28 ms·
Hiring discrimination: a problem for men in female-dominated occupations
- slackfan 5y ago
- throwadogabone2 5y agoAnecdotally I have seen this in person at a large tech startup. The recruiting team was all women, mainly white, and they were incredibly cliquey. Every hire was a woman. Men were turned down with vague excuses like “not a culture fit.” All while aggressively pushing DEI initiatives and interventions on the tech side. I don’t think the irony of this ever crossed their minds.
- cperciva 5y agoMen were turned down with vague excuses like “not a culture fit.” That excuse might have been entirely accurate though. Most men are indeed not willing to participate in such a blatantly sexist culture.
- lostcolony 5y agoSure there are. Just not a blatantly sexist culture -they don't fit into-. There are plenty of male dominated companies, with male dominated recruiting teams, that still hire mostly males. To be clear, I'm not saying it's okay either way, I'm just disagreeing with the idea 'most men' won't participate in such a culture; most men (oftentimes unwittingly) do.
- gatvol 5y agoTrue, though the study addresses that point too, and that demonstrably does not happen, in Sweden at least.
- forum_ghost 5y ago> that demonstrably does not happen what exactly doesn't happen?
- toolz 5y agoCan you name any of these male dominated companies that hire men disproportionately to the gender demographics of their applicants/interviewees? The issue isn't the distribution of employees, it's whether there is sexism present or not and the first thing you'd probably want for evidence of sexism is disproportionate hiring of a demographic compared to their applicant/interviewee demographic. Just because something is more represented by a demographic does not make it sexist. e.g. Nordic countries seem to be generally celebrated as being socially progressive and ridding themselves of sexism, yet female representation in STEM fields is incredibly low.
- SamReidHughes 5y ago
- QuarterReptile 5y agoYou missed a part. From GP: >The recruiting team was all women I guess this is what you get when you outsource hiring.
- PeterStuer 5y agoIn house HR is predominately female nowadays as well.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoFair point. I guess the ideal for getting actual "culture fit" would be for the good applications to somehow reach the team needing the new hire without being filtered for "culture" by a completely unrelated team elsewhere in the company. Come to think of it, I believe that's what an in-house referral is... Hopefully someone becomes rich for solving that problem without needing a friend of a friend to get your foot in the door.
- nicoburns 5y ago> That excuse might have been entirely accurate though. Most men are indeed not willing to participate in such a blatantly sexist culture. Right, but that's exactly the sort of problem that these inclusivity initiatives are designed to tackle (they aim to forcibly change the culture to the point that it is no longer prejudiced). That this one was doing the opposite is highly ironic.
- rmbyrro 5y agoSo what, let'em choose to work with whoever they want. If it's all women, so be it. Only men? Whatever. I don't wanna work in either of these organizations. I think the best answer to these divisive, sexist or racist behaviors is to show them in practice they're dumb, kick their ass in the market. An open-minded, welcoming organization is going to attract the best minds. Collectively, these people will kick those ideological-driven asses. EDIT: my point is we cannot legislate change to these people's minds. The only sustainable way forward is to let reality teach them. If we try to impose change like this, it'll only lead to more divisions in society. If I see a lot of racist behaviors against blacks, or latinos or whatever, I'd be glad to join them and work hard to kick these racists out of the game.
- Manuel_D 5y agoWhy can't we legislate away discrimination? Make it illegal, and prosecute the companies that engage in it.
- emaginniss 5y agoHow do you prove it?
- rmbyrro 5y agoIn the public realm, we must legislate equality to all. But in the private realm, I think it's not sustainable. It's better for us to work hard and make people learn from reality. These people are extremists. If we try to legislate change in their private realm, they'll get even more extremist internally. They'll crave for a chance of revenge. Even if it takes decades or centuries. It's unsustainable.
- coffeeblack 5y agoFor some reason I suddenly have to think of Twitter and Firefox. Dunno why.
- jrsj 5y agoIf the average person actually knew what these initiatives meant they would be against them. In practice what it does is make it so members of designated groups typically win by default whenever they & other candidates meet minimum requirements for a position. It’s not even good for the people who get promotions faster as a result imo because everyone around them knows things are rigged in their favor. And who has benefitted? This stuff was supposed to help people that lacked opportunity but for the most part it’s people who were upper middle class (predominately white women) to begin with reaping the benefits & using these policies as a political weapon to get more influence inside companies. I’m personally hopeful that the upcoming Supreme Court case involving Harvards admission practices also affects the private sector and that these types of policies simply become illegal.
- Manuel_D 5y agoThis is my observation as well. Most women don't want to be hired on account of some eng diversity target. It gets really toxic when a company is simultaneously engaging in this kind of discrimination while also harshly cracking down on anyone who points it out. In 2015 I worked at Dropbox when DEI discrimination was ramping up. Among other things, we only interviewed boot camp grads if they were diverse. We also have diverse applicants two tries at the phone screen instead of one. The onsites we're pretty fair, save for a couple hiring managers. If you asked someone in person, nobody would ever admit to anything. But the company did a poll on whether the hiring process was biased against men and 83% responded yes. What did Arden, the head of HR at the time, do? Rant about how offensive this was to women and how we're all sexist. To reiterate, most women and URM did not want these policies. There was some more support for affirmative action supporting URM, which makes sense to me and I largely agree with: things like lower college attendance and family income are concrete examples of systemic disadvantage. Women, on the other hand, attend college at largely the same rate and the disparity is due to choice rather than lack of opportunities.
- jrsj 5y agoIn general it’s also a problem with what is considered diverse. If you’re a white man from a poor family with no college education, the policy is to explicitly discriminate against you. If you’re a white woman from an upper middle class background, you’re considered diverse and given advantages despite the fact that you could have gone into any field you wanted, could probably afford to switch on a whim, and don’t have to worry about things like family members potentially dying because they can’t afford their insulin.
- xienze 5y ago> All while aggressively pushing DEI initiatives and interventions on the tech side. > I don’t think the irony of this ever crossed their minds. They were likely thinking of it in terms of “righting wrongs” in the overall sense by increasing the percentage of women in the company. Publicly, everyone will swear up and down that “diversity” doesn’t mean “fewer whites/men”, but in practice, it’s how those “ideal” demographic ratios are achieved.
- basisword 5y agoI’ve seen the same anecdotally. Marketing in particular at multiple companies was all white women whereas other departments (even stereotypically non-diverse departments like engineering) where a mix of genders and races. It was reinforced every time there was a self congratulatory post in the company wide channel referring to the “marketing ladies” great work.
- daenz 5y agoI've worked in 2 companies that were majority white and asian women. The degree by which they explicitly favored women and minorities probably bordered on illegal, but you'd have to be stupid to bring it up to anyone. Yay, diversity!
- FFRefresh 5y agoI can also attest to this, I just left a pretty well-known tech company who leaned hard into DEI in the wake of the summer 2020 protests. The exec team essentially set up quotas, with every race+gender group getting priority over white males. Execs were given bonuses if they increased the percentage of non-white male employees. The crazy thing was that white males were NOT over-represented in the first place. 2 years later, they are the most under-represented group, and the overall org is now more unrepresentative of the population than it ever has been. There are 3 times as many asian females as there are white males in the org, even though there are ~10x as many white males in the population at large (which is allegedly what the org cares about), which produces a representation disparity between the two groups of nearly ~30x. Most white males left the org, as they could all see that advancing at the company would be nearly impossible given the incentives put in place. For the record, I think it's perfectly fine if asians are over-represented in a tech company (i'm asian myself), I just think this type of thinking that is informing hiring practices is pretty gross, and is actually moving things farther away from the stated goals.
- gedy 5y agoI think it would be helpful if you name the company. Nothing bad about sharing that info.
- jokethrowaway 5y ago> I just think this type of thinking that is informing hiring practices is pretty gross, and is actually moving things farther away from the stated goals. If someone ever believed the stated goals they are not capable of rational thinking. I know plenty of smart people who sadly go along with this BS just because it's what all "reasonable" people are doing and don't spend a lot of time thinking about it. The same people don't think about politics and parrot what left wing media tells them. The activists themselves are not capable of rational thinking.
- eldaisfish 5y agocomparing to the population at large isn't the most valid thing to do. Many fields are dominated by women - nursing to name just one. Even within nursing, there are a lot of latino and phillipino nurses. by your logic, the largest ethnic group of nurses in a country like the US or UK should be white women. There are many more factors at play here.
- duxup 5y agoHR department at a previous workplace was like that. All women, all friends, all worked with each other or were relatives of someone... their personal lives were entirely intertwined with work. Most weren't at work most days and this was when they had a no work from home policy years ago. Loud personal calls all day long. I wasn't even in that department and the drama that came from it was exhausting. They would often take longer than their allotted meeting time in meeting rooms because after their meeting someone in there was crying ... why? Who knows... it was only known within that group. It just kept happening over and over... Along with folks storming down the hall all upset, again who knows why. Now stuff happens sometimes at work, no big deal, but running into these exhausting people couple times a week really takes a toll on you. When were moving offices the tech support team was seated next to HR. At one point HR invited the both all of tech support and HR (at least those at that building) to a meeting to discuss why tech support wasn't "social enough" and "spent all day in their cubes", I duno maybe they're working... Thankfully that got cancelled quickly after a number of people (me included) noted to a VP that "No matter what the reason, there's no way this meeting ends in anything but a total disaster." Then came the litany of complaints that HR sponsored events (where HR planned everything to HR's preferences) were not attended enough by the tech support team and how much work they put into it and so on... I even left those events early because it's a lunch event and I don't want to eat veggie pizza only, I can only take lunch for so long.
- yamazakiwi 5y agoMy team goes through something similar with our sister company that's in the same building. Their product is made better by being ran by social types so their organization is entirely personable, outgoing, and very social. They constantly complain that we don't join them in multi-org events but none of us (including our manager) want to join them. If I had to consistently have small talk with a bunch of socialites, I would quit.
- duxup 5y agoWorkplace culture is a weird thing. Sometimes a group's workplace culture is ... not a lot of culture. Depending on how things are going, that might not be bad.
- chrchang523 5y ago"Your margin is my opportunity." Is this behavior significantly reducing the startup's competitiveness? If so, this should be exploitable by a competitor. Assuming you don't have the bandwidth to directly work for or advise a competitor of this type, you might still be able to benefit as an investor. If not... I have a hard time getting worked up about this. It's contrary to the dominant narrative, but if this female-dominated organization is actually doing a good job, I'm inclined to leave them alone and pay more attention to biases that actually harm businesses, because it's not like there's currently a shortage of those. [additional note, in response to comments: I agree that this behavior still constitutes an injustice. However, among the numerous injustices in the world, one has to prioritize what to fight. My main point is that, as a practical matter, there are plenty of instances of biased hiring that ALSO reduce overall economic efficiency; let's fight those easier and more broadly profitable battles first.]
- adamsmith143 5y ago> if this female-dominated organization is actually doing a good job I'm inclined to leave them alone and pay more attention to biases that actually harm businesses So your only metric for biased hiring practices being problematic is business performance??
- forum_ghost 5y agoyou start businesses to lose money?
- xiphias2 5y ago,,Is this behavior significantly reducing the startup's competitiveness?'' No, if money is used politically. In a free market you would be right, but with the amount of money printing going on, we're not living in a free market.
- Manuel_D 5y agoSo if a blatantly sexist organization that deliberately only hired me is still doing okay, that's not a problem?
- dudul 5y agoMy favorite is when, during a quarterly DEI meeting, the DEI team would show a slide with the pie chart for "diversity when hiring last quarter" - "We hired 70% women! Yoohoo! we're super diverse!" :)
- paxys 5y agoA lot of tech companies prioritize hiring women (whether officially or not) in roles like HR and admin to make their overall diversity numbers look better.
- umvi 5y agoCan confirm, my last company's HR department was 100% women, but it still didn't offset the 90%+ male engineering department enough to satisfy DEI targets
- at_a_remove 5y agoIt isn't irony, it is hypocrisy. And they have considered it. When you put the thumbscrews on them, they say things like "You can't discriminate against men" and talk about punching-up versus punching-down, etc. They have a bunch of thought-terminating cliches in place to deal with this already. They will talk about the "larger context" of society, and "every day is already men's day." There's a pretty funny picture of the HuffPo team at one point and it is just ... young white women. That's it. That's your diversity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tootie 5y agoRead the summary. The finding was driven by female-dominated professions. Presumably things like teaching or nursing. Definitely not tech. Research was also done only in Sweden. I've never seen a US tech company that wasn't overwhelmingly white and male.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- koshergweilo 5y ago*In Sweden
- chokolad 5y agoThis is in line with earlier findings in different countries. In a meta-analysis of hiring discrimination studies during 2000–2014, Rich [9] documented high levels of discrimination against men applying to jobs in female-dominated occupations in China [13], France [14], England [25], and Australia [11].
- koshergweilo 5y agoI don't disagrees with the conclusion, but these studies only prove it in their respective countries.
- _0jki 5y ago
- bestbuyer__ 5y agoSome women are born to wealthy families and some men to poor ones. This policy would elevate wealthy women to the detriment of poor men, a completely unethical outcome.
- rmbyrro 5y agoRegardless of one's opinion, I wouldn't take laws as a good and definite source for my judgement. History provides plenty of examples showing it can lead to some of the most inhumane behaviors we've seen.
- matt321 5y agoDiscrimination in hiring is always harmful, what matters is if its acceptable. If you don't hire a high school drop out to be a physicist, he is objectively worse off (harmed). Even if you assume that men are better off than women (I don't) discrimination is harmful (they are worse off), but they wind up still better off than the woman so its acceptable.
- patmcc 5y agoIt can be harmful to individuals without being harmful to the group. Men aren't marginalized in society, but an individual man can certainly be discriminated against in a specific instance. If a hospital had a policy of never hiring male nurses that shouldn't be acceptable.
- Manuel_D 5y agoNo, the protected classes are things like "gender" and "race". It's baffling how many people seem to think that discrimination protection carve out exemptions that permit discrimination against men.
- mrguyorama 5y agoIndeed, just because some stupid zoomer on twitter said all men must die or something equally stupid; 1) does not mean men are discriminated against and 2) does not stop the law from protecting a man from discrimination for being a man. Sure, shit like that is really hard to prove, but so is it for a woman looking to be in a male dominated field. Add that to how often discrimination is subconscious or accidental or otherwise not a purposeful, organized effort to harm a specific group of people and you run into the situation where we struggle to prevent it.
- quattrofan 5y ago
- coffeeblack 5y agoAnd in male-dominated occupations. Discrimination happens on the individual level.
- Manuel_D 5y agoThe study found no discrepancies in mixed and male dominated industries. > Male applicants were about half as likely as female applicants to receive a positive employer response in female-dominated occupations. For male-dominated and mixed occupations we found no significant differences in positive employer responses between male and female applicants.
- matt321 5y ago
- frob 5y agoI'm working for a company that has over 50% female engineers and it's the best experience I've ever had. Im a guy and I've worked as a tech lead at a FAANG, at a startup, and in academia.
- rjbwork 5y agoFind better work. I'm currently on a team with a number of women (and many, many more men) who are great.
- 3l3ktr4 5y ago
- dog_boy 5y ago
- Ourgon 5y ago
- jobs_throwaway 5y agowhat would be more helpful is if you actually showed where those comments were wrong rather than just cry about it
- frob 5y agoCan we please change the title to what the paper is actually titled? "Gender discrimination in hiring: An experimental reexamination of the Swedish case"
- throwaway0wha8h 5y agoThrowaway. I'm happy to have more women in tech and hope it occurs or continues. However, virtually everyone recruiting in tech has observed some toxic diversity initiatives, I would venture. Some examples I have seen personally or one degree removed from me. - pressure on HMs to hire more women despite 95% of applicants being male - people in interview panels openly saying "but he's a white man" / "do we want to hire more white men" etc. - people championing all women teams as a win for diversity - women getting a salary premium to help companies boost DEI "representation" I think eventually this will be shown for what it is, but it will take a long time. Personally every tech founder I know thinks it's bullshit but won't say it in public.
- thewileyone 5y agoTotally agree with you. It's becoming toxic in many companies.
- antiverse 5y ago>- people in interview panels openly saying "but he's a white man" / "do we want to hire more white men" etc. Not surprised to hear people saying this, but am surprised that nobody brings that up as a plainly racist/sexist thing when it is said. Bystander effect?
- rubyist5eva 5y agoAt my last company all hands, our CFO was talking about "increasing diversity" at our company. The entire C-Level or our entire company are people of colour. 4 out of 5 department heads are PoC. Customer success team are majority PoC and mostly women. Out of our entire engineering department, there are only 2 "white" people - myself (anglo-Canadian), and another man of Swedish ethnicity..though I suppose all white men are the same... Engineering is the only male dominated department, we used to have a few women developers but they left for better opportunities and hiring is currently frozen. 2/3 of our QA department are women and PoC.
- anon867 5y ago> Engineering is the only male dominated department, we used to have a few women developers but they left for better opportunities and hiring is currently frozen. Other than C-level, what's the best-paid department/position in a tech company? Food for thought, if you were take the total of money paid to men vs women in your company, and really think hard about it, how would that balance out? Even if you took C-suite, really think about the answer
- tomerv 5y agoBut if hiring for that department is frozen, as GP stated, how do you expect it to be fixed?
- singlow 5y agoFood for thought. Read through all of your comments and count how many of them are condescending. I mean across all your throw-away accounts. Really think about the answer.
- rubyist5eva 5y ago> what's the best-paid department/position in a tech company? In our company specifically: sales. And like every non-engineering department at the company: female dominated. Also, just a few months ago there was a downsizing of the engineering department in order to stack our sales team. We've also lost 20% of the remaining engineering team since then from attrition/austerity.
- MrMan 5y ago
- gizajob 5y agoIn my experience, I've always found it quite strange that HR and recruitment is a field that seems to me to be female dominated, at least in the part of the UK where I am, and I can't help but feel that the imbalance at this level of the process reflects who gets hired.
- paxys 5y agoHR & recruiting are female dominated simply because hiring women in these roles is the easiest way for a company to get their diversity numbers up.
- unicornmama 5y agoProof?
- anon23anon 5y ago100% this. At my company they created all these product manager type roles and fill them w/ women and minorities and then count them as part of the software engineering team to get their diversity numbers up.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoI'm really skeptical of this. Women as a percentage of the workforce in general isn't low, and just as some fields seem to attract a lot of men, some fields attract a lot of women. Even if you believe that societal pressure is part of this, that still means that by the time you're talking about "who applies to companies for X jobs" there's self-selection at play.
- dolni 5y agoNah, that's not why. Women, on the aggregate, like professions that are people-driven. HR is that. Recruiting is that. Nursing is that. Programming isn't.
- gizajob 5y agoI'd agree with the comments that reflect women's skills in networking and team consensus, rather than saying it was because of any sort of diversity quota. I've been at recruiters frequently where it was all-female offices, and, at risk of labouring a cheap point, it's sometimes been difficult to get my technical skills understood, outside of buzzwording.
- jedimastert 5y agoThis comment section is gonna be a RIDE... To actually comment on the topic at hand: the reason there's still male-dominated spaces is that women are weeded out far earlier than the hiring stage. See, for example, statistics about women in STEM and especially computer science and realize that hiring managers don't even have to be sexist for male-dominated fields to exist, even though they still are.
- shtopointo 5y agoAre weeded out, or do they weed themselves out?
- BlargMcLarg 5y ago>women are weeded out >especially computer science By choice or by force? N=1, but I still remember teachers saying "all the girls that should be in CS are going to math instead, they think CS is a boys' club" despite repeatedly catering 'women in tech' and such. According to some anecdotes I heard, this also changes outside Western countries, where women pick CS much more quickly. >statistics about women in STEM Actual statistics would show women aren't underrepresented in STEM as a whole, or not nearly as much as people claim. This discussion keeps being raised and they conveniently omit fields which are very much science, and have far more women than men coming in. Medicine, veterinary, agriculture, biological science are all fields women tend to compete or dominate to a certain degree. See https://www.hesa.ac.uk/news/16-01-2020/sb255-higher-education-student-statistics/subjects https://www.hesa.ac.uk/news/16-01-2020/sb255-higher-educatio....
- pyuser583 5y agoI wonder if all the “women in tech” programs simply serve as warning signs that there aren’t enough women in tech, and there’s a good chance a woman going into tech is going into an all boys club.
- csdreamer7 5y ago> "all the girls that should be in CS are going to math instead, they think CS is a boys' club" One of my female classmates who took an intro CS as an elective hated how the class was run. Essentially half the class was already proficient in programming and were expected to solve the problems on your own without talking. This was different than my math classes which were more likely to have female teachers and we were to work in groups to solve problems (this was how precalc was done). She said she felt scared by the expectation to already know these things before the class begun and all the silence while working.
- nabaraz 5y agoDuring my career, I've seen enough discrimination in the name of DEI as well. But what bothers me more is the ageism. The number of times an old person has been rejected from a job is too damn high. The reasons have always been "he may not work well with young people", "seniority complex", "he is over qualified" etc. Most of the times, they were more than qualified. I fear when I am into 40s or 50s, I will face the same discrimination.
- duxup 5y agoAfter age 40 I did a coding bootcamp to change careers. Another guy in the camp was doing the same. We compared notes on interviews. One day he gets a call back from a recruiter and he put the recruiter on speaker phone. She told them they liked him but chose someone else because (drum roll) culture fit. He asked what she meant by that and she outright said: "The other person is younger. You're old." We were shocked and he pretended he didn't quite hear her... she repeated it word for word. I don't think she even realized it was illegal. The other guy never made a complaint, he needed a job and I could hardly blame him not wanting to put up a fuss / fight over a job at a place he didn't want to be a part of anyway ... it was shocking to hear it made that clear. Long run we both got jobs and are doing well, but man... that call sticks in the back of my head anytime I think of job hunting.
- t_mann 5y agoWould be interesting to compare this across areas. My impression is that eg Finance (another popular destination for mid-career switches) is far more open in that regard. Experience, even if it's in a different field (as long as it's a technical role or one that will give you a rich set of contacts) seems to generally confer seniority. Would be interesting if someone could weigh in.
- bumby 5y agoAnecdotally, the hard engineering fields (e.g., mechanical, civil, etc.) are much more tolerant about age and more receptive to the benefits and tradeoffs of both youth and, erm.., "experience" (said tongue-in-cheek because age does not necessarily equate to experience)
- wmichelin 5y ago
- colordrops 5y agoNice straw white man.
- yolo3000 5y agoThere's no "white man", everyone is an individual. Whoever discriminates is an idiot, man/woman/white/black/red/gay/whatever.
- wmichelin 5y agoI agree, but it's not exactly the best look to complain only about instances of the majority getting discriminated against when minorities are getting discriminated against constantly
- swayvil 5y ago
- jleyank 5y agoHoo, boy. If true, there must be a staggering shortage of men in the software design biz. At least judging from the stuff I have to deal with. Maybe being an asshole is a Y-linked trait?
- swayvil 5y agoI didn't understand that at all. Speak plainly.
- jokethrowaway 5y ago
- OptoContrarian 5y agoWhen discussing discrimination, the concept of intersectionalty discrimination is something I find needs to be addressed more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimbob45 5y agoThis is the wrong conversation. The problem is not discrimination - the problem is that recruiters can do the dirty work of discrimination (or harassment or false advertising) and entirely shield these companies from lawsuit. The companies can simply claim ignorance to have known what was going on with the recruiting firms. The recruiting firms aren't big enough to sue. You wouldn't get anything out of them monetarily and you'd be unlikely to generate much publicity suing a recruiting firm that no one's heard about. If we're going to move forward with this model where recruiters are run out of firms not associated with the company, the main company needs to be liable for any abuse on the part of the 3rd party recruiters they hire.
- okwubodu 5y agoI’m glad I scrolled far enough to catch one of the few thought-provoking comments in this thread.
- beepbooptheory 5y ago
- acomjean 5y agoI think this is sarcasm. But I can’t tell anymore. As a white guy with a really not white name, I will note that things seem to go better when I’m seen. There seems to be a lot of complaints and outrage from people that have it pretty good.
- jleyank 5y agoThere has been a number of cases with people using a francophone name vs. An anglophone or allophone name in Quebec yielding different success in initial hiring stages. People are tribal.
- chucksta 5y agoEveryone knows a great way to get anyone to give up powering willingly, is to make them feel more at risk and make fun of them for it
- anothernerd2 5y agoI think it’s hilarious that you think were all white men
- beepbooptheory 5y agoI mean I don't think I ever implied that, but regardless I think we need to care about those who are most the disadvantaged with a certain level of priority.
- anothernerd2 5y ago> Very sorry for all the white men on here who are unjustly discriminated. You did, in a way, assume that everybody here who’s upset is a white man. If you were truly unbiased you would have said “people” in place of “white men” Rather than spending billions of dollars and hours sanitizing language we could use that energy and money towards solving real problems
- maire 5y agoIn the US, male nurses are highly valued. I am not sure why this is not so in Sweden. On the other hand, people are wary of male preschool teachers. These two fields seem to be equivalent in Sweden. In the US - Cleaners are not well paid. I am not sure why men want to join this field. The best cleaner I ever had left as soon as she landed a better paying job. I see plenty of husband and wife teams where the wife does the cleaning and the husband does the gardening. The husband is typically paid at least 30% more than the wife. Maybe this is a higher status job in Sweden?
- pyuser583 5y agoCleaning had, at least in theory, lots of flexibility.
- moeris 5y ago> I am not sure why men want to join this field. Because having a job is better than not having a job. You could say the same thing for being a dishwasher, say. Just because people typically don't want to make an entire career out of a job doesn't mean that discrimination isn't problematic.
- maire 5y agoI just did a quick check and on average cleaners in the US are paid less than warehouse workers (and for that matter dishwashers). I also used to buy into the theory of male blue collar jobs disappearing until I saw all the well paid blue collar jobs that men won't take. (After all, I supported Yang.) I think even Yang now disbelieves his own theory and is looking at other reasons why men are dropping out of the work force.
- nitwit005 5y ago> In the US - Cleaners are not well paid. I am not sure why men want to join this field. There are some well compensated cleaning jobs in some (definitely not all) hospitals and schools.
- markus_zhang 5y agoI think we should play diverse more on financial background, not on racial/gender.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoA few workplaces ago the company was hiring from a recruiter instructed with bringing only female or non white people. When I opposed that I was pointed to the actual UK law for positive discrimination which explicitly allow discrimination. I never had faith in society, but I had no idea we fell so low. I think most western countries are completely lost and will never get back. With woke activists controlling big tech, universities and the press, there is truly no hope for western countries. I moved to a country where society is a bit backward for modern standards and I'll look into moving again once they catch up with the modern world.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I never had faith in society, but I had no idea we fell so low. I can see an argument that tolerating discrimination in the universe direction as part of a scheme to deal with the lasting impacts of a long history of discrimination against certain groups is flawed, inadequate, of incomplete progress compared to the period of discrimination. I can't see the argument that it is a fall, though, unless one views the preceding discrimination as a good thing in itself.
- specialist 5y agoThis OC isn't grinding an axe. I may be wrong, but it seems this paper's contribution is using analytical techniques (whatever "correspondence testing" is), with the customary roles reversed, to better calibrate those techniques. If so, I think that's genius. So many times I've found myself facing a (ethical) problem with nothing more than noob wild-ass-guesses on how to solve it. Perhaps better understanding hiring discrimination in all contexts will help divine context-free rules. Neutral strategies we can all agree to use. That'd be awesome. Because right now the only notion I have for tackling bias is using lotteries (eg sortition). And that's a hard sell even for me.
- theslurmmustflo 5y agoreading the comments, if you think software jobs are bad, try getting a job in a design field
- JCM9 5y agoThere are very concerning patterns developing at the moment in the DEI space. DEI efforts, and often those leading them, are increasingly the most biased and close minded parts of the organization. Spreading selected stereotypes and often solving concerns about “discrimination” by being very biased and inequitable. For example at my last company a report showed that slightly fewer of a certain minority were promoted. This was pointed out and discussed extensively. However when someone pointed out that the same data showed that there were zero of the same minority in performance plans and that everyone on performance plans was a white male, the conversation was shut down. As in it was incredibly important we address this very minor statistical gap on one end, but when the same data suggested that we might be biased against older white males the same DEI department (which had no older white males by the way) shut the convo down immediately. DEI can’t just be about selected DEI that meets a certain biased definition that is, ironically, not inclusive.
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago
- ghufran_syed 5y agoI find it amazing that you think this kind of blatant racism is acceptable - what does being “white” have to do with his behavior or performance? or do you think certain skin colors are limited in their abilities and performance?
- bjt2n3904 5y agoIt's been the norm between 2020 and about five minutes ago. Don't let this comment get flagged or buried, let people see it.
- cafeoh 5y agoMore amazing yet, perhaps, is that some people find it acceptable to talk about racism in a situation where the word doesn't apply. Discrimination against white people can be a thing, racism doesn't. Discrimination can make sense (for obvious reasons), racism doesn't.
- jleyank 5y agoIf somebody was really good and presented themselves well, why the hell would they want to sling code for somebody else when they could go into finance or medicine? Yeah, being a tech founder can be amazingly lucrative but for anything else the non-tech roles are better respected and paid quite well. Think of a good quant or surgeon.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fdgsdfogijq 5y agoFunniest quote I read recently: We wanted diversity and inclusion, all we got were white women
- SCAQTony 5y agoOf course, there is discrimination between the sexes, sexual orientation, nationality, politics, or any other religion or philosophy. People hire their friends, they will hire people of like mind, and fairness be damned. (Don't me get me started on age discrimination.) I think it is demonstrable that women have it tougher than in most fields, especially in the art world. We are all created equal under law but who "watches the watchmen? And how do you regulate decisions? Even algorithms that declare a certain race percentage be balanced are discriminatory.
- dijonman2 5y agoLast two companies I have been at simply do not hire any white males, and blatantly give bonuses for hitting targets of DEI. It’s no longer about merit or skill, it’s about woke crap and identity politics.
- coward123 5y agoI've been on both sides of this, having been in a male-predominant industry and then in a female-predominant industry. In the male world, there was plenty of "mansplaining" and in the female world - I was actually really surprised at how female colleagues approached me. There were hilarious moments of "reverse mansplaining" where a group tried telling me all about the industry I had just come from, when none of them had any experience in that field. I remember a moment too where I was offering a business opportunity that would benefit all of them, but they very clearly did not think I was qualified simply by being a male - but would have been totally on board if I brought in a female partner. On the other hand, there were places where they wanted my opinion because there were (to me) weird gender role things at play - something like "we need a big strong man to defend us here, so let's get his opinion." Men and women approach things in very different ways that even now with 40 years of life experience continue to surprise me. I think some of the bias is not intentional, but rather a lack of awareness, and frankly acknowledgement.
- mkl95 5y agoIn my area, 40+ developers basically fall into two groups: - Burnt out developers who still like their job. These people often have a background in some STEM field, may hold a PhD etc. They can be difficult to work with due to the odd outburst, but their approach to problem solving is pretty constructive. - Burnt out developers who hate their job. This is the most difficult group of people to work with I've encountered in my career. These people struggle on a daily basis and cannot be properly integrated into a team. Now, if I became a recruiter, I would be aware that hiring 40+ developers can be a gamble. I know I will probably be one of those guys some day, and I don't see a non trivial approach to solving it. The software industry simply sucks.
- titanomachy 5y agoThe approach to solving it is to get promoted a lot. All of the directors and many of the staff+ engineers at my company are 40+. They are highly respected, receive eye-watering compensation, and if they move more slowly and cautiously than young folks it's chalked up to experience rather than senility.
- streblo 5y agoI've worked with plenty of 40+ developers who aren't burnt out and match neither of these categories
- johnnyanmac 5y agowhy do you assume burnout by default?
- mkl95 5y agoI'm not assuming, I'm just saying a vast majority of 40+ devs in my area fall into those groups. It's a different story at tech hubs where there's actual career growth.
- johnnyanmac 5y agoI see. This conversation tends to be focused around tech hubs, so I figured you were talking about tech hubs by default. Which goes starkly in contrast to my exprience with senior developers. At least in tech hubs, it seems like by the 30's they'd burn out. Those still kicking in their 40's seem to still enjoy their work, IC and mangement alike.
- forinti 5y agoI've worked in a predominantly female team and there was discrimination against, well, me. I've worked in a team with lots of older folks and the younger members weren't taken as seriously as they should have been. It also happens when a company has lots of outsourced programmers. I think there is a lot of emphasis on discrimination made by young white men because they simply are the largest demographic in IT and, of course, they don't generally behave as they should because they are immature (as young people tend to be). The solution, if it is to be accepted widely, is to work on the group dynamics that all groups show.
- pvarangot 5y agoYeah Unconscious Bias training is one of the DEI policies that I think is valuable to everyone, that's if it's training and not indoctrination.
- randomsearch 5y agoIs there rigorous evidence that supports the idea of unconscious bias and the effectiveness of training in reducing it? I’ve seen it advertised in academia and wondered if it’s evidence-based.
- ok123456 5y agoIt's a form of 'original sin'. It's valuable as a form of control, but it's flimsy science---indistinguishable from the null-hypothesis.
- jmpman 5y agoAbout 10 years ago, I consulted for a huge company in St Louis. St Louis’s racial makeup is approximately 50% white and 50% black. In the company’s IT group, the makeup was 50% white males, and 50% Indian. The only African Americans were the security guards. If companies were serious about DEI goals, they would require their contracted IT consultancies to have a representative racial makeup of the local population. I’d happily support any company with that DEI goal. Anyone know of one?
- codelord 5y agoIt's interesting to me people make all sort of assertions about why men or women are dominant in an industry without anyway to falsify their hypothesis. I provide some data points having lived in several countries that may offer some insight. Draw your own conclusions. I got my undergrad degree in Iran (a relatively conservative society with an ultra-conservative even anti-women government), where the ratio of women to men in our computer science class was roughly 60/40 in favor of women. The ratio was similar all across the board in STEM and non-STEM fields as more women were admitted and graduated from universities than men. To get admission in Iran everyone has to go through the same standardized test nationally. Women were scoring better and better in the nationalized test than men every year until they passed men the year I went to school. (The trend continued later even prompting the government to introduce legislation to cap the ratio of women at least in certain programs.) When I went to Europe for grad school (to a very progressive university in perhaps the most progressive European country) to my surprise I had only one female classmate who was a non-European international student in a class of 40. I let you judge what caused this discrepancy. But I hope we can all agree the issue is much more complicated than some want to make you believe.
- gruez 5y ago>I got my undergrad degree in Iran (a relatively conservative society with an ultra-conservative even anti-women government), where the ratio of women to men in our computer science class was roughly 60/40 in favor of women [...] >When I went to Europe for grad school (to a very progressive university in perhaps the most progressive European country) to my surprise I had only one female classmate who was a non-European international student in a class of 40. also known as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-equality_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-equality_paradox
- telomero22 5y agoIt's because in poor and conservative countries women must choose a high paying job if they want to escape oppression and arranged marriage. However, the more egalitarian and wealthy a country is, the more women are free to choose which job they like most and they are not so interested in Engineering it seems. EDIT: Ha, looks like this is just a Jordan Peterson false claim. Women seem to be strongly represented in science and engineering in developed countries. https://bigthink.com/strange-maps/women-in-science/ https://bigthink.com/strange-maps/women-in-science/
- geraldwhen 5y agoMy company presented a DEI slide a couple years ago showing black employees on the rise, and white on the decline, with targets of 35% black employees by 2025. We also have intern roles that specifically require you be black, or lgtbq. It’s wild. I looked into what it would take to report the job postings, but from what I can tell you need to be discriminated against personally to make any claims.
- jimbokun 5y ago35% is almost 3x the share of black people in the US population (assuming you are talking about a US company).
- TulliusCicero 5y agoThe left in the US has a very broken mentality when it comes to this. How it is: *Sees picture of company that's 50% white and 50% black* "Wow! How diverse!" *See picture of company that's 50% white and 50% Asian* "My god, it's nothing but white people!" You might think I'm exaggerating, but I'm not. I've seen plenty of articles from mainstream tech blogs and the like talking about how very white tech companies are, even though they're actually less white than the US population as a whole. The articles often do their best to ignore the Asian population present.
- vmception 5y agoTwo thoughts on that: Yes, that is an overcorrection on representation. Many places that are highlighted are having things like 1-3% black employees in any capacity. Yeah getting that to 13% with qualified people would be neat! Secondly, when it comes to being above the national average I think the local area should be considered. When having a company in an area with a greater % of minorities already, with credentials and other marketable skills, then its not really proportionally. Obviously only if the goal is to be equitable or brag about being equitable, as this kind of proportion would be at the expense of the white population national average. The main goal is to recruit from areas that are being overlooked. There are plenty, they exist. Not just pester a minority that a recruiter found.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Saint_Genet 5y ago
- thisismyusrname 5y agoThere are a lot of examples of illegal hiring practices in this thread. I recommend speaking to an employment attorney if you are affected by these somehow.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThe DEI movement started with good intentions and did a lot of good but in the long run dividing people along categorizes like gender or race is way too simplistic. For example I am white male but my life experience is probably more similar to a lot of black males vs people like Tim Cook or Elon Musk. And I have no connection to a white male that grew up in a poor mining town in West Virginia. If you want to define groups I think it makes way more sense to do that by income. A woman who makes 1 million will get more respect than a male who makes 20k. I feel we are changing the preferred groups from white males to other groups but in the end we aren’t creating more equality or inclusion. We are just shifting the in groups.
- Proven 5y ago
- Zigurd 5y ago46% of the Swedish legislature are female. About the same in Finland and Norway. That's an indication of not only numbers being roughly balanced, but power and influence as well. About 25% of the US Senate and House of Representatives are women. That looks bad. But it is about the same in technical roles in US companies. The percentage of women in leadership roles in tech companies is much lower. Work remains to be done.
- rdl 5y agoIt's pretty amazing how useful working with the military has been in changing my views of a lot of groups/demographics. I probably would have assumed nurses = female almost entirely, but there were a lot of nurses who were male, both the specialty types and more generalist nurses. (Also, I grew up in a suburb where it was basically "different white ethnicities", with the exception of some black students from nearby poor areas bused in as part of our special education program (since we were rich and had lots of resources comparatively.). I then went to school at MIT which is basically white/asian predominately (although a fair number of international students.). Then Bay Area which is again basically white/asian in tech occupations. In the military, especially outside combat arms, there's genuine racial and geographic diversity across a lot of roles; good and bad people of every type. IMO, a useful experience.)
- pvarangot 5y agoThe tech industry knows they are far behind on the DEI metrics and they overcompensate playing this culture wars chess move where they make everyone sick of hearing them virtue signaling about diversity so that they can't be questioned. They loose even when compared to "conservative" institutions. It's not only the military, in San Francisco the police department is more diverse than Lyft, Uber, Google. The club I go shooting to in Richmond has more black people on a weekend than what I've ever seen inside the same room at Lyft. Richmond is a moderate democrat city where everyone that doesn't work for the government works for Chevron. Until I started shooting I think I had only interacted with three black people in the Bay Area. One from work, one from co-living and another one that hangs out with a crew I party with. Of course all those circles lean tech-heavy. First "conservative" thing I dare do and there's loads of latinos and black people and we are all confused as fuck as to where all the evil white people we keep on reading about actually are.
- bell-cot 5y agoMy sense is that most responses here are only to the title of the submission (the actual article title is "Gender discrimination in hiring: An experimental reexamination of the Swedish case"). Skimming through said actual article, it looks like the "against men" hiring discrimination is ~completely driven by this: "...In female-dominated occupations such as cleaner, childcare provider, preschool teacher, accounting clerk, and enrolled nurse, positive employer response rates were much higher for women than for men. This is in line with earlier findings in different countries..." Which sure sounds to me like "employers try to fill low-status, low-pay, often-crappy female-dominated jobs with yet more females". It takes a certain sort of mindset to react as if men were clearly the (sole) group being wronged by that. (Or do millions of men quietly aspire to jobs cleaning up dirty toilets, dirty diapers, and dirty bedpans, and I'm just ignorant of their dreams?)
- dang 5y agoYes - the title here was so egregiously editorialized that I'm not even going to revert it. Submitters: breaking the site guidelines like this will eventually cause your account to lose submission privileges. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and note this one: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize."
- idiotsecant 5y agoThis is pretty dismissive of the men who want to work in what you consider low status crappy jobs. There are plenty of men out there who expressly go to school with the goal of being an educator, for example. The discrimination those men face is very real. It's ok to admit that there are some areas society has decided men shouldn't work in. It doesn't diminish the struggles of anyone else
- bell-cot 5y agoYes and no. For instance - there's generally a big gap between "go to school with the goal of being an educator", and being a preschool teacher. At least in the U.S., the latter tends to offer far lower status, pay, job security, etc. than being (say) a 7th grade teacher. Between the low desirability, high turnover, and "we must fill the opening" nature of most bottom-end, female-dominated jobs, I'd guess that the anti-male discrimination is a fairly weak barrier to men who really want those jobs. Apply a bunch of time, especially when unemployment is low, and it's pretty likely that you'll be hired because they had no acceptable alternative. Or (say) a preschool wanted to have one male teacher, to be a social role model for little boys. Or (I have seen this done) a bookkeeping dept. wanted a couple males, to dial down the social drama that they experienced with a all-female clerkforce. And for those concerned less about individual rights (to get the job one really wants, etc.) than about the larger-scale social downsides of discrimination, making it more difficult for men to obtain some types of low-status, low-pay jobs is a "pretty weak poison".
- bradlys 5y agoI'm not going to bother with the actual study itself - as it's not really what a lot of the discussion here is about. Instead, I'd like to ask this: Why do we have DEI measures for race, gender, and sexual orientation but none for socioeconomic class/upbringing? I have a thought as to why but still - I wonder what others here think.