DA recall election is a sign that we're going to see the pendulum swing in the other direction as more people realize that the progressive platform is toxic trash.
- jugg1es 4y agoWe should not be punishing smart kids even if some of those smarts may be due to income inequality that may have some basis in racial inequality. It's not the kid's fault that their grandparents generation thought that lower taxes were better than good governance.
- nlittlepoole 4y agoProbably late posting here but going to post here to maybe offer some understanding to why it is people support policies like this. For the record, I'm not personally for it but there is a method to the madness. I'm black, take that for what it is. "unacceptably white" is probably the most triggering thing in here but it actually represents the core of this conflict. The people trying to eliminate gifted programs are recognizing that many forms of power in society are zero sum. There are plenty of ways to get a great education but there is only one Harvard. Access to higher education opportunities is not only a pathway out of poverty but also to power within the institutions that hire grads. The supporters of this form of affirmative action recognize that in a system where black/latino/indigenous students have structural disadvantages (poverty, prejudice, health, etc) but also operates as a pure meritocracy leads to a system where their racial group possesses disproportionately less power vs their population. Less kids in these groups in gifted programs means less of these kids going to top universities and on to top positions in government and business. Many of you may see this as tribal or even perpetuating divides on race. But I'd respond that you fundamentally are underestimating how much marginalized communities distrust communities outside of their own. I'll use the black community because I'm a member of it. There is very little trust (myself included) that the white individuals who attend these programs and (hopefully) go on to succeed in higher education will use their influence for the benefit of blacks. I don't believe that because I think white people are racist, just self interested (like most people). That thinking extends to other groups like east and south Asians. Personally my views on this are not to eliminate gifted programs, I benefited from one myself and know how important they are. Ideally we'd do what many others here suggested and just build more programs. If there is this much of a fight about it obviously there is a lot of demand for schools where Algebra I is taught in the 8th grade. So let's make more of those. That won't solve the issue at the college level though. There is a reason there are not 50 Harvards and its because the access/power/influence that degree offers is zero sum. Until we figure out a way to ration out that power in a way that people think is fair we're going to see constant contention over it.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoIt really pains me to say this but I find it impossible to see how this is anything other than an attempt to address inequality by eliminating any and all objective measures and drivers of success, talent, and/or performance. The promise for a long time was that we weren’t going to try to achieve equality by dragging down the high achievers but that appears to be exactly - exactly - the goal here.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- EddieDante 4y agoI'm OK with eliminating "gifted programs". I'm not convinced that "gifted" kids need them. I think that what they need is a library card and free rein to follow their curiosity wherever it leads them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- erikerikson 4y agoThe problem is not privilege but its expansion. Continuously and responsibly raising the bar and the expansion of the tent should be the goal and will lead to contribute to the contributed expansion of prosperity.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beebee94kai 4y agoI was a black child in the gifted program as a kid. At that age, there were other black kids too, it just depended on which school you came from. And I wasn't privileged, my classmates had way more money at the time and I could tell back then. But they were still my friends and treated me no different. I think its the parents that put the emphasis on it and use it as a status symbol for their kids. As a child, I had fun. But however, I do remember this one white girl, she was so stuck up and thought she was better than everyone else. I was in the 2nd grade and even then I could tell that. But I don't think it was because of the gifted program, she was just stuck up. But her mom was also a teacher, and her mom was super nice.
- zjaffee 4y agoGifted programs, depending on where in the country they are located, are deeply related to equity. Things have gotten better over the past decade even without their total elimination, but for the majority of people who are of age to be posting here, if they were in a gifted program, it likely is because they had parents who helped them study for the tests to get in by spending money. Once in said program, fundraising through the PTA is easier done because the average student is better off financially than at the nearby public school. When I was growing up in NYC I was in a gifted program, and the average family was donating several thousand dollars a year per child. There were benefits such that if one child was in the program, other siblings automatically got in. This allowed us to have privately funded music program alongside privately funded teaching assistants in every classroom.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago> "but for the majority of people who are of age to be posting here, if they were in a gifted program, it likely is because they had parents who helped them study for the tests to get in by spending money." Source? It's certainly not the case for me individually, having been an immigrant child who got through on my own since my parents didn't know enough English to help me on homework and we were too poor to afford tutoring.
- skyde 4y agoWow as a white men that is completely against affirmative action I still 100% agree with everything in this article. Basically if only 2% of student taking algebra 1 are black then the solution is : 1- not to Remove algebra 1 completely. 2- not to force a % of the algebra 1 student to be black by accepting student that are not ready for this level of Math 3- not too invent a new (non-racist) version of algebra 1 that is easier to understand . The solution is simply to embrace asynchronous development! If one student test score below average in English and Geography but above average in math. He should still be allowed to take Algebra 1. Also algebra 1 should be offered as an option in all neighborhood (including poor one) even if only a single student in that neighborhood would like to take it. I see being allowed to take the class if you qualify as a Right similar to the right to Vote. So the parent should not be forced to drive the student to another school because the local school prefer to not offer the class.
- IAmWorried 4y agoIt's hard for me to tell how many of these "progressive" programs are motivated out of a sincere desire to make the world a better place, and how many are simply motivated by hate and spite, a "if I can't have it nobody can" kind of attitude. Certainly eliminating advanced classes seems to fall into the latter case.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- hardwaregeek 4y agoThe bigger issue I see is the arbitrary separation of students into grades. Just because everybody is the same age does not mean they're at the same level in a subject. You should be able to take 8th grade math as a 7th grader. In fact it shouldn't be 8th grade math, it should just be Pre-Algebra. Montessori schools put three grades in one class which solves the problem somewhat, although talented students in the top grade quickly get bored. This stratified structure also impacts how students view social interaction. Each grade is separate and therefore a different social entity. Sure, there are interactions across grades but it's still quite funny to see a sophomore make fun of a freshman when they're 15 and 14 years old respectively. To this day I know people who find it weird that I'm friends with someone who's 18 when I'm 23. I don't see why. We have the same interests and similar personalities. A few years difference doesn't matter.
- DAlperin 4y agoAlright, I don't imagine this will be a common take here but here goes. I am a product of the New York City public school system. I have spent the majority of my life as a student in it. The New York city public school system is both the largest public school system in the country and the most segregated. The argument about removing gifted programs are built on the faulty assumptions that the students in those programs are "more gifted" than everyone else and that the work is truly more advanced. Neither of those are the case. Gifted programs are used to advance and maintain the status-quo of segregation in our schools. The correlation between medium household (of which Black americans are at a disadvantage) and acceptance into the gifted program is much stronger than the correlation between merit and acceptance. I've spent my life in this system and I can tell you with one hundred percent confidence that the reason many if not most of my black peers don't get into these programs is not due to any lack of merit or intelligence. Now lets look at the second assumption, that the gifted programs provide a higher level of education. This is not true. What happens is that gifted programs get significantly higher funding than other schools and so the gifted programs can afford to give a good well rounded education, which is a good thing! The problem is that so many of our schools, especially in Brown and Black neighborhoods) are completely underfunded, without enough teachers or resources. This of course perpetuates the systemic inequities that begun this cycle in the first place thus repeating the whole cycle. When we are calling for an end to "gifted" programs in New York, it is not because we "hate smart kids" but because we want resources to be evenly divided so that everyone can get a well funded well rounded education, not just the rich kids in gifted classes. This is not a single issue but is a larger component of an attempt to dismantle segregation in public schools. It drives me crazy to no end to see smart people fall into the ideological trap of believing gifted programs are something they aren't.
- slothtrop 4y agoIn other words you're arguing it's zero-sum, as though gifted programs take up a sizable chunk of funding rather than, you know, the schools.
- DAlperin 4y ago> as though gifted programs take up a sizable chunk of funding rather than, you know, the schools. I am saying that. "Gifted" programs and the schools that house them eat up a sizable chunk of funding.
- lesgobrandon 4y ago[dead]
- __abc 4y agoI moved my family as the town I lived in did exactly this. They also removed support programs for those falling behind vs racing ahead. All under the equity banner. The New town we moved to is great. Oldest kid in accelerated programs, accelerating. Younger kid got the support she needed to catch up. :chefs_kiss: Taking a step back, I don’t know how ‘equity’ got twisted into creating a lowering tide for all vs. a rising tide for all. So confusing.
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- nikolay 4y agoWhen people talk about Communism, they imagine everybody being equally rich. Well, the reality showed us that Communism can only make people equally poor and miserable. Similarly, liberalism tries to make everybody equally stupid, not equally smart! But, as we know, the road to hell is paved with good intentions! As a father of a decently-gifted son who gets bored to death at school and who's bombarded with brainless homework to stay "out of trouble" when not in school, I can tell the California education is the worst I can imagine in a civilized country!
- MarkMarine 4y agoAs a "gifted" student in a tiny town, I had my 3rd and 4th grade math "class" in the hallway, where the teachers drug my desk and slapped down a geometry textbook and told me to teach myself. In other classes they tried to get me to help teach my classmates the concepts, which is not a great place for a 4th grader to be in. By high school I'd learned to read the textbook, ace the tests and do fuck-all for homework to the frustration of every educator at the school trying to teach me hard work alongside the actual material. There were actually AP classes in high school that I never qualified for because I never learned to actually work at school, and by high school I didn't really care. I was completely unprepared when Junior year in college, it actually got so hard that I had to study. I almost flunked out. I can empathize with the gifted kids that are just a different shade, not getting challenged, basically getting the small town experience I got. It is a ton of potential being wasted. I agree with the article, throwing away gifted programs and just lowering the bar is a mistake, but raising everyones bar to the gifted level... that's going to leave some of the most vulnerable behind which I don't think should be done either. Maybe working to shore up the problem of black/brown kids having equal test scores and not getting into a gifted program is the first hurdle, and then we can look around and see what to do next.
- luxuryballs 4y agoEvery time I read this stuff I don’t get it, it always feels like some form of missing the forest for the trees when you try and make determinations based off of percentages/ratios of groups rather than keeping it about the individual. Uplift the individual first, trying to tweak things just to pump your numbers up seems like missing the point. I would rather treat education on a more personal outcome level than to treat it like a retail shop where I’m just trying to boost sales to meet some number/category goals. (I think something similar can be said about this concept when it comes to politicians on TV recommending medical treatments or vaccines “for everyone” which I think is worth mentioning to help frame what I am getting at here but that’s another story.)
- roody15 4y agoSomehow in last few years equity has been promoted and even equated with equality. They are different concepts. Equal Opportunity is a universal goal that as a society we continue to strive towards even though is impossible to fully achieve. Equalized Outcomes (Equity) Is a dystopian nightmare. The idea that all possible differentials between humans can and should have the same outcomes is ludicrous. I work in education and will give you an example of this nonsense. In a well to do district in Chicago they found that Black students do not do as well in AP Calculus. After years of intervention the district achieved growth and had a record number of black student now enrolled in AP Calculus. However after five years and despite the increase of black students it was still found that white and asian students got higher scores on the AP exam. The district solution was to cancel AP Calculus and now it is only offered as a third party online course not taught by the school district. Why was the goal for all groups to have the same test scores? Just absolute rubbish.
- aidenn0 4y agoThe courts will let you eliminated gifted programs, but in many cases they won't let you enforce affirmative action on enrollments into them.
- dontbenebby 4y agoI wrote an essay about special education a while back: https://boingboing.net/2013/01/05/pedagogyofthedepressed.html https://boingboing.net/2013/01/05/pedagogyofthedepressed.htm... Boing Boing never ended up importing the comments from back then, and when I reached out to a contact about writing a follow up, the entire site was DDOSed. Too many teachers purposefully abuse the gifted, then react irrationally to perfectly reasonable responses. (I wasn't paid, and they put it out without my opt in, though to be fair, the editor did quite a bit of editing and free graphics work when they could have thrown the text up as is - a few of the wording changes were probably a good thing, looking back with the wisdom of a 30 something.) On the other hand, never once have the folks who abused me ever apologized, and they continue to gaslight me and obstruct me to the point I'm considering moving to Italy. I'm really sick of rude people, and I know it's hypocritical given some of the comments I make on the internet, but from early on in life I've had perpetual issues with folks who have a very high standard for my behavior, but not their own. I have literal scars from some of what they did, but I also have enemies in the education and medical community who continue to engage in illegal, retaliatory behavior for my first amendment protected free speech. I cannot emphasize enough how badly it backfired that neoliberals engineered society around the idea that you can't interact with people without permission, then melted down when my response, due to COVID, was basically "Fine, you're right, I have anger issues. I'm also not your caregiver, so keep back six feet."
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoIf I’m leading a system in which the population of eighth graders taking Algebra I has a disproportionate number of white and Asian students, then eliminating Algebra I as an offering for eighth graders looks like an obvious pathway to equity. Well, yes, if by equity you mean the race composition of every class equals the race composition of the school as a whole. But shouldn't equity in education mean that every student gets the instruction and support they need to achieve their potential, insofar as the school is able to provide it, without respect to their race, class or sex? There were no gifted programs or classes when and where I attended school (6 decades back, in a very rural part of the Great Plains). But there was a teacher in my school who took it upon herself to run a reading lab that you could get into with the blessing of the school principal. Mostly she taught remedial reading to those who needed extra help, but one of her 5 periods each day was called "advanced reading lab" and into that group she took students who showed exceptional or nascent exceptional intellectual capability. In the guise of teaching us to read better and faster, she exercised our brains with science, history, and even math. She's the only teacher I remember by name, and she did more to launch my success in life than any 5 other teachers combined, behind only my parents. Because she made going to school worthwhile - interesting, exciting, and mind-expanding. (She also taught me to read 2000 words per minute with retention, which was a hell of a useful skill, but only a skill - the world of knowledge and thinking was her real gift).
- AmericanChopper 4y ago> But shouldn't equity in education mean that every student gets the instruction and support they need to achieve their potential, insofar as the school is able to provide it, without respect to their race, class or sex? You’re taking about equality. Equity is always just a euphemism for equality of outcome. Which can only ever be achieved by lowering the outcomes of top performs to the same level as the lowest performers.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoI know. But I refuse give up the meaning of the word "equity" - which is not equality of outcomes, but rather fair, impartial. In the case of schools, that means fairly and impartially meeting the needs of every student. You can call med old fashioned, if you wish (I'm certainly old).
- SpaceManNabs 4y agoI went to a charter school because my designated high school was very prone to violence. I am an afro latino immigrant raised by a single mom. I truly understand that these public schools are losing their best performing kids to these charter schools which leads to worse aggregate outcomes. However, I am certain that I would not have been able to get into my ivy league alma mater without the support and isolation from chaos that my charter school provided. Why should I have a worse outcome just to raise the mean scores in a place where everyone else isn't capable (due to harsh environment) or willing to learn? In addition, I think it hurts arguments for affirmative action. When people think of affirmative action / need-based approaches, they think of these other kids and not me. (You wouldn't be able to tell that I benefitted from those programs if you met me given my high school achievements from over a decade ago).
- nofinator 4y agoThis 2021 article strikes me as mostly a straw man and a veiled sales pitch. It's rare that a Gifted Program simply gets eliminated due to inequity with no replacement. The school district almost always proposes an alternate program to replace it. (The author is the CEO and Founder of one, though he does acknowledge this near the end.) The author also links to two examples of districts with reduced or eliminated Gifted Programs. But one article says the Anchorage program was cut because of a budget shortfall, and the other (Boston) said they suspended their advanced learning program only at the city-wide level mainly because COVID made it hard to administer!
- sharmin123 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoI think minimal standards are a pretty good idea, for both mental and physical education. The attitude that all children should be able to reach these standards, and if they don't that's the fault of the educational system, also makes a lot of sense. What those standards should be is a matter for debate, but if we look around the world (China ahem) we might get some ideas about what the competitive level is currently. To enforce this, you need to do two things: fire underperforming teachers, and their administrative overseers if the problem is pervasive, and pay teachers competitive salaries to attract the best talent to the job. Teaching is a skill, and highly skilled people should be well-compensated for their work. This is just labor market 101. If you don't value education, you pay low salaries to educators and you scrape the bottom of the talent barrel. If you do value education, then you make the job competitive by offering high salaries and eliminating underperformers. Of course, maybe the politicians and bureaucrats and corporate executives don't actually want a highly educated competent population? Perhaps they'd prefer dumb sheep who believe whatever propaganda they're fed and whose consumption habits can be easily directed by skilled advertisers and marketers. Herds of compliant consumers who do as they're told, that's perhaps what elite leadership is after. Might be a conspiracy theory but there's some truth to it I think. What it really looks like is one set of schools for the aristocrats, and another set of schools for the serfs, and it's more about maintaining a certain class structure, just as in late 19th / early 20th century British schooling systems.
- bfaviero 4y agoI grew up as a dirt poor immigrant. The only reason I got into MIT, and am successful today, was because of the gifted programs that allowed me to stand out from the other mediocre students at the schools. Were most of my gifted classmates wealthy? Yes. But being among them did more for my social mobility than anything else the school ever did.
- SpaceManNabs 4y agoI posted my similar story in a separate comment. It is truly a shame that we walk two worlds that people refuse to understand.
- PebblesRox 4y ago'If equity is the concern, we should also name the inequitable reality that parents with means will always find a way to ensure their children receive whatever out-of-school enrichment resources their children need. My greatest concern? The admirable but demonstrably false notion that school systems can fully implement an “all kids are gifted” framework that attempts to address the issue of eliminating the need for specialized gifted programming.' This sums up my concerns with detracking.
- nscalf 4y agoIt's probably time to stop letting people in our society that are not building up systems terrorize the rest of us with scarcely hidden threats of slandering your name as a racist. There is nothing racist about having a merit based system within education. If the problem is that it is not entirely merit based, the solution comes from improving the on ramp, not from destroying the program. We should treat people who want to tear down systems like this as radicals trying to cause harm, not well-meaning individuals trying to build equality. We have been increasing equality for decades by building up systems, and to act like everything in existence now is racist and invalid is absurd. My experience with public school gifted programs was simple. The gifted program was not significantly better in what they taught, or how they taught it. The gifted programs only major advantage was that the people who were there wanted to be there, and worked to do well. This allowed us to move faster, and go deeper into topics. In non-gifted classes, students could not care less about what the class was doing that day and hated that they were trapped there. Some students definitely worked hard in non-gifted classes, but in my experience, that was the exception.
- scarmig 4y agoThere are plenty of students (more than some) in non-gifted classes who genuinely want to learn and work hard. But there are two issues that make those classes terrible: 1) Teachers dedicate 80% of their instructional time to the 20% worst performers, and every incentive pushes them in that direction. 2) More than that, it only takes one or two kids with behavioral issues to reduce teachers' instructional time from near 100% to near 0%, and there's no way to move them out of regular classrooms to classrooms focused on their needs. So if you're a regular student in a cohort with a couple students with behavioral issues, you're pretty much screwed.
- sokoloff 4y agoI'm pretty nearly convinced that the primary signals derived from many private school interviews are "parents will pay the tuition" and "kid will not be a behavioral problem".
- 4y ago
- matt321 4y agoIf certain groups of students are excluded because of their ethnicity, that is wrong and should be condemned. If certain groups are excluded because they did not have a lifestyle that nurtured their talent and therefore do not meet the requirements to join, their lifestyle needs to be structed differently so that then next time around they do meet the requirements. In the meantime, holding Asian students back is not going to solve the problem of other student having parents who don't recognize the importance of their education.
- chicob 4y ago[...] school systems are making the decision to contract or eliminate their gifted education and advanced academic offerings. On the surface, this seems logical. If I’m leading a system in which the population of eighth graders taking Algebra I has a disproportionate number of white and Asian students, then eliminating Algebra I as an offering for eighth graders looks like an obvious pathway to equity. This doesn't seem logical at all. It sounds like sweeping under the rug. I'm assuming that what is obvious here is that these programs reproduce inequity, and are not a cause of it. [...] As these scholars argue shutting down gifted programs only deepens the inequities for brilliant, underrepresented students of color and adds another barrier to unlocking their genius. Does one really need scholars for this?
- derevaunseraun 4y agoWhy is this site becoming more and more infested with politics? It's going to end up suffocating anything actually worthwhile
- MrZongle2 4y agoIt's always worse in (US) election years, and I think it's inevitable for all online discussion sites. When people conflate their identity with their political beliefs, everything becomes political. That said, HN has historically done a very good job in policing this through the vigilance of its admin team. I wouldn't be surprised if this discussion pales in comparison to the stuff they've axed.
- moth-fuzz 4y agoI'm not sure at the end of the day there's such a thing as 'intelligence', in terms of how we talk about it, like some sort of RPG stat. In my experience, kids aren't really 'smarter' than other kids, they have learning styles and brain patterns that match up with how the courses are run. Anecdotes, I know, but I was terrible at math compared to the kids in high school who could all just memorize and regurgitate (I have ADHD & very poor working memory, and no random-access). These kids also regularly looked up answers to future quizzes they found online and bsed their way through. But, in college, which involves a more abstract and rigorous (and dare I say meaningful) understanding of the material, I excelled while many of my former colleagues fell behind as these were 'new problems' they couldn't just look up because they didn't have answers. My point is intelligence is not a scalar axis in which some people are 'gifted' and some people are not, it's a multidimensional series of mental configurations that must be adapted to in the classroom and outside. Hire better teachers and pay them more is the only concrete thing I can think of. Gifted programs aren't the way as they're entirely arbitrary to a specific environment. The wrong teacher for the right student will ultimately make the student worse for it, and these programs don't account for how truly uninspired some teachers can be. Not to mention parents, or availability of learning materials, quality of libraries, etc etc.
- ryan93 4y agoThere were lots of people at your college that excelled. They were in all likelihood kids who excelled in high school.
- atx42 4y agoMy quick take on "gifted" programs. * These are really supposed to be for kids that learn differently, not necessarily "smarter". * The percentage of kids in these programs is higher than should be expected. * The number of kids that happen to have teacher parents or some possible inside track seems high. I think people hear "gifted" and think they are being left out, but that's not supposed to be the case. Sort of the difference between classroom and home school, sometimes one works better for a kid than the other, not that one is necessarily better than the other.
- tssva 4y agoIt has been decades since I was in school. I was in the gifted program and found it to be an utter waste of time. My daughter is now in a gifted program and we both find it to be an utter waste of time. I attended a school in a middle class area and my daughter attends a school in a fairly wealthy area. Is there any studies which show a benefit to gifted programs in schools which are adequately funded?
- omgJustTest 4y agoI went 3 different high schools in several states as a child. Some schools had lots of money (ie gifted programs) and others were quite literally at risk of losing state funding due to low standardized test scores. I was the first person in my family tree to graduate college and only person to ever have a PhD. The teachers at the well-funded, near-apex "Magnet" school in North Carolina were generally better and had more time with students... especially in Science/Math. Teachers had more adult expectations of kids, but most importantly they were _consistent_ with their expectations and cadence of material presented. Teachers at the under-funded, near-loss of state funding school in Tennessee were kind, "normal" people who happened to go to college at some point in the past. Primary detractors from the classroom were that student's low-expectations often led to large portions of uncontrolled "worksheet" tasks. Work was not graded well, inspected well or feedback given in a timely manner. I personally graded all the science teacher's Junior level homework as a Senior. She often didn't appear to understand the subject and was doing her best to not let the bottom students fall through the cracks. Elimination of gifted programs, in my opinion, is the best option. The best students will learn what they need to, their parents will make sure of it, and the best teachers need to work with the worst students at this age group.
- postfck 4y ago
- alas_141 4y agoNo child should be actively excluded based on a metric like race or gender, just like no student should be deliberately included because of race, gender, class, or any other metric that a parent could use to coerce a school to place their child in a gifted/magnet class. That should be common sense. Kids should be placed in the gifted/magnet track because of performance, and performance alone. I don't believe that a meritocracy is racist, sexist, or biased in an unfair way. Placing students in classes where they may under perform, and excluding kids who would perform well in an accelerated program are unfair, and a meritocracy mitigates both of these problems. The article raised a good point about schools that marginalized groups would attend don't have a gifted program, precluding them from even participating. That can be addressed a couple different ways. Either redirect high performers to a school where there is a gifted program present, or mandate the presence of a gifted program in all schools. There will, of course, be differing quality of the program from school to school, which would favor the former course of action. Having gone through the "gifted program" through elementary and middle school, I can say that the only real differences I felt weren't related to curriculum, we were taught essentially the same things, with slight differences. 1. Smaller class size. In a class of 4th, 5th, and 6th graders, there was maybe 25 kids. 2. Less rowdy/troublemaking classmates. Made for less distractions. 3. Less busywork. The routine of getting a packet every night for homework was not something I had to suffer through like many friends I had that weren't in an accelerated program. I don't believe you will ever truly eradicate inequities within public services, and the cost of private services, especially in education, preclude many from participating. That said, we should strive to mitigate them. My fear is that the steps taken to mitigate inequity will just move the availability of opportunity from one group to another, where the true solution is increasing the availability for all groups, and let performance be the selector of who is admitted to gifted/accelerated programs.
- _-david-_ 4y ago>redirect high performers to a school where there is a gifted program present I am a bit hesitant of this. One valuable thing you get by having geographical schools is the same friends in and out of school. If you have friends at school but they are too far to hang out with or do homework with it can be bad for the kid learning social skills. Mandating gifted classes as you mentioned seems better.
- sbarbarian 4y agoAnother major issue in this discussion is the definition of 'teacher'. As referenced throughout these comments, a 'teaching' job varies dramatically on the district, age, etc. Students from a difficult home life need a social worker than an algebra teacher, yet the state mandates the class no matter how poor the delivery, content, outcome, etc. Meanwhile, teachers get stuck with responsibilities not in their job description...no wonder so many quit. Its antithetical to the American dream (i.e. an equal starting point for everyone) but we must provide different paths better suited to acknowledging reality and providing reasonable outcomes. Staff them with job descriptions fitting the actual need, and work from there.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agowhen I saw equitablemath.org a few months ago, I couldn't believe it wasn't satire
- bsimpson 4y ago> Since when does equity mean everyone gets nothing This is why equity programs are controversial. When skeptical people hear "equity," they think of the allegory about crabs in a bucket. Too often, instead of helping more crabs escape the bucket, our society creates policies that make it harder for any of them to escape the bucket, or pick and choose which crabs get to escape the bucket.
- at_a_remove 4y agoI was told that Vonnegut wrote "Harrison Bergeron" as a satire of the fears that the right had of equality, not as a satire of the left's possible execution of it. And yet here we are, firmly in "1984 was not supposed to be a how-to manual, people!" territory. Of course, the shell game has continued. Recall how often you used to hear about equality and not equity, and yet somehow those goalposts have shifted in the last five years. Equity has somehow come to mean that you'll get "your share" of the pie even if you haven't contributed, or despite being completely untalented. We should sort (not segregate, never that) students by race (self-reported, of course), and then grade such that only a certain percentage in each bucket get As, a few more get Bs, and so on. This ensures a perfect equity balance. If we do this for each grade and each subject within a grade, well, we ought to have very equitable outcomes. Diana Moon Glampers will shotgun down the grades of the Asian "Schroedinger's Minority" group to be in line with everyone else's. Can't imagine that this won't work out.
- lettergram 4y ago[flagged]
- micromacrofoot 4y agoMy issue with gifted programs, and this is the reality in many cities: wealthy kids with tutors and intelligent parents are the ones benefiting. This essentially creates a two-tiered schooling system, and since it's very tightly tied to income, this further exaggerates economic disparity, which is closely tied to race. My city's school system is comprised mostly of minorities (~80% black, hispanic, and asian) and the gifted programs are predominantly serving wealthy white kids (~50%). We also have exam schools. The most popular exam school in my area receives tens of millions of dollars in private donations. If you combined the private fundraising of the bottom 90% of schools in the district, it's still less than this one school. This school is also 50% white in a school system where only 15% of the kids are white. So we've essentially created a private school in a public system. I understand why people don't want to eliminate gifted programs, but they are further exaggerating economic (and racial) disparities. I have not seen any good solutions for this, but it does feel incredibly unfair. Having been someone who was poor and happened to be in a gifted program, I personally don't think the benefit is worth the divide.
- kova12 4y ago> The case for expanding opportunities for brilliant Black and brown children Just black and brown, the rest of children are on their own, right?
- ken47 4y agoEquality of opportunity is impossible. Equality of outcome is an order of magnitude more impossible. Each of us was born into this world through a randomized process that was not created by humankind: the genes you were born with, the environment you were given before you could manage your own affairs, the accumulation of genetic mutations over the course of countless millennia that resulted in who you are today. This is the opportunity you were born with. To think that we can compensate for this random process with any level of precision is to wage war with nature, and I'd bet that nature will win. It is an admirable goal, and certainly we can take steps to reduce inequality of opportunity. But true equality of opportunity, or anything close to it, is unattainable in this universe.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoIronically, equality of outcome is actually easier to realize, because you can just drag everyone down to the same crappy level by state mandate and call it "equity". True equality of opportunity would require the admission that certain cultures glorify things which are not conducive to academic success. We accept that black culture values athletics (and that this creates outsized athletic success for black people), why can we not accept that that same culture would deprioritize academics over athletics?
- ken47 4y agoWhat you describe is not equality of outcome. If you impose some kind of lifestyle on different people, each of them will have different subjective experiences. Some will be completely content in state A whereas others will be extremely displeased. Are the outcomes equal? No. Simply the conditions.
- deanCommie 4y ago> Equality of opportunity is impossible. Your next paragraph focuses on inevitable natural inequalities. Fine. Not everyone is Einstein, Picasso, or Jordan. But what about SOCIETY is natural? Is society itself fair? Or does it include inevitable unfairnesses created to perpetuate "natural inequalities"?
- shp0ngle 4y agoWill we get 2000 comments on this bad boy?
- seydor 4y agothe phrase 'luxury beliefs' is over- and wrongly- used , but it is useful in the sense that luxuries are one of the first things to dispense during crises.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI hate this woke nonsense about equity in students. Man I probably would have been so bored in school and settled for the status quo if I had to be in classes where the lowest common denominator was the average American student. Luckily all we had to do was pass an assessment to get into gifted classes. They really should change the name though, but keep the classes. We are equal in our human rights, not in our capacity to learn certain things. That said, obviously students in less academically strenuous classes shouldn't be swept under the rug and they should get as tailored an education as possible. Trying to squash all kids into the same politically correct group won't work and hurts everyone.
- javajosh 4y agoWe should spend more on gifted programs, not less. These are the kids with the most potential push society forward, and they should get every opportunity to flourish to the greatest extent possible, even if they have the great misfortune of being born white.
- dadjoker 4y ago“Since when does equity mean everyone gets nothing?” Unfortunately, in Oregon, Kate Brown and her acolytes think that it is "equitable" to get rid of all basic learning requirements for high school graduation, because they are "white supremacy" or something. The soft bigotry of low expectations. https://www.wsj.com/articles/dumbing-oregon-down-kate-brown-proficiency-requirement-high-school-graduation-11628796270 https://www.wsj.com/articles/dumbing-oregon-down-kate-brown-...
- whatevenisthat 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y ago> My behavior challenges came from a lack of being challenged. I've heard this a lot - it's always someone else's fault. In my experience in school, the disruptive students were not the gifted ones. They were the ones who never experienced negative consequences for their disruptive behavior. Neither the teachers, administration, nor parents ever disciplined them. The unchallenged gifted students would read a book during class, or draw art in their notebooks, etc.
- ODILON_SATER 4y agoGifted programs as we know, are basically advanced programs for shape-rotators, which closely relates to IQ. The IQ distribution is different across race groups, therefore you expect to have more representation of certain groups relative to others. It's obvious that Asians --I am not Asian-- perform extremely well in IQ tests compared to other groups. Same with Ashkenazi Jews. These groups would have, relatively speaking, a higher representation. It would also be more male than your typical classroom. Just like we have "physically gifted programs" in sports, and in some Blacks are overly represented. People don't seem to bat an eye for such "inequity", because it is understood that, on average, Blacks have superior athletic ability in some sports. People really have a hard time understanding basic statistical facts, and they take these things personally. When we compare average heights across countries, nobody gets offended because everybody is aware of their own height. A 6'4 American is just as tall as a 6'4 Indonesian, so people don't take personally. Somehow average IQ is this thing that people take personally as if it was an indictment on their intelligence. Besides, there is much more than IQ. Plenty of people with average IQs are successful. Sure, the premium on IQ increased in our society, but there is so much variance in activities and other inherent or acquired characteristics, it is really not that big of a deal. With that being said, it is important for a nation to identify exceptional talents --including intelligence-- and nurture these individuals so they maximize their potential. It's good for them, it's good for society as well. Recognizing that people should have different educational experiences is the right thing to do.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt is worth noting that IQ is heavily impacted by environment and nurture, especially so at the ends of the spectrum. When different groups have different home and social environments, it is expected that there will be IQ differences. It is strange that people can be vocal about the harsh conditions difference groups are subjected to, but in denial about the damage done by those conditions.
- rflrob 4y agoAs a student who went through gifted programs in public elementary and in private middle and high school, but otherwise not plugged into the literature on it, what does the evidence look like that gifted/magnet programs actually provide significant tangible benefit to the students? One way to break it down would be to look at the relative number of students in these categories: 1. Students identified as gifted who do well because of their gifted program/who would have done well if they were in a gifted program. 2. Students identified as gifted who would do well regardless of whether they had a gifted program, even if they might do marginally better in a gifted program. 3. Students not identified as gifted who would benefit from additional resources/gifted peers in their non-gifted program 4. Students not identified as gifted who would not particularly benefit from gifted peers/already have adequately resourced classrooms. I would have a hard time believing that the number of students in any of those categories is negligibly small. So then the question becomes how do we, as a society, best balance the tradeoffs between them. For any given student, we don't generally have the ability to try it both ways and see what would have been better, and of course any given parent will tend to prefer to take any tiny marginal improvement in opportunity for their children, regardless of whether it's net beneficial for society. But some of the role of society is to not allow people to take actions with mismatched externalities. If there are more #3 students than #1 students (and/or the benefits to society are larger), and if we cannot distinguish between #2 students and #1 students, then yeah, let's get rid of gifted programs. For myself, I think I was probably a #2—I had affluent, educated parents, benefited from significant extra-curricular enrichment, and could probably have had more enrichment with several tens of thousands of extra dollars per year of saved tuition. At what point could my parents have known that I was a #2?
- bluehackangels 4y ago
- kurupt213 4y agoEliminating gifted programs is insane. It makes way more sense to concentrate education resources on the children who will benefit the most. Maybe more effort needs to go towards identifying these children earlier. A bright child is obvious, regardless of race.
- yarg 4y agoThe fact that this case even needs to be made is insane. There's a degree of nobility in the ideal of "no child left behind" - but childhood potential is not democratically distributed. The smartest kids in schools should not be left to flounder on account of those who can't keep up.
- rubyfan 4y agomy hunch is that the hacker news crowd is not representative of the rest of the US on this particular topic
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gerash 4y agoThe crux seems to be who belongs in this "genius" club or should we eliminate the "genius" club altogether because it creates animosity. A very similar debate can be in sports. Should we have a single league or a tiered league? I've seen siblings with very different performance and outcome from the young age. Obviously they are both genetically close and were raised by the same parents. There are certainly differences in people but the reason might not always be some "genius" gene. It could be very circumstantial. For example they were grouped with people who happened to do poorly in whatever was being measured so they were always the top of their group (academically or athletically) in their formative years. That provided them with a lot of self confidence throughout childhood which led them to believe they can achieve anything and always spent countless hours making sure that's true unlike their sibling who never developed the self esteem and settled for less all their lives. Maybe they didn't get too stressed when faced with challenges due to genetic or childhood differences. So IMO there should be separate leagues (just like sports teams) but also some mobility across these clubs in case someone possesses the skills and has the motivation to compete at the higher level.
- Blackstrat 4y agoHarrison Bergerson. That gifted students are disproportionately white or Asian reflects the value placed on education not racism. Outcomes will never be equal in a fair society. Provide equal opportunity. Those that take advantage will thrive. Those that don't, will not.
- main3523 4y ago